ML18046A771
| ML18046A771 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palisades  |
| Issue date: | 06/23/1981 |
| From: | Crutchfield D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Hoffman D CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| References | |
| LSO5-81-06-083, LSO5-81-6-83, NUDOCS 8107080002 | |
| Download: ML18046A771 (8) | |
Text
0 '
Docket No. 50-255 LS05-81 083 Mr. David P. -Hoffman June 23, 1981 Nuclear Licensing Administrator Consumers Power Corrq:>any 1945 w. Parnall Road Jackson, Michigan 49201
Dear Mr. Hoffman:
t:>~'!.
~
- ~:
NRC PDR LPDR TERA NSIC ORB #5 RF DCrutchfield GLainas HSmith TWambach OELD OI&E ( 3).
ACRS ( 10}
GDeegan ( 4)
I BScharf (10}
RDiggs Gray File Xtra Cy (4)
RSchaffstall, KMC
SUBJECT:
Administrative Changes to the Safety Evaluation on Equipment Qualification for Palisades Plant Reference (a):
NRC letter of June 1, 1981, transmitting the Safety Evaluation for the Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment This letter transmits page changes to Reference (a). These changes are
. the result of our i dent ificat ion of i nconsistenc1 es between the Safety Evaluation Report (SER) and the Tecnnical Evaluation Report. Please replace the effected pages w1th those attached to this letter.
Enc 1 osu res.:
As stated above cc w/enclosures:
See attached Si nee rely,
()!tiguial signed b1 '
Dennis 1<<"~ crutohf 1e14 Dennis M. Crutchfield, Chief Operating Reactors Branch #5 Division of Licensing I
C.0
- (
I I
I
\\
NRC FORM 318 (10-80) NRCM 0240 OFFICIAL RECORD. COPY.
USGPO: 1981-335-960
1'
.t
- * "C4 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 June 23, 1981 Docket No. 50-255 LSOS-81-06-083 Mr. David P. Hoffman Nuclear Licensing Administrator Consumers Power Coflllany 1945 w. Parnall Road Jackson, Michigan 49201
Dear Mr. Hoffman:
SUBJECT:
. Administrative Changes to the Safety Evaluation on Equipment Qualification for Palisades Plant Reference {a):
NRC letter of June 1, 1981, transmitting the Safety Evaluation for the Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment This letter transmits page changes to Reference {a}. These changes are the result of our identification of inconsistencies between the Safety Evaluation Report {SER) and the Technical Evaluation Report.
Please replace the affected pages with those attached to this letter.
Enclosures:
As stated above cc w/enclosures:
See attached
,_,5'CoCi'1"'..., 7Jt ~.
...,._.....--......... r' nnis M. Crutchfield,*
ief Operating Reactors Branch Division.of Licensing
F l
1* l I
l
- 1.
Mr. David P. Hoffman cc w/enclosures:
M. I. Miller, Esquire Isham, Lincoln & Beale
. Suite 4200 One First National Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60670 Mr. Paul A. Perry, Secretary Consumers Power Co~any 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 Judd L. Bacon, Esquire Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 Myron M. Cherry, Esquire*
Suite 4501 One IBM Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 Ms. Mary P. Si nc 1 a i r
- Great Lakes Energy Alliance 5711 Summerset Drive Midland, Michigan 48640 Kalamazoo Public Library 315 South Rose Street Kalamazoo, Michigan 49006 Township Supervisor Covert Township Route 1, Box 10 Van Buren County, Michigan 49043 Office of the Governor (2)
Room 1 -
Ca~itol Building Lansing, Michigan 48913 Wi 11 i am J. Scanlon, Esquire..
2034 Pauline Boulevard Ann Arbor, Michigan 48103
- Palisades Plant ATTN:
Mr. Robert Montross P.l ant Manager Covert, Michigan 49043 June 23, 1981
- u. S. Environmental Protection Agency Federal Activities Branch Region V Office ATTN:
EIS COORDINATOR 230 South Dearborn Street Chicago, Illinois -60604 Charles Bechhoefer, Esq., Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
- u. s. Nuclear Regulatory Corrmission Washington, o. c.
20555 Dr. George c. Anderson Department of Oceanography University of Washington Seattle, Washington_ 98195 Dr. M. Stanley Livingston 1005 Calle Largo Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501.
- Resident Inspector c/o U. S. NRC P. o. Box 87 South Haven, Michigan 49090
~..
a plant area exposed to the sa'me environment were grouped; 79 item types of equipment were identified and assessed by the staff. In paragraph 4.1.1 of the TER FRC has pointed out that valve position indicat~ng switches should be re.viewed; if failure of a Limit switch degrades the safety circuit or provides false information to the operator, qualification should be addressed.
The Licensee should provide resolution of this concern.* The systems and instrumentation list is contained in Appe_ndix D.
3.2 SERVICE CONDITIONS The Commission Memorandum and Order CCLI-80-21>, dated May 23, 1980 requires that the DOR Guidelines and the "For Comment" NUREG-0588 are to be used as the criteria for establishing the adequacy of the safety rel.ated electrical equipment envi r.onmental qualification program.
These documents provide the option of establishing a bounding pressure and
_temperature condition based on plant specific analysis. identified in t~e Licensees FSAR or based on generic profiles using the methods identified in these documents.
On this basis the staff has assumed, unless otherwise noted, that the analysis for developing the environmental envelopes ior Palisades relat~v~ to the temperature, pressure, and the containment spray caustics, have been performed in accordance with the above stated requirments.
