ML18059A483
| ML18059A483 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 10/25/1993 |
| From: | Wong J CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML18059A477 | List: |
| References | |
| EA-FES-93-277, EA-FES-93-277-0, EA-FES-93-277-01-R00, EA-FES-93-277-1-R, NUDOCS 9311030076 | |
| Download: ML18059A483 (7) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT EA* ;:- e S ... 'I 3 - 2 '71- o I ENGINEERING ANALYSIS WORK SHEET Sheet of '-I -~#S I lllillUI w o.,. .. ac. .... l"\(",.)'r ( C.l4CGi<.c..'1 aT 1 Title '5tr~ti.i.ca I ~g(~~" ::&b: -ike M~c.~~e-' -tlu*~.~Q 1..1.le.l I ~ IE=-01ot INITIATION AND REVIEW ln1t1ated Initiator Review Method Check ( ./) Tecnn1cally Reviewed Re*11ewer Rev Appd Appd
# By Date Alt Det Ou al By Date Description _By Cale Rvw Toest By 0 Original Issue J.C. Wl'VI 10--"ltr.If* *~E~q ./ ~.aa \i.. /Ofisl~"S B~~/< ~wl.~**i..- Ii ;
~
~ ' 0 JJN Reference1Comment
/_O Ob/ecttve.
l~e o.bjec:t:J~ o{ +k~~ a"'dy~~.s -;-~ to de J'v\o~~~te
-tle -s;: f.,.,,._ c.. +u. ri=\ I 'N..+IC i 'r ~ -t.1 ot ~e rY\. o.. c:. L- ~Lo;\ e~
-+ke.rYV'\o well fo< T~ -~I Oj. f2~ f~r -to -tkce. l?e-\. l
~ES- 'r~a.17 'R4v~ o J a.. -s.e ~-\ ' 0 \.Ii o.f ~~
exte'(Y\Cl. \ s ""'v-{~c e e.. + -t\...e i'\ ~ v- tv\..o w e. t I ~s
""~c..\...~"'e~ .wL-.:--C~ re.l.u..Le~ -t'-'e or,' 'f V\ oJJ.. Ji' a.IM. e"'tev-of 0' lt" -;-(\ c..."'-e~ to o. " 8 (;;" ~~c.~e"'S.
2,0 Refe<e1Ac..es I FES -'l. s-271 Rev. C>
- Mo. c...~ -:--""e The.v~ol...)e II 1'.o" TS -o 10 I
- 2. As ME ][ I 1?12. ~d.. Appel\J~y 'I.. \a..~\e I-1~. I I
3 A5ME ]L , t "i72 EJ.. r.'J. 1-(A-Z.
. If. ~f-re~qfh 6f M~fer'.Ctls b~ 5:. T.' ""'O ~ ~ ll) k.o ~rd f.d p~(!_ 2-o1. 9311030076 931027 ~
~DR A°.OCK , ~~Q9~~~5 **, :. '. I
<,-. Ce A"'.-.Qyt;cJ 0.e.por-f C...1=NC- Ill<+ *~ P~ 1~ s.-.J~~ pzR I Form 3619 6*89
EA- F~S 277-0 f PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet _ _2. _ _ _ Rev II - ' " - - - - Reference/Comment (s TP 3fb 4 5 b. ""rte VAi[ -+~~cl('."'~<; s 1:1{ -+kc. M~ c.\,.. >. . .<<~ CS: ec.""t~o ~ Rie. {, ) 6
;s o. :Lll~ -:-"'-c..I..,~~. D~e.1r d_ ~Me~ ~,'oVl~
skQ~~ 7 a.v-e ~If\ -ti..e ~:tt.:1 cl,,e~ Skt'" -tc.~ 8 9 10 11 4 .o A5sum p~":'ol"'\S 12 13 16 17 20 21 ~c:. ~ermo we l\ ~s s.u.. b I e c.t tC> Q. V' e )( terV'I ~ 22 pres~1..1..v-e (0&1..cf~.,1 "+ Pr~M~"'/ Ce;o/.:i ...-t pr()5d1Are. 23 Tuea~e. , -the A <;ME JJL exfev-V\oJl f'i"~ s ~ c..t re. 24 de~;*yn IS ~.ppt\c ~bt~. For Tf> 31/:; Sf-. ~ .. le~s 25 26 Sfee IJ R.e.f. 2. n.. t~c.*a_ to -l"'-e d e~,'j"' cJ., ~ ... -t Ref.3 27 1=":-~ t1A-'2. 0 f Ref', 3. To defer~~~ -tl.-e 28 utlow4'1(e ~e\"'r\\*v-1~(( -tkl'-d<.."'-Q">5. t"'-~ ~ll~c..1-:- . . j 29 30 P4't ..,...~ ,.,.,_e~~ V\e ec::it -t~ be C...<=1 le ~t~tec:J.. 31 32 pre~~ure <; +v~ s set: - l "'
