Text

SEIS Reference - Health of the Harbor: the First Comprehensive Look at the State of the Ny/Nj Harbor Estuary by N. Steinberg Et Al
	ML083360721
Person / Time
Site:	Indian Point
Issue date:	12/31/2004
From:	Lisa Clark, Steinberg N, Susalla M, Suszkowski D, Way J; Hudson River Foundation
To:	; Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
	Download: ML083360721 (86)
	v • d • e

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

4HE&IRST#OMPREHENSIVE

,OOKATTHE3TATEOFTHE

.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY

+XGVRQ5LYHU)RXQGDWLRQ 3UHSDUHGIRUWKH1<1-+DUERU(VWXDU\\3URJUDP

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

7KH)LUVW&RPSUHKHQVLYH

/RRNDWWKH6WDWHRIWKH 1<1-+DUERU(VWXDU\\.ANCY3TEINBERG

$ENNIS*3USZKOWSKI

,ORI#LARK

ULIETTE7AY

=jYhdcG^kZg;djcYVi^dc

&,7ViiZgnEaVXZ Hj^iZ.&*

CZlNdg`!CN&%%%)

lll#]jYhdcg^kZg#dg\\

7KLVUHSRUWWREHFLWHGDV6WHLQEHUJ1'-6XV]NRZVNL/&ODUNDQG-:D\\

+HDOWKRIWKH+DUERU7KH)LUVW&RPSUHKHQVLYH/RRNDWWKH6WDWHRIWKH

1<1-+DUERU(VWXDU\\$UHSRUWWRWKH1<1-+DUERU(VWXDU\\3URJUDP+XGVRQ

5LYHU)RXQGDWLRQ1HZ<RUN1<SS

!REPORTTOTHE.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAM

'.%7gdVYlVn

')i];addg CZlNdg`!CN&%%%,

lll#]VgWdgZhijVgn#dg\\

7DEOHRI&RQWHQWV

,QWURGXFWLRQ

+DELWDWDQG.H\\6SHFLHV

+DELWDW$FUHDJH

HWODQG$FUHDJH

&KDQJHVLQ1HZDUN%D\\

/RVVRI:HWODQGVLQ-DPDLFD%D\\

+DELWDW/RVVLQWKH+DFNHQVDFN0HDGRZODQGV

$EXQGDQFHRI:DGLQJ%LUGV

$EXQGDQFHRI)LVKDQG&UXVWDFHDQV

6WULSHG%DVV

$PHULFDQ6KDG

LQWHU)ORXQGHU

6XPPHU)ORXQGHU

KLWHSHUFK

$PHULFDQ(HO

)RUDJH)LVK

%OXH&UDE

%HQWKLF&RPPXQLW\\+HDOWK

6HGLPHQW/RDGLQJ

7R[LF&RQWDPLQDWLRQ

&RQWDPLQDQW/RDGLQJVDQG/HYHOVLQ6HGLPHQW

6HGLPHQW7R[LFLW\\

3&%VLQ6WULSHG%DVV

&RQWDPLQDQWVLQ)LVK7LVVXH

3DWKRJHQV

$FUHVRI2SHQ6KHOOVK%HGV

'LVHDVH/LQNHGWR&RQWDPLQDWHG6KHOOVK

/HYHOVRI&ROLIRUP%DFWHULD

%HDFK&ORVXUHV

)ORDWDEOH'HEULV

)ORDWDEOH'HEULVLQWKH(VWXDU\\

1XWULHQWVDQG2UJDQLF(QULFKPHQW

1XWULHQW/HYHOVDQG/RDGLQJV

'LVVROYHG2[\\JHQ

&KORURSK\\OOD

7UDQVSDUHQF\\

+DUPIXO$OJDO%ORRPV

&RQFOXVLRQV

5HIHUHQFHV

$FNQRZOHGJPHQWV

HE.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY.9.* (ARBOR%STUARYISAREMARKABLEPLACEOFSURPRISINGCONTRASTSABUSEDBUTRESILIENTINTENSIVELYDEVELOPEDBUTVEINEDWITHNATURALTREASURESATHRIVINGPORTANDATEEMINGESTUARYAPOPULATIONCENTERFORPEO

PLEFISHANDBIRDSALIKE!SSHIPSBRINGGOODSINANDOUTOFONEOFTHELARGESTPORTSINTHECOUNTRYANDINDEEDTHEWORLD ANDCOM

MUTERSCROSSOVERANDUNDERTHEESTUARYSWATERSINFERRIESBRIDGESANDTUNNELSEVERYDAYAPARALLELWORLDJUSTBELOWTHEWATERSSURFACEISCONDUCTINGITSBUSINESSASWELL3TURGEONCOMMUTEUPRIVERPASTTHESKYSCRAP

ERSOF-ANHATTANANDTHECLIFFSOFTHE(UDSON(IGHLANDSTOSPAWN.UTRIENTSARESHIPPEDINANDOUTOFTHEESTUARYVIATHECOMMERCEOFNATURALCYCLES!NDALLTHEWHILEOSPREYSSOAROVERHEADANDBLUECRABSCRAWLALONGTHEBOTTOM

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR I

)NTRODUCTION 4

I]ZXdgZVgZVdgVc\\Zi^cid[XdcXZgc[dgi]Z

=VgWdg:hijVgnEgd\\gVb=VgWdg8dgZ6gZV

.%7*%23%9

.%79/2+

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND (UDSON2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

AMAICA "AY

,OWER.EW9ORK"AY 2ARITAN "AY 3ANDY (OOK

.EWARK"AY 0ASSAIC2IVER

!RTHUR+ILL "2/.8 15%%.3

.!33!5 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2//+,9.

"%2'%.

(5$3/.

5.)/.

%33%8

-/.-/54(

-)$$,%3%8 0!33!)#

(

A C

K E

N S

A C

K 2

I V

ER 2

A R

IT A

N 2

I VER

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR 4HE IMPORTANCE OF THE.9.* (ARBOR %STUARY ECOSYS

TEM WAS RECOGNIZED BY THE 53 %NVIRONMENTAL 0ROTECTION!GENCY %0! WHEN IT WAS DESIGNATED AN %STUARY OF.ATIONAL3IGNIFICANCEINANDINCLUDEDINTHE.ATIONAL%STUARY0ROGRAMCURRENTLYESTUARIESAROUNDTHENATIONENJOY THIS STATUS 4HE.9.* (ARBOR %STUARY 0ROGRAM(%0 APARTNERSHIPOFSTATELOCALANDFEDERALAGENCIESBUSINESSINTERESTSSCIENTISTSANDCONCERNEDCITIZENSHASSPENT THE PAST YEARS DEVELOPING AND IMPLEMENTING APLANTOPROTECTANDRESTORETHEESTUARYTHE#OMPREHENSIVE#ONSERVATIONAND-ANAGEMENT0LAN##-0 "ECAUSETHEESTUARYISSOIMPORTANTITISCRITICALTOUNDER

STANDTHESTATUSOFTHEESTUARYSHEALTHANDWHETHERITISGETTINGBETTERORWORSE)NORDERTOASSESSTHESETRENDSA VARIETY OF MONITORING PROGRAMS ARE CONDUCTED MOSTLYBYGOVERNMENTAGENCIESTOMEASURECERTAINASPECTSOFTHEESTUARYSECOLOGYINTHESAMEWAYYEARAFTERYEAR4HESEDATACANTHENBEANALYZEDOVERTIMETODETERMINEWHETHERTHEESTUARYSHEALTHISIMPROVING4HISTYPEOFANALYSISCANHELPMANAGERSDETERMINEIFENVIRONMENTALPOLICIESAREHAVINGTHEDESIREDEFFECTANDPRIORITIZEFUTUREACTIONSANDALLOCATIONOFRESOURCES4HISREPORTTRACKSPROGRESSINTHEENVIRONMENTALHEALTHOFTHE.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY THROUGH INTERPRETING TRENDS IN A SERIES OF ENVIRONMENTAL INDICATORS4HEINDICATORSWERECHOSENINATAWORKSHOPATTENDEDBYLOCALENVI

RONMENTALMANAGERSSCIENTISTSADVOCATESANDOTHERSWHOSECHARGEWASTODESIGNANENVIRONMENTALMONITORINGPLANTOACCOMPANYANDSUPPORTTHE(%0S##-0)NDICATORSWERECHOSENTHATWOULDWHENTRACKEDINDICATEWHETHERTHE(%0SGOALSWEREBEINGMETANDWHETHER(%0INITIATIVESWEREMAKINGADIF

FERENCEINTHEENVIRONMENT/FTHEAPPROXIMATELYINDICATORSRECOMMENDEDBYTHEWORKSHOPPARTICIPANTSAREEXAMINEDINTHISREPORT4HEREMAININGINDICATORSARENOTEXAMINEDBECAUSEAPPROPRIATEDATAARELACKING4HEAVAILABILITYANDACCESSIBILITYOFDATAAREADDRESSEDFOREACHINDI

CATORINTHISREPORTINTHEFORMOFASMALLBARGRAPHATTHEBEGINNINGOFEACHSECTION4HETWOBARSINDICATETHEAVAILABILITYOFRELEVANTTEMPORALANDSPATIALDATAFORTHATINDICATOR!NALYSESFOCUSONDATACOLLECTEDINTHE(ARBOR#OREAREASEEMAPABOVE ALTHOUGHTHE(%0SPURVIEWINCLUDESTHEENTIREWATER

SHEDOFTHE(ARBOR%STUARY

'ENERALLYTHENEWSISGOOD4HANKSTOPROGRAMSIMPLEMENTEDUNDER&EDERALAND 3TATE ENVIRONMENTAL STATUTES RAW SEWAGE AND TOXIC MATERIALS ARE NOLONGERDISCHARGEDTOTHEESTUARYTOTHEEXTENTTHEYUSEDTOBE!SARESULTLEVELSOFCONTAMINANTSINSEDIMENTSANDFISHANDCONCENTRATIONSOFBACTERIAINTHEWATERHAVEDECREASEDOVERTIME(OWEVERTHEREISSTILLROOMFORMUCHIMPROVEMENT#ONSUMPTIONADVISORIESAGAINSTEATINGFISHANDSHELLFISHCAUGHTINTHEESTUARYREMAININEFFECTBECAUSEOFUNACCEPTABLELEVELSOFCONTAMINANTS

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR INTHEIRFLESH#OMBINED3EWER/VERFLOWS#3/S STILLCONTRIBUTERAWSEWAGETOOURWATERWAYSWHENITRAINS!NDSOMESHELLFISHBEDSHAVEREMAINEDCLOSEDFORDECADES0RIVATECITIZENSREGULATORSANDSCIENTISTSSTILLMUSTWORKTOGETHERTOREALIZETHE(%0SVISIONhAHEALTHYANDPRODUCTIVE(ARBOR"IGHTECOSYSTEMWITHFULLBENEFICIALUSESv 4HISREPORTISORGANIZEDINTOSECTIONSCORRESPONDINGTOTHEMODULESOFTHE(%0##-0 (ABITAT AND +EY 3PECIES 4OXIC #ONTAMINATION 0ATHOGENS &LOATABLE$EBRISAND.UTRIENTSAND/RGANIC%NRICHMENT7ITHINEACHSECTIONARECHAP

TERSCONTAININGINFORMATIONABOUTINDICATORSRELATINGTOENVIRONMENTALTRENDSINTHATSUBJECTAREA

)NPRESENTINGTHESPATIALANDTEMPORALTRENDSOFTHEVARIOUSINDICATORSTHISREPORTEMPLOYSTHEMOSTWIDELYUSEDREFER

ENCELEVELSORWZcX]bVg`h!FOREACHINDICATOR(OWEVERITISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATSOMEOFTHEBENCHMARKSPARTICU

LARLY THOSE RELATED TO TOXIC CHEMICALS ARE NOT UNIVERSALLYACCEPTED"ECAUSEOFANUMBEROFFACTORSINCLUDINGOURINCOMPLETETHOUGHEVOLVINGUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEHUMANHEALTHEFFECTSOFTHECONTAMINANTSOFCONCERNTHESEBENCH

MARKSWILLCONTINUETOBEDEBATEDANDUPDATEDINFUTUREYEARSASNEWINFORMATIONISDEVELOPED

/NEEXAMPLEISTHEUSEOFTHE:((ZXihGVc\\ZBENCHMARKINTHEDISCUSSIONOFSEDIMENTCONTAMINANTCONCENTRATIONS4HISMEASUREHASBEENENDORSEDBYSOMEAGENCIESCRITI

CIZEDBYOTHERSANDDEBATEDWITHINTHESCIENTIFICCOMMU

NITY!LTHOUGHITISWIDELYUSEDASGUIDANCEITWILLLIKELYBEREFINEDORPERHAPSEVENABANDONEDINTHEFUTUREASNEWRESEARCHRESULTSBECOMEAVAILABLE

!NOTHER EXAMPLE IS THE ASSESSMENT OF FISH TISSUE CHEMI

CAL CONCENTRATIONS IN TERMS OF 53 &OOD AND $RUG!DMINISTRATION&$! ACTIONLIMITS)NTHISDOCUMENTTHESELIMITSAREUSEDASREFERENCEPOINTSBECAUSETHEYARETHEONLYNUMERICGOVERNMENTENFORCEABLESTANDARDSINEFFECTINTHISREGION(OWEVERTHEACTIONLIMITFOR0#"SnPARTSPERMIL

LIONPPM nISYEARSOLDANDINCREASINGLYCRITICIZEDFORFAILINGTOTAKEINTOACCOUNTCURRENTINFORMATIONABOUT0#"HEALTHEFFECTSESPECIALLYINRELATIONTORECREATIONALFISHCON

SUMPTIONPATTERNS2ECENTHEALTHGUIDANCEDEVELOPEDBYEIGHTSTATESBORDERINGTHE'REAT,AKESUSINGMORECURRENTSCIENCESETSGUIDELINESFORFISHCONSUMPTIONATMUCHLOWERCONCENTRATIONSTHANTHESTANDING&$!LIMITS%0!SRECENTLYPUBLISHED h3CREENING 6ALUESv FOR CONTAMINANT CONCENTRA

TIONS IN FISH CONSUMED BY RECREATIONAL ANGLERS INCLUDE AVALUE OF PPM FOR 0#"S SEE THE SECTION ON 0#"S INSTRIPEDBASSONPAGE

4HEREFORETHEUSEOFBENCHMARKSINTHISREPORTSHOULDNOTBEVIEWEDASENDORSEMENTOFTHEMBYTHEAUTHORSORTHE(%0 &URTHERMORE THEY MUST NOT BE INTERPRETED ASABSO

LUTETHRESHOLDLIMITSFORTRIGGERINGHUMANHEALTHEFFECTS)TMANYINSTANCESITISLIKELYTHATEFFECTSCANOCCURATLEVELSBELOWTHEBENCHMARKS

5SEOF"ENCHMARKS

(!.'%3).(!")4!4!2%!

4HE(ARBOR%STUARYISAMOSAICOFHABITATSFORHUNDREDSOFSPECIESOFFISHPLANTSBIRDSANDOTHERORGANISMS3ALTMARSHESPROVIDENURSERYAREASFORYOUNGFISH5NINHABITEDISLANDSINTHEHARBORAREIDEALNESTINGANDFEEDINGGROUNDSFORMANYSPECIESOFAQUATICBIRDS-UDFLATSARECHOCK

FULLOFSHELLFISH2AREANDENDANGEREDPLANTSCANBEFOUNDINTHEUNIQUEMARITIMEHABITATSOF3TATEN)SLANDAND.EW*ERSEY4HEHARDEDGESOFTHEURBANESTUARYBULKHEADSRIP

RAPANDPILINGSEVENPROVIDEHABITATFORARICHCOMMUNITYOFINVERTEBRATESANDOTHERORGANISMS

(ABITATSARESETTINGSTHATPROVIDECRUCIALCOMBINATIONSOFFACTORSTHATSUPPORTPARTICU

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

(ABITATAND+EY3PECIES

LARORGANISMS-ANYANIMALSREQUIREMULTIPLEHABITATTYPESASTHEYPROGRESSTHROUGH DIFFERENT LIFE STAGES &OR EXAMPLE STRIPED BASS SPAWNING HABITAT ISFOUND UPRIVER OF THE HARBOR CORE AREA IN FRESHWATER REGIONS OF THE ESTU

ARY/NCEHATCHEDTHEYOUNGSTRIPEDBASSLARVAEPROGRESSDOWNSTREAMANDGROWTHROUGHTHEIRFIRSTSUMMERINTHEFOOD RICHPROTECTEDSHALLOWAREASOF(AVERSTRAW"AY)NTHEFALLTHEYTAKEUPRESIDENCEINTHEHARBOROFFTHESHORESOF-ANHATTANWHERETEMPERATUREANDSALINITYCONDITIONSAREOPTIMUMFORTHEIROVERWINTERSURVIVAL!SADULTSTHESTRIPEDBASSWILLMIGRATEBETWEENTHEIROCE

ANICFEEDINGGROUNDSANDTHEIRUPRIVERSPAWNINGHABITAT!LLOFTHESEHABITATSARECRITICALFORHEALTHYSTRIPEDBASSPOPULATIONS

-ANY OF THE HABITATS OF THE ESTUARY PARTICULARLY IN THE URBAN HARBOR COREAREAHAVEBEENALTEREDANDDESTROYEDOVERTIME!BOUTOFTHEHARBORSTIDALWETLANDSANDUNDERWATERLANDSABOUTACRESROUGHLYTIMESTHESIZEOFTHECURRENTAREAOF.EW9ORK#ITY HAVEBEENLOSTBECAUSEOFFILL

INGDREDGINGANDOTHERHUMANACTIVITIES3HALLOW WATERHABITATSHAVEBEENFILLEDSINCETHEBEGINNINGOF%UROPEANSETTLEMENTAPPROXIMATELYOFTHEAREAOF-ANHATTANISFILLEDLANDWHICHWASPREVIOUSLYSHALLOWWATERHABITATORWETLANDS#ANAL3TREETIN-ANHATTANUSEDTOBEANACTUALCANALCREATEDBYCHANNELIZINGANEXISTINGPORTIONOFASALTMARSH"ATTERY0ARK#ITYISAMORERECENTFILLSITE!LTHOUGHMANYOFTHESEACTIVITIESARENOWBANNEDESTUARINEHABITATSCONTINUETOBETHREATENEDBYDEVELOPMENTPRESSUREANDVARIOUSTYPESOFPOLLUTION!SRECENTLYASAMAJOROILSPILLINTHE!RTHUR+ILLDESTROYEDORDAMAGEDALMOSTACRESOFSALTMARSHMUCHOFWHICHHASSINCEBEENRESTOREDTHROUGHTHEEFFORTSOFTHE.ATURAL2ESOURCES'ROUPOFTHE.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF0ARKSAND2ECREATION

4HEMOSTSTRAIGHTFORWARDWAYTOTRACKTHEHEALTHOFESTUARINEHABITATSISTODETERMINETRENDSINNUMBERSOFACRESOFDIFFERENTHABITATSOVERTIME!CREAGESOFHABITATTYPESCANBEDETERMINEDUSINGAERIALPHOTOGRAPHYACCOMPANYINGSURVEYSONTHEGROUNDAND')3'EOGRAPHIC)NFORMATION3YSTEMS TECHNOLOGY4HISTYPEOFWORKISDIFFICULTANDEXPENSIVEANDSOACREAGEDATAARESOMEWHATLIMITEDBUTEXISTINGDATATRENDSAREDESCRIBEDHERE!HARDERTHINGTOMEA

SUREBUTJUSTASIMPORTANTASAREALEXTENTISTHEFUNCTIONOFEXISTINGHABITATSnWHETHERTHOSEHABITATSAREHEALTHYOVERALLANDWORKINGTHEWAYTHEYSHOULD4HEREISNOPROGRAMTHATMONITORSHABITATFUNCTIONDIRECTLY(OWEVERONEINDI

RECTWAYTODETERMINEWHETHERHABITATSAREFUNCTIONINGPROPERLYISTOEXAMINETHEPOPULATIONSIZESOFORGANISMSTHATTHOSEHABITATSSUPPORT4RENDSINPOPU

LATIONSOFSOMEFISHANDBIRDSPECIESAREDESCRIBEDLATERINTHISREPORT

7ETLAND!CREAGE 7ETLANDSAREAMONGTHEMOSTPRODUCTIVEANDIMPORTANTHABITATTYPESINTHEESTUARYPROVIDINGESSENTIALNURSERYFEEDINGSPAWNINGANDNESTINGGROUNDSFORAVARIETYOFFISHANDWILDLIFESPECIES"ECAUSEOFTHEIRHIGHPRO

DUCTIVITYWETLANDSARECRUCIALLINKSINSUPPORTINGTHEESTUARINEFOODWEB7ETLANDSALSOFILTERSEDIMENTANDASSOCIATEDCONTAMINANTANDNUTRIENTRUNOFFFROMTHELANDTHEREBYHELPINGTOPROTECTWATERQUALITYINTHEESTU

ARY&INALLYWETLANDSPROVIDEIMPORTANTFLOODINGBUFFERSFORSURROUNDINGAREASATTIMESOFHIGHWATERANDSTORMSURGES

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

&IGURE8dVhiValZiaVcYadhhZh^c

h^mCZl?ZghZnXdjci^Zh!&.-**&..*#

AdhhZhVgZgZegZhZciZY^cVXgZhGji\\Zgh

Jc^kZgh^in'%%'#

5NFORTUNATELYSINCETHETIMEOF%UROPEANSETTLEMENTINTHEREGIONTHEVASTMAJORITYOFWETLANDSINTHE(ARBOR%STUARYHAVEBEENDESTROYEDORDEGRADEDBYHUMANACTIVITYINCLUDINGBULKHEADINGFILLINGDREDGINGCHANNELIZATIONANDINPUTSOFTOXICCONTAMINANTS&IGUREDEPICTSTHECHANGESINMARSHACREAGEBETWEENABOUTANDINTHEHARBORCOREAREAONLY4HESIZEABLELOSSOFSALTMARSHINBOTHSTATESISCLEAR&IGUREDEPICTSTHELOSSOFWETLANDSINACRESBYCOUNTYFORTHENORTHERN.EW*ERSEYCOUNTIESTHATBORDERTHEHARBORFROMTOLATERINTIMETHANTHEDATADEPICTEDIN&IGURE $URINGTHATPERIODOFTIME.EW*ERSEYLOSTAPPROXIMATELYOFITSNATURALWETLANDSSTATEWIDE4HEGREATESTLOSSESINTHOSEYEARSOCCURREDIN(UDSON#OUNTYWHEREACRESOFWETLANDORNEARLYTHEAREAOFFOOTBALLFIELDSWEREDESTROYEDBETWEENAND)TISLIKELYTHATTHELOSSESWERESMALLERINMOREURBANIZEDAREASSUCHAS5NIONAND%SSEX#OUNTIESBECAUSEBYMOSTOFTHEHISTORICALWETLANDSINTHESECOUNTIESWEREALREADYGONE"ETWEENANDNEARLYACRESOF.EW*ERSEYWETLANDSWERECON

VERTEDTOURBANLANDS

&IGURESHOWSHISTORICnINTHEPINKCOLORS ANDMODERNGREENSHADES DISTRIBUTIONSOFBOTHFRESHWATERANDTIDALWETLANDSINTHEHARBORCOREAREA4HEMAJORLOSSESAROUND*AMAICA"AY.EW*ERSEYANDTHE!RTHUR+ILLAREAPPARENT4HEREWEREALSOEXTENSIVEWETLANDSFRINGING,ITTLE.ECK"AYANDOTHER%AST2IVER7ESTERN,ONG)SLAND3OUNDBAYSANDINTHESOUTHEAST"RONX

!SOFTHEMID SANDEARLYSTHEREWEREAPPROXIMATELYACRESOFTIDALMARSHESREMAININGINTHEENTIRESTATEOF.EW*ERSEYANDABOUTACRESIN.EW9ORKTHEVASTMAJORITYOFWHICHWEREOUTSIDEOFTHEURBANIZEDHARBORCOREAREATHE(ACKENSACK-EADOWLANDSBEINGANOTABLEEXCEPTION !PPROXIMATELYACRESOFTIDALWETLANDSNOWREMAININTHEHARBORCOREAREAINBOTHSTATES ABOUTnOFTHEHIS

,ONG)SLAND

.EW

ERSEY

.EW

ERSEY "ERGEN n

"ERGEN n

%SSEX n

5NION n

-IDDLESEX n

-ONMOUTH n

n

(UDSON (UDSON

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

%XISTING!CRES

D[mOeha D[m@[hi[o 9ecX_d[ZIjWj[i

&IGURE9ZXgZVh^c\\bVgh]VXgZV\\Z^ci]Z]VgWdgXdgZ

VgZV^cCZlNdg`!CZl?ZghZn!VcYWdi]hiViZhXdbW^cZY!

&.%%*&.-%Hfj^gZh&..'#

4HE4IDELANDS OFTHE.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY

>_ijeh_YJ_ZWbM[jbWdZi

>_ijeh_Y<h[i^mWj[hM[jbWdZi J_ZWbM[jbWdZi

<h[i^mWj[hM[jbWdZi 4ODAYS%STUARY TORICALMARSHAREAINTHEHARBOR7ETLANDSANDOTHERUNDERWATERLANDSWEREFILLEDTOEXPANDTHELANDMASSOF-ANHATTANAND"ROOKLYNTOCREATETHE.EWARKAND*OHN&+ENNEDYAIRPORTSTOMAKEROOMFORRAILROADTER

MINALSANDTOPROVIDELANDFORPETROLEUMFACILITIESALONGTHE!RTHUR+ILLAMONGOTHERUSES!LSOMOSTOFTHEACRESOFFRESHWATERWETLANDSTHATEXISTEDINTHEURBANCOREAREAINPRE COLONIALTIMESARENOWLOST

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGURE=^hidg^XVcYbdYZgci^YZaVcYh^ci]ZCN$C?=VgWdg:hijVgn#=^hidg^XaVcYh

WVhZYdci]ZGVioZgHjgkZn&,,+*&,,,VcY&.i]XZcijgnJH<H!C?<H!VcYJH8dVhi

VcY<ZdYZi^XHjgkZnidedad\\^XVabVehVcY]VgWdgX]Vgih8dm'%%(#

!LTHOUGHLOSSOFWETLANDSHASSLOWEDDRAMATICALLYSINCETHEIMPLEMENTA

TIONOFSTRICTERWETLANDSPROTECTIONLAWSTHEREARESTILLMANYTHREATSTOWETLANDSINTHEESTUARYMOSTOFTHEMRELATEDTOHUMANACTIVITYSEETHEINTRODUCTIONTOTHISSECTION

HANGESIN.EWARK"AY

/NEOFTHEMAJORWAYSINWHICHHUMANSHAVEAFFECTEDTHEESTUARINEENVI

RONMENTPARTICULARLYINDENSELY POPULATEDAREASLIKETHE.9 .*METROPOLI

TANREGIONISBYFILLINGINCOASTALHABITATS-ARSHANDOPEN WATERAREASWEREFILLEDFORANUMBEROFREASONSBEFORETHECRITICALFUNCTIONSOFWETLANDSWEREUNDERSTOODTOCREATEMORELANDFORRESIDENTIALCOMMERCIALANDINDUSTRIALDEVELOPMENTTODISPOSEOFWASTEINLANDFILLSANDTOFILLMARSHESTHATWERECONSIDEREDMERELYMOSQUITO INFESTEDPUBLICHEALTHTHREATS&ILLMATERIALRANGEDFROMCELLARDIRTTOEXCAVATEDROCKTOGARBAGE(UNDREDSOFTHOUSANDSOFACRESOFMARSHESANDOPEN WATERAREASHAVEBEENFILLEDINTHE(ARBOR%STUARYBEGINNINGINTHELATETHCENTURY3OMEFAMILIARLANDMARKSTHATAREBUILTONFILLEDLANDINCLUDETHE&RESH+ILLSLANDFILLMUCHOF%LLIS)SLANDAND"ATTERY0ARK#ITY,ARGE SCALEFILLINGACTIVITIESARENOWSEVERELYRESTRICTEDINFACTNEARLYELIMINATEDBYWETLANDSPROTECTIONLEGIS

LATIONANDOTHERLEGALTOOLSPUTINPLACEINTHEEARLYS4HISHISTORYOFRAMPANTFILLINGOFAQUATICHABITATSFOLLOWEDBYAVIRTUALCESSATIONOFFILLINGISTYPIFIEDINTHE(ARBOR%STUARYBYTHEHISTORYOFTHEFILLINGOF.EWARK"AY)NORDERTOFOLLOWTHEPROGRESSIONOFFILLACTIVITIESINTHE"AYTRENDSINTHEAREAOFTHE"AYWEREEXAMINED&IGURE !BOUTACRESOFMARSHALONGTHEEDGESOF.EWARK"AYWEREFILLEDBETWEENANDTHEEARLYSFORTHECREATIONOF.EWARK!IRPORTANDFORTHEPORTFACILITIESOF0ORT.EWARKAND0ORT%LIZABETHTHEBUSIESTPLACESINTHE0ORTOF.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY4HATFILLISREFLECTEDINTHELARGEDECREASEINTHESIZEOFTHE"AYBYABOUTONETHIRDBETWEENAND"ETWEENANDASARESULTOFRESTRICTIONSONFILLINGACTIVITIESTHEREWASVIR

TUALLYNOCHANGEINTHESIZEOFTHE"AY4HESETRENDSARESHOWNGRAPHICALLY

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGURE=^hidg^XX]Vc\\Zh^ci]ZVXgZV\\Zd[CZlVg`7Vn!

&-***'%%&Hjho`dlh`^&.,-!CD66'%%&!CD66&.-*#

!CRES

LOSS

ACRELOST PERYEAR

LOSS

ACRESPERYEAR

LOSS

ACRESPERYEAR

GAIN

LOSS

IN&IGUREWHICHTRACESTHEPROGRESSIONOFFILLINTHE"AYBYDEPICTINGITSSHAPEOVERTIME4HEBLUEAREASARETHESURFACEAREAOFTHEWATERINTHE"AYWHILETHEREDSHOWSAREASTHATWEREFILLED)NADDITIONTOFILLINGACTIVITIESDREDGINGHASCHANGEDTHESHAPEOF.EWARK"AYASWELL!LTHOUGHTHE"AYHASBECOMESMALLERITHASACTUALLYBECOMEDEEPERASARESULTOFCHANNELDREDGING/THERBASINSOFTHEHARBORHAVEEXPERIENCEDTHESAMETRENDDECREASINGAREADUETOFILLBUTINCREASEDWATERVOLUMEBECAUSEOFDREDGING&OREXAMPLEBETWEENANDTHEAREAOFTHE5PPER"AYWASREDUCEDBYDUETOFILLINGACTIVITIESBUTDREDG

INGCHANNELSINCREASEDTHEAVERAGEDEPTHFROMTOFEETOVERTHESAMETIMEPERIODEXPANDINGTHEVOLUMEOFTHE5PPER"AYBY

,OSSOF7ETLANDSIN*AMAICA"AY 7HILEFILLINGANDRESULTINGLOSSOFWETLANDSHAVEBEENCURTAILEDINTHEESTUARYINRECENTDECADESTHEREHASBEENANALARMINGLOSSOFTIDALWET

LANDSIN*AMAICA"AYPARTICULARLYTHEMARSHGRASSISLANDSTHATARESCAT

TEREDTHROUGHOUTTHE"AY!CCORDINGTOANALYSESOFHISTORICALMAPSANDAERIALPHOTOGRAPHSCONDUCTEDBYTHE.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION.93$%# THESIZEOFTIDALWETLANDSIN*AMAICA"AYREMAINEDNEARLYCONSTANTBETWEENAND!SSHOWNIN&IGUREBETWEENANDABOUTACRESOFWETLANDWERELOSTTOFILLANDOTHERHUMANACTIVITIESATANAVERAGELOSSRATEOFABOUT

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGURE8]Vc\\Zh^ci]ZCZlVg`7Vnh]dgZa^cZ!&-***&...#GZYgZegZhZcihaVcY

XgZViZYl^i][^aa#Hjho`dlh`^&.,-!CD66'%%&#

&IGUREI^YValZiaVcYadhh[gdb?VbV^XV7Vn^haVcYh!&.')*&...#6XgZV\\ZhlZgZ

YZiZgb^cZY[gdbVZg^Vae]did\\gVe]n;VaadcVcYBjh]VX`Z'%%'#

ACRESPERYEAR3INCEWETLANDSLOSSHASOCCURREDATANEVENGREATERAVERAGERATECURRENTLYABOUTACRESPERYEAR)FLOSSCONTINUESATTHISRATEANDNOTHINGELSECHANGESINTHESYSTEMALLOFTHEMARSHISLANDSINTHE"AYWILLDISAPPEARBY&IGUREDRAMATICALLYDEPICTSTHELOSSESTHATAREOCCURRINGATTWOREPRESENTATIVESITESINTHE"AY4IDALMARSHESINTHESEAERIALPHOTOGRAPHSARESHOWNINPINKFOR$UCK0OINT! AND%LDERS0OINT" INAND$UCK0OINTMARSHESDECREASEDINSIZEFROMACRESTOACRESALOSSOFAND%LDERS0OINTEXPERIENCEDASIMILARDECLINEFROMACRESTOACRESLOSS

)NA"LUE2IBBON0ANELWASCONVENEDBYTHE.ATIONAL0ARK3ERVICETOINVESTIGATETHEREASONSFORTHEMARSHLOSS!NUMBEROFPOTENTIALCAUSESANDCONTRIBUTINGFACTORSRELATEDTOHUMANIMPACTSONTHE"AYWEREDIS

CUSSEDSEALEVELRISEDUETOGLOBALCLIMATECHANGEDISRUPTIONOFTHESEDI

MENTBUDGETOFTHE"AYWHICHMAYPROHIBITTHEBUILDINGOFNEWMARSHINCREASEDWAVEENERGYANDSUBSEQUENTEROSIONINTHE"AYDUETOTHEEXISTENCEOFDREDGEDCHANNELSSMOTHERINGOFTHEMARSHESBYBLOOMSOFSEALETTUCEEFFECTSOFCONTAMINANTSLEACHINGINTOTHE"AYFROMSURROUND

INGLANDFILLSOROTHERSOURCESEROSIONALLOSSOFMUSSELSTHATSTABILIZETHEEDGESOFTHEMARSHTHEPRESENCEOFANOVERABUNDANCEOFMUSSELSTHATMAYhDAMvWATERBEHINDTHEMATLOWTIDEANDCONTRIBUTETOBREAKDOWNOFTHEMARSHANDEXCES

SIVECONSUMPTIONOFTHEMARSHGRASSBYWATER

FOWL#LEARLYTHEISSUEISVERYCOMPLEXASMARSHLOSSMAYBEDUETOANYORACOMBINATIONOFTHESEFACTORS#ONSEQUENTLYMORERESEARCHMUSTBECON

DUCTEDINORDERTODETERMINEWHICHIFANY ARETHEMOSTIMPORTANTCAUSES(OWEVERTHE0ANELRECOGNIZEDTHATACTIONMUSTALSOBETAKENRIGHTAWAYTOSTEMTHELOSSOFMARSH3EVERALPILOTPROJ

ECTSHAVEBEENFUNDEDANDAREUNDERWAYTODETER

MINETHECAUSESOFTHELOSSANDTHEBESTWAYSTO

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

!CRES

LOSS

!VGACRES LOSTPERYEAR

LOSS

ACRES LOSTPERYEAR

LOSS

ACRES LOSTPERYEAR

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT(ABITATAND7ETLANDS

WETLANDSFWSGOV WWWEPAGOVOWOWWETLANDSVITALTOCHTML WWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEDFWMRMARINEMHABITATHTM WWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEDFWMRMARINETWLOSSHTML CRSSARUTGERSEDUPROJECTSLCURBANGROWTHINDEXHTML 3IGNIFICANT(ABITATSAND(ABITAT#OMPLEXESOFTHE.EW9ORK"IGHTREPORTTOTHE(%053&ISH7ILDLIFE3ERVICE

REMEDIATETHEPROBLEM4HESEPROJECTSINCLUDEMONITORINGTHEIMPACTOFFORAGINGBIRDSONTHEMARSHGRASSANDTAKINGSEDIMENTCORESAROUNDTHE"AYINORDERTOEXAMINEPATTERNSOFDEPOSITIONANDEROSIONOFSEDIMENTSTHROUGHTIME%XPERIMENTALPLANTINGOFMARSHGRASSWILLALSOBECONDUCTEDANDAVARIETYOFADDITIONALACTIONSAREUNDERCONSIDERATION

(ABITAT,OSSINTHE(ACKENSACK-EADOWLANDS 4HELARGESTREMAININGTRACTOFTIDALWETLANDSINTHEHARBORESTUARYSYSTEMISTHE(ACKENSACK-EADOWLANDSIN.EW*ERSEY7HILEMANYPEOPLETHINKOFTHE-EADOWLANDSASAPLACETOGOTOWATCHAFOOTBALLGAMEOTHEREQUALLYEXCIT

INGEVENTSOCCURTHEREONADAILYBASIS/SPREYSANDHERONSCAPTUREFISHTOEATFIDDLERCRABSDIGTHEIRBURROWSANDSEARCHFORMATESYOUNGFISHEATANDGROWANDFAMILIESOFOUROWNSPECIESCANOEANDKAYAKTHEWINDINGWATER

