ML20033B495

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Diagram,Demonstrating Licensee Failure to Follow Health Physics Procedural Requirements,In Response to 810302 Request for Concurrence Re IE Insp Repts 50-277/80-33 & 50-278/80-26.Mgt Enforcement Conference Recommended
ML20033B495
Person / Time
Site: Peach Bottom  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 03/03/1981
From: Knapp P
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To: Joyner J
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
Shared Package
ML20033B470 List:
References
NUDOCS 8112010467
Download: ML20033B495 (2)


See also: IR 05000277/1980033

Text

A q , 0 Ftd

'

-

,

--

ATTACHMENT 2

-

-

..

EP.;?J.nDUM FOR

' J. Joyner, Chief, Technical Ir.spection Branch

FROM:

KnaPP, Chief, Facility Radiological Prot'ection

Section

SUBJECT:

R9CCMMENDAllDN FOR PD:tGE."LNT ENFC; CEMENT CONF ERENCE '.li!H

PHI L'sDE L?HI A ELECT RIC CC.: ANY , DDCKET ';b".EGS 50217 :ND

50-278

RE E E RE' Cr:

Memorandum to G. Smith From P. Knapp Dated February 9,

1981, Same Subject, Copy Attached

On March 2, 1981, I received for concurrence Inspection Report Numbers 50-

277/S0-35 and 50-278/S0-28.

The associated Notice of Violation contains a citation for failure to comply

with 1.5. 6.13.

(Two individu,is were observed working in a high radiatica area

without a radiation monitoring device which continuously indicates the radiation

dose rate in the area.)- From the details, it a'ppears that the RWP required an

ion chari.ber under " Monitoring Required", apparently in order to satisfy the

requirements of T.S. 6.13.

However, since a pocket dosimeter is also an ion

chamber it is not possible to cite in this instance for failure to follow procad_ al

requirements (T.S. 6.31).

Regardless of the technicalities in this case, this seems to be still another

indicati-n that there appears to me to be a continuing problem of failure to

follow radiation protection procedure 3.

(Ncte attached form RSS 5.)

I again recommend that the management conference outlined in my February 9,1081

memorandum be called

e

,

l

P. J. Knapp, Chief

Facility Radiological Protection

Section

CC:

E. Erc.r.er

E. '%Cebe

l

l

l

l

l

8112010467 811109

.

PDR ADOCK 05000277

l

G

PDR

1

.

- _ .

_

-

.

.

.

-

-

_ -

-

.

<

u.-

.

.

~. : -

. ~ . . . . .

,,_ -

.

n

.,-

c

.s

.

~

,

, , . .

,

c..

.

g p , ,.s c x

. ,'

, . s.. t,. ~,. ,..

~

-

. .

.

..

,a n..u;-

u

1. 4.a:. g. ,p ; ,-- ,

9.r . ..

n:

t.:

s.

,J > ;.. .

.

/

,e e :r t a.a,,

,- u- ;.-

< . ,.-

, -

zu

. (.; s-. , 3 ;5

,- ;,.. m

-

s

.

.c

.

-

,>

.,c...

.

r .

m.

.$.

, . . ,

,s Q . r.v. .

c. a ..

,

,, %j _ . --- . n. e a 3. .-

.

.y

, --

s

,

s %A.

.c

..,,3

5

_.

.

y3 .e ,, , .

a*

47 .

.,y

w . .g.g; p s.u. ..g-%jg; . p..

.

w ,. . . m. ry t %, g w

- .

-r-

r s-

i n

7 . . . ~ .q . x . r

c. as,pg .q,;.tf.g.cy 29 s - .;_.,;.. e,32 o 2.wc,wm..u. _ g -

a

L

9

.

I

!

'

I

!L

!

l

[n1

..__

___ [ _ .[w - _ _t

w

j _._ am

tin.q

u

4

G f, -

H

GL '"/ .' G'.'E 7'

. )y

,

--

. %'s

e

,

-

-

74 -l! *

.

a-

p

fr

p

_G/

9,' G l

'. ~, gk

l

__

_

_

_

_

_ _ ,12 4- ane

s

s

. ,

0

fmi

F

, % w ,.

s-

w

u

>

t. ,

-m+.

t

a

y

y

7

a

I n ez co n is

p;24

ss

,,

s

m.

.-

Vr

_ ; _-

--.

.-

-

-

-

_

---

-

-

__

I wc i car e

v

~. y -)

~<g ,,:c ,.. '.+., _

p; m,l

o

'

%

r .. l< .

k

j Q' 12 si at - ?- F

  • .>m.

,.

-, s

T:.%

T

f

sv w

M'~

.. ,%.-

.

. , . + >, ,'m. , .

s

.

.

..

..

, 'h,.

L

6L -/-// 7/. 2/ E/

"%

N

'

.,.-

".?.

k,I ' 1'..

f

  1. !m.

Q

t,,,

,

5

%

J

.,)

&l CL sG !/

') h3 ' '

\\D

>

[

s ,u %

'

l

r[g- hk

~%., t

-

., %w%s , c ,

-

?

n. yl

l

l'

i

l

s! x-'w mz o

-

,,e.<

.,q,

p

_

,

_=_-~.----

-

- . .-

.,,,

.'

,f_.

  • ;,

es -'

W4

'g

g

l [glj

{

..__ _

. u;.

s 3

,. g % ,- c ..

_, -

m

-.,y

m

s

3

S

D

.J

n, . . - .

