TXX-6148, Forwards Revs 0 to Evaluation & Resolution of Generic Technical Issues for HVAC Sys..., SAG.CP23, Seismic Design Criteria... & SAG.CP24 as Part of Facility Response Team Cable Tray & Conduit Support Program
| ML20207P635 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 12/23/1986 |
| From: | Counsil W, Keeley G TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC) |
| To: | Noonan V NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20207P636 | List: |
| References | |
| TXX-6148, NUDOCS 8701160347 | |
| Download: ML20207P635 (14) | |
Text
,
Log # TXX-6148 File # 10068 10010 clo TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY fiv C$ b
[(G:Ut I, kt December 23, 1986 G
dA A
a[Qcu"w r
ra = =:n, n,q
Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
& bo[ <35 M Attention: Mr. Vince S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project Division of Licensing
, _. f g g U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555
SUBJECT:
COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)
DOCKET NOS. 50-445 AND 50-446 TRANSMITTAL OF DOCUMENTS FOR EVALUATION AND RESOLUTION OF GENERIC TECHNICAL ISSUES FOR HVAC DUCTS AND DUCT SUPPORTS
Dear Mr. Noonan:
Enclosed are 15 copies of the documents for " Evaluation and Resolution of Generic Technical Issues for HVAC Ducts and Duct Supports prepared by Ebasco Services Incorporated for Texas Utilities Generating Company. These documents are part of the Comanche Peak Response Team Cable Tray and Conduit Support Program initiated by Texas Utilities.- A list of enclosures is attached for your. convenience.
Should you have any questions please do not hesitate to call John Beck or mysel f.
Ltv-Sic.\\
Very truly yours, Dace 3en3 3
3
% NorMin 2
2.,
Re3 4i\\e5 l
I W. G. Counsil C..T rommtl \\
i nnneget \\licMi-l I
By:
cook G. S. Keeley D / -
g Manager,Nuclearpicensing LPDR.
JDS/mlh o c POR
\\
Attachment Enclosures NG L C.
I I
ftCS.$
\\
\\
R.Woro 9 I
I oP
" ' ~ '
8701160347 861223 7,Z.
PDR ADOCK 05000445 A
4 C' : Attachment to TXX-6148
. December 23, 1986 Page 1 of I list of Enclosures Enclosure A:
. Evaluation and Resolution of Generic Technical Issues -for HVAC Systems (Including Ducts and Duct Supports), EBASCO Summary Matrix.
Enclosure B:
Texas Utilities Generating. Company Comanche-Peak Steam Electric Station, Evaluation and Resolution of Generic-Technical Issues for HVAC Systems (Including Ducts and Duct Supports).
Enclosure C:
Reference Documents, ~ 4 Volumes a:; follows:
CI:
Reference:
2 C2:
Reference:
4 Sections 3.1.2, 3.1.3,.3.2, 3.3 and 3.4 Atts. 5-1, 5-2, 12, 13 and 15 6
Books 6, 9 and 16 7
9 13 14 15 16 18 Appendix K C3:
Reference:
3
'C4:
Reference:
20 21 l
L
r
.ms 3
4 s
v Log # TXX-6148 File # 10068 10010 clo TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY,.
..qc December 23, 1986
~86 DEC 29 Pl2:03 WhlC L M 2, 0 FT,'..
00G6e; Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention: Mr. Vince S. Noonan, Director Comanche Peak Project Division of Licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555
SUBJECT:
COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION (CPSES)
DOCKET NOS. 50-445 AND 50-446 TRANSMITTAL OF DOCUMENTS FOR EVALUATION AND RESOLUTION OF GENERIC TECHNICAL ISSUES FOR HVAC DUCTS AND DUCT SUPPORTS f
Dear Mr. Noonan:
Enclosed are 15 copies of the documents for " Evaluation and Resolution of Generic Technical Issues for HVAC Ducts and Duct Supports" prepared by Ebasco Services Incorporated for Texas Utilities Generating Company. These documents are part of the Comanche Peak Response Team Cable Tray and Conduit Support Program initiated by Texas Utilities. A list of enclosures is attached for your convenience.
Should you have any questions please do not hesitate to call John Beck or mysel f.
