ML20213A124
Text
.
(
l
(
JUL 2 51979 Mr. J. LaGrone, Manager San Fmacisco Operations Office U.S. Department of Energy 1333 Broadway-Wells Fargo Building Dakland, California 94612 -
Dear fr. LaGrone:
FY 1979 NUCLEAR REGULATORY RESEARCH ORDER 50. 60-79-235 FOR LAWRENCE LIVElWERE LABORATORY Please authorize Lawrence Livemore Laboratory to execute the pmgram as described in the enclosed NRC Order.
If this meets with your approval. it is requested that acceptance be indicated en the enclosed form and the original be returned to this office and a signed copy to the NRC Controller.
(
Stacerely, orwnd sien d nu T. E. Murley Thomas E. Hurley, Director Division of Reactor Safety Research Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research
Enclosures:
Distribution
- 1. NRC Grder subj 2- Program Brief circ chron cc w/ enclosures: Rtggs:rdg E. McCayley, LLL lR. Cudlin, RSR R. W. Barber, 00E/NSC T. Hoskins, RSR D. D. Mayhew, ODE /ASEY:DE T. Murley, RSR ,
M. Hayes A/D WRSR File RECORD NOTE: Endorsed 12/13/78, Levine/Denton memo.
8702030110 870120 /./(
(
,I PDR FOIA MORROW 85-782 PDR f j ,h orrect > RES:SCMB Rfsl[ MBb RSR /
- r- RSR f, RSR j f b,% ,
Schofield d eh RCudlin SFabic Jo n/ Tong T!ur, ley suanaut .1 o ve, 7/ /79 7/g/79 7////79 7//4 79 7//6/79 7/)ff79 e.............y..w.,. .. .
_ _ _ CDR@ FGam 310A (4@l NR@M O2040
l
(
, . NRC eone 173 u s hucLE An macutaton, Couuission omog n numes A t2-18
( 60-79-235 l
^
8TANDARD ORDER FOR DOE WORK JUL 2 51979 INUEDTO (DOE O'fleel 198UED SY. (NRC Offacel ACCOUNTINo CIT ATION i APPaoPRIAviom svusow l San Francisco Operations Offic e Division of Reactor Safety .31X0200.609 Research esR avessa PERFORMING ORG ANIZ ATION AND LOCATION 60191001 l F8N NUMBE A Lawrence Livermore Laboratory A0118-9 WORK PERIOD THis ORDaR FIN TITLE FINED D ' ESTIMATED Q Pressure Suppression Test and Analysis Fao"- 70-7/15/79 9/30/79 08 LIGATION AVAf LABILITY PROVIDED BY.
A TMis ORDER S 69,0b0
- ^ ' " '* '* '*' "* "^***'** 5,732,000 s'OE'R THU2h"E51'4E'Dedi8"DOv'M A e0S*'AN DNE sR$WOUR o$f5 OF Tk'E s ;
'1& A NVMBE A' CITE D ASOVE C TOTAL ORDERS TO DATE (TOTAL A & si s 5,801,000 0 AMOUNT INCLUDED is C ArauCAs.E TO THE " FIN NUMSER" C8TED IN THl3 ORDER. 8 FINANCIAL FLEXIBILITY.
O FUNDS WiLL NOT BE REPROGRAMMED SETWEEN FINS LINE D CONSTITUTES A LIMITATION ON OsLIGATIONS AUTHOR:2ED
(.
O FUNDS MAY SE REPROGR AvvED NOT TO EXCE ED 110% OF FIN LEVEL UP TO $50K. LINE C CONSTITUTES A LIM 6TATION ON OswiGATIONS AUTHomi2ED STANDARD TERW AND CONDITIONS PROVIDED DOE ARE CONSIDERED PART OF THis ORDER UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED.
ATT ACMM E NTS THE FOLLOWING ATTACHMENTS ARE HEREgy SECURITY.
MADE A PART OF TMi$ ORDER D WORK ON THis ORDER l$ NOT CLAS$lFIED
$ $7ATEMENT OF WORK O WORK ON THis ORDER INv0LVES CLA$$1FIED C ADDITION AL TERMS AND CONDITIONS INF ORM ATION NRC FORM 18715 ATTACHED.
