ML19320A728
| ML19320A728 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Marble Hill |
| Issue date: | 06/20/1980 |
| From: | James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | Shields S PSI ENERGY, INC. A/K/A PUBLIC SERVICE CO. OF INDIANA |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007020548 | |
| Download: ML19320A728 (1) | |
Text
-
1 na as UNITED STATES Ib NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 8
o REGION 111
- a y
799 ROOSEVELT ROAD
\\.....,o #
GLEN ELLYN, ILLINOIS 60137 Rf0N 20 hsf Do ket No. 50-546 Docket No. 50-547 Public Service of Indiana ATTN:
Mr. S. W. Shields Senior Vice President Nuclear Division 1000 East Main Street Plainfield, IN 46168 Gentlemen:
This IE Circular No. 80-15 is forwarded for information. No written response to this circular is required.
If you have any questions related to this matter, please contact this office.
Sincerely, b-a James G. Keppler Director
Enclosure:
IE Circular No. 80-15 cc w/ enc 1:
Mr. Steve J. Brewer, Nuclear Safety and Licensing Supervisor Central Files Director, NRR/DPM Director, NRR/ DOR PDR Local PDR NSIC TIC LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae Mr. Dave Martin, Office of the Attorney General Mr. John R. Galloway, Staff Director, Environment, Energy and Natural Resources Subcommittee 20 &[
Pr
~
s SSINS No.: 6835 i
Accession No.:
UNITED STATES 8005050073 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION OFFICE OF INSPECTION AND ENFORCEMENT WASHINGTON, D. C.
20555 June 20, 1980 IE Circular No. 80-15 LOSS OF REACTOR COOLANT PUMP COOLING AND NATURAL CIRCULATION C00LDOWN Description of Circumstances:
This Circular contains information on the St. Lucie Unit 1 response to a total loss of component cooling water (CCW) flow to reactor coolant pumps.
Pres-surizer level and primary system pressure response indicate that voids were formed in the reactor vessel during the ensuing natural circulation cooldown.
The void was believed to have been steam in the area located directly under the reactor vessel head.
At time 0226 on June 11, 1980 with St. Lucie Unit 1 at full power, an electrical short acrosr. a solenoid valve terminal board caused one of two series containment isolation valves in the CCW return from all reactor coolant pumps (RCP) to fail shut.
The terminal short resulted from environmental effects of a minor steam leak in the immediate vicinity of the solenoid valve.
After unsuccessful attempts to restore CCW flow, the reactor was tripped manually at time 0233. Within two minutes, all four RCPs were also manually tripped.
A natural circulation cooldown was initiated at approximately 0300.
Component cooling water flow to RCPs was restored at 0400.
The solenoid operated air valve whose terminal board had shorted was bypassed with a temporary air line to reopen the CCW valve (HCV-14-6).
Although variations in seal leakoff flowrates were observed, the seals on the four idle RCPs did -
not fail.
St. Lucie has Byron Jackson reactor coolant pumps with three stage mechanical seals plus a vapor seal.
Controlled reactor coolant bleedoff flow is used for seal cooling and lubrication.
The pumps do not have a seal water injection system.
The natural circulation cooldown continued uneventfully until after time 0600.
The highest cooldown rate achieved was approximately 65 to 70 F per hour.
Between 0600 and 0630 RCS pressure was reduced from 1140 to 690 psi by charging water through the pressurizer euxiliary spray line.
Pressurizer level increased rapidly around 0700 while charging via the auxiliary spray line.
Pressurizer level continued variations for approximately five hours while the cooldown and depressurization continued.
When charging was shifted to the RCS loops, pressurizer level decreased at rates lower than the rates of increase in level when charging through the auxiliary spray line.
During a two minute interval while charging into the pressurizer auxiliary spray liric at 88 gpm, pressurizer level rose at a rate approximately ten times greater than the charging flowrate.
o IE Circular No. 80-15 June 20, 1980
'4 Page 2 of 4 The cause of pressurizer level variations appears to be formation of a steam void in the reactor head area due to a temperature lag with respect to bulk coolant temperature that developed because of insufficient cooling flow in that area during natural circulation cooldown.
Gas concentration in a 0730 RCS sample was determined by the licensee to be 32 cc/kg hydrogen and 16 cc/kg nitrogen. These concentrations were not high enough to cause a significant volume of gas to come out of solution.
The indicated subcooling margin (Tsat - Thot) ranged between 220 and 150 F when the reactor head steam void developed between 0600 and 0700.
The minimum required subcooling of 50 F was not approached during the cooldown until around time 1219 at a pressurizer pressure of approximately 110 psig.