For this review _the staff reviewed the qualification documentation to ensure
. that the qualification specifications envelope the conditions established by the Licensee. The staff assumed that for plants, designed and equipped with an automatic containment spray ~jstem, which satisfies the single failure criterion, the main steam Line break environmental conditions 6
APPENDIX B
- List of Equipment in Section 4.2, Equipment Requiring Additional Information And/Or Corrective Action
-LEGEND:
Designation for Deficiency R - Radiation T - Temperature QT - Qualification Time RT - Required Time P - Pressure H - Humidity
. CS - Chemical Spray A - Material Aging Evaluation, Replacement Schedule, Ongoing Equipment Surveillance S - Submergence TER EQUIPMENT ITEM NO *. DESCRIPTION 2
sov Operator 3
sov Operator 4
sov Operator 32 Cable 33A Cable 338 Cable 35 Motor CR)40A sov Operator CR)40B sov Operator.
CR)41
-sov Operator CR)42 sov Operator CR)45 sov Operator CR)46 sov Operator NOTE: CR) Licensee has committed to replace equipment M - Margin I - HELB Evaluation Outside Containment Not Completed QM - Qualification Method RPN - Equipment Relocation or Replacement, Adequate Schedule Not Provided EXN - Exempted Equipment Justification Inadequate,
SEN - Separate Effects Qualification Justification Inadequate QI - Qualification Information Being Developed RPS - Equipment Relocation or Replacement Schedul provided MODEL/
MANUFACTURER TYPE DEFICIENCIES*
ASCO NP-831654E QI,S, CS ASCO WPX..;HAV-QI,QM,A 202-3012 ASCO HTX-8320A16V QI ROME UNK QM ROME UNK QM,A ROME UNK QM,A GE SK405YK232 QM,A ASCO LB8316C-44 QI ASCO LB8316C-34 QI ASCO LB8316C-36 QI
- --~----
ASCO LB8316C-46 QI ASCO LB83612 QI ASCO HPX8320A26 QI B::-1
n...
TER EQUIPMENT ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION 50 51 (R)53A (R)61 (R)76B (R)76C (R)76D (R)7,6E (R)76F 79 90C 28 31
- 34.
(R)52 (R)58
- (R)62A 628 62C Motor Motor SOV Operator Transmitter SOV Operator sov Operator SOV Operator SOV Operator sov Operat<?r Cable Transmitter
- Cable Cable Cable Motor
- Transmitter Transmitter*
Transmitter Transmitter APPENDIX B (CONTINUED)
MANUFACTURER Westinghouse GE ASCO Foxboro ASCO ASCO ASCO ASCO ASCO ROME Rosemount Anixter Wire Universal Wire Time Wire GE Fischer Porter Fi sch er Porter Fi sch er Porter Fischer Porter B-2 MODEL/
TYPE 68F13512 5KB188 47A100 HT8320A22 613DM DEFICIENCIES QI,A QI QI A,QT,R,QM,S WPHT8300~86I-RF QI WPHT8300-B61-RF QI WPHT8300-B61-RF QI WPHT8300-B61-RF QI WPHT8300-B61-R F. QI UNK QI,QM,A,CS 1153A A,QT UNK QI,QM,A UNK QI,QM,A UNK QI 5K256YK161 QI 50EP1072A QI 13D2465BA QI,S 50EP1031B QI 1 OB2466AAAB1 I
\\;-.
APPEND.IX B C CONTINUED)
TER EQUIPMENT MODEL/
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION MANUFACTURER TYPE DEFICIENCIES
,--= ---
(R)65 Transmitter Foxboro 613HM QI,S
- 68.
Positioner Masoneilan 8012 QI,QM,A,R (R)69 Alternator Square D 9038 QI,A,R (R)70 Posit"ioner Honeywell M-233 QI,A,R (R)71 Thermostat Johnson T-7170 QI (R)74 Temperature Rosemount 104-V ex*
QI (R)75 Rad Monitor Vi ctoreen 847-1 QI,QM,A,T,P,M (R)89 Transmitter Foxboro 611GM A,QT,CS,R 91 A Transmitter Foxboro 611GH QI,S 92 Transmitter Foxboro UNK QT,S,R 48 Motor Louis-Allis 828925001 QI 87 MOV Limitorque SMB-3 GM,A 88 MOV Limitorque SMB-3 QM,A 84 Cable Universal Wire UNK
.,QM 82' Cable General Electric UNK GM,S 80 Cable S. Moore
- Code T26 QM,A 55 MOV Limitorque SMB-00 A,QM 56 MOV L imitorque SMB-2 A,QM 57 MOV Limitorque SMB-000 A,GM 25A Cable General Electric UNK QM,A 23 Cable General E Leet ri c Code 263 QM,A L4 Terminal Block Westinghouse 805432 GM,..CS,A B-3
.~
e APPENDIX c Li st of Equipment in Section 4.3 Equipment Considered Acceptable or Conditionally Acceptable c..-;
TER EQUIPMENT MODEL/
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION MANUFACTURER TYPE DEFICIENCIES
)
7 E/P Connector Fischer 546 11 A Penetration vi k i"ng P4/C1 A
11 B Penetration Viking
.P3-6 A
12 Connector Amphenal 74868-A LI59-A-U 16 Penetration.
Viking UNK A
17 P enet ra~ ion Viking LINK A
18 Penetration Vi king UNK A
19 Penetration Viking LINK A
20 Penetration Viking UNK A
24 Cable General Electric A
258 Cable General Electric NA A
26 Cable Okonite Code P-08,09 A
27 Cable Okonite Codes 214,215, A
514 29 Cable Anaconda II II A
30 Cable Rockbestos Code 214 A
31 Cable American Insulated Code I62 A
Wire 34 Cable Time Wired Cable Code 2CX
.A 36 Hydrogen Westinghouse Model A A
Recombiner 77 Cable Rockbestos Firewall Ill A
-~--=-
78 Cable Rockbestos Firewall III A
83 Cable Okonite Codes L10,P10 A
C -
-