ML20209E094
| ML20209E094 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 05000000, Clinton |
| Issue date: | 03/11/1985 |
| From: | Siegel B Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20209D360 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-86-274 NUDOCS 8503250270 | |
| Download: ML20209E094 (9) | |
Text
A g
m a
e.
- ~-
t j.a"ac.g fi f.
UNITED STATE.S y
) c ( ',g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
-l WA$HINGTON, D. e,20555
%,,y.
MAR 11125 Docket No.: 50-461 Pennsylvania Power and Light Company (PP&L)
APPLICANT:
FACILITY:
Susquehanna Steam Electric Station (SSES) Units I and 2
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING TO DISCUSS THE SSES FIRE PROTECTION REQUIREMENTS AND COMMITMENTS A Meeting was held on February 26, 1985, in Bethesda Maryland between the NRC staff and representatives of PP&L to discuss the SSES fire protection requirements and commitments. A list of meeting attendees is contaired in.
This neeting was called as a result of a Region I fire protection inspection the week of February 11, 1985, that identified potential violations and deviations from the connitments contained in the licensee's fire protection program, the conditions of the license and from the technical requirements of Section III.G of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50.
Mr. W. Barberich stated that PP&L believed they were in compliance with the NRC's requirements and cited as the basis for this position the information contained in Revision 2 to PP&L Fire Protection Review Report and the staff's SER and Supplements. Enclosure 2 contains copies of the viewgraphs presented by PP&L during the meeting.
A discussion between PP&L and the staff followed during whjch the staff attenpted to derive the basis for PP&L's position that Revision 2 of their fire protection plant satisfies both Appendix A to the fore protection Branch Technical Protection (APCSB 9.5-1) and Section III G J and 0 of Appendix R to 10 CFR 50.
Following the discussion the staff caucused and provided PP&L the following i
_ staff position:
1.
PP&L should not construe our SER and supplements as explicitly or implicitly approving PP&Ls fire protection program as satisfying Appendix R Section III, G J and O.
2.
To the extent PP&L chooses to use the analysis, either in whole or part, that formed the basis for the Appendix A fire protection j
evaluation, PP&L should be cognisant that the staff indicated during its audit that your Appendix A evaluation would not be sufficient to demonstrate compliance with Sections III of G of Appendix R.
l
(
N
~%
$ ghej N l
N 270
. 3.
The staff suggested that to the extent that PP&L needs to go beyond their Appendix A fire protection evaluation to demonstrate compliance with Section III.G. then the scope and completeness of any re-analysis should be in accordance with the guidance presented in the regional fire protection workshop.
It was agreed that PP&L should take several days to consider and evaluate the staff position. PP&L indicated they would inform the staff during the week of March 4, 1985 as to the course fo action they intended to take to resolve this issue.
'- %.i Byron L. Siegel, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 2 Division of Licensing
Enclosures:
As stated cc: See next page t
m 4
j
s 5
Susquehanna Mr. Norman W. Curtis Vice President Engineering and Construction Pennsylvania Power & Light Company 2 North Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Jay Silberg, Esq.
Mr. N. D. Weiss Shaw, Pittman, Potts, & Trowbridge Project Manager 1800 M Street, N. W.
Mail Code 391 Washington, D.C.
20036 General Electric Company 175 Curtner Avenue Edward M. Nagel, Esq.
San Jose, California 95125 General Counsel and Secretary Pennsylvania Power & Light Company Robert W. Alder, Esquire 2 North Ninth Street Office of Attorney General Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 P. O. Box 2357 Harrisbur'g, Pennsylvania 17120 Mr. William E. Barberich Manager-Nuclear Licensing Mr. William Matson Pennsylvania Power & Light Company Alegheny Elec. Cooperative, Inc.
2 North Ninth Street 212 Locust Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 P. O. Box 1266 Harrisburg, PA 17108-1266 Resident Inspector P.O. Box 52 Shickshinny, Pennsylvania 18655 C
Mr. E. B. Poser.
