ML18059A483

Structural Evaluation for Machined Thermawell for TE-0101

ML18059A483
Person / Time
Site:	Palisades
Issue date:	10/25/1993
From:	Wong J CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:
Shared Package
ML18059A477	List: ML18059A476 ML18059A478 ML18059A479 ML18059A480 ML18059A481 ML18059A482 ML18059A483 ML20059D881
References
EA-FES-93-277, EA-FES-93-277-0, EA-FES-93-277-01-R00, EA-FES-93-277-1-R, NUDOCS 9311030076
Download: ML18059A483 (7)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:-~#S I lllillUI Title '5tr~ti.i.ca I IE=-01ot Rev Description PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ENGINEERING ANALYSIS WORK SHEET ~g(~~" ::&b: -ike M~c.~~e-' INITIATION AND REVIEW EA* ;:- e S... 'I 3 - 2 '71-o I Sheet of '-I w o.,... ac..... l"\\(",.)'r ( C.l4CGi<.c..'1 -tlu*~.~Q 1..1.le.l I ~ ln1t1ated Initiator Review Method Check (./) Tecnn1cally Reviewed Re*11ewer Appd Appd By Date Alt Det Ou al By Date _By Cale Rvw Toest By aT 0 Original Issue J.C. Wl'VI 10--"ltr.If* *~E~q ' ./ ~.aa \\i.. /Ofisl~"S B~~/< ~wl.~**i..- Ii ; ~ ~ 0 JJN Reference1Comment /_O Ob/ecttve. l~e o.bjec:t:J~ o{ +k~~ a"'dy~~.s -;-~ to de J'v\\o~~~te -tle -s;: f.,.,,._ c.. +u. ri=\\ I 'N.. +IC i 'r ~ -t.1 ot ~e rY\\. o.. c:. L-~Lo;\\ e~ -+ke.rYV'\\o well fo< T~ -~I Oj. f2~ f~r -to -tkce. l?e-\\. l ~ES- 'r~a.17 'R4v~ o J a.. -s.e ~-\\ ' 0 \\.Ii o.f ~~ exte'(Y\\Cl. \\ s ""'v-{~c e e.. + -t\\...e i'\\ ~ v-tv\\..o w e. t I ~s ""~c..\\...~"'e~ .wL-.:--C~ re.l.u..Le~ -t'-'e or,' 'f V\\ oJJ.. Ji' a.IM. e"'tev-of 0' lt" -;-(\\ c..."'-e~ to

o. " 8 (;;"

~~c.~e"'S. 2,0 Refe<e1Ac..es I FES -'l. s-271 Rev. C>

• Mo. c...~ -:--""e The.v~ol...)e II 1'.o" TS -o 10 I

2.

As ME ][ 1?12. ~d.. Appel\\J~y 'I.. \\a..~\\e I-1~. I I I 3 A5ME ]L t "i72 EJ.. ' r.'J. 1-(A-Z. ~f-re~qfh 5:. T.' ""'O ~ ~ ll) k.o f.d . If. 6f M~fer'.Ctls b~ ~rd p~(!_ 2-o1. 9311030076 931027 ~ ~DR A°.OCK, ~~Q9~~~5 **, :. '. I <,-. Ce A"'.-.Qyt;cJ 0.e.por-f C...1=NC-Ill<+ *~ P~ 1~ s.-.J~~ pzR I Form 3619 6*89 1

4 5

b.

""rte 6

s 7

a.v-e 8 9 10 PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET ..... ( s EA-F~S 277-0 f Sheet __

2. ___ Rev II -'"----

Reference/Comment TP 3fb VAi[ -+~~cl('."'~<; s 1:1{ -+kc. M~ c.\\,.. >..... <<~ CS: ec.""t~o ~ Rie. {, )

o. :Lll~

-:-"'-c..I..,~~. D~e.1r d_ ~Me~ ~,'oVl~ skQ~~ ~If\\ -ti..e ~:tt.:1 cl,,e~ Skt'" -tc.~ 11 4.o A 5sum p~":'ol"'\\S 12 13 16 17 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 37 38 ~c:. ~ermo we l\\ ~s s.u.. b I e c.t tC> Q. V' e )( terV'I ~ pres~1..1..v-e (0&1..cf~.,1 "+ Pr~M~"'/ Ce;o/.:i... -t pr()5d1Are. Tuea~e., -the A <;ME JJL exfev-V\\oJl f'i"~ s ~ c..t re. de~;*yn IS ~.ppt\\c ~bt~. For Tf> 31/:; Sf-. ~.. le~s Sfee I J R.e.f.

