|
---|
Category:Letter type:RA
MONTHYEARRA-19-091, Commitment Change Summary Report - 20192019-12-27027 December 2019 Commitment Change Summary Report - 2019 RA-19-080, Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) Related to Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station - Post-Shutdown Decommissioning Activities Report2019-10-18018 October 2019 Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) Related to Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station - Post-Shutdown Decommissioning Activities Report RA-19-076, Request for Continuation of NRC Actions and Approvals Following Transfer of the Licenses from Exelon Generation to Holtec Decommissioning International, LLC2019-09-12012 September 2019 Request for Continuation of NRC Actions and Approvals Following Transfer of the Licenses from Exelon Generation to Holtec Decommissioning International, LLC RA-19-065, Signature Verification and Acceptance of Amendment 19 to Indemnity Agreement No B-37 to Renewed Facility License No. DPR-162019-08-28028 August 2019 Signature Verification and Acceptance of Amendment 19 to Indemnity Agreement No B-37 to Renewed Facility License No. DPR-16 RA-19-052, Security Plan, Training Qualification Plan, Safeguards Contingency Plan, (Revision 18)2019-06-11011 June 2019 Security Plan, Training Qualification Plan, Safeguards Contingency Plan, (Revision 18) RA-19-023, Annual Radioactive Effluent Release Report for 20182019-04-30030 April 2019 Annual Radioactive Effluent Release Report for 2018 RA-19-019, Submittal of Changes to Technical Specifications Bases2019-04-12012 April 2019 Submittal of Changes to Technical Specifications Bases RA-19-012, Supplement for License Amendment Request - License Condition Revision for Removal of Cyber Security Plan Requirements2019-03-0707 March 2019 Supplement for License Amendment Request - License Condition Revision for Removal of Cyber Security Plan Requirements RA-19-007, Response to RAI and Supplemental Information Re Request for Changing Emergency Preparedness License Amendment 294 Effective Date (Change to Adiabatic Heat-Up Calculation)2019-02-13013 February 2019 Response to RAI and Supplemental Information Re Request for Changing Emergency Preparedness License Amendment 294 Effective Date (Change to Adiabatic Heat-Up Calculation) RA-19-003, Amendment No. 17 to Indemnity Agreement No. 8-372019-01-0808 January 2019 Amendment No. 17 to Indemnity Agreement No. 8-37 RA-18-103, Annual Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report - 20182018-12-13013 December 2018 Annual Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report - 2018 RA-18-080, License Amendment Request: License Condition Revision for Removal of Cyber Security Plan Requirements2018-11-12012 November 2018 License Amendment Request: License Condition Revision for Removal of Cyber Security Plan Requirements RA-18-098, License Amendment Request Supplement - Proposed Change of Effective and Implementation Dates of License Amendment No. 294, Oyster Creek Emergency Plan for Permanently Defueled Emergency Plan and Emergency Action Level Scheme2018-11-0606 November 2018 License Amendment Request Supplement - Proposed Change of Effective and Implementation Dates of License Amendment No. 294, Oyster Creek Emergency Plan for Permanently Defueled Emergency Plan and Emergency Action Level Scheme RA-18-097, Exelon Nuclear Radiological Emergency Plan and Addendum Revisions2018-10-24024 October 2018 Exelon Nuclear Radiological Emergency Plan and Addendum Revisions RA-18-092, License Amendment Request - Proposed Change of Effective and Implementation Dates of License Amendment No. 294, Oyster Creek Emergency Plan for Permanently Defueled Emergency Plan and Emergency Action Level Scheme2018-10-22022 October 2018 License Amendment Request - Proposed Change of Effective and Implementation Dates of License Amendment No. 294, Oyster Creek Emergency Plan for Permanently Defueled Emergency Plan and Emergency Action Level Scheme RA-18-093, Request to Reinitiate Consultation Regarding the OCNGS Sea Turtle Incidental Take Statement2018-10-16016 October 2018 Request to Reinitiate Consultation Regarding the OCNGS Sea Turtle Incidental Take Statement RA-18-091, Request to Reclassify Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station Under 10 CFR 171.15, Annual Fees: Reactor Licenses and Independent Spent Fuel Storage Licenses2018-10-0101 October 2018 Request to Reclassify Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station Under 10 CFR 171.15, Annual Fees: Reactor Licenses and Independent Spent Fuel Storage Licenses RA-18-090, Notice Regarding Proposed Amendment No. 1 to Master Terms for Decommissioning Trust Agreements2018-10-0101 October 2018 Notice Regarding Proposed Amendment No. 1 to Master Terms for Decommissioning Trust Agreements RA-18-083, Certification of Permanent Removal of Fuel from the Reactor Vessel for Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station2018-09-25025 September 2018 Certification of Permanent Removal of Fuel from the Reactor Vessel for Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station