ML15348A435
| ML15348A435 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 11/12/2015 |
| From: | Kwong L S State of NY, Office of the Attorney General |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY RAS | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML15348A433 | List: |
| References | |
| 50-247-LR, 50-286-LR, ASLBP 07-858-03-LR-BD01, RAS 28663 | |
| Download: ML15348A435 (3) | |
Text
NOVEMBER 12, 2015 NYS NOTICE OF OBJECTION ATTACHMENT 1 to NYS DECLARATION
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
x In re: Docket Nos. 50
-247-LR; 50-286-LR License Renewal Application Submitted by ASLBP No. 07
-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC, DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.
November 12, 2015 -----------------------------------------------------------
x STATE OF NEW YORK'S OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATION S FOR CERTAIN WESTINGHOUSE DOCUMENTS In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergy's designatio n of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non
-disclosure
. The documents are various documents prepared by Entergy's vendor, Westinghouse
, relating to metal fatigue evaluations for structures and components at the Indian Point nuclear facilities
. Based on the State's review, the documents appear to primarily contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R
. § 2.390. Entergy's request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore
, overly broad
. At minimum, Entergy should produce public, redacted versions of these documents.
To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse
) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the documents it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim (s); and (3) the harm that would result fro m public disclosure
.
The documents at the subject of the State's Objection are the following:
EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION AND DATE CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION ENTR00681 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17199-P, Rev. 2, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 2, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00682 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17200-P, Rev. 2, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 3, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 4 "Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF Analyses and EAF Screening Evaluations," Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00689 Westinghouse, WCAP
-12191, Rev. 5, Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation Report for Indian Point Unit 2, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00690 Westinghouse, WCAP
-16898-P, Rev. 2, Indian Point Unit 3 Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation
, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000727 Westinghouse, CN
-PAFM-09-21, Rev. 4, Indian Point Units 2 and 3 Charging Nozzles Environmental Fatigue Evaluation, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. These documents were disclosed on November 4, 2015 and produced to the State on Friday, November 6, 2015. Entergy yesterday filed a motion requesting permission to submit these documents as exhibits.
Executed on November 12
, 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York
The Capitol Albany, New York 12224
(518) 776
-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 2
NOVEMBER 12, 2015 NYS NOTICE OF OBJECTION ATTACHMENT 1 to NYS DECLARATION
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
x In re: Docket Nos. 50
-247-LR; 50-286-LR License Renewal Application Submitted by ASLBP No. 07
-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC, DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.
November 12, 2015 -----------------------------------------------------------
x STATE OF NEW YORK'S OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATION S FOR CERTAIN WESTINGHOUSE DOCUMENTS In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergy's designatio n of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non
-disclosure
. The documents are various documents prepared by Entergy's vendor, Westinghouse
, relating to metal fatigue evaluations for structures and components at the Indian Point nuclear facilities
. Based on the State's review, the documents appear to primarily contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R
. § 2.390. Entergy's request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore
, overly broad
. At minimum, Entergy should produce public, redacted versions of these documents.
To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse
) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the documents it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim (s); and (3) the harm that would result fro m public disclosure
.
The documents at the subject of the State's Objection are the following:
EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION AND DATE CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION ENTR00681 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17199-P, Rev. 2, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 2, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00682 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17200-P, Rev. 2, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 3, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 4 "Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF Analyses and EAF Screening Evaluations," Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00689 Westinghouse, WCAP
-12191, Rev. 5, Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation Report for Indian Point Unit 2, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENTR00690 Westinghouse, WCAP
-16898-P, Rev. 2, Indian Point Unit 3 Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation
, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000727 Westinghouse, CN
-PAFM-09-21, Rev. 4, Indian Point Units 2 and 3 Charging Nozzles Environmental Fatigue Evaluation, Nov. 2015. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. These documents were disclosed on November 4, 2015 and produced to the State on Friday, November 6, 2015. Entergy yesterday filed a motion requesting permission to submit these documents as exhibits.
Executed on November 12
, 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York
The Capitol Albany, New York 12224
(518) 776
-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 2