ML17208A341

Forwards Proprietary & Nonproprietary Versions of Responses to Six site-specific Questions Re Disc Integrity in Westinghouse 1800 Rpm Low Pressure Nuclear Turbines. Proprietary Version Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790)

ML17208A341
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	03/19/1980
From:	UHRIG R E FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:	EISENHUT D G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
L-80-90, NUDOCS 8003250471
Download: ML17208A341 (81)

Text

'REGUlATORY INNATION DISTRIBUTION SYSTE(BIDS)

ACCESSION NSR:8003250071 DOC~DATE: 80/03/19 NOTARIZED:

YES FACIL:50 335 St.LUc{e Planti Unit ig Florida Power 8 Light Co.AUTH~NAME AUTHOR AFFILIATION UHRIGiR,ED Florida Power 8 Light Co.REC IP R NAME RECIPIENT AFF ILI AT ION EISENHUTiD,G.

Division of Operating Reactors I'UBJECT: Forwards proprietray L nonproprietaly versions of responses to six site specific questions re disc integrity in Westinhouse 1800rpm low pressure nuc)ear turbines'roprjeta'ry version withheld (ref 10cfr2~790)~DISTRIBUTION CODE PA01S COPIES RECEIVED:LTR

+ENCL g SIZE: J~TITLE: Proprietary Info after Issuance of License DOCKET 05000335 NOTES~Os OO W~W Wf ee W WW W W W W f%W~W W W&&&80 W WW OMO W W~W I'M WtW W M W W W W~%t~wW w W w ww w W&W Oa%tw&W W RECIPIENT ID CODE/NAME.

ACTION: DE SC EIgg RAAg INTERNAL':

01 REG FILE 11 TA/EDO 10 ENGR BR 16 PLANT SYS BR 18 EFFLI TRT SYS GELD COPIES L'TTR ENCL 7 7 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 RECIPIENT'O CODE/NAME 09 I 8 E 12 CORE.PERF BR 15 REAC SFTY BR 17 EEB NRC POR STS GROUP LEADR COPIES LTTR ENCL 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 EXTERNAL,e 19 ACRS NSIC 16 16 LPDR 1 P j!A SMITHi H~W/AFF'Ps 1 0 j gd/EP'dE-ical/W POE W ERIC'SA g ae.6~3&P-5 gag 2"1>980 TOTAI NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED: LTTR 39 ENCL 33 P H HP V II P P

~p,ft secfg 0 cp fz e UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C.20555 OEM)UH FOR: TERA Corp.FROM:

SUBJECT:

USÃRC/TIDC/Distribution Services Branch Special Document Handling Requirements I.Please use the following special distribution list for the attached document.0 2.The attached document requires the following special considerations:

Do not send oversize enclosure to the RRC PDR.Q Only one oversize enclosure was received-please return for Regulatory File storage.c Proprietary information

-send aff'davit only to the NRC PDR Q Other: (specify)cc: DSB Files TELIC/DSB Authori"ed Signature P.X 529100 MIAMI, FL 33152 FLORIDA POWER 8 LIGHT COMPANY March 19, 1980 L-80-90 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention:

Mr.Darrell G.Eisenhut, Acting Director Division of Operating Reactors U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.20555

Dear Mr.Eisenhut:

Re: St.Lucie Unit 1 Docket No.50-335 Turbine Rotors Florida Power 8 Light Company (FP8L)has reviewed your letter dated February 25, 1980 requesting, in accordance with 10 CFR 50.54(f), information relative to disc integrity in Westinghouse 1800 RPM low pressure nuclear turbines.Specifically, your request attached a set of six site-specific questions and a second set of eight generic questions.

Your letter also urged that the generic questions be addressed through an owners group.As requested, responses to the generic questions were coordinated through a task force, of which FP8L is a member, which is chaired by Mr.Wayne Stiede of Commonwealth Edison.It is our understanding that Westinghouse will submit responses to the generic questions directly to your office and that you are in agreement with this method of submittal.

As a result of discussions at an industry Task Force meeting in Tampa, Florida on March 12-13, 1980, we understand that a site-specific information submittal date of March 19, 1980 is acceptable to the NRC.Such information is provided in Attachment 3.St.Lucie is currently shutdown for refueling, and inspections of the LP rotor discs will be performed during the outage.Please note that our response contains information considered to be proprietary by the Westinghouse Electric Corporation.

In conformance with 10 CFR 2.790, as amended, we are also forwarding an APPLICATION FOR WITHHOLDING INFORMATION FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE (Attachment 1)and an Affidavit (Attachment 2).The affidavit sets forth the basis on which the proprietary information contained in Attachment 3 may be withheld from public disclosure by the Commission.

p f4)g8 q$gP-/6(4m s6g r NP is 8~L~I<~P g pO~~/~/80080 50lfpy PEOPLE...SERVING PEOPLE

~..Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Page 2 Correspondence with respect to the affidavit or application for withholding should reference AW-80-19 and should be addressed to Mr.R.Williamson, Manager, Customer Order Engineering, Westinghouse Electric Corporation, Steam Turbine Divisions Lester Branch Box 9175, Philadelphia, Pa.19113.Very truly yours, Robert E.Uhrig Vice President Advanced Systems 8 Technology REO/DKJ/cph Attachments (3)cc: Mr.J.P.O'Reilly, Region II (w/o attachments)

Harold Reis, Esquire (w/o attachments)

Attachment 1 APPLICATION FOR l!ITHHOLDING PROPRIETARY INFORMATION FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE DOCKET iVO.M BBQ DATE'OTE TO NRC AND/OR LOCAL PUBLIC DOCUMENT ROOMS The following item submitted with letter dated Q 4)3 I Tram///C 5~is being withheld from public disclosure in accordance with Section 2.790.PROPRIETARY INFORMATION pg rg 5 P.Distribution Serrice's Branch P,M-'80-.19 March 14, 1980 Darrell G.Eisenhut Division of Operating Reactors Office'of Nuclear Reactor Regulation US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington DC 20555 APPLICATION FOR WITHHOLDING PROPRIETARY INFORMATION PROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE

Reference:

Turkey Point 83 and 4 Docket$50-250, 50-251, St.Lucie 50-335 Information in Response to NRC Request for Information of'February 25, 1980, Relative to Low Pressure Turbine Disc Integrity.

Appendix A letter from R.E.Uhrig-to Eisenhut, dated 3/19/80

Dear Mr.Eisenhut:

This application for withholding is submitted by Westinghouse Electric Corporation

(" Westinghouse")pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (b)(l)of Section 2.790 of the Commission s regulations.

Withholding from public disclosure is requested with xespect to the subject information which is further identified in the affidavit accompanying this application.

The undersigned has reviewed the information sought to be withheld and is authorized to apply for its withholding on behalf of Westinghouse, STG-TOD.The affidavit accompanying this application sets forth the basis on which the information may be withheld from public disclosure by the Commission and addresses with specificity the considexations listed in paragraph (b)(4)of Section 2.790.of the Commission's regulations.

Accordingly, it is xespectfully requested that the subject information which is proprietary to Westinghouse and which is further identified in the affi-davit be withheld fxom public disclosure in accordance with 10CFR Section 2.790 of the Commission's regulations.

Correspondence with respect to this application for withholding or the accom-panying affidavit should be addressed to the undersigned.

Very truly yours,'(yu R.Williamson, Manager Customer Order Engineering

~Westinghouse Electric Corporation Attachment 2 AFFIDAViT IN SUPPORT OF APPLICATION FOR LIITHHOLDING PROPRIETARY INFORMATION FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE

~~Ref: AW%6-19 AFFIDAVIT COMMONWEAL'TH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF DELAWARE: Before me,.the und'ersigned-authority, personally appeared Robert Williamson, who, being by me duly sworn according to law, deposes and says that he is authorized to execute this Affidavit on behalf of Westinghouse Electric Corporation

(" Westinghouse")and that, the.averments of fact set forth in this Affidavit are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information, and belief: Robert Williamson, Manager Customer, Order Engineering S>corn tg.a~~~sub@rib.d before rrre HM$e ygNass~~~d>1 Of~a~~o Qo9%i~~~.~"'"Q NPY;.,E.SQUlLLACE'ielaq peb'lie)llarple Twp., Delaware Ce.Jdy Qrmrri(s'sillrr Expires Oct.18, 1980]/~~rl~><ail~"

(1)I am Hanager, Customer Order Engineering in the Steam Turbine Generator Technical Operations Division of Westinghouse Electric Corporation and as such, I have been specifically delegated the function of reviewing the proprietary information sought to be withheld from public disclosure in connection with nuclear power~plant licensing, and am authorized to apply for its withholding on behalf of the Westinghouse Power Generation Divisions.

