ML19318A930

Supplemental LER 80-045/01T-1:on 800509,gate Between Spent Fuel Pool & Cask Loading Area Found Not to Be Designed or Constructed to Category 1 Requirements.Caused by Overlooking Loading Effects in Seismic Analysis

ML19318A930
Person / Time
Site:	Sequoyah
Issue date:	06/18/1980
From:	Maehr S TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML19318A925	List: ML19318A924 ML19318A930
References
LER-80-045-01T, LER-80-45-1T, NUDOCS 8006240396
Download: ML19318A930 (2)

Text

e

..g,

.r-s.n

( )

w et ,e r , . "" - . u v wet v.sn ncent s tc.ity rovvimo*

ts !!)

LICLI :II. E VENT H Li'Olt r FXII:nlT /i c e,r na , t er.

[ ,j_ , j Lj,_{() u t s r... t rpm t en n rt At t er.cuen t a ,*:, e n'. .st,c as l

E, l] ,_l T_hL.$___lti

, p .. , , . .

_jJ..)]L,$. i L,Q ! Ol . L o.L...c,lo I o! oJ fo. LnJ.GL. 4). 1. .l .111,j_JJ@

,l G) c" n I I ' .l

, s'W L.,t,JEL,,oll_Lo.Ls,,! -

d 212.LLKDL,9L510

. . . , . . 19 I GLo,.'GI,,016 111,e._.J.8_Lo_J,G

~.-,t .~..; .

i vi i t., ...a.... .i,...

. . . c ., z., o, a . .. . (T;-) .

17;T 1 LT he gate between the spent fuel"peo_1 and the cask .Lo_ad_ing_ ar_en_is._not_ ..

8 L esicned d or constructed t;o._s_cf.emic_.CategorLl_.re4uf recents.___.Anclysis _.

L'_W I shows the _ gate could f all during_a seismic event with. v.ater_cn bctit_.___. _.

I n i .. j gsides due to water oscillations en the two sides being c_ut of phase. The p r 1 [ consequences _ are neg1_igible since no spent f uel__i.s_p_r_tc ently _s tor _c_d.. in_ the lf_L'.J l .PS01*

F, I'~1 E 9 L . _ . _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . _ . - . _ _ _ _ . . _ . -_

.*,," r .r f f .v . C r.:.

• L u... t.L: .t C *:' t '1l se.s.C*.

u' 3

• P  %-vatgF,  :

,lfJ.!,JG l,,aJG LAJO L.xJl.ll!.x.L21 x!G l..l!P ll. l @

. ,m....,, .,. . ~ ,,

. , , . . 9.s. . < < . , sa O / :.; I.L la N

L-J Ld l o11 i L

., I of, n L.9_L4J SJ

. ., L.=IJ L--! u L1J .

, i, - . , . . . . .. .. ... .,

...,,..,.a

. . . (,c; .. .. n n .,v,.. .i

.... ...t.

i.,t.., . ,r..

LfJ:.;!,FJ v .

O L M'l 13J 6 IiiliLo._!:pj ,, L.XJO L.:xjG L.,7JO l- l 9 [9.12.

u u, ,,:,....,r,,:,a,..,,.

. . ..n... c1,. ,1

[TI-l [ Failure to consider the seismic iga _ dins _e Eccta._en...thc..cank_ loading.arca._.

L7 I. ] L_ gate when both the spent fuel pool .'.ad the cask loading area are filled j t,y l with water. Analysis is beint dopet tp_.dctermin_e. the :redif._icILt_len_.ne.edsi_

mI to satisfy _ceist.ic categotv I regt'it ements.

, 0II!

. . ..,....... t , . ..,o,.,.....

r ,>

EID. La l0 L. oJ_o Lo.,l ,1 N/A l LAJU.LDrs_ inn _mtew _ _ ._J me & g . .. . ,,g. y.O g l 7.\ ? t, i., ( ., ..g Lt f.*,,

m l __ j EEJ- L3J

,o..t... LzJ'.yL_

.;; , . ." Nh_____.__ ._._j ~ "

z, ,, ,.s ... . I ..?

L'_LU i o! _olof uf L ._ _ _ El^

._. . .__ _ -J

...m ". .6 9 F i IIa ,ol_0La,M, L J ruA.__ __ .

J

. . , , . , . . , 7,:

. . . .. . . . - .@_p .

I > 1.4 L. .zf A, .,__ . . . .__.__ _N./.o_. I w -

3w .,

(3 ,,,.c.c, ...t, .

O,. L,HJ$ L___._ .

___tilA . I I ! ! ! ! I ' ' !l_LL!

k.

.u....,,,....-,,,p, Steve R. Mcehr ,...,,, t. 615-84 2-020 5

{~ *# 39A ,

r=

g . . no T:nnegoce Valley Authcrity Sequoynh Nuclear Plant LER SUPPLEN.NTAL INFORMATION SQRO-50-327/ 8045 Technical Specification Insolved 6.'9.1. 12.1

' Reported Under Technical Specification 6.9.1.12.1 Date.of Occurrence: ~5/9/80 Time of occurrence: 1745 CDST Unit 1 Tdentificatien and Dencription of Occurrence The gate between the spent fuel pool and the cask leading area is not destgr.ed or constructed to selsnic category I requirceents as' required by Reg. Cuide

-1.13. Analysis shews that under seismic loading this gate could fail if water was present on both sides of the gate.

Conditions Prior to Occurrence Unit 1 in Mode 4 below 350 0F during system heatur.

Acticn specified in the Technical Specification Surveillance Requirementa due to inoperable equipment.

N /. .

Apparent Cause of Occurrenct Overlooked in the seismic analysis.

Analysie of Occurrence _

No danger to public health and safety.

Corrective Acti tn The Mechanical Engineering Branch is in the process of a design modification to correct the deficiency.

raflure Data N/A lt 1 .

i*

I i

+ --