ML17055E470
| ML17055E470 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Nine Mile Point  |
| Issue date: | 01/24/1989 |
| From: | Haughey M Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Hodges M, Huan Li, Newberry S NRC |
| References | |
| TAC-71842, NUDOCS 8901260290 | |
| Download: ML17055E470 (28) | |
Text
January 24, 1989 Docket Nos.
50-220 and 50-410 THRU:
FROM:
Robert A. Capra, Project Director Proiect Directorate I-1 Division of Reactor Projects I/II Mary F. Haughey, Project Manager Project Directorate I-1 Division of Reactor Projects I/II MEMORANDUM FOR:
Those on the Attached List DISTRIBUTION llRRpoll PDI-1 Rdg SVar ga BBoger CVogan MHaughey RBenedict OGC EJordan BGrimes ACRS (10)
Plant File Docket fil
SUBJECT:
TECHNICAL STAFF SALP INPUT CONCERNING LICENSING ACTIVITIES FOR NINE MILE POINT UNITS I AND 2 (TAC 71842)
On October 6, 1988, NRR Office Letter No. 90?,
"NRR Participation in the SALP Process" was issued.
This letter provided new guidance and directions regarding the level and method of NRR technical review staff participation in the SALP process.
Included was a requirement specifying that, in addition to SALP input being provided with safety evaluations
- inputs, SALP inputs should be provided for NRR activities which do not necessarily result in safety evaluations.
Examples of these activities are on-site inspection activities, reviews of significant safety and technical issues that do not result in a formal safety evaluation, and interactions with the licensee during meetings.
The Nine Mile Point SALP Assessment period for both units ends on February 28, 1989.
Enclosure 1 is a list of significant activities completed during the assessment period (March 1, 1988 through February 28, 1989) for which a SALP input has been determined to be appropriate within the guidance of the office letter.
This list also notes the issues for which an input has been received and the branch that supplied it.
Enclosure 2 contains a list of ongoing activities which have had significant activity during the assessment period and for which a SALP input has also been determined to be appropriate.
Me request a
SALP input be provided by the indicated branch for each of the issues indicated on either of the enclosures (unless the enclosure indicates that a
SALP input has already been provided for that issue from that branch).
The inputs should be provided to Robert A. Capra, Director, Project or=of 8901260290 S90124 PDR ADOCK 05000220 o
Sth t+s' C I It
>>> n(,
1 1
~
hats<<
~
TI Ci
'ps<<pi
\\
I ilT<<r y q ~
h 1'I' Cltl f
>> ~f fl ~
ts
~
Es f r I I 7 1
'I E
~ ~1th,<<<<,'
g f qtsty ts r E'
ft
>> <<T ss ~
st s."1",
~ S<<
I'J ll stts<<sl II ls, st(s s Ifi C
I s Ttjf I I
Ps i
s r,tg fCI<<
f<<J "t
f) ""' '"
Csh
't Sl
'sl' C
1 I~ rs I
"<<l Sl C t,
C I
sf' jtt ipC( f.
"<<,)
r<<
L st Jfl ll r
1 l
cCI"<<J
~.
I irsy t s
s
~1
~I'I
~ s~t ii l'<<
VI k
~ IC 1 ~ <<11 s
I ts>>sf\\ g L
>><<C ~
r s'i I,
~
I )
t sg<>C" i
IC Ih l<< )s
~
'<< ~ '>>
<<1 I
I I
I r
tl'I I.,'t 'il
's
<< "a II 11 i
I s
sr <<
><<>I
Directorate I-I no later than February 3, 1989.
A copy of the inputs should be sent to Eileen McKenna, PEB.
Time expended on this effort should be charged to TAC 71842.
As you may already know, the SALP reports receive a very high level of attention by licensee management.
Your efforts, therefore, to assist us to provide a
complete and thorough evaluation of the licensee's efforts to the SALP Board will be greatly appreciated.
o
Enclosures:
I.
List of Significant Activities 2.
List of Ongoing Activities original signed by Mary F. Haugh'ey, Project tlanager
'Project Directorate I-I Division of Reactor Projects I/II NAME
- CVogao +
- >1Haughe DATE:I/ 89: I/T.
89
~
W
- bh RCagra
- I 89 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
k N
II II R I'
II II n
il, i
I ~
1
'I
ADDRESSEES -
MEMORANDUM DATED:
January 24, 1989
SUBJECT:
TECHNICAL $TAFF SALp INpUT S.
H.
