ML20137P795

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comments on Sser 6 (NUREG-0798) Re Differences in Fact Between Ser,Fsar,Tech Specs & Correspondence.Maint Engineer Now Repts to Newly Created Position of Superintendent
ML20137P795
Person / Time
Site: Fermi 
Issue date: 11/27/1985
From: Jens W
DETROIT EDISON CO.
To: Youngblood B
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RTR-NUREG-0798, RTR-NUREG-798 VP-85-0199, VP-85-199, NUDOCS 8512050105
Download: ML20137P795 (7)


Text

c::

?

v$e9* 1$?'.

5

'^

s us-on-n Detroit ORr Edison EEBm W Operations November 27, 1985 VP-85-0199 Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Attention:

Mr. B. J. Youngblood, Chief Licensing Branch No. 1 Division of Licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555

Dear Mr. Youngblood:

Reference:

Fermi 2 NRC Docket No. 50-341 NRC License No. NPF-43

Subject:

Comments on SSER 6 Detroit Edison recently completed a review of Supplement 6 to the Fermi 2 Safety Evaluation Report - FUREG 0798 (SSER 6).

The review was conducted to identify differences in fact between SSER 6 and the Fermi 2 Final Safety Analysis Report, Technical Specifications and correspondence.

The comments provided complement previous comments on the SER and its Supplements 1 through 5.

Please direct any questions to Mr. R. L. Woolley at (313) 586-4211.

Sincerely, o

Attachments cc:

Mr. P. M. Byron Mr. M. David Lynch 8512050105 851127

/

R

{DR ADOCK 05000341

,0{

0 PDR I

L i \\

=

3 SSER 6 Section:

Appendix =R, Item IV.C SSER 6 Page: R-9 Current SSER 6 Discussion "The licensee has agreed to add the lube oil system and the combustion air intake system and make other minor clarifications to the list of items subject to the operational QA program".

Detroit Edison Comnents The referenced statement pertains to proposed diesel generator modifications and, as such, is not relevant to the discussion of the Independent Design Verification Program in Appendix R.

SSER 6 Section:. Appendix S, Item F SSER 6 Page: S-5 Current SSER 6 Discussion "The Onsite Organization is being changed by elevating the position of the Plant Superintendent to an Assistant Manager plus combining under his/her authority, functions which deal with plant modifications and Outage Management.

This latter item increases the responsibility of the previous Maintenance Engineer and'thus elevates his/her position to a Superintendent level".

Detroit Edison Comments In-lieu of elevating the Maintenance Engineer position to a Superintendent level as indicated above, Detroit Edison created a Superintendent position to which the Maintenance Engineer now reports.

--9 g

.ey-e..

e

.ww-p.

4

-w

SSER 6 Section:

Appendix R, Item IV.C SSER 6 Page: R-9 Current SSER 6 Discussion "CYGNA has agreed to provide a clarification of its overall conclusions related to the acceptabiJity of those

' observations identified as potential ilndings CYGNA also has agreed to update its root.cause classification list by categorizing-the root cause of the design control observations".

Detroit Edison Comments

- By copy of a letter from CYGNA Energy Services to the NRC, dated May 17, 1985 (No. 83021.060), Detroit Edison believes the requested information has been provided to the NRC.

If additional information is required, notify CYGNA of what is needed.

I 4

t s

-n,.

e

--o.

i.

m.c

~.-+v

--4,

-., - - - -...---+

-v w

.--...,_,~w-w v--.

w w-

SSER 6 Section:

22.2 SSER 6 Page:

22-5

- Current SSER 6 Discussion "The Licensee's position is that the Fermi-2 leakage

-reduction program tests gaseous-systems by measuring,-to within.two standard cubic centimeters per minute (SCCM)..... "

Detroit Edison Comments This-statement should be revised to read within " twenty standard cubic centimeters" instead of'"two".

This was a typographical errcr in the June 3, 1985 submittal.

F

~

F

'-my-

-w-----r

(-g

,w yr y

wg7 w

g-m,-i,-

,w wwy-w-w-y-y y

v

  • -w-e-pwt-

ww


,~

w-

r :.

~

SSER 6 Section:: ' Appendix A SSER 6 Page:

A-1 ff

' Detroit' Edison Comments The following letters should be included in the chronology.

Date Letter No.

Subiect 04/02/85-NE-85-0466 Additional Information Relative to Inservice Testing Program 04/22/85 NE-85-0463 Testing of Control Center Emergency Filtration System 05/07/85 NE-85-0707 Resubmittal of Fermi 2 Vacuum Breaker Report 05/07/85 NE-85-0706 Schedule for License Condition 2.C(7) 05/16/85 NE-85-0708 Post-Accident Sampling and Analysis of Plant Effluents (Radiodines and Particulates) 05/17/85 CYGNA,83021.060 NRC Review. Questions and Conments Independent Design Verification Program 05/21/85 NE-85-0705 Edison Schedule for Resporise to Items in Supplement 1 to NUREG-0737 06/03/85 NE-85-0391 Additional Information Regarding Fermi 2 Leakage Reduction Program 06/03/85 NE-85-0711 Comments on SSER 5 06/06/85 NE-85-0710 Technical Specification Change Pequest 06/10/85 VP-85-0132 Detroit Edison Response Inspection Report 50-341/85009 i

[

06/12/85 NE-85-0722 Fermi 2 Process Control Program 1

1

.~.

06/14/85 NE-85-0143 Emergsncy Preparedness Exorcism for Fermi 2

,. 06/18/85

.NE-85-0142 Additional Clarification Concerning Fire. Doors and Fire Detectors 06/18/85 VP-85-0144 Medical Arrangements for Contaminated Injured Individuals 06/21/85 NE-85-0896-Additional Technical Specification Changes 06/24/85 NE-85-0900 Additional Information Concerning Electrical Separation 06/26/85 NE-85-0904 Evacuation and Localized Flood Conditions 06/27/85 NE-80-0399 Additional Technical Specification Change 06/27/85-NE-85-0906 Nuclear Liability Insurance Secondary Financial Protection 06/28/85 VP-85-0140 Primary Containment Coatings Transmittal of Final Report No.

DECO-12-2191, Revision 4,

" Evaluation of

~

Containment Coatings" 06/28/85 NE-85-0907 Representative Sample No. 11 of the Electrical Separation Review

. _ _. _ _.. _ _