ML20153B028

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of Operating Reactors Events Meeting 88-25 on 880621.List of Attendees,Discussion of Significant Elements of Events & Summary of Reactor Scrams Encl
ML20153B028
Person / Time
Site: Browns Ferry, Perry, Indian Point, Surry, Waterford, 05000000
Issue date: 06/22/1988
From: Lanning W
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Rossi C
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
OREM-88-025, OREM-88-25, NUDOCS 8807120688
Download: ML20153B028 (14)


Text

_ .

. . g&

MEMORANDUM FOR: Charles E. Rossi, Director Division of Operational Events Assessment Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM: Wayne Lanning, Chief Events Assessment Branch Division of Operational Events Assessment Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

SUBJECT:

THE OPERATING REACTORS EVENTS MEETING June 21, 1988 - HEETING 88 25 On June 21, 1988 an Operating Reactors Events meeting (88-25) was held to brief senior managers from NRR, OSP. AE00, and Regional Office: on events which occurred since our last meeting on June 14, 1988. The list of attendees is included as Enclosure 1, The events discussed and the significant elements of these events are presented in Enclosure 2. Enclosure 3 presents a summary of reactor scrams. One signif.

icant event was identified for input to NRC's performance indicator program.

One event was suggested for long-term followup.

0ric M .tisg;,nc g,

,hm 0 ! .cyyg. y IIayne Lanning, Chief Events Assessment Branch Division of Operational Events Assessment Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/Enclo.:

See Next Page e J

DISTRIBUTION () /

Central File 1/

EAB Reading File , # / F, 0 6.

4 Mg Circulating Copy EAB Staff ,V MLReardon, EAB D0udinot. EAB y gr Pd b LKilgore SECY, PDR (W

C:EAB:liRR  :  :
EAB:HR8 OFC

.....g.9/g.l(...:... .....:............:............:............:............:...........

NAME :HLReardon :WL ~ cy-  :  :

f bkTE bbhh[hbb bbhh,hb8 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY 8807120688 880622 PDR ORG NRRD PMR_- --_ _ _ _ - -_ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

'r i_

^ b'-

n, c'c:

j i

J. Sniezek, l'2G-18 T. Murley, 12G-18 F. Miraglia, 12G-18 J. Forsyth,-INP0 1 E. Jordan, AE0D T. Colburn, 13E-11

E. Beckjord, NL-007 K. Perkins, 13E-19 W. Russell, RI C. Patel, 14H B. Davis, Rlll -H. Berkow, 14H-20

- J. Nelson Grace, Ril R. D. Martin, RIV )

J. B. Martin, RV

- W. Kane, RI

q L. Reyes, R!l .!

E. Greenrnan, Rlli -

J. Callen, Rly D.- Kirsch. RV S. Varga, 14E-4 D. Crutchfield, 13A-2

. B. Boger, 14A-2 1 G. Lainos, 14H-3 1

- G'. Helahan, 13E-4 L. Shao, 8E-2

d. Partlow, 70-24 B. Grirnes , S A-2 F. Congel, 10E-4 E. Weiss, AE00 S. ' Black,12E-4 T. Hartin, 12G-18 J. Stone, 90-4 R. Hernan, 13H-3 H. Bailey, AEOD J. Guttunn, SECY A. Thacani, 7E-4 S. Rubin, AE0D R. Barrett, 10E-2 M. Harper, EWS-263 e
  1. o

'g UNITED STATES

. E c. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION h -k WASHINGTON, D C. 20555

\...../ JA $ i WF MEMORANDUM FOR: Charles E. Rossi, Director Division of Operational Events Assessment Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM: Wayne Lanning, Chief Events Assessment Branch Division of Operational Events Assessment Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

SUBJECT:

THE OPERATING REACTORS EVENTS MEETING June 21, 1988 - MEETING 88-25 On June 21, 1988 an Operating Reactors Events meeting (88-25) was held to brief senior managers from NRR, OSP, AE00, and Regional Offices on events which occurred since our last meeting on June 14, 1988. The list of attendees is included as Enclosure 1.

The events discussed and the significant elements of these events are presented in Enclosure 2. Enclosure 3 presents a summary of reactor scrams. One signif-icant event was identified for input to NRC's performance indicator program.

One event was suggested fer long-term followup.

