ML20248E160

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Insp Rept 99901340/88-01 on 881201.No Violations & Noncompliance Noted.Major Areas Inspected:Review Records Associated w/masoneilan-dresser Valve Trim Parts Supplied to Commercial Nuclear Power Field
ML20248E160
Person / Time
Issue date: 01/13/1989
From: Baker E, Petrosino J
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To:
Shared Package
ML20248E153 List:
References
REF-QA-99901340 99901340-88-01, 99901340-88-1, NUDOCS 8908110270
Download: ML20248E160 (14)
v • d • e


Text

_ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -

4... ,

j ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED  :

L, LIV 0!ilA, MICHIGAN REPORT INSPECTION INSPECTION 1 l

NO.: 99901340/88-01 DATE: December 1, 1988 ON-SITE HOURS: 24 l

CORRESPONDENCE ADDRESS: S-W Controls, Incorporated 35980 Industrial Road i Livonia, Michigan 48150  ;

ORGANIZATION!4AL CONTACT: Mr. William F. Sample, President J TELEPHONE NUtiBER: (313)464-7500  !

1 NUCLEAR INDUSTRY ACTIVITY: Supplier of Masoneilan-Dresser valves and replacement  ;

parts.

, dhj/O /

ASSIGlED INSPECTOR: b/Mdh // 6449 J. J/Pqtrosino, Reactive Inspection Section / ,Date No'.1/(RIS-1)

OTHERINSPECTOR(S): V. VanCleave, NRC-Region IV T. Tinkel, Sonalysts, Inc.

APPROVED BY:

E. T. Baker, Chief, RIS-1, Vendor Inspection Branch Date INSPECTI0fi BASES AND SCOPE:

A. BASES: 10 CFR Part 21.

B. SCOPE: Review records associated with Masoneilan-Dresser valve trim parts that are supplied to the commercial nuclear power field.

PLANT SITE APPLICABILITY: Big Rock Point (50-155), D.C. Cook (50-315/316),

E. Fermi (50-341), Davis-Besse (50-346), Perry (50-440), and Palisades (50-255).

~

8900110270 890008 PDR G A999 EMV****

  • 99901340 PNU

ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS,' INCORPORATED LIVONIA, MICHIGAN l

REPORT INSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 2 of 14 l

A. VIOLATIONS:

None B. NONCONf0RMANCES:

None C. UNRESOLVED ITEMS:

None D. STATUS OF PREVIOUS INSPECTION FINDINGS:

None E. OTHER FINDIllGS AND COMMEllTS:

1. Background On.0ctober 18, 1988, Consumers Power Company (CPC) submitted a 10 CFR Part 21 report to the NRC regarding questionable valve trim replace-ment parts, which typically include the valve stem, plug or disc, cage, seat ring, and retention pin, for its Masoneilan-Dresser (M-D) valves.

CPC identified approximately 65 questionable valve-trim parts after a M-D service. technician brought some suspect parts that were found in a turbine bypass valve at the Palisades Nuclear Plant to CPC's attention.

Two years previous, CPC had sent the subject turbine bypass valve to a M-D valve facility for refurbishment. They also sent M-D the . correct valve trim, since it was an in-stock warehouse item. After the valve was refurbished, reinstalled, and the plant started operation, CPC dis-covered that the turbine bypass valve continued to leak. However, CPC decided to operate with the leakage and resolve the problem during its 1988 refueling outage. CPC contracted with M-D for its 1988 outage to provide on site technical support for valve refurbishment.

During the 1988 turbine bypass valve refurbishment, the M-D technician identified dimensional and metallurgical discrepancies in the valve trim parts that were previously installed at the M-D facility and addi-tionally identified problems with the new valve trim parts that were to be installed. Subsequent CPC investigations determined that the author-ized M-D distributor, S-W Controls, procured many of the valve trim components from manufacturers / suppliers that were not authorized by M-D to make the parts. Two companies have been identified as manu-facturing replacement valve trim parts without authorization from M-D:

Control Valve Speciality Company (CVS) and COR-VAL, both located in

". ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED LIVONIA, MlCHIGAN REPORT INSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 3 of 14 Houma, Louisiana. A third company, GEMOCO, also located in Houma, Louisiana, has been identified as advertising replacement parts for M-D valves. M-D has indicated that GEM 0C0 is also not an authorized manufacturer or distributor of M-D parts.

