ML20249B866
| ML20249B866 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 07001201 |
| Issue date: | 06/15/1998 |
| From: | Birmingham J NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Essig T NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9806240345 | |
| Download: ML20249B866 (50) | |
Text
v June 15, 1998 h
7p /29 l
- MEMORANDUM TO: Thomas H. Essig, Acting Chief Generic Issues and Environmental l
Projects Branch l
Division of Reactor Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM:
Joseph L. Birmingham, Project Manager Original Signed By:
Generic Issues and Environmental Projects Branch Division of Reactor Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF JUNE 10,1998, MEETING WITH FRAMATOME COGEMA FUELS On June 10,1998, representatives of Framatome Cogema Fuels (FCF) met with U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff to present information on recent fuel performance and to discuss topical report status. Fuel performance issues discussed during the meeting were fuel reliability and integrity, fuel handling, control component performance, distinctive crud pattern status, post-irradiation examination results, and reactor coolant system water chemistry. The presentation indicated that FCF fuel continues to perform well and to behave as expected from the design models. During the meeting, FCF emphasized the importance of approval for its advariced corrosion resistant alloy to fully use existing fuel burnup limits and as a basis for increased fuel burnup limits.
During the discussion of topical reports, FCF summarized the status of previously submitted topicals and the dates by which NRC approval was expected. NRC staff indicated that, in general, the review of these topicals was on schedule but cautioned that changes in staff resources could affect their completion dates.
Meeting attendees are listed in Attachment 1 and the nonproprietary slides presented at the meeting are in Attachment 2.
Attachments: As stated cc w/atts:
Mr. F. McPhatter, Manager Framatome Cogema Fuels PO Box 10935 Lynchburg, VA 24506 i
Mail Code OF 57
\\'-
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\JLB\\06-10MTG. SUM OFFICE PM/PGEB:DRPM SC/PGEB:DRPM NAME JBirmingham:ayw FAkstuNh b
go DATE 06/1 /98 06//S /98 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY 9806240345'990h15
~
PDR ADOCK 07001201 C
sY p
q'a UNITED STATES e
i j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 2
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20066-0001 l
June 15, 1998 MEMORANDUM TO. Thomas H. Essig, Acting Chief Generic issues and Environmental l
Projects Branch Division of Reactor Program Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM:
Joseph L. Birmingham, Project Manager Generic issues and Ep ironmental Division of Reactor P ogr[am Projects Branch
(
,g g
anahemen%
t Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation l
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF JUNE 10,1998, MEETING WITH FRAMATOME COGEMA FUELS On June 10,1998, representatives of Framatome Cogema Fuels (FCF) met with U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff to present information on recent fuel performance and to discuss topical report status. Fuel performance issues discussed during the meeting were fuel reliability and integrity, fuel handling, control component performance, distinctive crud pattern status, post-irradiation examination results, and reactor coolant system water chemistry. The presentation indicated that FCF fuel continues to perform well and to behave as expected from the design models. During the meeting, FCF emphasized the importance of approval for its advanced corrosion resistant alloy to fully use existing fuel bumup limits and as a basis for i
increased fuel burnup limits.
During the discussion of topical reports, FCF summarized the status of previously submitted topicals and the dates by which NRC approval was expected. NRC staff indicated that, in general, the review of these topicals was on schedule but cautioned that changes in staff resources could affect their completion dates.
. Meeting attendees are listed in Attachment 1 and the nonproprietary slides presented at the meeting are in Attachment 2.
