ML20195C764

Forwards Pages That Were Faxed to J Peschel on 981113 in Preparation for Telcon That Will Be Scheduled Wk of 981116. Info in Attached Pages Based on Info Obtained from Licensee & Includes Specific Subjects to Be Discussed with Licensee

ML20195C764
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	11/13/1998
From:	Harrison J NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
To:	NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
References
NUDOCS 9811170213
Download: ML20195C764 (5)

Text

. _ - - _. . . . _ . . . _-

. -c November 13, 1998 MEMORANDUM TO: File FROM: John Harrison, Project Manager Original signed by Project Directorate 1-3 Division of Reactor Projects - 1/II Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

SUBJECT:

SEABROOK REACTOR PRESSURE VESSEL INTEGRITY CALCULATIONS AND LIMITING MATERIAL CLARIFICATION l

I The attached pages were faxed to Jim Peschel, Nuclear Licensing Manager of North Atlantic Energy Service Corporation on Friday, November 13,1998, in preparation for a telephone conference that will be scheduled next week.

The information in the attached is based on information obtained from the licensee and also includes specific subjects to be discussed with the licensee. Therefore, this memorandum and its attachment contain no draft or predecisional information per the guidance of Office Letter 106, Revision 1 - Release of NRC Draft or Predecisional Documents and Information.

l Docket No. 50-443

Attachment:

As stated DISTRIBUTION

" Docket Filei PDI-3 Rdg.

JHarrison 4 TClark l Posuc.

FILENAME: G:\ HARRISON \rpv-rai. fax ,, )

OFFICE PM:PDI-3 LA:PDl-3 D:PQfd( / /

NAME JTHarrisoM TLClark3k COEhomask DATE W / \$/98 // / /3 /98 [ / l /98 h / /98 ,

f i

OFFICIAL RECORD COPY l 4 1 9811170213 981113 ~

fDR ADOCK 05000443 PDR 1 7 ^- Q 9,1.

l

_ .g . ,p%* l

.; .- J UM

m[

l l

- 1

1 .

l '

f

\

pn n'auq, p *4 UNITED STATES j

l g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 2 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20665-0001 i

\...../ -

FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION DATE: 1) l ~$ q g TO: bIm eghg\

FAX NO: (60'3)775-774O TEL NO:[663)773-7)q4 FROM: John Harrison l U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

! OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REACTOR REGULATION 1

FAX NO.: (301)415-2102 TEL NO: (301) 415-3199 l

PAGE 1 of 2 PAGES i

REMARKS:

l We. need to schec ule a con-[erence Celi to discuss t.h aMached.

1 4

4 e

i op usamb t i

The following is an edited excerpt of an E-mail received from Andrea Lee of EMCB on 11/2/98:

The reactor vessel integrity d'atabase (RVID), which performs integrity calculations for all of the RPV beltline materials in order to determine the limiting material, was recently updated. As a result, we would like to discuss the following.with the licensee:

The RVID calculations show that plate R1806-1 may be the limiting material (highest RTpts) and not plate R1808-3 as reported by the licensee.

A June 5,1998 surveillance report shows that the chemistry factor calculated from surveillance data for plate R1808-3 may have only used the transversely oriented plate surveillance data and not the full set of data which includes the longitudinally oriented data. The result of the calculations using all of the data (shown on page 4 of 4) may result in a higher RTpts value. The data used for the beltline plates (other than R1808-3) are from the licensee's November 20, 1995 response to GL 92-01, Rev.1, Supp.1.

We need to have the licensee confirm the information on the docket.

O

MTE l808-3

"~ _ - - -

,%QTp.. O.. -QT/iNJ I'.

[(~ ' .] t': Delete ~l ~TaVf'~ l ~' PrtRF "j -" Cfde ~j i 4,$~5.hYhh$5.'-d"ernmU"*E g ? ,"'; Plant j SEABROOK O&,,=::;.: mig -- x ;;p;;:,.;; u:ch

[Reacto'r Type:

.e +

• esselThickness:, 8.62 c.