2. n.. t~c.*a_ to -l"'-e d e~,'j"' cJ., ~... -t 1=":-~

t1A-'2. 0 f Ref', 3. To defer~~~ -tl.-e utlow4'1(e ~e\\"'r\\\\*v-1~(( -tkl'-d<.."'-Q">5. t"'-~ ~ll~c..1-:-.... j P4't..,...~,.,.,_e~~ V\\e ec::it -t~ be C...<=1 le ~t~tec:J.. pre~~ure <; +v~ s set: - -+he c.. y I~"' J.... ~co.l -:."'e / { l "' a; Po b L ( Q 2.. ) h?. I+~ ~.? wh ~r~ 'b = D~s:J~ ~, ~ _. 6S.r- ~,u. - 2 =.~~~t"' 0... ~ -:-v-.s~J.~ t"<ld,'ut; : * ~ c+-ir- -. 2..11 ~ =-. I 2. ~ Form 3650 10-91 Ref.3 ~~-~

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

• 20 21 22 23 24

. 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 37 38 EA-r6-S- '13-2-77 -o/ PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet ___ 3 ___ Rev If. _ 0 ___ p : 2-S-Oo pe;: c-::. r ( I+ l ) - t;7 b 8 p ~. Co" ~~'f u.:;.. I~.-e... \\j a.. ~s tA. V°t' ~ -t\\.._.o;i- -tke ~ ~' +\\ r C!'. I e 111. 'l..... ~ o.+ +he -+J.,..~v--w.o~etl c.y\\~"'dicr- 'Is u.v-.dE!r b ~~: pres':. v.re ~-+rl c-s. /2e{er "to i'k~ Q'f\\.._c.I..~&. sk.~+c. \\...., ( <c.:t '--:::.. l 's '1 ?{Q I') .q ~ 2. / .bS<; ])/f

• 6 8 !; = 3. l S"
• 2.17~

"Fv-o~

F~. ~ ~~ R.ef. s. ~e FAc 1oe A 612'/e>""d -+h~ ~~y-t~co.R. v-a.V17e. Tkv-ef<_'Ve,1 ~ -+l.-..t ~tJ...V'fO.S~ e>f ~ ~~<;, ;-5, .::\\. Covi~ev-uc...\\:~ 'Fr-o r"\\ Qe{. S B

r:-~C-TCJR..

~~ t 3 ( ooo then"1 owe. ( ( F°'G/ H-A-1. I f~r A~* 01 ps:. w~~~ "- -8....e CoY't'<t>'ipot1 J,,..,. j f~~ f"~-r(.-+IA..t ":::. 7 a 0 * -p. '\\"~ wel\\ a_bo11e *e de~~... p~<~txte: Df 2:t"oo p~: .. S-h-e<; ~ S-76 S Reference/Comment L.-----------------------------------------------------------------------_. Form 3650 10-91

~ £.o 4 5 6 7 B 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 37 EA. FES - &/ 3 < 7 -o I PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet __ J/-___ Rev 1 _o ___ _ 10.~s ~nJvs-:-s de.VV\\c'A.c::h*at"e& -+\\..& -t\\....e ~r~(\\t\\.:ny <<STr-e..Ss~~ '\\'VI -+ke VY\\<(. i:..J.... I""' ~cl. -th. e..- l'V'I <J w ~I\\ a..r~ w ~ th.; V\\ +he C ~ d e

a. l l o"" a b I e.

Tu e iv\\ A..... :-,.,., "'4.."""' s+H:." Sc; ',,, +ef;ls~ t I """ -t\\...~ v.rv:u:."' ~IA e.o( s-c:~ ~ 0 "' 's-6 -+ 2. * ~ ~ 8. ts !< c:,,' c.....> h ~ c.h ('~ c.veil beloGJ -tke. Y'Y\\a.tev-~~ s+re~4+l- -{?ov -t~e S $. ~I b Sf., l"k (e~i; ~tee.\\.J:: ~ ic. clrc. ~)..., -fe~p>Y41u~ ~~ bc...ck:I ;.,-.7 s~"'1+~ o{' -the Vl"-"1.ct.-.:-... eo{ cy/.'1.1.deV' ex.ceeds --t-i-12 f:.?_e-(. s s.--f~p""'-lo..+~c.l v~\\u..e.

• Bee~~ ~f

-+/,..a.ve .~ ~e~'iA..Ji.'/ 11 {) s4r'l.l.c.~r~ res -t ra ~~'*- ~ -+ t...L -t ~ ~ 0 ~ e If,.,. -t-"'e 'S~ C.f.J"1'\\ da r y ~+r.e!.>~S GiV"e '"'s:'7.,..~{ *'~"'-t. tt '\\S ~s ~c...(u.d~cJ.. fl..i~t f-1.._e. mAc~~"'"eo( 'fi...eY'"wi.*14J.elf ~de4'-'~ -{-rr- ~ (.vd-e11e ~e\\ cyc.Je. Reference/Comment 38 L-------------------------------------------------------------------~~..... Form 3650 10-91

A ft fl. ct:fV' ~ - PAjt! rot" !; \\ I

1.