f Attachments: As stated l
cc w/atts:
Mr. F. McPhatter, Manager Framatome Cogema Fuels PO Box 10935 Lynchburg, VA 24506 Mail Code OF 57
1
.4 h
DISTRIBUTION: Mtg. w/FCF June 10.1998 -
Hardcony (w/att 1&2)
Central File 2 PUBLIC PGEB r/f OGC ACRS T. Collins E. Weiss M. Chatterton E-Mail (wlatt 1)
F. Miraglia B. Sheron J. Roe
, D. Matthews T. Essig G. Holahan J. Birmingham I
Attendees for NRC Meeting with Framatome June 10,1998 l
l NeME ORGANIZATION Tom Coleman Framatome Cogema Fuels Frank McPhatter Framatome Cogema Fuels George Meyer Framatome Cogema Fuels David Mitchell Framatome Cogema Fuels Joseph Birmingham NRC\\NRR\\DRPM Eric Weiss NRC\\NRR\\SRXB Margaret Chatterton NRC\\NRR\\SRXB TalHuang NRC\\NRR\\SRXB Shih-Liang Wu NRC\\NRR\\SRXB i
Frank Orr NRC\\NRR\\SRXB 1
ATTACHMENT 1
]
i i
2 TNE tD ATTA s
s s
s s
e e
e e
e t
t t
t t
d u
u u
u u
n n
n n
n n
i i
i i
i m
m m
m m
aC 0
0 0
eR 5
6 2
5 3
cN n
r ah e
t t
mi t
8 a
w h
r 9
P o
f g 9 c
M r
1 n
ei F
Pt 0 e
.C 1
l l
e e
le r
uM e hc w
e l
l y
A n
t e
e i
Fg u an M
v M
i e
n rn J m
B R
o oi e
A i
f s
o D
C s
l u
a n C
R G
lc N
de n
c A
e r
s o
c e
a C
l ni eL T
n d
t a
n t
d i
g m
U m
n n
r b
a A
o o
s u
y f
l i
t r
a S
r c
e t
a u
t P
e m
i d
m r
r e
b u
m o
l t
t u
u u
u n
F S
F S
I V
V 1
(
1 1
l 1
1 I
!1lllll 1ll
g s
l n
e i
u t
F ee n
8 a
a 9
m M
m9 e
1 e
go l
F o
0 C
C 1
C e
e m
n m
F o
u o
/
T J
t C
a m
R a
N r
F
~
[I
d n
n a
a lp e
C c
o t
R n
d g
N a
e m
d n
e r
e i
h o
s e
t f
l t
r a
n e
d e
tt n
p n
i e
a m
o l
M i
F e
b t
u u
a C
f s
m F
s r
f g
o o
n F
n f
e C
d i
n e
e F
n i
w e
w e
v t
n h
i e
o p
t e i
t b
f C
o Cv c
g Rre e
o R
s N
u Nl l
a j
a t
b d
e a
ec i
i t
h p h
s O
t e
t s o
u e n s
et n
t a s
de al u
i i
r t
p c
v n
d u
o pe s
ot r
r u
i c
u d
pf u
o ot o
or u
o T
Tf T
Tf m
a a
a 5
1
CRN l
s e e l
c e
u u
n F
Fa a8 l
l gam e
m9 h
e9 imr n
c g1 t
t eo i
o e
gf M
0 C
r d
1 e o e e
e i
MCP mn va D
o u
t J
el a
e mu ma oF r
t F
a marF
yr ts i
me hC re ta W
e e
g c
)S a
n s
a uC r
R m
a(
t e
r t
v o
S m
f o
r
)
e e
P C
t s
p s
et C
y u
n D
S s
e
(
t s
n d
n i
y o
u a
s t
g p
r l
i m mC o
n l
i a
o n
b i
l ad o
r eC o
in c
g v
i l
r s
e al oi t
RH o
r c
oe u
t t l
r P
n ca c
t l
l i
t ad n
e e nE u
u oI s
ep o
i F
m a
a a
a a
a W
l le s
w e
lc l
g y
s e
n C
e u
mW i
lc l
B e
y F
r uC o
F f
k
)
F r
l r
5 e
e a
h C
M x
nF 1
p t
u d
5 o
F n
1 h
Mt f
a s
(
t n
o e
n B
4 o
r a
2 ul k
M n
t p
r a
a 8
o md M
s 8
1 i
e n
1 t
e n
,s g
a r
g s
t s
i n
r ai t
s t
s n
e n
a e
s e
l p
nd aDlaP l
g P
P e
e e
O is s
AlcA s
e u
F yF u
t D
o C
o n
h 7
7 h
l e
e g) 7 7
g le u
n7 1
1 n
r u
i i
F t 1 r
sxWF Wts g
e7
&tn&
e u
n W (1 B eB W
C i
t r
s u
a r
a a
ix u
E C
m m
i
,/
n em
,/
~
~/
y t
",/
ir 1
g s
t e
l
/
na P
t d
n l
.,/
e eu I
F F
tn
/
l l
C a
F e
P fo u
y t
t tg F
in e
t
.e F
r
/
F leu s
e C
L k
~"#
k s
a r
e e
a F
F e
C L
F F
o C
N F
it h
h t
w iw t
t
,/
n n
l la a
P P
O u
,/
~/
2 5
1 5
O 3
N 0
0 1
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 O
0 0
O 0
0 2 N5g& i*
g
f.