Docket'No:1 50 443 as:;.u mmm .. -unmuut.n w .gf rPiatelD(generated by system):

542 . ,

~

3 -

' ~- J- mEp;:c,wssA&L.%5 riNPUT DATiki4102 ant:%@%;.~y,#+m s @ p%iQ  %%wn{W5M M,Q.5,9 ny4;ygp si46 # g"@ ]

fa%=pp ,x  ;

[ [** Ne'at D i I[ Bettlini10.

NA/PL-C kN$aIh- NN bbfhhNk/N:kh $$h43 a INTERMEDIATE SHELL R1808-3 M '

p;,fqgy 7 % gp;y? . ; %,gp ....y .2..M. , s.WM.M.,.gm$M ac l-~r:n z .;

.' Base Metal;,- A 5338 .ncm

> 1 :.kD Q M M;nt;..,~.

.*e i ": .4 p,,.n +%, ,cvE W % --p 7nW Q?g'm' . r,;yd6 ""*'~""

" ~ " ' - . . . - . - . _ - - . .

m. ,e Chemistry C JO,.; 'M'W ~ ~ -

+

.<,.- Cu: 0070 0.590 www~ :lCA"L.CU" LATED."DAT"@M Amr ' F-Add <-% Notes:- -)'

l. wo..%.w.r. o%aM 4

• l n .

p -n .&, 1 4gp y yyy;ps- ,

d Q .. P:, 0.007

> . 6:e 0.010 sqq.22 g?y n.c. v.*it;g :n g y-e m

. - .. h ' h p'M* M.e" ' --

[

?,*~T i y.;;~*RTndt(u): 40.0

??.["d?P[V ?

'dA*N l01f ae .. , g Nh.9y$k.,N M:/

~TNIf[84e PLANT SPECIFIC l RTndt(u) f,

{  ; Fluines Factof@ EOLj 1.233 Msoy'(.is.11og(nuance (ID))iM {

L 7 ' * ' RTndt(u):' 40.0 i PLANT SPECIFIC Q  ; 3QChemistry Factors 40.8 W

SURVEILLANCE NON-RATIO ( .

e E, Fluence.(ID) EO.L;' 2 370 PT_ sa.6M'*.Wr i 8 , %Tndt @ EOLi

t. .

50.3 LFxCF l SURVEY EALC DFTAfti qv ' Chem Factorn errsa m mer  !?c ",~ ,2 7 4 5 a001 0.0 PLANT SPECIFIC l RTndttu) :

LW,;%c(81h 7M,2 d C"'

.-M. . c(Q.!n LENE SUue

{ %rMC.e(A)]

8 T 8.5 SURVEILLANCE DATA l 4 .

__ _ C .2

. . _ 'f1. ' . Afargirq-- 17.0

=

. . POSITION 2.1 (S DATA) gt. , Margirl.:

n . . ,. . . - -

+ . s,-

Limiting Material:{

, {[-y [:. , ..USE }'l:T @ RTpts EOL b[4T)':

@ EOLL*W.37 64.5 . , .,

1.413 IFluenSe (1/4T) @ EO "

RTn,dt(u)iDRTnd g-. Unirr USE:j 78.0 l DIRECT h.

-s -

l' } *ADrop @ EOL(1/4T);

,a-17.3 ( POSITION 2.2 (S DATA) .

--((.

L o .2 4

._a ,1 j  ! f

1 1

~ -

PLATE. 1806-g !GTOM0Nhl! ;[-

' .m.:, -

n~.,'., . - - . . - . - - . , - - - - - , ,

j .f. .. . + .

,*&. 3,f,. Q4 j.4 j ) j Hj . ).[ . = ; 4> J - Delete - l he ~ j Print ' 'l Close" l!