On November 18, 1988, M-D transmitted a letter to the NRC staff dis-cussing the above issues. The letter identifies a potential for failure of M-D valves if parts manufactured by unauthorized companies are installed by the end users (licensees). The letter also indicates that the suspect parts are typically' procured as commercial grade and dedicated by the licensee for use in safety-related systems.

The 10 CFR Part 21 Palisades report and the M-D letter have brought into question the functionality of valves that have valve trim components installed that were not manufa'ctured by an authorized company. This issue may not be limited to M-D valves, but could include other manufacturer's valves.

2. Discussion On December 1, 1988, the NRC inspection team met with the president of S-W Controls, Mr. Bill Sample, at the S-W Controls facili! / in Livonia, Michigan. The NRC team leader explained that the NRC was conducting an unannounced inspection of S-W Controls as a result of a 10 CFR Part 21 notification by CPC on October 18, 1988. The CPC 10 CFR Part 21 notification addressed potentially suspect (non-genuine) replacement parts supplied by S-W Controls for Masoneilan valves installed in the Palisades Nuclear Power Plant. The NRC team leader stated that the team wished to review the S-W Controls quality pro-gram, purchase orders, and other related documentation that may be pertinent to the NRC's evaluation of the CPC 10 CFR Part 21 notifica-tion. During the course of the inspection, various discussions occurred between the NRC inspection team and Mr. Sample. A summary of the major topics covered in these discussions is presented below:
a. S-W Controls (formerly Sample-Webtrol Controls) is an authorized representative for Masoneilar valves for specific geographic areas in Michigan and Ohio. The office in Livonia handles purchase orders from CPC for Palisades and Big Rock Poir.t Nuclear Power Plants. As an authorized Masoneilan representative, S-W Controis is not allowed to handle other valve competitor's product lines.
b. S-W Controls does not use a formal, documented quality program.

Personnel are trained on the job and follow policies and proce-dures that have evolved with time.

_. . _ - _ _ . ___________.________A

- ~ ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, 2 INCORPORATED LTV0NIA, MICHlGAN REPORT INSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULIL: PAGE 4 of 14

c. Purcnase orders are received from S-W Controls customers and are processed by the S-W Controls inside sales personnel.

With respect to nuclear orders from CPC, S-W Controls filled past orders by either initiating a purchase order to Masoneilan, the original equipment manufacturer (0EM), or initiating a p.urchase order to a secondary source manufacturer (e.g., CVS orCOR-VAL). Mr. Sample stated that the following S-W Controls policy has been used to guide the internal decision on how to fill a particular CPC order:

(1) Safety-related Orders. These are processed by initiating a purchase order with Masoneilan. Secondary-source manu-facturers were not used to fill any nuclear safety-related orders. Orders that were not identified as safety-related were treated as commercial orders. Purchase order reviews indicate that the commercial grade replacement parts were shipped directly to CPC from COR-VAL and CVS.

(2) Commercial Orders. Commercial orders for Itasoneilan valve parts were handled in one of two ways:

(a) Cenmercial Order Requiring Certification Documentation.

Tole commercial orders required certification documen-tation such as a certificate of compliance or a certi-fied material test report. All commercial orders that required certification documentation were filled by initiating a purchase order with l'asoneilan. Secondary source manufacturers were not used to fill any of these orders.

(b) Commercial Orders With No Requirements For Certification Documentation. These orders could be filled by initia-ting a purchase order with Masonellan or by initiating a purchase order with a secondary source manuf acturer.

In a number of cases, S-W Controls initiated orders ,

with secondary sour;e manufacturers. Mr. Sample noted I that parts ordered by SW fron a secondary source manu-facturer are not dropshipped. Instead, they will be shipped into the S-W Controls facility. However, a review of purchase orders to COR-VAL and CVS revealed that some of the parts were shipped directly to CPC by C0h tAL and CVS.

d. Mr. Sample provided the following backgrouad information concern-ing secondary source manufacturers for tiasoneilan valve parts:

___________.___________________m

9 ;. . l

^

u ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED l LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN l~~ ,

l

! REPORT INSPECTION N0. .: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 5 of 14 (1) In the early 1970's, Masoneilan was experiencing difficulty {

providing timely delivery of replacement parts for their valves. To eliminate the bottleneck, Masoneilan licensed l

CVS to start manufacturing and supplying replacement valve trim parts. Masoneilan then advised S .W Controls and its  ;

other distributors to obtain replacement parts from CVS.