Project Engineer
, Bechtel Power Corporation P. O. Box 3965 San Francisco, California 94119 Mr. Thomas M. Gerusky, Director Bureau of Radiation Protection Resources Commonwealth of Pennsylvania P. O. B0x 2063 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 J
1 e
SSES UNITS 1 & 2 FEBRUARY 26, 1985 FIRE PROTECTION MEETING ATTENDEE'S NAME AFFILIATION Byron Siegel NRC William V. Johnston NRC A. Schwencer NRC T. Novak NRC T. Michaels NRC Jack Strosnider NRC Vicotr Benaroya NRC Leon E. Whitney NRC R. L. Ferguson NRC M P-407db6'rgT NRC g
R. L. Perch NRC S. V. Pullani NRC Dennis Kubicki NRC P. J. Telthorst IPC Bill Le Fave NRC Eric Oesterle Bechtel Power T. M. Crimmins PP&L N. W. Curtis PP&L W. E. Barberich PP&L C. T. Coddington PP&L 1
1 l
j
l PURPOSE OF THIS Pigjg o
DEFINE THE SSES FIRE PROTECTION NEWIREMEIGS AND C0 m !TMENTS O
DEMONSTRATION OF THE SSES DOCIMNTATION AND l
APPROVAL PROCESS e
i e
e 4
i f
e 4
1 e
l 4
f m
9 W
l s
Wr h4
.-.,, - ~,-,-,--.- -
r-------
APPROVAL PROCESS o
BTP APCSB 9.5-1 (APPENDIX A) ISSUED BY NRC (FEB, 77) o SSES FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW REPORT (FPPR) ISSUED (JAN, 78) o NRC PROPOSED RULE 10 CFR 50.f48 AND APP. R PUBLISHED FOR C0rtENT (MAY, 80) o NRC SITE WALKDOWN ON FIRE PROTECTION (OCT/NOV, 80) o NRC ISSUED 10 CFR 50.148 AND APPENDIX R (DEc, 80)
NRC ISSUED I0 AND 281 SERIES QUESTIONS (FIRE PROTECTION) o 4
To SSES (JAN, 81) o PP8L RESPONDED To NRC OUESTIONS (FEB, 81) o PPal/NRC MEETING (VAR, 81)
PP8L COMMITTED TO III.G, J 8 0 (DOCmENTED IN PLA-683) o REVISION 1 To SSES FPRR ISSUED (PAR, 81) c NRC ISSUED NUPEG 0776 (SSES SER).(APR, 81) o NRC ISSUED SUPPL. #1 To SSES SER (JUtt, 81) o NRC ISSUED SUPPL. #2 To SSES SER (SEP, 81) o PPal COMPLETED RENTE SHUTDOWN VODIFICATION (DEC, 81) o PP&L REQUESTED VARIANCE FOR USE OF 1-HOUR WRAP (FEB, 82) o NRC ISSUED SUPPL. #3 To SSES SER (JUL, 82) o UNIT 1 OPERATING LICENSE ISSUED (JUL, 82) o PP&L C&NITTED To NDIFY l-HOUR WRAP (AUG, 82) o PP&L COMPLETED WRAP f0DIFICATION (OCT, 82) o NRC ISSUED SUPFL, #f; To SSES SER (N0v, 82) 0 REVISION 2 To SSES FPRR ISSUED (DEc, 82) o PP&L REQUESTED LICENSE AMEN MENT TO INCORPORATE REV. 2 ToFPRR(JAN,83)
~
o NRC ISSUED SUPPL. #5 To SSES SER (MAR, 83) o ANEN TENT 16 To UNIT 1 LICENSE ISSUED TO INCORPORATE REV. 2 To THE SSES FPRR (SEP, 83)
~
0 NRC ISSUED GENERIC LETTER 83-33 (OCT, 83) o PP&L REQUESTED EXEMPTION FROM APP. R SEPARATION CRITERIA (DEC,83) o NRC ISSUED SUPPL. #6 To SSES SER (f%R, 814) o lhllT 2 OPERATING LICENSE ISSUED (MAR, 8l4) 4
.p.
q
.e
-w
~. "
e.
f DOCUENTATION OF CO MITE NTS o
FSAR SECTION 9.5 40 SERIES QUESTIONS 281 SERIES QUESTIONS 441 SERIES QUESTIONS 1
o FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW REPORT THROUGH REV. 2 4
9 0
LETTER CORRESPONDENCE t
?
4 1
e i
I 9 Ah a v
w yw~~e-n-r--g
<-m-----
9w mm-gw----
,,n,,mp e_,p y
-am,,
p7 p
g..
,,-yyy
---s-~,
m 3+-
<y--
g-r
4 i
REQUIREPENTS AND C0mITENTS
'o GDC 3 0
10 CFR 50.l48 o-BTP APCSB 9.5-1 (APP. A)
O SECTIONS III.G, III.J, AND III.0 0F APPENDIX R To 10 CFR 50
- d o
9 e
O S
, + - -
,_,-.m
.v-,- - - - - --
r -
y___-
.....4 e
,.r v
.----r
-?
r r - er- - * - - -
/
LICENSE CONDITIONS litIT 1: PP8L SHALL MAINTAIN IN EFFECT AND FULLY IMPLEMENT ALL PROVISIONS OF THE APPROVED FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW REPORT, AS AMENDED THROUGH REVISION 2 DATED NOVEMBER, 1982. IN ADDITION, PP&L SHALL MAINTAIN THE FIRE PROTECTION PROGRAM SET FORTH IN APPENDIX R To 10 CFR PART 50.
UNIT 2: PP8L SHALL MAINTAIN IN EFFECT AND FULLY IMPLEMENT ALL PROVISIONS OF THE APPROVED FIRE PROTECTION PROGRAM.
+
l f
l l
~ -.
~-
-, -. -,. -