NOC-AE-07002147, Supplementary Information for STPNOC Alternate Source Term License Amendment Application
| ML071620446 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | South Texas  |
| Issue date: | 04/10/2007 |
| From: | Bowman C Southern Nuclear Operating Co |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NOC-AE-07002147, TAC MD4996, TAC MD4997 | |
| Download: ML071620446 (19) | |
Text
Attachment 2 is considered Not for Public Disclosure Nuclear Operating Company ~in accordance with 10CFR2.390.
South Teas Proted Electnc Gencrabn$Station PO. Box 289 Wadsworth, Texas 77483 A April 10, 2007 NOC-AE-07002147 10CFR50.90 D43 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attention: Document Control Desk One White Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, MD 20852 South Texas Project Units 1 and 2 Docket Nos. STN 50-498, STN 50-499 Supplementary Information for STPNOC Alternate Source Term License Amendment Application
Reference:
Letter from David W. Rencurrel, STPNOC, to NRC Document Control Desk dated March 22, 2007, "Request for License Amendment Related to Application of the Alternate Source Term" (TAC Nos. MD4996 and MD4997, NOC-AE-07002127)
STPNOC submitted a License Amendment request for the Alternate Source Term in the referenced correspondence. As agreed to with the Staff, STPNOC is providing the Staff copies of our analyses, computer code input decks, and meteorology data. These items are on the enclosed CD. A table of contents for the CD is provided in Attachment 1. (proprietary) provides the Containment Sump post-LOCA pH calculation, performed by Polestar Applied Technology, Inc. Confirmation of this information as proprietary to Polestar Applied Technology, Inc. is supported by the affidavit in Attachment 3 signed by Polestar Applied Technology, Inc., the owner of the information. This affidavit sets forth the basis on which the information may be withheld from public disclosure by the NRC and addresses with specificity the considerations in 10 CFR 2.390(b)(4). Accordingly, STPNOC requests that Attachment 2 be withheld from public disclosure. A non-proprietary version does not exist.
Correspondence with respect to the proprietary aspects of the sump pH calculation or the supporting Polestar affidavit should reference this letter and should be addressed to:
David Leaver Polestar Applied Technology, Inc.
One First Street, Suite 4 Los Altos, CA 94022 There are no commitments in this letter. ,
STI: 32144069 ADO!
NOC-AE-07002147 Page 2 If you have any questions, please contact Mr. D. E. Gore at 361-972-8909 or me at 361-972-7454.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on / /6
/9r/ tOcfi7 Date Charles T. Bowman General Manager, Oversight Awh
Enclosure:
Alternate Source Term Data CD Attachments:
- 1. Table of Contents for Alternate Source Term Data CD
- 2. Containment Sump post-LOCA pH Calculation (Not for Public Disclosure)
- 3. Affidavit for Withholding for Information in Attachment 2
NOC-AE-07002147 Page 3 cc:
(paper copy) (electronic copy)
Regional Administrator, Region IV A. H. Gutterman, Esquire U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP 611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 400 Arlington, Texas 76011-8064
- Mohan C. Thadani U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Senior Resident Inspector Steve Winn U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Christine Jacobs P. 0. Box 289, Mail Code: MN116 Eddy Daniels Wadsworth, TX 77483 Marty Ryan NRG South Texas LP C. M. Canady Ed Alarcon City of Austin J. J. Nesrsta Electric Utility Department R. K. Temple 721 Barton Springs Road Kevin Pollo Austin, TX 78704 City Public Service Richard-A. Ratliff Jon C. Wood Bureau of Radiation Control Cox Smith Matthews Texas Department of State Health Services 1100 West 49th Street C. Kirksey Austin, TX 78756-3189 City of Austin Polestar
- David Leaver
- Jim Metcalf
- Including ehclosure
Attachment I NOC-AE-07002147 Attachment 1 Table of Contents for Alternate Source Term Data CD
Attachment 1 NOC-AE-07002147 Page 1 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\CD contents.doc (this file) Content description of this CD x/Q ANALYSIS
\calcs\meterology\NC-6509R0.pdf I\Q calculation RAW MET DATA
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\RawDataListing.pdf Text listing of raw data files
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\SQL-query.txt SQL query which generated the 2001-2004 data file.
to 2004 met data.txt
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\2001
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\JanO0.met Monthly met data for 2000 in native output format (This was the format in which met data was produced until 2001).