(2)I am making this Affidavit in'conformance with the provisions of 10 CFR Section 2.790 of the Commission's,regulations and in conjunction with the Westinghouse application for.withholding accompanying this Affidavit-(3)I have personal knowledge of the criteria and procedur es utilized by Westinghouse Power Generation Divisions in designating informa-tion as a trade secret, privileged or as confidential commercial or financial information-(4)Pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (b)(4)of Section 2.790'of the Commission's regulations, the following is furnished for con-sideration by the Commission in determining whether the information sought to be withheld from public disclosure should be withheld.(i)'he information sought to be withheld from public disclosure is owned and has been held in confidence by Westinghouse.(ii)The information is of a type customarily held in'confidence by Westinghouse and not customarily disclosed to the pub-lic.Westinghouse has a rational basis for determining the types of information customarily held in confidence by it and, in that connection, utilizes a system to determine when and whether to hold certain types of information in confi-dence.The application of that system and the substance of that system constitutes Westinghouse policy and provides the rational basis required.

Under that system, information-is held in confidence if it'falls in one or more of several types, the release of which might result in the loss of an existing or potential com-petitive advantage, as follows: (a)The information reveals the-distinguishing aspects of a process (or component, structure, tool, method, etc.)where prevention of its use by any of Westinghouse's competitors without license from Westinghouse consti-tutes a competitive economic advantage over.other companies.

{b)It consists of supporting data, including test data, relative to a process (or component, structure, tool, method, etc.),.the application of which data secures a competitive economic advantage, e.g., by optimization or improved marketability.

-(c)Its use by.a competitor would reduce his expenditure of resources or improve his competitive position in the design, manufacture, shipment, installation, assurance of quality, or licensing a similar product (d)It reveals cost or pr ice information, production capac-ities, budget levels, or commercial strategies of West-inghouse, its customers or suppliers-(e)It reveals aspects of past, present, or future Westing-house or customer funded development plans and programs of potential commercial value to Westinghouse.(f)It contains patentable ideas, for which patent protec<<tion may be desirable.(g)It is not the property of Westinghouse, but must be treated as"proprietary by Westinghouse according to agreements with the owner.

(h)Public disclosure of this information would allow un-fair and untruthful judgments on the performance and reliability of Westinghouse equipment components and improper comparison.with similar components made by.-competitors-There are sound p'olicy reasons behind the Westinghouse, system which include the following: (a)The use of such information by Westinghouse gives Hest-inghouse a competitive advantage over its competitors.

'It is, therefore, withheld from disclosure to protect the Westinghouse competitive position.(b)It is information which is marketable in many ways.The extent.to which such information is available to competitors diminishes the Westinghouse ability to sell products and services.involving the use of the information.(c)Use by our competitor would put Westinghouse at a com-petitive disadvantage by reducing his expenditure of resources at our expense.(d)Each component of proprietary information pertinent to a particular competitive advantage is potentially as valuable as the total competitive advantage.

If com-petitors acquire components of proprietary information, any one component may be the key to the entire puzzle, thereby depriving Westinghouse of a competitive advantage.(e)Unrestricted disclosure would jeopardize the position of prominence of Westinghouse in the world market, and thereby give a market advantage to the competition in~those countries-(f)The Westinghouse capacity to invest corporate'assets in r esearch and development depends, upon the success in obtaining and maintaining a competitive advantage.(iii)The.information is b'eing transmitted to the Commissi'on,in confidence and, under'the pr'ovisions of 10 CFR Sec-tion 2.790, it is to be received in confidence by the Commission.

r (iv)The information is not available in public sources'to the best of our knowledge and belief-(v)The proprietary information sought to be withheld in this , submittal is that which is appropriately mar ked in Appen-dix A to letter from R.E.Uhzig to Eisenhut, dated March 19, 1980 ,, concerning infor-mation in response to NRC request for information of February 25, 1980, relative to low pressure turbine disc integrity.

The information enables Westinghouse to: (a)Develop test inputs and procedures to satisfactorily verify the design of Westinghouse supplied equipment.(b)Assist its customers to obtain licenses.Further, the information has substantial commercial value as follows.(a)Westinghouse can sell the use of this information to customers.(b)Westinghouse uses the information to verify the design of equipment which is sold-to customer s.

(c)Westinghouse can sell"services based upon the ex'per-fence gained and the test.equipment and methods developed.

Public disclosure of this information is likely to cause substantial harm to the competitive position of Westinghouse because it would enhance the ability of competitors to design, manufacture, verify, and sell, electrical equipment for commercial turbine-generators without commensurate expenses-Also, public disclosure of the information would enable others having the same or similar equipment to use the information to meet NRC requirements for licensing documentation without purchasing the right to use the information.

The development of the equipment described in part by the information is the result of many years of development by Westinghouse and the expenditure of a considerable sum of money.This could only be duplicated by a competitor if he were to invest similar sums of money and provided he had the appro-'riate talent available and could somehow obtain the requi-site experience.

Further the deponent sayeth not.

ATTACHMENT 3 RESPONSE TO NRC REQUEST FOR INFORMATION RELATED TO TURBINE DISCS SITE-SPEC IF IC GENERAL QUESTIONS I.LP Turbine design and o crating data: A.'~bi The Florida Power 8 Light Company, St.Lucie¹1 unit consists of one tandem compound four flow, three casings, condensing, 1800 RPM turbine utilizing 44 in.last row blades in each low pressure element.The low pressure element is designated as a Building Block (28l.B.Hours of o eration for each LP Turbine: Both LP rotors installed in the Unit 1 turbine had operated a total of approximately 24,120 hours0.00139 days <br />0.0333 hours <br />1.984127e-4 weeks <br />4.566e-5 months <br /> as of March 15, 1980 when the unit was taken off-line for refueling.

Based on current Westinghouse i nspection criter ia, an inspection of the Unit 1 LP rotors would be indicated based on the 5-year operating criterion rather than the P ll CI tl postulated crack size criterion.

Unit 1 will not achieve 5 years of operation on the LP rotors until mid-1982.However, in recognition of current NRC concerns as well as the potential commercial penalties associated with a disc failure, FPL will inspect the LP rotors at St.Lucie Unit 1 during the current outage.fP8L will provide the results of this inspection to the NRC when the results become available.

C.Number of turbine tri s and overs eeds: Based on the limited review predicated by the required response time, our records i ndicate that Unit 1 has undergone approximately 9 overspeed trips and 62 turbine trips from power operation.

The 9 overspeed trips were the result of required testing of the overspeed trip device, and the 62 turbine trips reported are based on records of reactor trips.As reactor trips at low power levels will not necessarily involve a turbi ne trip, this number (62)is also subject to revision.We will continue our review of existing records and advise you of any changes to this response resulting from this review.D.Information ertainin to each disc: 1.T e of material includi n material s ecifications:

The material specified is Ni-Cr-Ho-V alloy steel similar to that a aa.'trat.m~'Cl%~~"gl'r, I c tag I It'C r It'I a'Iar r~C t I'~a.I EII<<ICa'ta at*a~C C t C a~II'IC'.I I,*aa C, C t.r~I II I~M I C;t ,a II Cgr t I C I/'taC I t It Ctr a r a'lat I C~'It q~t C C'a, I t t l,<dati~(l tfC t pa taa p,at f rc Lr't I'"'t'L!'l"'ca'l Ir r f Lac I"~'I'I II I 0[f.a)a C a C.*f I~C C-.I I'tt arltar a~t I C II specified as ASTM A-471.The material properties for each disc'I ar'e included in sections A, B, and C of Appendix A (attached).

2.Tens il e ro erti es data: Tensile properties data determined from testing of hub and rim material are also included i n Sections, B and C of Appendix A.3.Toughness ro erties data i ncludi n Fracture A earance Transition Tem erature and U er Ener and Tem erature: These properties are also included in Sections B and C of Appendix A.Note that Upper Shelf Energy is not listed when the value is identical to the Room Temperature Energy.4.Ke wa tern eratures: Keyway temperatures are listed in Section G of the Appendix A data for each disc.This is the calculated temperature two inches from the exhaust face of the disc at the bore during full load operation with all moisture separator reheaters functioning.

Note that this value, as the major input into the calculation of crack growth rate, is only valid for calculational purposes for those discs which in normal operation run"wet"-Westinghouse data indicates that no bore or keyway cracking has occurred in discs that run"dry".

