ML20248L853
| ML20248L853 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | FitzPatrick  |
| Issue date: | 06/04/1998 |
| From: | Williams J NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| IEB-96-003, IEB-96-3, TAC-M96146, NUDOCS 9806120007 | |
| Download: ML20248L853 (51) | |
Text
- June 4, 1998 i LICENSEE: New York PowIr Authority FACILITY: JImss A. FitzPztrick Nucirr Pow 2r Pirnt
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
OF MAY 21,1998, REGARDING EMERGENCY CORE COOLING SUCTION STRAINER MODIFICATIONS (TAC NO. M96146)
On May 21,1998, representatives of the New York Power Authority (NYPA) met with members of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff in Rockville, MD. The licensee had requested this meeting in order to brief the NRC staff on plans for modification of emergency core cooling system (ECCS) suction strainers at the James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant (JAF). These modifications are being made to respond to Bulletin (B) %-03, " Potential Plugging of ECCS Suction Strainers by Debris." A list of attendees is provided in Enclosure 1. A copy of the handout provided by NYPA is provided in Enclosure 2.
NYPA plans to install new ECCS suction strainers during a JAF refueling outage scheduled to begin October 16,1998. The existing residual heat removal, core spray, and high pressure coolant injection strainers will be replaced with large stacked disk strainers. NYPA also plans to replace the reactor core isolation cooling system suction strainer.
NYPA indicated that following installation of the new strainers, it plans to desludge the suppression pool every other refueling outage. The NRC staff stated that the licensee needs to ensure that the suppression pool cleaning frequency is sufficient to ensure the strainer design basis assumptions for sludge and foreign material accumulation are not exceeded.
NYPA noted that its calculations of available ECCS pump net positive suction head assumed that 2 psi containment overpressure is available throughout an event. NYPA stated it believed using this overpressure credit is consistent with the original plant design basis as accepted by the staff in its safety evaluation of November 20,1972. However, it was noted that is not clear what duration for this credit was proposed by the licensee and accepted by the staff. NYPA and the NRC staff plan to review the licensing basis to clarify usage of the overpressure credit.
The NRC staff and NYPA discussed what information will be required to provide the staff with an adequate description of the suction strainer modification. The licensee presently expects to make the modifications under 10 CFR Part 50.59, so that prior approval by the NRC staff would not be required. Overall, the staff believes the new strainer installation provides a net safety benefit. The staff stated that it would like to receive information sufficient for confidence that the new strainers do not create any safety issues. )
);
Original Signed by: )
Joseph F. Williams, Project Manager :
Project Directorate 1-1 Division of Reactor Projects - 1/Il e;g J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation / j
- Docket No. 50-333
Enclosures:
- 1. List of Attendees
- 2. Handout MM 7'i r p-~
cc w/encls: See next page DISTRIBUTION: See next page MUbd Qjll?@TU DOCUMENT NAME:G:\FITZ\M96146.MTG To re:eive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment / enclosure "E"
= Copy with attachment / enclosure "N" = No copy 0FFICE PM:PDI 1 /f lE LA:PDI 1n() l D:PDI 1 . ff g l l l NAME JWilliams:lepF'V SLittI # SBajwe//[A fi d DATE 06/ 4 /98 / 06/Af/98 06/ gG98 / 06/ /98 06/ /98 Official Record Copy 9806120007 980604 PDR ADOCK 05000333 G pm ,
Meeting Summary Distribution: Date: Jene 4,1998 .
l LICENSEE: New York Power Authority FACILITY: James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
- MAY 21,1998 MEETING REGARDING EMERGENCY CORE COOLING SUCTION STRAINER MODIFICATIONS (TAC NO. M96146)
E-MAIL (w/ encl.1) Hard Coov (w/encls.)
S. Collins /F. Miriglia (SJC1/FJM) Docket File B. Boger (BAB2) PUBLIC J. Zwolinski (A) (JAZ) PDl-1 R/F S. Bajwa (SSB1) J. Williams S. Little (SLL) OGC.
T. Martin (SLM3) ACRS K. Kavanagh (KAK)
J. Kudrick (JAK1)
D. Jeng (DCJ) cc: Licensee & Service List R. Elliot (RBE)
M. Marshall (MXM2) l A. Serkiz (AWS)
B. McCabe (BCM)
C. Hehl, Region I (CWH) i l
l i
I I
(
LICENSEE: New Ycrk Power Authority June 4, 1998 i l
FACILITY: Jam 2s A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant f
s
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
OF MAY 21,1998, REGARDING EMERGENCY CORE COOLING SUCTION STRAINER MODIFICATIONS (TAC NO. M96146)
On May 21,1998, representatives of the New York Power Authority (NYPA) met with members of ,
the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff in Rockville, MD. The licensee had requested l this meeting in order to brief the NRC staff on plans for modification of emergency core cooling l system (ECCS) suction strainers at the James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant (JAF). These modifications are being made to respond to Bulletin (B) 96-03, " Potential Plugging of ECCS Suction Strainers by Debris." A list of attendees is provided in Enc!osure 1. A copy of the l handout provided by NYPA is provided in Enclosure 2.
NYPA plans to install new ECCS suction strainers during a JAF refueling outage scheduled to begin October 16,1998. The existing residual heat removal, core spray, and high pressure coolant injection strainers will be replaced with large stacked disk strainers. NYPA also plans to replace the reactor core isolation cooling system suction strainer.
NYPA indicated that following installation of the new strainers, it plans to desludge the suppression pool every other refueling outage. The NRC staff stated that the licensee needs to l ensure that the suppression pool cleaning fruquency is sufficient to ensure the strainer design l basis assumptions for sludge and foreign material accumulation are not exceeded.
NYPA noted that its calculations of available ECCS pump net positive suction head assumed that {
2 psi containment overpressure is available throughout an event. NYPA stated it believed using j l
this overpressure credit is consistent with the original plant design basis as accepted by the staff in its safety evaluation of November 20,1972. However, it v,as noted that is not clear what duration for this credit was proposed by the licensee and accepted by the staff. NYPA and the ;
l NRC staff plan to review the licensing basis to clarify usage of the overpressure credit. l The NRC staff and NYPA discussed what information will be required to provide the staff with an i adequate description of the suction strainer modification. The licensee presently expects to l make the modifications under 10 CFR Part 50.59, so that prior approval by the NRC staff would not be required. Overall, the staff believes the new strainer installation provides a net safety benefit. The staff stated that it would like to receive information sufficient for confidence that the l new strainers do not create any safety issues.