An annotated record of pressurizer level is enclosed only to illustrate the high amplitudes and rates of pressurizer level variations.
Insufficient information is contained in the enclosure to enable detailed evaluation of the RCS behavior.
Shutdown cooling using low pressure safety injection (LPSI) pump 1B was established at time 1051.
At time 1227, LPSI pump 1A was started taking suction from the refueling water tank (RWT) and discharging into the low pressure safety injection header common to both LPSI pumps.
The common recirculation line motor operated isolation valves to the RWT were opened at 1226.
LPSI 1A was operating with its recirculation (miniflow) line open.
The LPSI pump 1B recirculation line should have been closed.
The pressurizer was filled to what was believed to be a water solid condition by charging at 88 gpm and using LPSI pump 1A to inject water and maintain near shutoff head pressure on the RCS.
RCS pressure rose from the minimum 110 psig to 200 psig (time 1300 reading) during the time LPSI pump 1A was operating.
The cold calibrated pressurizer level instrument indication rose to 64 percent and remained constant while hot calibrated channels rose to 100% level.
Temperature correction data for the cold calibrated level instrument didn't extend to 360 F, which was the approximate pressurizer tenperature when the pressurizer indicated full.
Constant level on the cold calibrated channel indicated the pressurizer was solid, but continued charging flow at 88 gpm was not causing pressure to rise above 200 psig, as it should have had the RCS been solid.
Letdown had been secured while filling the pressurizer.
The indica-tions of a steam void in the reactor vessel head were no longer evident after RCS pressure increased although the exact time when the void disappeared has not been established.
During the time LPSI pump 1A was operating with miniflow recirculation to the RWT, the absence of rising pressure in response to charging flow was investi-gated.
RWT level increased 0.3 feet (approximately 4500 gal.) during this period.
Miniflow from LPSI pump 1B operating in the shutdown cooling mode is believed to have been the discharge path from the RCS to the RWT.
After shutdown cooling system warmup, the LPSI pump 1B miniflow manual isolation valve had been shut.
After RWT level increased, this valve was found one turn open, which would have allowed miniflow back to the RWT from LPSI pump 18.
At time 1357, LPSI pump 1A operating in the injection mode was secured and
IE Circular No. 80-15 June 20, 1980
'd Page 3 of 4 miniflow was isolated.
Continued charging with two pumps at 88 gpm total flowrate caused a slight rise in both pressurizer pressure (to 260 psig) and cold calibrated pressurizer level.
Letdown in excess of charging flowrate was established at 1430, and by 1500 a steam bubble was drawn in the pressurizer with level in the indicating range.
The RCS was degasified over the next day, then depressurized and drained to inspect and replace all RCP seals.
All seals have been removed and visual inspection showed no signs of degradation of these seals.
This event is significant for several reasons.
It is an example of a natural circulation cooldown during which a steam void formed under seemingly normal conditions that was large enough to cause large, rapid variations in pres-surizer level. The possibility of a total loss of component cooling water to reactor coolant pumps due to the single failure of any one of four CCW contain-ment isolation valves was highlighted.
Inadequate control of LPSI system alignment allowed an unanticipated discharge of reactor coolant directly to the refueling water tank apparently through a pump recirculation line.
Recommended Action fcr Power Reactor Licensee Consideration:
1.
Dic,seminate this information to all licensed operating personnel working at power reactor facilities.
These personnel should become aware of the possibility of steam void formation in the reactor vessel head during natural circulation cooldown even when a high subcooling margin exists in the reactor coolant loops.
2.
Review and revise natural circulation cooldown and shutdown cooling procedures to caution operators against the anomalous conditions that occurred and to include appropriate recovery action if they do occur.
3.
Establish a natural circulation cooldown and depressurization rate envelop that will both preclude steam void formation and assure adequate core cooling.
Incorporate this envelop in cooldown procedures.
4.
Evaluate the design of component cooling water systems to determine j
vulnerability to single failures that could cause loss of RCP cooling, common cause failures of RCP seals and reactor coolant system leaks through failed seals at multiple locations.
5.
Consider installation of a reactor vessel head metal temperature monitoring system, if not already installed.
It should aid the operator in preventing a reactor head to bulk coolant temperature differential large enough to form a steam void during natural circulation cooldown.
y,
.s
- IE Circular Ni -'80-15' June 20, 1980
'+
Page 4 of 4 If you have questions regarding this matter, please contact the Director of the: appropriate NRC Regional Office.
No written response to this Circular is required.
-Enclosurei Annotated record of pressurizer level I
l l
s
,i lhililIM' FESEM.Inyi Mil! :;!iI'.ill '. i ll 'iii h i-f
$I[ Md j! N h$p;;iti.