/ ,

/

ay Lanning, Chi' Eve ts Assessment B ahch Division cf Operat' nal Events Assessment Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/Enclo.:

See Next Page

1,3 ENCLOSURE 1 7

LIST OF ATTENDEES OPERATING REACTORS EVENTS BRIEFING (88-25)

June 21. 1988 NAME ORGANIZATION NAME ORGANIZATION R. Schc11 NRR/DOEA D.M. Verrelli Ril J.E. Dyer NRR/DRIS- T.O. Martin OED0 B.A. Boger NRR/ADRI P. Baranowsky NRR/00EA D.C. Fischer NRR/00EA W. Lanning NRR/00EA J. Roe NRR/DLPQ T.M. kovak AEOD/DSP C.E. Rossi NRR/DOEA D. Crutchfield- NRR/DRSP J.A. Zwolinski hRR/DLPQ J. Shiezek NRR L.L. Kintner NRR/DRP1-2 R.C. Wilson hRR/DRIS J.R. Levine NRR/DRPB I. Speckler NRR/DRPB l G. Gears OSP K. Perkins NRR/DRSP T.-Silko AE00 G. Lainas NRR/DRP M.L. Reardon NRR/00EA l

ENCLOSURE 2 OPERATING REACTORS EVENTS BRIEFING 88-25 EVENTS ASSESSMENT BRANCH LOCATION: 12-B-11 WHIIE FLINT TUESDAY, JUNE 23, 1988, 11:00 A.M.

SURRY UN'TS 1 & 2 CONTAINMENT SUMP DEBRIS AND DISCREPANCIES PERRY 1 HIGH NEUTRON FLUX TRIP i GENERIC ISSUE PREPARATION FOR DRAUGHT-RELATED SITUATIONS l

l l

88-25 SURRY UNITS 1 AND 2 CONTAINMENT SUMP DEDRIS AND DISCREPANCIES JUNE 16, 1988 PROBLEM LOOSE PARTS WERE FOUND WITH SUMP SCREENS ARRANCEMENT DISCREPANCIES IN THE UNIT 1/ UNIT 2 CONTAINMENT SUMPS.

CAUSE PROBABLE CAUSE DUE TO INADEGUATE (LACK 0F) SURVEILLANCE PROCEDURES AND PCOR NAINTENANCE PRACTICES FOR TYPE-C TESTING ON VALVES, SAFE _T1 SIGNIFICANCE ELOW BLOCKAGE DUE TO DEBRIS IN THE LPSI SUCTION PIPING COULD CAUSE AN UNANALYZED ACCIDENT CONDITICN.

DISCUSSION o THE CONTAINMENT SUMP SERVES THE INSIDE AND OUTSIDE RECIRC, SPRAY AND LOW PRESSURE S1 (RECIRC, MODE).

o JUNE 7, 1988, DURING INITIAL FLOW TESTING 0F THE "A" UNIT 1 INSIDE RECIRCULATION SPRAY PUMPS, DEBRIS WAS FOUND CLOGGING THE OUTLET l TEMPORARY STRAINERS OF THE "A" RECIRCULATION PUMP, '

i c FLOW TEST WAS BEING PERFORMED FOR THE FIRST TIME AT THE REGION'S REQUEST.

o UPON RESUMING THE FLOW TEST, THE STRAINERS CLOGGED AGAIN - LICENSEE THEN DECIDED TO PERFORM A FIBER OPTIC EXAMINATION FOR UNITS 1 AND 2.

c DISCREPANCIES IN SCREENS ARRANGEMENT WERE NOTED AND DEERIS WAS l

REMOVED FROM THE SUCTION PIPING OF THE LPSI AND SPRAY PUMPS.

o 41 PIECES OF DEBRIS WERE REMOVED FROM SUMP /LPSI SUCTION PIPING /

CONTAINMENT SPRAY PUMPS, o 2 OUT OF 41 PIECES COULD HAVE BEEN LUDGED IN THE LOW PRESSURE S1 PIPING VENTURI (1 1/2" DIA.),

o THE TWO PIECES (lF LODGED) COULD SIGNIFICANTLY DEGRADE FLOW IN THE LPSI TO PLACE THE PLANT IN AN UNANALYZED CONDITION, o THE LICENSEE BELIEVES THAT PROCEDURAL DEFICIENCIES FOR TYPE-C TESTING ON VALVES (WHICH REQUIRED REMOVAL OF THE SUMP SCREENS) IN THE SUMP WAS PARTLY THE CAUSE OF DEBRIS IN THE SUMP.

l CONTACT: J. THOMPSON, NRR

REFERENCE:

50.72 # 12571

SURRY UtilTS 1 AND 2 .

o 0F THE 7 $UB-ATMOSPHERIC CONTAINMENTS, CNLY SURRY DOES NOT HAVE T/S ON SUMP SURVEILLANCE.