WAYSTHATCRISS CROSSTHEMARSHES!SWILDASTHE-EADOWLANDSARETODAYHOWEVERTHEYUSEDTOBEEVENLARGERANDWILDERORIGINALLYAGLACIALLAKE,AKE(ACKENSACK OVERTIMETHE-EADOWLANDSEVOLVEDINTOASUCCESSIONOFTYPESOFFRESHWATERWETLANDSANDBECAMEBRACKISHONLYAFTER%UROPEANSETTLERSCHANGEDTHEHYDROLOGYOFTHEAREAWITHDIKESANDDAMSINORDERTOCONVERTTHEWETLANDSTOFARMLAND/VERTHEPASTYEARSORSOTHE-EADOWLANDSHAVEBEENDRAINEDANDORFILLEDFIRSTFORAGRICULTURALPURPOSESTHENINMISGUIDEDANDULTIMATELYFRUITLESSATTEMPTSTOCON

TROLMOSQUITOESANDLATERFORINDUSTRIALANDCOMMERCIALUSESANDTHECREATIONOFLANDFILLS4HESECHANGESDESTROYEDVALUABLEFISHANDWILDLIFEHABITATANDALTEREDTHEFUNCTIONOFTHEAREASTHATREMAIN

&IGURE6Zg^Vae]didhYZe^Xi^c\\i^YVa

lZiaVcYadhhZh[gdbild?VbV^XV7Vn

^haVcYh!&.,)*&...#;^\\jgZ,6h]dlh+*

VXgZhadhiVi9jX`Ed^ci0;^\\jgZ,7h]dlh

,*VXgZhadhiVi:aYZghEd^ci#I^YVabVgh]Zh

VgZh]dlc^ce^c`CNH9:8'%%'#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

$UCK0OINT

%LDERS0OINT

4IDAL-ARSHESSHOWNINPINK

ACRES

4IDAL-ARSHESSHOWNINPINK

ACRES

4IDAL-ARSHESSHOWNINPINK

ACRES

4IDAL-ARSHESSHOWNINPINK

ACRES

&IGUREDEPICTSTHELOSSOF-EADOWLANDSTIDALESTUARYACREAGEINCLUDINGOPENWATERMUDFLATSANDMARSHBETWEENAND4OTALACREAGEHASDECREASEDFROMABOUTACRESATTHEENDOFTHETHCENTURYTOABOUTACRESTODAYATOTALLOSSOFAPPROXIMATELY3IMILARLYTHE53&ISHAND7ILDLIFE3ERVICESTATESTHATTHE-EADOWLANDSHISTORICACRESHAVEBEENREDUCEDTOACRESTODAY 0ARTICULARLYTROUBLINGISTHEFACTTHATTHERATEOFLOSSWASHIGHERBETWEENANDTHANITWASINTHEYEAR PERIODPRIORTO"ETWEENANDTHERATEWASABOUTACRESPERYEARONAVERAGEWHILEABOUTACRESPERYEARWERELOSTFROMTO"5.$!.#%/&7!$).'")2$3

)NTHEMIDSTOFTHEMOSTURBANPARTOFTHE(ARBOR%STUARYISAREMARKABLEPOPULATIONOFWADINGBIRDSCONSISTINGOFAVARIETYOFSPECIESOFHERONSEGRETSANDIBISESCOMMONLYREFERREDTOASAGROUPASTHE(ARBOR(ERONS4HE(ARBOR(ERONSCOMPLEXREPRESENTSONEOFTHEMOSTAMAZ

INGCOMEBACKSTORIESINTHEESTUARY!SRECENTLYASTHESTHEREWEREVIR

TUALLYNOWADINGBIRDSINTHEHARBORTHEIRPOPULATIONSDEVASTATEDBYHUNTINGMOSTLYFORTHEIRDECORATIVEFEATHERS POLLUTIONANDLACKOFSMALLFISHFORTHEMTOEAT!STHEENVIRONMENTOFTHEHARBORIMPROVEDHUNTINGOFTHESEBIRDSHADBEENBANNEDATTHETURNOFTHELASTCENTURY THEIRPOPULATIONSGREWTREMEN

DOUSLYANDTHEYNESTEDANDFORAGEDFORPREYINANDAROUNDTHEUNINHABITEDISLANDSOFTHE!RTHUR+ILL+ILLVAN+ULLAND%AST2IVER#URRENTLYTHE(ARBOR(ERONSCONSTITUTEABOUTAQUARTEROFALLOFTHENESTINGWADINGBIRDSIN.EW*ERSEY.EW9ORKAND#ONNECTICUT

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

4IDAL%STUARY!REA!CRES

LOSS

!VGACRES LOSTPERYEAR

LOSS

!VGACRES LOSTPERYEAR

&IGUREI^YVaZhijVgnVXgZV\\Z!^cXajY^c\\deZclViZg!bjY[aVih!VcYZbZg\\Zci

bVgh]!^ci]Z=VX`ZchVX`BZVYdlaVcYh!&-.%*&..*=VgibVc'%%'#

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

&ORMANYYEARSTHE.EW9ORK#ITY!UDUBON3OCIETYHASMONITOREDTHEPOPULATIONOFTHE(ARBOR(ERONSWITHTHEHELPOFTRAINEDVOLUNTEERS4HEIRLATESPRINGSURVEYS OF.ORTH AND 3OUTH "ROTHER )SLAND IN THE%AST2IVERAND3HOOTERSAND0RALLS)SLANDANDTHE)SLEOF-EADOWSINTHE+ILLSCOUNTNUMBERSOFBIRDSNUMBERSOFNESTSANDOTHERPOPULATIONPARAMETERS&IGUREDEPICTSTHENUMBERSOFINDIVIDUALSOFVARI

OUS(ARBOR(ERONSPECIESRECORDEDONTHESEISLANDSBY THE !UDUBON SURVEY BETWEEN AND 4HESE DATA INDICATE THAT THE NUMBERS OF (ARBOR(ERONS BIRDS MOST NOTABLY THE BLACK CROWNEDNIGHTHERONCATTLEEGRETANDGLOSSYIBISONTHESEISLANDS HAVE GENERALLY BEEN DECREASING OVER THEPASTDECADE4HESEDECLINESCOULDMEANTHATTHESESPECIESARESIMPLYNESTINGELSEWHEREINTHEESTUARYORSOMEWHEREELSEALONGTHE%AST#OASTORCOULDINDICATE THAT SOME DISTURBANCE OR ENVIRONMENTALFACTOR IS AFFECTING THEIR POPULATIONS IN THE ESTU

ARY -ORE RESEARCH AND COAST WIDE MONITORING ISNEEDEDINORDERTODETERMINETHEACTUALCAUSESFORTHEDECLINES4HE!UDUBON3OCIETYHASOBSERVEDNESTINGWADINGBIRDSONOTHERISLANDSINTHEESTUARYINRECENTYEARSINCLUDING(OFFMAN)SLANDOFF3TATEN)SLAND#ANARSIE0OL IN *AMAICA "AY (UCKLEBERRY )SLAND IN,ONG)SLAND3OUNDAND'OOSE)SLANDINTHE(UTCHINSON2IVER 2ELOCATION MAY ACCOUNT FOR THE DECLINES ONTHEISLANDSDESCRIBEDABOVE)THASBEENWELL DOCU

MENTED THAT THERE WAS A LARGE DECLINE OF WADINGBIRDSON3HOOTERS)SLANDAFTERFROMPAIRSOFBIRDSINTONONEIN!SIMILARDECLINEHAS BEEN OBSERVED ON )SLE OF -EADOWS (OWEVERDURINGTHESAMEPERIODTHENESTINGPOPULATIONSOFWADERS ON OTHER ISLANDS INCREASED DRAMATICALLY/VERALL!UDUBONREPORTSTHATPOPULATIONSOFMANYOFTHESEWADERSHAVEDECREASEDSOMEWHAT

HEMICALCONTAMINANTSINTHEESTUARYMAYHAVEASIGNIFICANTEFFECTONWADINGANDOTHERBIRDSASTHEBIRDSBIOACCUMULATECONTAMINANTSTHATAREPRESENTINTHEIRPREY&OREXAMPLELEADLEVELSINTHEFEATHERSOFSOMETERNSINTHEAREAINCREASEDBETWEENANDANDWEREFOUNDINSOMEINDIVIDUALSATLEVELSTHATHAVEBEENASSOCIATEDWITHBEHAVIORALIMPAIRMENTANDRETARDEDGROWTHINLABORATORYEXPERI

MENTS(OWEVERDECREASESIN$$4ANDOTHERPESTICIDESINTHEENVIRONMENTCAUSEDEGGSHELLTHICKNESSINMARINEBIRDSTOINCREASEFROMTHESTOTHESITISIMPORTANTFORBIRDSTOMAINTAINEGGSHELLTHICKNESSSOTHATTHEEGGSDONOTBREAKDURINGINCUBATION

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

!BUNDANCE.UMBERS

8bWYa#Yhemd[ZD_]^j>[hed O[bbem#Yhemd[ZD_]^j>[hed

=h[Wj;]h[j Idemo;]h[j B_jjb[8bk[>[hed

=h((d#XWYa[Z>[hed 9Wjjb[;]h[j

=beiio?X_i Ej^[h

&IGURELVY^c\\W^gYedejaVi^dchdc[^kZ^haVcYhH]ddiZg1/4h!EgVaa1/4h!>haZ

d[BZVYdlh!Cdgi]VcYHdji]7gdi]Zgd[i]Z=VgWdg=Zgdch8dbeaZm!CZl

Ndg`=VgWdg!&..&*'%%&#7ZXVjhZi]ZhjgkZnlVhXdcYjXiZYY^((ZgZcian^c

&..-!i]VinZVg1/4hYViVVgZcdi^cXajYZY]ZgZ#I]^hYViVgZXdgY^hhjWhZfjZci

idi]Z&..%d^ahe^aahZZh^YZWVgEVghdchVcYLg^\\]i&..&*&..*!@Zga^c\\Zg

&..+*'%%'#

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT"IRDSINTHE%STUARY

(EARTBEATSINTHE-UCKBY*OHN7ALDMAN,YONS0RESS

4HE(UDSON!N)LLUSTRATED'UIDETOTHE,IVING2IVERBY3TEPHEN03TANNEETAL2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS

"EFOREAND!FTERAN/IL3PILL4HE!RTHUR+ILLBY*OANNA"URGEREDITOR2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS

WWWNYCASORG

"5.$!.#%/&&)3(!.$#2534!#%!.3

)NHISCLASSICBOOKABOUTTHE(UDSON2IVER4HE(UDSON2IVER!.ATURALAND5NNATURAL(ISTORY 2OBERT"OYLEWRITESh&ORFISHESTHELOWER(UDSONISAKINDOF4IMES3QUAREv"ECAUSETHEESTUARYISSUCHAPRODUCTIVEECOSYSTEMANDPROVIDESPROTECTIVEANDFOOD RICHNURSERYHABITATFORYOUNGFISHINPARTICU

LARITISTEEMINGWITHADIVERSEFISHCOMMUNITY3PECIESRANGINGFROMMARINEBLUEFISHTOFRESHWATERSUNFISHAREFOUNDTHERE-IGRATORYFISHESSUCHASSTRIPEDBASSSTURGEONANDSHADSPENDMOSTOFTHEIRLIVESATSEABUTCOMETHROUGHTHEESTUARYONTHEIRWAYTOFRESHWATERSPAWNINGGROUNDSALIFECYCLECALLEDANADROMY/NCESPAWNEDTHEOFFSPRINGOFTHESESPECIESSPENDTHEIRFIRSTSUM

MEREATINGGROWINGANDHIDINGFROMPREDATORSINTHEESTUARY!MERICANEELSWHICHEMPLOYTHEOPPOSITESTRATEGYCATADROMY MOVEINTOTHE(UDSONAFTERHATCHINGSOMEWHEREINTHE3ARGASSO3EA!DDTOTHISMIXTHEOCCASIONALSTRAYFISHFROMDEEPERORWARMERWATERSANDAHIGHLYDIVERSEANDDYNAMICFISHCOMMUNITYRESULTS!LLINALLMORETHANSPECIESOFFISHCALLTHE(ARBOR%STUARYHOMEFORSOMEORALLOFTHEIRLIFECYCLES-ANYOFTHESESPECIESAREIMPORTANTINCOMMERCIALANDRECREATIONALFISHERIESONTHE%AST#OASTORINTHEESTUARYITSELF)TISESTIMATEDTHATABOUTOFTHENATIONSANDOFTHE.ORTHEAST!TLANTICS COMMERCIALLY CAUGHTFISHDEPENDONESTUARIESATSOMEPOINTINTHEIRLIVES!NGLERSCOVETTHEWILYSTRIPEDBASSANDACROBATICBLUEFISH'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR 4HE!RTHUR+ILL/IL3PILL

.EW9ORK(ARBORISBOTHTHELARGESTOILPORTINTHECOUN

TRYANDAPRODUCTIVEANDDIVERSEECOSYSTEM4HESETWOASPECTSOFTHEESTUARYCLASHEDIN*ANUARYWHENALARGEOILSPILLACTUALLYALEAKFROMANEARBYREFINERYANDSTORAGEFACILITY INTHE!RTHUR+ILLTHREATENEDTHEONGOINGRECOVERYOFTHEESTUARY$URINGTHENIGHTOF*ANUARY MORETHANGALLONSOF.OFUELOILLEAKEDINTOTHE !RTHUR +ILL 3OME OF THE ORGANISMS THAT WERE MOSTDIRECTLY AND IMMEDIATELY AFFECTED BY THE SPILL WERE THEBIRDSOFTHE+ILLS"ECAUSETHESPILLOCCURREDDURINGTHEWINTERMIGRATORYSPECIESTHATRESIDEINTHEESTUARYONLYINTHESUMMERWERENOTDIRECTLYHARMED"IRDSAREPAR

TICULARLYAFFECTEDBYOILSPILLSBECAUSETHEOILDESTROYSTHEINSULATING AND WATERPROOF PROPERTIES OF THEIR FEATHERSCAUSING THEM TO DIE FROM HYPOTHERMIA OR PROHIBITINGTHEMFROMDIVINGTOCOLLECTFOOD)NADDITIONTHEYCANINGESTORRESPIRATETHEOILWITHLETHALCONSEQUENCESANDTHEOILCANDESTROYCRITICALNESTINGANDFORAGINGHABITAT

!BOUT DEAD BIRDS MOSTLY GULLS AND A FEW SMALLWATERFOWL WEREFOUNDINTHEESTUARYIMMEDIATELYAFTERTHE SPILL BUT WHAT LONG TERM EFFECTS WOULD THE OIL SPILLHAVE &ORTUNATELY SCIENTISTS HAD BEEN COLLECTING DATAABOUTTHEPOPULATIONSOFBIRDSINTHE!RTHUR+ILLBEFORETHE SPILL SO THEY WERE ABLE TO COMPARE THAT INFORMA

TIONWITHINFORMATIONCOLLECTEDAFTERTHESPILLINORDERTODETERMINETHEIMPACTOFTHESPILLONBIRDS!LTHOUGHITISDIFFICULTTODIFFERENTIATEBETWEENOILSPILLIMPACTSANDNATURAL POPULATION FLUCTUATIONS A SHARP DECLINE IN THENUMBEROFGULLNESTSINTHE+ILLSWASOBSERVEDINTHESUM

MEROFANDASMALLERDECLINEWASNOTEDIN)NTHENUMBERSSTARTEDTOCLIMBAGAINBUTVIRTUALLYNOGULLSNOWNESTONTHEISLANDSOFTHE!RTHUR+ILL.9#!UDUBONBELIEVESTHATTHISABSENCEISDUETOCHANGESINHABITATONTHEISLANDSTHATHAVEELIMINATEDGRASSYAREASTHATARESUITABLEFORGULLSTOLANDANDTAKEOFF #HANGESINFEEDINGBEHAVIORANDDECLINESINREPRODUCTIVESUCCESSOFMANYBIRDSPECIESWEREOBSERVEDINTHETWOYEARSAFTERTHESPILLASWELL-OSTSPECIESSEEMTOHAVERETURNEDTONORMAL ONLY A FEW YEARS AFTER THE SPILL WADING BIRDSRETURNEDTOPRE SPILLREPRODUCTIVESUCCESSTHREEYEARSAFTERTHESPILLFOREXAMPLE (OWEVERTHELONG TERMEFFECTSOFTHESPILLONBIRDSANDOTHERSPECIESINTHEESTUARYARESTILLNOTKNOWN

WHILECOMMERCIALFISHERSTARGETSHADANDBLUECRABWITHINTHE(ARBOR%STUARYINTHESHADOWOFSKYSCRAPERS

)TISAKEYGOALOFESTUARINEPROTECTIONPROGRAMSTOENSURETHATPOPULATIONSOFNATIVEFISHANDCRABSARETHRIVING)NTURNABUNDANCESOFFISHANDCRABSPROVIDEAMEASUREOFTHEOVERALLHEALTHOFTHEESTUARYINTERMSOFHABITATQUALITYANDECOSYSTEMFUNCTION)NORDERTODETERMINETHEHEALTHOFFISHANDCRUSTACEANPOPULATIONSINTHEESTUARYMEASURESOFABUNDANCEOFEIGHTREPRESENTATIVESPE

CIESAREDEPICTEDINTHEFOLLOWINGPAGES"ECAUSETHEREARENORELIABLELONG

TERMSTUDIESOFFISHPOPULATIONSINTHEHARBORCOREAREAOFTHE(%0TWOOTHERSETSOFDATAINTHEESTUARYWEREUSEDFORTHESEANALYSESONEIN(AVERSTRAW"AYSLIGHTLYNORTHOFTHEHARBORCOREAREAANDONEIN*AMAICA"AY"ECAUSESOMEOFTHESPECIESDISCUSSEDINTHEFOLLOWINGPAGESDONOTOCCURREGULARLYIN*AMAICA"AYTHE*AMAICA"AYDATAARENOTSHOWNFORTHOSESPECIES

"ECAUSEITISVERYDIFFICULTTODETERMINETHEABSOLUTENUMBEROFAGIVENSPECIESINTHEESTUARYINDICESOFABUNDANCERATHERTHANANEXACTCOUNTOFABUNDANCE ARE GENERALLY USED !N INDEX OF ABUNDANCE IS GENERATED BY USING STANDARDSAMPLINGMETHODSOVERASETPERIODOFTIMETOEXAMINEPOPULATIONSIZE4HESE"ESIDES WADING BIRDS THERE ARE MANY OTHER BIRD SPE

CIES THAT LIVE IN THE ESTUARY FOR ALL OR PART OF THE YEAR&IGUREDEPICTSTRENDSINSOMEOFTHEWATERBIRDSPECIESTHATAREFOUNDINTHEHARBORAGAINFROMTHE!UDUBON3OCIETYSSURVEYPROGRAM'ULLSAREONEOFTHEMOSTFAMIL

IARAVIANRESIDENTSOFTHEESTUARY4HE!UDUBON(ARBOR(ERONSSURVEYHASNOTEDADRASTICDECLINEINTHEHERRINGGULLPOPULATIONINTHEHARBORINRECENTYEARSWHILETHEGREATBLACK BACKEDGULLPOPULATIONHASREMAINEDSTABLE$OUBLE CRESTEDCORMORANTSOFTENSEENDRYINGOUTTHEIRWINGSAROUNDTHEHARBORHAVEEXPERIENCEDALARGEPOP

ULATIONBOOMANDHAVEBEENEXPANDINGTHENUMBEROFHARBORISLANDSONWHICHTHEYNEST

7HILE#ANADAGEESESEEMTOBEEVERYWHEREINTHEHAR

BORREGIONTHEIRNUMBERSSEEMTOBEDECLININGASWELL/THER WATERFOWL POPULATIONS SEEM TO BE FAIRLY STABLE/NEBIRDTHATSEEMSTOBEINCREASINGINNUMBERISTHEOSPREYAFISH EATINGTYPEOFRAPTORTHATLIKESTONESTONPILINGSANDOTHERSTRUCTURESAROUNDTHEESTUARY!SPRO

FILEDIN2ACHEL#ARSONSWELL KNOWNANDIMPORTANTBOOKH^aZci Heg^c\\! POPULATIONS OF THESE BIRDS WERE SEVERELYDEPLETEDBECAUSETHEYWERESUSCEPTIBLETOTHEEFFECTSOFTHEPESTICIDE$$4USEOFWHICHISNOWBANNEDINTHE5NITED3TATES4HERESURGENCEOFTHEOSPREYISAGOODINDICATIONTHATTHEESTUARYITSELFISCLEANERANDHEALTHIERTHANITUSEDTOBE

4HE HARBOR IS ALSO AN IMPORTANT STOPOVER FOR WHAT ARECALLEDhNEO TROPICALMIGRANTSvSMALLSONGBIRDSTHATTRAVELBETWEEN.ORTH!MERICANANDTROPICALREGIONSIN#ENTRALAND 3OUTH !MERICA 4HE HARBOR PARTICULARLY PARTS OF*AMAICA"AYAND2ARITAN"AYPROVIDESSPECTACULARBIRD

INGWHENTHESEBRIGHTLYCOLOREDBIRDSCOMETHROUGHINTHESPRINGANDFALL

!BUNDANCE.UMBERS

ekXb[#Yh[ij[Z9ehcehWdj

>[hh_d]=kbb

=h[Wj8bWYa#XWYa[Z=kbb

&IGURE8dadc^ValViZgW^gYedejaV" i^dchdc[^kZ^haVcYhH]ddiZg1/4h!EgVaa1/4h!>haZ

d[BZVYdlh!Cdgi]VcYHdji]7gdi]Zgd[i]Z

=VgWdg=Zgdch8dbeaZm!CZlNdg`=VgWdg!

&..&*'%%&EVghdchVcYLg^\\]i&..&*&..*!

@Zga^c\\Zg&..+*'%%'#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

/THER"IRDSINTHE%STUARY

MEASURESCANPROVIDEABASISFORCOMPARISONOFONEYEARTOANOTHERSHOWTRENDSINABUNDANCEOVERTIMEANDTELLUSWHETHERAPARTICULARYEARWASAhGOODvYEARFORTHATSPECIESORARELATIVELYPOORYEAR4HEYDONOTPROVIDEANABSOLUTENUMBEROFANYGIVENSPECIESPRESENTINTHEESTUARYINAGIVENYEAR

)TISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATDETERMININGTHECAUSEOFCHANGESINABUNDANCEOFFISHANDCRABSPECIESFROMYEARTOYEARISALSOVERYDIFFICULT6IRTUALLYALLSPE

CIESEXPERIENCENATURALFLUCTUATIONSINPOPULATIONSIZEOVERTIMETHEREASONSFORWHICHAREUSUALLYCOMPLEXANDOFTENUNCLEAR0ERHAPSANENVIRONMENTALFACTORISCONTROLLINGTHEPOPULATIONINAGIVENYEARnADRYSPRINGORACOLDWINTER CAN HAVE A LARGE IMPACT ON YOUNG FISHES SURVIVAL (UMAN INDUCEDCHANGES INCLUDING POLLUTION HABITAT DESTRUCTION AND OVERFISHING CAN AFFECTFISHANDCRABPOPULATIONSASWELL3OMESPECIESSPENDSUBSTANTIALAMOUNTSOFTIMEOUTSIDETHEBOUNDARIESOFTHEESTUARYSOCONDITIONSTHATTHEYENCOUNTERELSEWHERE ALSO WILL AFFECT THEIR NUMBERS IN THE ESTUARY PROPER )NTERACTIONSAMONG FISH SPECIES CAN AFFECT ABUNDANCE FOR EXAMPLE HIGH NUMBERS OFPREDATORYYOUNGBLUEFISHINAPARTICULARYEARCANRESULTINLOWERNUMBERSOFTHEIRPREYFISHINCLUDINGYOUNGSTRIPEDBASSANDSHAD)NORDERTODETERMINEIFASPECIESISACTUALLYEXPERIENCINGASIGNIFICANTPOPULATIONDECLINEASOPPOSEDTOANATURALSHIFTINABUNDANCEITISCRITICALTOEXAMINEASMANYYEARSOFDATAASPOSSIBLETOBEABLETODETERMINELONG TERMTRENDS4HEDATASETSUSEDFORTHESEANALYSESAREREASONABLYLONG TERMANDCONTINUOUS

7HILETHEFOLLOWINGDISCUSSIONSFOCUSONTHEPATTERNSINABUNDANCEOBSERVEDFORINDIVIDUALSPECIESITISALSOIMPORTANTTOLOOKATCHANGESINTHEFISHCOM

MUNITYOVERTIME/NESTUDYIN(AVERSTRAW"AYHASFOUNDTHATTHEDIVERSITYAMEASUREOFTHENUMBEROFSPECIESALONGWITHTHEIRRELATIVEABUNDANCESFOUNDINAGIVENAREA OFTHEFISHCOMMUNITYIN(AVERSTRAW"AYHASDECLINEDOVERTIME(URSTETALINREVIEW 3TRIPED"ASS

)FTHE(ARBOR%STUARYHADAMASCOTITWOULDLIKELYBETHESTRIPEDBASS)NHISBOOK(EARTBEATSINTHE-UCK*OHN7ALDMANCALLSSTRIPEDBASShTHEHARBORSSYMBOLAPIN STRIPEDTOUGHGUYTHATTRANSCENDSITSSURROUND

INGSv6OLUMESHAVEBEENWRITTENABOUTTHISPOPULARFISHTHOUSANDSOFHOURSANDMILLIONSOFDOLLARSHAVEBEENSPENTONRESEARCHINGITSECOLOGYANDBIOLOGYANDANGLERSGOTOGREATLENGTHSTOFISHFORITALONGTHEENTIREEASTCOASTANDPARTSOFTHEWESTCOASTWHEREITWASINTRODUCEDINTHELATESFROM(UDSON2IVERSTOCK 7HILESTRIPEDBASSAREAVERYPOPULARQUARRYFORRECREATIONALANGLERSTHECOMMERCIALFISHERYINTHERIVERANDESTUARYISCLOSEDBECAUSEOFPUBLICHEALTHCONCERNSABOUTTHELEVELSOF0#"SINTHEIRFLESH(EALTHADVISORIESAREALSOINEFFECTREGARDINGEATINGRECREATIONALLY CAUGHTFISHTHROUGHOUTTHE(UDSON2IVERANDHARBORASWELL

3TRIPEDBASSENTERTHEESTUARYINTHESPRINGONTHEIRWAYTOFRESHWATERREACHESOFTHE(UDSONBETWEENTHE(IGHLANDSAND+INGSTONTOSPAWN4HEEGGSANDLARVAEDRIFTDOWNSTREAMANDAFTERHATCHINGMOSTOFTHEYOUNG

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

STRIPEDBASSSPENDTHEIRFIRSTSUMMERCONGREGATEDMAINLYINANDAROUND(AVERSTRAW"AY)NTHEFALLMOSTOFTHEADULTSWILLMIGRATEBACKOUTTOSEAWHILETHEYOUNGOFTHEYEARWILLSPENDTHEIRFIRSTWINTERINTHELOWERRIVEROFF-ANHATTANSSHORELINE!DULTSCANBEQUITELARGEGROWINGTOMORETHANTHREEFEETINLENGTHANDPOUNDSINWEIGHT

3TRIPEDBASSHAVEUNDERGONEAREMARKABLERECOVERYAFTERAHUGECOAST

WIDEDECLINEATTRIBUTEDLARGELYTOOVERFISHING#OASTALCOMMERCIALLAND

INGSDECLINEDPRECIPITOUSLYSTARTINGINTHEMID SANDHEAVYFISHINGRESTRICTIONSINCLUDINGACLOSUREOFTHECOMMERCIALFISHERYIN-ARYLANDAND$ELAWAREWEREPUTINTOPLACE4HESEPOLICIESSEEMTOHAVEWORKEDSTRIPEDBASSHAVEINCREASEDINNUMBERSSINCETHATTIMEANDAREAGAINABUNDANTTHROUGHOUTTHEIRRANGE4HEFISHERYRESTRICTIONSHAVESINCEBEENEASEDBUTNOTEASSTATEDABOVETHATTHECOMMERCIALFISHERYINTHE(UDSON2IVERREMAINSCLOSEDBECAUSEOFCONCERNSABOUT0#"S

4HE.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION.93$%# HASCONDUCTEDASUMMERANDFALLPOPULATIONSURVEYOFTHEhYOUNG OF THE

YEARv9/9 STRIPEDBASSTHOSEHATCHEDINTHESPRINGANDTHEREFORENOTYETONEYEAROLD EVERYYEARSINCEINTHE(AVERSTRAW"AYREGIONOFTHE(UDSON&ROMTHEDATACOLLECTEDFORTHISSURVEYANINDEXOF9/9STRIPEDBASSABUNDANCEISCALCULATEDTOPROVIDEARELATIVEMEASUREOFTHESIZEOFTHATYEARSPOPULATION4HISINDEXISPLOTTEDIN&IGUREFROMTO4HEREISNOCLEARDIRECTIONALTRENDINTHEINDEXINTHEYEARSSHOWNRATHERITVARIESWIDELYFROMYEARTOYEAR(OWEVERTHEPEAKYEARSINTHEINDEXINDICATESTOCKRECOVERYBYREVEALINGINCREASESINTHENUMBEROFINDI

VIDUALSPRESENTINTHESYSTEM4HEINDEXWASAMONGTHEHIGHESTDUR

INGTHEENTIREHISTORYOFTHESURVEY)TISLIKELYTHATENVIRONMENTALFACTORSSUCHASSALINITYANDTEMPERATUREHAVEALARGEIMPACTONTHEYEARLYVARIA

TIONINTHEINDEX4HE(UDSON2IVERPOPULATIONSTAYEDFAIRLYSTABLETHROUGHOUTTHETIMETHATTHECOASTALSTOCKWASINDECLINEASDESCRIBEDABOVEBECAUSETHECOASTALSTOCKISCOMPRISEDMOSTLYOF#HESAPEAKE"AYFISHAPPROXIMATELY#HESAPEAKE(UDSONFISHAND$ELAWARE"AYFISH ANDTHE(UDSONPOPULATIONDIDNOTEXPERIENCETHEPRECIPITOUSDECLINETHATOCCURREDIN#HESAPEAKE"AY

&IGUREALSOSHOWS.93$%#SURVEYMEA

SURESOFABUNDANCEOF9/9STRIPEDBASSIN*AMAICA"AYFORTHEYEARSn.OTETHATUSUALLYTHEREAREFARFEWERYOUNGSTRIPEDBASSIN*AMAICA"AYTHANIN(AVERSTRAW"AYBUTTHATINWHENTHEINDEXOFABUNDANCEWASVERYLOWIN(AVERSTRAW"AYTHEINDEXWASTHEHIGH

ESTRECORDEDINTHESEYEARSIN*AMAICA"AY&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgi8EJ:

d[ndjc\\"d["i]Z"nZVghig^eZYWVhh^c

=VkZghigVl7Vn&.,.*'%%&VcY?VbV^XV

7Vn&.-)*'%%'#8EJ:kVajZhVgZ\\Zd" bZig^XbZVch#CdiZY^((ZgZcihXVaZhd[i]Z

ildNVmZh=jghi'%%'!=jghiVcY8dcdkZg

'%%&!BX@dlc'%%'!7g^hX]aZg'%%(#

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

(AVERSTRAW"AY

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

AMAICA"AY

>Wl[hijhWm8WoOEO

@WcW_YW8WoOEO

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[

ndjc\\"d["i]Z"nZVg6bZg^XVch]VY^c

=VkZghigVl7Vn!&.-%*'%%&=jghi'%%'!

=jghiVcY8dcdkZg'%%&#

4HEREASONFORTHISPATTERNISNOTKNOWN0ERHAPSCONDITIONSWEREBETTERIN*AMAICA"AYFORSTRIPEDBASSTHATYEARSOTHEYCONGREGATEDTHERERATHERTHANINTHE(UDSON)TAPPEARSTHATNUMBERSOFSTRIPEDBASSWEREHIGHINBOTHBAYSIN

!MERICAN3HAD

%VERYSPRINGASTHEhSHADBUSHvBLOOMSALONGTHE(UDSON!MERICANSHADRETURNTOTHERIVERWHERETHEYWEREBORNTOSPAWN4HEYMIGRATEFROMTHEOCEANUPTHERIVERPASTTHEHARBORTOMOREFRESHWATERPORTIONSOFTHE(UDSONBETWEEN(YDE0ARKAND#ATSKILLWHERETHEYSPAWN4HEADULTSTHENMIGRATEOUTOFTHEESTUARYBACKTOTHEOCEAN5NLIKESOMESPECIESSUCHASWESTCOASTSALMONSHADDONOTDIEAFTERSPAWNINGBUTRETURNTOSPAWNAGAINFORASMANYASADDITIONALYEARS4HEJUST HATCHEDSHADRESIDEINTHERIVERMOVINGGENERALLYDOWNSTREAMOVERTHECOURSEOFTHESUMMER4HEYMIGRATEOUTTOTHEOCEANINTHEFALLWHERETHEYLIVEFORFOURTOSEVENYEARSUNTILITISTHEIRTURNTORETURNTOTHERIVERANDSPAWN

4HESESILVERYRELATIVESOFHERRINGWHICHCANREACHPOUNDSCONSTITUTETHEMOSTIMPORTANTCOMMERCIALFISHERYREMAININGINTHEESTUARY5SINGMUCHTHESAMETECHNIQUETHATHASBEENUSEDFORCENTURIESSHADFISHERSFROMTHE'EORGE7ASHINGTON"RIDGETO(AVERSTRAW"AYPLACETHEIRNETSINTHEESTU

ARYEVERYSPRING3HADROEISADELICACYTHATAPPEARSANNUALLYINLOCALFISHMARKETSANDTHEFLESHOFTHESHADONCETHEDIFFICULTTASKOFDE BONINGITISACCOM

PLISHEDLIVESUPTOTHESHADS,ATINNAME!LOSASAPI

DISSIMA hHERRINGMOSTDELICIOUSv&ORTHEMOSTPARTSHADARENOTSUBJECTTOTHESTRICTHEALTHADVISORIESISSUEDBYTHESTATESFORMOSTOTHEREDIBLESPECIESINTHEESTUARYBECAUSETHEYDONOTFEEDWHILEONTHEIRSPAWNINGRUNSANDTHEREFOREDONOTAPPRECIABLYBIOACCUMULATECONTAMINANTS

.EW9ORK3TATECONDUCTSTWOANNUALSURVEYSFROMWHICHSHADABUNDANCECANBEDETERMINED&IGURESHOWSMEASURESOFABUNDANCEFORhYOUNG OF THE

YEARvSHADFISHJUSTHATCHEDINTHESPRINGCOUNTEDINTHESUMMERANDFALLANDTHEREFORENOTYETONEYEAROLD IN(AVERSTRAW"AYCOUNTEDASTHEYMIGRATEOUTTOSEA4HESEDATAINDICATETHATYOUNGSHADNUMBERSHAVEBEENDECLININGSINCETHEMID SINTHE(UDSON2IVER/THERRELATEDFISHSPECIESINTHE(UDSON2IVERSUCHASALEWIFEANDBLUEBACKHERRINGEXHIBITSIMILARDECLINESOVERTHISTIMEPERIOD

&IGUREWHICHSHOWSTHEABUNDANCEOFADULTSHADCAUGHTINTHECOM

MERCIALFISHERYINTHE(UDSON2IVERINDICATESADECLININGTRENDSIMILARTOTHEPATTERNFORTHEYOUNGOFTHEYEAR4HISDECLINECOULDBEDUETOA

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[

6bZg^XVch]VY^ci]Z=jYhdcG^kZgXdb" bZgX^Vah]VY[^h]Zgn!bVaZhVcY[ZbVaZh

XdbW^cZY!&.-%*&...=ViiVaV'%%&#

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

>Wl[hijhWm8Wo

@WcW_YW8Wo

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[ndjc\\"

d["i]Z"nZVgl^ciZg[adjcYZg^c=VkZghigVl7Vn

&.-%*'%%&VcY?VbV^XV7Vn&.-)*'%%&

=jghi'%%'!=jghiVcY8dcdkZg'%%&!

