ML20141H823: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Adams | |||
| number = ML20141H823 | |||
| issue date = 12/13/1985 | |||
| title = Insp Rept 99900054/85-01 on 850930-1004.Violations Noted: Evaluation of Defects Not Being Performed Adequately. Nonconformances Noted:Svcs Procured from Two Sources Not on Approved Vendors List | |||
| author name = Harper J, Merschoff E | |||
| author affiliation = NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) | |||
| addressee name = | |||
| addressee affiliation = | |||
| docket = | |||
| license number = | |||
| contact person = | |||
| case reference number = REF-QA-99900054 | |||
| document report number = NUDOCS 8604250049 | |||
| package number = ML20141E221 | |||
| document type = INSPECTION REPORT, MANUFACTURER/VENDOR/ENGINEER, INSPECTION REPORT, NRC-GENERATED, TEXT-INSPECTION & AUDIT & I&E CIRCULARS | |||
| page count = 2 | |||
}} | |||
See also: [[see also::IR 05000930/2010004]] | |||
=Text= | |||
{{#Wiki_filter:__ . . | |||
. . | |||
- | |||
. | |||
. | |||
ORGANIZATION: DPESSER INDUSTRIES, INC. | |||
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA | |||
CEPORT INSPECTICN INSPECTION | |||
NO.- | |||
. | |||
99900054/85-01 DATE(S): 09/30/85-10/04/85 ON-SITE HOUPS: 50 | |||
' CORRESPONDENCE ADDRESS: Dresser Industries, Inc. | |||
ATTN: B. G. Bronson, OA Manager | |||
Post Office Box 1430 | |||
Alexandria, Louisiana 71301 | |||
ORGANIZATIONAL CONTACT: Mr. B. G. Bronson, QA Manager | |||
TELEPHONE NUMBER: (318) 640-2250 | |||
PRINCIPAL PRODULT: Nuclear Safety arid Sdfety Relief Valves | |||
NUCLEAR | |||
business is INDUSTRY ACTIVITY: | |||
supplying valves Less facilities. | |||
for nuclear than 5% of Dresser Industries ( Alexandria) | |||
ASSIGNED INSPECTOR: \i r,m | |||
c .t # | |||
J. Cd Harper, Reactiv6 Inspection Section (RIS) Date | |||
OTHER INSPECTOR (S): L. D. Vaughan, Program Coordination Section (PCS) | |||
,. ,f /7' | |||
APPROVED BY: / -- | |||
re . , 3 6- | |||
E. W. MerschofVfhief, RIS Date | |||
INSPECTION BASES AND SCOPE: | |||
A. BASES: 10 CFR Part 21 and 10 CFR Part 50 Appendix B. | |||
B. SCOPE: | |||
To ensure that valves, model 7150 and 7250, Class 1 and 2 are | |||
being supplied to Fort Calhoun in accordance with established comitments. | |||
In addition, to ensure that valves and valve spare parts are supplied by | |||
Dresser to the nuclear industry in accordance with established QA | |||
procedures, applicable codes ( ASME Section III) and standards (Appendix | |||
B to 10 CFR Part 50.) | |||
PLANT SITE APPLICABILITY: | |||
Fort Calhoun, 50-285; Perry Nuclear, 50-440, 50-441; | |||
Davis-Besse, 50-346;'Diabl'o Canyon, 502275, 50-323. | |||
kop20o49e60413 | |||
999000$99 ENVDagy | |||
PDR | |||
__ | |||
_ | |||
~ | |||
. | |||
. | |||
ORGANIZATION: CRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC. | |||
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA | |||
REPORT INSPECTION | |||
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 2 of 7 | |||
A. Inspection Issues | |||
The inspection was conducted to determine whether rodels 7150 and 7250 | |||
Class 1 and 2 valves are being fabricated and supplied to Fort | |||
Calheun in accordance with the established Dresser QA and CC | |||
commitments. Dresser is supplying these valves as part of the Fort | |||
Calhoun outage work package. During the inspection, observations were | |||
made on the fabrication of other valves and valve spare parts that are to | |||
be supplied to the nuclear industry. The survey consisted of ensuring | |||
that there is proper implementation of Dresser QA procedures, applicable | |||
codes ( ASME Section III) and standards ( Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50.) | |||
B. Inspection Findings | |||
1. Violations . | |||
\ | |||
Contrary to section 21.21 of 10 CFR Part 21, evaluations of | |||
defects are not being performed adequately to determine if they | |||
merit reporting in accordance with 10 CFR 21. A review of | |||
Dresser's Part 21 procedure (#003.00 dated March 28, 1984) and | |||
Part 21 evaluation files for 1984 and 1985 concluded that as a | |||
result of an inadequate evaluation on file no. 84-01, Dresser | |||
failed to notify the NRC or its customers of a reportable Part 21 | |||
item (85-01-01). | |||
2. Nonconformances | |||
a. Contrary to Criterion VII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50, | |||
and Dresser Industries QAM, Section 6 paragraph 6.,1 and 6.2, | |||
Dresser procured services from two sources that were not on an | |||
approved vendors list (85-01-02), | |||
b. Contrary to Criterion V!1 of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50, | |||
and Dresser Industries procedure QTI-13, paragraph 3.6, | |||
Dresser failed to perform receiving inspection on 4 | |||
containers of type 7018 nuclear weldina rods (85-01-03). | |||
c. Contrary to Criterion XII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50, | |||
and Dresser Industries procedure QIT-33, paragraoh 9.0b, | |||
calibration of the Charpy V-Notch Impact Testing Machine has | |||
not been performed during the last five years (85-01-04). | |||
' | |||
. | |||
w | |||
__ | |||
. I | |||
, | |||
l | |||
l | |||
ORGANTZATiON: CRESSER INDUSTRIES, 'NC. | |||
. | |||
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA | |||
REPORT INSPECTION | |||
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 3 of 7 | |||
d. Contrary to Criterien XII of Appendix B to 10 CFP Part 50, | |||
and Drerser Industries procedure QTI-76, paragraph 2.1, the | |||
calibration certifications (*1343, *6141) for torque | |||
devices had no documentation of a standard serial number. | |||
Therefore, the calibration load cell and readout devices | |||
used as the standard for calibration cannot be traced as | |||
required (85-01-05). | |||
e. Contrary to Criterion XII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50, | |||
and Dresser Industries QAM, Section 12, paragraph 5.1, | |||
calibration of the WR-12 Carbon Determinator (used for analysis | |||
of carbon and sulfur content) was not traceable to national ! | |||
standards or equipment manufacturer's recommended standards | |||
(85-01-06). | |||
f. Contrary to Criterion XII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50, | |||
and Dresser Industries procedure QTI-13, paragraph 3.1, | |||
Dresser quality control failed to certify calibration | |||
completed on June 6,1984 for the nuclear welding rod oven l | |||
bi-metal thermometers TG-2, TG-4, TG-6, TG-8, TG-11, TG-20, | |||
TG-21 (85-01-07). | |||
g. Contrary to 10 CFR 21, paragraph 21.21, and Dresser's Part 21 | |||
procedure, *003.00, paragraph 3.2, Dresser did not identify / list | |||
the pertinent data to ' substantiate an investigation for | |||
Part 21 file no. 85-01 (85-01-08). | |||
C. Unresolved Items | |||
Nore. | |||
D. Other Findings and Comments | |||
The NRC inspector reviewed the parts and travelers for Class 1 and 2 | |||
Dresser /Hancock 7150 and 7250 model valves to verify that heat number | |||
stamping, nondestructive testing, correct calibration of gages, | |||
subcontractor agreements were r'et, and appropriate sign offs were | |||
completed according to Dresser commitments. | |||
The nonconformances found during the inspection did not involve the | |||
fabrication of valve models 7150 and 7250. | |||
' , | |||
_ .p | |||
. | |||
I | |||
h | |||
. i | |||
ORGANIZATION: DRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC. t | |||
ALEXAMDRIA, LOUISIANA | |||
REPORT INSPECTION | |||
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 4 of 7 | |||
1. 10 CFR Part 21 Reauirement | |||
a. A review of Dresser's Part 21 files for 1984 and 1985 noted | |||
that Part 21 file no. 84-01 was not adequately evaluated in | |||
accordance with 10 CFR Part 21 Section 21.21. File no. 84-01 | |||
identified a problem with the failure of the disc collar on | |||
model 3707RA safety valves. The file stated this problem was | |||