Very truly yours,
'-lf W. G.
cunsil By:
G. S. Keeley G /_
Manager,Nuclearpicensing l
JDS/mlh Attachment Enclosures A atMNON OF TEXA8 LTTLTTIES R&aCTRfC COMPANY
. - _ _ _ _ _ _ -,.. - - _. _ ~. - _ _ _ _.. _. - _ __...,- _ _
Attachment to TXX-6148-h,,
December 23, 1986-Page 1 of 1 l
e'
,e List of Enclosures
' Enc 1osure A:
~ Evaluation and Resolution of Generic Technical Issues for
~
HVAC Systems (Including Ducts and Duct Supports), EBASCO Summary Matrix.
j Enclosure B:
Texas Utilities Generating Company Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Evaluation and Resolution of Generic Technical Issues for HVAC Systems (Including Ducts and Duct Supports).
Enclosure C:
Reference Documents, 4 Volumes as follows:
CI:
Reference:
2 C2:
Reference:
4 Sections 3.1.2, 3.1.3, 3.2, 3.3 and 3.4 Atts. 5-1, 5-2, 12, 13 and 15 6
Books 6, 9 and 16 7
9 13 14 15 16 18 Appendix K C3:
Reference:
3 C4:
Reference:
20 21 9
e
% i, Q 9,.
F Wgg 7...... n P
M M
1_
n.
n n
D n
n COMANCME PEAR STRAM ELECTRI'3 STATION 32/15/86 ESASCO EVALUATION AND anewWION OF CENERIC TOCISICAL Bew. O ISSUES FOR HVAC SYSTEMS (IECIADIWC DUCTS AND DUCT SUPPORTS)
SUBSIARY MATRIK CENERAL ISSUE RESOLUTION APPENDIE SUB-ISSUE ISSUE ummen CENERIC TECHNICAL ISSUE TITLE DESICWATION CATECORY REFERENCE SECTION C1 Controlling 1.oad Case for Design DC. AMA 2
III.A. IV 3
Att F E2 Seismic Response Combination Method A
DC. AMA 2
IV.3.c B
AMA 3
Att F C3 Anchor Solt Design A
AMA 2
IV.1.a 3
Att C9 6
- Book 3 B
DC. AAA 2
IV.1.f.11 C
DC 2
IV.1.f.11 Apr 2 3
Att C D
DC. AMA 2
IY.1.f.11 E
AMA 2
IV.1.f.11 3
Att C 6
- Sook 3 11 F
AS 2
111.1. III.2 3
Att R 6
Book 16 C
AMA 2
17.1.t.11 3
Att C g
6
- sook 3 2:
11 9
l 1
8 N
AS 2
III.2 3
Att I ISSUE CATECORY LECEND AMA = Analysis Methods & Assumptions
- Referente under develorment DC
= Design Criterla DOCC = Design Document Control AB
= As-Duilt vs. As-Designed 0657a
-.a
I U
68/O 5
31.
/ 7 2 3 1 R I
U 38 9
C 5
2 N
t 1
8 O
t 8
0 I
A3 1
21 l
l
- e. 3 17 N
T 2
2 E
I S
O C
.k 2
E E
- 2. E 8
I 3
)
k I
k
- 1. t I
E pI o p
t 1
t o t
It T
t o LR T
S pI o p
t I
t o t
It Vt V.
t o AO U
AIB A
A I3 - - -
AB A
I P O
N U S
I E
t S
O R
E m
N U
U C
p O CD S
N o
l I
S E
f e
T RD I
R 236 2
7 7
3 34345 36 3
23 23 23 36 v
A EN E
1 1
111 T NA F
e S E E
d C CS R
r T
e I
FC d
2 OU n
T D E I
u C N E OC R L IN T ec E TI A U3 M ne M LU A OL T re E SC R f
T EN A e
S RIM R
( D K D U
A NS S T
AM L
R EP E
AEO NT RUC E
ESE OS M IT NST A
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A
TS EIA M
B C
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
CN C
C A
A D
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A
M U *C.
L O AY.
C VM E R OO N
J K
A 8
C D
E F
C A
B S
IC S
- I BS I
UE C
SD s
s n
d o
a i
n o
t o
t p
C E
m d
L g
l u
l e T
n a
s on I
s i
i s
rg T
r d
t A
ti
)
e a
r ns E
d b
U 4s e
oe S
't m
1 t n
CD e
r I
s I
S n
M eo d at s I
o sp d
D ol nA C
n rp n
N hre I
L
(
o eu a
E t em.