ecne irepxE leuF FC F
i
h E
9 0
W" k~
O'
<a 2
E."
u..
rpy y
O rs) rs)
H D4 C
W C
clt NW m
0 l
34 V:
e t
9 a
9 W*
O' F
(o 1:
af u.*
(eD y
3
<ss
(/)
W tl10 C
M 2
l l
M l
HH
@3 l
r l
a
~
l
ecna mro frl e
e PuF tnF enC oF ph mi t
ow C
lor tnoC
ecna mro frl e
e PuF tnF enC oF ph mi t
ow C
lor tnoC e
I
ecna em mu mro frl e
e PuF tnF enC oF ph mi t
ow C
lor tnoC
ecna m
g ro frl e
e PuF tnF eC noF ph mi t
ow C
lor tnoC
ecna m
f ro frl e
e PuF tnF eC noF ph mi t
ow C
lor tnoC k
8 pude mn uiBma 3
3 Ax 8
9 FE 1
3 p
ud mev u e Bi h 3
3 Ac 8
9 FA 1
3 y
ud p
e r
nr n lu ui a
Bm J
Ax 7 5 )8 a
1 m
1 3
FE 5 (5 9 5
m p
ud n e u
r v
u e Bi S
h 1
Ac 5
3 FA 5
5 E
p I
ude n
P r n ui Bma 3
6 Ax 8
1 FE 5
4 p
ud n e r
v u e Bi h 3
6 Ac 8
1 FA 5
4 W
n B
B
- 5
- 7 ig k1 k 1 les r
r x
x 5
ue a
a w
5 7
M',
FD M1 M1
7 0
e 0
0 W"
k-O'!
h (ob e""
u..
oQ Co mN o
C.
M 4O i
O e
6 e
W"II 0
i-
<o tz
(*
I ElE ce m
s num w
CC o>
- W k
O4
na lP E
IPr) a 'd t
en Yco
(
ev iF FCF
no iso rr d
o r
c a
d g
n n
a i
t d
s da dn lc a
s le s
E u
A I
f T
P s
n L
A o
1 s t
Tt c 1 e n
L a
Bl i
e 5
p b
f c
M me om
/
g e
e i
ms 4
e a
R Ml cE as c
xa E
I y
pP el n
c u
e I
P o
d n1 e u lcf 1
E e
r 1
uB yB 1
I d
b c
P e
n 2
k t
eh t
lc s
t g
e s
r y
r xi r a ei i
CF E
H nFM a
a a
o a
I M
c T
O a
a V.
-F
r-l l
l l
W*
2 -
O'
<o 11
<*o a
u.-
r 9 Mk w
W 2
k e
9 e
k-O' l-
<o tc
(*U W
u..
e m
=
wW 4
'+
l
)
O l
O 1-0,'
J (o
12 Qe.
{
t 1
m$ne
\\
h a
s==
w a
h t
wor G
y lb messA leuF FCF k
e i
'M P.7^
n o
i s
f o
r roC e
lb m
ihT
/e buT e
d iu G
B-L4
9 9
e e
ul*
1-
\\
O,'
E.,
(o 12
(*
z.,
u.*
ht
.-N O
eo M
W l
a
O e
0 II 0'
h$
<o 1x
<=
i 2:
i u
i
.t MC eoW
@34 l
1 4
n ig 0
n r
si 1
e dn w
e oi m l
r o
c r
p yPe cCt e
s e
I M Dd t
r n
u ai Tf n l
oi a
l pf mnp P
o ol s
y e
l e
u n
uC r
i t
f ih t
afD s
d o
t o
d nt a
a nw o
o t
e r
c a S
P h
t Ci P
e a n
t P
D wr Cind o
e ds D
md C
fo e e n
ev r
i D
t e
al ot o i
c r a er n em mdp e
p a
o o e.
o r
o r
n xt t s
u1 al e
et u r
c1 el s oa l
l c
n c
e of c o
eot c
pet f
l i
ct ot r
wyuH o un oo e
cb HPar n
r P
i a
m I
t oms C
i NTd D
m m
m kE
Wa I-0:
N<a Zz r:"
u.