not reportable since "The failure is an isolated case. Since | |||
1971, Dresser QA system has improved to preclude this failure | |||
mode." However, a letter dated July 2,1984 in the same file | |||
states this failure has happened twice since 1971 once in | |||
August 1981 at Toledo Edison / Davis-Besse and again at Diablo | |||
Canyon in May 1984 | |||
Information in file no. 84-01 indicates that in May 1984, | |||
during blowdcwn testing by Wyle Laboratories, Huntsville, | |||
Alabania, on the mai'n steam safety valves from Pacific Gas & | |||
Electric /Diablo Canyon 2 (Dresser valve type 3707RA), valve | |||
S/N BN 1741 lifted with simultaneous shearing of the disc | |||
collar / spindle threads and cotter pin. This occurred during | |||
the first actuation, at approximately 1065 psig. The disc and | |||
spindle deflected sidewise upon closing and the disc became | |||
wedged between the nozzle seat area and the bottom of the disc | |||
.hol de r. The valve became mechanically jammed and could not open. | |||
It also leaked severely because the disc was not seated properly. | |||
2resser was asked about the blow-down problems that they | |||
are presently experiencing on the 3700 series safety relief | |||
valves undergoi'ng testing at Wyle Labs in Huntsville, Alabama | |||
for Toledo Edison / Davis Besse. Specifically, Dresser was | |||
asked whether an investigation / evaluation was done or is | |||
planned to compare the problem experienced with the 3700 | |||
series safety relief valves to the problems documented in | |||
file no. 84-01. Dresser's response was "no evaluatinn has | |||
been performed." During a subsequent conference call on | |||
October 10, 1985, Dresser (Mr. J. Watz and Mr. B. Brunson) | |||
stated that " Dresser has performed an evaluation / comparison of | |||
file no. 34-01 and the valves being tested by Wyle Labs and | |||
determined the failure modes were similar. File no. 84-01 will | |||
remain closed, however, a new file, no. 85-04, will be initiated. | |||
This file (85-04) will reference file no. 84-01 and will be | |||
reported as,a Part 21". | |||
Violation 85-01-01 was identified during this part of the | |||
inspection. | |||
.__ | |||
._ | |||
_ | |||
. | |||
. | |||
ORGANIZATION: DRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC. | |||
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA | |||
REPORT INSPECTION | |||
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 5 of 7 | |||
. | |||
b. A review was made of Dresser's Part 21 evaluation and reporting | |||
procedure " Evaluating and Reporting of Deviations and/or | |||
Noncompliances Affecting Safety Related to NRC Regulation 10 CFR | |||
Part 21" dated March 28, 1984 and Part 21 evaluation files for | |||
1984 and 1985. This review noted that Dresser did not identify / | |||
list the pertinent data called for in their procedure to | |||
substantiate the investigation for Part 21 file no. 85-01. | |||
This Part 21 file identified a problem with Dresser's model 3050 | |||
diaphragm valves sticking partially open or closed. The problem | |||
was reported to the NRC by the Cleveland Electric Illuminating | |||
Co., Perry Nuclear Power Plant. According to Dresser file no. | |||
85-01, the problem was not reportable per 10 CFR 21 since | |||
Dresser had "no knowledge in power plant system design." | |||
However, Dresser's customers were notified. File 85-01 did | |||
not identify / list the information called for in paragraph 3.2 | |||
of pr.ocedure no. 003.001 to substantiate an investigation. | |||
In addition, a review of the purchase order and specifications | |||
for valves ordered by the Perry Nuclear Power Plant was performed | |||
by the NRC inspector. This review identified documents which | |||
listed valves as " active" and "non-active", " safety related" | |||
and "non-safety related" and "ASME Class 1, Class 2 or Class 3" | |||
valves. With this information Dresser should have been able to | |||
determine the safety significance of the deviation. | |||
Nonconformance 85-01-08 was identified during this part of the | |||
inspection. | |||
2. Purchase Requirements | |||
An examination was made of 20 purchase orders (P.O.) from Dresser | |||
for outside calibration services for gages, testing and measuring | |||
devices. Dresser was found to have purchased calibration and | |||
certification services for thermocouples TG-2, TG-4, TG-6, TG-8, | |||
TG-11, TG-20, TG-21, from two vendors that were not on Dresser's | |||
approved vendors list. Calibration of the thermocouples was | |||
performed by Honeywell-Houston on August 13, 1980 - Dresser order | |||
*26229-6'; on October 19, 1982 - Dresser order 848879-6; and, on | |||
December 4, 1984 - Dresser order 447671-6. Likewise, Honeywell - | |||
Ft. Washington, PA performed calibration and certification of the | |||
thermocouples on February 25, 1982 - Dresser order #41201-6. These | |||
thermocouples were used to monitor the temperature of the heat | |||
treating furnaces. ' | |||
- | |||
. l | |||
. | |||
. | |||
ORGANIZATION: ORESSER INDUSTRIES, INC. | |||
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA | |||
REPORT INSPECTION | |||
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 6 of 7 | |||
. | |||
Nonconformance 85-01-02 was identified during this part of the | |||
inspection. | |||
3. Control of Special Processes | |||
Heat treating and weld rod ovens were inspected and were found | |||
to be adequately calibrated and functioning according to Dresser | |||
procedures. The nuclear welding rod storage area was inspected. | |||
Weld rod containers were stored in either locked cabinets or locked | |||
weld rod ovens. The Section III weld rod ovens were marked " Nuclear." | |||
All rods were stored in the metal containers received and were marked | |||
wit.1 rod specification, lot and/or heat number to maintain trace- | |||
ability. However, four cases were found where containers of Type | |||
7018, nuclear welding rods, lot 3c504YOZ, heat #76175, were not | |||
stam. red (verified) by the receiving inspection personnel. Receiving | |||
Inspection is essential in verifying that cans are properly sealed,. | |||
and that identificatior. numbers, material type, and quantity ordered | |||
are correct. , | |||
i | |||
l | |||
Nonconformance 85-01-03 was identified during this part of the | |||
inspection. l | |||
3 | |||
1 | |||
4 Manufacturing Process Control | |||
) | |||
The NRC Inspector reviewed the parts, travelers, and drawings for | |||
four shop orders and verified that specified requirements such as: | |||
(a) heat number stamping, (b) nondestructive testing, (c) | |||
authorized nuclear inspector sign off, (d) final inspection, (e) | |||
calibration of gages, (f) serial number assignment, and (g) heat | |||
treatment had been completed and correctly documented. No | |||
nonconformances were noted in this area. | |||
5. Calibration | |||
The NRC inspector found that torque devices calibration certifications | |||
l | |||
81343 and #6141 had no documentation of a calibration standard serial l | |||
number. Therefore, there is no objective evidence that the torque ' | |||
devices were checked using a traceable load cell and readout device | |||
as the standard for measurement. | |||
Nanconformance 85-01-05 was identified during this part of the | |||
inspection. | |||
5 | |||
. | |||
Ig ' | |||
__ _ __ ___ __ , | |||
- | |||
1; | |||
. | |||
. | |||
ORGANIZATION: DRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC. | |||
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA | |||
REPORT INSPECTION | |||
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 7 of 7 | |||
The NRC inspector found that calibrations of nuclear welding red | |||
oven bi-metal thermometers (TG-2, TG-4, TG-6, TG-8, TG-11, TG-20, | |||
and TG-21) completed on June 7,1984 were not certified by quality | |||
control. Accurate continuous monitoring of the nuclear weld rod | |||
ovens (between 250 and 300* F) is essential for low hydrogen | |||