BX@dlc'%%'#

NUMBEROFFACTORSINCLUDINGLOSSOFSPAWNINGHABITATOVERFISHINGINTHERIVEREFFECTSOFPOLLUTIONORSIMPLYNATURALBUTPOORLY UNDERSTOODVARIATIONSINPOPULA

TIONSIZEOVERTIME4HEOCEANINTERCEPTFISHERYFORSHADWHICHCAUGHTLARGENUMBERSOFSHADINTHEOCEANBEFORETHEYENTEREDTHEIRRESPECTIVEESTUARIESTOSPAWNMAYHAVEHADASIGNIFICANTEFFECTONSHADPOPULATIONSASWELLTHISFISHERYISCURRENTLYBEINGPHASEDOUT6ERYLARGEFLUCTUATIONSINSHADABUNDANCEHAVEOCCURREDHISTORICALLYFROMVERYHIGHNUMBERSINCOLONIALTIMESTHEFISHERYEXPERIENCEDADECLINEINTHEMID SSPIKEDATTHEENDOFTHETHCENTURYANDCRASHEDIN#OMMERCIALLANDINGSEDGEDUPAGAININTHESANDCONTINUEDTOINCREASETORECORDLEVELSIN4HEYDECLINEDAGAININTHESANDARENOWEXPERIENCINGAFURTHERDECLINE

7INTER&LOUNDER

/NEOFTHEMOSTPOPULARSPORTFISHINTHE.9.*REGIONISTHEWINTERFLOUNDERANOTHERPART TIMEESTUARYRESI

DENT)NFACTITISSOPOPULARWITHANGLERSTHATINMOSTYEARSRECREATIONALCATCHESOFWINTERFLOUNDEREXCEEDCOMMERCIALLANDINGSIN.EW9ORKWATERS7INTERFLOUNDERGETTHEIRNAMEFROMTHEFACTTHATTHEYMOVEINTOTHEESTUARYINTHEFALLANDSPAWNTHEREINLATEWINTERANDEARLYSPRING4HEYMOVEOFFSHORETOCOLDERDEEPERWATERSINTHESUMMERTIMEALTHOUGHITHASALSOBEENSPECULATEDTHATSOMESTAYINTHEESTUARYBUTBURYTHEMSELVESDEEPINTHESEDIMENTDURINGTHESUMMERMONTHS 4HEYOUNGSPENDTHEIRFIRSTYEARINTHEESTUARYBEFORETAKINGUPTHEMIGRATORYPATTERNSOFTHEADULTS"ECAUSEWINTERFLOUNDERLIVEINCLOSECON

TACTWITHTHESEDIMENTINOFTEN CONTAMINATEDEASTCOASTESTUARIESANDFEEDONSMALLORGANISMSINTHESEDMENTCONCERNHASBEENRAISEDABOUTTHEIMPACTOFPOLLUTIONPARTICULARLYINCONTAMINATEDSEDIMENTONTHISFISH-ANYSTUDIESHAVEBEENDONEONTHEIMPACTOFPOLLUTIONONWINTERFLOUNDERRESULTSOFTHESESTUDIESINDICATETHATORGANICCHEMICALCONTAMINATIONCANCAUSEREPRODUCTIVEDEVELOPMENTALANDOTHERPROBLEMSINWINTERFLOUNDER)NADDITIONFLATFISHESINGENERALSEEMTOBEMORESUSCEPTIBLETOPOLLUTION RELATEDDISEASETHANOTHERFISHES(OWEVERCONTAMINANTSDONOTSEEMTOBIOACCUMULATEINTHEMUSCLETISSUETHATWEEATSOEATINGFLATFISHESGENERALLYSHOULDRESULTINLESSCONTAMINANTINTAKETHANCONSUMINGOTHERSPECIESACCORDINGTOAVAILABLEDATA

&IGUREDEPICTSTHERELATIVEABUNDANCEOFWINTERFLOUNDERIN(AVERSTRAW"AYAND*AMAICA"AYASMEASUREDBYTWO.93$%#YEARLYSURVEYS)N(AVERSTRAW"AYTHEDATAINDICATEASMALLANDFLUCTUATINGPOPULATIONNOTOBVIOUSLYINCREASINGORDECREASINGOVERTIME)N*AMAICA"AYTHEPOPULA

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

>Wl[hijhWm8Wo

@WcW_YW8Wo

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[

ndjc\\"d["i]Z"nZVghjbbZg[adjcYZg^c

=VkZghigVl7Vn&.-%*'%%&VcY?VbV^XV

7Vn&.-)*'%%&=jghi'%%'!=jghiVcY

8dcdkZg'%%&!BX@dlc'%%'#

TIONSEEMSTOHAVEINCREASEDAPPEARINGTOBELARGERINTHESCOM

PAREDTOTHES!BUNDANCEOFWINTERFLOUNDERISHIGHERIN*AMAICA"AYTHANINTHE(UDSON2IVERPRESUMABLYBECAUSEWINTERFLOUNDERPREFERMORESALINEWATERS

!LTHOUGHTHEYAREHEAVILYFISHEDTHEREISSOMEEVIDENCETHATHABITATLOSSANDDEGRADATIONMAYBEASINFLUENTIALASFISHINGPRESSUREONTHEPOPULA

TIONDYNAMICSOFTHISSPECIES"ECAUSEWINTERFLOUNDERSPENDAPORTIONOFTHEIRLIFECYCLEOUTSIDEOFTHEESTUARYBOTHESTUARINEANDOCEANCONDITIONSMUSTBECONSIDEREDINUNDERSTANDINGTHECONTROLSONTHEIRABUNDANCE

3UMMER&LOUNDER

-ORECOMMONLYKNOWNTOANGLERSASFLUKESUMMERFLOUNDERAREANOTHERPOPULARSPORTFISHINTHEESTUARY,IKEOTHERFLOUNDERSSUMMERFLOUNDERSPENDMOSTOFTHEIRTIMEINANDONTHEBOTTOMSEDIMENTSOFTHEESTUARYANDOCEANBUTTHEYAREACTIVEPREDATORSOFTENCHASINGPREYFISHALLTHEWAYTOTHESURFACE3UMMERFLOUNDERSPAWNINTHEOPENOCEANOUTSIDEOFTHEESTUARYINTHEFALLANDWINTERANDMOVEINTOTHEESTUARYINTHESPRINGSTAYINGTHROUGHTHESPRINGANDSUMMER4HENEWLY HATCHEDLARVAEPROB

ABLYENTERTHEESTUARYINTHELATEWINTERANDSPENDTHEIRFIRSTSPRINGANDSUMMERTHERE4HEFOLLOWINGFALLTHEYMIGRATEOUTOFTHEESTUARYAGAINSLIGHTLYAFTERTHEADULTSDO4HEYOVER

WINTERONTHEOUTERPORTIONSOFTHE#ONTINENTAL3HELF3UMMERFLOUNDERCANGROWTOBEINCHESORMOREINLENGTH

3UMMERFLOUNDERUNDERGOANAMAZINGTRANSFORMATIONCOMMONTOALLFLATFISHSPECIES7HENTHELARVAEAREFIRSTHATCHEDTHEYSWIMUPRIGHTANDHAVEEYESPLACEDSYM

METRICALLYONEITHERSIDEOFTHEIRHEADLIKEATYPICALFISH!STHEYAGETHEIRRIGHTEYEMIGRATESOVERTHEIRHEADUNTILBOTHEYESAREONTHELEFTSIDEOFTHEFISHITSRIGHTORhBOTTOMvSIDELOSESITSPIGMENTATIONANDITTAKESUPABOTTOM DWELLINGEXISTENCE

&IGURESHOWSRELATIVEABUNDANCESOFSUMMERFLOUN

DERIN(AVERSTRAW"AYREGIONAND*AMAICA"AYFROMTHESTO.OTETHATPOPULATIONSOFTHISFISHAPPEARTOFLUCTUATEWIDELY,IKEOTHERFISHSPECIESDISCUSSEDINTHISREPORTITISDIF

FICULTTODETERMINEWHATCONTROLSSUMMERFLOUNDERABUNDANCEBUTTHEFAC

TORSCOULDINCLUDEFISHINGPRESSUREPOLLUTIONANDHABITATAVAILABILITY

7HITE0ERCH 7HITEPERCHARESMALLERABOUTINCHESLONGASADULTS BUTNUMEROUSRELATIVESOFSTRIPEDBASS4HEREISVIRTUALLYNOCOMMERCIALFISHERYFORWHITEPERCHINTHISESTUARYALTHOUGH#HESAPEAKE"AYRECORDEDCOMMERCIALLANDINGSOFMILLIONPOUNDSASRECENTLYASANDTHEREARESTILLACTIVECOMMERCIALWHITEPERCHFISHERIESTODAYIN$ELAWAREAND#HESAPEAKE

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[ndjc\\"

d["i]Z"nZVgl]^iZeZgX]^c=VkZghigVl7Vn!

&.-%*'%%&=jghi'%%'!=jghiVcY8dcdkZg

'%%&!BX@dlc'%%'#

"AYS 2ECREATIONALFISHINGFORTHEMISSMALLCOMPAREDTOESTUARINEANDCOASTALSPORTFISHSUCHASSTRIPEDBASSANDBLUEFISH7HITEPERCHAREOFECOLOGICALINTERESTBECAUSEUNLIKESTRIPEDBASSTHEYGENERALLYREMAININTHEESTUARYYEAR ROUNDFORTHEIRENTIRELIFECYCLERATHERTHANMIGRATINGOUTTOTHEOCEAN

&IGURESHOWSTHERELATIVEABUNDANCEOFWHITEPERCHCOLLECTEDINA.EW9ORK3TATESURVEYINTHE(AVERSTRAW"AYREGION!BUNDANCEOFWHITEPERCHHASBEENDECLIN

INGINTHERIVERSURVEYSINCETHEEARLYSWITHTHEEXCEPTIONOFASPIKEINABUNDANCEIN ANDUNI

FORMLYLOWINTHESEXTENDINGADECLININGTRENDTHATBEGANINTHELATES!LTHOUGHTHEEXACTREASONSFORTHISDECLINEARENOTCERTAINITISLIKELYTHATCONDITIONSWITHINTHEESTUARYITSELFHAVEALARGEIMPACTONWHITEPERCHBECAUSEOFTHEIRYEAR ROUNDRESIDENCY4HEREHASBEENSIGNIFICANTCONCERNABOUTTHEIMPACTTHATENTRAIN

MENTANDIMPINGEMENTINTHECOOLINGSYSTEMSOF(UDSON2IVERPOWERPLANTSHAVEONTHEIRPOPULATION)TISALSOPOSSIBLEASSUGGESTEDBYSCIEN

TISTSWHOLOOKEDATWHITEPERCHABUNDANCEINTHESANDSTHATITHASBECOMEHARDERTOMEASUREACCURATELYWHITEPERCHABUNDANCEOVERTIMEBECAUSECOVERAGEOFINVASIVEDENSEVEGETATIONINTHE(UDSONWHICHWHITEPERCHMAYUSEASHABITATHASINCREASED3IMILARDECLINESHAVEBEENOBSERVEDINOTHERSPECIESTHATAREFULL TIMERESIDENTSOFTHEESTUARYINCLUD

INGTOMCODHOGCHOKERANDFOUR SPINESTICKLEBACK

!MERICAN%EL 4HESLIPPERYSNAKE SHAPED!MERICANEELISANOTHERFAMILIARFISHTHATRESIDESINTHE(ARBOR%STUARYFORPARTOFITSLIFECYCLEEXHIBITINGACATAD

ROMOUSLIFEHISTORYOPPOSITETHATOFANADROMOUSSTRIPEDBASSANDSHAD)NSTEADOFCOMINGINTOTHEESTUARYANDRIVERTOSPAWNEELSSPAWNABOUTMILESAWAYFROMTHE(UDSON2IVERINTHE3ARGASSO3EANEARTHE"AHAMASINTHE!TLANTIC/CEANORATLEASTEVIDENCESUGGESTSTHATISWHERETHEYSPAWNnNOONEHASACTUALLYEVERCAPTUREDANADULT!MERICANEELTHEREORSEENTHEMSPAWNING %ELSHAVESTRANGELARVAECALLEDLEPTOCEPHALITHATRESEMBLETRANSPARENTWILLOWLEAVES4HELEPTOCEPHALIDRIFTINOCEANCURRENTSFORUPTOAYEARBEFOREHEADINGTOWARDCOASTALAREASWHERETHEYMETAMORPHOSEINTOhELVERSvWHICHMORECLOSELYRESEMBLESMALLADULTEELSEXCEPTTHATTHEELVERSREMAINTRANSPARENT4HEELVERSUNDERGOANOTHERTRANSFORMATIONTOTHESO CALLEDhYELLOWEELvPHASEWHICHLASTSFORANUM

BEROFYEARSALLOFWHICHARESPENTINTHEESTUARY&INALLYTHEYELLOWEELSTRANSFORMINTOTHEFAMILIARADULTEEL!DULTEELSAREPROBABLYTHEMOSTBROADLYDISTRIBUTEDFISHINTHE(UDSONSYSTEMINHABITINGALLREACHESANDBASINSOFTHEESTUARYFROMSALTWATERTOFRESH!FTERRESIDINGINTHEESTUARYFORTOYEARSTHEYUNDERGOAFINALTRANSFORMATIONTHENMIGRATETOTHE3ARGASSO3EASPAWNANDDIE

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

/NEREASONWHYEELSAREOFGREATINTERESTECOLOGI

CALLYISTHATTHEYSPENDMOSTOFTHEIRTIMEINTHESEDIMENTSATTHEBOTTOMOFTHEESTUARYANDEXHIBITAHIGHDEGREEOFhSITEFIDELITYvMEANINGTHATTHEYTENDTOSTAYINONEAREAANDDONOTMOVEVERYFAR4HESETRAITSMEANTHATITISLIKELYTHATTHEHEALTHANDCONTAMINANTBURDENSINEELSREFLECTTHEENVIRONMENTALCONDITIONSPARTICULARLYTHESEDIMENTCONDITIONSOFTHESITEWHERETHEYARECAPTURED4HEYAREHARDYFISHANDEXHIBITSOMEOFTHEHIGHESTLEVELSOFCONTAMINANTSINTHEHARBORCOREAREAPARTICULARLYINAREASWHERECONTAMINANTSINTHESEDIMENTSAREFOUNDINHIGHCON

CENTRATIONS

4HEREISSTILLASMALLEELFISHERYBOTHFORFOODANDBAITINSOMEPARTSOFTHEESTUARY%ELSAREAPOPU

LARFOODFISHIN%UROPE)NTHESTOMILLIONPOUNDSOFEELSAHIGHPERCENTAGEOFWHICHWERETHEJUVENILEhGLASSEELSv WERESHIPPEDTO%UROPEANDBEYONDFROMTHEEASTCOASTEACHYEARONLYPOUNDSWERESOLDINTHE53PERYEARDURINGTHESAMETIMEPERIOD %ELSHAVESEEMEDTODECLINEOVERTIMEANDIN2ARITAN"AYBYONLYTWOEELFISHERMENWERESTILLABLETOMAKEALIVING

&IGURESHOWSTRENDSINEELABUNDANCEIN.93$%#SEINESURVEYSINTHE(AVERSTRAW"AYREGIONAND*AMAICA"AYFROMTHEMID STO/VERTHATTIMEPERIODTHEPOPULATIONOFEELSINBOTHAREASHASDECLINEDDRA

MATICALLY4HISTRENDISPARTICULARLYWORRISOMEBECAUSEEELSAREGENERALLYVERYHARDY THEYUSUALLYSEEMTOBEABLETOSURVIVEUNDERCONDITIONSTHATWOULDBEDETRIMENTALANDEVENLETHALTOOTHERSPECIES4HEREASONFORTHISPOPULATIONDECLINEISUNKNOWNHOWEVEROVERFISHINGISONELIKELYCAUSE

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

>Wl[hijhWm8Wo

@WcW_YW8Wo

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[ndjc\\"

d["i]Z"nZVg6bZg^XVcZZa^c=VkZghigVl7Vn

&.-**'%%&VcY?VbV^XV7Vn&.-)*'%%&

=jghi'%%'!=jghiVcY8dcdkZg'%%&!

BX@dlc'%%'#

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT&ISHINTHE%STUARY

(EARTBEATSINTHE-UCKBY*OHN7ALDMAN,YONS0RESS

4HE&ISHERIESOF2ARITAN"AYBY#LYDE,-AC+ENZIE*R2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS

4HE)NLAND&ISHESOF.EW9ORK3TATEBY#,3MITH.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

4HE(UDSON2IVER!.ATURALAND5NNATURAL(ISTORYBY2OBERT("OYLE77.ORTONAND#O

4HE(UDSON!N)LLUSTRATED'UIDETOTHE,IVING2IVERBY3TEPHEN03TANNEETAL2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS

WWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEDFWMRMARINEHUDSONINDEXHTML

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

>Wl[hijhWm8Wo

@WcW_YW8Wo

>Wl[hijhWm8Wo

@WcW_YW8Wo

@WcW_YW8Wo "AY!NCHOVY 3ILVERSIDES

+ILLIFISH

&ORAGE&ISH

&ORAGEFISHSOMETIMESREFERREDTOASBAITFISHISAGENERICTERMFORSMALLFISHOFNUMEROUSSPECIESTHATAREPREYEDONBYLARGERFISHFORMINGANIMPORTANTLINKINTHEESTUARYSFOODWEB(EALTHYFORAGEFISHPOPULATIONSARECRITICALTOSUSTAININGPOPULATIONSOFCOMMERCIALANDRECREATIONALFISHSUCHASSTRIPEDBASSANDBLUEFISH)NTHE(ARBOR%STUARYTHREEOFTHEMOSTIMPORTANTFORAGEFISHSPECIESARETHEBAYANCHOVY!TLANTICSILVERSIDEANDKILLIFISH!NCHOVIESANDSILVERSIDESBOTHABOUTnINCHESFULLGROWNARESPAWNEDINESTUARIESINTHESPRINGSPENDTHEIRFIRSTSUMMERINTHEESTUARYANDTHENMIGRATEOUTOFTHEESTUARYTOTHEOCEANINTHEFALL4HESETWOSPECIESARETWOOFTHEMOSTABUNDANTFISHINTHEMID !TLANTIC+ILLIFISHORMUMMICHOGARESMALLERANDCHUBBIERLITTLEFISHTHATARECOMMONYEAR ROUNDINNORTHEASTESTUARIESh+ILLIESvAREIMPORTANTFOODSOURCESFORBOTHFISHANDBIRDPREDATORS

&IGURESHOWSMEASURESOFPOPULATIONSIZEOFBAYANCHOVIES!TLANTICSILVERSIDESANDKILLIFISHASDETER

MINEDBY.93$%#SURVEYSIN(AVERSTRAW"AYAND*AMAICA"AY*AMAICA"AYONLYFORKILLIFISH 7HILETHEREISNOCLEARTRENDINPOPULATIONSOFANYOFTHESESPECIESTHEREISASLIGHTINDICATIONOFANINCREASEINSILVERSIDESIN(AVERSTRAW"AYANDPERHAPSADECLINEINANCHOVIESIN(AVERSTRAW"AY!LLOFTHESESPECIESPOPULATIONSAREKNOWNTOBEHIGHLYVARIABLEFROMYEARTOYEARANDCOULDBESUBSTANTIALLYAFFECTEDBYAVARIETYOFFACTORSINCLUDINGSALINITYTEMPERATURERIVERFLOWPRESENCEOFPREDATORSANDFOODAVAILABIL

ITY)NADDITIONTHEREHASBEENSOMECONCERNOVERTHEIMPACTOFPOWERPLANTSALONGTHE(UDSON2IVERONANCHOVYPOPULATIONSnINSOMEYEARSTHECOOL

INGWATERINTAKESATTHEPLANTSENTRAINDRAWIN ORIMPINGETRAPONTHEIRINTAKESCREENS POTENTIALLYSIG

NIFICANTNUMBERSOFANCHOVY

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[i]gZZheZX^Zhd[[dgV\\Z[^h]

^c=VkZghigVl7Vn&.-**'%%&VcY?VbV^XV7Vn&.-)*'%%&#

CdiZi]ZgZVgZcd=VkZghigVl7VnYViV[dg`^aa^[^h]#CdiZi]ZY^["

[ZgZciN"Vm^hhXVaZh[dgi]Zi]gZZheZX^Zh=jghi'%%'!=jghiVcY

8dcdkZg'%%&!BX@dlc'%%'#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

ATCHPER5NIT%FFORT

>Wl[hijhWm8Wo

@WcW_YW8Wo

&IGURE8ViX]eZgJc^i:((dgid[WajZ

XgVWh^c=VkZghigVl7Vn&.-%*'%%&VcY

?VbV^XV7Vn&.-**'%%&=jghi'%%'!

=jghiVcY8dcdkZg'%%&!BX@dlc'%%'#

"LUE#RAB"LUECRABSSOMETIMESREFERREDTOLOCALLYASBLUECLAWCRABSARECON

SIDEREDONEOFTHEPRIMESYMBOLSOFANOTHERMID !TLANTICESTUARYTHE#HESAPEAKE"AY4HESECRABSAREFOUNDINABUNDANCEINTHE(UDSON2IVER%STUARYASWELLINFACTBLUECRABSCONSTITUTEONEOFTHEFEWREMAININGALBEITSMALL COMMERCIALFISHERIESINTHEESTUARY"LUECRABSAREHARVESTEDCOMMERCIALLYANDRECREATIONALLYINBOTHTHE.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYPOR

TIONSOFTHEESTUARYBUTTHETOTALLANDINGSAREMUCHSMALLERHERETHANINMORESOUTHERNESTUARIESSUCHASTHE#HESAPEAKEBECAUSETHE(UDSONISCLOSETOTHENORTHERNLIMITOFTHESPECIESDISTRIBUTION(ISTORICALLYBLUECRABSWEREHARVESTEDINGREATNUMBERSIN2ARITAN"AYPARTICULARLYINTHESANDS)NTHOSEDAYSSTREETVENDORSIN2ED"ANKSOLDGREATNUMBERSOFSOFT SHELLEDCRABSINTHESUMMERMONTHSFORCENTSEACH&IGURESHOWSARECORDOFBLUECRABABUNDANCEASMEASUREDINASEIN

INGSURVEYCONDUCTEDEVERYYEARFORTHEPASTYEARSINTHE(AVERSTRAW"AYREGIONONTHE(UDSON2IVERANDFORTHEPASTYEARSIN*AMAICA"AY4HESEDATAINDICATETHATBLUECRABABUNDANCEHASREMAINEDFAIRLYSTABLEOVERTHELENGTHOFTHESURVEYIN(AVERSTRAW"AYWITHALARGESPIKEINABUNDANCEINTHELATES#OMMERCIALLANDINGSTATISTICSFORBLUECRABSFROMTHELATESTOSHOWASIMILARSTABILITYINABUNDANCEWITHOCCASIONALSPIKES4HENUMBERSOFCRABSIN*AMAICA"AYHAVEBEENMUCHMOREVARIABLEFROMYEARTOYEARTHANIN(AVERSTRAW"AY

"LUECRABSRELEASETHEIREGGSOFFSHOREANDTHENTHEMICROSCOPICCRABLAR

VAERETURNTOTHEESTUARYBYRIDINGONSHORE BOUNDCURRENTS&LUCTUATIONSINTHEIRPOPULATIONCANTHEREFOREBECAUSEDBYMANYFACTORSBOTHWITHINANDOUTSIDEOFTHEESTUARYMAKINGITVERYDIFFICULTTODETERMINETHECAUSESOFTHECHANGESINBLUECRABABUNDANCEFROMYEARTOYEAR!NINCREASEINABUNDANCEINTHEEARLYSMAYBEATTRIBUTABLETOTHECESSATIONOFPRODUCTIONANDUSEOFTHEPESTICIDE$$4WHICHHADALARGEIMPACTONAQUATICCRUSTACEANPOPULATIONS(OWEVERTHEREISNODIRECTEVIDENCEFORTHISEXPLANATION

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

%.4()##/--5.)49(%!,4(

!NIMALSANDPLANTSASSOCIATEDWITHTHESEDIMENTSATTHEBOTTOMOFTHEESTUARYCALLEDBENTHICORGANISMSAREPARTICULARLYSUSCEP

TIBLETOTHEEFFECTSOFCONTAMINATIONBECAUSETHEYLIVEANDFEEDINANDONTHESEDIMENTSWHICHAREFINALRECEPTACLESFORMUCHOFTHECHEMI

CALCONTAMINATIONINTHEESTUARYANDBECAUSEMANYOFTHEMARENOTMOBILEENOUGHTOESCAPEUNFAVORABLEORTOXICCONDITIONS4HESTRUCTUREOFTHEBENTHICCOMMUNITYnTHENUMBEROFSPECIESTHENUMBEROFINDIVIDUALSOFEACHSPECIESANDTHENUMBEROFPOLLUTION TOLERANTVSPOLLUTION INTOLERANTSPECIESTHEREAREnCANBEANACCURATEINDICATOROFTHEHEALTHOFAGIVENSITE)TISALSOIMPORTANTTOMONITORTHEHEALTHOFTHEBENTHICCOMMUNITYBECAUSETHESEORGANISMSAREIMPORTANTLINKSINTHEESTUARINEFOODWEBANDTHEYPERFORMCRITICALFUNCTIONSWITHRESPECTTONUTRIENTCYCLING

!MONITORINGPROGRAMCONDUCTEDBYTHE%0!CALLEDTHE2EGIONAL%NVIRONMENTAL-ONITORINGAND!SSESSMENT0ROGRAM2 %-!0 HASCONDUCTEDACOMPREHEN

SIVESURVEYOFTHEBENTHICCOMMUNITIESOFTHEHARBORCOREAREAANDCONCURRENTMEASUREMENTSOFSEDIMENTCONTAMINATIONANDTOXICITYINORDERTOCHARACTERIZETHESEDIMENTQUALITYOFTHEHARBOR)NANDAGAININ2 %-!0COL

LECTED SAMPLES OF THE BENTHIC MACROINVERTEBRATES LARGER BENTHIC ORGANISMSWITHOUTBACKBONESSUCHASCLAMSWORMSANDAMPHIPODS ATSITESTHROUGH

OUTTHEHARBOR!TTHESAMELOCATIONSTHEPROGRAMMEASUREDCONCENTRATIONSOFCONTAMINANTSINTHESEDIMENTSANDDETERMINEDWHETHERTHESEDIMENTSATTHOSESITESWERETOXICTOTESTORGANISMSTHEPROGRAMCOLLECTEDDATAINASWELLWHICHARESTILLUNDERGOINGANALYSIS "YCOMBININGANUMBEROFMEASUREMENTSOF CHARACTERISTICS OF THE BENTHIC COMMUNITY NUMBER OF SPECIES NUMBER OFORGANISMSBIOMASSTHEFRACTIONOFPOLLUTION SENSITIVEORGANISMSPRESENTANDTHEFRACTIONOFPOLLUTION TOLERANTORGANISMSPRESENT 2 %-!0HASDEVELOPEDAN INDEX OF BENTHIC COMMUNITY HEALTH BASED ON COMMUNITY CHARACTERISTICSATSTRESSEDANDPRISTINEREFERENCESITESTHROUGHOUTTHEHARBORANDELSEWHERE!PPLYINGTHISINDEXTOBOTHTHEANDDATA%0!CHARACTERIZEDTHEPERCENTAGEOFTHEBENTHICCOMMUNITYINEACHOFTHE2 %-!0SUBBASINSINTHEHARBORCONSIDEREDhIMPACTEDvOROFDEGRADEDQUALITY&IGUREDEPICTSTHEPERCENTAGEOFSAMPLINGSITESWITHINDIFFERENTBASINSOFTHE HARBOR THAT WERE CONSIDERED hIMPACTEDv IN AND THIS ANALYSIS WAS NOT DONE FOR,ONG )SLAND 3OUNDOR THE "IGHT !PEX IN /NE OF THE MOST INTERESTINGRESULTSISTHATFORALLBASINSTHEPERCENTAGEOFIMPACTEDSITESDECREASED BETWEEN AND &OR EXAMPLE IN OFTHESITESANALYZEDIN2ARITAN"AYWERECONSIDEREDIMPACTEDWHILEONLYWEREIMPACTEDINTHESURVEY)TISALSOINTERESTINGTONOTETHATTHESITESWITHIMPACTEDBEN

THICCOMMUNITIESWEREALSOTHESITESWHEREHIGHSEDIMENTCONTAMINATION LEVELS AND THE MOST TOXIC SEDIMENTS WERERECORDEDINTHEOTHERANALYSESCONDUCTEDBY2 %-!0SEEPAGESANDINTHISREPORT /FTHESITESWITHIMPACTED'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT"ENTHIC#OMMUNITIES

WWWCSCNOAAGOVLCRNYHARBORHTMLBACKGROUND

INTROHTML WWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEIMSMAPSBENTHIC

WEBPAGESBIBLIOHTML WWWCHESAPEAKEBAYNETINFOBENTHOSCFM

BENTHICCOMMUNITIESINHADEITHERHIGHCONCENTRATIONSOFCONTAMI

NANTSINTHESEDIMENTSORHIGHSEDIMENTTOXICITYANDEXHIBITEDBOTHHIGHCONTAMINATIONANDHIGHTOXICITY

4HE SMALLER NUMBER OF IMPACTED SITES IN IS ENCOURAGING 4HE DIFFER

ENCES BETWEEN THE YEARS IN THREE OF THE BASINS ARE STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANTSIGNIFICANTLYFEWEROFTHEBASINSITESWEREIMPACTEDINTHANINFORTHE5PPER(ARBOR,OWER(ARBORAND*AMAICA"AYBUTNOTFOR.EWARK"AY (OWEVERDATAFROMJUSTTWOYEARSDONOTCONSTITUTEATREND-OREDATALIKETHESEMUSTBECOLLECTEDINFUTUREYEARSINORDERTODETERMINEIFAPATTERNOFDECREASINGIMPACTEDBENTHOSISACTUALLYOCCURRING%$)-%.4,/!$).'

-ANY PEOPLE ASSUME THAT BECAUSE THE WATERS OF THE (ARBOR%STUARY ARE NOT CRYSTAL CLEAR LIKE THOSE OF THE #ARIBBEAN OR AMOUNTAINSTREAMTHEESTUARYISHOPELESSLYPOLLUTED"UTTHE(UDSON2IVERAND.EW9ORK(ARBORARENATURALLYTURBIDWATERSPARTIALLYBECAUSETHEYCARRYANDMOVEAROUNDSOMUCHSUSPENDEDSEDIMENT-UCHOFTHISSEDIMENTLOADBEGINSASSOILSANDANDMUDONTHELANDTHATISWASHEDINTOTHEESTUARYSOMEWHEREINTHEWATERSHEDOFTHEHARBOR)TCANTHENTRAVELDOWNRIVERUNTILITSETTLESOUTINAMOREQUIESCENTAREAOFTHEESTUARY3OMETIMESTHEJOURNEYOFAPARTICLEDOESNOTENDTHEREnPARTICLESOFSEDIMENTCANBERESUSPENDEDDURINGTIDALORSTORMEVENTSANDREDEPOSITEDELSEWHERE

!LTHOUGHITISNORMALFORARIVERESTUARYSYSTEMTOCARRYSUSPENDEDSEDIMENTHUMANACTIVITIESCANCAUSESEDIMENTLOADSTOINCREASEWITHSERIOUSENVIRON

3

&IGUREEZgXZciV\\Zd[WZci]^XXdb" bjc^i^Zh^beVXiZYVcYjc^beVXiZY^chjW" WVh^chd[i]Z=VgWdg:hijVgn^c&..(VcY

&..-#CdiZi]Vii]ZgZVgZcdYViV[dgAdc\\

>haVcYHdjcYVcYi]ZCZlNdg`7^\\]i6eZm

^c&..-6YVbh'%%'#

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY

5PPER.EW 9ORK(ARBOR

.EWARK"AY 5PPER.EW 9ORK(ARBOR

.EWARK"AY

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 2ARITAN "AY 5PPER.EW 9ORK(ARBOR

.EWARK"AY 5PPER.EW 9ORK(ARBOR

.EWARK"AY

.EW9ORK "IGHT!PEX

5NIMPACTED 0ERCENT)MPACTED 2ARITAN "AY

.EW9ORK "IGHT!PEX

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

MENTAL CONSEQUENCES -UCH OF THE SUSPENDED SEDIMENT LOAD OF THE (ARBOR%STUARYCONSISTSOFVERYSMALLPARTICLESnMUDRATHERTHANSAND-OLECULESOF CHEMICAL CONTAMINANTS PREFERENTIALLY ATTACH THEMSELVES TO THESE SMALLERPARTICLESANDTHENHITCHARIDEFROMTHEIRSOURCETOTHEESTUARY(IGHSEDIMENTLOADSALSOSETTLEINTHEHARBORCLOGGINGSHIPPINGCHANNELSANDMAKINGDREDG

INGOFTHESEOFTEN CONTAMINATEDSEDIMENTSNECESSARYINORDERTOKEEPTHEPORTOPEN"ECAUSETHESEDIMENTSARECONTAMINATEDDISPOSALOPTIONSARELIMITEDCONTENTIOUS AND FREQUENTLY EXPENSIVE &INALLY IN THOSE AREAS WHERE HEAVYSEDIMENTATIONISINDUCEDSUSPENDEDSEDIMENTCANSETTLEOUTONTOTHEBOTTOMANDSMOTHERSENSITIVEHABITATSSUCHASOYSTERREEFSANDSEAGRASSBEDS

,ANDUSEHASATREMENDOUSIMPACTONSEDIMENTLOAD$ENSETREESANDOTHERVEGETATION OF FORESTED LANDS hGRIPv THE SOIL TIGHTLY PREVENTING EROSION ANDRESULTINGSEDIMENTRUNOFFTOLOCALTRIBUTARIES,ANDCLEAREDFORAGRICULTUREISMOREPRONETOEROSIONANDTHEREFOREISAPROPORTIONALLYHIGHERSOURCEOFSEDI

MENTTOTHEESTUARY,ANDCLEARINGANDEARTHMOVINGFORURBANDEVELOPMENTISPOTENTIALLYANEVENGREATERSOURCEOFSEDIMENTTOWATERWAYSTHANAGRICULTURALLANDCLEARING&URTHERPAVEDSUBURBANANDURBANLANDSRETAINLESSSEDIMENTONLANDTHANVEGETATEDAREASANDPAVEDAREASCANCHANNELTHEFLOWINTOADJA

CENTSTREAMSANDCAUSEEROSION2ESEARCHERSHAVEUSEDINFORMATIONABOUTLANDUSEANDWEATHER PATTERNS TO CONSTRUCT A MATHEMATICAL MODELTHAT CALCULATES WHAT SEDIMENT LOADING TO THE (UDSON2IVERMIGHTHAVEBEENINTHEPASTUNDERHISTORICALLANDUSES&IGURESHOWSTHEMODELINGRESULTSASSEDIMENTFLUXARELATIVEMEASUREOFSEDIMENTLOADINGCOMPAREDTOTODAYWHICHISSETAS4HEFIGURESHOWSSEDIMENTLOADS FROM THE,OWER (UDSON 2IVER 5PPER (UDSON2IVERAND-OHAWK2IVERSCOMBINED4HEGRAPHSHOWSTHEPROGRESSIONFROMPRE COLONIALFORESTEDLANDTOTHEPEAKOFAGRICULTUREINTHE(UDSON6ALLEYINTHESTOTHEPRESENT DAYSITUATION4HESERESULTSINDICATETHATBECAUSEMUCHOFTHELANDONCEUSEDFORAGRICULTUREHASTODAYREVERTEDTOFORESTEDLANDSSEDIMENTLOADINGONALARGESCALEHASACTUALLYDECREASEDBETWEENTHELATETHCENTURYANDTODAY&IGURESHOWSESTIMATESOFCURRENTSEDIMENTLOADINGSTO THE HARBOR BASED ON DATA COLLECTED FOR USE IN THEMATHEMATICALMODELINGACTIVITIESOFTHE#ONTAMINATION!SSESSMENTAND2EDUCTION0ROJECT#!20 OFTHE(%04HESEESTIMATESAREBASEDONDATACOLLECTEDBYTHE53'EOLOGICAL3URVEY53'3 &IGURE!SHOWSTHEPER

CENTAGEOFTHETOTALSEDIMENTLOADTHATCOMESFROMAVARIETYOFSOURCESNOTETHATTHELARGESTSOURCEOFSEDI

MENTTOTHEHARBORISTHETRIBUTARIESTHERIVERSENTERINGTHEESTUARY &IGURE"BREAKSDOWNTHEPIESLICEOFTRIBUTARYLOADINTOSPECIFICRIVERS4HEVASTMAJORITY-BOEVTF

&ORESTED

PRE COLONIAL

!GRICULTURAL

S

4ODAY

S

!NNUALSEDIMENTFLUX

SCALEDTOCURRENTFLUX

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGURE8VaXjaViZYVccjVahZY^bZciadVY^c\\hidi]Z

=jYhdcG^kZgjcYZgi]gZZaVcYjhZ$i^bZeZg^dYhXZcVg^dh#

AdVY^c\\h^cXajYZXVaXjaVi^dch[dgi]ZJeeZgVcYAdlZg

=jYhdcVcYi]ZBd]Vl`G^kZgHlVcZnZiVa#&..+#

MWj[hi^[Zjh_XkjWh_[i I[mW][jh[Wjc[djfbWdji 9IE!IjehcmWj[h Ce^WmaH_l[h Kff[h>kZiedH_l[h Bem[h>kZiedJh_XkjWh_[i HedZekj!MWba_bbH_l[hi HW^mWo";b_pWX[j^"DWl[i_da"I^h[miXkhoH_l[hi FWiiW_Y!IWZZb[H_l[hi

>WYa[diWYaH_l[hi HWh_jWd!Iekj^H_l[hi BeWZ_d]i\\hecWbbiekhY[i Jh_XkjWhobeWZ_d]i

OFSEDIMENTSENTERINGTHEHARBORCOMEFROMTHE(UDSON5PPERAND,OWER AND-OHAWK2IVERS)TISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATTHEPIECHARTSIN&IGUREFORnREFLECTAVER

AGECONDITIONSINTHEESTUARY3EDIMENTLOADINGSTOTHEHARBORWERECALCULATEDFORTWOOTHERYEARSnANDn ANDTHERESULTSDEMONSTRATEDTHATTHELOADSCANVARYSUBSTANTIALLYFROMYEARTOYEAR&ORINSTANCELOADSCALCULATED FOR n ARE MORE THAN THREE TIMES THE AMOUNT ESTIMATEDFOR n 4HE AMOUNT OF RAINFALL ALONG WITH THE DURATION AND INTENSITYOFSTORMSSTRONGLYINFLUENCESTHEAMOUNTOFSEDIMENTTHATWASHESINTOTHEESTUARY

&IGURE6ccjVahZY^bZciadVY^c\\hidi]Z

CN$C?=VgWdg:hijVgn!&.--*-.#;^\\jgZ6

h]dlhadVY^c\\h[gdbi]gZZhdjgXZh/ig^WjiVg^Zh!

