ML19242B509
| ML19242B509 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Rancho Seco |
| Issue date: | 06/20/1979 |
| From: | Bickwit L NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19242B477 | List: |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 SECY-79-051-B, SECY-79-51-B, SECY-A-79-051B, SECY-A-79-51B, NUDOCS 7908080627 | |
| Download: ML19242B509 (2) | |
Text
.
'A37*0 5ilh.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ADJUDICATORY 1 TEM'-
June 20, 1979 StCY.A 9-s.l3 CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM F0~:
The Cc--dssioners Frcm:
I.eonard 31c' git, Jr., General Counsel r
Subject:
?.evised Dra"t Order in F.ancho Secc*
D _' s w~ n s s ' ' n -
'u.. e
.a ~. ~w a C ".a C' C.~' a..' ~.. =..* *. a. c t s.- =. 'I
- s _* * ".s
.. a ?. =. '. ".
^
.w v.
A us _.4
..s
,aa c..e. e e o Co mm_4 s.y e.,..a..,s c c. e. s.
.,. e 4..d _
-Q *,e -
/e u..d a..y, l _4.,,. 4.,,.e
.S d
4 A b a.e. A dela 4cns av,a.
u
, 4 n_4,,.g o t.
w s e c
- 4./ a. _l,t,.
'."k.. a.
o s *e
..m a, 7 a.
w
.v
.. y
.a. A d_4
- 4 c n 4 s
- M. e e. e.,t _ s _4 e n f a.n a.e.
_4 n.P - m a ~., 4 ~ a.1 4
m v.
q2, -
4,.
~ m.o.
O
,/. w. a.
w. 4 a. # 4
- c.c
..w. a. C, -,4.s4..
w.
y._.
....e
-. c.4_...e.es a.v,,
c.o
.w. a..,, a...
2,,
. m.,
e e
Two minor additions have been nade by CGC.
A clause has been added to item (1) on page 2.
r.s
,y
.os 4s ~-
,,.,.,re.],
.x4_. w.
- s. c..o.
a.,
y e, 4.c 4., _e../
t.c e _ e ~.,. d g a.-,e., -n...
.w.a.
a
_. e
- u.,
..ie a n d.r.e.
.a h _4
.u. ~ha.
v e
same page sough: to convey in gene"al terms --
a r_e s u,2n
.4.,.
.w. a. w 2., _4..e 2
a c 3/. w.a.
w.a r
a e
S o c.e.e, s. a r. e._.. 4..a ~. 4,,,, -u.a.
.ne a
c.,,, c.,.,
.e s s o.e
_ ~..
e.
shcrt-ter actions have been completed s a,.,,, v..d ad o_4 4_,, n e s..
C m. v, e
4 w
3.2. 4 s.# _2,,*,,. _4, /.
- n. o.a v.
-a ke,.4 s n ga a.
c
.s.e.a. c e.r.,_4.,... s,..,o f a 3 a
o e
e
(" Contrary to the centention...can be taken a
.u.a.
v e.tt').
4s aa s.a. e_,
- a. A
- o.. a. s y C., d 4
w e _ossam..4sts
.a..d a.,
a,.Q
_4 C a,.
- . _ a..e.s s n.o 4
3
. w w
v,
.a v.e r..
r w
-a,,...
e.4 7 4.. e.
. w.a.
w.
...a,..
a w..a.,,.e a s
..a.. a.
v.
aa o.,, a..e
- s o,,.,. w.. a.
w a
-...,_w e
at e 7 0 4,,,, e..a.. -
.c,,. :.3.-,.,, 7 a.
.w.
.~
.m e
.c..
.w
. w. 2 C 5....'. Q Q.'...,.=.~ cJ
^=..c.'.~'_*.a.*.~.e~
~. ". =..' ee L 'y'. =. ~.,.' w'.. ~.. *.. ".. =
~
^.
y d'
qw,w....=.=,,,a..=.=
- 3. v. _4i e.d s =., Me#'F.=
we a. t.J. a..g q# * 'm. a w
=
S Y
e.
e d
w
.a
. e...w.-a
_ _e,,[d _. p w
w..
v v.. 4 a _
a,,
...a.e. a. **.2. 7.
A.. 3 4.w
- a....
i
"',O.**
'.' w a,. a.. v w
. v. 4. A.".,"T 4- %. 8'W% q
.i v. c
- a. 3
.(,d.7.).S I
- w O.. A. w.,
. 3
.,.-,..,..s...e..
v._.a pp M _kQQ_A..%. Q. %.J
-k y
w e.'.'