electrodes. The temperature range of 250* to 300 F has to be | |||
maintained in order to reduce moisture or hydrogen absorption of the | |||
weld rods. | |||
Nonconformance 85-01-07 was identified during this part of the | |||
inspection. | |||
The NRC inspector reviewed the calibration and procedure requirements | |||
involved in the operation of the WR-12 Carbon Determinator. Dresser | |||
was not able to show that the calibration standards used for | |||
calibrating the carbon determinator are traceable to national | |||
standards or the equipment manufacturer's recommended standards. | |||
The WR-12 Carbon Determinator is used to determine material carbon | |||
and sulfur content. For applications where high levels of carbon | |||
and sulfur are detrimental to impact strength and low levels of | |||
ca.rbon are desirable (i.e., some corrosive environments), accurate | |||
analysis of carbon and sulfur level is essential. | |||
Nonconformance 85-01-06 was identified during this part of the | |||
inspection. | |||
10 Plant Tour | |||
A tour of Dresser's facility was performed by the inspectors. The | |||
activities observed were receiving, nuclear material storage area, | |||
nuclear weloing rod storage area, heat treating furnaces, stock | |||
rooms, valve assembly clean room, calibration records area, and the | |||
metallurgical laboratory. The storage, laboratory and work areas | |||
were neat, clean and free of extraneous materials. Operations | |||
observed appeared to be well planned and progressing in an orderly | |||
fashion. | |||
i 1 | |||
' | |||
\ | |||
! | |||
. | |||
. | |||
- | |||
'l | |||
PEDSCNS CONTACTED | |||
Company ) ret S YR $^YJCRICC Dates M 20 | |||
m .-- r - | |||
49.f | |||
m,= | |||
Occket/ Report No. Q 99806[4 bf- 01 Ins;;ect::r /MMt ' ha. ud.g | |||
- | |||
i | |||
/ < | |||
[s.-12a.s- * ace I of I | |||
NAME(Diesse Drint) TI'l.EIDie!Se DP%tl 0 30'C ' ~'O N / :' u s e : 4 --i | |||
- | |||
S. $ bAUNSc & A'[0Wsc &f, 0weiL &ck he us ex. J/tc | |||
f T BoLfER cw can . c.ur.<, xw swe3 i, .. | |||
1 / 2 E e n n :- (A>l3 sodv !)/0:: ,- Jim | |||
d 9 \//AT 1 9.-c.;'d hA f_% T r e.sser Do | |||
> | |||
i | |||
G C 3 Lu.n c C CNrEase L,as au c a hu mee ve | |||
'). S. L Al | |||
. | |||
D M - c,na m - | |||
n Ku, ivo | |||
v | |||
Dh 0N5 h- iV6A VS?fMS Wl/$oh bry4S$4M j t/ 0 | |||
' ,~ .. ., .. n. n | |||
- | |||
.cwAva. = '. . | |||
. | |||
t- a | |||
cf . . u .u . c m,au | |||
. | |||
>ccss z iec | |||
d ZL VAtM RAn VPG Pc5 bnwremt) u.5. A/. R C.. | |||
_ | |||
k | |||
l | |||
l | |||
t | |||
, | |||
_ _ _ - _ _ - - - . - . - _ - | |||
! . | |||
. | |||
PED.SCNS CONTACTED | |||
Ccepany Dc o s s-a h Dates $hm-u, A - d - y ,m | |||
occket/aeper: no. ?Hwosvhr-n :nscec::r -l C e b,ues /, o , ,. | |||
1 | |||
I | |||
/ | |||
gi r Dace I of I | |||
NAME(Please Drint) IITLEfDiease Dri"tI l | |||
0:31N??i'ONf3' ease : 4- '- | |||
NbD TNGM&S OA GAi6? Sys% y Aupix DREMEj | |||
- . | |||
.n 4(cwp,g ig | |||
,w m | |||
_ a a _' - t' , s o | |||
, li?fb . | |||
i e L t'c< / 5 ?.- | |||
' 3, \ i-1 G i l.- / I I,a rr J ,-7c s | |||
w30HN d. V44TL Tra ci/d EA LMTP Tresyr 46_d A . | |||
Y S'. Le M . WQom am; | |||
, | |||
' | |||
dBot qcR usc c,vs,,vcen am /r | |||
G C. 5Lu.4 0.'.( Odier rease rz uac Ae, " - | |||
l | |||
F G Beadsca %eea %,n Gn i n | |||
. | |||
' | |||
* l | |||
L D . S l ' , ', ,' yp pc, | |||
' | |||
., p .- - ,. '' _j, 3,,,y. k ,- | |||
. | |||
_ | |||
. | |||
_ | |||
h | |||
. | |||
i | |||
i*i : | |||
o | |||
9 | |||
l | |||
6 | |||
- | |||
y | |||
hl L l | |||
I $' i | |||
,7 y | |||
4 vi Q | |||
< | |||
- | |||
wy | |||
l | |||
- | |||
n x, | |||
e | |||
X :i | |||
I | |||
i | |||
! | |||
i ! q 'Q~a + i | |||
Q >(n i | |||
n , | |||
,g yi i. v ! u : ,\ , | |||
i | |||
m yu . | |||
$ \ s | |||
. | |||
l j d (' $ \; | |||
.bh | |||
3! | |||
ra D 4 | |||
! \} | |||
w I | |||
iS si | |||
N | |||
i | |||
$! h i | |||
.v . I | |||
4 -o %i | |||
7Nn(. %Gi | |||
I 3 i u ! | |||
6 . | |||
b | |||
I | |||
SR ; % m ks h. i | |||
y 'l I | |||
h D | |||
kQ' il | |||
. | |||
i | |||
$ | |||
d . | |||
R | |||
E , | |||
4 fl 4 ! b | |||
2 as i st v, y v m t : h. | |||
o. | |||
S.4 ba, | |||
- | |||
: w 1: L. at | |||
hu | |||
Ng f.s7 %ji} vLD f | |||
$ u' %%s dr$t $ | |||
' | |||
s | |||
' M' s e s$ | |||
d | |||
i @:t ag' b 4 44 | |||
N $ N c8 7 | |||
' | |||
!kd4 1 s | |||
4 3)4 | |||
. | |||
% | |||
s | |||
r | |||
a \ | |||
i | |||
10 | |||
nq | |||
- | |||
S | |||
> | |||
% 4 | |||
m | |||
9 | |||
\ | |||
ia | |||
a | |||
I s.a Jc rs | |||
s | |||
3< | |||
- | |||
8 Y - R zy e A \ | |||
t t | |||
$) a k k 43 k k | |||
o | |||
w | |||
a | |||
N 4 m | |||
T | |||
tl 4 4j yc s | |||
#$ | |||
' 3 | |||
?. | |||
N %s | |||
2 E c | |||
3 'B eRQ | |||
. | |||
y , ! s n 4; e ; de | |||
i ; | |||
' | |||
d 4 %el 2 } | |||
x | |||
e at9$ .4; | |||
s e i ( | |||
4 | |||
5 | |||
4 | |||
1 e a$3 | |||
t- , 1 4a ') d r ' * y | |||
0 | |||
Td i | |||
d | |||
' | |||
., . L | |||
1 Wq t' l i t 3 e siW( | |||
ww a ?;s( b | |||
> | |||
s 04 44 | |||
' | |||
, | |||
3 a 4' M W- I | |||
5 Q Osj 0W N3 4 g e 3 # | |||
3 | |||
% b" | |||
N ' | |||
Eh b lE ' | |||
dh$ . | |||
f | |||
1 e 4 444's!444 J Ntt.4 4 M[3 h4 | |||
j f | |||
w%sMN '5 = w T S 'g.4 i y%i% | |||
m s w , a .a m -s e=u em s 3e eL | |||
~ ~s | |||
' F- | |||
I | |||
* q % | |||
y b~ | |||
# | |||
au | |||
I- | |||
V as | |||
Lw E 's | |||
u & | |||
O | |||
, | |||
4 A s' y - | |||
y | |||
n | |||
D | |||
:> | |||
Sr. | |||
j sj ~s?> | |||
M N d_W | |||
,. - - | |||
,n | |||
2 | |||
,- | |||
' CL | |||
O b s | |||
! ' ' | |||
2 ce | |||
W W csQ' s o | |||
~ | |||
V | |||
g cz ? N 0 k ,s ~ | |||
Fsr | |||
C C5' Q M Nb b | |||
s- | |||
y 8 es ?" | |||
E D E' E 'e . | |||
NJ7o | |||
- ' | |||
Q Q Q}~i%( yu e ,, | |||
. | |||
2 I . o 2_ u e : s e ,- | |||
o _ ee | |||
$ $! E ;% a d d h is W W q h 4 W h a 35d N=. | |||
fi g N. AW$ 5 E * * W W W b W kW | |||
7*'TM1 | |||
mo , | |||
o c==d | |||
Ch | |||
' | |||
hM !s M c4 m & % % rh oo cr-i g 2,. d y c$E'd | |||
E | |||
? | |||
. | |||
__. __ . . _ . - - - . - , - -~ -- - - - ' | |||
-- i | |||
, | |||
, | |||
' | |||
9 | |||
h | |||
s , | |||
iM,k['g$f$ds' | |||
' | |||
&p, u. | |||
, n. | |||
Rs | |||
w . | |||
i ,g. , | |||
,. | |||
, | |||
. | |||
.s s | |||
Id . | |||
.w o il l'8 | |||
.6 %g hl | |||
. >i i | |||
!$ | |||
d : | |||
;i- | |||
.4A | |||
e %; | |||
m r. R:! . | |||
. | |||
, | |||
, | |||
' | |||
m - | |||
' | |||
. | |||
- , | |||
l | |||
' | |||
; , | |||
s $, | |||
I t$4 | |||
i | |||
E.h. | |||
C"' | |||
. & 1 | |||
l | |||
sw! J T | |||
3 s l 193 :: e .l | |||
p %e k i | |||
l* ' ' | |||
C | |||
, | |||
(y | |||
' | |||
Q,flt si tg u ! | |||
' 4 | |||
j i | |||
%-' V % : | |||
t)'l 1, 1 .! : f$ k | |||
h | |||
} | |||
; | |||
r ) M | |||
x: sii t | |||
4 .: - | |||
g %g4t { | |||
1 | |||
! | |||
v i | |||
[ A A ! i i s ; | |||
, | |||
'g 0- s, q ,, N- i s | |||
I l | |||
0 | |||
s y : s l 1 | |||
- | |||
l | |||
, , | |||
.. . | |||
= | |||
2 | |||
- sk ,f - \ss R , | |||
. | |||
a' R y | |||
hI : ~ , | |||
Cl I >g '. | |||
, | |||
' | |||
. . | |||
e > | |||
es -; u( i | |||
B y; c3i !k, | |||
a | |||
r>N | |||
, | |||
1 | |||
2 w s : tt | |||
W -\ | |||
71 | |||
q t | |||
w'I | |||
S 4 | |||
u | |||
sle4 i | |||
! | |||
' a | |||
% | |||
e > e r | |||
(l 3d | |||
~ - | |||
J '* | |||
f i 3l ) d E N | |||
1 | |||
s 3 xs | |||
q! s N f | |||
Tj S G' d d# d l 'jdd | |||
cb f\ | |||
Niji | |||
, | |||
k .'h | |||
- | |||
susw.kil | |||
.- | |||
xh 5 | |||
- | |||
wsms k l $mi k | |||
' | |||
ni: ; | |||
24.w | |||
'l !II | |||
N | |||
e | |||
' | |||
' | |||
N - , | |||
]h i I \ | |||
)l ' | |||
hlYd | |||
1 | |||
I | |||
. | |||
nu' | |||
' q ? % | |||
3 : 1 : s .i | |||
y, e 3 | |||
wac h | |||
s 6=2 u | |||
. | |||
u u | |||
i | |||
n c4 : | |||
,ni s e s ,. | |||
- | |||
-= | |||
. | |||
i | |||
M lh i | |||
h Dl D D | |||
e | |||
bot | |||
ew s | |||
' , | |||
! - | |||
g,Q . | |||
, | |||
-0 | |||
2 gr i | |||