@O O
U GO
~%
i U
wC km kW kO
O 0
0 k"-
O' N('
o
<*x:
u.
g
.C m
.bb
~
V2 Q
H 4O4 s;
W
.m
-um.
... i
.-immea
Hp tegra t
le moH u
pt p
i pL t
F n
D2 mt a P
2 p
s F
o p
n t
o E
y 2
c H
r 4
se2 a
p t
t s
t a
n t
s a
ni n
i t
e a
a a
i m
mc s
n s
r t
t t
yi e
r L
e ni n
a t
d o
o h
s n
c m
C i
i oL C
mr t
o e
oi at l
t s
n h
B nHi n
o m
L S
C u
p ot u
i m
ei C
i i
t d
h S
p9 e
s cd t
R C
p6 s
a i
eAL a
e r
R0 e
r i
cD ch r
0 n7 H
c e
n g
t i
e1 pInD ei ZH r
r u
r a
a a
mt a
a u
u C
F a
m
g e
n o
t s i
c t
i ds i
n m
ea e
a c
m db i
l t
e e r
n o
o nt s
eh f
a es m
r im.
s m
pe sn) l r
s r
ed g5ot i
fi o
o )e s Mo m i
romt e (t
f i
c ad l
r n
m ydt
-n e
gie on n i
e i
t l
l P
hs scl a r
a r
e ey s u t
i l
wd ct t t
nic e
sl am me e ie l
u e obu sl v l
t f
F wr spo i
ml f
s ub e
f gd o
r na n e r
r o
0t n us imtc0 n obp y
r e oi u
r op( c sgn 1
f o
r x nr a
nd r
ee ri u t
on osb m
p sia ci r
x e sa er m
giedes i
t rt e e a len ce c
u ui s e f v emn u c r
S ada vyn a
F h
r i
i Ce x adl l
Fb OpAfuo t
a m
m h
Y{
S;
s d
a na n
(
y e
t n
e i r o
b g
i t
e a
e tn g
va i
i ts h
le e
u v n s
n n e m
f t
ik e
o n
i r al e
et b
s
.dn o
l l
u e
r l
c P
ne p
ue c
x C
e b
e n
D e
m r
ei e
f a
o v
o v
t a
sa p
C e
eh o
h c
u r
s oe n
s d
n t s e
sioA sa rr i
ee gt R
r u
c n
u c cia
/C n
cl in odeAd t
i n s nv op w
ai C e t
v c u eh cCr Fn nl eRe r
r e
r s
Cu o
uo ob Fb NFcNo m
m m
m l
l
g s
l n
e i
u t
F r
e e
8 a
e tt 9
m M
a 9
h e
1 P
go F
c 0
C M
1 C
k e
e F
n n
m
/
a u
o r
J t
C F
a R
ma N
rF l!
0 2
[
e 0
0 l
2
(
u de h
)L 0.
