ML20137N514
| ML20137N514 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Beaver Valley |
| Issue date: | 12/02/1985 |
| From: | DUQUESNE LIGHT CO. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20137N440 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8512040132 | |
| Download: ML20137N514 (444) | |
Text
su m ymw m w:y :w w=m w em> mwL w' . ,
- ' = ^
nwxxx mW N ,. M.i .
W "n%wW-
~
- E o z , ,
1m IL<'a, A c.
a w- m' y, - > "*
w mA spv.m .gy' ,* ., n R y. m -Tus ;(^
j *3, L O K B:da.pj C4-' ' 'e Q. ,. ,
' m< - ~!. R > %a 4 s
2, R .,%yWf. , DNT #,_-C.RMRDDM; DESIGNR'EVIEWs "
u w w w g :m W g yxw m,
><.3 4 w ,
4 7 T [ ,T $ r Nj %
m , . s
+
.g "j
^
>;-h' lN
~
@$s
, LW, , i ,
.h$w{^ Y Q h__; "3 Mc:4
'?-f i
.(& ' ' ' _
~
- M u.O 4 vg m?$M : ; '
y 4 1 T ir , . .. .. H p h M F_ >gMW' uiTiahs'g.'Ehyineering1 Discrepan
' 4
' ~ - .
JL ( y,,'
> - ?, r ' --a :s,' x
[S : , . . - N' <
"4.N' b g 3 " <'
N%-' fe. M'M
~
g % ?; ;' , , %. .^ ~ , , -
- , s,
,,WM k,,
M ' a :: >( Dl '.&# RUi* l . X'h* ' V l, l [ b %g &in'"*. ."-
-2 e A"'b & [ y,'C'..~; . , ,
x
~ ~ ' :, h&'",
li -',
,c i qq ? '
+Q* .. -
^
- 7. 7; p W*f<.bCM - y;-
'- , V'Olu; . . .me431
%. c::M - y, w;q;p&m.-
'.r k,. ^-
h' .: s ,1 n-c
-.u a -'
rm% . ~,. r., ,
o , v..
"n" .g. .Wq y,%., .
- 9t ;m _ - ~ e m A
n@ws.~
m qM >gQg y ., m.m 3)9, ' tm M b,M , 3 4
zw . g4
~
Ir . )[_ -? - ^
tv * (
!%W (3 h
~
,4 e$,v , ,
_ ^ &e..;,(m u M. n
, . _ gE m n ,.;,. __3 ce,. :J'm a -
+ ~
. )m% - .
- - -4w a r : :h+. 7- . ,'
$ $ l $wsh e ; W l~$ (Y
?
&e
- bg
,e >
. m*,
l:i;'.n m.:u sr .p.
.ex y a. o s -
, y: C ._ . ,.
j 'h l_n-,
Q'. ' ',p b y,;
- f
- fy's_~, k,? ,
?.*
s; h - ~~ q m -
pf o:
< - , w: ,
Z p - 7he >
, M.
.e - y. .
y, -:' e 3 , . n . .A lM - .
i^ ' 5 '
i \> W..y A*an : m ,. j,9 e
Y25 m . ;lm&f ? Nh ,_
,f - 1,:
- i~
s
,1. N3 _ ~s< > ., _-g %< .
n ..
a 19 * $ ,
i& % Q Q f fw...s , , A / s ly.X 3c 1
_; w w \
e
- w k**
. m ., j, f Va& -
s 1:,
v cw#?+a.
{l
-+ M:" M_' ' _- {.$Q 9' { +[' h .' {%
'c.
y Q'l: i,
_y;; ,i
- g a -
N ,.m 5
$ f4 7e,. Qm
- % -
- %+
.l. 2 . [MN AM= p+y y ' m>' '
- f y -AJs a - ~
m w ra ,
~
-* syyn,~anm*
~ . wa av -~; -
mgg&,
, "s . hym. +:
>'.w;;g
- s'_';p 3._.-
rn c
t ,
, ry '
- . ;A.s; -:M 42 .3. r f a. ?
,x , .
- m. , ~
a w~%
M..,- S.,M b a.
s-L u^
+ .'
~
~
~
.a ,-
/
y
- >w f
..m -m
- r n w+
- w. ~
- ./ ,
,* :.1? *
. r 0,
- * $. ,6 sw .,- .
so w
mgy
,,~,., ;> u < ~ :] + + -n
- m. . . . . . , > ;M r
e,- ,p.
m ,~ gm4.c: .- 4 v e. u .
s ~ ; - r .. wp rw -s- , m' .>=-m.
M&l% u~ .;cmt . ,
- L. L^
mt.
pqpy:p; < - -
h t
. -3. i. g, e::
i h
'%q ;;g" AM3h g ; _(- '
s -
,' y
- n ,.
o a ,
- ~.~m .
uws s-Wff:} . ,
O N"- C p,
+ m, % .a- 9 %s,p.y_ : 3 - y-n 7 .
. %;-_ %3 - , n y . : .. , , 2 s
.]. :
y_.e
, j y 1;.:,
r
, ~-
%. y . Mw w - - +
p 3, C;j fmW: e.h,mpl;,
- a -. c a % %.
- .- ~_ . y , :
n' u ,. - .. ~ . - .
.#.- .^ g^ .- . . . . - - -. -- __.
,@3Y # 7 .m, b i
.Y.'{[' '/N.' C '
x -
-7 7 , 9.4,'T' 4 D;' cee. Q.-n. g. p. . m m w
.w. c
..-"Q'm;z .,- .,n
,gs.*.m_x s
n v.:. g u,:fM . .- y n, - mg. ,
>:,, ,z .wav
,f f'y -
g
- a. - ~ r...g_.
J,3,. c k?- x _'
< e. . , . .s v _ f $_ 4 Y'f._@i ,
- J.; 2
/. l * . % c.2 ?f '- .~ . , -
w{ + ^ -e o, -. w ly gn s s.;w(
(Lso ga - f, ll_ &, c _.c,,,w
, ,p ng'-
- y 4.o g $_
u,a. ; W c- % .cp; e , .s -
o e
- - . . ,y4 .- - . .
[ N 1 DJ - ?'M ^ '
f;7 .m y --
.s n %wR w 8512040132 851202 x ..
h E'
- 9 l
1 h m . .m;. PDR ADOCK 05000412 nmmw F pop w>
gy..2 ' -
e i 37 ,i y ". G.h .Lt. , ,
.- : 2 n.1
,-$ JP 3.' c t
m.n~ '%'[
{
' =. b h .
,e<_ _- J l-1' "
1 r ..da s / 7 sa
, b"'i
'tm-f 'f ,', -. s T s
Y.
f., a . . 4 S
C ., . .. ..m . m m ; e ,., , s _. . . a A _, m ; .. - . -
i BEAVER VALLEY PdWER STATION UNIT - 2 CONTROL ROOM .
DESIGN REVIEW M
Volume 3 .
VOLUME 3 L
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCIES C -- Resolution complete or in progress E -- Equipment change required L -- Label change required ,
P -- Procedure change required No change required l
1
C RESOLUTION COMPLETE OR IN PROGRESS i
l 9
- - - - ~ _ _ _ . ~ . - . - _ _ _ _ _ _ , , . , _ . _ _ _ _ . _ . _ . . _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
~
HUMANENGINEER$IeGOZSCPEPANCY'(NED)'REDORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: ,
N;=CandbEr c) HED NO.: ON ~ I29 Ib d) REVIEWED BY:
- y e) DATE: /f!
(Westingw6use) / /
CR Nos. So o %2,71 j 3 (Essex) N kerangeme.n r o conhrb k5 O r- t'sp(GAfs f) HED TITLE: u OId (D i M Ef A q
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g Q h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: g,g,g Csmpen6 are_ n ob arr an 9L-,n a ( p , t , % --4c,. rt. 6 oc- he 40 bo44eh m-c .
Tacg we nc4 m 40 coinci & w/ ce=ra6s <xpeckak .ns.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: )
N&.Gd&ki@t% CC COnW W CkOG5 (R~L )
j) SPECIFICHUM5NERRORS(s)OREQUIPMENTDESIGNPROBLEM:
Wam r q, m a, h incorrec.b oc UqM, l
l u
k) REV8EW AND RECOMMENDATlONS: 6
-for eninevidual ecomundaken .
i 4.WQ 6 og kak mko cowstba w CovtstsgsNW 4owk<gh b sk1.
U %%Q Eoc om 4 GC 6kks ,b 4 i C hpM % Nhw o4 cess - % ue Aceu d.e 4 -Aama tw Ese a s owgM ,
V hYau ESSEX HUMAh FACTORS PROJ MANAGER faVS/w OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER A. J. M A A WESTIlt@NOUSE % COORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
j7Le-m $ lek 6 M MJ " - A/st, la/h are at s'y s,y m
9 DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$ L^ / hYN OUQUESNELjdHTC$NYDEG.'AFFAIRSMANAGER 8WC
[OUQUESNELIGHiCOMPANYOP
i neo na: 2 s us-nos }
l c. ':
<mrvr cg E*
I
- c. Exis-ing arran Press.u-itec It4L\/ rebd valve.s, 7
a.Rcw Pcv 455b, 4 55 C 4% 3 a nd.
Pressurizar M Nod: va'Ves
@Rcb4 Ho\J 535 3 556, 5373 535 M
U
!)2 ~IE4 bon 5% i .J
$ N V$D
= m
'h' lM i i I W
3 \A g p 5 1bh'.\Wh5 ( (u At%yM sb bwh b v<&q\q, aquu% unt cs aus-@d 46 b""Mc
. A wh a cou sa.g m a RT ack,ioau p hak prevtsions ha<e been cnade b crange. con b's in a togcal alphenomenc. crden Q: -
eom.. _.
S. 2 m. mr -
~~ ~ ~~
HUMAN ENGlNEER!NG DTSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: , H Franche c) sed No.: QH#-i2o1 E d) REVIEWED BY:
- !, & e) DATE: /f!
(
(WestingWouse) / -
CR Nos. lioj O, %2,71
~
(Essex) K isp(6A/S l f) HED TITLE: k era A g et h s'r o Conh M S O r-i w (
O.Cg_ t MVA a
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Se WW h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: g,g,g
%6 loo are. bh nd arra.n<pl ,a a t y d t,(i 40.cg oc- 4cp 4e m = c.e. T h a g u .e_ % & a ce 40 coincicte w/wabs <xee h t.ns.
l i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION l NtNBER: }
ka.kIdA ci% C (Of\ Fra co W M C. 065 }
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
indorrecb of My I
Mfd'M F q_ % ,
i
I ;
k) REv8EW AND RECOMMENDAT1CNS:
e a ached 5;%3
-for enindwidual recomundaken bTWQ 6 0% k a k mk o Co w st b o.t w h(,
M taw CoTtstsggNW L owhds b for om 4 6 4 O s.
G C. k s , b Cl t C Q w p
(.c d c o\ s a w h h { .S S C o 4 T R <. Mhs shodd ma tw Ese o em9 ,
N\>M V
ESSEX HUMAh FACTORS PROJ MANAGGt W A.4rA -
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER R L MA A WESTIttlSIOUSE % COORDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
j7Em [ ifA f M MJ 1 _- _ Wh A/St, are at dyy G m
~
OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l r f L- / ?YN DUQUESNELjdHTC$NYSEG.'AFFAIRSMANAGER f 0%&
DUQUESNE LIGHi COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT Sv PS .1 .
5 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: N . M n d w c- c) HED NO.: 'O d) REVIEWED BY: / , e) DATE: Y3 iS (Westingfouse) [
CR A . 6 ~$
T (Essex) x\N A f) HED TITLE: 11C cx ce ck ScJk om b c-e-. N c o ed + c-g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
SOP %al leb(( hlow ,2c us - F R t 54 P3 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
- 6. 5. l .4 d n') scde swo, sd by se_\e c i < J b :
En pi q $p.7cc yiMe_. scale cag ng LcLn. p en
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
C' k $ C3b i on C clsk pcbc m an c.C Ca pb), h ,
1 ublij ( R acs) L .L\.%
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
C5 < - D- \ C C-b%ca Cd'SP( ^156 0'O \[ f i
I
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
C. x > U . re. -1, a\ q -- - , :- ..t R. . _ , _
v i.
,3
- 37a j\ i t u d ws - , . . . .: .~ .
L g' ^ .
., ,f
^
- C .(G .? ,q, c,h t . , e i
]'{' Ace _. _ _ [
g s4 6 O _
- igm Sc de (4c och,wg a g Sam p C4.c.s< b \h M ,
\
T M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PRO MANAGER MAun DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
~
WESTINGpE PROGRAM C00RQMlATOR ,,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
p W OV'/
() AJ- 9 M p~ _
O
- e DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY E RIN MANAGER A,, Axe, MANAeeR
_ eSN 7 1 r ,4ee.
~
7~~~4'~'97 w DUQUESNE LIGkT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
! HUMAN ENG8NEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) 7 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: . N-F r e n O
- r' c) HED NO.:
d) REVIEWED BY: - e) DATE: 3 I (Wes[nghouse) / [
R M (Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: Mc.or-r4 c b $4 M en J yr&br-e.
cae M r g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Mi L. a nJ. Te pe A . R,0 orc 5-TR.40% '
~& Tw.n reeor9ude.e--
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (,,Q,3,] C4 ,
%4 We_ reck anel gree, acrews am \abeled A v e.
l 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
l go e roo m chim,3 k p C kDo) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Y' O(~ Yaf 'y @M C4B b's r\
k) REVIEU AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Q,cp(d kabek u's y b u Ca t. ,
COfr's
, 9. QQ di Gew s9 %
. rdCo m01gnds cb p c- E eve hN ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PM0 JECT M7 NAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER D. I. %
WESTI @ USE PROG Q RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
O W DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
'lJ (
DUQUESNE T C0%NY JtnG, AFFAIRS MANAGER
[8@M
' 000UESNE LIGHf COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
ATTAcHMrNT Ct.AnipicAriews. To .NEp _ No. t.vst- t4o4 THIS .RtteRDER_ IS LocArgo_ VERTic as GoAso arcitu__ BA _ Nor__62
__. . AS.. . INolc Att0_Sy THIL_HE D_N v M ORK __J. ive.n_M_s __ ._o.N__ swac_panw % ____
R__!.11_41 - R 4 .15 M. ), _ _ . _
whaN RE n.A_St_u.4 Rtcenes R THAT swg? wiring,_pinsRAMs pen pgg NDIE la " Hlow An # Awp Pew I la " T_gg, ".
V-'RTit. A L BOARD SMow Paw i M ^- 9-16-8 T 1
""-#" " ' ' * +---_e ,,,e, , , , _ ., _
e e-
o HUMAN ENGINEERZNG OfSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) l f PLANT / UNIT l
b) ORIGINATOR: N- r Anr hPT c) HED NO.: dYO N d2-d) REVIEWED BY:
e) DATE: \b9 b'Ib (Westir(ghouse) (/ C R. No. 75 7 O (Essex) ] ,
f) HED TITLE: Incorrd @ ara medaz.c ' 8 b e b e' O e3 scde g) ITEMS INVOLV$D: gpg$ - @ Ln7 STM GEN at A Lv \
7 I fa, 9 ( C.
b h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: C, Q , ,k cc.4a.\s , aispla s acd obe 4 .pme.nz h 4 obsf N k.OShed,'dadiled,or n,a.A pedaec\ swad be apereende% aca aeaetc3 l a%),d 40 pes ns 4 co pi d emd. accu.cale hunlao par 6nwa.oc e ,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: 1 VM G hyc)A C M M CO ldOC4:
, Ca o.bs i les; $ou rdbiI- ( R l\ 05) (,.l.1.1 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
! 7 I C cabc D'd Dit s'\ n +%CCI C'gk BLi-ec tb nuabo .
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
Qg n dfz r" Cdd) "5 ' C- ! --
2 ,
l t C 2 4C(_. p5 1
, s .c h au ,, ,
[4
- I. ', - i ,
i cc*
r-
-e s(.y 7. w m ,. L y , , c a , , , . \y c , , , L , , ,,.,
- u. m- ,1 --
(>
'q \ t - s
"' e 1 '_e b . c, , t, f; - (qyegl ggc c,ccQ
- c avb- Skovlc! N 0 " l00 N Y,A ESSEX HUMAh FACTORS PROJ MANADER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- Yr l?
WESTINGl@USE PROGRAM GSORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/
M/A f DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER f E O ' .
7-2t-8, C DUQUESNEpT COMMfiY fGG. AFFAIRS MANAGER Y. k 9ferzr>sa
'DUQUESNE LIGHT DOMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGZNEERINC"JISCREPkNCY (HED) REPORT l
a) b ~
PLANT / UNIT I b) ORIGINATOR: , NEranM: ~ ~ c) HED NO.: b@~Md j d) REVIEWdDBY: - e) DATE: M (Westip6 house) / '
No-.O C.R
, % ~ s,A ~l (Essex)
]- '. - -
f) HED TITLE: @DW6T letek IS ehM" 1
- ) ^ i n d r w.S. -
M SM N dyprWd in deh I bA g)
ITFMS INVOLiED: - ,
Y 1 Q ? l a n k h m's n W + r Sbc Tv b.4
\
L,UhY Q Wt Al) Ab , 'I '
( e h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (, , $ , \ , Q.
Scale is cck cradahd ard. nember=d .so bl reeAgs are r=.\aM ,n e Ae,d and pckei way bb K brs heb, '
?
- 1) DATA COLLECTION. DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER: ,'
Vahab d Canb\ %cmLchns -
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: ,
0xnes ca & may & h ere d .- ,
i A.
u
,s
^
[a l g /
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONS: % e hke hace EGk So h4 i4 wu\ be pr, secs 44d in a crece ya cA-1 ca.\ wa.y .
RT egs6 make 4he c.hange as itsled. awe.,
hhs. A Aso nbenc T w s r b e.l m bt, l N e ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PltD'JICT MANAGER m- -
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER he t )
WESTIN@USEPROG COORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
em DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER fI p - f' $
DUQUESNE L,IJMT COMtARY ffEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER f0$ &
DUQUESNE LIDHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
I HUMAN ENGINEERING OISCREPANCY (HE2) agpgg7 w
- a)
PLANT / UNIT
/dd c) HED N0,: 168/ M 26 b) ORIGINATQR:
d) REVIEWE0 BY: A//A e) DATE: k!//I!d7 (Westinghouse)
/v'/4 (Essex) f) HED TITLE: bLeCK SWs 7CsFM / d 4 W /c&cG,c4 c d/2CM g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
5W, WT i V/6, 3 '/7, 340, 3(< /
~
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH N(MBER:
& c-f&Y- /d,lA CA - T5 Hru cs u , oe , " -
. 5 7.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION kview o hif l NYS.
(/pir.[ for bl bA SrV'f) r
{/ 'r / Nfb $*. Nd J) SPECIFIC-HLMAN ERROR $(s) OR EGJIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
SWIkb f n ol 6</Y yW Ic-G l
l
b) REVZED AND RECOMMENDATZCNS:
{*V / FC/W $$'t # $ h[ $<.)st/2 (f ANG C' ,
[A')72 /ffEW//hf f#v&f I /$ s/r4 Wsf# G ,
h'l O 0 7TO M . /l//S /s }7'E o,4 96 @ /^J l~'N/Ch' 77tf
~
Stu t/ dWU /v0 J& Q 2r &567) bute//V0 .4 f0CV CR A'Sc uvSfo x.
/$/
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJECT MAN /.GER d- / k >%vn/ W()
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY 4tEVIEW TEAM LEADER
/1/ /V WESTINGHOUSE PROGRAM COORDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
x
.e h r i
~
} t)t A l(-15-0
' DUQUESNE LIGPT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 5 , ll'/a d 00GJESNE LJtHT CorA6Y REG. AFFAIRS MANAGE fS hmm' / /' - / 5 ' W OUQUESNE LIGHf COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER 1
1
BEAVER VALLEY UNIT 1 HED REPORT
! HED N0: CROR SOURCE:
PHOTO NO: LOCATION:
073 GUIDELINE (S):
hl h.
OISCREPANCY:
& . = = s ga) #[ A dvd de a4M wkue al zo/m e b /e,a a' ol & ru.
/ hY POTENTIAL OPERATOR ERROR (S):
POTENTIAL CONSEQUENCES OF ERROR (S):
ERROR / CONSEQUENCE ANALYSIS:
f
(
ylg POINT IN HISTORICALLY 00CUMENTE07 ASSESSMENT LOGIC
'* ACC10ENT RELATE 07 NO YES : @
4 VIOLATES TECH SPEC? NO YES : @
I : @
NO : @
e IS HED A PROBLEM?
Le ACCIDENT RELATE 07 YES @
b VIOLATES TECH SPEC 7 N YES 2 b
' = @
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY
\
v ERROR / CONSEQUENCE ANACYSIS (CONTINUED)
ERROR RECOGNITION / AUTO RECOVERY? NO O YES O
[0ESCRIBE IF YES) l l
- HED CORRECTIVE ACTION (S)
[k2nyC {CN I/C*1)
CORRECTIVE ACTION (S) ANALYSIS (USE ATTACHED CHECKLIST) f/
l f RECOMMENDED RESOLUTl05 O ENHANCEMENT thy 4 Gll/l(9}/f6/ }/3/4'Lf )Rf 80ARD MOD O INSTR. M00 0 REUESIM O PROCED'JRE O TRAINING O OTHER SCHEDULE PRIORITY COMMENTS:
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY
i HiF16 ENGINEER' SNG DlSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l
l a) BvPS~1 PLANT / UNIT l 4
/
b) ORIGINATOR >,
IM I c) HED NO.: DGM 0 I d) REVIEWED BY:
M, b --$ e) DATE: 3 9/75 (Wes6nghouse) #
__ ~
IM '
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: k6. cord.e 4- tSca e_ Yakues do n d o =Qe s bx/ s i
\ ,2, 6 .c (D l
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Condenser Yac_u. carn recorder- $de A,S
& c t4R - PR.103 -
Co-so) e n g -va c_
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 070d PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Yakwes O rs N't s Sc.ak.5L a re_: o ,6 , \ 2. , s e , 2t} , "? o D ese be ncb p ca i , z ,5 o r- t o .
( (, .s. ) . 5 a.h D s.6.4.1 c.
l 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION l NUMBER:
Yc~1UbQ ch O G CD\ ce m c -ons @ 0(o l
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
V25 '
'\ O 8 .e 6 i(\re k.n M sca.e
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: CoccecA- b6 Sc V8. ' k inch'ca6d by unik cyalu.abns do 1,2, 5 o c (O
~$~ a h _['s s c [Y wow -.%
U7.
<uhY
,)'.s - ,va i a . - k. \.\ -
c
' I \ <. U !d d' - Diab A \ c w; sgJ g<go.w %g u.wks d l A,5 ov g ,
h ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT MANAGER frrL/xs DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY'1tEVIEW TEAM LEADER A/VA ~
WESTl p SE PROGRAM 960RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
... /
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER fSh //- / W UV DUQUESNEJIGHT CDFXNY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER f 6 ? ~? ? w o-n - er
'DUQUESNE LIGHT DOMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGXNEERZNG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
M . Franhc c) HED NO.: d- BR-30 l f d) REVIEWED BY:
- < e) DATE: 3I /9 Ib (Westinghouse) #
N d '
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: Cod ov'Nr%2. => robc.h ors sys 6 Th ;
PA !e + _ 500$ tAES Misdii nc _
G g) ITEMS INVOLVED: cold M ag e ure pdchion 9 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (0. N . N .b The confro\ cegwee,wents Cor- %is sqske dic_ bakes .
4{g Q c. Hon be.in ' con %v04 s h o 4 b h e. seccab Qins. ac ivafior
...em . t,a n. _ _ - - -i Unik i has a k.cy - c9ecabel cc,nbre)3, 03 hr Wi s s y $4-e.m W l i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
I 00 BON N (Y\ hions(gqg i j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
M C(N1 ON DfW f
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
Inska\\ kglock. swilthas- on Benchbcaccl (3 as in U.n d 'L ._.
RT sugesb eaf a kefeck swi46 is peeC<<cred , ' rem o.<-
l
~f 4%s carno b inshMdek , Gn d\ber nahve soldon puQ Q b inskaB some_ hee oh p eds b preve.nb acedMa.\ och<abon, here:
(),at 2 ha chff%t colcl oveepressure pdcbu s ysh cd-:d m , el regu:a kov [7cke ).
% Merts ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJ K MANAGER 2~ KEA- //sxSs DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- h. .
RDINATOR -
WESTIN@USEPROGRAM
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
M l
^
41E8 ua ,
& WL- a& II~11'-11 "
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
/fKa'O.,no r DUQUESNELI8ptCOMP&MYRtG.AFFAIRSMANAGER' S$% */S,W
- DUQUESNE LIGHT CDMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
o _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
l 1
L LABEL CHANGE REQUIRED m
l l
l l
t i
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l
a) f t!M- 2 PLANT / UNIT ZKgK IlO I-b) ORIGINATOR: ,
tS i< 0 c t c) HED NO.:
d) REVIEWED BY: / e) DATE: til7/fN
/es'tinghouse/ .
m l .M' (Essex) f) HED TITLE: 9 ^0uan* 6 03N $4'- 0F % ""M c h u U%W g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
k uud aroc. M M W C h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (p.(p,/,/
/N h.mArea. oe.nich VMG ww iu aove.t,mm oems tofrJco of a t:iu. V Aw - OJew we Pa.x4rs o.c Fiwi4 % gw mg ,
- 1) ; DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER: Lg,R Gi,y g4 Mcd Rikg g LdA 230 - 8103'1 l
~
1 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
D M 4r-c c n n + n u .v o 7N r a ce k w w t (bM WemuM]
k) REVIEtf AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
. ND$tN0MA[ bbhbdkMEt.E9H6NCEMnT TECMos @E5 SHov2 BF tMP(,rMEwrFD t Bsb sa DISTwGusMIM 6 FIL(. val.V E5PW bMla VMVE5 T *'
StMMceS&n, digycj;d jf'g{y Q ,g
"' bf b 0'b . hs ofevent[ggp, yg9, 3;gg.
Il0 2, Il0 3 7 M ESSEf HUMAN' FACTORS JECT MARhGER z?AYr C' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER e -
WESTIlgff0VSEPROGRAMCfDINATOR -
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
0 ei.
DU(IUESNE OfGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER S r.
, DUQUESNEfGHTCON#ANfREG.AFFAIRSMANAG 1 DUQUESNE LIGH? COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT s) B\/ PS / A PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ J.be:no, c) HeD NO.: a#47 -rios d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: b3[I@
(W(stinghouse) /
hM (Essex) y ~
f) HED TITLE: [h hnm ul'saa0 Om Liim aa.Ls.- i g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g gG (
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Ah \M 6c.hgt.W 6Mk be, u.Ae d_ -
a.ncL mb,A . hkcA g chou ne4 Q tdLk. th cEwim.
G.6, . I . 2
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
k be.{S Clock LcCoi b k d 6 d lo.I BS . Y j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Mb3 t<\ CLc.I(dCM d a h tLCLk. 0_O% W
'A$o uo.ad e_ M % Aesud$.
acMecdica o
{'
n: REVIEW AND REC 0804ENDATIONS* Ws C_ ht.twa Md , J. h P_.L' * ]
& tn a..u m h w wik 07cc , - ,3 7.x c .c_ . i 0N- -
N W. L ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PRO MANAGER fs u ~ W L DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER ha r -
WESTINGtjK)SE PROGRAM y NATOR REVIEW ANo oISPOSITION: -
(#1 m awha
- n j A.
n$ Gll1 DUQ6ESNE L]GHT COMPANY'E NEERING NANAGER s/
DUQUESNE'QGHTC@ANYRef.AFFAIRSMANAGER 1
/W DUQUESNE LIGHT CO W ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER .
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) D b !A PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: *d umtnO c) HED NO.: 1NM - l DI
/ i d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 2! 3! b
/
~
(Wgsfinghouse)
M
' (Essex) N kh pmItsir ^ fY M A e b t-- (CLhds tNaek f) HED TITLE:
CkeAdL$s. tdctn601. mennpS 0ochnkt M 3 ) nr g&; - -
s s q \
M\ku.edd(OA e#1nsM_
dodkoks a_ui.ck.ig g .
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Ms do ted Mk l t h 0 ,_; d wh&
(.o .lo , S.7a, .
ot- d.(sp .
onoo h h
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
La.loels a.lcl. Locaib GA SuAceq A C14' O 903 l TPI. . t 8b3. 33 J) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
E- W N d V o pe).ai. t h a t nG O UU2 1 DNI[
g
k) REVIED AND RECOW4ENDATIONS:
~fu t.oa% youpeA eda e dh. pep & A cc u.y ;7 a. . .bu_ aLk. 07cc a uyapk
~
(: h 1 ]Q.
' bppl y k;t rarobc.d hdin to Q%O,fy h v % b ,a n d ly ye),Q gons.
W A ESSEX }4LMAN FAC M
ht0 JECT MANAGER Ym DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h a WESTI @ SE PROGRAM NATOR VIEW AND DISPOSITION: e l}f^&
u.a Js A whW -
~
$iG4 /
DUQLiESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGIEERING MANAGER S /.
GHT COM!ANY' REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER DUQUESNE
. w= J
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER ,
[
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (NED) REPORT s) BVPSl2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
d L3n t n a c) HED NO.: ? MMM-//07 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 3[?Lf (Wedinghouse) /
Y N (Esse'x ) T f) HED TITLE: bu 8 L & S8 LA /1 1 o o i t k M- ~
A0 \ t 2 do D
_ kO GM LAN3NM b-P1nkd imp g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
O AQ bg.dk h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION ANO 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
b bE
@bo c1L.RILAGEIItA- Ok ioa.w_loe%dewMyse.tateoLcb>qq.
br.b. b .2 a. (t)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
DLCZA/ IQ433 L aheh a,d t-ocoh a 6uveq
-rPG.;a;3.so j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
l De- Lw c h4EP MM. o' med M N oMt O(fid'n e
tncould dh.% k htal . ,
(
k) REVIEW AND' REC 0604ENDATIONS8 wW, 6 dS R M .G . rs 6hc d d_
g u.v.JL ~ O e ( a '. c - U de oa_ ke c h d ty_p(
RLL % .g 3 L/,(.6,,ga[;}
,,. 3, .f 3 _L- 2 c 6~100 8 .
1 I
$ M ESSEX NUMAN FACTORS % BCT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT CODFANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER ha e A 4 WESTI y SE FRDGRAM TOR VIEW AND DISPOSITION: -
l n <
a/>
~
f 1 afk Gbt DUQUE'SNE LIfdrT C00FANY INGINEERING MANAGER f5 w .. /
DUQUESNE L)(sHT CO WANY 4 G. AFFAIRS MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT C00FANY OPERATIONS MANAGER .
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a> BVPS lR PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: d ta n tna c) HED NO.: ) M * - IlO8 J s d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 2!3/'N (Wgafting'h'ouse) '/
M (Essex) ] '
f) HED TITLE: Lkm N d_oun111n b -
~
w ifxO.lu.olo k Yn o n b r. $ d N -
r udn~'5N &
w ,k-g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
d-Q M d Y2b h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
tdo hnes o' cb mo.cdth whick skou_02. be. M
-b c.e. loss }_M% ho bnt A c_ong o700 9ungh 6 do. 6.3-a (A)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
- 1) L L I N F 'N 3 l a. beds ccnoL !sotica OA %
r-P la.l B1h , sI j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
t A. d( b (LOA >da.k. N0%
o n
Lam un d co & oR~ % w a - .
i I
l _ . Y , E_ - _ _ _ c_ :m s_. _ m g e..L % _;< c.c- J n a Q : : d 1 A Q J M L'-
,,- u u .i u 1.c . 'Lk D G h 6 &d 2%
w FUSEX HUMN FACTORS n\- ~T MANAGER OL DUQUESNE LIGHT CODFANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
& L WL:A 2
REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
fr u A b de- w & ' % 5 ,
( Y, e/ g L. ,de-/,
J J
- thal. & Wu DUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER S .
DUQUESNEL)dHTCOMPANfREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER 68NW TMJOUESNE LIGHT'C06FANY OPERATIONS MANAGER ,
/
h f'. '.'. L ** c ! N t. E I N 3 D ; b C4;.; A *iC Y (HiD) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: M . Franh c) NED NO.: 2xg . u i g d) REVIEWED BY: M e) DATE:
(Westidifghouse) /
M (Essex)
]
f) HED TITLE: O O 5 OCI AVN k 8 E g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Con}c.o(s bah teci w 61. si p\s y are_ o
- N r y G r- SLI, h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NtNBER: (o . (o . (o . l h op.cabcs performanen cact be enhanced Hvogk h ose. eV iocatten ads, se es c ol o r- cob g.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
chic 2L 00 C COGWb\borOCOC50tE(R$
j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Mas; ch Oper rtM' p se d. m ro inamL4me.
k) REVIEW AND RECO WENDATIONS:
F-GhancE $ L-I. <-mh k s wih Y< l(oW Enhance sy_ c c,n Q W4 Red Geb~
ubbab hkhi w w .
s G. %
C. \ h wn, k C\6 0 hua 5 g7 m A .- d W Co wsts w b k k-i [,i.e. , css o,Lh M i ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS % ECT MANAGER 42%.~
DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h/ ~
J WESTTNQ@USE PROGRAM INATOR .
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
f U f N Nt' eacA Mpineere/ Skyvards kre etcN Tb Y Y W P W b (,#7 W , vs bes,e f .) / / l N S y A e {ke h p:// dave L co/ot'- :.rd/ l e d n ,,) N ,nytas , d d
/yik /$ 7 u A assk k ops,7br~ in ole ltrm**} HAA Cd-/,n
& c ,- p n t J J d L E $ $ l w f ,. m e A" A.h Se.
- 4 .s l .
J j
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INGIAEERING MANAGER gg g ,
y 2 N C O - 0 316 2. hSY ~
> 7"/fWV DUQUESNEfGHT C@ANVREG. AFFAIRS MANAG
[@W
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS NANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: .
N brandbge c) HED NO.: O ~ I29 I
d) REVIEWED BY: - - " e) DATE: /!
(
, (WestingN6use)~ /
\ -
CR Pos. So, % \ ' 12' 7 ^h
( -
(Essex) N f f) HED TITLE:
kerangem r o conhrbS k Or- iSP hVS
(
Srg th Oc t r' A \
Q g)
ITEMS INVOLVED: Se WM h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: g,g,g 46 are. ned area.g ,A a '.t p , \ , %...te, n p oc- 4ep b bo4ch mm . Theg we.ne& an- 4 40 coinc;ae w/ wabs w h I.ns.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: )
Maf.ddtm of Cond bm bc.Nons @ 406j' i ,
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
t -
ddM I f_. Q R 't hdorrec, of y ,
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDAT80NS:
-f r eMndMd' recomunda. hen ,
N T 4.wg 6 o\A ka k mk o cowsg h o, gk M T4w CoTtsL%ggdW Lowhgh b gkl, ne f em da AJ sW% N u uomyA 4 %
(.cdeksawhh @ N Co 4 4(- . M h s s h o wk e cs c h tw Ese a s owqs ,
' t- NYx>u ESSEX HUMAA FACTORS PROJfCf MANAGER N
$tri4YYW 0000ESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER R L MA A WESTI @ SE % COORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW ANO DISPOSITION:
/7FM W # /5.5 _
-slh Ant, GAA Ww CA '/?rna f _
f f
e 0
OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$ 2-- ' / l'Yl.
DUQUESN HTC$NYSEC.'AFFAIRSMANAGER OWC
[DUQUESNELIGHiCOMPANYOP
. - - - . _ _ - -. __. _ u~.. _ _ _ . _ a -_.a ff E O No.: 2 5 9 -1291 F
s F. Ekk3 @sT vAm w w A arr. p ed iwi uis c VCi;L
' .-s(
3[l
% (W5ss94 LMEL k:L , M i.aE un Lt n__,___;:::: ::::::e a a
,211111:2 Tj v
~l 3,
9- 1 (g
y ,- 1 ,
g_e i s Egg pxg T, s e
2 .m .
i < - . m .s, % 3 l
- ' "jdb 1m l '*** **' 8 l 1
f %m, d 11, t ., %aAN JFWE #LI to4Al MM l ad ,v., o i m 6.s a.d L. redo cy c4t..- ma.cch lm i v/zq/fg r
gj ,
VCA W WW V
- =. . '
/
,., N A =
a 3
i t , . :
. , ~ .m im ios '~h
& tit. s (yeyect by Vann). Se ty'pe- A s <L av AmA (eg . Meby o /, - c.b,)
. # < n. n ge4 .xhe k n sep Jal ,
l 1.y PAM %ts , -4 PA m Sds (a) w W k l lemnca:lt/ > soma sy A -(w& e ss. x t~ l cru de.
HED Na : 2 A t * -12cl E c.o\d % Enjeden bl.% vaw,3 g y . p n ,d e Arrangemenk Cass X Movs67 A,B, c, D y y,, y
,1 or, 9'8 88 EE 5 M M n, no , g
'.'"'"y'5" E'8)!28, E< I T g8sW 8
,5;;!!,l w,o ll in'n al n Ja J ,
,, u , i E f G j Rg is., s ,.
p: 72 ' A
,i
' ' " *I Q.9 ' Eiif 88 00 *9 Pg-a ! 'iSt: C-
'9' T ,g.or T6%
!!u
,, o.. ... e !.S... S...
, s.s .,
WtI T , 1 /i4. .
,! > . c., i
'* - Tjl!F!
'MCT 4) j, [
m C).. .
/ Non ger , c ca\ eman - -
V B/D on te94 artAg[C ors c '.
Sy3bw . M ( m k b u m , g\q u ww+7s l i \oche Aa c.o ec.u pah k g t w % % 7% 4 7 \ \ .
J *J womnvuds, us'g he Pf
- a14.
2.s T$
n.. e,oa
$[ "(( W 2.s r..a s.s
'y.["g" g 'n This, mwd- b; a M e REDa-n fa?
2 111, niEt S11 ,s2]. sex - i2m o.
?$. W.iG W' LQ .Q ' 9,.. sa ma.w s.
g y ,,,, sa na <. 5a. ' s.m I itEdll.f,d.Qo 7 1 % 6)
G@ct DG .5l 3CMdQA c D.J;' R1131
.a'(L
~
i
.B Lsa:MERI,N5 Ch:4:.; As;t (HiO) REPORT l
a) b~b PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR . _ M . F,-xneher c) HED NO.:2ABXOlot d) REVIEWED BY: O, d , _ e) DATE: (o/6/85 (WestindKouse)' ' /
% M (Essex) N
]
f) HED TITLE: No Wahon M n M onblaM O t-Q
\ t"Is. d \adon S ee n tsan\c Aen ecolornon" dN!r ASP eo.m . ' '
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g g gf ggy h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
No locAMon has h o denn hed. Q insk30ahon ch C.o menor0cakio n equipfnenk neehd kc- br-iogog b planh .h a sak doMown conf ,;oq . [p. .g,g(3
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtN8ER: 9,1 3 t
c g. sveye.y TP h(t (.Ryot a t
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERROR $(s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
h uis. Op ram e utili no4 oc able +o Cornmunicab cd4 of' ASP area .
k) REVIEW AND REC 0 MEN 3ATIONS: hso re NN c3 ( oc, 3,,hio n 15 Aest Jed & 4be ePeropriab c.ommoni c.a%
equ (he - N loc.didn shog,{d be og -
by N suprvipe., ,as,. (E dcces5 3
s sv.gog ug % g ,' N
~
ESSEX' HUMAN YACTORS PROJ MAmiGER -
w p
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LE ADER
- / -
- fEST1 SE PROGRAM % INATOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
,,M AW% gguf;
/7&As 2., 57ch 59 >< vacygs ( FW Flo0) MBATrod ME dPE%78od
, DFCvATE 7 ,
Sc, Rsvuseo 'Ta Asgrawcg 3, fro DU/ LGS ME j UG e 4' Ta t Tc 05 C.LQ C. Chi Com/'uTEC 1's Mf 4 $$ 16:lsTA J27 m wt Lt. )%%./s . Sd W /c/E W JNbid A f~se ed Qd ' Dot.JU /A7"E <
A
& lo . , gf
' [pd DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l
PAW DUQUESNE f1GHT CtWPANaPTEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
~/ 79V
,/
f6D 97DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER i
7
--- +----------------------,--,-r e,---v-+ , - - - - - - - -
ATTpcH HENT Ct MiPicArious To HED blo. 2.A 6 4 07.ol A LocArlon.__ HAs_. Sgan__psslow ATs0 Fon TwE INsr At6mview_ oF. CoMM9NicATaoN A S P_ _Il00 M - - -- SWEC .D_RAWiNG. Mo, ._itt4i -RE. _80 L - 96
_EnviPeswr _IN. . lHE
.__ {. pay sp. _. i t. S4) . _ Swown___A CoM&MATl0N__ WALL _ H AN05ET[$PEArtM AMPuma4 l b .._ PEM(,HEO . . T0_ 64 I N STAu.EP.__I N_. ._TM E__$1.SE _Roewi _. _ON__.TH E _ _w Akt ._N E A A . . .TH E.
poog Tb Tus_ Asp hem. A LouciesAMAR___lh ALw Sgoww tw THE_ ASP _ R0aM,_
-.-e a MAi n MvM Davawen THE WALL /Nmwosar SPsawan A mp6ipian tou t.p THE _ _ _
PenbiG64 64 kunTas FRom Twa FnowT 05 THE ASP la APPRetiMATEuf R .
FEEP C. l P Lt&MED Nthe Tut 6 _) . SwEC WILL GE INhtmuctEn av COPY ON T4th hep To
^
N LocAva WAN95tr Ct.ab a EwoWW To The ASP 59 AN BPERAT8R CAN u!a PHowE Awo ornahtm CowTanth oN TM E A S P.
IF NECEMARY INSTALL AN ENTRA L.eN6- CORD ON NANDig7 No tied Ac h wf EatsTs Siwes h commuu m* Tau I!4viPMtx7 ..__.
W AS IW CO R$3&TED INTb The DE Mes. _ _ _ . .
b._'"s 9-14-$5 .
e _
f _
L__ _ _
-_e.s-me mammqmm==mie 4.-eege, .,imembe e** e am eme--.umem *.-e
- -e.+e . w ee
- O** 1
-- . =
4e --=---=o-l
l HUMAN ENG8NEERING DESCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.3 BVPS-L PLANT / UNIT D, Cme ( blC - C>P c) HED NO.: 2 E C 3 -30E b) ORIGINATOR:*
d) REVIEWED BY:
.- / e) DATE: 2!27 E (West @ ouse) / C_ R Mo. 7'i A
/\A sA "
(Essex)'
f) HED TITLE: bTATIO N AIR CNDRU EOR RE AOW .
.e M c sta,rcaes wTeawees "/ e *<.a orxER g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g4 g _ p_ y4 S hS - P- 2)$
C h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: b.N Isk C.o@ LS. /*oov Tvb To o C LoS C See. 3 .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
Rde.ma_. \e.de.r- N D ic>s,1 : o o 2 2.
~
j .
f) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
w 4 W DEN S AS - p _ 2 t A gg gg py g,g 7g t,c c,gc POSMov j S AS - P 2,) S oo g go7 ggg gpov gg
.. 0 LE Nt/W C E w GF Rtb p tA. 6 sTAp_T-pos s TTo a ,
k) REVIEd AND RECOMMENDATIONS: IN S TALL "T 197 ce a7cz, KMOLE 'Tb 6ET R c wh v % e.te mu g ,
I4(-Q mWm ab4V4
. m N N ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJECT % GER AWdan 0000ESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER S/ML WESTI % SE PROG 6 RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW ANO DISPOSITION:
L
~
OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGI NG MANAGER ff, , ~7-wR-OMPANtMtEG(AFFAIRS MANAGER DUQUESNE L1 A . W n s=)
DUQUESNE LIGHT DOMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) Dri'M l
a) -d
, PLANT / UNIT i
l b) ORIGINATOR: ' M . Feder c) HED NO.: E k- 20 d) REVIEWED BY: -
e (Westdhghouse) e) DATE: /I!f5
[/
O f) HED TITLE:
(Essex)
Coni-rdls
]
are loC b ke5 bb8n ~b
'nches i @co m h bnb M chCmso\.e_
M g) ITEMS INVOLVED: G56 k Mov e,65 A,8,C 9.CHS h- L cv 4eo A . 8 '
a9AS k Hov 702 A , 7oa A , B br3ency (aenerabe J1-1(sbeh.
. #~YS "S h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLMBER:
Controis care. nok Sc_k back_ he. m' nirnom of 3 indws 4
Grom N.Ccon4 g 4u probeci- ga'*%k aa_(da.da.\
S cF' 46hm. G .l.c'L. a. d. O
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
C . R. Su.n/e.es (R403 1
j ) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
E OC6b dChs(AbOO b1 @ c.
1
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
\) Ce\DCdN b^\ESe. Con W o\S "g) pcoe Je. covers 40 pceu.4 accA 4a \ acL.Acn
") 3 pco<. de a cped ca,\ along h Genked p IAXI dM f O'Ihf L $ned boa gt osJi $'- ' (
QCk .
c r~ :~(%.: > ~L \h h a c q\l g, coq Soc \NS 'IM g o N (E w o \ w M L 4. -
Y M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT MANAGER fffAw DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
)$ =
WESTfpSEPROGRAMC0QPOINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
ESP y/d 6 4 . hind m .
+pawwu-axw - na
& J e a~ wa fY a g x,p a w w, nw - a f
g , ,
grrmd ,A e p < . oh 2fh DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY (NGINEERING MANAGER 6
,$,ce' 74 av/ .
A gg g sr DMA(1/ > w rs '
..e p .1 ,1..A,,AIRSM. R tesolva 6 &~A gg y_
'DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGZNEERlNG DZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) {
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
- Fran& c.c c) SED NO. av& cloo 7 d) REVIEWED BY: e / e) DATE: I fd T { T5 b (Westing W (/
CR No. 6%
h\ M (Essex) K f) HED TITLE: in s are CW c4 O
% Asdevs canx L I Q g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
w h hst -
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION Ai40 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G.5. ,.Q a sede uri, rs dneu a b co ns;is y n--
Wih % Qcce oC preeision avd accurecg b O@cdbr
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION HlNBER:
bxTica. hon of bak perbemarxe
. Capebi ;l6., ,La 4.AAl' , ( hsh L . A.I.h
! $ vmbcLce,on CReo()
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Of On Ocfr MbiM 5 Ce sAqs nh ,nCna%
1
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
$c a\e s shctd2 bs mct$ t b e2 b O CO Cd C IGt lC -E fCV ' . t (3- em&a)
~
wh ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT MANAGER
%Y/D ~
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER Yr WESTIrglMOUSE PROGRA VCOORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
h h ms a a s u. H n - u.
W v)-
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER ARW -
7dr =K' DUQUESNEpT COMPMY Rf5. AFFAIRS MANAGER 8NW DUQUESNE LIhHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
2v u -2ao7 5 O. Ce C( '3.\ i C' k'
]d De ss 3 i-(
(\ \ '} O\\
ps s .,,J A a qss e=w.* ses.
LR loo
. o-,oo..~ -
Nsr level
. .maa mm, m n23_,,. ., # , .,
& FNC -
LIl IdaA , i OR e3 3% bi pccllevel p-.4 sceu = 0 -s= ma,s . .,.,a,a am ,s se , . ,
lRSS -
LR 15l Ccak b p lead c2 RSS LI l5lA , t 5l 6 Cooh &o,P l eve! -
,ym.4 x A = 0 _ ,2<, .ams re aded td(ugs c3 c e .ac S I n c h < s 190 i.1cbe ,
Qow ' ceeMd yb are bW prof.M by
- -A %4p A s%Jy h - ee, g
W
- he e se -
O
HUMAN ENG8NEER1NG OISCREPANCY (HED) REFORT m m ..
a) ('kl 7h ~ . 9 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: .
- dOd V I
~
c) HED NO.: b-A N d )' REVIEWED BY: - e e) DATE: \ f9f!8 b (Westindhouse) (/
0$~ No. b5 (Essex) M E WNEC\ \ Sdi. s amc2 is mOk f) HED TITLE: ' Q N W<b 2 b g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
QM SdkE D ,9 D' dm- PNww ,
acNM pr io (
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
CCMe w.M 5 AGr_ och consi%kh LOs k A ck.gu 'cf p re o s; o n necded b f A <_-g cd c C . 5 l. a ct.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
h Ma perbr nuncGf (d ,1,h i gc,.
\ ect s ci3hion a l
fek\ci.GLg R%5) L L.\.%
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
KO V= CES Ctn H W Y & d c-(
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: <
.. h w, , . . , , , , , , ,
.t C .} (', OS* C Y (b ,
'Y ,y -i'v
\b ,c.k,3 -
( Gv =, b6Ib iuk -- N -i w $b t id eq ctu, . g 3
I C, - tC'O c; k' saGOd 4 t. w nwb gbh -
_z e g y. . , , .. ,(
m \sk
\ M\\e ESSEX HUMAk FACTORS PROJE MANAGER W
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- b. t WESTINpuSEPROGRAM900RDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/VS,b O
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY EN RING MANAGER f //
/rAn sa DUQUESNE L' s
COMPhREf#FAIRSMANAGER
/6-b/4C
~~
f 6?97'-
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
. E l EQUIPMENT CHANGE REQUIRED l
s l
I e
HUMAN ENGlNEERING DlSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: N Erandber c) HED NO.: Obb- I2? IA d) REVIEWED BY: - e) DATE: If!(
(Westingw6use) / -
CR Nos. 3o, %), %2,7 3 (Essex) N f) HED' TITLE: brCAA4em e.n'i O ConhrthS C)t-- ISP {OUS w i
(
dLG2. IlO i CC E CA q
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g Q h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: g,g,g Compcnen6 are. n d a.cra. @ a a lyd, le ? -fo-rip oc- hp 40 bo44ein. m-ce . T h o. g u .e. n o & a ce % g 40 coinc_iae w/ wabs <xeed.J-t.ns, t) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: )
ke 'ddEm i O M Te( R N W CkOG5 M 6) l J) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
I -
Wd I 9 % 6. l IV., o rt':E4. o( % ,
l
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
I h SM p gf'indW Idudh.\ Q comNG M.
bi@g 6 ow ka dst swko cows g kbc o, s gi wrg J&a nnes s u L R L u s t.
Eoc om 4 GC 6 ks ,b 4 t ( % w % O s.
(.cdco\s ow % @ d co t kh . ,@ < hs sh$d mao tM E5@ Q t Owp ,
b- k\)M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJECT MANAGER N
$ <rirt Y Y W DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER Y '
WESTIttfikOUSEPROGyCOORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/7Eh' /Eh4 M /Zj _/h fdnt, aff a2Wu el y e
g.
~
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$ / fYN ouQuESysT CeNY JE6.' AFFAIRS MANAGER ff97w DUQUESNE LIGHi COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
Q on-Sh.T,SAS MD No. 2 y g_no ce o. ss E.XiSM A kh@c Neam. Mvc(enhol(crs kccry 44GPK.lol A c B
'_/
iWilY G G--W[- # ,g ylg #"
l 8 D i '8 8
.. = ya i m L .
E y .
y N
!a n - [ A E ,.
.+. . .
..... u . a +. v . p .-. w p . . m b
I kcrangame.nY ass * **' ABC ~
- e--et-le rIr 9 3" G~ V M'8 8 .;$ = y m
- ! =-
,r n+
_ -d 1@y- =. =nw . ar r _. ,.
. - L- . ! .
! .....L-._ A 4 , y .f ._. w ,. y i ._.L,.
(6'X9 M J / nom =. wl l , 25Ncle0VAC-2M( ISAKm ,
RT s % =sks c< ace.n g n 3 cm6ks as bs44 abo <e
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (MED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:1 N brandb#C c) HED NO.: Obb-I29 b I d) REVIEWED BY: - =
" e) DATE: /f!
(
(WestingW6use) /
'\ -
CR No.So,O,82,t1 D N N (Essex) \
f) HED TITLE: kerM4em w m'r 6 Conh M S Or diMVS i
(
Off. (D i M E f" A g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g g h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: g,g,g Compen.n6 are. ned arra wyd in a(
oc- hp 4e bo44eh m .
Thag 4.%4 uqcd le% 9.--4 g 40 coinc.i cte w/ ceerdus <xeedak.ns.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NL.MBER: 1 d&, ciN O (ONFra Oo W M C. Or\5 3
}
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
~
Mq
\
@M I 4. % i N'orre.c.b of ,
1
k) REv!EW AND RECOMMENDATZONS: t h SM
-f r ee nhvidal reconvnendahen .