hZlV\\ZigZVibZcieaVcih!VcY8HDhVcYhidgb

lViZg#;^\\jgZ7WgZV`hYdlci]Zig^WjiVgn

hdjgXZXViZ\\dgn^cid^cY^k^YjVaig^WjiVg^Zh

B^aaZg'%%(#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT3EDIMENT,OADING

NYWATERUSGSGOVPROJECTSPOUSED

NYWATERUSGSGOVPUBSWRIWRI72)2 TOCHTM WWWCARPWEBORG

/.4!-).!.4,/!$).'3!.$,%6%,3).3%$)-%.4

/NEOFTHEMOSTCHALLENGINGANDSERIOUSPROBLEMSFACINGTHEESTUARYISCON

TAMINATIONOFITSSEDIMENTSWITHAVARIETYOFORGANICANDINORGANICTOXINSINCLUDING0#"SDIOXINSMERCURYANDOTHERHEAVYMET

ALSPESTICIDESSUCHAS$$4ANDPOLYCYCLICAROMATICHYDROCARBONS0!(SDERIVATIVESOFPETROLEUMPRODUCTS 7HILESOMEOFTHESECONTAMINATEDSEDIMENTSAREVESTIGESOFTHEPRE #LEAN7ATER!CTINDUSTRIALHARBORTHEREARESTILLACTIVESOURCESOFCONTAMINANTSINCLUDINGINDUSTRIALDISCHARGESLEAKSANDSPILLSLANDFILLSANDINPUTSFROMSEWAGETREAT

MENTPLANTSCOMBINEDSEWEROVERFLOWSANDTRIBUTARIES4HESEPERSISTENTCONTAMINANTS

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

4OXIC#ONTAMINATION

CANCAUSEANUMBEROFECOLOGICALANDECONOMICPROBLEMS/NEOFTHEMAINPATHWAYSFORCONTAMINANTSTOACCUMULATEINTHETISSUEOFFISHANDSHELLFISHINCLUDINGEDIBLESPECIESISTHROUGHTHEFOODCHAIN#ONTAMINANTSBUILDUPINTHEBOTTOM DWELLINGORGANISMSTHATFEEDINTHESEDIMENTSWHICHCANTHENBECONSUMEDBYBLUECRABSSTRIPEDBASSORANYOFTHEOTHERESTUARYRESIDENTSTHATWEWOULDLIKETOEAT!NOTHERPROBLEMISTHATTHEDISPOSALOFCONTAMI

NATEDSEDIMENTDREDGEDFROMTHEHARBORTOENSURETHATTHEPORTISNAVIGABLEISEXPENSIVEANDCONTENTIOUS&IGURESTHROUGHSHOWTRENDSOVERTIMEINSEDIMENTCONCENTRATIONSOFMERCURY 0#"S DIOXIN AND $$4 A PESTICIDE FOUR CONTAMINANTS WHICH AREOFCONCERNINTHEHARBOR4HESEDATAWEREGENERATEDBYTAKINGCORESnINTACTCOLUMNSnOFSEDIMENTFROMAREASINTHEESTUARYWHERESEDIMENTISDEPOS

ITEDINAUNIFORMWAYANDNOTERODEDOVERTIME"YLOOKINGATCONTAMINANTCONCENTRATIONSATDIFFERENTDEPTHSINTHECOREWHICHCORRESPONDTOPARTICULARYEARSORSPANSOFYEARSAHISTORYOFSEDIMENTCONTAMINATIONATASITECANBEGENERATED

$URINGTHEPASTYEARSLEVELSOFMOSTOFTHESECONTAMINANTSHAVEDECREASEDONAVERAGEBYABOUTANORDEROFMAGNITUDE FOLD 4HISDECREASEISDUEMAINLYTOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFANUMBEROFCONTROLMEASURESREQUIREDBYTHE#LEAN7ATER!CTINPARTICULARASTRICTPERMITTINGSYSTEMFORTHEDISCHARGEOFTHESECHEMICALSINTOOURWATERWAYSANDIMPROVEDSEWAGETREATMENT)NADDI

TION$$4AND0#"SARENOWBANNEDFROMPRODUCTIONINTHE5NITED3TATESSOTHEREAREFEWACTIVEDISCHARGESOFTHESECHEMICALSALTHOUGHLEAKSANDSPILLSOFSTOREDMATERIALARESTILLPOTENTIALCONTINUINGSOURCESTOTHEESTUARYASAREBY PRODUCTSOFVARIOUSINDUSTRIALPROCESSES 4HEHORIZONTALREDLINEONEACHOFTHEPLOTSINFIGURESnINDICATESTHE%2 -EFFECTSRANGE MEDIANSEEBOXONPAGE FORTHATCONTAMINANT)NALMOSTALLCASESDECLININGCONTAMI

NANTLEVELSINALLAREASAREAPPROACHINGORBELOWTHATLEVEL0#"SINTHE!RTHUR+ILLAND.EWARK"AYSTILLEXCEEDTHE%2 -INTHISANALYSISASDOESMERCURYINMANYOFTHEBASINSSTUDIED$$4LEVELSAREHIGHINTHE,OWER 0ASSAIC 2IVER AND JUST ABOVE THE %2 - IN.EWARK"AYANDTHE!RTHUR+ILL,EVELSOFSOMEOTHERIMPORTANTCONTAMI

NANTSNOTABLY0!(SHAVENOTDECREASEDATTHESAMERATESANDARESTILLOFCONCERNINTHEHARBOR

&IGURES n SHOWSURFACE SEDIMENT CON

CENTRATIONSOFAVARIETYOFCONTAMINANTSASMEASURED BY 2 %-!0IN AND AGAIN IN )N BOTH YEARSTHE 2 %-!0 PROGRAMMEASURED THE LEVELS OF'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREBZgXjgnXdcXZcigV" i^dch^cCN$C?=VgWdg:hijVgnhZY^"

bZcihdkZgbjai^eaZYZXVYZh#GZY

a^cZdc\\gVe]h^cY^XViZh:G"B[dg

bZgXjgnhZZh^YZWVgdc:G"Bh

7dee'%%%#

&IGUREE87XdcXZcigVi^dch

^cCN$C?=VgWdg:hijVgnhZY^bZcih

dkZgbjai^eaZYZXVYZh#GZYa^cZdc

\\gVe]h^cY^XViZh:G"B[dgE87h

hZZh^YZWVgdc:G"Bh

7dee'%%%#

2ARITAN"AY (UDSON2IVER

!RTHUR+ILL

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY 5PPER"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

+ILL6AN+ULL

.%7*%23%9 2ARITAN"AY (UDSON2IVER

!RTHUR+ILL

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY 5PPER"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2//+,9.

+ILL6AN+ULL

.%7*%23%9

.EWARK"AY

-ERCURYPPM

S

.EWARK "AY

-ERCURYPPM

S

+ILL6AN

+ULL

-ERCURYPPM

S

!RTHUR+ILL

-ERCURYPPM

S

S 2ARITAN "AY

-ERCURYPPM

S

.9.*

(ARBOR

-ERCURYPPM

S

AMAICA"AY (UDSON2IVER

!RTHUR+ILL

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

+ILL6AN+ULL

.%7

%23%9 (UDSON2IVER

!RTHUR+ILL

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 15%%.3 15%%.3 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

+ILL6AN+ULL

.%7

%23%9

.EWARK"AY

0#"SPPM

S

S 5PPER 0ASSAIC 0#"SPPM

S

.EWARK "AY 0#"SPPM

!RTHUR

+ILL 0#"SPPM

S

.9.*

(ARBOR 0#"SPPM

S

AMAICA "AY 2ARITAN"AY 2ARITAN"AY 5PPER"AY 5PPER"AY

&IGURE9^dm^cXdcXZcigVi^dch

^cCN$C?=VgWdg:hijVgnhZY^bZcih

dkZgbjai^eaZYZXVYZh#GZYa^cZdc

\\gVe]h^cY^XViZh:E6<j^YVcXZ

KVajZ[dgY^dm^chZZh^YZWVgdc

G"Bh7dee'%%%#

&IGURE99IXdcXZcigVi^dch

^cCN$C?=VgWdg:hijVgnhZY^"

bZcihdkZgbjai^eaZYZXVYZh#GZY

a^cZdc\\gVe]h^cY^XViZh:G"B

[dg99IhZZh^YZWVgdc:G"Bh

7dee'%%%#

(UDSON2IVER

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

+ILL6AN+ULL (UDSON2IVER

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 15%%.3 15%%.3 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

+ILL6AN+ULL

.%7*%23%9

.EWARK"AY

.EWARK"AY 2ARITAN"AY 2ARITAN"AY 5PPER"AY 5PPER"AY

4#$$PPTR

S

,OWER 0ASSAIC

4#$$PPTR

S

.EWARK "AY

4#$$PPTR

S

.9.*

(ARBOR

4#$$PPTR

S

AMAICA"AY

!RTHUR+ILL

!RTHUR+ILL 2ARITAN"AY (UDSON2IVER

!RTHUR+ILL

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY 5PPER"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

+ILL6AN+ULL

.%7*%23%9 2ARITAN"AY (UDSON2IVER

!RTHUR+ILL

-!.(!44!.

AMAICA"AY 5PPER"AY

,ONG

)SLAND 3OUND 3!.$9

(//+

34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2//+,9.

+ILL6AN+ULL

.%7*%23%9

.EWARK"AY

PPg$$$PPB

S

,OWER 0ASSAIC

PPg$$$PPB

S

.EWARK "AY

PPg$$$PPB

S

!RTHUR

+ILL

PPg$$$PPB

S

S 2ARITAN"AY

PPg$$$PPB

S

AMAICA "AY

PPg$$$PPB

S

.9.*

(ARBOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREAZkZahd[

bZgXjgn^cCN$C?=VgWdg

hijVgnhZY^bZcihVh

XdbeVgZYidi]Z:G"B

kVajZ^c&..(VcY&..-

JH:E6&..-W!6YVbh

'%%'#

&IGUREAZkZah

d[XVYb^jb^cCN$C?

=VgWdg:hijVgnhZY^"

bZcihVhXdbeVgZYid

i]Z:G"BkVajZ^c&..(

VcY&..-JH:E6

&..-W!6YVbh'%%'#

&IGUREAZkZahd[

c^X`Za^cCN$C?=VgWdg

hijVgnhZY^bZcihVh

XdbeVgZYidi]Z:G"B

kVajZ^c&..(VcY&..-

JH:E6&..-W!6YVbh

'%%'#

-ERCURYIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0

-ERCURYIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0n

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

ADMIUMIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0

ADMIUMIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0n

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

.ICKELIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0

.ICKELIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0n

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREAZkZahd[

aZVY^cCN$C?=VgWdg

hijVgnhZY^bZcihVhXdb" eVgZYidi]Z:G"BkVajZ^c

&..(VcY&..-JH:E6

&..-W!6YVbh'%%'#

&IGUREAZkZahd[

h^akZg^cCN$C?=VgWdg

hijVgnhZY^bZcihVh

XdbeVgZYidi]Z:G"B

kVajZ^c&..(VcY&..-

JH:E6&..-W!6YVbh

'%%'#

&IGUREAZkZahd[

Y^dm^ch^cCN$C?=VgWdg

hijVgnhZY^bZcihVh

XdbeVgZYidi]Z:G"B

kVajZ^c&..(VcY&..-

JH:E6&..-W!6YVbh

'%%'#

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

,EADIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0

,EADIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0n

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

3ILVERIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0

3ILVERIN3EDIMENTS2 %-!0n

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

$IOXININ3EDIMENTS2 %-!0

$IOXININ3EDIMENTS2 %-!0n

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

"ELOW%2 -

!BOVE%2 -

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

THESECONTAMINANTSANDOTHERS INSURFACESEDIMENTSATTHESITESREPRESENTEDBYTHEDOTSONTHEMAPS4HEREDDOTSINDICATESTATIONSWHERETHECONTAMINANTINQUESTIONISABOVETHE%2 -EFFECTSRANGE MEDIANSEEBOXBELOWFORANEXPLANATION FORTHATCHEMICALWHILETHEBLUEDOTSINDICATESTATIONSWHERETHECONCENTRATIONISBELOWTHE%2 -FORTHATCHEMICAL)TAPPEARSTHATNOTMUCHCHANGEHASTAKENPLACEBETWEENANDWITHRESPECTTOTHELOCATIONOFTHEMORECONTAMINATEDSITES&OREXAMPLELEVELSOFMERCURYCADMIUMNICKELANDLEADINALLOFTHEBASINSARENOTSTATISTICALLYDIFFERENTINAND&OR SILVER THE ONLY SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE IS IN.EWARK "AY WHERE SEDIMENTCONCENTRATIONSOFSILVERWERESIGNIFICANTLYHIGHERINTHANIN.EWARK"AYANDTHE+ILLSSTANDOUTASPROBLEMAREASINBOTHSURVEYSANDONEORTWOSTATIONS IN THE %AST 2IVER7ESTERN,ONG )SLAND 3OUND EXCEED THE %2 - FORSOMECONTAMINANTS4HEREWASNOTMUCHOVERALLCHANGEINDIOXINLEVELSINTHEESTUARYBETWEENAND.OTETHATSTATIONSIN,ONG)SLAND3OUNDANDTHE"IGHTWERENOTSAMPLEDINTHESURVEY

7ATERCOLUMNMEASUREMENTSOFHEAVYMETALSSHOWPATTERNSSIMILARTOTHOSEOBSERVEDINSEDIMENTS)NTHEMID TOLATESSCIENTISTSMEASUREDLEVELSOFCOPPERCADMIUMNICKELZINCMERCURYSILVERLEADANDOTHERCONTAMINANTSDISSOLVEDINTHEWATERTHROUGHOUTTHEESTUARYANDCOMPAREDTHEMTOSIMILARMEASUREMENTSTHATHADBEENMADEINTHES4HEYFOUNDTHATMOSTMETALCONCENTRATIONS DECREASED SIGNIFICANTLY IN THOSE YEARS SOME AS MUCH AS4HEYATTRIBUTEDTHEDECLINESTODECREASEDINDUSTRIALANDSEWAGETREAT

MENTPLANTDISCHARGES(OWEVERTHEYPOINTEDOUTTHATCURRENTSOURCESOFMANYOFTHESEMETALSARENOTSOEASYTOCONTROLASTHEYSEEMTOBECOMINGFROMNON POINTSOURCESSUCHASRESERVOIRSOFCONTAMINANTSINWATERSHEDSOILSANDESTUARINESEDIMENTS

!NOTHERIMPORTANTPARAMETERISTHEAMOUNTOFAGIVENCONTAMINANTENTERINGTHEESTUARYATTHECURRENTTIMERATHERTHANTHECONCENTRATIONPRESENTINTHESEDI

MENTALREADY4HISPARAMETERISCALLEDTHECONTAMINANTLOADING,OADINGSARENOTORIOUSLYDIFFICULTANDEXPENSIVETOMEASUREANDASARESULTVERYFEWMEA

SUREMENTSOFLOADINGSHAVEBEENMADE!COMPREHENSIVECONTAMINANTMONI

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR 7HATISAN%FFECTS2ANGEn-EDIAN

4HE%2 -ISANUMBERUSEDTOCORRELATESEDIMENTCONTAMI

NATIONWITHOBSERVEDEFFECTSINORGANISMSANDBIOLOGICALCOMMUNITIES)TWASORIGINALLYDEVELOPEDBYSCIENTISTSATTHE.ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION!N%2 -FORAPARTICULARCONTAMINANTISTHEMEDIANSEDIMENTCONTAMINANT CONCENTRATION AT WHICH ADVERSE BIOLOGICALEFFECTSHAVEBEENOBSERVEDTHEMEDIANISTHEVALUEINADATASETTHATHASANEQUALNUMBEROFVALUESONEITHERSIDEOFITANDISTYPICALLYDIFFERENTFROMTHEMEANORAVERAGE 2ESULTSFROMAVARIETYOFSTUDIESOFTHEGIVENCONTAMINANTAREUSUALLYCOMBINEDTODEVELOPTHE%2 -4HESEVALUESARENOTREGULATORYGUIDELINESANDTHEYINDICATEONLYACOR

RELATIONRATHERTHANACAUSALRELATIONSHIP(OWEVERTHEYAREAMONGTHEONLYGUIDANCENUMBERSAVAILABLEINEXAM

ININGTHEPOTENTIALEFFECTSOFSEDIMENTCONTAMINATIONONORGANISMS&ORDIOXINTHE%0!GUIDANCEVALUEISSLIGHTLYDIFFERENT FROM THE %2 - AND REPRESENTS THE SEDIMENTCONCENTRATIONATWHICHTHEREISHIGHRISKTOMAMMALIANWILDLIFECONSUMINGFOODCONTAMINATEDWITHDIOXIN

TORINGPROGRAMTHE#ONTAMINATION!SSESSMENTAND2EDUCTION0ROJECT#!20 ISCURRENTLYCON

DUCTINGANASSESSMENTOFALLOFTHELOADINGSTOTHE ESTUARY OF A LARGE SUITE OF CHEMICALS !FEW OTHER MEASURES OF CONTAMINANT LOADINGSAREAVAILABLENOW&IGURESHOWSESTIMATEDLOADINGS OF MERCURY A TOXIC HEAVY METAL TOTHE HARBOR BETWEEN AND -OST OFTHESEESTIMATESWEREGENERATEDFROMINDUSTRIALANDOTHERRECORDSOFMERCURYUSEANDDISPOSALINTHE(UDSON 2ARITANBASIN4HELASTBARONTHE GRAPH COLORED BLUE WAS GENERATED MORERECENTLY USING A SIMILAR APPROACH 4HE PAT

TERN INDICATES A TREND OF INCREASING LOADINGSTHROUGH THE S AND A DECREASE FROM THESTODUETOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFANUMBEROFENVIRONMENTALLAWSANDMORESTRIN

GENTPOLLUTIONPREVENTIONINITIATIVESUNDERTAKENBYDISCHARGERSINTHES4HEPIECHARTIN&IGUREDEPICTSTHETHREEKEYSOURCESOFTHECURRENT LOADINGOFMERCURYTOTHEWATERSHEDOFTHE(ARBOR%STUARYWASTEWATERDEPO

SITIONFROMAIRBORNEMERCURYANDLANDFILLS/FTHEAPPROXIMATELYKGOFMERCURYTHATENTERSTHE(ARBOR%STUARYYEARLYTHEMOSTIMPORTANTVEHICLEISWASTEWATER4HETABLEIN&IGURELISTSTHEMOSTIMPORTANTINDIVIDUALCONTRIB

UTORSTOEACHOFTHOSESOURCES$ENTALFACILITIESCONTRIBUTETHEMOSTMERCURYTO BOTH THE WASTEWATER AND LANDFILL POOLS OTHER IMPORTANT SOURCES INCLUDEHOSPITALSAUTOMOBILESWITCHESFURNACESANDTHERMOSTATS7oh[i Z[9[hh[e

-ERCURYMETRICTONS

BWdZ\\_bbi MWij[mWj[h 7_h

+G9R

+G9R 3OURCE

-OST)MPORTANT#ONTRIBUTORS 7ASTEWATER

$ENTAL&ACILITIES (OSPITALS

,ABORATORIES

!IR 5TILITIES&URNACES

)NDUSTRIAL#OMMERCIAL&URNACES

!UTOMOBILE3WITCHES

)NCINERATIONOF&LUORESCENT,AMPS

!UTOMOBILE&UEL#OMBUSTION (OUSEHOLDS&URNACES4HERMOMETERSETC

,ANDFILLS

$ENTAL&ACILITIES(OSPITALS

!UTOMOBILE3WITCHES 4HERMOSTATS

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGURE:hi^bViZYbZgXjgnadVY^c\\hidi]Z=VgWdg[gdbV^g!lVhiZlViZg!

VcYaVcY[^aah#IVWaZh]dlhi]Zbdhi^bedgiVciXdcig^WjidghidZVX]d[i]dhZi]gZZ

eddahYZ8ZggZdZiVa#'%%'#

&IGUREBZgXjgnadVY^c\\hidi]Z

=VgWdg:hijVgn!&--%*'%%%6ngZhVcY

GdY&.-+!YZ8ZggZdZiVa#'%%'#

&IGURE SHOWS THE ESTIMATED LOADINGS OF $$4TO THE ESTUARY BETWEEN THE MID S AND -ORECURRENTESTIMATESOFLOADINGSWILLBEPROVIDEDBY THE #!20 PROGRAM DESCRIBED ABOVE "ECAUSE$$4USEWASBANNEDINTHE53INLOADINGSTO THE ESTUARY HAVE BEEN DECLINING FOR DECADES(OWEVERREMNANT$$4INTHEESTUARYSSEDIMENTSASWELLASLOADSFROMLEAKSANDSPILLSOFSTORED$$4ISSTILLAPROBLEM

%$)-%.44/8)#)49 3EDIMENT TOXICITY TESTING IS ONE WAY TO DETERMINE THE QUALITY OFMARINESEDIMENTS4YPICALLYTESTORGANISMSAREEXPOSEDTOTESTANDREFERENCESEDIMENTSFORAPROSCRIBEDNUMBEROFDAYSANDTHENTHESURVIVORSARECOUNTED4HERESULTSOFTHESETESTSCANTELLUSABOUTTHEIMPACTSOFSEDIMENTQUALITYONTHEHEALTHOFTHEMARINEENVIRONMENTBUTTHEYDONOTINDICATETHEIMPACTOFTHESESEDIMENTSONHUMANHEALTH/NEPROGRAMTHATHASGENERATEDSEDIMENTTOXICITYDATAIS2 %-!0DESCRIBEDPREVIOUSLY ON PAGE 4HIS PROGRAM EXPOSED AMPHIPODS FOR DAYS TOSEDIMENTSAMPLESFROMDIFFERENTSITESINSIXBASINS.EW9ORK"IGHT!PEX*AMAICA"AY7ESTERN,ONG)SLAND3OUND.EWARK"AY2ARITAN"AYANDTHE5PPER(ARBOR%AST2IVER ANDTOCLEANREFERENCESEDIMENTS4HERESULTSAREEXPRESSEDASAMPHIPODSURVIVALASAPER

CENTAGEOFTHESURVIVALOBSERVEDINTHEREFERENCETANKSSUCHTHATIFTHESAMENUMBEROFAMPHIPODSSURVIVEDINTHETESTSEDIMENTSANDTHEREFERENCETHESCOREWOULDBE!SCOREBELOWISCONSIDEREDTOXICANDASCOREBELOWISCONSIDEREDHIGHLYTOXIC&IGURES!AND"SHOWTHERESULTSOFTHESETESTSINAND#LOSE UPSOF*AMAICA"AYAREINCLUDEDFORBOTHYEARSFORCLARITYSINCESOMEPOINTSAREOVERLAPPINGANDOBSCUREDONTHEMAPSOFTHEENTIREHARBOR

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

$$4LOADINGMETRICTONS

&IGURE:hi^bViZhd[99IadVY^c\\idi]Z=VgWdg:hijVgn

b^Y"&.)%h*&.-%6ngZhVcYGdY&.-+#

3

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT4OXIC#ONTAMINANTS

WWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEDOWCARPINTROHTM WWWRPIEDULOCKERDXHARBORWWWHARBORHTML WWWEPAGOVEMAPREMAPINDEXHTML WWWEPAGOVHUDSON WWWNANUSACEARMYMILBUSINESSPRJLINKSDMMPPREVENT

WWWNYASORGSCITECHHARBOR

WWWCARPWEBORG

!COMPARISONOFTHEANDDATAREVEALSTHATTHENUMBEROFHIGHLYTOXICSITESINCREASEDFROMSITESOFTHESITESSAMPLED INTOSITESOFTHETOTALNUMBEROFSITESSAMPLED IN4HEGEOGRAPHICALDISTRIBU

TIONOFhPROBLEMSPOTSvALSOCHANGEDSOMEWHAT4HEAREAOFHIGHESTCONCERNINn.EWARK"AYANDTHE+ILLSnREMAINEDSOINBUT2ARITAN"AYEXHIBITEDFEWERTOXICSITESANDTWOHIGHLYTOXICSITESWEREREVEALEDINWESTERN,ONG)SLAND3OUND*AMAICA"AYISANAREAOFSERIOUSINCREASINGCONCERN&OURSITESINTHE"AYWERECONSIDEREDHIGHLYTOXICINANDSEVENSITESWEREDETERMINEDTOBEHIGHLYTOXICIN

)TISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATWHILETHEDIFFERENCEBETWEENTHETWOYEARSSUGGESTSTHAT THINGS MAY BE ON THE WRONG TRACK THE DIFFERENCES ARE NOT STATISTICALLYSIGNIFICANTFORANYOFTHEBASINSORFORTHEHARBOROVERALLSOTHEDATADONOTINDICATEASIGNIFICANTTRENDINAPARTICULARDIRECTION-OREYEARSOFDATANEEDTOBECOLLECTEDINORDERTODETERMINEIFSEDIMENTTOXICITYISREALLYGETTINGBETTERORWORSEINTHEESTUARY

n

(IGHLY4OXIC 4OXIC

.ON 4OXIC (IGHLY4OXIC 4OXIC

.ON 4OXIC

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREIdm^X^inaZkZahd[CN$C?

=VgWdg:hijVgnhZY^bZcih!&..(6VcY

&..-7#I]ZWdiidbildbVehh]dl

ZcaVg\\ZbZcihd[?VbV^XV7Vn^cZVX]

nZVgJH:E6&..-W!6YVbh'%%'#

4OXICITYTESTSDONOTDETERMINECAUSESOFTHEOBSERVEDTOXICITY!NINDIVIDUALCHEMICALORACOMBINATIONOFCHEMICALSCOULDCAUSETHEPROBLEM3EDIMENT4OXICITY)DENTIFICATION%VALUATIONS4)%S ARETESTSTHATCANISOLATETHECAUSEORCAUSESOFSEDIMENTTOXICITYMOREOFTHISTYPEOFWORKNEEDSTOBECONDUCTEDINTHEESTUARY4HE.ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION./!! CONDUCTEDAVARIETYOFTYPESOFSEDIMENTTOXICITYTESTINGTHROUGHOUTTHEHARBORIN4HEFOURTYPESOFTESTSWERE THEAMPHIPODTOXICITYTESTUSEDBY2 %-!0 MEASURINGTHEMORTALITYRATESAND DEVELOPMENTOFCLAMLARVAEAND EXAMINING THE AMOUNT OF BIOLUMINESCENCE LIGHT PRODUCTION EXHIBITED BY ACERTAINSPECIESOFBACTERIA&IGURESHOWSSAMPLINGSTATIONSWHERESTATISTI

CALLYSIGNIFICANTTOXICITYWASOBSERVEDINATLEASTONEOFTHEFOURTESTS%ACHCIRCLEREPRESENTSAMEANOFTHREESTATIONSATTHATLOCATION

,IKETHE2 %-!0RESULTSTHISANALYSISSHOWS.EWARK"AYANDTHE+ILLSTOBEAREASOFCONCERNWITHRESPECTTOSEDIMENTTOXICITY(OWEVERTHE%AST2IVERAND3ANDY(OOK"AYALSOAPPEARASTOXICINTHISANALYSIS*AMAICA"AYWASNOTSAMPLEDINTHISPROGRAM

4AKEN TOGETHER THE 2 %-!0 AND./!! SURVEYS SUGGEST THAT THERE IS SOMECONCERNABOUTSEDIMENTTOXICITYINMOSTPARTSOFTHEHARBOR4HESITESWITHTHEMOSTSIGNIFICANTTOXICITYAREGENERALLYTHOSEWITHCONSISTENTPATTERNSOFSURFACESEDIMENTCONCENTRATIONSOFMANYCONTAMINANTSSEETHEDISCUSSIONOFSEDI

MENT CONTAMINATION ON PAGES n ./!! ALSO MEASURED CONCENTRATIONSOFAVARIETYOFCONTAMINANTSINTHESEDIMENTSATTHEIRTOXICITYTESTINGSITESANDFOUNDCORRELATIONSBETWEENTHEAMOUNTOFTOXICITYOBSERVEDANDCONTAMINANT,ONG)SLAND 3OUND 5PPER

"AY 2ARITAN "AY (UDSON 2IVER

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND

AMAICA"AY

AMAICA"AY 5PPER

"AY 2ARITAN "AY

.EWARK "AY

-ANHATTAN

.EWARK "AY 3ANDY(OOK (UDSON 2IVER

-ANHATTAN

%AST 2IVER

%AST 2IVER 3ITESINWHICHTOXICITY RESULTSWERESIGNIFICANT INATLEASTONETEST

.ON TOXICSITES

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREGZhjaihd[[djghZY^bZciidm^X^iniZhi^c\\

bZi]dYh#GZYYdihh]dlh^iZhl]ZgZh^\\c^[^XVciidm^X"

^inlVhdWhZgkZY^cViaZVhidcZd[i]Z[djgiZhih#HZZ

iZmi[dgiZhiYZhXg^ei^dchCD66&..*#

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT3EDIMENT4OXICITY

-AGNITUDEAND%XTENTOF3EDIMENT4OXICITYINTHE(UDSON 2ARITAN%STUARYBY%D,ONGETAL./!!4ECH-EMO./3/2#!

WWWEPAGOVEMAPREMAPINDEXHTML WWWCERCUSGSGOVPUBSSEDTOX RESPONSERESTORATIONNOAAGOVCPRSEDIMENTS

SEDIMENTHTML

CONCENTRATION&OREXAMPLETHEREWASASTRONGRELATIONSHIPBETWEENAMPHI

PODSURVIVALINTHETOXICITYTESTSANDTHECONCENTRATIONOFTOTAL0#"SINTHESED

IMENTS(OWEVERTHESEANALYSESANDCORRELATIONSARENOTENOUGHTOPROVETHATTHESESEDIMENTCONTAMINANTSCAUSEDTHEOBSERVEDTOXICITY4HERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTOXICITYANDCONTAMINANTCONCENTRATIONISTHUSFARCORRELATIVEANDNOTCAUSAL)NORDERTODETERMINEWHATEXACTLYISCAUSINGTHETOXICITYWHETHERITISASINGLECONTAMINANTORTHEADDITIVEEFFECTSOFMULTIPLECONTAMINANTSOROTHERSTRESSORS4)%SMUSTBEPERFORMED

"S).342)0%$"!33 4HEMOSTRECOGNIZABLEREPRESENTATIVEOFTHE(UDSON2IVER%STUARYSFISHFAUNAISPROBABLYTHESTRIPEDBASSAPROMINENTMEMBEROFTHEAQUATICCOMMUNITYALONGTHEENTIRE%AST#OAST7HEREVERITISFOUNDANDREGULATIONSALLOWTHEMTOBEHARVESTEDYOUCANBESURETHATENTHUSIASTICANGLERSANDCOMMERCIALFISHERSARENOTFARBEHIND4HE(UDSON2IVERSSTRIPEDBASSPOPULATIONISTHESECONDLARGESTONTHE%AST#OAST

5NFORTUNATELYASWITHMANYOTHERFISHANDCRUSTACEANSPECIESINOURESTUARYTHEFLESHOFSTRIPEDBASSISCONTAMINATEDWITHAVARIETYOFORGANICCHEMICALSINCLUDING 0#"S 0#"S OR POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS ARE A CLASS OF ORGANICCOMPOUNDSUSEDINAVARIETYOFCONSUMERPRODUCTSANDINDUSTRIALAPPLICATIONSFROMTHESTOTHESMOSTNOTABLYINTHEPRODUCTIONOFCAPACITORSANDOTHERELECTRONICEQUIPMENTBY'ENERAL%LECTRICINTHETOWNSOF&ORT%DWARDAND(UDSON&ALLS.9$URINGTHOSEDECADESAPPROXIMATELYMILLIONPOUNDSOF0#"SWEREDISCHARGEDTOTHERIVERFROMTHE'%FACILITIESWHERETHEYSPREADDOWN STREAMANDWEREFOUNDINUNACCEPTABLYHIGHLEVELSINTHEFLESHOFRESI

DENTANDMIGRATORYFISHES#ONSEQUENTLYABANONALLFISHINGWASINSTITUTEDINAPORTIONOFTHEUPPERRIVERSUBSEQUENTLYMODIFIEDTOCATCH AND RELEASEREGULATIONSIN THECOMMERCIALFISHERYFORSTRIPEDBASSWASCLOSEDANDHEALTH ADVISORIES ON CONSUMPTION OF STRIPED BASS AND OTHER SPECIES WEREISSUEDTHROUGHOUTTHEESTUARY

)NADDITIONTOTHE'%FACILITIESTHEREARESOURCESOF0#"SINTHEHARBORITSELFWHICH ARE IN THE PROCESS OF BEING QUANTIFIED BY THE (%0S #ONTAMINANT!SSESSMENTAND2EDUCTION0ROJECT2ESEARCHSUGGESTSTHATABOUTHALFOFTHELOADINGOF0#"STO.EW9ORK(ARBORCOMESOVERTHE4ROYDAMFROMTHE'%SITEANDHALFISFROMLOCALSOURCESINTHEHARBORCOMPLEX

&IGURESHOWSTHATLEVELSOF0#"SINSTRIPEDBASSGREATLYEXCEEDEDPARTSPERMILLIONTHE&OODAND$RUG!DMINISTRATIONACTIONLIMITFORCOMMERCIALSALEOFFISHTHEREDLINEONTHEGRAPH WHENDATAWERECOLLECTEDINTHEMID S!S0#"SWERENOLONGERBEINGACTIVELYDISCHARGEDTOTHERIVERLEVELSDECLINEDINSTRIPEDBASSTHROUGHOUTTHESANDS)N0#"LEVELSINCREASEDAGAINBECAUSEOFDOCUMENTEDRELEASESOF0#" BEARINGOILAFTERTHECOLLAPSEOF

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR 0

0#"SPPM

!VERAGE4OTAL0#"SPPM

Bed]?ibWdZIekdZ 7bXWdo#F((aia_bb F((aia_bb#DO9 DO#D@>WhXeh ANABANDONEDMILLSTRUCTUREADJACENTTOA'%FACILITY4HISINCREASEISEVIDENTINTHEh!LBANY 0EEKSKILLvLINEIN&IGURE$ATAFROM,ONG)SLAND3OUNDFISHARESHOWNINTHEINSETOF&IGUREFORCOMPARISONPURPOSES.OTETHATLEVELSIN,ONG)SLAND3OUNDFISHHAVEALSOBEENDECREASINGOVERTIMEANDAREMUCHLOWERTHANTHEPPMLEVEL,EVELSINTHE(ARBOR%STUARYHAVECONTINUEDTODECREASESINCETHEEARLYSANDINTHELOWERESTUARYAVERAGECONCENTRATIONSARENOWBELOWTHE&$!GUIDE

LINEOFPARTSPERMILLION4HESERECENTLOWERLEVELSHAVEPROMPTED.EW9ORK3TATETOBEGINANEVALUATIONOFWHETHERTHECURRENTBANONTHECOMMERCIALHARVESTOFSTRIPEDBASSCANBELIFTED"OTH.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYCONTINUETOISSUEHEALTHADVISORIESONTHECONSUMPTIONOFSTRIPEDBASSCAUGHTINTHEESTUARY&ORAMORECOMPLETEDISCUSSIONOFFISHCONSUMPTIONADVISORIESSEETHE h#ONTAMINANTS IN &ISH 4ISSUEv SECTION OF THIS REPORT PAGE AND THESIDEBARONCONSUMPTIONADVISORIES0#"LEVELSINSTRIPEDBASSSTILLEXCEEDOTHERGUIDANCEVALUES&OREXAMPLETHE%0!HASISSUEDA3CREENING6ALUEALEVELATWHICHTHEREAREPOTENTIALCONCERNSFORHUMANHEALTH FORLEVELSOF0#"SINFISHCONSUMEDBYRECREATIONALANGLERSOFPPMTIMESLOWERTHANTHE&$!STANDARD#ALCULATIONOFTHIS3CREENING6ALUETAKESINTOACCOUNTCURRENT TRENDS IN FISH CONSUMPTION COMBINED RISKTHROUGHCONSUMINGMULTIPLECONTAMINANTSANDOTHERPATHWAYS THROUGH WHICH PEOPLE CAN BE EXPOSED TOCONTAMINANTS

!SPECIALINTENSIVESTUDYOFLEVELSOFAVARIETYOFCON

TAMINANTSINFISHSPECIESINTHEHARBORWASCONDUCTEDUNDER THE AUSPICES OF THE (%0 IN &IGURE !SHOWSTHERESULTSOFTHATSTUDYFOR0#"LEVELSINSTRIPEDBASS'ENERALLYLEVELSOF0#"SWEREFOUNDTOBEHIGHERUPRIVERANDDECREASEDOWNSTREAMTOTHELOWERLEVELS;dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT0#"SAND0#"SIN3TRIPED"ASS

WWWEPAGOVHUDSON WWWEPAGOVTOXTEAMPCBIDDEFSHTM WWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEDFWMRHABITATNRD

INDEXHTM CONTAMINANTSFWSGOVRESTORATIONPLANS

(UDSON2IVERCFM

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREE87XdcXZcigVi^dch^c=jYhdc

G^kZgVcY=VgWdg:hijVgnhig^eZYWVhhi^hhjZ!