. #.9 4 q.
. d
_A.g 4Q m. a..
_. a..
q w
G
. a.. a.
2 "."..S.*.
,, h c n f 4.'".e.,, :
00.I-A i.,; _ 1T.0 OL..-A
- -O_A
- b.,-) (,
i 4
tj J L sj
. - s d
w 7908080
)
. Ccmmissione s' comments or consent should be provided directly to the Office of the Secretary by c.o.b. Wednesday, June 20, 1979.
Commission Staff Office comments, if any, should be submitted to the Commissioners NLT Noon, June 20, 1979, with an information copy to the Office of the Secretary.
If the paper is of such a nature that it requires additional time for analytical review and comment, the Ccmmissioners and the Secretariat should be apprised of when comments may be expected.
This paper is currently scheduled for affirmation at an Open Meeting on Thursday, June 21, 1979.
DISTRIBUTION:
Commissioners Commission Staff Offices Secretariat l C.
n EJ20 uio
f*
e a
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COWilSSION COMMISSIONERS:
Joseph M. Hendrie, Chairman y q n g irg i ',, *1 + i" 1Ar Victor Gilinsky v.
I, C \\ y4\\h @( Q O d,6 N;;.nj.16 M e
Richard T. Kennedy
.)
d Igb i
W Peter A. Bradford John F. Ahearne
~
)
In the Matter of
)
)
SACRAMENTO MUNICIPAL UTILITY DISTRICT
)
Docket No. 50-312 Rancho Seco Nuclear Generating Station
)
ORDER Sy a confirmatory Order dated May 7,1979 the C:mmission directed that the Rancho Sec: facility, then in a shutdown condition, should remain shut dcwn until certain actic,s specified in the Order were satisfactorily ccm-pieted, as confirmed by the Director, Office of Nuclear Reacter Regulation.
The Order also directed the licensee to acccmolish as prcmptly as practicable the long-term modifications set forth in Section II cf the Order.
The Order stated further:
Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Creer, the licensee er any perscn whose interes may be affected by this Order ay re-cues; a hearing with res:ect to this Order.
Any suca eques snail net stay :ne immediate effectiveness of :nis Orter.
Requests for a hearing have been received f :m F-iends cf :ne Earth and fr:m members of the Ecard cf Direct:rs of the Sacrament: V.unicipal Utility Distri:t.
The
- cmissi:n hereby H.irects that the Chair an of the A::mic Safety
.e and Licensing 5 card Panel shall, pursuant :: IC CFR 105(e), select a beard
- deterr.ine whe:ner the requesters mee the requisite persor.al interes tes and to C:rduC: any hearing which may be required.
') { }
O [, U
Replacement Page 2 of Rancho Seco Order (SECY-A-79-513)
The subjects to be considered at the hearing shall include:
1.
Whether the actions required by subparagraphs (a) through (e) of Section IV of the Order are necessary and sufficient to provide reasonable assurance that the facility will respond safely to feedwater transients, pending completion of the long-term modifica-tions set forth in Secticn II.
A contention challenging the correctness of the NRC~ staff's conclusion that the actions de-scribed in subparagraphs (a) through (e) have been completed satisfactorily will be considered to be within the scope of the hearing.
However, the filing of such a contention shall not of itself stay operation of the plant.
2.
Whether the licensee should be required to accomplish, as promptly as practicable, the long-term modifications set forth in Section II of the Order.
3.
Whether these long-term modifications are sufficient to wiii provide continued reasonable assurance that the facility will respond safely to feedwater transients.
in-a d d it s e n-te-th e s e-s pe e s die-s ubj e c ts 7 -th e-b e e rd-may ee n s i d e r-c e n t e ntie n s - r e le va n t-te-th e - s a f e t y - e f-epe ra ti ng-th e-Rench e -
Seee-deetisty7-prevides-that-these-eententiens-ere-seated-with-speci-sietty-and-ere-reasenebiy-reinted-te-the-sensitivity-ed-the-reseter-te deedwater-transients-es-discussed-in-the-erder-ed-Mey-77-i979-Resumed operation of the Rancho Seco facility on terms consistent with the Order of May 7, 1979, is not stayed by the pendency of these proceedings.
Contrary to the contention of the Friends of the Earth in their filing of June 8, 1979, the transcripts of the Commission proceed-ings of April 25 and 27 reflect no Commission intent that 3
)
u
.w-~sw n..; Y
,~
y<
E,*
s r.a \\
d, : >
es
, ' i i
f y d' ' g, s i.
