ML20197D846

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Further Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re NUREG-1055.Forwards App a Documents.Apps a & B Documents Available in Pdr.Availability of Other Documents Listed
ML20197D846
Person / Time
Site: Diablo Canyon  Pacific Gas & Electric icon.png
Issue date: 04/24/1986
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Oneill E
CALIFORNIA, STATE OF
Shared Package
ML20197D852 List:
References
FOIA-84-516, RTR-NUREG-1055 NUDOCS 8605150073
Download: ML20197D846 (5)
v • d • e


Text

_ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _

0 0{l,* $ h

/ jog UNITED STATES

! o NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

$ p WASHf NGTON, D. C. 20555

\...../

APR 2 41986 Mr. Edward W. O'Neill Public Utilities Commission State of California California State Building IN RESPONSE REFER San Francisco, CA 94102 TO F0IA-84-516

Dear Mr. O'Neill:

This is in further response to your letter dated June 19, 1984, in which you requested, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (F0IA), three categories of records related to NUREG-1055. This letter also responds to subsequent letters from your organization dated December 26, 1985, February 10, 1986, and April 2, 1986.

As noted in our letter to you dated November 27, 1985, item 101 on Appendix P, a copy of which is enclosed and which was released in response to F0IA-84-293 (Leighton), is a bibliographic list of material reviewed in conjuction with the Diablo Canyon case study included as part of NUREG-1055. This list was com-piled for the Quality Assurance study team by NRC contractor personnel and consists of records reviewed by the Quality Assurance team in the course of preparing the Diablo Canyon case study. Included on the list are records in the NRC's possession as well as utility records examined by the QA team but not in the NRC's possession.

c In my of a telephone conversation between Mark Fogelman of your staff and David Meyer staff on December 26, 1985, Mr. Fogelman requested that we review the documents included on item 101 of Appendix P and determine, for those records in the possession of the NRC, whether they are publicly available. We have completed this review and have made the following determinations regarding the records included on P/101:

1. Items 1, 2, 3, and 4 are Atomic Energy Commission records which the staff has been unable to locate in any NRC files. The files searched include the NRC Public Document Room (PDR), Central Files (including both the docket file and microfiche of the NRC chronological files), the Document Control System, Region V office files, and the files of the NRC project manager for Diablo Canyon.

2.

, Items 8,10, and 11 are PG&E records of which the NRC does not possess copies.

3. Items 35, 39, and 40, as identified on the enclosed Appendix A, are now available for public inspection and copying at the PDR in folder F01A-84-516 under your name. Copies of these three documents are also enclosed.

4.

Items 5, 6, 7, 9,12-34, 36-38, and 41-47 are already available for public inspection and copying at the PDR. The enclosed Appendix B lists the accession number and/or file location for each of these records.

8605150073 860424 PDR FOIA O'NEILL84-516 PDR

Mr. Edward W. O'Neill In your letter dated February 10, 1986, you requested three additional categories of information which had not been specifically addressed in earlier correspondence. We have conferred with the staff who worked on the quality assurance report and have been informed of the following determinations regardirig the additional information you requested:

1. Interview notes taken during on-site visit to the Diablo Canyon )lant -

The only NRC staff person who participated in the on-site visit to tie Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant as part of the Quality Assurance Review Group study was Dr. Willard D. Altman, who accompanied NRC contractor personnel. ,

Dr. Altman, who is no longer employed with the NRC, has informed us that he did not, maintain copies of any interview notes taken during the Diablo Canyon on-site visit. Dr. Altman also informed us that the NRC did not have in its possession any interview notes which may have been taken by NRC contractor personnel. The NRC, therefore, has no documents subject to this category of your request.

2. Minutes of the third review group meeting of January 10-11, 1984 - The staff has informed us that no minutes of the third review group were created.

This meeting, held to obtain comments from industry and peer review groups on the draft report, was, however, summarized in the group's published report, NUREG-1055, " Improving Quality and the Assurance of Quality in the Design and Construction of Nuclear Power Plants," beginning on page 10-25.

3. The " site-specific field notebook" prepared by the Case Study C Team prior to their field visit to Diablo Canyon. Dr. Altman informed us that the field notebook for each site visit was actually a compilation of several publicly available items regarding the power plant to be visited. Items in the notebook included portions of the PSAR or FSAR, as appropriate, utility organizational charts, plant and site drawings, etc. Dr. Altman, the only NRC employee on the Diablo Canyon visit, said his notebook was discarded shortly after the on-site visit. He also informed us that no other copy of the field notebook was kept by the NRC.