Original Signed by: ,
j Joseph F. Williams, Project Manager Project Directorate 1-1 .
l Division of Reactor Projects - 1/II l
, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation -
Docket No. 50-333 i
Enclosures:
- 1. List of Attendees !
- 2. Handout cc w/encis: See next page DISTRIBUTION: See next page ,
DOCUMENT NAME:G:\FITZ\M96146.MTG To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment / enclosure "E" ;
= Copy with attachment / enclosure "N" = No copy i OFFICE PM:PDI 1 /s lE LA:PDI*1n () l D PDI 1 , a fy l l l NAME JWillIans:iepF'V SLittI#V $8eJwa // 7 4 57 8 DATE 06/ & /98 / 06/ 4 /98 06/ W 98 / 06/ /98 06/ /98 Official Record Copy
. @ te u g 1 UNITED STATES s* E NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20566-0001 g June 4, 1998 LICENSEE: New York Power Authority FACILITY: James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
OF MAY 21,1998, REGARDING EMERGENCY CORE COOLING SUCTION STRAINER MODIFICATIONS (TAC NO. M96146)
On May 21,1998, representatives of the New York Power Authority (NYPA) met with members of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff in Rockville, MD. The licensee had requested this meeting in order to brief the NRC staff on plans for modification of emergency core cooling system (ECCS) suction strainers at the James A. FitzP. trick Nuclear Power Plant (JAF). These modifications are being made to respond to Bulletin (B) %-03, " Potential Plugging of ECCS Suction Strainers by Debris." A list of attendees is pro ided in Enclosure 1. A copy of the handout provided by NYPA is provided in Enclosure 2.
NYPA plans to install new ECCS suction strainers during a JAF refueling outage scheduled to begin October 16,1998. The existing residual heat removal, core spray, and high pressure coolant injection strainers will be replaced with large stacked disk strainers. NYPA also plans to replace the reactor core isolation cooling system suction strainer.
NYPA indicated that following installation of the new strainers, it plans to desludge the suppression pool every other refueling outage. The NRC staff stated that the licensee needs to ensure that the suppression pool cleaning frequency is sufficient to ensure the strainer design basis assumptions for sludge and foreign material accumulation are not exceeded.
NYPA noted that its calculations of available ECCS pump net positive suction head assumed that 2 psi containment overpressure is available throughout an event. NYPA stated it believed using this overpressure credit is consistent with the original plant design basis as accepted by the staff in its safety evaluation of November 20,1972. However, it was noted that is not clear what duration for this credit was proposed by the licensee and accepted by the staff. NYPA and the NRC staff plan to review the licensing basis to clarify usage of the overpressure credit.
The NRC staff and NYPA discussed what information will be required to provide the staff with an adequate description of the suction strainer modification. The licensee presently expects to make the modifications under 10 CFR 50.59, so that prior approval by the NRC staff would not be required. Overall, the staff believes the new strainer installation provides a net safety benefit.
l The staff stated that it would like to receive information sufficient for confidence that the new 1
strainers do not create any safety issues.
/
Joseph F. Williams, Project Manager
, Project Directorate 1-1 Division of Reactor Projects - 1/11 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation 1 Docket No. 50-333
Enclosures:
- 1. List of Attendees
- 2. Handout cc w/encis: See next page
v C
James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Authority of the State of New York Power Plant cc:
Mr. Gerald C. Galdstein Mr. F. William Valentino, President Assistant General Counsel New York State Energy, Research, Power Authority of the State and Development Authority of New York Corporate Plaza West 1633 Broadway 286 Washington Avenue Extension New York, NY 10019 Albany, NY 122034399 i Resident inspectors Office Mr. James Knubel U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Chief Nuclear Officer P.O. Box 136 Power Authority of the State of Lycoming, NY 13093 New York 123 Main Street Mr. Harry P. Salmon, Jr. White Plains, NY 10601 Vice President - Engineering Power Authority of the State Mr. Richard L Patch, Director of New York Quality Assurance 123 Main Street Power Authority of the State White Plains, NY 10601 of New York 123 Main Street Ms. Chariene D. Faison White Plains, NY 10601 Director Nuclear Licensing Power Authority of the State Mr. Gerard Goering of New York 28112 Bayview Drive 123 Main Street Red Wing, MN 55066 White Plains, NY 10601 Mr. James Gagliardo ,
Supervisor Safety Review Comittee l Town of Scriba 708 Castlewood Avenue '
Route 8, Box 382 Arlington,TX 76012 i Oswego, NY 13126 '
! Mr. Arthur Zaremba, Licensing Manager j Mr. Eugene W. Zeitmann James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear President and Chief Operating Power Plant i'
Officer P.O. Box 41 Power Authority of the State Lycoming, NY 13093 of New York l 99 Washington, Ave., Suite No. 2005 Mr. Paul Eddy
, Albany, NY 12210-2820 New York State Dept. of l Public Service l Charles Donaldson, Esquire 3 empire State Plaza,10th Floor l Assistant Attomey General Albany, NY 12223 New York Department of Law 120 Broadway New York, NY 10271 Regional Administrator, Region i U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406 t
ATTENDEES FITZPATRICK ECCS SUCTION STRAINER MODIFICATION MAY 21,1998 N6ME ORGANIZATION PHONE Joe Williams NRC/NRR/PD l-1 (301) 415-1470 Kerri Kavanagh NRC/NRR/SRXB (301) 415-3743 Jack Kudrick NRC/NRR/SCSB (301) 415-2871 David C. Jong NRC/NRRIECGB (301) 415-2727 Rob Elliot NRC/NRR/SCSB (301) 415-1397 Harry Salmon New York Power Authority (914) 287-3812 Kenneth A. Phy New York Power Authority (315) 349-6967 Michael Marshall NRC/RES/GSIB (301) 415-5895 Al Serkiz NRC/RES/GSIB (301) 415-6563 Douglas Harrison New York Power Authority (315) 349-6210 Jim Sherman New York Power Authority (914) 287-3410 Andy Krinzman Proto-Power (860) 446-9725 Peter Mast ITS Corporation (505) 872-1089 Jon Artert>um Duke Engineering Services (770) 441-5238 Norm Hoy New York Power Authority (315) 349-6203 Jay Dunkleberger New York State Health Dept. (518) 458-6458 Jim Costedio New York Power Authority (315) 349-6358 Pete Kokolakis New York Power Authority (914) 681 6254 Donna Skay NRC/NRR/DRPW (301) 415-1322 Paul Swinbume New York Power Authority (315) 349-6563 Tom Moskalyk New York Power Authority (315) 349-6505 Enclosure 1
o jz t
e P c
t a
t r
i S c t k r
a E N iC n
r C e
MR a C S y P r e D S 2
1 e s s u e ic 1 n g t i
9 t a no 9
a n t
8 i o nS n dt r Ea vn a e i
u r l
E a
t n i o
c l
o s
u r
e 2
n 1
ECCS Suction Strainer Project Project Organization Chart D. Ruddy N. Hoy K. Phy PLT-Project Sponsor Projed Manager Jr. Projed Manager i
I -- t.-----
E. McCarty ,- H. Robinson a CM s' Qual ty Supervisor,
, Procurement QA s I
s P. Morris i I I e Quality Supervisors C. Fuhrmeister l JAF-QA l
- D. Sancic a--- 3 --- e Project Erqineer Project Support Eng. l J. Sherman J. Lef'er Design e------!.--------