, | |||
l l | |||
l 6 | |||
c 2uc2Ce | |||
.yce: | |||
O N ! | |||
c | |||
s < p | |||
5 | |||
y y g I"O g^ | |||
gl' o a - | |||
u | |||
"w | |||
F | |||
, | |||
- ' | |||
"2 c | |||
'p$ cg e | |||
au s | |||
v | |||
h | |||
$ l' d,,_g - | |||
N 'i "l | |||
oo | |||
H@ l$df | |||
2 V | |||
_ | |||
4 | |||
, | |||
, | |||
! | |||
' | |||
NMU | |||
w-l N hl Qo (T-' c v===a | |||
. | |||
yl A | |||
% - N l ''D nj (4 j ~3*l | |||
N. N g l | |||
l | |||
! | |||
,w | |||
5 7 s 2 ' V '- | |||
04b M | |||
_ . _ - . _ . - . ,_. . ~ . _ . . _ . __. . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ - . -.__ | |||
' | |||
3.Lwaf | |||
. . | |||
TtJSPEcToR l AFPY D. VA t1GriA/cf | |||
scope- Dock:cT sao. A 9 9 C)O O S'/ | |||
OccOMENTS EXAtisdED Rcroar rio. _ V | |||
~ | |||
_ J'/ | |||
17 Mjg ' mg.4 r 64 0 #. dew E | |||
pnGE $ 06: d | |||
) Te n E /suSjecT | |||
N }_I. . ?L-9I ~~' ~~ | |||
3056 | |||
_ _ _ | |||
P/APA GA C,> n'' . V' AUC | |||
21 6 | |||
2b' %~OA ~ | |||
. | |||
2y^_ A/ 84-01 - | |||
& ! S25v2-&RG/rr yALVC. Of-GPADidG Ta !S25 VF-3.-// | |||
- | |||
. . | |||
DISC puT Aivb COTTEp P/M SWCAF/^)Cs ff | |||
]c 2/ S 3 -Q 2- ' - | |||
o | |||
3' ? o c) Eriz/CS | |||
U)N~ VAtyrs _ _s V6 BtomDaM N' P8aBt cms. | |||
[ ~ | |||
N UcLcs9g P C vi n~rto N v NoAscamPuRNCC L.os rot { /MitrA / | |||
. | |||
.. | |||
SP- $3 /- o/ ~ | |||
C c 'Z' 's * D c s/ G F) | |||
' | |||
32- | |||
~ | |||
% 2.9- Q O. h__ Yl9b. ' TPrc,ys/zS'gtC7y /%CLATCO Vgl.VCS " | |||
' - Gaff,Rs_QRC ANQ. CMCc_i[. ptLVCS . . 2 Ldsk_ StM LLC &_ | |||
y_ PPO 971- 3/ (=, | |||
t0/b7h9 TPccisti | |||
pccx:;gcucp75yplg 4 bocyeciumy.pn~7p/gty71o+) | |||
... _ . _ | |||
$b A M.r H P./H'r N 7 Z.(N | |||
Y {Pk_ (~ ll90 A 5 | |||
_ | |||
!s? o.C &#MEr72' /N~MTrD M& | |||
dst >-5 3/-01- | |||
_f L /S 7 OUq/f_4 pad-Ac 7/gr s'Ar r7y Rft'nFr.D c | |||
_ yAf.VFS__. _ | |||
.h S'f'CC g w]-co | |||
~ | |||
4 | |||
/c'///f__'{ Ss_tt 're 45 . . _ _ - abo VC | |||
O'O ' /^ N7 S.> | |||
_ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . . - _ _ _ . | |||
^ | |||
3lA0/Yf U 1 7 csF- S/t L. Or /'?AT S /PCfJT/FY/NG Ct. ASS .I V84.V(3 | |||
__ | |||
-. | |||
_ . - - . . | |||
'f A 0- ~ " | |||
. - - . . | |||
, | |||
_ _ _ /Jff&vcb Vrf DOP i 'S L iS 1 5 / S S o r l) OyAf]_(gsy__h78{ lbra_9h?/ | |||
6/8 */ | |||
; | |||
g VAR ~~ ~ ~ | |||
G / 8 5_- ven z>of | |||
Aoec_BetoR7.s 82f _ c4binc7 ccmf DCTRoq nt_cN. | |||
; gy ,, ,,, c nucisi e srecm ry in cre | |||
h@ EdK - _ | |||
- | |||
... T 9LM . - | |||
..- -- | |||
,, ,, | |||
. - - S' YEA CS' '', N' Y- - - - | |||
\/A X | |||
- | |||
Ljj - - | |||
G/8 'i 'l '' # " | |||
Agtune.D Gr.rce. ABA/ ..oA7/c | |||
, | |||
. . _ _ _ . _ _ _ , ._ | |||
i._i _ _ . . _ . . | |||
T/PE 05 DOC: | |||
. | |||
/WA. | |||
; | |||
d _VCA,3op Aup/7 frCPcM7- / | |||
l p a r. - psmW HG | |||
t r R - L ii T T E R | |||
, | |||
sva | |||
run-- s,eacGnaeE | |||
g | |||
Vccsrecnnsod 1 - fturl.. Al C t/ALUA TIOg g/M | |||
' | |||
nog qis 1AHt)AL - 11 4 _ B P.h K. | |||
- QgJpf1Tf/4 7 FU'T(PWs g g g ac cpcp-l- | |||
gfcn E | |||
< | |||
qc nocuem or | |||
., ,9<,w ract . | |||
_. _ _ _ _ . -- | |||
. | |||
ItJsrECToR .] L Mf t A RR7 P- YAOC,HAN | |||
SC. OPE - | |||
_ | |||
OOC O tie N TS (W Atie s3 E D | |||
Do cke.T slo. _9990005 Y | |||
Rtt'ont rio. _6 - o/ | |||
! | |||
7" MM y *jo"'# RsdI Dtvr E | |||
Ta nE /SuBMcT | |||
'lla ? | |||
N-. .Y0 $ | |||
_ | |||
_ - _ . - . | |||
9/RS - 1 CFJ.D.o& ( untocust e vci. ps | |||
I'> | |||
GlA I A't UQ11_ RE1Q675.EoE_. .C17c M ff_czipcryg_ /u E | |||
. | |||
. - T .- - .. Glh.G | |||
it i s, it | |||
PA. | |||
W | |||
. | |||
-- - | |||
. . .. - | |||
//8 thy . - . - . - | |||
N ^ ~ | |||
&,$jd j a 2/M__ | |||
si /t | |||
it et .- &.4AW kAl?6Q M. } f' f f f v M, 1 A .-. | |||
0k | |||
N | |||
/ | |||
9/s / *r | |||
/ l' l- AR SON 4 SONS cH/cAg,q,_Tt f.. | |||
Y0 8-.. .~~..- - $ ri (t | |||
8}B5 -.- TE XAS 80LT CO | |||
9/8Y NO US7? ''s .1'X . | |||
- | |||
Vb VA L - ~ ~ | |||
A/As | |||
/t /< t< <t | |||
S O W A N _S P /t/n 6 ,._ tro uS7op | |||
- | |||
, TX | |||
h_. ddO__ 2 | |||
~ | |||
, | |||
_. | |||
98 .ZAR - | |||
- | |||
*/c h Asy uni /P YE~/ Hot | |||
--- - - - | |||
g g g. Aub17 /E'Pof:T | |||
.. | |||
.. | |||
..- . . . | |||
! !." Y E | |||
, a * | |||
- | |||
- | |||
-.-- - - | |||
Y- | |||
a -w a # # + | |||
, | |||
l Lp. | |||
. | |||
s $Y Q l Y,x'G Y l ,Pj' 5h | |||
* | |||
~?g | |||
Y l6 )' k-f - t YL | |||
8 | |||
_--.1 x | |||
.._- . | |||
. _ . . _ . | |||
N-f {' 0 $-~- Y -h A -- -- -- -- ?- -h - * | |||
[Q AG | |||
- - - ~ ~ - - | |||
- - ... & Ar7 5 | |||
. - - - - . . . . . . - - .. | |||
QvAar!'A-T'nA>_Fof R LTMM(4 CAP '90D!7DCk i | |||
G-L H-Or~fh ds);..- f. N. Gkf'C~N T f3/..AEN MQ?..G N 0AAN G, | |||
._ . . . - _ . | |||
.- - | |||
- | |||
- | |||
- | |||
, | |||
T | |||
S=---?0ENEOS | |||
_ . . . _ . - - . -. | |||
y- NEh '* ?) NA NbN O N) ' | |||
H-.ScHR o dC&CA; | |||
. . . . .- | |||
- - . . . . . . | |||
T (. M E Z & ^r D _ (1 & , Ft. c 7 c y % _ _ | |||
{l ?O. '4 8b 3'3 ~ ?l'.b1, -rc \ . - | |||
- . . . - . | |||
< cixo z.)on7c,p.- cA s7/xs _c onP. qseA1l7x,.ro & . P/5c. | |||
- | |||
TVl'E O 5- doc. | |||
.e | |||
DW - I b5'I\k) i M G (, F R, - (,(( ( ( [ R | |||
i | |||
SPait - 5 5'E c 5 IC nisoel p, .y | |||
; | |||
un- > enc e ou v e ;Lffvool AODi7 /lf gg | |||
e. g u A/ T /' | |||
q sn - 4 tr 1%n n o s h /]Q t_goryg | |||
qc > - q c nocong.Jr ooAs I F/CRT/cH | |||
rg_ - _. c+,cicc,t ,f 3 r,..ra.. v. .s s | |||
, , | |||
. . s | |||
. DI e | |||
' | |||
* | |||
l g | |||
N , | |||
, | |||
- n | |||
o | |||
. | |||
' | |||
4 4l | |||
f | |||
i | |||
i | |||
i | |||
i | |||
; | |||
, | |||
i | |||
h, t,j | |||
. | |||
- | |||
M | |||
. | |||
. | |||
c i ! ol . i : i . | |||
0 4; tl - | |||
b , | |||
a li : , , | |||
o X ~j ' ' | |||
O t | |||
o i ti s | |||
i y | |||
l y N ' | |||
IiCq. L t> ke y - | |||
e- i W - | |||
e A b VT (si | |||
' | |||
yi | |||
- | |||
mb% , 'd | |||
0 | |||
e s | |||
~ q R> i | |||
. | |||
' .' ' | |||
i | |||
' i*9 Gllg 0 RQ < | |||
$ | |||
: | |||
d i% " ti- , s ; , i | |||
' | |||
26 g i A: o a' t | |||
o | |||
. | |||
Q R l ! | |||
i ,' ' | |||
de bI 3 2 (3 | |||
, | |||
** u b ;4 | |||
, | |||
, | |||
4: %dh yi | |||
s i I . ' i 1. | |||
s' j | |||
5,w$ R t s. cl T e | |||
' | |||
tl i i | |||
e a | |||
rlAq b | |||
N e i y 1 . . ' | |||
o ce c- %s g O! 4 b 4 o e ;' .s j : ; 2 ,' | |||
hw4L Rt < d' n;, I , | |||
i | |||
q w - | |||
, , | |||
: r bE qt; u c' R c ! | |||
R! , a o i TJ q - | |||
U ( j h l ! o | |||
O | |||
E, | |||
e | |||
f'Ligfti $. $' N7 2 e k t 4, u | |||
b | |||
h | |||
I I | |||
l D$ | |||
e - | |||
.w | |||
R sl' R I - | |||
g i | |||
W | |||
2 | |||
N O, | |||
cil | |||
O | |||
i L ', x | |||
~ | |||
T sh'GM h~ | |||
N ni | |||
,s . | |||
N yi (c | |||
w | |||
O. | |||
0 ct | |||
, | |||
l l | |||
E C | |||
6 fD ! k DE k 4. I i g! d | |||
N- l I i | |||
'8 | |||
g | |||
;[ f M ,) 21 0 k bd 4 ' | |||
' ' | |||
c 0 | |||
,. | |||
0 i ("{i l | |||
- | |||
', | |||
N. | |||
- | |||
y u | |||
Al R T | |||
m | |||
v3 | |||
e i^ | |||
i | |||
i Ri | |||
i | |||
- | |||
I | |||
- | |||
, | |||
, | |||
, s | |||
b 3 | |||
Li N y @! E n( Qi C1 | |||
' ' | |||
e i L ei 5 'ci F i | |||
W | |||
2 | |||
g 2, d g, l | |||
U ' | |||
0 v' | |||
< | |||
i I | |||
h | |||
' | |||
l ' | |||
i c4~ | |||
4 w | |||
OI | |||
0 | |||
A k Ak an | |||
w O. C1 t a L(. a I - | |||
r | |||
i | |||
pl X '\ l o Lg s L ! | |||
C19 | |||
o | |||
v | |||
I | |||
Li | |||
i e' | |||
' R - | |||
q we. R Mi Lu | |||
R | |||
s | |||
- | |||
N. . s h!wl l | |||
s | |||
~ ri ad'sa- | |||
gl ' c! ' ,,(s g N 3 N | |||
q , | |||
o -in | |||
y , %y 4 | |||
o 4 ! , | |||
I | |||
P_ n | |||
- ' | |||
- | |||
,, % , R > g i j | |||
,i p | |||
, , | |||
, | |||
- , . | |||
, , | |||
e i | |||
$ hMhk | |||
s s e $s elkll.: f | |||
* | |||
! | |||
: | |||
! | |||
. | |||
- | |||
, | |||
$hd | |||
:ces | |||
m n i,i, -w s w | |||
. . | |||
- ; | |||
a o. i ei : ! 1 | |||
3" .h llL/1 !P Cs! m el | |||
''qlM. or ''''' | |||