RA-18-088, Radiological Emergency Plan Addendum Revision. Includes EP-AA-1010, Addendum 3, Revision 4, Emergency Action Levels for Oyster Creek.2018-09-25025 September 2018 Radiological Emergency Plan Addendum Revision. Includes EP-AA-1010, Addendum 3, Revision 4, Emergency Action Levels for Oyster Creek. RA-18-087, Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) Related to Post-Shutdown Decommissioning Activities Report2018-09-24024 September 2018 Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) Related to Post-Shutdown Decommissioning Activities Report RA-18-084, Secondary Containment Capability Test2018-09-14014 September 2018 Secondary Containment Capability Test RA-18-078, Submittal of Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report 2018-0042018-08-15015 August 2018 Submittal of Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report 2018-004 RA-18-077, Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report 2018-0032018-08-14014 August 2018 Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report 2018-003 RA-18-072, Pressure and Temperature Limit Report Revision 12018-06-29029 June 2018 Pressure and Temperature Limit Report Revision 1 RA-18-066, Response to Questions Pertaining to Licensed Operator2018-06-18018 June 2018 Response to Questions Pertaining to Licensed Operator RA-18-070, Submittal of Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report 2018-001 on June 04, 20182018-06-0808 June 2018 Submittal of Sea Turtle Incidental Take Report 2018-001 on June 04, 2018 RA-18-068, Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) Regarding Request for Approval of Decommissioning Quality Assurance Program, Revision 0 for Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station2018-06-0606 June 2018 Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) Regarding Request for Approval of Decommissioning Quality Assurance Program, Revision 0 for Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station RA-18-065, Registration of Use of Cask to Store Spent Fuel2018-05-31031 May 2018 Registration of Use of Cask to Store Spent Fuel RA-18-059, Request for Relief and Rescission of Commission Order Modifying Licenses with Regard to Requirements for Mitigation Strategies for Beyond-Design-Basis External Events2018-05-30030 May 2018 Request for Relief and Rescission of Commission Order Modifying Licenses with Regard to Requirements for Mitigation Strategies for Beyond-Design-Basis External Events RA-18-055, 10 CFR 50.46 Annual Report2018-05-23023 May 2018 10 CFR 50.46 Annual Report RA-18-053, Update to Spent Fuel Management Plan2018-05-21021 May 2018 Update to Spent Fuel Management Plan RA-18-052, Supplement to Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 50.54(w)(1), Concerning On-Site Property Damage Insurance and Supplement to Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 140.11(a)(4), Concerning Primary and Secondary ...2018-05-0808 May 2018 Supplement to Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 50.54(w)(1), Concerning On-Site Property Damage Insurance and Supplement to Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 140.11(a)(4), Concerning Primary and Secondary ... RA-18-049, Registration of Use of Cask to Store Spent Fuel2018-05-0707 May 2018 Registration of Use of Cask to Store Spent Fuel RA-18-046, Oyster Creek, Transmittal of Annual Radiological Environmental Operating Report for 20172018-04-30030 April 2018 Oyster Creek, Transmittal of Annual Radiological Environmental Operating Report for 2017 RA-18-047, Annual Radioactive Effluent Release Report for 20172018-04-30030 April 2018 Annual Radioactive Effluent Release Report for 2017 RA-18-018, Submittal of Changes to Technical Specifications Bases2018-04-13013 April 2018 Submittal of Changes to Technical Specifications Bases RA-18-021, Request for Exemption from Record Retention Requirements2018-04-12012 April 2018 Request for Exemption from Record Retention Requirements RA-18-028, Request for Rescission of Commission Order Modifying License with Regard to Reliable Hardened Containment Vents Capable of Operation Under Severe Accident Conditions (Order Number EA-13-109)2018-04-12012 April 2018 Request for Rescission of Commission Order Modifying License with Regard to Reliable Hardened Containment Vents Capable of Operation Under Severe Accident Conditions (Order Number EA-13-109) RA-18-027, Request for Rescission of Commission Order Modifying Licenses with Regard to Reliable Spent Fuel Pool Instrumentation (Order Number EA-12-051)2018-04-12012 April 2018 Request for Rescission of Commission Order Modifying Licenses with Regard to Reliable Spent Fuel Pool Instrumentation (Order Number EA-12-051) RA-18-036, Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) and Supplement Regarding License Amendment Request - Proposed Defueled Technical Specifications and Revised License Conditions for Permanently Defueled ...2018-03-29029 March 2018 Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) and Supplement Regarding License Amendment Request - Proposed Defueled Technical Specifications and Revised License Conditions for Permanently Defueled ... RA-18-019, Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 50.54(w)(1), Concerning On-Site Property Damage Insurance2018-03-29029 March 2018 Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 50.54(w)(1), Concerning On-Site Property Damage Insurance RA-18-020, Request for Exemption from 1 O CFR 140.11 (a)(4), Concerning Primary and Secondary Liability Insurance2018-03-29029 March 2018 Request for Exemption from 1 O CFR 140.11 (a)(4), Concerning Primary and Secondary Liability Insurance RA-18-032, Revision to Commitments Relating to Resolution of Anchor Darling Double Disc Gate Valve Part 21 Issues2018-03-27027 March 2018 Revision to Commitments Relating to Resolution of Anchor Darling Double Disc Gate Valve Part 21 Issues RA-18-034, Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 50.82(a)(8)(i)(A) and 10 CFR 50.75(h)(1)(iv)2018-03-22022 March 2018 Request for Exemption from 10 CFR 50.82(a)(8)(i)(A) and 10 CFR 50.75(h)(1)(iv) RA-18-015, Withdrawal of Application to Revise Technical Specifications to Implement BWRVIP-18, Revision 2-A and Relief Request for Extension of Torus Examinations2018-02-15015 February 2018 Withdrawal of Application to Revise Technical Specifications to Implement BWRVIP-18, Revision 2-A and Relief Request for Extension of Torus Examinations RA-18-014, Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) and Supplemental Regarding License Amendment Request - Proposed Changes to the Oyster Creek Emergency Plan for Permanently Defueled Emergency Plan and Emergency Action Level Scheme2018-02-13013 February 2018 Response to Request for Additional Information (RAI) and Supplemental Regarding License Amendment Request - Proposed Changes to the Oyster Creek Emergency Plan for Permanently Defueled Emergency Plan and Emergency Action Level Scheme RA-18-008, Summary of Changes to Quality Assurance Topical Report, NO-AA-102018-02-0808 February 2018 Summary of Changes to Quality Assurance Topical Report, NO-AA-10 RA-18-010, Supplement to Relief Request for Extension of Torus Examinations2018-01-24024 January 2018 Supplement to Relief Request for Extension of Torus Examinations RA-17-086, Commitment Change Summary Report - 20172017-12-21021 December 2017 Commitment Change Summary Report - 2017 2019-09-12
[Table view] |
Text
July 1, 2008
David Lochbaum Director, Nuclear Safety Project Union of Concerned Scientists 1825 K Street NW Suite 800 Washington, DC 20006-1232
Dear Mr. Lochbaum:
I am writing in response to your letter to Sam Collins dated June 20, 2008, in which you indicated that there were two points raised in a June 6, 2008 letter to Mr. Collins from Janet Tauro of the Grandmothers, Mothers, and More for Energy Safety, that "caught your attention." Ms. Tauro's letter pertained to remarks made at the 2008 Oyster Creek annual assessment meeting. I am responding to your letter on behalf of Mr. Collins, since I was the senior NRC manager in attendance at that meeting.
Regarding your question with respect to the staff's remarks at the meeting on the current condition of the Oyster Creek drywell and the associated 2.0 factor of safety margin, I stated at the annual assessment meeting that the Region I staff had reviewed the ruling from the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (ASLB) proceeding on this subject and did not identify any new information that called into question previous conclusions regarding the current safety condition of the Oyster Creek drywell. In its ruling, the ASLB concluded that the drywell shell will maintain the necessary safety margin during the period of extended operation based on the frequency of AmerGen's planned ultrasonic testing measurements, in combination with other elements of AmerGen's aging management program. The basis for the ASLB's conclusion is documented in its published ruling.
The basis for the NRC staff's position regarding the condition of the drywell shell is documented in the staff's submissions to the ASLB and transcribed testimony provided by the staff during the September 24-25, 2007, ASLB evidentiary hearing. Region I staff, in concert with staff from the NRC headquarters office, were responsible for reviewing the adequacy of the protective coating, monitoring and maintenance program for the Oyster Creek drywell to ensure that aging effects on the drywell going forward are managed. The results of this review are documented in NRC Inspection Report 50-219/2006-007, which is part of the evidentiary record in the Oyster Creek license renewal proceeding as Staff Exhibit 5, and is enclosed. Region I also issued NRC Inspection Report 50-219/2006-013, a copy of which is also enclosed, which documented the results of the extensive evaluation by the NRC inspection staff of the operability of the drywell. That report specifically states that the NRC staff determined, "there were no safety significant conditions with respect to the primary containment that would prohibit plant startup and there was reasonable assurance that the primary containment is capable of performing its design function throughout the upcoming operating cycle [fall 2006 through the fall of 2008]."
