ML20207F040
| ML20207F040 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Harris  |
| Issue date: | 12/31/1986 |
| From: | Cutter A CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| To: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| GL-84-16, NUDOCS 8701050401 | |
| Download: ML20207F040 (16) | |
Text
~
(
CP&L Carolina Power & Light Company December 31, 1986 Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT DOCKET NO. 50-400/ LICENSE NO. NPF-53 ONSHIFT OPERATING EXPERIENCE
Dear Mr. Denton:
Carolina Power & Light Company (CP&L) hereby submits additional information concerning onshift operating experience at the Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant (SHNPP).
Based on preliminary examination results released on December 30, 1986, Mr. E. Brooks failed to pass the annual written requalification examination administered by CP&L on December 19, 1986. Based on this, Mr.
Brooks has been relieved of his licensed shift duties and placed in accelerated requalification training.
Mr. Brooks had been previously designated as a qualified individual fulfilling the requirenents of onshift operating experience.
In addition to Mr.
Brooks, Mr. D. Batton who was also designated as a qualified individual fulfilling the requirements of onshift operating experience will be unavailable to participate onshift for approximately two to three weeks due to hospitalization for removal of a growth on his thyroid.
In order to maintain a qualified experienced individual on each shift, CP&L hereby l
proposes a revision to the previously submitted plan for onshift j
operating experience.
1 Mr. J. Collins, the SHNPP Manager-Operations, will be designated l
as a qualified experienct.d individual to work on shift.
Mr.
Collins has had six years of previous operating experience as a licensed S20 onshift at the CP&L H. B. Robinson Steam Electric Plant. During that period, Mr. Collins participated in both full power operations and reactor startups and shutdowns.
Mr. Collins presently holds an SRO license at SHNPP, however he has not yet taken an NRC administered simulator examination.
Mr. Collins' operating experience far exceeds all requirements for previous onshift operating experience.
Mr. Collins would only serve as a designated experienced individual onshift for the period of time until other members of the shift could fulfill the requirements of l
onshift operating experience. The requalification reexamination for Mr. Brooks is scheduled f or January 15, 1987. As with any short term absence, Mr. Collins' position as Manager-Operations will be designated to Mr. J. Thompson, the Operating Supervisor.
l There is presently one individual onshift with four and a half 0
months of previous PWR operating experience, Mr. H. Carter.
Mr.
,g Carter served onshift at the H. B. Robinson Plant as licensed RO I
(
(7fl$f64'DW h %
i
Mr. Harold R. Denton Page 2 December 31, 1986 s
s and this experience included both full power operations and a startup and shutdown. With an additional six weeks of operating experience at SHNPP with the plant in an operating condition (greater than 350* F), Mr. Carter will meet the requirements for previous onshift operating experience. This additional six weeks experience will be completed by February 1, 1987.
CP&L scheduled shift manning to satisfy the requirements for having a qualified previously experienced individual onshift is included as Attachment 1 to this letter.
This schedule would be effective for the period of time from exceeding five percent power (approximately January 10, 1987) to February 1, 1987 when Mr.
Carter will fulfill the experience requirements and Mr. Batton and Mr. Brooks are expected to be back on shift. Several possible options are provided. Our preference is to implement Option A-1 for the period 1/5/87 to 2/1/87. Option C would then be implemented commencing 2/1/87. Shift rotational schedule for Option A-1 is provided in Attachment 2.
Resume's for Messrs. Collins and Carter are included as Attachment 3.
A chronology of these recent events is included as Attachment 4.
The proposed staffing plans for onshift operating experience, as outlined above, satisfy the requirements of Generic Letter 84-16.
If you have any questions on this subject or require additional information, please contact me.
Yours very truly, 20 m A. B. Cutter - Vice President Nuclear Engineering and Licensing i
j Attachments i
l cc:
Mr. B. C. Buckley (NRC) l Mr. C. F. Maxwell (NRC-SHNPP)
Dr. J. Nelson Crace (NRC-RII) l
4 4
\\
\\
ATTACHMENT 1
HARRIS NUCLEAR PROJECT SHIFT STAFFING PLAN JANUARY 5 - JANUARY 15, 1987 OPTION A-1 SHIFT FORMAN EXPERIENCE NOTES GARNER GARNER 1.
5 SHIFT ROTATION KYSER KYSER 2.
COLLINS PROVIDES ON MATTHEWS BARilANN SHIFT EXPERIENCE CARTER COLLINS 3.