NT@g 6 og kak swkocowsg h a,i i e %w9A & ce m se A g a d m\s a b'hi..
d s$ Abu Foe C c+\f o p\s ow hh { Soss S C o 4 % <-
aMMChs a cdS s%Ys ,N a <
m Ese a<n q ,
- N.
V i x\ M ESSEX HUMAh FACTORS PROJ MANAGER
&dr'K/L DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTI @ SE COORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
j7En S lfA4 A M[
fh A/$f, ae2 at eLy y,L+a l
9 DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER bEWL -
DUQUES
/ 7"20]
TC$NYDEG.'AFFAIRSMANAGER 8WC
[DUQUESNELIGHiCOMPANYOP l_----_---_---_______ ._
- _ . _ _.,_ _ ,~~_ __ _. g ,
Ex n ST lrJ 6 M RAN Ci EM E91 kr l OLE - 267 - 4 3 16K-5) N r_ -1 M-@l b, "
il22A 112 2 31 N CHS* (" N CHS- (I[XIS7Wbj t.C V CHS-FcV I y
Pcv NOTE 6(8 llCos gp 145 A iis A ym ml4) O S ' CNS* CHS- WC CHS cas. N' CNS- CHS cH S-PK//6B \nc - 31/5 CK//3A pg - HIC, ,
Htc H t c '. Q g g(a s _
tyt -
18 Co 14 5 ; q-97b 97"I 970 ~132 909 'I T- ~133 746
'u N
- I ul j--
4m q -
e's .E I,W i cHs-
[5] . 8 -l cHs-Sets - -
iei i -
N Fot5 lensv a zi A I le. ssp 2tc 1 ggw '*waiwl N t ns- e t 2 n___I Ic vi MOV Ul 11 3 VHU N804* -
l(. 8 I N'h ao I y s I20 -
TYS cn me.c- cww e,e some. I , *-
- l 99- 753 scio 722 P P- H "5 I ru@sw@,.ui I k s'7c -
R MO -
cus. ,
14o "T 4~I _
G e R
p g ; % 9g goatc l
- g
_.n, & . 'va,,,1 ncio -
se ss.s l I l \
W5'
- 86'Al H
si l cog 7pict l gy I i i L__I .hl
' 9
_ _ _ _I g~ ~ 9i 7, .3 i t_ _ _ J i i
{ g g NOTE IS DN 4
, R
_ mS _
G '
_e G e R G 8 R
e R
G o R h
_G .- g . 9- _ _ _ _ @ e 5- _ _. _G _ _ _
3..s.snilr.,: acr mi n e ra m icsso o nani ts.cw zao*> ic wt si it e to.u ice - anos y A7c5 A q O m m # 748 O 4 2' 72 755 V V733 .
V V N N
,1 ; a .r .1 _ _c. 1 r.r 15 L
_ 1_ _ _ .a
_ _r. _1 ->
- .- _ _ _ _ H
- - .. ,. o - ,. , _ __ , . _ , ,
- ~ . , . n. - y n7to 73 788 M' O 135 O
742 749 O
75G d
O129 v v v a v vs _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ R-s,s
_, i _ s. _ ,..
as -o 'ln,s._3 ,
1- 3 s . .a
, $ ,s. - . . - m --
ss ,<
239 s._ u 'I N
O O n. O D k
,D . @'j
- s
(_m _
b6 @0 Ill9 Q
Note. 14 e , R s G . , e . e . . e NOTES
~
le/ - --
Itas TC1H'31 lotmetov e hl bs e neveric ] [QBT{5Gl60 k
Aeus us o 1 la c kw 1C vl4il lI J 947 "
U O CCVER g h O b d, 3 gg
( g-G T R R R o R 'G e a e R _G e R N
_ .= _ _ _ _ _d_ _ _G ._ _ _ _G _ _
rsidynst 1 I OMS
- d Ic 5 lCUM I ICNS 1(/h@ [2513 erovey L g u v n S es l [cuse n vn u l fluf4T[577Til l LK//2 k e' l Z 721 N O O g
S na m i
7.,
qs3 g m NOTES 5 t 6 NOTE. C q f I l
. . i , . . . ,, . l, . , , . . , . . , .l. .
2WW Go1 io\
- == CR STONE f. WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION Mo. 90 ,ih Pass dd D - 81 4 v 3 K
=- P *,.M *
- p * ' ' "< pf ^:y: :p 'g :(" :p - muu q,,..,, j. .,... *<f l+JJ :!Ijs w.M..., . ij: i y@';.. . . . . . .~.:. . s'
- G e e
!.[. i
.s.. . . . . !.!!. i.. . l{ cai: ots2j: - '-"y'"g~ *+lg:{I.:l- + g951g;j; ;N:j m.nh@ 1!..!j!!!:=.%..: j - %g -..qq.,:^ EMS.i.
- m wa:!;
mr.1ll;gi la t twermhji.'-
- . :. g . :.:.:.:.:... . #ge
. ;m3, mum.
'+- '
- i. east.c2 gent::- Mi-7/$ %;: iiinto ! tW5$ii:
- ncitR6i:.
wwwsss:
itc*ks.:i ww4ti::
gj,o j ....
.mhh.l4 f jii;< .l......
2w*stss* sje sf.{ %
33c ~,.- pqp.is+&o: s, ~
~ smit. ..
- :sm . p.:s ws g. ig:.: 2:g:
- . :3 e .::
! i:):i: i:fiUiz .8* ilg h E!! 'N' ~ u-tM ! SOMfC. if One . .
iitti isttijfts, * +S-s$i u : sig[jggdji N"Qi!!
w w ss m 2: w r. g jf
- C/#ia: n H4 irtis. . . styi :iiriin.. s;74252 s. g ~,.. ;W"ig yi g g iMun!Mii! li!9i49# iE i ! ~!!
! M E D 2.w v k - i ?. o ii.
2 a,y. 'd..:.y.y
+'so p '.
- ss2..:v "::sssss..
-M : - - :.v.-.
- e e
- sx ~ +:st:
t:SMs :.
Y , . :.
,n.+:-. . . . 9?sa:s . .+: . . . . n:-
Q
..~n.: m . . . . .
s.k g !! :!N g.,
p--r een m i - :
1
(
, g.g.;; ,g. . . .- { {
r
.:.y,. lf;f u. . g jjJ * 'lf R'
! ll cid.
.ljjj. uu.g.[:%s@;.: a,,pnk 3f"s
- w=xs'Rg:!ii@ q :s.g. jj s! g .. .+t gj. se ...... *
,.s i b. ,n.g.s,.
.,. jgij EE . l:iEFA#f2dHy ',.,.,,.,,.
- iif: 4
..: .,. . ,.., . G3 g = % % m t'- ~ -
' ~
L+' .. :;<= .:s
!!.Fj::,Q.%[; gr T 9 Qij s:3 G ; f( R ; !!$:
fj 4f E:iii
- 3 :.
=
_. .- ; .: -e =f. --l- : +: .Gl<::
S
, .y . : :
h ......... . ....... .
i ff .k. ., u m nM i:
- . 3 [ .
~p . :!r"""T"Q""'hy. menea
- s .
.. wm m
...g, ..;, n. :*yg;yitar;4
- q ,p OEb1*w-tzoid ,D IE@ b va p llll.v...hs V.
it u u G T
-E .i.a.' . iiii :;.ep/ +@... +..j!!j{:!:! $!!!ll ...'i...,. y.
- n. .:..@lijj!:(m.:.
iii !! --; ft:i dsi!
yg
....g. ._ .: .- y .
seu . an egima n: <os_ - m re . .
f !! :g ::: :: !!!,,. f :gg ,
vi l!!$ 1. sn!p<Eig,.. MIN""~ $ :!!!j$;:.$!
$!M(issx:: ua:itusin ssss b "~ vM Steies:sidl3siss:!! 4M*
TITt.E CutNT or o4T pg c3gytg 3g e m ner FREPARio J.o. No.
cuscuso bCo unttuotgo kEAtt.A u Gissuto av appnovao 09 S i m f c. u c t cart navissoms av e e e e e numet.t caTE
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) RE?CRT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - H. Franchec c) NED NO.: QW-i2pl b d) REVIEWED BY: - e) DATE: /f![
(
/
~
(WestingN6use)
C R. Mos. 50, % \ 38 2, 7 ^6 K
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: ber&A4em Conhtb5 k O r- isphys i
v l Srg. ( OcieA Q
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g Q h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: g,g,7
% 6 ac< nd a.rrm in al oc- hp 40 beh sec.e .@Thag .uyd %4mp te (i-6.
40 coinc.r ae w/ wh <xeeht.ns.
t) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER: }
N&.k dE ci% C (M Frp Oo W W C. Or\S }
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
I -
WS'M I e_. % iBeorrec.b oc by ,
k) REVIEC AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
hr(di A \ V Id'O- Q CornNn Aht'c(N, bThy 6 QW ak sw o Cows t b o. k M taw Co TtR4 gg Niw L owkeds b gk(, I ncg\sowhh Ccdfo %da \kCo4SRbiM<hs:ShEh M sW k Nunoq A mb<h Sh tw Eseasn+g~ ,
"E \Nd\ M ESSEX HUMAh FACTORS PROJ MANAGER LiHffw DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER R L MA A COORDINATOR WESTItt$kOUSE
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/7&.7 [W A /Zj w __
Wh fAsst, afA d el ab O
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$ L' / f l-DUQUES TC@NYSE6.'AFFAIRSMANAGER f WW&
OUQUESNE LIGHi COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HED No. : 2 KK K-1201 b
- d. E.>6di tra k i
- 29. Alian Charminz/HHSI Pump Suction To VCT Vg(qch Lh( on dg'ing, 4
a.
OPEN VCT isolation va?ves usc = ~7 5 1
[2CHS*MOV115C and 111!.] ll$ E : '[ \ h l b. CLOSE Rh'ST isolation valves it s a = 74 5
[2CHS*Y.0V115B and.115D]
7i7 n5 b =
fi @ s.s ss'B*a ss
@ Ilgtg G9 Y I ss 88i98 9l 8 E.8 E.s aB BB B.S M M M M[
T!tgg 7 7.
y.0 e e 9!
E 8 g E* ;
9 s
~
SJ E g,g g- 'E.8 g.g J l y g- I emma Ga8 '! Bmme
- E !,
a l
c o- t 1
'h
- c o ""G d wh\ ""*Y d A**
e ET99 ... wo 1 8 GGG
,1=a p g ug m n m.s ee aeae m.e gy'7 g g RT cecommend=. ken- 4 is g o.s, g g g , n g t g ,s; g g e s 6 A h t h c e d r et s BI GL 8 & G .g _21,.. S be ceac m n y d a in Acm 1 o's g k q O s
4 ,o o ws w.w ang udm ism.
g S' L gh.movig sw loukere FE k"jy,g,[ M l,h "gg Y rm A w each b one - inbaea*
m 11 & 1
l HUMAN ENG!NEERING DISCREPANCY (HEO) REPORT j
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - N brandbEr c) HED NO.: ONE ~ 12? Ib d) REVIEWED BY: - e) DATE: /f!
(Westing (6use) / /
CR f los. So,O %2 7 3 3
'\ d (Essex) y f) HED TITLE: bf CAA48f" COO CD S \ O r-- isPI6A/S w i
(
Srt ( C)C Y f A \
Q g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g Q h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION ANO 0700 PARAGRAPH NLMBER: g,g,g Csmpen.n6 are. nd a.tran<pd in a ( q d i , (... f o - rigt oc- hp 4e b o b h m - c.< . Tacg we ~4 m g 40 coinc.iac w/ w h <xee<b k .ns.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER: )
~
k&. id&, ci% C (OfVFrp 00 W M C. Orgs j
\ .
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
I -
Ufd'M I f_. % 't odorrecb of by ,
k) REV8EW AND RECOMMENDAT80NS: l
-for <& nbv idua.\ re comundaben .
bT T AWQ 6 0% kGk sw o Cows t bo. i w s- f & e- n n gAq uka, a %%.
Eoc o NN 4 GC 6 ks ,b 4 ( ( Qwpw % Nh s.
Cc+\fk-5, ow hh 6.S d co4ta.h , M ths showd mahch m Ese as cmq ,
E kMMANAGER ESSEX HUMAh FACTORS PROJ EaaHts/K DUQUESNE LIGHT Cor ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER R L 2 (zA h
- WESTItglNOUSE COORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
fA/St, j7Em f l&h41 A /Z]
ase a s ci , a,y La/j w _-
9 OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$ L' / h N DUQUESNELjdHTC$NYBEC.'AFFAIRSMANAGER 8WC
[DUQUESNELIGHtCOMPANYOP
HEb No. 2vv'e - \7 o s 6 C. Wecommenc6c/ arec y ,n mt 8/ CR 9o.82-Aw. Mdwe dee-- )er./ve.t99*kr as rdown debos (mt zG-der es1.s6y ESP acryn+) :
Remme,ncled ; ,qePAR^#
e a se ma i vu A 9t.e , a ^t o
' ?
o O O l O o i
i O
SG% SG-c.
%-A %-o S CT C.-
3 SC-r8 O
\ f W.- 4 t
s
/ \ /
\
bht %k
- n
. f s /
< ~
I.
/ 'w f _.
' N j /
/ g g
- y. ..
~ '
6 0 .
D.O O O
._ _ . . _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ I,
HilMAN ENGZNEERlNG DZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT s) B y PS /2 7 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: -
~
O' de I/#C #1 M S MY c) HED NO.: 2 A N *- fotn d) REVIEWED BY: ' < M e) DATE: I /22 /fr.F (Wes1[inghouse) f
' \ ~
\ rN\ '
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: hil S S ING CONT #dL 8d#A4 C4 d C I(
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
COMTRol RdoA4 CLdC W
\
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
C O NTBoL RdoM Cloc li ODES Ne T E XIS T oN THE A1AIN Cob' TB oL B oA R D 3.7.2,i
- 1) ~ DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
VERIFICATMk 0F AVAIL ABILI TY, R f o 5, C.2, I,I j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
DE VIc E DOES No T EXIS T QN THE AeAIN cow 790L BoAMD To PRoVIDG Ilyfo A A4A ntsN NECESSA RY 70 latPLEMENT THE Foll oWIN G ofERA7en 7A$WS; E S-I. 2, l s; g-I, z l,2 2 ; FR -P. I,2 4 ) E S-l. I, 24 ] E S-l.2, L I, FR - fo l, kl3
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
PROVIDE A TIAt E of DAY clo ek ^ oN THE hfAIN CM 7/1/ L boa R O, A Dt6t r+t. C coc k- wu e. o /2 e- perpegggh,
\N ESSEX HUMAN FACTOR OJECT MANAGER fA L -
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h*
WESTIN460USE PROG P RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
DUQdESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 5 w ,
DUQUESNELpTCOMPgYRIMi.'AFFAIRSMANAGER WWW &
'DUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERlNG OISCREPANCY (HEO) REPORT
.3 EvFS-JL 7 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: i Franchec c) sea NO., 2 *c+ -21/ 7 d) REVIEWED BY: ' l e) DATE:
' b (westig'ghouse) 6 CK No. LG v _xNi %
(Essex) N Nub ScMd indscitbcs a np ossch hoc f) HED TITLE:
measuc,nc AC vchs anc!
s AC t b oth O
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: 5'/NC4 vous o c co t . ., normal Bc3
.5 % C \lo LT 5 i nccas amagenc VCS h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (,.5.t.4 E b Mis d e irdic b c5 Shov0d he ducadEN UOI eSS bMj can be wskGel as cf c>pcabicaai bed M pretad. ons are oud6 b aWcAd cgxarahcr Cobsie n
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION N'erMdco oh Iask. lhGcne y C3pp, @ g, btuhabidy ((14G6) bk5\
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
O i s calc ( s c9,e o suf (w cL w g <_\
,/-
,\ k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
/ <
.' ea
[7 , ;, .
? ', s, ~3 - , --
N~
C 1, _,. ,
{Q Q 0 ' <
~
,. 's ; ci ' a - ' ., - v - c~ ~- _
y geibCPdI (V ' C Ww, t m td \ g t ~i N C b ,~ T I O p gh.- s _ h u s.d d \ M. Dke ,, c .k + i ,
1
$w' d kt t dwg i oy
$Gl6b e O 1 G n' V SCALE [
\ 'M ESSEXHdMANFACTORSPROJE%
r - MANAGER" v
XJ W DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WEST {pidHCUSE PROGRAWCOORDINATOR ,
~1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
Jh
'~"'~i) d i; 0-c W ; -
9 DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY EN NEERING MANAGER n, of / d-Lh W DUQUESNE LIG COMo g RfG. AFFAIRS MANAGER f67Mw ODQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY' OPERATIONS MANAGER
- i
h.' :'. ENGlNEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: : H . Franchc- c) HeD NO,: DABk-20r7 d) REVIEWED BY: - /
/
e) DATE: 6 S!B6 (WestMghouse)
M (Essex) f) HED TITLE: CCMPonenks (isbed. in prec.ed.m are.
% s 4 pc- d.J on A Ncnde Sh4 clown Pane.\
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g g,34 3.1.\ ' W h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
compe, nenb am ned ava'i\ab\e on Asp i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION Nl.NBER:
- C.R. S u csec.ys (mo3) +
N k\ka to d Cd RW sd (R$46\
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
O fD rs. r e.<~ ro c5 b.a Ye.
awnc.e OP compr> ens .
k) REVIEU AND RECOMMENDATIONS: SC dbd c_ o~e', 03.5%~ ^ . ~ , S'yu(, 3 .>T=^ 01 C.%~d 3 u >c a o u b % y_2. + .c : 3 us, \ ua 'nbu%
a i s O.t h ' f & s sic'g g o ( w e.k tg s Y o shd Scu o Ac g\a su % > hb g (a#% en ga;d gr'W an. ~ig., '
TVa @ cckui2 shoq h ha CM < b4.vs ic <. Qk aggi t(
T,-h% ok $ , hvoCa. u r.e , w h M r s % sshagQk qf(
n ~ gocek<,zw< k .
\ h ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS htT'MMAGER
~
BBf_
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER Hf.
WESTI' L .: t SE FROGRAM CfDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
- p P^
> J~h-
_ E Fl '
c1 ( a4 Tf 4,
)
ASP Q &p 'A e
'DUQUESNE
- LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER f / /N /W ~ b DUCUES IGHT GdkPA W M Gt AFFAIRS MANAGER
(( NW
' DUQUESNE LIGHT C0!ilPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
c u q u en&s h sb)_ .n em coa,cc are d pmvrded on Aiberra&e shoWcwn hel 2AB $-2 0l9 NEEDED -
REytEW & RECoMKEbiDATIDM C OMPONENT In6meatJe. Rany ha me A.S. P. wh he nudear paeer level mer meg Swem,4.
e C\ock -
% ve %e ASP u % a d xk- o r ensmoe ge ws. -r a atr_h O O
ion fevidt R. LEth C6 %tIlp.
Doo F /wc) -
V ), tW MY P A
Mt. MAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (ED) REPORT a) b Y bb -2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: b A /d hNN c) ED No.: 2 ON -3N d) REVIEWED BY: ._ e) DATE: 7[1/!EIN (Wo(tinghouse) /
No, 62 g CR (Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: b.Mde b ^ YM
\ 4
( JCL2 W r n]& b CSvt& ,
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
P. B. W , M h ( 3 3 r) - PN L Bl3 2 P. S. C&M , Mm 0% ( I 70 ) - PAIL BC3 -
J h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
kr d M & y ~
,W h e r ji w o. m pu.tt Gr,2 4 w w~A hut 4 3 <e y 6.4.a,Ia b
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
C>n, M , T f 4.I B 3. M % b JLCIM R403 l
Y %\.ekios (Rclo6 j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRDR$(s) OR EQUIFENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
YWw WW .
%s ap &a, .
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
(hm L ,
MdM ',M b 0 O b} ,
- 6vsn~c Mj M10~s Drw+7s prom Sus e tv~r , yo mm (hir ./.
=
6Y14r 7e $Econw rsa w om wvnw A N ESSEX HLMAN FACTOR 7ECDIAISGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER 21 VR WESTINGt%(JSEPROGRAMCOORDINATOR .
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
dhe- -__. d -f
. M N " ! ? erv A . be f p p & _
- s f-t'~L (ckck.e M g OK J DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER DUQUES CdBANY41EG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
[8@ W
'DUQUESNE LIGHT Cor ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l .) BVPS -1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: N . Frd.nder c) HED NO.:
~
d!
1 d)- REVIEWED BY: - , A e) DATE: 2 N I[,
(Westifghouse) /
CR No. 6cl
\% ,O (Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: DOS t
OG Con Bec is inconsis6b b ope Nbc5 ex JLhom g) ITEMS INVOLVED: RM Mh(on Con 4. I h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: b. N NO. ,
The. a@.ng con red mmereds ( emsh I-u F~ard 40 l
pwll rods ou Y , and. ~pa\l lever- kr.) pmh rob in) bCWS OCb cokcoT to pp4ahoA deco ps . A\so Ih is neverse_ }o 4 hah oF un; F 1,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
\la\ihaf\ o (onhok rcom t v._ht o n s @ LIOfo) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
ch3ge conbAr arotund so i b is \h Onit 1
~
OLAT lbd 4 Ws(.-
, c.\ma. eb e
b IN O' TAT RT t <M nnab Q as per e%,
\\
T x :x \\ c 4 GER ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJECT K E^sc L d m a DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- h.
- COORDINATOR WESTIf%USEPROG ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
1 OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY EN NEERING MANAGER
/YY'b DUaueSNeujCgYRyA,,A1RSANAeeR saen w
' DUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGZNEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
,) -1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: -
M . Franche.c c) SED NO,: AEsyr- loo i l
d) REVIEWED BY: -[' e) DATE: 8//S/86 (Wes[nghouse) f h\
(Essex) T f) HED TITLE:
(CMfen 5 is in prec.ed.m am 4 provdel on E . S. Le3 4
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g g,f h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Compo nenb acn_ nd ava' dab \e on ESP
- 1) DATA COLLECTION 0ESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
C.R. S u m ys (RuoO +
1
%Lba A tR b6k (R%Q j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EOUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
0 fRrs. r e.rro c5 b.a Ye_
a h ce of compne4.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: gg dg k ce'.ms.-4s.
. s
's
, '- ^p-s >
3 'u ) gg q\g g
'a M %' )' .s : h b J qk, m , 39 , , , .
-- 's C T G ' ^- (3( ) w ? <. c . 7 C \-\ C 0 -x c J. O i :.. .c 's
.3jg, Coo \hov43 c dq sd g4 g 4abaTw : r. h u,\. ' T a e m a h a g m y 4 Q y ,
A u b d w c q <,.d1 d 'u h . Pro dq,m y ;,g.
% 4: C W 6 (5n<k<wd A m h ro e 1, . ., N
(
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT MANAGGR C
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER l
- b. ~
WEST p uSE PROGR K COORDINATOR .
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
Scr str7Mors & r:
srfm s /, z. .- SMp S e.A9t-y v+svd3'fsPLU P60 La iposc g ap Mr M &3$s,s&4p- M $W f./M P e f W'#
- EgydG stgnsrv y
,Mr 2: AQscer) t/stts yo ogn9Mwt*
AWFM CG uJr o f- 7W f Tc Tw. * /- C LO C/C cd M**'iftt TW 4 Y V*, pg figt. t.4-yt ap fpor c A-714H ** !L V P&V NPf!k C/ f
- Y w coe t. s.JM
$~ WT Lkm- I DUQdESNE LIGHT COMPANY TNGIN ERING MANAGER s
A DUQUESNE LI
. ~n . 7M-FJ~
COMPAN#7R EGV ^FFAIRS MANAGER
- f. $ W&
DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
's
ceuqcnenb h sk"A 'n F*'h
- O P""
on E m <c p r .y shoWcen het 2 e 3, _ ,,, ,
seeceo .
COMPohlEbJT - REVtEW & RECOHHEWDATicN 5.G . Aa F.v1. Emp Conhot Pmysa. N ESP wth a S.6 . A Ew. p-p arw n_ $ P 2a. G.F w P
- P e%1 l
N4 l
Tndicab'on of ED. AuWe"9 b a N_Es? w;m me n ec ,ssa ng q u p.
(consny Nd i
h esp A We. nec sary_ egep.
Tcvg (ze.s) ( 53s r) Pc3 vile.
L 2. A ese am b neemy ye.
bc3ency ((wh Rabe <*6 toop/ac)
N K Cto& . bic!< ESP we a c(ocic. o c- em cc opuaA ,es weac math.s ok l
HUMAN ENGENEERING DISCREPANCY (HEO) RE?CRT
.) BVPS- A PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: H. Franche<- c) sEo NO.: as-% 2 2 d) REVIEWED BY:
< e) DATE: /.5[85 /
(WestMghouse) [ N., 7 2 CR.
N
~
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: [ Ok arranaeme_nk is oc3h V
(OMP2dr'iloke b opccab rs ahens g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Nm e- blame _ hk so6T ac.gs 3.LcV ll6B 9.01 T ACWSAsov 2o6 _
ao8T act4s
- tcv us c ac9T S c "s
- 1.CV us E_
k'i?h $ NN I Nov So h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6.%.d.A .b.
Coupnenhs ace- M arranged in a conk nw;u.s alphabeMe c.
sequence . %e.e.sh. - 4 acmyA accordc q 6 ee--6cs omh%s.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
C. D bu eq 5 RMO3 t Ndtk se hk Ck kuwC WN4 N N l
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Opc&c may ackide. c 3co n
- contrcA c>r may have de4 in reading.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: see_ d d 5 $ ojd dw w d b cwn:.dh.X w Wc b i % *R4-a p a diw N{b\d < 44 V 4 'A O d /r p 'Q S 'g N ( '\ u k' ? 4\ \%'s J, b IlJ .s q, 4. ., w e d d b o r- < d 'r .
Y M ESSEX"HUMANFACTORSPRDdpCTMANAGER S ((Y~/ffh OUGUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
~
}h Mh WESTI p uSE'bROGRAM [ DINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
>~
N A, M DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER Y-S S# N DUQUESNE ,LJGFfT COMPA# REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
~
C8@C 0000ESNE LIGAT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
2 E51- 3o22.
STONE & WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION LEG Eub *.
- xsam No.
Em2m o c. A%,.m. m.i I
2.04 1 7 O'l ZDB !i 2,09 l 2go 1ll Lcvusa t.sv nsc t cviis o Sov aou Levitse wov a,so 1
TMWA s din 6.
- ~
C onaseie) f
(%e) be.o w woo d w ereur -
7 CL l i 00 20B I'i 'Zo7 l ,1 2.\ o loi E\l U UsevE tcvnse t.cv u s a i cvus c. tevosa Mw sse McTc '.
- 4. M\ M Attw Gu shers, 99 sc EN2so GM 2.C w s +
1* kEPEft., h EMqtthENC.S SHu?De wN bd b.tb 2.
h ,% a.x- 2.sw l flTLE . cLeaNT ey part p\ qg 3. g .
,,ogger exto arenovso
" " N 40to 5dTT.%
b^/* $
- h ,',
oars RevismNS SY $ $ $ $ $ NUMBER DaTE
HUMAN ENGINEERING OISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) D '2 ~
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: -H . Fcanar c) NEo NO., AEs4 -30 2 3 d) REVIEWED BY: '
> e) DATE: 5/6/K5 (Wespnghouse) [ I R No. 70 hk n4% ~
(Esseic)
]
f) HED TITLE: Transke proce.ss ud i z.c.s ho hee.s of rot m .svaSche-s g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
a.R as F K (.o66 they hpe.
TPAMSFER, ,
o,\ M4 $d b a Res hic 758 B 1. W. tNb. LT5-SA)tTC.4Es e h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDEER: G. 4 l. ) C.(.Q(.2.)
The. t p of co A \s listed ar normally ankte.tpabad Gr 4=
aatodmen of valves, wm c.nwk Ao not ma.ve.g okk c conkrets &c 4ke sww % .n.
( oilkthe swikch osed obere smai\ J 6 dl=. ace anfte.ipahed )
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
con 6li Spev4y D LC W rwo3 l TP 41 B3.b J) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Operadner oNsy use- wro g conkoI and/oc may havaincrease. .n cesponse_ be.
k) ' REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: IG E CE ok' E $wihdes uik ,.
hansGr.c- oi\ k sul O es b h Ccxisishe nh, bsuhr2hmo M
ESSEX HLMAN FACTORS GDT'M)DDGER N e-m DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTIpSE MDGRAM @ TOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
\ -
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
[ ~7'/EWl~
DUQUESNE T C W ANV REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER 8@
DUQUESNE LIdHT COWANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
i HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (NED) REPORT s) BVPS-a ~
PLANT / UNIT M
b) ORIGINATOR: Wber c) HED NO.: ONN - slo / 4-b !/ 5/e /ss
~
d) REVIEWED BY e) DATE:
(Westj6ghd6s'e)' g -
C.R No. 73 T th "
(Essek) T~
f) HED TITLE: 6Cales w'i b mEbD$iers ace nd- needed g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
See. e.wM _
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NIMIER: G,. 6 . l . 3. b.
At\ disp \ays shoA .ncirc.ake vatoes in aGm t uvned;Je usable. by me epicAc wAJ 4,-;"h '"** i ' ""*"'*g-
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLM8ER: .
I Yed(icak-fon o7 Tas.k PerCorrnanc.e Ca.pab {$ bi<S
-N4ab l:g (Ryos) l- J) . SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EGJIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Opersbrs ac. bien end.y b e d.e3 63 e d oc incorred- 6 4o mental conversion
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
gh pc.ed_uces and scales are cornpaVibk g g,,w m,aa c--we. E Mnde % (< d') mo'itipliecs
'w AYs e.d gaa j hs Su y q,d 4 o c'3 {
ESSEX HUWW FACTORS 'NANAGER fM L DUQUESNE LIGHT CGFANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER B lM1 WESTI p SE PROGRAM INATOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
DUG.lESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGIEERING MANAGER Y'Yl$
DUQUESpGHT C@PAdli' REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
~
M.2% w DUQUESNE LIGHT W ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
2 V A t.- 20 I 4-Inch ca6c scale Locabon Aktv\ b DOMP Sh at A.B.C O - I so < t o Pst ca VA6 asss PL tot A e,c Comp Cool Sopy HtA A,8 o - 7oo
- to 6PH vc5 accv Fr. it7 At,et HI 4* WM4(me.
ConipCml CLG; %i 3iDR. o _go x io 2
GPM Vc5 acce et it7 A2.i B 2-t.cw aANAE staar og rw vomp Di n it.ss o -oto x to' GPM VCG -
.1Fws-P3.t52. .
Shn 6en Feel Han'M o -ao x to" Tsi4 V C.6 G.FWS - VI.155
$6e.nbPros %s 0 - 15 0 x to vs m Vc6 MEum{ 2HSS-Pr.to4 A B,c.,
g TW9hT + ISE STA6E.lA,IB STHius 0 - t 50 xtO %) G VC7 GMSs -9I to2. A .B Rc hp - 39 o-iao no %s vA9
. aus - vas A,s,c l
HUMAN ENGINEERZNG DfSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
,) BVPS - a PLANT / UNIT 10 b) ORIGINATOR: . M. Frand er c) HED NO.. e3 \/ % -
d) REVIEWED BY: M. <
/
e) DATE: 2!/h [ (
(Westi(ghouse) b be, bb (Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: hMoA de r e c;t is neh 4
neM iR. scale _ mud 4iol;er c 3 enn,mg .
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: AkMOS. Skca.m cb.mp 86 al A,6,C.
2 K S $ - W oi A ,B ,C.
i M
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: h.5.l.1 A-Pre 55vse ' cab cange. frexn 0 - 1500 psi c, sca.\<.(Face' ceads o - sso x io vsm
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION Nt.NBER:
\fa\iddton .
of Concrol rwenCccktons (6od j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
C D Da M M A.} b f. Old. EG. Or may 'i ncorrecdg %d sca.).e.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: % gg exJdtg scale face be c cA 4e o-gsoo 7 33 ,,
( f?.Jc scap m J ip er a cohneed.d.)
R T cuemm mas as pec e e .
m ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJ % MANAGER K E C L / A n E' d DUQUESNE LIGHT CvMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h, ,
WESTI % USE PROG y COORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
M 4
DUQUESNE LIGHT C PANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
- f. e u1f~~~
i.e.. Area 1RS MANAGER DUQUESN y C g Y
~
,6~291w DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGZNEERlNG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) B VPS /2 y PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
- O'd Y#CNINS#E c) HED NO.: 2 MM - 300 2 d) REVIEWED BY: h, / , e) DATE: I [2 7- [ 7 I (Westinghouse)
[
7 m \ bu (Essex) Y f) HED TITLE: AAl ss /NG AfAIN S TEAMil#E I SCL A T/oM A1 ANUA L INITlh TloM SWITcFl (PVSd8vrTo^/5.)
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
SWITC H AAAIN STEAAALINE ISOLA 7/oM AtANUAL INIT/ATIoM h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
IklT/ki/s# 36*/7CH A htAIM STEAMLINE ISdLATloN At ANVAL Doff sV/ T &XJST dM THE AtAIN Csk 7$rL BOARD 3,7. 2. I i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
VERIFicA TIoM of kVAIL A8il/TY , A 40 F, Go L l* I j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
DEttic Lc DoES No1 EXIS T ON THE AfA/N con Trot GpApp To lMPLEMENT THE PotLow!"G ofE M Ton TasW l 5. s, l.T
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: _. _, T 'N ghjp g A h1hlYN STEAhLING $R LA7/fN\tAroflA TL Swi7cH ep -
THE\ &ld' \ 'J k ~
%c*}
O DQ 'hd\ C i D( Q g yg Q g ,- (
I'>3 \M \ L o-sw p k%q ltosn 6 g.y g % . g-
% 7m' v~h w& a6 . 6bW3 sbA 6 wh b P< / sc -b cas s b h 6 wtsA 69% s 56\bws . .
Cucac Paocetuass q\
ESSEX H'UMAN FACTORSWEdT MANAGER
\
, /we DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
/
WESTIld60VSE PROG p ROINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
p -
YYA y sr 3 % A~ W "' -
l DUQUEUNE LIGHT' COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER f / 7 /(~SW OUQUESNE LI T C0f4PfNYNE'G. AFFAIRS MANAGER hkwd
'DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPAhY OPERATIONS [4ANAGER
Attac m rur C t. ARIFicATlWS To HED No. 2.
- e m - 3 oot Sn. 1 oF +
THg CONTROL 5_D5 tun $gp_lN . HEP No. 2.59W -3001 ARE Foun _wasTi sa.use OTt. . TYPE _lUSMBUTrow$ ._
t oes taplE D A $ ItaMs. 789, 'lto 3191 AWp 79E. .IN _
._ THE . N AME PLATE _ E9MAVING _ LIST { P87tD. Il-30-8d" . AW9.__ PR8wlNo. Itt41-RE-tSV-6 .
INE NAMEPLATE _Ll$f5 C 4u.)__ITE M&__199_ANp_30_L_ ____ ___ _ . __ _ . . . . _
l M N >l STRAMkiN(__I_Sek& TAN _ _ _ _ _ _ . .
SYSIgM . Lavgi, Ac.TUATieel ___
Ts_ma A Lirewest 3 Ira ms 741 Awo M1 ARE LISTED A$t
" MAlw STEAMuwa TRLATand _
SYSTEM LEVE_L AC.TV4TioW . _ . . _ .
TRmiu a _ _ _ ._.
IMIL_StArsstur tw Tar " Review Awo _ Prestview " src.Taog_ op Tas_nsp___. __ _ _.
Is D v a g__Syr Imt.i. ins THE En 157 No. Nemafmre weapi_uc. sS_
twsontee.T on twaotavmTE. Tite woRolws- 1.1ST_EPJ5wE_y14** Ruta,_lh conne(T AND Arftats CLEAR. THERE FORE No CMAG_E_la_Tas_NA msti. art woAnig f., l.s RE caem Ewpt9, ..
___ _ _ THE_ " R EviEw AND RE C*M MSMORTioWa"_SEctl*H OF_THE.. HED__ftfC.6MMEN95 THAT
_ _ _ _ . W_ _.I.OBE.LINf_r'__SE__A99ED _ TD__TME . . IEW*dSO4RP TO_ Zw)T RWCT ThE CPaggiatS . 70. Mtth._SeIM._8977M _1*A. A. GivsN _ TmW . _ SIMu i. tad E**46.Y To
. _ . _ IN8TI ATE . N AiN STEAMWWE . %$en.W. Wo RDlH G. To THli EPPRtt couLD SE Appse To TME Bonap.15 ops.RATieph BELitvtS THis To SE A WORTH w MILE.
Alp 319 Appitiw to cFERmun Twaimwt , IT caw Bn AppEp. Basiers THis OPERAT6R AlD OR AS Aw ALTERNATIVE TO IT SOMs 7YPE OF PAlwispfe OR TAPlHQ. OF THE 8seicH6o4R0 SHooto 85. CcNaipCRap To DaMAnceTE THEst
Atrac % wr CLanspacAT lows To HED No. Esay -Joet. S4 7 oF4
~
C o m R ot.s. ._.S H etT_4 of TMas AT7mcHME47 SHows Tar PRasawr Annweemany oP ..ZTEMLit9,_7.10_CtRMw A) ... Awp_ .70, lit ( TRAIN B)._ SHast. 4_ 4Howh A su56serEp. DemancarwL.or Isass_. courm usi'*(,. . TAPE To Gneur THEM 1
1
._ Awo.. orPast . THem . . Fnam_rne _ _tasswoma...op_rne._ as48A _ .. . . _ . . . _ . . _._ .
1 Tet tourm._b_.RavatwA Pon__si-LA.4e__sv-t sHaw6p h T _fea t___.
l Awt OSMO ENNANta m POR THt6B W Ah b 6AA. Ah %181.E, n -
AJ.bg 1 lo- t3-$Y
-Me -
am m-6e > -ee. me e N
MA
'eMm ae.usmmm,.-
quem we.. aea h_6 egm--,-+-ee. -w-gne=.emm>-w- 6 en . e .-e-em. u- mus a e
,may._..--m.e w w .. .- ,,e, ..
- dW-ha.m - sha h *-mr=+-- '
a _. . - . - _ _ . ~ . - . - . ._ - . - . . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ----
CuWtimcATwk TD HED. No.10w M see. 3 op +
Ext $reeat, Altinno66EMaert CF Cm 78),W,19 w M1 cenc ., muw. itte- as-tev-9
< MAIN STEAM LINE SYSTEM LEVEL ACTUATION 24 -
W 8
. = _
l /3s Y D I ' ' "" "f %\ g'
-EARRIER)
-kr smros it sw>
l o (78 h (791h 8
= ~
, 3(( l
-ggy lLamSRKaaneel I 1 y b D D Qg
- NOTE 21 4 m
(
NOTES 5,8 arl6 e Y-AVE m; IVE. srx Ii *M I*O R
-p l- 85555 2 5'asmaa '
@ @ E ~
umana d -
@drm I .
~~
umagant a g% wsns w _ f t -
99 u 98
-.n _ - ,_. _ 9an888! ., ,._,_ _ _s . , _ . .-
CLaas pications To Htp PJo. Esg o -3oot Atracumar
""N O b I7tMS '789,190,79, gpo g MAIN STEAM LINE SYSTEM LEVEL ACTUATION I
e 24 -
I .\ Ml nC.
D {
~ ; 8"
! \ BARR$R)
. ; -w v
smros it sw>
l 4 (78 h (791h 8 e hl t
. ~
, 3fy [
_gy ,ggsersaisee 1 O "
O AD o
" NOTE 21
_hm V/
N(OTES 5,8 arl6 a
- g. l-- ,
!, . /s.itiivu xvg: s rx
-~ % e ._
p
- i - _
n
-m
( iD MM 1TO M BA R 1 t -
re;esgaisp p wassa _=r ' -
n 8va
.E 98 swa g . . .. . _ , ,, . m
,, = . . _ - . - _.
HUV.AN EN3 NEERING DISCRECAN31 (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:.' ki . Fcan A c- c) sed NO.: M M -Il 21 i
d) REVIEWED BY: h- f - -'d6 e) DATE: [#!S!86 (West % house) f x M (Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: b_ h a . ark oh ' och Inn alc< f 'nierar ch'cAl \ AdiAc ., -
g u.manahan in,s ; mimic lim , and symbold.,on ASP.
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
ME.L.-
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Opcew Mermance can b. ,.nhorua
%i kk=
4 W Wn atAs soc.L as Aem c J ..n, colo,-anarnien;c.0 M pr .nF, %% .m. msng %m A As7) (c. 6 6.t-
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
(Q Srft 0' W
" Labek +Loca6n Ads, j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (e) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
pre y [oca.Jon d hegg., ss
- a SNA Ae d yea-ree error d /or delay in respose kme ,
k)' REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
k y Pec-(narie.nh { hh q anA demvcukm- as wended. m b s6ne.&Wdm H Fe hviu andin acc_erdan ce wik H G m e c[; p e a ft e n 3 FesMig bm b %V95 -2. CRDR.
b sugofdd docu, -
s-ei ESSEX HUMAN FACTO
)ECT'QR 1
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER l
B h W:A WESTi p SE PROGRAM C % INATOR l
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPO3ITION: . <:
> en_ s ,
w.
l L
EM- I L1 T DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 7 / 7-/8 [
ouGUESNE upT COner* ,u. AreAIRS MANAGER t
rss~DUQUESNE LIGHT. COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
1
. _ _ - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ . _ _ - . - - . - - . - - - ----- - - --- - - -- - -- l
A T TA CH MENT C LAvu FIC ATioNS To EA8 5 -lig)
~
Nr.,Ta TsnT THant NAVE _6ae,4 Cumwoss Mage To Tag ASP _ 5:wct ras
_._. I Muawet,_ __ OF Tat __8Eggggwesp__swEc._. HPE __RE vity _o A T u r__ A S P. (J. e " A LT-
___ERNmTIL $HUTOgwRfANtt._RUMAN_ F_ ACTORS EN6)ME(6,ldG_. Revise E PArgo._ t-ts- 31).
TMESE___C9mMGES. INCtV0E T_ME__ ARP_Lrjow y Pgl.craow og _ . RgLat.AT*LOF . CERTAld hg5 09 The ASP. __ __ _ ___
l i
THe Pancese LasawwG Awo DasancArtes cowraiwso tw Tas swsc nee __
Review caw avia,_Ss u6so As A GuipEuwt _
F6a ASP Ewamwcans97. ..
emwe
+-,4mh 6--
~--som,m-
,--..mm e-.
eN- -erm4*
e '+eremum nod -ew see.se w w 696WJ '*s'6h A ' .
. _ . - _ -..y .,. , - - , . . _ - , . . . . , . ,
O*4 *
- e 9 ,, --..e .w. .-,-%
+a +4,ie-a,e-=g-e me.
l
-- - - , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ , - - .-.c -,..------.--a-r,a_ - - - - - ~ - - , , ~-----
klMAN ENGINEERING O!SCRE?ANCY (NED) REPORT TITC :
l
, )_ bY ~
h PLANf/ UNIT l
b I D) ORIGINATOR:
Ib O hE -
c) HE0 NO.:
o RE m wEo sv A / M i lt - .) Om, i /w/ci (w.stingfous.') g TI t4sdtzb (Essex) b# I "' dN N' S ' 'O f) HE0 TITLE: Q a \ aci.c a\ ocb cr
~
u
- 5) m"5 '"** * &amc,$wca6c m A,ai3,aic
.y.& .ca,y lu a .
m,qn, qn o Res t1 h) PROBLEM DESCRIMION AND 070C PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
(, ,% Q ,
I The a cra,1 me. w ,
cC displays. ss occ t3'ca.
% f 4clid w arMnp in alpiube! , c sequa. w
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMP Nt.NBER: va ch cab cf bask. pec6c yun c, cageb; As ; sw L4,t. y (' R- 4c5) L.1.1.1
) Wb Ad: ion CR4o6).
j) SPECIFIC NUMAN ERROR $(s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Opca6cs rs_sponv o s y 6 d e l e y e c_\ cl e L heased 3 cck Ane 6.c J,spl ay 4
P
k') REVIEW AND RE00* ENDAT10NS:
1N ^
SLCegNec.~N Y E] 3e '
v.
1 \) * .,
I t' be -oh d L.L ' aM 4 9 -(,' c1 J g 1 suc)cysbcd ca u .,$ s are c A6e. - m a & w A vTo\a k =d tws Wid Qfi (MbiO ou p T, b k .10.
o hN hh (y %M, 3ap r. vel Leb'$g dN P-
- h. A ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS RDJECT % NAGER
/Y '
w zz~ $h OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEACER n.1&ti
- WESTINdn0USE PROGR/R COORDINATOR .
- 1) REVIEW ANO DISPOSITION: ,
$.n &
ao.u u .
n$ Io-I-Tr 0000E5NE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAG fY ?" $
000DE5tfVLIGHTd2)MPftnY REG. AFFAIRS MAN
- 2r >- e - )
DUQUESNE LIGHT ' COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAG
, .4 a. . . . , . . . .
2vc 6 - zoor "~~::-
.s . _ . . . - - --
.w _
p,
. 1, n a ,4 n -, c-qa . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ .
. i i -
Tl l ;4;.hbl
' Q lulfilbp e- 'F s_ a ...,....... 9... .. . . . $t , ga m g ] y["
l; h..* WN G liti l:fai 'hillid li j-i ii ggg i.jg,g ir ll
. j , f E l 1 lll," Rid , @d n 45!1!I P ll a -
i i 4i -
m14 l! !!!!?!! ll l j l lMd i I
i EL! 4 ii T!!!?!1 ll
. l 1
llM,w a s ta lli Talit ,
ll l g
- - -'u ra az r.w .q l ..szer M ll,,l
~ '~
!-AllG:Id I h i III C
,r ,
m,m
~
i ,
o ,
IIIE: I he E24 l,[y gl w ,,6 , '5'SL-f ma g
]
l l 48 8 ,
4tlBRth :P :i' d r o , l i WW bi a_
ii
' 9
'i ga il i
- f' Befusa I
, l J k
, j gidla s i
fi%sbl
,,WA k
,['gi o_ g@i 4 d l l stril d a 1 pgmgp u
- s gen - rf 1 titt M-1 ~ -
i -
i 3 n 4.- lb l
W l i il1H A tii1 % ! 18 Ils i li i $ g l pr_
._ / Ig irl ' '
llvl l
l N* Y ll D :!I14. I t!!Il<l*f l!! -
i n la allelLWE ~
i &t-N 2 !. I!! lr "
I ma' "r '
l lJ.Babett42 PROBEM [- 3 ,g.......
l
- , l Q.Babsit=d I %gg , ga,Ma[@ a
, .% g lp ,
. . . . .. ..a.. . .~. l(m. .w.;
b
] l m ._ ........... ...... _ ... ,
i
. ,l I " titti bt M... ,d
~
a thri ei E' l l l*
lmi i n pil ilm$O!'IE I8.e!! ' h.r !@!88aphw:i i
l m 1 !!' li i! ll !
c : : me 9: i- -
i g i
i..
Il Y " M
!!!p/[8
=========a, lg e !
8
=H ==x d t m e h -$
e_ + .
) n == =p '
1 r-.- -
, ,i , ,,
...a __,
2 V C (:, -2 cog ""^# " " "
~~
g, - .
. .=.
,}r
," 1[ !.' tl -
- . p T ldEsbl f ;#
j_ ~ .... .. . . . . .;. . . . . . . . . .
'#, g'
- 5 hulilhp1 inggs
<g5 j g;g7 i
(:.i l ~ ) q:' si:: W,tr l[ it Ild
. i l O. r i lhi !.fM 'F .
'.[l I
y' l IIEHEI L
{ jiii455lb! ,, RIElid I 1
' 4' l , if4 I lli!!!iHbi '
F l fj !! 15dNd d J4 lll II -
- i
! ! ll , , e4 ei!in!rP ll l! !!!!!!!
l l Null d5 -
$14 ll 5 lliM 4 I , til4 ti 15!!!L ll l *
, l ll,But he I sa a 14 ll i
L!alin_ ll
. , l,, - -
--%= = == . e . . q i ...n=r_Miqi -
,i 41I0:14i $ .Tf a 4 i. gggg si n
,'[n
~
g $ !d )
y g = ma l ! , i ,,
, 'fSfd "%!ll r Il !% L o , ,
5 'is g w 48 '
i ,
er 2 ggwg 4 W ;;
!l $, h
,- 5pW i ,
- i , i M h..ll i
,[b. -
y , b' ll IndW8 1 i 'H - jEI HT u d R$
Li!! bl 8 '*,,E E Nd H
ri-R!!!r&tE e. !h i
ill fin 1 li
~
% ll tiid A 610 td l
- f l'k W 4
~
i l FF-
- - 7- T-l iG Irl l l l #* i a:!!ns. t ll<l!II ll i
l a e g ist iel N 3 t-E; 1M> M 1 1 !! r w rWid 8 f......! .a l
_ i l lJ. p p m e gg.
, l Q.ppsit=d P I % 3 l E *l P g g M.[@-
g g a
,J
., i l p . , .- . . . . n j q m.w
.a i l ,l (f], j_ l u ._ ........... ..... . .. , , ,
I i' mn ist ie M:,=7@P$* ..
p . . ,
a l l* mu res *8 . ;I :n i -
l -
1
- a l m
.!. h $:!!N i me e- vi ,- !h h eg *
!@!"I .h
- NI 'I i.
lT $- ; -
e [ =! = Mm4=
~
l
+L___ i.
= = = = = = a, = = = = -
ly =_ = =P_ _
__ i e r'
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) bYI'$ - d f PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
6 ( c) HED NO.: O VMN/3 d) REVIEWED BY:
I e) DATE: I -
(Westing 66use) y /
T id (Ess'ex)
\
f) HED TITLE: sea gin 6 a ca 4ct, pc.,c.sek, clo G noA b c- N I Y Ceh$ on SCO 2 g) ITEMS INVOLVED Se2 Sha h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G. 5. \ . 9 a
$de Mecb. io n Sc_a.6 W'M cace nob cow'okeoY u2% Vne dafcee oG precise and ac cacy needecA by %e cpenhec.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION git s (_chs c s o T<3sk Pa.<6 m capaioil.%s , E ba6 f, h (R %s3 L.A.L.1
) vd.Am b w (R40 0) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
hyra;bMS reqpose may h delay-eco
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
N o .,e n e SC 6 <U C- Gk se g g cfMhg -
^
T .f A sd po,n Le'a p.%csekrasccmaAh
'O % (Chr\/hrt v'E n OCGhr- I-is realad on 4hp_ Sca\c (chsp)e mA s6pe% A mm@ n s on sAb scM so 9 b s< (. *w Ma rwsk gd 1 gte bs d a, sw e.g .
\
ESSEX HUMAA FACTORS PROJfC MANAGER
//A 1 ,n v DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTINGpSEPROGRAMCQ6RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
so -
/
. g _
,. ' }
I N. -
% Sz.uc.E W Y bha > ll-r 7 -fs DUQUEbNE LIGHT COMPANY EN INEERING MANAGER g - /
si fs 7-N-[T DUQUESNE LIGj/ COMPhNY RSd. AFFAIRS MANAGER we 97w
'DUQUESNE LIGHT t0MPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
- - e em* an m# * * *e % - y , .% M w ,
by, U $ # ,
w .
\
)
em as - a w M d aredud-pons cf io . ... w. V cW . sz, 5 e .,
"r , s c ze r Prv rm... e 4 dl .s G_4 iE pg res - PI uca ,4c2 ,,cadulien-s o( 50 .. .
N. . [. . .ol cdm3 .
cas e2
- ts Frer- e .. _
ekcer.g m.sM_hs. .J 7 hpAM.o o no, Wt' , W e >
+ M 4 Em .--a
- --ee6-
,. .me .-ww
% O CC=%iuCtwi.lnek re3d . .s e c a
myhA G:e ad K ._. .
- N ..+_e.
m-== sen 2rsC % W i @ y 490 - -. _
tc
. ,._ .- . ___ F
\ .. C D '.. '
' 'wckd._k.c 2"Q' _.O 7 3.'
u .c \ ec$ c'o 9 ts h are nce ceahc_y_3.wrde d Nc(2.M _. , 4 B R 5 r_
aL4 ta__ _. 4 dii d ..
% 1 - m 5' D"g"".y_L, 5 .
y,.q.. .. _G3. ._4_. _ .