FOLLOWUP o THE LICENSEE WILL INCORPORATE INTO THEIR PROCEDURES SUMP SURVEILLANCE REQUIREMENTS SIMILAR TO WESTINGHOUSE STANDARD 12ED T/S, o NORTH ANNA WILL BE INSPECTED AT THE NEXT PLANNED OUTAGE (11/88 AND SPRING OF '89) l l

l l

I l

l 1

C

- _ R I

C ES B RP E M A DU I P S

T

- _ U O

2

/ D 1

N

_ 2 A

, )

n 'v l

\ 9 1

O n

y /

1 1

S T

I

. N D g g U n v \

i F Y R

n

< cb R Y _

U S_

A C R R P

S N ,

r(B I

C E

R E

O n' 3

'v 1 D

I a v S I

C g T N A

L U

D n

n C c(

g v

v !

<(4 I

C _

R I

C C.S R

E RE I

R CL EO RO C

W_-

5y3S

. 1

IE iI' 3; e ss93:eesii sbeD w. M if . . . . .t .K ,, ,-J ' E R t . - : : :

EWR 88-247 ATTACHMtWT I ITEMS FOUND WITRIN LOW BEAD SAFETT INJECTION PUNP AND RECIRCULATION $ PRAY PUMP FINE M28W SCREEN AND SUCTION PIPING LHSI SUMP _AND_ SUCTION PIPING __2-SI-P-1A,B (Connon Suction) 1 - Svagelok fitting 2"L x 1/2" Dia, SS 2 - Washer 1" Dia x 1/3" Wide, CS 3 - Hoes claap lb" Dia.

4 - Tia wrap $"L i

5 - Chain link fence T 2h" x 2" x 1/4" Dia,

! 6 - Electrical wire 3"L x 1/8" D$n.

7 - Nut 1/2" OD x 1/8" Thick, CS 8 - Plastic hose 3/4" Dia, x 2t 9 - Wood piece d 2" 10 - Degraded red tape 7 6" 11 - Wire I" Long folded 4 tip s l 12 - Bolt 1 3/4" Long x 1/4" Dia, 13 - Nut 1/2" OD x 3/8" Thick 14 - Wood piece 3 1/2"L x 1/2"W 7. 3/8" Thick 15 - Metal piece 1 3/4"L x 1"W x 1/4" Thick 16 - Rubber hose 1/2" CD x 3/4" Long 17 - Bolt 3/8" x 1h" Long, CS 18 - Wood, block 3" Long x 1/2" Wide x 1/4" Thick 19 - Metal piece Triangular shaped 1" x 1" x 1 1/2" x 1/4" Thick 20 - Nut 3/8", CS 21 - Wira 1/16" Dia., 18" Long (folded up to 6" Length) 22 - Wire 1/16" Dia,, 2" Long -

l 23 - Rubber chunk 1/4" Thick. Dina sisc 24 - Wood chunk 1" Long, 1/4" Squara 25 - Wire pieca 1/16" Dia. 2" Long l 26 - Plastic tie wraps 27 - Natal pin 1/4" Dia. round. 1" Long, SS, one end jagged 28 - Metal pin 1/4" Dia. round, 1/2" Long, SS. one end jagged l Notes (27) and (28) do not fit together l 29 - Metal chunk 1/16" Thick, Diae size, 55 jagged 30 - Metal chunk 1/8" Thick, jagged edges

- Many small bits of paper, cruably much and mira. All material clumped l together ved1d as about the atsa os a softball.