S-W Contrels began to use CVS to fill commercial orders for Masoneilan valve parts following this notification.

(2) In about 1981, Masoneilan_ terminated the license agreement with CVS. However, CVS continued to produce valve trim and S-W Controls continued to buy some valve trim parts for Masoneilan valves from CVS. S-W Controls also ordered a few replacement valve parts for Masoneilan valves from COR-VAL, another secondary source manufacturer.

(3) Mr. Sample stated that all parts purchas.r from CVS or COR-VAL since 1973 were commercial grade. According to Mr.

Sample, these commercial grade parts were used by him to fill only commercial customer orders from CPC that did not require special certification documentation,

e. The NRC team asked M . Sample whether CPC knew they were receiving secondary source replacement parts for th:ir Masoneilan valves.

He said he did not k10w whether CPC was aware. The NRC team questioned Mr. Sauple on whether the secondary cource parts were represented as beint, manufactured by Mas neilan, rir. Sample stated that his cortpany did nothing explicit to repre;ent the parts as being inanufactured by Masoneilan. However, his company ,

also did not ideatify that the parts were not manufactured by Masoneilan. Ti'e NRC team noted that CPC may have thought they were receiving Masoneilan manufactured replacement parts because they were ordering the parts from an authorized Masoneilan repre-sentative. Additionally, the part identification was typically identified on the S-W Controls invoices as, P/N XXXX, Masoneilan valve stem,

f. The NRC team asked whether there was any special way of distin-guishing between a part manufactured by Masoneilan and the same part manufactured by a secondary source manuf acturer. He stated that, in general, one would probably not be able to distinguish the differences by simply looking at the part. However, he stated that current Masoneilan supplied parts are typically packaged and labelled with a part number and the Masoneilan name and logo. The parts obtained from secondary source

)

_ - _ - _ _ - _ _ __ a

. t, .

' ORGANIZATION:- S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN 1

l l

REPORT 1HSPECTI0!l l NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 6 of 14 manufacturers are marked with a part number on a plain shipping tag. The HP,C team observed some examples of this during a tour of the S-W Controls parts storage area. Mr. Sample stated that none of the secondary source parts were supplied to CPC with either the Masoneilan name or the Masoneilan logo nn the tags.

g. Mr. Sample stated that he was very concerned about the questions that had arisen with respect to supplying secondary source manufactured parts to CPC. However, he stated that to his knowledge, the quality of the seco:idary source manufacture parts supplied by his company has never been questioned. Further, he noted that nothing in the S-W Controls contractual relationship with Masoneilan prohibited the use of secondary source manufacturers.

Additionally, he noted that nothing in the purchase order requirements from CPC prohibited S-W Controls from using secondary source manufacturers. Mr. Sample did'say that because of the large amount of effort required by all parties to evaluate the overall issue, S-W Controls will no longer use secondary source manufacturers to fill orders for

-0EM equipment replacement parts.

h. Mr. Sample stated that many companies in the country are involved in supplying replacement valve parts for valves originally manufactured by someone else. Further, he stated that secondary source manufacturers for valve , arts is just the tip of the iceberg. A larger secondary source market exists for many other typ2s of related equipment such as pumps (e.g., impe11ers). Additionally, the secondary source market is common in other industries. Mr. Sat.ple also noted that another entire side of the issue is that OEM replacement parts could be purchased by the OEM from the ame secondary source manufacturers that provide parts to companies such as S-W Controls.
3. Purchase Order Review. The NRC team reviewed a number of S-W Controls purchase order documentation packages for CPC orders to more fully understand the nature of the procurement and identify how S-W Controls filled these particular orders.

Details associated with the review are presented below. In gencral, this review substantiated that these orders were handled in accordance with the policy and procedures explained by Mr. Sample during the course of the inspection,

a. CPC P0 5019-1467-QA (1) CPC PO 5019-1467-QA, dated December 30, 1986 1
  • ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN

~

REPORT INSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 7 of 14

  • Item 1: Pin for Masoneilan valve model 38-20571.