';n - c ( 7 %
,_ 1(Ck- - Md I k' 'h -
e a gua.e wm.*h 4 ese a.e-.* a e.w =
CCS-TI "G u23 . . . IU" J 5~
< ".4 ~ G cd ..wd .u M G :-
nw ri. u s u tsgis ac- : .
ice ccJ y b e s
[ g_y p..u.A c .y_ .a- c-- Se.
e nd , <. .
.s
.. .. .z 2 &Ak-2213
- *.4edewee-
%* V '
- 6
\.,,-.. . -.. J msr u ma c_ % s,w u 6 w ,w 3
3% c mc ~e ,eArc 66. , -
7 7a .9 - 731 9 6
(n d e _ hc.9 E_ _Vil y_ g c e , Qca_q 1 .C - 7CC " )
I l e w e **-*-N
. gm.w,,. e-m.e..eN.
lh C_LR icRA\ . _ . _ _ to.~.% 1. 5.,%
fPI ceJ.- L.s .. ., _ cam .m ,wM__6-
}
ahs UTR 9ec k O
asm Il +45 M % !co Sr J. 50 sor
_ b. _' ' ' b_ . ~ ' ( v _ _ . _ _ . C< =' d 5 ^d Oe'CCb#cb (~ IC S b #g'w c vu 4, he c,aci [39,5 - 586 2) _ . _ _ _
\
em-4y. p
.e'.=4he,mem.-w.. ..-m.+=*
am .*4
. + pmw. e . e.g m a st_ c.~ 6 be mA ( 3s. 9 - se s a )
/ a s t v. c,,sca\e , c w A cannJ cua b< w aco.y.., m 4A .
v i
l
- c tv S - F f t a v y, $. y 9 9 6
..r _ _ _ . . . ___.__.._____ ._
0 F to $ i :I q77 9s1 qq7.
.. og a g,m 3
. .f ., . _- _. _
% $p.r Fw Qu 7 , g ,, , Lt ;,,, q ig 4, g, y
1 1. LL - 2 211 p % E n FL to. A,6>L\ p s
, s, f4'" I< m', :.1 )* . , , 5'e i J. . s
< . . . Je g cc) Sca <.s ('-% I '
wh - d , , <v a- 4' . c r cJ - x - .
~ )
heben C - m c- -
) c .w gCSS F R ',M A ,6x . _ _ __ . . . _
.., Aw S4 P % J 3= .1% I qcdL h 1 N' A ' ih .n ~ r ea di o_ __
..g d w fcO g res p a'd_ _is_ _. A $p M _._ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _
- -==v yp L ,,. .~m _ em--..-e- om ws-.
-m +me = w-6
-,w.y .- --
m em
-aoet,= -%+eway-. a=+ - -e- amuye e4.muus weme same u
- g. __ .- __ . . _ -. . ._ _ -_ _ _ . -.
. . e ._. ___ ..
gp +-.eeep- m_ em .
,.m e.ees se si ww m ens up eewe. -e -
da y m -e.e.,. w .wmm emi m we, 4- eme- m-
,ig.
- musewmasse me e.- + -
sw+ e mw .i .e.,
mW_ m -w M-w .-
4 w e- = cm y m. - .--e w .+ --
e ., r* h ---**ge a e*
- M -
e , e p -. m.mmw+, es-,-
me
l kkbm&w% l S W W iG HED*2W# -%t13 h+p; inks w ._ 4 e yacisely de. fined to ac.bauy be read en scak..
RC.S WR P re e ce t149 ps%
PD WST t. \ g4,3% i n As, Skeamline ?ce w re sus ps%
$% 6enerab NR kval 3 . 5 , 4.5 , sa .5 */o
@(_S pse,u re 181, iB3 ps% .
AFW % 3 (,a. 6pm L al Feed. 4w 36a Sem s C, pre. Ms Ps t c, RWsT Uvd W inches
'RCP Amp H5 a ,s MS6 M& we. 4 5 - so % G5 =\ )
Ar7AcHmaar C L As,l mcATi695 To HED No. R.m t s - 2.t :5 SH.ioP3 1
l MosT. __0 F_.lTHE__ S PEciFic Iw&TRuMENTS LisTap tw THE HED
. APPE A A To __BE APEq,umTE . _ I F. THE... SET Ps NTS .lN AufSTitw C$w $E
.8CVISED. WiTHouf $ $* _ fMPACTtW4. _ Tet _0PERATjoN O F _T s e . P6.a w r? IT
._APPeAns. Tant .lw. Mnr (.Asts___Twa_ sat 3twis_ _Ana _ Mont Pnacistw .
DEEtwto TnAw.. Ih NECEnaAY Awo TasT REvistar _ Tat _ 5eresiwis_sNeutp. _ _
NW HAve ANY Impact ow PLApr oPERAThN. IT IS RECoMMENDEP j __ __
HowsvespMaT_Tas SELacr19 on Twasa (. Awo Awv oTnsa) savPomis.._aa_
co-enoiwaigo wire av-a so Tust 6 wxmar APPnerminta BaTW 6V-1 SN D__Sv- 1 wtLL HNE THE Samt S E TPotNTS.
Fon Twa Fm awiw6 IwsTaumrdra TME HED STATEMENTS Su M gir TMmT Eit utR Tan Paz.sewT TNarmoMrwra ARE IN ADE_quATE OR T'H AT res_ftep STATEstNrs ARE A MihawTERPnETATmN op THE A cr um6. orggerigwn,y _
REAutREMswTS. Tatsa IwsTauss975 Aat: . . _ _ _ _
2.GLSS _LE_100 $cALE P_ TID N6T Cova R NEEDED RAN6E. THis wAh_ Ah50_ _.
hoTap Id H ED No. t.v.15- too7 App wiLL B E _ N a w oc s p.
As PANT op THnr hep. _____
_.__ 2.525..E FI 945 Awo 946 hep _SIMES TM_LNSTAveWHI_ MV5T_. St. REmp FReM .
l
. __ _ 39.5 e To__5_85. L THat Nvmesas__ Wane _Psosmacy
. _ OsTAlpep__ Fasn__ATTer.gmENT_3_ _olt ._Eo P_
- E c a - 1.1 *.
_ATTAcWwt_s _ ,_Howayma, .1s. _ Arruc moi,s. To STEP 11 of l
E c A - 1.1 .wmcH REgvines Tua OPERAToA To oPERnTE THE APPRotninTE Hunaan op Hm,7./ cannra9G Pumr5 To Pnoviot
- FI942
(
l Awp % M ewtTon DiscHAR&E Fkom THE 1.WSI Pvm PS.
THanspbnEy h Tas. hep STpTamsg Tant vAtoa3
ATTACHMEur l Connitic ATiows b HED A. terxg- 1113 SH. E op 3 fRM 39,5. To 585. t GPM Must at RaAp is luce A4EcT.
._ _ ___.IME _Existeur _. issraumeNr Hos A sq.umns _Roer sces.s Fnom o .To__5000 G.PM._J8evt.. losoGPm TntRE_ta. A Div>W4. Fon ArrasumAra4.y
. ._._ _ _Ev5Av_LoofrPM._ _ h_ &_REmptwt . A _. NAt.v5_op ^l61.5 GPM lS_P.p6680s K TaEN ALT
- ou6H TME_ SErner__ RAY HME. ID. _ .
BE CHANG.ED To EITHER Iooo GPM OR lo5o GPW_ No HARD_ WARE CHpaa GE APftAti NECEskARY. __
ESIS E Ft_tib_AND 943 b THue.s INWRmRNri Nett.Mt M p u " p l.o w . Ai Iwol&ATED I N_
THE HED C pro * ^*LY_
p DPOW A T T A r.w m t w T A 6 p seP
- ECA-1.1 Awo SinP 11 op THAr PR6CEndAE) TME OPR.RA?St is Rectuinao Ta Paavica A " Miwimum ar FLo_w
- ___
Rad 6ws. FRom 39.9 To 585.1. CAS A puNcrian op Tmd. ___
THE Exisitwt, Inc.Trumtwri NAVE A Stunnt Roer_ SCALE _
FR6M o To loto GPM. A8 eve 200GPM Tatne la A puestow _
Fon summy to c,em. Bai ow_ loo s rm rw ang_ u t_opi t Divisiews.
POR 6 ANO lotGPM. _ _ _ . _ _ .
QWE OF Tut P St&TED Punposas on Yur f%ocu punt.. _is Ta DaLnv Drettim_oF_THE_lwST_&Y_. _ REDuci>tr ouTF t.aw "-
In- OP_EMmDw&__IN1ENPS ._I6 ESTAouan_THE Mwimum SI
. _ __ ___ _ _. . __. EL *w Ah_APPLitas6s__EA6h. ATTACH A4EMT. 3._0F ECP "ECA-12.')
Amp L . .. W_AL50.. To._..TMftoTTLt Tkt. . Fw. To _K'a:P Tets St Flew l
t
.JuST_.A6 ova THIS Mlwimum SI Flow THE ExisTINt, Flow Zweie.nTens May Be WAos stunTE, is ertamTiows IS oWW CowcEsaEp Tum? 8,I L,,r y T, Tug Miwis m at FLN IS E6rAsq.swas witwoor RE44n0 To Mimmtitu ti. ORWDowd
hYYhLum cuY
. CLARlFlC ATtoNS __IO . MED_ No. I.Es W - Ell 3 SH. 3 0F 3 1806eoty_ Ape (vaTE. INE . ACTU AL 0PER ATnW 6 . RE dtvlR EMENTS SNLp_BP.L_ REVIEWRD BY. OPERnhoNS STAR 7uP. 4Roo P. Ip
_ _ _ _h4mLMC- + RW.ST_ _ DR8WDewtL..lS_ AM_0fERA74t*WL Retu.imaMaw?
..lN_ Ints__ca6E_. A__MANGL RILguest swes.60 Se_SusMir.Tta _
To__hwasneait TMis EoRTnaA _ _. . . -
lus, raw.rwn vor N4 M EFwE 5 FI too A 8:c. Awect 3 Twna temme unwt sevana cor segas (Nar Loo. scates),
C,avn 4 Fm) u.JP - Twa Fact Tunt Tunna 16 oww owt Gnnovatw Sgtwggs_o
' 6 a Awe leoGPM Cop The o To 400 GPM &cALE) is .t r a Ano y- p e- -
.40 0 M'k WILL Ga DISPealtsouto As PART OF HEP No. INc6-Mit.
fe ~ pse ECHS - FR LT4 A Apo & Twdr Fac.T Thn? fr la Dipricute To tano Tur Lmu Ewo
(,RcP Wo.t saan,wra.
05 THESE StewARE Roer SCA Las, T. Tnt Rreoseep DeGate op LaanePP)
AcevR AcV la ADDREA1Ro Awa Wats. Sa Dd f aS171swfD A 5 PARr op hee No. EvA9- 2.403.
. Acoariewan. conaipicariews r .
i alc i) 1.RCS - 410 AND 41,0 Listro 09 Tua HED Shouko Ba T.Res a TI fio Awo_4'20
- 1) THE LAsr ENTW oN Tna Pha,a Matuts "AccawooM To SvarAguTY #ED s'tDA-Etl3?
CAu40 APW NR LtvtL D8ES NOT M48et sed 5E f & Sinc.R fr fi R EFEARIN6.__ ..
l In._h4EA E?M-- Twa lev 8L og A y F I, TWE cent _Tamm_Stevi.p_cgscat_
ie.t. a nr i=wnunc~r wa5 e__op coscuaw. _ _ _ _ _ __
N kgS chek _j. . w ^> _ jokMn .Wh s r - W / w L ,. <> x a __.
-.we ...e w-. . ~ .
. 10 %F
HUMAN ENGENEERZNG OZSCREPANCY (HED) REPCRT f
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: . bW c) HED NO.: $MM-J2 2 0 d) REVIEWED BY: !. e) DATE: b[ N (West [ghouse) [
& u& '
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: b ' S ON re<4M AW E on scale.s .
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: G;ge is.k d wd {'tSkl h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G. 6. I . R a.
ScMe. Seleckien - Scal. oniks are nch eendsMe.n4 w$ degree of prect s'*o and acceacy need.cl by ope..we ,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION Nt.NBER:
YeF.h ca.h on oh Toak Me4emargeg, G ab'il' P hI e s
- uM (:4 y Cg4os) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
b y etS.k o r s Cosponse, m&y be. de.{ayqc{
C V 'l n CC W4.C-- .
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: $c ink codb be roecked og Sca\es as appre9N ah . A\ so ., cound oQ s,_kpombs 4e 4he, ng Conse.Nah Ve nornbe c i s eagesb,cl .
5 3u qkg qg ,
dm ESSEX H M N FACTORS PRO MANAGER 1MLw OUCUESNE LIGHT COMPpsiY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
& L kfa WESTI @ SE PROGRAM C0 % NATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
g # ,t e r+
& . d
? ^ - ^^ "" 'A- A ;5"g,[
S::_A h r O.I fy W, " .
sa w s sL a 6. s dd'~ s wM&
WAs W E~b . A , i nk Otf00ESNE Lf 3HT COMPANY ENbI Skr RING MANAGER
~ !/ ?"/f5F COMPAgfREG/ AFFAIRS MANAGER DUQUESNE L W P 97 w
'0UGUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
2M H -gazo RC.S Colcl leg tv.mp ('F) GU;l 2 2Rcs. Ti910,Mac 5G % ssace. 40 toss 525 ( ya_
2 *" "' '"5 * "'
io75 avs Almo g e e.P m W R RCS % c._ (e.Q 3 foO -
a u a a n u.s. .,
% t4R 6e.\ 54.1'/.
. t rwan L1 54N,9M,49'1 FRzR teve.\ 57.4%
2*cTM LI 499A,ago, agg RCP ccP _ sys _ cc.hrn flew 60 < 16 O CC.P - T l 105 A S, d _ __
HLMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (NED) REPORT s) av ps /a PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: -(k bar\t Aa c) HED NO.: $ # N -//O T d) REVIEWED BY: [ e) DATE: '!3!hN )
(Wesfinghouse) /'
M (Essex) K f) HED TITLE: bbdMEL A kr 4 S b bar= M EtanX3 ryd- hMed kor- ' tdPLAk_[ [mYton g) ITEMS INVOLVED: 6ceo_ M gg4, h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
wqe. 4 6 og d e.4 e W d 6 6 64 h & t o c h o.ve.5, hMed_ Qor- nl. 6de4Qh
> og a.wg en4e_. e4 a.:id_ki~ tLn_ . patin_a do N::rt hk o dah l b.i.tk w g . (,.1. 6. a d. O
- 1) DA A COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQU NE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
Lo.be.t.s o_ul. Lomh M:lA. %
DLM N M03 T ~P t,.I s s.to y l
l i
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
oP kn ob44.b d(CA di pkop do l g ,se. m tcce o) "d6 w.m ee d eo%M
\ w.s g~ %.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: g r\Atkt.na o_ h p M .,
kot- bbe. brig Ek GXdS gQ g@ d M ch M t3UL e_O.A b t(L.
4 h4cnq h as YAb A I' S & dp ba- numeric bY on <& Coceck am of a # s4hs /p H p aA , m a m m &
MG (k t 2.
Y ~ A ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS MANAGER
- t/a DU6UESNE LIGHT CON'ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
&LKLL WESTIpSt PR(XiRAM INATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
e l
DUQUE'SNE LIGitT COWANY l ERING MANAGER
~
f j DUQUESNE COT 3NY IEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER Wh$w
'6UGJESNE LIGHT COWANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
, NE'* .' +- X-+ -//c 7 6 t^ b A $ gh5. K wels *.
r% acha%n 435. reoP Th.am 4 dou9) h_sm th Mbadi_on egs. .-Cr4c? -riEaI4 & ( ic1o) PWL BA$
md.tn 61rw c1.wn isobb sittb (ioso) pol VC 4 Extboo_k :fkrn i atr- Mat-- iscbh doe stnko Pat vcf
( 1o193 sm %ms m s-t e r n A m + m oe) %_ ac.
drn gen t k p 5 q rv Ll din A>> s 3 (19') Pwu ac.
sp cp.n (st Pdt sc..
- t s i. e g n a .1 s a t m
%eq %d Pa.sa me.ter-. (scs) A a.a Renobr- coch4 me h (* 65 ) Pai sa<
6 l
l
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) BY A PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: N k900 9 c) HED NO.: N' III .l_
d) REVIEWED BY: 8 '
e) DATE: TOW M.tk (Westinghouse) /'
% M (Essex) f) HED TITLE: INCoat WKML'f SG TV.EM1; Aetenvi Anod Aa o AcAo ovM P4:.Ro.O Lanvr.rJ G - Mar Ace a en a maw tmargousp ,,
g) ITENS INVOLVED: SCG 4
ATfAc.wii.o UW h h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
IucouctrioT- Osc oG rae.cu,, Asseni AT.345 A*C ASAWYN-ac ua usca ia c.4. ws me c % au m cy s u co J m~ ~ ,
mm.an uw u.-- ep. . w rim.y aurc e , u.u, 3.3 . x ,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NWBER:
CCWN BNTIONS SUAVEY MA~ % N hN D L,(rg R yoj C')^f L / YT S U d vG' y' 7-fy fg3,f$
l .'
L j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERROR $ts) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
I MA'f 40SE DuMS, A4o/o a, CAAs% W oPEAA%R RCs%MES.-
l t
k) REVIEW AND RECOMENDATIONS:
g RC EuGGAuJ tu cou&tTAft" LAtEL.s To corroe,ei To rbC M9bGoNO usta a F W%, Ngoca'ggg, go A&gEgegog ,
$) MIG AC44 l2NL 4 coch of. M94AVd C i JST~
=
x\@ss '
% 5Aa am&s s u g s b A O s U D
% aa<AA p am T h ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJ MANAGER' WL DUQUESNE LIGHT CO W ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h' <
~
l WESTI p SE PROGAAM INATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: -
f& gg6_i - 9 c.s-r 4f \
/
y u t yyAmM saw.nA .
- I b ~
6[//
DUQUESNE' LIGHT COWANY ENGIEERING MANAGER hf DUQUES A f- 3 / -85~
IGHT Ctr>KNY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
[8 YN
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
H E D
- 1. N Vc % -l/ II Lock ce ro )sesrcacy ecAoss LAsets i E)(Prf4PLC.S - -
AARefPPux Id f.asa Stan i@ rELj7%77 - -----2 gg p g yg-D. 94 No . tercried D Pf, G.fu6 tA)1L)fr .. _. ._ _ __ ~~
syyca VOLTS I, 26 .w.Es. sus r e s .,ve. e n e z . ._ _
e o
w m e- . _ , ,
- -m"****WUP+ * * = ear - . e e mumumm -im-....
N V03 8 U 3 _. _ ._ . ._ A v M iax , A M c a, . _ _
~~
~
~~ ~
Fa si c.i;ase mism. 2.
e O dd 6W3 NN 1 . . . . _ _ _ _ ._ _ _ _ _ _ ,
3 g,y I:sA GC 3 'gu-3 4 Lv Ms abFPimes. .. . ____ _ _ _ .
p g g gc, y,g n e, C0
- j. gg g _g- p63 A 'f' s +"gr"o* bqgt Asu or,,,2, - o k . _ . _ _ _
"* "3 5"" V ' V 8 ** "V
% Oc 1 P63 3f%5* 544isaA.%
Mmid vs R GW(
Geget %y C C, S ame.we os. PvM h 6'M 3 S T M 6
- PJ IS
~~
ra g o W-g4 (: Lv 30 N M P
- N' % b 7Y n b = PQ Oh k e s e.
- - . .. .. . . . am -eisc
,.- , 4 W @y *e*
- trrAm Ptass e.r,
- . - _ . . _ . _. .. .'l CV & ~~ f* i n0M \
CRt.T* UP WL ****
- h. \Q%\ Q .\ $Qb - acos-Pa -
um m ~e m eo-, --
g Nu wSt 866 PvMt 104 ear,,, . g
d[N -((//
g4c c PLMG qpg 4v6e cJi,xr E 4 tb , ng,so ,
(Anta r.i t yyt. W.N8Lh
- 7. 2n .- *gw;> ees %'itt ; WL' ' .
. - . . .c. . . . .
. .t 9 - .
2)$ W4020 br S14 S ..
Pt.3 A. m,Ma Sy _ . . _ _
T$ot.ATid VAI.*W6
_ . .T.M 6 MD4.518 . _. A____..._______....-.
4**9e -6. e h, e O
VAL 6 . 101.
coat'amk Mutu sus ot ge , . sev.aae, .
~~ ~'~
twuwe sanwit.( SEM 6L.Dir W4C STATl*O
- IO$ M" fAMG N .S aym .sovALS -- - -
me d ga
.g . 4 ,.
le-6 *er' .
mm .,
M u.
G
= = > . - ..
1 L. . . ..
I G I
.~- ..
m a e- *
'we.
, w. . . , , ,
H ED+ a &-XN-IllI ABEREVIR'.odi 05LB MAT ma: cot cAJ %r M6GMwads Lin- Ancesvgt.4 i%
8CeA 0 m 4 .. .___ __. Irsta yo , g en te set.r e d . _ - _ . _ . . _ M T 3 Pr_
l OA M . t 39 4 . _
cA.-3 _ . _ _ _ _ %J : _
CRoM ._. M53 __
.__ GB 4 .. S W1__ .
Ebd G41 os S.
Mid .
Syc 581 .. . ._ en 3. _
96 5
_ set 64 . e n -3 es3 .
ocso e.AT' 'L'E _ _ _ _ % d4 _. . _. . .T
$37A k VAS Bui 6 ec- .
swC % f' O A.-) 00} _
FPW \M &ch satucCg P4 OQ3 _
Tourcer Acu.em mr6 AMoumor.q t5 sacouccr ce ust erm an . eenes s.tv.4 .
, = vqpr c um" 851- t #-L SWI
_ Cont w .
EM5e e e ME R. 5M _ _ _. g .1 .
FSb Sercri D eref SL Soar- 2. .
M-4 SGI
(,tO 24r k -g f63
_ STM . ._ triu i
i l ._ .
~" ~ = ' "-n, - - - - , _ _ _ _
1 Hl.MAti ENGINEERING OISCREPANCY (hEJ) REPORT TITI. :
a) 3 ~ ' [
PLANT / UNIT c) HED NO.: 1XL'-III3 b) ORIGINATOR: } i h8 nC3W r _
- _, 4 -)
e DATE: I!I2 !5 b d) REVIEWED BY: .
(West 6nghouse) f M
(Essex) T b^%' L%v\ s Arv incc , wd HED TITLE:
f) g) ITENS INVOLVED:
aNadad \ish See -
)
6,h,j,l h) PROBLEM OESCRIPTION AND 070C PARAGRAPH Ntm8ER:
9,ieYW(O W 5 I b6 c3 nd er ged mg,f ,Qg f
,cL;4 L J gc og, ggd -
3 r % J h < 1 c c a k c\
,g
~
.. ., aClcrk h bl :i- k \ e d ~ k o p r r- aP i d c)id s
N 'fC'ea L.,Cf -
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT CONP NUMBER:
C't) M O C 6 d ci ton C dI '_.>
Q6 '
6g g ,t', We.s , ' %,1dj.13 ( GL4c5Y (, .1,\,b b
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
(1 id 5
~~
TS- C05<1 tv u h c}ce h a ,,,e i
- w I
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
'5bcr.d b kV ( G r rc C b t' <- a e, l i k c_f
/-\ U labks
} GP (3 Ad'\MG_t recommends m/ab i'r a ccorclmw
//fD 2 xrff - /// /
bri of ferms, aldaviafrans d oc9.m H.$ w affroad 7Aa HED reida 4f rebomA fa, Y 'N M ESSEX HuhtAN FACTORS PR T MANAGER
/?f #b OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY RErfEW TEAM LEADER h- < N k'
~ WESTIN@CUSE PROGRAM @ ROINATOR -
i
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
1
) _
i i
ad OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY to-t4-#
INEERING MANAGER d d' M DUQUf5 GHT C @ ANfREG. AFFAIRS MANAGER l
fSW&
OUCUESNE LIGH'T COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAG
p h^ Y d= ~;> s* %
- 2 A ti-III 3
.s 'aw ! %,, s A
/C 3 9 ; N.C - LI lOAA , B .; u u -ce 6
.a.
ic S 2CwE - LR icupt ::
i as <<.,,a s PSE."hM4 ...s Oc 4c I L'
~
+w a ced ._ . _P RI " _ _ ._ . -
~. ;
=-
_..._. - p @ckoP " . - - - . -.
J Sl.$. - F I 44 S Tabd ceA_s NEN _ iN3 . ADR Ag?
suoA red YU \Nd SW 4 -
[ lei
$Eki._.aFLJE_ x P ~L (00,A ,. B . O , C cl ,
3
..___t ab\ s read CO B a. tct fS tCO C2 ac G
.s ch dd thi tco A too Cr _. .tco B cc d
.* ew .>pm, ww &
Si...._SCR$3_50va06 = W c'
elaas ad E C P .___ _ b J ,
_._ .. 4 C Y S h h 0 'v M k =
\abat ~ ea^*\ _ . . . _ . -
SS./B.6'- QC.C.P <PaiC Prio u c y ( c a c '
una.ce e-e. Wo . ef We abase e's Ccc3 n6Nr iL v ~t A % _ ca.me 4 4J wt-ff s f- oN c .ft c e /us cc ec,,, M . / b es c I k g % ,
bCN [ah2 cds EMMC QC4beawedb-s .__ M-@ 6csSpesc)
/ - L.L h rJJ.kch_ ,s O a velL el-( c 7
~
. _ . . + . . . . _ . . . _ . . _. . . . . . i.
BA1 BAS 2 RMSv HCV 1c t 6 ' 'lCtA <-
As %,yg.Xc.a4.m) l-W ce aca We, c,F each eC 64 H a c k i e w e e.<.
, % 'p .
"'is (,! . .. m., (= _.
314, , . t ,11....,,,m, , ,ky,,,,_b.s .
.,...,_,,t,...
3 44 - \\ \ b Te.n I cdL 't o n OF sa La6;1: ,y 4ED 4 Tc h
- a. M k - 1113 Some (abb am 'incornac_k h tabeb on 505\S
- HOV867A , c 3 sa.y : ReGeling W akesbag Tk
. ~_a ss* ses s,9 3 say Ak g % hy sk
%se sh.M be. N b mab:.h 6.. . , T k or T k)
)
- 2. Ex.L g wt e m y cy braAron Aov a oG A.J4. bec. A\ kecere E,we cy bahm 50 V a.o 6 s
hi'ss N ec k id b b in pq S M on h0V 350 sh tab.- e ,.
enc.y Arakr.n HoV 350
a Jbeking proble.ms, 2~-oa con &co\ . "kw L.d Pump" m e.kr T Sb GienF4.ed y p'
~
co nbl Am. F4<1 r%we 7 ar -
Asa s b C ta.n Au x F4<J g eg" Y
d hh astcs Gr bgass. valve [acNs -nov't053 huh label W 3- Ea cg s - sov (os J N
/ Seem e) 05 feve
\a\oe\ -
m *A "
shouM D B" E
sww\6. read Q unch spm( Pv.mp
l l l
3vv -ii G es a d rc. ads . M ets rure. Gefdc reheder Sb 5T y ValV6 \
h -A m r= ads. Reheak.c Cto m con 6\ b4ock. val *s "
[QHss- Hov looA,&3 i Di<sai .
OM ~
break.ers.
, -tk s is. eccced , see_ aeb exisk as 2m-N s E.\O , a Fto C&S A Oni& L ALL real " Chemica\ Abion bk cedrc. re
.B6k\ a oss W sov tooA, tot A,' to* A.
\ abet re=Ls C.h emi f.aI [n'gc.hort y > discha y S W A rend Cht/MiM AddihioA yp d ts,d)d.
t w\ ceads " s4a.% seevsce W6 t- pep s "
P*TAhhia L a um e rre ud<.r- P+m es "
l l
l l
To HED No. E Wo m - 1113 SH.1 op 7 C L A n i r ic ATiows u . . _ cd,pgM ' #" #
Twt Fottowiso. Coe$rurs je Awo Connecrims Arety T. Twe IwoevipuaL Irrms Lisrep ON Twe _ .RE FEnE9cE0 N E D .: _ _ . . _ _ _
.1. _ _ .TH E_ . _ N AM E P'*T L. I. Ts u c_( i . e.
A grLart Ewenaviwe. List "partoli-30-8M..
Fan _ ITEM _108_B_- 1 SMoutp_JEAD & F N C- d_lo_t3m_ M AYE Co R3 EcTim_. _ .
3 THE N AMt PLATE LisTwo Fon " tJrs
- FI 94'1" (. T T E M 1004 ) is
$+
u MicH waao SAFETY INJECTiew FLeme A E5ts - FZi41' -
THES Wompiac ArreAas Ap_teyATs Excerr THAT Tnis is A PAM h s?Aus m T.
Awo AN ASIERISK SNouto APPEAR IN TNa MARN' No. lusramp of ./L_PAsg.
.THg_ SAme C.Ms_gNr A Prugs To ITEM 1009. NOTE TutSE INS _rAmegr4 .
8RE ON VERYicAL BOARD SECTioN A8 Not A&. _ . _ . _ . _
b___ _. _ _ _ __ . _ _ _ _ .
b.L.. . THE hIAMEf_ Lave Last Fo# ZraM 1015__ptF w E - LSjo+ A i JEAPS :
PninAny__Gagos W evgg .
STonAsg__Taww Ls. vat _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
W p_ . _ EF_wE .LMo3 Al _._ _ _ . . _ _ _ . . _ _
i Tut ArrucAeLa MAi.w C.avnet Benne. Fnowr. view DRAww4 3. ItJL41-RE-15A 3
, At.so Rtrans To[Pavanny GnApe warsa ... Levst.". Ori+sa Documswis ,
INCLucin6 Arru cAots Flow Daawins in41-KM-156 REFEA To THis TAww , EFws e 7xtio , As "PaimAny Puwr DeMewenattiep waran StoRAc.c TA ww ' .
THE PRE Fanneo .. . _ _ _
NAmr SHouto St. LlaED ON THE Mc8 .
AND
, Cl.ARIFICATnows To HED No. Eggs - lit 3 SH ZoF ')
Aw A rrE mer ..To respAnpear Tas USE op Tuis Patsanase NAW ON ALL Ev-2. Pasascr..Aw. <ri_.3nev'p. BE MApe - - ._
A. THE . 18 AMEELATE_ _Li$r_ _Atap__Pnayec._ llt41_ _ RE . E5 R 3 I_TEMS. 917 App 993,_... .
._ARE THR5t__fotwT I*aptGATafts.__F_og E FwE _* EI_l0* A_,100.6_A*P_foo.C __ Aw p
__EPwt_W_F_I lo0At 10081 Amp l**CE -rRESEECTWEl.Y.
3 THis la Cannter Awo No
. C HpWGE S ARE NERD 40.
- 5. Tur NnMsELart List Has IrsM 786 As
- ECHS e A0vEoc*. T9is is luconnect Seaca Tuis VALVE la A Dir scr Acriac. Sotswoio VALvs.
CHAW &E NAMarunta List To " E c M S si Sc V t o 6 *. -
6 Trus__E_4twiPMEWT E C c P a P a tc.; IS A SwsN6 PUMP WHICW caw RE fhetsp_
3
._Bom Eiraan Tus onAnot on ihPLa TRMNS. theta FMt4_TEEne Ana
..._Two CowTRots Fon E ctP W P 11C 6w THE M C8. No Cnew6e hiespap..
THe__NamertaTa List Has ITre 117 As * " Emanssac,Y G.s wta pria 7.- t l'L__
_Govsasen $_tgan . Tms Swires is A Govanwen c. wen.s Usse T.
. _ .Cwygy. THa Emdasade.Y Damast Ew&4=E O_PEsp. ANY NAMg_WNetW Cowveyi _
TNis Manuewa, T. Twa ortgagon Swov9_Be AcssersoLs._..A snasme><r _wirw .
Exisnus, Sy-1 Taa**wetour Fws_._TMis Cawra*L_SHousp_Be _ Cassioetta.
._. TWO 1066f064 NAME4 Ant ._ _ .. _ _.. . _ _ _ _ _ . . . _ _
_ EMegs tee.t Gawannyna _ .t-7. _ ._ ___._ ._ .
. _ _ . _ _ . SPEED _ CM4Aeb" ._
OA e
Emensswe.Y Gswannvin t-t Gewanuen Cowinot
C Lanipicariou3 7. Map _.eJo._ En w - 1813 SH. 3 cF "?
ItaM l%L h_ Hie.g_JS Tees SAMg Cowrnet Fon_ . Estac,an.y _ piasst.
GawsR* Ten _t _L_ uses . Tut _ _LATran TEad._ . THE_Temo_ Fen. Irses .
.._!%1..Awo__ til __.N eu6,_._ St._lw -_Asattr4sNT._ _ ______. _ _ . _ _
- j. Efil45_W Nov ~108 8 ANp Z.Rn6stgav 70:A, Sta W_Im G Asovt. ___ ..
PJo C#+mwM NLEptp.
- 4. L408L6 Pea 2. 3 2 5 g s c v 3 C 7 A i c. Awe 742setsov367 8(p. AtTumPr T6 Stewspapiss use oF Ts.ar en TK wussa hhees6r . Pow'r saa raws ruawsss-
- TEucy A5 #w AmfwAy canspela#W6- To THE OfERaveAh HenvEVEA. 3 l
10.t11. Tus Parsrwr TiTLs Fon Tram "I t 6 iw Twr "NAMertaTE ENsnAviwer
- o u ll57 (DArtD 11 83) is : EmansENtv BoRATiow ECHS
- Aov tot __
IIrM '764 IN Twe SaMa Lisr is C ALdp : __
" cHARGl4G pumps sucTrow va!,vr i Faos Beni Acio Tawws 2.CHS
- Mov 350 ITEM " int 'is tw Enson StNet Tum7 N/A w e is Sr_RictLY sol E N o!.p__
OreRATrp Ci.e. Manw No. 16 tc14 5_(56v_to6) . __ __ _ .__
1
_ _ . _ . 3r TITLES LISEp tw TMIL_h/AtattmTE__ List Ant _CoustsigwrLY t> SED 09
, _ _ . . _ _ _ _ CIMits_ BV-1 D o c utiENIi._ . - . . _ _ _ _
_ _ . . _ . _ . _ . . . _ . CwnwstNG_ To THeT T6ts__Sv.6fsSTED IN TMr Hao : " ALTERN ATE a n so
. _ . . EMEnr,suc.y _ SwtATJew C FOR... IrtM 786) AND EManGENcy SmR AT 10N (FoK ITErt 7G4) HAS P4 ERIT. IF . TH AT.. 15 TMs W Mmuuta sw wHICH TE H BV-2, OPERArons WILL vr:Litt TPtEst VALvas Awo/og THE i CoAttESPONotNs BV-1 Valves HAve SEEN 2psNTIFIED SY TNost TITLES.
CtanFicATieds To HED No,1SM -1113 SH 4os7 it . ITEMS. _GG AN.D._i]_gTM cowygot s FOR THE N . STEAM GEstaAron FEsowArsn Pumps .ARE_ l. lit EP . .I N Tat .Nargruns usr ASt __ _ . _
u El A_MAnw FRED Pump tFws- Pt A '______._ __.___
Awo Ela Main Etap PUMP 18 wa- P1f 6 i
TNe6 L a 6 E m t JG- WA% Ay Tua ggevest op Tng ptej&v4 uPau Afvatw 4F Tow, Paavavs vaaseow ese THE NAmmeuvre Liar. Twe Pheviews Lassi, Pen Irew f.t. was:
. " F STM Gaw Reso Pome t sw&- Pil A
__IHit P_qtvst96 ..L A&E LLIN6 WAS IW A M ERt*Ew? WITH TME A METER LA&EA5_r_.
- Ah_.TME OPPitiAL NAmr or Ties E e WIP M EesT AND Dip 967 R_Efter TSE
t Hogw PAcreas Aaract it is Racew3sumes Tan 7 Tne farvavt_Laanwnr. .
__B_ql_RSED Pea con sisrtwe.v. _ . _ _ _ _ _ . . . . _
$..__ ITEMS....tu Awp_U+__1w_Ine_Hama tLATg_u1T__ REAP..LPen. _r. Ten tu). _. .
. _. ._ E38 AvhILimfu.FEtownren PUMP LPat
- P13 A J
THis L.Aasww6 we Rectut>7Ee or TM D Lt. /suc, upow Review or T ng
C LAmpicAwe vi To HED No. tew y - 1113 $H. 3 op7 PntvievLVERhiek oF Tut N AmePLATE LtSr. Pnom _A Human FAcrop Asegcr 17 th N 6T. NEcE55att_To__ggrgAy ras "p A " rannow _op_ rat _NnAR Ne.___ow Tur !
,Rassa.
NAMeP6 ATE AND._ .Twa._..H aME PLATE Snoutp 0. 2- _ To _ . T HE .__3rsAm Gaus44 mas.
_A R5cortmtbi9st L40EL__you Lp _.S E s Sr. AuAL'1 ARY FeEpwmTsA Pump ___
EFwE W P 7.3A
- 14. NAugtkarn L.Lar Etted 44 IS :
u CowpensATE SPILL VLv SvPASS LCHa- Movit5 TJtis LAostuwG. IS C*RREsr. T H u A f r_6tc 4 06a Mta Fnout Maw Da_nwino.__ _
_Lin4L. RE- t.s v ) NAs Tp_g Iweenntcr as NAmir No. FoA IJsn 44 _
Lt.e._lcw M- Mw Ios) . Daawins, 11141- Ra-t su w n.' sa coRnacrap. No orasa_ .
__ _ ._ Ac TMx_Et c asbatY. __
15_ m 31sras SCI Awo Gos' Aer usrep As "QutNea _
Pune* ON Tus NAmrE _
_ _L.167__ Awo OTwas Pasase.T Pewme<rs, Sema SV-1 DeumsutL_IN'.Luptwo_.THE Psan
_. . R E.Pt.n To EESS $ Pli A fr __tt 4 sli.LA__/M "Num .sr3 Ay_fuMPs ", _ _ Rec.mmoe l_... A - A . M o_ . S V.- 1. USE A Comn.w_yJrkg _(,w n33mEMJ __ fas peg nam.El, _
.-_ sensinu e n s w ._ h Nors raar ._is_. Terts,_r.a. Irsats'I14.r .rs cease trar% str,_.st,s.,cos_.39o. coy sno ut, Ats. Se Revano Acconoiao'v. C Twast Ang PauNAnca . Aso Socm.w VaLvas Fen Tgg Pmes),
i C L AMIFic.pnew s To H E D N o. 2.5 K M - Il O SH.Gep7
~
- 16. ITEM $. It0__ Awo___Il1.__ou Namer 6 ATE 1.15 7. ITEM l'8 REA*6 :
MouruRt SEPA#ATo#._ REntAtt RS. _ _ .. ._ _
._ __ _ ._ _ _ _ R E i _ A ( C __ S t a a n apPPLT_VALvs ._ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _
EM_%- MeV 16* A _ . _ _ _ _ _ .
Iram IN ll pea N2 8 ( D. ReceMasso THAT 8v.i Awp (W.t uaE_Ips w __
Names FoA T o s aa ' V a i.v s s Isa Twa StarsMa ARE IoruriaAL. Tus NaMs. unae IN TC gaevat y slausmus ( MontwAE JamsaAnA) RtutATrA Fw Cwrnet B&ect VA6vt* SEEMS ABr />* Aes.tPranLE ALTE4wATavt.
- 17. Emensegcy p,esaw oureur A=_= w ens Aan t.aio Awo 2Peo. No cua*6c wasma.
1%. .NAmte.6Arg_ l.ist ITsM 406 REAc6 :
o CHEMmAL Apotrasa PvMP
- 2. 4 M ' P 13 " _.
_._ -_ DisAsmaa Tsar _NAME SE EXPAwoa0 To
- CNae31cmL ADomed._ TANK . MEcl RUL*Insw .
Pume*. _ ,,
l9. E.955 W Sov 1.co otA._ Awp lotA . (. Irems_150t.15e Ano ese(). LAssi.s %
TNast I EMS T WirH__RapensWcE To C nemic AL IwatcTiew PUMP 3. ls Connect.
ITEMS 150 ANp .150k U.,qss y P14A AND tQSSKP?A8) SHouto RgAo C HE Micat Iw J ac.T t*N FvMF" tJST CMEMicAL A00etsow PuM P". Naimage4m6f N ANr Pt. ATE Ll5 TINS .sefouto Sg CORRECTED.
l l
Cl. ARiflC ATl6 HS To HED tJo. E EW 4 -1113 S H. 7 o F 'l So. Hgp _ SUGGESTCs_ To cwAsc,s T 7tt of STANpsy SEtvecE WArER j PUMPS To " AuxiugRy._5savice wenn PpMPS ". T a g __ % E b fa'?- TITM Fon, Tnest Pumps __Luws.u Ptl A ANP IS'" E
- Pt,1 Q _ H% . Sase cowbiirtNT-LY __ . .useo oN__.6Y-2. __Po ci,ma NTS.. --__ . _ . _ . _ __ _ . _ _ _ _ .
NNr_REE W874 THE QN THE H E p _ _5 t C Tio # _ _ ._
IN SutiMNLT_r1 STA_IEMENT k) Review Awo RecossawoaTiows* THar " ALL L A n tL1 _ 4 Mews.o S E Cetaterz o As LISTED 09 AIIAC.MMENT SINCE IN $5VERAL CA6ES THERE 11 Nor Givtw INAT THE C MAW (e8 WOui.D 83 Aw I mpRev f.
SUFFKlENT do.iTIF ICATioW MENT EtrAER SY 8Eawa, M att- TECHMICALLY COARECT AND/aa OElwG.
Cows 4TrNT wiTn EaTABLIANED TERhlh9bo(W QN 6V-1. ML$p; Tw SOME CASC$_
twTMt Nao
SfArtsawr ^oF wHAY Twa : _ Parsaur LAest SAYS _Does Twa N or A 6ftgE WirH THE List is t, tw THz " NAMEPLATE Epe maven (, Li&T
._(, tMIED__Jl-10-81) #
whitu THE CogrAat Room Review TEAM Shou tp__8g __
USIN o. As Tat _Buis Fon com PAnisow(awo As wyAI_tguas97tv " omic Ai.'Y "
_EJtlSTS ALT _Hoveg IN PRELimiwhRY FO RM).
__Sost OP THE Re camM EgpED Cnaght$ IN THa HED NAY Ba J_uSrmED.
__. W THE 8tavinia Tkam agevop VtAtEL waru Bv-1 MfErnER_._THESE .
_ c MmW Anu Iw A4 Rat _ ment wirn B v-1_Tanwwer__Fes___ THE.. ip awricA L
. _ - . - CoME*wtM7 ESPEciALLY 3 8w___THow__CA6g3 wgsat _._THE._ E m tsTiwo._ _ 8v-2.
_.. . TERmiNoco6Y_.L,._Ite_Wic4LLY Cosat c.T._. _. _ ___ _ _ _.
)
l I O - 2.1 - 8 5'
nJv.Ah ENGl'..:...'5 c.:. :. RE JmT
..t ; ')
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: .bN d ef -
c) HED NO.: UN ~ Il I0 d) REVIEWED BY: b< [
e) DAW: O (Wespghouse)
Y x M ~
(Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: 5 0 NNC ~ \ b " C- @ COO O O k
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: $CC r.a.V 'M + CEC WiwJ t 8C M G- hst e r ;+ .
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (o . G .3.a.. l ro .c, . 3 .2 s .
Ed O[exiding lakls clo ned conespnd b G n opaca {ers expec4akons of hcw &4 iisle A ( 6 s sheJ d be labebcl.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
Nektc{ hbevs of Conn (Loons 'COS. Oh j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Ma O(- inCCrr e c OBSfo% Of "
k)
"j
- , e ,7REVIEh AND "% "cqy k- (% -
RECOWENDA m cg . a.-a< _ w.1c%w . , s __=rma.m. ,
ocs % % ocs ??'r .-
Ch c.g. : Oc.'ib %. j, oc_T6 E3 i
h c ct_ ^r CC\cnanct ; D ElO & 'Q. F \o +o e&R p. O F oj
@gpQD s'mu >h \x ; . . .g \
'1 m .s } + ~- \- ry s ',, ) ,-
~: -- (
- %E.%sAR\Csecj.sy,9dvdbs O'+ %. b y ' - > v>l c -4 gucu,e , % z va o Qs \ G. v' s . .- .3s
. e q .1.
ESSEX HUMAN FACTDR PROJECT MANAGER
/ A&
DUQU SNI LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER e
~
WESDN USEPROGRAMCpDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
11 __
/
s lO - 2 'f"$ ;
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 1
, , 7 2C-Pr 0 I DUQUESN C0 Q Y RfG. AFFAIRS MANAGER f fn - . ./
l DUQUESNE LIDHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
l
AtrAUMEur C LARIFic ATioN5 TD HE9 No. F. M g - ll15 SH.10F4 IN .R ES H5 To __TH E FouR Irtns Ll5TED VNPER SEVIEW,ANp_
6EcoMMENDAriewsf' .THE.. foi.LowlN6_ _ C4MMENTS k PfLY. !_. _ _ _ _ _
1a.__. Pumps Matss ste_t4a.__ase._t. Ass a Pass ? Ana C.wsisvewrLY _RE7_ tanto -_
10 _ 85 "_CMEMiC AL_TNJEtInN PM25 ' op _Sv-1_P_ocuegNTS bg. PSA R; DMw1MO Awo Suram Ps#stenens ). T u d w a m a ci.ar t twosawNo. List *
(Parte in-so-s$ 3 Irams 15oifisos; twunaterty Liar Tacer Pumes As
" cusMico_i._ao_parien PuMrs '. Twr NA Maturfs 46ews D R E mo "cN r sicas. ,
)WJECTiow Pu me)". AD L IT I_S Nor CLEAR WuAT Pumps ARE astwo RtPaas9cro. It APPEAas Tant This la Awornam RepratHtt To TnE Punes Diso3sco A M IN w me.u m ss Tne Ceseswr ib :. Enaos AND No CNnN45 li NigpfD, g,o *O fLLhw 4KRtFY. 7e~- nmp wretxeco is Tor 2055-P2 3 we &
NES&r WET. gapos 'cmics Attmo~ %m*"
A # pao PetMu- NhS&EMLAtted L w wovo em w ooeu ca speAy m -M c.te%ew-.- wce Nm ? ",
3 OC 8_31__AHO oc.5_13 Posmmu Iwo#tane4- l-s**rslaso con -ca.nto, wwirt__
Fog orsN) WEng _ItaMs lit Awo 196 , RastecTavgi.y_3 on Tag __gAtw _
cent!te&_ Somas FAowr Vsaw Danwiw6 1L141- RE-15 w - 4 Ago Tus NaearAArt_
E90naviNS usrt carro ti-a-ts). Dug To Tat _tvloomearap om rag _
.138KV OPFSeit Powas avP14es To_ SV-t leemsterto_puaiwd._Tae_
..BV-i_.Ranvs6th ouTA4t__tN OCT,_JW _DEC,7]ili _ 0c6 91 AND oc8 83
.. ARL_N o_ Lew 4 tR ___8 %$ 944ATED____WlTH_%L_ _ E R&e_s w o. 11141 - R E- t 5 W _S_ _ . .
sis S Hows Iram M is How OCS S4 wwica is_ Int .oppsirs. Powgg Surm
_ FRom. 138Kv 594 t. _. t w Tes S w ir c a y a m p. TitM 196 is Now OC8 85 WMicM lb CowstcTBo Tb l38KV Rub i #w THE iwir&WYARD. Ai.so T.rt M 1468 WAS Apat o Fo A Tet NEw " DISC *wwecT SwiTc4 S9-LA ' WHicN la A Moren o PE RArap pescowwger .%,tra n au Teg* Itani 138 KV Sept CP
- _ - - . e -
ATTecosaur l
l C Lenips cAriewt, To itE0 No. t5my 1) 5 SH 2.OF 4 System srAries__saivLct _TgmH3penegg CA. SuGGEST THAT THE M iMic 6 us A uoceme.p. wirH e _ Items __tts# Awp 196 sH ww ow _Daws. Itz41 Re-tsw-s BE M opspin p { & m a n g__._To TMs A77A(Map .. SMET 44 -- *N THL Fm.wsuG PAse)
To SEPbtCT Tt4AT_ .. l T EM__) G 4 8.. la _ PNysicALLY..___C eNNacTER.. To _. .ocs_ $ K Awo IS E ._ _fNYal_CA LbT___C6NNE cTED_ _ PintcTLY _To __l3&Kv__Su4.1._ ._ .. __ _ _ _
4, Sgg_gtegs ZE 16 Awo EPlo. No CHANGE RQvgEp. __ _
- b. km IO- 4 -SS* -
f emmume-e6 g.ma. e e et
- -- -.a.se w,+
==_--m---- _M
+Ne e m.e-+-e*
-o =- g .._w e
-eemm gm he e W = =p W6
-. **-ee- -- .-
.-w.*
.ee em -e,.we. mm
- "*4** ""'
.m,e , ,,,
_m, .
-, ,,,.g ..-e.< e
- w. p
-..c-. m. .-
M-* e e es a
I
i I
'- .. i :
.o . . --
~r 5
. . - . . . . . . . _ - . ~ .
I C, L ARimcATt0Nb To MEP No. 2.W M - lil5 SUGGESTED 3
(sH.5*F4) 3 ; ,_ . . . -
1 i : i
- s tw
- l 1
. %.. , i. e.. ,,.... , nsss;,
.v0 . .-(y J . . : .J ..or *> _. .
1 s t
- .s J. . . , .
I; .tg;.F
.a. .s e.
, ,.m . s. ; -: . .. .. . ... ; ..
,. ,. e. c. ,, s t .
.,,. A k, x., -..., .
- c.. . .
n, , .4., . , ,
I t a i
> $ i i : :
, ! L o
% 9C. 9e a ..
1 I- J I i (- i L _. . ~ . . .
> 1 E ov Bos2A 41( oM em '2EJ M o v P> b Z t- Mov Eua-
%w.s Ec. % W ?.c G.M'.5 20 '
nr 45 ;.
A.M P ;
At@s AW5 i tr,.A?S I
96 ,
9D a I - .
Sr.
. . ~
L s . -- - -
.n _ . -
r- C~ea.-m^- ^ _l f.m. . .o I
i i I -mQ a .s .me ,.
,1
,p 3..N....W. / @, - -'J.
. ~ ,T a I 3, * ----Hu t 3
. g '7*** .
t .- A~7,1 ' . . .2,7
~ , Q ,,
g ,,._ ,
+7 m"
q ;l _iqi qt -
v -
R W
,_j -
R 5,, w= IRI s l r i 4 OCB 85_j l9G i _--)
ra* ,
3 ', ,
_ _ , t
~
5 J. g!. OlSC.GW .uPE V OCB I l
_ . . . i U
SS-2A , .S S.'.'; _ . . _ 1 3.l , '
.Shls , rannS ! . . .
1 166f -. ..
BL'. l
' ,' 'S7 p' ~-. i , C'ENf./\f 4 l /NA/ '
,A,.
\ 'j- - '. .s
/s/\/',A U /\/\/\1, /\/ % ,A/\/\,/\. -
i n . I i ! (*'
J/ ij! l :
. . . ')
' L -. -/ l .
- - L_ _.._.]
a " _..._. i...i /
- j -
C \. Ll ,I /'~d) .p_ A[/7 l C" \ j ' "
T~~7
- ., ; .rCN
...i, .; \. i . ~. : ,. ! T -
...i... ..
, c. . . .
.g .. .. , . . . .
}
- s. . .
,' . l ,>
p
.l.-
.1 . ' ; ..:,
'*-- -._s,- _
, , . . . . . , f...-. . - - . _ . _ .
.- ; v .
J CLAAltleAfte**6 T O H t p N o, g,g g , . 1815 Exit >TiW, QuM -RE -15 w-5)
I o, 4 .,4)
- ,t
- ' 6 ~l y.~....p...,e
, 1 f -
- e } . . e. .ss u- .. s... - ... :.g .:
i .. .
"., e - . > .
. ..> .s e- t
,..w. w: r..:. .;
... a ..,,,
- I gs .
t
- ; ;,...,>.seg h... I ;
t.e,, .u> , ..
-5 .
w .v. .. x .. ,
' c s <
l r i i t I i <
i
'= L
- ) ts 9. C.
s .-- -
s -
_a, _.
l
! .1 1 _1 (.._ ._.
- t. _ -
y,
=-
__..,, i
..(
I 4
l 4 I 4.'.Ga V E >!.
i i '
AMM BoS 2A M uto'4 G us 2 B A 4 3 < L W .'20 '
f 9 ' a5 2 u 7GAtu 2t '. W . A.s'. .. ..