IN8IDE RS PUNP, 2-31 31 - Wut Dit:. x 1/2" Thich 32 - Metal pin Dir. 1" !.c.t1 33 - Metal piece pire 1/8" Thick l 34 - Rubber o-ring ,-

x 1" ID 151PS025-6

:  :- -  :  :  :: ;. :: _. :. 7,._ __. . _ _ ,,

e asp?iessit sve n sc:ee:tv e . . : , , , , i . , ', , - ,

INSIDE RS PUMP, 2-RS-P-15 35 - Metal chunks 2" Long 3/4" Wide (9 pieces) largest 36 - Curved metal piece 1/4" Thick, SS, has worn pattorn 37 - Hose clamp for 1" hose 38 - Wire 1/16" x 6" Long 39 - Wire 1/16" x 1" Long 40 - Washers 1 3/4" OD. CS

_0UTSIDE R$ PLHP, 2-RS-P-2A,B 41 - Screw 1/4" Dia. x 2" Long i

t I

i 15178025-7

, "j ,,

h ,_ ,

88-25 P_ERRY UNIT 1 HIGH IE]). TRON FLUX TRIP

-< JUNE 16, 1988 PROBLEM REPLACENEtiT OF AN. AUTO FLUX CONTROL' CARD CAUSED FLOW CONTROL VALVES TO RAMP OPEN, CAUSE CONTROL SYSTEll DID NOT PERFORM AS INTENDED OR EXPECTED; TRANSIENT WAS UNEXPECTED, ELECTRIC NOISE IN GROUND CIRCUIT, SIGNIF LC ANCE THE NEUTRON FLUX CONTROLLER HAD AN ADVERSE EFFECT ON REACTOR RECIRCULATION FLOW EVEN WITH REACTOR FLUX CONTROL IN MANUAL, DISCUSSICN o REACTOR WAS OPERATING AT 100% POWER, t

o FLUX CONTROL CARD WAS LEING REPLACEDs TROUBLESHOOTING SYSTEM,

o REACTOR TRIP OCCURRED AFTER RECIRCULATION FLOW INCREASED, l 0 MAXIMUM FLUX WAS 125%s FLUX TRIP SETPOINT !S 118%

o REACTOR RESPONSE WAS WITHIN THAT OF THE USAR ANALYSIS FOR FAILURE OF MASTER CONTROLLER OR FLUX CONTROLLER, i c FOXBORC DETERhlNED THAT REPLACEMENT W!Tl' FLUX CONTROL CARD W!Til CONTROLLER IN MANUAL COULD CAUSE TRANSIENT, l

' COMMON TO BWR Gs, o

o LICENSEE PLANS TO OPERATE IN NANUAL FLUX MODE AFTER STARTUP, E0LL0hilE o FOXBORO IS CONSIDERING A PART 21 o EAB IS PLANNING TO ISSUE AN INFORMATION NOTICE, CONTACT: J. CARTER

REFERENCE:

50,71 # 15270 AND MORNING HEP 0f,T 06/17/00

f:

ENCLOSURE 3 REACTOR SCRAR SUMARY.

NEEK ENDIN6 06/19/88 c

l I. PLANT SPEC 1 Fit DATA

$1TE UNIT POWER Sl6NAL CAUSE COMPLI- YTD YTD YTD DATI CAi!CNS ABOYE DELOW TOTAL

' 151 151 i.

3- 17 A EQUIPMENT N3 2 l' 3 r- 06/14/68WATERFCRD 3 3 6 06/16/63 PERM 1 '100 A EQUIPMENT NO 1 2 06/17/89 ICIAN POINT 2 100 A PERSOMEL NO 1 e

e

. . t PageNo. 1 (4/20/E PDIFDNQ IE! CAT 5lS $!>1FICANT EMS

.i GLET IWE EST EST M30!!5T13 GTR$16NIFICAE M'E c PDIM ! 06/16/5 RDUCD0ff 7 A RUI C0hTO. CARD CMiG RW C3mEL 2 MIPECTD PLMT IESPME TO A ET M'KS TO R#F 50. REACT 3 TRIPPG W HI9i FLUI. 7 CDCIT!3Ei l

l s

l 6

I i

1 b

f L

~ ,- ~, + , , , _-.n-, -c.,, , ,- -.--.... - ----e, ,--_,wn, , ,,-- , , - = - - - , ---, - - .s--- - - +--

v - n 7

i 0

I e e

.. A W .~

M ~. W t i ;i m g 6

r b5 O "$

24 5

=

b E

a

?

r U

4, J

DD W8e g.

~

e8 tt :s ~

s M31 s

3 G'u I W F a

[

w

$ - - e .

S a I

1 n Mu)

- =_

l 0 4 53M l

7. p .

l t

N g d Mm3"gs 2  :" M a 4 Gu 1

l E-swjf a _- -

l 3 W 85 "

L .-

as u.l._ga.

g =

- cIiW cs 5 -

Se b 44 a

E @

l l 3 a l

.s b .-.e

. . 3 2 '.*. 5= p p% 4

. , .e w

e. em A