Catalog No. 971342-010-163. Size: 2-1/2 inch, 50 lb, various serial numbers (S/Ns).

Invoked CPC Specification P20: Certificate of Compliance required.

(2) 5-W Controls P0 19154, dated January 19, 1987 to Masoneilan Item 20: 971342-010-163', Pin.

(3) Masoneilan Certificate of Compliance, dated May 4, 1987 States item inspected and conforms to quantities, sizes; naterials, and specifications shown on S W Controls P0 18154 and to our (Masoneilan) specifications.

Red stamp on document: Material non-nuclear.

' Identified Item 2: Part Number (P/N) 971342-010-163, Fin.

'( 4 ) 5-W Controls Invoice No. 3342, dated May 27, 1987 to CPC

Description:

971342-010-163 Masoneilan Pin.

b. CPC P0 1007-9218 (1) CPC P0 1007-9218, dated July 31, 1987 Item 1: Plug, P/N 013431-062-163 for Masoneilan valve model 38-20571. Various S/Ns. Material, ASTM A-479 Type 316.

Invokes requirements for documented QA program in accordance with (ANSI) N45.2. Must extend appro-priate QA requirements to subtier supplier.

  • Certificate of Cunformance and Certified Material Test Report required.

(2) b-W Controls Transmittal 19675, dated Au9ust 18, 1987 to Masoneilan (Customer No. P01007-9218-Q)

.____--__-_-.__--___-_-Q

i

' ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED l- LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN' REPORT- INSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 8 of 14

  • Item 10: 013431-062-163, Plug for model 38-205'1.

Various S/Ns.

  • Invokes requirements to comply with specifications in tne customer order.
c. CPC P0 54078-Q (1) CPC P0 54078-Q, dated April 19, 1978 Item: Seat Ring, P/N 010236-001-163. Various S/Hs, various tag numbers.
  • Copy 2 of PO has a red "Q" stamped on it (no explanation of significance).

(2) S-W Controls PO 3283, dated April 24, 1978 to Control Valve Specialists (Customer Order P0 283 [54078-Q]).

  • Item: 010 236-001-163 Seat Ring for Masoneilan valve S/N G-83918-5.

. (3) S-W Controls Invoice No. 1249.0, dated May 24, 1978

Description:

010 236-001-163 Seat Ring for Masoneilan valve S/N G-83918-5.

d. CPC PO 32343 (1) CPC P0 32343, dated November 14, 1977 Item 1: Valve, 6-inch butterfuly, DEMC0 No.

4914-1215341. Varivus material specs.

Reference catalog B-76, dated Februery 15, 1976.

(2) S-W Controls P0 2768, dated November 11, 1977 to DEMC0  ;

(Customer Order 32343)

  • Item: 6-inch, DEMC0 butterfly valve 4914-1215341.
e. CPC PO 68155-Q (1) CPC PO 68155-Q, August 24, 1978
  • Item 1: Plug,P/N 013434-082-163, S/N G-83918-32.

I

_. __ _______________.-____.m_ _ _ . _ . _ _ . _

ORGAlfilATION: S-W CONTROLS, IllCORPORATED LIV 0NTA, MICHIGAN r .

REPORT. IllSPECTION tl0. : 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 9 of 14

  • Requires certified material test report for valve plug material.

1

, (2) S-W Controls PO 3002, dated October 26, 1978 to Masoneilan (CustomerOrder68155-Q)

, ' Item 1: Plug, P/N 013434-082-780 for S/N G-83918-32.

~ 10 CFR Part 21: CPC P0 68155-Q attached to S-W Controls P0 3902. 10 CFR Part 21 invoked by reference.

f. CPC PO 5022-2694 (1) CPC PO 5022-2694, dated February 16, 1988 Item 1: Plug, Item 20: PL-5068 for War thington Control Valve, Model 559AB.

(2) S-W Controls P0 21190, dated February 24, 1988 to COR-VAL (CustomerOrder 5022-2694)

Item 10: 010431-095-596. Plug for model 559AB.

(3) S-W Controls Invoice No. 36664, d:ted March 15, 1988 to CPC Item: Masoneilan plug for model 559AB.

g. CPC PO 5019-6060 (1) CPC P0 5019-6060, dated February 25, 1987
  • Item 1: Lower Seat Ring, Masoneilan 3-way valve.