, T R .'s M.s Z e. ,
- ,;;.9 5 ARS6 I A.MV 6 4,, ~ .? .,> .
I l ',
c..g c3. f c,. s.- l
.av ..._.,. . .
, 1
- u. . . . _
sl '
p ,.... 4_ i
, y 3.....,
..3 t -
g.-r
, u .w. ,...r. .- - ~I i, )> Lf . r .c . . L.s.,_
. . a. e . i i i .,, -
. m.
-, m ,,,, d.- . .,..., , .,,t i
. s
.3 , "
- p- .
- r. . c.j ,,,. 1.u. .
-- q i l .
1a- z - \. --
lt W.2
't Rs t- e
<A v]
4 m}\ 5 ,, d. r ,?. c.'.}
m, . ,, h
. U
>r ., , l
! ocs 8sj 1% , r- ,__ _ . . ,_,
j
~
., L__ ,
5a ;i l OlSC GW . uP4 1
N5 .
_ , i! .
SS-2A '
f3 4.> 5 .
__1._
a\ '
l
<. ) Q. ! .,
y,-,; . :.:. . c \ai c .i s j
- a ;
i 3 .
li>bl o \_ . . .
--6 .
, ..! k * ,.!, f( . d .- '.
. . . , ,) Y f.h '*'e**.N,)b ) ,(/k / )7 ,
- 1. 4 I\ r...-.__, ,
ln
' ~ '
/ ,' i / ,g ,\ f\ ,* g ,s'
\ i ,, .
t: l
- ' . i:.. - l .
'! j L ... _ . . . .
l i .' . 5
.: )
, , ... ,.\g .-- ,.. . (/ .J g...._ .
., ., _6 I' g . _. , ~
~
- , i ,, s .
/ i . ,. .
.' ' i
\, ... . I ;, \, / .' \ .' . / .! . g.
hl ! ,
i . .
g '
t , ,, ;
1 ,
)a 9.e q e
,1 (
i e * . _ _ . _ _ _ . _
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT (1
b) ORIGINATOR: - I c) HED NO.: ON
~
d) REVIEWED BY: b N. e) DATE: 5 (WestWghouse) f M
(Essex) N f) HED TITLE: PrD M E ren b hrs M <xme valves are_
m\ ss's nq _ \hYi e ay 0C rancs_
Q G g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
M bM -
includin @cse- on E.5.P.
bbe- Va54 5 ; 1,2.i 3,4 ;
c)oenor va.Wes.: ( , 2, 3,9 .
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: h,6. } . l Labe\s are neM b perron capa and acco.cale human Id omance. hplay sca\es ceaa o - too y, , be bee is no lab.kng inecakng www endpoint spres.nts valve. cpen - oc valve dosed .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER:
g,c-M hg en
[ ckSk 6 NCC. b i
"' _. u. w c ce%s) 9 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
y IN prake g.crbC- o ('
' ne coased Mynse_ h rne ,
l k)' REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: { nyg k.;pd- p y (g g ;p A
is .indahd as ' deb, skoJJ nJ . cati i wbde 3,, 1 c E s c- geen;pc:ake M op h c~w,A.g w kc.h 's 5 c \ cd -
h3 S u gy 5 hog'.R ; Nn 4t( 'A t e W G ~h O q'/ f a.4J m \ \ m . ,% m r ~ ,~ s..h >4(^%
A s ;
M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT MMAGER Kf~rL/An 0000ESNE LIGHT C00FANyftEVIEW TEAM LEADER
- 0. 0 YA )
WESTfNGdJSE" PROGRAM ROINATOR -
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
DUQUEfELIGHTCOMPANYENGINEERINGMANAGER A n d / Q v. n- x -2 y '
DUQUESNE LJ/aHT COM9ANY" REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER W@ W&
000UESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUV.AN ENGINEERlNG OlSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: .F a c c) sEoNO.,hEs M N d) REVIEWED BY: ,
., , e) DATE: 5//5/86 (West 1#ghouse) h
ryh (Essex')
f) HED TITLE: haWb6n & bmWWV k N u
/
should. k ahd. o ESP g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
lH55 W SOV 105 A i B :C. ,D ,E f I% Mo:, ,
107,110,109 , (OST, toB, O t, i g 2. , \t)T h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 4 ,g , 4,3 one psWbn + cans 4- a:*cs Wu vawes. . un,3 ,,9 demarc.&hcv1 shev.\d k prursenb b enc. lose _ bhorgaM3 c.aAM canko\s
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBE9:
- c. R su<vey s (moy j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
(a.brs a c.b'on me k d e_k a.g c.c.
l l
l
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS 1 The_ EX.'* 5 gr&n Mcnk ' Co ukcl h ecaNors on'aMc.hed' echu
- s ~ cid~ s '
page. a -*<ghb g sWdh 6 d u ag t Q1lfh, tearc a Don h not prac.thd M dis, cc e, t recc mo+nc1cto i s hs S u $ b q ,on A ubd, '
'^Y M - n;-N l ESSEX HUMA)4 FACTORS P CT MARAtRR h (
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER i i ~
~
RDINATOR WEST p uSE P ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
I
, %.Manu-YY lIIT J
Y
[ ,
[ f i,r in in.
i i3
~
& Tf "W SA
[w g o . g -31 DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER J WA~ & , 7 /5'/f DUQUESNE / IGHT @ A f % G. AFFAIRS MANAGER WSNmu
'DUQUESNE LIGW COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER i
1
( ArtAcwugut C taniPicaTi.ws To HED No. EE51-1119
._ THe, . DEMARc ATiod Eiwei Rsconsegoso . lw _ THE. HED . Agr__lwconnecT._ IrgM No.
__l087 .is Tst,_ TRANSFER fy>SMITON 10R EMss a sov Aos A,c awo p wqics
_ , ConRESPeH05_ T6 ITEMS Iq7 pol _A ND_ l.0$_CN THE__ ESP._IJEM No.1817 IS THE TRANWER_f9M6y. nod Fon ?. MSS _A_ soy _1oi S3 E fr F WHicH 10RRESPodD5 T0_ T T E MS _ __ .
Ilop1LANQ__Itt__w Tur ES P. _ . _ . . _
WiTu op THESE PEvict.s, ow Tm ESP Tg uht OF Tas AnRmetsswT DEMAswatinw Liwes la IM PR ACTics. . RE w a90 THav N AMarueras RE Angp Pusatorvads ( Ivtms No. IogT Aug 11:T)
THtst Two Fon Taawista wwicw Davant Ant A ~ iares wlTH Tun Posnavvvews.
w conta i.
Ex amu TRawapan Ron Fem EMss u Sev 25 A C Awe D
- Nort Age wiu commacT Damwawe, Itt 48 -RE-tS DE Fon ins PESCRIPTiew OF ITErf5_
l0S T AND IIIT.
S. T b 9-n-as
--_e A we --
.e ew Wh4u.es N *h~mee mm.em-., .4.m.e .em.-.
l l
l
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (E D) REPORT e) %V PS l2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: 1%tnc c) HED NO.: 2 E N -//O Y d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: [ 3!?
i (Wesfinghouse) /
\ ~- M (Essex) ]
l j
f) HED TITLE: U M6 MM Oh o
- k. \ r A 60b dt.MU d'__ Oo kL d
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: 4 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
1-.a.bek re4 conitste-4 pCo nod. &t>.a__ S p\ ele.d % cine.dh.t , .
4 6...a.ia
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER:
Labels a.d wa-tim Ah dLC.ru R Lt 0 3
-rp 4 1 E,s.9 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Mk% in opeFG_M o GO F M G dF d.n-% 'm cbses061% o em.uc.A cL_Ag%
ma.
e
e k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
} c~;,; 3. (At y
- - . ,_ 2 -) - '. M
~
g-
- ,3 *- e
}
G.d . _ G , . 's '. OCoK b1 6. ((,(c {/ EL.
3, nc( c. dv-[a~-
bee aY .
t- hift k 3b5N Git-- ob-k test SbuN kVL \be15 (AbVe_ he. cdesc6bd Com fo v b ( b b et. h t oom) @ av o i d. co[v s .o n ,
3 %M ESSEX HUkAN FACTORS T MANAM R W
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER 1
br INATOR WESTE(GH003EP
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
aK I
f j
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 5A /
DUQUESNE p C W ANfREG. AFFAIRS MANAGER NW DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER 1
s -
H er b 46=
[ )
l~Ne.se.lQer\ . 7-l 6 pee _h kdt ^ ^ b __
[17l4) ~Pnt M4 oK - Yte.sid Qe.n . 1-A 6 pee.h (oA thM (111 B) P r\ L. BC.4 t hds oud i<dinAm (St1Q Pru_ Bea t ntee ur AIo +_ L Q e. d Is pOo q (377A) Ptst GB3
{hae. Ra.nge. &q% (SW s) Pnt aB3 Tw pa.*4 -9lu.% ~r Jt o akC (313) Pn L EBA dix pcLet Ye.tnp. kotAlf14deLJ (.$%) RL IB'BA es .
EnL &&A
@3\ "Ttc'o p t Yd.rnp.idUla h.
(314) one. pa_et 6pecol indthnTert) (ald RL BBA Rom % 0 4 4 p p & G h \ (ttlosh Rt- BA9
& 9e p h % s. 6h+ % L& be.1 (st,Q Rt BA1
( gen es innabo (so';) W_ s ai e
-_ -..-,-% - ,_y #-__,._--,.__..,w,. - . . . - . . _ _ _ - - - w- , , - - --,.c .-----7,ee,y - - - . - - _ . - - _ . , ,
HUMAN ENGINEER 8NG OfSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) EM 95 - 1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: ..M hDEl.\N E RV RRV c) HED NO.: MW'dd <
d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 0'T. i i , i%4 l
(W4tinghouse) /'
t Ym hggsffw' # wsTnsW f) '. ' ' ' di tod % Wd % tr'Id bo I (P_ S ieb(r rt br . s a HED TITLE:^ S 4Wes LT 'WO '
w bob Wr o. el A '4
- u P b Yon d
' .een g) ITEMS INVOLVED: MS u6M 6,c;O M"E ".95" ON SCt<Wi%MD SECTtoNS, E.5PG.CIPlug,
- u. a 4 c r . .
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
M\NWB T.W YORmWTscA W 9bhc5. b 7% W6% o$ (EGCM u 6\TT5 % ~\ MET 7* \M E D\Yf SC4CT % M hD
(,,6.1.14(.M
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
[hsin A45 502.wl TP 5,1 B3 7 O L C.t N @ Q
\
i j) SPECIFIC NUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
W5h6 hD\t4 &' (4.GE.W D5 gg brc M \N REhD\W(r (EG 6.Hb5 h
-- -- - - . . -...-,.,.-.-,---.n. - - , - - - , . . - -
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONS:.'
t /GW7S heUO1 EO $ MOLD BE M -L/r15Y.A 6D MTS %D9_0l A)(.,
CEM7alED v]MICtt Setoutb PP_ou tDe SPN.E RT TOP s sorrar. s. wens swww se. tw emer.mu 3 g C.t.._uedEs.
wh ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS
~
CT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
! /
WESTING'HO % PROGRAM COORDINKTOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
3 d- A $W' .
I"- Y Y '"
,J Wp%.s,y C
uw.n aA~,~ :
V W = '.
- e4 (22MA un DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY EhGINEERING MANAGER
% W/WW/
DUQUESNE s=J6PT COMf4thf REG ( ATFAIRS MANAGER
- e. R 97 w
'0UQUESNE LIGHT C0ffAN', OPERATIONS MANAGER
m r.n 4 ace.n4aw vo w e i s ru.s , a.-u
- 0) ' 3' ? 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: "F h ' ~t GA /-- E c) M D NO.: 284N-2N E d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: b /D!IN (Wd~stinghouse) /
~
T <L (Essex) ]
t) MD TITLE: Mae E ~rAA.d #L4 blhlfS. f%) h$U M [hinrCWC w.-.,-
eei,y 6 &hLl6 hht n& PBMMM
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED:
6A.4gy20j $t,753,9%
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AE 0700 PARAGRAPH NupeER:
bRvm covaWR. conws McLE THW Peut b16rts uJ tTH cur bRovPI46 cut SFPM4ptsh 3y N MA5 cd bEC vM A t- @owT' G . S . C . I n ('.')
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION BRMBER: .
D'50La i r 5.02.J E 4 i p 5 # B3.51 3 N j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERROR $(s) OR EWIPIENT OESIGN PR00LEN:
cha e.Gsu ui oa h 'ust.e4 ot 10:% C T~r 9T~n CitJh l
l 07 7e 2. Lcoa cgone_
r l
0
k) REVIED AND REcotNENDATIONS: 3
&$0
- THE bl6(r5 ca THE? bRu M GD U AS 6Y ComM A5 j Wif* A L PoseJTS, o g. Abb(TidL smes g
.Y ser vast#1 HEb % ',
,a , ,,
. g 1
l w I ESSEX NLMAN FACTORS CT W WAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER '
- o .
Yy i WESTINQ$USE PROGRAM GQuNDINATOR
- 1) IEVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
4 i a
, , * * 'N- '
, . - 7 RT rb g ,$ce A c :.- X d~m ccvh ma '
s k .sw Ac..mk , ccm,w. , e ,- '
s aN Neal op m,, as m< m LC bei4l $ a 4 0 4 4 - ((
DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY ENGIIEERING MANAGER ,
k avc s . ..- L.~e r ce m g e,, y o ,
WS$2h DU(RESE "COWAhY EK AFFAIRS MANAGER w ana DUCRJESNE LIGHT Cdr ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER k
s M
-+
Arucwmtsr Coas:Ficariews To H Ep. No. E 8A4 - P. Sol THE .___ NansEATE__1.ist (parto 11-3o-s3) _ NAs lism 99t_ Listap As:
. __ -. .Bomc, Acip_ To Oi.teleen ___ __ ._
t_ _ . . _ . . _ . . . _ _ _ Toras.Marese . Ew_ _. . -_ . - - . . . . _ _ . . . . - _ _ _
o<
acu - ER_MS__ . _ _ . _ _ _
. Racarr Ten wone "T " su Tnt Fitsr u wa. TsTs. MAwauf Flaw Fnew Twa " Bong. A_cp RLegesa* la Sanno. M tA suasp.
run A s, A RetATap Iran; Iram 855 is Li6ito tw THE NWPLArs klar As:
" Sogie. Acto To 86sso symn E cHs- FRit3 .
WW IttS___8Eco8 eta HAs Two IMP _irta. cwt _JA Fen Benie A c.ip FLeta, Ta Tur 6.6tNorg,
._THE_ 0DtER_lt Fon h MAweve f4m_.,_Em THE 8tKepJa. IME_fAE5sur .
Tits a _.la _Tusem ens Wr EwnasW A< wnaTE. _ Aw Ai rEAwarts Nag ante .._.
_Cou60 SE: . _ _ _ _ _
- .. _ _ _ _ 66Mir. Ac!0._.BLEN_088_ _. . __
EcHS~ERh3
, p +,_ _m = - . . , .
IO* _ . . _ . . . _ . _ _ _ _
. Bonic. Acio To S.supaa
- MAktuP Fe4M BL4WoER
- h. 10 8 5
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.) ENPS-2. l PLANT / UNIT i
b) ORIGINATOR:
~
bancher c) HED NO.: N ~ UIO d) REVIEWED BY: bi a e) DATE:
(West $ghouse) [ '
(Essex)
]
f) HED TITLE: Temham/ \Mks arme. Och plad I \
Move e paneb elemt M bey deECNbA g) ITENS INVOLVED: -
imecycy Sho en Pm _
- au componenk h) PROBLEN DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDEER: 4,G,a,l 4,
\Ms shodd be p\ad above. 4he. panel Met (s)
% desedbe..
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
Labe6 5.w g D LC ' W #R)S j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Av1 Opca6c enay no b 6 ab\e b real a la6e\ l uw- his hana is en % con 6( . '
. l
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Who pc.%gf g gg. ;
aCCtx4 A , N % 4\5 5%M be pia.cedk abme we a 4 \. m e O M 4=.y d.ese.c% ,
hs s >g h $ct ( < ( v, -c4 ; <. , , e, c ; , ,
DA ESSEX HUMAN FACTO 3ECfMANAGER BfL-DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
$ ft ' - _ fj WESTI p SE h RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
gu p.m.ama-4 O
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
~
WF j 7 mec-DUQUESNE p T C0 h Y gEd. AFFAIRS MANAGER
~
N@w DUQUESNE LIGNT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
ATTAc.t+M297 j C t. ARirie.ATioN5 T0e HED N o. EESA -ll15 l
l Twg . ESP ERONT view DRawims_(, Swf c Dnawin .l E7.48 - RE- ?.5 De, # e
_ -_tS D F,_-tfD_ AMP -15 0H ) .___3 Mw__Ig4L__ N AM P_ E LATE 5__ArtE_PE5ir,wep_ To _ GE. l ACwa TH g .. cosi m u_ pg g gs. Tat TgmeenttL _t.asta__Sacap_ow _ D t__ ESP..
-0T- FIELO. Regpssth Ner Conna63wp__Je TCpapw;wr, Nameptarg L.caypus, _ ,
THE PcAL%Nasr Nawetaras witt Be Aceve T'He PAwat Davit.E5 M.f m 9-it-ir r .
,-~e-- -
, ..- - we ume-.a mee
-wa e. .e e*eeen m ew gep=----ee--ee4-eN
--.._ee_- -****'"NN
.,w ,m, e. e m .-e -,---*-e
HUMAN ENGENEERING DESCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) b ~
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
bdGhe.F c) HED NO.: 1 EN~U ; U d) REVIEWED BY: /h., e) DATE: 5//Y/65 (Westiffhous'e) [
tM
' ' ~
(Essex) f) HED TITLE:
NSInc_pIGhes]are. iMh cM br h3 E.("tzn h G.an cb\s .
g) ITEMS INVO( VED:
~
aRHs X- MoV '7 oG -
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NtNBER: (,. (a .3 .6 h name_ are idenh ca\ ' a means of cOng sho41 be. pla'ke.s osea. b ceauce.
%e uscany con \-c.\.
% p%mk ,pj se. tech 5 t) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER: i i
Cooro, Room Sorvy gqog j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
An p r a k o r- ma.j Sele <h N4 w rong conbetd.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: The 080 k 6hode, hE Soch d bey WMbe, d'ssbogWshO be chan34.d c>oe. anchbec.
L 2: p ->)q .
i c: .. ; . ,_
.t
\ > ~4 + :
'a
~
. ST
, sq . . ,, ., ,
.. , , . .) .
9 ESSEX HUM 5N FACTORS T MAhAGER hhW DUQU8SNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- h. h. ~
WESTI SE PROGRAM K DINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
iu 10 - t - b DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENG ERING MANAGER dK DUQUESNE 7-x-fr-T COMP g REC. AFFAIRS MANAGER
\ #~iRP7 w I DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
ATTA m eur C LeciFicarious To. ..HED No. tEs t(- lato
.. TMe .PastLim8 NARY NAsteLars ENGRAvitiG_ List 7_ . DArtp_11-30-s3. cestniws-
_..A._ Paoecsap FonMAr Asp C occ a _ C o ctu o. Sc. HEME Fon__Nat4er_ tats 5 oN
_IME___t4miu Conno t BoAno, EtieRetacy SAurpoww PAwet ANP_ALuRwATE _.__
_Squisown PastL. Twa ComL__R> Review Team Saou'p_Appsess. Tarss Pbrosats on A GEwenic Basis Awo wivu SV-1 swo_u60 Autta ou A SPECIPic FORMAY FOR Coton Coo #wc, AND LABEu.INfr 0F N Amt PLATES.
Tum ' Peorosso Namnetmess Fon 7.RHse Mov salm Awp 2RHS 4mv7els tiwo EAtu) ON THE ESP As Li&T ED IN THE " NAMEPLATE ENGRAVin List *; wouco BE coton copso W To Restre.r Tur Pwen sovace Usao C i.e. omaast c:n Punet.t) Awo u uko IwcLuom Tus SPEcipic McTen CtNrR64 C Ewrea Paim wmicw Powan Is SuPPump.
Twe C.m mewrs Iwctu se IN Tuis MED FOR 7 RMS EMeV 707. A AND I.%l%$N MSW")Dl6 LE w ALSo APPLY To Awy ovusa Equipmewy wHica is cAPAnne og Ars PowERep PaoM ETusa Tue omnesa on PunPLE TRAINS Awo Has Costant D.vits,i, esa Tat Mca on ESP.
T-'D _I 5" . . . - . _ _ .
- w. .
h=we. -e ,w.,
- wp -e_-me- - -e e- .-
- ,wM--.=-.-m .m . - -
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l
a) 8V 6 b l PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
1 N k f:aadLV c) HED NO.: AVFM-Il / 2 d) REVIEWED BY: # e) DATE: 7!3/(('N (Wesdngh'ouse) / '
M (Essex) N' f) HED TITLE: IM 5 6 TENT'l 05 kJMJd('*% %4 AG Aers'% di Aos /k e s *H MS g) ITEMS INVOLVED: .6EE ' FrWAr.AEt. u r b a
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Arn s:o n ma. nr. w,e.e s,;+T o as M o scauvs s &
N o? torastgTyrai" %TM A W R M M Lait" AQ Wh h4 M E'O C ac. e n g W % 4. (.ouT1a.ow h o*4. (ab M c .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
c gA,ygN.77 Og g .7 u 4 uD/ 7p" I' I Ol ~I - L C I N 8 L/ O 2 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN E
'{s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
m c~sa sans ~c n eesn u e,wn awam = .
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
Q s o.c%s iucous.5 m e Lesi. s is mur..m r3 3,,r o pp e av FQ uT' of Traris, AcGsiaWwt Ano Pr.c.2 % M 5 .
2)L':.. 60N u.Gl %T. o C co w % ,,, o p gapaosgg u p
- 3) chap * %w% b ' h6 %~8 on bles M-V \%.
~T am ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT'RANAGER ff D DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
/
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
9 DUQUESNE LIGHT Cor ANY ENGINEERING MANAGER WY /
DUQUESNEfGNTCOPANTREG.AFFAIRSMANAGE W. 6P Wm "DUQUESNE LIGHT bor ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
11604 4? 1t W- lll2 4
!' . i'~. 5 =/ I_ J __ .
1N(O((C(,,,T, B66Gid LSTiO4 -
bik7 L.O C A T'.3 .3 )
._. O
$ rA04/)(t A . & 4 FD QTA FQ
. . . - A*J AJ . la r g , __ , ___ _, , _ , , _ , _ _ _ , _
C*l ~, faid _.. . N Add A4 . _ ___ .
i . - . . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . ._
l
' . ___ .. Lot %T .W _, ,,
SM '(p C0 @ 6(ma 1% bh4 bOJf.N A4O @ h" ui.w n s L..P A PO A Lo a i.o M Ft.n a Lad . . . _
cm Ava 4 mp R s ATth ThP
$1'M O E A) O nO beg 3 /(,,$'W4 ANO AI .,
bW q Lao P & P O unT A
- 04 l@a .
A7 o c's a Tt.
- P f464.. e 9;G AuO Puu WOILOC Lac,dnT M L.CO P __ h&
onsea.a a-~ sv AT , PiuTO-TSRQi AN ON _. _.
Stzw Roo utb
.__.-e. . _
P.c u c. C AM p6ng, .
'M "*'
Fm etsT" MC ONd .
$#rg M 44Otf Avc orwwi4._. _ _.
W. ._
Lof *O. ._ LS.T"~..
ANN N 9 46 v.- _ . _ _ _ _
htGR5 -
PM frQ _
NSI ..
. Ad #h Me,
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.3 Bv P5 cL _
PLANT / UNIT !
b) ORIGINATOR: M.FrMdher c) HED NO.: MM - $0(. I d) REVIEWED BY: . .
V, e) DATE: 6//e[f35 (Wesdnghouse) [
! N '
(Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: Dtspa.ys c- same ym&c a.m_ nok cocnpa.kib\e g) ITEMS INVOLVED: R C,p { bg, p g(p.g 2 RCS - TR We A.,13 -
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 07D0 PARAGRAPH NtMBER: (o . 6. \ . 6 d . , 6,5. L . O.
wgtn .hoo d,9 ays\ oC b. same pasameb musb be. ccavamd, scales s w d a to n com %le.
se' -/ sca\e. orgzakon. in numes cal peepss. ten and p '4< i s A. -
b r4acSucs, ac.e od c4g\dk gow%s Maaqss4The scales 3
ane. , &c:So - 3004 o%c omawdh g ggg_ o _ 3oc, . p
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER: .
VE.ri hicah on oh TdSbPC &OcE_ ikihe S m uab,U g (aucs) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPNENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
hay remlh in p cc3 h m 't 5 r M- i s and /o c delay oC repu
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Q,an e $cd c s I
$ c., ,' M ,' %
ace com phb\e Sc A s a c< es u.e ck . %c. c < Ala s a 0 w.c q [.I .
h u nA3 %J%t b g s.fb d%x\p_qa(,y h m gs. 5u(pg\u d 3 \sb.\s s k u\Atu Q M4 l bN'\ i ti c Q "O 5 a Ab 1 i h%, op ,
aco ws , .
$c , s3 gg hn *QT d ko @ cm.55 cc 4 x Sce d e cd L M w L_SETwtEM _.._
sentts is Requingo. PattawTLv; No Laast.uwo. Exists ow THE VERricAL 00ALRp Fo(
THasa RacoRotas. Twis wiLL Be Apoco Larsa F6m Tur loswrim Ation 0F INoev10va t _._
ELC930ER Poiwis. _ _ . _ _
[ _ _..
REC 6MMEW9ED MaiwvENA_ma ow RecoReces Ptn MwupactunsaIN6TRUCIML_$HeVbP_I KEEP Rtc4AttR5_jp_M h h 8_.E L8 ASLE COM0luoN,._ Caccie WITH SV-1 ON _Tyft Awo_ FgtginawcL_.ty Awy__ Pagoogms _ . EscomTsato.
HUMAN ENG8NEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT 9
.) BVP5 -1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:. . br&OC_.b I c) HED NO.: I N II l _
d) REVIEWED BY: . // e) DATE: I U
[
~
(West % house)
T ~ M '
l (Essex)
]
f) HED TITLE: k6kahe In 'Ca r N rs ch o O Gr g) ITEMS INVOLVED: pes w~iw c(ee RG-LI. 459 A ,4 (o ( , %c 1 1 ~lC
(
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: DE dcran ownh oh cbsp b ys are Ook kieM . ~i%. 4hree re bd depseys a c e i n 1 ) "(anUnwn c s se:gence (0 S 1.1/
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION
"**'"' kri R cehen 4 Task PecGxnwm Capbb-ies ,
14abd%(ms)(,.L\.%
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Cd CTS CdS. 'O T O'dA E_ e d. e .
cm -cc g n,m t m,
~f 6 caea C a.ol,_d
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: -
'e
. , . m, ,j,,- .-
s'e y, i
~d ,f
, . W '. t *.' . . , _ : s", \'e g 3 , ,s _
C'd < I '
ib p a u ' d e_ , f/m . e. e
/,A nf /Jo s~ rib 5- (cd-c 4 y.wk b) Cepwtal'% c ( be %)
tioif leve l suced 5w,%2r (.rw 32 +Q cA=v/d de-tker /9erruei n .- i,v/icu ,b.s pml .
es/ Ju & wcler o l 4 d k.< / ors. ,: e.,
eh h- y& j. lW owel I .ar -r ; w'e& .s.y LQ"*"
'7-2,eby :h I 2r .u
\
4 'N_ 1 \\ /%
\
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PRO CT MANAGER OS/-
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
~
WESTINGH%EPROGRAMC00$lPINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: p
- S .'
g & 0-FA' deu'sL &
N . s f '
dem 32 Y is c/c,
~
f^
/
7 2CT - R T c ,c o m , 4 3 7
r < ~~ hd c.ead:
% =e ww w m acce &
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERI $ MA/AGER
& A2 -
j(gANNEL SELECTDL
! f?E / 7-2d-/V DUQUESNE L,IfMT'COMPAN}dRE V 4 FAIRS MANAGER l DUQUESNE LIGHT (COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
P PROCEDURE CHANGE REQUIRED l
l l
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (SED) REPORT )
,) B V P S /2 ,
PLANT / UNIT l b) ORIGINATOR:
OJ VoCHIN5kV c) HED NO.: 2 U *-3dC\b )
d) REVIEWED BY:
.~c, k e) DATE: 1/2 3 h5 (Westirighouse) g
% .__ \ N'ah K
~
(Essex)'
f) HED TITLE: M I SSIN G Co N TAINAEN T lAIS TRUAENT AIR OBYER t
S WITc H I ;
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
cow 7hlNA< ENT INSTRUMENT AIR DAVER S TART /sref Swt TcH
~
(21 A C- DR Y2 I) _
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
CoNTAINM EN T INSTRUMEN T AIR DA YER S TART /S7af SwircH A
DoEs NoT Ex t.S T o N THE MAIM CoNTast GoAR D 3.7.2.I i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
\/ERIFI CA T/oM of Ab4fLA91LITY , R 40S, l.L 1. I
- j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
DE vic & DoES NoT EXIS T ON THE MAIN con 7kol GoARD To P BoltI OE THE coNTRrL NECESSAR Y Ta IMPLEAIENT THE
- Fot.t.o wing OPERATOR TASKS.' E- 0, 3 8 j ES-!*l, S*j E- 3, II .
h) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
pp V5 g SksTcH pre v10 E A cix7AwstEs7 INS TRVh1 EA! T AtR ON THE AMW C#N7tdL Bo A ND.
N \S Gossth b \^htsiww asc kg th q ]
y' " N N u\v \ p k \v v g u s . k .T h p c, gg
's y d A a s \o c h gct d . 9s m b <4 w A 4
- AW\ % sg " wl \ ','
- '\ W i ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJEC NANAGER ErlAm DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER i
512d&A WESTING (SUSEPROGRAMC00(DINATOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
26 DOQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGI'NEERING MANAGER
/ E&
DUQUESNEJ 7-f/r d GHT C00fPANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGE f med
'DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
s v ,. . . . a . . . . ;. n . i. a w a , r .s .. s w v) nt. eon s
.) Bv PS - A PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: M. Frach c> sed NO.: MG-Ro 7 d) REVIEWED BY: '
3 e) DATE: 5//5//35 (West 66ghouse) [
W (Essex)
]
f) HED TITLE: Con d S wikches hor MOS
\ t cVd. (T\i6Si 04 hhOC .
a u g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
A\\ pomp con 4to\ u&_hes on ASP h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6. 5. l. l b G.4 . l . l C( .
% cowd pep ssMes do ned- hue Mag 4s wNc6 3 4he_ procedwres ask_ for.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
(
b k, h ev s 903 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
ra_hr (vvL incorreck Osh b m contro\ adM oc ks echn may be. Ad @.
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDAT10NS: b O M I&_ f' c5 ana eppuie<4 are 'n i
agree %L u,4 eds obr by e%ec 0 vcos,ag pmp _ A w ma 6.geb oc
- p. C.h > , preced.gs b g re.e. u.aih ad(able 9'.
S u g p sk )dA.ktt m .' M ,o s w s b h k o .c '
s d(p
< se. g v A. '1 S '
Qt4V' kQCG s g( m M ' S-gook.Jsa as 199 < 4 < x . ~
- 4. ,,. cec 4,+ d an:t ied m e A 69% s M -or, M
ESSEX HUMA'N FACTORS P T M7tNMER W l DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
< t WESTING SE PROGRAM C0QMDINATOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
i h& AA
~
Yw /0 * / -Ts" DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 7# 2 & b5 DUQUESNE LpT COMPADRE (i. AFFAIRS MANAGER g Qn - _ ,
DUQUESNE LIGAT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGZNEERZNG DESCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) -
PLANT / UNIT
- 0 6 b) ORIGINATOR: _- NI8 td N2 4" c) HED NO.:
d) REVIEWED BY: , /> e) DATE: I AGkD (Westighouse) [ .
T~- h '
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: S w . h S] M c, m2, missi,w cm ,
cca nkmhe es g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
O0)DC7NbCY ICCM,6I C\ 3 5 (11 P,ioC J ocon EscAahn de3 t-4 K.y AC& @ , gn4) aug f,3qgf h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: Q,Q,\,1 3,g}
('c cCh Grd GC eM e gtG h4. Gc e G4d ens -
h g Fpou , w z ao nJ pm.& a m E e,e,d can y oS Co d crd.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
d C i hi ca. iQT C cDk chnCC C3 fab \ Nw s swbM \'v3 (cges) J ,Li,1 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
'C pO at sk C C nn' NC C N y
- b. {e (3 ;
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: .
c< . _ ..,.d-bL ',.'..- -.' ~ \ ' . _ '- k .
{._.
,.7..s N :-
,. ry . , . _ . , , . ,
y
-t [y - M4b- N . {# ' c ,
y ly 'l L' V la C ' ' ., ha ., - ,y (
4C l C C1'-- V-g i <- ' t v' si bk E * ~' P'- C - '
1l(9 5\ : c .' N
\x- e p\occh w 4-h p3140 \c;clc +t p eco,pu x.d s.
N S E E AT- TACHEb x '
Mw N \ rA A ESSEX HUAAN FACTORS P T MANAGER" i /W \
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER B. /. Wx WESTING % PROGRAM COOSWINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
M 'u& ~
h e ( !d = W l
TJ A= w ) W ~ $ M Dexax 9 _
i
}
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l l
DUQUESNE TCgNYRW,AFFAIRSMANAGER 9 ~~ 3 ='97w
' 0UQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
.. ._.. . AEAc HroEN T ro . H E D ._ _ 2 B W - 32. o 6
. . . .....-...Thrd k whe d oi %/G.._. _^64 w 3.ewn. _ _n ._ done _. . <
Io cs0Ya 9tocdct - 3 NsAd.._. M eid ..._...hk'is. Y .
SkV_ ACA 42A y..m_ t_ A. -,_2 %.._.2 -
8 , MZ.15.__ ._b o . . .
_. __.pccc.edM w. (E-t mes. I)
._..__. ..--_.Mk__tt{uiN ..?9 N.r_.ho.r_I =c k. . y ,
__ _. .._ . _ _ . _shoME_.ee- _cM_g.__ ___ _ _ _ . . _ . _ . . ..._
O
= w e9* eu.e. emmm.--e sei= weem.
M . e +
6mrOuWei ~ 6m . gg 83*. N . ,
u-t e e m*e .
ehe es e a 9 '
-.e- - . _
.e eup e . m .
O ee ese ee -
em -- wew N h6 MMN_W_ h e og . m- age, w e.aw9 gg ese.e ee ea N".' # mM + Ogum. *e s upe se awe wape e.e wees= -wa me e- e enMev4ee ese oem ee wm _e. e. w e emm_ . m e.e 4mmismmm. emmips . __.N-e.,_e e6m .me .a* -e.e.m aE.*-*4h==
HUMAN ENGINEERING OZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT bOf c) HED NO,: O N b) ORIGINATOR: -
d) REVIEWED BY: h- [- e) DATE: '
b (Westidfghouse) #
T (Essex)
] b f) HED TITLE: Y dvf rNY 'rbI &_s CannOh
.Se. br a T>ressuma sibrpoin F g) ITEMS INVOLVED: gp;
$.. g h g{qq g}Q (ams
- PMot A,B C] 3 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: h k . !, k q (t)(h ws cen6t t.s ed 46 fe,- % gnJ;.,3 ,4. :s sg b Paerm . Il chn be se- for 'percen4 Pat C, value. cannch be set on conbile.c.
w" Wa
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: ,,
6L 00 DOTT'b 00m M 'S q 06 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
NT %d\I idCOCOC4. ,
k) REVIErf AND RECOMMENDATIONS: hurre ) 'o 00COkr (CCGb prog r-Ce ces on operabr- h be presen Q l h me,,
w c A\L
%N a\\u %gAw % MA A sh cA c bs sba 6 acb ado wa Mk, M M* N b W
- DAbd e BIO.9m hb ,'TN4.ghY g cudch c*w b d t-< 5 w castqcessu m au. w u q w
- bt W Ag
- di(h (.Medwcs w 1 %s wo % \d (gy h ANS Ar h <oc eto\ake. g re=<ur_,a ko S. mwkg % , T.
co,s\ ohes cawwd M N ho maM 'w de 2. v sb4' shgd mphh;&c wAsg6 cs4mb a sN h N ( d -- A h $ r-esNu ws , !
yM v* 7' s ESSEX HUMAN FACTOK PROJECT MANAGER f,h & $$ v Y k n J/ n o 4 g pc;[e_. DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER se-hw'W. / k ). 0 , Y b ,
\pKak-. p ..-
WESTIN p uSE PROG p RDINATOR ,
V iY 'REVIEiFXA'D D SPOSITION:
W(f g aem t%m /
., $ A u m am ce ual- ,h ,w& ,f/,) ,Z/a. c h Y ft nd p / 4 JtL ist as as cpA % &fs ~
fan LyJ. .L AL ApJ c,JJ1~. ~df4 m
9_ sa as - sa:sa~u A 2/A) edW cuv. '
LY buYmY C C. /\ h.h~
\q Q9 i DUQUt$sE l.IGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING PANAGER I
l 7_g.s r
[ /7'2helV DUQUESNELIGRf)COMPANYgG.4FFAIRSMANAGER V. hWw
'DUQUESNE LIGHT DOMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
\
f l
Att ac%sgr i C L ARI Fi cATiogs To H E D E B A* - 3014 ATMOSPHERIC STEAM _ puMe VALVES . po Attove Tat __c=inottah_ Eon _ THE Aw .o renaroR_.__To_ __ SET _AND M Alw TA!w _A._ Parssust ._WMtw Twe. Cos_vantLsg. la _
L . P6ac so_ . lw _ _ _ AutoMAric .. __S at ._ AT3.A cH MENT.._1_ ..Fo n_ _ ExeL AN ATies _ _o r _ __. _ .
1 C#N_T.RO LLE R_._QEER AI!0N.
e Io__OSTAIN A _DlRacT Renat96.__ OP_ Tar 3Egune_saffowr_
lJtLEersp_A A Sverstearwrm uscatt_GaaovArno IN PstG CaukO__SE _ flu se __
Ntst Th far sarPetNr .54 h 8 (
- GReevesD IN o to lae%) or Tu r C6ggettgef _
IF DEstaED.
THERE ARE PRES 5 PRE IN9 ttaTtRE Fon " newespwaait .sreAM pmp STsAM GawsRATOR PRassuRE
- Or* TME VERTiaAL BOARD 5tcTisN A& DiarcTLY St SEHowD THE AtmosentRic Staas Dume Vaws Cawrma_uML Two Pamuner twoicavans_ Aar IrtMS S 'l9 A , B % C, ON Swat DRAvins 11t 4: -RE - EK8 wiTH Mmne Numaggs_ '
EMss - PI tol A 8 $c. Tatsa Iwoscarsas ARr -
Nor eta 55 JE ,
But Ti.itY po Rective Tamm Ses_ynt FRon Twe Sare c6mu it f%gssumt paso TRa w si o iT_r tets Twara Twa Atmospheric MAM DUMP VAwt_C,9_TKo.btE85.___TML Raptnacecas := ryeuse PRE 34uRE I Noicanas M Locatto oN VERTicat Roaan Secrw CE ^ Ant _
C L AM__at Post Accipaar Mowirmanwa, twsTRoMENTS wgica Ant _P_ap Twatg_Jaq,wnts FRom A papegggre 5sr op c6 Ass it PRE 46pAE TR AW hMiff aR5. _ _ _
p.m. my-m.e.mw e, .- ._-_-ow
_a. .
-.e . = . - _ ---.m-
@ wen
- w*
- . m- eea ._e-. _. --e- - -
""'hwe= *
- e-e*sa.=e-M- -
+em.-*-e -.w e -e en._ .. .-.e.. .
3 155i "1D:5. STCLEEEti E?ti tC.CIs cc2 ATTAc4McNT 2. To H ED "# S A D - 3014 0 mss *Priot A,6;c peco1 A#uidu ( 4-2em sigah 4o A. procaa cabiAe44. 'dUtee.,, N4. 4-2ema sigf4 is canueri<d b o, corresp4 card.,Gr g
ose A4cem( o-iovac. si d(l yk.(9 p1~
wt4% 6.pecess c=6ii4.4c. 442Wa y(g .
seyd-dnim cac& cm4Wvood $aec.4es a o-toube sdy'd Segn45 =4 adpsks Ws ookp& w ill- rubes a # 3iL( kms.c /decreau
.qivA Gm 6. 4 m/A .sk% ion . TA4. ex4t*((te .e451 rekas kafk Va.a.proa.ss st $ u( e.d 46a. Qd squ(, compw.s %
d <enerale a ce 4 ( %=( oo4.y4 io 6. co&p4 decw. c.,d, i 4. a.h4 de;o c c,ed,in kc1, cmverts +Co..rovsc ce44 col squi 4ea4 h cas4mt ste u.( .dak. k 444. eo4p4 A 4a. preos. s ceAs 4e & cx4cel. w(ve.. L nIs doce. esosietv.si AAc Th. ioded poA4- in c 6 46a, s de+ w'44 A. cx4de<-
cord comr A se.4 pk4- 4e 4A., FOUSI Sh \j OM Mh 1 b vo(% posMA, 4 e4M- is Ehl as 6. c.4%( pA4-eur<ss.A as a sarcaale; e eS k oeeriu reeacs o um, e.k.% you 4
~
44 ' e4 wkd per~cabc es 4ke 4masMr- 4 dI{[foo whF E pn.ssorsso le ix4eeded af.h v uk. en c A a papinada a s%%
isnot4.pessa4. ik precus on;4. e. 9st$.74 ch4 eas;L; a w a a os % w :_
f . .
~
pp %A mq -
> o-isoo es<a
' g/ Sehykk - = y %*(o. .
~~
Ced pide . # (,55)y(J ops!G) H . tas PsiG
- ~-- M ..c.-. g.. . ..q ..
Y )
i-r ,;'
W.
. toa t d: 9 AUTO _l:
J :
2 _, .
S -.=? 4A _i E: ss.rpow o3 I5 OY 'U E P:' 7:
R oTE. pi STATION o]i' l gj NJ '
Tf 9A T ~l
.J ouTPor !
I $V l
-!: --i MAN. ._.
- E PRocass cA&lNET I
l i ORivag .
I I CARD 4 U i I A-i I
(SATf4 DINT) ~ CcetTRou.EJR DRivam 1 Y CARD - F -
como I i 20m I ' ~
4 I
4 .
(ouTNT) I i
I I , SUPPIN L O-10VDC. 00TP0i' I CARD I To i
I coNTRob l
l_ VA1.VE
________________________________I f420ma FROM MEASURgp
_ SOcwr_vtn _- _ - _ - _ _ _
HUMAN ENGENEERlNG OfSCREPANCY (HEO) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT
[h OS*
b) ORIGINATOR: 2 GBAdW c) HED NO.: S bM -Y4 d) REVIEWED BY: /h- , e) DATE:. AK '
(Westi,dshouse) [/
3 nW (Essex) y'~
bDEC e CN C(' D M ISS I D C, G\
f) HED TITLE:
Coob g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
2 CN6 M EMk Mb i b n c. lk d Yx C onys h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
b .4 O R (U The d u ovr? C c n b ' 3 t'C cl Q U e- bc ba bCicG ' @ "M - -b L Cbs och pyroy ,j< 8 ,g [ ic e,d -
i,, .
c t c a % \.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
\hri h 'op o CEC 6 40ErlCE bp d3d' lES LWL3 ( m s') , i v a A b - Ct900 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
1 gya cc n'ay a e st cc. m i incem a
k) REV!ED AND RECOMMENDAT!ONS:
IN CC# 30 C L Y> C'W-(, , . p , i ca s , (2 I. < _ F-; -,._,I-
, e., it
$ },J xm*?r % .cl,m i I
gg L A - y m b yb >.s a 4..a +L& h u h sc he s,'/ $71 a& vo.cid e_ s, guJ. 3 +kAr_
e 7mulac y,d be et<WE M ob%%k wM3M% %"h[s ,
\ s x N / N' ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJEC IMNTGER 4 EEL /&
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
=N 1 WESTIN @ USE PROGRAM p DINATOR _
1)'/ REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/
N 4 DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINElRING MANAGER r lW DUQUESNE IGHT (4MP 7- /T=K' ANi REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER W
' DUQUESNE LIG4T COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER j
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
- N. ErancMer c) HED NO.:
08 d) REVIEWED BY: / , d e) DATE: 6[/5/B5 (Nespnghouse) /
l N j (Essex)
\
f) HED TITLE: Vamp conbro( sdEc._h does mk pre #gh i
- d-selden b * "ED N 21W4 ~520 g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
AC 06 -Vr 722A &Q.E 3 b c-. d 5 d 5% sbr 90 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (, . 04 . l . l O M
'ike. abo ve.- Canbi
- L per6 ~ s .n am is cob %%4e Qc b khen mk p ae a s.&a C.o r\h \. mt ca$e J
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
( S. '&J %O j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
d M Os C O Ci' M 's n c_ogy.q y
(ENitR(. ENC / SM VTbo (,4p et.}'
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: __
jQ p (obt%k \1 ^ \
'a .h t43 !.sL - pi '\s _t (q ,
i'waf ss j g.a . . , p s .x 3 . tu b 3( M 4, s'w3:fM. ,
m x s ., .s ' \ 'm . N :. .
s.
2.~
c:s o .
2 .p i c ,s ') d; g A U.
\ ,_ .
g .; -j ) .; t . mX.a - .' - T -;
(
7 . ), - \, , \ -gg \\hU
- b '--
M',h\ AWN fk k68 O C8 S (D bf hah M h < h k ( % 'b' S%M ^ {-R >
( hwf W\u ESSEX HUM 4N FACTORS T'MANATER l TF L DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
< / _
WESTI SE PROGRAM DINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
l l
)
1
\
a>Ik ku /G~
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINfERINi!l MANAGER ff -
/9'/PSS~
DuoueyIGsT emepY REG. AreAIRS sANAG fMm-DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
l
l HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
- b r~ c) HED NO.: OD-d) REVIEWED BY: ,
e) DATE:
(WestMghouse) 9 /'
O (Essex) f) HED TITLE: Sehoc' inh e^Gnc8 b Om 4 Q'
,Oqrsgood cmd O rhi c & Me, o
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: A4 Feed flova :n4cedoes C#FWE K Pl. tccB 3 ioo ca]
ob VI.-\oc h _
V1-We BAAlp C4 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (,. 5. l .c2 R .
Sco\e selecJrion- scale uni 4s. a.re m4- consAnt WM % < eg, ofpcIC% M ac%gey M by % .p.,.4.e,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: y Y6bd ion o ( OCKYN C.hions j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
S.
MAN [ % i O CCe tO!!". C.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: k eg b on g be 6 n O W lm ym. Ws nwt wncA- be aane 4e bu 5 0 3 pus. sim he uk. is (gasbc. M bs dehgbW ced Rd gnahr4sbuth huw\qsh k4.Sk bOV4 ok \qg M (\h b ) ( 6 R> @
Nw .LA h h t A s c. o b . s\ J ( M9Q %
d$e\au xv t
e- o m sah c,r s _ ,y ,
\ C %T S c4k a gk, S R o h rJ k R.4 % f 4 a w n d s esp Os4,( . 1 T D, M
((m
.p.w h -g d
~
ESSEX HUMAN FACTOMS PROJECT MANAGER
- At12% PL FtED, g OSUG ddS yd4<[ h OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER m9 enu.
g g .m l WESTINGHOUSE PROGRA @ RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
M '
h.$ dC IG ll~l 2. fb i Q _%h DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l OUQUESNELIGHfCOMRAMYRFg.AFFAIRSMANAGER 8 @W
[DUQUESNELIGHTCOMPAN l
~
~~ ~
CL ARIPicATio45 To hep No. Evct- Eti s l
- 4 ,
THE_ _RE FFRE_d_CES _ Te____ LOG R t TH Mic SCALES IN _ ThE NEh_ , _dH&U@
Rtap Squm RE. R **T
- Sca'84._-__._.___..---- --- ---__.- _ ..._ ---- --._ _
_ _.. 0 A&ED.. _ #_UPDea hit. STA_MMaraT__Jo_.Ing__Raview_.eHD_fLgcoMMewoA7suu SEC.Tibw of THE Mt.p THAT osuo, Has A G REED __Te_ _MopmV_ Tag E OP___Th _ _ _ _
man 9thw A PSED Flew 0F 100 e.PM Tan sewAna Roar Iwoc.i ADM__WITH_ _ __
A 0 - 400 GPM RANGE ARE ADRatwATS.
AGREE THAT A LINEAR SCALE Co- 40DWM) OR A >JARR6W RAM
&cALE lb Nor Nacennay, SASED t>Po,J A6ovE STAT EmE NTS.
. +_- + 10 $_f v __
4 oTE *,,
/ 'EW G .dk. FE Tb l50w bol(M S NHf 8tTN JN5kk L Ek.__
ia r 6wDeo s .toom . Gry #Enn 0-V00 6A&79 0D ____.
&_._tsnEN: Tcs E' M~ /wcKEm6:v rt of JO 6AQ _ _ _ _
/hrAEMr MY AFACIN 4 4Go vE- 20 6M1 rM#r /5 ._
4 /rru l.7 m 6 ~ or= [ es," tr c frno ou 7t'e55-twmcers.eL .,
A B[3'T as = mew,._ w. mw e-4-m. wea.
- w e e--wa.e.-_.
..,we- , . , . w. ,e -,e- . e e A4 m,6m--.m._e_me
=w
HUMAN ENGINEERING OISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - M Frandnec c) HED NO.: M - DIS d) REVIEWED BY: b' & e) DATE: 5/6/86 (Wes d ghouse) f x N (Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE: bosi hi on ka3bd s och mns't shen-- W Yecms osect in ademe_nk 6Ws g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLA4BER: (o.4.l.{Q[G,6,(4e,
% eshn labets on % mnbeds hsbA are ne \- % em as b yesNon kerms f.<en in h e.demenh bM es t) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
Ve.r1 hc dg on oh Task PeMmaune_e. CapaSChies
- EMW h (R4os) j) SPECIFIC HlNAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
%ca.brs d ons may be__ delqd or may choose. wrong psW on .
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: d c.%cce c.n on On; $ t ; y'7 , .
() A ce skandby anA Ab We sase in mean n er LW 5 i ees
- 2) \5 hoe- 3 O*eA b.c A Na b# D'E b^* cab m ,3 cs - o .%. . , . b .. h . P"Mi**
. . .a : . . . , m y b be oh herms We_ meanin s are 4he. same ,
c, am F.ch[es. Tetp vs 5% , di%er,Tc49 Open vs (bc uc3) 3 GLon vs %A-se , d sbwid be ensored thsh- We. proceduces gre- s th We boaca taba\in .
M {pc 'J a ci q s N
~
ESSEX NUMAN FACTORS E'CT MANAGER 4ML-DUQUESNE LIGHT CO W ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER RL Le WESTipSEPROGRAMC00pINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
W h 6 sw 4/A p~ -
Cu_ m3^ %
L- m e A .
wb l o - , -n -
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 7-lJ cfJ DuGUESNepTC0mANYdifG.AFFAIRSMANAGER fen ~
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
2 k b.K - 301%
^
Requiced SCbak Loca % n Open, Clos.l. CS Main (aenera.Lc- Owh\ Tripictosed 5cesk r- Pcs-353,; 3(cA 1
a.in laeneceer Excdakon Op close. Tr-;p ; cle cs
$ccaker ACB- 41 N y ows PatA.s Tr-ip sb y c.t S6l pump s4ches*NU,a 5% /56*MG A2
$bp/51ard6j
'b'*
bt 4AE 2Ato 9ty beh Open; dosec Tcip; clod ACS - URF , a E T
' Y 05 N supply break.c Ope,0;closEk. Trip; closed ACB -2010 , a F7 bNs tb bc(E obpouser op , close Tr p I s,e cs Sese.\ ptake odpr breaksis cpeo; clow Tsg/ctose/ [ct}
.2ELO; Q.F to Pott +o Lock.
- i ^ !$W sryg)((kb[pp D 5* pad B c i run /s kd
l 1%Kt-301%
fnformaken or bafra!