~f It l F C F I'<<<<: I'f b I~rv~<<N kl, lkF,F~Ill I I I,~t r>>k.<<,'N*p>>>>>>.F l~',<<t...I, lb.l k.~I I N>>v'fi k tI I I Nt'if~w f.I'l>>t"<<N, lt>>N N I'Fy tlt<<~, tlt tt I t tl Fk tt t kI't b~tb, INF<<kw,l N,N NN(.'F rF t~<<(II, t I I I@IN k F>>N i gl t'>>F't'J.'E ii 4f<<t r tl'Nl Nt.~I (NN~F I N M N~,I, F I N FNI~I N')\Nfl p N F l t I<<k N~<<l:~kl<<k)<<'N If N II kt'Itt<<FI t,~<<~, tllr>>L-llk'ttF I<<t<<kl t b i>>t.b, f t>>N>>k)N'C~kk:>>~N tt bk I 1k k N','NI<<

5.Calculated ke wa crack size for turbine o eratin time in I.B.above: See item I.D.4.The calculated crack size is a function of the estimated maximum crack growth rate, based on empirical data, and the equi pment operating hours.This value, based on current NRC criteria,'is given in Section G of Appendix A.Recent Westinghouse research and analyses have yielded conclusions that differ significantly from those values based on current NRC criteria.A summation of results pursuant to these conclusions, which also address items I.D.6, 7, and 8, is appended (Appendix B)~Our response is based, where applicable, on these conc'fusions.

6.Critical crack size: See item I.D.5.above.7.Ratio of calculated crack to critical crack size: See item I.D.5.above.8.Crack rowth rate: See items I.D.4.and I.D.5.above.

I II r III f J II H 9.Calculated bore and ke wa stress at o eratin desi n overs eed: The bore tangential stresses at design speed and design overspeed are presented in Section E of Appendix A.The values presented include the stresses due to shrink fitti ng and centrifugal force loads only.Additional analyses to include thermal stresses and pressure stresses are being performed but are presently not available..Keyway stresses vary from zero to a high fraction of yield strength.10.Calculated K data: The fracture toughness, K1C, of each disc is calculated from the Charpy V-notch and tensile data.These values, presented in Sections B.11.and C.9.of Appendix A are calculated at either h the Upper Shelf Temperature or room temperature, whichever yields the lower result.ll.Minimum yield stren th s ecifi ed for each di sc: The minimum yield strength for each disc is presented in Section B.l of Appendix A.II.Results of com leted inservice ins ections: Relative to the disc bore and keyway areas of the Unit 1 LP rotors, only visual inspections have been performed.

No significant abnormalities U.U have been noted.III.Provide the nominal water chemistr conditions for each LP turbine and describe any condenser i.nleaka es or other si nificant chan es in secondary water chemistr to this oint in its o eratin life.Discuss the occurrence of cracks in an iven turbine as related to histor of secondar water chemistr in the unit: Unit 1 does not have the capability to perform chemical analyses at the LP turbine.However, FP&L, in conjunction with Westinghouse, is conducting testing on both Turkey Point Units 3 and 4 to determine several parameters (pH, conductivity, and others)of the steam entering the LP turbines.We can provide, at your request, the results of this testing when the results beccme available.

Nominal water chemi stry philosophy and a record of condenser inleakages are, however, included in our response as Appendix C.We have been unable to identify to date any correlation between turbine disc cracking of any type and secondary chemistry.

In point of fact recent industry research indicates that disc cracking may be independent of secondary water chemistry, that is cracking may occur even in a pure steam envi rorment.IV.If our lant has not been ins ected describe our ro osed schedule and a roach to ensure that turbine cracki n does not exi st in our turbine: It is presently impossible to ensure that cracking does not exist in the Unit 1 LP rotor discs as cracki ng has been empirically proven to exist

~i r a)l(KN~)r 4 I, I ll il'Ii V I~hV V t'I~VN~~I'I t VV II)ir~Iv'I I-jvfvrv r>>Nv lr)NV'I I I Ll-" VVNV)i u N N r N I=N k.I'V~Il NV'I r I V Il~r V'I't.N VVII N I VI'I ah Vy~.V , r'NV tt>>V~I 1 l IV NN~*VVV II I'I y'I I I I,.NIC'"'V)VN Iw'l I ,NN I, h'\ll~v,v,V, N)V,v r~V),,')V in some operating LP rotor discs.However, if cracking does exist, analyses show (see items I.D.4.and I.D.5.)that the maximum expected crack size will be significantly smaller than the critical crack size at the time of the inspection as delineated in Section I.B.See also Appendix B.V.If your lant has been ins ected and lans to return or has returned to power with cracks rovide our ro osed schedule for the next turbine inspection and the basis for this ins ection schedule: This question is not applicable to St.Lucie Unit l.VI.Indicate whether an anal sis and evaluation re ardi n turbi ne missiles I have been erformed for our lant and rovided to the staff.If such an analysis and evaluation has been erformed and re orted~lease provide a ro riate references to the available documentation:

This information is included as Appendix,D.

r\&S/C t I'h APPENDIX A

~t>'F (~

ID¹: D281100601.Mc5T1iJcrkxpsc 7RopcLGR'.u LP TURB I NE D I SC INFORHAT ION A~UNIT I DENT IF ICATI I~BUILD IN G BLOCK.2e VNI.T..ST~3~CUSTOMER)FLOR'I~LP¹S, LOCATIO~.6,e D 1 SC.(l.7~TEST NOe TNI ON 281 L.VC I E¹.I.IDA PMR.LTe I GOV..L 273 8>>2e SUPP(, I ER~N!OYA f P8))ST 3e YoSe (KSI)122e000 pe U~T~S~(KSI}136e00(}ELONGATION 20:9 6~ReAe 65.9 7~FATT{DEGoF)-115 8, ReT.IHPACT{FTeLBe) 81 Ver IHPACT'TKHPe 75 DKG F).{D Oe UoS~IHPACT KNG~81 (FTjLBe)U~S~KIC 213.7 i i-ii-ital.I bee Ie YeS~(KS'I).125.500 2e U~TeS~(KSI)..140,000 3~ELONGATION

~20.6 6~RoTe IHPACT(FALSE

)i 81 7e UeSe IHPACT TEHPe 0 DKG.F}8~UeSo IHPACT E'NG~'FTeLB~)9~U~S o K I C b.a,.e i K s i o s eR J(i N>i lpga<..>J HATER I AL PROPERT I ES{HUB)C~HATER I AL PROPERT I ES{R'IH}I e-TYPE br.e TE (HIN~Y~S~Q20e0'QSI))e 3 De CHEHISTRY MN 4-Cw---b-~a--=----.h-C;e-----b-e-e D a CR i gp V t'25'253 i EQ73.008'1+2j i e I o 39 e'21$S C)e Ee BORE STRESS SPEED{RPH)STRESS 1800{KS I}2e 2160{$20$)(KSI)G~SERVI CE DATA L 69e]007 76o200$F~CRACK DATA 1~A~CReOP (1800 RPH){INe)3 02 b,c.,e 1 r,-i le OPERe TEHPe HKTAL TEHPe HUB (DKGeF)2~KSTIHATKD HAX DA/DT (IN/HR)sz~~<<ti 30ii 00iij

ID¹;028]100601.4!S5 C.iuBeouSE PINON.RIE1)AIRq LP TURB I NE 0 I SC I NFORHAT I ON Ai UNIT IDE'NTI'Fi'CATION

"""" B~" NATER1'A'L PROPER'TI'BB INUBI]~BUILDING BLOCK 28]~]~TYPE@b t~e TF (HI N e Y e S~, Fl 30~G3'(ks I))2~UN I T ST~LUC I E¹I 2.SUPPLIER,'EKTHLEHEH STEE(.3 CUSTOMER'S FL'ORIDA PNR',CT, 3"Y S'('.K'Sl),.'2 00 (~LP¹],','t~U>>T~S~(KSI)'E)9'00 5~LOCATION'OY Se ELONGAT,ION

-"-'.']8>>5'>>DISC¹2==7>>TEST NO>>TN']35E(7 FAT'T I'D'EG~F f" fOB i~O 8 R T~IMPACT(FT~LB>>)70ep 9~Vest IMPACT TEHP>>75>>0 (DEG>>.F).]0~'V'r S e IMPACT'ENG>>

'.,-70>>0 (FT>>LB'~)-.1]e U>>S>>K IC ,-20E)i56 KS I gS~R~(IN>>)),C e HATER I AL.O'RPPERT'jES 1 R IÃ)QIC)C]~Y~S~(KSI)'.2~Ue Tis>>(KSI)3'ELONGATION

=E)~.R>>.A~5.FATT (DEG.F)6~R>>T~IMPACT(FT BULBS~)..7~V~Se IMPACT.TEHP>>.(.OEG F!.(FT>>LB>>).9~U~ST KIC S I~S~~U.N cL)32;000]pe 000]7>>5 62>>6~/dgiO 7o r'0.75>>0 70op'20'(~56 DE CHEMISTRY r<>U'eJ E>>BORE STRESS SP EED-(RPH)"=-S TRESS.L'!:::~1'"'.