C OTHER
(
l REMARKS:
AMG AU[fiORITY e)/ ,/ ACCEPTING ORG ANIZATION sic ~* Tu n s t y sic = At uat n't
- Division of Reac W Safety ti'LE l Research
"^
NRC rORM m 12 rs
.I
\ 'f
-= - . . - --
i-
~
t FY 1979 PROGRAM BRIEF
( PROGRAM: WRSR TITLE: PRESSURE SUPPRESSION TEST AND ANALYSIS FIN NO: A0118-9 '
CONTRACTOR: LLL SITE: LIVERMORE STATE: CALIFORNIA NRC TECHNICAL MONITOR: R. CUDLIN PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR: E. McCAULE.Y OBJECTIVE: LIAISON FOR FULL SCALE STEAM CONDENSATION TESTS FY 79 OBLIGATION: $131K BUDGET ACTIVITY: 60191001 69 THIS ORDER FY 1979 ADDITIONAL PROGRAM SCOPE TOTAL T200K THE FOLLOWING TASKS ARE TO BE PERFORMED AS A CONTINUATION OF THIS PROGRAM:
THE CONTRACTOR WILL ACT AS THE NRC'S PRINCIPLE LIAIS0N FOR THE FULL SCALE STEAM CONDENSATION TESTS THAT ARE BEING PERFORMED AT THE JAERI TEST FACILITY IN JAPAN. THE CONTRACTOR WILL BE THE DESIGNATED U.S. RECIPIENT OF DATA GENERATED BY THESE TESTS AND WILL:
- 1) GENERATE DATA REPORTS FOR EACH TEST AND DISSEMINATE TO DESIGNATED ORGA PER NRC INSTRUCTION.
[
- 2) PROVIDE TECHNICAL EVALUATION OF THE TEST DATA AND DEVELOP A MORE FUNDAME UNDERSTANDING OF THE STEAM VENTING PHENOMENA. IT WOULD BE DESIRABLE THAT TECHNICAL EVALUATION OF JAERI TEST RESULTS BE PLACED IN CONTEXT OF THE OVERALL TEST DATA BASE. THAT INCLUDES GKSS AND DOMESTIC SOURCES.
- 3) PERFORM OTHER LIAISON ACTIVITIES WITH THE JAERI TEST PROGRAM PER NRC INSTRUCTION.
- 4) DATA REPORTS TO BE PROVIDED FOR EACH TEST. PROGRESS REPORTS TO BE PROV TO NRC TECHNICAL MONITOR ON MONTHLY BASIS.
- 5) THOSE JAERI REPORTS (AND THEIR EVALUATIONS) THAT ARE DESIGNATED PROPRIE SHALL ONLY BE DISSEMINATED TO NRC. THE APPROPRIATE CARE IN HANDLING SUCH REPORTS MUST BE EXERCISED BY THE CONTRACTOR WHILE PROCURING TRANSLATIONS.
l.
t __ .__ .. ___. 2._. _ _ __ _. ._ . . . _ . . . .
l
- 4. ~
- I
- p. p,-
t 'l Distribution
'JULE bN Subj Circ Chron Branch RF SF RF LST CY bec w/o encls: S. Hanauer F.'Schroeder Dr. E. W. McCauley R. P. Denise Nuclear Test Engineering Division W. Butler Lawrence Livermore Laboratory J. Kudrick P.O. Box 808 0. Anderson Livennore California 94550 bec w/encls: L.Rrcudlin
Dear Ed:
Please find enclosed:
- 1) A copy of the program letter that is now being officially pmcessed and which explains the nature of your -liaison work with JAERI on their MARK II containment research. Notice that $69.000 was added by this program letter, making a total of $119.000 for the contined GKSS and JAERI work. ,
- 2) Two JAERI reports and a copy of viewgraphs presented at a recent
(' meeting attended by Dr. Tong. All this material pertains to JAERI's MARK II containment steam venting tests and all is marked proprietary.