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\FebOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\MarOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\AprO0.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\MayOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\JunOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\JulOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\AugOO.met Monthly met data for 2000"
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\SepOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\OctOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\NovOO.met Monthly met data for 2000
\calcs\meterology\RawMetData\ASCII\Dec00.met Monthly met data for 2000 Joint Frequency Tables from Raw Met Data
\calcs\meterology\JFT\STP JFT 2000-2004
\calcs\meterology\JFT\STP JFT 2000.xls
\calcs\meterology\JFT\STP JFT 2001.xls
\calcs\meterology\JFT\STP JFT 2002.xls
\calcs\meterology\JFT\STP JFT 2003.xls
\calcs\jneterology\JFT\STP JFT 2004.xls OFFSITE X/Q ANALYSIS
\calcs\meterology\PAVAN\STPPAVAN.INP PAVAN input file
Attachment I NOC-AE-07002147 Page 2 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item I \calcs\meterology\PAVAN\STPPAVAN.LOG PAVAN
= output log file
\calcs\meterology\PAVAN\STPPAVAN.OUT PAVAN output file CONTROL ROOM & TECHNICAL SUPPORT CENTER x/Q ANALYSIS (ARCON96 case descriptions are provided on page 15 of calculation NC-6509, Rev. 0).
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2000.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2001.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2002.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2003.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2004.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stplslrl.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp lslr2.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp 1s2rl.rsf ARCON96 case input file'
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp 1s2r2.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp Is3r 1.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp 1s3r2.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s 1r l.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s 1r2.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s2rl.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s2r2.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s3rl .rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s3r2.rsf ARCON96 case input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2000.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2001.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2002.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2003.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2004.MET ARCON96 met data input file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp Is Ir 1..log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stpl slr2.log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp 1s2r 1.log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp 1s2r2.log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stpls3rl .log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp Is3r2.log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s 1r 1.1og ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s lr2.log ARCON96 case output
Attachment 1 NOC-AE-07002147
. Page 3 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s2rl.log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s2r2.log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s3rl.log ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s3r2.1og ARCON96 case output
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stplslrl.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stplslr2.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stpls2rl.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp l s2r2.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp 1s3rl.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp 1s3r2.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2slrl .cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2slr2.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s2r 1.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s2r2.cfd Case Cumulative Freq Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s3r Lcfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\stp2s3r2.cfd Case Cumulative Freg Distribution
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2000.LOG ARCON96 case log output file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2001.LOG ARCON96 case log output file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2002.LOG ARCON96 case log output file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2003.LOG ARCON96 case log output file
\calcs\meterology\ARCON\STP 2004.LOG ARCON96 case log output file PLANT DRAWINGS IN SUPPORT OF X/Q ANALYSIS
\calcs\meterology\drawings\3M019C04050R4.tif Concrete Mechanical and Electrical AUX Bldg Roof Plan @ EL 80'-00"
\calcs\meterology\drawings\3M019C04053R4.tif Concrete Mechanical and Electrical AUX Bldg Roof Plan @ EL 80'-00"
\calcs\meterology\drawings\3M019C04056R8.tif Concrete Mechanical and Electrical AUX Bldg Roof Plan @ EL 80'-00"
\calcs\meterology\drawings\3M019C04059R9.tif Concrete Mechanical and Electrical AUX Bldg Roof Plan @ EL 95'-00"
\calcs\meterology\drawings\3M019C04060R8.tif Concrete Mechanical and Electrical AUX Bldg Roof Plan @ EL 95'-00"