I! yi i.i'h THIS DOCUh!ENT CONTf,!;!S i
!J
.l
.::".i u,
- 1: h.,-
P09R QUAUTY PAGES
. g ui. w.:l.!ih n,p,.. %.a.
,,3fi 3
-,. y
- 3.,i,.. o g.
3 M
'..*fi;,.. e.,
..o.,
.l.! :. p'h l lydPii ci u,pm'h 'i . m' :@8 k.
!!.4 - E'. 'N N-tj r
ilk i k, N! ;!!! i!'i
' N i. :.i;!.; 'lh ;II $dl$ lui Oi ;I
'h!
'l jih IhI!.k.h.
i, I'ij!YihIfik ?!i @ MNi!hlN!!liU h!! IIII.
t I
- I.' Ii'..!i'l ij, sl:U!!!.!ij !!!i h; lll- 'lhlilj' I hlUU :jl!llh' 4!i!!l'i I
i!i: nWi!Iii 'lli iu gi: IIFF i ti!!![ !diiisi@
N y4 '
p i ;ilQ'i'!
(tg M p Q ilIh
' TIM l.$3IM ll!i Idi dl !ll! d.Illl!
!! lib hll !ll! O!
i i!6lilQ*!
iT_ :%,UM:iihlsi'i it;U I@s :ir!ihihijt.
.l Q )n {: e$
$'i~$!!'in :Pif;iifl!Bi lii$
s liMIM Ifnisi!ij ti c
s 1 i,lPi.h h f.. Idk -lih!!!
l} l!!I
- b l ik il'l l ll l I! ;;!l 'd! ;id 4
Silh.", k!.i'..!3!lll!!
l l [
lI ll 5 Il l lI hO ".O !l ! lll
!li i
i i,! l l l l! 'Id hl! II!. lll!iiij Od !!!! !!ll 1.
CP S
- .!i l !I,'!!i.k i. l'.i l !'iIld'i i
gh I
- id ;d.it: 1.:l;li!p ll l ll l
'l i 11gli l'1h !i; w%n?i l%p lty
- g n iiF
- itich.im s win i
! iaui I
i n ii C;
o233 -
1
- F-,
n;:M ni a H M !ii gj'oai it in n!.
41 O 3 0 0 T:.
s.
1*ag'.,i, !'.j'0 ':
... ::', --- b.osq., l ;vil @i,q.."..in hi lii i.
- a.
!st4
- f... ". 'J ew ". g F-
.!;l.Oih i!h p.
i
.l :1;l llf,::0 o
.c
.o 0.
i i
(
. hy n.- [jjy, p.
i
. i...,j,,.d:,.i I,,.p e
4hl;; l; ll..:IM !!h !! l l!'! dil lI lliItpl l A :iN jlj ! li jl.
i
- jWi jig h'h:P.. SWci i i !!i ilii
!!! !!?4;i i
ip tii n'i i
e i!,
0400- r..:e e.. i,... l o.m..
. t ! e.i; ii lii d..i. ;ll its.li; ll
'lb1. c. i.
l
.i gg l
- i.
i i
.bCh f di l!i I!l dN bl!l!Iij g.. jN,,'jd gjlj $
M.jdj [ lido!. ;I I[ 'Ol I.l lli l
I ill, Ui 'd if l, !ilI i.!F.lli t i "Yi:Ij!
- D iS l fi.,j'i:-
- k $l [0 ii
,.l l li { d;l [.h l4' 6,L l
S' J3' j !.
g'8 O rQ C T.l..!jip:n,'iq,Q yc otii i!i$1 iil:i!;
iL
- E$.:h"8"it
'"8 *~
8 O--'~_
to
. l.1 :4.
- .o.
- i is..
o.;
,ij u
i s
. ni ai q::
t i.
misa
!iajjgily,i i
. ! iil 9 I!ii ': :
i.i_!:inli. ti;I t j{ !!.: dj i
i:i'. ip.E :j; !,1 (o ;ij j; lllll i !Iij !i ini :-
!:li !!
i 9
- h. !iin iiil tl) DEPRE3ruasaF 060o 7
.i: aikili n.!e;-. j! iti iti: ili nji a; i;il :::i!ii! t
"* f#I * "
- f J
~
"l"im
. l.i. :tFjN Hij li' i! ;ii! !,!! ;:d i,QJ{p; l' ! :i l' i iiii s'S!i ll i: Wil n i
l lii! jk i' PI n g'g'Tii I
l l
H
!: !c !:P li i li !i I (?%Bi IT, ?; l i
d 3 ici i
e 6700 -
m :c li Mhn aig yr L li !