P. Swinburne l R. Martinez !
Pro W _
Enoineer 8 Engineer Lead Mech.
Enoineer l NYPA Fabrication l D.Eng l-QA/QC
- - - - Inspector Structural D. Burch Enoineer R. Neff Mechanical Constr. Services Enoineer 0 3 JAF Plant Support Lead Mech. Supv.
Engineer D. Robert - Radweste Supv. #
- n. Esken W. Proctor Planning Coord. constr. Servces Mech. T. sntant - B. Bock - Chemistry Craft Enoineer Structural J. Ratigan - ALARA Supervisors (TBD)
Engineer l l l F. Wilbur J. Morrison J. Costedio Cost / Schedule Eng. Convad Mrrunisestor NnsN Engineer DE&S Project Team
~
Project Mgr.
J.Arterbum J. Park G. Ashley Responsible Design Review Engineer Team leader Field and Test C. Warchol P. Breglio P. Mast D. Rhind Engineers Lead Eng. Mark I Lead Eng. (Mech.) Licensing Strainer Supply (DE+S/PPC) (Structural) DE+S PPC Compliance (ITS)
_ (PCI) l A. Krinzman MOD Package Lead PPC
S S P R t
r t r
l a e p a a n s i c
i n
i n t o l s e
r e
r Cu t o i o
f o
E Dn n r v e f i
a s g A u g up l i r
D i
a t
n a p s o Ro i t i
r o c n qe n a u s
c Mu e r n i
a h s i
o e d t
h o mDe n d e o n t
s i
l s g o
g n y P a
r a
m t
e e
r s
_ P CF S S e u o Mp u u s o
c mt a p Ep t l i
n P r
e i
o u n
Sg t r s i u
r s o s i S o v Pg o n t
r ar r e n io a A
mP i
g n l
l r o p a a e n
o r c p e m l
/ R r S o p
e D t a
r a l a c
a t i a n ec h e
R r m e
v Ce n l
i e
t e a w n
_ l i
n e
s s
m
c TS Pe S - HR Pe co he a
p Cl I e wA il Cp t i
s e c t t l oi r t a e c c
t d
i f
i
)
s' t e
hh l
a u o
I s
a c n i
e f c d rg t r n r
i s
o r
a l
l S
uP g
e h
,r n ag i
SA t
t hy i
c e r e e- r p o ne rp s a d
d e
s Fo r f a s a t
n e x r i ao ia l i s s s nc o g ome l i t
p s
s e c
n
' wa vE s
C C ig wn i e
r e n t r S t
h r
f o
f o
r Sc t
a e ny a
is l a
R R e
r ms u c e s r H p a e k Cr t
e g R n o c n e o ,m e ,
l a
e B
dn t r e
p C c a
n Da r p a o e d W ic l a s e r h
Rs t c s m y E ki n i
n i vS e d
r o
C C tr, Sg g
R s a ep r n t
y d S a I C ry t
n yS in I C a n
a .c ia s s nn mt e ie c m r s' t r
a e d r
i ms n s e
a s
r s
4
_ H P C R H y
s vi S co a z S t
- C R e t I
m l
e i ud e t oi nn R s o
4 4 4 De SA
- 0 5 5 ip f
_ " " " al a oe r n t d
mce A d
d i
i i s rp
_ .a .a .a Le mp t e u a
_ x x x e e nr ep a r ia 5 1 4 g xtnr c nc 2
2 0
1 2
t h cASx o
hes eh l
o l l t t
r p u r n o o ia e f g n n vi en R
nf i g g e r e t c e i
r e a p S t n l R a i t u
r Sp e A o s c n u f t l 1
a r ap 1
3 3
3 1
2 c a e i e r cp ) r e 3 6 8 n o f emx m A a f f f t t r re. c t
e 2 2 e n e
a n
t a
r t
e a
_ 5
a r
1 I I o i o l ,
l
@l i, .
3 nl !
l \ l ) 1 s
I. ty v -
k O 0: 0 00 O O
O O
- 0 o o O 5 g O -
0 g O O O 3 O O O t
- O O O O O O O O
)
5 O O I.___ .j_. .I. O O
Og O
y
- {
k O O O O 3
- O t O O -
! O O O O o ! ! o O -
O O O O O O O ! O O
O ! O O -
0 0 11 D 0 j @ O OO OO O c % .in -
o r
, , m e j "I
.a
/ Y ,
_ oj i i i
1 i.l l{ ] &, 4 I, a
s i o m m ... e ,
i ;
~ I ~
I! !il ! !! ! !'!! ! ! ! ! ! .