COLLINS SIMULATOR BRINEY BATTON*
EXAM TO BE DEFERRED TO MARCH 1987
- 4. EXPECTED MEDICAL LEAVE. EXPERIENCE COVERED BY
" EXPERIENCED SR0" FROM 0THER SHIFT.
EXPERIENCED PERSONNEL ON 4 SHIFT (MAX HRS / WEEK ~ 48 HRS)
OPTION A-2 1
SHIFT FOREMAN EXPERIENCE NOTES GARNER GARNER 1.
4 SHIFT ROTATION KYSER KYSER 2.
COLLINS PROVIDES ON MATTHEWS BARMANN SHIFT EXPERIENCE CARTER COLLINS 3.
COLLINS SIMULATOR EXAM TO BE DEFERRED TO MARCH 1987
.-u
.--.s HARRIS NUCLEAR PROJECT SHIFT STAFFING PLAN (CONTINUED) s s
JANUARY 5 - JANUARY 15, 1987 OPTION A-3 SHIFT FOREMAN EXPERIENCE NOTES GARNER GARNER 1.
4 SHIFT ROTATION WITH KYSER KYSER 3 EXPERIENCED SRO MATTHEWS BARMANN 2.
MAX HRS./ WEEK BRINEY (ROTATION)
~ 60 HRS i
4 4
~w---,wnn,-,.,,,,
9 HARRIS NUCLEAR PROJECT SHIFT STAFFING PLAN JANUARY 15 - FEBRUARY 1, 1987 OPTION B-1 SHIFT FOREMAN EXPERIENCE NOTES GARNER GARNER 1.
5 SHIFT ROTATION KYSER KYSER 2.
BROOKS RETURN BY 1/15 CARTER C6LLINS k
MATTHEWS BARMANN BROOKS BROOKS OPTION B-2 (CONilNUEWITHA-1 ORA-2)
I l
t
HARRIS NUCLEAR PROJECT SHIFT STAFFING PLAN FEBRUARY 1, 1987 AND LATER OPTION C SHIFT FOREMAN EXPERIENCE NOTES GARNER GARNER 1.
ANY 5 0F THE ABOVE KYSER KYSER 2.
CARTER WILL HAVE CARTER C4RTER ACHIEVED 6 MONTHS HOT
~
BATTON BATTON EXPERIENCE BROOKS BROOKS 3.
COLLINS NO LONGER ON MATTHEWS BARMANN SHIFT f
f 6
-m
,--,,,.w, w
..,e g
- - - - - -, - r
-rn-,,
w
6 4
\\
\\
ATTACHMENT 2
OPTION A-1 ROTATION SCHEDULE
- s s
January 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Days D
D D
A A
A A
E E
E B
Nights C(B) C(E) C(E) B B
B D
D D
D C(A)
January 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Days B
B B
A A
A C(B) C(B) C(E) C(E) B Nights C(A) C(A) E E
E E
D D
D A
A
- Letter denotes shif t.
Letter in parenthesis () indicate individual providing experience.
Shift Foreman Experienced Individual A Kyser (A) Kyser B Carner (B) Garner C Briney D Carter (D) Collins E Matthews (E) Barmann
/
NOTES:
1.
No experienced SRO will work )60 hours6.944444e-4 days <br />0.0167 hours <br />9.920635e-5 weeks <br />2.283e-5 months <br /> in a work week, nominally about 48 hours5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br />.
/
2.
4 shift rotation for experience ends an4 or 5 shift begins upon return of either Batton or Brooks or experience fullfillment of Carter on 2/1.
3.
Collins will be replaced upon return of any two of Batton, Brooks, or Carter.
4.
The Shift Foreman and his shift always rotate as a unit with an experienced SRO coming in from another shift as required. Required only when shift C on shift.
. ~.
1^
\\
\\
1
[
ATTACHMENT 3 l
l
)
i
~
SUPP FSAR TABLE 13.1.3-29 27 Joseph M. Collins Manager - Operations 27 I. Education and Training B. S. Degree in Business Administration - Coker College A.
II. Experience Octot,er 1967 - Control Operator - Operation and Engineering 27 A.
Production and System Operations Section, Roxboro Plant, Department, Roxboro, North Carolina January 1969 - Control Operator - Generation and System Operations B.
Department, Nuclear Generation Section, Robinson Plant, Hartsville, South Carolina Nuclear C.
April 1971 - Shift Foreman - Bulk Power Supply Department, Generation.Section, Robinson Plant, Hartsville, South Carolina September 1973 - Nuclear Generation Specialist - Bulk Power Supply D.
Nuclear Generation Section, Robinson Plant, Hartsville, Department, South Carolina E.