G~SFRY I CE DATA F~CRACK DATA]e A<<CR<<OP (]800 RPM)(IN~)*2>>A<<CR<<OS (.OYERSPEED)-(IN>>)]~OPER~TEHP~METAL TEHP~HUB,(DEG,F)

'I'"2631 2~ESTIMATED HAX DA/DT (IN/HR)'" , Lr]03<<00't$

10¹: D28 l I QQ601 (u'~s~uuc u(s(sos Peon<i'~LP TURB INE 0 I SC INFORMAT I QN O', Ao U 3 lo t 2~'i 3~3(g~Se 6e 7~B o HATER I AL PROPERT I ES (HUB)1 t TYPE b,e.,(T D (MIN o Y~So ll lo~03 (KSI))SV H 5 E NIT IDENTIFICATION BU ILD1NG BLOCK 281 UN I T.....ST o.LUC CUSTOt'(ER I FLOR I DA LP¹LOCATION D I.5C)(TE5T t<0~TN)356 L)zo,soo l38eooo lso5.62 e,6<<105oo l0 I eo 75oo lol~0 239e21 IE.¹l.....2.Pf'.L.IER,, BET LEHE5..3'MR~LTo 3e Y~Se (KSI)l USTA Se (KSI)GO'I/Sg ELONGATION 3 R~Ar 7e PATT (DEGeF)se ReTo IMPACT(FTeLBe) 9e U~So IMPACT TEMPo{DEGSF)*'l 0'o" U~S~IMPACT ENGo (FT~LBe)U~ST KIC~KSI<gqRT{Iq, 0 CD MATERIA).PROPERTIES

{RlH)b>C38 I o Y~s~(Ks I)2e Uo T~5~(KSI)3e E(.ONGAT I QN'te ReAe.6e R~Te IMPACT(FToLB

~)7~VS ST IMPACT TEHPe DEAF)(FToLB~)9~UtS~KIC.(KSI~SQRT{IN

)))2ieooo l39 F 500'l9eo 62~l.lo5.0 lol~0 75to")Ol.a 239t68-b-c;.---=---DE CHEMISTRY-=C--=---4;C-e

--L"-=S-g-a-----'-,;a=

-'-~--c-,~----b C-e-~M----,~;~----------b-~-;~--'-

---

.---NI..Lng, t~~by~SN Lg~Ln P~g p i 3 E.o BORE.SJRKSS SPEED (RPVt)STRESS 1~I SOO (KS I)G~SERVICE DATA lo OPERo TEHP~METAL TEMPo HUB (DEAF)2o ESTIMATED HAX DA/DT (IN/HR)209 f 328<<QQSJ F CRACK OA ,O ((Q l e 4 CR.OP (1800 RPH)(IN~)2~((CR OS (OVERS~Pf,D~(N~

W l ID¹l D2S1100601 gES7 Iud¹usw<d&pe~Ry LP TURB I NE 0 I SC I NFORHAT ION t L 2~3 e't~5>>7.t 6 UNI T ST~LUC I E¹I, 2>>CUSTOHER'CORIDA PMR~LT..3.LP¹LOCATION GOY 5~DISC¹6.TEST NO>>TN1225 7 f Se 9>>10>>A e UNIT I DE'NT'IF ICATION"'e HA 1~BUILDING BLOCK 2S 1 1~1 l 5 e 00'0 132>>200 21'63~0 120e0 71>>0 SO~0-Y'e S~"(KS'I)'AT>>S>>(KSI)ELONGATION E R~A~F"A TT (D E'G~F)R~T~IHPACT(FT>>LB

~)AS>>IHPACT TEHP~(DEAF)'U>>ST It(PACT EN'FT>>LBt)

U~S~,KIC (.K S I e S Q R~T(N e L)I 1~0.'93>>70 TER I AL'PROPERT'I'ES (HUB)TYPE I Qc a TD (HIN>>Y>>S>>I I IO~0$(kSI))SVPPL I ER ,'UNITED STATES STEE{.'Ce HATER I AL PROPERT IES ('R IH)1>>Y>>S~(KSI).2q U~T~S~(KSI)3~ELONGATION.

(~R>>A>>5~FATT ('DEG>>F)6>>R~T~IHPACT(FT~LB~)7~U~Se IHPACT TEHP~8~U>>S>>IHPACT~NG>>(FT>>LQ~),9~U~S~KIC (AS I oSQR<{IN eg g 20 e'(0 138>>SOO 21>>0 65>>0~120eO ,76>>0 SO~0 76>>0 205>>25-b-a-e-.S t.;OTZ j~-<-.<-D~CHEH I STR Y--C-32'-'.=C-.-OSg-

'-"'t:-;0063==='

.t:.I-.a23-..-~;-L-.~53>>--C.-I33 r:" I'-L.:-~-"-..r-'S t:=]~" L=j" Ee BORE STRESS'SPEE'D (RPH)'STRESS 1 e 1SOO 2~2160{120%)F~CRACK DATA'1>>A CR OP ()SOO RPH)(IN~)2=A CR OS{OVERSPEED)(IN'~)2~70 bee G~SERVICE DATA 1 OPFR~TEHP~HETAt TEHP HUB{DEG~F)(1 S ll~'~EST I t(ATED HAX DA jDT (I t4/HR), Le 168~005$

ID¹I D280060} 4'eSVTAAC,P(auSZ P+OP,RiSP ATq LP TURBINE DISC INFORHATION A e UNIT IDENT IF I CATION}~BU ILD I NG BLOCK 281 2~UNIT,...ST~LUCIE¹1 3e CUSTOMER(FLORIDA PMRe LTD Et~LP¹}Se LOCATION GOT(t 6 D'SC" 5 7~TEST t<0~TN}276.D IK 3~Y~S~,{KSI)t~Ve T~S~{KS I)ELONGATION At RE AD Tt PATT (DEEP(8~R~T~IMPACT(FTeLB ~)9~U e S~IHPACT Tf t1p~(DEG~F),.}O.URS.IN>ACT ENGe (FT~LBe)1!~U~ST KIC.(.K.S I.eSQRXil.ke LL Lt20500 129 F 000 21'65 e'2<<88'78'75'78iO 21}e76 Be MATERIAL PROPERTIES (HUB)'~TYPE bACY(-T D (NINe YRSe Q}Gee (KSI>)2 SUPPLIER~Ml VA HEPPEt<STQL ~TEe.!e Y e S~(K S I)2~Ue TeS~(KS I)3~ELONGATION Se,ReAe 6 ReT IHPACT(FT~LB)7~VASES IHpACT TEMPO DEGOF){FT~LB,)9e U~5~K IC (KSloSQR3'(INe)) }22 F 000!33 F 000 2}e9 68e5<<88iO ORO 95e0 232'7 b,c,a DE CHEMISTRY Ng 4 ("='-N-b c (=---I--b c-(.----Q-((D'.-<<.5 e-e-.=<<-0--.b e.e-BORE STRESS SPEED (RPM>STRE5S}e 1800 (XSI>2',2!60{)20@)(KSI)Ge SKRV ICE DATA L66e(OOJ F~CRACK QATA.1 A CR OP (1800"PH)(IN>[Et 3g~++2~6 ER~OSOYE R~PSg (D~(~'~L3~Eej lo OPERe TENT HKTAt TEHPe HUB (DK'6~F)Ze ESTIMATED HAX DA7DT (INAt'HR>~200<<05