'- ' i ill ll ll l l' %,W | |||
se m | |||
m n s s | |||
** | |||
. | |||
m <? | |||
$ d d ' c'- | |||
l >; w | |||
fl,'h , | |||
'' l Nl L' | |||
- | |||
A | |||
cc | |||
3 | |||
{2 | |||
g | |||
d $ (i | |||
>t | |||
B; ', | |||
g' | |||
e | |||
(c: e{ | |||
4' | |||
( | |||
g; e | |||
q' | |||
4. | |||
(ie, x | |||
i | |||
-l- (MCl(!OC'b! | |||
, | |||
,s is | |||
,! | |||
iOi | |||
N T | |||
M y OO bL I k b, l hlh' | |||
su e m$$ | |||
. | |||
. | |||
- | |||
2 : i ; | |||
' | |||
I | |||
O | |||
-i,$ I.I C'i | |||
Q c,'9 | |||
! | |||
l | |||
'O clC | |||
M | |||
c | |||
%! w O g:l | |||
q- ol A | |||
C C!c | |||
G A | |||
Clcl!5'h5 | |||
,',t | |||
e ll eg qlp: | |||
v s | |||
yg Q;w t - | |||
c. ! O,. (! q i | |||
, | |||
% | |||
egig.o .,f | |||
u | |||
:mie c. c | |||
,e .. | |||
m | |||
Q b 4 N | |||
a q, Q j \g, r | |||
I I | |||
Q4 %l w w | |||
i i | |||
, | |||
s = 3 :- ee | |||
, | |||
d.(.. pudj , - | |||
*ntsPECTo R t A RR Y O- v'A u GHAN | |||
St. OPE oocvm_r do. _7 99 0o0 5'/ | |||
_ | |||
O OC O t4E tJ TS liX Alie d E D Rcg> oar rio. _8$'- (>/ | |||
j;"J $ | |||
Mg, *4'"M asv 1 pawe PnGc 6 _ o s: C __ | |||
( Tine /suaaacT | |||
_ | |||
. ,._. . | |||
._-_ _ _ | |||
... $- | |||
$0N_._ ...NS_0$$_lD61_ __ D$ h.V$- | |||
_ | |||
. _ . _ _ _.. __ _.? . | |||
. _ . | |||
__ _ _. | |||
RDO | |||
-. -_ _ . . . - _ | |||
9a676 | |||
- - - - | |||
(78 | |||
-. | |||
- . | |||
_ - _ . - | |||
. _ . . _ . | |||
a " - _ - | |||
- | |||
~ ' ~ ~ ~ | |||
_ _ _ _ . _ . _ | |||
# | |||
.___...____._____- | |||
_ 0'l ? l _ | |||
_ | |||
II " U | |||
_ _ . . . _ _ _ . | |||
yp eDo asmo - | |||
o u o | |||
Yl | |||
-_ | |||
PRO | |||
- | |||
oo3 o 0 - | |||
's/A'At c e Ai. un 7in s ob pc rorvriw:_, o r o c wg ,,c.,y, | |||
._ | |||
__ - - _ _ | |||
. _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . | |||
_ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ yy/oa | |||
NO v t'nMPL /AA/iXL | |||
___ | |||
AEUd_/NC ..1 -2- [U_E..f G d Z_&. | |||
. _ . _ _ . . _ _ - - . . _ . _ _-__._ _ ._ _ . . | |||
._ - _ . . _ | |||
b) . NS ?- ' ?0Y.N~h O/Y ' | |||
' t.1. b'- | |||
. | |||
.~..._k{' _ | |||
' | |||
. _ _ _ _ _ _ | |||
_ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ - | |||
.__.__ _ __ | |||
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . . . _ | |||
- -- - | |||
.. ~. .. __ _ _ . | |||
---- -~~- | |||
.._.-_.-___._..._..-. . . _ _ . . | |||
--- | |||
_ _. _ _ _ . _ | |||
- - - - - | |||
_ | |||
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . .. . | |||
___ ._ | |||
4__.._. ._. _ _ _ _ _ _ | |||
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ .. | |||
_ . _ . . _ _ ~ _ . _ . . . _ _ . . . . | |||
-_._ _ _ __. . | |||
___ | |||
- . _ _ _ . . _ . _ _ _ . | |||
- _ _ _ . _ - - . . | |||
._ . | |||
__ _._ . . _ _ _ _ . _ . _ . ._ . _ . _ _ . _ _ . . _ . . _ . . . . _ . | |||
. _ _ _ _ _ . _ .___ _. _ __ ___ _ _ _ _ _ . . __ | |||
. | |||
_. | |||
. | |||
._____l _ | |||
1 __i | |||
._.__.i._______.._.___.._._. __ __.__ | |||
_ _ _ _ . . . _ . . _ _ _ | |||
TVl'E 0 5- Doc *. | |||
.e | |||
DSJ G - DI?ObJ IPJ G ( l' R | |||
srec- ss>ccirec ni oa >o g f {Teci | |||
.er ([ g,i cN N ,' N /OM OB Df'8 # | |||
gun _ r enc G no u r. e - y , . , w .,. r., , a n 1,. | |||
n | |||
All - Q a\ iM *3 0 A l_ g g .- 3 pgZ e g g ,g,. y ,q . n .2,s.v c e (~e,2rir,4,4t,..,/ | |||
tU-QC nolve aus Y | |||
., . . . . . . . . . . . . - - . . . , _A. L _jw.j ',y, , ,y a s , r . . -,<<r >o.- v | |||
-. , . . - - - - | |||
__ _ _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ | |||
}} |
Latest revision as of 14:51, 27 October 2020
ML20141H823 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Issue date: | 12/13/1985 |
From: | Harper J, Merschoff E NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
To: | |
Shared Package | |
ML20141E221 | List: |
References | |
REF-QA-99900054 NUDOCS 8604250049 | |
Download: ML20141H823 (2) | |
See also: IR 05000930/2010004
Text
__ . .
. .
-
.
.
ORGANIZATION: DPESSER INDUSTRIES, INC.
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA
CEPORT INSPECTICN INSPECTION
NO.-
.
99900054/85-01 DATE(S): 09/30/85-10/04/85 ON-SITE HOUPS: 50
' CORRESPONDENCE ADDRESS: Dresser Industries, Inc.
ATTN: B. G. Bronson, OA Manager
Post Office Box 1430
Alexandria, Louisiana 71301
ORGANIZATIONAL CONTACT: Mr. B. G. Bronson, QA Manager
TELEPHONE NUMBER: (318) 640-2250
PRINCIPAL PRODULT: Nuclear Safety arid Sdfety Relief Valves
NUCLEAR
business is INDUSTRY ACTIVITY:
supplying valves Less facilities.
for nuclear than 5% of Dresser Industries ( Alexandria)
ASSIGNED INSPECTOR: \i r,m
c .t #
J. Cd Harper, Reactiv6 Inspection Section (RIS) Date
OTHER INSPECTOR (S): L. D. Vaughan, Program Coordination Section (PCS)
,. ,f /7'
APPROVED BY: / --
re . , 3 6-
E. W. MerschofVfhief, RIS Date
INSPECTION BASES AND SCOPE:
A. BASES: 10 CFR Part 21 and 10 CFR Part 50 Appendix B.
B. SCOPE:
To ensure that valves, model 7150 and 7250, Class 1 and 2 are
being supplied to Fort Calhoun in accordance with established comitments.
In addition, to ensure that valves and valve spare parts are supplied by
Dresser to the nuclear industry in accordance with established QA
procedures, applicable codes ( ASME Section III) and standards (Appendix
B to 10 CFR Part 50.)
PLANT SITE APPLICABILITY:
Fort Calhoun, 50-285; Perry Nuclear, 50-440, 50-441;
Davis-Besse, 50-346;'Diabl'o Canyon, 502275, 50-323.
kop20o49e60413
999000$99 ENVDagy
__
_
~
.
.
ORGANIZATION: CRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC.
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA
REPORT INSPECTION
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 2 of 7
A. Inspection Issues
The inspection was conducted to determine whether rodels 7150 and 7250
Class 1 and 2 valves are being fabricated and supplied to Fort
Calheun in accordance with the established Dresser QA and CC
commitments. Dresser is supplying these valves as part of the Fort
Calhoun outage work package. During the inspection, observations were
made on the fabrication of other valves and valve spare parts that are to
be supplied to the nuclear industry. The survey consisted of ensuring
that there is proper implementation of Dresser QA procedures, applicable
codes ( ASME Section III) and standards ( Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50.)
B. Inspection Findings
1. Violations .
\
Contrary to section 21.21 of 10 CFR Part 21, evaluations of
defects are not being performed adequately to determine if they
merit reporting in accordance with 10 CFR 21. A review of
Dresser's Part 21 procedure (#003.00 dated March 28, 1984) and
Part 21 evaluation files for 1984 and 1985 concluded that as a
result of an inadequate evaluation on file no. 84-01, Dresser
failed to notify the NRC or its customers of a reportable Part 21
item (85-01-01).
2. Nonconformances
a. Contrary to Criterion VII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50,
and Dresser Industries QAM, Section 6 paragraph 6.,1 and 6.2,
Dresser procured services from two sources that were not on an
approved vendors list (85-01-02),
b. Contrary to Criterion V!1 of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50,
and Dresser Industries procedure QTI-13, paragraph 3.6,
Dresser failed to perform receiving inspection on 4
containers of type 7018 nuclear weldina rods (85-01-03).
c. Contrary to Criterion XII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50,
and Dresser Industries procedure QIT-33, paragraoh 9.0b,
calibration of the Charpy V-Notch Impact Testing Machine has
not been performed during the last five years (85-01-04).
'
.
w
__
. I
,
l
l
ORGANTZATiON: CRESSER INDUSTRIES, 'NC.
.
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA
REPORT INSPECTION
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 3 of 7
d. Contrary to Criterien XII of Appendix B to 10 CFP Part 50,
and Drerser Industries procedure QTI-76, paragraph 2.1, the
calibration certifications (*1343, *6141) for torque
devices had no documentation of a standard serial number.
