ML19280B554

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comments on 810730 IE Rept, Adequacy of IE Investigation 50-358/80-09 of William H Zimmer Nuclear Power Station. Factual Inaccuracies May Exist in IE Rept.Detailed Comments Will Follow
ML19280B554
Person / Time
Site: Zimmer
Issue date: 09/17/1981
From: Dircks W
NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
To: Palladino N
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML19280B555 List:
References
NUDOCS 8112080185
Download: ML19280B554 (2)


See also: IR 05000358/1980009

Text

'

[pannc.

-

u

'o

UNITED S TAl cS

-

Ehe( Eh

NUCLEAR REGULAYORY COMMISSION

E

wAssmcias p.c.20ns

, * - ,

  • ...+

5eptember 1/,1981

MEMORANDUM FOR: C.'nirman rallacino

FROM-

William J. Dircks

Executive Director for Operations

SLC 5CT-

IULY 30,1981 OIA REPOP.T, " ADEQUACY OF IE INVESTIGATION

0-358/80-09 AT THE WILLIAM H. ZIMMER NUCLEAR POWER

STATION"

Gr DIA findings and supporting arguments contained in the August 7,1981

r.:emwandum, J. Cummiags to the Commissioners. disturb me deeply.

I am

'urced to conclude thct OIA may not clearly understand the NRC mission or

prioriti:s, nor tiie processes and controls involved in the construction of

a nrclear power plant.

I am unable to conclude that the OIE investigation

of Applegate's allegations was unsatisfactory.

Our gcal for plants under construction is tc :nsure that they are constructed

in 3 manner to provide adequate public protection efter they are licensed

to operate. We attempt to ensure that all potential construction defects,

irrespective of how they are iden::ified, are adequately corrected prior to

the operation of a nuclear power plant. To that end, the optimal use of our

?cscurces is achieved wher identified defects are verified to be in a

utility's corrective action system. The potential for further reduction

of risk to the public is not commensurate with the incremental resources

required to broaden the depth and breadth of this type of investigation as

suggested in the OIA report.

I have been informed there are factual inaccuracies in the OIA report.

I

will be forward'ir,g our detailed comments on the OIA report in a separate

remorandum.

-?.EC'3 c m u_

Willi .,. J. Dircks

.,, e p g n . g

Executive Director for

-

Operations

cc: See next page

CONTACT:

T. L. Harp.:ter, IE

49-24774

8112000185 811116

IE

ADOOK 05000358

CF

<

,.

-

. . -

Chairman Palladino

2-

-

cc: Commi;sioner Gilinsky

Commissioner Bradford

Ccmmissioner Ahearne

Commissioner Roberts

SECY

OPE

OGC

OIA

-

e