ID¹l 0281100602 .4657 (.N.&HO.ma~Os~!S TAP,L}, A i UNI T 1DENT I'F I CAT I ON I~BUILDING BLOCK 281 2~UNIT ST~LUC I E¹I 3~'USTO(E'ER' FLORIDA PMRe'.Te S~LOCATION.GEN 6p DISC¹1 7e TEST NO'TNI 27((LP TURBINE D I SC INFORMATION Be"MATERIAL PROPERTIES (HUB)I~TYPE gee TF (MIN~Y~Se r120~0$(KSI))2e SUPPLIER,'e YeS~(KSI)VeT~Se (KSI)Se ELONGATION 6g ReAe 7~<ATT (DEGeF)8>>R~T~IMPACT(FT~LBo)ues.IMPACT TEMP>>(DEG.F)10e VeSe IMPACT ENGe (FT~LBe)U~S~KIC o(sggR(((M)J 3~5'38,500 19.1~.2:,)..-%10 84 75 84-""-2I 9.2-b(c(c f o VeSe (KSI)2~U~TeSe (KSI)3e E(ONGATION (1~Re Ae Se FATT (DER")6e RE Te IMPACT(FT~LBo)7~U~Se IMPACT TENT DEGeF}8~U~ST IMPACT..ENGe (FTeLBe)9~U~So KIC.LK$IGSQRT(I.28e 500 142~500 20.5 67 5=110 84-0.93 223~l t.C~f<ATER I AL PROPERT I ES ('R I~}b,c,e.0, CHEMISTRY t--"(-gc;c-"-~-gc;c--pOoOo~t)o.e.- ~o-"q-t)c;c -t=gbc(e;-~-'b;a,e S.S-o-e Po~(o~'E~BORE STRESS SPEED (RPN')STRESS I~1800 (KSI)69el00 2e 2160 (120$)(KS I)76e200 F'RACK DATA 1 e Ao CRt OP (1800 RPH)(IN~)2e A~CR~OS (OVERSPEED) (INe)3 PP b(c.,P Ge SERVICE DATA]b)c)c l.OPER.TEHP.HETAL TEMP.HUB (DEG,F)7 32'}3'2~ESTIHATED MAX PA/DT (IN/HR)Ie309 00 lj

.Wasr'cia,Houss-.P.Ro!cR!4 7.4'D¹.'D281100602 !ie~7'P TURB INK DISC INFORHAT ION c lt'I A~UNIT IDENT IF I CAT ION B~HATER I AL PROPERT I KS I~BVILDING BLOCK 281 I~TYPE (MIN~Y~S~30 ,2~UNIT.ST>>LUCIK.¹l......2>>SUP f'LIER I B TH 3>>CUSTOMER l f LOR IDA Pl)Re'-LT>> 3>>Y~S 4 (KS I)'t~LP¹I U>>T~S~(KSI)5~LOCATION GEN 5, ELONGATION 6..DISC¹,...,,........ 2 be ReA~7~TEST NO>>TN1353 7e FATT (DEG>>F).8~RiT>>IMPACT(FT KALB 9>>U~ST IMPACT TEMP~(DKG F)D e 13 IO>>V~Se!MPACT EhfG>>(FTe(.B~)U~S~K I C 21 I KS I ySQRTIK I Q Tf 22 (HUB)~bee TF>>Ot (KSI))LfgKM STE 13 1>>000)4(8'00 18~0 6 2.e.6~>>85>>0 76'75>>0~)76'213'8 M.>>.L)C~HATER I A(PROPERTIES (RlH)bc.e I~Y>>S~(KSI),2>>V~T~S~(KS I)3>>ELONGATION g.e.R~A~5 e F A T T (0 E G~F 6~R e T~I H P A C T (F T e L B e)7 e V e S~I H P A C T T E H P~0 E G F)(DE y)8~V~S~IMPACT ENG>>(FT.(.Be)9~V~Se KIC (.K U~NR.T.(,.I.N>.) ).3)>>000 5le500 IGLOO.654 4(~8540 76>>0 75'76,O 2]54'(8 b).c)e 0~CHEMISTRY gc,a..'.M.s" c.!.!c,",e.=c<c+'.---cc,------gc-e;-'----"4 cra-'--------23 N.I h,c,P..KS..b,G,.e-,. SB...b,a.,e...SJl bc,e,...AL.b,.e.,a.CU-.bc,a 50 j gj Q c Q 30 31 32 33 34.34 J 33 40 41 42!i 4 3 l 44.c!T E e,PORK S.TJKS.S SPEED (RPH)STRESS 2~2160 ($,2,0$)f KS.L)$86.e 200J Ge SERVICE DATA A le OPER TEMP~HETAL TEHP~HUB (DEG F)(263l 2~KSTIHATED HA)(DA/DT (IN/HR)L>>103~00'IJ F~CRACK DAJA-I r A CR OP 1800 RPH)(IN>>).2>>A~CR~OS OVERSPEND (IN>>J Ll~8+5 0 I1 J I ea e I D¹(0281100602 ~.LYCEE.7)A@,Hoed ..HPP+86TA+P (.P TURBINE DISC INFORMATION O', HATER'1 A{;"PR'OPERT1ES AfUB)'C t MATER I AL PROPERT IES (R IH)1~TYPE lHIN~Y~Se 10~0 (kSI))'Ae ONI T lDENTIF1CAl'ION BUILD I NG B(.OCK 281'~UN I T STo LUCIE¹I Ze SUf PLIER, B THL HEH STEEL 3~CUSTOMER t'LORIDA" P'WR'e"'LTy'3p'Y~St'(K'S'I')LP¹1..f, Ue T,Se (KSI)5e LOCAT10N GEN.5, ELONGATION 6e DISC¹3 AA G~A~At~TEST NO~.'N1355 Te FATT (DELFT Bt RE Tt IHPACeT(FTGLBe) 9t UfSe IMPACT TEMP~(DEG F((D,"DeGe (((FACT ENG~(FT BULBS~)lie U~S~KIC-KSI SQRT{N))-4-c-e-----=-lo Y~5~{KSI)Z~U~TeSe lKSI)3.ELONGATION G~A~Ge PATT (DEAF'(6~RGT~IMPACT(FT~LBe)Io U.S, IMPACT TEHPo..(DEG,F)8~'~Se I"HPA'CT ENGe{F T~(-B.)9e UeS~KIC U<$I't S{LRT~1 N o O')7enOO 132e000 ZOe0 hht3 G 100eO 98~0 75'98'232ol8 De CHEMISTRY i C gnn..I,ca.~c,a, (ea,..(.,c,a.e-I.fS.0{1 130 F 000 20p0 67t7>>100e0 98eO 75e0 98 GO" 229 F 37.I.,~b,c.,e..),c,e...,~<c.,e.T,c,e.L,>-,e J L J 3 Lt"" ED BORE STRESS SPEED (RPH')STRES S F~CRACK DATA 1~1800 (KSI 2~2160{(20')(KSI)66~000 1~A CR~OP.(1800 RPH)(1N)Zo A CREDOS e(OVERSPEED) (Itive)'f e02 G~SERVICE DATA 1~OPER~TEMP~METAL TEMP~HUB (DEG F)t 209t 2o ESTIMATED HAX DA/DT (IN/HR)'e328~005J 'b t ID 0', D28]]00602 ihlfsTLN&(HPvsB,. lPRoNRIETARQ .LP TURB INE D I SC I NFORHAT ION 2~3~Re 5~.6~7 o UNIT CUSTOHFR)LPN LocAT ION D I SC().TEST NO~ST.(UCIE)(]..FLORIDA PM'TD 1 GEN TN]229 A o UN I T I DENT IF I CAT ION 8 1~BUILD ING BLOCK 281 HATER I AL PROPERT'IES (HUB}]~T"PE b.c,e (HIN~YeSe tl]ooog'Ksl)2 Supel IER>.N I TED.STATES 3~Y~S~(KSI)0~T~Se (KSI)5~ELONGATION 6~RoAe 7o FATT (DEGeF)8~ReT~IHPACT(FTeLB ~)9e U~S~IHPA'CT TEHP~(DE DEG F)~.)oe U~S~IHPACT ENGe (FTeLBe}I, UoS.Klc (KS.I OSQRT.(.IN ~LL, TD)TEE]]'(~200]32o'(00 21'63eo<<105~0 76eo 80eo 7beo 200')-4 ca-,-=----]~YES (KSI)2~U~Tes~(KSI)3o FLONGAT I ON ('F}'~FATT DEG~6e ReTo IHPACT(FTeLB 7e Ues~IHPACT TEHPo OEG F)(DE 8e UeS~IHPACT FNG~(FTeLBe)9e Ver KIC (KsloSaRT,(e)l.¹e 3.)...C e H ATE R I A L P R'P P ER T I E S (R I M)t 18e500 35 F 100.20eO 63eO"1'O5 e 0 75oo Oeo 75,O 202e30-b-C, g=------De CHEHI STRY-=-=------=-I C.=e--=L e27JLpg g S-?L>C.<, P, e g<----, i C*H'~C-e-.-=----.--'C-e --t-~I--=-<<bc-e---=-S--o c=e-3~39 bee-----S'-'-=-b c-e----b-e;e-=-.=-