[ P.4 4
a
%..e a.w a r.e~ s
.r e C a s s a.w.7 o nroceda.
w o. e
- a.w *, oi
- h e
.c o m 4 1 4 +. ".
$IC w.
a e
4 - si c.i w
-v w
.c y g a.2c*v %.7 4 4.w m o...s *v u.n.C a D-9 m,
n c C...y
'J..l a d k n
- 1. 2.d k n,
- w o.
w p n n.e
- o....o r. *.
-w a
2 v
v..
wy v.
a
..e v
- w-*
+w, 5, 2, 4.. e. -. 2 -w ae..,-
.c 2 4 6. a-b o ro na.
,a s,
aewo. s., e e,L,. 2
- 4, me au...c s..
e...
<..y y
a...a_.r..
a c "m ' v* ".. d ^ e s
.*.v^ *. = " #.#.' u e 4
- ". a.
n.a. a d f o r
.# A"*. ".e".
a ". # ^ ~.
m7 d 4 c a *. 4. s~
^
a to wa" rant a prohibition on restart of the f acilit".
I". the event
- h.a. a ".ead
- c." " ur. w..e."
- a. n..ac " ^ a..a.."..
.o ". 4 c.n b e c ^ m a. s
_e y a."a...'.,
- a..d * '.na."
. v.
=. ^y o.." ^ " " 4 a ' e 4 n. *w.
C - "2." s e c.#
. k. a.
h e _a
.4 ".~ v"
_ = *. n_ ".v.
m '. h. a " "'."..e,
^
~
v...
action can be taken at that t i.~.e.
.c r.. n
.4..
w -
... o.
_a c *. 4 c.r.s s 4.
ve. ~r -
2.o c
- w
.4 D~
..a s m.~d A e
- e n....4..o d
- e h m,
- w
.v m
subp ar agrap hs (a) through (e) have been completed satisfactorily,
-.n.
4...# c ".... a. d o.. o '
o v "..d a..# ' ". ~
. g s h.u.'.' c "^e "s. m.dda
. P. a.
r v^ r.."..' s.= #.ci. wd.i.
a and w
C a.n. L
,a w.J a n. g e n. a. n n.
sG e e wm....J u
- 4 r. ~
n s e + :1..
p-.0 47
,q k o..q 4 -.,. D
.r a w 4*D
- b.. o.
w*
- m
.m.e.J w
wL w y
v
. e
.-aw ww w
v.
s s
.3 T.n.
- b. p n,, h.d 74 w.
.c. m J 7.J *,7
'""".h.
k.d.p.Jo. f' 4.s. m
..e4 7.*
h, o.
n,
.n.
.m
- b.. o.
o V.
w
,w be iW-.
W.
W e
I4 b
Vv w
.d 7J.1 J.r.
- n. n g.e..e. C.
a n o..j
. A.e~ a 4
woop 4"4
- %...J e.
b.vs4 a..J'.4 e.[ 3
- b. o v...m.. 4.- c. 44 0m n.
an e.
. w w. * /. e. A w
Q w
s.
v.
-v
..w v.
- s
- h.. q g Tsg J.p g
. h.
yig J gg[
h, e,,
O y M. 3 99
.ie J
8'.8. M..M
- b. o-n.
U..
j9-.%.
b, /.h M..,
/'
d gy
.M.
v
-.3 i. _
v e d.;4., A.4 a. w *J v. p Aa
- a. n. 4.e.42
- 4 m m.. hu + b..o f' a
...J O D.4 m, ys.
be*
qw4 p
{n.97 s
2 mn m
- b. n a#
...D.
v 'M.e au j
MV V
.s Wew W f W
w W..wW e
,7 M. b...Q 9'% O. #.85 p 99 w e.I O.. $ T'hvy h
4
.M.
99 O N,. " h. 2,
e9. O -Q.M..T*
N 4..
h @.
b a.7. e
.Q. A 1. O, 9f
/9 I
4 M
O
. v.
.e is v
v.
- s. m s..d, e nn C a. a. A, 2 e. n
%-~
. e.
~
y.
s 4.
oc aC L.O.M ::* 0 -* m,.
- 4
- ' e n 6 %.a m.,,.. e J4. a c. m.e.
A
-e.
w.
sv Dr'~. -..
s.~....
,., ^
a.
.?. e e..w o.
3 w.'
.w. a. '.....4
,.4 v.-
ww g
ww
" q =v 15 2 ~. * ].2 m > 4.e. e..- m m.,
('.
4 p +.
m,'
v'
- n. o,
- i. C, "' C.
=.W. 4 -
--j s
a i s I
d-4
,,