M.
D.
J.
J.
C.
Newberry Li M. Hodges Katze Craig Pulsipher Y. Cheng S.
Lee G. Bagchi C.
T.
R.
L.
R.
J.
R, C.
D.
H.
R.
G.
F.
L.
W.
B.
F.
J.
S.
R.
R.
J.
C.
J.
E.
J.
Tan Huang Erickson Manili Marsh Li Kudrick Goel McCracken Notley Shaw Herman Johnson Litton Cunningham Meinke Marcus Rosa Lazevnick Meiss Ramirez Stevens Rajan Haughney Dyer Brach Jacobson
Unit I Nine Mile Point Units 1 and 2
Activities Closed During the Assessment Period Enclosure 1
TAC ISSUE 59116 ATWS Rule (50.62)
REVIEWER H. Li BRANCH SALP REC'D SICB Yes (SE 7/29/88) 66750 Scram Discharge Volume 0~der D. Katze SRXB Yes (SE 5/9/88) 68462 Exemption to App. J-J. Pulsipher Emer.
Cond.
Return Valve PSB Yes (SE 8/3/88) 68701 69217 69400 RV Beltline Material S.
Lee Reactor Building Crack C. Tan Liquid Poison Exemption M. Haughey EMTB Yes (SE 9/9/88)
ESGB No PDI-1 69203 TS Amend-Min Crew Comp R. Benedict PDI-1 69211 TS Bases Change-Fuel R. Benedict Load Procedure PDI-1 665528 66968 6?1708I 66551 TS Amend-MAPLHGR 8
MCPR changes TS Amend-ISI 8
IST T. Huang SRXB Yes (SE 3/7/88)
M. Haughey PDI-1 67863 65223 675065 69400 69203 TS Amend-Special Test M, Haughey Exception-Shutdown Margin Demonstrations TS Amend-Misc Amend B. Manili TS Amend 5 Exemp For M. Haughey Liquid Poison (50.62)
TS Amend-No. Operators R. Benedict on Shift PDI-1 RSGB Yes (SE 2/9/88)
PDI-1 PDI-1
Unit 2 TAC ISSUE REVIEWER BRANCH SALP REC'0 R. Li MEB Yes (SE 5/6/88)
J. Kudrick PSB Yes (SER 6/15/88)
B. Manili RSGB Yes (SE 2/9/88) 63425 Downcomer s 65330 Miscellaneous Amendments 65898 TS Amend SW PSB Yes (SE 3/4/88)
ECEB Yes (SE 2/12/88}
SICB Yes (SE 1/21/88)
R.
Goel Yes (SE 3/10/88)
EMEB PDI-1 PDI-1 PDI-1 PDI-1 PDI-1 PDI-1 66515 Fire Prot.
gA Program D. Notley 66573 ATWS Rule (50.62)
H. Li 67172 Code Case N-415 H.
Shaw 68155 FW/Turbine Trip Level M. Haughey TS Amend 69531 FSAR Update Exemption M. Haughey 63422 Redundant Fuses As Elec.
M. Haughey Protection RCIC Setpoint Tech Spec M. Haughey 67171 DC Sources TS Amend M. Xaughey 67173 TS Amend - Isol Inst.
M. Haughey
- SAFETY EVALUATIONS PERFORMED BY THE PM
Unit I TAC ISSUE Nine Mile Point Items Still Open That Had Significant Activity During The Rating Period REVIEHER Enclosure 2
BRANCH 54152 60450 60451 66000 67175 68722 69209 71163 Appendix J Review ISI - 2nd 10 Year ISI - 2nd 10 Year Changes to ODCM Rod Worth Minimizer ISI - 1st 10 Year R.G. 1.97 Semi Annual Rad.
Release Report J, Pulsipher H. Shaw G. Johnson W. Meinke R. Benedict G. Johnson B. Marcus W. Meinke PSB EMEB EMTB RPB PDI-1 EMTB SICB RPB 71449 71448 71450 Vital Area Concern B. Manili 125 VDC Battery Design J. Lazevnick First 10 Yr ISI Program H.
Shaw Safety Systems J.
Dyer Functional Inspection RSGB SELB EMEB RSIB
Untt 2 Nine Mile Point Items Still Open That Had Significant Activity During The Rating Period TAC 63429 65850 66070 66071 67460 67751 68152 IST ISSUE Containment Drawdown Time PSI ISI Revisions to Startup Test Program Semiannual Rad Effl. Release Report Annual Rad Report REVIENER H.