1 1
- e g g g g g a g i g g I
~
! ! ! 1111 li l l !
jl f
!! ri
!!j li ni l i l
3 ii ,,
h g D.g gE_ &.. S ... _ _. .,. .-. . , te c - EM&S dif=RE l' _
- e, , .
l l-liUIL ~n av,lf:, b= 1,. i=.
- __ I ____ = I e i e i o o
. l 1
o i
- I " I '
i
- r. 1 J
- ~* .
ow ., -
li i21, s 3 i
i liem .
e ji
/ 7.
l b l'r \
If- hk I s
f*
i t ' Ni *I i.m,.l P
~
B i
-~d i'.i A
gi i
,, w 3
a in g$
$ g d I h ,
ji I ' k' 3 !k ' i n .'%q '
$ )
"l);j\
15
\ il g
Nes Il gc. k k 'l Ii t's
' ll f ;-
(
% ^ J
$/ ;j
~
L i- z,,.sT s$
!h
_ =
i y e f 11 1
15 i
t pa.a4~ ~ sc - a, .
e,U{ [ n di l' i
i_ v} '! gT', $R[4
-s
- % ' m .{l 5 s t q
{$.I -l - l l )q '
- 0. ~
'[.{l agji w
'G h
- gg ,,oy eeo
- 3 4 5 8 * * * *I*
t i
se~ g M Gu f p p'!' i ! mit g"i r l i l i "i - l i aa
=
i i
- N5 i e.
.n
- u ; ; ; ; ; ; ;; ; ;; ;
a i pe. ,i.
i i
vi i
i l ini ii inl lni i
~
> I i
g l k l. ! ! !
1 1
.l' . , ll i aun e
p3 s
as is :
tig{
l,i, ,ii 1 I
i i n ii
,[ -! s t t il -
i, ' l.
i.
.t. I
} i i
!{!(( l l l l t t
=am
~
Q D.Epp, = =. -= =,- ,*::. ;~.~y =.= .,' n -
b ti :
~~~
4l._gq__=. _-g L = s i n = = r _
t - i " ._!E:. , ;-
r
- . - - . . . - - - - - . . _ , - - - - - - . _ - - - . _ - . . ~ - - . ,
' ' 1 I a I . , ,
l F
g, 4
f i ,t g L . I'? 1
. ng ,
a g
- r. . . . _
g ~e .
py
~+4
- a .~
y
.u . ! ,
R 9
/ -- _
j [g. ,
8
" e LL
~
-, d [@ D.?
i
- i
)
adY n
L ,
b\ "
!!g;g
- _ ldl fi i k l}
M:-qs 4 ,4 a
1 j' 3
~
.V 1 su i I . .
at l
- > z n: ug
, ,\ t0&.:
!n .
l$ )}
f jj j . . . . . . ,
hhl -
$ $h
" ? .
Ll :
- i s s s s H
8 .
- I l
! 11 '
$l r II -
l l*l ,, ,
u s E I
~
f I l j
$$ l j I I
'D d'et!!E3Mf-l, l
3#"7 ~- $$ )
$ - ,[~F ' '~
==~~
=
e m_ 1
- I -- I l a
r i . i o o i i - i ,
I usum=
m
' P ill 9
{
, fI h s L -..
'((((((((((W, _
3 MEL s
2 ll ' ,. .
r i ~
h l .
1 j
6
~
, 1 AxK m:
ij ,)li ,
/. f
/L.t ,
w '
1 I
...,3 . . . . .,
sil' - -
I'l
\
lil
. . . ,, i
?> I a a s s l
t itt I G ' l
~
.pa
!! s w I . I 5 11
$' I I I -
l l
.i. '
I ! I cr,=
je EE!@ dif523;-g
.f{ g ['F ' '~~~g DE&g ~"--}"T#%
9
. [~$. .
,---=====,:==. i
-- l
- - - - - T o - - T o pus RS I n S u
E r S B r p e n u u l
v idp u s p h s p g e u s r s g e pr a p a e e e c t e n c P r e n P s d q s e s e r s e s i
n r s o u d e t i d ip a s o s i
o a J s op n r n n e i
s t n n e p
e t
i c e n o u v t
i a p J r i
p o a u r v nr i
yf s r e o n a d ,e l
t o yr a l
t Pa c
d e
s e
i o c 1 i o oh o
i 1 l r n s n e 9 n
t i
e l 9 a 8 t 9 meRu d n e r 7 l 5
r P e I n
/
S i
a i n
fg u
i n r d f e e e
d r o 4 i t t o
r d l e g t i a r c
1 2
i n p s r a
i m t a i
Ro n i msbe v
l e
a
(
Ne s e n n
i n
o u e f e e r
g .v e to l
t w
f r
e 1
9 9 (
1 2 N R
e e
n C
l q
u )
6 NC 1 e n
e o B 9 a n
.v 8 c 9
_ 9 y 1 5
- l 9 1 i
)
9 6
0 2 9 9
6 n
e
_ s s
6
s p
ms uC o M o
t at r e e t a
t Ge np oE ny op u t e s e r s
s Cp n
t Eu i
t n e tr e r r n r ud a ria t ip ia n ntie u
r mo s ol r Po a l t c g os s s l s s l
s s o e t nt h
t i oA gp onino hs e a a hmoi a n rp ut on s r t t at n r
e ot c t op e pp u e mn i e
r p p l
ao s hn o c l r e y fp r oe o
r ep r t a
r t i e
r a fi a
l oa oc e m
s e a c n l fop ms i
dnr e r l e th t e t c ba i l i
n oy i l s n t we o inug r c h i e
s mdip e n on oat t hr y d
n s
u e nt p s ot rc o hw t s c ,t he h e c l
o u e e l
l u
r l l s ,l a bit uni e d u e s t tr o dp p s c l
oa os n a o prp u nt l
e os l dp u r den ep a
s o s r e t c io t
i o
p r a t
i s e is o n l
n i
o r e l ni s i s
udnt i
o vl ey p o n n l e o r nio e a t nfe e mop o s t
t s i i fa dp l ofoc a o ny r t e o fc r ,l o gir ot a f n mE C n
d C
S
_ 7
MS t RC Q os a r Oon u al r a - a t g i i in ner 1
3 t
i n
l i
f g
no s u i e s e d e
D -
M C Pp o o r s
i g n i
a t
oo g
n t o
i n r e r g a d i s F g n I m o n r T D A o r r d u y d s w i
t i
C e l
o o l n a a a t i n l
g n d C
o a d W e
t i
u r t g
n n i
w e
g l l
8 I
p T e r Cs r e in o d Cu St d
cin i
Pn E p g uA Ce m Cr f p So Sc s r um r e u
r vd e v e
io i a n l
l l l
nd a e c t e a n c
t e c e s o t
s l
l e
T e
c s
t e t d
D d a u
r t i
n a g
9
ODAL t r i C
o r hy l
l o mn a e
r w P e wtia a n it i
mt e
o l
l bg n t t I l e m e r
e n S e s n s S t r n t
i u t r a t
/
a l a i E
l t
a i n n e C Do i e r C
r n y r DS w
e He e si D l
l a g e
/ d n s i
W L Cg n e
t s o o w s n e d i
l t l i o
D e .