January 1976 - Senior Nuclear Generation Specialist - Bulk Power Supply Department, Nuclear Generation Section, Robinson Plant, Hartsivile, South Carolina January 1977 - Senior Nuclear Generation Specialist - Bulk Power F.
Supply Department, Generation Services Section, General Office, Raleigh, North Carolina August 1977 - Project Specialist - Simulator, Generation Department, C.
Generation Services Section, General Office, Raleigh, North Carolina May 1979 - Project Specialist - Operator Training, Generation H.
Department, Generation Services, Harris E&E Center Section, New Hill, North Carolina December 1979 - Director Nuclear and Simulator Training - Nuclear I.
Operations Department, Nuclear Training Section, Harris E&E Center, New Hill, North Carolina July 1980 to September 1981 - Vice President - Modification Systems, J.
Inc. - Raleigh, North Carolina September 1981 to April 1983 - Treasurer - Modification Systems K.
Inc. - Columbia, Maryland 13.1.3-44 Amendment No. 27
SIERP FSAR 27
^
TABLE 13.1.3-29 (continued)
Joseph M. Collins Manager - Operations L.
April 1983 - Training Supervisor - Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant, Technical Services Department, Nuclear Training Section, Harris Training Unit, New Hill, North Carolina 27 M.
November 1983 - Employed as Manager Operations in the Harris Nuclear Project Department, New Hill, North Carolina l
13.1.3-45 Amendment No. 27
SITNPP FSAR YABLE 13.1.3-26 l 27 Hamer L. Carter Shift Foreman - Nuclear I. Education and Training A.
Dillon High School, Dillon, South Carolina - 1968 27 B.
Francis Marion College, Florence, South Carolina - 1970 - Completed Three Years in Undergraduate Math II. Experience Prior to Joining CP&L A.
September 1969 to June 1975 - B. C. Moore and Sons, Darlington, South Carolina - Store Manager 27 B.
June 1975 to May 1977 - Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Florence, South Carolina - Salesman May 1977 to November 1978 - Segars Chevrolet and Cadillac Company, C.
Hartsville, South Carolina - Car Salesman III. Experience with CP&L 27 A.
November 1978 - Employed as a Helper (Harris Training Complement) in the Harris Organization, temporarily assigned to the H. B. Robinson Plant, Hartsville, South Carolina July 1979 - Promoted to an Auxiliary Operator B in the Harris B.
Organization, temporarily assigned to the H. B. Robinson Plant, Hartsville, South Carolina January 1981 - Promoted to an Auxiliary Operator A in the Nuclear C.
Operations Department at the Harris Plant located in New Hill, North Carolina (temporarily assigned to the H. B. Robinson Plant, Hartsville, South Carolina D.
August 1982 - Transferred as an Auxiliary Operator A to the Nuclear Operations Department at the Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant located in New Hill, North Carolina E.
September 1982 - Promoted to a control Operator in the Nuclear Operations Department at the Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant located in New Hill, North Carolina 13.1.3-40 Amendment No. 27
SIINPP FSAR TABLE 13.1.3-26 (continued) l27 Hamer L. Carter Shift Foreman - Nuclear September 1983 - Reorganization - Department renamed Harris Nuclear F.
27 Project October 1984 - Promoted to a Senior Control Operator "in training" C.
in the Plant Operacions Unit, Harris Plant Section of the Harris Nuclear Project Department.
August 1985 - Promoted to Shift Foreman - Nuclear in the Plant H.
Operations Unit, Harris Plant Section of the Harris Nuclear Project Department 127 IV. Professional Affiliations and Achievements None it i
I i
l l
l
~
l I
I 13.1.3-41 Amendment No. 27
e A
ATTACHMENT 4
P
- ^
Event Chronology
- December 19, 1986 Mr. E. Brooks takes CP&L administered annual written requalification examination.
December 22-24/29-30, 1986 Gradiag of over 30 exams by training personnel December 30, 1986 9:00 a.m.
" Plant Management informed of preliminary test results on Brooke December 30, 1986 12:00 a.m.
CP&L Management informs NRR of Brooks' preliminary results.
December 30, 1986 1:30 p.m.
NRC Resident Inspector briefed by Plant Management on Brooks' results.
December 30, 1986 5:00 p.m.
Plant Management informed about Batton's medical condition.
December 31, 1986 9:00 a.m.
Plant Management contacts NRC RII on Batton's j
medical condition.
December 31, 1986 10:30 a.m CP&L Management informs NRR of Batton's medical condition.
December 31, 1986,11:30 a.m.
Plant Management informed of final test results on Brooks.
All times are approximate.
L