\calcs\meterology\drawings\3M019C04064R 12.tif Concrete Mechanical and Electrical AUX Bldg Sections and Details
Attachment I NOC-AE-07002147 Page 4 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\calcs\meterology\drawings\6C 189N05005R6.tif General Arrangement Reactor Containment Building at EL 52'-0" Area G
\calcs\meterology\drawings\6C1 89N05008R8.tif General Arrangement Reactor Containment Building Section B-B Area G
\calcs\meterology\drawings\6G019M00025R5.tif General Arrangement Isolation Valve Cubicle Area 'E'
\calcs\meterology\drawings\6G0 19M00026R6.tif General Arrangement Isolation Valve Cubicle Sections 'A-A' & 'B-B' Area
'E'
\calcs\meterology\drawings\9M 13 lAO 1036R I8.tif Architecture Mechanical and Electrical Auxiliary BLDG Roof Plan Unit 1
\calcs\meterology\drawings\9M 132A01036R 1O.tif Architecture Mechanical and Electrical Auxiliary BLDG Roof Plan Unit 2
\calcs\meterology\drawings\9Y240Y0009R15.tif Yard Civil Storm Drainage Detailed AUX Bldg Ares LOSS OF COOLANT ACCIDENT (LOCA)
(Files for cases are defined on page 22 of the calculation)
\calcs\LOCA\nc6Ol3r16.pdf LOCA calculation
\calcs\LOCA\DCFFiles(inp)\1006fgrst.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\LOCA\Model Files(psf)\rb88casel.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88caselesf. psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88caselpen. psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88caselpur. psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2. psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2esf. psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2pen. psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2pur. psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LOCA\4odelFiles(psf)\rb88casel.out RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88caselesf.out RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LOCA\Model_Files(psf)\rb88caselpen.out RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88caselpur.out RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2.out RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2esf.out RADTRAD Case Output file
Attachment I NOC-AE-07002147 Page 5 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2pen.out RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LOCA\ModelFiles(psf)\rb88case2pur.out RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LOCAkNuclide InventoryFiles(nif)\strb88.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\LOCA\RFT Files\estst.rft RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing
\calcs\LOCA\RFT Files\st.rft RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing FUEL HANDLING ACCIDENT (FHA)
(This analysis was performed on a spreadsheet. Therefore, there are no RADTRAD files associated with the FHA.)
\calcs\FHA\NC-6508R0.pdf FHA calculation MAIN STEAM LINE BREAK (MSLB) ACCIDENT (Files for cases are defined on page 30 of the calculation) _____calculation
\calcs\_MSLB\NC6026_R5 .pdf MSLB____calculation______
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\INP\NC-6026 DCF.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\NIF\NC-6026X Cs&Rb.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\MSLB\AIspike\NIF\NC-6026X Gas-OrgI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\MSLB\AI-spike\NIF\NC-6026X 12-Cs-Rb.nif RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\PSF\CaseX Gas-OrglICR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\PSF\CaseX Gas-Orgl TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\Asspike\PSF\CaseX 12-Cs-RbCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\PSF\CaseX 12-Cs-Rb_TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\PSF\CaseX Gas-OrglCR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\PSF\CaseX Gas-OrgITSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\MSLB\AI spike\PSF\CaseX 12-Cs-Rb CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\MSLB\AI-spike\PSF\CaseX 12-Cs-Rb TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\MSLBAIsspike\RTFANC-6026.rft RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing
\calcs\MSLB\PE-spike\INP\NC-6026 DCF.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\MSLB\PE _spike\NIF\NC-6026Y GasOrgI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\MSLB\PE _spike\NIF\NC-6026Y_12-Cs-Rb.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\MSLB\PE _spike\PSF\CaseYGas-OrglCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\PE _spikePSF\CaseY Gas-OrgITSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\PE -spike\PSFCaseY 12-Cs-RbCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\PE _spike\PSFMCaseY_12-Cs-RbfSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\MSLB\PE _spike\PSF\CaseY Gas-OrglCR.o I RADTRAD Case Output file
Attachment 1 NOC-AE-07002147 Page 6 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\calcs\MSLB\PE spike\PSF\CaseY Gas-OrglITSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\MSLB\PE spike\PSF\CaseY 12-Cs-Rb CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\MSLB\PE _spike\PSF\CaseY 12-Cs-Rb TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\MSLB\PE-spike\RTF\NC-6026.rft RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing STEAM GENERATOR TUBE RUPTURE (SGTR) ACCIDENT (Files for cases are defined on page 36 of the calculation)
\calcs\SGTR \NC6034R5_Partl.pdf SGTR calculation, Part 1