-+he y c.. I~"' J. ... ~co.l -:."'e / {
Po b L Q 2.. 33 34 a; .:: h?. - ~.? ( I+~ ) ~~-~
~, ~ _ . 6S .r-wh ~r~ 'b = D~s:J~ ~ ,u. -
2 = .~~~t"' 0... ~ -:-v-.s~J.~ t"<ld ,'ut; : *~ c+-ir- - . 2..11 ~ =-. I 2. ~ 37 38 Form 3650 10-91
EA- r6-S- '13- 2-77 -o/ PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet _ _ _ 3___ Rev If. _ 0 Reference/Comment 4 p : 2-S-Oo pe;: 5 6 7 c-::. r ( I+ l ) - t;7 b 8 p ~. 8 9 10 Co" ~~'f u.:;..I~ .-e... \j a.. ~s tA. V°t' ~ -t\.._.o;i- -tke ~ ~' +\ r C!'. I e 111. 'l ..... ~ 11 o.+ +he -+J.,..~v--w.o~etl c.y\~"'dicr- 'Is u.v-.dE!r b ~~: 12 pres':. v.re ~-+rl c-s. 13 14 /2e{er "to i'k~ Q'f\.._c.I..~&. sk.~+c. \...., (<c.:t '--:::.. l 's '1 15 I') 16 ?{Q - .bS<;
~ 2. / .q 17
])/f
*6 8 !;
-
- 2.17~
= 3. l S" 20 :"Fv-o~ F~ . ~ ~~ R.ef. s. ~e FAc 1oe A 21
-;-::, 612'/e>""d -+h~ ~~y-t~co.R. v-a.V17e. Tkv-ef<_'Ve ,1 22
~ -+l.-..t ~tJ...V'fO.S~ e>f ~ ~~<;, ;-5, .::\. Covi~ev-uc...\:~
23 24 . 25 26 27 28 'Fr-o Qe{. S r"\ F°'G/ H-A-1. I -8....e CoY't'<t>'ipot1 J,,..,. j 29 B ::r:-~C-TCJR.. f~r A~* 01 f~~ f"~-r(.-+IA..t ":: . 7 a 0 * -p. 30 31 ~~ t 3 ( ooo ps:. w~~~ "- '\"~ wel\ a_bo11e *e 32 then"1 owe. (( de~~ ... p~<~txte: Df 2:t"oo p~: 33 .S-h-e<; ~ S-76 S 34 37 38 L.-----------------------------------------------------------------------_. Form 3650 10-91
EA. FES - &/ 3 < 7 -o I PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet _ _ J/- ___ Rev 1 _o_ _ __ Reference/Comment ~
£.o 4 10.~s ~nJvs-:-s de.VV\c'A.c::h*at"e& -+\..& -t\....e ~r~(\t\.:ny
<<STr-e. .Ss~~ '\'VI -+ke i:..J.... I""' ~cl. -th. e ..- w ~I\ a..r~
5 VY\<(. l'V'I <J 6 w ~ th.; V\ +he C~ d e a. l l o"" a b I e . Tu e 7 iv\ A ..... :-,.,., "'4.."""' s+H:." Sc; ',,, +ef;ls~ t I """ -t\...~ v.rv:u:."' ~IA e.o( B 9 s- c:~ ~ 0 "' 's- 6 -+ 2. * ~ ~ 8. ts !< c:, ,' c.....> h ~ c.h ('~ 10 c.veil beloGJ -tke. Y'Y\a.tev-~~ s+re~4+l- -{?ov -t~e 11 S $. ~I b Sf., l"k (e~i; ~tee.\ .J:: ~ ic. clrc. ~)..., -fe~p>Y41u~ 12
~~ bc...ck:I ;.,-.7 s~"'1+~ o{' -the Vl"-"1.ct.-.:- ... eo{
13 cy/.'1.1.deV' ex.ceeds --t-i-12 f:.?_e-(. s s.--f~p""'-lo..+~c.l 14 15 v~\u..e.
- 16 17 Bee~~ ~f -+/,..a.ve .~ ~e~'iA..Ji.'/ 11 {) s4r'l.l.c.~r~
res -t ra ~~'*- ~ -+ t...L -t ~ ~ 0 ~ e If,.,. -t-"'e 'S~ C.f.J"1'\ da r y
~+r.e!.>~S GiV"e '"'s:'7.,..~{ *'~"'-t.
20 21 22 tt ~s ~c...(u.d~cJ.. fl..i~t f-1.._e. mAc~~"'"eo( 'fi...eY'"wi.*14J.elf 23
'\S ~de4'-'~ -{-rr- ~ (.vd- e11e ~e\ cyc.Je.