Catalog No. 302460-000-163. Various S/Ns.

Item 2: Plug / stem components. Masoneilan 3-way valve. Catalog No. 350071-567-163. Various S/fis.

(2) S-W Controls P0 18469, dated March 5, 1987 to COR-VAL (Customer Order 5019-6060)

  • Item 10: 302460-000-163, Itasoneilan Seat Ring.
  • Item 20: 350071-567-163, Masoneilan Plug / stem assembly.

~

~

ORGAN!ZATION: S-B CONTROLS, INCORPORATED LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN REPORT INSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 10 of 14

h. CPC P0 5017-0914 (1) CPC PO 5017-0914, dated April 4, 1986 Item 2: Seat Ring, Masoneilan valve series 10,000.

Catalog No. 010?31-596. P/N 010231-030-596. S/N G-83918-38.

(2) S-W Controls P0 16409, dated April 21, 1986 to CVS (Customer Order 5017-0914) ,

  • ltem 10: 010231-030-596, Masoneilan Seat Ring.

(3) 5-4 Controls Invoice No. 29887, dated May 23, 1986

  • Item 010231-030-596 Masoneilan Seat Ring.
i. CPC P0 5017 0166 (1) CPC P0 5017-0166, dated March 26, 1986
  • Item 1: Seat Ring for Masoneilan Control Valve, 4 M/N 38-20571. S/Ns. Catalog No. 010237-001-163.
  • Note: Copy 2 of PO was stamped in red "CQ" (with noexplanation).

(2) S-W Controls P0 16360, dated April 4, 1986 to CVS (Customer Order 5017-0166-QA)

  • Item 10: 010237-001-163, Masoneilan Seat Ring.  :
j. CPC P0 1007-0548 CQ I.1 ) CPC P0 1007-0548-CQ, dated April 8, 1986
  • Item 1: Plug, S/N G-83918-27. Material A-276-TP316 ,

for Masoneilan valves. S/Ns and M/Us, Masoneilan '

drawing CP-1227 dated March 1, 1965.

  • Requires certificate of compliance to the material specification.

(2) S-W Controls FC 16390, dated April 21, 1986 to Masoneilan (Customer Order 1007-0548-CQ) l

\ \

I l

1 I

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ b

. ~ ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN REr0RT INSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE.11 of 14

  • Item 10: 013431-062 Plug Requires Certificate of Conformance with shipment.

(3) Masoneilan Certificate of Compliance, dated 'une 9, 1986

  • Certifies material inspected and conforms to quantities, sizes, materials, and specifications and is equal to or better than the original part.

References SAM 05617 and CPC P0 1007-0548-CQ. States the latest quality control procedures were followed.

Identifies Item 1, P/N 013431-062 Plug, A 479 TV 316 ST.STL. (Note: Separate memo states A,479 TY 316 is acceptable for A-276-YP316).

k. CPC P0 1007-3572 (1) CPC P0 1007-3572, date unknown.

Items 10-70: Various Masoneilan valve trim (i.e., plug pin, bushing, cage, plug / stem assembly, seat ring and spacer).

(2) S-W Controls P0 17465, dated September 30, 1986 to COR-VAL, Incorporated.

Items 1-7: Same Masoneilan valve trim as above. '

(3) COR-VAL Invoice No. 2231, dated October 29, 1986.

Items 1-7: Pin 971342-024-163, bushing 010110-269-220, cage 040006-413-182, plug 040006-281-215, ste... ul0868-248-583, seat ring 040006-361-587 and spacer 010110-083-152.

1. CPC P0 2000-7306 (1) CPC P0 2000-7306, dated Jurn 15, 1983.

" Items 1, 2, and 4: 16 plugs for Masoneilan valve S/Ns G-83918-1/2/3/4/5/6/7/8/15 and 16. Various P/Ns and M/Ns.

Items 3 and 5: 8 plugs for above Masoneilan valve S/Ns.

Various M/Hs and P/Ns.

__________-______O

l:

' ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN l REPORT. IllSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 12 of 14 (2) S-W Controls P0 10963, dated June 15, 1983 to CVS.