c 60 S
- 2
(
t R
r E
o S
p 9_
R E
5 9
e E
9d S
R
[
E l
a
- D
[
E c
T i
T 7
8 7
6 7
8 9
9 9
9 9
9 I
p M
/
/
/
/
/
/
9 1
9 9
9 2
B o
U S
T L
R E
B 9
1 3
9 N
M 2
9 3
8 22 O3 2
U 0
1 I
1 2
0 1
0 T
N 1
1 I
0 0
/
E P
W W
W NW W
1 D1 7
M A
A 2
A 2
B A
O B
A A
B C B B
/
N 0
/
C
/
1
/
1 F
/
/
t I
1 D D E
m h
W R
N H
E B
O C
C T
N C
A E
K UT I
LH l.P B
P R
U E
/
O S
O A
W A E C
T M
C M
B FM S
l
n yo e
b la e
c e
l r
h u
i t
d F
Z n
n nf r
i a
o a
o i
gt ee g
c gc o
n a
na t
i d
e al e
d R
h g
p a
cn n
7 R
l i
2 C
r a
W o5 b
h d
/
2 eP dM N
c nf 1
0 c
n l
ao r
a n
i Z
i r 1
a )5 ne e
f 4
n p
v os o
a-o u
t d
M u
y Wf i
A(
pe n
mo s
k t
i t
o c
a mh a
sa r
l l
i oi r
P An et ir ic e
xi a
h r o
r t
n t
C i
em V
eZ o
t e
Bia y
k o e
g t
t r aM r
e r
r o
at u
op a
o r
md c
d l
p l
l t
a a
r po e
e y
i v
u ut or n
H A
i r E
t a s6 p
t i
c r
r u
o 4 o
dpem e
e r
r t
0 P
r w
ww tS e5 ios c o
o sR a
e L
L oF s
d 5 prC sM m
m i
5 u0 f
i P1 M
t o
I u
m m
i
s le t
u n
f e
g e
p m
n d
u e
U i
d o
n v
t C
u o
om d
r a
r t /
a l
e p
sd c
c h
m pW 5
n g
u i
nG M
a e
i l
h e
r 1
m s
r 1
a c
u d
3 o
b o
at n
t r
a i
w a
m so f
2 r
t t
o 4
0 e
r e
a s
P op
-r 1
d d
e a
u Z
t o
l e
g a
ps c
t r
WF u
n u s o
i i
l r
s n f
i k
c a
.s r
A C
ul a
a na s
l l
l e
f oa e
d m
d I
i e
N o
t d
B ae o
h r
c u
t r
o R
m m t
nu m
E n
c et P
de e
u u
s mf e
e c b
r O
c t
C n
e s
e; t
n U
a s a
a v
r pt rl vm s
a mm oa i
r i/
pi l
r c
n u
o d
r t
e af e
d s
ot rW r
t ne x
o ca i
Ap E
M FG nm i
a a
m m
m
P 92 n
2 g
i 0
se 1
D
-W1 1
B A
kr B
a M
E
llll!
l j
l 1
n F
s M
g o
d Cm y
n o
F h
g 0
i m
t o
s r
t 1
o x
oo e
l i
d e
fC m
1 o
e-F N
h z
h t
s C
i C
t i
l I
e w
it n F
D M
ug
/
m os e
i
)
n s
t e m
I o
t yd o
i t
a g y a
i A
t i
v ol d
r b
m l
n e
o 3
o s
dm a
r C
n oe F
3 o
hs 1
d c
t s d
e ea r
0 e
t ml a
1 u
u e
d a
dy F
ng wu n
f uo e
a W
t nd s
l e o et A
vd ecc e
oo dnu d
i i
B mh vad v
t ee ovo o
rdr r
Rm pap P
m m
m m
1 ll ll li i
i llJ dna
)
e e
e e
gm e
t d
o g
ao l
a t
o i
k ka C
p c
o 8
c am s
t eC a
r 2
Pa P
r o
(
l 2
eF p
u 0
d s
d e
e c
d y
n o
a 1
o ob C
C a
Mf r r
d r
e T
o g
t.
WE r e a
t n
n p
e a
l i
C uo c
k I
A N
dl t
l r
u n
i e
e t
i
)
v aF m
L s
E o
B Me L
/
2 S
gU i
I C
,D e
S d
yO e
s a
nl l
i t
en bL r
a s
c a e mL oB si t
eO C
eh m
a c
p r
- s sP D
o a
g t
e n e
s a
r r
A (A t o d
3 DP G
nr u
i I
v m
a a
a a
l nn c
AE n
I s
a l
7ll!l
g s
l n
e i
u t
F e
r 8
a e
e 9
m y
M 9
e e
1 M
go F
e C
0 1
g C
e e
ro n
m F
e u
o
/
G J
t C
a m
R a
r N
F
- g. '
b uaO 2:5a
-IT l
l l
i l
- o. ?
00
- MM
@h
'A 5
0'A NeoO C
ce>
t<
s u
e r
r eu Ct a ne aF
,l n
II g
is a_D e
c<
5-4' Doo Cm a u
00 G
Y A