ML043100314

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
References from Nine Mile Point Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2 Site Audit - LRA Er Reference 4.3-31, Rg&E Population Estimates for Alewife and Rainbow Smelt in Lake Ontario (1982-2001)
ML043100314
Person / Time
Site: Nine Mile Point  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 01/01/2003
From: Sawyko P
Rochester Gas & Electric Corp
To: Leslie Fields
Division of Regulatory Improvement Programs
Fields LC, NRR/DRIP/RLEP, 415-1186
Shared Package
ML043130490 List:
References
Download: ML043100314 (37)
v • d • e


Text

Item 31 LRA ER Reference 4.3-31 Rochester Gas & Electric Corporation, Population Estimates for Alewife and Rainbow Smelt in Lake Ontario, 1982-2001, Unpublished Data, 2003

Always at Your Service

  • &orolaQAic) ICL_ J~

Ms. Carla Logan Constellation Nuclear Services, Inc.

2200 Defense Highway, Suite 400 Crofton, MD 21114 dr &3 criz--

Ms., 01'(r.

I enjoyed speaking with you at the recent Symposium. Who knows, with the amount of effort EPA apparently will require for 316(b), perhaps our careers will cross again!

Per your e-mail request of May 15, 2003, enclosed are the following materials for your documentation purposes.

1. ,A copy of the projected Lake Ontario lakewide populations for alewives and smelt

-with citations, as prepared by RG&E and previously transmitted to you on January 28,2003.

2. Copies of the pertinent pages from the citations identified in the table provided as Enclosure 1, above, which will document the origin of these numbers.
3. An excerpt from RG&E's 1987 through 1991 impingement report describing the process RG&E has used to extrapolate from the DEC / USFW trawl net catches to lake populations.

Should you require further information, please contact me at 585.771.2706 or, in my absence, Dave Dakin at 585.771.2707.

B~eegards, Paul M. Sawyko enc.

xc: D. Dakin An equal opportunity employer 89 East Avenue I Rochester, NY 14649 tel (585) 546-2700 ww.rge.com Ce MYEd

GLRER SECTION 4.2 ENT/IMP NOS. e5T.4-e- I

ROJECTED LAKEWIDE POPULATiONS YEAFR LEWIFE(A) kLEWIFE(J) ALE (A&J SMELT(A) SMELT(J) SME(A&J._ REFERENCES 1982 3.55E+09 1.87E+08 3.74E+09 2.72E+08 8.54E+08 1.13E+.09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1982 through 1986 Analysis Report, Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

B-13-328. 1987.

1983 4.24E+09 2.44E+08 4.48E+09 7.1 9E+08 4.69Ef08 1.1 9E+_09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1983 through 1987 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

____ _ B-13-314. 1988.

1984 1.30E+09 2.05E+08 1.51 E+09 2.80E+08 5.OOE+07 3.30E+08 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1984 through 1988 Analys!s Report, Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

__ I B-13-331.1989.

1985 2.55E+0. 6.0E+08 3.15E+09 1.12E+09 9.60E+08 2.08E+09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1984 through 1988 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

I B-13-331. 1989.

198 3.52E+0 2.20E+08 3.74E+09 7.OOE+08 1.OOE+08 8.OOE08 _ Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1986 through 1990 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

B-13-343. 1991.

19871 1.35E+0. 5.10E+08 1.86E+.09 2.42E+09 1.95E+09 4.37E+.09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1987 through 1991 Analysis Report, Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

-l 1988

. __ 8-13-357.1993.

1.95E+09 6.10E+08 2.56E+09 7.95E+08 2,05E+08 1.OOE+09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1987 through 1991 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

1989

_ _ 8.13-357. 1993.

3.27E+09 2.44E+08 3.51 E+09 1.25E+09 8.45E+08 2.10E+09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1987 through 1991 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

_ B-13-357. 1993.

1990 1.34E+09 5.63E+07 1AOE+09 4.78E+08 1.42E+08 6.20E+08 -Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1987 through 1991 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

I B-13-357. 1993.

1991 2.06E+09 6.63E+08 2.72E+09 7.28E+08 3.38E+08 1.07E+.09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1987 through 1991 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

IB-13-357.1993.

1992 1.37E+09 5.56E+08 1.93E+09 2.94E+08 1.62E+08 4.56E+08 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1992 through 1996 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

8-13-367. 1998.