Shaw J. Kudrick F. Litton G. Johnson R. Ramirez W. Meinke W. Meinke BRANCH EMEB PSP EMTB LQAB RPB RPB 68153 Revise Offsite Dose Cal W. Meinke Manual RPB 68156 Changes to FW Manual Flow Step R. Ramirez LQAB 68403 68463 69210 69563 65543 TS Amend - 3.0/4.0 GL 87-09 FSAR Chapter 14 Changes Part 21 Exemption RPS PGCC Class 1E Review M. Haughey R. Ramirez M. Haughey R. Stevens Isolation Valve Repairs J.
Rajan On The Recirculation Line Removal of Org. Chart M. Haughey PDI-1 PDI-1 LOAB PDI-1 SICB EMEB Counterfeit Circuit Breakers Inspection J; Jacobson VIB
January 24, 1989 Docket Nos. 50-220 and 50-410 THRU:
FROM:
Robert A. Capra, Project Director Proiect Directorate I-1 Division of Reactor Projects I/II Mary F. Haughey, Project Manager Project Directorate I-1 Division of Reactor Projects I/II MEMORANDUM FOR:
Those on the Attached List DISTRIBUTION all PDI-1 Rdg SVarga BBoger CVogan MHaughey RBenedict OGC EDordan BGrimes ACRS (10)
Plant File Docket file
SUBJECT:
TECHNICAL STAFF SALP INPUT CONCERNING LICENSING ACTIVITIES FOR NINE MILE POINT UNITS 1 AND 2 (TAC 71842)
On October 6, 1988, NRR Office Letter No. 90?,
"NRR Participation in the SALP-Process" was issued.
This letter provided new guidance and directions regarding the level and method of NRR technical review staff participation in the SALP process.
Included was a requirement specifying that, in addition to SALP input being provided with safety evaluations
Examples of these activities are on-site inspection activities, reviews of significant safety and technical issues that do not result in a formal safety evaluation, and interactions with the licensee during meetings.
The Nine Mile Point SALP Assessment period for both units ends on February 28, 1989.
Enclosure 1 is a list of significant activities completed during the assessment period (March 1, 1988 through February 28, 1989) for which a SALP input has been determined to be appropriate within the guidance of the office letter.
This list also notes the issues for which an input has been received and the branch that supplied it.
Enc'losure 2 contains a list of ongoing activities which have had significant activity du~ing the assessment period and for which a SALP input has also been determined to be appropriate.
We request a SALP input be provided by the indicated branch for each of the issues indicated on either of the enclosures (unless the enclosure indicates that a,SALP input has already been provided for that issue from that branch).
The inputs should be provided to Robert A. Capra, Director, Project
2 Directorate I-1 no later than February 3, 1989.
A copy of the inputs should be sent to Eileen McKenna, PEB.
Time expended on this effort should be charged to TAC 71842.
As you may already know, the SALP reports receive a very high level of attention by licensee management.
Your efforts, therefore, to assist us to provide a
complete and thorough evaluation of the licensee's efforts to the SALP Board will be greatly appreciated.
Enclosures:
I.
List of Significant Activities 2.
List of Ongoing Activities original signed by Mary F. Haughey, Proiect Manager Project Directorate I-1 Division of Reactor Projects I/II NAME :CVogan +
- MHavghe
- bh WWWW W%'WW W
DATE :1/
89
- 1/a 89 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY WW RCa ra WW WW ~
W W
- 1 89
&W&&WWW IWWWWW WW WWW&W&
WW
&Ot OW WWW WW WW
ADDRESSEES -
MEMORANDUM DATED:
January 24, 1989
SUBJECT:
TECHN>cAL STAFF sALp TNpQT S.
H.
M.
D.
J.
J.
C.
S.
G.
C.
T.
R.
B.
L.
R.
R, C.
D.
H.
R.
G.
F.
L.
W.
B.
F.
J.
S.
R.
R.
J.
C.
J.
E.
J.
Newberry Li W. Hodges Yatze Craig Pu1s ipher Y. Cheng Lee Bagchi Tan Huang Erickson Manili Marsh Li Kudrick Goe1 McCracken Not1ey Shaw Herman Johnson Litton Cunningham Meinke Marcus Rosa Lazevnick Weiss Ramirez Stevens Ra)an Haughney Dyer Brach Jacobson
Unit I Nine Mile Point Units 1 and 2
Activities Closed Durfng the Assessment Period Enclosure 1
TAC ISSUE 59116 ATWS Rule (50.62)
REVIEWER H. Li BRANCH SALP REC'D SICB Yes (SE 7/29/88) 66750 Scram Discharge Volume Order D. Katze SRXB Yes (SE 5/9/88) 68462 Exemption to App. J-J. Pulsipher Emer.