&.,**&..-#GZYa^cZ^cY^XViZh;96\\j^YVcXZ

kVajZd['eeb[dgXdbbZgX^VahVaZ#>chZih]dlh

E87aZkZah^cAdc\\>haVcYHdjcYhig^eZYWVhh

HadVc&..*!HadVc&...!HadVcVcY=ViiVaV

&..&#

OBSERVEDINTHE.EW9ORK"IGHTAND*AMAICA"AY!LATERSTUDYTHERESULTSOFWHICHARESHOWNIN&IGURE"FOUNDALLLEVELSINTHELOWERESTUARYTOBEBELOWPPMINDICATINGIMPROVEMENTBETWEENAND

/.4!-).!.43).&)3(4)335%

(IGH CONCENTRATIONS OF CONTAMINANTS IN FISH AND SHELLFISHTISSUE IN THE ESTUARY CAUSE THE STATES OF.EW 9ORK AND.EW*ERSEYTOISSUECONSUMPTIONADVISORIESFORMOSTESTUARINESPECIESCAUGHTINSPORTFISHING ACTIVITIES 4HE EFFECTS OF THESE CONTAMINANTS ON THE FISH THEM

SELVESARENOTWELLUNDERSTOODBUTCOULDINCLUDEADVERSEIMPACTSONREPRO

DUCTIONGROWTHANDDEVELOPMENT&IGURESTHROUGHSHOWTHEMEANSANDRANGESOFLEVELSOFAVARIETYOFCONTAMINANTSINFISHANDSHELLFISHSPECIESINTHEESTUARYASMEASUREDIN)NMOSTPLOTSTHEVERTICALLINEREPRESENTSTHELEVELATWHICHTHE53&OODAND$RUG!DMINISTRATIONLIMITSCOMMERCIALSALEOFFISHTHESTATESGENERALLYUSETHISLEVELASWELLASOTHERCONSIDERATIONSWHENCONDUCTINGRISKASSESSMENTSONWHICHTHEIRHEALTHADVISORIESAREBASEDSEEPAGESnFORAMORECOMPLETEDISCUSSIONOFHEALTHADVISORIES 4HEMEANVALUEMEASUREDFORTHEGIVENCONTAMINANTINTHATSPECIESISINDICATEDBYTHEGREENBOXONTHEPLOTANDTHERANGEOFVALUESMEASUREDISINDICATEDBYTHEHORIZONTALLINEANDCIRCLES)FTHERANGEOFOBSERVEDCONCENTRATIONSOFAGIVENCHEMICALDOESNOTEXCEEDTHEESTABLISHEDGUIDELINETHEVERTICALLINE INAPAR

TICULARSPECIESTHEREISLESSCAUSEFORCONCERNTHANIFTHEOBSERVEDRANGEDOESEXCEEDTHELIMITBUTITDOESNOTMEANTHATCONSUMPTIONOFFISHBELOWTHOSELEVELSISRISK FREE .OTETHATTHESTATESHAVENOTISSUEDHEALTHADVISORIESFORTHEFLOUN

DERSPECIESSEETABLEONPAGE &LOUNDERSTENDTOBELOWERINCONTAMINANT&IGUREAZkZahd[E87h^chig^eZYWVhhi^hhjZ^ci]Z=VgWdg:hijVgn^c&..(

6VcY&..,$&..-7HadVcZiVa#&..*!HadVc&...!HadVcVcY=ViiVaV&..&#

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND 5PPER

"AY

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 5PPER

"AY 2ARITAN "AY

.EWARK"AY

.EWARK"AY (UDSON2IVER (UDSON2IVER 3ANDY(OOK

%AST 2IVER

nPPM

nPPM rPPM

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND 5PPER

"AY

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 5PPER

"AY 2ARITAN "AY

.EWARK"AY

.EWARK"AY (UDSON2IVER (UDSON2IVER 3ANDY(OOK

%AST 2IVER

nPPM

nPPM rPPM

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

3TRIPEDBASS 3UMMERFLOUNDER 7INDOWPANEFLOUNDER 7INTERFLOUNDER 7HITEPERCH

!MERICANEEL "LUECRAB

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

MUSCLE

"LUECRAB

MUSCLE

C[hYkhoYedY[djhWj_edffX

PPB

MM

PPB F98YedY[djhWj_edffc

3TRIPEDBASSMM 3UMMERFLOUNDER 7INDOWPANEFLOUNDER 7INTERFLOUNDER 7HITEPERCH

!MERICANEEL "LUECRAB

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

MUSCLE

"LUECRAB

MUSCLE

!LLPPM

!TORBELOWPPTR

3TRIPEDBASS 7INTERFLOUNDER 7HITEPERCH

!MERICANEEL "LUECRAB

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

MUSCLE

"LUECRAB

MUSCLE

"ELOWPPB "ELOWPPB

JYedY[djhWj_edffX

3TRIPEDBASS 3UMMERFLOUNDER 7INDOWPANEFLOUNDER 7INTERFLOUNDER 7HITEPERCH

!MERICANEEL "LUECRAB

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

MUSCLE

"LUECRAB

MUSCLE

(")"-".#J9::ffjh

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREBZgXjgnaZkZah^chZaZXiZY[^c[^h]VcYXgjhiVXZVc

heZX^Zh[dgVaaVgZVhd[i]ZZhijVgnXdbW^cZY#GZYa^cZ^cY^XViZh

96\\j^YVcXZkVajZd['eeb[dgXdbbZgX^VahVaZ#<gZZcWdm

^cY^XViZhbZVc!\\gZna^cZhVcYX^gXaZh^cY^XViZgVc\\Zd[kVajZh

bZVhjgZY#H`^ccZgZiVa#&..+#

&IGUREIdiVaE87aZkZah^chZaZXiZY[^c[^h]VcYXgjhiV" XZVcheZX^Zh[dgVaaVgZVhd[i]ZZhijVgnXdbW^cZY#GZYa^cZ

^cY^XViZh;96\\j^YVcXZkVajZd['eeb[dgXdbbZgX^VahVaZ#

<gZZcWdm^cY^XViZhbZVc!\\gZna^cZhVcYX^gXaZh^cY^XViZ

gVc\\Zd[kVajZhbZVhjgZY#H`^ccZgZiVa#&..+#

&IGURE9^dm^c'!(!,!-"I899aZkZah^chZaZXiZY[^c[^h]VcY

XgjhiVXZVcheZX^Zh[dgVaaVgZVhd[i]ZZhijVgnXdbW^cZY#GZYa^cZ

^cY^XViZhCNH9D=a^b^i[dg^bedh^i^dcd[]ZVai]VYk^hdg^Zh#<gZZc

Wdm^cY^XViZhbZVc!\\gZna^cZhVcYX^gXaZh^cY^XViZgVc\\Zd[kVajZh

bZVhjgZY#H`^ccZgZiVa#&..,W#

&IGUREIdiVa99IaZkZah^chZaZXiZY[^c[^h]VcYXgjhiVXZVc

heZX^Zh[dgVaaVgZVhd[i]ZZhijVgnXdbW^cZY#GZYa^cZ^cY^XViZh

96\\j^YVcXZkVajZd['eeb[dgXdbbZgX^VahVaZ#<gZZcWdm

^cY^XViZhbZVc!\\gZna^cZhVcYX^gXaZh^cY^XViZgVc\\Zd[kVajZh

bZVhjgZY#H`^ccZgZiVa#&..+#

LEVELSPROBABLYINPARTBECAUSETHEYSPENDMOREOFTHEIRTIMEINTHERELATIVELYCLEAN,OWER"AYAND"IGHTRATHERTHANINTHEMORECONTAMINATEDAREASOFTHEHARBOR

!LMOST ALL OF THE MEAN OBSERVED CONCENTRATIONSTHEBOXESONTHEPLOTS FALLBELOWTHEACTIONLIMITFORTHATCHEMICALWITHTHENOTABLEEXCEPTIONSOFDIOXIN 4#$$ AND0#"SINBLUECRABANDLOBSTERHEPATOPANCREASTHEGREENSUBSTANCECOM

MONLYKNOWNAShTOMALLEYv 4HERANGESOFSOMECONTAMINANT CONCENTRATIONS STILL INDICATE SOMECAUSE FOR CONCERN IN THE CASES OF CHLORDANE APESTICIDE IN WHITE PERCH AND BLUE CRAB HEPATO

PANCREASMERCURYINSTRIPEDBASSLARGERTHANMMDIOXININSTRIPEDBASSANDWHITEPERCHAND0#"SINSTRIPEDBASSLARGERTHANMMWINTERFLOUNDERANDWHITEPERCH0#"RANGESFORSUMMERFLOUNDERANDWINDOWPANEFLOUNDERAREALSOCLOSETOTHEACTIONLEVEL!MERICANEELEXCEEDALLOFTHEGUIDELINESEXCEPTFORMERCURYMOSTLIKELYBECAUSEASBENTHICSPECIESTHEYLIVEINCONSTANTCLOSEASSO

CIATIONWITHCONTAMINATEDSEDIMENTSANDTHEYDONOT MIGRATE VERY FAR OUTSIDE A VERY SMALL HOMERANGE!SARESULTEELSTHATLIVEINCONTAMINATEDAREASTENDTOACCUMULATEHIGHLEVELSOFCONTAMI

NANTSANDDONOTDEPURATEBYMIGRATINGTOCLEANERAREAS.OTETHATWHILETHELEVELSOFCONTAMINANTSINCRABANDLOBSTERHEPATOPANCREASAREHIGHTHEMUSCLE TISSUE LEVELS THE PARTS THAT ARE USUALLYEATENARETOOLOWTOBEDETECTED#ONSEQUENTLYITISADVISABLENOTTOEATTHEHEPATOPANCREASOFLOCALCRABSORLOBSTERS

4ABLE SUMMARIZES THE DATA ON THESE CONTAMI

NANTS IN FISH AND SHELLFISH BY GEOGRAPHIC AREAWITHIN THE ESTUARY !N OPEN CIRCLE IN THIS FIGUREMEANSTHATNOSPECIESAREABOVETHE&$!OR.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTH TOLERANCELEVELSFORTHATCHEMICALINTHATBASINAHALF FILLEDCIRCLEMEANSTHATONESPECIESISABOVETHEACTIONLIMITANDAFILLEDCIRCLEMEANSTHATTWOORMORESPECIESAREABOVETHELIMITFORTHATCHEMICALINTHATBASIN4HE GEOGRAPHIC AREA IN WHICH THE MOST EXCEED

ANCES WERE OBSERVED WAS THE.EWARK "AY+ILLSCOMPLEX WHILE THE "IGHT !PEX HAD THE FEWESTEXCEEDANCES 4HE TABLE ALSO INDICATES THAT WHILE0#"S AND CHLORDANE ARE OF WIDESPREAD CONCERNTHROUGHOUTTHEESTUARY$$4ANDMERCURYARENOTOF MAJOR CONCERN IN TERMS OF LEVELS IN FISH ANDDIOXINISOFCONCERNINAFEWAREASALTHOUGHITHAS

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

9^behZWd[YedY[djhWj_edffX

3TRIPEDBASS 3UMMERFLOUNDER 7INDOWPANEFLOUNDER 7INTERFLOUNDER 7HITEPERCH

!MERICANEEL "LUECRAB

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

(EPATOPANCREAS

!MERICANLOBSTER

MUSCLE

"LUECRAB

MUSCLE

&IGUREIdiVa99IaZkZah^chZaZXiZY[^c[^h]VcYXgjhiVXZVcheZX^Zh[dgVaa

VgZVhd[i]ZZhijVgnXdbW^cZY#GZYa^cZ^cY^XViZh;96\\j^YVcXZkVajZd['eeb

[dgXdbbZgX^VahVaZ#<gZZcWdm^cY^XViZhbZVc!\\gZna^cZhVcYX^gXaZh^cY^XViZ

gVc\\Zd[kVajZhbZVhjgZY#H`^ccZgZiVa&..+#

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT#ONTAMINANTSIN&ISH AND#RUSTACEANS

WWWEPAGOVOSTFISH WWWHEALTHSTATENYUSNYSDOHFISHFISHHTM WWWSTATENJUSDEPDSRNJMAINFISHHTM WWWCARPWEBORG

dg;jaa=ZVai]6Yk^hdg^Zh

'/4/

WWWHEALTHSTATENYUSNYSDOHFISHFISHHTM.EW9ORKADVISORIES AND WWWSTATENJUSDEPDSRNJMAINFISHHTM.EW*ERSEYADVISORIES

NOTBEENMEASUREDINFISHFROMALLBASINSOFTHEESTUARY 4HESERESULTSARECONSISTENTWITHTHEPATTERNSINTHELEVELSOFCONTAMINANTSINTHESEDIMENTSINTHESEBASINSSEEPAGESn

4AKENASAWHOLETHESERESULTSINDICATETHATWHILETHELEVELSOFCONTAMINANTSINFISHANDSHELLFISHAREGENERALLYSTART

INGTODECREASEREFLECTINGTHEREDUCTIONINLOADINGSOFTHESECHEMICALSTOTHEENVIRONMENTTHEREARESTILLSOMESPECIESCHEMICALSANDAREASTHATARECAUSESFORCONCERNWITHRESPECTTOHUMANHEALTH(EALTHADVISORIESISSUEDBYTHETWOSTATESSHOULDBEFOLLOWEDANDSTEPSCANBETAKENINTHEPREPARATIONOFFISHANDSHELLFISHTHATWILLREDUCETHERISKASSOCI

ATEDWITHCONSUMPTIONOFTHESESPECIES(OWEVEREVENINTHOSESPECIESWHEREAVERAGECONTAMINANTLEVELSAREBELOWTHEACTIONLEVELSBODYBURDENSOFCONTAMINANTSMAYSTILLPOSEAHEALTHRISKTOPEOPLEIFTHEFISHAREEATENANDMAYADVERSELYAFFECTTHEANIMALSTHEMSELVES)NOTHERWORDSANACTIONLIMITISNOTAhMAGICvLEVELBELOWWHICHTHEREISNOIMPACTONHUMANSORTHEECOSYSTEM)NFACTASDISCUSSEDONPAGE%0!HASDEVELOPEDA3CREENING6ALUEFORLEVELSOF0#"SINFISHTISSUEFORCONSUMPTIONBYRECREATIONALANGLERSWHICHISMUCHLOWERTHANTHE&$!VALUE

0#"S

HLORDANE

$$4

$IOXINS

-ERCURY 5PPER"AY (ARLEM

%AST2IVER

+ILLS

.EWARK"AY

AMAICA "AY

,OWER "AY

.OSPECIESABOVEACTIONLIMIT

SPECIESABOVEACTIONLIMIT

ORMORESPECIESABOVEACTIONLIMIT NS.OTSAMPLED NS NS

.9"IGHT

!PEX 4ABLE>cX^YZcXZd[XdciVb^cVciaZkZah^c[^h]VcYXgjhiVXZVch#HeZX^Zh^cXajYZY^ci]^hVcVanh^hVgZWajZXgVW!6bZg^XVc

adWhiZg!l]^iZeZgX]!hig^eZYWVhh!6bZg^XVcZZa!l^ciZg[adjcYZgVcYl^cYdleVcZ[adjcYZg#=ZVai]VYk^hdg^ZhVgZ^cZ((ZXi^cVaad[

i]ZZhijVgnhZ\\bZcih^ci]ZiVWaZ#H`^ccZgZiVa#&..,V!&..,W#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&ISH#ONSUMPTION!DVISORIESINTHE.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY "ECAUSEOFTHEELEVATEDLEVELSOFCONTAMINANTSINFISHANDSHELLFISH IN THE ESTUARY THE STATES OF.EW 9ORK AND.EW*ERSEY BOTH ISSUE CONSUMPTION ADVISORIES FOR MANY RECRE

ATIONALLY CAUGHTSPECIESOFFISHANDCRUSTACEANS4HESTATESCONSIDERAVARIETYOFFACTORSINFORMULATINGTHEIRHEALTHADVISORIES/NEISHOWTHELEVELSOF0#"SANDOTHERCONTAMINANTSINTHEFISHFLESHCOMPARETOTHE53&OODAND$RUG!DMINISTRATIONACTIONLEVELSBYWHICHTHE&$!REGU

LATESTHECOMMERCIALSALEOFFISH&ORAVARIETYOFREASONSITIS NOT APPROPRIATE TO USE ONLY THIS LEVEL AS A DETERMININGFACTOR IN DEVISING HEALTH ADVISORIES FOR SPORTFISH CONSUMP

TION/THERFACTORSMUSTALSOBECONSIDEREDINCLUDINGTHEPOTENTIAL ADDITIVE EFFECTS OF MULTIPLE CONTAMINANTS IN THEFISHTHEVULNERABILITYOFDIFFERENTTYPESOFINDIVIDUALSTODIS

EASECAUSEDBYTHEFISHKNOWNHOTSPOTSOFCONTAMINATIONANDTHECONSUMPTIONRATESOFANGLERSWHICHAREGENERALLYGREATERTHANOTHERSRATES

4HE STATE ADVISORIES THEREFORE PROVIDE GUIDANCE ABOUT THEAMOUNTSANDKINDSOFFISHCAUGHTINSPECIFICAREASTHATCANBECONSUMEDSAFELY)NADDITIONBOTH.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYADVISETHATWOMENOFCHILDBEARINGAGEINFANTSANDCHILDRENUNDERTHEAGEOFSHOULDNOTEATANYOFTHESPE

CIESFROMANYWATERBODIESFORWHICHTHEREAREADVISORIES

4ABLEONTHENEXTPAGEOUTLINESSOMEOFTHEFISHCONSUMP

TIONADVISORIESISSUEDBY.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYFORESTU

ARYWATERSIN

!REA 3PECIESNOTENOTALL.EW9ORK!DVISORY

.EW*ERSEY!DVISORY SPECIESUNDERADVISORIESFORCANCERRISK

ARELISTEDHERE %AST(ARLEM2IVERS

!MERICANEEL

%ATNONE

.!NOTAPPLICABLE

%AST(ARLEM2IVERS

"LUEFISHSTRIPEDBASS

.OMORETHANONE.!

MEALPERMONTH

AMAICA"AY "LUEFISH!MERICANEEL

.OMORETHANONE.!

MEALPERWEEK

AMAICA"AY 3TRIPEDBASS

.OMORETHANONE.!

MEALPERWEEK (UDSON2IVERDOWNSTREAMOF!MERICANEEL

.OMORETHANONE.OMORETHANONE#ATSKILL5PPER"AY+ILLS

MEALPERMONTH MEALPERYEAR (UDSON2IVERDOWNSTREAMOF"LUEFISH

.OMORETHANONEFISHLBS.OMORETHAN#ATSKILL5PPER"AY+ILLS

MEALPERMONTH

MEALSPERYEAR FISHLBS.OMORETHANONEMEALPERMONTH (UDSON2IVERDOWNSTREAMOF3TRIPEDBASS

.OMORETHANONE.OMORETHAN#ATSKILL5PPER"AY+ILLS

MEALPERMONTH MEALSPERYEAR

.EWARK"AY(ACKENSACK3TRIPEDBASS

+ILLS.OMORETHANONE%ATNONE 2IVER+ILLS

MEALPERMONTH

.EWARK"AY(ACKENSACK"LUEFISH

+ILLS.OMORETHANONEFISHLBS.OMORETHAN2IVER+ILLS

MEALPERMONTH

MEALSPERYEAR FISHLBS.OMORETHANONEMEALPERMONTH

!RTHUR+ILL+ILLVAN+ULL

"LUECRAB

.OMORETHANCRABSPERWEEK%ATNONE DONOTEATHEPATOPANCREAS (UDSON2IVERDOWNSTREAMOF "LUECRAB

.OMORETHANCRABSPERWEEK.OMORETHANCRABSPERWEEK#ATSKILL5PPER"AY+ILLS

DONOTEATHEPATOPANCREAS DONOTEATHEPATOPANCREAS

,OWER"AY "LUEFISH!MERICANEEL

.OMORETHANONEMEALPERWEEK "LUEFISHLBS.OMORETHANMEALSPERYEAR "LUEFISHLBS.OMORETHANONEMEALPERMONTH EELS.OMORETHANMEALSPERYEAR

,OWER"AY 3TRIPEDBASS

.OMORETHANONEMEALPERMONTH

.OMORETHANONEWOMENOFCHILDBEARINGAGEAND MEALPERMONTH ANDCHILDRENUNDER%ATNONE

.EWARK"AY(ACKENSACK"LUECRAB

.!

%ATNONE 0ASSAIC2IVERS 0ASSAIC2IVERDOWNSTREAMOF!LLSPECIESOFFISHAND.!

%ATNONE

$UNDEE$AM SHELLFISH 2ARITAN"AY2ARITAN2IVER"LUEFISH

.!

FISHLBS.OMORETHAN 3ANDY(OOK"AY

MEALSPERYEAR FISHLBS.OMORETHANONEMEALPERMONTH 2ARITAN"AY2ARITAN2IVER3TRIPEDBASS

.!

.OMORETHANONEMEALPERWEEK 3ANDY(OOK"AY 2ARITAN"AY2ARITAN2IVER"LUECRAB

.!

.OMORETHENCRABSPERWEEK3ANDY(OOK"AY DONOTEATHEPATOPANCREAS

)N!DDITIONTOTHECANCERRISKADVISORIESSUMMARIZEDHERE.EW*ERSEYISSUESSEPARATEMORERESTRICTIVEADVISORIESFORALIFETIMECANCERRISKOF

ASWELLASFORHIGHRISKINDIVIDUALSINFANTSCHILDRENPREGNANTWOMENNURSINGMOTHERSANDWOMENOFCHILDBEARINGAGE 0LEASEGOTOTHEIRWEBSITE

WWWSTATENJUSDEPDSRNJMAINFISHHTM FORMOREDEAILEDHEALTHADVISORIES

.93$/(STRESSESTHATINADDITIONTOTHEWARNINGFORWOMENOFCHILDBEARINGAGEINFANTSANDCHILDRENUNDERSEEBELOW OTHERPEOPLEAREADVISEDTOEATNOMORETHANONEMEALPERWEEKOFUNLISTEDSPECIESINTHESE.9 WATERS

)NADDITIONTOTHESERECOMMENDATIONSBOTH.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYADVISETHATWOMENOFCHILDBEARINGAGEINFANTSANDCHILDRENUNDERTHEAGEOFSHOULDNOTEATANYOFTHESPECIESFROMANYWATERBODIESFORWHICHTHEREARECONSUMPTIONADVISORIES4ABLE;^h]8dchjbei^dc6Yk^hdg^ZhCNVcYC?

2%3/&/0%.3(%,,&)3("%$3&ORMORETHANYEARSFROMTHETIMEOF%UROPEANSETTLEMENTOFTHISREGIONCLAMSMUSSELSANDOYSTERSWEREACRITICALPARTOFTHEHARBORSECONOMYANDOFTHEDIETSOFLOCALS/YSTERSINPAR

TICULARWERESOLARGEANDPLENTIFULINTHEHARBORAREATHATUNTILTHEMID SAMAJORINDUSTRYINTHEHARBORREGIONWASTHEPROCESSINGANDEXPORTOFOYSTERS4HEMEATSOFh2OCKAWAYSvh*AMAICASvANDh!MBOYSvWEREEAGERLYCONSUMEDANDTHESHELLSWEREUSEDINCONSTRUCTIONMATERIALS(ARDSHELLANDSOFTSHELLCLAMSWEREALSOIMPORTANTFISHERIESPARTICULARLYIN2ARITAN"AY!STHEHUMANPOPULATIONINCREASEDIN.EW9ORK#ITYANDTHESURROUNDINGREGIONPOLLUTIONANDDEVELOPMENTBEGANTOTAKE

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

0ATHOGENS

THEIR TOLL ON THE HARBORS WATER QUALITY AND ON LOCALSHELLFISHERIES !LTHOUGH OVERHARVESTING AND LOW DIS

SOLVED OXYGEN LEVELS IN THE WATER DUE TO DISCHARGE OFRAWSEWAGETOTHEHARBORCAUSEDTHEDECLINEOFSHELLFISHPOPULATIONSINTHEESTUARYULTIMATELYTHEINDUSTRYWASDEVASTATED WHEN CASES OF TYPHOID IN THE REGION WERELINKEDTOCONTAMINATEDOYSTERSIN

7ITHTHEMAJORIMPROVEMENTSINSEWAGETREATMENTANDWATERQUALITYTHATHAVEOCCURREDOVERTHEPASTYEARSSOME AREAS ARE ONCE AGAIN AVAILABLE FOR EITHER DIRECTSHELLFISHHARVESTORRELAYHARVESTEDSHELLFISHAREPLACEDIN CLEAN WATERS TO PURGE THEMSELVES OF CONTAMINANTSBEFOREBEINGSOLDORCONSUMED ORDEPURATIONHARVEST

EDSHELLFISHAREPLACEDINTANKSOFCLEANEDTREATEDSEA

WATERTOREMOVECONTAMINANTSFROMTHESHELLFISHBEFORETHEYARESOLD 3TATEANDLOCALGOVERNMENTSNOWASSESSTHESUITABILITYOFSHELLFISHBEDSFORHARVESTONTHEBASISOFAVARIETYOFFACTORSPRIMARILYLEVELSOFCOLIFORMBACTE

RIAFOUNDINTHEWATER/THERFACTORSSUCHASHISTORICALWATERQUALITYPROBLEMSORPRESENCEOFOTHERPOLLUTANTSALSO INFLUENCE THESE DECISIONS )N.EW 9ORK hADMIN

ISTRATIVE CLOSURESv BASED NOT ON BACTERIAL MEASURE

MENTS BUT ON CIRCUMSTANCES KNOWN TO CAUSE SHELLFISHTO BECOME CONTAMINATED ARE MAINTAINED YEAR ROUNDNEARSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTSANDNEARMARINASINTHEBOATINGSEASON!DMINISTRATIVECLOSURESAREALSOISSUEDINSOMEAREASAFTERHEAVYRAINFALLSBACTERIALSAMPLINGISCONDUCTEDINTHESECASESINORDERTODETERMINEWHENABEDSHOULDBEREOPENED!LTHOUGHTHEREARESMALLDIF

FERENCESINTHEWAYSINWHICHTHETWOSTATESDETERMINEWHETHERSHELLFISHBEDSSHOULDBECLOSEDTOHARVESTBOTHSTATESFOLLOWTHE.ATIONAL3HELLFISH3ANITATION0ROGRAMGUIDELINESESTABLISHEDATTHEFEDERALLEVELFORMONITORINGSHELLFISHBEDS

&IGURESHOWSTHEPERCENTOFAVAILABLESHELLFISHBEDAREA OPEN TO HARVEST IN THE STATE OF.EW *ERSEY FROMTHE MID S TO 4HE INCREASING TREND IN OPENACREAGE STATEWIDE CAN BE ATTRIBUTED TO BETTER WATERQUALITY MOSTLY DUE TO IMPROVED SEWAGE TREATMENT/PEN BED ACREAGE IN -ONMOUTH #OUNTY .AVESINKAND3HREWSBURY2IVERS3ANDY(OOKAND2ARITAN"AYS HAS REMAINED FAIRLY STABLE OVER THE PERIOD SHOWN-ANY OF THE CONTINUING CLOSURES ARE DUE TO A VARIETYOF GENERAL ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS PRESENCE OF #3/SHISTORICAL CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION IN ADDITION TO POORWATERQUALITYFOREXAMPLEHAVINGCHARACTERISTICSSUCHAS LOW DISSOLVED OXYGEN OR HIGH CONCENTRATIONS OF

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREEZgXZcid[VkV^aVWaZh]Zaa[^h]WZYhdeZc[dg]VgkZhi^c

CZl?ZghZn!hiViZl^YZVcY^cBdcbdji]8djcinVadcZ!&.,,*'%%%

:^hZaZ'%%%!CN$C?=:E'%%'W#

OFALLAVAILABLEWATERS D[m@[hi[oIjWj[m_Z[

Cedcekj^9ekdjo

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT3HELLFISHAND3HELLFISH"EDS(EARTBEATSINTHE-UCKBY*OHN7ALDMAN,YONS0RESS

4HE&ISHERIESOF2ARITAN"AYBY#LYDE,-AC+ENZIE*R2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS

WWWHARBORESTUARYORGPDFHEPSHELLFISHPDF WWWSTATENJUSDEPFGWSHELHOMEHTM WWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEDFWMRMARINESHELLFISH WWWHSRLRUTGERSEDU WWWNYNJBAYKEEPERORGOYSTER?GARDENHTM

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

COLIFORMBACTERIA 3OMEAREASARECLOSEDPERMANENTLYFOR EXAMPLE PARTS OF THE 3HREWSBURY AND.AVESINK2IVERS FORADMINISTRATIVEREASONSSUCHASINSUFFICIENT#ONSERVATION/FFICERSTOPATROLANDENFORCEREGULATIONSINTHOSEAREAS4HEREARESEVERALSUCCESSSTORIESIN.EW*ERSEY WATERS INCLUDING THE REOPENING OF AREAS OF THELOWER.AVESINK IN AFTER HAVING BEEN CLOSED TOSHELLFISHINGFORYEARS

&IGURESHOWSTHEPERCENTOFAVAILABLESHELLFISHBEDAREAOPENFORHARVESTINTHREE.EW9ORKWATERBODIES.EW 9ORK "IGHT 7ESTERN,ONG )SLAND 3OUND AND THEESTUARY FROM 0EEKSKILL TO THE HARBOR "ECAUSE OF CON

CERNSABOUTPERSISTENTWATERQUALITYPROBLEMSANDOTHERPOLLUTIONPROBLEMSDIRECTHARVESTIEWITHOUTRELAYORDEPURATION OFSHELLFISHISNOTALLOWEDANYWHEREINTHEHARBORITSELF/VERTHETIMEPERIODDEPICTEDTHEACREAGEOFSHELLFISHBEDSOPENHASREMAINEDFAIRLYSTABLE

&IGURESHOWSTHESIZEOFTHERELAYFISHERIESINEACHSTATETHE2ARITAN 3ANDY(OOK"AYFISHERYIN.EW*ERSEYFROMTHESTOTHELATESANDTHE3TATEN)SLANDHARDCLAMRELAYFISHERYFROMTHELATESTO&OR.EW9ORKTHEORANGEPORTIONOFTHELINESHOWSBUSHELSOF CLAMS THAT WERE DEPURATED OR HARVESTED FROM THEENVIRONMENTANDTHENPLACEDINTANKSONLANDTOCLEANSETHEMSELVES FOR HOURS 4HE DEPURATION PROCESS WASNOT USED AFTER FOR ECONOMIC REASONS 3TARTING INTHEGREENPORTIONOFTHELINE CLAMSHAVEBEENHARVESTEDFROM2ARITAN"AYANDRELAYEDTOAREASIN,ONG )SLAND 3OUND AND 0ECONIC "AY FOR AMINIMUM DAY CLEANSING PERIOD /VER TIMETHEAMOUNTOFCLAMSANNUALLYTRANSPLANTEDFROM3TATEN)SLANDHASRISENFROMABOUTBUSH

ELSTOMORETHANBUSHELS)N.EW*ERSEYTHEAMOUNTOFCLAMSDEPURATEDANDRELAYEDHASGROWN FROM BUSHELS TO ABOUT BUSHELS

'ENERALLY SPEAKING AS WATER QUALITY HASIMPROVED MORE HARVESTING PARTICULARLY UNDERTHE RELAYDEPURATION PROGRAM HAS TAKEN PLACEIN BOTH STATES EITHER BECAUSE IT HAS BECOMESAFERTOCONSUMESHELLFISHFROMTHEESTUARYORBECAUSE IMPROVEMENTS IN WATER QUALITY HAVELED TO INCREASES IN SHELLFISH POPULATIONS ANDINCREASES IN THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE HARVESTINGSHELLFISHCOMMERCIALLY

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

OFALLAVAILABLEWATERS 7jbWdj_YEY[Wd M[ij[hdBed]?ibWdZIekdZ C_Z#[ijkWhoWdZDO%D@>WhXeh

OFALLAVAILABLEWATERS

DO:[fkhWj[Z D@H[bWo[Z:[fkhWj[Z DOH[bWo[Z

&IGUREEZgXZcid[VkV^aVWaZh]Zaa[^h]WZYhdeZc[dg]VgkZhi^c

CZlNdg`^ci]gZZVgZVh!&.,%*'%%%AZl^h'%%%!7VgcZh'%%%#

&IGUREGZaVnVcYYZejgVi^dcXaVb[^h]Zg^Zh^cCZlNdg`VcY

CZl?ZghZn!&.,-*'%%&hZZiZmi[dgZmeaVcVi^dcd[i]ZhZegVXi^XZh

:^hZaZ'%%%!AZl^h'%%%!7VgcZh'%%%!CN$C?=:E'%%'W#

)3%!3%,).+%$4/#/.4!-).!4%$3(%,,&)3(

4HEDECLINEOFTHESHELLFISHINGINDUSTRYINTHEHARBORPARTICULARLYT H E OYSTERFISHERYWASHASTENEDWHENOUTBREAKSOFTYPHOIDINTHEAREAWERELINKEDTOCONSUMPTIONOFCONTAMINATEDOYSTERSSEETHESECTIONONSHELLFISHBEDSPAGE )NATYPHOIDOUTBREAKWASTRACEDTOOYSTERSHARVESTEDFROM 2ARITAN "AY 4HIS OUTBREAK CAUSED ILLNESSES AND DEATHS !SA RESULT THE 3URGEON 'ENERAL OF THE 53 ESTABLISHED THE.ATIONAL 3HELLFISH3ANITATION0ROGRAM.330 INTOCLASSIFYSHELLFISHWATERSINSPECTSHELL

FISH DEALERS AND ADDRESS THE PUBLIC HEALTH ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH SHELLFISHHARVEST

-OSTOFTHESHELLFISHTHATPEOPLEEATAREFILTERFEEDERSMEANINGTHATTHEYPUMPWATER THROUGH THEIR SYSTEM TO FILTER OUT PHYTOPLANKTON MICROSCOPIC PLANTS ASTHEIRFOODSOURCE)NPOLLUTEDWATERSTHEYMAYALSOFILTERANDACCUMULATECONTAMINANTSSUCHASDISEASE CAUSINGBACTERIAANDVIRUSES4HESEDISEASE

CAUSING ORGANISMS WHICH USUALLY COME FROM HUMAN SEWAGE SOURCES SUCHASCOMBINEDSEWEROVERFLOWSILLEGALSEWERBYPASSESSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTMALFUNCTIONSANDBOATDISCHARGESCANBECOMECONCENTRATEDINTHEGUTSOFTHESHELLFISHANDULTIMATELYCAUSEAVARIETYOFILLNESSESINHUMANS4HESEILLNESSESINCLUDETYPHOIDFEVERANDCHOLERACAUSEDBYBACTERIA ANDVIRALGASTROENTERITISANDHEPATITISCAUSEDBYVIRUSES 7ITHTHEADVENTOFADVANCEDSEWAGETREAT

MENTINTHEPASTYEARSSOURCESHAVEBEENGREATLYREDUCEDASHASTHERISKOFBECOMINGSICKFROMEATINGSHELLFISHGROWNINHARBORWATERS

)TISIMPORTANTTOKEEPINMINDTHATEVENSHELLFISHHARVESTEDFROMSEEMINGLYPRISTINEWATERSIFCONSUMEDRAWCANCAUSEDISEASEIFTHEYHAVEBEENFEEDINGON DISEASE CAUSING ORGANISMS OR IF THEY ARE MISHANDLED AND CONTAMINATEDAFTER THEY ARE HARVESTED #ONSUMPTION OF ANY RAW SHELLFISH REGARDLESS OFWHEREITWASHARVESTEDCARRIESSOMERISK WHICH CAN BE REDUCED BUT NOTNECESSARILYELIMINATEDBYCOOKING

&IGURE SHOWS THE HISTORY OFOCCURRENCEOFTWOOFTHEMOSTSERI

OUS SHELLFISH ASSOCIATED DISEASESTYPHOID AND HEPATITIS CAUSED BYCONSUMPTIONOFSHELLFISHIN.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYFROMTHEEARLYSUNTIL)NMANYCASESTHESOURCEOF THE SHELLFISH WAS UNKNOWN BUTWASOFTENSUSPECTEDTOBEFROM.EW9ORK.EW *ERSEY OR #ONNECTICUT4HELASTKNOWNTYPHOIDCASEWASINANDTHECASESOFHEPATITISTHEFIRST KNOWN APPEARANCE OF WHICHWASIN HAVEBEENFEW

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

.UMBEROFCASES

S

,ASTAPPEARANCE OFTYPHOID

4YPHOID (EPATITIS

&IRSTAPPEARANCE OFHEPATITIS

&IGURE>cX^YZcXZd[ine]d^YVcY]ZeVi^i^higVXZYidi]ZXdchjbei^dc$]VcYa^c\\d[

XdciVb^cViZYh]Zaa[^h]a^`Zan[gdbCZlNdg`!CZl?ZghZndg8dccZXi^Xji!&.%%h*&..%h

=dgc&..%!Lda['%%&#

.UMBEROFOUTBREAKS

&IGURE SUMMARIZES ANOTHER DATA SET COMPILED BY THE.EW 9ORK 3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTHONSHELLFISH ASSOCIATEDILLNESSMOSTCOMMONLYGASTRO

ENTERITIS RECORDEDIN.EW9ORK3TATEFROMTO4HESOURCESOFTHESHELLFISHTHATINDUCEDTHESEOUTBREAKSISFREQUENTLYUNKNOWNANDMAYNOTBELOCALINMANYCASES-OSTOFTHEOUTBREAKSRESULTEDFROMCONSUMP

TIONOF,ONG)SLANDCLAMSANDTHESOURCEOFTHEILLNESSESINWASMOSTFREQUENTLYTRACEDTO2HODE)SLANDSHELLFISH4HEOUTBREAKWASTRACEDTOSHELLFISHFROM/YSTER"AY,ONG)SLAND4HEINCIDENCEOFREPORTEDILLNESSHASDROPPED MARKEDLY SINCE ITS PEAK IN $ECREASES IN SHELLFISH ASSOCIATEDDISEASECOULDBEDUETOANUMBEROFFACTORSINCLUDINGBETTERSEWAGETREATMENTLEADING TO REDUCTIONS IN CONCENTRATIONS OF DISEASE CAUSING MICROORGANISMSMORERESTRICTIONSONHARVESTOFSHELLFISHFROMCONTAMINATEDAREASANDMOREAWARENESSAMONGTHEPUBLICASTOTHERISKSASSOCIATEDWITHCONSUMINGRAWSHELLFISH

/NEIMPORTANTCAVEATABOUTTHEDATAPRESENTEDHERE3HELLFISH RELATEDILLNESSISPROBABLYUNDER REPORTEDANDISLIKELYTOBEMISDIAGNOSEDWHENITISREPORTEDBECAUSE THE SYMPTOMS ARE NON SPECIFIC 7HILE THE INCIDENCE OF SHELLFISH

ASSOCIATED DISEASE IS MUCH LOWER IN RECENT YEARS ASCOMPAREDTOTHESANDPREVIOUSYEARSITMAYBETHATTHEABSOLUTENUMBERSOFCASESINEACHYEARAREHIGHERTHANREPORTED

!LTHOUGH SHELLFISH BEDS ARE MONITORED CAREFULLY FORPATHOGENICCONTAMINATIONTHELEVELSOFCHEMICALCON

TAMINANTSINSHELLFISHARENOTASWELL STUDIED

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGURE>cX^YZcXZd[h]Zaa[^h]"

gZaViZY^aacZhh^cCZlNdg`HiViZ!