\calcs\SGTR \NC6034R5_Part2.pdf SGTR calculation, Part 2
\calcs\SGTR \High Temp\AISpike\DCFFiles(inp)\NC-6034 DCF.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrgITSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrglICR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High-Temp\AISpike\Model_Files(psf)\NC-6034 FlashCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 FlashTSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 CsI RbCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 CsIRbTSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrgl_TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrglCR.o0 RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Flash CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Flash TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\Nuclide InventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6034 Core CslRb AI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \I-ighTerip\ALSpike\Nuclide InventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6034 RCS Nobles-&-OrglIAI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\AISpike\RFTFiles\NC-6034.rtf RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing
\calcs\SGTR IighTempPESpike\DCFFiles(inp)\NC-6034 DCF.inp. RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\PE Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034_Nobles_OrgI_TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\PE _Spike\Model_Files(psf)\NC-6034_NoblesOrgICR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034_Flash_CR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Flash_TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs IRb CR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \High-Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs IRb-TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrglTSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrgICR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
Attachment 1 NOC-AE-07002147 Page 7 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\calcs\SGTR \HighTemp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 FlashCR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 FlashTSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \HighhTemp\PE Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\PE _Spike\NuclideInventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6034 60uCi RCS CsIRb PE.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \}-ighTemp\PE _Spike\NuclideInventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6034 60uCi RCS Nobles &-OrglPE.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \High_Temp\PE _Spike\RFrFiles\NC-6034.rtf RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AUISpike\DCFFiles(inp)\NC-6034 DCF.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\Model_Files(psf)\NC-6034 Nobles OrgITSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrgICR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \LowTemp\AI_Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 FlashCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \LowTemp\AI_Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Flash TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb CR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs IRbTSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrgLTSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 NoblesOrgLCR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Flash CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Flash TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\ALSpike\Model_Files(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I RbCR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\NuclideInventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6034 Core CsIRb AI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\NuclideInventory_Files(nif)\NC-6034 RCS Nobles-&-OrglIAI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\AISpike\RFT Files\NC-6034.rtf RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PESpike\DCFFiles(inp)\NC-6034 DCF.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\Model_Files(psf)\NC-6034_NoblesOrgLTSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034_NoblesOrgIICR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR _*ow_Temp\PE _Spike\Mo~delFiles(psf)\NC-6034_FlashCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034_FlashTSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \_*ow_Temp\PE _Spike\Mo~delFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs IRbCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\Model_-Files(psf)\NC-6034 Cs IRb_ TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034_NoblesOrg*_TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034_NoblesOrgI_CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034_Flash CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
Attachment 1 NOC-AE-07002147 Page 8 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\calcs\SGTR LowTempPE _SpikeModelFiles(psf)NC-6034_FlashTSC.o0 RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \LowTemp\PE _Spike\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \LowTemp\PE _Spike\Model_Files(psf)\NC-6034 Cs I Rb TSC.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\Nuclide InventoryFiles(nif)NC-6034 60uCiRCSCslRbPEnif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \LowlTemp\PE _Spike\NuclideInventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6034 60uCi RCS Nobles_&_OrgPE.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\SGTR \Low_Temp\PE _Spike\RFT Files\NC-6034.rtf RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing CONTROL ROD EJECTION ACCIDENT (Files for cases are defined on page 29 of the calculation)