Therefore, the calibration load cell and readout devices
used as the standard for calibration cannot be traced as
required (85-01-05).
e. Contrary to Criterion XII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50,
and Dresser Industries QAM, Section 12, paragraph 5.1,
calibration of the WR-12 Carbon Determinator (used for analysis
of carbon and sulfur content) was not traceable to national !
standards or equipment manufacturer's recommended standards
(85-01-06).
f. Contrary to Criterion XII of Appendix B to 10 CFR Part 50,
and Dresser Industries procedure QTI-13, paragraph 3.1,
Dresser quality control failed to certify calibration
completed on June 6,1984 for the nuclear welding rod oven l
bi-metal thermometers TG-2, TG-4, TG-6, TG-8, TG-11, TG-20,
TG-21 (85-01-07).
g. Contrary to 10 CFR 21, paragraph 21.21, and Dresser's Part 21
procedure, *003.00, paragraph 3.2, Dresser did not identify / list
the pertinent data to ' substantiate an investigation for
Part 21 file no. 85-01 (85-01-08).
C. Unresolved Items
Nore.
D. Other Findings and Comments
The NRC inspector reviewed the parts and travelers for Class 1 and 2
Dresser /Hancock 7150 and 7250 model valves to verify that heat number
stamping, nondestructive testing, correct calibration of gages,
subcontractor agreements were r'et, and appropriate sign offs were
completed according to Dresser commitments.
The nonconformances found during the inspection did not involve the
fabrication of valve models 7150 and 7250.
' ,
_ .p
.
I
h
. i
ORGANIZATION: DRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC. t
ALEXAMDRIA, LOUISIANA
REPORT INSPECTION
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 4 of 7
1. 10 CFR Part 21 Reauirement
a. A review of Dresser's Part 21 files for 1984 and 1985 noted
that Part 21 file no. 84-01 was not adequately evaluated in
accordance with 10 CFR Part 21 Section 21.21. File no. 84-01
identified a problem with the failure of the disc collar on
model 3707RA safety valves. The file stated this problem was
not reportable since "The failure is an isolated case. Since
1971, Dresser QA system has improved to preclude this failure
mode." However, a letter dated July 2,1984 in the same file
states this failure has happened twice since 1971 once in
August 1981 at Toledo Edison / Davis-Besse and again at Diablo
Canyon in May 1984
Information in file no. 84-01 indicates that in May 1984,
during blowdcwn testing by Wyle Laboratories, Huntsville,
Alabania, on the mai'n steam safety valves from Pacific Gas &
Electric /Diablo Canyon 2 (Dresser valve type 3707RA), valve
S/N BN 1741 lifted with simultaneous shearing of the disc
collar / spindle threads and cotter pin. This occurred during
the first actuation, at approximately 1065 psig. The disc and
spindle deflected sidewise upon closing and the disc became
wedged between the nozzle seat area and the bottom of the disc
.hol de r. The valve became mechanically jammed and could not open.
It also leaked severely because the disc was not seated properly.
2resser was asked about the blow-down problems that they
are presently experiencing on the 3700 series safety relief
valves undergoi'ng testing at Wyle Labs in Huntsville, Alabama
for Toledo Edison / Davis Besse. Specifically, Dresser was
asked whether an investigation / evaluation was done or is
planned to compare the problem experienced with the 3700
series safety relief valves to the problems documented in
file no. 84-01. Dresser's response was "no evaluatinn has
been performed." During a subsequent conference call on
October 10, 1985, Dresser (Mr. J. Watz and Mr. B. Brunson)
stated that " Dresser has performed an evaluation / comparison of
file no. 34-01 and the valves being tested by Wyle Labs and
determined the failure modes were similar. File no. 84-01 will
remain closed, however, a new file, no. 85-04, will be initiated.
This file (85-04) will reference file no. 84-01 and will be
reported as,a Part 21".
Violation 85-01-01 was identified during this part of the
inspection.
.__
._
_
.
.
ORGANIZATION: DRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC.
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA
REPORT INSPECTION
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 5 of 7
.
b. A review was made of Dresser's Part 21 evaluation and reporting
procedure " Evaluating and Reporting of Deviations and/or
Noncompliances Affecting Safety Related to NRC Regulation 10 CFR
Part 21" dated March 28, 1984 and Part 21 evaluation files for
1984 and 1985. This review noted that Dresser did not identify /
list the pertinent data called for in their procedure to
substantiate the investigation for Part 21 file no. 85-01.
This Part 21 file identified a problem with Dresser's model 3050
diaphragm valves sticking partially open or closed. The problem
was reported to the NRC by the Cleveland Electric Illuminating
Co., Perry Nuclear Power Plant. According to Dresser file no.
85-01, the problem was not reportable per 10 CFR 21 since
Dresser had "no knowledge in power plant system design."
However, Dresser's customers were notified. File 85-01 did
not identify / list the information called for in paragraph 3.2
of pr.ocedure no. 003.001 to substantiate an investigation.
In addition, a review of the purchase order and specifications
for valves ordered by the Perry Nuclear Power Plant was performed
by the NRC inspector. This review identified documents which
listed valves as " active" and "non-active", " safety related"
and "non-safety related" and "ASME Class 1, Class 2 or Class 3"
valves. With this information Dresser should have been able to
determine the safety significance of the deviation.
Nonconformance 85-01-08 was identified during this part of the
inspection.
2. Purchase Requirements
An examination was made of 20 purchase orders (P.O.) from Dresser
for outside calibration services for gages, testing and measuring
devices. Dresser was found to have purchased calibration and
certification services for thermocouples TG-2, TG-4, TG-6, TG-8,
TG-11, TG-20, TG-21, from two vendors that were not on Dresser's
approved vendors list. Calibration of the thermocouples was
performed by Honeywell-Houston on August 13, 1980 - Dresser order
- 26229-6'; on October 19, 1982 - Dresser order 848879-6; and, on
December 4, 1984 - Dresser order 447671-6. Likewise, Honeywell -
Ft. Washington, PA performed calibration and certification of the
thermocouples on February 25, 1982 - Dresser order #41201-6. These
thermocouples were used to monitor the temperature of the heat
treating furnaces. '
-
. l
.
.
ORGANIZATION: ORESSER INDUSTRIES, INC.
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA
REPORT INSPECTION
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 6 of 7
.
Nonconformance 85-01-02 was identified during this part of the
inspection.
3. Control of Special Processes
Heat treating and weld rod ovens were inspected and were found
to be adequately calibrated and functioning according to Dresser
procedures. The nuclear welding rod storage area was inspected.
Weld rod containers were stored in either locked cabinets or locked
weld rod ovens. The Section III weld rod ovens were marked " Nuclear."
All rods were stored in the metal containers received and were marked
wit.1 rod specification, lot and/or heat number to maintain trace-
ability. However, four cases were found where containers of Type
7018, nuclear welding rods, lot 3c504YOZ, heat #76175, were not
stam. red (verified) by the receiving inspection personnel. Receiving
Inspection is essential in verifying that cans are properly sealed,.
and that identificatior. numbers, material type, and quantity ordered
are correct. ,
i
l
Nonconformance 85-01-03 was identified during this part of the
inspection. l
3
1
4 Manufacturing Process Control
)
The NRC Inspector reviewed the parts, travelers, and drawings for
four shop orders and verified that specified requirements such as:
(a) heat number stamping, (b) nondestructive testing, (c)
authorized nuclear inspector sign off, (d) final inspection, (e)
calibration of gages, (f) serial number assignment, and (g) heat
treatment had been completed and correctly documented. No
nonconformances were noted in this area.
5. Calibration
The NRC inspector found that torque devices calibration certifications
l
81343 and #6141 had no documentation of a calibration standard serial l
number. Therefore, there is no objective evidence that the torque '
devices were checked using a traceable load cell and readout device
as the standard for measurement.
Nanconformance 85-01-05 was identified during this part of the
inspection.
5
.
Ig '
__ _ __ ___ __ ,
-
1;
.
.
ORGANIZATION: DRESSER INDUSTRIES, INC.
ALEXANDRIA, LOUISIANA
REPORT INSPECTION
NO.: 99900054/85-01 RESULTS: PAGE 7 of 7
The NRC inspector found that calibrations of nuclear welding red
oven bi-metal thermometers (TG-2, TG-4, TG-6, TG-8, TG-11, TG-20,
and TG-21) completed on June 7,1984 were not certified by quality
control. Accurate continuous monitoring of the nuclear weld rod
ovens (between 250 and 300* F) is essential for low hydrogen
electrodes. The temperature range of 250* to 300 F has to be
maintained in order to reduce moisture or hydrogen absorption of the
weld rods.
Nonconformance 85-01-07 was identified during this part of the
inspection.
The NRC inspector reviewed the calibration and procedure requirements
involved in the operation of the WR-12 Carbon Determinator. Dresser
was not able to show that the calibration standards used for
calibrating the carbon determinator are traceable to national
standards or the equipment manufacturer's recommended standards.
The WR-12 Carbon Determinator is used to determine material carbon
and sulfur content. For applications where high levels of carbon
and sulfur are detrimental to impact strength and low levels of
ca.rbon are desirable (i.e., some corrosive environments), accurate
analysis of carbon and sulfur level is essential.
Nonconformance 85-01-06 was identified during this part of the
inspection.
10 Plant Tour
A tour of Dresser's facility was performed by the inspectors. The
activities observed were receiving, nuclear material storage area,
nuclear weloing rod storage area, heat treating furnaces, stock
rooms, valve assembly clean room, calibration records area, and the
metallurgical laboratory. The storage, laboratory and work areas
were neat, clean and free of extraneous materials. Operations
observed appeared to be well planned and progressing in an orderly
fashion.
i 1
'
\
!
.
.
-
'l
PEDSCNS CONTACTED
Company ) ret S YR $^YJCRICC Dates M 20
m .-- r -
49.f
m,=
Occket/ Report No. Q 99806[4 bf- 01 Ins;;ect::r /MMt ' ha. ud.g
-
i
/ <
[s.-12a.s- * ace I of I
NAME(Diesse Drint) TI'l.EIDie!Se DP%tl 0 30'C ' ~'O N / :' u s e : 4 --i
-
S. $ bAUNSc & A'[0Wsc &f, 0weiL &ck he us ex. J/tc
f T BoLfER cw can . c.ur.<, xw swe3 i, ..