- i i...
i
.p w :e a T
oq37-%sh,.Etj,Clig SToP LEThouw
..e - s hieT--i4
'l bil l
ih! h lYih 2 NG'd' M lii@MQ l
i.i gag S7oP FTEb
. $ il p!: IS.)ill i
@ DO T di. d!;!9 NIIlfHu,iMMIIIiI.i E iiOQ 3 cHarenic po=es y'
l gi y$
di d
% ir.;$g
Ji. ;$ji.F
% F i
i Mitji; smar nen H iN
~
i 3
y
- .- !kthQ.ic j;ii 9;i PTtJil MiT - AM ilff ICHAACsus Pom>
A g O900.T i !ii!Di :~,.7 :h2ii:iiid:itirditiihM!M...$5% DSTAu terb.was 1
PERCENT. LEVEL tu G
l
.r-y--
,.,,m-
S-3!*lQ*jj SiY lP*:lisiNihWTERM,P uP
+
Eii! flh:i'fA CHAAitd.sh To llt IIIQ :!: !!;f" N lii! illi C!I 1:!llllt ij lif ill; !il: i !! it' %,iiW m;!;f 44X.8FAAY y:.:
/Oog-
- jg,;;,y 3
- 3;;;;.; j
- p p
jg ig:;p
- j
- , q.f
?:M iii,i::.liti y M- :j!! :j;G, f... i TC 6 ~~ # AMP heulM e
i li!, i.i.i!>$'!!@ it hia!liiiil siMWi![f' f':P.E -
CHAMS #G 76
.;,g;h
. Rc3 1. oops ji[ :. gt jjj;;g; ij;i g,;,:3+4 Mi II!ll:fd !!!.
g
..o
// d 0 -5i. i.T_. '?.
iW IIi 5.o_...; :iN.=!.i. ;,a" "*7 r o- '..'..i.ki v,.... iiu,n
.. ;u.. nu r
...n i n.,....
i ;
i E'ij !;hf,*:.1:;*~ ~* ',[N
'2#it:: ?llli '
.i!..!h,i!!'
j i.!! iij: in: !!!5.'; lli ii t'.'!::.
- ittis
- i: iiFil lIII 6 iiii laM;t!' <.
.,i I
7.:p.
it iili!;P !!;i mmpr-
- / i.?
STAnr L.Pf1 N..:M:,
- i=
_ J A /N.TEc71aN 3' I'h
'N'"'*
IT:
wai mee"m"'"3"'"e' ' :f';:4..
mel.
.j,
- Y.: j" ;y%/* f J.'
T'o A C S' 7
r3oo_f;a !!!b.f$q::..Sd! S H
.Pt t!
n om a w.r g:iiO"ffW: g, :1d's. F.; '
- --li.,)'b,p;%0. 1!:; -gh rYi.
il I
c.o 7 o::.;: c !.8 i
.. l.ty-c. ello.9"N! iii; o.. ;o.ql.oT.,.
ip.
- il.
1
.p 9.; ::.'
L Nii k,fi ih ( fIP
! !! !h
(
!i '3h l'
- 3!.d "I, li I
,: 1:ilb;;. - # ifi f!!P:..!! :!!! iigiii T! c ;!..l.
M ij :ii a::
/ 4 0p -qFj:! k;i:
.,; y; :p;;;itQ Tip
!!,; ;,y SEcu R.E
- ..i. 3;, ;j AP3I 1 A, iii
- !" @ !!i; J.. i: 1 p: '!!# yi; in:m.T..f.!;,1 -
l,....
~n
.o;,, lib
.t ". +4' !.:n!.d...>
i.
- !..ii :.'i.
a;
-m
.l i Iiii
.i..,.
.f > 6..ii n,...n.o.
l
!:r ;;.
o.
n I
..i
.:.L n
!.; i.
i.pi:;;.; %.e.t J. i.1:i)~..'
Cl; #:l%
- 3-i
- .!
- c; iii%ih 'li; i!!
i w.i :.., -.. m,:i -il'l! it 4.'l'!: :; d
' t' D/hgufIN G t
/ 70 0. -f.. p".; :e id....
. ijj~ T.
) :. ['
. oq,.
c y....
3,..
.a.
e m.
l Silh"!i!.