Please arrange for translation of the two JAERI reports, making sure that their proprietary status is not jeopardized. Proprietary material must be clearly identified as such and could only be disseminated to NRC.
i
- 3) A copy of NRR's memo mquesting establishment of liaison with JAERI and monitoring of MARK II containment research.
~ '
Sincerely.
Original signed By S.8 M f: Chief Analysis Development Branch Division of Reactor Safety Research
Enclosures:
as stated C
sociagoma-W?
.....WR,S,R@I;@WRS,[((,, M ,,,,,,,,,, T
. ..S.:...F 8.tc .9 naso.a..P ......................... .......................... .....................
. - - . .... .wm.. . . . . . . .-..u.r..a9......... 1..&41. 7 ......
l
. o :
',' FY 1979 PROGRAM BRIEF k PROGRAM: WRSR TITLE: PRESSURE SUPPRESSION TEST AND ANALYSIS FIN NO: A0118-9 CONTRACTOR: LLL SITE: LIVERMORE STATE: CALIFORNIA
' NRC TECHNICAL MONITOR: R. CUDLIN PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR: E. McCAULE.Y OBJECTIVE: LIAIS0N FOR FULL SCALE STEAM CONDENSATION TESTS FY 79 OBLIGATION: $131K BUDGET ACTIVITY: 60191001 69 THIS ORDER TOTAL T20DK FY 1979 ADDITIONAL PROGRAM SCOPE THE FOLLOWING TASKS ARE TO BE PERFORMED AS A CONTINUATION OF THIS PROGRAM:
THE CONTRACTOR WILL ACT AS THE NRC'S PRINCIPLE LIAISON FOR THE FULL SCALE STEAM CONDENSATION TESTS THAT ARE BEING PERFORMED AT THE JAERI TEST FACILITY IN JAPAN. THE CONTRACTOR WILL BE THE DESIGNATED U.S. RECIPIENT OF DATA GENERATED BY THESE TESTS AND WILL:
) 1) GENERATE DATA REPORTS FOR EACH TEST AND DISS'EMINATE TO DESIGNATED O PER NRC INSTRUCTION.
(
- 2) PROVIDE TECHNICAL EVALUATION OF THE TEST DATA AND DEVELOP A MORE FUND UNDERSTANDING OF THE STEAM VENTING PHENOMENA. IT WOULD BE DESIRABLE THAT TECHNICAL EVALUATION OF JAERI TEST RESULTS BE PLACED IN CONTEXT OF THE OVERALL TEST DATA BASE. THAT INCLUDES GKSS AND DOMESTIC SOURCES.
- 3) PERFORM OTHER LIAISON ACTIVITIES WITH THE JAERI TEST PROGRAM PER NRC INSTRUCTION.
- 4) DATA REPORTS TO BE PROVIDED FOR EACH TEST. PROGRESS REPORTS TO BE PR TO NRC TECHNICAL MONITOR ON MONTHLY BASIS.
- 5) THOSE JAERI REPORTS (AND THEIR EVALUATIONS) THAT ARE DESIGNATED PR SHALL ONLY BE DISSEMINATED TO NRC. THE APPROPRIATE CARE IN HANDLING SUCH REPORTS MUST BE EXERCISED BY THE CONTRACTOR WHILE PROCURING TRANSLATIONS.
(
_ _ 4
t
. m
. . O. ..v.m._. ._T:.. .-IC., ,
_ C-
- f. ' vefy.'. .%.*fgne e, . * *w K . .eT 9 **. ,* 34, *% *,&* ^ ** *% G * * * '"= . * ; . **' ' ' d y, ** *. * ~'* ')". 'y L M y em*$eo f .{ag ie;,n W h 86ficf*'**l'
,FROM OATE OF OccuwtNT OATE REClevt0 asO - .
NRR * ' '
.R. P. DENISE 5/30/79 5/30/79 2579 - '
LTR est uO espORT . OTHER
~
.y ... ;, .
- On6G -
' *TO . CC. . OTnam
,; ,r. ,, , , ,
- . .. n y . .. .
,s
,.. TONG - .