1 / 2 E e n n :- (A>l3 sodv !)/0:: ,- Jim
d 9 \//AT 1 9.-c.;'d hA f_% T r e.sser Do
>
i
G C 3 Lu.n c C CNrEase L,as au c a hu mee ve
'). S. L Al
.
D M - c,na m -
n Ku, ivo
v
Dh 0N5 h- iV6A VS?fMS Wl/$oh bry4S$4M j t/ 0
' ,~ .. ., .. n. n
-
.cwAva. = '. .
.
t- a
cf . . u .u . c m,au
.
>ccss z iec
d ZL VAtM RAn VPG Pc5 bnwremt) u.5. A/. R C..
_
k
l
l
t
,
_ _ _ - _ _ - - - . - . - _ -
! .
.
PED.SCNS CONTACTED
Ccepany Dc o s s-a h Dates $hm-u, A - d - y ,m
occket/aeper: no. ?Hwosvhr-n :nscec::r -l C e b,ues /, o , ,.
1
I
/
gi r Dace I of I
NAME(Please Drint) IITLEfDiease Dri"tI l
0:31N??i'ONf3' ease : 4- '-
NbD TNGM&S OA GAi6? Sys% y Aupix DREMEj
- .
.n 4(cwp,g ig
,w m
_ a a _' - t' , s o
, li?fb .
i e L t'c< / 5 ?.-
' 3, \ i-1 G i l.- / I I,a rr J ,-7c s
w30HN d. V44TL Tra ci/d EA LMTP Tresyr 46_d A .
Y S'. Le M . WQom am;
,
'
dBot qcR usc c,vs,,vcen am /r
G C. 5Lu.4 0.'.( Odier rease rz uac Ae, " -
l
F G Beadsca %eea %,n Gn i n
.
'
- l
L D . S l ' , ', ,' yp pc,
'
., p .- - ,. _j, 3,,,y. k ,-
.
_
.
_
h
.
i
i*i :
o
9
l
6
-
y
hl L l
I $' i
,7 y
4 vi Q
<
-
wy
l
-
n x,
e
X :i
I
i
!
i ! q 'Q~a + i
Q >(n i
n ,
,g yi i. v ! u : ,\ ,
i
m yu .
$ \ s
.
l j d (' $ \;
.bh
3!
ra D 4
! \}
w I
iS si
N
i
$! h i
.v . I
4 -o %i
7Nn(. %Gi
I 3 i u !
6 .
b
I
SR ; % m ks h. i
y 'l I
h D
kQ' il
.
i
$
d .
R
E ,
4 fl 4 ! b
2 as i st v, y v m t : h.
o.
-
- w 1: L. at
hu
Ng f.s7 %ji} vLD f
$ u' %%s dr$t $
'
s
' M' s e s$
d
i @:t ag' b 4 44
N $ N c8 7
'
!kd4 1 s
4 3)4
.
%
s
r
a \
i
10
nq
-
S
>
% 4
m
9
\
ia
a
I s.a Jc rs
s
3<
-
8 Y - R zy e A \
t t
$) a k k 43 k k
o
w
a
N 4 m
T
tl 4 4j yc s
- $
' 3
?.
N %s
2 E c
3 'B eRQ
.
y , ! s n 4; e ; de
i ;
'
d 4 %el 2 }
x
e at9$ .4;
s e i (
4
5
4
1 e a$3
t- , 1 4a ') d r ' * y
0
Td i
d
'
., . L
1 Wq t' l i t 3 e siW(
ww a ?;s( b
>
s 04 44
'
,
3 a 4' M W- I
5 Q Osj 0W N3 4 g e 3 #
3
% b"
N '
Eh b lE '
dh$ .
f
1 e 4 444's!444 J Ntt.4 4 M[3 h4
j f
w%sMN '5 = w T S 'g.4 i y%i%
m s w , a .a m -s e=u em s 3e eL
~ ~s
' F-
I
- q %
y b~
au
I-
V as
Lw E 's
u &
O
,
4 A s' y -
y
n
D
- >
Sr.
j sj ~s?>
M N d_W
,. - -
,n
2
,-
' CL
O b s
! ' '
2 ce
W W csQ' s o
~
V
g cz ? N 0 k ,s ~
Fsr
C C5' Q M Nb b
s-
y 8 es ?"
E D E' E 'e .
NJ7o
- '
Q Q Q}~i%( yu e ,,
.
2 I . o 2_ u e : s e ,-
o _ ee
$ $! E ;% a d d h is W W q h 4 W h a 35d N=.
fi g N. AW$ 5 E * * W W W b W kW
7*'TM1
mo ,
o c==d
Ch
'
hM !s M c4 m & % % rh oo cr-i g 2,. d y c$E'd
E
?
.
__. __ . . _ . - - - . - , - -~ -- - - - '
-- i
,
,
'
9
h
s ,
iM,k['g$f$ds'
'
&p, u.
, n.
Rs
w .
i ,g. ,
,.
,
.
.s s
Id .
.w o il l'8
.6 %g hl
. >i i
!$
d :
- i-
.4A
e %;
m r. R:! .
.
,
,
'
m -
'
.
- ,
l
'
- ,
s $,
I t$4
i
E.h.
C"'
. & 1
l
sw! J T
3 s l 193 :: e .l
p %e k i
l* ' '
C
,
(y
'
Q,flt si tg u !
' 4
j i
%-' V % :
t)'l 1, 1 .! : f$ k
h
}
r ) M
x: sii t
4 .: -
g %g4t {
1
!
v i
[ A A ! i i s ;
,
'g 0- s, q ,, N- i s
I l
0
s y : s l 1
-
l
, ,
.. .
=
2
- sk ,f - \ss R ,
.
a' R y
hI : ~ ,
Cl I >g '.
,
'
. .
e >
es -; u( i
B y; c3i !k,
a
r>N
,
1
2 w s : tt
W -\
71
q t
w'I
S 4
u
sle4 i
!
' a
%
e > e r
(l 3d
~ -
J '*
f i 3l ) d E N
1
s 3 xs
q! s N f
Tj S G' d d# d l 'jdd
cb f\
Niji
,
k .'h
-
susw.kil
.-
xh 5
-
wsms k l $mi k
'
ni: ;
24.w
'l !II
N
e
'
'
N - ,
]h i I \
)l '
hlYd
1
I
.
nu'
' q ? %
3 : 1 : s .i
y, e 3
wac h
s 6=2 u
.
u u
i
n c4 :
,ni s e s ,.
-
-=
.
i
M lh i
h Dl D D
e
bot
ew s
' ,
! -
g,Q .
,
-0
2 gr i
,
l l
l 6
c 2uc2Ce
.yce:
O N !
c
s < p
5
y y g I"O g^
gl' o a -
u
"w
F
,
- '
"2 c
'p$ cg e
au s
v
h
$ l' d,,_g -
N 'i "l
oo
H@ l$df
2 V
_
4
,
,
!
'
NMU
w-l N hl Qo (T-' c v===a
.
yl A
% - N l D nj (4 j ~3*l
N. N g l
l
!
,w
5 7 s 2 ' V '-
04b M
_ . _ - . _ . - . ,_. . ~ . _ . . _ . __. . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ - . -.__
'
3.Lwaf
. .
TtJSPEcToR l AFPY D. VA t1GriA/cf
scope- Dock:cT sao. A 9 9 C)O O S'/
OccOMENTS EXAtisdED Rcroar rio. _ V
~
_ J'/
17 Mjg ' mg.4 r 64 0 #. dew E
pnGE $ 06: d
) Te n E /suSjecT
N }_I. . ?L-9I ~~' ~~
3056
_ _ _
P/APA GA C,> n . V' AUC
21 6
2b' %~OA ~
.
2y^_ A/ 84-01 -
& ! S25v2-&RG/rr yALVC. Of-GPADidG Ta !S25 VF-3.-//
-
. .
DISC puT Aivb COTTEp P/M SWCAF/^)Cs ff
]c 2/ S 3 -Q 2- ' -
o
3' ? o c) Eriz/CS
U)N~ VAtyrs _ _s V6 BtomDaM N' P8aBt cms.
[ ~
N UcLcs9g P C vi n~rto N v NoAscamPuRNCC L.os rot { /MitrA /
.
..
SP- $3 /- o/ ~
C c 'Z' 's * D c s/ G F)
'
32-
~
% 2.9- Q O. h__ Yl9b. ' TPrc,ys/zS'gtC7y /%CLATCO Vgl.VCS "
' - Gaff,Rs_QRC ANQ. CMCc_i[. ptLVCS . . 2 Ldsk_ StM LLC &_
y_ PPO 971- 3/ (=,
t0/b7h9 TPccisti
pccx:;gcucp75yplg 4 bocyeciumy.pn~7p/gty71o+)
... _ . _
$b A M.r H P./H'r N 7 Z.(N
Y {Pk_ (~ ll90 A 5
_
!s? o.C &#MEr72' /N~MTrD M&
dst >-5 3/-01-
_f L /S 7 OUq/f_4 pad-Ac 7/gr s'Ar r7y Rft'nFr.D c
_ yAf.VFS__. _
.h S'f'CC g w]-co
~
4
/c'///f__'{ Ss_tt 're 45 . . _ _ - abo VC
O'O ' /^ N7 S.>
_ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . . - _ _ _ .
^
3lA0/Yf U 1 7 csF- S/t L. Or /'?AT S /PCfJT/FY/NG Ct. ASS .I V84.V(3
__
-.
_ . - - . .
'f A 0- ~ "
. - - . .
,
_ _ _ /Jff&vcb Vrf DOP i 'S L iS 1 5 / S S o r l) OyAf]_(gsy__h78{ lbra_9h?/
6/8 */
g VAR ~~ ~ ~
G / 8 5_- ven z>of
Aoec_BetoR7.s 82f _ c4binc7 ccmf DCTRoq nt_cN.
- gy ,, ,,, c nucisi e srecm ry in cre
h@ EdK - _
-
... T 9LM . -
..- --
,, ,,
. - - S' YEA CS' , N' Y- - - -
\/A X
-
Ljj - -
G/8 'i 'l # "
Agtune.D Gr.rce. ABA/ ..oA7/c
,
. . _ _ _ . _ _ _ , ._
i._i _ _ . . _ . .
