ML20196A897

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Package of Supplementary Info for Topical Rept 045
ML20196A897
Person / Time
Site: Oyster Creek
Issue date: 02/05/1988
From:
GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP.
To:
References
NUDOCS 8802050198
Download: ML20196A897 (21)
v • d • e


Text

$6fSf /h b ~.W f n:

  • 7 %nsh OYSTER CREEK NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION TOPICAL REPORT 045 SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION 3

A comparison has been performed between M003 & M004 on three transients, namely pressure perturbation, level perturbation, and turbine trip using point kinetics for all transients. Results of the pressure perturbation are shown in Attachment 1, while level perturbation results are 2own in Attachment 2 and the turbine trip in Attachment 3. The transient's description is the same ,

as in TR-045.

=

The results show that for mild transients (pressure and level perturbations) the two versions of the code are identical, while for a severe transient (turbine trip) there is a small deviation that showed in pressure, core flow, level and steam flow during the later stages in the transient. Those deviations have no impact on thermal limits or peak pressure because they take place past those limits.

The cause of the deviation was found to be the non-equilibrium pressurizer option used for the upper downcomer when this option was turned off, identical results were obtained. It is believed that the error corrections on this model caused these deviations.

The turbine trip test with point kinetics shown here in no way indicates its validity for reload application since such option is not used by GPUN and it was done for comparison purposes only.

I i

i l

l l

l 8802050198 0G0205

, PDR ADOCK 05000219 I P PDR j l

k

~

. htg//f lID . 0 ' $

samecrA6%sy AWMWMW ATTACHMENT 1 Pressure Perturbation Test Plots Dome Pressure Rise Power Change Level Change Feedwater Flow 0

g i

o I

8 i

m'$ 8 I

l 1

I i

- J .P.

t -

m 8 o

CD 4 8

E '

(

u,

- .- ev

- w.

w s ' -

8 - l E '

l i vE h

l T

e.,

l o

3, a ..

. I.

.s y g L4J c- ,

c.n i m - , , _J -

CL 8 .Y w t

- i W i d . \  !

G -

-4

' 7, r /s l I

I t t i OE CI O 01- 08 EOOOW*ISd *251e G3ad 3 WOC t._ i a. . .... i CE Of O C1- CC-

. enow

..,k AI

.i.

I I I h '. .

i I

f I

t ..

-3 ~

I l

i I

i 4

a, m l 0

l v.,

agu l~H E i E, w i ,i p. .- m z i I

l a o m w

o _.

a s

c,,J l

u w i

I a-

~

f w

'F 1

w J

- u n - .

u d' P. '

S i

< t i

h  !

I i  !

of s o s- o f?

EOOOW*%* SON 6HD USMOd i f  ! i i

et s o s- 01- r i

. 500W ,

f

.4

t. d 2

i i I E-l 8

t 4

i I

i l

(

- _; p1 -

1 I

i i

l ..

~ ~. -

i m .

O 9 i O / a E

l .

m -

y 8

> i

-H --

n i 5 \ i l

a a: N i i i

o -

9-. .- r l i 1 -

a

- 1 O cc ' ,Si 7 .i e m .a. <1

~

u l i

c.

u, I cc C.

apI w l 4

- i w ,

W

.') I.

i l

a~ i

./ ~] R i

! , 1 i l I l

i l t I  ! I i os sc oo s c- c6

. EOOOW*CNHO INI) 1A7 i  !  !  ! l I cs se ec s e- o s-naow 1

i i i ,I i

l I

i l

1 .

-A

-~3-

, i I

I t

a w ' .

c, l o ,

a 9 l l

c, , _

o 4 :- ._- .

> t j

i 7 4

_c .

E5 l r , w o

m re _r.

l _

l '-

G _

l c

=

c= l m

a_

s. _ o a ._,c=

g I wW u l _

- i c_

i 1

LA I x

Q o my l w i

w i

)

o .

l >- _

o -

I ca h.

l I l 1 .

l I t i

o ot s e. os sc c'i3 l E OO O W * ( WH ' G ~lW ) M C l .-J M.d i , , i l

l o ct s i. os se ao

. nOOW

ATTACHMENT 2 Level Perturbation Test Plots Power Change Level Change Change in Feedwater Flow Dome Pressure Rise Steam Flew

.. f

,  !?

i I I I i l l I i i I

+ 1 y' l t -

l '

I i

1

)

i F "Ei

z: } l C i I W l l

g i _

m z-sa

-W o Vi c_:2 6 I

m i

! O I C i E ~

18 m l

> t O r

A l O

,n a [ .

Q gl - g * .I u .-

l W

- x

c_

~

l O

\ w - -

l >

\

~

~

l w

J u

- . j -

P.

o l l l l 03 O! O O!- 08

. EOOOW*%'3ONdHD W3 nod 1 I f f I CE Of C 01- OZ-

, h00W s

-v

s t

y.- -:, .

5 '

'd ; L' .

M

.. ,. . __ , :3 i i i l i i i

i I I

i t -. 4 i

/

  • ~

g I

l l I l

I I

L _I s. _

E, v.

E '

sG k

e . - H_

O i I i

M 1 O

o i I w E -

'55 -

m

> c r tit a

- i

. _a r ,

't M a .; . .u=

l J C

A o

w a

i en

> E-J i

I W

J '

o- -

p, 1 O I 1 os se oo s a- oF l

1 EOOOW'(8H,Os1 NO1J Md ONHO l 1 l  !  ! l l cs sa cc s c- o*s-

. SCOW 1

I s$

l 1 i

j

e r r u , .i I I r , ,

s 1 I l I I i 8

i I i u i..