&.-%*&...=daXdbW'%%%#

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT3HELLFISHAND$ISEASE

(EARTBEATSINTHE-UCKBY*OHN7ALDMAN,YONS0RESS

WWWCFSANFDAGOV^MOWCHAPHTML WWWCDCGOV WWW SEAFOODUCDAVISEDU

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

%6%,3/&#/,)&/2-"!#4%2)!

"ACTERIAAREALLAROUNDUS INTHEAIRINTHEWATERANDEVENINTHE FOOD WE EAT -OST BACTERIA ENCOUNTERED ON A DAILY BASIS AREHARMLESSOREVENBENEFICIALANDNECESSARYTOSUSTAINLIFE(OWEVERTHEPRES

ENCEOFSOMEBACTERIANAMELYFECALCOLIFORMBACTERIAINESTUARYWATERSISANINDICATOROFFECALWASTEANDTHEREFORESUGGESTSTHATOTHERMOREDANGEROUSPATHOGENSMAYBEPRESENT4HESEPATHOGENSCANBEATHREATTOHUMANHEALTHIFWEEATSHELLFISHTHATHAVEBEENINGESTINGTHEMSEETHEDISCUSSIONOFSHELLFISHBEDCLOSURESBEGINNINGONPAGE ORSOMETIMESIFWESWIMINSEWAGE CON

TAMINATEDWATERS4HEMOSTCOMMONRESULTOFEXPOSURETOTHESEPATHOGENSISGASTROENTERITISBUTMORESERIOUSCONDITIONSCANALSORESULTFROMEXPOSURETOSEWAGESEETHEDISCUSSIONOFSHELLFISH RELATEDILLNESSONBEGINNINGPAGE

"EFORE THERE WERE SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANTS RAW SEWAGE WAS DISPOSED OFDIRECTLY INTO OUR WATERWAYS AND FECAL COLIFORM AND OTHER PATHOGEN LEVELSWEREVERYHIGH.OWTHATSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTSHAVEBEENCONSTRUCTEDANDUPGRADED THE MAIN SOURCE OF COLIFORM BACTERIA TO THE ESTUARY IS COMBINEDSEWEROVERFLOWS#3/SROUTEAMIXTUREOFRAWSEWAGEANDSTREETRUNOFFDIRECTLYINTOTHEESTUARYDURINGANDIMMEDIATELYAFTERRAINEVENTSWHENTHEPROCESSINGCAPACITYOFTHESEWAGETREATMENTPLANTSISEXCEEDED/THERSOURCESINCLUDEILLEGALSEWAGECONNECTIONSSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTBYPASSESWHICHSOME

TIMESAREDUETOPLANTMALFUNCTIONSORCONSTRUCTIONATPLANTS SOMEINPUTSFROMTHEPLANTSEVENWHENTHEYAREFUNCTIONINGPROPERLYSTORMWATEROUTFALLSNON POINTSOURCESSUCHASSTORMRUNOFFANDLEAKINGSEPTICTANKSANDINSOMEAREASEXCESSIVEWILDLIFEWASTE&IGURE SHOWS THE MEAN CONCENTRATION OF FECAL COLIFORM BACTERIA IN THEHARBORASMEASUREDDURINGFOURYEARSBYTHE.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL 0ROTECTION .9#$%0 4HE PROGRESSIVE IMPROVEMENT IN COLI

FORMLEVELSISCLEARFROMTHESEFOURTIMEPERIODSWHICHREPRESENTFOURPHASESINSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTUPGRADESANDIMPROVEMENTSIN.EW9ORK#ITY)NMANYSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTSINTHE.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEYAREAWERENOTYETUPGRADEDTOSECONDARYTREATMENTMEANINGTHATRAWSEWAGECONTIN

UEDTOBEDISCHARGEDINSOMELOCATIONSANDDISINFECTIONWASSPORADIC!TTHISTIMEMOSTAREASEXCEEDEDBACTERIALSTANDARDSFOREITHERFISHINGORBATHING)N SOME UPGRADES HAD BEEN MADE TO EXISTING PLANTS BUT TWO OF THE#ITYSPLANTSWERENOTYETBUILT.ORTH2IVERAND2ED(OOK )NTHELARGEIMPROVEMENTSDUETOTHEOPERATIONOFTHOSETWOPLANTSWHICHENDEDTHEDIS

CHARGEOFAPPROXIMATELYMILLIONGALLONSPERDAYOFUNTREATEDSEWAGEFROM-ANHATTANAND"ROOKLYN CANBESEEN&URTHERIMPROVEMENTSTOTHEPLANTSSIGNIFICANTREDUCTIONSOFILLEGALDISCHARGESANDINCREASEDMAINTENANCEOFTHESEWERAGESYSTEMCAUSEDMEANCOLIFORMLEVELSTODROPEVENFURTHERASSHOWNINTHEPANEL

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

.%7*%23%9 (UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

.%7*%23%9

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND (UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 5PPER "AY 5PPER "AY 2ARITAN "AY 2ARITAN "AY 3!.$9

(//+

!TLANTIC

/CEAN

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

(UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

(UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 5PPER "AY 5PPER "AY 2ARITAN "AY 2ARITAN "AY 3!.$9

(//+

!TLANTIC

/CEAN

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

0RE 70#05PGRADES

#OMPOSITE$ATA

0RE 70#05PGRADES

#OMPOSITE$ATA

0OST.ORTH2IVER

2ED(OOK

0OST.ORTH2IVER

2ED(OOK

)NCREASED3URVEILLANCE

-AINTENANCE

)NCREASED3URVEILLANCE

-AINTENANCE

0OST 70#05PGRADEBUT

0RE .ORTH2IVER

2ED(OOK70#03

0OST 70#05PGRADEBUT

0RE .ORTH2IVER

2ED(OOK70#0S

.%7*%23%9 (UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

.%7*%23%9 (UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 5PPER "AY 5PPER "AY 2ARITAN "AY 2ARITAN "AY 3!.$9

(//+

5NIT&ECAL#OLIFORM#ELLSM,

!TLANTIC

/CEAN

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND (UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

(UDSON2IVER

%AST2IVER

-!.(!44!.

7%34#(%34%2

/5.49

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 5PPER "AY 5PPER "AY 2ARITAN "AY 2ARITAN "AY 3!.$9

(//+

!TLANTIC

/CEAN

.ARROWS

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EWARK"AY

!URTHUR+ILL 34!4%.

)3,!.$

"2/.8 15%%.3 "2//+,9.

.OT MEASURED

n

&IGUREHjbbZg\\ZdbZig^XbZVchd[[ZXVaXda^"

[dgbXdcXZcigVi^dch^c=VgWdghjg[VXZlViZgh^c[djg

hZaZXiZYnZVghCN89:E&..-#

&IGURESHOWSAMOREDETAILEDRECORDOFFECALCOLIFORMDENSITIESFORn

FORTHREECOASTALSITESIN.EW9ORKANDTHREEIN.EW*ERSEYOUTSIDEOFTHEHARBORCOREAREA#ONCENTRATIONSOFCOLIFORMATTHESECOASTALSITESWEREUNIFORMLYLOWERTHANCONCENTRATIONSINTHEHARBORSEE&IGURE ANDVARIEDONLYSLIGHTLYFROMYEARTOYEAR&ECALCOLIFORMCONCENTRATIONSALONGTHECOASTAREINFLUENCEDBYSEVERALFACTORSCONCENTRATIONSINWATERSFLOWINGOUTOFTHEHARBORLOCALSTORMWATERDISCHARGESRUNOFFFROMTHELANDCONTRIBUTIONSOFBIRD AND OTHER ANIMAL WASTES OCCASIONAL SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT MALFUNC

TIONSANDDISCHARGESRELATEDTORAINFALLWHENFECALCOLIFORMGETSWASHEDINTOLOCAL WATERS,EVELS OF COLIFORM AT THESE SITES GENERALLY DECREASED BETWEENANDTHEMID STHENINCREASEDAGAININSOMEAREASMOSTNOTABLY2OCKAWAY0OINT.9AND-ANASQUAN)NLET.*)NNOYEARATANYOFTHESITESDIDTHEDENSITYOFCOLIFORMAPPROACHTHE3TATESGUIDELINEUSEDINMAKINGBEACHCLOSUREDETERMINATIONSOFFECALCOLIFORMCELLSPERMLOFWATER

7HILE FECAL COLIFORM IS THE MOST COMMONLY MONITORED INDICATOR OF FECALCONTAMINATION IT HAS CERTAIN LIMITATIONS &OR EXAMPLE IT CANNOT DISTINGUISHBETWEENHUMANANDANIMALCONTAMINATIONSOURCESBUTITISGENERALLYBELIEVEDTHATHUMANFECALCONTAMINATIONPOSESAMUCHGREATERHUMANHEALTHRISKTOBATHERSANDSHELLFISHEATERSTHANANIMALWASTE4HEPRESENCEOFFECALCOLIFORMALSODOESNOTCORRELATEWELLWITHTHELEVELSOFHUMANFECALVIRUSESWHICHMAYBEMOREOFACONCERNWITHRESPECTTODISEASETHANBACTERIA&ORTHESEREASONS.*$%0HASCONDUCTEDRESEARCHINTOTHEUTILITYOFMONITORINGANALTERNATEINDI

CATORCOLIPHAGESWHICHAREVIRUSESTHATINFECTONESPECIESOFCOLIFORMBAC

TERIA4HERESULTSOFTHISWORKAREPROMISINGBUTMORERESEARCHNEEDSTOBEDONEBEFORETHISMETHODBECOMESWIDELY USED 2ECENT FEDERAL LEGISLATION THE "EACHES%NVIRONMENTAL!SSESSMENTAND#OASTAL(EALTH"%!#( !CTWILLREQUIRECOASTALSTATESTOMONITORENTEROCOCCUSBACTERIAAMORERELIABLEANDSENSITIVEINDICATORASTHEPRIMARY INDICATOR FOR SWIMMING WATERS WITHIN THREEYEARS.EW*ERSEYISALREADYEXAMININGTHISINDICATORBUT IT IS NOT YET USED TO DETERMINE WHETHER BEACHESSHOULDBECLOSED

.UMBEROFCELLSMLWATERSEASONALAVERAGE

HeYaWmWoFe_dj"Do Bed]8[WY^"DO

@ed[i8[WY^"DO IWdZo>eea"D@

7iXkhoFWha"D@

CWdWigkWd?db[j"D@

&IGURE6kZgV\\Z[ZXVaXda^[dgbXdcXZcigVi^dchVi

h^iZhdcAdc\\>haVcY!CNVcYi]ZCZl?ZghZn8dVhi!

&.-.*&...JH:E6GZ\\^dc'&.-.*&...#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT#OLIFORM"ACTERIA

.9#$%0ANNUAL(ARBOR3URVEYREPORTAVAILABLEFROM$%0AT ORWWWCINYCNYUSHTMLDEP

HOMEHTML WWWEPAGOVREGIONDESANYBIGHT

%!#(#,/352%3

)FYOUSAYTHATYOUAREhGOINGTOTHEBEACHvINTHE.EW9ORK

.EW*ERSEYREGIONMOSTLIKELYYOUMEANYOUAREHEADINGTOTHE*ERSEY3HORETOONEOFTHEWELL KNOWN,ONG)SLAND3OUTH3HOREBEACHESSUCHAS*ONES"EACHORPERHAPSTO,ONG)SLAND3OUND%XCEPTFOR#ONEY)SLAND.EW9ORK#ITYANDTHEHARBORGENERALLYARENOTCONSIDEREDPRIMEBATHINGDESTINA

TIONS(OWEVERTHEREARESEVERALBEACHESINANDNEARTHEESTUARYTHATWITHWATER QUALITY IMPROVEMENTS ARE BECOMING MORE ATTRACTIVE AS CONVENIENTLYACCESSIBLE SWIMMING HOLES !FTER HAVING BEEN CLOSED FOR DECADES BECAUSEOFWATERQUALITYCONCERNSSOME.EW9ORK#ITYBEACHESNOTABLY 3EAGATE "EACH ON #ONEY )SLAND AND3OUTH AND -IDLAND "EACHES ON 3TATEN )SLANDHAVEOPENEDAGAINFORSWIMMINGINRECENTYEARS3OMEPEOPLEHAVEBEENSWIMMINGOFF0IERINTHE (UDSON 2IVER IN RECENT YEARS AND THERE HASBEENDISCUSSIONOFTHEFEASIBILITYOFCREATINGSWIM

MING BEACHES OR FLOATING POOLS AT OTHER POINTSALONGTHE(UDSONIN-ANHATTAN

2ESPONSIBILITY FOR MONITORING THE WATER QUALITY OFBATHINGBEACHESINTHEESTUARYLIESWITHANUMBEROF AGENCIES ALL OFWHOMUSEDIFFERENTTESTSCRITERIAANDADVISORIESINTHEIR MONITORING PROGRAMS.EW *ERSEY HAS ONE OF THE MOST COMPREHENSIVEBEACHMONITORINGPROGRAMSINTHECOUNTRYALLMILESOFOCEANANDBAYBEACHESAREMONITOREDFORFECALCOLIFORMONCEPERWEEKDURINGTHESUMMER)TISTHEONLYSTATETOHAVEASTATEWIDEMANDATORYBEACHPROTECTIONPROGRAMTHATINCLUDESABACTERIALSTANDARDTESTINGPROTOCOLANDMANDATORYCLOSUREREQUIRE

MENTS.EW *ERSEYS BEACH MONITORING PROTOCOLS HAVE BEEN THE SAME SINCE.EW9ORKDOESNOTHAVEAMANDATORYBEACHMONITORINGPROGRAMBUTTHE$EPARTMENTSOF(EALTHOFALLCOASTALCOUNTIESIN.EW9ORKINCLUDING.EW9ORK#ITYDOCONDUCTROUTINEBACTERIALTESTINGATALLPUBLICBEACHES)NMANYAREASAUTOMATICPREEMPTIVECLOSINGSAREALSOISSUEDAFTERHEAVYRAINFALL

7HATMAKESITUNSAFETOSWIMATACLOSEDBEACH-OSTBEACHCLOSURESAREDUETOPATHOGEN CONTAMINATEDSTORMWATERRUNOFFORCOMBINEDSEWEROVERFLOWSWHICHRELEASEUNTREATEDSEWAGEINTOOURWATERWAYSWHENITRAINS0ATHOGENSINCLUDINGVIRUSESFROMRAWSEWAGEORRUNOFFCANCAUSEGASTROENTERITISWHICHISACTUALLYANUMBRELLANAMEFORAVARIETYOFILLNESSESTHATCAUSEVOMITINGSTOMACHACHEORRELATEDSYMPTOMS OROTHERINFECTIOUSDISEASESSUCHASHEPA

TITISANDSALMONELLOSIS!FEWBEACHCLOSURESHAVEOCCURREDFOROTHERISOLATEDREASONSSUCHASSEWERLINEBREAKSANDOILSPILLS!LTHOUGHSOMEOCEANBEACH

ESIN.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYWERECLOSEDAFTERWASH UPSOFMEDICALWASTEINTHELATESTHESEINCIDENTSAREEXTREMELYRAREANDTHERISKTOSWIMMERSOFANYKINDOFINFECTIONFROMTHEMISEXTREMELYSMALLSEETHE&LOATABLESINDICATORDISCUSSIONPAGE

&IGURESHOWSTHETOTALNUMBEROFBEACHCLOSURESATOCEANANDBAYBEACHESOF-ONMOUTH#OUNTY.EW*ERSEYFROMTO&IGURESHOWSBEACH'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

CLOSURESANDADVISORIESFORSOME.EW9ORK#ITYBOROUGHSAND7ESTCHESTERAND.ASSAU#OUNTIES.EW9ORK.OTETHAT.EW9ORK#ITYHASASTANDINGRAINFALLADVISORYFORALL"RONX1UEENSAND3TATEN)SLANDBEACHESWHICHARENOTINCLUDEDINTHETOTALSONTHEGRAPH4HEREDOESNOTAPPEARTOBEACLEARTRENDINTHENUMBEROFBEACHCLOSURESFOREITHERSTATEOVERTHETIMEPERIODSHOWNHEREMOSTLIKELYBECAUSESOMANYFACTORSCOMBINETOINFLUENCEBACTERIALCONCENTRATIONSANDBECAUSEADVISORYSTAN

DARDSCHANGEOVERTHEYEARSnTHENUMBEROFBEACHESMONI

TOREDORTHEREQUIREDDURATIONOFANADVISORYCANCHANGEFOREXAMPLEALTHOUGHASNOTEDABOVE.EW*ERSEYSMONITORINGPROTOCOLSHAVEBEENTHESAMESINCE

4HE"%!#(!CTDESCRIBEDONPAGEWILLREQUIREALLCOASTALSTATESTOIMPLEMENT CONSISTENT AND RIGOR

OUSBEACHMONITORINGCLOSUREANDPUBLICNOTIFICATIONPROGRAMSBASEDONMONITORINGLEVELSOFENTEROCOC

CUS BACTERIA %NTEROCOCCI HAVEBEEN MORE CLOSELY CORRELATED WITHGASTROENTERITIS IN SWIMMERS THANFECAL COLIFORM AND THUS WILL BE ABETTERINDICATOROFHEALTHRISK.OTONLY WILL BEACH MONITORING PROTO

COLS BECOME MORE CONSISTENT ANDSTRINGENT BUT THE "%!#( !CT ALSOREQUIRES%0!TOMAINTAINANATIONALDATABASE OF BEACH WATER QUALITYINFORMATION SO TRACKING THIS INDI

CATORSHOULDBECOMEEASIERINTHECOMINGYEARS

&IGURECjbWZgd[WZVX]XadhjgZh^cCZlNdg`8^in

VcYLZhiX]ZhiZgVcYCVhhVj8djci^Zh!CN!&.-.*&..-#

9ZXgZVhZ^c&..(XadhjgZhlVhaVg\\Zani]ZgZhjaid[

YZXgZVhZYgV^c[VaaaZkZahVcYX]Vc\\Zh^cCN81/4hgV^c[VaaVYk^"

hdgnegd\\gVb!l]^X]^cXajYZY[ZlZgWZVX]ZhVcYgZYjXZY

i]ZYjgVi^dcd[VYk^hdg^Zh[gdb)-id&']djghCG98

&..&*&...#

.UMBEROFCLOSURES

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT"EACH#LOSURES

WWWEPAGOV/34BEACHESTECHNICALHTML WWWNRDCORGWATEROCEANSTTWTITINXASP WWWNJGOVDEPBEACHES

WWWHARBORESTUARYORGPDFHEP?BEACHES?PDF EY[Wd8[WY^[i 8Wo8[WY^[i

.UMBEROFCLOSURES

&IGURECjbWZghd[dXZVcVcYWVn

WZVX]XadhjgZh^cBdcbdji]8djcin!C?!

&.-.*&...CG98&..&*&...#

,/!4!",%$%"2)3

!LTHOUGHDEBRISINOURWATERWAYSANDONBEACHESOFTENCALLEDhFLOATABLESv RARELYPOSESANIMMEDIATEPUBLICHEALTHTHREATTRASHINTHEENVIRONMENTISUNSIGHTLYOFFEN

SIVEANDAFFECTSOURQUALITYOFLIFE4HEPER

CEIVEDHEALTHTHREATPOSEDBYSOMEFLOAT

ABLESSUCHASTHEMEDICALWASTEFOUNDONAREABEACHESINANDCANHAVETREMENDOUSECONOMICIMPACTTHEECONOMICLOSSESDUETOTHE.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYBEACHCLOSURESINANDAREESTIMAT

EDTOHAVEBEENBETWEENMILLIONANDBILLIONIN.EW*ERSEYANDMILLIONANDBILLIONIN.EW9ORK)NADDITIONFLOATABLESCANPOSEHAZARDSTONAVIGATIONIFBOATSHITLARGEOBJECTSORSUCKSMALLERONESINTO

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&LOATABLE$EBRIS

ENGINESANDPROPELLERSANDTOWILDLIFEWHICHCANBECOMEENTANGLEDINFISHINGGEARORCANDIEFROMINGESTINGSOMEKINDSOFDEBRIS

7HEREDOESTHISDEBRISCOMEFROM4HEMAINSOURCESOFESTUARYFLOATABLESARECOMBINEDSEWEROVERFLOWSANDSTORMWATERBOTHOFWHICHFLUSHDEBRISINTOLOCALWATERWAYSWHENITRAINS0REVAILINGCURRENTSCANCARRYTHISDEBRISTOTHE*ERSEYSHOREBEACHESANDLESSFREQUENTLYTO.EW9ORKBEACHES /THERSOURCESINCLUDEBEACHLITTERERSANDDISCHARGESFROMBOATS

4ABLE SHOWS THE TOP TEN CONSTITUENTS OF TRASH REMOVED FROM.EW 9ORKBEACHES BY THE !MERICAN,ITTORAL 3OCIETY SPONSORED VOLUNTEER #OASTAL#LEANUPINnCONDUCTEDONASINGLEDAYIN3EPTEMBEREVERYYEAR ANDTHEOCCURRENCEOFMEDICALWASTESYRINGESONLY FORCOMPARISON.OTETHATSYRINGESCOMPRISEONLYATINYPORTIONOFWHATISFOUNDINTHESEBEACHCLEANUPS

&IGURESHOWSTHEAMOUNTOFDEBRISREMOVEDFROM.EW9ORK.EW9ORK#ITY,ONG)SLANDANDUPSTATE AND.EW*ERSEYSHORESPERMILECLEANEDINn4HE.EW9ORKBEACHESWERECLEANED BY !MERICAN,ITTORAL 3OCIETY VOLUNTEER CREWS IN THE#OASTAL#LEANUP4HEYEARLYVARIABILITYINTHE.EW9ORKDATACOULDBEDUETOANUMBEROFFACTORSINCLUDINGHOWMANYVOL

UNTEERSPARTICIPATEDINAGIVENYEARTHEMETEOROLOGICALCONDI

TIONSTHATYEARANDEVENTHEWEATHERONTHEDAYOFTHEBEACHCLEANUP.ASTYWEATHERCANDETEREVENTHEMOSTENTHUSIASTICVOLUNTEERS.EW *ERSEY SHORELINES WERE CLEANED BY THE.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTIONS#LEAN3HORESPROGRAMNOTETHATTHEAMOUNTREMOVEDPERMILEOFSHORELINEHASDECREASEDOVERTHEYEARSFORWHICHWEHAVEDATA4HE%0!USESHELICOPTERSURVEYSTODETERMINETHENUMBEROFhSLICKSvORAGGREGATIONSOFFLOATABLESINTHEHARBORTHOSEDATAARESHOWNIN&IGUREFORn/BSERVATIONSOFSLICKSHAVEBEENDECREASINGSINCETHEYINCREASEDFROMTHATYEAROVERPRE

VIOUSYEARSBECAUSEOFANEXPANSIONOFTHEPROGRAMAREA

0RIORTOTHE(%0THE.EW9ORK"IGHT2ESTORATION0ROGRAMINITI

ATEDA&LOATABLES!CTION0LANINTHEHARBORINTHELATESTOPREVENTDEBRISFROMGETTINGINTOTHEWATERWAYSANDTOREMOVEIT FROM WATERWAYS WHEN IT GETS THERE 4HIS PROGRAM INCLUDESTHEOPERATIONOFhSKIMMERVESSELSvBYTHE53!RMY#ORPSOF%NGINEERSANDTHE.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION THAT CRUISE THE HARBOR REMOVING FLOATING DEBRIS&IGURESHOWSTHETONSOFDEBRISREMOVEDBYTHOSEEFFORTSTHE.9#$%0PROGRAMWASINITIATEDIN FROMnTHEREDOESNOTSEEMTOBEADIRECTIONALTRENDINTHISDATA(OWEVER%0!CONSIDERSTHE&LOATABLES!CTION0LANTOBEVERYSUCCESSFULASITHASELIMINATEDBEACHCLOSURESDUETOFLOATABLESIN.EW*ERSEYAND,ONG)SLANDANDHASINSTITUTEDABETTERMECHA

NISMFORNOTIFYINGBEACHOPERATORSOFPOTENTIALWASH UPSOFFLOATINGDEBRIS

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

-OST#OMMON$EBRIS)TEMS&OUNDON.EW9ORK#ITY"EACHESn

$EBRISITEM0ERCENT

OF4OTAL)TEMS

IGARETTEBUTTS

0LASTICFOODBAGSWRAPPERS

0LASTICCAPSLIDS

0LASTICBEVERAGEBOTTLES

&OAMEDPLASTICPIECES

0LASTICSTRAWS

'LASSPIECES

'LASSBEVERAGEBOTTLES

0LASTICPIECES

0LASTICCUPSUTENSILS

-EDICALWASTE

SYRINGESONLY

4!",%9ZWg^hdcCN8WZVX]Zh

6bZg^XVcA^iidgVaHdX^Zin&...#

&IGURE6bdjcid[YZWg^h

gZbdkZY[gdbCNVcYC?h]dgZ" a^cZh!&.-.*&...#CNWZVX]Zh

^cXajYZi]dhZ^cVaaWdgdj\\]h

d[CZlNdg`8^inVcYCVhhVj!

Hj((da`!LZhiX]ZhiZgVcYjehiViZ

Xdjci^Zh6bZg^XVcA^iidgVaHdX^Zin

&...!C?9:E'%%%#

&IGUREDWhZgkVi^dchd[[adViVWaZhha^X`h

^cCN=VgWdg!&..'*&..-#6¹ha^X`º^hYZ[^cZY

VhVc¹V\\\\gZ\\Vi^dcd[[adVi^c\\YZWg^hd[^cYZ[^c^iZ

l^Yi]VcYVb^c^bjbaZc\\i]d[Veegdm^bViZan)%%

bZiZgh#ºCdiZ/^c&..)!hjgkZ^aaVcXZVgZVhlZgZ

^cXgZVhZY!gZhjai^c\\^ci]ZaVg\\Z^cXgZVhZ^ci]Vi

nZVgJH:E6&...#

&IGURE6bdjcid[[adViVWaZYZWg^h

gZbdkZY[gdbi]Z=VgWdgWnCN89:EVcY

JH68D:h`^bbZgkZhhZah!&.--*&..,#

CN89:E1/4hh`^bbZgkZhhZaXdaaZXi^dcegd\\gVb

lVh^c^i^ViZY^c&..)#JH68D:egd\\gVbjhZh

(kZhhZah!CN89:E1/4hegd\\gVbjhZh*kZhhZah

JH:E6&..-V#

D[mOeha D[m@[hi[o

0OUNDSDEBRISMILESSHORELINE

.UMBEROFSLICKSOBSERVED

KI79E;L[ii[bi DO9:;FL[ii[bi

4ONSOFDEBRIS

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT&LOATABLE$EBRIS

WWWALSNYCORG WWWOCEANCONSERVANCYORGDYNAMICISSUESTHREATS

DEBRISDEBRISHTM WWWEPAGOVOWOWOCEANSDEBRIS WWWNYCGOVHTMLDEPHTMLFLOATHTML IdkdajciZZg[dgWZVX]XaZVc"jeh/

>cCN/#ONTACTTHE!MERICAN,ITTORAL3OCIETYAT

OR OR

VISITTHEIRWEBSITEATWWWALSNYCORG

>cC?/#ONTACT#LEAN/CEAN!CTIONAT OR

VISTITTHEIRWEBSITEATWWWCLEANOCEANACTIONORG

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

542)%.4,%6%,3!.$,/!$).'3

.UTRIENTSSUCHASNITROGENANDPHOSPHORUSAREESSENTIALFORTHEGROWTHOFALLORGANISMS)NTHEMARINEENVIRONMENTTHESENUTRIENTSCANCOMEFROMAVARIETYOFSOURCESINCLUDINGRECYCLINGOFNUTRIENTSFROMDEADORGANISMSRUNOFFFROMTHELANDANDGASEOUSNITROGENINTHEAIR(OWEVERASHUMANPOPULATIONSAROUNDWATERWAYSINCREASEDANUMBEROFNEWANTHROPOGENICHUMAN CAUSED SOURCESOFNUTRIENTSBEGANLOADINGINTOWATERWAYSOFTENRESULTINGINhTOOMUCHOFAGOODTHINGvFORTHOSEWATERS)FTOOMUCHNITROGENORPHOSPHORUSISADDEDTOWATERWAYSTHEYCANBECOMEEUTROPHICOVER ENRICHEDINNUTRIENTS )NEUTROPHICSYSTEMSALGAETHATUSETHOSENUTRIENTSGROW

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

.UTRIENTSAND/RGANIC

%NRICHMENT

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR Cjig^ZciAZkZah Cjig^ZciAdVY^c\\h INRAMPANTBLOOMSANDTHENDEPLETETHEIRRESOURCESANDDIE!STHEYDECAYOXYGENISUSEDBYTHEBACTERIATHATBREAKTHEMDOWNANDWATERSCANBECOMELOWINOREVENDEVOIDOFOXYGENSEETHESECTIONOFTHISREPORTONDISSOLVEDOXYGENONPAGE AFFECTINGTHEOTHEROXYGEN BREATHINGORGANISMSTHATLIVETHERE%UTROPHICATIONCANCAUSEOTHERPROBLEMSASWELLINCLUDINGDIMINISHEDQUALITYOFSEAGRASSBEDHABITATCHANGEDFOODWEBSRESULTINGINDECREASEDFISHPRODUCTIONNOXIOUSODORSANDINCREASEDNUISANCEALGALBLOOMS

)NTHE.9.*(ARBOR%STUARYANTHROPOGENICINPUTSOFNUTRIENTSPARTICULARLYNITROGENAREQUITEHIGHBECAUSEOFTHEHIGHVOLUMEOFWASTEWATERTHATENTERSTHEESTUARYFROMMUNICIPALSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTDISCHARGESANDINPUTSFROMTRIBUTARYRIVERS!PPROXIMATELYBILLIONGALLONSOFMOSTLYTREATED WASTE

WATERENTERSTHEESTUARYEVERYDAYFROMMUNICIPALSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTS7HENITRAINSMORENUTRIENTSENTERTHESYSTEMINTHEFORMOFUNTREATEDSEWAGECONTRIBUTED BY COMBINED SEWER OVERFLOWS 5PSTREAM SOURCES SUCH AS FOSSILFUEL COMBUSTION AND AGRICULTURAL FERTILIZER ARE ALSO LARGE.UTRIENT LOADINGSTOTHEESTUARYAREPROBABLYHIGHERTHANINANYOTHERMAJORESTUARYIN.ORTH!MERICA

$ESPITETHEHIGHNUTRIENTLOADINGSTOTHE(ARBOR%STUARYTHEDEGREETOWHICHEUTROPHICATIONORHYPOXIAOCCURSINTHEHARBORVARIESANDISLESSSEVERETHANMIGHT BE EXPECTED FOR A VARIETY OF REASONS /NE IS THAT ALGAL PRODUCTION ISSTRONGLYREGULATEDBYTHEWATERRESIDENCETIMETHETIMETHATWATERREMAINSINTHEESTUARYBEFOREBEINGFLUSHEDOUT-UCHOFTHETIMETHEESTUARYISWELL

FLUSHEDSOTHOSENUTRIENTSGEThWASHEDOUTvINTOTHEOCEANBEFORETHEPROB

LEMATICALGALBLOOMSCANOCCUR)NADDITIONBECAUSEITISSOTURBIDMUCHOFTHEESTUARYISOFTENhLIGHT LIMITEDvMEANINGTHATNOTENOUGHLIGHTPENETRATESTHEWATERCOLUMNTOPROVIDEFORPHOTOSYNTHESISANDBLOOMSTOOCCUR(OWEVERWHENTHERESIDENCETIMEINCREASESASDURINGYEARSWITHLESSRAINANDSNOWOREVENDURINGCERTAINTYPESOFTIDALCYCLESTHEHARBORESTUARYCANBECOMEEUTROPHIC#LIMATECHANGEMODELSPREDICTTHATINTHEFUTUREONAVERAGETHEREWILLLIKELYBESMALLERFRESH

WATERINPUTSTOTHEESTUARYINTHESUMMERANDTHEESTUARYWILLPROBABLYBECOMEMOREEUTROPHIC

&IGURESHOWSTHETOTALNUTRIENTLOADINGSINCLUD

ING TOTAL NITROGEN TOTAL PHOSPHORUS AND TOTALORGANICCARBON TOTHE(ARBOR%STUARYINnAND n AS MEASURED AND ESTIMATED FORSOMEOFTHESMALLERLOADS DURINGTHEDEVELOPMENTAND CALIBRATION OF.EW 9ORK #ITYS 3YSTEM 7IDE%UTROPHICATION -ODEL 37%- 4OTAL NITROGEN ANDORGANIC CARBON LOADINGS WERE LOWER IN nWHILE TOTAL PHOSPHORUS LOADINGS STAYED ABOUT THESAME !LTHOUGH THESE DIFFERENCES COULD BE DUE TOINTERANNUALDIFFERENCESINOTHERCONDITIONSSUCHASFRESHWATERFLOWITISINTERESTINGTOEXAMINEHOWTHESOURCES OF NUTRIENTS ARE DIFFERENT BETWEEN THE TWOYEARS AS IS SHOWN IN &IGURE )N THIS FIGURE THE4OTAL

.ITROGEN 4OTAL 0HOSPHORUS

n

4OTAL

/RGANIC#ARBON

,OADINGMETRICTONSYEAR

n

&IGUREAdVY^c\\hd[i]gZZcjig^Zcihidi]Z:hijVgn^cildnZVgh#

HdbZd[i]ZhbVaaZgadVYhlZgZZhi^bViZYgVi]Zgi]VcbZVhjgZY

=nYgdFjVa'%%&!B^aaZg'%%'#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

340

3/

37 42)"

,OADINGS

METRICTONSYEAR

!4-340

3/

37 42)"

,OADINGS

METRICTONSYEAR

4OTAL0HOSPHORUS 4OTAL.ITROGEN

!4-340 42)" 4RIBUTARIES

!4- !TMOSPHERIC$EPOSITION 340 3EWAGE4REATMENT0LANTS

3/ #OMBINED3EWER/VERFLOWS 37

3TORMWATER

3/

37 3OURCE 3OURCE 3OURCE 42)"

,OADINGS

METRICTONSYEAR

4OTAL/RGANIC#ARBON

!4-

'/..¸./

'//*¸/+

'/..¸./

'//*¸/+

'/..¸./

'//*¸/+

LOADINGS OF NITROGEN PHOSPHORUS AND ORGANIC CARBON ARESHOWNFORTHESAMETWOYEARSFROMSPECIFICSOURCESSEWAGETREATMENT PLANTS COMBINED SEWER OVERFLOWS STORM WATERTRIBUTARIES AND ATMOSPHERIC DEPOSITION &OR NITROGEN ANDPHOSPHORUSINPUTSFROMALLSOURCESHAVEDECREASEDEXCEPTFORSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTSWHICHEXHIBITINCREASEDLOAD

INGS &OR ORGANIC CARBON THE ONLY SOURCE THAT IS LARGER INnISSTORMWATER.UTRIENTLOADSFROMSEWAGETREAT

MENTPLANTSWEREHIGHERINnASCOMPAREDTOnBECAUSEOFTHEINITIATIONOFSLUDGEDE WATERINGREMOVINGTHEWATERFROMSEWAGESLUDGE ATTHESEWAGETREATMENTPLANTS3INCETHEEARLYSTHESOLIDMATERIALTHATISFILTEREDOUTOFSEWAGEHASBEENDE WATEREDATSOMEOFTHE(ARBOR%STUARYSSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTSRATHERTHANDUMPEDINTHEOCEANASITHADBEENPREVIOUSLY4HATDE WATERINGPROCESSMAYNOWBECONTRIBUTINGMORENUTRIENTSTOTHEHARBORITSELF)TWILLBEIMPORTANTTOCONTINUETOMONITORTHEPLANTSTODETERMINEIFANINCREASINGTRENDINLOADINGSFROMTHEPLANTSISACTUALLYOCCURRINGANDIFSOWHATIMPACTITISHAVING

,OOKINGATNUTRIENTLOADINGSOVERAMUCHLONGERTIMESCALESUGGESTSTHATDESPITETHESEWAGETREATMENTPLANTUPGRADESINTHESTHATRESULTEDINDECLINESINNUTRIENTLOADINGSTOTHEESTUARYTHESELOADINGSAREEXTREMELYHIGHTODAYCOM

PAREDTOPRE COLONIALTIMES&IGURESHOWSESTIMATESOFNUTRIENTLOADINGSINPRE COLONIALTIMESTHESANDSASWELLASAPROJECTIONFORAPPROXI

MATELOADINGSSOMETIMEINTHEFUTUREIFCERTAINNUTRIENTCONTROLMEASURESARE

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREHdjgXZhd[adVY^c\\hd[i]gZZcjig^"

Zcihidi]ZZhijVgn^cildnZVgh=nYgdFjVa'%%&!