\calcs\CREA \nc6014.pdf CREA calculation
\calcs\CREA \DCFFiles(inp)\NC-6014_DCFKrXeICsRb.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\CREA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014_Sec LeakTSC_KrXeOrgI.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\CREA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014-Sec LeakTSC_CsIRb.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\CREA\ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014_Sec Leak CR KrXeOrgI.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\CREA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014_Sec Leak CR CslRb.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\CREA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6014_ContLeakTSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\CREA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6014_ContLeakCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\CREA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014_SecLeakTSCKrXeOrgI.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\CREA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6014_SecLeakTSCCslRb. o0 RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\CREA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014_SecLeak CR.KrXeOrgI. oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\CREA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014 Sec Leak CR CslRb. oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\CREA WModelFiles(psf)\NC-6014 Cont Leak TSC. oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\CREA \Model Files(psf)\NC-6014_ContLeakCR. oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\CREA \NuclideInventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6014_Cont Leak KrXeCsIRb.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\CREA \NuclideInventoryjiles(nif)\NC-6014_SecLeak CsIRb.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\CREA \Nuclide InventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6014_Sec Leak KrXeOrgI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\CREA \RFT Files\NC-6014.rft RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing LOCKED (RCP) ROTOR ACCIDENT (Files for cases are defined on page 25 of the calculation)
\calcs\LRA \nc6028.pdf LRA calculation
\calcs\LRA \DCFFiles(inp)\NC-6028_wCsRbDCF.inp RADTRAD DCF input file
\calcs\LRA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6028 Uncover TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LRA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6028_UncoverCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LRA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6028_NoblesOrglTSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
Attachment I NOC-AE-07002147 Page 9 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File " Item
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028_NoblesOrglCR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028_ICsRb_TSC.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LRA \ModelFiles(psf)\NC-6028_ICSRb-CR.psf RADTRAD Model file
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028 UncoverTSC.o0 RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028 Uncover CR.oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028_NoblesOrgI TSC. o0 RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028_NoblesOrgICR. oO RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028_ICsRbTSC. o 1 RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LRA \Model_Files(psf)\NC-6028-ICSRbCR. o I RADTRAD Case Output file
\calcs\LRA \Nuclide InventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6028_SG CoverICSRb.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\LRA \NuclideInventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6028_SG CoverNoblesOrgI.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\LRA \NuclideInventoryFiles(nif)\NC-6028_SG Uncover.nif RADTRAD Nuclide inventory input
\calcs\LRA \RTFFiles(rtf)\NC-6028.rft RADTRAD Release Fraction & Timing METEOROLOGY PROCEDURES
\Procedures\BUTowerCal\maintenance\OPMP08EM0002R4.pdf Backup Met Tower Calibration:
Electrical Maintenance, Rev 4: Eff 01/31/95
\Procedures\BUTowerCal\ maintenance\OPMP08EM0002R5.pdf Backup Met Tower Calibration:
Electrical Maintenance, Rev 5: Eff 10/01/02
\Procedures\BUTowerCal\surveillance\OPSP05EM0002R8.pdf Backup Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 8: Eff 12/01/99
\Procedures\BUTowerCal\surveillance\OPSP05EM0002R9.pdf Backup Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 9: Eff 06/18/01
\Procedures\BUTowerCal\ surveillance\0PSP05EM0002R10.pdf Backup Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 10: Eff 04/24/02
\Procedures\BUTowerCal\ surveillance\OPSP05EM0002Rl1.pdf Backup Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 11: Eff 12/05/02 to 08/08/05
\Procedures\MetData\OpgpO3zaOO87r4.pdf Meteorological data procedure (delineates the responsibilities for operational control, maintenance, collection, and reduction of meteorological data);
Rev 4: Eff 03/30/98
