ML20209G866

Requests That Investigative Inquiry Be Conducted Into Allegations of Intimidation by Util Employee Re Need to Fire QC Inspector for Writing Condition Identification Work Authorizations.Portions Deleted

ML20209G866
Person / Time
Site:	Waterford
Issue date:	10/24/1984
From:	Martin R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
To:	Herr R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV)
Shared Package
ML20209G843	List: ML20209G840 ML20209G853 ML20209G866 ML20209G872 ML20209G880 ML20209G883 ML20209G893 ML20209G907 ML20209G923
References
FOIA-85-123 NUDOCS 8509190719
Download: ML20209G866 (3)

Text

, ,p'"*., tir. sit p 51 A1 5 - '-

.'. Q4-84-049  ;

NUCLE AR Rt GULA10RY COfAMISSION  !

I.4

'.  ?*

.$ ni cioN ev b / 611 RY AN PL AZ A Dhlvl stilit 1000 .

• %, / ARllNG10N.1[h As Mol)

=...*

't.

OCT 2 4 m4 HIM3RANDUM FOR: R. K. Herr, Director '

Of,fice of Investigation's, Regio 6 JV FROM: Robert D. Martin Regional Administrator, Region IV SUBJICT: POSSIBLE IN11MIDATJON (WAltRIORD 3)

/ 5 A ( , ,_ , contacted the Resident Inspector, Trecy A. T11ppo, with goncerns that he has bten intin.i ated by statements made by the Jf&L

[ - . .j,$ ~ ~. '~ ~

lduringameeting,kE"- ~"' l was not

,present a,1 the sneeting, but was ' informed by another individual (unknown) that E ~~ .llallegedly stated he should be fired for identifying problems. The problems 'hsd becen ipentified in CondiJion 1dentificption k'ork Authorizations (CIWAs) written by m f . -

_- =. - who is an Ebasco C inspector, was allebed to h6ve been pVesent in the seeting with .

)

Ei sed o' n the above information, I am requesting 01 to conduct an investigative inquiry into this matter. Region IV will provide technical assistance as necessary.

(

Robert D. Martin Regional Administrator

.: w .n .

r- ~~ M .

,v s f. m.

,e. 4 m i

s

' 57. d.I $

- L M3 . ,.c i E= P. c, 4 Ut - -

p c-

.$ ~

q;k,

?~. 14 ,V*

~

' . ; = __

l

'.  ;.- c .*

.f.k. f .

i_

x, ,

<v. j. , D

,., ,., ' -s S., us

-f&M E ~ .. yl.. % ;,9.

8509190719 850910 PDR FOIA EXtlIBIT (1)

BERNAB E85-123 PDR w

F-s'O ' ' 8, UNIII D 11c.18 &

.

• NUCLL %R REGULATORY COMMISSION h' f ' F' [. t o

Al GION IV I, 4 I' .

• l Sit RY AN PLAI A ORivl . SL' lit 1000

'* ARLING10N.1tRAS M011 t.

OCT 2 419N MEMORANDUM FOR: R. K. Herr, Director i Office of Investigations, Region'3V .

FROM: Robert D. Martin Regional Administrator, Region IV

SUBJECT:

POSSIBL[ ]NTIMIDAT]DN (WAT[RFORD 3)

A contacted the Resident Inspector, Tracy A. F11ppo, with 6ncerns that he has t'een intim{ dated by statements,made by the (P&L l during a meeting. was not resent a themeeting,butwas'informedbyanother(individual (unknown)that

, allegedly stated he _ _ j The

' problems had been/ 1 fentified in Gopdition Identifi(atiisn Work Authoritations (C]WAs) written byl whoisan[pstoQC ]/

inspector, was alle'ged to have be,efi present in the' meeting witg ~ .,,/

P4 sed on the above information,1 am requesting 01 to conduct an investigati.ve inquiry into this matter. Region IV will provide technical assistance as necessary. ,

~

Robert D. Martin Regional Administrator i

• 8 *

...e ***'..er

?

~

. me , , g 6 Ek' g g a .

g .

i i

r 9 ~ic "

i H e-!

L? f=e O en f ' C rl w Le,

.; i!. " h f't:.

i .

t.::

W j.jl

!. D

<. m

. Fo / A - 5 553 d 6/+

Q4-84-049 QUALITY TEAM QUALITY CONCERN g DISPOSIT10h FORM -

FILE i: QI-84-057-1 ,

DATE OF PREPARATION: December 3, 1964 CONCERN (S):

During a Plan of the Day Meeting, a LP&L employee commented that Ebasco needed to transfer / fire QC inspector for writing CIWA's.

FINDINCS(S):

During jat a Plan of the Day Meeting between LP&L and Ebasco Quality and Construction Supervisors, a LP&L construction empl,oyee

~

connen d to an Ebasco supervisor that a QC inspector who wrote f .,

[ hould be transferred to South Texas Project and then terminated. No other P&L supervisors or Ebasco personnel at this meeting expressed any (

cariousness about this comment, C ~~~ ~ , ~ ? ~ ~ 1 took up for the QC inspector and spoke out about the inappropriateness of the suggestion.

CORRECTIVE ACTION (S)

TAKEN:

NONE. No discrimination against the QC inspector occurred. LP&L project

. manager advised that he would call the LP&L construction employee into his office for counseling on the inappropriateness of the connent.

~

t CLOSURE STATEMENT:

This concern has merits, although no discrimination is substantiated.

ocCLOSED** .F r

EXHIBIT (2)

._ . . _ _ .