I I

()Of umpnl T 1114' ST Q.IJ t. Tu tU\\ L llpm Pag* and/or fllumbpr S*ct1on Number I P~<. c. 3 '2. PAr.C 2. ~ P~~r 3 4 Pf\\&£ 4 A R*~_-<J u ~J ~orm)l1~1

• NUCLEAR OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT Document Review Sheet EvAL.1JA*10.J Fon....

.1 Docum*nt Number MQr..a.1...lro T~rll.,.,owC't.L-Tf-0101 £t1-t=E:.S - '13-2'1? -o/ I Rev1,1on Number l ------- 0 Page I n' Comm*nts R*spons* or Resolution Jr fiAY f'3£ Wo Q. T"H ~ N-1 c.. l" Tc COM PA~r S7 G.R' 1:>SX ~'fe <I-, +k s 1:== 8. t-- fes; ~ ~ 0... Tr:l S-. To Si-+owTt-4AT Tt-n:_ Tfof1C.K THre.ho~f'L..L. * ~~ev-ca..""t:-,,,e esr.-1\\1\\ttt':b"' l>f- -+k... Y1Cl.C>S ~cro~c... IT Bue:.. ~t..C S. prl!S.SL-t~ s~.s te~s -tl.,C\\"' ~.....

• 1; S,ErhS ltHH'" A.:> ~SS 0 f'\\ ~,, 0.;:) Is M,q &) c. -,-;;AT

'"'"~ ~V-0.. ~12ol Tt1 c:. C..'< l..'..Jorn_<.. TtH"l'lM o ~cl..\\. }, ~ l:J."'l.1 g '{ f'"\\M Cl~ I(,, Is N o.,... C '-'C' A a._ W "' rT,., r ~,, Ii,, £ *frr"~I..) A 4.. \\~ <:_c.~f>>~-t~ l'T IS Pi?rssue c.. 0 fl E: 'I< '"TT R..JJ n "" P~r&.iu(Zc_ Si-eFcS J' THr 11-\\rttt-io l,.;) r~~ WA..S /..JSCll....T"C-J) ~"' ~~rC2o(__ I i.J'Tc> I H c. '-"""[-* NO~':!LC MA..lvl-h.L.Y lJ 1'°'"1~ SohC. l Bl.>T NoT hvc..H) !=' 0 IH. C Tt+C""-E ~ue r -Aa..Jy T.t f"t..ti/H.. £ v. PA~ 'I 0 ~ J .STerssc-s FolL A S1...J<.ol.-C. ~v CL ~C.\\.-C: l::'on_ ll-l1.S Uuc...T1L..C MAT (,_, IH....s W-0 V\\.-b @ C lcHJ ~A IJ.. \\...(', I oNfr~t;n h ~ c/ S I D*t*~ / I J~w Coort'J'34 Jo 2S CJ~ .. C.* ~ D*t* o-2-t'" -'F 3 I Docum*nt "'"M>' ~u' ~C, Dete to(r..s(,~

TECHNICAL REYIElf CHECKLIST EA - I= cs -9} -200-o/ REV. _D __ Pree No 9.11 Athchment 5 Revision 5 Page 1 of l This checklist provides guidance for the review of engineering analyses. Answer questions Yes or No, or N/A if they do not apply. Document all cormtents on a 3110 Form. Satisfactory resolution of conments and completion of this checklist is noted by the Technically Reviewed signature on the Initiation and Review record block of For11 3619.

1.

Have the proper input codes, standards and design principles been specified?

2.

Have the input codes, standards and design principles been properly applied?

3. Are all inputs and assumptions valid and the basis for their use documented?

{Y, H, N/A) y

4.

Is Vendor information used as input addressed correctly in the analysis? Y __ _

5.

If th* analysis argument departs frOll Vendor Inforllition/Recoaaendations, is the departure justification documented?

6.

Are assumptions accurately described and reasonable?

7.

Has the use of engineering judgement been docU111nted and justified?

8. Are all constants, variables and fon1Ulas correct and properly applied?

y

9.

Have any *inor (insignificant) errors been identified? If Y yes; Identify on the 3110 Form ancl justify their insignificance. (

10.

Does analysis involve welding?.If Yes; verify the following infol"9ltion is accurately representld on the analysts drawing (OUtput docU111nt).

• T~of Veld t

-ef Veld Betng Joinld -* s of Material Being Joined

• Loc1t10tt of Veld(s)
• Approprt1t1 Weld Symbology

11.

Has the objective of th* analysis been.. t?

12.

H*av1 adllin1strat1v1 r1qu1r-nts such as nUllblr1ng and format been sat1sf11d? y}}