. ired %d %
bec 4-RCP Sw&hs mp sh9 /w/sM ALj 2RC5 -78.1 A, B ,C Nakeup SbpvaWe u.kh 4n/Cose sbe/sku4 A4 Hake up ConFrot u:kh o r n/cIose sbp/dack A'-
Cm61s/seches for s6nd by, sua em es, heej 6enecobrs cun,sbp s 6 p p..a A n G -
BreakerSoiL6s b Wy open/c.tose Tc;e/ dose.
oke go-c lo Emer. 6mes 1
Scric Ac.tci Rakeuo c,en /cjcse sbc4-/s+0p Ai4 valve. posnien Reacbr coclant mbp cpen /close shd /sbe cc,n\ rots f
1 I l i
NO CHANGE REQUIRED b
e 0 0 l
f HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREFANCY (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT i
b) ORIGINATOR:
c) HED NO.: M ClC.- 03Ql d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 3
/"
b (West 6dghouse)
[
f) HED TITLE:
T (Essex)
]W SID is \ es bG 00 rn aum o$
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: y h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (o.7.l.h .
key 6 card st pe. is appc.osm k4g ia..s- Q m begzon4 G A bne hmds anow beke, is anA a.o J.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION
' SA he r(\E 3 Errors cand hgh wd\ ocaw Y
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS g M'b N M h&S a keybar-d s I 6 - M d EgW.S ., d t.
CPcg 017 $ JdOove dtsc yc_y M p MQies no acken since 4he Peabes are_ neb e>eec_bd 40 spercl a9 lon priods of 44 nte M be - %M ,
- Am @ rro H 3 %
ESSEXHUMANFACTORSP%CTMANAGER E M dan /ech DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY 4EVIEW TEAM LEADER
&/Xhb WESTIt$FCUSE PROG p RDINATOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/
Y k I$$ #
l 5
'M _ -
,,y > h
~
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
[ ~ C~.2/~ W DUQUESNE,,JIGHTQ@lPARYREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER
[ Q We: ==J DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) FW - 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: d Ahe/ c) HED NO.: hM- //02 d) REVIEWE,D BY: k //__ _[ e) ATE: <</t /H
(%stinghouse)/ .
. .- - M ,
(Essex)
\
f) HED TITLE: "A
- sr accsuatome n 4,oyo a n o a r~c r s m.u. ver g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
' i9 ' ST ACLuttsosA rcot ra r wwr ud abcnnees Loa.-
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 4 fr . I. l .
p,,,v,n a A " S o Arvesse rt< ~
- s ces ,n.:n .z, s waa asaca roc ; 5 rars r g ra usc v o) A Du co m teer Losu g .
,A t so sfcsvry ol- AH J N asra'it cotavaa)<, a (4s%&, J.sp l ays, m ,d eder er, a.,a mt iunt %r ms
- b< /xo k c!, ded C e J *=
cpmPro AG orrc/c/M f / f n4/<J b f***'d AAr*d *~ / oes ss1c-4 Nss"sfv/AN U sho 4 bt t). ,n p r k ervrta
- 1) . DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: g p g . g 3 c,9 g gg QC gg ggg j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Sinesome cxce arauvo is m re sc uw ecssw.,mc 'er.,:a as c.+nasm] j l
l l
I
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
3.,yai LM ; M pm NVRf6 -O'M 601)ERM 6.6, /. j
- A,/beSSeY 54 la he l } Sc he m s (i1EF. H E0's 2 AM -lto I, jjo 3 g., Ad* .per/[c- 76 T /;/M,
--4 (g ESSEX HUMAN' FACTORS PRO Di MANAGER A4 H DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h*
- A .
WESTING @ SE PROGRAM % INATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
od A4 &
' i t EM DLTOUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER DUQUESNE HT COPE!ANY ' REG. AFFAIRS MANAGED f$ ; --: J "DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGEIt
HUMAN ENGINEERfNG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT e) BVPS l 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
,\
ALn A c) HED NO.: 2MZ-# -Ilo(o g
d) REVIEWED BY: N /
e) DATE: 3!IN (Wed.inghouse) m M ~
(Essei) f) HED TITLE: /2Ak ok/ sin 6tos( nn4 3 A Yt a 0 W N r(v m N % (% G1 & kGs nf Fph,k, A,, o 0 '
3 to 0dA4 g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
~
h\\
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
-rgp4 loss og so 4aEdi.1 h c6 O a c gw nhu_2 shou.lat be FM-t ru. (La.belag h ^d Nb
%ndu.,d.
1 :
m a.t
- 1) DATA C v a+k.
LECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
DLCtu R433 Mbeh, ad Locot. h paa, 6%
-rec..i e,s .s9 j) SPECIFIC HlNAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
O So kk , ogO.o'I.h o' g.
elek C de.% 6 an h h =3 b& '
una4 codrch. q mu.lf ObsewmitA o( thao e d4-chs oo da.g in obserocit'on
f k) REVIEW MND REComENDATIONS8
.b ( JOM d h o_ hoh h1'd$C "
(
~'
. c.s ^1 edL da> t oM*'
g /g gr, on VY f*
$9 corn'***
W ESSEX HUMAN FACTOR
,u ECT M NAGER i
&&%f/-
DUQUESNE LIGHT C0r ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER I e -
WESTI p SifFROGRAM INATOR VIEW AND DISPOSITION:
~
G 2 wwerLa
~
' #d m/gp ffu-a-f.x A . >
1 '
CCCCilMIL e, t
5i.'i 'v_ E snc c,n Q}m k h i )
- w;G p. 4 ~ % Q e,n . w",,.
\dkGitI DUQUEAIE LIGHT COMPANY INGINEERING MANAGER
\
._ i
' ' < < ' T.; Me er o sa,g4 l
& w *. > .' . e .-& :n,,e,-) ,4 f[ ,
- 7/ ./ s3 DUQUESNE LRiHT C W ' REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER J
ifUQUESNE LIGHT DOMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER )
i
l HlMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) W NM e d PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: ,
OLA3 LnQ c) HED NO.: .3 % M - /// O_
d) REVIEWED BY: '
e) DATE: E !3[ > U (4s(stinghouse) /
Y M (Essex) \
f) HED TITLE: Luot m +1 i >1 3
( \ cl') Pwt sc.;
" m ,e m 9 n -este y stabu Gst h_ sc..a vw %rra>.q 71o.4.4 Na_merem (acs) Rt.sa1
< ? 'ftenebr- Gooia.4_h pup sh (96s') Pea say
- t'*'*-,. /~ a=
= * .J A ~,.
.- .njL
+ 1 s,-
. .m,... *
.,4 *,
'l ,. P *
- '4 -
' g,- . *
- ~. . .
gf, g{T.') f'.'? ;'* t . _
r, ,,
,. - iJ -
. , . . - . ~g ..,....
3 e o . 3u_. . s.,
=
uo .. p . . .
=. w.. =. . . - . . .2a .y, .
=
e a
- 2. . . ( . . .
u _.' . . -_- I.. J.I. _4. .' aff A ./ '. .,3~ . f f' e' .
- . s
.. _. . _ _ _ . . . . .._. , . j. .
_-g,.- ,- -. - - 7_, ;_. __.
\
, -. M -i- .
- I . .. _. - - _ . . _
- a m
' e -*m e
e, *
.. , 18 ,
4,,.,.. m .4.
.a*M m .
. ._ t_-. . .. - h- . - _ ~
4 .. . ,';.J.
..v-i t. - ' C._ .-g. _. . . . _ .
i . . _ . _ __
.m. -. ___ _. ..
O
- a. -
. _ a- . ,J OT.
t
..l 4
. . ._.. . ' a ,j .a.
=
et S
- * * . .e* .
=&m e mme64
.. en ein e*,'
- m. ,m -
-6 . d e.= o.p..up e m
- e. e e s g to
- 8( . .
.? -
"~ pL.L
. .. . 4 (3 Q .
r . we . - ...*. .- -.4 ..-
-de m .e e- ee 6
m.e slik- er . . -e.w p
N -
e 6 ps W WM a y .m .em MMe&
. W*m. g ww .- .ese 4e.
. S. h er e -w. *=
e ee*
- e M .
.'M k
,
- b W - - . .. . ...
4**
6 j e e.'
. s-* *s-. - ..
. . . -mee - = = . - =+ *-
pm ,
,k
'Y.. ...
.- .2' .' _ . . .
eD
. 6
a) b ~
PLANT / UNIT h . Ens.mcher c) HED NO.: 2 NMI - h (+
b) ORIGINATOR: _
d) REVIEWED BY: h f, Ih e) DATE: O /f 85 (Wesdnghouse) #
w \\ a
~
(Essex)
' ~
f) HED TITLE: A k u ra bi e rts o Aa c>nums ace _ rcJr ..
C. OTT Si FM
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED:
- CAN 1 hOik k
- c. .c.R - cc_P _
c.c T = CC.S h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 4.G ,3.3 q ,
Inconsisbenh ase o( dm.v fabtens and Ac.mnp be6 Urnk i and VAN Di , Agreved V.sf noh adminidraf tvaI <-cr\ b tled ,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY IN NtNBER:
$ D
\ [C&ridn C O j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
b 6.N'5 CDF dIFOG DY COLA $lE in cpera!vs respnses .
/
g) ggg;to As RECOMYENDAIlO*si: b ~ _ g - c- , u
..g-ygn -
t C b cc,nGt-ns @ h' apwec, list. cL e t- m s ( g_c c e n ,,s G) E nsure. d rn'.res4rabe. con Lcct c.?
.g g a ho( emerYrionech 5 3sh-c.rn Ac.co ny m s ,
b -;,p f~'~ d bd hu
.W -
y G C c,V J ;,, ., , ', _ . , . ',
&. a i W y X li 4 % e .., ) g. ,, Q
& ge ;\c;
' n d \ad by.k s bs 4_% k ~ '
~
u AgUS7i .<,( .L ko Spo.ki c. M C kN Th '1, A C h E( , ..,.\!
w r,e e n..J,,G x Js cc s % c-pa ( b ,?. % Lc ab ,(n q C.,.hst ~
(eN x.d Csd mh
@ JECT'M@AGER c /i % c A nar1 < W .ESSEX HUMAN FACTO
.8 ag M
/[
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER D. !. Vh WESTI SE PROGRAM f DINATOR .
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPDSITION:
n> .
3 ,
$ lo-24.-f DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
/K&O' 2- / pts" DUQUESNE/IGHT d>4PANfftEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER h g, ,_: = 2
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGfNEERING D8SCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.) m se/a
' PLANT / UNIT I409 b) ORIGINATOR: d.E. bO u._so d c) HED NO.: N M'5D0 d) REVIEWED BY: h- < e) DATE: .l l-4:Lb - FM (Wesdnghouse) 9 T' - x . M "
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: Ds59 tans EYCEro m Avs mum 4 m- Wr UMiMDedS g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
SeE AVACittb LWT h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G , ) , g ,g g , (,)
Numtvous duhpla.qs frCeed Mw mcLxi ,% m tito(wme.vded W.Aght cf w ;
i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER:
66\ Pam Svug , T.P. \.2 & \.).\,4 W m ? =
- M. cs hLc.tN RWu j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
hubO h ac.cavah\g vieua k v4ad displaM5
- mueaa % meem. s _ ._
k) REVIEt AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
4 g g A n9 d of Y.a " *t o ku o k '
ggs a opsolt< pehm ctuo * "wm mende d k g ddp\qs whidi Nguks, usM W [wt M odahv;J shouga kn eod w& 4g g kkw 60 ad 66 induo hem & Moor (G. \.2.5 b(af .
? hse- 3f p art. If aY bM / lor le psk ek,dau - A A ~e dd-n.
,, ams f
n W ESSEX IANAN FACTORS
,m x 5CT MANADER L WL /sA DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANJ4EVIEW TEAM LEADER r - /
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
'T Q
a s$ '
DUQUESNE LIGHT C6MPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$E i //- /~~Jr DUQUESNEJIGHTCOAPANf'R'EG.AFFAIRSMANAGER ff 'Pfw "-w wi'
'DUQUESNE LIGHi COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
w .
T p
.W v Ar ee n e Te c - s. A A6PEMO)% 61 1 Me As.4.a.g. moKL tA% 2VV V - t4 e }
% nuesma. 6
- A v tx \la t u-v - :L . T O - \ .1, Ltsr iA, D A C t m- /05cmaAt on irrty _
bstPt_p u sy tErbi d h mM i muvy's , TVts? D\b 9tA'f 5 ARE A Es s a t- Li m i T- 5 @ L A O E'b W\ O Q.C %d
% t Q c.W ts A600r W T- LO O A . TH \S L\ST A PPL\E S to cQ.iT EA \ A (o . \ . L . 5 b. (,D .
A-5 e N T tstt. Toe GDW of tss9tAV5 A-(o E tJTiRE TDP ROs4 0F DtS 9Lh'f 5
_A - T - -
E 8J T10.E TW (Iow CF DtS AAYS AS G MTt RE m:e R0va CF bitPLA YS A-4 re>J T\ a e wp Ao w of b\L9LA YS -
1- (.
ENT) RE mDe g.oS Op b\SPt AY5 c-s E N E R.E TD P R.O W O F- b\tPLAYS ENTT RE TDP AOeJ 04 " E.XTW.A Q.T\O Q ST1W \SOLAT)O N NVL k F EEtW ATCW. ATA. \ tot NV 1TA'hA % " tubscytte. t.\ BHT PAWEL.
- \O \9 l
2.h% f - \ M O }
4 e-w\
EtJTiRE TOP R4,VJ OG b\ 5 P t A NO E N TL GX TC9 (LC W C f- *[0AtQ STh\ t(LA 6 PJ TLOL ABCfd NV $ TAM L " gtaLg S E L L\ 6 H T PAMEi O tO QO
- c. ; i : - W_
'~
m rw w o._ wame oaTE 249 bR6iMC 3 PEED VALVE k ROTDf 905 iTiO 4 f.E CCa.O LR css wee,me en No PAust (tAepea. so%) ,
sosus Lafn tT S lN Dich 70GLS
. , fWotJ LTDR.h TMOR\E, vat VE fb5 l'UCd?'
409f.JR.004 MMG. @C4 M0d[ f.1Eh%
409 c.0 6b i VALVE (b5 l'D04 L.a m 1T j 1, EMTSE TOP 9.QvJ oG N/O L T Ws tT 6A S
.g*
's E e
k 4
m
~
L
l HUMAM EhGINEER3NG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT PsW a) b ~
~ PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ 7 h . %E c) HED N0.2 ASYM / g d) REVIEWED BY: ~
e) DATE: b . IN (pstistghouse) [
r~ \\\a (Ess'ex) ]
f) ED TITLE: T- o* h M 58 bk i g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Cedt.\s(w &qQ C6%,
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6, {,\ ,
T%.\Md c 4 .b un. \et.dd e Qhe \hk'gg6,\.OC. axt w Q
% d w w h c u c k .5i A 5
- e r d b. b h . au s\s.
odstha.h ho,ub..k& cuck 4 % gsu e4; Q g O c O %.wcW oadt 6* dik.An grs
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUES k
LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION (ult 6 h< g
- T9 i,2.as.t .\ getzg fg g,3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM
1 i c T4 m c M(.a.55 4 t. b h\5 b[h w uA e.A .
t t
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS 8 .
T* ** 4C 4AM\kg DJ ick c,ghtwh eh h garde
,, 9t A s.Sbgb b aA*A Ak Akg 4%Abhld
% c
("Jf g w.w %boad . %sna uck ce%b uR._,
& M e,m w4g\R. . l n s ,co n , n s sa meum, nner ,,na Skt deve.s sucu 4tc en nu s n, reo r- rko4Lr (sn,, g, , ,_, ,,,
1
- frecer-o No Afcnew x (A ESSEX hlMAh FACTORS % 9@iAGER M
DUGN LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER t 1 2 WES p SE PROGRAM INATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND~ DISPOSITION: ,
\n b (f DUQUESNE LI4iT COMPANY l!NGIPEERING MANAGER DUQUESNE lip 6T C00GAN % d. AFFAIRS MANAGER NW DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER 4
j
\
\
2.-l.1n.h.1&1. Funai0 rat REMA MosuRCHERTS \ HEv
- 1 6 M .' W l
\\ \ \
'N x s N
\g y
\
N %,
N
\
- 's s \ {
i N
s s
's N I .g 1
N \ i
\ A j N \ l ust _
Enom.cta,
\ \_ sc 4,'
s (fetim4L (Ent>4)to MEinMT \ .g , rync3,wgg
%" M4 l MACH)
W \
\
\
\ t
/ 15 ,,
' 1 i
/
s ', / '
ii /
. I g g,,
~ - - - ~~ ~ ~ "if k M / /d
- Mtv.mT Fw 6 / /
s~ tt<paa n Fe w y
I a ,Iu' n<e.t ) J /// <
dt.DED / f j -
1
// L ,
II'S$,
o, i . , s.
2' 0 / , ,I / ,
b
/
\
) e. . 1
_ _ ssa
, 81441" r.
/
t
> t k*
a 4 h N i !
\
- I 4 ,
i
\ . .
= .-
- e y i , ,
' / /
LivlQ ,
- S'iO - = l SC ALE
- -
- 1. 37 5 in.= 1 f t. 'seiv- esmovms' l
,..,..... . .. . ..., *^
APPEracix 81.1 hEAsuF.EhErJTS ORTg NCr D MGM-l 40l DuGN%NE, hEAVhLLE'1- IP-l.'). Ll5T l.l Phfd 1(MC%0hRo) 3 Cot 3TGt.5 09%DE McN00-0 F9NCT)0Nht RE5EM OF 5" f C-ACEr4 7s LE PE N LP (,THESE Cadwots RLso tNTsioE of Fmtinov3h' REhca of SSH PEACOTTILE RE '15 F hhtE 69T vwtam E-CIENDEO FowcTmaSL b ITEM Mo. NAME PLh'TE
(.corinots os 19S ComThw Isot PH-A' QonThw NEWT Isot.
- %ATitAC 19 4 TAhin-A-conTAsN PHA
- VENT N66T i
SEcTinN of 5%0 cor9 Tass at Ca- 6 CbMTAM Nedt &b l%cnecy.0) 151 CONThtre b t P A-6 Ce6 Thin NEct 1606 55A Couth % I.StL PH-8 Sfith'1 ftsET 1Y, h' 1% hh4 FESET FDW 150L. T%)N A
%$9 C o hit h ird I S n L e fHhc c dThthi NENT 360L Mr ComhlN 150!. PHhc C.omhw s w Isnt Rib 6T-TR- 6 ..
%%b ConThw ISOL PH-D ComhW NENT ISOL M4 ceTfThw 150L PWD CoMh\N NEgi ISDL
%% CcNThtm 15bt PR-D SfFN fsEstT 'TR 6 M9 hhN SE5ET F0W ISol T9aw 6 (corm.ots os %0 'J.ssR$ A0V10 SA1
'Hoenorche s 519 ACvs* Aovt31 ili 1C45
- ADVIS A 5EC7)tra 6tNcHBob'dW )9% A Oh5* h0V100, 493 AccPt noy150-1 500 atCP
- n oy151- 1 S 0% 1 55 &* DV1.09h 1 5%1 Acys
- ovisib slo 1CV5+ 04151.6
.s 2,0 1 Dh 5 + DV100p 515 ACCP
- Mot 150-1 5 31 a CCP
- MDV 151-2
, acts on 9 % As5 Fs* hbV 11
Hofs TnC 4'56 AGNS* 1- 1 SEtniera S%5 2. ^ ON100 c 1 6Cwc%Dh4D DM k0YlllC1
.2,CMSt hDV30%A CLostR,7ahd)
'1" m m toet 50%Ti cus* hoy30'66 HSK hoV 301C Sr5 a. Q - O Y 1.01-1 928 SPhRE '.
5)9 ACH s
- A0V1
HED*2 E44-140I RE -15G l
ITEM hio. Nat1EPLhTE (Co8Tous od -659 f(cat tsooE stt sw, TRmN A
'W GKAL" 1501 A455
- PAHA
%b STEnti LINE I.5bL ACSET Sf2313N 6EncH6bfADUf 1 ) 50A AQSs 4 50V100 h 15os xat6
- sovi01h 15o4 1Qss
- SoV10AB Th0 hhw htTohT10N snF IN3 61c, t[
65 tihw 4sBT ShF lus 5% TGiN A AEctKt M00E SQ SW TRhtN 6 99 shFEcu %t sNS STAT (corm.ot.s oN Wt 1SWE - PK1 A
'Mos)towT6t' 53, ASW6- Pl.1h SEcuew or 59% A5wS*PAlc SENCH60hr4 550 A51S
- PA3h SSS AR55
- pal h 553 ARss
- PAlc F6i 1 0,55 *I th Sb5 ASIS
- A -
S'il asL5* M9 39% WE- 6 W5* 116 51%
5%4 ASW PAlc.
51A. 2,5ws+. P A16
/
(.C Rots m 594 15WS *Mov105C
" Hoda AL' Mil ASW S <h0V1 SE2.aterra 699 SV 5
- P 13C SENtnouPAD ASS 10Vlol CLt60R TMhd 531
- N09%s1A Y Nh togo S% 513 shoYt51 A 1557 515 *. AOV150h 15 15
- 60Y1L50E>
59 6 5 ADV150c 559 sws 09 losB SWI SW5
- h 113B
%7 A $ w s
- h ov t %' c 595 A515 t hC 999 4
)
l-lEl)* AEYk-l40I KE- M H ITEM No. t%MEPLATE (Cor4TOLs Ud -15DS A455
- P A9 o
'VERTtOL 9(9 STEhM LINE 160L RESET 150L A QSs
- SoV ibt SECTION BENCH 605.0 of )
1504 a.as5* SOV 101 150'6 A Q55* SOY 10A th hhw hCTuhTtoM S AF IN3 5)G
$% MhN RESET ShF IN3 s\G TRf\M 6 11506 ARH5
- MON 4506 1150A ~
ARMS
- MOV '150 A 1: 95 ARMS
- MOV '1016 L15L ARMS
- MOV 401 A
- .10 6h SPhRE 1101 AGws,*hov 10 6
4L 1RMS
- PAi A TEST
- L '1l ARH5
- Palo TEST L L04 AGWS* A0V104 i L 05' AGWS
- A0V 105 1049 hhN hCTUhTION S/S IN0f TRhlN A 1040 t%N ACTVATION 675 INOP TRhm B (cmT&ots og 69 6 1Rss* PA16 "HoRitoNTAL 6 01 1RSS
- P Al D
$ELTt 0N of , 605 Aqss
- P A1 D 6EncH6bMOJ 610 1515
- P11 D 419 15 LS < hov %41
'509 A315 *Moy191 DS ADAS
- PloH h Ih0bb SPhRE 66 61 ARHs
- P11 A Atuts
- C ALA b55 A WS *CMG 65% A DGS
- PAih
'A615
- Nov 5 sta" 63.4 l "HAR(n (10 ASIS
- h b5 SEcTtow or 9.GN ov553C !
bEr4cabohRo pl *hov % 50C )
- h0V 550F l
Cl06E THM)LA6 Y W.th EOGE b31 s* Rcv 934 6 As cv 101h 99 15v5* '01C 00 LS15fLPLt M 6
NN E.f.f-/ 40/
RE- A5J l ITEM No. N AME PLhiE (conTets,M -10 03 15GC -SOV109h
'1CWIKAL 1004 A5GC -SoV104 6 secTltw UF 945 ACMS - PCV11bA bErstHachRO) T% A.CHS - PcVL1 6 9% ACMS - LCV 11 A al% ACHS - LcVi F l 319 ACH5 - FCV1lah (Coma.et.s DN bb% ADG5 - Pata.h "HeitewtPC 6'15 16A5 - P1APr 3*1 16A5- Palh SecTitna 6ENCH60Ntb er )t4 ASGC - P A3.h 401.
S$$E~fiII A6Gc - Pl.56 691 Eihf aih 70 316 150thT10N V V's
'94 15GC - P AS 6 ici 3sGC- P AT /'Assc-sult .
. 4 12. ACMS*PX1h
' 0% ACHS*PA16 4}n ACH 5 - Moi 3,11
%0 GDRic AClb FLOV4 TO 6LfadOth TOThu7h ROLS 0N (34% 16R5-60V1 "HM) T A L' b1A 16AS-A0 06 SEcistrr4 MS A5GC- LW 6ENCHG%to AS -
CLOSER Tau 46 C 606091%L6 Vin
'S' FRot1 ED6dlS11 SGC-MCn00
. tm 1. c-hovnSA 9 06 A5G V1158 9 a.C45-ho 1 AC HS- LCV 19 VOL CONT TK L, oNTilot 911 ACMS'-LcV115h /%CH V111
HED*2SM '@l RE-1GK ITEM N3 N AMF PL ATE (CONTR.ets evo_ Thl ACMS-FcVibt
<wcus" so9 acus-Htv.165
%9 'ACHS - M CVL'14 btttH60MO SEcliev4 of) t-1jl% aCHS-HCV M
. )aA AGNs- Pcv 101 A AGNS-PC V1016
(+1Db bi ACMS-HCVl91 bTRot.s er4 940 ACHs*PalA ,
' hor)tonTht" 997 ACMs*P11C
'Tlow) of ACHS
- MOV%iSOh teLov.0)953'45't
%1 1CH5rMOV%1'506 gCHS*PA16 Y1 Ph 5-PA1B
}41 Arcs-PALC,
'%9
- ARCS-h0V5% _
"H D W s kks c '
Sftz.Titv4 0F A 1.CH L15C 6tNCH6 cyto 4 th0V i'16 CL%bt THhrJ %% HSth OV '1%i
%' FRCh EDGb CC 4194
% A.CH S- P
- t% ACMb -Fcy%D n
%1 ACHS-FC.v b
I
HEDNEN @
RE-150 -
ITEM NO. NMTPLME (Comths gr4 _ $1T) 6 RODS OUT
" VERTICAL 11% b AbOS IN GECUoraof)
M6bPAD (CA4TRALS 09 M '} ARcP-H1c,
HocturAT ht' ST. 4 AfstPtH 25'l asRCf4'HA as &cfVHg.
bit. Tion e5 bb4cason D ) 165 .
l 366 1RCPfHAE M1 KEfcTM. 9 MS 1-N 34 h (insTRontwT NoQ M4 1-N 158 ora 3:L9 L5/9517 C. . tab)
"Hofstre n At PRtL9#t o e u c o - 1t e t.
SECTitn4 Of T15 3 CV955A _
Etwcasches o 5% S* PCV9556 C4' 06til THhr4 3 Sh PAES PRESS CRR4TAbL a Ff#1 tDGE '
RCHS* 6
'54
- MCS< Pt9 45 151 A Rts +Pc4 45SC, 1096E At9N/ GAT cowra.ot Pomet.
e
HeD=2CM -Nou RE-1E P ITEM NO. N At t pt_h T E _
(Cergtets M '6% 1C.CPE NOV103 A
\lbt1itAC' -SS ACcf
- fioV10%
5tt,Tiera of 3t'b ACCP vh0V1036 l 60 Ten bond 361 AccP
- M0Y10 % l 3%4 XcP -h0\ 1%
LiS1 AccP
- Abil'%
341 1CCf 4hb110SC
'b')0 ACCPvA 6 A95 'AccP v.h %
LS5' AccP-M01 C.CONTF#.s oN 5% AFNC- P2.9h"htisl10NThC' M5 3.0&S- PAM Mi AQ55-PA4
$ECTioW 6Er4cM60MD af) 'i@ 'AFNcwPAl A 9 01 ACCP4PAlh 9ox ACCP
- PA1C QA-ccfc6, instr N0')
905 ActPyog18 9(ti ACCP *PAlc, (1h-CCPcl\ ,insTA 90.')
905 9.FMC
- PA16 9% 1 0,5s - P A 3 (CONTno 9*10 .
%ccP*
asa nor m e' < wvitic
' 6 f:t.T l e N 0 7 bttitM CL gm RM WN
HED%=n-140s KE-1EU ITEM NO. NhMmE (cor4 Trots oN -b3 RCWS-Pl%
HtrM.0NTat" 19 ACW5-PA16 35 ACW5-f41C EEtTiOM 6C,4CR04tiRD of)56 A.CWS-f 3lD AH0H-PnA SA m 1CNM- PA1 A Fo 1CNn- 6 si ACWn- 1C t AFWS-McN150A
'AFWS - 104150 6
-~ ~ nAq 1604-
$1ETAU DA F34=7C W SELECT (fS/9%UN6R. N s, i Sen4T 93t iSL Ho-3is op o3 ecastAo STM-FLOW F 9M, 6. Mb.
Ch0" g)
, RE-1s\/
ITEM NQ NAt4EPLATE (comR.ots oN h3 hN STn L)NE 51S L9L hCTUPrTiots TR h "VfATKhC' Yio MN STn LINE 615 L1L ACTVPrlimJ TR A Y11 Mt3 6Th L)NE 515 L9L CTVhTioN TK 6 Sr1Tiera bEMcHE0ftie tif 4*lA
) hN STM LINE 515 LNL CTMT10M TR6 ll M h AFWE c Sovico A 11 M 6 AFWE
- 5b1100 lb
.1}9 TUR6 FIRST STAGE f(Es rzceAott (DerrqMLSUM 91 1M55
- 1rfV101h "HerAnonT AC 11MM Ands
- 50y loSh SECTlBN OF 1191 D A M 3 5
- 6 0 V 1.0 5 D 6ENCH60MO 111 $Phf.E 13% AGM0-9101 lit AGSS-FN11A 119 ATMG-Blos 115 A.
131 a ThL-PA09 rML-Pals Wi ATn&- xdiA 115 AT- A096 PAbA.
S'1 ThL-PA10 195 'A.Gn0 - PM1
He2f-W '@l y 16iGtDNS ITEM No. NAhE9 LATE
- 2ts en4- " M AFWE*Hcylo "H5ti l1 AFWE*H E G MC. Tion ofr S
L AFW V100F bCNcM0cV4 *HCy100D 110 ss-noyiooA cttffgTgg)
F FRoh toGt 111 -MON 1006
'94 EHC Ctr4TLbt FAW EC1 11ht-CA1A RE -:L%f ITE.M NO. tu hEPLATE (CoroTOLsor4 1% DI,n0- P106
' HOR 12.0MThl" 155 NORMhL SW 6Kfs SSA 1 59 Eh6R 57NC bKTs 151 SECTioN GerataWOF 1E5 ) Nt*hht 51r4C 6KR SA 156 EhEA 5114C 6KR 3bl l'6'6 h 'ilbo V T8&is AA N0LTS A 9140 V TRANs 1b VOLTS L)NE 606 TC ANS Chi TROLS ora :j5rl 11ht-tal(,
% t1 165 EyciTEf, SE.CTitnr4 of 59 '
EE4tH60SO - 1 CLW:A THht4 1. 1 SPBR.E 1" FROM EOGE) 1.
E oS Chte. 1-1 VOLT AD305T 10Vih 05L GEN -
hhN FLD FLASW 1061h DSL GEt4 3.- OLT 6EG CONT lao C,EN 3.-l. V h030%T 10 6'ib En$,
DSL G EN 4'l hfrN Lash 10016 DSL GEN 1-1 NOLT REG CONTROLL
HUMAN ENG8NEERlNG DESCREPANCY (HED) REPORT PS a) bk-1 __
PLANOUNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _bMMinMME. O odd c) HED NO.: AByf -/402 3 TS d) REVIEWED BY: a) DATE:
(4stihghouse) /
~ <W (Essex)
]3 t N C,% ftS @ FR.00T ED 66 I f) HED TITLE: bts w rt% tu os: (n Nso LE g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
CONTROL 6 IN A~TTh C 6 @ L\ E h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: fo.\ . Q . J O)
% \i M u m 6 \s an. w&m 3 A Aw of % M ema
" "- S ed'd d4o bc.s ok db (,DAtbkt. Yiolah 3imkw b b W sole <Ay b umbis .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTIO NtMBER:
T P 1 %%S.\.\ DkIy jz t,33 b b l k m h rvey; (1 &
u <_,,o 1
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
kutosaa k%ok d who\s, I
k) REVIEtt AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
(1) A%:e_h a gwod reu\ wouwd k bochbouck, p%es%.yk is thus yu c{ ca b o% % en<hro\1 \is%s.
% %u pbls uk4 m 4 vdokd u crikon % p 6 3 opa..ai % , L whbb 4 dasku prokcbe uoevs u vaA.6 h a e^6L bbioch vwq ab proo sa.: o.
- b\ cpard aganih accideuhe.\ add %
- cae ro,,, ,,c,--e. ., ,,.n.~e, ~wa s~~ r*~r a w 0F MfM; Mom b , & - ~\
ESSEXHUMANFACTORSyJECTMANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTINGpSEPROGRAM INATOR fREVI' W AND DISPOSITION: _
b iu/b dJuAdf<-c/aA
<W p s -- f ~NM. @[- . at ,
1 DUQUISNE LIGifT COMPANY INCINEERING MANAGER
$5h
! DUQUESNE JJGHT COIPANi REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER i
DUQUESNE LIGlHT COWANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
7 P. \ .1 A NTW Q O P o NhE.%\ C. 5 AeetM o n 61.d- NEO 26Fh-lW)L w.smume uTs. oATA buGu uNE M M E*- V ALL EN - A ; T P - t . a , L\ST L \ ; P MLT 3 (e Mc.* ao M Db grau oo " ac.c i temw_ se no a os ecuc.w6 card ca.o s en 7 %i4 O mum EDQE.
11tm .Jumaut. MME Pt.AE et-asF: (cornaot.5 oA 'i43 ASS ft.* AbV 113 A
Hon 11.osuc 4% AGNS
- 60V101-1 .
setniew ev 955 2.60r. + hon 100c1 6Ewc6 60%D 9% 3.SDS* 40YlllCl CLosm mM SYi 2.CHSt 10V30%A 1" Fach toGd 505 cHS* NOV30156 504 '
CHSk hoyS01C 513 A GhS& A 0y1,01-1
%8 SPhRE 519 ACHS
- A0V10'l er-as@ (.ctrovotsow Sql ASk15 *MOV10SC "HCArtoNRC' 90 2.5W S <h0V111A Ser_mera of 69 9 W 5
- hoV113C 6tNc8EpAo SEb ASS -h0V101 CLost. Tahd 511 515 AMOV%51A
~6" FAch EoGO 575 1.515 *h0V151 A 155 7 1515 t AOV150f\
155% 1515 Sh0VM06 15 5'1 515
- ADV150c Sti SWS
- h0V 105D 5M Sw5
- h0V L138
%3 A$W5 *h0V 11SC 595 ASIS thC 941 ge-ast (omJncts ou 6D 'A515
- Nov 55'Aq "HcRtwen4' 10 . A515
- h oy%S B Str_ mew ev (619 RGNsvhov 553C 6Enca60hao p1 ASIS *hbV % 50C ASIS
- h0V 550F cL0%A Y i?ti EQGE THb6) LA6b% AGNsvscv934 635' A5V54 PcvtolA bvi Asys
- Pcv to tc R0
- 1NA A5v5* {cv 1016 N/NT ekYrMpana.
hE.: h; C-+g -i902
_vtEtA kb. Mwq SLATE _.
eg.as r: (CowTROLS ON (34% 16R5- AOV100 A
- HORIT.oNThL' btA 16&S-A0Vlboo SECTiera of us AsGC- Ovt11A
- 6EWCH Ges.O '116 A5GC- 091116 l CLOSER Tapn4 995 ASGC- OVill l
l" FROM tDGE)lS19 ASGC-MCN 100 tos 15GC-hovi.15A 9 06 A5GC-ADV115B W1 a.C 45-Moy111 4.15 Ac Hs- Lcv115E 9 19 VOL Cot 4T TK CONTROL
'B1 ACMS-LCVilSh ACH 5- LCV 111 pe_agg,.- (cemen.s ew 151x 515* hse 4D "HORit.orsThe' ~195 CHS* LCt.156 S&Tio4 W 45A 1.CH5* LCV h15C 6tNCH60$D '4% CMSWh0V a')6 s CHSth OV 1,%1 -
CL6ta Ti'.a JWT) 'h5 5" F.kh EOGE CCP-TCV194 Y)O A c H %- PCV195~
Y& ACd "PCVin 411 a.CHS-FCV%D as-ase (CoNTRots 09 319 LS/459'T (Issu. tab)
"Refar orn e ' 339 Mess N Y.eA. LENC1 CInvU41.
AEcTica UD 215 2.Rcs+ PcV955A 5CwtHGofd.D 5% 1RCS* Pcv4556 Cp w.THhss ST) PAE5svinK PRESS CBNTRbL 3 Man t0GE) 313 RC HS* LCY 9(>06 M4 MCS< PCV 45b Ss1 A Rts tetV Hssc 10966 ANN / CAT curn.ot Pamn.
% -35 0 (CONTaots era 9 10 %ccP* Aovios '
"Hom.own t" 913 AccP S hDv111C S&Tm a ey 6tt4tM60W@ -
cLo3eg Tgma )
L" RJJD DO6E
hE0* 'erH.jo z.
ITEM No: NAmE PLATE-lbOC,- h0V 110 "u , (cocr tuts ON 1114
" Hon 1Z.M4TAL"- t oA FW -FLOW SetEcT (F T E (,It 61L N 5ECTieA of 103 6Th-FLOW SELECT 6t-r4cH6c MO 10 7 STii- FLOW 6CLECT hl,1N5TF. t4D. ) ,
g gn y ctost-ainha) .
RE-1sV (coni)
, ITen No. NAhE9 LATE ase car 41 a s e9 9% AFWE*HCV100C
- (%Atbr.ThL" 9i AFWE*RCV100G SECTiera 01: (1 t, AFWE*HC.V100F bSIcn6DK0 '$ 1FWE *HCy 1000 -
1}.L0 AM55 -nov100A ct w THM) l' F4h tOGt 111 Ah55-M OV1006 AGss-novaol in j_30 STh D\)MP I.NTLA TTIFh55 SC LECTod-h5 l'Ac1 STh Dunt IllTLY. CdPh55 SC LECTcfCh5M i94 EHC CONTibL Ph tJE L 11 11AC-CA1A
, -asW: (CONTROLS Or4 . 51 llhC-Cll(,
EYCITES AC6 E 'HORi?.ONT h L" 165 SE.CTiew of 1.bb SPME
! EE4t%bgo- 1(A 59 pat CLou:ATRAA LA SPBRE l 'a" FRoh EOGQ 1.69 59P9.E 1%s tec4. GEN 1-1 VOLT Ab3uST 1069 A 05L GEN 3.-l hAN FLD FLASW 1061A 2 DSL GEN 3.-l VOLT 6EG CONT lao EnfR GEN -;). VOCS hD30%T 106'16 DSL GEN A hhN FLD FLASH l
l 10(,1 6 DSL GEN 1-1 NOLT REG CONTPs0L g
HUMAKEG8NEERING ISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT T4 a) D A PLANTAINIT b) ORIGINATOR: dE Q msed c) HED NO.: 26M-NO3 I d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: ?N (Wistirighousi /
T IM (Essex) 3 f) HED TITLE: k u Abratik'TE Mor ROOvn uMOER len BoMt.M g) ITEMS INVOLVED: kLA. h u h M fd Uh%D 3 kAA. oc m h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 07EPARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6.l . ~3 . A ,
b N IAb t M ca N b EtenAk. db Vtur 'C.m
- *Nd A W hm a- 6hra. .
AM deavawu b 3.sq.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTE AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION
}
pg ,
DLCIN /Ryoj j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) (ROUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
y p w Ltm Y. s1 *M.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
Inddla6 d o. M tai \ eroom3 L b4 4 6 64 board wouM prova a 4" c.kweno. b O, ud ka.lp o x y c.o u prob s wA daptgs ma mhob bo doa b&
Heb tJ. . nw-isoy g 4 A boosa. (see.
Di*cro-@$<-g m o%s (s.s %w \( A Q th g\w b\50- Ak
- N Suww ,ho vr Si d y asuwe ph . %g Lw a uhsday4 M
flSlf C Q eD Q ' g~.fffj
~t ESSEXHUMANFACTORSPKECTMANAGER H V>#f D DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTIp0SEPROGRAMC0gp10lNATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/fd2- & d' y .4 Q "AJo ,,r9c 7 ,,* s J ,
//[8 AY~a^ a.o s M W a.g.sv- tM4., aWc p -E== n =d A+ r; y &
m 4s: L <t Jo xc> aJ* u DUQUE$NE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER Y / h /V < 5 ,
COWNY l I
DUQUESN itEG. AFFAIRS' MANAGER S . dF% w
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGEF
q H'JM% EN31NEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT 9
a) b N~ A ..
PLANf/ UNIT T., -!
b) ORIGINATOR: _
4% c) HED NO.: d d) REVIEWED BY: h. , e) DATE: hb 14 (We'st1% house) [
Tm M (Essex) f) HED TITLE: Ce Ak#sh sh %tekic b 96wh lowte %a thwtw'w
%A. o g) ITEMS INVOLVED Ca+b\s %%h bbw elbs= *w% Ahhhpy- .
RE-%5R (C-O ~Ihm b d owAp(dq _ N
\t w (Icws42,, I.usTR tJQ M
%o Ac*S- msmx g ,s.c O ,E y,5)\,(Ys u
. %%4 \ oC AL/ RT MME. stdcygg n h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
C M < b a rs. \ 6 % % w % 4 4 % % m g % J w.g* 4 w"
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER: gg 3 T P t. s t s.s \
l-l i
DLC. IN MM j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
imaN ik\. kh pb R. La % LD I
sqq&k r NQum.
k) REV3Eh AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
C6 55 % ow A ((,gh g m ).
A m isme % sa r c-re.ss con veer. nes) me nr coi nen, mw c.~wss me .-
s e v e ~ 6, <~o me ut as y ausaurns on ra e vrwr. a so Go co~rero.~).
- $1EA3 //3 o "st, 4:, ff yf su 6000 te<Mrw [!tetor' fet Mr/dMr) Actsrsue 7, russa- e~en.. , p., car nu c.s ra. s , so - n ~r.
- %r 70 s st~ r tw evsr'seco SM4Y eo~ rea s is svar c4 rien t. , m pero r, n ,. ,,
- Arcommeno A/a Ac nw .
T x M l ESSEX HUM N FACTORS PRO ANAGER" m)
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
/ i WESTI SCPROGRAMC9fRDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: -
g ,p # 0 /10/d &
)
DUQ'UESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING' MANAGER i
DUQUESNE CO@NY4tfG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
$ WJ e &
' DUQUESNE LI6HT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
\w.b4E TN C 6 -\ %4 I
eerdsen % b A A b ( - w n h mum wu(W (M" %
s,a A 4. Ib -h NanwddR Bu$N
~ E-h56lb-0 6 (, A wuuJvEika M" Rc-ML (E-5) 333 u nuw),ab Si6 m 3 t
M- h5g (c-s') \\ws. Acws-vo Q o3 E gy' tosc h stws-A g e g A3" ET - h5R (C- f.} \\3tf
'\CwSW& A9" RC -155 (fif) 9% 'hb.% bed q.3 cAcl. Q _
ci knuw.6 Clena d
O I
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREFANCY (NED) REPORT PS a) 6 Y N'h l PLANT / UNIT i
. b) ORIGINATOR: T %R< c) HED NO.: 2 VN -/M d) REVIEWED BY: d/ e) DATE: b AM (W(stinghouse) /~
T (Essex)
Ma '
f) HED TITLE: bebu u o
- N ov- k]t< E4we\1Gr.aImaYawkg e
NW krsvw Nhemi\ V t w bfAL G .
O g) ITEMS INVOL b,s y
- y dVED .u.Q \M .
h) F90BLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: ( .\.k.\ 4 h. k.A Di.<pbgs, hww Nb y .wA vw% A p 4 cs+wA k 6h p w d b h m ( h w . , m A vi w ) y ,(i b h NA* w4 .\o s \.ac hi y a b b A L y.w. ww w u %g% h<
- \\ bse\4gs n M . Tcq%n..h. absgegs abut.).lut. 66v4 So','
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION HlMBER:
G%\ km Swes ,%akvqrwd7ais T e i. u s.t.s DLcIN Ry 0a j) SPECIFIC HlNAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
% k\ ko Ce a \S 6 g, .
k) REVIEW AND RECOHCNDATIONS: ,
b 5t. L<e\M W !<J $ 5 6% q(,
A%A ph4 phes/sabA g -b % wh4 wg
- W g s % % th W \ u h 4 W g % m % . A '< 4 eaJs us um swe.k hiphy *<=\ocA d .6 n k 10% k Ctlht.
. s-' % a r- m c a ,n a , ~ . , , , ,,, o,- - er is ~" - **s" ^ * -
cei we-Irrors 76o a I /OS~ 8 (SG /rerr. A r!- 4 #CS W.A L>e Aar. Ar-) "o D'5'( " v5 mr KrneML s~ / Lor F** "T" *** 8t"#ck w b par & M E* Af4 tr- t ecnie , i. e . H'CMM vP C +'
- Artoc+rr fos- po s'C0 A^^ ^^
VitTIC A L PANEL.
~W' ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT M AGER 8th DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
< / ~
j WESTI @ SE PROGRAM INATOR 1_) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
76 & ; % . A m A &-
xx -
,1 d= Lh' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY EN REERING MANAGER
/E/ 7ap fr l DUQUE GHT C0 d NY 5EG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
[8WC DUQUESNE LIG#T COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
_ - - - _ - - - - v - -- -- -
2 HEt
- 2 Vf.u -!y05-
. l'3 o
p____h______4
=
k ,.
'a ce
- * % p <
I F 1'-
=
- : e e
1 I- / a I / a e l
?
I C I /
I g -
a I
l I /
=g l
- wg I /*
I g i /
i/
- ,s ll II
. s
=
l [
.g -
3 sue J #fuS
- M&
f t
-s 73 a .
as
.4 a 45
- h "o~
- c . .
g, . . .
}g M se .s r nap
TP-J,g h"'%ROPotec x R1cs Hep;yy _l g5 SPPCND\X B1)4 mthsuncxc.ms ohTh -Arac *e* r f DMQuEst4C, E.hN Ef'4htLEy-% ,7p-g 1 L\9 l.4,9 BRT E (VERTK6L P6dELh O\l T -of- N 16 V4 D \5PLhY.S Thqs e. &sp Cu~ *
- w eg g da 5 skkwwdhe. nt R A e.
%%\,
h, Mc.4 htws \ N wb A<* a f a,e M 99 ow va44ida\ ga h Cg 9com m k = A c/r 6 .ck h a r & sT .
%s\ikogL.1.1.Eb. s4o c.v A c.t 4.l.1.b4 A-7 "LTE A N 6. DESCQIPT O N T1*$ SoRoet mcWERY DEGhstriER %)h+us T f Mecabtu Rs. RE coRbER -
A-S '
l O l (o BWlc ActD- ThdK LEVEL MconDEC
% 6> b REhCSOR. <ccLhtC SYS WlDf RANG E'
_g yv
~
96555URE RECORDER see ArrxHmeur 1
~
h-9
\D % T P CQ. D RM XF R, TK Al M0tch'MR.
W%% PRI DE R Kr R %h,A Wb\ch%R Wbl 94hCTOR Com suT*P tf.YEL 0 EcsRBe R, ,
%% L%f %\,W ,M Cot.D LE6 Tcae c 6.wtuac Rcces.oER c, R inbsc.AToa L-s c> ttTsj
(.hw Acp TEMP 99OR DER.)
- ~ - y-HEEua v4+ --i tos-h*"' " /
l c_5 ;
ITEth RB. B E s c R \ 9 t\ ot4
\ E \%h STenM BRPGMSTEMP RCcoQ.D E.R
\6\%S EATRACTtod SW hM QRh\t{5 TEtwe RECORDER, c- 6 sm Gt.N xiSAc press
' i o5 REco 0.0 E R.
N'# ao e, cws mov iwusum. uom
, ,t x
\\3o c, b GAR wuicmos uenTs 1
/
C.7 + c. E C, R. tuotcAToA LwnTs, wea. R0ul
%55 $6 Remed Pe*c.R , P owcR UN G
u 1 S le e.cs setret\cTi PoviLR ,
M7 Diff E.x P Powc R. ,
\t 6 A Rc5To g. P os Ge d ,
asi SPEC.B+%WE foytEg,
%54 CWdG 6%PhNS\bd " "
0.6%R 9csmoN Mta, u%h TwR&wC \d $T66E PRE 55 95.ccADE R.
1646 TuR EWC \d $T666 9R555 (RECoRbER
~~.
c 7 s CL (carhmM Heo %vn -mor ArrdedMd 1.
T TC ft M4. D ES c. Ri9T\Ge4 lioW h,g,c, sin cB Ro "L N b \(-AT l6G LI6 HTS t%C, F, G,H c-A w9F G ATT h-6 NBLTS 2nd tco co R l
noF G eTr A-b GRo\tt40 NoLT.5 Ie4D\ckTcA 9
e 9
9 i
H E D No. ~2 v ++ - 19 o s-Arr4c.ame ~r 2 g, wrcli It% 96 0 -
bc.% - 66t SA y Ude. L _. y Pms.~
[ tRc PR 907.]
W\Tl4, E)TH M lb S4 9 - $TA.b = . b enup bwp. 21 A ,2) & Feed Ww Recurci.er
[ 2 S GC. - P A 1o%]
oR , 16 545 - An. %. b Ewp. (?eb. .le r 2tA It\B inss. 6uk
[24ss - PR \\ t ]
b, $w nca vrem toS f3 - % . Cw isA,B,c., h s. Teco M
[ 2 MSS - PR 475]
wirH 2h 2 M - CoMe Sc.wm S-A. A ,5 Je'6 M s. M i
[2cNm -eg to3]
I
i v ~~
-t-l e m. 2v - we m /4 rt A c WE di 1 i M ]l- ~ ""
-;-r = = =,= ... , = = - _ ,a. - , -<
_ _ _ =_3 7,,=
- .u w :.w.yl- - . _ t8.,_ il$<.1, ---
, z ,, n
- w. a. =. := := := ll a l = = = =w.-
I
- 7. :- u. = = x:. = i.p:,, ,, m. .w- ::.:. = .= e. ::::. :== = .... .
, w. :::.lm.w.m:
'a " "~
Es1 u.c R'. b uw
- e. e. ===
=ce'"n; c = a 3- w. n,j n "'*
- C'ME. r**
- A !.a;"- l " ro P'sitoi n.u. pe,o i
y ii mi.
'l , s !. 2. v g i.=, i.u, I p.. .....
~*
~ ---
, .l ..
- 6 1~ ~ ! Sb ~~
P. 6/* l 8 '. 5* '
5 - -l o l he m ==
am nn L,' n ,,,u.ml . 1. ... .. .. ss s Eil e = =
I C '::::M 'd'* T-
= et I n 4, m.... m0 si.a. air est aus .ee.... .
- = ;c =w te.s.was x* une tr e c: c:
VA M 25. """ '*'* "*
li 1.
u 2 sa: , ties "" " ' " ""*
- un
"" Msc.5 s 2 u. ...
> I ,
ni e,h lis,o
___ m .
esi as:
est,
[l n.a g, n- ,. = ,
M1 i
.m. . i. ya
- I
= ' hl e m:
F#It~ ~*!.= .6,_
=.
"i '5+
F m
,u . .n.
y -
y:
sm. l W
i 1
v.
L Iw am
_L
.. s !
. s r. 2 ....e.,...-
p Lw:,y inia l
l tu.n.
- u. css visse ' ig,
' 4 an. uin- _L--u. .ns,3 l t
,,3 .,=.=. .
I e mien muse [p, , , ,
I i .... l 4 g., .
-) . . , . .. . , i Tny a ~ - _-) _ - -. .. - _ . e I sort +} ~ -*$F ~ ~ .3 I
.: d ll~
y ip 2 f= 1 l p::~.- m.- en ..n. . .. ,, .. .. . =*
~
iI ',i"" ,.-....,,... ........ r, s a .,-
,, - -. =...:.:5.3.
i r,.m .
co.
swe. tue.
l
, Il 2nc tti i a sc.s- ,Mb ws I
l y
3**
- 6. o e...
i.negn 1,)$ -
,y1 Fmi us,s.tuc
-s a
, ii.5 utam &
i l
gMin jl, sai '
mrua siem ess
?
=I l = +I
= = =.= s = =- 3
= = w. ~l's p1 t
h g,
La enm assc s l e
!hx l tains & set.c.