1993 2.87E+09 1.88E+07 2.89E+o9 8.09E+08 5.74E+08 1.38E+09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1993 through 1997 Analysis Report, Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

B-13-370. 1998.

1994 1.93E+09 3.00E+08 2.23E+09 2.94E+08 6.76E+07 3.62E+08 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1994 through 1998 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

1995

_ _3_ 8-13-376. 1999.

1.93E+09 3.63E+o8 2.30E+09 1.43E+09 1.22E+09 2.65E+09 _ Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1994 through 1998 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

_______ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ 8-13-378. 1999.

1996 8.73E+08 2.75E+08l 1.15E+09 9.56E+08 4.73E+08 1.43E+09 IRochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1996 through 2000 Analysis Report, Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

_ _ B-13-381. 2001.

1_

1997 9.10E+08 3.13E+07 9.41E+08 1.32E+09 1.01E+09 2.33E+09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1997 through 2001 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

I _ _ _ _ B-13-389.2002.

1998 6.23E+08 8.75E+07 7.11 E+08 1.03E+09 1.22E+08 1.15E+09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1997 through 2001 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

1999 5.99E+08

_ 8-13-389.2002.

1.51E+09 2.11E+09 6.62E+08 4.86E+08 1.15E+09 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1997 through 2001 Analysis Repor. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

_ B-13-389. 2002.

2000 1.81E+0 4.75E+08 228E+09 1.69E+08 7.43E+07 2.43E+08 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program, 1997 through 2001 Analysis Report. Ginna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

iI 2 B-13-389.2002.

2001 2.62E+09 1.25E+071 2.63E+09 3.68E+08 2.36E 6.04E+08 Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation. Fish Impingement Program. 1997

- ~ through 2001 Analysis Report, Glnna Nuclear Power Station. RG&E Report No.

___ I_ _ I__I_ B-13-389.2002.

01282003.Yls AbS LO POP

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-328 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1982 THROUGH -1986 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1982- 1986 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE C) 11000 0

-j

-j I

o50 Fn U/)

YEARS Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

July 1987

TABLE 3 PROJECTED GHINHA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIKNTED LAKEWIDE POPULATION FOR ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) SKELT(A&J) 1982 0.00075% 0.00103% 0.01484% 0.00300% 0.00586%

1983 0.00108% 0.00108% 0.00055% 0.00119% 0.00080%

1984 0.00310% 0.00433% 0.00144% 0.01420% 0.00330%

1985 0.00273% 0.00131% 0.00396% 0.00187% 0.00220%

1986 0.00062% 0.00248%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) SKELT(A&J) 1982 26534 1917 40367 25593 65960 1983 45703 2624 3946 5597 .9543 1984 61040 12979 4 469 7525 11994 1985 102023 11371 10009 25018 35027 1986 31866 7695 7420 11178 18598 PROJECTED LAKEWIDE POPULATIONS YEAR 'ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SHELT(J) SMELT(A&J) 1982 3.55E+09 1.87E+08 2.72E+08 8.54E4-08 1.13E+09 1983 4.24E409 2.44E+08 7.19E408 4.69E+08 1.19E+09 1984 1.97E+09 3.OOE+08 '3.11E+08 5 30E+07 3.64E+08 1985 3.74E+09 8.71E+08 .2.53E+08 1.34E+09 1.59E+09

.1986 5.12E1-09 7.50E+08 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (#/BG)

YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) SMELT(A&J) 1982 200.67 11.38 '434.06 173.39 607.45

  • 1983 471.61 24.29 28.11 47.51 75.62

'1984 527.32 96.16 31.13 48.02 79.15

  • 1985 887.80 .76.23 92.64 208.04 300.68 1986 186.06 43.12 55.42 73.85 129.26 314

-sc v~

RG&E REPORT NO. B-1 3-328 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1982 THROUGH 1986 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1982 - 1986 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE Ci:)

z 1000, 0

-j

-j z

0 500 C',

0 YEARS Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

July 1987

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-314 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1983 THROUGH 1987' ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION

-Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation July, 1988

A.