n s
b r
i s
1
_ 0 d )
D
- - - - - E - C r
a AHCSR C o nt w
c o
t u P o o Cre s uHCaMn b
RS r t
a t
ao i
y k o mI S s S S i
n nf m
I l
i n a Spy eys t
g t
i s
r a y C m c y mte s o n e t
w a DmS e
- mte t n e e a ni mnmD t
e r p *y L
/ i t f
r r
e s
t e o /o t
o m
s s
u m wDe n e Ea t
o r
r i
z
- P e r
e s t
Sg s
i Cn u
s a t
s s
u i
g n
y s n CD t
h e
i o
n r
e t
e m
Ss r
e f
o y S C o Dg r
e r
s t
e o
l a s e
q e
m n ir u (
t I g n
i e
r A jn s
u D e c
c S t t ) i i
o o n n s (
t r
a L
i P n C e
r I s )
1 1
iu mp ep poms y
t Mlut a
ia l
n m
i t
r e r
i n e i n r i e i i nf s
s a
t o
m u
m m u )e C o gg i
r
,m F m n o A l o o d Sr n c t
Nwr i t P
i o o t r o n r m
s M a
x i
o n
a in o
l a
l i s n o m ( e T r u r e M m L m a x N O D p i u C e e m u
m A sg r
a b
e / in t
m r L g u
r F
l o
o f O n e w P
u O C a m ,P ot n p d
O s S i
n ds N p g
n i a
P e r t l i a
e o S
t i
H n o
n v s a
l s
1 2
t C S I Rem
(
m i
t N>s
/1
> s smT i i A0 1
0 1
0 1
0 1
0 im
)n e nf gg P N u u Sr 1 1 1 1 2 1 p
momf b
t r
s e r ao i
4 ,4 ,6 ,7 ,0 2 1 (
F n 2
5 7
2 0
0 7 8
,0 5
pg l o er 0 5 0 0
0 0 0
0m
- 0) w P uS D
e o
op 1
2 1 1 2
1 1 1 ( lp s i
5 5 r 0
1 4
0 1
4 5
0 5
0 )F es Te g pms o
i n
n C
,7 7
,7 7 ,4 ,4 ,4 E
C o 0 0 1 N0 ( 00 00 00 Sc 0
1 1 Ce S ne ds A (R R (C (C ( Pno
/
i H H S Cud t
)S m
)R )R )S
) i p
o E n s
1 1 1 2 1 ( C N
/
,2 ,3 ,
1
,4 ,4p gSo CT 4 7 8 9 6 A2 5 0 0 0 0 mFa t
0 0 0 0) l l o
1 w
3
S H R y l P C H s ot C S t I R e m w an bg l
,4 ,4 ,6 ,7 ,0 2 1
,0 e
2 7 0 7 8 5(
5 0
2 5
0 0
0 0
0 0
0g F 0p o l St t
mw r
)
aa in nd e
r T
e m Hg 1
5 2
1 1
5 2 1 5
1 5
( p e e 0 )F atr 1
0 1 0 1 0 aP da 0 4 0 4 0 0 u r
e Lm ot s
S t s r
LaA oi l l
s no s er wa 1 2 1 2 (f 7 4 8 1 9 2 t
. Hb l 6 3 7 9 1 2) ea e d
1 4
y w
e l
l
- R e MMeT K T N I r n h
Mf e c n ma i i U
e mn oe i
l c
t r
o -
Kp -
u f
e r
mOy K Sn I
s nr s
vr e al i
v e h T M@
a a
l
- N s t l u uo d e e a iw r t
W@ l no Ro l M
e t
a m
p r
a mto
- n i
aa t
Fc @ i od l
Oru 1
3n r
e t
l nD y
i n
s 5 t
a l
,5 ,2 QA up l
e 5 3 2 8 3 ap d 0 1 7 0 7 0 n r i
0 5 3 0 0 0 0 t o i
s ( ( ( ( ( ( ( t t
f t
f t
f t
f t
f 1 1
f y .x o 1 t
_ 3 3 3 3 3 3
) ) ) ) ) ) )
b e
1 5
a t e 0a t
- vF l
wr e
l t f
l l
i f
C A ht ai l t u z l
l D r
a k %e e d i
g D e eP s at S y l
u w e
s p
op e
n e b
r e f xa e r r Pf d r r i
c g l l
o y n
)
i a i s
e t og t
k- f m c/ e yT i
d x
s o u
p e a d t n
e c
d d
p a
t i
n i
r t
p e e i
f i
c e
b r
i n
t g
s
/
d u
nt t
e s i v i s d t a
l u a l
e s
r e
v i
1 4
0 1
1 1
(
I ba Qu r
D e
w 5
5 0
0 7
0 5
0 8
5 5
0 mn t y w
) i e t y
d a
n d
J A M a U
R U U R R e
l c F r l o g ,G ,G ,G /
n f e M i n S S S i
r m
e d
a s
u r
e
(
t c
o a o n
e c
t i
e c
t i
o c
t i
o e
R Wm ee n
i n n e t w
t o m g 3 3 3 f
e e r n s .