A i
vS C
et us C
n s
s d
E Micv i
g s
ne a
L ro u
i e
ap e
sCDt n
s r
ry D
T i
l M
s e
p TT R
snni i
D m
e O
yggu i
o dl m
C lii B t
C na a
E ass -
C l
an r
T nees T
o f
i F
A ADDA R
B o
F ld C
au t
==
N r
n ct r
E R
E o
g ii o
U C
C h
i t g p
S A
C c
s rn p
S MCOB n
e eo u
I ADDA A
D Vs S
K I
R DR NE EB 3
4 5
6 PM 0
0 0
0 u
PU AN an l
I
9 f
o68 3/O 5
e1.
g/ v a2 e 2
P1R 1
5 1
t t
t A
t A
2 1
3 B.
A.
2 1
J J
1 3
3 J
c.
5 3
3 3
3 3
8 8
8 VI VI 2
VI 2
2 I
I 2
I V
1 B
0 2
2 I
I 2
.H
.H I
1 1
5 5
.N I
I 5
N d.
d.
d.
I I
O 1
5 B.
3 1
I I2 I2 V
- c. 9 2
5 l
l 1
- a. I 2 1
N T
,E
.E E2 E2 B
C B
.E 1
1 8
2
)
S O
C
- 1. k
- 1. b t T
I E
- b. t
- b. t t
t o
t1 t
t1 t
t t
I 1
t I
LR T
S t
t Vo t
t t
t t
t V
.t 1
t I
AO U
1A IA A
IB A3 A
A3 A
A A
IEA 1
A I
CP L
IP O
NU S
t HS E
n C
R e
ET m
TC E
E p
N U U
YO CD S
o l
NI S
E I
e AT RD I
R 3
3 3
26 34 3
34 3
3 3
23 2
2 3
2 v
PA EN E
e MT NA F
d OS E E
C CS R
r C
T e
CI FC d
NR OU n
IT D E u
TC N I
AE OC R e
RL IN T c
EE TI A n
N UD M e
EN LU r
CA OL Y e
E SC R f
ST EN A e
ES RIG R
E I
( D TK D U
IA NS S Y
LE AM L
R A
IP E
AEO M
T NT RUC A
UE OS ESE H IY NST A
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A
SC TS E IA M
M M
M C
M M
M M
M M
M B
M M
AN A C
C A
A A
A D
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A
AA UC EM LA TO AV C VN E E OC N
CF O
B C
A 8
C D
E F
A 3
C S
IC S
- I I
)
i F
t g
A p
E n
D m
d L
i
(
u l e T
t s
on I
c s
y s
rg T
e r
s d
A ti l
o ne u
ns E
g t
ol s
t oe U
e c
io l
S CD S
N a
t H e
s S
F c
d n
dat s I
s et o o D
oinA e
n Sl N i N
hre L
cy o
o t
E t em.
A at i
rB N
a G
et us C
ri t
e A
i E
Ml cv I
Bc a
b o R
v L
eo N
i c
mt T
e sCDt H
er i
e S
D T
i l
C l t f
Me t
A R
snni E
gn i
u p
N t
O yggu T
ne l
nd e
n C
li iB Ac p
i c
f i
E ass -
C c
m s
n o o T
nees I
fE A
ne o
P A
ADDA R
o oi C
y C
E g
c it t
g
==
N nn i
t r m
i n E
E gi m
c e e
d i
U C
C id a
u r
t l
k S
A C
sa n
d s
l r
S MCOB eo y
e y
a o
I ADDA DL D
RT S
V W
X I
DR NE e
EB F
8 9
0 1
2 7
PM O
0 0
1 1
1 5
PU 4
AN 0
I llj il;
t m
m m
fm
.m m
- 7**, * * ~...m m
m r
CONASCHE PEAK STEAll ELECTRIC BTAf!OE 12/15/96 ESASCO EVAIA'ATION AB SESofETION or CMIC TSCIWICAL Dev. O ISSUES FOR HVAC SYSTEMS (IlfCLUDI5C DUCTS A m SWCT SUFFORTS)
SUfetASY HATWII Commear Issus aggotyyIog AppsuDIK SUS-ISSUE ISSUE menee camemIC TROWICAL ISSUE TITLE DESICWATION CAT 500RY REFERENCE SBCTION 12 Idorking Point Deviation Study (Cont'd)
D AMA 2
III
. Apr 2 3
I.