TABLE 3 PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIMATED LAXEWIDE POPULATION FOR ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

  • PERCENT OF LAI]WIDE POPULATION IMPINGED YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE (J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) SMELT (A&J) 1983 0.00108% 0.00108% 0.00055% 0.00119% 0.00080%

1984 0.00310% 0.00433% 0.00144% 0.01420% 0.00330%

1985 0.00273% 0.00131% 0.00396% 0.00187% 0.00220%

1986 0.00062% 0.00248%

1987 0.00071% 0.00066% 0.00032%. 0.00030% 0.00031%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) -SMELT(J)^ SMELT(A&3) 1983 45703 2624 3946 5597 .9543 1984 61040 12979 4469 7525 11994:

  • 1985 102023 I 11371 10009 25018. 35027 1986 31866 7695 7420 11178 18598 1987 13558 4739 ' 11085 6665 19750 PROJECTED LA]=WIDE POPULATIONS YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) SMELT(A&J) 1983 4.24E+09 2.44E+08 7.19E+08 4.69E+08 1.19E+09 1984 1.97E+09 3.OOE+08 3.11E+08 5.30E+07 3.64E+08 1985 3.74E+09 8.71E+08 2.53E+08 1.34E+09 1.59E+09 1986 5.12E+09 7.50E+08 1987 1.90E+09 7.20E+08 3.50E+09 2.90E+09 6.40E+09 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (I/BG)

YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) SMELT(A&J)

_-n.ofe_ rG_

1983 471.61 24.29 28.11 47.51 75.62 1984 527.32 96.16 -31.13 48.02 79.15 1985 887.80 76.23 92.64 208.04 300.68 1986 186.06 43.12 55.42 73.85 129.26 1987 76.49 26.39 65.11 57.29 122.4 II I 36 II

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-314 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH'IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1983 THROUGH 1987 AJNALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION.

Data Co'llecte-d and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation July, 1988

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-331 1.r.

ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1984 THROUGH 1988 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION

', .I Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation September, 1989

w . * -

TABLE 3 PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIMATED LAXEWIDE POPULATION FOR ALEWIFE AND SHELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED YEAR ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1984 0.00470% 0.00633% 0.00160% 0.01505%

1985 0.00400% 0.00190% 0.00089% 0.00261%

1986 0.00091% 0.00350% 0.00106% 0.01118%

1987 0.00100% 0.00093% 0.00046% 0.00044%

1988 0.00414% 0.00215% 0.00088% 0.00510%

AVG 0.00295% 0.00296% 0.00098% 0.00688%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT YEAR ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT (J) 1984 61040 12979 4469 7525 1985 102023 11371 10009 25018 1986 31866 7695 7420 11178 1987 13558 4739 11085 8665 1988 80635 13119 7022 10457 PROJECTED LAXEWIDE POPULATIONS YEAR ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1984 1.30E+09 2.05E+08 2. 80E+08 5 .OOE+07 1985 2.SSE+09 6.OOE+08 1.12E+09 9.60E+08 1986 3.52E+09 2.20E+08 7.OOE+08 1. OOE+08 1987 1.35E+09 5.10E+08 2.42E+09 1.95E+09 1988 1.95E+09 6.10E+08 7.95E+08 2.05E+08 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (I/BG)

YEAR ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1984 527.32 96.16 31.13 48.02 1985 887.80 76.23 92.64 208.04 1986 186.06 43.12 55.42 73.85 1987 76.49 26.39 65.11 57.29 1988 456.9 73.08 50.05 68.02 34

U.-.

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-331 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION

  • FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM .

1984 THROUGH 1988 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation September, 1989

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-343 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1986 THROUGH 1990 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1986-1990 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE

/

700/

/

600

/

eD, z

25SW / /

C z

400 ./V /

0 / /

D 3Q It -4' AA a) ALL SPECIES IU 200

  • i2 o0 SMELT l .I A YELLOW PERCH 0 -1 SPOTAILSHINER 1986 1987 1988 , 19:8 1990 YEAR
  • Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

Environmental Laboratory December.1 991

TABLE 3 PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIMATED LAKEWIDE POPULATION FOR ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1986 0.00091% 0.00350% 0.00106% 0.01118%

1987 0.00100% 0.00093% 0.00046% 0.00044%

1988 0.00414% 0.00215% 0.00088% 0.00510%*

1989 0.00120S 0.00150% 0.00007% 0.00015%

1990 0.00365% 0.00203% 0.00033% 0.00182%

AVG 0.00218% 0.00202% 0.00056% 0.00374%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1986 31867 7695 7420 11178 1987 13558 4739 11085 8665 1988 80635 13119 7022 10457 1989 39225 3648 874 1275 1990 48967 1144 1582 2584 PROJECTED LAXEWIDE POPULATIONS YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1986 3.52E+09. 2.20E+08 7.OOE+08 1.OOE+08 1987 1.35E+09 5.10E+08 2.42E+09 1.95E+09 1988 1.95E+09 6.10E+08 7.95E+08. 2.05E+08 1989 3.27E+09 2.44E+08 1.25E+09 8.45E+08 1990 1.34E+09 5.63E+07 4.78E+08 1.42E+08 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (#/BG)

YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1986 186.06 43.12 55.42 73.85 1987 76.49 26.39 65.11 57.29 1988 456.90 *73;'08 50.05 68.02 1989 251.78 24.31 7.45 8.37 1990 278.18 6.44 10.80 15.66 32

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-343 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1986 THROUGH 1990 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1986-1990 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE co z

0 C'D z

I ALL SPECIES C', ALEVMFE

.SMELT

/YELLOW PERCH SPOTAIL SHINER YEAR

  • Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

Environmental Laboratory December.1 991

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-357 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1987 THROUGH 1991 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1987 - 1991 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE 700 U,

Z600 0

4500 C, 4 0 0 .

0 3 ALL SPECIES (l)100ET h FE o YELLOW PERCH 1POTTAIL SHINER YEAR Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

Environmental Laboratory February 1993

TABLE 3 PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIMATED LAXEWIDE POPULATION FOR ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF IAE WIDE POPULATION IMPINGED YEAR ALEWIFE(A)AIEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1987 0.00100% 0.00093% 0.00046% 0.00044%

1988 0.00414% 0.00215% 0.00088% 0.00510%

1989 0.00120% 0.00150% 0.00007% 0.00015%

1990 0.00365% 0.00203% 0.00033% 0.00182%

1991 0.00035% 0.00035% 0.00086% 0.00078%

AVG 0.00207% 0.00139% 0.00052% 0.00166%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1987 13558 4739 11085 8665 1988 80635 13119 7022 10457 1989 39225 3648 874 1275 1990 48967 1144 1582 2584 1991 7213 2307 6265 2633 PROJECTED LAXEWIDE POPULATIONS YEAR ALEWIFE(A)ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SHELT(C')

1987 1.35E+09 5.10E+08 2.42E+09 1.95E+09 1988 1.95E+09 6.10E+08 7.95E+08 2.05E+08 1989 3.27E+09 2.44E+08 1.25E+09 8.45E+08 1990 1.34E+09 5.63E+07 4.78E+08 1.42E+08 1991 2.06E+09 6.63E+08 7.28E+08 3.38E+08 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (f/BG)

YEAR ALEWIFE(A)AIEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J).

1987 76.49 26.39 65.11 57.29 1988 456.90 73.08 50.05 68.02 1989. 251.78 24.31 , 7.45 8.37 1990 278.18 6.44 1D.80 15.66 1991 231.74 52.31 42.99 16.83 33

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-357 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1987 THROUGH 1991 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION

- 1987 - 1991 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE 700

MO z

0 Zig

20O SPECIES 0o 01o YEAR Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

Environmrental Laboratory February 1993

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-367 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1992 THROUGH 1996 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corp.

Environmental Laboratory January, 1998 .

I 1:

1 , . t .

TABLE 3

PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIMATED LAKEWIDE POPULATION ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED ALEWIFE(A IALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1992 0.00192% . 0.00435% 0.00027% 0.00043%

1993 0.00046% 0.00032% 0.00010% 0.00007%

1994 0.00007% 0.00362% 0.00007% 0.00114%

1995 0.00014% 0.00015% 0.00001% 0.00026%

1996 0.00206% 0.00028% 0.00085% 0.00211%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1992 26300 24193 801 705 1993 13297 60 791 374 1994 1273 10868 197 772 1995 2677 527 126 3190 1996 . '17956 781 8106 10002 PROJECTED LAKEWIDE POPULATIONS lALEWIFE(A) lALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J)

.1992 f 1.37E+09 5.56E+08 2.94E+08 1.62E+08 1993 2.87E+09 1.88E+07 8.09E+08 5.74E+08 1994 1.93E+091 *3.OOE+08 2.94E+08 6.76E+07 1995 j 1.93E+09 3.63E+08 1.43E+09 1.22E+09 1996 8.73E+08 2.75E+08 9.56E+08 4.73E+08 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (#/BG)

ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1992 147.1 169.0 7.5 5.3 1993 156.1 0.7 9.0 2.5 1994 8.6 62.8 1.4 . .5.6 1995 18.1 3.1' 0.8 22.1 1996 236.5 6.7 90.5 83.3 27 L.