.i

O

h,

n;>

. c

E _',5 - -

Q Q-

g

4q>

es

.:p p or? W w

.,.**-j

u

,.

s

r

,,

,'. -

4

>

h

W

h

l

)

?)-? ? 'I

'&- PE - S

-

  • 6,

~* . , y,

s

.,;m-

z -w-

._.

.__

_ _

.

-._

_ _ _

_c-3 -i- a

M >? p

- _y

y'

5

7

,p

.

a

,

3 y?y

m ,.

~

m'

3*(y

,,> %m *-f

h.-~l _

_-nau

\\s

Q

q

~

W F- S

  • / r? 6

k v . ~,_ _

_

. - _ _ _

_

_ _j_

. . _ _

_

._

_

v

, ' ' . -

. ~

x

.

\\ %," y

m,n

ma

,.

g

a

a

r

,

r

x~

a

,

.

y

n

,*..' n

p

}

l2+>t-s je r? >

ty

y

c.,<

p

,

.>

r

c'

--*A.,

g,

."

" A ,&

E c:;

y

l u-%5

@si e

,

c

-

y s%

<,

-

,9y

-

_

_

s

C

{

'p

. ,w f E

,' y")'

'J '

d

_

-g.

n=,s

Q

a

u

a

,

! -,

ws

o

-

Y

N% _

~

~

~

~

,

-~,v,fc

// >;l

El

S] l @ .?2 t

@ az .3

g

p

.

.fJ

-

--

__

C'

M

' m.y

  • "w-"_,

~

s.

\\ Wj4

N 7# e.)

a _g ;.

___ _ _

[__[__

. _ -

..

_ _ _

[

q_

___

,,' g,

>f,. "J-,J N,

%

, ,_~.

,

u~

~

._. .

__

%

m

e

->

-v

r

s

_ _ _ _ _

'*4g

p

s'

i

-

\\

e -(g

.*h

M

/

.q

_ _ _ _

_ _ _. _ _ _ .

__

_

. _ _ _

_

._

__

. _ _

._

. . .

--

__

.__

_

~ .; a.,, s'-

- _ .

_ _ _

. - _

. . _ , . _

.

__

- . _ .

__

__

__

-

.-

-

>

%

,_,,_

__

___

_ _ _ _

_ _

,-

, _

_

. _ _

, _ .

.__

_ , _ _

D ,. ,, q ,'*'g

,

C.

y,

%

I

_ _ . _ _ , _.. _ _ _ , _ _ _ _ .

___

.

n

m '- u

,

, > .

%-

%, m_ -

%

3

_a_

_

_, _

4

-

- - -

. - - - -

.

s __L. _ - __L___

_

__

_

_i_

__

_

_.

s

_

._ _

s

_

_

.-

. _

t ___L_

!

okN

l

[. . .

. _ . _ . -

- - - . . -

. -

-

- - - -

ll

[

L1

-f.

l

L

l

I

I

i

N

[

l

[

[

l

I'

I

N

T

s.

' ' .

I

l.

I

I

Il

__l

'

>

.

!

[L .

I

l

!)

{

i

l

~

1

t

i

'

>

_z

_

i~f_ ~

"

-

i

l.

.

- I

il -

I

'I

i

[

i

-

.-

..

. .

.

..

-

.

,

A'

L

'N

.

^1,

}

(:

A

-

-

c

d

i...

G

.*

-

.

,

4

.)

1
},

h

d

,

,

.: ::

$Y

'I~

.

9

}I

.I'

~

' t, jhf

S

'

1

n

.

s

- .

4

s

,5

3,=

' t

,c:

,

<;

a-

e

<

4. 2, ' ,

";-

7

'4

"%

s

,'

,

-

.

3

j's

-a

)

' . ' -

i

%

.t

(

x

v.

^

-

s

  • .)

,G

  • e

N

s.

3

\\

sN

<

,

,

4 .

m] g

s .

\\)

t*

',.,3

- *

}' }.. )'

f.

P.

A

g

,

-

g,

.

c.

..

i

- ,,

,

.

s

,.

a

s

(

% ?x.

  • -)

j

t.

, . -

j

d

t

  1. h a, I#

J

4

- *

,3 ,I,

,3.=.-

...[ u/

,-

1i ' i -

.$

a

=

'.-

g

3

J

4

2

's

>

t.-

e.

s a

3

> .J .'

)2

'

r

'# k

I

,D

q

}

>

0

'1

x) b *'.

1

i

y

(f

(

-.

-

4

_,

s

y

-f

-

-c ,4. y

t

s

n

e<-

.

2

'

3. ,. ,

a

,

s

s

i

n. .n .

>> e

,;

s

R.

(-

'4

g

4 -

f .

I

' ~ . < ' '

a,

,

Q {',,a

.,

$ j '.

,

A

I

'

'

,,

,>

<

1

,.

g

'

s

, .-

N

.

W -

,41 I

t

u

.,

,

  1. -

,

(e

'2)

,'e

t

)

V

.

?.

,'4

w

a

,4

,

  • p,
.tj

. ,

. . .

's

%

--

s

,

-j

y '

"3

.-

'

'*

e

,'

a (+

.'*

~t'

.. , *

,,

(

't

  1. .

$'

.J

,

  • j ., ' ., -

e

'

s

-

- -

.*

4

.

,

x

. , . f

.-

s

.-

,, ,; -

d

-+

y ' l

'e I( ~ ;^

.

c

'*

^

-

2'.?

( ,, ,j..e1

  • ;,.

,l.

'

l

L

. !

i

O .

  • *

,d

- ,

I

i

1-

i-

!'

!

'

'

L