During the recent Oyster Creek annual assessment meeting, I did not state that the drywell factor of safety margin was specifically 2.0, but rather I referred to the ASLB's published decision in this matter, and stated that we (the NRC) had reasonable assurance that the safety factor was at least 2.0. In their decision, the ASLB stated that, "although the precise value of D. Lochbaum 2 the safety factor can not be determined without performing more extensive measurements and actual calculations, compliance with the acceptance criteria - which incorporate several significant conservatisms - permits the conclusion that the safety factor is at least 2.0, especially given that the thickness of the shell is on average greater than 0.736 inches." In addition, ASLB Judge Baratta wrote that, "when all things are taken into account, including the actual thickness, the safety factor is likely to be greater than two, which I concur with."
As you know, an appeal of this recent ASLB decision is now before the Commission. Based on this ongoing legal action, it would be inappropriate for me to discuss this decision further. However, I have provided as an enclosure, the letter Sam Collins recently sent to Ms. Tauro, along with the attachments to that letter and copies of the two recent submittals by the NRC staff in this proceeding, dated June 11 and 18, 2008.
Regarding your comment/question with respect to the statement made by Richard Conte at the meeting, as characterized by Ms. Tauro, I promptly clarified the NRC's position on the current safety condition of the Oyster Creek drywell, reiterating that the drywell is considered operable, based on a thorough NRC evaluation and inspection. In that clarification, I again made reference to the documented basis for that operability determination (NRC Inspection Report 50-219/2006-013). I also commented that if the NRC obtains any new information that indicates the operability of the drywell is in question, the NRC staff will take appropriate regulatory action to ensure public health and safety. However, as I noted earlier, the NRC has not identified any new information that indicates that the Oyster Creek drywell does not have the necessary margin of structural strength to prevent the drywell shell from buckling under a worst case condition, which in this case is during refueling, when the refueling cavity connected to the top of the drywell is fully flooded.
If you have any further questions regarding my response to your letter or the NRC staff discussion at the Oyster Creek annual assessment meeting, I can have my staff arrange a conference call. Please contact Richard S. Barkley, of my staff at (610) 337-5065 if you have any further questions in this matter.
Sincerely,
/RA/ Marc L. Dapas Deputy Regional Administrator
Enclosures:
- 1) Letter to Ms. Janet Tauro, GRAMMES, dated June 23, 2008 2) NRC Inspection Report 50-219/2006-007, dated September 21, 2006 3) NRC Inspection Report 50-219/2006-013, dated January 17, 2007 4) NRC staff briefs responding to the Commission's Order on Oyster Creek, dated June 11 and 18, 2008
D. Lochbaum 3 cc w/encls via email: NJ Senator Christopher J. Connors (senconnors@njleg.org) Paul Gunter (paul@beyondnuclear.org) Peggi Sturmfels (psturmfels@cleanwater.org) Jeff Brown (jbnj@comcast.net) Janet Tauro (jtauro@comcast.net)
Paula Gotsch (paulagotsch@comcast.net) Willie deCamp (Wmdecamp@cs.com) Jill Lipoti (Jill.Lipoti@dep.state.nj.us) Lisa Jackson (Lisa.Jackson@dep.state.nj.us) Julie LeManse (jlemense@easternenvironmental.org)
Richard Webster (rwebster@easternenvironmental.org) Adam Zellner (adam.zellner@gov.state.nj.us) Arvin Ganesan (Arvin_Ganesan@lautenberg.senate.gov) Lisa Plevin (Lisa_Plevin@lautenberg.senate.gov) Joan Zielinski (joan.zielinski@mail.house.gov) Ryan Goodwin (ryan.goodwin@mail.house.gov) Michele Donato (mdonato@micheledonatoesq.com)
Diane Screnci (diane.screnci@nrc.gov) Neil Sheehan (neil.sheehan@nrc.gov)
ML081840630 To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box:
" C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure " E" = Copy with attachment/enclosure " N" = No copy OFFICE RI/ORA RI/DRS RI/RC OGC RI/RA NAME RBarkley RConte KFarrar MBaty/via e-mail MDapas DATE 06/25/08 06/26/08 06/26/08 06/26/08 07/01/08