I' O o
lI Ilg 1
,i lt I.
lI g
3 Is I e.e.uve lI H il jgs. e l l IssC UR8085 l3 sllj ese j ld l ll
!3 D
- SeEC AtaO ll 9t r.tc4 Ccx1As.T 010 % l, y TAME LEEL 'l SY& %f.Ot geserg l l ICMS-LAiO6 ll .et L5uM4 l y
{r $
ej l' IEs,.,
" il n
'I#C4*P9*0% h$
et l5 -"! io.
inl f l1 ap ier c!!H il p
si e 135 let5 NOTE' l 4'al 8" n l z =>
t_
!.l E
. ly N
,' IU aw lg lil 2==
e_l-;- l =.= __
e _=r-REAi 3..=.rJ_.g=.p=p=__._ i i
, _3.- _ _ =. =.','=i = r -= a = r E[Ei -
- Ihf I . i_ ,i_ _ _ _ i._ a _ ,i_i _i _ _ _H _, _ u _ _ J i'_ 3 __ i__i ___ _4_+i____
8 i
_ _ _ _ 4 _ t _ _ _ _ a ..
i m__,i i .rw rRe v 8
- i l I I i i di i i i e il ; i i ne l l l 8 l
7,w,ammuol i l 3
i n i i i i i i i ' l u,.m .
i i il,i : i n
,i l i i ii ra me m4 i . n i :
I i i i i i Il ,;
! ma,=h 8
e
' i l ti ;i l 1 1 l l i ii l REFE i i '
u i i ni , i cE,Es i
n 'i ' i ni . .i j w'a'M I !
l l l n !! FRONT VIEW l i l i i i ii l n
i i i ;
i 1 ' VERTICAL BCMRDSECTION A8 SH4 i ,
i l I :
ll
__l_____g_____j_y__q,'_J_q___.7,BEAVER VALLEY POWER STATION-UNIT to.2, j
-71.= g.=== = .= =6 = = = = =H. _4 _g= = p t=- * =. -k ._ e.e = r
, AAIN 1mu-tE-250 -i--
- 6 TTP Il
_ _ _ _. _ _ _. __ _ 26:
i
! l lli,,
II
- e
1 5'th d' 'I r* E N I#-c l72 i g 1
.e .
W. . I II bt . jt eM4RJ
- "g/ ; Tip'
- h. EsYe[e f i t.dc".,
A W. a i,t.' p.". i.O'T %"ME.
I 'l eJM!.'d/ '/J .?.*.
I1,ff.!J.i n im arc
- WW men ,q 63... y' *g~
cm.
s's .. .,
e.suu,r, 4 a.n. es .as ~
.y i
.i'aa'a.ra eaj y ns esa r D1 t q* ' O 4.m. < r. 2 t., t.u g.. .eis.on t.n :
l' q at & &I lst 62 tt { to to g ,,
y, ,3 ,!j 4ytI 8'D 'gEQ ,,,
p l .aos a;oljms[ae was . r.e : yy I j g4 .
,,. n ,
l ,,,
Ny qgQgm i ,, ,,, ,
U ioao i m. tr., y , ' . . I nous stis ta'e 1%L vs 3 li inyAu.
p, ll us.e. sr.rv s ,,,,j ef g H j. . w. l k.l Y.'. .q c
W M
- c. v.
- '." HED No. 2. V v v - 14 c 5- p ,-
'h y usar...e, .
- l g7,, ;;.t . ,
pmagrgrt 3,ggim(Tig3 T ,{gl;Q Q* , Q g Q p .p, y ay {Q=* N 1 g ,, ,
, O tease ST[ AM I 1 4.; g gg t*y* ,,
u.,
lfy Ch a--*% s t e41 o t. 4 s a 7 w. ig
! .u. .k n- u. A
's . - km pa % __ ,( n ..*6 j
k W:I 7"+--
f7 ft[(t$
- ~if I.Ad
~:
$ sYoi ,3 #
.#ito 2.~~f 5
l 8
M\
.-Ao .-A'e r
2.E '.; '!; r_. m,
,.@ ,.@^ t,g l1,
".* l m a :=, 2.x r
- .'e
" o'~ S'lr.G554Cv4a EM :.
i 4- e .,
.' <m. ,,
W [t' .Y E." #'.'"'
6.* it *."
dI II"),' , I !Is' D 'lav .s a D.b.S .i I.
- 2 w--ioi =250S A0v128gL.
,r __ ,1 D... i AY.a . - g ,ni 4Q .aa t y. -
.9e n
I sdha a w r n = = = = ==ar ,ana = = y ,g
- .40f EST 6, t R L2 l
sia 94 zu. 'n ll q G~of ~Xey ES %67 -
j g~ , trs] y
e a M-= = = .=..,
I Od e. ate..= =nota = = =s= = = = x=37- =. < .r=. _Ty/P'
--. a ;
a% k.l', , ~ i n . m .,
p_ g n. -d.r H n,.
h,,., (g, A::,
C' I?'.*, C; ll C f/* ff-Iy
,,,,.,, e.u'A /s'o'I. 'i e.
ll tao ',acw" ., gg a ,,,,
n we eessa 08 2i3 bc y g.s o,a,s egs re r r,e,
. ,, f Leu (cur re ccL.ev
? l ll g teis-t(semi.a 3, , , , , ,,3 ll 'T g/ ' ' ' ' ' '""** i %,'
g;
)
- *j 3*j 7por gI
. Il
[g "Jo o t 6 u ,,r,a t
- b.s-8 tita utsskitic l z, y
u tru 2M a n..nmps c fl eoa eos tw a **Ison Y, ,,4, .. o lg g
986 J.Z2. 9// ") is 2 7t.
~'
wo l Y l
, % n.="a,~,~4
- ===- I 1;l h V = = = == =,=,= - = = = == =Ii*l =
h]=]= l
=
== -
y pawit IS DLOCatt0 Sf i
' etconces sqgeggge gg I
/ l $115MIC FAAME 7 llp _ i. .,.
4.
.g aene L i ts,me. s a n r.,e s. e ,,,'I e
$4 a - ig st= v. T ll ilY g _,*_*
i aus Sin eso s a.o.3 #tmeAT '
F dqg l i 2 Rtutaf STs4 astm g
gg g hlig l stow { ne u.,,lo.. n oss e= n t yt v,w, ai o. .
I ,,,
, g ll1, i = / . c_
eh isur @
n, gl g suil.nas teoA 28c6 ie l -I- , IY f' Y l[ @ @' ' I p n. s ey.. ,urs l nir i d I - 8. g.j ' 'p. - 'hala) i!.s krs.vl.ss = , I4-)Ili i =I i
@ r_) I ira .s* sie ness i"ii I V ,,l
,,i 11 I-1-~p
[.gj a gE},wt.H---5 n
, sra osa tec r=<n l
~
Er T} 3, [ >
o es W H 8
g AmsFa*75 l' Ij1,;li (a'gdig esa<t .
I ,i g 4
' $, gr7 ~
I :A at
@'M.7.3tM,pl l,i f son, 1058 0I i~_y .
i Sienataiu etc.: w l i,i, ;,
- L 1 . otts s a ti41 g s**st is emcuto ev stusic. rnAn.E -r lof ,
=; = = p n=m .T = :t = =- : = = = = 4I 9 l' 8 i
= y' .- -h:, ::= = = =I 3 :y= = = = = =ni = = p I I I e '
i e #
L_L._ _.4_A __ __.d.
..J__p__,'l__ ___.___s_ p.
il l I l 8 8
) i i
. g _ _ _ _ _ _ .4 _ I I I I
I I il l l l 1
l s I l Il I I I i( I ; l l l ll l' u e a l l l l n l i 1, ! l
'i l , l '
it i e i i l l l
1 I ll 8 I
i
' 8 I I h i i 4 1
l ll 1 i
.: ' ' 8 la i i i e F- i
- i. . . a r i-- 7 '--i si l n' ...a il 3 ll g 8
e i
' I 11 i --'l l 1 3
I i #1 '
I 0
ll ' I 1 i i 0 8
i ' l :l i I e i I li c i o i i i i i,' l ll ' ii l i i i i ,
n ! i !, i , i il a
i i ii t I i
.i l 8
l l
9 .____.4 p' _ _ _ ._ _ _ q_ l,_
11 i 8 i
_.a.________y_y____;_p__ p_________q__p___._p .
t= =u = .= = =t. :.r= = _p = =. = = = = = =.r= =l = = = . i= = i= = - =!- = l= =. h.
3 Zfs Il b.
i it It II t ll il O I
.s .++,_ 3 -
I %, i a 2-2 I
p3 - * $
u
\
O VERTICAL B BON C6.SH2 ~~~~
N
.. u_
, _ _ _ _ __ _ _a______a__.--_______ _ _ _e BEAVER VAlt.EY POWER STATION UNIT NO.2 c o ma sa.
AA No 1HH-RE-25R
- 2J E lv ANN MF C. CO. Ow C. NO. E.35? ?,5H 2, Alv 's.
it.Lu M
HUMAN ENGZNEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) BV P5 /1 PLANT / UNIT b) , ORIGINATOR: ptE WIL50b c) HED NO.: A VM 'd -ID
.0 d) REVIEWED BY: 8 e) DATE: 7- 3)-Th
(>!aitindhouse) [
$ (M (Essei) %
CRT VIEW t tJ 6 AM 6LE' 700 sry) ALL_
f) HED TITLE:
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
tgmAs CRT 4 5 , SE.CDO M <- OG VtAT\%L BONt b lATILi'N CAT 4(p y BECDON A CF VERD CAL BoAA.D h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: b.l. Q.3b hui6ebes mcmmend % b m uu m g le \aa.h w a m & c p olt. h Los bL ney m g\ w y (, 4.3new % 4 gp qi mw skewld 6 %*. g3\% % opuo.b. d% oy A daditohd c< spews 4 sblg O v ie.w.e 3 a.w}c. 6 \ns Ao %!
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
bnho\ bbHy# %
T p \.a. a s.\.\
DLCLN Ryo3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
n\5k b piM3 .w d atmmhl vitvJ CRT disphy,
4 x) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
g< den, dh e.obabl3 hsw b mo" M o po5dcw Artdd3 %
he,d d CRTs b cod % dabpq h su&j ck sman v wing agle n nc\ m Atad a nwge< p roblem . N o w..hibdww re.e.= em.d Ak .
. ra,--e-. 24 s~.
A M ESSEX HUMN FACTORS T MANAGER MA DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER ,
t WESTINpSEPROGRAM INATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: -
- O /9 C"7~~/ d O k
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER S
- DUQUESNEp COWMY RfG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
@W -
DUQUESNE LIdHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
O 01 !
A I
- T
, I i
i I
i >
i m '
I \
' N I
i 1
e d *
.n .
N i.
i e i i
' M t ,MI I I I i 1
- 3 i x g l M N N $ s 5
("4, -
C[ ,.__.
W -
b "
- l i
N -
__ n 3
I * /
~
's /
l,xx.Q
' 4 /
a
- f .
f E i ,, /
- s : - /
.j i\ /
h a j ; # ,
a
' e O , e-5
, 5 o
- -s s1
- 4) N e- F s
h
$,h h
a j x
HEf)* ^ vs 4 -14 06 l
-- , s
. /
' %/
- s, ,
).,
!/ \
i s
/ \
l y e
e 1
l \
I s/ 'j,~ s \
\
r** i g' . ., ' \
.<' 1:
s .y
' t i !11 PrailO '
, ",~-@7 p i/
i /
' **$ /
t l
E i 3 !'
' nt l
is3 l
' Assi Al O
W i h ; e i/
. g
.p ,
n .
,5 ' 5
- 3,, i a 4
$ o .
I 4 4 4 w 4 I >' i g F, . j lu o 3 x- i /; ,,, :
- V
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a)_ RV PS -A .
. PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: M Fra o c_he.c c) sed NO.: MS- W oB d) REVIEWED BY: /h, , 3 e) DATE: k$Mk6 (WestSighouse) [ '
Y x M "
l (Essex) f) HED TITLE: COG S ,
are and o%cd bC.Monal reach of 4he 5t h pecceMle Re_ ad&.
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
See aM acheel Ush.
~
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G. l .2 .O d . (2)
Con 4ccAs a ce arsproMma.hdy w" Frocn bhe Geni- edge CO ne console . The. maxmm reach oG We 54 percenelle femde adu.lf is aeeceximahd3m,a
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
(_..k. SorVey (R403) j) SPECIFIC HlNAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
5% percenW\e female _ ockdf operelecs are n:h accornmodahd.
I k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: h From aOeched lish, de_k, rrednq, 'W hi c.i'.
con \rds a % d opece M o n { orponksde 4o % eder hc by shemta be poc_ab,a. t cunc on he beard. En son 2.
con 4ru\s are locabel no <mce M as inches from Ne. -Fren
$"-o9 b eonsole.
@ n a s % u .-a a m \ s. M an epoca4ees s o be. alste to reach dois sc < - ..- .
. > _ , , . ,, . .; _ y . z . = % G . -
'% N .hn:q ~n) a- G S(? u z . . , as s E :. +c, -
.. cmh'
. ; d, , (.
p a a,&,b % d pac cou d t
%, pa J rip \a<%tN-a eb d cdn\s, \u en% ti.<6, ESSEX HLM5N FACTORS 'ECT RXNAGER No A cTl a tJ p- n DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h, . -
WE'S p 5E INATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION-i A'
DUQUEINE LIGHT ' COMPANY ENGINEEpNG ' MANAGER l
/EM 0. 7./s=rs -
DUQUESNEJIGHT40MPANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER I
@W
[DUQUESNELIGATCOMPANYOP l
2 E S k - 140 8
)\
~
/ -
f ,- ~
r e.%a.A %d,r4a. a.w / r
/
/ /.
l /-
p a e h4a.**)
4.- m'<. as " ' '
c.t.s
//
s 9 f'_
V s 1
, f y7, (wa.w esa. r Q 9.4, i
.\.
w mu 88 .
g w su. %
.\
a3 K
1 I
B' n' W V i
07.5 I
i I
I V V V i y
' i i c o" bM6C COGNf $h okh ew(N 9806.
Y' Q \f s c4 O
I4-0%
WED D ESK -%
contro6 are beyonA Hw bac a En< bana\ reach 4 H'e 5^Pu=Lt. 6L am
.Es t IreK NO
- 9. Svs w Pcv to1 A , e, , c_ process cochro b es i 19 ,i 2 0 ,v u G.5V5 M PCV io t A , e, , c. -fransEcc sd'bcheS li95 1205 tat 3 3 w(_.V tog s2a 96v5 h pcocess conkroh e-2 sus
- Mcv tcA +consfec .s i \ ci , uns tsa ac as - T E Yt aa. process cen4roN.c., transGe w A h asa;asg%
RC4S - kov 31) conhoi sui.4c_h ., p;shba+on bnfor asq ; a qq PR'Z_R SL BLE. RESET confro\ sAch aac
$TM LIN E SI BUL RESET selecbr sdch aa\
5tS BLk RESET poswoA4=n & cans 7er aacT N SL BLL RESET codrei mLb aaa STHuNE SL BLK RESET sekecb< switch aa3 SIS BLK PsESET pos% Mon Fransfee asar c
QCMS - MO V 3\o coMre\ 3J.fA ; p2shbMon transrer &?H,pa41
-ES3 dCRS - PCV 195 processcodrobe; Nnder sMch 3t~l;3i76 OCHS - HOV 100 A ,B confro\ sui.fch , pushbbo (-ransEc sib ,3) ct 3tt s,3A s
- 2. RSS - Fcy GOS A procc35 con 6N ; fransk,- sw,\ cts 3ao, nog
gr.n 9 ESM -36 l40% I 6 n No.
ES3 N g RH s - H cv 758 A preceos cedrokc; hnsfermilch 3m ,nts a.RHs - HoV 7aoA ccdrd s d; pushbubn hander 322;an T aR145 - HOV 750 A con 4rel swik_h; ymsh6b Lder us)sasT E.5 -$
9.RHS - Fo/ 505B pecess cmhder, ("*ro\ swih:h His,4tes RRRS W ~758 ptxess cdcobr; cocAcel .swike.h en,4ns 2RBS - Roy 7aoB eon 4rol e A h ; Mao;yaor
%6bn franskc s.Rns - Hov 755 B conhol sAch ; pos%bfcander 4ai; 9atT Suppl y Breker RE7 cook. sua. ; pos%bIconsCee 4\5pitsT 39ly Breaker RF7 ccd. sw. ; psM:Jren harsQc 417,417T
HUMAN ENGZNEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) 0A~S PLANT / UNIT A).ReOJay c) HED NO.: M*d /70/
b) ORIGINATOR: _
e) DATE: IIff!fY d) REVIEWED'BY: '
%st'inghouse) /
Y x M (Essex') ]
f) HED TITLE: f4u.uts # evFwM 4!^a Neceoen AcA x
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED:
GFfwtarCtow MCconcia. D'!UE CGAk Awa secco<out twoe Rou.c em .
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Deba s / usa,o GletsE, rite epf u >ur c w Kun cocua PA M rne oc aa oa oe, < eas saa n+c sco<oa m.,. 2.
ao suor- acrenr.
80 L.L. tf4f., ono A,: d~ H [Ytt M .rc s /,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY s pro .3 ooog ER MM D MN D%h j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
A'WM occxanaJ en eawx /Arcac QAs suor ehuoxeo.
O
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
R5,sa,J pegwsrfdC7 fcESADEG CN smsxDaa&G L20 cock.Pw x cums en_o at m o tr rac caana kw~oo4~ han~~
{&7SO4A*c") YD AS$ 4Gs.C PG8m%.
, joewisrsanuec o racas er w nur ro p *cves r- M prouce rne ax w uoco a ru.s p.eesese .
- AKoM("O A/o a Ayrw Y (A- A l ESSEX HUMAN' FACTORS P 'MXNAGl9t DUQUESNE' LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- 9. 2, V D WESTIN SEPROGRAMC00pATOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
)
mn aa na y,~ ep A w M 4M M a.o ,
24vl&
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l
1 I i DUQUESNE T COMPMY FfEG. ' AFFAIRS MANAGER fS Ww DUQUESNE LIGkT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
\
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) bb- 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: /J. N 6J d4 V c) HED NO.: AI*'E' # I d) REVIEWED BY _
e) DATE: ///V[8'l (W(stinghouse) /
(Essex) x 'M -
f) HED TITLE: Wl*M 'A S?2&r OE4, s) Acnusry out rs eggu ,em
.frLi/Pcx re cto sreAt1 Ho w g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
th eit 7D851 10 Mrx Ocmen MLG" /. gg. g. .,p g h xtl/4 ty .trE M 02 4,s W 6 6iAVdFC A.!M /M h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
Linfar feo, s w ayt: Fsvusraer tra' kre,. cs4vseDB/ Ws4tav&df fvJe CDsc5 in rite ,4cf exaMin. du"Ac cF- I- ca-c -to nt, JEscuruv isa overins e c W/YDes4rN M W. I Nd A4/uMr .57E'o4r'1 OC4od Ricertue?R tWi*3 CAILdD
'1o* flGvatts- (ke RGraicoe f& cuerJLous,0c.,,
- 1) , DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION LER Jgo- gjoyg .
MR QE.Vit.W DLCW M6 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Eb&rnur' /*Attor.E #suur1Jo- o d wcen9eeD .s7aers De4W AeThiry.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
&'VicJ ixsrxo.wors,r,a.J res An <eiE znow< xts e f&iMifMr Keii uw <<i.r Asse f sansec' rv cebR I
m
\ NA
\ t ESSEX' HUMAN' FACTORS 63ECT MANXGER et w DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
' t j RDINATOR WESTIpVSEPROGRAM ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
-N W DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY ENG NEERING MANAGER f ~
1 DUQUESNEpT COMRflihY RfG. AFFAIRS MANAG WWmw
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HL. MAN ENGIEERING DISCREPANCY (ED) REPORT a) BVPS-2.
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: M ADElhl E RY8EY c) ED NO.: 1444 -A@2 d) REVIEWED BY e) DATE: OLT . 11. (484
(#stinghouse) /
C. P. No. W N _ m h (Essex) ] '"
f) ED TITLE: I'd A A AtT rA b l LA ELis f o u S Asdn Sou I u6s .
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
SEE A'TTM.HED L\STS h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NL8eER:
4.5 .1 D, d ORAR. ALTR D)MSM510MS %D 59 ACM -
M 51RorE Wl0TB-Tb- CRAt.ACTEML- BE.16WT RATIOS MLETTEA MOTn-To HE16%T lt.ATI05 (f)popelt.AL wno1H-TO- ret 6KT RA~fl0S g)Mtum0M 59 ALE 84TwepJ CRAv ALTGK5
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
DiSPLAM sue.9eN5; 79 5-1 S t.) 0\ C.\N R%3 l
j) $PECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EGJIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
CW cAuSE ERROR. lu EEAbscq DtSRRf5 Ahc DELAMED OPERAh tagspousE, 9
k) REVIEd AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
ME\4 54.hk M wiTH P9 O% O.MC& DIMElJSieUS A00 SPAav4 se:ote es Mw.tso, no/- trov C w a 79 As'inws , x ! Y umss) m wc terre <~G oa
, zrms we om.kse,*m .. veny aoWeevLT m oveo. As , regneg ggg- o g, a fttum.m cq0 M rttM6 /7T01 $* //O / - //Otf ytnf A snot r AMMSL L~
/* W " MC f y. 04rek t F77t9t'l^'& *H s, ptrF" RA ct GA*c.owof jvoTf 77Em.$ il O / - //0 */ ;Ao<./k he W Ctk hotv St- a f c.lmik lek!'s on cl<rk back ny oQ
- cluacfer ,/.merviemt ms pc.hg tvent.- .G d 6 4- no pn Wer.'
N\
ESSEX H M N FACT MOJECMAGER
- s/w DUQUESNE LIGHT CorANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
$ ' /
WESTI SE PROGRAM INATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AN SPOSITION:
p ,L A J AW n'M /
p AM A
,xh 3l s Atd AD f'"#
- m. , ,
a h ( 14 gj I[ DUQUESNE LIGHT ~ COMPANY 1:NGINEERING MANAGER 7l2'll6E
- t" e ls hd ilem he, h p p E'J '
DUQUESNE IGHT MMPANf REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
'- C' 4 1 ' w. k, *{ e ce c ., 1, c.
.[l C'*- +e ,cc .. . h +
, ' DUQUESNE LIdHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
\, '
v.l;l m.
R'#. c3 ' . . A L. h.... di. .. .
.t..l t _
\ / 3, 2VCS-Ft.og/ 90 g$09 M HD %. -
- . (- x - -- _. _
l L . 5, t .3 ,d YG 04 Wh%-A 2.
(t) 5TCot.E - w nota - To - CH At2.M_Ts - l4616HT E.NTloS S HoOLD i BG BelvaseN 1 6 No I: 6.
CtR.tOUWc ~4AETEQ.5;. BL 4 - Ili A 4 o Oteet C,.ew Saseo .._
HPetAu MAuuAt_ (outr_otten. States . 6A4 -9T1, e As -909,,39,.
146,16l Tasao Fetotoms . %4 - sb+ A As ; yas- 444- AAa; vcs - tott Age
(.M (EITER. W\CTIM -To- %GhnT SATI05 SHOULO 25 SETWetpJ t'. \ A ra b 3 . 5..
[tRtot. Af. METER.s , BC4- D1 AqB plE5EL. HEN 5 PEED
(.3) MmAGEAL \nttrin-To- mwT pttos swout.o se s.S.
Cte.toue. nelc45; 6c4- ill AA6 OiE5EL C-as SR5tst>
UAtou M Auunt. CouTa.ottee SCAtes'. BAA- 9T1 ; ras - 909,139,746,76 1
(t) kAtusMOM 5PNe estWeed ctw2.M: Tens swout.o es.
cm STgotc6 W1oTH.
$cM .0atutAt. udTERS: Vts- l tot -ito4- x41 wiuose l
!.MActAN kAAuvAL (A01Eott&5 Cates: BA4-911 ; bas-9cA,119,1%,14i i, TRENo (leto?_0a6 : (.ML1 An- Nesa\u6nouss) VA6 - Edi,971',
i !j VK1 - Bn , stb, Bt4 ; VAB - B3\ , B44,645, tot 6 ', 9 A9 - Ss3 A ,863 a t
a q _ ST1,1041,4% ; NBb - 44B. 444, ASB ,4S9 ; V86 - %l A ,44)S, A4i 4 i[ 4410, 4% A , 445 A, %5 8, 4 4 5c, 443 0, 4+16 ; Vc.G - 274,tBo A',
i:
li; z. sos, zei ,ss2, ioss ; vc, - 244 e, 264 A ; ku- tws- m u ,
!!! zwvc-98.zi
HUMAN ENGZNEERTNG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) B M - 2.
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ MS E L\ n E %YhEY c) HED NO.: hn*-D3 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: O/T. 12.1964 (l(stihghouse) /
T \M (Essex') ]
f) HED TITLE: (nR AtimTns tamGikVTS AS A 911McTIOM OG V i L%)t M(a btM A tarC g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
C1R.LuLAE. ME'IER.S ANb COMED SCALE
- M69.Tt LAt, 1Mb tCATots j' Rog.tzouTM 190tcxtomj cogTAottsm; mt.swo ae7.ocoa3 (exc.sy7 VAS : iott-tois; yAct , Ba As,s ; as: 444 A As; VCs tois A g 6 ;
Vc'7 : 2A*),151/2 5 2.) .
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
GRADUATioO %GetW% A6 A FONCTtot4 0F VtEWiMC1 DLSTAMCE M 0700 CsotDet.tues, lo,S ,1, S ,b ,) DD MOT MEE*i f164010.E -
rems.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CO,MPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
D15 PLANS pt*NED T 5. \ Bl.1 Md MQ j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
l 69.ADOATt0MS M OT O Y R EtotA p e u DEO Het6KT uhN LAvsE OPEW.AitcN ex.itot gu RE ADiMe) ANO DEL M (** 96PouiE Tt M6 .
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONSg G m W e 6.5.i.5 b b ,ss 4 b h sm w c o h (;_
-N. bb&% bbum s%\< gmLA. . Lyk MV,h The 455 LAN
- M Sh W a b Ak .sc Akst f 4 WLO ,
M 9M wo t ( %v4 (t's. . M h5 '4 N m hsJm.5). M c G 5 5 4 t%
b \ kco t T R C %(a %Ar N E Av4 sw d wth wik hb Aw Ch\ A d C/5 5 % c k d C A h h G.\ 8- h\$1 gelq,tg h4 d s b wA shw@4j<u.-k+k ,2A % 6 4M a bin..
uL
% IM ESSEXHdMANFACTORS]JECTMAIGIGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEM LEADER
' /
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
~ Wd
~
&4 DUdUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER ff00.
DUQUESgLIGWC#FANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER t .t / - &
f f;;=- _ J --
DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER 1
HUMAN ENGZNEERZNG DlSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.) RvPS -2 f PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: ' E G A C. b e C c) HED NO.: \/M c2Ods d) REVIEWED BY:
) e) DATE: \ [J9 !M d /
(Westindhouse) (/
v (Essex) 3% '
f) HED TITLE: dedm et[- is Mid n a hon disp \ cid O '
I g) ITEMS N LV TR?w w'd P m RCS - M M
(. F) Tg RextecCoolanh (wp \ z,3 rR_46
^ Sham CTn CPSt Q) Fra_%une 2Hss PR - 4'7 b I /o) 8WST lave l GCSS LR- IDC; h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
v.sud d, splay p m M i1 % w M l mcm cL'd c;,u cpcabcs ch % ,.6 .mb a tml sqh .n ..lu a eJ p$.2.vele e v d e necclech ko,% l b k recg .c i eN .1Ls [G.5.1 I b ]
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND uuGUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION 6 Cc1 CA C k h M OCG Cd 5 k\ R e i cb i kM b ik.k .h 5I W\ icA cub,o s (R400 ,
^
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Opacabe rny mbsn6 W dWe ecl info
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONSt ggb I pg ) Q(
CO 6 CO Sd6
{i7MM IM ESSEX HUMAN FA'CTORS PROJECT XNAGER 2
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER b* Y/
WESTIN % USE PROG Q RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
Le g&W ~
's
- A M- %6 _
3lta/s ; - .? -te.- ,r..l le
. < ~ b ; 'e s , .wa .urj
.[* ,, . t .{ >,,4 v.( c n 3.. r .%,
l,8 = /w ,
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER r,,., .
,... , , 3 d,/ cn z o.
,-( i.. -h '
f j pl f;~
' 4- W'/,
...v c ,, DUQUESNEpHT COMPANY ARG. AF/ AIRS MANAG m, .s . . . . -
.... n a." Y' O-2 >- s J
' DUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER t .m,
l l HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
~
a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:_ N kM b c) HED NO.: UE*M d) REVIEWED BY: , ,
e) DATE: 349/85 (West %ghouse) ~'~/
%-_ eM J (Essex) M f) HED TITLE: lows VEM on d o 15 och nom boEkd I l
I g) ITEMS INVOLVED: ,
ALMS WPI. 950,15 L', 9 5a , 953 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6.5. $ .1 kg,3 a, u nck nunh,A s.44 comey are. wQ fo opabr4mks
/,e ma 4.=A umy. w- ham va\u or -e psigd oes nov pc on sca\e Face. % bors$ s u s4.4 w.+h-s e c g ed % s%
a4. zem Co) psg.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION
&I ico OrcicOs (RW]
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
& W Wy W C W A C.
t
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDAT80NS:
M -6 b ,5C d4 8Cd5 f8(,MM M*- ' O CC- II~O 'I S d Ck C in p cess M IModiGj 4he range h -5 b 55 yg,w,
%af** P g "-S" on he n e w s e a .\ e face, SEE 2VA7 2216 i WN/E5 Ac/ x c;atoyok/;,wD U a Mes- Lu $1 hedsim -
Of
- 7d'T o
~
\ _ \\ /wA ESSEXHUMANFACTORSPRdJ(CTMAAAGER" T$$
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER he ho WESn @ USE PROG @ COORDINATOR -
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
& h 6 A ) d.,Le. & $~O/Ah as:s p x-9 a d-$ra) p p c M' -
amm fm f /
a A /s n.
I s.
L1e DUQU$SNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$ N $ k , 7-/5-fT '
DUQUESNE L C0 6 Y ' REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
[
$. W
' DUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY OPERATIONS FANAGER
1 HUMAN ENGZNEERXNG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a)
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: M Fr-M M c) HED NO.: OVC 8 -20 Il d) REVIEWED BY: , f, c- e) DATE: '
8' E
(Westindjiouse) ~ /
% s% ~
(Essex\ ~
f) HED TITLE: D S P, I & v, $dE 5 does no r (nah Chr-ee OQ Pre. cts' son nooA S OperaNc.
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: h ec (tmc dbC' O- I W6 Nmm II
)i b' 1-h h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G.5.l.1 o.. b.
h sca\e. uniks are nef conssLn) w th h <L,ge-.. oCpuen and acorac.y needed. % 4h. o&ra6 c . A\so hos digay dces not inAtca6 vabes ina fecm inwedefek t usable W the. prabe,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
Mab del iOO O (OGN k00m uncrions [0(o j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
fb'DC $' b\(0 O\' ECCL C- C S C i n c Q (
inbegedi n d<.spla.y.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: M Ogi .S i. 6Cch6 rc3 gg kg
~
0-to mecfdds. The Proced"ce5 asE rea&g 'i n W\o a ns. - 5 '- m u % Hfoed pcd6442 cd ~. b 4h
, ~-2 . r +a s 5ceo W tem.onHs ,
I n .s m es M !'.d a W. I ~ < M A ,- ,m t. s n.= _1 v - - - (~--- - w .D,,,
a a y\ _ ca mg RT sgesk h4 he s.A ag scake be A p b 6 c d o io p wicous so Ad 4 ag<es w& 4he p4,es (%ni) ay Q ncemd opahn p-ten (r.shf is 4Wagle q e b sea W (se ,
' f^g'j #"!""' &m x
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJECT MANAGER E 7. S L' /#4a6 0UQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
} ~
WESTIN p VSE PROG p RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
j fj & h SY '~k l
g _
p/ g D x d<. o- m er u u
/
m.
l DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 1
/ & 2/-[
000UESNEpTCO@YRfG.AFFAIRSMANAGER 8WW
' 0UQUESNE LIGAT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
1 HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
~
a)
. PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
ErAO d er c) HED NO.: A\lC(0 c10 I $
d) REVIEWED BY: B.0, d M , e) DATE: Slai55 (West 1[ghou'se) [
LO (Essex) f) HED TITLE: b C6in" 35 br- iS CAicke Ah d'wlavs i
rame sj g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
8.6. keVe.k indica.br aFu)G V LI. HM p84 q@ ,
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: bbkd A-wmed 6A o f >tcc % , scate asks Gr cea2 3 range is currek y o -ioo % . scale unik ace _nch cens de_nb w.N % e d gree _ 4 MMon and accecu.o needed by oeceder .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER:
Ver'shiciL' ors ch CNT( ' Ies
- n - w i:4 7 (mos) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
rG. c rs SC ion m k de(a.je .
m - + ' "
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Yl&C r DCDCeduCras o,recf C(662rs b ensucc $6m 6emra6s are. O , Mu.c ,4e e e.sw,46W eccM\ ask."> b o p h c- Er a read.nc. % 4 conoch 6 read..
() goo */c, . CSkAMi.sh A b \'s kh (s.d\ h gyI gh kg Q o,d A.wS%t 34, hsk\ SCa hac-R &d g i g<.st dw o.s g <4 gh g tid wh\ % e_4 usaw\ .
cwhmk s bain , s Y0 > N a ts N 4% JL \ls (23 b b ' (4 .*
@< h G S O , bokh t%c.a. h g i \w b c gg Q (,
G@@%i t M -
A)O ACTlOM -
M
.- ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS P ECT MARRGER fl E L a DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANY REYIEW TEAM LEADER
/
WESTINpVSE'PROGRAMpRDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
dAs DUdUESNE LfGHT COMPANY ENdINENRING MANAGER
$ . *f- l.P N ~
DUQUESNJA.IGHT 4dMPANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER k WW DUQUESNE LIGHT DOMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGZNEERZNG DESCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.) EvPs -;;L
. PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
M . lCra.n & c r- c) HED NO.:
O '
d) REVIEWED BY: .h.# e) DATE: b 6
l (Wes%ghoIJse)
V M '
(Essex)
\
f) HED TITLE: 7c0M WC W IE d 55I % m '"
M I5p h4ctf_
g) I M S INVOLVED:
(2cvteenor-Va\ve.s (,z,s,(-t-h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G.5.1 l b
- 14. VisM display does ri c h <p r o d i d a corviplake i d r m a.hiar),
o - 10 0 as inar ca6 cl to wl- Pne pa.e .m e%-e r ( 7d n.
mism,ng,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
\/grlhicAhek [ Yask airrbp3&Ke (ggil.Mws
- S ., w l: (e.qoE o
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
b6 N I& OFcLbC de o c- m, sce.aa n
UFM C Et P4w de CcXe ~
n d?
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
- fcudes a per CenL pdramdec kC T_ U 4. y' _-- j L. ;,
,,,,yg ; pf3 k// Y3 &.ut rtof need #60 &.
i Ns A-Ah ruomadad'.
\ D ESSEX HUMAN F S PROJEDTJMANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
& I, R ~
WEST: I p SE PROGRAM 900RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING 44ANAGER
$ /
/ FJ/-lT DUQUESNEjGHTCgANYRsG.AFFAIRSMANAGER y 2 97w DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT o
a) EVl5' - 2. '\
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: N k40c# c) HED NO.: AM- Zlol d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: /,/5'/54 (nstinghouse) /
~
m .
b M (Essex) f) HED TITLE: fe,w,e ro e ,3,.-r- gu,ff g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
u s n,e team- pe, r ea No 1 h<. kk de dr.A Edo-h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
&L2srac G.4 J fu ofe cr~ s l Ocul lan a.r pre n., r e, ala r M o ' r'e re cep<rsan oh:49 4aws 4/ h%t he wJ shado! <hihkle an adHe riyno/
a,,) scha r/c auw red uc/ aduro~las,u uonas hk h peoside, pidwe corfin g . G.3. t. S~
- 1) ; DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER: cgg ag,. goo 93 ( g,g L G g V ut.'w D L C \ 0) @Dl h .
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Ofew fi.i/ age, f5 Mcs/ alat:m fladt of'd'nvamt.)
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
y! L -':J A J G yL 'f,, w,J'~c 6.37: 1.
) % m t' Ev h" c P'v" N 0 V a .< n d f v a v d b r W k $ genkol_.- rou w ik k hadte h c.Aca f4 bk .
i.
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJ ANAGER '
/[ v ##A DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER A L ZOL WESTINGftfUSE FROGRAM CQ9CINATOR _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: _
Y,Me <
Q O
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEfRING/ MANAGER
[ w/ 7 J&&f' DUQUESNE TCO@NY4EG.AFFAIRSMANAGER fkWW DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) ON ' A PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _
A/ X/vveff c) HED NO.: MM-2/or d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 'i/5 /$ V West'inghousgf T M~ ~
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: b l6S EL GeG PJtHP fu n_ On L Eve'L t cs$ % NaueCD g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Ds65CL //d '
A"'#
~
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
fun or waa Rs ru o,cs a t=,ec Arme w as rosao n er wn 1% r terec e c.% secco ra an .vd M r *an & c1.
- 1) : DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NWBER:
Lee no , s,o <, ggp v a g(gg qg\g, j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Aomusine+nc woesi+a arbe oa onasc,e,v e
m
k) REVIEtf AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
1 Tr s ra .t. i.us u s n f. scaH I (~. % a. um. ~ e us Nor sm e ewe- n close , som.so srenvr cams twC 1
I
~
Y %k ESSEX HdMAN FACTOR JECTillANAGER
/kD DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER l
~
(
WESTIN'G $ PROGRAM C60R OR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
- #14 W }'+*&, 8V"s2- &MQ a sagn. _
b S
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
? '
DUQUESNE p COME5hY f%G. AFFAIRS MANAGE 78@v, -W
' DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
l l HUMAN ENGINEER 8NG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
,y SEA (IGR VALLly mwGR sinrton .ugarz.
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - hay"j 0 c) HED NO.: AYAU 2 /OT d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7 /3/ [I t/
(W4stinghouse) /
T x M (Essex) ]
f) HED TITLE N l*>'A V>:df M /4W4/017As Reacht 8 m d b:L -
.%u A. <W g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
awnwtahu h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: [ia.S.l.34(#jl M i.5./,36]
p Tag -
% * * *kr.f.1 Mfwats. }wt out peu4;ot m.saacs, p]$- gp saw. a rrmeetos.
and. .Ane4am. Ajk a44. all A duumante paast Ar.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
(in m a TP 3.183*l d 1. pt c.IU Ryd3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
b M& & & A f G9N & .
- - - - - ~ - - - - - - - . . , - - -
( k) REVIED AND RECOM4ENDATIONS:
flau. Ntt ***usna<ht,O f kok &,W S & & W 4 n g a.a. n = e m p .
.,fsw. /nes /45 is s camswro msr- our P4Hr1.
. Sceps tr- was N*r wrraro Def 7.> cr~ ran e. tec ni " on Exis n~ G RAS'***r pan rL , ,4tw, aqpe op wm wg ,4 gym s ,5 c pro w og cgrg
&* +ftD m fxtivwr~
4VfCom'f" V /Lc /+CTW &
k A eb ESSEX HLMAN FACTOR CT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
/ . E. Y1 1)
WESTfpE PROGMM COO STOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
hp g g , ,' h fs< NM ~ W j w = j 2' p n w ~ %
m 4 A f e/~dy bOy
& m(w)waM-Wd DUQUEf4E LIGHT C0fPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER h? ,
DUQUESNE L p Cor AN9 RES. AFFAIRS MANAGER
- f. kW. , = s '
l DUQUESNE LIdHT C0r ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT g} drAuse VMlGY PowGE Smn0N- umT 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - /72A144k4 dawNam c) HED NO.: JYA T-d!Of d) REVIEWED BY: // e) DATE: 7 [3 / /? U-( dstinghouse) /
\ M' (Ess'ex) f) HED TITLE: f M 6*f M O h bl m gw>
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
WSU, % V A T h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: le.3. I. 3a b) /
k 2D,3D & 4D en fMel R$ hed dild M/&.
ilD I, I So iDg(, C W (fKy SGA LOW lik $G is LcW LEWL/
LOOP A FD Nm Loora Fo WTR L W7W ptcW LOW k oore FDpg,ow Ley /
FLOW LDW i REAcTDR TRIP a REAcTDR TRIP k l__RENTDK T1t Pd
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER: ,
W w k % TP3.IB3,4 D L.Lt N PM o 3
- I j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
k b 5 Ochal & kAAOgA$-
1 l
k) REVIEW AND REC 0844ENDATIONS:
M Q 4 0
- Me*** W 6 U.4 f rt All N Att N d & </ died a ng is e r irn u r s , G r s as4 6f3 MT *Mu Y S!"Gt r ne ir Nf*O ffarneo2(A,,er pt st* 7/ SW5
- Av i+c. 7s OH "x -
N ESSEX HUAAN FACTORS PRO MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER L d WEST'IpuSEPROGRAM DINATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
d i !
E Md DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER KO0 DUQUESNE p T COMpfNY dEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER W$$w
'DUQUESNE LI@T COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
c,
- y. HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a} BEMGM' VAUEV PowCR STnnoN- UNIT 2.
PLANT / UNIT l l
b) ORIGINA:r0R: h howAw1 W W c) HED NO.: dM -1/Ch ,
d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7 [3/b'M (pstinghouse)/
h\M (Essex) T
f) HED TITLE: Nib O^4h"Rh Wk $c'^hs EA &
nT lilt ul % o*uk1 A>
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Gnnnnas40< cM*45. h. Q h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (G.3. S.3 c(7)]
M auigntm m. . beau d 4 lgt us .benn au 4 m n . Jiaq a a y a w 4 a a % a u.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTW NLMBER:
%% TP3.123,3H DLCrd R4a3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
fo yv0My di a .tds
k) REVIEC AND RECCM4ENDATIONS:
7N094 h ALB eMed45e8 desty'M&L4! on hts benm f* h /*P 4 m aw.
. Fest is A8evr rpr t est oc rtG k f- orric ekr*
FDUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) NAVEA- VAllD/ f%vER. STAnors- vast 1 PLANT / UNIT c) HED NO. ,9 W / -)/0G b) ORIGINATOR: - Yrf aldtw haaulidA d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7 [3/ / h '- ~
(W(sti'nghouse)[
i rTN-Qk (Essex) \
f) HED TITLE: O ol D #, Al0 So W j E iA> t b ~5'o-g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
W, p,qu VB (, (iH ), PN L. V 6 T ( As'), PNG. VC. lo ( Al ],
PNL V (.' 7 ( n T ), PN k' V C i ( 0 f*) _
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: [2,.J.3.3d(t),
JAL t\emb9t & 2Abd y Al8 .txclade SO }M MLA &MMk Atti.-
AB - 60 (8xto) Al,-99(BrIL) 41- SS tents) p 4. ga ( sxq)
AS- M It VS)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
% 'I.ev % TP 3.16 3. 3 L DL.C I U R403 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
%?"; % a m apa,tmtaa..
( k) REVIEU AND RECOM4ENDATIONS:
& N N8$ mal .ted t.10 .bE4/se+ praZu5 N y grgd aMgrry he L MBS.
h e p asn w s Swo w To rm* " M di8s ,, a e e omr n - a-tnche r rrw~o aut &<M w.s s a s w ee m a y covooc wlr wb svm yt~o sm o.
- o~ s s ,
h
- Stred ~on aere- deu m obscuss1o n x e a//$vy} nah In >Semm e z wif$ CiMO, 6fis nmy naf /c. s_
p, e%m a-f- 8,y( /eca<se $
0,0W !r M -lr5 /n ^ '" y oas -tk car aecagg -r/ar .m 74 a rt n s' c M h " d , b -
~ - -a OM ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT MAllAGER
~
' ' ' "p s.b 8 AM C
DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER A
M . g gg& - CV f 70 -
WESTI Q SE PROGRAM TOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
tr m. w . _ t _ _ ,a l' "
e w . . s. . . a d 4achn;
(
- h. < d<- ap Wa \ gg b ' ac..i &aQ %lQ- W n t '~e Cf\ ,
L tc, 6 3,,3,3 g { ,p [
0000ESNI LIGHT DOMPANY ENGINEERING' MANAGER ffd DUQUESN s uc-tr-GHT C @ ANY R G. AFFAIRS MANAGER WS$&
'0UQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
- - - - -r-r ----
HUM?.:s ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l
a) 60ua VALLDf fewCR S h411CAI- UNIT 2 PLANT / UNIT zB2 LIO7 b) ORIGINATOR: Saqaw M2,M c) HED NO.: /)
G g d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7 / 3 / / 'I '
( dstin'gh'ous'e') /
i M (Essed)
K f) HED TITLE: h add'h> h ALAS ht- Il Lu++wlLA g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Anrumciskt VM bit A/0 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: f(,,3,3,3 p [
hv av %.dtud& blad AMJiu 6st. M8 AD
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
TF 3./ 6 3, a ya 3Lc I N h@ g cloa j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRCRS(s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
Y tb 4g, d ut k a. A ld rA Alit N.
M & %F VO .
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONS 8 M N A M % m 5' M kok.djaf Md.t JMb ud M % do not & q.
Air m e.s er i~ irrr n.oe, m o,. . ,- a,sar wm n . ,n ,- ,_ o,,,,
~ ^ .* fo M 770N ~
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS CT MAMGER C
DUQUESNE LIGHT CODFANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER !
/ /
WESTIyE Pff0 GRAM C00RfTOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
-)sp W r
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER DUQUESNE p COW dNfREG. AFFAIRS MANAdER
[8NC DUQUESNE LICHT CODFANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
l HUMAN ENGINEER!NG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l a) BeAusit VAU.EV R*EE $7mh0Al -UNrr 2. ,
! PLANT / UNIT
. b) ORIGINATOR: - DA&*" Aash c) HED NO.: 2 \/M - E /08 i 0 U d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7b//N
( dstidghouse) / '
M' ch (Essex')
f) HED TITLE: MM 4 O PA h ute a el e TdvLLL, g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
OMsetah}n byb h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: k) A1Y4 un q m a n y a m spAyaw y co % ra u g tuf
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGNT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
T f 3.113 3. 3 0 .p L C ~tiv 19 4 o 3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
b"fyI>>Ih; 4 Q Mtd wrldkohner f .lkt h M W q alep " N Q 4.s uu4 au g. .
h k) REVIED AND REComENDATIONS8 heek ille needy y M NAMh W-
. i
. s,,, ~ ~n . <-e s n, raa ex <ess ~ ~"r A sse der.
T _\ d ESSEX HUi4AN FACT'unsyJECT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER d / f
, WESTIyE PROGRAM C00RpfNATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
o 300 Pm C,3.3. 4 (c-) dx .d M. E D & x664. & W* y' W -
" pa
,f y4 m I
Y)re/- e c. .n ~.a~.bs - cu, s ,e &,\[ l gg
' < "e q 4 -L r <- pss;Q q L'cn e sl a cd.t ,d aatn ,v,gh y DUO'ESNE ULIdHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
-'S, b3 4.-d d
""~4 o..J5 *6
- b. I .u , . ~~. .
=s~eart a""* *a ^"^'as "^~^a'a
""N c\ rsw DUQUESNE LIGkT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER ch .',.( , 7 1
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) BE4VG VAMEy bote smneN-awr2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: Ma> bra hE'4He c) HED NO.: 2 YMY- 2 /d7 d) REVIEWED BY: '
e) DATE: 7 b//bh (dstiiighouse)/
T K
~
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: Ah A'uda Jm bl a
Ei-e had htraums g O/nia g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
O m s e net E G L U h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: [G.3.3.Sc.l yn uay amancatu klu, ou atum 4.uaa &daue m m ext eond&k (le.e. h>ckd fdt;) kuntuaso daw
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
M Sm T F 3./B 3. J I DLcIN 89J3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: !
coqwa % acna un&.
1
f k) REVIEO AND REC 0804ENDATIONS:
a mn M.
s~wm nu 4 addwad f HAVf O # A' ' '
, y. g pHigojoPHy l$ !"
mm p.e~s- comons up on rur cn'n CAT swues errmur df M AM Ccw* OIried No # c Tr W T h ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS JECT MANAGER
<dWA DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER l
{
WESTI b 0W tlo SE~ PROGRAM TOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
N YAA) &
DtflUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l .
I DUQUESNE f#sHT CWPAff REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER fh$w DUQUESNE LIGkT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
4 C 2 '/.f F - A jo ? !
Gc3.1.3tL(2), G. S.S.4C. \
l 6 nan 9mak 3,Ai W .gtuu & M wakeCaio l paw mwny:
20 30 AD
$6 A Lou) h / $6 en LCW Leva./ S6 c low LEVE/
Lo0P A FD WTN LOOP 6 FD WTR LooPC FD WT'R Flow low ytoW low ptow tow REACTDR TRIP REACTOR TRif , REACTDR TRtP -
&. $. 3. 4 C I
$4 , do nbl& addstw y'f4h condthbrw-nwty M Atu.l y:
knMTM Al ID l
HD fE pecuy enray wter=W commmuar LT6 BAT NNP PArnAc passs onntATud/ puro sTw/ H ssn/ Low 6056 oF DC. Auto.sror -
1 1
IF SF 4F CMTAtlMENT AIR REC 4RC SPRAY I 6ERVICE WATEf
""# Avid-T.
Auto s RT/ /
hlW/L8N AUTD-5TDP AH TV stDP i
I IG IG NEVTRoM SitELD INCORE NST RM/
ExPANSloM TANK CNMT 6DMP LevtL t.ow/ . L.EVEL HIGH/
TEMP hl64 , VALVC Not ME$ET I MONCIATCP A 2.
lc I I% '
[Sc LIWID REACTDR COOLANT REACTDR. C00LMT WASTE MAIM NMP sus PdMP Vl64AT104 TAN ( LEVEL VNDERFRG40CNCY/ AL4T/ DAN 6ER ktowlLOW VNDERVOL.TA66 l
H ~t e ;Vtk -2109 INuNelA100 30 50 zg EF AA CHA%ING !VMf 00 TIC ACID 80 ele ACID RUctot C00LMT AWTD- STRET/ p;gg gg4g SLENDElt TMW5/
A urp- STDP ' !
YENT Por TRou6tE DEV FROM SP l'l
~ MVEL HIMK0W
!!4 Hz MAtyZeaf REIDH8 mitt.
LOCAL PingEL TRo06LE i NCel ATD6' A3 plW5 Volg
> PHmDH0$E nun) -
7 h
9 e
e 8
l$50i*EY$$')\0]
AkNuNesATOR, 18 N Rt Pitt.56uRitf.A PetssuellEt ALE 560tl2ER. I#
commet, LEVEL c,mm CONTROL LEVEL PRESS DEVt4TtWI Hl6H/ LOW PitES$ DEVIATION Hl6d/ Lod _ HIGH/ LOW HIGH/ tow ,
16 PEl:560ftatEt, CouTRot PILE 5 DDIAT10Al HM/ LOW i MmMtA100 7A flA 16 4D STM 6Eg g A6 gm enwry Apr FW PvMP mr Fuel 80' t,agt. H16H Low /
nuTo.sinar/ LEV"'
LE WL. gg4g.g 6H/
TEMP HMH AWTD-570f Hl64/ low Low / LOW-low top $TP.6f,N 6 IID 5F W 6TM 6EM C ecMDENSEE QTW PDIAlf LP LEVEt, LEVEL hoTWELL FW HTR 2VA/8 H164 Wl6H/ HtGH-HIGH/ W EL LEVEL Low / Low.LDW Low / low-LDW Hl64/ LOW HIGH/ LOW 7
is W 70 Pitt foHP -
cowoeW54TE t tcVR STx pelnr LP C00 Lid 6 PVHP TFR TK S/23 FW NIR 2SA/B nuTo sTn4 LDEL LEVEL HI Hl(L0\f CN Hl6MILOW Au MN#ft c,autt4702 FIELD '
A7 Ovrecatswf/
GNOl LOSS OF 600 PAertcT10AJ
HEb # 1ll5 - 5 lO9 MMClQTOL $A SA 40 SD
$% DilSEL GEN 2-l pgg$gl, GEN L-L DIE 6EL 6td t -I DIE 6tL GEM 2-L ACb 2680 ACb 2Fl0 Lots of PittD/ LOSS 0C FIELD /
Aviv-CLOMl pa - y gl Low Exc! tan 0M LM EXCIMRod A4TD - TitlP -
num-nelP ,
pgWNCIATOL 36 48 53 ZD coMTROL 6LDG ceMTeol BLb6 LEAK talECRCW gjg conTEoc SLO 6 RIR EVMallST nlR Sur9LV INb1
- EELAyRM Alt UNAU67 YAN FAA tem! TEA m t FLDN 1%10-sTMitT/$10P Rufo STMef/SDP #16H/L*W HIdd/40W E PIPC 5F GHE*GEA0Y **WI cans yAULT {
g)fc W SM4A $UPPLY TVWEL gag eg ntet Agg4 YE#DL4T10N TEMPE#ATWE. T5MPCRATUte A/C GN3T AuTD WRT/ RIM p H Hl6 Low gato.sipp W-STaf7/5EP 54 7#
IMIT OV set $MIC SMI7Ely A00M acEED PRESET ex#AwSTFA#
AN0/OR SPECTRAL, #HTP-SD9tT/
ucLL6KRDunb MWO-$70f ANMs0A pg 6G -
0" SHroup FAN RFID-staff /
AMTPSTDP S
0 en *
,-, ,. -- -- -- - - ---r.