1.. Atts. 5. E. C.
N. I J 4
3.1.2.5.10. 3.3.1.A.3. Att 15 6
- Sook 3 6
Sook 16 11 E
ASEA 2
III.2.3 F
AB. AMA 2
IV.1.s I
3 Att E2 C
DOCC 2
IV.1.s 3
Att E2 K
AMA 2
III.2 I
AMA 2
III.2 J
AMA 3
Att El 13 meduced Spectral Accelerations A
Afl4 2
III.1. III.2 IV.2.c 3
ASEA 2
IV.2.c. III.1. III.2 3
Att 31. 52. 33 C
AMA 3
sII. Att C9 14 Non-Confomance with AISC Specifications A
DC. AIIA 17 3
DC. AIIA 3
Att V 6
Dook 6 17 l
C DC. AIIA 3
Att 52 4
3.1.2.B.11, 3.1.2.3.12. Att 12 17 l
l ISSur cATEcoer tactuo AMA = Analyste Nethode & Assumptions
- Reference under development l
= Design Criteria l
DOCC = Deelga Document Control AB
= As-Built vs. As-Designed na u.
l C
R C
I l
I C
2 ggg age $
COMANCHE PEAR STEAN ELECTRIC 37ATION 12/15/86 BSASCO EVALUATION AND RESOLUTION OF CENERIC TEclef! CAL R2v. O ISSUES FOR HVAC STSTEMS (ICCLUDING DUCTS AND DUCT SUPPORTS)
SUsetART MATRIK CENERAL ISSUE RESOLUTION APPENDIZ SUS-ISSUE ISSUE I'JMBER CEWERIC TFCHNICAL ISSUE TITLE DESTC5ATION CATECORT REFERENCE SECTION 14 Non-Conformance with AISC Specifications D
DC. AMA (Cont'd)
E DC. AMA 2
IV.1.s 3
1.b. I.d. IV Att E2, H. I and J F
DC. AMA 3
VIII 6
- Book 13 17 0
DC. AMA 2
17.1.f 15 Member substitution DOCC. AB 2
III.2 16 Weld Design and Specifications A
AB 2
III.2 3
Att X 6
- Book 20 8
AB 2
III.2 3
Att X 6
- Book 20 C
AMA 2
IV.1.s 3
I.b. I.d D
DC 3
II E
AMA 2
III.2 3
Att X
- Book 20 17 Embedded Plates Design A
AMA 2
App 2 3
VII 11 App 2. 4. 4W. 5. 5W 8
AMA 2
App 2 3
VII 11 App 2. 4. 4W. 5. 5W ISSUE CATECORT Lactuo AMA = Analysis Methods & Assumptions
- Reference under development DC
= Design criteria DOCC = Design Document Control AB
= As-Built vs. As-Designed 0657s
1 M
n n
P R
R C Q g ggg %
R R
R
_ C %2 6
- f U
CoeuusCHE PEAK STEAM EL7IC STATION 12/15/86 NW ETAl#2 TION AND FESOLUTION OF CENERIC TECIMICAL Rev. O ISSUES FOR NVAC SYSTEMS (IEC1RDINC DUCTS AND DUCT SUFFORTS)
SUDOMRT MATOTE CENERAL ISSUE RESotAFTION APPENDIZ SUS-ISSUE ISSUE NUseER CENERIC TECHNICAL IOSUE TITLE DESICNATION CATECORY REFERENCE SECTION 17 Embedded Plates Design (Cont'd)
C DC 2
App 2 3
VII 11 App 2, 4. 4W. 5. SW D
AB 4
3.1.2.B.6. Att 5. 13 E
AB 2
III.1 3
II F
DC 2
Apr 2 11 App 2 18 System Support Co.wiections AMA 3
II. Att 81. 82. 83 4
3.1.2.8.10. 3.3.1.A.3. Att 15 19 FSAR toad Combinations DC 9
20 Differences Between Installation AB 2
III.2 and Design / Construction Drawings Without Appropriate Documentation 21 Design Control A
DOCC AB 2
III.2 3
Att I B
DOCC. AB 2
III.2 3
Att X i
l l
C AB. DOCC 2
III.2 3
Att K l
D AMA. DOCC 2
III.2 3
Att C1 2
AS 2
III.2 3
Att I F
DOCC 18 App K C
DOCC 18 App K N
DC 2
II.la. II.2 l
\\
i l
TSSUE CATECORT LECFWD l
AMA = Analysis Methods & Assumptions
- Reference under development I
= Design criteria i
DOCC = Design Dociar-nt Control
)
= As-Built vs. As-Designed 0457s I
E HM M
M MSMESMUMM M7 O
7 O
.I
~
COMANO8E PEAR STEAM ELECTRIC STATICII 12/15/86 ESASCO ETALUATION AND RESOLUTIOS OF CENERIC TECINICAL Rev. O ISSUES FOR FTAC SYSTEMS (INCLUDIsc DUCTS AND DUCT SUPPORTS)
SUIstARY MATRTE CENERAL TSSUE RESCtET!75 APPENDIX SUS-ISSUE ISSUE BUlf9ER CENERIC TECNWTCAL ISSUE TITLE DESICNATIOW CATECOEY REFERENCE St TION 21 Design control (Cont'd)
I AB. DOCC 2
III.2 3
Att Z 22 Design of Support No. 3136. Detail AMA. DC "S"
Drawing 2323-3-C905.