ACTE = necessAR, 3 CO Cuma. CE O DAfa A=s-ameO e
- sO ACTION NGCESSAmV COaststes?
gy e'
. CLA55sp POST 0871C1 FILE COOE
, 5 e'
y ;,e ;, .
. . 'w' ,..
. OtsCR r T ON EaA,s 3. twees.sms g attenREO TO DATE RECE*vt0 ev OATE REQUEST FOR RSR PROGRAM TO .
MONITOR MARK II CONTAINMENT TONG 5/31 '* -
- ' -42 '. RESEARCH AT JAERI . . .
...2
, s gesCLD5uR&5 .- , ,
., ,. ...~- .
4 . . . .
' ~
, . _ . , CYr MUDT.eY -
JOHNSON . .
SERKIZ -
u n.'"
FABIC ~. .
BENNETT SPANO , ,
LARKINS - .
- u. .n.v_ r_ e _
FILE u S NUCLE Am REGuLAfomy COnsmisssON FOmu NaC 32ss le.fs>
- -- MAIL CONTROL FORM w
a a r - =-- = - " - 2 hg .' +'f N** * * #
4 i
I
- *~ *
. , a. n.. .v .
.% * *: . , .. c5. s; t . * * ? ' "-@ ='v' * =% ~'"* " W*
- W 'Y'
_ _ _ _ - _ , . _ _ . _ - _ _m ,. m
. b Sp h -- -
2579
. pm m$*g y
,[ ) g UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION wAsmworos, p. c' mosas
( T Aj
' *g(,**og/***
IRAY 3 01979 MEMORANDUM FOR: .S. Tong [AssistantDirectorforWaterReactorSafety Research, RSR FROM:
R. P. Denise, Acting Assistant Director for Reactor Safety, DSS
SUBJECT:
REQUEST FOR RSR PROGRAM TO MONITOR MARK I CONTAINMENT RESEARCH AT JAERI This is to request that a program be established by RSR for monitoring and evaluating the JAERI full scale multivent Mark II steam tests.
Early in 1977 we discussed the need for additional test data applicable to the steam venting phase of a postulated LOCA in a Mark II containment. As a result of this discussion, RSR conducted a survey of the existing data base and plans for related test programs in the near term. RSR also investigated the feasibility of conducting NRC funded full scale Mark II steam tests. It was concluded that NRC funded tests should not be conducted
( in view of the high cost of the facility and equipment for such a test and the near term availability of applicable data from the tests to be conducted at GKSS and JAERI.
Action was taken recently by RSR to set up a monitoring and evaluation program for the GKSS tests. We propose that a similar program be established for the JAERI tests. The need for this program is as follows. The Mark I owners The have recently completed full scale multivent steam tests using the FSTF.
Mark II owners, however, do not intend conducting full scale multivent tests.
The applicants for several Mark II intermediate plants have indicated that they will take credit for multivent load mitigation effects rather than utilize the lead plant bounding load specifi:ations. The associated load specifications for these intermediate plants will be based on Mark II scale tests conducted in the range of 1/10 to 1/2 scale. The GKSS tests will provide some However, qualitative the information dealing with large scale vent interaction effects.
results of these GKSS tests will be of limited use for quantifying multivent interaction effects. The JAERI facility is prototypical of the Mark II plants.
These tests will produce data that would be applicable to the Mark II containments.
Contact:
C. Anderson, CSB
- 492-7711 b
- ~ ~ -
WO]300ff - - - . . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . .,
o
- l 3 0 1979
( L. S. Tong Infomation exchange te date with regard to these tests has been limited. We see a need for improved comunications with JAERI regarding these tests.
Therefore, we request that RSR establish a program to monitor and evaluate the JAERI tests. This would enable us to discuss the facility design, instrumentation and test matrix during early phases of the test. In addition, it would expedite the transmittal of test results at the conclusion of the tests. I
~
R. P. Denise, Acting Assistant Director for Reactor Safety Division of Systems Safety cc: W. Butler J. Kudrick C. Anderson F. Schroeder S. Hanauer
(
l i
. = ..... ._ ... .___ _ _ _ . . . . _ _ . _ _ _ . . . . _ . . . ..
j _. ._. _
_