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) 0EAVDl VM. ley SbsdER MTIo Al - yarn r 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: hth c) HED NO.: AVC.4-2/M V !
d) REVIEWED BY: $! e) DATE: 7!3/[N ;
((estinghousn ;
b w M ~
(Essex) ]'
f) HED TITLE: Ymal.O Anum-&ndunawl-M- M w( AuOl.
9'
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Pa t- ve r ( A 7) Q PNL V C %* ( n ?)
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6.3.3.5~t.Cl)J hv. aa. Ninth NA0 Ort. ooh:wact bt A'l dhof 64 tadttn en yhhNb g f g M }ht M $ 14. T*vs** @
T** O
'%^,5 no W l
sm un d svssa w 26 w. At 1** lAlle WW hmiaQ ;#Ltl N' t.t_ Vnt. ho&& $
pyt, ggs i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
&& TV3, I /3 3, )I bl Ca.I Al RN3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
/%6 jf.tQ atsu(L M AM anwnaAllps tila Mt24 5.
i
k) REVIED AND RECOMENDATIONSs Q h"~2-*h AlllCe labbt ,Q %,
7#t ws- 3r- paso, pn'oro <nm 7?m ~ arur Ac 7'"!l. fet4ARVEO MLG3 WERE' /tvf74L i fb .
pyo p/7 Mfg _ dt-11os oe rderdFb .
M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS h GER "
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTI Q PROGRAM CODRDINA
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
"M W -
e
/
h DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER fM DUQUESNgGHTCofDAWREG.AFFAIRSMANAdER .
DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
j HUMAN ENGINEERlNG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) BW% VMLW Mwat smnog uytrg PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: hacAU daNidMs c) HED NO.: DVMW-2llI d) REVIEWED BY:
e) DATE: 7!3/[b9 (WeIst16ghouse) /'
eM '
(Essex) K' f) HED TITLE: 46 armMad/M M q o u L a 2. w ~lT ~ i I/,,
~
{' C j 1
ALlA$[b Ti A g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
AMtMtakAko h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 4.G.G.24(/)/
DesrtMenfths Asted. Mt & uMA fv .stzclas yo6drif MM A
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
k+ TP 3. te 3. s 4 4 4 o D LC TW R403 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
$0 .teifsk, a f*Mwt/ lb a -for14 des y et adoecu.ftd. 4d y co,cteds et dd p.
D% kd4e-sh% ot dihyiq a. po66*t flag *'1 '
+4.
l s -
[;6. k) REVIEW AND RECCM4ENDATIONS: u. Dennep & M Ahgeld lM t/M d h y M sts. g W atamp..
~ prmace.e is p r- pssoscia w My i+wsrcin-7*xs Aer
~
vsru. /qpa,incinggg ,g g .:ctyg y p u na~ cty fauc6 J DfMcnnow is por ,+p sti^ce94 At h.
- /t/0 M72/M
<a ESSEX HliMN FACTOR TMARh5t ML-DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEMLEADER A /, MJ:A WESTI y SE PR6 GRAM CO [ INATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
- N l
i j' / {
\'
l kW W l DU'O UESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGIEERINEMANAGER , DUQUESN @PANfREG.AFFAIRMANAGER NC DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS ENAGER l l l
HUMAN ENG1NEER2NG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) OWM VA M A0WR STAT 70N - UNtr 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - Tyy hash c) HED NO.: 0 Y-F E - 2 II E d) REVIEWED BY: Y e) DATE: 7/3/[Tf9 (dstinghouse) /
$ M '
(Essex) ]' f) HED TITLE: />H2t Ae"M and hoa m SL12, ttL woo nd,
- o J f c$v et% ma r e x%
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Onr.anaakt. CJuuMutJ h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: [//. 3.3.Sdb)[
.dbutt-wid4 7b chaudit. .).itfl Aala JxcAsdd I:8. (d}O 1:9.3 )
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
W M r { T P 3 . / B l. I
.DLC U (R 403 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
jht .batu will lx Q bMad y demt fwkhte N N "
k) REVIEU AND RECOW4ENDATIONS: hyl ~r h w a dk # m ek % chstaoi2v M d W
-k 0708-@ sbML*1<M h ekmcat -Y 6-B T w\ a ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJ NANAGER' 9/ D DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER Y , /
WESTINGH0 git PROGRAM'C00RDIJGTOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
64'/D 4^'CG f0A' sf A' T i o f f ( W } 0 76 e f/'w!OEs ; ff' G , / S(/- 2.-
/3f/- 2 DrvieTEs Mm gc/tD4 p c g e n .x ar e~ r co/av- /. Tuess,s4ri o.u oi c- oyce
/s Gu s oms ou x Crie ic v es~cf uootD m's ALAA MJ D'FRC o 4-1 CAcwD k 7TSb Ncr- /u n g t.v 6
~.7b /(EAD { b CS d LY /m A4 /A' E 4 f f 7 ~ f k f 4 A 7 ~S 4~
e /: .D ru er,ev3 67miunr/ou.c/'4pp w racs - o c.xage r-e c ' t w Ghu r DUQUEShE LIGHT (OMPANY ENGINEfRING MANAGER m P$/f('" DUQUESNE LI,Gpf COMPAW RIG. AFFAIRS MANAGER W, 8 91 m : J DUQUESNE LIGHT DOMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER 1 l l
i- ; HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT n) WUE2 MW MR b"M- DAUT 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: h>as4u DaAuNfho c) HED NO.: 2 MF- lll3 4 9 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7!d//2d (Wgtinghouse) /'
& ~
r% ~ (Essex) ]" f) HED TITLE: $1h1 bmOnewne dad fwida arm , i mln ELK nd me e T en $Te n s A_, g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Omsta w a feLob f h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (,f3'8 g ) Wm n m mata..synas an. y~a no asa hyah<,y hu chnada wid% (.19"), 0% m maa W > versa. M b h """'l *'" cAAudR..
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION Nt.NBER:
-v # 3./4 /./ bLC2N R403 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
4 cxd WotAo h1 b-
k k) REVIEW AND RECOMENDATIONS: fintakt % n^'"uy N d M AW & 5 W( N G hti Q f - [AM4k'M2 y) 9 [h w ylbYG, ofefabr5
- Ao fm hw teachy 4,,xc, w&L fu>, ; abo, ca r u.4 4' *d po MPOL N \
ESSEX HOMAN FACTORS cb-h ECT MANAGER i DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER r m iJ
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
WW b W tt %z DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 2 8-W SS~ l DUQUESNE T W ANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER [8 T-
"DUQUESNE LIGHT'COWANY OPERATIONS MANAGER I
1
? -3 HUMAN ENGlNEERING DESCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a} AGAVCt VMLEV Pou)ER STnnoN-VMrTZ PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: Max dul<da M c) HED NO.: dINd//Y d) REVIEWED BY: #
/
e) DATE: 7/3/[IE (Wifstirighouse) 1 M ' (Essex') f) HED TITLE: d>+h t DIkot4tino andd_% ud AMW J t_s t d a g _ h cb m.T mut7 UArk g) ITEMS INVOLVED: h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: la.3.5.Sd((o)[ lAjersd A4nG n Awmus< ashed att f Jard b c49M (.09"0W) y M chetac44 (26) W qaa line m uu he ni A*Af * & & q (.I+).
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
Ot.c tN e%g CW
% Tf 3.u3 f. /
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
&MitMEQNb% f a Nb5A -
=
4
b) REV8ED AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
$ w *bau W *vAuu.A = p, M Asia. (5 u"rs toe in.e)-
O k 7 "2vn-ws n/es a /g;Ue. , ser sus /ci70M 7 Y N ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS T MANAGER 4 tub ~ DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
' f -f _.
WESTDOHO% PROGRAM C00RDINf0R
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: .
'fp fh $M' .
aid. DUQUESNE LIGH'T COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$NY 4- 2l~fr DUQUESNE p T C0 g NY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
[8T-s
'DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (E D) REPORT l a) 3U95 /1 PLA'NT/ UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: d boo Asom c) HED NO.: NNM. d) REVIEWED BY: ! West'inghouse) / e) DATE: /o// r/9 4 M (Essex) \ f) HED TITLE: Mo l * * *\'- E o<bt *v <"A!^^
- < j g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
dw ~ mc,',asocs h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (,.3, p. 4.f A (t) Q)') Tw . < c. < < .s o p < W y I eo s 6. a o , o .u_% b - go t No m e .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTIO N!MBER:
Co ns < o\ c oo ~ <vey, A nund s -o S p + e- TP 3. I B 3.f 3t.c.\d su405 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: A \=yob te sgo%e.- ik hp q < As 7 e s \c. . , s saw los- pos au._3 .a m ,,n ,, m j c o m , < . _, hss u www suoa % gqo_g w (g,
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: L g\.~ ~s g. i :h n.a s s'e m Syp4 - si W I ( n'oi a y j.
, ,, c v; =N cehe q (cetoe, go-lu o, , mp ,57-bo t 4) .,& o m a,y ,
cLu). @<j, i N *%* sN 6 3- , % - p .5 g e ,e , h :2.a ws , o aus,
- c. 2.2. s . ac*a. y < u, % .g. )
ySw& Two peotay uvas (usr es set:ano ) e,e e- me-emance.wr was . - o jf // $ 0 */ o "'l a /a r n s s etw fr$s yea on .+ v ~' n . L L "'"
'gy padra b'm stl*rM Q*
G7dri4) { re , J p .v.*b ) gro.,& e AW Y y
, g ypvcede cpu * '# E ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS MANh6ER fake. sob % avn ~Il " S
((c} gg C- . DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
&" 8. [Wb,
.f
/ NEp r/,. F WESTI'NGHg($EPROGRAMC00%,NATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
~
oA= sLkr DUQUISNELIGHTC.1MPANYENGINEEl[ING/ MANAGER WW . 7-26PS
~
0000ESNEL17c0M,ANY.irG. Area 1RSMANAG
+ w n~
'DUQUESNE LIGHT t0W ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) Td?S/1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - 1 Ge,e Ason c) HED NO.: Nb d) REVIEWED BY: M e) DATE: /o M /9#/ (y(stinghouse) / h M (Essex) ' T f) HED TITLE: b 4- AL%s cais be cesh boe o 6 *a'!u u L oche A h c m xse\. g) ITEMS INVOLVED: A11 ,A(, c.u n b. h / 6 (, sc7 . So_ Ac2 , A 9 ,, a w. <<ms % ,., L a c_ o u , te.a y co M \. h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (,. 3. T. 5. c . (3) T,s Las* * 's .2 9 " ** <
- b r *- m a "~ ~s vi* "' g d#s'**** '%
a ~ . ,,', u w c o :o- u swo, is 707
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER:
Lossw.o\ <.. - se. *f, Am- ..',uwc +y5t<- T T 3.\ ~4 3. J 3 gc.s# rho 3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: 34.b pb se go es g. - 4 4~. e. reyutre.h 6 ve t N s m4+ y a) 5. ge _g, e co A W ce a.b ca e u c a wy . E s o < r e (_* ce p g - te ., s t a $ om rw is' M e g g c e_+a t to m
, ok 3 14.
l
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
%w. 4 %w o m . u.b y 5s. h .. s- m o ~ C spm,f(e, eq *** A Lv, 3 %% m_ w got So~ h.
A CHANGE- To REMVE THl1 DIB CgefAhcY WA s IWnoo n y A prpoyy o He TE : ANO wott as Impsemey,g a Sa- cx r a(A3) w m.er n ynr .reepw c- sw/ccr en tw.o s sne-n a ws swansr r8e meme. sm aw r-o p, ameW bor Rreo" G~## . Y LM ESSEX HUMN FACTORS ECT MAlBGER W-DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER 4 WESTINGHOUfPROGRAMC00lyINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
MO Mod,M DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY EN ERING MANAGER
.1W DUQUES
~
T C@NY Riis. AFFAIRS MANAGER ff97w
' DUQUESNE LIG4T COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
~
HUMAN ENGINEERZNG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l
.) 3t/95/ 2 PLANT / UNIT j
b) ORIGINATOR: 1 O c>o A 50 ^ c) HED NO.: ASO'Ml7 1 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: / o // 5~/ 9 4 l T Vst'inghouse) [ j h h (Essex) A~_ a, .%u w, xmms ,,,,_,_ # om a f) HED TITLE: , t<\u N; ><- tewuo,5 av EM*"-N w , ek * * * %' o a ' . g) ITEMS INVOLVED: N=o% lb 6 ' '* 7, 16'a IG 3 co i 3 c.o wo% ks 410 urh Aw . h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (,*. ~5 4 2 c.. A q
- e x gs=, p 4 o # ~ m et a c .,,_w w a, , % 4 y asaegu mw nak s <.% 4 Nt sec u cCow av 4;K,, 4 .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION Nt.MBER:
Coe ho\ coo - % <st y , d r w o m u;.u w sp s,,, , y g u c,s Al %4o3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: L o . , 6<A r=, qo -w -
, but .
ss.,* a w b c.usw mg mos % . b \c. y <,5 < < yo n.,c. l
)
i n I
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Lv' d **w co a<ow vbi c w a,. wm,g,a . O 4 8 Ca a ** *la "*^*4 O Co e \ $ 0\ C= EA % g y y%g
)
Ate 7E ,' A CHANGE To ME5*wE THo s puent/Mc v wA s Perwoony A f teovf D N o will BE In NEM ENT&b
, ,, ,ev e y W6x '
- ri w LFR"Il 6 l d\\m ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS CT MANAGER 2 1 A' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTING $E FROGRAA C00RDfNATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
, ,fc DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
. /> ~
DUQUE T COMP M R M. AFFAIRS MANAGER cenw
'DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HLMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (ED) REPORT l l a) D D/ i PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: ~) boobso n c) HED NO.: hb N-MlO a) DAlli: /o// r/g </ d) REVIEWED BY: (dstinghouse)/
'r M (Essex) M f) HED TITLE: rk- Jabe u wois n e* c ol = a 4: SC ~ &ty A-n w e. < p\ e e ms. os s .
g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
/(eis,/(a7,/bV, iia 7 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (, . 7,, 4. 2.. b Q) ,0) ,(9) co A<ow -o* m a a 6 6 % +s 7 9o_ on, , g
-or h %,mos o, G. . q .9 C o - s c os<.
A ;w
- i - w
- s'sc ,
Skoto ai co-Aso\% oo+
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
C ** * "' S
- o ~ w i ve. y 3 A ~ ,._ a o w, gy, _ Tp $ ,g g3.fg
%. c.xN 4403 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
3 t\ayck u +go-sc - A M ,,,wy m loco.* $<osqok 9 c oavo% .
k) REVIEM AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
% c ._ -uh .- s h s\
%g ns s geo- q M = ~m' awe co a , -4
#:e co b-s % 4 .a is c o , c9u e yim otw,c 7 he ww%
oNec c.o euo%,
~
$7&9M.C /MVS S&SW lW J
- llN_ WN M7 $0/V MO &
. is ~n e,,,- m -~co
, J Y rh ESSEX IiUMAN FACTORS LECT MlNAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER bi / ) WESTINGHO% PROGRAM CDORDINFOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
M g DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER DUQUE 5HT C @ NT REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER SW& [DUQUESNELIGATCOMPANYOPE
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT l a) dis /2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATORr d. C 0o6 % c) HED NO.: bM ~M d) REVIEWED BY: jp 7.f- / M. e) DATE: /o/M/9 4 I I (4sfitinghouse) / M (Essex)' f) HED TITLE: b~ a%>r co ws A**t y *Ws
- e k =W< w A49 * = +
co e% o \ 004 s ah;on, a g) ITEMS INVOLVED: , 160,167,16 9 ,1 GT h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6 3. 'i. 2, c,,
.A-~- A %c ws os q. % wom. c., w uu a,_ by l% , < 63 o cou 6 tut << a,o m b W <. ju shutww,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
****\ . koo ~ s " < * *. ~t . A-- :.sc +1 -- m sa s ,.ca TLC \M A40%
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: ce
% c. 7 .4 b s 7.%,.
O ~ wse b c. *zo - ,<. ,
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: L p e. a co e % cw w +b q.., % w % %, ,,4 g ej @< -s a .e co m n., ars eqa u w c A ,_ a '" u . n s, o+ w w' *"* '- o m . k sw, p of apW*S DI scR EPAMY "W4 s PREVI"!L Y NeTE: A CHANGE To AEsoLVE THIS A ??AavE R App wall BE IA flEMENTf D in - ,~ - n, .a .,
. y[tncet.
n . _Gont c b.a-u.a
,,w pys.ptr /kJio" -
KE10ttEd - \ T rhA ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ~ECT MAfiAGER
- 44?A~ w DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTINGHO % PROGRAR COORDINA(OR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
Y<
~
!al DUQU$SNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$f DUQUESN CO@AN M EG. AFFAIRS MANAGER C# W-
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
?
HUU.AN ENGINEERIN3 DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) AGt/D? VAMEV AOU!d SIAMA]-(Milr.2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: 772,./. Dud'Je* c) HED NO.: AN N -AI2O d) REVIEWED BY: __/O.d. e) DATE: \\ M ~ (Wesfinghouse) f/ N amuJm" '\ f) HED TITLE: ^ ad.HirNnssh} a bt oAmidt" Lum bsmhA i
%ukwu b<s'kses g) ITEMS INVOLVED: doruerciatu, c/J(4 I
i h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 16.535d(')I (.29 ")
& 'dMa & M A Mbw:wrx WI4'al Y Ob 5 /
n . Wi y d54bw.,0 , ur[tu h y d ufara @ M
- 70. -
1 l
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION !
NLMBER: (edd d% m b utVA, bD M(, W.C 79 3.\ E\bdA b(CiN E9Q j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: J # M A<n7tunccatet, tL].op h Gmaur' y ArttEbv. s .
k) REV3EW AND RECO*NENDATIONS: M '
\ caw hg
~xau% s~M % ,ad (sji')O A % 4 Y,1 % \1 % h h 7 (-
- d c m d p w h Nuge(,-en g l h
- A A *S5(gacg 6.b uwhas A h A *' haO V g
[3 {-} T-m --a A N *=,a b C-e 4.WA.b b$ 5 t w.On. s b w.,5 A c.os b h\ o,\.,w A % b ,'k
'
- g*b tg\so%
s v / " L g s skcohwdkh b *> Y Y M w N.L #
=me. 4,~ ~ . . ESSEX HOMAN FAC&"N"JtCT RRNAGER
' ^ ' a FW ' O ;; ' hi 7
. ^^ tAa* c E- -
F ~4 u =o av i' W3 - DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER tvo M o a t rrn Du A///4 v u a + rie % s s a- en r ,
,S w p,conr of A as-actu l'" ' ' -
" 5 I" # ^" I grpiv sr stenas. ma errw
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
01 I DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$~ Y W DUQUESN @ AfiY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER 7 -
~
DUQUESNE LIGHT CQMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISChtFANwT intv) RtP0di
,) bYhb ~ 1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
M Frank c) sEo NO.: Mem 21 1 d) REVIEWED BY b- < e) DATE: [f (West 1(ghouse) M~ (Essex) f) HED TITLE: knMcle.b Mar-ms mema,M Cur.rm'iss'84 g) ITEMS INVOLVED: g gg . (g "S?*'iaD Y Permis5'i m_t _ h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (, .3 , f .) / 6.3. J.4 bf b ie M n u nc. M b r S conkat o p e r- m ' ss s W e s whic.h clca nd dascribe an ad .P fol=rar<.e cond W on oc %ey do not (4. ink f m p Cflob c.ah p n tj ,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPA NSTRUCTION NLMBER:
Vaher: ion of Contce\ Pe GcRed (eWoQ : j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: ffk C Q NOCO M
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATZONS: R g(onlyy\g n d h g h p n,$ giqq li k5 be, c.okor- cMM h k- U M I So k%k e.lk p r4 kcrs w'.II N OlC i mtvied1obe ic M i (sf p rynis
-from alor ms .- piO U blev^Wbbws'.he u bM R&W . Lgd id sktEn cwda itss, sw p Estn sG b A 6 6 2t w A\ a\*<ws p 4 s % k %,\ ,_ u,a,as M a s CAR etcwt. k b bk b Gsh- A paA hwckia Y""'% Q #
oM bh c.\o< t b a tok ge @ h<, hg h mwd L &. % no ws p u sstJu
% dat m (Mkdt. \
sum m : M
. acld \mbe.\ desc.r big ESSEXHUMANFACTORS%6JECTMANAGER h eA AG S^cD * ^
+ color - co.1 a. pe m ;'*Mues
(( [ ~ jff/A] DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER C 1:9F47.)
- a. O. % L k WESTINGH0f5E PROGRAM @ RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:g =*::=: 4 m /-n- gy +f_~.
a : 8 ' 0
& :: k u & A ya .?u n+ % M x w
- yu &
-cs th y~ m m -/ 9 ff d
& M daA 8 & h A/ n 4 f == l DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER f DUQUESN j d Z /#f] 1 1 HT CO@Y #EG. AFFAIRS MANAGER 60'P7&
'DUQUESNE LIGW COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
~ .. .... ~.. .. .a- - .-..... .. .
l c) EvC5 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: TG W re e_ u 9 E +rt c) E D NO.: 2 VC7 - R 40/ d) REVIEWED BY: a) DATE: I!/0f94 ' (%tinghouse) /'
- "W W (Essex) \
f) E D TITLE: C CA h & M M h/ AW L ) Ev i 2 c. #o g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Sc_At.s o t-3 WIL VC ? (psh Tuowr wium.- N au~wicm h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AE 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDSER:
~
DD "
'. ; . MS , r. , : >c A ' n BY 00 iT GE>be *S hI o p 9 -T3 #- un s uv u n ot is b GN SCH2 i, 2,5, o h w- o= 0.
NotTtPLG} o 3 to i 12. K
" 0.}.3f.1f.47.l G,. S.l. S c (J) s /.. S . 4. I c, 6" 3 6 9 'l
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION IRSWER: .
DISPLFy) hd@! - T'P 51 B3 25 DLGN DO j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERROR $(s) OR EWIPENT DESIGN PR00LEM: b j
k) . REVIED AND RECOW4ENDATIONS: 5o 7-eG q + u ra : tarcw sh
, % i * ~ W6 & r c2 yy l y $, g
* '" G 2k %QFm 303 C U f 2 5? S S
% D5 E _V e W E I t-t J LE P c f D 3N EME DW E b O F ' O.
- m uvesnsw pscreatry e ewM trp/- Sing- op Q- /d/ pg C --/h psM inctGm &T2 a *=
ScA l E" (0 - /S-) 7D ,#
rwo. Sam.u- o~ x,wr rio s- ! ~ -
L ~2>>J s --~'s c) ED ND.: d V F Y -b02 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: IhAA IO 1i2O '
(%stihghouse) / )
~
_ \ (Essex)
\ xW f) ED TITLE: b ec-1 ~T As ME S .o n E
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED: MESE.RS @ N pci, v-t(9?B)
VA - 0 (. B40, 6 T L444 A,444E) V , f,-[4 ri - h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION A2 0700 PARAGRAPH NLMIER: he'G. mA: AE.E t3GT S NPL.w . G. S. O. 2 c,( Q . IN DiC A'ToA Loor., uu E W15'- 3
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
DiC.Pc;- i; -. 42. \) 2 / i-~P5.I M ,gq DKlN IkNQ j) SPECIFIC HIMAN ERROR $(s) OR EWIPENT DESIGN PRDOLEM: _ l iR 'DC LM/ 07, 1 Mc 0 C. e U CT G r A T. . O g CW 2.T5SO L T O= M 7;E G . 4
i k) REVIED AND RECXpe4ENDATIONS: J5E A Sa s P W E. %g Og Tr G AE,
. ,,o,,s veu, vvv s, ,~, vro (e vs a- v>, -. n ve) ggve pmrre.s wicx oesteer Sed &E <r:4@!^*6S. -h4s.t s~ vfSr/ G+ft~
, ,gopoegf /kys,;yg n ,< n9'fS F A F CO M D R S,
. ompts up"ED # f~ ON.
K,k ESSEX NLMAN7 TuRS PRIDECT MANAGER fM/ d DUQLfSNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
& f, ML WESTI @ E PROGRAN COORDINRTOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
A]/ Y~> d d'k. c/ w / ,, W p p M ~.e22C ..y DA nAmM
,, ,2 / ;J&gu s g uyL / 6-j pd w;s, yd 2 'M M a&.
,,,,_ , , a a t SAe w DUQUESNE LIGl4T CorANY EGIEERING MANAGER
/ tA, W/
& k '(, & / ouGUEypI A FhC d O/ s-3*F F n awe RE.. maIR$ ANA.ER
/
/ w/A ~d
,/ n '
VS W&
/s 'DUQUESNE lie 4T CorANY OPERATIONS MANAGER n.
HLMAN ENGIEERING DISCREPANCY (ED) REPORT a) BVPS2 , PLANT / UNIT l b) ORIGINATOR: MADEllME RNA9N c) HED NO.: [MN - M 3' l d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: ElfAIE4 Westinghouse) /' 7 (Essex)' T f) HED TITLE: MMOE. IUTGWEb4TF LMB M1La_ MABo A7 tot % M Der biFFG1 tLi i p MM1A
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED:
9M.Eh 0:a P4ae.5: Vf% (4E.454,453,445,4%,44 I,457,4s0
'v BS (,44 A . 44te, 44tc., 4410, 44tA , 442.8. 444 A . 444 B)
BBt (310.31),1o1) - Ba2. (315, 316.317) ac2. ( t,17) e c _i ( 2 4 ) (.coMTiuveD OR ATTAC.HED SBEE% h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLSEER: M AJOR , IUTEgMED1 ATE. AND MINOR GrgpDutCTIOM MAttXS DO / JOT DIFF t& DM LdNhTH (o. 5 . l. 5 . a O )
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
DtSPLAT SOM E.Y , 7P5.IBB.24 OLc.LN R4o5 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPDENT DESIGN PROBLEM: CAM CAGSE DttAc] to MEADINb sLALE I
\
k) REVIEM AND RECOMMENDATIONS: MMM. lHTGKMEDIATE Abf) MtMOR&t.ADJNR0kjs ou DLE. Stbotb G.E D)FFCS6tdTIATED E.Y L6b4dTH OF M AiO:.S N 6Y tw k0 % z< E A vs ; y, O , y w bN M55 b\ \M S:s . % V A. D4 Q wg pg t o h \NN No < ich f4 L c h a wh ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS CT MANAGER f[ M = J c23 DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
' l l WESTINgf60SE PROGRAM)3tDRDINATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
O
$4dk DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 47-) f 5 DUQUESNE CO @ fREG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
/. R 97w
' 0UQUESNE LIGHT' COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
i M O -ftA03 g.)4offdhue.d) E.CI (AA ,4A,4A 76B,7A, $ A ,10,11,11A , ISA , 2 .l) _. _ 3 E.(A (9 A ,9C , 9E ,9 61, B B 18,9 6,9 D ,9F ,914. )36, \2.6,2.2.) ...._.. l ' ' l , %, (Bri, BtB, Bt 4, B18) r VAB (637A, B316,410,646,1008,1009,65t 852, B53,855,B56,t54B ,iolcuy , l \0\o8,lo\b) VA4 (Bbt A , BG16,86tc , Bbs,Bb1 A ,6bo Bb4, Bb 16,965 A ,Wc,%b4 A,6648 ) VC1 (15b,152,26oA ,26o6,2 A ,236,2.B) CS ( 25 o A , 2 36, 2SBc ,36 , 46, 232A ,2.39 , 2.37 A, 2.316, SB, 915 B , 240, 24 ) , 141,14 3,244, 2.3) AT 9 ,2.M Vc9 ( 13 2 6. 232C ,13 2 D,232E.,1.32 F, 22.9 A , 2.3o A ,2.336, 2.33C , 92 3 8, 2 29C,' $ 2 50C , 234 A , 234 8, 2316, 219 6, 2306, 2290, 236D, -z2A E , 23cE ,120 F,150F) NAS (MA ,196 6, lois, f ol2, lois , tol4., 945 ) yAG ( GozE ,' BIS , B13 Ap36, 91+ A,9MS, 402, 904 , 619 8, SW ,918) vcs a( 9ss<A ,jos A , qsi,9 s,s, 269, soss, 295) . vuo ( 3.e 3o4, si3,9is . z,4A , zue,qie,, z,,) 3 y suco,m )ma. (1Ae vcus, zop ws) t .
'h 9
1 s 'T . 1 i ' _-l
HlMAN ENGIEERING DISCREPANCY (ED) REPORT a) D bb 1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: tA ADEU UF RMARN c) ED NO.: A M N ~2204 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: P3l7~Ll934 (Wo(tinghouse) [ I M (Essex) ] f) HED TITLE: INCnM9 TEE lb3FORMKTtoM OM 5( ALE FACE g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
\le.\tHC AL. SC ALES OL) P ANELS BB- 1 (.314) -
V A -(o (0; t3) SS-S (z Nms - vb h 2Nes -57 b) h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NtAGER: INCorAPLETE INFoRMAllot3 ON SCALE FACE. taeeATtve AND PostTtyE VALOE5 1.'OT CLGRL1 DEI lNEO. 6.5.t.4.a(.1)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
D\SPL AMS SOR9Ey - TF 5.) B3.M DLcIQ R4o3 J) SPECIFIC H(MAN ERRORS (s) OR EGJIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: ( AN EESOLT I4 ET2 Scc IM READtMeg oF SCALC 1
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: l NC.q A t ' t)E VALU Eb 5 tbutt BE l
\ND\CATED %ECEN NA EN.H WE01 ATWE. NOMELRKAL NALVE co STALE.
. zmn.s sw no 813 ne ex.
-
- 2^/#)S - 5/D l $2D (Sar&p <b idk:<6cs) cms
- we + sw&4nue~ sv6" ok konx Mcr l
V d ESSEX HUMAN FACTOR ECT h SER
/H2 &
DUQUESNE LIGHT C00FANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER i
/
WESTINGHD PROGRAN COORDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
& w & ~
g O '& 4 ~ MfN W.k A &f f_- f 1 e l DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER DUQUESNE C0pegYREd.AFFAIRSMANAGER
. SWw DUQUESNE LIdHT CODFANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
i t
HUMAh LNb1NttHINu U1WKU'anwI (Mty) Mggn i a) 3'/95 2. PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: Irstw e:-e b 7 " E c) ED NO.: 2YCE~21 E d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: /0!N ' (%tinghouse) / CR No. 71 (Essex) f) ED TITLE: h 2. r n a , a z'T" n>J Room 0 MTER SCALE 9 g) ITEMS INVOLVED: mb H Ence em9t.hNS . DN PArosu vc,-8 [L t oi ,110 2. , ,,0 3, s ia +} h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDGER: Pooe. C.ocr eo _su comu oc 0.xs2se.x esAr_w.se.mo sw. G .S . I . 3 c 03 4(2.)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESbRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
b tC 9 LN 5 CJQ ViEy TP5.IB1.I OLCI A/ R403 j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERROR $(s) OR EGJIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: ito E 3 Ab J h 'l"E ~D ' ' # N - C/W eu.::o t T ip b E.c A si
- _ . . _ _ . . _ _ - _ . _ _ . _ __ - ,__m. _ . _ _ . _
k) REVIEU AND RECONMENDATIONS:
, c 4.s r v, k'Ee o 3 L r V- LEfG"% OU W ' ~ E- MC 4?CO A jv Tde. pbe~boyApk ob- Yus ihslmb (on k n'ack-vio) nuEes th,,, /..k w.,u. . -/L, +4y & hy an. Me., awe 4 n fk ae6d ca&/ ro.- ff.u idou b, m -Sv d 6 de.,
y * ~ . A* f # S'"'. / /0 $ 7/O \
, N
'V rd E ECT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER D. LM WESTINGHOU T PROGRAM C00RDI W OR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
w& Y W M - f (W f -- / p L /%
/~s4j-f AA w -s:
N' WM cf4 Wl yy/ A A A A c f.i DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGIEERING MANAGER v ~), 5 N'S DU(WES COWANeitEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER (M^y' l ' ' Q 0 4 c g r ' g-~~ g .
~~~ ~
DUQUESNE LIGHT Co r ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
t e .s.n.,n .. ~ ~ ,.... .. .. . _, .... l a) ENPS 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: 'T F N N ' c<- 9 . D' M c) E D NO.: O b M~ mob
.) EvIEnD av k/[M8/
(Wstinghouse)
.) DATE: ?//o/P4
\
(Essex) 7 N\% 7 f) E D TITLE: O nES" Nvh cN M 'mE h C 5 ? PLA '/ W<m .
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED: ,
O4 PAasL. CS-1 (3M, 3 0, 3 u, 512., q ;4,34, 3 7,. M na - A,+ , es coe cm.s e,e,-2 (5t'b,M, v 6, in), 3 B-3 (bis A, 5,e e), Bc.-t (3D,M p ;j4,pp4 E' A b/ , 'M -3O S, 3 t. 4 A St. c, A, e G , . J, i i, o f A , M ,16 +, 7 A , G A,,W, (Sk 94,R6.0c,Rb,% i t ,1=9c,,9 , gg,93,gzy,s ?, a 5 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDGER:
*L' M- ?'
1 ics ". cWcto na ( E novi=.2r:4 - L+%WN 2 %: .. g. 6.E.I.4t:. i< C 4-(c
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
D 'M N LEE 4 7p s.l f33 ,ig Q (C(h) QQq j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR ECRJIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: d43 W ~o F ,9 A dsvyv ,9 Es.bpq 9 5 DisPW
k) REVIED AND REcotMENDATIONS: 7,.- , .. z - 7.a.. : ' =W :
,:. a ( 4 ,3 p e-x m er
~ f f ' : ~."' ' v' C ~-Y2:
~
9E bis PJ 4 Th G
- facexs b$"=b*
- sc eler cloe-r no t flocl neeY I" "Y'"-
7A:s w:// 4e cAcc4ed d<y (Y;4% m/44n3 41, 7d.ru Se^
-A b_. a ,n ow u// te -ik av Hrb s. ir. ,.aa ~.-
~_ -
eu rnts mfd, N _
/M ESSEX Hl. MAN FACTORS ECT MANAGER B/SL a DUQUESNE LIGHT CODFANY REVIEW TEAN LEADER
- s' ?_
WESTI @ E PROGRAM C00RDfhATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
e . DUQUESNE LIGHT CODFANY ENGIEERING MANAGER
$f ,
- A , . .. m ms - A.ER
.UQUES y ren-
'DUWJESNE LIGHT CODPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAh LNG 1mLR1NG UL whLt % 1 tmas aven a) M2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: "T7 M e , : sc. W G E c) ED NO.: dE C3 - 2207 d) REVIEWED BY e) DATE: b!/O!2 (Westinghouse) / M (Essex) N f) ED TITLE: Maur#^ c BJ rvh C-A v~2 NT VFCNAL ._
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Fug) E c.g L.w; N 4 M G L- 3G. - 3 W , IM) h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLSSER: NwT2 h5 00 =&5n Sc+ug ha3 0 0~ NG12~1c t - (o .E.2 A o. i 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER: 4 b1S PLh'lr Sm 54 7 9 5. l u,y y LCzy g i.jc3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR ECWIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: N N O 'T IG A Yr LA y iO 2.ggg 4 -- . g 35 *W .
* ~
k) REVIEW AND REcobe4ENDATIONS8 rgjw6E -E E-: t =._ "o
. -E u ; v.vt N # z =_ g 2- : A ,,
* /Ar A l'k* B& . NUMEAALS ARE AGAM9LG .
fa pyrow xer.om- w e h M ESSEX HQNAN FACTORS MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER B 1, M4 WESTI % PROGRAN C00RDINNTOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: -
DUQUESNE LfGHT CorANY ENGIEERING MANAGER hf a DUQUESN pE CO# AN FREG. AFFAIRS MANAGER [Y W DU(WESNE LIM CorANY OPERATIONS MANAGER w
l, HUMAh t.NGlNEf.RINu UAWAm,I (MLD) HuwI a) 3NPS Z PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: C EJ O WE- DCG c) ED NO.: EMO- 2EOS d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: /Oh4 (WWitin~ghouse) / Y A th (Essex) T f) ED TITLE: M'J E ~ We0 4 ' 4 "= 4 9 A N A~"W EE N-r N-M. 3, t v c _ - no re e me g) ITEMS INVOLVED: t e : n .- 09 Ov o J:
~
Ttc - 3 (6h,6*3,n ik, l'1l a, IV2, IH, I5) E(, - I ( 29.3A)
- c,- 2 (.I-O ,
r - -i (H$) M
-t ( ?.. D C_a.m J. c7 u h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AfD 0700 PARAGRAPH NLMBER:
p ou vu 4 Pi? ~4. AO 9-ef 6.PA ag r w n :7 p,w c 3a : e _r - G.5.I,c o 6) g /o.6-4.tc,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION IRM8ER: .
bmm u2 m/ - W 3. l 33 . 2.2. BLCIN R 4CLf j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR ECIAIPIENT DESIGN PROBLEM: . h OF h h.: P + ~; .
k) REVIEU AND REC 00MEWATIONS: .
.. ,_, g n1 SLFus 50 MD 40C E '
O& ^
, ,.y r.-r.2 0 ~; ST P '~ i & ~ 3 Q V u' T F 4 's Q.ah aLc. ras < (44 ,00 Q< ion r a My ,
\ .
s ESSEX MMAN FACTORS PROJE X \ 'M R J hw Eb DUGJESNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER b/ , , WESTIpSE PROGRAM GQinw1NATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
/4 - A, -
DUGJESNE LIDIT COWANY ENGIEERING MANAGER
"$f ~ & 2 / * ?]
DUOms.j.NT .a er =G. mIRS -GER f 6?'3? m DUGESNE LIW CorANY OPERATIONS MANAGER i
-.,._.,..--._.--._..,% _.-e-._,,,,.-_.y- - _ . . . , _ . . _ . , _ . . - _ _- , , - _ . - - . _
9 HED# M-)t-M .2.106 tcoa om r p s.i 2 3 . 2 2.
- 2. . c .A L Aoc 2.o;23 (;- C -Ti;.? % 2H YS -Ff 2:J A, M 5- FC 22, M*VD ~Tl :5,
,24 d 5 - 7 6 22't:,, 2C.t,; + G%) ..
e,. ,coan, naa,w s m a, m e, m io .- .
?4 - S (.;4@
Vf * $ C,c'. - #5me el)
'- C. -lo (Qibh,'t Q 4 ~1,23 3h, 4. A , ?.D ,0013 0, '~' ':, .' ~, 2 h b, IINI, A bb BC. - 5 ( I3, D,$ 07, O6O 3, d%,290 A, 9 S~/ A,305 A,963, 95 73, 252, 3c 3, ZId, IOi bh)
\/G-5 ( Hl A ,44144I c,4 f( D,4 52' ,442.5) -
r :- - s A u , nas, ass, ns,, + ss, es=, Ash, a.s, +s, +n . g: . e: ( 9 /T ; , SM , S GC, 96 c,, Oo ' G , 84 I A , 2G 2 a, b ; . - a ;. O , ,
%s, sais, s i., s,o, su ic, eu -x, eaAs) i t+ 5 ( ~?9 b , 2 9 S & ,~/ % ' , G<*=, .
V-b p - s ( C49 3,949 :~ , b - %, S? , :,, GT t = ,2 ':, " . 1
.' :6't , 5 '.' k .
E:. T:s GS:/ '91~)toIa,;c :/ 2. ? - ) (B*t,209%,9;.2A,30A, B".1~5,O',;.9 VA-(o ( 6 0^:,B.~2,3's s, O' '1, 6~4 A, 099, 9.0,90'2, 9 ^J, ft /4 4,Cr/4 1,2 /'Ab ,S','i, 33 % , F) 9
a) ~ t/E 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: ^. <./ -> ~-: c) E D NO.: M N ~1'09 si) REVIENED BY: a) DATE: /!/ O ! Ebl (Ne(tinghouse) /
~
$ x
\
M (Essex) f) E D TITLE: 'Po,arra Tips a rra t L a tr n. d4-b u 47/oa tAkRR$ o Ch All uan Fat A.Lf
- 9) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Akb 20L>t1h MF7FES h) PROBLEN DESCRIPTION AW 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMER: DM TIPS Wh L 6RhbuFrto9 Mhews OR. rJ w vgA45 c.s 22m d)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQbESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLM8ER: .
D69L M5
- 50ft9py Tp g., } gho,,, 3o ,DLC.IN RV03 j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERROR $(s) OR EWIPENT DESIGN PR00LEM:
CA9 RESULT # bEthy 02. W ooR Rirc_T REAbW6 OP TH E ScA LE .
k) REVIED AND REC 08MENDATIONS: TMA 3 %
jk > Ue.>E wh )R
&.s2 y mats &
1
. x-a..s ._ n - - - -- -no 2fEo c4n ae-- / ogg y,p,g gy pterER PMrr/oM
' lb #-174~' A' Rome ovD 62) l 1>W ESSEX MLMAN F ECT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COBFANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER t / -l 2 WESTI C00RDINMDR U REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
he 6 DUER5NE LIGHT CODFANY ENGIIEERING MANAGER f DUSE C@ANpfEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER 70 WW DUWESNE LIWT DODFANY OPERATIONS MANAGER i
% .. ~ .. m . .. . .. . ._ . . . . .. .. .._ .
1 c) BuPS 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: T EE N a e 4 4"n c) ED No.: _le'l X ~22#0 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: h!/O ! W (Wdtinghouse) /'
~
V A oA (Essex)
] ~"AN0JA c N 40 S f) E D TITLE: ':O O' T6 %f 2
- Or O r e,c,3 ro,e on e T "= C. Amsme g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Sc.A L.y 3 ou ppatts: .
W - B (4 0, 6 4 9,1006,1009,9 5 8, '39, 6 3 E) VA - 9 ( 94 ' A, 04 \ 9, Ote \C, Ovo,9(o 1 A, lor 4 0 6, Sa t, C+ 78, 961 C,) Vf l / C 4 ES, 4 04, 4 T/, 4 % , + 4 S, 44 o. .H 7) - Vc 6 (44,1 se,;-a B,9i9; - Vc,>[hok,;eoO h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUNBER: 20 e u Ls noo ef. era w ron e 9.s 2n x: u .20 0* fc. & E u Px op co . C. 3.a e
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER: .
'.) ! S M ' i.* 302d M - W s,\ y., % DLCZN I{ Ll 03 j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERROR $(s) OR EmlIPENT DESIGN PR08LEM: .
g. p w , SLb L-5 , t 4
k) REVIEW AND REcote4ENDATIONS:
- p. .1.2 =c.a cz: To A B&oADER STf L E O Ps
&A CdtON OF BETTFR CONTR AITy C HM6-E PolNTGIA 5~
To R Eb.
. b re w.r ikr di<DMY /ED, if TAfY kM "'DM 7uty twvs O concem. 7ar scAw 6xA/Mru~ t7Wk' tbs 90 /wdeef.
* ,/f4 , k T M ~' AKd"MY.
% NNW5 %
ESSEX MMAN FAsi 'QECTMANAGER 1 D60DESNE LIGHT CODFANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTI Q PIIOGRAM y INATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
f DUQUESNE L1GHT CCDFANY ENGIfEERING MANAGER
*$f DUGESEp C$ANY'llEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER W. f 77er->& _)
'DUGJESDE LI9fT DODPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
. ~ , . . , . . ..- - . . . .. . - . . . . . . ~ _ . . . . _ . - . . _ . -
.f.. _.._....--.._.-.-.7,~.
a ., 4 1 A n Hw' M ix - a.zio , I g W [* _, c . P n'- s , r-- 63,, I d^ '
- u 1 s. .
. hg[$ 3~/ k A , 3 ~$ . -
!' ~ VA -5 804 %%b k vp4.DEC. M h,S-t 2 'M. B*SA,8#5 3 BN, #M 2. St A, =746,'; 4 + $ ( f
. N r
4 1 4. l
- e '
e 1.
}, .
t
- e wr
.f f
i {' J b '- s I 4 i f e i . . . .j i y~ d 4 s t > L* l i 1: i- ! 4 t j t 4
, l l
e
HUMAN ENGZNEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.) BVP5 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ N bMdW c) HED NO.: 2 "M l l d) REVIEWED BY: $h. /-
(Westigouse) H/ e) DATE: 3/8I/II T% .d (Essex)
]~" y
.6.F f) HED TITLE: Mo in ca cy 5 6 min, g) ITEMS INVOLVED: yyg h .p g gq
% , H,6s , % G
$!(o, 4 % ,M Woj ,
RCS WR Pcesswe [ z acs g pr g o.g , % g h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: ,5, } , g, Q] CuccenNy o p ra.h rs ham k compem cg pI's g% t DCS WR FTs -b come up WMWA ?. The ,nkrodtx41on of k Steanhne AT .narde udd ehminale 9 ra. N versiccs
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
Va.k's A ion o CCO E fY\ d- COS te%Q j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: CB- PS O d. '\ G C C c r h e c-CRKS$e_. (YW. clelaye.A.
-_ _,_ -- - _ _ _ - - . - . ~ , - - _ - - - -
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Er\$ h di O( Qa a h kai M Ass-ce - r k <>. .- Of C d Pre d u CE. rer.c M e M (RCS ad $6 ggxh ( CEC.h o e r- so e e i ook. at ~j vsk one pa ne.\ ( an,L en ebr-) .fc> gas ~ . nG:c.uk e n , RT mgdM 3 as an opatch aid. , Ms AP be allebte on com c c,igh xy
N\a %
T ~ ESSEXHUMANFACTORSPROJEQIMANAG$R
#M OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- h. .
WESTIN($1buSE PROGpRDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
4 <d 8 M g/g
/
M ,( & ~ M MEN WV
~ .
.e W '2;f #
ya 4 & "' M r = # W ~.~.
~
_Y lC ' I -$4 4}
' ' * ' ' U + , . ,;, s 3 g ap ; DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER u re ..bJ. en,,y (
\ t ,
5 -r w , .. . - d 000DETNE LIGH COMPANL REf. AFFAIRS MANAGER
, ,u 3,l *%
') LI % y qr 644 b 5 s - ..s L .e ,
.. e my f {c; & ,n a'?.!.,. i DUQUESNE LIGAT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l h hwt h bc w A- YO ff- i
HUMAN ENGZNEER8NG OZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) PLANT / UNIT l b) ORIGINATOR: IllnbMI c) HED NO.: @N E d d) REVIEWED BY: -
e) DATE:
I ' (Westingfouse) / / [/ 3 x (Essex) cement b; L i kt f) HED TITLE: Sca\a ba kces n
\
[N66CC t 21 # knskrt.W e S g) ITEMS INVOLVED: i
.1Res -PR,$84 w i 4 41GLcs -PI % ,M T'r ais. d w r Pc w w.
2/ .2 af.5g 40% u% 2R(_s -TI. 40A , %m A,43) A CC5 he, Nd
- 3) 2pm -LR55\ ide a.gss - L1 15%A 15tB 9
i (sec a h d e ne
- b. 5 .\.4 cl F r'i n k., en h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
be dsqby face. VIben 4Wo oc mcre dkpays l cf 4he ATw raramek meL be ccn9sced , scdes shca.M be ccepak.b(.c
' n numee. cal Scessten and scde gn ,dc>n i -
t) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION Yd6heCcbCX'N O C b<sEE22C d h M Cd b h ' * \/
$UEc6lIg C R - % 5) (..X .\.1 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
CSn NE(.dk A N l c3 dv_.Ac Y 'ocorrac.hre.cQ',ng 04_ % a,spey
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONSa
'lIC r3 E S C G d(5pI8 p Shc%dh_ k% g q,, , . . \
7 C6 CCmy ib k'\( , ( gQ_ Tw% is Noi A N cc e s u m , $c.M ca 2 d u4 6 3 are capd.k{c. w[ esc.k oNr f 'I-t is not Aete Kcwy hu r b k b k -}k. 3..d'.cah t c.c M ickwD.ce$
@c corbe c. c. d4 .
elo Ac Tto P 7 ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS P CT MANAGER 5~Z EA / ash DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- Y.
WESTI $ 5E PROGRAM C00pFINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
i$. c h 'e n DUQUISNE LIGET COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER lN $-WVf OUQUESNEpHT C#APli REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER N NW
' 0UQUESNE LIGHf COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
9 h N E ID E I ca.') p h b i NED NLc ;,k,h-lilt j i(ishineb ScMes dire i pcs f ge4M _ = tE I #i co - aiCO A 3C (- ac co y %, ..w ...,a y,41
. O_.W__ Pr 44_.,._4- 4 M = I BC4.; JLCC GGCC 9@O ~._.
- u. , - .
r ._ _ y . _ - _ . . . . _ . L_.__ _ __ _ = .. _ l
.2 Rc5 - TR.4ot = 530 55u 570 Seto 4,I c- -630
?;kewel w.4 i - l .
- 3. .a.a.c s. . rt _m..i _i A w Ami A _ _'
5% 560 530 60 0 6X' GT
,, . . . . _ . _ ~ _ . . . _ _ . O Rss...u.t ts. i -.
O 90 40 6C W .I.C .C.. .. t .2 0 >b- a. 4. J h. . ._- cass i.I isiA i ss i & O 3C ____. =(-c_0_ 9 C_ . I O C-7 w - e weeW. went was's enemMweeue vuodwem=- 6 _ h n- a t -eme - w etwasse-m -
' *4
- v heB4 6.eWWuDD-emendmune e gge+ wee pog_. eseg es e g . m --gap .M .ew e me -
- e ergee uste e s ama e. a e e4. wm. 4 4 gagem a. w. fn-h ww. a
***a w wg e M.$. 4e gas r 3:e gy3 4 ==$
G
, ~. - ---,---~.,.-,,ry,_m,. .
m., _ . , _ . _ - ,,,._.,.,m.,___,, . , _m., _ , , , , , , ,
HUMAN ENG8NEER8NG OISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT 9
.3 .b @ 5 2.
PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ OdVC c) HED NO. M 6-32/4 d) REVIEWED BY: . r MJ I e) DATE: I % (westigghouse) /
'T a (Essex) \
f) HED TITLE: Ahrd3v a nd cm. 9 : c, ul seg { e n .W
)
Usec\. b e vec,,Nw a larcec dice a g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Cenhnmenh C ,
&cq. g , h o_g3 g ,2 Con 6,n ne,4 S 5 Pee.m ( % ,,3,g g o- w p q
\
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER (G.5.\.l b
. . D ' S P'Op sbpd 3 1.- d , c A y a L % , , ,,, ,
~
v r.Ak \H % vp.krL s'gh3 me.shi cu, gc.\. , , , ( v g v i r ,. .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION
"'(R9c5) \le ri Gehe.s of f ank_ p.ckcoww C O gb\[i\.di se s ' L. la b . \ .
6 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: h J t.. s % f (/ *' . gb i Yt h"hh/ le e Os (t
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONSa DM S c a k. [g \A t h k m C. o M t g W % f
- GT.R 55 % fA kh-\S s' 9
h *.s d t 4 \A s.eh ko C owVg o.hmtwb gos-s% %-% kk k <x h Nh4 s \A .s (,@ sth vs. p st wN<\ w La.skN=s <.oW4e5 \ *w 3MAA a k g e d,s k h
%g iAss t g c.4.s.S.\rf.m.s N b 5
- W g &<4%hs(udks) g<
( owMw'% $csh 1. k (.o h k (b M bekN
~ Q%\h k g' Mb g ak. NA cah 4b5 NN\ *I N
- 5 @ (*.55 % ta pt 4 s S t.a.
gguM & gs A *th (- t 4\ T' % * *
- yE
- M S-1aon Y ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJfhT' MANAGER 2 t(bt^^O OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER b*
- WESTIN@USEPROGRAMfDORDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
fj/sh lS Ov' C'UO ZA/D/MT/O Sud4%ospMa. sic _. Cn7t<wn
/31/- 2. /MC ,4 f(Vore psi s- is ~
-fe Sesrun c svo'"* *',
f r ,.