Items 1-5: 4 plugs P/N 013437-055-163, a stems P/fl 010154-111-163, 4 plugs P/N 013438-078-163, 8 plugs P/fl 013436-061-163 and 4 stems P/N 010154-101-163.

m. CPCPO2000-7308-C_q (1) CPC P0 2000-7308-CQ, dated June 17, 1983.
  • Items 1-4: 4 seat rings P/N 010237-001-163, 4 stems P/N 011156-125-163, 5 pins P/N 971342-024-163 and 3 seat rings P/N 010238-044-163. Various S/Ns and M/Ns.

(2) 5-W Controls P0 10964, dated June 15, 1983 to CVS.

  • Items 1-4: Same as above. l (3) S-W Controls Invoice No. 21963, dated August 31, 1983 to  ;

CPC/Palisadec.

Item 1: 010237-001-163, Masoneilan seat ring, quantity - 4.

" Item 2: 011156-125-163, Masoneilan stem, quantity - 4.

  • Item 3: 971342-024-163, Masoneilan pin, quantity - 5.

Item 4: 010238-044-163, Masoneilan seat ring, quantity - 3.

n. CPC P0 1006-1984 (1) CPC P0 1006-2984, dated April 17, 1985.

Item 1: 1 plug, P/N 010136-002-163 for Masoneilan 3 inch ,

valve, model 526, S/N G44938-1. l (2) S-W Controls "O 14375, dated April 23, 1985 to CVS.

Item 10: 1 P/N 010136-002-163 Masoneilan plug for model 526, 3 inch valve.

(3) CVS Invoice No. 11602, dated May 14, 1985 to S-W Controls.

Item 1: 1 each, 010136-002-163 plug.

i

_-_-____-__-.___.-_--.__-2__.___.__.__ -

c..,. j

' 0 ORGANIZATION: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED

[l l

LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN

[.

RE00RT INSPECTION

l. N0. : . 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 13 of 14

)

)

(4) S-W Controls Invoice No. 26576, dated May 20, 1985 to CPC/ Palisades.

Item 1: 1 P/N 010136-002-163 Masoneilan plug for model ,

526, 3 inch valve. l 1

c. CPC P0 1006-6330 (1) CPC P0 1006-6330, dated October 1,1985.  !

Item 1: 1 plug stem, P/N 010167-091-163, reference drawing A8396-D, 2 inch. 150 lb. for control valve M/N 38-10271, S/N G83918-18-1.

(2) S-W Controls P0 15309, dated October 9, 1985 to CVS. I Item 10: 1 P/N 010167-091-163, Masoneilan plug stem. J (3) CVS Invoice No.12498, dated October 28, 1985 to S-W Controls.

Item 1: 1 010167-091-163 stem (plug).

(4) 5-W Controls Invoice No. 28067, dated November 14, 1985 to CPC/ Palisades.

Item 1: 1 P/N 010167-091-163, Masoneilan plug stem.

I

p. CPC P0 1005-1454 (1) CPC P0 1005-1454, dated November 18, 1983.
  • Iteas 1 and 2: 1 plug, P/N 013434-043-163 for Masoneilan valve M/N 38-20571, S/Ns 83918-18/29 and 35, and associated stems.

(2) S-W Controls P0 11818, dated December 8, 1983 to CVS.

' Item 1 and 2: 1 P/N 013134-043-163 Masoneilan plug and 1 P/N 010168-142-153 Masoneilan plug stem.

(3) 7-W Controls Invoice No. 23030, dated February 9,1984 to CPC/ Palisades.

  • Item 1: P/N 013434-013-163, Masoneilan plug.

l

' i.; . * *

-

  • ORGANIZATI0ll: S-W CONTROLS, INCORPORATED LIV 0NIA, MICHIGAN Is
  • REPORT IllSPECTION NO.: 99901340/88-01 RESULTS: PAGE 14 of 14 (4) S-W Controls Invoice No. 23029, dated February 9,1984 to CPC/ Palisades.

Item 1: P/N 010168-142-163 Masoneilan plug stem.

F. PERSONNEL CONTACTED:

W. F. Sample President, S-W Controls Linde Sicard Secretary Lola Horn Bookkeeper h

1 i

i ,

_ - _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ -

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20248E160&oldid=3149323"