24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 37 38 L-------------------------------------------------------------------~~ Form 3650 10-91
A ftfl. ct:fV' ~ - PAjt! rot" !;
\
I 1. I I
NUCLEAR OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT Document Review Sheet ()Of umpnl T1114' .1 Docum*nt Number IRev1,1on Number 0 l ------ I n' ST Q.IJ t. Tu tU\ L EvAL.1JA*10.J Fon.... MQr ..a.1...lro T~rll.,.,owC't.L- Tf-0101 £t1- t=E:.S - '13-2'1? -o/ Page llpm Pag* and/or fllumbpr S*ct1on Number Comm*nts R*spons* or Resolution I P~<. c. 3 Jr fiAY f'3£ Wo Q. T"H ~ N-1 c.. l" Tc COM PA~r S7 G.R' 1:>SX
~'fe <I- , +k s 1: == 8. t-- fes; ~ ~ 0...
Tr:l S-. To Si-+owTt-4AT Tt-n:_ Tfof1C.K THre.ho~f'L..L. *
~~ev-ca..""t:-,,,e esr.- 1\1\ttt':b"' l>f- -+k...
prl!S.SL-t~ s~.s te~s -tl.,C\"' ~ ..... Y1Cl.C>S ~cro~c... IT Bue:.. ~t..C S.
'2. PAr.C 2. *1; S,ErhS ltHH'" A.:> ~SS 0 f'\ ~ , , 0.;:) Is M ,q &) c. -,-;;AT '"'"~ ~V-0..~12ol Tt1 c:. C..'< l..' ..Jorn_<.. TtH"l'lM o ~cl..\. } ,~ l:J."'l.1 g '{ f'"\M Cl~ I(,,
,, Ii ,,
~ P~~r 3 l'T Is No.,. . C'-'C' A a._ W "' rT ,., r ~ IS £ *frr"~I..) A 4.. \~ <:_c.~f>>~-t~
Pi?rssue c.. 0 fl E: 'I< '"TT R..JJ n "" P~r&.iu(Zc_ Si-eFcS J' 4 Pf\&£ 4 THr 11-\rttt-io l,.;) r~~ WA..S /..JSCll....T"C-J) I i.J'Tc> I H c. - ~"'
' '-"""[-* ~~rC2o(__
NO~':!LC MA..lvl-h.L.Y lJ 1'°'"1~ SohC. l Bl.>T NoT hvc..H)
!=' 0 IH. C Tt+C""-E ~ue r J
-Aa..Jy T.t f"t..ti/H.. £ v. PA~ 'I 0 ~
.STerssc-s FolL A S1...J<.ol.-C. ~v CL ~C.\.-C: l::'on_ ll-l1.S Uuc...T1L..C MAT ( ,_, IH.. ..s W-0 V\.-b @ C lcHJ~A IJ.. \...(' ,
R*~_-<J u A
~J IoNfr~t;n h ~ c/ S ID*t*~
Jo 2S/ CJ~ IJ~w Coort'J'34
.. C.*
~ D*t*
o- 2-t'" -'F3 IDocum*nt "'"M>' ~u' ~C, Dete to(r..s( ,~ ~orm)l1~1
Pree No 9.11 TECHNICAL REYIElf CHECKLIST Athchment 5 Revision 5 EA - I= cs -9} -200-o/ REV. _D__ Page 1 of l
- This checklist provides guidance for the review of engineering analyses.
Answer questions Yes or No, or N/A if they do not apply. Document all cormtents on a 3110 Form. Satisfactory resolution of conments and completion of this checklist is noted by the Technically Reviewed signature on the Initiation and Review record block of For11 3619. {Y, H, N/A)
- 1. Have the proper input codes, standards and design principles been specified?
- 2. Have the input codes, standards and design principles been properly applied? y
- 3. Are all inputs and assumptions valid and the basis for their use documented?
- 4. Is Vendor information used as input addressed correctly in the analysis? _ _Y_ __
- 5. If th* analysis argument departs frOll Vendor Inforllition/Recoaaendations, is the departure justification documented?
- 6. Are assumptions accurately described and reasonable?
- 7.
8. Has the use of engineering judgement been docU111nted and justified?
- Are all constants, variables and fon1Ulas correct and properly applied?
y
- 9. Have any *inor (insignificant) errors been identified? If yes; Identify on the 3110 Form ancl justify their Y
insignificance. (
- 10. Does analysis involve welding? .If Yes; verify the following infol"9ltion is accurately representld on the analysts drawing (OUtput docU111nt).
- T~of Veld
- t *-ef Veld
* * ** Betng Joinld .
* -
- s of Material Being Joined
- Loc1t10tt of Veld(s)
- Approprt1t1 Weld Symbology
- 11. Has the objective of th* analysis been ..t? y
- 12. H*av1 adllin1strat1v1 r1qu1r-nts such as nUllblr1ng and format been sat1sf11d?}}