S -

9-RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-367 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1992 THROUGH 1996 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corp.

Environmental Laboratory January, 1998

.1, -. .. :,' 0 RG&E REPORT NO. B-1.3-370 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION

.FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM.

1993 THROUGH 1997 ANALYSIS REPORT

.GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1993 -1997 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE

. C i z I o GAALL SPECIES

-j ALEWIFE 0

. 0 SMELT

.I

  • co SPOTTAIL SHINER IC
  • U).

I STICKLEBACK

. III II i

Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation June, 1998

TABLE 3 PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIMATED LAKEWIDE POPULATION..

ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED I Al C\^/H AEf I AI C1AIIc nP. 1 t acAt ri,A% CAMI Tt ti I %JIvlL-L Qlvlv-Lljr-%j I %%P) 1993 -0.00046 0.00032% 0.00010% 0.00007%

1994 0.00007% 0.00362% 0.00007% 0.00114%

1995 .0.00014% 0.00015% . .0.00001% . 0.00026%

1996 0.00206o ., 0.00028% ;09.00085% .0:00211%

1997 0.00152% 0.00733% .0.00041% 0.00035%

AVG 0.00085% 0.00234%,o 0.00029% 0.00079%

PROJECTED .MENT_

6LANlRIN ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) S.MELT(A) . SMELT(J).

1993 . 13297 **. aI.BG .'- ?"791

6 374 1994 1273 10868 ,  ;' 197 772 1995 . 2677 . 527 ' 126 3190 1996 17956 . 781 ; '100028 1997 .13875 .229 l- 392

? 3547 PROJECTED LAKEWIDE POPULATIONS ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A)- . SMELT(J) 1993 2.87E+09

  • 1'88E+07 8.09E+08 5.74E+08 1994 1.93E+09 3.OOE+08 2.94E+08 6.76E+07 1995 1.93E+09 3.63E+08 1.43E+09 1.22E+09 1996 8.73E+08 2.75E408 9.56E+'08 4.73E+08 1997. 9.1 OE+08 3.13E+07 . 1.32E+09 1.01 E+09 PROJECTED iPLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (#IBG) -

ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J). SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1993 156.1 0.7 9.0 2.5 1994 8.6 -'62.8 1.4 ' ' :5.6 1995 18.1 3.1 0.8 22.1'

i0 1996 236.5 . 6.7 9Q.5 83.3 1997 77.6 13.0 . 35.1 -2a.4 28
  • I !,

0 r

7 RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-370 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION

.FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1993 THROUGH 1997 ANAtYSIS REPORT-GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1993 -1997 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE v

z ( ALL SPECIES I

0 ALEWIFE

.:i zo ( SMELT

. I R Io SPOTTAIL SHINE

. U-STICKLESACK I

YEAR 1997 i

I Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation June, 1998

-a c0I RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-376 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM . ,

1994 THROUGH 1998 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1994 -1998 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE i

V)

Z

, 0 IF(WI ALL SPECIES

-i f

/J[ALEVVFE

  • CD z

i/ SMELT I -J I

, o F I I. Q / SPOTTAIL SHINER I I

  • ML II STICKLEBACK II i

YEAR 1998 i

-2 Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporaion June, 1999

. .. -1 TABLE 3 PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED ALEWIFE(A) I ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1994 0.00007% 0.00362% 0.00007% 0.00114%

1995 0.00014% 0.00015% 0.00001% 0.00026%

1996 0.00206% 0.00028% 0.00085% 0.00211%

1997 0.00152% 0.00733% 0.00041% 0.00035%

1998 0.00024% 0.00017% 0.00018% 0.00063%

AVG 0.00081% 0.00231 % 0.00030%1 0.00090%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1994 1273 10868 197 772 1995 2677 527 126 3190 1996 17956 781 8106 10002 1997 13875 2295 5392 3547 1998 2164 . 138 1900 763 PROJECTED LAKEWIDE POPULATIONS ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1994 1.93E+09 3.OOE+08 2.94E+08 6.76E+07 1995 1.93E+09 3.63E+08 1.43E+09 1.22E+09 1996 8.73E+08 2.75E+08 9.56E+08 4.73E+08 1997 9.19E+08 3.13E+07 1.32E+09 1.01E+09 1998 9.04E+08 8.1 3E+07 1.03E+09 1.22E+08 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (#/BG)

ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1994 8.6 62.8 1.4 5.6 1995 18.1 3.1 0.8 22.1 1996 236.5 6.7 90.5 83.3 1997 77.6 13.0 35.1 23.4 1998 12.1 0.8 11.1 4.7 27

RG&E REPORT NO. B-1 3-376 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1994 THROUGH 1998 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1994 - 1998 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE WI Clb z

.0 / ALL SPECIES

-j

-j ALEWIFE 0

0 SMELT I -j SPOTTAIL SHINER i

. I STICKLEBACK II YEAR 1998 i

L

',4 Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation June, 1999

  • '  ; . 1.  ; $ .. .. . ........
  • .- . ;.  ; .  ; P t :;;  ;............  :.. .. .I> ,-ti ........ ...

RG&E REPORT NO. B 13 381 4 .

ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION

,*-'! .~dJ ' .,,. a b*- -';.r~

FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM

' '1996THROUGH 2000-ANALYSIS REPORT ,

4.

§,', GNANbERPOWVER GINNA NUCLEKAR iW.EiR*STATON i i  ; - A 71

,':.' 199 *' ,. ,'4.,'"..'"

  • ., .  ; -99S1999ANNUAL

, o IMPINGEM-ENT RATr..: i-.'fl . . .7

  • 4 50.00

-0 35'9.

400.0.

p. .  : >.':i- ioaot oo0w-.>:* .1 4.
0 Dat Il L and

. ' . '.B :B ... '. .::~Report Prepared by . 7 -

.. .. < -, .  : .. ; .. . . -Rochester Gas and;:

,; . .. . .;Electnic Corporation  ;

i~~~Dt ' -,,: .o ','e . June, 2001 n.;d

.b.y. -Rpr Prpae

I TABLE 3 PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED ALEWIFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED SMELT(J)*

ALEVV1FE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A)

ALEWIFE(A) Ij ALEVYIFE(J) SMVELT(A) SMELT(J) 1996 0.00206% 0.00028% 0.00085% 0.00211%

1997 0.00152% 0.00733% 0.00041% 0.00035%

1998 0.00035% 0.00016% 0.00018% 0.00062%

1999 0.00089% 0.00001% 0.00019% 0.00016%

2000 0.00011 % 0.00024%1 0.00377% 0.00061%

AVG 0.00099% 0.00160% 0.00108% 0.00077%1 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT, ALEWIFE(A) ALEW1FE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1996 17956 781 8106 10002 1997 13875 2295 5392 3547 1998 2164 138 1899 762 1999 5311 136 1246 776 2000 2001 1141 6375 452 PROJECTED LAKEWIDE POPULATIONS ALEWIFE(A) ALEW1FE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1996 8.73E+08 2.75E+08 9.56E+08 4.73E+08 1997 9.1OE+08 3.13E+07 1.32E+09 1.01E+09 1998 .6.23E+08 8.75E+07 1.03E+09 1.22E+08 1999 5.99E+08 1.51 E+09 6.62E+08 4.86E+08 2000 1.81E+09 4.75E+08 1.69E+08 7.43E+07 PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (#IBG) l ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J) SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1996 236.5 6.7 90.5 83.3 1997 77.6 13.0 35.1 23.4 1998 12.1 0.8 11.1 4.7 1999 29.7 0.8 31.3 16.9 2000 12.0 6.4 44.6 3.0 29

.-- :T1 U lM. -95..9,.AN .GMN..

I~T ROCHETER9S & LECTICCOPORAION ~ .3j ~ A FIHIPNGMNPRGRMo.*

O'C

--- 5 9 30 19- 99tNNM- W t-.F3

-. 2504;4-ME.T--"4'"*'t-

'a. a

'00:.a" L ~

50, t..4(0

.4 I .. A .'. ...