T/PE 05 DOC:
.
/WA.
d _VCA,3op Aup/7 frCPcM7- /
l p a r. - psmW HG
t r R - L ii T T E R
,
sva
run-- s,eacGnaeE
g
Vccsrecnnsod 1 - fturl.. Al C t/ALUA TIOg g/M
'
nog qis 1AHt)AL - 11 4 _ B P.h K.
- QgJpf1Tf/4 7 FU'T(PWs g g g ac cpcp-l-
gfcn E
<
qc nocuem or
., ,9<,w ract .
_. _ _ _ _ . --
.
ItJsrECToR .] L Mf t A RR7 P- YAOC,HAN
SC. OPE -
_
OOC O tie N TS (W Atie s3 E D
Do cke.T slo. _9990005 Y
Rtt'ont rio. _6 - o/
!
7" MM y *jo"'# RsdI Dtvr E
Ta nE /SuBMcT
'lla ?
N-. .Y0 $
_
_ - _ . - .
9/RS - 1 CFJ.D.o& ( untocust e vci. ps
I'>
GlA I A't UQ11_ RE1Q675.EoE_. .C17c M ff_czipcryg_ /u E
.
. - T .- - .. Glh.G
it i s, it
PA.
W
.
-- -
. . .. -
//8 thy . - . - . -
N ^ ~
&,$jd j a 2/M__
si /t
it et .- &.4AW kAl?6Q M. } f' f f f v M, 1 A .-.
0k
N
/
9/s / *r
/ l' l- AR SON 4 SONS cH/cAg,q,_Tt f..
Y0 8-.. .~~..- - $ ri (t
8}B5 -.- TE XAS 80LT CO
9/8Y NO US7? s .1'X .
-
Vb VA L - ~ ~
A/As
/t /< t< <t
S O W A N _S P /t/n 6 ,._ tro uS7op
-
, TX
h_. ddO__ 2
~
,
_.
98 .ZAR -
-
- /c h Asy uni /P YE~/ Hot
--- - - -
g g g. Aub17 /E'Pof:T
..
..
..- . . .
! !." Y E
, a *
-
-
-.-- - -
Y-
a -w a # # +
,
l Lp.
.
s $Y Q l Y,x'G Y l ,Pj' 5h
~?g
Y l6 )' k-f - t YL
8
_--.1 x
.._- .
. _ . . _ .
N-f {' 0 $-~- Y -h A -- -- -- -- ?- -h - *
[Q AG
- - - ~ ~ - -
- - ... & Ar7 5
. - - - - . . . . . . - - ..
QvAar!'A-T'nA>_Fof R LTMM(4 CAP '90D!7DCk i
G-L H-Or~fh ds);..- f. N. Gkf'C~N T f3/..AEN MQ?..G N 0AAN G,
._ . . . - _ .
.- -
-
-
-
,
T
S=---?0ENEOS
_ . . . _ . - - . -.
y- NEh '* ?) NA NbN O N) '
H-.ScHR o dC&CA;
. . . . .-
- - . . . . . .
T (. M E Z & ^r D _ (1 & , Ft. c 7 c y % _ _
{l ?O. '4 8b 3'3 ~ ?l'.b1, -rc \ . -
- . . . - .
< cixo z.)on7c,p.- cA s7/xs _c onP. qseA1l7x,.ro & . P/5c.
-
TVl'E O 5- doc.
.e
DW - I b5'I\k) i M G (, F R, - (,(( ( ( [ R
i
SPait - 5 5'E c 5 IC nisoel p, .y
un- > enc e ou v e ;Lffvool AODi7 /lf gg
e. g u A/ T /'
q sn - 4 tr 1%n n o s h /]Q t_goryg
qc > - q c nocong.Jr ooAs I F/CRT/cH
rg_ - _. c+,cicc,t ,f 3 r,..ra.. v. .s s
, ,
. . s
. DI e
'
l g
N ,
,
- n
o
.
'
4 4l
f
i
i
i
i
,
i
h, t,j
.
-
M
.
.
c i ! ol . i : i .
0 4; tl -
b ,
a li : , ,
o X ~j ' '
O t
o i ti s
i y
l y N '
IiCq. L t> ke y -
e- i W -
e A b VT (si
'
yi
-
mb% , 'd
0
e s
~ q R> i
.
' .' '
i
' i*9 Gllg 0 RQ <
$
d i% " ti- , s ; , i
'
26 g i A: o a' t
o
.
Q R l !
i ,' '
de bI 3 2 (3
,
- u b ;4
,
,
4: %dh yi
s i I . ' i 1.
s' j
5,w$ R t s. cl T e
'
tl i i
e a
rlAq b
N e i y 1 . . '
o ce c- %s g O! 4 b 4 o e ;' .s j : ; 2 ,'
hw4L Rt < d' n;, I ,
i
q w -
, ,
- r bE qt; u c' R c !
R! , a o i TJ q -
U ( j h l ! o
O
E,
e
f'Ligfti $. $' N7 2 e k t 4, u
b
h
I I
l D$
e -
.w
R sl' R I -
g i
W
2
N O,
cil
O
i L ', x
~
T sh'GM h~
N ni
,s .
N yi (c
w
O.
0 ct
,
l l
E C
6 fD ! k DE k 4. I i g! d
N- l I i
'8
g
- [ f M ,) 21 0 k bd 4 '
' '
c 0
,.
0 i ("{i l
-
',
N.
-
y u
Al R T
m
v3
e i^
i
i Ri
i
-
I
-
,
,
, s
b 3
Li N y @! E n( Qi C1
' '
e i L ei 5 'ci F i
W
2
g 2, d g, l
U '
0 v'
<
i I
h
'
l '
i c4~
4 w
0
A k Ak an
w O. C1 t a L(. a I -
r
i
pl X '\ l o Lg s L !
C19
o
v
I
Li
i e'
' R -
q we. R Mi Lu
R
s
-
N. . s h!wl l
s
~ ri ad'sa-
gl ' c! ' ,,(s g N 3 N
q ,
o -in
y , %y 4
o 4 ! ,
I
P_ n
- '
-
,, % , R > g i j
,i p
, ,
,
- , .
, ,
e i
$ hMhk
s s e $s elkll.: f
!
!
.
-
,
$hd
- ces
m n i,i, -w s w
. .
- ;
a o. i ei : ! 1
3" .h llL/1 !P Cs! m el
qlM. or
'- ' i ill ll ll l l' %,W
se m
m n s s
.
m <?
$ d d ' c'-
l >; w
fl,'h ,
l Nl L'
-
A
cc
3
{2
g
d $ (i
>t
B; ',
g'
e
(c: e{
4'
(
g; e
q'
4.
(ie, x
i
-l- (MCl(!OC'b!
,
,s is
,!
iOi
N T
M y OO bL I k b, l hlh'
su e m$$
.
.
-
2 : i ;
'
I
O
-i,$ I.I C'i
Q c,'9
!
l
'O clC
M
c
%! w O g:l
q- ol A
C C!c
G A
Clcl!5'h5
,',t
e ll eg qlp:
v s
yg Q;w t -
c. ! O,. (! q i
,
%
egig.o .,f
u
- mie c. c
,e ..
m
Q b 4 N
a q, Q j \g, r
I I
Q4 %l w w
i i
,
s = 3 :- ee
,
d.(.. pudj , -
- ntsPECTo R t A RR Y O- v'A u GHAN
St. OPE oocvm_r do. _7 99 0o0 5'/
_
O OC O t4E tJ TS liX Alie d E D Rcg> oar rio. _8$'- (>/
j;"J $
Mg, *4'"M asv 1 pawe PnGc 6 _ o s: C __
( Tine /suaaacT
_
. ,._. .
._-_ _ _
... $-
$0N_._ ...NS_0$$_lD61_ __ D$ h.V$-
_
. _ . _ _ _.. __ _.? .
. _ .
__ _ _.
RDO
-. -_ _ . . . - _
9a676
- - - -
(78
-.
- .
_ - _ . -
. _ . . _ .
a " - _ -
-
~ ' ~ ~ ~
_ _ _ _ . _ . _
.___...____._____-
_ 0'l ? l _
_
II " U
_ _ . . . _ _ _ .
yp eDo asmo -
o u o
Yl
-_
PRO
-
oo3 o 0 -
's/A'At c e Ai. un 7in s ob pc rorvriw:_, o r o c wg ,,c.,y,
._
__ - - _ _
. _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ . _ _ _ .
_ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ yy/oa
NO v t'nMPL /AA/iXL
___
AEUd_/NC ..1 -2- [U_E..f G d Z_&.
. _ . _ _ . . _ _ - - . . _ . _ _-__._ _ ._ _ . .
._ - _ . . _
b) . NS ?- ' ?0Y.N~h O/Y '
' t.1. b'-
.
.~..._k{' _
'
. _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ -
.__.__ _ __
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . . . _
- -- -
.. ~. .. __ _ _ .
-~~-
.._.-_.-___._..._..-. . . _ _ . .
---
_ _. _ _ _ . _
- - - - -
_
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . .. .
___ ._
4__.._. ._. _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ ..
_ . _ . . _ _ ~ _ . _ . . . _ _ . . . .
-_._ _ _ __. .
___
- . _ _ _ . . _ . _ _ _ .
- _ _ _ . _ - - . .
._ .
__ _._ . . _ _ _ _ . _ . _ . ._ . _ . _ _ . _ _ . . _ . . _ . . . . _ .
. _ _ _ _ _ . _ .___ _. _ __ ___ _ _ _ _ _ . . __
.
_.
.
._____l _
1 __i
._.__.i._______.._.___.._._. __ __.__
_ _ _ _ . . . _ . . _ _ _
TVl'E 0 5- Doc *.
.e
DSJ G - DI?ObJ IPJ G ( l' R
srec- ss>ccirec ni oa >o g f {Teci
.er ([ g,i cN N ,' N /OM OB Df'8 #
gun _ r enc G no u r. e - y , . , w .,. r., , a n 1,.
n
All - Q a\ iM *3 0 A l_ g g .- 3 pgZ e g g ,g,. y ,q . n .2,s.v c e (~e,2rir,4,4t,..,/
tU-QC nolve aus Y
., . . . . . . . . . . . . - - . . . , _A. L _jw.j ',y, , ,y a s , r . . -,<<r >o.- v
-. , . . - - - -
__ _ _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~