---

s-t e-------.g-b c-.e--BORE STRESS SPEED (RPH)STRESS Fo CRACK DATA]~A<<CR<<OP (1800 RPH}(I N~)SERVICE DATA lo OPER~TEHP~HETAL TEHPo HUB (DEG,F)2e EST IHATED HAX DA/DT (IN/HR}b,c)a e]68<<OO gl"L 4 ID¹l D281100602 4I&s77$cvh'oos6....A...Pi~RIE'TARcf LP TURB I NE D I SC I NFORMAT i ON)0 A e UNI T I DENT IF I CAT I ON I~BUILD 1NG BLOCK 281 2 e UNIT ST~LUC I E 3e CUSTOHER e=FLORIDA PM'f~LP¹5~LOCATION 6 DISC¹7e TEST NO~"=TNI'275 8~"HA TER I AL PROPERT I ES ('HUB')I e TYPE bye TD (MINe YES'3.10,0$

(KSI))HEPPENSTALL Ce MATERIAL PROPE'RT IES ('R lH)1'15.000 130.:000 2-2'.-6='6-:8 0.0 I e YiSe (KSI)2~U~TeSe (KSI)3e ELONGATION ')p ReA~5~FAYT (DEAF)6~ReT~IMPACT(FELON )7~UeS~IMPACT TEMP~(DEAF)Be ueso IMPACT ENG." (FTeLBe}9e UeSo Klc , WXSI~S.ART.(LN,}'92.0 199.54)¹I 2e SUPPLI c.R..DPAL R~LT" 3e YeSo'(KSI)"'14,00 I'le Ue T~Se (KSI)129 000 GEN 5e ELONGATION 22 6~RiA~7i FATT (D'ELF)" Be ReT~lMPACT(FTeLB,) j5"0 9e OeS~IMPACT TEMP~75.0 (DEGpF)10e U~Se IHPACT ENGe (FTeLBe).-il f y';)U~S e.'K I C'" 198~75~+Sf.4eSqRT (IN e.J), De CHEHI STR Y C MN Sl t..25 g't.'27j L'04 j P CR HO~V I.007]~+t 1,61$-+'~$38 7'$103 Nl AS-..-SB SN-==I--i=-----=----g-e=-----------g-a-e 4p Q i+t 3't,0024 3 e'ED BORE STRESS'SPEED (RPH}STRESS"*" Fe C~ACK DATA CU b-c-8 I S t.010T--b-c-, e Ie 1800 (KSI)Z, 2169 (IZOS)(KSI)G~SERVICE DATA 58 F 200]bbe}OOJ lo A<<CR<<OP (1800 RPH)fiNe ze A<<CR<<QS (OVLQRSPEED) (Ih'3.76 I~'5~L2 833 HUB (DEGeF)I 188 l HR)ge200<<0053, I~OPER~TEMP~METAL TEMP~2~EST I HATED HAX DAI DT (IN/