b t ) 2 2 2 e e n l
e s
2 2
2 2
2 2
c e
e l
s 3 2
3 l
t 6 1 2 h
a n
1
- D e
U R b G r i
s 1
6 l
SQF t
u r
a r o n
n a i n
i n s c e
t r
t i
o e
r u
r n
c S D t
t i a r o l e
u n R s c e i t
u Rq g r e u n a q i l
u re R. r e
i m e R
e me q q e n u u
_ t n s i
r i e t r m
s e e m n
t e n
s
_ t s
1 7
o e s o c D e ni u r uB5 c
n u 0 l ut a e b l
e l l %ed l t l e r t i
s s e t b s i nea h ni e s oD i
ns
- on t
l o t r dp c
h9 e 6 r
k e
a i
n Xd or a ag l
w0 d e Pl ut i c
R t
r So
_ i3 s s e iHs l
e a n h e eq j
ud s q s
a y a g t
i f e R d, l ,i 3 c r r e
ur ig e .
s o 3 i
e o
s a i
r d
G s g s t e e u
i d
e t
o b
r e o a u f r t
m e
h n
1 e t e l a
e n
8 b i t
_ ,2 a s '
d s e hs 0 R
a tr e d 1
.v o na i n
Xn s 2
r e b Per h a
o q
S l
u t h s l i
r e
a a Hh b m e l e
_ e q u
l n
- t i
r e
,s a
1 8
- - - SR oa AAS s t t
r e aq nn s
d r s
up o a i
iu ni t
r n e r
e t e e r r e r ue c
pSm s
t d s r a a t ig a
ip e np r r
e e tn o e
r s p o
n n
o c
is f
nR a r r
e i
a p
- id c e Rq r
t e r e a t v e o
b s
e s
s ie q u
s c
t i
u r
e ol n po u t o r e in r
a n n
d s e t
a d e o
o f i
n a m f t h gn i
n e g
h i e c
d n q
h Ao S
s p t s
u Mpm e a E o c i
l i n f t
y Ce i o n t
e d s d e
i n
1 9
- - D- -
M -Q oi uCQs n o u e n l
e gio v P
r C o
a t
e N10 o
A s nn a n r C t s s s i l
i n i f o i AF r ot e s f i
e d
e r a S R us t
hn d d ml s M5 E ,0 c e
r t t o wt o t w i C pA i wiA it h A t
e oR j
s h e
F S
M C T e
S r t
i f
p e
n ne r
Ru i
ut s
i z E t i
M c d a i e x f S t
i f at P C o
i e p t
B e
i e r d d e c
r e q di c k
e
,S Mi a c f
i q
u ue in P e t e a i
r e r l
a n
c t
i r
i a
t i
o d e t o l n m n T s U
n II e e n
m m i
,I s t
_ q t m
u S R s e u m
e p
Ab o
s n e r a c
_ t l t s y i o
s n
_ i s
N R
e C
_ p /
_ o r
N
,t F
SAVn C e u
NW o oi n
bc c o o l s
l u n d s e ep c m Dor e
f i n
t r
u t
ia on t
e t
r s
t mg c nc e i
,c r t o t Nre u in Cq u
S u
r c
t i
A S oR n
i r
f a v e M m
e e
c
,e EC o E R e
n a n x a d q p
t s
e d
V m e
,S ue in r
T i e r
n e
e c .
Ax a
t i
o S
t m
a Mmo in e
I n
E n
i X
n s
Ca
_ t t o s i
d o
,e n S
e c
t i
_ o n
m
_ I I
,I 2
1 i
l l i; '
~
+ SS t I c S t r
- - - r a T oUUtiEe e C N (P r CNDNoma Cot r un ce i
c n E i t r Aer DiDnbn f
ht R n t i uD c nG AaiOiOa ia ner naiE i
t r e a
l m 0 -
)G ,P 4 2 o2 i
n1 n t s as i e
moh lg i
An6 l a 5 8 s c t 6 t
i v
L ,1 o
n83 t
U ,1 or "
R8 e
p ,8 e n a ns ll t
Rn ee R i " a qq u t n n yg ATef S
a q i
u M" t
("
MRnb a
r e de ui e e r L k e aq a ir e
- t r
7ny "nE Ak nI DI a v c u c a eme Pva r
ol y a
l P )R C r
o l n ue ap l
i f
mn es t
g u s o t a i r
a a
t sig r
i n
t i
ond t
a e n pAa i
o t
,m n ,m m e nc e of s RR p S
n P r c r l t e e sp i
c tr P oo a u r or io l
gog r e t
ic t l r u ,t ot u r a
t n r a a r d oM i
n a r
Ga u
l mmis a, ok iA L ol o f dc o G
I ,e c "pe a fa e
e n
r t
a n
d Md a
i c r c e k 2
2
- - r J
a AT J a AT un c
mnR e a
- manR - t sy s
l 5 3
e sy l 5 s 3 uD r
i2 2
.A s 1 .A s i
1 as F R ,2 -
F R ,1
- lg ie zp t
PoM a r ie zp t
PoMa a r e
R t
t a t t
qq r or r or c fk i i c fk ui kt hI kt h I ir Ne C o Ne C r uTn c ot uTo c ot n e
l e u a
r a r s n i
l e u a
r s n r a i m e
PAm ot t ne PSm oue n t
p n wa e c t wp e
t s r h P r r e r P e r P dg o l
Ps sg o l
a Pr a o r i
nia n n a t
"pn ,m i
t
" C ,m
( (
Pg P l P ahP l Ufa Aon r t Uma Abt n e
)RthU
)Rr U e n fn q
i oi rq u t u e he e
n
OS t t y H r u
h r d c e a r t r i n o u Ae f r d y r a
f e E n a
l c v a E t
m e
d l
u i c va a l Ct L u o o i o
mn a a t
p d i o E o n
e v
a n n l t
E u
a t
M e
v a
i o t h
l n o u
a d t
t i
o o
l n o g
y 2
4
i nLo y ur dt uc CGL S t
a uORha d r r h
l F Hn dCVe i s oa u y g e s Al o iFc dl E id d r s e /
Co a da z l
o y v S o t t
d o o s Pm na t
r u n y
a n pmsd b a ap aua l c a t
u r ml iy a u o t
e r pmd c s e
t r
ie c
u t mt io i
e c t i
c Pu o k d c n I
n Ma n LM Ps u r t a goed t l i e n ot e s t a
c t
r s C
o c
h n
e r a sup mia l En Ag i
ah o i
o e qis n n dd o
(
n F
f f
i c
u e
g L
t t
e s
Rme Eo l S
i e
s Dt t vg Rs
)
I n h ay L
t a o l n d o
a d o u d
i t
s l
o a t
D A g i e
v p y o e
l o
p l
i s
p n
p c a e m
e t
i o c i
n t
n f i
e d
2 5
- - - - dC r
uS d s E o c C a o dt s u iAt r f e a g n r oa e b f d fj a f l s ds t e oq e
r e s u
ie nc e t f
f c i u ve o vr dl c l y
r o nt ms ia ju l ue s n c
e s e f
h e te n d ua na t
mt n
t i
t yft e it n
o ( b l
e Ca s e v i
au m
e
_ s t m s m s l t oiha e n e b) a fd d h io wg d
ey c a te e oo s
e r n c
e d t
LM m
r f t o u d r vr u a a r r o o
a a ne d md t
c ot l h l n
s c i
ue nu e r t r u o t e fc iy n ah n
fc oo a in s
t i m' i
t o
i e a dd nt n n r n t e
dm Eo f f e fo g l f
uir y vg m
r r o r fi o oc umd t
r e e
e s h s f S n omr l
ay d gio r ug s l m
h u
e r
y v c nt e s d r a
, t s e a o r s a
_ l n s F o o r a is t us a e t
r l l o d d n/ a i
i o
wcy yn e t r a o v c i i n a r c n a
nt e l
nimme i
s s r i p
_ l l m r oe e dc o
n e
_ a g t r mdr n
d t
o t ( a ut a h y Cs s l i s
s o m a p
e m e a
y n 2
= n d .