In a telephone conversation between Mr. Meyer and Ms. Maloney of your staff on March 26, 1986, she asked about public comments received. Mr. Meyer described the number and type of public comments received by the NRC on NUREG-1055 and explained that these comments are available for public inspec-tion and copying at the NRC Public Document Room. In response to Ms. Maloney's subsequent request in her letter dated April 2,1986, Mr. Meyer is providing copies of these comments to her under separate cover.

Mr. O'Neill The records released to date under F01A-84-293, and the additional records '

addressed above, comprise all records provided to us by the NRC staff in response to your request. As explained to Mr. Fogleman and Ms. Maloney by.

Mr. Meyer in conversations on December 26 and March 26, respectively, the only remaining records related to NUREG-1055 are ten boxes of drafts the final NUREG report. Neither Mr. Fogelman nor Ms. Maloney expressed an interest in these draf ts. Accordingly, if we do not hear from you by May 9, 1986, we will consider these drafts to be outside the scope of your request and NRC action on F0IA-84-516 to be complete.

Sincerely, W

- Donnie G. Grimsley, Direc or Division of Rules and Records Office of Administration

Enclosures:

As stated r

I i

1 RE: F01A-84-516 APPENDIX A .

DOCUMENTS IN PDR FILE F01A-84-516

1. 09/24/82 Memorandum for Darrell G. Eisenhut, NRR:DL, from T.W. Bishop, Region V,

Subject:

" Summary Status of Region V Diablo Canyon Action Items" (13 pages).

2. 11/09/82 Memorandum for Robert H. Engelken, Region V, from Harold R. Denton, NRR,

Subject:

"Diablo Canyon Design Verification " (1 p)ofage) cript (pages 92-98 with Commission 10/20/82 attached portions Meetingofre-trans-garding potential for programmatic deficiencies in the PG&E design process (7 pages).

3. 11/17/82 Memorandum for Harold R. Denton,' NRR, from Darrell G.

Eisenhut,NRR:DL,

Subject:

"IDVP Potential Conflict of Interest" (3 pages).

e b

3 l

RE: F01A 16 APPENDIX B -

LOCATION OF PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DOCUMENTS INCLUDED ON LIST IDENTIFIED AT F01A-84-293, APPENDIX P, ITEM 101 No. of Item .-

on P/101 Accession No. and/or File Location

5. 8112230598 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
6. 8204260188 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
7. 8210290214 PDR/SECY-82-414
9. PDR Press Release File
12. 8112030289 PDR/AD0CK/50-275Q
13. 8202160053 PDR/A00CK/50-275Q
14. 8203040080 PDR/AD0CK/50-275Q
15. 8112180191 PDR/AD0CK/50-275U
16. 8203160320 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P 17, 8203160320 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
18. 8203170237 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
19. 8207070348 PDR/AD0CK/50-275G
20. 8112100352 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
21. 8504250409 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
22. 8203160309 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
23. 8211150012 PDR/ADOCK/50-275G
24. 3204080444 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
25. 8601020554 PDR/F0IA/LEIGHTON 84-293
26. 8208010014 PDR/F0IA/REYNOLDS83-130
27. 8207070335 PDR/AD0CK/50-275G
28. 8208170161 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
29. 8210130056 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
30. 8202120164 PDR/ADOCK/50-275G
31. 8203090062 PDR/ADOCK/50-275P
32. 8207140401 PDR/AD0CK/50-275G
33. 8207070340 PDR/AD0CK/50-275G
34. 8601020576 PDR/F0IA/LEIGHTON 84-293
36. 8601020576 PDR/FOIA/LEIGHTON 84-29S
37. 8203010366 PDR/ADOCK/50-2750
38. 8211230398 PDR/AD0CK/50-275Q
41. 8210290214 PDR/SECY-82-414
42. 8601020565 PDR/F0IA/LEIGHTON 84-293
43. 8208190388 PDR/ADOCK/50-275P -
44. 8601020502 PDR/F0IA/LEIGHTON 84-293
45. 8212080479 PDR/AD0CK/50-275P
46. 8202040233 PDR/AD0CK/50-275U
47. 8202230495 PDR/ADOCK/50-275P I

- _ -_ _ - _ _ - _ - - - - _ - _ _ - _ _ _ - :-

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20197D846&oldid=3341940"