Attachment 1 NOC-AE-07002147 Page 10 Contents of the STPNOC Calc/DataCD File Item
\Procedures\MetData\OpgpO3zaOO87r5.pdf Meteorological data procedure; Rev 5: 01/22/02
\Procedures\MetData\0pgp03za0087r6.pdf Meteorological data procedure; Rev 6:10/22/03 to 12/08/05
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\maintenance\OpmpO8emOOO1r6.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Electrical Maintenance, Rev 6: Eff 01/23/95
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\maintenance\OpmpO8emOOO1 r7.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Electrical Maintenance, Rev7: Eff 04/17/01 to 05/12/05
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOOlrl3.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 13: Eff 09/19/98
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOO1rl4.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance ,Rev 14: Eff 08/01/00
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOO1rl5.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 15: Eff 01/10/01
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOOrl6.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 16: Eff 04/04/01
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOO1rl7.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 17: 04/24/02
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOOnrl8.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 18: Eff 05/30/02
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOO1rl9.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 19: Eff 08/08/02
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOO1 r20.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 20: Eff 12/05/02
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOOlr21.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 21: Eff 07/09/03
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOOlr22.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 22: Eff 07/10/03
\Procedures\PrimaryTowerCal\surveillance\OpspO5emOOO1r23.pdf Primary Met Tower Calibration:
Surveillance, Rev 23: Eff 09/01/04 to 1
05/23/05 NOC-AE-07002147 Attachment 3 Affidavit for Withholding for Attachment 2 Adobe Acrobat 7.0 Document (Icon for attachment in electronic copy)
Polestar Applied Technology, Inc.
AFFIDAVIT I, David E.W. Leaver, being duly sworn, depose and state as follows:
(1) I am a Principal and an Officer of Polestar Applied Technology, Inc. ("Polestar") and am responsible for the function of reviewing the information described in paragraphs (2) and (8) which is sought to be withheld, and have been authorized to apply for its withholding.
(2) The information sought to be withheld is contained in portions of Polestar-prepared report NC-65 11 (see paragraph (8)). This report has been prepared for South Texas Project Nuclear Operating Company (STPNOC) in support of an STPNOC submittal to NRC on alternate source term (AST). The Polestar report addresses post-accident sump pH at the South Texas Project.
(3) In making this application for withholding of proprietary information of which it is the owner, Polestar relies upon the exemption from disclosure set forth in the NRC regulations 10 CFR 9.17(a)(4), 2.390(a)(4), and 2.390(b)(1) for "trade secrets and commercial or financial information obtained from a person and privileged or confidential" (Exemption 2.390(a)(4)). The material for which exemption from disclosure is here sought is all "confidential commercial information".
(4) Some examples of categories of information which fit into the definition of proprietary information are:
- a. Information that discloses a process or method, including supporting data and analyses, where prevention of its use by Polestar's competitors without license from Polestar constitutes a competitive economic advantage over other companies.
- b. Information which, if used by a competitor, would significantly reduce his expenditure of resources or improve his competitive position in the analysis, design, assurance of quality, or licensing of a similar product;
- c. Information which reveals cost or price information, production capacities, budget levels, or commercial strategies of Polestar, its customers, or its suppliers;
- d. Information which reveals aspects of past, present, or future Polestar customer-funded development plans and programs, of potential commercial value to Polestar;
- e. Information which discloses patentable subject matter for which it may be desirable to obtain patent protection.
The information sought to be withheld is considered to be proprietary for the reasons set forth in both paragraphs (4)a and (4)b, above.
I
(5) The information sought to be withheld was submitted to STPNOC (and, we trust, to NRC) in confidence. The information is of a sort customarily held in confidence by Polestar, and is in fact so held. The information sought to be withheld has, to the best of my knowledge and belief, consistently been held in confidence by Polestar, no public disclosure has been made, and it is not available in public sources. All disclosures to third parties including any required transmittals to NRC, have been made, or must be made, pursuant to regulatory provisions or proprietary agreements which provide for maintenance of the information in confidence. Its initial designation as proprietary information, and the subsequent steps taken to prevent its unauthorized disclosure, are as set forth in paragraphs (6) and (7) following.