'*t---

N .,i Plantd mya:' . :r . .Etre SEABROOK rn. ~ ~ ~ ' * " ' - -. :- .p-am.:.,v w rc=y. c.y. n:a: y;. igg, ire 4

$'R'eactorType:{ PWR kasselThkkne a: 8.62 f, ,

f{.(DocNt Nd:, 50-443 6 %PisteiD (generated by systern): 543 L

]

- s- a ..;w.E.+5.q; s.- y ;y, p l. ws ,;.. , i. :.g mca:4:7,64.;.e.,, .s:, w;;e sc.+,

M "+ .

y (lNP.UT

.a - 1 DA. TA7*42:wu '~h~ u4NMAN.ge yhy: ~ ' c; . y,.: g g g :.;F.,4"" p yy y. /- MMMMM4 C K ,

g

+ . . Heat ID: NNPL-D bra Cale- 32 9%LW 3*- -

4 Y

j

Bettline 10. INTERMEDIATE SHELL R1806-1 kpa1.waw, w). ._,noy

,.9 . c.;d9c vig . (y,gx -- s P . Base Metal, A 5338 A, x. .. _ . . ,h, m";M' s

3. g "t p"*+ 4 4 .~i.,. ,,,.

--. "p+v.

• 'W'h;*****

.y s.,.

A ie / p.*(, % &t*4 C, l's "V";";41,-

m,s ' ('2'1 4  ; t.. ..-~.sk,.. t.< p Qc L .

. ,; g y . , , .

g .._  ; g;g.= ggg ggg;g , ; ; ,,, - . -- - - -- , j 0 045; g. , chemistry c qs;, 2 =

u

! < y>, ~ ,Cu.',,

.s Ni: < 0.610 m M. .M '

'Ch,LCULATED DAT4W.19.

x.-

iCAdfN6taE

.,M%O % j  !

a s m i pa ns  !

"P: i 0.012 - S: ,,ya~lue ; m.gg w r: Method,,g. , G ::

b:w?! g. .a;-:~w+m,, 'y;%&r ;ea,-c; 4 v s.. .

i i pyMki 9 .O. f.

0.012 s.-

- NAW m ,0.,.. g; d. A a:"'/ .4 j

> ~

W. 'I r~M$r.~ m.% 3. R. .T. ndt(u): 40.0 i ..

• . -- ~ PLANT SPECIFIC l RTndt(u) l.t l l ..Waluen $'3MethodjM., .

)

[. ..9 ~q&i'Mr m RTndt(u): 40.0(b l PLANT SPECIFIC l

luen. ce Fador @ EOL:

1 1.233 28.5 Buence(tofLis i1M. v TABLE $

i! Fluence (ID) EOL , 2.370

[/Qg*ggg hA . Chemis.try 35.1 Factoh,[ RFacFM.@c lyspTndt M MM.$3 @ EOg i p* l, Chen1 Factor:, smsm ovunmoe '

,d:N'TP'Ncyc(M 0.0 PLANT SPECIFIC l RTndt(u) (

e muss, ..w q nl.) e a(o) Ls oTwsmass ce, L4 g g j ,_; ( $

,tt.g; 17.0 NO SURVEILLANCE DATA !t 4, . m , v.A A MA) i - - -

I ccc <

1.EME DLMC ' 3 1!41 ,.[* Marhiii 34.0 POSITION 1.1 (NO S DATA)

!  ;;b .,s ,- Marg. . h1: . ,

f ye _ ; ' <

4k. , ,.,> RTpts;_ @ EOLP09.1? RTndt(u)* DRT'ot+ n Margin ' 72 t

6,Lkniting

, Materiat] hc.m. - , , . . a; -g t f ; E,< - @ EOL (1/4T):

. ' . ..~s

, .USE 65.1

, Unirr USE:] 82.0 l 1.413 kluence (il4T) @ EO l

fJ,, . s, s .,s.

DIRECT l r % Drop @ EOL(1/4T): 20.6 [

t

,m.

7 4 . , . .c y, - r. ,

., , .,,,% POSITION

, ,, 1.2 (NO m .

S..,,c.

DATA) h, l

l l

l l

• l l

l l

1 r

l 4

1 k

i

'"* ad