B^aaZg'%%'#

TAKEN7HILETHEDECLINEINLOADINGSFROMTHESTOTHESISCLEARBOTHOFTHETHCENTURYLOAD

INGSESTIMATESAREFARHIGHERTHANTHEPRE COLONIALESTIMATE AN APPROXIMATION OF THE hBACKGROUNDvLOADINGSWITHOUTSIGNIFICANTHUMANINFLUENCE4HESESCIENTISTS BELIEVE THAT THE hPOTENTIAL FUTUREv LOAD

ING ON THE GRAPH CAN BE ACHIEVED IF A COMPLETECONVERSION TO NUTRIENT REDUCTION SEWAGE TREATMENTTECHNOLOGIESISACHIEVEDALONGWITHSTRICTCONTROLSON#3/SANDSIGNIFICANTREDUCTIONSINLOADINGSFROMUPRIVERTRIBUTARIES4HESECONTROLSAREESTIMATEDTOCOSTAPPROXIMATELYTOMILLIONPERYEAR

!NOTHERWAYTOLOOKATTHESTATUSOFNUTRIENTSINTHEESTUARYISBYEXAMININGAMBIENTLEVELSOFNUTRIENTSINTHEWATERRATHERTHANINPUTSIEEXAMININGHOWMUCH OF A SUBSTANCE IS ALREADY IN THE WATER ASOPPOSEDTOHOWMUCHISBEINGADDEDATAGIVENTIME &IGURESHOWSTHESUMMERMEANAMBIENTCONCENTRATIONOFAMMONIAANDNITRATE NITRITETWOTYPESOFNUTRIENTSASMEASUREDBY.9#$%0S(ARBOR3URVEYFORFOURBASINSOFTHEHARBORFORTHEYEARSn/VERTHISTIMEPERIODTHESEAMBIENTNUTRIENTCONCENTRATIONSHAVEREMAINEDFAIRLYSTABLEFLUCTUATINGSOMEWHATFROMYEARTOYEARWITHAHINTOFADECLINEINAMMONIAINTHE5PPER"AY#ONCENTRATIONSOFTHESENUTRIENTSISSIMILARAMONGBASINSWITHSLIGHTLYHIGHERANDMOREVARIABLELEVELSOFAMMONIAFOUNDIN*AMAICA"AY#HANGESINTHESEPARTICULARNUTRIENTSWHICHAREDISSOLVEDINTHEWATERCANBEDUETOAVARIETYOFFACTORSINCLUDINGCHANGESINUPTAKEOFTHEMBYMICROSCOPICPLANTSPHYTOPLANKTON

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT.UTRIENTS

4HE(UDSON!N)LLUSTRATED'UIDETOTHE,IVING2IVERBY3TEPHEN03TANNEETAL2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS

.9#$%0ANNUAL(ARBOR3URVEYREPORTAVAILABLEFROM$%0AT ORWWWCINYCNYUSHTMLDEP

HOMEHTML WWWEPAGOVMAIAHTMLEUTROPHHTML WWWCHESAPEAKEBAYNETNUTRHTM 0RE #OLONIAL

%ARLY

S

S 0OTENTIAL FUTURE

4OTAL.ITROGENGMY

&IGURE8VaXjaViZYc^igd\\ZcadVY^c\\idi]ZZhijVgnYjg^c\\[djg

i^bZeZg^dYh#EdiZci^Va[jijgZadVY^c\\WVhZYdcbdYZa^c\\gZhjaih

Vhhjb^c\\XdbeaZiZXdckZgh^dcidcjig^Zci"gZYjXi^dchZlV\\ZigZVi" bZci!Za^b^cVi^dcd[8HDY^hX]Vg\\Zh!VcYVh^\\c^[^XVcigZYjXi^dc^c

c^igd\\ZcadVY^c\\[gdbjeg^kZgig^WjiVg^Zh=dlVgi]ZiVa#'%%'#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

)33/,6%$/89'%.

&ORMOSTMARINEANIMALSPRESENCEOFOXYGENINTHEIRENVI

RONMENTISASCRITICALASITISFORHUMANSBECAUSETHEYRESPIREBYUSINGDISSOLVEDOXYGENINTHEWATERAROUNDTHEM7HENWATERSBECOMEHYPOXICLOWINOXYGEN ORANOXICLACKINGOXYGEN ORGANISMSUNABLETOMOVEAWAYFROMTHEAFFECTEDAREAEXPERIENCEASPECTRUMOFPROBLEMSRANGINGFROMLOWGROWTHTOMASSMORTALITY(YPOXIAOCCURSWHENDECOMPOSITIONOFEXCESSORGANICMATTERINTHEWATERUSESUPOXYGENTHATORGANICMATTERCANBERAWSEWAGEORDEADALGAETHATHAVEBLOOMEDINRESPONSETOANOVERABUNDANCEOFNUTRIENTSANDTHENDIEDOFFQUICKLYLIVINGALGAEALSOCONSUMEOXYGENWHENTHEY ARE NOT IN THE PRESENCE OF LIGHT (IGHER TEMPERATURES IN THE SUMMER&IGURE6bbdc^VVcYC^igViZ"C^ig^iZ

XdcXZcigVi^dch^c[djgZhijVgnWVh^ch!

&.-**'%%%GVc]Z^b'%%'#

!MMONIA.ITRATE .ITRITEMGL

)NNER(ARBOR

AMAICA"AY

,OWER.EW9ORK(ARBORAND2ARITAN"AY 7cced_Wc]%b

D_jhWj[#D_jh_j[jefc]%b

7cced_Wc]%b

D_jhWj[#D_jh_j[jefc]%b

7cced_Wc]%b

D_jhWj[#D_jh_j[jefc]%b

7cced_Wc]%b

D_jhWj[#D_jh_j[jefc]%b

5PPER%AST2IVER 7ESTERN,ONG)SLAND3OUND

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

MONTHSCANEXACERBATETHEPROBLEMWHICHISALSOUSUALLYWORSEINTHEBOT

TOMLAYERSOFWATERBECAUSETHEYARENOTASWELL MIXEDANDOXYGENATEDASSURFACEWATERS

"ECAUSEDISSOLVEDOXYGENISSOCRITICALTOSUSTAINMARINELIFEANDISADIRECTMEASUREMENTOFWATERQUALITYITHASBEENUSEDTOGAUGETHEHEALTHOFTHEHARBORFORALMOSTACENTURY&IGURESHOWSDISSOLVEDOXYGENDATACOLLECTEDBY.9#$%0BETWEENAND.9#$%0TAKESWATERSAMPLESATASERIESOFSTATIONSTHROUGHOUTTHEHARBORABOUTEVERYTWOWEEKSFORTHISANALYSISTHEDATAFROMALLSTATIONSWEREAVERAGEDTOSHOWTRENDSOVERTHEWHOLEHARBORFORTHESUMMERMONTHS$URINGTHEYEARSSHOWNTHEREHASBEENANUPWARDTRENDINTHELEVELSOFDISSOLVEDOXYGENINSURFACEANDBOTTOMWATERSOFTHEHAR

BOR#ONDITIONSIMPROVEDSWIFTLYANDDRAMATICALLYSTARTINGINTHEEARLYSBECAUSEOFCONSTRUCTIONANDUPGRADINGOFSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTSASREQUIREDBYTHE#LEAN7ATER!CT0REVIOUSLYDISSOLVEDOXYGENLEVELSINBOTTOMWATERSOFTHEHARBORWEREROUTINELYBELOWMG,INTHESUMMERMONTHSALTHOUGHTHEAVERAGESWEREALWAYSHIGHERASREFLECTEDINTHEFIGURE ANDTHEREFORELETHALTOMOSTORGANISMS4HESECONDITIONSWOULDOFTENPER

SISTFORMANYWEEKSATATIME&ORTHISENTIREDURATIONAVERAGEOXYGENCONCENTRATIONSHAVEBEENABOVETHE%0!SGUIDELINEOFMG,THEMINIMUMCONCENTRA

TIONTOWHICHMARINEORGANISMSCANBEEXPOSEDFORMORETHANHOURSWITHOUTEXPERIENCINGINCREASEDMORTALITYOFJUVENILESANDADULTSSEETHEDISCUSSIONOFTHISBENCHMARKBELOW 4HESEDATAPROBABLYOVERESTI

MATEDISSOLVEDOXYGENLEVELSTOSOMEEXTENTBECAUSEALGAECONSUMEOXYGENINTHEDARKGENERALLYLEADINGTOLOWEROXYGENLEVELSJUSTBEFOREDAWN

3OMESCIENTISTSBELIEVETHATSOMEOFTHEFLUCTUATIONSSEEN HERE CAN BE ATTRIBUTED TO VARIATIONS IN PHYTO

PLANKTON PRODUCTIVITY RESULTING FROM CHANGES IN THEAMOUNT OF FRESH WATER ENTERING THE ESTUARY 7HENFRESHWATERDISCHARGESAREDECREASEDDROUGHTYEARS THE RESIDENCE TIME INCREASES LEADING TO MORE ALGALPRODUCTIONANDULTIMATELYLOWERDISSOLVEDOXYGEN

&IGURE SHOWS MORE DETAILED TRENDS IN DISSOLVEDOXYGEN LEVELS OVER BOTH TIME AND SPACE BETWEENANDFORBOTTOMWATERSWHEREMORESEVEREHYPOXIA IS MORE LIKELY TO OCCUR 4HE COLOR OF THEDOTS INDICATES THE LOWEST LEVEL OF DISSOLVED OXYGENOBSERVEDINTHEBOTTOMWATEROFTHATSTATIONINTHATYEARRELATIVETOSOMERECENTLY DEVELOPED%0!GUIDE

LINES WHICH PROVIDE GUIDANCE ON APPROPRIATELY PRO

TECTIVELEVELSOFDISSOLVEDOXYGENINMARINEWATERSOFTHEMID !TLANTICREGION4HEGUIDELINESSTATETHATMG,ISTHEMINIMUMCONCENTRATIONOFDISSOLVEDOXY

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT$ISSOLVED/XYGEN

.9#$%0ANNUAL(ARBOR3URVEYREPORTAVAILABLEFROM$%0AT ORWWWCINYCNYUSHTMLDEP

HOMEHTML WWWEPAGOVOSTSTANDARDSDISSOLVED

WWWNYCGOVHTMLDEPHTMLHYPOXIAHTML

$ISSOLVED/XYGENMGL

Ikh\\WY[:_iiebl[ZEno][d 8ejjec:_iiebl[ZEno][d

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREBZVc]VgWdg"l^YZY^hhdakZYdmn\\ZcXdcXZcigVi^dch

hjg[VXZVcYWdiidb!&.)+*'%%&GVc]Z^b'%%'!NVd'%%'#

,OWER(UDSON

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

AMAICA"AY

AMAICA"AY 2ARITAN"AY

,OWER(UDSON

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

AMAICA"AY

AMAICA"AY 2ARITAN"AY

,OWER(UDSON

,OWER(UDSON "ELOW*UVENILEAND!DULT

3URVIVAL,IMIT

"OTTOM-INIMUM$/LEVELSMG,

3HOULDBE-ONITOREDFOR,ARVAL 2ECRUITMENT3UITABILITYn

%XCEEDINGTHE#HRONIC0ROTECTIVE 6ALUEFOR'ROWTH

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

AMAICA"AY

AMAICA"AY 2ARITAN"AY

,OWER(UDSON

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

AMAICA"AY

AMAICA"AY 2ARITAN"AY

,OWER(UDSON

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

.EW9ORK (ARBOR

!RTHUR+ILL

+ILL6AN+ULL

AMAICA"AY

AMAICA"AY 2ARITAN"AY

GENTOWHICHMARINEORGANISMSCANBEEXPOSEDFOR MORE THAN HOURS WITHOUT EXPERIENCINGINCREASED MORTALITY OF JUVENILES AND ADULTS )FTHE$/ISBELOWMG,THESITEDOESNOTMEET%0!SOBJECTIVESFORPROTEC

TION$/ABOVEMG,ISCONSIDEREDNECESSARYFORGROWTHOFMARINEORGAN

ISMS)F$/ISABOVEMG,ATASITETHESITEISCONSIDEREDTOMEETOBJEC

TIVESFORPROTECTIONOFMARINELIFE)FASITEFALLSBETWEENTHOSETWOGUIDELINESITSHOULDBEMONITOREDMORECLOSELYTODETERMINEIFTHEDURATIONANDEXTENTOFHYPOXIAISSIGNIFICANT

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

&IGUREB^c^bjbbZVhjgZYWdiidb9DaZkZah

^ci]Z=VgWdg^c[^kZhZaZXiZYnZVghGVc]Z^b'%%'!

NVd'%%'#

4HENUMBEROFSTATIONSTHATEXHIBITAMINIMUM$/BELOWTHEJUVENILEANDADULTSURVIVALLIMITOFMG,HASDECREASEDOVERTIME)NAND$/BELOWTHEMG,GUIDELINEWASOBSERVEDINMANYPARTSOFTHEESTUARYMOSTNOTABLYINTHE%AST2IVERANDTHE+ILLS!FTERSEWAGETREATMENTIMPROVEMENTSINCREASESINBOTTOM$/WEREOBSERVEDTHROUGHOUTTHEESTUARY)NANDMINIMUM$/ATMOSTSTATIONSWASOBSERVEDTOBEINTHEnMG,RANGE/XYGENLEVELSCANEXHIBITAHIGHDEGREEOFVARIABILITYWHICHAFFECTSTHISTYPEOFTRENDANALYSIS&OREXAMPLEMETEOROLOGICALDIFFERENCESAMONGYEARSCANCAUSECONSIDERABLE INTERANNUAL VARIABILITY IN OBSERVED $/ )N ADDITION THE MAPSSHOWNHERECANBEAFFECTEDGREATLYBYSINGLESHORT TERMEVENTSTHATMAYNOTHAVEANYECOLOGICALCONSEQUENCESAVERYBRIEFHYPOXICEPISODETHATHAPPENSTOCOINCIDEWITHASAMPLINGDATEMAYCAUSEASTATIONTOAPPEARTROUBLESOME)TISLIKELYTHATTHESETYPESOFVARIABILITYMAKEAPPEARTOBEWORSEWITHRESPECTTOBOTTOM$/THAN4HEREAREMORESTATIONSWITH$/LESSTHANMG,INTHANBUTTHEDATAFORNOTSHOWNHEREACTUALLYSHOWFEWERMG,STATIONSTHAN/VERALLDISSOLVEDOXYGENLEVELSHAVEIMPROVEDDRAMATICALLYINTHEHARBORDURINGTHECOURSEOFTHISSURVEY

(OWEVERITISIMPORTANTTONOTETHATEPISODICHYPOXIAANDANOXIASTILLOCCURINSOMEPARTSOFTHEHARBORINTHESUMMERTIME.9#$%0REPORTSTHATHYPOXICCONDITIONS PERSIST AND IN SOME PLACES HAVE BECOME MORE SEVERE IN RECENTYEARSINPARTSOFWESTERN,ONG)SLAND3OUNDANDTOALESSEREXTENT*AMAICA"AY4HE#OMPREHENSIVE#ONSERVATIONAND-ANAGEMENT0LANSOFBOTHTHE.9

.*(%0ANDTHE,ONG)SLAND3OUND3TUDYOUTLINESTEPSTOIMPROVEDISSOLVEDOXYGENCONDITIONSBYADDRESSINGNUTRIENTLOADINGSTOTHESEESTUARIESSEETHEDISCUSSIONOFNUTRIENTLEVELSANDLOADINGSONPAGE

(,/2/0(9,,A

HLOROPHYLLTHEhGREENvPARTOFGREENPLANTSISTHESUBSTANCEINSIDE PLANT CELLS THAT PERFORMS PHOTOSYNTHESIS TURNING SUN

LIGHTCARBONDIOXIDEANDWATERINTOENERGY4HECONCENTRATIONOFONEKINDOFCHLOROPHYLLCHLOROPHYLLACANBESURVEYEDINTHEWATERSOFTHEESTUARYASAMOREEASILY MEASUREDSURROGATEFORTHEMASSOFPHYTOPLANKTONnMICROSCOPICALGAEnINTHEWATER7HILECONCENTRATIONSOFPHYTOPLANKTONVARYDRAMATICALLY OVER TIME AND SPACE IN RESPONSE TO ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONSLARGEAMOUNTSOFPHYTOPLANKTONCANBEANINDICATOROFEUTROPHICATIONORANOVERABUNDANCEOFNUTRIENTS7HENPHYTOPLANKTONBLOOMQUICKLYANDPROLIFI

CALLYINRESPONSETOAHIGHLOADOFNUTRIENTSORSOMEOTHERNECESSARYFACTORFORGROWTH TOASYSTEMTHEYOFTENUSEUPTHOSENUTRIENTSANDOTHERRESOURCESQUICKLYANDTHENDIEOFF4HEIRSUBSEQUENTDECOMPOSITIONUSESUPOXYGENPARTICULARLYINBOTTOMWATERSLEADINGTOHYPOXICLOW OXYGEN ORANOXICNOOXYGEN CONDITIONSWHICHCANADVERSELYAFFECTOTHERORGANISMSINTHEESTUARYSEETHEDISCUSSIONOFDISSOLVEDOXYGENONPAGE

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

0HYTOPLANKTONDOBLOOMNATURALLYINTHESPRINGANDFALLINTHEWATERSOFTHEESTUARYANDFORMTHEBASISFORMANYESTUARINEFOODWEBS%UTROPHICATIONCANRESULTFROMLARGEINPUTSOFNUTRIENTSFROMSEWAGETREATMENTPLANTDISCHARGESCOMBINEDSEWEROVERFLOWSNON POINTSOURCERUNOFFFROMTHELANDANDOTHERSOURCESSEETHEDISCUSSIONOFNUTRIENTLOADSANDLEVELSONPAGE .9#$%0 HAS BEEN MEASURING CONCENTRATIONS OF CHLOROPHYLL A AT STATIONS INTHEHARBORSINCE!VERAGECHLOROPHYLLACONCENTRATIONSINTHESUMMERMONTHSWHENEUTROPHICATIONISMOSTLIKELYTOOCCUR INFOURDIFFERENTBASINSOFTHEHARBORARESHOWNOVERTIMEIN&IGURE4HEREISAGAPINTHEDATABETWEEN AND BECAUSE THE DATA FOR THOSE YEARS ARE NOT RELIABLEBECAUSEOFPROBLEMSENCOUNTEREDINTHELABORATORY4HEREMAININGYEARSOFDATASHOWNHEREAREACCURATE

HLOROPHYLLAMGL

HLOROPHYLLAMGL

HLOROPHYLLAMGL

HLOROPHYLLAMGL

Kff[h;WijH_l[hWdZ M[ij[hdBed]?ibWdZIekdZ

Bem[hD[mOeha>WhXeh HWh_jWd8Wo

?dd[h>WhXeh

@WcW_YW8Wo

&IGURE6kZgV\\ZhjbbZgX]adgde]naa

VXdcXZcigVi^dch^c[djg=VgWdgWVh^ch!

&.-+*'%%&#HZZiZmi[dgZmeaVcVi^dcd[

b^hh^c\\nZVghGVc]Z^b'%%'#

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

)NMOSTOFTHEHARBORFORTHEYEARSSHOWNCHLOROPHYLLACONCENTRATIONSAREFAIRLYSTABLEFLUCTUATINGSOMEWHATFROMYEARTOYEAR4HEREISAHINTOFANINCREASEINTHE5PPER%AST2IVER,ONG)SLAND3OUND!TRUEDIRECTIONALTRENDISONLYAPPARENTIN*AMAICA"AYWHERECHLOROPHYLLACONCENTRATIONSINCREASEDDRAMATICALLYOVERTHISTIMEPERIOD!LTHOUGHINCREASEDANDIMPROVEDSEWAGETREATMENTHASLEDTOIMPROVEMENTSINMANYWATERQUALITYINDICATORSINTHEESTUARYOVERTHEPASTYEARSSEETHEDISCUSSIONSOFDISSOLVEDOXYGENNUTRIENTLOADSANDLEVELSANDFECALCOLI

FORMLEVELSINTHISREPORT CHLOROPHYLLALEVELSARESTABLEINMUCHOFTHEESTUARY2ESEARCHERSFROM#ORNELL5NIVERSITYHAVECOMPAREDOTHERCHLOROPHYLLADATASETSANDBELIEVETHATCHLOROPHYLLACONCENTRA

TIONSWEREACTUALLYHIGHERINTHELOWERESTUARYINTHESTHAN IN THE S SEE (OWARTH ET AL 4HERE ARE ANUMBER OF POSSIBLE EXPLANATIONS FOR THIS TREND )T IS MOSTLIKELYTHATWHILE NUTRIENT INPUTS TO THE ESTUARY HAVE FLUCTUATED OVERALLNUTRIENTCONCENTRATIONISQUITEHIGHMEANINGTHATNUTRIENTSARENOThLIMITINGvINTHISESTUARY/THERFACTORSLIGHTAVAILABILITYFOREXAMPLEPLACEACAPONPHYTOPLANKTON PRODUCTIVITY REGARDLESS OF THE AMOUNT OF NUTRIENTS ADDED TOTHESYSTEM 4HEREFORENOMATTERHOWMUCHEXTRANUTRIENTLOADISADDEDTOTHEESTUARYNOADDITIONALPHYTOPLANKTONBLOOMSCANTAKEPLACE)NADDITIONPHYSICALFACTORSINTHEESTUARYPREVENTALGALBLOOMS&OREXAMPLETHEhRETEN

TIONRATEvOFTHEESTUARYISGENERALLYFAIRLYLOWNUTRIENTSGETWASHEDOUTOFTHESYSTEMBEFORETHEYCANCAUSEALGALBLOOMS!LSOTHEVERTICALMIXINGINTHEESTUARYISFAIRLYHIGHTHEWATERISMOVEDRAPIDLYBETWEENTHESURFACEANDTHEBOTTOM4HEREFOREPHYTOPLANKTONhSPENDMORETIMEvDEEPERINTHEESTUARYWHERELIGHTFAILSTOPENETRATEPREVENTINGTHEMFROMGROWINGVERYFAST)N*AMAICA"AYHOWEVERTHEREHASBEENANINCREASINGTRENDINCHLOROPHYLLAOVERTHEYEARSEXAMINED7HILETHEREASONSFORTHISINCREASEARENOTENTIRELYCLEAR IT CAN BE SPECULATED THAT *AMAICA "AY hWORKSv DIFFERENTLY THAN OTHERPARTSOFTHEESTUARY&OREXAMPLEBECAUSEITISSEMI ENCLOSEDPERHAPSTHERETENTIONRATEINTHE"AYISHIGHERTHANINOTHERPARTSOFTHEESTUARY*AMAICA"AY IS ALSO QUITE SHALLOW A GREATER PROPORTION OF THE PHYTOPLANKTON THEREARE GROWING UNDER GOOD LIGHT CONDITIONS LEADING TO MORE GROWTH ! RECENT.9#$%0ANNUALREPORTNOTEDTHATh*AMAICA"AYWATERSCONSISTENTLYEXHIBITTHEGREATESTAVERAGECHLOROPHYLLACONCENTRATIONSANDHIGHESTLEVELSOFVARIABILITYWHICHREFLECTSTHEDEGREEOFPLANKTONICACTIVITYATASITE v.9#$%0

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT#HLOROPHYLL

.9#$%0ANNUAL(ARBOR3URVEYREPORTAVAILABLEFROM$%0AT ORWWWCINYCNYUSHTMLDEP

HOMEHTML

2!.30!2%.#9

!SDISCUSSEDINTHESECTIONOFTHISREPORTONSUSPENDEDSEDIMENTLOADSPAGE THEWATERSOFTHE(ARBOR%STUARYARENOTANDSHOULDNOTBE CLEARLIKETHOSEOFTHE#ARIBBEANBECAUSETHE(ARBOR%STUARYNATURALLYCONTAINSALARGEAMOUNTOFSUSPENDEDMATERIALSnSEDIMENTPLANKTONORGANICMATERIALSANDMORE(OWEVERCHANGESINWATERCLARITYCANBEINDICATIVEOFHUMANIMPACTONAWATERBODY&OREXAMPLEASUDDENINCREASEINWATERCLARITY TRANSPARENCY ISOFTENASSOCIATEDWITHACIDIFICATIONOFLAKESDUETOACIDRAIN7HILETHISPROCESSDOESNOTTAKEPLACEINTHEHARBORITSELFOTHEREXTERNALFACTORSCANINFLUENCETRANS

PARENCYINTHEESTUARY&OREXAMPLEHUMANACTIVITIESCANDECREASETRANSPARENCYBYADDINGANOVERABUNDANCEOFNUTRIENTSTOTHESYSTEMTHATCANRESULTINPHYTO

PLANKTONBLOOMSANDDEVELOPMENTCANCAUSEINCREASINGRUNOFFANDSUBSEQUENTEROSIONOFSOILFROMTHELANDINTOTHEESTUARY.OTALLCHANGESINTRANSPARENCYAREDUETOHUMANIMPACTSTRANS

PARENCYNATURALLYFLUCTUATESINTHEESTUARYOVERTHECOURSEOFAYEAR$URINGTHESPRINGFRESHETTHEINCREASEINFRESHWATERINPUTTOTHEESTUARYFROMSNOWMELTUPSTREAMCARRIESWITHITMUCHHIGHERCON

CENTRATIONSOFSEDIMENTRESULTINGINDECREASEDTRANSPARENCY%VENA HEAVY RAINSTORM CAN INFLUENCE TRANSPARENCY OVER SHORT PERIODSOFTIME

/NEOFTHESIMPLESTMOSThLOW TECHvWAYSTOMEASURETRANSPARENCYISBYUSINGA3ECCHIDISKADISKDIVIDEDINTOQUADRANTSTHATARECOLOREDBLACKANDWHITEANDSUSPENDEDFROMAROPEALONGWHICHAREMARKEDDEPTHINTERVALSSEEILLUSTRATION 4HEINVESTIGATORDROPSTHEDISK INTO THE WATER AND LOWERS IT THROUGH THE WATERCOLUMNRECORDINGTHEDEPTHATWHICHTHEDISKCANNOLONGERBESEEN4HISDEPTHISREFERREDTOASTHE3ECCHIDEPTHOFTHEWATER3ECCHIDEPTHHASBEENMONITOREDATSTATIONSTHROUGH

OUTTHEHARBORBYTHE.9#$%0SINCE!VERAGESUMMER3ECCHIDEPTHFORBASINSOFTHEHARBORFROM TO IS SHOWN IN &IGURE &OR ALL BASINS3ECCHIDEPTHDOESNOTAPPEARTOHAVECHANGEDMARK

EDLYOVERTHEPERIODOFTIMESHOWN4HEREISAHINTOFADECLININGTRENDIN*AMAICA"AYSEEMINGLYRELATEDTOTHEINCREASINGCHLOROPHYLLACONCENTRATIONSOBSERVEDTHERESEETHESECTIONON#HLOROPHYLLAPAGE !STATISTICALCOMPARISONOFSECCHIDEPTHANDCHLOROPHYLLACONCENTRATIONSIN*AMAICA"AYREVEALSTHATTHETWOPARAMETERSARECLOSELYRELATED

3ECCHI$EPTHFT

@WcW_YWXWo

?dd[h>WhXeh Kff[h;WijH_l[h WdZM[ij[hdBed]

?ibWdZIekdZ Bem[hD[mOeha>WhXeh WdZHWh_jWd8Wo

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR HZXX]^Y^h`

&IGURE6kZgV\\ZhjbbZgHZXX]^Y^h`bZVhjgZbZcih^c

[djg]VgWdgWVh^ch!&.-+*'%%&GVc]Z^b'%%'#

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT4RANSPARENCY

.9#$%0ANNUAL(ARBOR3URVEYREPORTAVAILABLEFROM$%0AT ORWWWCINYCNYUSHTMLDEP

HOMEHTML DIPINKENTEDU 4

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

!2-&5,!,'!,",//-3

-ICROSCOPIC ALGAE OR PHYTOPLANKTON ARE AT THE BOTTOM OFMOSTMARINEFOODCHAINSANDARETHEREFORECRITICALTOSUSTAIN

INGLIFEONTHEENTIREPLANET4YPICALLYINEARLYSPRINGASMID !TLANTICWATERSBEGINTOWARMANDNUTRIENTSBECOMEAVAILABLELOCALWATERSEXPERIENCEAPHY

TOPLANKTONBLOOM4HEREISALSOASMALLERBLOOMINTHEFALL5NDERAVARIETYOFSPECIALCIRCUMSTANCESWHICHARENOTWELLUNDERSTOODASMALLNUMBEROFALGALSPECIESCANUNDERGOBLOOMSOFVERYHIGHDENSITYATOTHERTIMESOFTHEYEARWITHAVARIETYOFUNDESIRABLERESULTS4HESEBLOOMSOFASINGLESPECIESWITHSOMEHARMFULATTRIBUTELASTINGFROMDAYSTOMONTHSAREREFERREDTOAS(ARMFUL!LGAL"LOOMS(!"S $EPENDINGONTHESPECIESANDSEVERITYOFTHEBLOOM(!"SCANCAUSEFISHANDSHELLFISHKILLSANDCANCONCENTRATEINTHEFLESHOFEDIBLESPECIESCAUSINGILLNESSANDEVENDEATHIFFISHORSHELLFISHFROMBLOOMAREAS ARE CONSUMED 3OME SPECIES ARE SKIN IRRITANTS CAUSING DISCOMFORT TOBATHERS!LTHOUGHMOSTOFTHESEINCIDENTSOCCURINCOASTALWATERSINSIXFISHERMENON'EORGES"ANKMILESEASTOF#APE#OD-ASSACHUSETTSALMOSTDIEDFROMCONSUMINGMUSSELSCAUGHTINTHEIRNETSTHATHADBEENEXPOSEDTOA TOXIC BLOOM 4HESE MORE SEVERE AND DANGEROUS IMPACTS OF BLOOMS HAVENOTBEENOBSERVEDINTHISREGIONTODATETHEWORSTIMPACTOF(!"SOBSERVEDIN.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYOTHERTHANIMPACTSONSHELLFISHOFBROWNTIDEREFERREDTOBELOW HASBEENRASHESEXPERIENCEDBYBATHERSINTHEVICINITYOFSOMEBLOOMS

4HECAUSESOF(!"SARENOTKNOWNWITHMUCHCERTAINTYALTHOUGHTHEREDOESSEEM TO BE A CORRELATION BETWEEN POOR WATER QUALITY DECREASED DISSOLVEDOXYGENANDANOVERABUNDANCEOFNUTRIENTSFOREXAMPLE ANDTHEOCCURRENCEOFBLOOMS

)N OUR ESTUARY SEVERAL AGEN

CIES RECORD THE OCCURRENCEAND EXTENT OF THESE BLOOMSINCLUDING.9#$%0.*$%0THE )NTERSTATE %NVIRONMENTAL#OMMISSIONANDTHE.ATIONAL0ARK3ERVICE&IGURESHOWSTHE TOTAL NUMBER OF BLOOMSDEFINED IN THIS CASE AS ACHLOROPHYLL A CONCENTRATIONTWICE THE LONG TERM MEANFOR THAT AREA RECORDED BY ALLMONITORINGPROGRAMSBETWEEN AND 4HE MAPINDICATES THAT THE,OWER "AYANDLOWER*AMAICA"AYARETHE&IGUREIdiVacjbWZgd[]Vgb[jaVa\\VaWaddbh!

&.,**&..*#7addbhYZ[^cZYVhX]adgde]naaVaZkZah

il^XZi]ZbZVcaZkZa8dheZgVcY8ZgVb^&..+#

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND 5PPER

"AY

,ONG)SLAND 3OUND

AMAICA "AY

AMAICA "AY 5PPER

"AY 2ARITAN "AY

+ILL6AN+ULL

+ILL6AN+ULL 3ANDY(OOK (ARLEM 2IVER (ARLEM 2IVER

-ANHATTAN

%AST 2IVER

nBLOOMS

n

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

(

'OOD

$ATA!VAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL

&AIR 0OOR

AREASMOSTPRONETOBLOOMSBUTTHISINFORMATION DOES NOT TELL US ANYTHINGABOUTTHEIMPACTOFTHOSEBLOOMSONTHEECOSYSTEMORHUMANHEALTH

4ABLE SUMMARIZES THE SEVERITY OFDOCUMENTED BLOOMS BETWEEN ANDINCOASTALWATERSANDINNERBAYS OF THE (ARBOR %STUARY AND.EW9ORK"IGHT4HENUMBERSINEACHCOL

UMNREPRESENTTHENUMBEROFBLOOMSOFAPARTICULARSEVERITYINAPARTICULARTIME PERIOD 4HESE NUMBERS ARE NOTBASED ON MEASUREMENTS OF CHLORO

PHYLLAASIN&IGUREBUTINSTEADAREBASEDONDOCUMENTEDOBSERVATIONSOFBLOOMS IN WHICH QUALIFIED PERSONNELDETERMINEDTHESPECIESOFTHEBLOOMASWELLASITSOTHERCHARACTERISTICS.ONEOF THE BLOOMS WERE SEVERE ENOUGHTO CAUSE FOOD POISONING IN HUMANSAND MOST OF THE BLOOMS ONLY DISCOL

OREDTHEWATERANDREDUCEDWATERCLARITY!FTERARELATIVELYSEVEREEXTENSIVEDINOFLAGELLATEBLOOMIN.EW*ERSEYCOASTALWATERSINBLOOMMONITORINGINCREASEDPROBABLYACCOUNTINGFORTHEHIGHERNUMBERSOFBLOOMSRECORDEDINLATERYEARS/NETYPEOFBLOOMTHATISNOTINCLUDEDINTHESEDATASETSIShBROWNTIDEvWHICHHASHADADEVASTATINGEFFECTONTHESCALLOPFISHERIESIN,ONG)SLANDANDHASSTARTEDTOAPPEARIN.EW*ERSEYCOASTALWATERSASWELL4HISSPECIESHASNOTBEENOBSERVEDTOBLOOMINTHEHARBORBUTITHASAPPEAREDIN'REAT3OUTH"AY,ONG)SLAND7EALSOHAVENOTEXPERIENCEDBLOOMSOF0FIESTERIAPISCICIDAINTHISAREA4HISMYSTERIOUSDINOFLAGELLATEHASCAUSEDFISHKILLSANDEVENNEUROLOGICALDAMAGEINPEOPLEFROM.ORTH#AROLINATO$ELAWARE4HEREISSOMEEVIDENCETHATANON TOXICFORMOF0FIESTERIAEXISTSINSOME.EW9ORKWATERSBUTITHASYETTOBLOOMANDVERYLITTLEISKNOWNABOUTWHATCAUSESITTOBLOOM

4!",%CjbWZgd[YdXjbZciZYWaddbhd[XdggZhedcY^c\\hZkZg^inaZkZah#AZ[i"]VcYl]^iZXdajbch

2WaddbhdWhZgkZY^cXdVhiValViZgh0nZaadl2WaddbhdWhZgkZY^c^ccZgWVnh#CjbWZgh

^cY^XViZcjbWZghd[Waddbhd[i]VihZkZg^in^ci]Vii^bZeZg^dY#DWhZgkVi^dchbdhia^`Zan

^cXgZVhZY^cVaaVgZVh[daadl^c\\i]Z&.,+Waddbd[i]ZY^cd[aV\\ZaaViZ8ZgVi^jbig^edh^c

CZl?ZghZnXdVhiValViZgh8dheZgVcY8ZgVb^&..+#

dgBdgZ>c[dgbVi^dcABOUT(ARMFUL!LGAL"LOOMS

WWWWHOIEDUREDTIDE

WWWNWFSCNOAAGOVHABBLOOMSHTM WWWBIGELOWORGHAB

9EAR

n

$ISCOLORSWATER ANDREDUCES CLARITY

AUSES HYPOXIA (ARMFULTO SHELLFISHFISH

)TCHING

RESPIRATORYILLS INHUMANS

&OODPOISONING INHUMANS "LOOM3EVERITY

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

4AKENASAWHOLEWHATDOTHETRENDSINTHEINDICATORSDISCUSSEDINTHISREPORTMEAN)STHEESTUARYGETTINGCLEANER(EALTHIER-OREPRODUCTIVE"ETTER(AVEMANAGEMENTPROGRAMSBEENSUCCESSFULINPRO

TECTINGANDRESTORINGTHEESTUARY7HATCHALLENGESREMAIN

4HESE QUESTIONS ARE OF COURSE VERY DIFFICULT TO ANSWER THE REASONS FOROBSERVEDTRENDSAREOFTENUNCLEAR(OWEVERSOMEGENERALOBSERVATIONSCANBE MADE ABOUT THE DATA PRESENTED 4ABLE SUMMARIZES THE TRENDS IN THEINDICATORSPRESENTEDINTHISREPORTCHARACTERIZINGTHETRENDSAShIMPROVINGvhDETERIORATINGvMIXEDTRENDvANDhNOTRENDv4HEREISAFAIRLYEVENDISTRIBU

TIONOFTRENDSAMONGTHESECATEGORIESWITHSLIGHTLYMOREINDICATORSSHOWINGIMPROVEMENTTHANSTAYINGTHESAMEORDETERIORATING7HILESOMEMEASURESOFESTUARINEHEALTHHAVEEXHIBITEDIMPROVEMENTOVERTHETIMESCALESDISPLAYEDHERESUCHASDISSOLVEDOXYGENCONCENTRATIONSANDLOADINGSOFCONTAMINANTSOTHERTRENDSARENOTASPOSITIVE&OREXAMPLEPOPULATIONSIZESOFSOMESPECIESOFFISHAREDECLINING)TAPPEARSTHATTHESTORYOFTHEHEALTHOFTHEESTUARYISASCOMPLICATEDASTHEECOSYSTEM!LTHOUGHMAJORIMPROVEMENTSHAVEBEENMADEONTHETIMESCALEOFACENTURYIMPROVEMENTSHAVENOTCONTINUEDATTHESAMERATEONMORERECENTANDSMALLERTIMESCALES4HE#LEAN7ATER!CTANDOTHERLEGISLATIONHAVEHADATREMENDOUSPOSITIVEIMPACTONCLEANINGUPOURWATERWAYSANDPROTECTINGHABITATANIMPACTREFLECTEDINTHEIMPROVEMENTSINDISSOLVEDOXYGENLARGETIME SCALECONTAMINANTLOADINGANDTHEDECREASEINLOSSOFWETLANDSCOM