I O 00001L.I U.SeC1Eas.~ Ind C 'LL0130000

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-389 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1997 THROUGH 2001 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION Data Collected by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation Environmental Laboratory Report prepared by David D. Dakin Environmental Laboratory And Paul M. Sawyko Fossil/Hydro Engineering June, 2002

TABLE 3 I PROJECTED GINNA STATION IMPINGEMENT COMPARED TO ESTIMATED LAKEWIDE POPULATION ALEW IFE AND SMELT (ADULT AND JUVENILE)

  • PERCENT OF LAKEWIDE POPULATION IMPINGED ALEWIFE(A) IALEWIFE(J SMELT(A) SMELT(J)I 1997 0.00152% 0.00733% 0.00041% 0.00035%

1998- 0.00035% 0.00016% 0.00018% 0.00062%

1999 0.00089% 0.00001% 0.00019% 0.00016%

2000 0.00011% 0.00024% 0.00377% 0.00061%

2001 0.00003% 0.00091%1 0.00004% 0.00024%

AVG 0.00058%1 0.00173%1 0.00092% 0.00040%

PROJECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT AKLEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J)[ SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1997 13875 2295 5392 .a547 1998 2164 138 1899 762 1999 5311 136 1246 776 2000 2001 1141 6375 4521 2001 715 114 139 571 PROJECTED LAKEWIDE POPULATIONS

_ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J)l SMELT(A) SMELT(J) 1997 9.10E+08 3.13E+07 1.32E+09 1.01 E+09 1998 6.23E+08 8.75E+07 1.03E+09 1.22E+08 1999 5.99E+08 1.51E+09 6.62E+08 4.86E+08 2000 1.81E+09 4.75E+08 1.69E+08 7.43E+07 2001 2.62E+09 1 .25E+07 3.68E+08 2.36E+08 PR JECTED PLANT IMPINGEMENT RATE (WIG)

ALEWIFE(A) ALEWIFE(J SMELT(A) SMELT(J)

I.i 1997 77.6 13.0 35.1 23.4 12.1 0.8 11.1 4.7 1999 29.7 0.8 31.3 16.9 2000 12.0 6.4 44.6 3.0 2001 4.0 0.6 1.1 4.4 29

4.

C,] I RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-389 ROCHESTER GAS & ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1997 THROUGH 2001 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION Data Collected by Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation Environmental Laboratory Report prepared by David D. Dakin Environmental Laboratory And PaulM.Sawyko Fossil/Hydro Engineering June, 2002

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-357 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1987 THROUGH 1991 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATION 1987 1991 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE m

700 500 0400' 03 v LSPECIES m520 0100VI 0 PERCH 1987 ~ ~ 10 SP7PTAIL SHINER YEAR Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

Environmrntal Laboratory February 1993

1985b). In order to assess the impact of impingement for alewives and smelt, the number of these two species estimated to be impinged are compared to the Lake Ontario alewife and smelt populations.

These Lake .population estimates are based upon data reported by O'Gorman, et al (1992) for the 1987-1991 period. It should be noted that.in years previous to 1989 O'Gorman, et al had presented actual population estimates for alewives and smelt for the U.S.

waters of Lake Ontario. However, in reports subsequent to 1989, these authors report only trawl collection data and no extrapolation to Lake population has been included. Therefore, RG&E developed a correlation factor between the trawl data and the population estimate for the five years of information presented in O'Gorman, et al. 1989, and applied this factor to trawl data provided in their 1992 report (O'Gorman, St 1,, 1992). This correlation-factor was found to be quite consistent for the five year period presented in O'Gorman, et al, 1989, thus justifying its use. This procedure was utilized to determine Lake pbpulation estimates for the U.S. waters of Lake Ontario for adult .and juvenile alewife and smelt. It should be stressed.that the.Lake popl.ations utilized _a-2Crau.&.. w;a'orz oZ Lake Ontetriv only, thus theoretically these populations could be doubled for impact assessment, or alternatively, the percent impact could be halved.

Impact of impingement upon the Lake Ontario yellow perch population is done qualitatively utilizing available information concerning this fishery.

11

RG&E REPORT NO. B-13-357 ROCHESTER GAS AND ELECTRIC CORPORATION FISH IMPINGEMENT PROGRAM 1987 THROUGH 1991 ANALYSIS REPORT GINNA NUCLEAR POWER STATIPN 1987 - 1991 ANNUAL IMPINGEMENT RATE 700 zeoo 200

-I 4500 z.

0

. e ,. % *.

M200 u)100 MELT 0 ELLOW PERCH P0T7TAIL SHINER YEAR Data Collected and Report Prepared by Rochester Gas & Electric Corp.

Envlronmnntal Laboratory February 1D93

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML043100314&oldid=2605307"