b 0 e )
2 6
c a F uc y ba y c S a FP r c S dc c a t
r c c SUve I r TNe l n e
i e l s I
Ae l e o l
oa c Uer e e r oR r a dl h Ta r a f t a a d y q
n i Etia Con t
i oa wn a t
is o d na u Hsnay nr al l
e l
s ey s n s e r da e u ni v r ds s a ns du t i
a e v m io e nbt u i i Fi nl dop c wg oi l LM i i z z l t e ui z a e d aMnd e Ped a d ot b r id t C b y knFg r
io ou ah NIPta z i
t c
kn us dd Rr P Pn t
i ni n t
e a Co g nt r Uu d ig El vg o ra uia c Au nt g o ay n
a mtik RmD r l n oP t oy a u u o
t nU c
r u n t
t e
s a
h e uA s a s t r vR r s m nh ue i d e t o
hi c e ,s a o o
c s
du r l l
I t
i l
l n k
e e s v s n c o t
e h l
(
n p
oe l l C e
d D
I
)
2 7
- PAhA n n (S Uny r ac p
r e
s U
s e p dR e
SAa l da r l iu nr o o e SRy s oy el nf s n) , dz r e S dt e e iy s e s R a S e nche x nd mamtr Ev c
c S t c
e s vu aa e
p f o dnpi t
h c a i
l t
e c do r yq nu t
s o d
l oe r i
n uo a
a eq u s a ybm t
b ms Nin c s e a iur a s da s s i
ot Ra l e s nh t
Ci o r em e in odo n o a t oa m dot s b S f s l y
E c s
,R Ma o ued f o
dk a
t ep r
I mms boi r i
c r n
di nfb e o r
Mpni e th r ag r e d i
n a
c s s n l hy q 1 s u a
,0 e t
a n 1 m r d 9 e s
8 3
- 2 8
- - - C hu o
Ts o t r nt I
T o
e r
r a e r pm u i n r n u s
wr a
e a l p s
e o
n A fv t
s n e fa n
t e
r r e u rt t e v
o c a t
u t s c t
l r
i o r e u e n e m
e s
a ,s v i
dn n
d c g r
i n
e w C ot o g e pm p
mid r d
o e n r s oo e
n t
s a
n ng d e n
i n a t
c l
t a t o c s h E p
e r p e
d va o
xp i
l mgn ii u
i t
a t
y i t
o o n
2 9
P 0T t hu r .
o Re l VP P 3 e
SM r
a p i p
i u
mcimi%s r i
p e gn i
e l
v e n i
e Al h s ug i f y a n i w
i c u o np r kg p e
d a a m a fv fa r t t e e or r r y i
o w e e e
r r t r
r e n a r c e
n f
i s
e e
d e
i n
f mLe o e r t
v o
t e
o t t
s o v v e l dn r
c gn g e
i ir c d i
l o l u e u m
e (2 n
(4 mi e c f
m m e C n h s n a e ot s d a u (t ti m
t
(
3 n g p o t
i l e v e p 2 l n l
c r p o o s a
l v )
r s r t
s c
a e
t m e a oo ng e ) t a s
)
s i o t e e
)
n s m i
d n t
n b i
y m E u
m l
e s
va T s l e
c t h u h
n a a t
i c n i a
l o n
3 0
XS P
t r
D e
r a
S a b i i
Hn e r i
n e
s r
a MrHe G E r
g e a
n e v a
i n d r a l E L t i u v o o a a s s n t i
l u
/
T o a
t r
a n i
o n n s p M e
o r t t h o
d o
l o
g y
3 1
- - - B Dt e
r a
i dU e bS e As a be n R
> > rp xl r r t
e e hp l e r GTy DDS a e l ip d i s E mc p i
a uo i z
e kr l
o a c i c i
o t o v io n e mb t n a Gu l e e mof e l e
o f
c a l y n t
l t
o b
i i t
e r e b
t i
oo Z a a nl i
E e a t n n n r a nt o a
l e
d s
u o
f d e ,n n a e y rl b R e i
i nd l
a t
a e
,d k c s z e oo e a G r n a
s us t l
e r
t ig o e n t r
u n
nf s I dk s M aM t
ie t u r i
dn f o e t ic o t p e e l n t oh ni o p e
i s t
r a
r iu ne g n 1
2 h
o nod dn /
e t i n : c e
d /o Tl br r a e d ( g h
i o l r go sins b Z h o ay npo i
s r r
e a )
O I
e n
g y s n
e p
ut f
k c o gr ,
p p
r e
a c
t p m y l M e
o r
s o i
s r u n t t is t e e h o u s ns d a o p e a t n d o d e d ot o a g 3 l c r h e a
t e
r
e D ei b
r be r
i i PPRDSMMTKTN a
iiuu a l u iihnee s s nnt ss dnc a mUK D Q r r G
t t t
/ g -
up
- - De Koh t m -
Oe u ML O i
r t e r
W @f a MNb r a e a
r C mrpa t
@ sin nt g
nAJ i
Ci o t t
e r
i n
e t
t t
s i s e aM t
i u
e o
n t D n B /
T A r (i
a 1 1 0 1
n s
u n
s 1 2 p 7 8 5 5 0 05 0 00290 8 3 3 3 7 5 0 Qp r p l
bbbbb l l l l 6 00 9 O u e 5 a ss o r
mmmmmt f f f 3
t t 3 3 f