23 Leadint in STRESS Models A
AMA 3
Att B3 3
AMA 2
III.1 3
II C
AMA 2
III 3
1 23 Design of Flexurst Members A
AMA 3
Att 31. 52, 83 8
AMA 3
Att St. 82. 83 C
AMA 3
Att 31. 82. 33 D
AMA 3
Att 31, B2. 83 E
AMA. DC 3
Att E2 13 14 15 P
AMA 3
VI C
AMA 3
Att V2 6
Book 6
, 17 25 System Strwetural Quellfication A
AMA 2
IV.1.d. IV.2.d. V S
AMA 2
III C
DOCC AB 2
III.1 3
Att C1 ISSUE CATECORY LBC1 tup AMA = Analysis Methods & Assumptions
- Reference under development DC
= Design Criteria DOCC. Design Document Control AB
= As-Built vs. As-Designed 0657a
M M'
M M
M M
% Mg&g U
F CDMANCHE ptAK STRAN ELECTRIC STATICE 12/15/96 saaern EVALUATION AND RESOUFTION OF CENERIC TSOWICAL Bew. 9 ISSUES POE HVAC SYSTWIS (INCLUDING DUCTS AND DUCT SUpp0RTS)
SupetARY MATRIE CEstaAL ISSUE DESOLUTION Appt3DIZ SCS-ISSUE ISSUE UUDIBER CENFRIC TTOerICAL ISSUE TTTLE DESICWATION CATECORT WWFERENCE SECTION 25 System Structural quellfication (Cont'd)
D AMA 6
- sook 15 7
26 Sase L gle Design A
AMA 3
AMA 3
Att E2 C
AMA 2
III.2 O
AMA 2
III.2 27 Suppert Qualification by Similarity A
AMA 2
III.2 28 Critleal Support configurations and A
AMA 2
III.2 Imadings 29 Chamulatlwe Effect of Review Issues AMA. DC. DOCC. AB 30 System Desping values AMA 2
IV.I.c 31 Modeling of Boundary Conditions AMA 3
III 6
- Book 3 32 Concrete volds DC 3
III. Att C 4
3.1.2.3.9. 3.3.1.A.10 33 Caps Between Duet and Da t Support AMA 3
Att 31. 32. 33 4
3.1.2.3.10. 3.3.1.A.3 Att 15 34 Attachment of Transwerse Supports AMA 3
Att St. 32. 33 to Ducts 35 Integrity of Duct Joints DC 34 Effects of Openlass In Ducts DC. AMA 37 son-Linear Response of Fire Desper DC. AMA Sleeve ISSUE CAT 3 Cont LICEWO AMA = Anslysis Methods & Assassytless 85eference under development DC
= Design Criteria DOCC. Design Docsament Control As
. As-su11t vs. As-Designed 0657.3
[
[
- !e ni
[
[
,l =ia gi i
s s
Ej. t.
lgi _l l
U mj u,
1 l si l
}
.;l=l s
r e
s i
a x
x i
a el.
11 l
c-ti I
[
l Ru F -1 n.
[
i f
]
- 31
~
[
g i ]i i
l1;ja 8
I!
=~
=i
[
[
il vr 5
jf I i$E
~;lij~!Si il
. ills!
~
a o
[
l sv 11 a sa!
11 2
g Ixt n1 x2
[
llx x
s 8
..... -.....