PAREDTOEARLIERDECADES"UTPOTENTIALONGOINGSOURCESOFCHEMICALCONTAMI

NANTSANDTHELEGACYOFPOLLUTIONINTHEESTUARYHAVEMEANTTHATSEDIMENTTOXICITYISSTILLACONCERNWITHIMPLICATIONSFORBIOACCUMULATIONOFCONTAMI

NANTSASWELL4HEDECLINEININDICESOFPOPULATIONSIZEOFSOMEFISHSPECIESISALSOWORRISOMEANDCOULDREFLECTCHANGESINHABITATQUALITYINTHEESTUARY$IVERSITY OF THE FISH COMMUNITY IN (AVERSTRAW "AY HAS ALSO BEEN DECLININGOVERTHEPASTYEARSPERHAPSANOTHERTROUBLINGREMINDERTHATWEHAVEMUCHWORKLEFTTODOINTHISREGION

&INALLY INADEQUATE AVAILABILITY OF DATA IS A SIGNIFICANT BARRIER TO PROPERLYINTERPRETINGTHEESTUARYSHEALTH-ANYOFTHEINDICATORSORIGINALLYSELECTEDFORMONITORINGCHANGESINTHE(ARBOR%STUARYSEE)NTRODUCTIONPAGE ARENOTCURRENTLYMONITOREDANDADDITIONALDATAGAPSAREDUETOGEOGRAPHICORSPATIALINCONSISTENCIES OF SOME EXISTING MONITORING PROGRAMS 4ABLE SUMMARIZESTHE DATA AVAILABILITY GRAPHS PRESENTED IN EACH CHAPTER )T IS CLEAR FROM THIS

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

ONCLUSIONS

TABLETHATALTHOUGHMANYINDICATORSAREBEINGMEASUREDEXISTINGMONITORINGPROGRAMSAREINADEQUATETOFULLYDESCRIBETEMPORALANDSPATIALTRENDSFORMANY(%0INDICATORS)NSOMECASESDATAAVAILABILITY MIGHT BE INCONSISTENT BETWEEN.EW 9ORK AND.EW*ERSEYFOREXAMPLE.EW*ERSEYSBEACHMONITORINGPROGRAMISCOORDINATEDATTHESTATELEVELWHILE.EW9ORKSISNOTANDWHILE.9#$%0S(ARBOR3URVEYHASMONITOREDTHEWATERSOF.EW9ORK(ARBORONTHE.EW9ORKSIDEFORALMOSTYEARSTHEREISNOSUCHCOMPREHENSIVEPROGRAMIN.EW*ERSEYSWATERS)NADDITIONTHEDATATHATAREBEINGCOLLECTEDCANBEDIFFICULTTOFINDORUSE)NORDERFORAGREATERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEESTUARYSHEALTHTOBEDEVELOPEDNEWORBETTERMONITORINGPROGRAMSFORTHEFOLLOWINGINDICATORSNEEDTOBEIMPLEMENTED

s )NCIDENCEOFHARMFULALGALBLOOMS s 3EDIMENTTOXICITY s $ISEASECAUSEDBYCONSUMINGCONTAMINATEDSHELLFISH s,EVELSOFCONTAMINANTSINFISHANDSHELLFISHTISSUEOTHER THAN0#"SINSTRIPEDBASS s #OLIFORMBACTERIAOUTSIDEOF.EW9ORK#ITYWATERS s "EACHCLOSURESIN.EW9ORK s (ABITATACREAGESSOMEISDONEFORWETLANDSBUTAMORE COMPLETEREGULARINVENTORYOFTHEESTUARYSHABITATSNEEDS TOBEIMPLEMENTEDINCLUDINGSHALLOWHABITATSSUCHASMUD FLATS DEEP HABITATS AND ACREAGES OF SUBMERGED AQUATIC VEGETATION

s (ABITATFUNCTION s &ISHPOPULATIONINDICESFOCUSINGONTHELOWERESTUARYIN BOTHSTATES s "IRDREPRODUCTIVESUCCESS s 3USPENDED SEDIMENT LOADINGS AND AN OVERALL SEDIMENT BUDGETFORTHEHARBORBYREPEATINGAVERSIONOFTHE#!20 PROGRAMPERIODICALLY

s #ONTAMINANTLOADINGSANDLEVELSBYREPEATINGAVERSIONOF

THE#!20PROGRAMPERIODICALLY

s &ISHTISSUECONTAMINATIONFOCUSEDONTHELOWERESTUARYIN BOTHSTATES s 3EDIMENTFLUXESOFNUTRIENTS s,EVELSOFCOLIPHAGES s )NCIDENCEOFILLNESSRELATEDTOBATHINGATLOCALBEACHES

%NVIRONMENTAL MONITORING OF A SHARED RESOURCE SUCH AS THE.9.*(ARBOR%STUARYSHOULDALSOBECOORDINATEDMORECLOSELYBETWEENTHESTATESOF.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEY,ESSONSLEARNEDABOUTBI STATECOOPERATIVEMONITORINGBYTHE(%0S#ONTAMINANT!SSESSMENT AND 2EDUCTION 0ROJECT #!20 SHOULD BE APPLIEDTO OTHER TYPES OF MONITORING SO THAT BETTER SPATIAL COVERAGE ISACHIEVED &OR SOME MONITORING PROGRAMS RESOURCES COULD BESHARED BETWEEN THE TWO STATES TO REDUCE THE BURDEN ON THEINDIVIDUAL STATES &OR OTHER INDICATORS PERHAPS GREATER FEDERAL

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR 4REND IMPROVINGTREND DETERIORATINGTREND MIXEDTREND NOTREND (ABITATAND+EY3PECIES

HANGESIN(ABITAT!CREAGEOVERALL

7ETLAND!CREAGE

HANGESIN.EWARK"AY 7ETLANDSIN*AMAICA"AY (ABITATINTHE(ACKESACK-EADOWLANDS

!BUNDANCEOF7ADING"IRDS

!BUNDANCEOF&ISHAND#RUSTACEANSOVERALL

3TRIPEDBASS

!MERICANSHAD 7INTERFLOUNDER 3UMMERFLOUNDER 7HITEPERCH

!MERICANEEL

&ORAGEFISH "LUECRAB "ENTHIC#OMMUNITY(EALTH 3EDIMENTLOADING 4OXIC#ONTAMINATION

ONTAMINANT,EVELS

ONTAMINANT,OADINGS 3EDIMENT4OXICITY

ONTAMINANTSIN&ISH4ISSUE 0ATHOGENS

!CRESOF3HELLFISH"EDS/PEN

$ISEASE,INKEDTO#ONTAMINATED3HELLFISH

,EVELSOF#OLIFORM"ACTERIA "EACH#LOSURES

&LOATABLE$EBRIS

.UTRIENTSAND/RGANIC%NRICHMENT

.UTRIENT,EVELSAND,OADINGS

$ISSOLVED/XYGEN

HLOROPHYLLA 4RANSPARENCY (ARMFUL!LGAL"LOOMS 4!",%HjbbVgnd[igZcYY^gZXi^dc[dgZVX]^cY^XVidg^cXajYZY^c

i]^hgZedgi#6ggdlh^cY^XViZ^begdkZbZci!YZiZg^dgVi^dc!cd

igZcY!dgb^mZYigZcY#

PARTICIPATIONINMONITORINGWOULDBEHELPFUL!FOLLOW UPTOTHEWORK

SHOPSHOULDBEHELDTOREVIEWTHEMONITORINGPLANUPDATEITIFNECESSARYANDFURTHERDISCUSSHOWTOIMPROVEEXISTINGMONITORINGANDIMPLEMENTNEWMONI

TORINGPROGRAMSASNECESSARY

&UTURE(%0)NDICATOR7ORK)TWILLBEIMPORTANTFORTHE(%0TOCONTINUETOEXAMINETRENDSINENVIRONMENTALINDICATORSONAREGULARBASISINORDERTOEVALUATETHE HEALTH OF THE ESTUARY AND THE EFFECTIVENESS OF MANAGEMENTACTIONS 4HIS PROCESS WILL SOON BECOME MORE IMPORTANT THANEVERBECAUSETHE(%0ISNOWESTABLISHINGSOMEFIRMTARGETSANDGOALS STATEMENTS OF HOW MUCH IMPROVEMENT THE PROGRAM WILLSEEK TO ACHIEVE BY SPECIFIC DATES )T WILL BE CRITICAL TO MONITORTHEPROGRAMSPROGRESS ASWELLASTHEESTUARYS BYEVALUAT

ING TRENDS ANNUALLY IN A SUITE OF INDICATORS SIMILAR TO THE ONESASSESSEDINTHISREPORT

(EALTHOFTHE(ARBOR

)NDICATOR

$ATAAVAILABILITY 4EMPORAL 3PATIAL (ABITATAREA "IRDABUNDANCE

&ISHCRUSTACEANABUNDANCE "ENTHICCOMMUNITYHEALTH 3EDIMENTLOADING

ONTAMINANTLEVELSLOADINGS 3EDIMENTTOXICITY 0#"SINSTRIPEDBASS

ONTAMINANTSINFISHTISSUE

!CRESOFOPENSHELLFISHBEDS

$ISEASECONTAMINATEDSHELLFISH

OLIFORMCONCENTRATIONS "EACHCLOSURES

&LOATABLEDEBRIS

.UTRIENTSLEVELS

.UTRIENTLOADINGS

$ISSOLVEDOXYGENCONCENTRATIONS

HLOROPHYLLACONCENTRATIONS 4RANSPARENCY (ARMFULALGALBLOOMS POOR FAIR GOOD 4!",%HjbbVgnd[YViVVkV^aVW^a^in

[dgZVX]^cY^XVidg^cXajYZY^c

i]^hgZedgi#

2EFERENCES

!BLE+7AND-0&AHAY4HE&IRST9EARINTHE,IFEOF%STUARINE&ISHESINTHE-IDDLE!TLANTIC"IGHT.EW"RUNSWICK.*2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS!BLE+72%-ATHESON77-ORSE-0&AHAYAND'3HEPHERD0ATTERNSOFSUMMERFLOUNDER0ARALICHTHYSDENTATUSEARLYLIFEHISTORYINTHE-ID !TLANTIC"IGHTAND.EW*ERSEYESTUARIES&ISH"ULL

!BOOD+ARIM,-3%NGINEERS0ERSONALCOMMUNICATION

!DAMS$ARVENE53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

!DAMS$!*3/#ONNORAND3"7EISBERG53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY3EDIMENT1UALITYOFTHE.9.*(ARBOR3YSTEM!N)NVESTIGATION5NDERTHE2EGIONAL%NVIRONMENTAL-ONITORINGAND!SSESSMENT0ROGRAM2 %-!0 .EW9ORK.953%0!

!MERICAN,ITTORAL3OCIETY.EW9ORK3TATE"EACH#LEANUP!NNUAL2EPORT

!UERMULLER2OBERT$IVISIONOF7ATERSHED-ANAGEMENT.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

!YRES2AND322OD0ATTERNSOF0OLLUTIONINTHE(UDSON 2ARITAN"ASIN%NVIRONMENT n"ARNES$EBORAH.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION$IVISIONOF&ISH7ILDLIFEAND.ATURAL2ESOURCES0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

"OPP2ICHARD2ENSSELAER0OLYTECHNIC)NSTITUTE0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION"OYLE2(4HE(UDSON2IVER!.ATURALAND5NNATURAL(ISTORY.EW9ORK.977.ORTON#OMPANY"ROSNAN4-AND-/3HEA,ONG TERMIMPROVEMENTSINWATERQUALITYDUETOSEWAGEABATEMENTINTHELOWER(UDSON2IVER%STUARIES n

"UCKEL*!$/#ONOVER.$3TEINBERGAND+!-C+OWN)MPACTOFAGE BLUEFISH0OMATOMUSSALTA

TRIX PREDATIONONAGE FISHESINTHE(UDSON2IVERESTUARYEVIDENCEFORDENSITY DEPENDENTLOSSOFJUVENILESTRIPEDBASS-ORONESAXATILIS #AN*&ISH!QUAT3CIn"URGER*OANNAED"EFORE!FTERAN/IL3PILL4HE!RTHUR+ILL.EW"RUNSWICK.*2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS

"URGER*+6ISCIDOAND-'OCHFELD%GGSHELLTHICK

NESSINMARINEBIRDSINTHE.EW9ORK"IGHTnSTOS!RCH%NVIRON#ONTAM4OXICOLn

"URGER*-(OROSZEWSKI,AVERYAND-'OCHFELD4EMPORALCHANGESINLEADLEVELSINCOMMONTERNFEATHERSIN.EW9ORKANDRELATIONSHIPOFFIELDLEVELSTOADVERSEEFFECTSINTHELABORATORY%NVIRON4OXICOL#HEM n

HAMBERS*2#OASTALDEGRADATIONANDFISHPOPULATIONLOSSES0Pn)N2(3TROUDED3TEMMINGTHE4IDEOF#OASTAL&ISH(ABITAT,OSS0ROCEEDINGSOFASYMPOSIUMONCONSERVATIONOFCOASTALFISHHABITAT"ALTIMORE-$-ARCHn.ATIONAL#OALITIONFOR-ARINE#ONSERVATION3AVANNAH'!#HYTALO+AREN.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

OSPER%-AND*##ERAMI!SSESSMENTOFHISTORICALPHYTOPLANKTONCHARACTERISTICSANDBLOOMPHENOMENAINTHE.EW9ORK(ARBORESTUARINEAND.EW9ORK"IGHTECOSYSTEMS&INAL2EPORTTOTHE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION

DE#ERRExO!,#-0ANEROAND3"OEHME0OLLUTION0REVENTIONAND-ANAGEMENT3TRATEGIESFOR-ERCURYINTHE.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR.EW9ORK!CADEMYOF3CIENCES.EW9ORK.EW9ORK

%ISELE"ILL.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION"UREAUOF-ARINE7ATER-ONITORING.EW*ERSEY3TATE3HELLFISH#LASSIFICATIONS0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATIONn

'REBE(ELEN53%0!0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

(ARTMAN*EAN-ARIE2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

(ASSE*AND2,ATHROP-EASURING5RBAN'ROWTHIN.EW*ERSEY!2EPORTON2ECENT,AND$EVELOPMENT0ATTERNS5TILIZINGTHEn.*$%0,AND5SE,AND#OVER$ATA3ET#ENTERFOR2EMOTE3ENSINGAND3PATIAL!NALYSIS2UTGERS5NIVERSITYHTTPCRSSARUTGERSEDUPROJECTSLCURBANGROWTH

INDEXHTML

(OLCOMB-ARA.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTH"UREAUOF#OMMUNITY3ANITATIONAND&OOD0ROTECTION0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

(ORN%'3EAFOOD3AFETY!2EGULATORY0ERSPECTIVE)N.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAM#LEANING5P/UR#OASTAL7ATERS!N5NFINISHED!GENDA0ROCEEDINGSOFA2EGIONAL#ONFERENCE-ARCHn.EW9ORK.953%0!

(OWARTH272-ARINO$03WANEYAND%7"OYER)NPRESS7ASTEWATERAND7ATERSHED)NFLUENCESON0RIMARY0RODUCTIVITYAND/XYGEN$YNAMICSINTHE,OWER(UDSON2IVER%STUARY)N*,EVINTONED BOOKONTHE(UDSON2IVER

(OWARTH27$3WANEY4*"UTLERAND2-ARINO#LIMATICCONTROLONEUTROPHICATIONOFTHE(UDSON2IVERESTUARY%COSYSTEMSn

(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION3UMMARY2EPORT.EW9ORK(ARBOR%STUARY3EDIMENT"UDGET7ORKSHOPPROCEEDINGSOFAWORKSHOPHELDATTHE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATIONON$ECEMBER

(URST4HOMAS0.ATIONAL-ARINE&ISHERIES3ERVICE0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

(URST40AND$/#ONOVER.EARSHORE&ISH#OMMUNITIESOFTHEMID (UDSON2IVER%STUARYn3TONY"ROOK.9-ARINE3CIENCES2ESEARCH#ENTER35.93TONY"ROOK

(URST40AND$/#ONOVER7INTERMORTALITYOFYOUNG

OF THE YEAR(UDSON2IVERSTRIPEDBASS-ORONESAXATILIS SIZE

DEPENDENTPATTERNSANDEFFECTSONRECRUITMENT#AN*&ISH!QUAT3CIn

(URST40+-C+OWNAND$/#ONOVER)NREVIEW)NTERANNUALAND,ONG TERM6ARIATIONINTHE.EARSHORE&ISH#OMMUNITYOFTHE-ESOHALINE(UDSON2IVER%STUARY

AMAICA"AY"LUE2IBBON0ANELON-ARSH,OSSAND#OASTAL3EA,EVEL2ISE!&UTURE!GENDAFOR-ITIGATIONAND0ILOT)NVESTIGATIONS&INAL2EPORT"ROOKLYN.953$EPARTMENTOFTHE)NTERIOR.ATIONAL0ARK3ERVICE+ANE2AND0+ERLINGER2ARITAN"AY(ABITATAND7ILDLIFE)NVENTORYn&RANKLIN,AKES.*.EW*ERSEY!UDUBON3OCIETY

+ERLINGER0.EW9ORK#ITY!UDUBON3OCIETYS(ARBOR(ERONS0ROJECT.ESTING3URVEYn.EW9ORK.9.EW9ORK#ITY!UDUBON3OCIETY+LAUDA2**"-C,AREN2%3CHMIDTAND70$EY,IFEHISTORYOFWHITEPERCHINTHE(UDSON2IVERESTUARY!MERICAN&ISHERIES3OCIETY-ONOGRAPH3CIENCE,AWAND(UDSON2IVER0OWER0LANTS!#ASE3TUDYIN%NVIRONMENTAL)MPACT!SSESSMENT PPn

,EWIS$ANIEL.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION$IVISIONOF&ISH7ILDLIFEAND.ATURAL2ESOURCES"UREAUOF-ARINE2ESOURCES3HELLFISHERIES0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

,O"UE#ARL.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION,OFTIN6IRGINIA$IVISIONOF7ATERSHED-ANAGEMENT.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

,ONG)SLAND3OUND3TUDY#OMPREHENSIVE#ONSERVATIONAND-ANAGEMENT0LAN

-ACCARONE!$AND*."RZORAD7ADINGBIRDFORAG

ING2ESPONSEANDRECOVERYFROMANOILSPILL7ATERBIRDS

-ACCARONE!$AND*."RZORAD4HEUSEOFFORAGINGHABITATSBYWADINGBIRDSSEVENYEARSAFTERTHEOCCURRENCEOFMAJOROILSPILLS#OLONIAL7ATERBIRDS

-AC+ENZIE#,*R4HE&ISHERIESOF2ARITAN"AY.EW"RUNSWICK.*2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS-ATTES+#4HE%COLOGYOFTHE!MERICAN%EL!NGUILLAROSTRATAINTHE(UDSON2IVER&INAL2EPORTTOTHE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION-C(UGH*,,IMITING&ACTORS!FFECTING#OMMERCIAL&ISHERIESINTHE-IDDLE!TLANTIC%STUARINE!REA)N%STUARINE0OLLUTIONAND#ONTROL!SSESSMENT0ROCEEDINGSOFA#ONFERENCEn7ASHINGTON$#53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY

-C(UGH*,AND*AY*#'INTER&ISHERIES-%3!.EW9ORK"IGHT!TLAS-ONOGRAPH!LBANY.9.EW9ORK3EA'RANT)NSTITUTE-C+OWN+IM.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION0ERSONALCOMMUNICATION

.ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION.ATIONAL/CEAN3ERVICE.ATIONAL3TATUSAND4RENDS0ROGRAMFOR-ARINE%NVIRONMENTAL1UALITY-AGNITUDEAND%XTENTOF3EDIMENT4OXICITYINTHE(UDSON 2ARITAN%STUARY./!!4ECHNICAL-EMORANDUM./3/2#!

.ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION.AVIGATIONAL#HARTOF.EWARK"AY

.ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION.ATIONAL#LIMATIC$ATA#ENTERWWWNCDCNOAAGOV

.ATURAL2ESOURCES$EFENSE#OUNCIL4ESTINGTHE7ATERS

.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTIONWWWSTATENJUSDEPDSRNJMAINFISHHTM

.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTIONWWWNJSTATEUSDEP

2EFERENCES

.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION$IVISIONOF7ATERSHED-ANAGEMENT.EW*ERSEY#LEAN3HORES0ROGRAM2EPORTWWWSTATENJUSDEPDSRWATERSHED

AREA APPENDIX CHTM

.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION.EW9ORK#ITY2EGIONAL(ARBOR3URVEY

.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION.EW9ORK(ARBOR7ATER1UALITY3URVEY.EW9ORK.EW9ORK.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION4HE3TATEOFTHE#ITYS7ATERS)THACA.9#ORNELL5NIVERSITY.EW9ORK3TATE7ATER2ESOURCES)NSTITUTE.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAMA(ARBOR(EALTH(UMAN(EALTH!N!NALYSISOF%NVIRONMENTAL)NDICATORSFORTHE.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION53%0!.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAMB4HE3TATUSOF3HELLFISH"EDSINTHE.9 .*(ARBOR%STUARY53%0!

.9.*(%0

.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAMC.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY"EACH#LOSURESAND-ONITORING)NFORMATION53%0!.9.*(%0

.EW9ORK .EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAMA!NALYSISOF0ATHOGEN3OURCES0REPAREDBY(YDRO1UAL)NC

.EW9ORK .EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAMB#OMPREHENSIVE#ONSERVATIONAND-ANAGEMENT0LAN53%0!.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATIONWWWDECSTATENYUSWEBSITEDFWMRMARINETWLOSSHTML

.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTHWWWHEALTHSTATENYUSNYSDOHENVIRONFISHHTM

2IPPEY323HELLFISH BORNE$ISEASE/UTBREAKS3HELLFISH3ANITATION0ROGRAM4ECHNICAL2EPORT&OODAND$RUG!DMINISTRATION.ORTHEAST4ECHNICAL3ERVICES,ABORATORY$AVISVILLE2))N.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTIONAND.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAM0ATHOGENS7ORK'ROUPREPORT#HARACTERIZATIONOF0ATHOGEN#ONTAMINATIONINTHE.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY

3AxUDO 7ILHELMY3!AND'!'ILL)MPACTOFTHE#LEAN7ATER!CTONTHELEVELSOFTOXICMETALSINURBANESTU

ARIES4HE(UDSON2IVER%STUARYREVISITED%NVIRON3CI4ECHNOL n3ECOR$(AND7%-ORRISON0ROGRESS2EPORT9EAR%COLOGYAND#ONTAMINATIONOFTHE(UDSON2IVER!MERICAN%EL2EPORTTOTHE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION

3INDERMANN#*1UANTITATIVE%FFECTSOF0OLLUTIONON-ARINEAND!NADROMOUS&ISH0OPULATIONS./!!4ECHNICAL-EMORANDUM.-&3 &.%# .ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION.ORTHEAST&ISHERIES3CIENCE#ENTER7OODS(OLE-!

3KINNER,#.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION/RGANIC#HEMICALSAND-ERCURYIN3ELECTED&ISH3PECIES4AKENFROM.EW9ORK(ARBOR

3KINNER,#!*.EWELL*7ALDMANAND*3HASTAY*RA.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION#HEMICAL2ESIDUESIN&ISH3HELLFISHAND#RUSTACEANSFROMTHE.EW9ORK .EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0!(SIN7INTER&LOUNDERAND3OFTSHELL#LAM

3KINNER,#20RINCE*7ALDMAN!*.EWELLAND*3HASTAY*RB.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION#HEMICAL2ESIDUESIN&ISH"IVALVES#RUSTACEANSANDA#EPHALOPODFROMTHE.EW9ORK .EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY$IOXINSAND&URANS

3KINNER,#3**ACKLING'+IMBER*7ALDMAN*3HASTAY*RAND!*.EWELL.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION#HEMICAL2ESIDUESIN&ISH3HELLFISHAND#RUSTACEANSFROMTHE.EW9ORK .EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0#"/RGANOCHLORINE0ESTICIDESAND-ERCURY

3LOAN2"RIEFINGON3TRIPED"ASS0#"2ESULTS&EBRUARY"RIEFINGMEMOTO*AMES#OLQUHOUN.93$%#

3LOAN2"9OUNGAND+(ATTALA.93$%#4ECHNICAL2EPORT 0#"0ARADIGMSFOR3TRIPED"ASSIN.EW9ORK3TATE

3LOAN2AND+!(ATTALA.93$%#4ECHNICAL2EPORT 4EMPORALAND3PATIAL!SPECTSOF0#"#ONTAMINATIONIN(UDSON2IVER3TRIPED"ASS

3OBSEY-$%VALUATIONAND6ERIFICATIONOF0ATHOGENIC)NDICATOR0OPULATIONSINTHE.9.*(ARBOR3YSTEM&INAL2EPORTTOTHE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION'RANT.UMBER

2

3QUIRES$&1UANTIFYINGANTHROPOGENICSHORELINEMODIFI

CATIONOFTHE(UDSON2IVERAND%STUARYFROM%UROPEANCONTACTTOMODERNTIME#OASTAL-ANAGEMENTn3QUIRES$&!(ISTORICAL2EVIEWOF#HANGESIN.EAR

3HORE(ABITATSINTHE3OUND (ARBOR "IGHT3YSTEM)N#LEANING5P/UR#OASTAL7ATERS!N5NFINISHED!GENDA 0ROCEEDINGSOFAREGIONALCONFERENCE-ARCHn.EW9ORK.953%0!

3TANNE302'0ANETTAAND"%&ORIST4HE(UDSON!N)LLUSTRATED'UIDETOTHE,IVING2IVER.EW"RUNSWICK.*2UTGERS5NIVERSITY0RESS3T*OHN*OHN(YDRO1UAL)NC0ERSONALCOMMUNICATION

3ULLIVAN24HE-EADOWLANDS7ILDERNESS!DVENTURESATTHE%DGEOFA#ITY.EW9ORK.93CRIBNER

2EFERENCES

3USZKOWSKI$*3EDIMENTOLOGYOF.EWARK"AY.EW*ERSEY!N5RBAN%STUARINE"AY0H$$ISSERTATION5NIVERSITYOF$ELAWARE.EWARK$ELAWARE

3USZKOWSKI$*#ONDITIONSINTHE.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY)N#LEANING5P/UR#OASTAL7ATERS!N5NFINISHED!GENDA #ONFERENCE0ROCEEDINGSOFREGIONALCONFERENCE-ARCHn.EW9ORK.953%0!

3WANEY$0$3HERMANAND27(OWARTH-ODELINGWATERSEDIMENTANDORGANICCARBONDISCHARGESINTHE(UDSON

-OHAWKBASIN#OUPLINGTOTERRESTRIALSOURCES%STUARIES n

3WANSON2,AND2,:IMMER-ETEOROLOGICALCON

DITIONSLEADINGTOTHEANDWASHUPSOFFLOATABLEWASTESON.EW9ORKAND.EW*ERSEYBEACHESANDCOMPARI

SONSOFTHESECONDITIONSWITHTHEHISTORICALRECORD%STUARINE#OASTALAND3HELF3CIENCEn

4HATCHER-,AND#-ENDOZA&INAL2EPORT.EW9ORK

.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAM-ODULE(YDROLOGIC-ODIFICATIONS.EW9ORK.9.9.*(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAM

53#ONGRESS0UBLIC,AWnTH#ONGRESS"EACHES%NVIRONMENTAL!SSESSMENTAND#OASTAL(EALTH!CTOF

53%0!!MBIENT!QUATIC,IFE7ATER1UALITY#RITERIAFOR$ISSOLVED/XYGEN3ALTWATER #APE#ODTO#APE(ATTERAS

53%0!'UIDANCEFOR!SSESSING#HEMICAL#ONTAMINANT$ATAFOR5SEIN&ISH!DVISORIES6OLUME&ISH3AMPLINGAND!NALYSIS4HIRD%DITION

53%0!(ELICOPTER-ONITORING2EPORT!2EPORTOFTHE.EW9ORK"IGHT7ATER1UALITY3UMMERSOFAND

53%0!2EGION&LOATABLES!CTION0LAN!SSESSMENT2EPORT

53&ISHAND7ILDLIFE3ERVICE3IGNIFICANT(ABITATSAND(ABITAT#OMPLEXESOFTHE.EW9ORK"IGHT6AUGHN$33ECTION%NTRAINMENTAND)MPINGEMENT)MPACTS)NTRODUCTION!&3-ONOGRAPH3CIENCE,AWAND(UDSON2IVER0OWER0LANTSn

7ALDMAN*(EARTBEATSINTHE-UCK4HE(ISTORY3EA,IFEAND%NVIRONMENTOF.EW9ORK(ARBOR.EW9ORK.9,YONS0RESS

7ELLS!7*!-ATOUSEKAND*"(UTCHISON!BUNDANCE4RENDSIN(UDSON2IVER7HITE0ERCH)N3MITH#,AVETTED%STUARINE2ESEARCHINTHES!LBANY.93TATE5NIVERSITYOF.EW9ORK0RESS

7OLF'ARY.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF(EALTHAND3ENIOR3ERVICES#ONSUMERAND%NVIRONMENTAL(EALTH3ERVICES&OOD$RUGAND-ILK0ROGRAM3HELLFISH#ONTROL0ERSONAL#OMMUNICATION

7OLFE$!%2,ONGAND'"4HURSBY3EDIMENTTOXICITYINTHE(UDSON 2ARITAN%STUARYDISTRIBUTIONANDCORRELA

TIONSWITHCHEMICALCONTAMINATION%STUARIES n

7OODS(OLE/CEANOGRAPHIC)NSTITUTEWWWREDTIDEWHOIEDUHAB 9AN%h-ARSHLAND-YSTERYv.EW9ORK.EWSDAY3UNDAY!PRILPP!

9UHAS#.*#LAMS-EET(IGHEST3TANDARDSFROM(ARVESTTO-ARKET4HE*ERSEY3HORELINE n

ISKOWSKI**,$ESPRES 0ATANJO2!-URCHELANO!"(OWE$2ALPHAND3!TRAN$ISEASEINCOMMERCIALLYVALUABLEFISHSTOCKSINTHE.ORTHWEST!TLANTIC-ARINE0OLLUTION"ULLETIN n

2EFERENCES

!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS 4HEAUTHORSWOULDLIKETOTHANKTHEFOLLOWINGINDIVIDU

ALSWHOPROVIDEDUSWITHDATAANDIMPORTANTINSIGHTSANDADVICE4HISREPORTWOULDNOTHAVEBEENPOSSIBLEWITHOUTTHEIRASSISTANCE

+ARIM!BOOD,-3%NGINEERS

$ARVENE!DAMS53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY 4OM!THERHOLT.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

-ICHAEL!UCOTT.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION 2OBERT!UERMULLER.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

$EBORAH"ARNES.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION 2ICHARD"OPP2ENSSELAER0OLYTECHNIC)NSTITUTE

OHN"OREMAN.ATIONAL-ARINE&ISHERIES3ERVICE

ULIA"RISCHLER.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

'ARY"UCHANAN.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

+AREN#HYTALO.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL #ONSERVATION "ARBARA#OHEN!MERICAN,ITTORAL3OCIETY

%LIZABETH#OSPER#OSPER%NVIRONMENTAL3ERVICES

ENNIFER#OX2EGIONAL0LAN!SSOCIATION

ENNIFER$I,ORENZO.EW*ERSEY-ARITIME2ESOURCES

-ARY$OWNES 'ASTRICH.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

+IM$URHAM2IVERHEAD&OUNDATIONFOR-ARINE2ESEARCH 7ILLIAM%ISELE.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

$AVID&ALLON.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION (ELEN'REBE53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY 4OM'ULBRANSEN"ATTELLE

EAN-ARIE(ARTMAN2UTGERS5NIVERSITY 7ILLIAM(ASTBACK.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

+ATHY(ATTALA.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION-ARA(OLCOMB.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTH

%DWARD(ORN.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTH 2OBERT(OWARTH#ORNELL5NIVERSITY 4OM(URST.ATIONAL-ARINE&ISHERIES3ERVICE 4HERESA+ENNEDY.9 .*#/!34

'REG+ENNEY.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

,INDA,ANGSCHIED2UTGERS#ENTERFOR%NVIRONMENTAL)NDICATORS 2ICHARD,ATHROP2UTGERS5NIVERSITY

$ANIEL,EWIS.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

ARL,O"UE4HE.ATURE#ONSERVANCY

AMES,ODGE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION 6IRGINIA,OFTIN.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

+IM-C+OWN.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION 2OBIN,ANDECK-ILLER(YDRO1UAL)NC

,ARRY-IGLIOZZI.EW9ORK3TATE/FFICEOF0ARKS2ECREATIONAND(ISTORIC0RESERVATION

&RED-USHACKE.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION 2OBERT0IKANOWSKI.ATIONAL-ARINE&ISHERIES3ERVICE

.ICK0ROTOPSALTIS)NTERSTATE%NVIRONMENTAL#OMMISSION "EAU2ANHEIM.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION 2OBERT2EID.ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION

$AVID2OSENBLATT.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

,ISA2OSMAN.ATIONAL/CEANICAND!TMOSPHERIC!DMINISTRATION

,ARRY3KINNER.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION 2ON3LOAN.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

OHN3T*OHN(YDRO1UAL)NC

!LAN3TUBIN.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

$ENNIS3WANEY#ORNELL5NIVERSITY

+ATHY5RFFER(ACKENSACK2IVER+EEPER

'ARY7OLF.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF(EALTHAND3ENIOR3ERVICES

RAIG7OOLCOTT-EADOWLANDS%NVIRONMENTAL2ESEARCH)NSTITUTE

.AJI9AO.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

ATHY9UHAS.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAM

4HEAUTHORSWOULDALSOLIKETOTHANKTHETECHNICALPEERREVIEWERSFORTHISREPORTANDTHEPREVIOUSREPORTONINDICATORSINTHE(ARBOR(ARBOR(EALTH(UMAN(EALTH 7EAREVERYGRATEFULFORTHEIRPARTICIPATION

+EN!BLE2UTGERS5NIVERSITY

+ARIM!BOOD,-3%NGINEERS

$ARVENE!DAMS53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY

OEL"AKER5NIVERSITYOF-ARYLAND 3USAN"OEHME.EW9ORK!CADEMYOF3CIENCES 2ICHARD"OPP2ENSSELAER0OLYTECHNIC)NSTITUTE 2ANDY"RAUN53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY "RUCE"ROWNAWELL3TONY"ROOK5NIVERSITY 2OBERT#ERRATO3TONY"ROOK5NIVERSITY

%LIZABETH#OSPER#OSPER%NVIRONMENTAL3ERVICES

-ARK$ORFMAN.ATURAL2ESOURCES$EFENSE#OUNCIL 3COTT$OUGLAS.EW*ERSEY-ARITIME2ESOURCES 7ILLIAM%ISELE.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

+EVIN&ARLEY-ANHATTAN#OLLEGE

%RIC&EERST.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION 3TUART&INDLAY)NSTITUTEOF%COSYSTEM3TUDIES

$AVID&RANZ"ROOKLYN#OLLEGE

,ARRY'AUGLER53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY 7ILLIAM(ASTBACK.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

-ARA(OLCOMB.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTH

%DWARD(ORN.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF(EALTH 2OBERT(OWARTH#ORNELL5NIVERSITY 4OM(URST.ATIONAL-ARINE&ISHERIES3ERVICE 0AUL+ERLINGER.9#!UDUBON3OCIETY

OHN+RAEUTER2UTGERS5NIVERSITY

AMES,ODGE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION 6IRGINIA,OFTIN.EW*ERSEY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION

-IKE,UDWIG.ATIONAL-ARINE&ISHERIES3ERVICE

!LAN-ACCARONE&RIENDS5NIVERSITY

!NNE-C%LROY3TONY"ROOK5NIVERSITY

+IM-C+OWN.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

&RED-USHACKE.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

OEL/#ONNOR53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCYRET

-ARIE/3HEA53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY 0ATRICK0HILLIPS53'EOLOGICAL3URVEY "EAU2ANHEIM.EW9ORK#ITY$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION 9AIR2OSENTHAL2UTGERS5NIVERSITY 0ETER3ATTLER)NTERSTATE%NVIRONMENTAL#OMMISSION 2ON3LOAN.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAL#ONSERVATION

OHN3T*OHN(YDRO1UAL)NC

-ARK4EDESCO53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY,ONG)SLAND3OUND3TUDY

$ENNIS3WANEY#ORNELL5NIVERSITY

,ARRY3WANSON3TONY"ROOK5NIVERSITY

.ANCY7ELSH.EW9ORK3TATE$EPARTMENTOF3TATE 4HISREPORTHASBEENFUNDEDINPARTBYTHE53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCY%0! UNDERASSISTANCEAGREEMENTS#% AND#% WITHTHE(UDSON2IVER&OUNDATION4HEAGENCIESREPRESENTEDONTHE.EW9ORK.EW*ERSEY(ARBOR%STUARY0ROGRAMS-ANAGEMENT#OMMITTEEWOULDLIKETOACKNOWLEDGEANDEXPRESSTHEIRAPPRECIATIONFORTHEINPUTFROMANDPARTICIPATIONOFTHEPEOPLELISTEDABOVE

!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS 4HISREPORTISPRINTEDONRECYCLEDPOST CONSUMER PAPER

AVndjiVcYYZh^\\cWn<gZ\\<VbW^cd!'%+)YZh^\\c BVehVcYheZX^ZhYgVl^c\\hWn=ZaZcLdgi]Vb

ML083360721

Text

Navigation menu

Search