t 3ft t 3
f n 3 t i
o t in t
y p o
o l
)
3 3
D e e b
r be r
PPRDSMMTKTN a
iiuu a s u l
hne i
s i
s nns t t t t i i dnc- r e
r a mUK D Q De Komfup G
/ g
- - t h -
Oe u ML a O i
r t e r
ma W@MNb r a
@s r a n
e g
r C p t i nt nAJ i
C o t t
i e r
e n i t s t
i t
u e
s aM t
i e
n o
t S B
n
/
A T r
(i a 1 1 0 1 n s
n s
7 8 5 5 0 05 0 0 0000 4201 1 p
pu Q u l
bbbbb l l l l 7 07 7 0 5 a mmmmmt f ft ft tfft tf n 3 t pr 3 3 3 3 3 o
r i
t t
y e s
s i
o n
p o
o l
)
3 4
l
t uSe o hA t Dt ei r
a r f e l CuS t bn
_ S bd l o r uiLr r re e e e
n d bd d mOfe i
s e
r uii l
e e mme e n l
e Cob r s E v
v n c tn n n Ae r a v
a t
i e
/at a t
t t
p ta t
t r
i s Gu ea l
bi a sa i
e r o o hi ni o t
y l
e n n a o ns d
a krf b s n e s u e r n e s a a o p t
e r
ic z t e o i
s e
d of f d om r e aM t
ie t
m n o Le e td oth i
n s n e
d a
r B Obr ,d o nod f
e L O Cs i db /o Tl a
c r f u
n C ,A c ue r r go t c Kbo n i s ay gnu i
o n
s t
iAa o
n Gs s s p
n s
i d o E e d t
ue p p
e p
f c o
de r r n o o
s o d o e bd ue r i
t o e :nd l l t
e a e ,d d
o f n a t
p n t
n e s
t r h d r .
a i
a s
n e e
r s
3 5
I
+ + + SS map t
- - - - - F r ar t
P F F o F r i
b ai n a
r i
b i
d i t MBsa o r ie nr t e b
e e l
t r
i c d o e u i
r r a eE c
uq t l
/ t u i f d s r va l
a uy Co il a i
e o a pe o n n t
n t d D I l u
/e f
i t
i t
r r
e Me o
t o
a Ne Ub r I
et a by e
r (t l a
d e c c R i ao i mi h t l
o E s dn u G a c s
s k
n if o
n r
o m
n t
/
C LM ot e r e f o R h a
t i )
s s VB a L r
t 6 2
s s o d
o l O h i 2 o i c d
a C
K k
f 4
M Moy eg l
t i A i b e t
o t
G e h h
r o n
E o
b d
e o d
s o l
d g
y o l
o g
y 3
_ 6
w
+ + St S r
FMEF e
be DS P t
r a an i
r t uh l
o e r t R ie r n
a o wb a I eE r i in T r v d r s yr a e o t q e u r e s
a l
1 l
o a e d t I u n s s I a
_ ,8 yg t i g et i 1
i y/ n t
ao 9p r m dn 9e 7s i
x Le M e oth n
t s o e s d o
d Mg l
t o o
ey N
t R h o
C d o
b y l o
I g
T y
S o
n 3
_ 7
t c" r I
n S t
l e
an ie B E t
e r B r
a a n
n a
s l
b c
o a s
i n
e e
r e o n e r s d n d o
n
,s w
t e
e o c n t
i Mt o a d
r i
H et h
a e g np u
u n ao n s o P b l
e s
e r dn d l b r ii s "
o o
r" pn i h e Le a g k
c m d ot s
o s Ce h o s t
s r
r e mt e a l
a t
i dp s o su
" n r
e M
ey o ,
e t l n
s r n s e s t
d t
h u
c o e
r d
,s p
ol p
i i
o g
n g y 3
8
_ - - - - Aoi fF Pa d un Sn VMAImd o i r n /r p i
i t
e a l
l H
t e iS a i d o N x mt c
_ g i
n u e mmf a
t o n a
s t
r a S P M au s v l u
b mb b
u b
a r
i o
u AnH s
i e
r m g
r in n
s e l e .s s a g
r e r ip s e n a ng r s g i Ee c se a e t m n vt o te i
m e n
i n
ao l
n e r c
t s c l
uo ao h u t a d iy g
n i n o e
s g n o l n o s
N s P e S s H t m h r
a r o g
i n g u
h 3
9
Meeting Summary Distribution: Date: June 4, 1998 LICENSEE: New York Power Authority i
FACILITY: James A. FitzPatrick Nuclear Power Plant
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
- MAY 21,1998 MEETING REGARDING EMERGENCY CORE COOLING SUCTION STRAINER MODIFICATIONS (TAC NO. M96146) .
l
- E-MAIL (w/ encl.1) Hard Copy (w/encts.)
S. Collins /F. Miraglia (SJC1/FJM) { Docket Fila"I B. Boger (BAB2) PUBLIC J. Zwolinski (A) (JAZ) PDI-1 R/F j S. Bajwa (SSB1) J. Williams l S. Little (SLL) OGC 1 T. Martin (SLM3) ACRS '
K. Kavanagh (KAK)
J. Kudrick (JAK1)
D. Jeng (DCJ) cc: Licensee & Service List R. Elliot (RBE)
M. Marshall (MXM2)
A. Serkiz (AWS)
B. McCabe (BCM)
C. Hehl, Region I (CWH)
'1 t
1