Cond.
Return Valve PSB Yes (SE 8/3/88) 68701 69217 69400 RV Beltline Material S.
Lee Reactor Building Crack C. Tan Liquid Poison Exemption M. Haughey EMTB Yes (SE 9/9/88)
ESGB No PDI-1 69203 TS Amend-Min Crew Comp R. Benedict PDI-1 69211 TS Bases Change-Fuel R. Benedict Load Procedure PDI-1 665528 66968 TS Amend-MAPLHGR 8
MCPR changes T. Huang SRXB Yes (SE 3/7/88) 67J.705 66551 TS Amend-ISI 8E IST M. Haughey PDI-1 67863 65223 675068I 69400 69203 TS Amend-Special Test:
M. Haughey Exception-Shutdown Margin Demonstrations TS Amend-Misc Amend B. Manilf TS Amend 5 Exemp For M. Haughey Lfquid Poison (50.62)
TS Amend-No. Operators R. Benedict on Shift PDI-1 RSGB Yes (SE 2/9/88)
PDI-1 PDI-1
UnIt 2 TAC ISSUE 63425 Downcomers REVIEWER BRANCH SALP REC'D R. Li MEB Yes (SE 5/6/88)
J. Kudrick PSB Yes (SER 6/15/88)
Yes (SE 2/12/88)
Yes (SE 1/21/88)
Yes (SE 3/10/88)
R.
Goel PSB ECEB 66573 ATWS Rule (50.62) 67172 Code Case N-415 68155 FW/Turbine Trip Level TS Amend H. Li SICB H. Shaw M. Haughey EMEB PDI-1 66515 Fire Prot.
QA Program D. Notley 69531 FSAR Update Exemption M. Haughey 63422 Redundant Fuses As Elec.
M. Haughey Protection PDI-1 PDI-1 RCIC Setpoint Tech Spec M. Haughey PDI-1 67171 DC Sources TS Amend M. Haughey PDI-1 67173 TS Amend - Isol Inst.
M. Haughey PDI-1
- SAFETY EVALUATIONS PERFORMED BY THE PM
UnIt I TAC ISSUE Nine Mile Point Items Stil> Open That Had Significant Activity During The Pating Period REVIEHER Enclosure 2.
BRANCH 54152 60450 60451 66000 67175 68722 69209 71163 71449 Appendix J Review ISI - 2nd 10 Year ISI - 2nd 10 Year Changes to ODCM Rod Worth Minimizer ISI - 1st 10 Year R.G. 1.97 Semi Annual Rad.
Release Report Vital Area Concern J. Pulsipher H.
Shaw G. Johnson W. Meinke R. Benedict G. Johnson B. Marcus W. Meinke B. Manili PSB EMEB EMTB RPB PDI-1 EMTB SICB RPB RSGB 71448 71450 125 VDC Battery Design J. Lazevnick First 10 Yr ISI Program H. Shaw Safety Systems J. Dyer Functional Inspection SELB EMEB RSIB
UNIt 2 TAC ISSUE Nine Nile Point Items Still Open That Had Significant Activity During The Rating Period REVIEMER BRANCH 63429 65850 66070 66071 67460 67751 68152 IST Containment Drawdown Time PSI ISI Revisions to Startup Test Program Semiannual Rad Effl. Release Report Annual Rad Report H.
Shaw J. Kudrick F. Litton G. Johnson R. Ramirez W. Neinke W. Meinke PSP ENTB LgAB RPB RPB 68153 Revise Offsite Dose Cal W. Meinke Manual RPB 68156 Changes to FW Manual Flow Step R. Ramirez LgAB 68403 Removal of Org. Chart N. Haughey PDI-1 68463 69210 69563 65543 TS Amend - 3.0/4.0 GL 87-09 FSAR Chapter 14 Changes Part 21 Exemption RPS PGCC Class 1E Review M. Haughey R. Ramirez N. Haughey R. Stevens PDI-1 LOAB PDI-1 SICB Isolation Valve Repairs J.
Rajan On The Recirculation Line ENEB Counterfeit Circuit Breakers Inspection J. Jacobson VIB
E