(6) Initial approval of proprietary treatment of a document is made by the manager of the originating component, the person most likely to be acquainted with the value and sensitivity of the information in relation to industry knowledge. Distribution of such documents within Polestar is limited to those with a need to know.
(7) The approval of external release of such a document typically requires review by the project manager, and the Polestar Principal closest to the work, for technical content, competitive effect, and determination of the accuracy of the proprietary designation.
Disclosures outside Polestar are limited to regulatory bodies, customers, and potential customers, and their agents, suppliers, and licensees, and others with a legitimate need for the information, and then only in accordance with appropriate regulatory provisions or proprietary agreements.
(8) The information identified in paragraph (2), above, is classified as proprietary because it contains detailed information on and results from trade secret methodologies developed by Polestar and applied under the Polestar 10 CFR 50, Appendix B Quality Assurance Program. The trade secret information is identified in ((double bold brackets)) in the calculation. Specifically:
Page 5 - dealing with Assumption 2 related to Polestar's knowledge of possible forms of acids in containment and how to address these in a pH calculation.
Page 6 - a list of key references that were used in Polestar's pH models Pages 8, 9, and 10 - details of the calculation of conversion factors used in the determination of the amount of acid generated by the cables Page 11 - information on the calculation of the trisodium phosphate, boron buffer Pages 12, 13, 14, and 15 - details on the calculation of re-evolution of iodine in reduced pH environment Pages Al - A3 - the inputs and outputs of the Polestar pH calculational models 2
The trade secrets used in this South Texas Project work are several of a number of Polestar developed methods, models, and codes. Development of these methods, models, and codes was achieved at a significant cost to Polestar, well over $200,000, which is a significant fraction of internal research and development resources available to a company the size of Polestar.
The development of the methods, models and codes, along with the interpretation and application of the results, is derived from the extensive experience database that constitutes a major Polestar asset.
(9) Public disclosure of the information sought to be withheld is likely to cause substantial harm to Polestar's competitive position and foreclose or reduce the availability of profit-making opportunities. The information is part of Polestar's comprehensive technology base on application of the AST to operating plants and advanced light water reactors, and its commercial value extends beyond the original development cost. The value of the technology base goes beyond the extensive physical database and analytical methodology and includes development of the expertise to determine and apply the appropriate evaluation process. In addition, the technology base includes the value derived from providing analyses done with methods which have been developed and are being maintained in accordance with 10 CFR 50, Appendix B requirements.
The research, development, engineering, analytical and review costs comprise a substantial investment of time and money by Polestar.
The precise value of the expertise to devise an evaluation process and apply the correct analytical methodology is difficult to quantify, but it clearly is substantial.
Polestar's competitive advantage will be lost if its competitors are able to use the results of the Polestar experience to normalize or verify their own process or if they are able to claim an equivalent understanding by demonstrating that they can arrive at the same or similar conclusions.
The value of this information to Polestar would be lost if the information were disclosed to the public. Making such information available to competitors without their having been required to undertake a similar expenditure of resources would unfairly provide competitors with a windfall, and deprive Polestar of the opportunity to exercise its competitive advantage to seek an adequate return on its relatively large investment in developing these very valuable analytical tools.
3
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ))
ss:
COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA )
David E.W. Leaver, is being duly sworn, deposes and says:
That he has read the foregoing affidavit and the matters stated therein are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information, and belief.
Executed at Los Altos, California, this 2 day of Ape, ( 2007.
Aa4~
David E.W. Leaver Polestar Applied Technology, Inc.
Subscribed and sworn before me this day of 2007.
A "Ii,'NN
,r . NoayRUTH TUBBS Commission # 1439944 S Notary Public-California Santa Clara County
@I My Comm. ExpiresOct 8,20071 otary` tate of California 4