ID¹(D281 100603 (V E.S~IA~I<OV58'=..P.ROPBlE'7ARg'P TURBINE DISC INFORHATI ON A~1 2 3'{5 6 7 UNIT IDENTIFICATION o BV ILD ING BLOCK VNI T...--., ST.~LUC~CUSTOHERI FLORIDA~LP¹(;OCATION~.DISC({.TEST NO~TN1277 281 IE¹I, Ph'RE LTD 2'O/.l BE MATERIAL 1 e TYPE (MIN~2~SUPPL I 3~Y>>S>>(U~T~So ELONGA 6~R~A~7~PATT (8>>RENT>>I 9>>U~Se I'V'0, V>>S>>I 11>>U>>ST K ER>>H/DYALHCP KSI)(KSI)T ION 120~SOO 136<<000 21'66 F 6~90'79'75>>0 DEAF)MPACT(FBIB ~)HPACT TEHP>>..(DEG>>F).HPACT ENGo (FT~LBr)IC (KS,I..e SQ.R.T.(IN.>>l.t 79>>0 209>>68 PROPERTIES (HUB)bee TE AS>>Q 20'(KSI))I f'TAL b----1>>Y>>S~(KSI)r 2>>U~T~Se{KSI)3>>ELONGATION R~A.~.~.....Se FATT (DEAF 6~R AT~IMPACT(FT>>LB'~ )7e U~Se IMPACT TEHP~(D.EG;F.).8.U.S.IMPACT ENGe (FT>>LB,)9>>UeS>>KIC (KSIOSQRJ(INy)) 120~SOO 137 F 000 21>>7 66>>6 90>>0 88>>0 0>>0 88<<0 222'8 0~CHEMISTRY Q-~...N gg-'Q=Q+'+Q QDQ 6'0 0>>29]'L.>>30'~L>>06)p L>>007'i Ll>>86)>L~39-J>>Q~13/--p-p--~bo e.-~-'.>-gb,o-,e.- --Loooo)qgbce- -L->>Nogoqbc;e -L-"-"-~-ba;.e -L,o)qgbo;e y-,o fog b-,c,e BORE STRESS SPECD (RPH)STRESS 1~1800 (KSI).2 r 2,1&0.(.1 20%.)...-.(.KS I.)L76.~3QOJ..F~CRACK DATA 1~A~CR~OP (1800 RPH)(IN>>)-f 2>>89l S"CR Q~O~ER5fMCPJ J3S L=.LZ~3 1J G~SERV ICE DATA 1~OPER~TEHP~METAL TEHP~HUB (DE'G~F)(37'{l Ze ESTIMATED MAX DA7DT (IN('Hg)'>>309~00'Ig 0 4!a,Snu;used~ Pr'ro~ri~a) ID¹)D281100603 (.P TURB INE D I SC INFORHAT I ON A~UNIT IDENT-F ICATIONB'A'TER I AL PROPERTIES (HUB')BUILD 1NG BlOCK 281~1.T Y PE-bae TF (HINe Y~5~Q30r0)'(KSI))2~UNIT ST~LUCIE¹I 2~SUPPLIER(BETHLEHEM STEEL 3 CUSTOMER)"" FLORIDA PWR"l:T'Y(KS1)9')'0'f~LP¹2 U~T~St (KS I')~)58e500 5e LOCATION GOY 5~ELONGATION 17e5 6, DISC(t 2 7~i TEST" NO~TN1357 8~R4Tt IMPACT(FTtLB ~)69eO U~ST IMPACT TEMPe 75eO o (DEG,F)=f0 e U~S'e IMPACT E'N'G e 69eO (FT~LBt)UeSe KIC (KSPoSQRT(INt))'e HAT'ER I Ag PRO?ERT'IES=(R I'H"j ,f~V~S~(NS I)2~U~TeSr (KSI)3e ELONGATION (e ReAe 5.FATT (DEG.F)6t R~T~IHPACT(FT~LBe)7~U~ST IMPACT TEHPe.iso Fi (FTeLB,)9~U~S~KIC (KS1 OSqRT (I.N)S3-;000 158 F 000 17e5 63r0 95eO 69tO 75t0 69"t 0 210'9 De CHEMISTRY S---I-oooo'---~- --g4~.-~-~-'-q-;ois j ED BORE STRESS SPEED (RPH)STRESS=" le 1800 (KSI)f77o000j 2~2160 (120%)(KS I)J 85 t 200)b,c,e F~CRACK DATA I~A>>CR>>OP (1800 RPH)(IN~)toe a 2'$2e'CR>>OS (OYERSPEED) (lN)-lt76 Ge SERVICE DATA':~1~OPER~TEMP METAL TEHPe HUB (DEAF)f" 2633 2t ESTIHATED HAX DA/DT (IN/HR)Le))l>>DORY I I ....W~lNC HOOSG'eil')Eia mATq.ID 0: D28}}00603 LP TURBINE DISC.INFORMATION Ze.UNIT 3o CUSTOMER(LPP LOCATION 6 D I SC()7~TEST NO~ST~LUCIE))}FLOR IOA PMR~LT 2 GOV TN}359 A o UNIT IDENT IF ICATION 1 o BUILD I NG BLOCK 281 2 t 5",PPL I ER.l BWT9LEHE)'.l Sj't YoSt (KSI)~U~T o S~(KS I)5o ELONGATION 6 RtAo 7t FATT (DEGoF)8t RtTe IMPACT(FT LBo)9o UtS~IHPACT TEHPt.l.0.E.G.~.E.l.le VEST IMPAET ENSE (FToLB~)l}o U~ST KIC'K.SI+SqRLL I,N~)L l3oSOO}30eOOO le 5 62 e.l<<90iO 1}2~0 75e0}12o0 2'(5~6'(B, HATER I AL PROPERT IES AIUB)I~TYPE bc,e TD (HIN~Y~St Pl}0~03 (KSI))EE C~MATERIAL PROPERTIES (RIH)t bc)e-}e Y~Se (KSI)2~U~ToS~(KSI)3~ELONGATION R A~Rt~.Se FATT (DEGei)6t RE Te IMPACT(fToLBo) 7~U~ST IHPACT TEMPS (DEG.t F)...8o UoSt IMPACT EN'f T~(.B~)9~U~5~KIC.(K,S I o S Q f}T(I N t,3)123o500}SO.OOO 20t0 6I tS<<90oO}}ZoO.75oo l}2'255e63 0~CHEHI STRY.g-8-~-Q g.-=~Q Q-==a.~gp.---~~y-c--s--gQ,lA)---<<-L~22 l'L 29 J'.C 0}3'L o008 J't}~63 3 Q'}8 g't}OJ C.G-----At"-)4---=----=--al-=----"--=ut-~-=---."-~-=---bC-e,----b)Q.).K Et BORE.STRESS SPEED (RPH)STRESS 66 F 000 3 73'OO/F~CRACK DATA Gt SERVICE DATA lo OPER~TEMPe METAL TENT HUB (DEG 2e ESTIMATED HAX DA/DT (IN/HR),s l g Sos]I~0 1 l t ID¹l D28 1]00603>QEss-(I(c.Hous.r=. 'owa(.cr6p(,(4, LP TURB I NE DISC I NFORHAT I ON A~UNIT I DENT IF I CATIONt'HATER I AL PROPERTIES (HOB)I~BUILDING BLOCK 281'I t TYPE b,n,(TD (MINt Y~St l I]0>>0)'tKSI))2~UNIT ST>>LUCIE¹1'~SUPPLIER((TNI TED STATES TEE fe U~T~S~(KSI)137'00 5~LOCATION GOV ELONGAT ION 19.0 6, DISC¹f 6~R>>AD 60'7i TEST NO~N]227-7, FATT (DEG.F)=1 f5 0'~R>>T~IMPACT(FToLB ~)68>>0 AS>>IMPACT-TEHP~80e0 (0EG~Fl (0~'0~S~I RP A C T EWG~A 0, 0 (FT>>LB~)ll~U>>ST KIC 192~95 (KS I oSQR~T f f(I>>))C~RA>ERI A<PROPER>I ES TRIH>'l~Y>>5~f KS I), 2~U~T>>S~(KSI)'3~ELONGATION 'f~R~A~5>>,F'ATT (DEAF")6, R.T, IMPACT(FT>>LB.) 7~U>>ST IHPACT TEMP>>(DEGoF)8e U~ST IHPACT Ehl6e (FT>>LB'~).,9~U~S>>K I C]2'l t 606 l 36~IOO 2]00 66>>0~I I(5>>0'7>>0-0~6 67'92e Efb DE CHEHISTRY C MN L>>2~J S.I.SG-)-,00 L"-..-)--,0;-t--=-00TR~-;<;0- -(-~P j L J't~0'(G]ED BORE STRESS SPEED'RPH)'ST'RESS]~]800 (KSI)2, 2160 t120)f;)(KSI)F, CRACK DATA I A CR OP, (l 800 RPH)(IN~)2 671 2>>A~CR>>OS (OVERSPEED) (Itkt)2>>06)Gt SERVICE DATA lt OPER~TEHP~METAL TEMP~HUB (DEAF)P]8]3 2~ESTIMATED MAX DA/DT (IN/HR).L>>168 OOSJ C I D¹: D281100603 KV~aSZi&6>WS< -.PBOPRI82&fRg LP TURB I NF-D I SC INF ORMAT1ON A~1 2 3't 5 6 7 UNI T IDENT IF I CATION o BUILD IN G BLOCK 281 UNIT-.S3'.>>LVCIE.-¹1 o CUSTOt<ER 1 FLOR I OA PMRe{.T~LP¹2~LOCAT I Ot4 GOV DISC¹, 5~TEST NO~TN1279 8~2>>.SVPPL IER1 OVALE HE V>>T>>Se (KSI)ELONGATION tt>>A~FATT (DEG>>F)a R>>T~IHPACT{FT~LB'~)U~ST IMPACT TEMP>>(OEG,F)IJeSe IHPACT ENG>>(FT~LBe)V~Se-KIC.M.K.S1>>Sq.R.I (.I.N>>,))b,c,e 1~Y~S~{KSI)2~U~T~S~(KSI)3>>ELONGATION '{~R~A~6~RE Tt IMPACT(FT BULBS~)'~UPAS>>IMpACT TEtkp~(.O.EG.F){FT~LBr)9~U~St KIC (K9feSggJ(1Ne })3 5 6 16>>00 132.500 21~8 69t7=100,0 72'75'7 8 9 10 72.0 195>>-95 MATERIAL PROPERTIES (MUB)'a MATERIAL PROPERTIES {RIH)1a TYPE bee TD{MINa Y~So 110~0){KSI))PP N TAL 113~0o0}2S,500 22'.68'-.-'1 00.-0 93'0>>0 93'222t79 De CHEMISTRY'j<<'i"'" g'""=g<Lt25J>>L~27 J'+L~0't 3>>L>>0073'Ll>>61/>>L>>383'Ct)OJ N.I b,c,,e..A S E>>.BORE STRESS SPEED{RPtj)STRESS F CRACK DATA le 2 t 1800 2160.{120g,) 1~A~CR OP{1800"PM)(IN~)2~A~CR~OS{OVERSPEED)(IN)p 6ca Go SERVICE DATA}o OPER~TEHp~HETAL TEMP~HUB (DEAF)t 1881 2 EST1HATEO HAX DA/OT{IN/t(R)'200-005$ gt I$I/ ID 0: D28110060'(e gCS~T&~K E~JTO&~l87 e¹e FOCI.LP TURB 1 NE 0 I SC I NFOR)lAT I ON=A~UN'I T IDENT'I'F I CAT ION I~BUILD ING BLOCK-281 2 U¹1 T ST~LUC I E¹l 3;s CUSTDRER'l FLDR'lDA FRRe LT'5t LOCAT ION GEN 6I DISC¹l 7~TEST RD-Twl27¹.Bi MATERIA'l.'R'OPERTIES (HUB)1~TYPE.g bee (H I N~Y~5 y 6 20~03'KS I 2~SUPPLIER)HlDVALE HEPP 3~'Y'Se'(KSI)'(~Ut TSSe (KSI)5~E(.ONGATION bg RyA~7y FATT (DE'6')8 RtT~IHPACT(FT~LB)U~ST IMPACT TEMP~(DEAF)(Og Uy"S~17(PACT-E'NGe (FTSLBy)llt U~Se KIC (KSIeSQRT(IN ))e I TE))ENSTALL'120y500 ,136 F 000 2 l e'2&&i&<<O'0 e'0 79'75'79eO 209 AD&8.b)c,e l~Ye S~'(KS I).2e U~T.~S~(KSI)3~ELON G AT 10)l.E(~R e A~5e FATT (DEGep)&t R AT~IHPACTtFT~LBe)7t Ver I('(PACT TEMP~(DEGeF)8~U~S e I H p'A C T""EN6 e (FTeLB~)9e U~S~KIC 120 e 500 137 F 000 Zlt7 6&j6~90e0 88tO OeO 8'8iO 222f De CHE'HISTRY 4 n m 4 n L¹D Wg~QQ,~..+b>Q,LCD ,.~,Q.AC~,~..)C)r.c D.;¹Sq~¹<--'L-"-g~¹'R=-Le¹OTS?--l;DTSQ'~5-t..V'i l'C o'TD3 Et BORE STRESS S P E E D (R P H.)=" S T R E S S F~CRACK DATA I e 1800 2e 2l b0 (I ZOX)(KSI), (KSI)69 l OO l~>C)+76'00J le A CR OP (1800 RPH)(lN~)2~A~CR~OS t OVERSPEED)(I N~)Ge SERVICE DATA le OPFR~TEHp~METAL TEMPS HUB (DEGeF)I'2(l 2~ESTIMATED HAX DA/OT (IN/HR).(¹309~00'(J