- p iri :I
~
i:P' : si*.iWit?'.::: d@!:;i9 ni9 P E R Bue s s
..c..:,
I;;;hii [ } Nfili ;:.i.f;
- 4iF $ jij: JM! l:RQg l!: y-
- i. ':! Yii ii liil: l!! I.ii' ilfM.r c ':!S liflM i:i' i
I
- ninli!!I!4 li Pd Ul.N.!;h I!ilNN Q.'.IdjNhi
- " DE.M
!!!:$'%i ; il siU ii!! 'l lir f lli! 11 di N%jijgj..!!b
.!:: kMi IIE-STbP R#6 Illi kl! illi3 '!htil!! l1
- ilf if lif : 1 ii
!!!diMIII @8D tM :!:! Ilj C H A A 6tNc. M
?
I :,,v,;,; ;.n,,
.,n g y,;,m..n,.p,h-trg.
I P
m
!ii, I ti i;i llliliil: :l Id'
/7oc -
wh p;...I _;.
c 7
g;,
.;,, g,g
,pa..n.:... < M_ b.
..u.
.;.o.
1,.
l, o. :1;.5 e w,, l:oI p.e l..
.s I.g..,. e.
..b.4i
,p n.
.o.
.-..i..a i:
' l,!ili I h yN' h h.4 N th *!N
'l k !ie:. l.3 hil! Ili![h!:
m
- i. 6lII. tim.hii:
i l
a i
- ::4
- i;;c iMihljii15
~
l
' h: M!ng:
g
.N.l!it
. !! !!!; il 'ih
,! lh li.! i.i IlIi!. d.'.: N ii!.'
's?.W[;$
N; *; i l!!.dt; L,;4..;!l,li: c'. ':
P/' [p, i!L ? "I. n -
';;*iii!
e ;gf 7.,. lr... n..j :..-.s..:.; <.,-
y, -..;
i "
..h i
f
.:L.
t>-
- .f.
.: ;t.
. ; i.-
- m.4. i li p
- ~
y t,p ii.n ;.e
- ll.;-;n.-
.,, a:
th p.i n,.
l Co Q
l'.
- ,g
- p.,,l.i r,
. t. oi
- l!!. :;.,.. tit ik, :.,i.
y r "::i.p...,
o.
.m d:.
,;.. i... U P..
h y
- . a
- i
- ..q
- _
.r 3
i, s p,,l p i 'l. il..l, '..I.
- p !!.':. !.,A. fti.1t j 'l.' I.i
".l
.,j1. 0. :
w.i.!C..'&.sih 4
P
- -.. il:jp.
N ft) 1.%. ! t:
.i
- i. -
i_
7 e..
3.7' rn 7
...o.. p. o...-,yo:j..pe o,..-
1,o'h
- e..
Hi.M' ilINo.y.h. o..4.... ki$
Nih :h,N hNhl ib N !! ~i o
si;i 9
t bli k i
.L N
!ll !:i'
!!i 'ii; !!i! !;j' i:;l li.i li ! l'n@ jFi !itii,
+
i l
- b'@ @,ti ' 'f!! !Ii!
'NI '.:.li:f!r !ili !P di: it? :ih ij;! /.!Ild 0;. ;!il !'h !!!i si ilifni i
.......m..u.,a.n..................
- - - - ~ -
r m
V IE Circular No. 80-15 Enclosure June 20, 1980 RECENTLY ISSUED IE CIRCULARS Circular Subject Date of Issued to No.
Issue 80-14 Radioactive Contamination of 6/24/80 All holders of Power-Plant Demineralized Water and Research Reactor System and Resultant Internal licensees (Operating Contamination of Personnel and Construction Permits), and Fuel Cycle licensees 80-13 Grid Strap Damage in 5/18/80 All holders of Reactor Westinghouse Fuel Assemblies Ols and cps 80-12 Valve-Shaft-To-Actuator Key 5/14/80 All holders of Reactor May Fall Out of Place When OLs and cps Mounted Below Horizontal Axis 80-11 Emergency Diesel Generator 5/13/80 All holders of a power Lube Oil Cooler Failures reactor OL or CP 80-10 Failure to Maintain 4/29/80 All holders of Reactor Environmental Qualification OLs and cps of Equipment 80-09 Problems With Plant Internal 4/28/80 All holders of a power Communications Systems reactor OL or CP 80-08 BWR Technical Specification 4/18/80 All General Electric Inconsistency - RPS Response BWR's holding a power Time reactor OL 80-07 Problems with HPCI Turbine 4/3/80 All holders of a power Oil System reactor OL or CP 80-06 Control and Accountability 4/14/80 Medical licensees in Systems for Implant Therapy Categories G and G1 Sources 80-05 Emergency Diesel-Generator 4/1/80 All holders of a power Lubricating Oil Addition and reactor OL or CP Onsite Supply 80-04 Securing of Threaded Locking 3/14/80 All holders of a power Devices on Safety-Related reactor OL or CP Equipment i