I 'l .J I

==, ,

I, I

if, a l

- 1 l 4 l l -

cr r o aao E

l

!, ~ d

. , , i i I

o l eL r a ,I a5~

w c.n c

~2* W SE! 2C g- o -

gc w

e._

u g -

i -

9 w

a u -

d a

8 I I oct os o os- co F EOOOW 'ISd '3GI8 G38d SWOO i  ! i 1 I o01 og o og- 001-

. MCOW 5

._ ,e i i e i

, i

g. I I

I i

i ,

F i . r.

I t

i i I

(

I I

z l "a i

C l C i

@IL - sa eI o i H_.

" l c,

o O w E -

o -

gr c.n

> e c 7 i l

W a.

,@ cc a

m k -

m a

7 a

w w

M a

18 o*ot s't os s'z 09 E O O O W * ( M H., G l W ) Mold WO31G I i t i l o'ot s'L O'S 9'E C'O

, . bOOW k

ATTACHMENT 3 Turbine Trip Without Bypass Plots Power Response Domo Pressure Rise Core Inlet Flow Average Heat Flux Normalized Feedwater Flow Change in Water Level Relief Valve Flow Normalized Steam Flow e

e e

9

-4

MOUUw a so too 1so 200 i i i i i NOR F1 AL ! Z E D PCWER-M0003 50 i t'O 150 200 7_.__, __ . _ _ ,. _ . . , .

I t

i s*

0 *'*

.g~.~. o

  • . t

=

3 T

i g * ,. ~D W ...***#

g Z

' "m

t

,e / . t a

Z

, ,L - ,6 l

' /

/

i w I

i

" Y.'

, ..' ,, _ U*)

I m ' o ef I C m

ri .

I Q

I I

-

  • I i e_ e , ' . , f

" W

{ l j W m I l aC i .e '

it 8

7 l

m I

., _ u Il N i,

'tI

\ $

13 .t -

1 1

1 1

! l

~

2 ,

I il II i

4 l!

'.T) m_ . _6__ _ i {

l 9 )

1 1

1 f

'R

. , -~ - . ..-.

i 10 UU4 O 100 200 300 *00

, i i i ,

00: 1E P PE : :. P ' 'iE - tiOO O 3

  • t i.'o .oo 3co woe 4._ , , . . . .

d I

[' '. ,

t ..

~

i

\ c,

, - O

, t 4 i

'N.  %

I M e ,3 at m. -

? l h

( - ,

,  % ~

,r, 8db ,

W -

fC I i

---4 E. I e

~ ,*m & ~ e E I w m a g-t l

c sJ s N i

\' s.'.

t ,# = ., ,L - .. _ m D l 'T 1 <_A m l l g w s. t -4 ,'.,- = w M m f aC f- , I - l 3e ~n m I .9 .p 8 7J g c N i .t . . .. Iit> - o . e d i m l .1. f t . . .. .. l l l l T e ~. s e M0004 * -0.00 - .50 1.CO 1.50 2.CO , .... 7 _. , , . . AVE. HIPT F LI.tx - M O D O 3 * @ 0C .50 1 00 1.50 2.00

  • ~~~~~~'~ ~ ~ ' -

~~~~--' i b i i i ~l n c3 i \ l .E. ? - r .o _ w D m . er rT9 C -a & ' t >-- _ e g 1 --e i9 I El-I .. i e '. I .9 e e.n - t3 l " i 4 l # 1 i .,'p _ I I e 6 j .' ! . . _ . t . f I r . - - .. _ _ _ _ . .__--_. _ _ -- _ Y e M0004

  • c so too 1so 2co i i , i m

t it? Rll FEED F L. 0 W -MO DO 3

  • 50 100 150 200

{, .___ _ __7.___ . y ._ .-- -. , , I ' I e t I

  • I n C"2 e L. p -

~x C 1 7 I I

  • D l Z 1

LA i O 31 2 . p. . .. I e I i M '. - - F* C n s, N a a I i - t

  • .# I sp 3 F* =

65 c. - i o \ . w ' , . = 1 N l 3 L

  • 4 l

l e . - i > " D . _ _ _ _ .. .t - o -i k i NOUow - -30 -10 10 30 50 , i r i i CHNCE IH WATER LEVEL-MCOO3 ,g C -10 10 30 50 gp 7 I I i I i _.l y ~~ ,* o o ep 1 / ( , _ m r~~ o D 7 vs m C 1 i -e 4 I m s Q ~ ~ m m sc-u. l 8e m i O af . *J g i M i . I i 1 ~,. - p

6. l I

l 4 '8' s I i l I I M0004

  • O 200 wCO SCO 900 REL!EF V AL VES F l. 0 W - M O D O 3 Q 200 +6 00 800 000 g ,

_ .7_ . , 1 O g* - 9 m i I C.O 1 O e* 3 i "E ,7 &- = L. - ._ __ mW !"~ C - - fO ~D i 3 c 9 m u N C 9 i -a - - li - T._g T l l m 6,5 m i C"> @ ' g - + - v n '. - ti - I 1 I I ' . ' '. ._ . . . ( _ .. - -.1- I L MODO 4 -se o so too 250 i i i i r NORM. STEAM FLOW-MODO 3 g.p 0 0 50 300 150 e i i j t") G - r' - R 5 s g \ 5 g~ _ g ./ e 4 L _ v> E,, / o - i W 2 l R eg - (/ . 9 C )) - l  ?-j , - . i l I i I c . I k 1 . . _ . I l l \ l l istew- -'

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20196A897&oldid=2987662"