P I D¹I D281 10060'I LP TURB INE D I SC INFORMATION A VNTT tDENTIF ICATION 1~BU ILD1NG BLOCK 2~UN I T ST e LUC I E 3r CUSTOHER9 FCORIDA PN RE LP¹5~LOCATION 6~DISC¹=7'e TEST NOe"" TN]360 B,=K'ATER I AL PROPERTIES (H'UB)TYPE bee TD (Hl N e Y~S~t.110~03 ('KS I))2e SUPPLIER(BETHLEHEH STEEL 281¹)R e;CTr, 3 e Y'e'5~.(KS I)2 , 9~UtTeSe (KSI)GEN 5e ELONGATION 3 6t R'e A~7~FATT (DEGeF")Be RiT~IMPACT(FTeLBe) 9~UtSe 1HPACT TENT (DEG~F)(FBI.Bt}-11~UtS~KIC LKS3~$&DJ N;g)13ef0 130 F 000'62yl~90'112'75eO 112'2'l5e69 C~HATER 1 AI.PROPERT I ES-.{R rn)2t U~TeSe (KSI): 3~ELONGATION 9 or Re A~S.9AVV rOES.F)6~RE Te 1HPACT{FT~LBr)7e U~Se IHPACT TEHPe (QEG~Fl (FT!LBr'}~9e U~ST KIC L~I eSQRR I~N~123 F 500'-Sot000 20e0 67'~90 r 0 112t0 75eO ll2~0'-255'3 De CHEMISTRY C Qe22J'e'e~'z'9 Je'Q e t',or>4<@C',oas'5 ceo'>.gag'Qi t',9s g e e~.>o"3'e>~t 3 6$]Qb 0;e P"q Qo 9Q$4iQE g-.~b-,c;,e -'~g b,s;e~~-u;a-,e -L-~QQ9 J b;Q e ED BORE STRESS=--SPEED-(RPH) --STRE'SS--=-F~CRACK DATA 1~1800 2e 2160 (120%)KSI 66,000 A~CRr OP.(1800 RPH)(IN,)2e A~CR9 OS.(OVERSPEKD) I.INr)tq oq]L,c,,e Ge SQRY ICE DATA'1~OPKR~TKHPe HEVAL TEHPe HUB.(DEAF) (2093 Zt KSTIHATKD HAX DA7OT{fN/HR),./F328005/ ' ID¹;D28{)0060{4lesTTATcmusc %or Toi zTAe: q 3{Je Ae UNIT IDENT lf ICATION I~BUILD I NG BLOCK 281 2..UPI.T.ST..LUC.IE.y.)3~CUSTOMER;-.FLOR IDA PMR~,LT~LP¹2 Se LOCATION GEN 6e DlSC){.7~TEST NO~TN1220 LP TURB I NE D I SC I NFORHAT ION B~HATER I AL PROPE'RT I ES (HUB)I~TYPE b,e,,e (HI N~Y~S e tl I 0 e 0$(KS I 2 SUPPL,.IER I UH,I TED/TAT/39 YiSS (KSI)'{~Ve Te S~(KS I)5f ELONGATION 6e R'eA~7e FATT{DEAF)8 R AT IMPACT(FT~LBf)9, Ves, IHPACT TEHPe{DEAF l/Oeee~e S~IRPACT ERGe (FTOLB~)I I e V~Se KIC{.K P.I.e S.Q 8:U I.N.RJJ TD))ST.EE.L 23e100 IS{0~'{00 20fO 63q0<<I')0'63eO 8090 6390 187eOS C~MATERIAL PROPERT 1ES (RIM)l,c-,e------.Ie YES.~(KSI)Ze VATES'KSI)" 3~ELONGATION ReA~ef R~Tf IMPACT{FTRLB~)7~U~Se IHPACT TEMP~{O.r.G F.)..(FTeLB~)9~U~ST KIC LKS I eSQB.T{IN e..)..)239600'{I~900 1990 6{e0<<I{OR 0 6"~0 ORO 6'{e0" 189'03 DE CHEMISTRY 9 IQ T Ee BORE STRESS SPEED{RPH)STRESS 1800{KSI)Ies.800l Fg CRACK DATA 1 e A CR OP{1800 RPM){IN~)'~'{9 Ge A'RS OVERSPEE~O(3AeJGe SERVICE DATA:: "'I~OPER~eTERP~SETA'EMP~HUS, TOES').T 18)l O C+" 2~EST I HATED HAX DA'/PT{IN/HR)Le 168<<005/ wt\r 1 3~,e ID tt'281)0060'{ QGST)L3G gyes))W L~)ETR>TEKthTA)A, LP TURB I NE D I SC I t<FORHAT I ON" A'-,-UNIT-IDENT IF I CATION---8,'ATER I aL PROPERT'lES-(HUB) 1~8U I LD I NG BLOCK 281 I e TYPE gc,e{HING Y~Se Q IOGGl (KSI 2~UN I T ST~LUC I E{t I 2~SUPPL I ER,'l DVALE HEPP 5~LOCAT ION GEN 5e ELONGATION 6e DISCtt 5.6e R~A~7 TEST NO=TH}280==7 F'ATT ('DEG F)8 R AT~IHPACT(FT BULBS~)9~U~S~IMPACT TEHP~8)OEG,F)10e eel Ge fHPACT ENG~(FALSE)11~-UeSe KIC{KSIoSQRT(IN ))e.eTD))ENSTALL'1138500 128~500 20e2 58.y I 120'85'75o0 8580 212~17 Ce t<ATER I AL PROPERTIES ('R IH).)>, C,G.le YGS~(KSI)2~U~T~S~{KS'I)3~ELONGATION HADAL 5e FATT (DEG F')6~ROTE IHPACT{FTGLB ~)'~U~So, IHPACT TENT (DEGoF[8~U~ST IHPACT ENGe{FTeLSe).9~U~Se KIC" l)7'On 31 F 500 22o0 70e9->>}20'0-107o5 OGO 10722{3 e 85'e CHEHISTRY c)3eG')]5'~eOOTT=JL",OT2$.L~'Oe)'Q~eOTOQ ED BORE STRESS SPEE'0 (RPH)STRESS F~CRACK DATA 2 le 1800 2~2160 (120g)(KSI)(KSI)58'001 66.100)1e A CR-OP (1800 RPH}'IN'~)2~A~CR~OS (OVERSPEED (it{)'828 Ge SERVICE DATA 1~OPERe TEHP~HETA<TEHP~HOG)OEG,F)1" 1881 2e EST}HATED HAX DA/DT (IN/HR)QG200 005' 0 J~4 APPENDIX B ~k I r wE wI uc'used mamic~~em')fL r LP.i,, gv 4;2.3....O'Avid.195 lO PgxlQ.Qg7,xlQ Roe.tm I.o l2.~~i~Q$r 4T'LUc.lR'.UNMg@HQP+u>C Qgp, , dA gt~~~qG)cking&M~TH~lMGP 4,~,~b,c,~Z42 1.R 34'266'.A b,c,e.~~i 0,~/~CQ..4.'1 22-G3.C8:--(CP I;LPl.-6Ekl I, LP2.CB}1 p;l ,23..;5 , I ,I..'2..;5.'r..m (o~.l65xlo W2xlD.QgxlQ PuM DAY.Mx(i)~.RdxlQ ,42xt6.'KZ io Rue Gh', xi@.1SS~lQ.4%<15.252>lb 8ous Chr b,c,~I 1,c,a'.1-Z....-12.0&'l.1'1'.45 l.l'2 cia l2.04 l;c~h,c,e,Q-56 l.55 5.8.RK'-61 882 g-Os"2-Sl 3 62)-91 ll b,cF.20.o4.05.53."tb.'23.63.G3 bc@,=b,c,~r r~',c,z I+4T Dm<cA avB2SPBHO'~) APPENDIX C St.Lucie Unit 1 has utilized AVT for secondary chemistry control throughout the life of the plant.A summary of Unit 1 condenser inleakages follows: 5-19-77 5-19-77 9-28-77 9-30-77 10-4-77 1-3-78 1-7-78 1-31-78 2-6-78 APPENDIX 0 0 t t ie 4 l.~ The consequences of turbine failure for St.Lucie Unit 1 has been reviewed by the AEC during the operating license stage.The document which addressed turbine missiles in detail was PSAR Revision No.13 dated July 15, 1973.Potential turbine missile sources and the method of turbine missile A protection for safety related structures and equipment axe provided in FSAR Section 3.5.3.2 b'.AEC position on acceptance of turbine missile design is provided at Section 3.5 in the Safety Evaluation of the St.Lucie Plant Unit No.1 dated November 8, 1974. ev STATE OP PLOBXDA))COUNTY OP DADE)ss H.A.Adoma t , being first duly sworn, deposes and says: That he is Executive Vic~praa~r~ J-, of Flori.8a power 6 Light Company, the Licensee herein;That he has executed the foregoing document;'that the sLate-ments mad in this said documenL are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information, anQ belief, and that: he is authorized to execute the document: on behalf of said Licensee E.A.Adomat Subscribed and sworn to before me this NOTARY PUBLXC, in and for the County of Dade, 8 tate 0 f Florida NOTARY PVBUC STATE OF FLORIOA st LARGE MY COMMISSION EXPIRES AVOVST 24, ISGI expires: RCNCEo TNRv NIAYNARo RCNCINa P'SENZ 4/s I ~v, fy I F V x!.g}}