,[ 4/ w '
N Ad f$d' OUQUESNE LIGHT COM#ANY ENGINEERIND MANAGER
' / 7-/hf?^
DUQUESNE LIGHT OMPANtA EG./ AFFAIRS MANAGER
. M "OUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGZNEERZNG DZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) PLANT / UNIT N.bnaer c) HED NO.: bU b) ORIGINATOR: _ d) REVIEWED BY: - l, et e) DATE: (Westing (ouse) /
\
(Essex) W f) HED TITLE: Wo WW me.kr avad49 e in Conhrek hm h.akWdtr m Qr Lc6tne A r. <<n 3, y _ .s g) ITEMS INVOLVED: 7 ; g., NY b~kh . h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 4 .3 ,j ,\ h ,
% ece M no RPP m e b - p re,vid d : n % ce6\ n=em se arx everalec canU,' Jre \l . f pwwps ar rumi, t) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
vah 4 Conm\ Pam4&cos (RAoQ j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: ; Id Md INort~,e f W6% 5
Ih
~
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: '3 f@dC M0W'Lt B ch~ RPM rnels be. indaNE 'sn 4I cen&coI nac n, se Mf clrx opera 40 r
~
can reS ',G 4e pmps ace renn- @ RT r.ccmm.nas +hak b Teac= June 6 chayd su<h 4ha4 +be. cya.6c. ,s 6 ver.fy M the skam gly saluts are cp, i F there is no am VeelAt-(Ice then m r,% ar.an 6 444 < ps.mps ac=. b 6. ch..wJ tocotty yo kVY a N NQ *
\ '\M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS's ROJECT MANAGER E1 s:L ha OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER D. L Mb WESTING $ USE PROG' RAM p RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
M 9 DUQUE!INE LIGH'T COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER fY b N-RC DUQUEShiVLIGHTdNNPANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
- f. M@md OUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
S . HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREFANCY (HED) REPORT 2 a) 6" P' , PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: /1KRJRV ' c) HED NO.: M k'2JOI d) REVIEWED BY:'I e) DATEi // 7/rV ' ()(estinghous() K; _g a - -
~
(Essex) *
~]i -
f) HED TITLE: l_oss om 80 LNoe Gwd 70 eunuoGR MO Gt T* ggcinc r Lo d
- x .m ROJer ;,Js- F;eus M*banacei cuccc. iia A/8 SMo somsh cwstanaa.r ,
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: _' ',, ,
~1/6 Pump Sxnau cm coucc7 curex
.s
=
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: ~ 4-055 o P (DC C A *O ALJJ ;. 6gwoaz e40 A sus C o'- 6* r RW GC W dessu rco co-1 n mcc Amm re w.se on A/e Psmo ew;s caounet. <corect. nas sa ca .w) ced Bu r ~ A s .2 ro.w.s Awa r hw ro c Cwsco sur maa. , q t asc. Acao tsa a s aifr Ran,w u am woe os.v. .tuerr>D . ' N
~
- 1) ; DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: K R Gav o,o 6i.c\N Mg\ tg ,
4 4 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN. PROBLEM: y-VAwd wsokD ott-a &r w so rue.m pn v #<>1 M ClosuD k'*' ~.
- Q. ,Wavr l'Fw&r. I?cw r.& iM M s i C sttL AM0 #"
k) REVIE0 AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
- uwann :-- . o g r ,. . . . n c; .a . . --
....,._,..,i....n
,,...m.
. BV- 2 is DevGwro suck .rke- Borx ses l Geers 4 1 7~~ 4Wk VfivE- /s /w frDic+n ov G tifM75 pic L. Er tyv / pit +C.>, E21InrE f03/ 77*
a ,@'o /ff 77d W /ffZ~dd N W ,
\
N ESSEX HUMAN' FACTORS P BCT MANAGER
^
/L DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTINGpSE PROGRAM C0QMfD4ATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
S
)
DUQU$SNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER 0000ES f GHT C0f(BhNY" REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
~
see % DUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
- f% Matt LNulter.r.KAMu UA.wMarchI g pg.,g j pggre a
" ' I ',GS 2. s ' alc
*- PLANT / UNIT .s pu-uos 1
m .m wm u ORIa!.roR: .) Eo No., o :EvIEno er h/38Md (llntinghouse) /
.) OAn, 7//o/ PW j'i l ~ M . ,
(Essex) $ ; l f) ED TITLE: Lwe 9;M nM Lre m t$ -r is -70 0 N -
.\
g) ITENS INVOLVED: L%1Epo c4WS PAWL g A 2. (Mk B A -3 ( t04, iogo), %-4 (%51 N/C- 6 ( (030), VC,- S (10\ h , BB-l (3001 BC. (IS,19,46,47) ; V EE.T C A L - Aow u ne -( pa 33- og ,gp- , uty- pgy,A . h) PROBLEN DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDSER:
;s Lzmn.rg cwt coo cd LL co usEM ' 'M~ ! - d L M ,
" h~D )A.,\77"y o/L , I a 5- * -- 6, g' f. j w t
(
- 1) DA5A COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLM8ER: .
bl5PLAc -s e ss T P =a.t S l. \ DLcIn Ryo3 j)- SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EMAIPENT DESIGN PROBLEN: p V 'hW
'l 39 aso a
'\ ,o A tisLAy ,9 E E o U M 6 -i n 5 4
no u m a snu u m nunu m s
'1K % si ue =: a o =- - .
~-~=c
?:n ca , . ,- _
,.,>. .c., +n_,
,+ asr- [- ne~ <~ w w~6- -* w unr3) n ,n c , ,,
enw~,- umx s,rr , xewa war.vw um irs os narge fpi~a kn-WC M E C C'rf- C P 7Ad&T C/M.S , Jt 7%y we. y,C
,4W xcestmy, eles b d4s are_ A, ly ;fle . syg,,,j 4 o,,6 w./A Awa A y, b.a L ./ k cA do J A, nact ves6;c d S~ d /9h 6 , d s is no t a pn d/em.
suo ac nw W __ g
- - - ESSEX M FACTORS hANAGER M
DUQUESNE LIGHT CCDFANY REVIEW TEAN LEADER x WESTINGNQp$EPROGRANC00RD3NATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
DUQUESNE LIdHT CODFANY ENGINEERING' MANAGER WY d-2/'ff' ou0uESpeHT q$PAff REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER y SWw DUQUESSE LIdHT C00FANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
resWe LNu12tHANu UAW'uhi L%UJMtMme a) 3M 1 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: 'T E Nu i FGrA D e -i G r E c) ED NO.: 2OUK-~2 D d) REVIENED BY: a) DATE: /0 /7h (Ne(tinghouse) / M' ~ M (Essex)
\ i'M 5 IS DC-f) ED TITLE: (~3m EW A4 Wr A g) ITENS INVOLVED:
gm ts Ts ou PAduL Gk - % (.,4d.i, b A -4 (%S), 6 B-I (3ck h) PROBLEN DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDSER: M2. c.a .>re A :.T v p b c c A s Q, A s T ucvgr % ~ W- "E '"I '* 93 %. et c ~NL(LOOch c I4 . 3. 3,3 4 (i.)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
hWW a ,1.aeu r r TP s.\ %3.6 3LCIN R403 j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR E(ElIPENT DESIGN PR08LEN: CA O EssatT 19 A ma f ( ,a g.c r. . 3s 5 3 a . . r,
1 k) REVIEW AND HEC 0084ENDATIONS: P 3'-k K L E ~c. X d f, W "- pggg.g 2 .;., ' :-M
,,;. -e c. % 20..ya * '
g pgy - si: gotoA CodM' WoAG g.Td"S '~ ' ' b#'3 ' I
's !
\ .
l ESSEX HLMAN FACTORS HiGs MANAGER' DUQUESNE LIGHT CODFANY REVIEW TEAN LEADER DLdkb WESTIW HiGiridM C00itDpoR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
0 7_ gg.c-20 o 7 a 0 /W8 tw!b Y W '
A
/ ,
. ,& wa) f. Y #A " ' p < A '
- 7/?l/tr
'$"fui'derdond s col,c 4g "d 7 c- %w ddte/1Tod DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGIIEERING MANAGER
.K 5 - Cec.n ~cd H-d bLC 4 %cu s H .c \- : , g. - e, sce f -
/_ S- 3'/dV iv c c < p k b\ e_ < &., a c Lya sy, l DUQUES CIIDPAiY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER f$ W&
DUGJESNE LIllHT CODFANY OPERATIONS MANAGER i
.. ~ .. . ~. . ..
w..................-.-. c) ENPS ~7 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: NW ,4E Wis nf c) ED NO.: MN-2 MI d) REVIEWED BY: I e) DATE: 8f(0/? (Ne(tinghouse) ~ f M
\
~
(Essex) N WE5E Lracc or cp rrge v A f) ED TITLE: -h> w +5rt c - A Po =A1 ou :rce ,, L * + ~ ~~3 g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Ee-2[qtp4),'E:A -3 OccA,in $) LFc5m 3tmos'S ON PeRCL vc-co Doub. vc-sdain h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION A2 0700 PARAGRAPH NLDSER: V M CC *.- yn u Tappt w % c CD W ito m at: 7,- s. O
% esE L, p e.; OF LS T R aM .
(o. s. 3 9 b ro
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLDGER: .
% EMUDI M 9 S.t 6'5. t 2. }(,,C,z y R LlOf j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EGJIPDENT DESIGN PROBLEM: .
(pa 7_.g- g I ed h- % T3 J 4 ga 8.E,xy a Ez ,,5 3 :;_ ;~ 3 4 9
k) REVIED AND RE00lMENDATIONS: garr
~ ~ _ : C':- ~ r] N .1G
- C 'W G S 400 "E ang;q
/6-< :., / v s , cs, A G e e s s e ur :oW S.
~V ~ N ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS AANAGER h
DUQUESNE LIGHT DOW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
~
WESTIpE PROGRAM CG0iulNATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: -
b . ST ^G.SV c k.a b;)ff)k i A Yll l DUQUEskE LIGH1 CorANY ENGIIEERING MANAGER
- Ef8/. c3/-tr' DUQUESN pE C M P4NY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER N@W
'DUGESE LIeff CorANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENG8NEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) 8VY1!2= PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: N iCFOJR9 c) HED NO.: 'J FN- 2306 , d) REVIEWED BY: a) DATE: 7/3//IM (WMtikghouse) [' N NN \\
\ M ~
(Esse'x ) f) HED TITLE: I N C O M 5 i s'D D T LA 6 0' A 08 C 00 5 4 & eti C tR C R W S R u n ti
-TMB\d ATIo f4 g) ITEMS INVOLVED: MinoN LQQ't W 4'-. E' 08hb" W CW C'5 C G AW4 44N SQ m *.
PNL 6C A ~
/49ch %> J SASC 214 150 tr A O w G p ases.c_Al8 i6i tr% Edgd M y h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
A hAn.w cvtiu.ut hb MW&- Q,5 Ld , w /.6 (c(2), d(Q && g 00 j 4a. 2
, { 6.4. a. 24'O)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION M BER: SO AV Y, Tgt,/g7. .7 C oN vgN7,O Nd ,
DLC.EN R l-l33 i j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORhts) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: tiny CAusc LGLAvs occ/ot. G(exs 54 occuro4 Amt.s 5
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: . Rd Mc.C WH iT Ivc,ctnog wigwg ce; cace.c.g e.omey cu rows wo t-8JE^J u6 nis t em.4 co s e. coo,~ w w eis h v o Df,0. goev& Ytow 15 yp;m pp RCO AK ///b/f VhlT4Af cttcoor BefMMS PO MEra &O XG1) F. x tm Voc Ydhr, OPEX}PIDtS wveeXJ74Nb Anb Me~ WEZ L 7M/"O) ctv TH/J' conve~nua.
- h $ 71 W ff[dfA &'&L-b
\ ~
ESSEX HLMAN FACTORS PROJECT NN R ! DUQUESNE LIGHT Co r ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
, / ?
WESTI @ SE PROGRAM C00RSINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: .
9
/ /
#/0A A DUQUESNE LIGkT COW ANY E NEERING MANAGER f .= ,
DUQUESpIGHT ($5A3(REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER ((@W DUQUESNE LIGHT CDWANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
r HUMAN ENG8NEERZNG DESCREPANCY (HEO) REPORT l
,) SV b- 2 di PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ M Feodsc c) HED NO , 2 ea+ -n o 7 d) REVIEWED BY:
t e) DATE: D (Westinghouse) # 7 N M (Essex) ] f) HED TITLE: lodicebr \idb Q a re oc !ccc3 ec C I Ge E)SSCdcl #d Ccn k. g) ITEMS INVOLVED: ac45 #FCV llM s I; j ?. A . * ) 1* *% g k [ " 7ggg.y pcv i\'5 A - brt hA 2 n eck:5~ 3
% ~iLW 7. \ -
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: b 9 . 2. 2. CA The pcMhrced Con (tgdabien C 3 d " (h'
~
-Iccahl cb re c.1{- ake eads C u dcc\ i., e d used ',w c _ c di C.Y_
's SE loca ech 7 '.ndvs k., w (e h ch b .wu.dA^ co, , kje r,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
Drihcahon, of Task @cka mcuce capab '.(s , hu B 3t k t A R4CID b .h.\.h j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: lM6DL 5 ff5h0Se' O'aq h be { c) cd
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
,'icej
% k. _
N .aw dbe. c,L_{
. y;k.h & 8lerulbl ecvi?ni carc.A. ,
b'y/$h gg yn/be pos; pm vanovs e,d2%,, n.// jfes,n,r on ee' ha Y* /5 , Nl d 2olel yolffenleir Y i gJ , A'Y., -/90Y f ' ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJE MANADER
~
TEL DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
& J. k;[s WESTING $W$EPROGRAMC0QR6INATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
^
[ O l f
~
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEfRING MANAGER j 0fW DUQUESNE L 7- 2&M ANYdEG.'AFFAIRSMANAGER [F 91w DijQUESNE LIGHT C6MPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER 1
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT i
~
a) PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ N ECMOSF c) HED NO.: 2 d) REVIEWED BY: . //, e) DATE: [ f (Westingffouse~) / / 1 (Essex)
\
f) HED TITLE: Poidion indM4bces m's sM nc. Gr- Rw wh M TR\9 0
%@ b\l&%Si w of' dd Mr5 i3 C RA S g) ITEMS INVOLVED: %
{ b igd. C3 h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: h ( , b. Ope.cbr- hAS no ki b 't o d i c a k e_ 4he_ PM Org oO 4e_ bypass bre= L ers, A tc @ b m h s,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
VaC d dien oC Gb Rem knd-toos (L%) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
- y. . y
% C Mdj SO&e
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Jng gjk indi cahors l i YcM 5 a bov - H& AD b p-' N43k. ass s N rdCorY\ - S % ac On cd bM Ch b e Ecaber p o's h e n s aw cemn ava'dalote e 4he ccmpb c. O L5 0, N V Aciqb g b() '{ } b on d#l h gkI W k^
'v> ece k U i5 c. I o u_<d ,
pp Krky
' N
$ N M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJ MANAGER EYS$m DUQUESNE L'IGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h h. ~
WESTI @ USE PROG p RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
h[
- I DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$Y DUQUESN
/ d- 2-}55 GMTCpANVR$G.AFFAIRSMANAGER
[8NM
'DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER I
l HLMAN ENGfNEERING DISCREPANCY (E D) E PORT i l a) 7N% 2 ,_ PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - $ E y M , wo W 'l UN c) ED NO. : 2YC7-2NI d) REVIEWED BY: a) DATE: 2 !/ O [ 9 '[ (Ma(stinghouse) / M ~ (Essex) f) HED TITLE: Peo( teuTitasr oN c a r.& R E=to rice rt 3 C, A l G - g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
.g t a cc g e, op p NaEL. VC -7 [.2eQ Tv.c nia c Cov7eoeeen %my 'Il mg -
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUNBER: Poo2. Cor>r6As.T- ylms t tec.g os her w EN 4EM L.S. (.S c ( O ((2.)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CONPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
M P r~f Sva0EN T P 5.( B3.1 DL C-TN Ryo3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEN: C m> ev.co m is A tegy to 9_ s A d , % ~~- 6 D'59 A'I
k) REVIEt1 AND RECOMMENDATIONS: SNE ~2 6 W
- (f + " F+ ' i t. c s , rAc a q o LN s y, ;. 'E biC'45 2D M b n KQ $ iS; :: ,i5i'**WM
'V1 ! IS AW]* E y
[ef:1bgk,-l1if*.O. (5 ee - >ec fian f & +/ec 7.5 M)
~7J/ff ET -aow<: eccLu, \
l , i %<lbe r commendahb ESSEX ' N sd HUMAN FACTORS 'TMANAGER ach l09ad c,O C css %sbcy: ' DUQUESNE LIGHT CG FANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER A /L d A : L WESTI @ E PROGRKM C00RDISTOR -
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
7to A;ue. A l DUOLiESNE LIdHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER SfW DUQUESNE C @ ANf REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
# ~~ M 5 7 ~
'DUQUESNE LIGHT CGFANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
i
HUMAN ENG8Nf:ERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) BWS '!. FLANT/ UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: ._ E R M \.\N g QV M Y c) HED NO.: 12Bh-150/ d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: OFT t t . 1%4-(Wed.inghouse) / K & ~ (Essex) 7' f) HED TITLE: On' mt v' ri/r t r.% d 3 ed ivv yt'n '4 yM H3 no g epfA NOVeiM#vit g) ITEMS INVOLVED: ' Shuid.Mn and LordVOI DCLAK Coundi Dr. 82. h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (ounO/ d()r.% inCYE a56., yglug, yjg4h d;y V,y rd (Jovf T.TTI (c.C.6.k(2) s
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
D15PtlNS, 2FJ Ei - 7 f - 5.1 B3 D DL.C \H 6t3Q j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: DT.,L.M \n Cht5Th\M\N@ bE hD\Mh
g ggg 9gg g47 g g k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
\ wi' TALL DCL0fJ COOMT O? S Tr%T IMCRER% \A)OH MO\leMEtJT.
. re,m ene is nm ru si s. (2 he~rs townm o .,s is i. a w
_rwe.e in O/c@os s~ vt< 5 Eb,
*O/ W 4 ff45 Oldt?/ft- 2 44) kgtypes N0Y PoS$rder 7e /rfoDif y ,svot /S / f* GO57 (7FfC/70'E /V APW6~
FXISTINb FG eo f es rp7~
- no cM&Sr gfzp/r:me- p pg,
'N 'y ,h \
ESSEX HUMAh , ACTORS NANAGER ~ DUQUESNE LIGHT C00FANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER s WESTIpSE PROGRAM C0096INATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
K DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER Y ,
-Sp.1.AsYRee.A,,A1RSANAseR oce w~
6UQUESNE LIGHT dblFANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
smo, u, ,, . ru w. w wo m cu ns vo w n.... a) b/D' 1 PLA fT/ UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: O a o .s-e ct O '- 'N c) ED NO.* S8M-DT o EvrEno v Y/<@a(## (Ne(tinghouse) /
.) , P //o / 2 v '
~
_ -i ' \/Dr%. (Essex) ] f) ED TITLE: %E- me- P $ 1~ ' </ N Ws -:
- wt r o . 30
* -: rv t'. v ,,A cp r h dh g) ITEMS INVOLVED: lav q cour G.: oo Pt
- 7 bA-+(%O,P,13,HQ
'? ? ~;- [ W I, " '2 2 ' , 3 :2 2, 3 a: ,3? O, 2: 6'. ~ % '? . 3 ^ & C. ~:- & 3, 3 ;6 % ,
hR5 SLB6,3-Pr') . E ~.- C 44'; h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUEER:
.- - 5 af -t U : o >> kurv . yy s>eTM 2 HMS Pook C-.a n TM *T, 5 H N L C 6 6 Gt A C!v kBT7'CllE Cfl v)litT','=
C k':A' :') G. PA C C b , T, S, ( w (q)
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION IRMBER:
GCP Pa ':.39.J;E - -P s.I c,3 n D L C. M R y 03 j) SPECIFIC HIMAN ERRORS (s) OR EmlIPENT DESIGN PR08LEN: .
- m
.e Mm.
l
%,_ s 3_ ,
'T h G D3 OJ c D 0 Q-( CR ,
1 I
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
-y g m e.v a L.c0QTE25 ')~L i- & - ~~5G -
w h, , , y, .-- cg e._ M c GO 2 %CS
. n s, is cooo a ~ cores.
,;w ypw x w ~ e-oep r
l
\ ~ i ESSEX HIMA4 F UT MANAGER l
DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANY REVIEW TEAN LEADER BL WESTI Q PR(ERAN 000RDI ET0R l - t
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
O DUQUESNE LIGHT C0rANY ENGIEERING MANAGER
~
[ . DUQUES8E COMIAhY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER W W W m _:= J l 1IUEJESNE LIGHT DOWANY OPERATIONS MANAGER ) l 1 l
HUU.AN ENG3NEER3NG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) BW6 '2. l PLANT / UNIT l b) ORIGINATOR: - M hEDWE o h esY c) HED No.: x m -3 o ol, d) REVIEWED BY: k e) DATE: bCT, Y2. 1984 (Wes(ingh'ouse) / ,
\ M (Essex)
\ ,
f) HED TITLE: $KtRT blALAF-TENL nu WWituunOS An itMiMAl'T I?nT Ati C6tTffl0LS J g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
% tQ.7 5 W CCMilMU005 ?.OTAR\6 M P AMS
NCB - S%ttr% ou c.owfit)uous ROT Afttm oQ P9KL65 C.ctnettep.g, (.At.t Owa.s) h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
$6lR.t Dt AMEIER. CDsh2.0 i m e ( u m m e d eh M. %\a<h
(,.4 4 +.e C6 i
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
TP 4 d B L i 1,9 D L C 1 6 R % 's l CouTP_ots 'So9\lEN : l
.I j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORSIs) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
1 D\Y & \GM \M %h457 \d 6 9%?EEY. e
k) REVIEh AND RECOMENDATIONS:
}nc(temE Sg.tC Di AMMEL To "2 . o W CHt7 Mh G.R E. 945 S f(3 \.E ,
a~ + v eu re-s. re- .~,
, g ,,,,. gie ,- o.a ncmarmxazw-nr y p.,,,ss y norw 6 ** 0 01 & lsout 0 1f* 7D Afstov[ &J ggpgg ,q g (
$y,7CMf3 of 7WO 7Y/E~ w t1W # l'^'! 7 C M dA 4- Dis =f m e s-r rysaq
, y f pH $ W #f
\
'W ESSEX h FACTOR
~ LN CT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT Cor ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER hi < i l J.
' ~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
2A 44 e e h e DUQUESNE LIGHT CorANY ENGINEERING MANAGER ff DUQUES7GHTCoeANrREG.AreAIR
~
e awv DUQUESNE LIGHT CorANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERIAG DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
,) B VPS /2 5 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGIN /iOR: _ O'd. YdCNIM6NI c) HED NO.: 2 MY N~ 30b3 d) REVIEWED BYi' / - - M e) DATE: l /2 2 /PT (Westitighouse) t
[
% \ fi% '
(Essex) g f) HED TITLE: AAI S SIN G A EAC tor HEA D VENT VALVE SWITCHES P g) ITEMS INVOLVED: - REACTop HEAD VENT VALV E SwircMES h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: THE BEAc7oB HEAD VENT VALVE S Od wlTCHES *To CrNTRol McT EXIST ON THE AfAVM' opgAA7 top of .THE VALVES Ca# 7##L BeA # D Qg hcavs x mygw s, 9 d 6 y dres .7 w, 7, 7. 2, / NUS N ** g.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
\/ERIFICA 7/0/ of AVAILARIllTY , R 40 C (, 2 , J. /
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: DE VIC E S Do N4T EXIS T !N THE A1Alf crNTRst Go AR D 'To PROVIDE THE C#N7Rol NECESSAR Y Td TA S K S : F'R- C,1,10, f At PLEM ENT THE foLL* WING OPERA 70A IT1 FR-H.I,Ic.
k) REVIE!1 AND RECOMMENDATIONS c ourpot PR0 VID E~ 8 c'S (tEhc7on HEAo VEN T VALVE SWIT C H E5 ON THE Afaly CoM 7BdL BodR D d M cM, k o tbv \* W \ M MA (odegh-c, b k wnA %c w 4W dm .
~
* & es,ee, s A' 444 5 V4L v FS /H W REF^J AvA o^' 4 & Kevastop ap D & '^'6S-
.No Mnons ."*cc3Mxg M
i ESSE HUMAN FACTORS P &T MANAGER V 4
//Ar7A J W tiUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
' /
WESTINGididjSE PROGRAM C00flDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
&d G
i DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER fEk .
& >/
- 5,V DUQUESNFLIGHMO@ANY REG. AFFAIRS' MANAGER 8DC
'0UQUESNE LIGHi COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER I
HUMAN EhGINEERING DISCREPAN;y (HED) REPORT s> BVPS/z PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: D. J. Vocn/N SNY c) HED NO.: 2 m- som d) REVIEWED BY:' ,, gr , e) DATE: / /22 /S'5' (Westigghouse) [
\
D \ 't M" (Essex) N f) HED TITLE: h11s ssNG St A ce vgoL A rn R NITRoGEM FILL ANO HEADER VENT VALVE S WITc H E S
- e g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
Si Accupv4A70R NITRO GEN FILL VALVE S WITCHE S ?. GNS M SoV 8 5 3 0 , E,f;, NITROGEN MEADER VENT VALVE S' WITCHES 2 GNS >% SoV 8 g4 AlB h) PR09.LEM OESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: THREE S I A ccOAULA70R MITMcGEN FILL VALVE SWITcME S AND Two NITROGEN HEADER VENT VAL VE SWITCHES Do ks T . EXlST oN THE AfAIM CONTfot B okR D 3,7. 2,1 i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NW4BER: VERIFlch7IoM OF AVAILABILITY , p 40 5, C. 2.1, l
- j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
devices D o N# 7 EXIS T Ch THE AtAW C !N T Rof_ 9eApp To PRwthe THE NE cESSA Ry csNTRol To IbtPLEMENT THE poLLowlN G ol'E RAToM ThSWS l E S - I . 2, a 5' l E S- 3. 3, 2 ; F R c. I, I 2 j FR- c.I, 2 0 ,' F R - P,1, ) 5 ,
k) REV8EW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: fB0Vl0E S t Ac c mu t.A 7en istTR0 GEN' FIL L VAL VE AND pj7BdGEN HEADER VENT V'fL VE S wi rcMEJ w THE SAM Cox TBf L BohAD 5 '" shc bYAd CR 5 Q NN W gw cw g d h5% w % azb % Ad. Vg - f
- Y xm ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJE MANAGER' 8* '
f fA M p/ , OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTINpSEPROGRAMC0pINATOR .
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
Ct DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER WFWb d -l e M ~ DUQUESNEgIGHT @Atti REG. AFFAIRS 54ANAGER WWWm: _)
~0UQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCRE?ANCY (HED) REPORT a) B VP S /2-PLANT / UNIT
]
i b) ORIGINATOR: _ D. J. VocuiNsxy c) sEo NO,: 2 4 ** - 3ms d) REVIEWED BY:' , L. 3 //t e) DATE: I /2 3/7 S-(Westin/ghouse) f i T- w \ (Essex)' %) tu" AA I S S ING HYDA0 GEN RECoM 8INEA S S TA TU S f) HED TITLE:
, $N DI c ATION AND CnN TRo L S
\ ,;
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: HYOR0 GEN REccM BINER S h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: . HYOR0 GEN RtcoastNERS S T/t TU S INDICA 7/ok A ND CONTROLS Do NOT exist ON- THE MAIN CoNTR0L BOAR D
- 3. 7. 2. I i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
VER IFIC A TieN OF AVAILABILITY , 8 $0 fj S A
- l' j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
INDIC A 7/0 N AND coNTMol DEVICES D o NO T EXIS T ON THE AtAIN control 80AA D To pro VID E THC INfoRMA T/oM AND control AtEcCSSARY To IMPLEMEN T THE Follobb'ING OPERA 7dA 7 ASKS l E S -l. 3,1 ; FR- C.I, 8 ) E-0,20] E-1, ICj r R- 2,1, (,9,
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: PRoV IC E H YOR6 GEN REcopBINER lN 0(c A Tion ANO CrNTAoLS oN MAIN CoNTAol BoARO THE bVa. VN q\ . \
- \ 5\ W W NN q p grg
/v 2senwesjs Am%d .
- f./. Acno~
\
T d \m ESSEX HUMA@ FACTORS PROJEC5 MAtTAGER wN l
/
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
/
INATOR WESTING %E P'ROGRAM _
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
A c42& - e 9 A DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER fY-__ i d- Z/- PV DUQUESNfLIGHTR01@A'NYREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER fd&,; wJ DUQUESNE LIG4T COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
n #AN EhGINEEA;hG DISCRE:ANCY ( -E]) REPcAT C u
,, 8 vPS/2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: O' de Y#C NIMS N Y c) HED NO.: 28AN-3047 A ' e)~ DATE: I b 7/8 I d) REVIEWED BY:
(Westdtghouse) [ N ~
% % \\W (Essex) %
- f) HED TITLE: AAI S SIN G SI S EdulPA4 ENT S 7A TUS IN0icA 7tr/V AND CoNTRots g) ITEMS INVOLVED: 2 SW S % S TRN 4 *f 4 7 SERVICE WATER 5 TBAINEJPS ALTERNATE b)!NI Flow IsoMT/sN VALVE S 2CHS $h10 V 380? I L 7, 2 J-h) PROSLEM CESCRIPTION ANO 0700 PARAGRA?H NUMSER: STRhlNER AN D VA LVE C oNTRoL S AND S 7ATUS INDIC4 7//N Do NOT EXI S T . 0 N THE A1 AIM CdNTROL SCARP
- 3. 7. 2, I .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTIO NUMSER: -
VERIFICATIsN of AvkILh81LITY, $ 40 5, fr 2 r la l j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROSLEM: 1)EVIC E S 00 No 7 E1i S T dN THE hlAIN CsA'7P/L Gd4RD l INFoANATion AND CdkTRdL NECESSARY To PRovlDE THE 70 lA1 N EM EN 7 THE FdLLswlv G O P E R A 7sA? 7'ks K , l E-O,2I (A T7hcHA4 EhT)
k) REVIEW AND RECOMENDATIONS: Fs A TH E S TR A! VERS pgovl0E Swl Tc HE .s AND S7A 70 3 UGHTS (SoLkTirN Vht l/E3 oM SEC TI s A' BA of 7p 5 A kiy AND C /N TRf L :,%= boa R D. 5 *th EWk hb\wbMkce Q A d y WM" '}' h< R $ ON osOngn gq o,s h\h6 % d g
%\\NNN W T.E ht$w b gyg9493kh *"
M\\ % 6 shdO a = =,V a.5 ug%ds) .
, % aA a w=&A.
\
N % ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS P ECT MANAGER
//n 2 DUCUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEACER
/ .
WESTINGHQ68% PRDGRAM C00RDfNATOR
^
7 1), REVIEW AND DISP 05: TION:
'F
\
f aAs-- DUQUE$NE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER f / d- Z)" W DUQUESNEJGHTC6MEAhYREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER f* & OUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HU.AN ENG' NEERING DISCRE.:AN Y (HE?) Ri30R7 s
,> B VPs /z q PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: D. J. Vocnis s><Y c) HEo NO.: 2Bc # -30o7
- d) REVIEWE0 BY: - r e) DATE: 2. // M F 5' (Westifghouse) [
N ' U " ' (Essex') 2. . f) HED TITLE: A41SSING FW Pam P DiscuAnGE t/All/E B YPA SS VM VE S swlTcMES kHD STATU S LIGWT3 I l g) ITEMS INVOLVED: s VALVES A FW S- 19 9, 3dd, 3 I 9 h) PROBLEM CESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: VhlVG SWITCHfS AND VALVE S7A7t/S LIGHTS 372.l - i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHTt~'COMPANY INSTRUCTION ' NUMBER: . VERIFIC ATioN of A VAIL A BILIT Y , R $ 0 5,~ C r .L I- l j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROELEM: DEVI C ES Do No T EXIS T ON THE AthtN c aNTRoi. BokRD 74 f$eviDE THE /NFoRMR71*H AND CsNTRaL ArEc6SSAR Y To. IM flGAt ENT THE foLL* wwG l 0 PfRA 7en TA S K .' FR-H.I,Gy
. l
k) REVZEd AND RECOMMENDATIONS: VALVE S ARE LOCAL, AlANykL VALVES. PRocEpuAf SHooLP BE REVISED AND TRAIN tN G SHovLO [ p fflA SI Z E VALVE LocATidM D. \M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PR fMANAGER L/ m OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
~
, / --
WESTINpuSEFROGRAMCOOCINATOR l
- 1) REVIEW ANO DISPOSITION: .
YALVES JAf AMf USdD A1./ M.E/2& fo dfDud' 6)
/6 M -
1
'?l?4/35' -
In/ves # p ca/br' e d ,w , fd- W. / / ~Cb $ j 1 s co e ,w e><y*cy OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINLERIsG MANAGER ff
~
t' ' ^ ' ' * * ) ' - , f /[}} l 46.^ /-c c lico 00QUESNE gT COMMNYdl$6. AFFAIRS MANAGER w .!J k .dv c LI, OUQUESNE LIGHT' COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l l
n,MAh ENdlN5Eh!NG CISCRiFANCf C-ED) AE?C E '.
.3 a> B VP S/2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR D. J, VocHINS KY c) HED NO.: 29A #b d) P.EVIEWED BY: A- M, hbI V e) DATE: / !3# SI (Westthghouse)
\\
~
Jh M (Essex) % , f) HED TITLE: MISSING Coal TAlWMEMT ISotAT/oM PHASE A VALVES SWITCHES { LIGHTS g) ITEMS INVOLVED: E-0, A 77AcHAEkT 4 VA L VES NoT C HECKED oN A TTACHED ~ CHEcKLIS T [y I, g +, C,7,9') h) PRCELEM CESCRIPTICN A?C O'00 PARAGRAPH NUMSER: VAL V E S wl T C HE S AN D S TATt/.5 LI GM TS Do Nc T ExlS T oN THE M klN con TRo L BOARD 3 7.2.I
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCR.PTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION '
NUMBER: VERIFicA71oM of AVAILkfluTY , $ H5, C,2, I, / j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: DEVICES D o MrT EXI S T GN THE Mh!N con 7RdL BOARD
'To Pfov!DE THE INFdRA1ATIo/ AND CdNTf/L NECESSA R Y Fo A 71+E IM PLIhtEN Th7/on' OF THE FoLLsw/A'G TASX '
E-6, STEP 2I (A77AcM cwr 4),
k) REVIEW AND RECOMME'4DATIONS: pgavios swncHes A ND VAL VE S7hTOS LI G H TS op 7p g A4,+1Af Cpg 7BIL 80kRD FoA VAlt/E S NOT C H EC h'ED ON E- 0 , A 77Ac M EN T +. A 00 To SECTioN BA.
's '
be bh uk hwh ~I.cUs(%V 5*lN \ 63h
- kipW S'Eb us %g & '
sh.h k l a S G d u b M % os s W \5 % b h . h s4 an m t\ Q , p s ub sa. 4 c b h k Us h b Y u < u M c h s cA c a[ w 2.\\ u m - n bSD a % 6 s t w s %% , [ w b g -. - = ~ c~ ~ y -
Oend b* as J Se s b'as C s A* Il I e*J " Gaillh y sentee CestuI Pon e h ' a h pse s 7 f1 of ACCadhes1 4. ok.
D IN M ESSEX HUMA'N FACTORS PRu CT MANAl'IER g ' f 7~F M sc; DUCUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVJEW TEAM LEACER
) ' t' d_ .
WESTtA USE' PROG' RAM ROINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND OISPOS! TION:
P
\ LS DUQUEShE'gLIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
[ b - 2 / 'f C DUQUE$N IGHT @.tPM4Y REG. AFFAIRS VANAGER ff < ./ OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
l BVPS - E0P 2.53.A I 2 gh $-3o09 i NUMBER TITLE E-0 - Reactor Trip or Safety Injection
! A~ TACH"ENT 4 }
CONTAINMENT ISOLATION PHASE A CHECKLIST MARK NO. DESCRIPTION REQUIRED POWER SUPPLY INITIALS ,( Benchboard Section A
, 2RCS*A0VS19 Primary Grade Water To Closed [PNL*DC2-10] ~ ; (SOV 519) $ Pressurizing Relief Tank Bkr 8-12 *ie 2RCS*A0V101 N Supply Manifold To Closed [PNL*DC2-10] ! (SOY 101) P4essurizer Relief Tank Bkr 8-13 4
2GNS*A0V101-1 Na Supply Manifold To Closed [PNL*DC2-11] (SOV 101-1) BA1 S.fety Injection Accumulator Erk 8-4 l 2GNS*A0V101-2 Na Supply Manifold To Closed [AUL*DC2-02] : (SOV101-2) @ i S.fety Injection Accumulator Bkr 4-11
; 2DGS*A0V108A Primary Drains Transfer Closed [PNL*DC2-08] I I
. (SOV108A3) BA1 Pump No. 1 Discharge Bkr 8-4 j
2DGS*A0V108B Primary Drains Transfer Closed [PNL*DC2-10] Bkr 8-17
~
(SOV 108B) BA1 Pump No. 1 Discharge 2DAS*A0V100A Reactor Containment Sump Closed [PNL*DC2-07] (SOV 100A) BA1 Pump Discharge Bkr 8-20 2DAS*A0V100B Reactor Containment Sump Closed [PNL*DC2-10] (SOV-1008) BAl Pump Discharge Bkr 8-4 h 2CVS* V153A Air Activity Monitor Closed [FNL*DC2-11] l .-. ( Inlet Bkr Ckt. CVSAB 11 AG A / D-2CVS* OV153B Air Activity Monitor Closed [FNL*DC2-10] Inlet Bkr Ckt. CVSBB 11 AG 3CVS*SOV151A Containment Vacuus Pumps Closed [FNL*DC2-11] : Suction Bkr Ckt. CVSAC ' 2.C@ 40V 15\ A 11 AG 3Al PAGE 1 of 8 REVISION O
BVPS - E0P 2.53.A g g A h- 3009 1, NUMBER TITLE . E-0 - Reactor Trip or Safety Injection I ATTACW!EN-" 4 ! DESCRIPTION REOUIRED POWER SUPPLY INITIALS MARK NO. Benchboard Section A (Continued) Letdown Isolation Closed [FNL*DC2-06), 2CHS*A0V204 f y\ Bkr 6-25 & [PNL*DC2-10], t , Bkr 8-18 - l}!CC 2-E05), i 3CHS*2!OV378 RCP Seal Water Ea urn Closed Bkr 4C i M$ 2CHS*:iOV381 Closad [:!CC*2-EM j ,
% , RCP Seal Water Re urn Bhr 4C
{ i
- V ,
Secondary CCW Heat Closed i::CC*2-E02 ) ,
, , 2SWS*:10V107A Exchanger Skr 6A ;
i BA\ V
'l Secondary CCW Heat Clesed [:!CC*2-E04 } ,
Q . 25WS*>!OV107B Bhr 6C
, 13 4 Exchanger /
t [MCC*2-E03), e : 2SWS*!!OV107C Secondary CCV Heat Closed Skr 6C i y) Exchanger V 2SWS*MOV107D Secondary CCV Heat Closed [MCC*2-E04), BAA. Exchanger Bkr 7A
/
2SSR*AOV109Al Safety Injection Accumulator Closed [FNL*DC2-03), 8 "Ple Inside Containment Isol. Skr 4-11 BM 2SSR*SOV130A1 FRT Gas Sample Inside Closed [PNL*DC2-03), Skr 8-20 ( Containment Isol. V 2SSR*A0V100A1 Pressuriser Liquid Space sample Closed [FNL*DC2-03},
. g Inisde Containment Isol. Skr 8-11 V
2SSR-A0V112A1 Pressurise'r Vapor Space Sample Closed [FNL*DC2-03], Ekr 8-11
.( 3A.{InsideContainmentIsol.
( PAGE 3 of 8 REVISION O
l l BVPS - EOP 2.53.A
~
i 2 BA M- 3co9 l l NUMBER TITLE , I' E-0 - Reactor Trip or Safety Injection 4 ATTACH.!ENT 4 } (' REQUIRED POE R SUPPLY INITIALS MARK NO. DESCRIPTION Benchboard Section A (Continued) RCS Cold Les Sample Outside Closed (PNL*AC2-E8], 2SSR-A0V102A1 ( SAi Containment Isol. . Skr 8-11 RCS Hot Leg Sample Inside Closed [ FNL*DC2-03 ] , 2SSR*SOV128A1 Containment.Isol. Skr 8-20 2SSR*SOV129Al R Sample Inside Closed [PNL*DC2-03), Containment Isol. Bkr 3-22 2SSR*A0V109A2 Safety Injection Accumulator Closed (PNL*DC2-10], g Sample Outside Containment Isol. Bkr 8-11 - 2SSR*SOV130A2 PRT Gas Sample Outside. Closed '[FNL*DC2-10), Containment Isol. Bkr 8-27 l I 2SSR*A0V100A2 Pressurizar Liquid Space Sample Closed [PSL*DC2-10), BM Outside Containment Isol. Bkr 8-1 .l [FNL*DC2-10],
/
2SSR*A0V112A2 Pressurizer Vapor Space Sample Closed M 's Outside Contaiument Isol. Skr 8-1 2SSR*A0V102A2 RCS Cold Leg Sample, Closed [PNL*AC2-E8), Outside Containment Isolation 5kr 8-1 RCS Hot Les Sample Closed [FNL*DC2-10], 3SSR*SOV128A2 ; Outside Containment Isol. Skr 8-2 2SSR*A0V129A2 RH Sample Outside Closed (later) ( Containment Isol. 2 PAS *SOV10SA1 (later) (later) (later) 2 PAS *SOV10SA2 (later) (later) (later) Air Activity Monitor Outlet Closed (PNL*DC2-10], ./ 2CVS*SOV102 Skr Ckt CUSBB 11 AG I PAGE 4 of 8 REVISION O
I 28A%-3009 NUMBER TITLE E-0 Reactor Trip or Safety Injection l
! ATTACH.'!ENT I. l MARK NO. DESCRIMION REQUIRED POWER SUPPLY INITIALS Benchboard - Section C . 2IAC*MOV130 CNMT Instrument Air Closed (later) l CNMT Isolation Valve 2IAC*MOV133 CN?ff Instrument Air Closed (later)
CNMT Isolation Valve 2IAC*MOV134 CNNT Instrument Air Closed (later) , .: CNNT Isolation Valve Building Service Control Panels (Trains A and B) d') 2HVS* MOD 202B Leak Collection to Main Closed [PNL*AC2-E2], Filter , , Bkr 2-11 2HVS* MOD 218A Leak Collection Filter Isol. Closed [PNL*AC2-E1], Damper Bkr 1-12' f 2HVS* MOD 2188 Leak Collection Filter Isol. Closed [PNL*AC-E2], Damper Bkr 2-13 Charcoal Filter Deluge Closed [FNL*AC2-E1], v 2FPW*AOV204 Bkr 1-23 2FPW*A0V221 Charcoal Filter Deluge Closed [FNL-AC2-E1], Bkr 1-24 2FPW*A0V20S Containment Deluge Valve Closed [FNL-DC2-07],
- Bkr 8-12 4 2FPW*A0V206 Containment Mose Racks Closed [PNL*DC2-07),
Bkr 8-13 ( PAGE 6 of 8 REVISION O m_.____ __ _. - ., _ _ _ _ _ - , , - _ _ . - , . , _ _ . _ _ _ . - _ . _ , _ , . _ _ . ,_. . , , . _
i I N 2pk k-3009 NUMBER TITLE I E-0 Reactor Trip or Safety Injection ! 1
. ATTACHMENT 4
[ DESCRIPTION REOUIRED POVER SUPPLY INITIALS MARK No.
.%..!Yh__ _ _3,}?,,'%_. ?, ?_ ..T. ?
.b.... O '*h^ ^* 0
- a Aux. Bldg. Exhaust to Main Closed [PNL*AC2-E1],
2HVP* MOD 22A Filter Bank Dampers Skr 1-9 { Aux. Blds. Exhaust to Main Closed (PNL*AC2-E2], 2HVPMOD22B Filter Bank Dampers Skr 2-9 Leak Collection Filter Isol. Closed [PNL*AC2-E1],
'2HVS* MOD 203A Bkr 1-12 2HVS* MOD 203B Leak Collection Filter Isol. Closed [ PNL*AC2-E2 ] ,
Bkr 2-12 1 v
-l t2NVS* MOD 201A Leak Colleciton Filter.. Closed [FNL*AC2-E1],
Bypass Skr 1-11 Leak Collection Filter Closed [FNL-AC2-E2], k 2HVS* MOD 201B Bkr 2-11 Bypass .
,/
Leak Collection to Main Closed [FNL*AC2-E1], V
- 2HVS* MOD 202A Filter Bkr 1-11 l
Supplementary Leak Open [FNL*AC2-E1], l 2HVS* MOD 210A Collection Damper Bkr 13 , Open [FNL*AC2-E2], V 2HVS* MOD 210B Supplementary Leak Collection Damper Bkr 13 Open [PNL*AC2-E1], V 2HVS* MOD 211A Supplementary Leak Collection Damper Bkr 13
- (
Supplementary Leak Open (PNL*AC2-E2], 2HVS* MOD 2113 Collection Damper Bkr 13 1 k l PAGE 7 of 8 REVISION O
2ph$r~3009 TITLE [ NUMBER E-O Reactor Trip or Safety Injection l } - l ATTACH.!ENT 4 ' { MARK N0_. DESCRIPTION REQUIRED POWER SUPPLY INITIALS i 4 7_,.2 [, d"db3D_M..^.d.
- Supplementary Leak Open [FNL*AC2-E1),
2HVS* MOD 212A Bkr 14 ( Collection Damper V Supp1ementary Leak Open (PNL*AC2-E2], 2HVS* MOD 212B Collection Damper Bkr 14 Open (PNL*AC2-E1], l 2HYS*.'!OD213A Supplementary Leak Collection Damper Bkr 14 l j Supplementary Leak Open (PNL*AC2-E2], 2HVS* MOD 213B Collection Damper Bkr 14 j v f 2HVS*CH219A Supplementary Leak . On [480V 2-8] Collection Heater Cu IOC [480V 2-9], I Supplementary Leak On 2HVS*CH219B Collection Heater Cu 10C
.END-PAGE 8 of 8 REVISION O
nsMAN ENG;NEERINo CISCREPANCY (-EC) REPCRT [ a) BVPS/2 I PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR D, J. \/dC N /N S KY c) HED NO.: 2 M8 4-3dla 1 d) REVIEWED BY: L N / e) OATE: I /71/PI' (Westinghouse) / K
~
(Essex) f) 'HE0 TITLE: A11 SSIN G C eM7AINMENT lhlS TRUA CNT h/R VklVES SWITCHES AND- S 7A 70.5 L/GHTS g) ITEMS INVOLVED: VAtvES '2 t A C $Mc VI 3 5,13f, CdN TAINA ENT INSTRobeENT AIR
)30 h) PRCELEM CESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRA?H NUNSER:
Do NG T EYI S T ON VALVE SwticHES A NO S 7A Tus LIGHTS THE MAIN CoM TRel. BOAR D. 37.2,I i) DATA COLLEC. TION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUC NUMBER: y eRIFick7/oM or MML 48tLITV , R4"G 6,1,1<l f) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR ECUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: DEVICES Do Na7 EYtsT ON THE AthW con 7kol. 90ARD To PRoyIDE THE cow Trol AND I WFon N k T!!N NGCE SSAR y 70 lh1 ?L EM ENT TH E PoLLo w/p G O PEfk To R T*A S W S .' E - 0, 3 9 ,' E S ~I's I Tj E-]!Ij FR-H,1,ig,
k) REVIE# AND RECOMMENDATIONS: fro y ID E Swo7c H E S AND $ 7i% TirS LIGH T S Pc R TH E cex7.ss w- c t&l8 VkLl'E S 0M TH & A kiy CON Tf 0L 80.490 IN5 7BVA CNT D u WA MA twa\ -t < (G. N \ $ w 4k (. gw t .ak
% auk b M'd 'n Ad w b M mh b h Mach,kw\ph o /Wo AC770M 1
. s ,
-N\
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PRO T MANAGER
/
DUCUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEACER
- t' WESTIN USE PROGRAM COORDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING .vANAGER [ v b 2/-P I UQUESNj/ LIGHT 4fC#ANY REG. AFFAIRS NkNAGER [YW
~ 0UQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEER 8NG 08SCREPANCY (HED) REPORT 9
~
a) PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ b EcA O dNC C c) HED NO.: O PRi- 3d// d) REVIEWED BY: h. , ' 4 e) DATE: \ !d9!D (Westing %se) f T= M (Essex) T f) HED TITLE: Conkok 5 c3 ca ncb c c t w n ecd ', n a s order
~~
a las ea\ O e4 g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Proc,5gi tec- Mers (ca bak5 3RCP - M S A , c e> ,3C , a D , S E h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: 6 $ J J cA . C o n,ponenks are nob a crancgci (o O bv cighb
$P c3 A c3k @ B h e b t C36'C(w% 7c4 hsenk accanymen4 ss C A DB E.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLNBER:
ef@po o E Test recGcn,ance Cap *.t.N s., 5 J hiU Lj ( R.40 5) L.A.\.1
% dica a.t, ion (R406) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
g gcf 0 18 s/ r s pci'd i O Ccr i F C
]
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: 13 S~t>< 1s! ,k ;I t,.- x i <~* :3 C: 2s R' g a ', 3 p [w \ . , t, - u, ( s
*'p- v) -
3 3
~
.; - e -r , C -
,c g, a. , .,_, --
~
), __
L ;. , (c ' a o r- c- \$ , r , ,. A ,- se g ,s.;e , F '
> J+=$ .
# 9 %-
m' "~'"** c , , ,. ,, , ,, + ~ c ~ rc e - sf0 ac o~ opg en rat , *
/s am y sprev /c #4 r ( '
'^' " O " M S ^ Y, ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJEC
\Q ANAGER y g- yea o r~ ACATres o^' ,
y ,a yr/n G~ r. s r e r M C " l' &% /NVO
/ OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAR-l.EADER GD,/!M 6 is 4 o G r t' 4 t- .
1 Yq A,e so c.17oe'
- WESTIffdOUSCPROGRAM$60RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
s -
.c {&.se S
bk DUQU$SNE LI3HT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
$8Y DUQUESNE p HT C # ANf REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER (b- 2d -8f
@ $@w
' DUQUESNE LIdHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
1 HUMAN ENGINEERZNG DZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT 1 a) BVPS/2 g PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: D. J. VoCHinsxY c) HED NO,: 2 4 # *-3012 d) REVIEWED BY: * >
- rf7A e) DATE: I //2 /PS~
(Westinghouse) g - s N ~ \lN (Essex) M~ f) HED TITLE: Adls S ING S00 ACE RAIVGF DE TEC 70R voL 7A GE CONTROL g) ITEMS INVOLVED: SovRCE RANGE NEO7 ROM DE7EC7oR HIGH VOLTAGE SWITCH h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: A SovRCE RMGE DE TEC ToA VoL7 AGE ENERG12E/DEENERG128 ON THE MAIN Cm7tol BOARD
$ WITC H DOES - No T EXIS T 3.22.1 i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
VERIFICA7/os of AVAIL ABILITY , )? 4 05) C2,1, ! j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: 0gyiC E doe S No7 EXI5 r oN 7HE AtAIN CrN7A/L BoAAD To P R* V ID E THE CoNTRfL NECESSARY Tr IM PLEMENT THE FoLL0wlN G OPEA h7tR TkSMSa' E S -l. I,2 S',' E S-1 2,2 9 j e - s, rr.
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
- Plio vt 0 E Source 19ANGE DE TEC To R V0L TA CE S lut TCH (ES)
ON THE A1MN CeN7Aos BoAPD.
- AM I 'M ~
y J & A A - m 4%A &p>.
. ns~ In . .
$ N \M ESSEX HUMAN' FACTORS PROJ$ ANAGER 3 E ,= c A ,, _ / a c 2 s DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPAffY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h'
WESTINgkDUSE PROGRA @ RDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
MR l & WS & ^ kJ h d, -/C
#h 7&
1 l l f A ' DUQUESNE GHT ' COMPANY ENGINfERI MANAGER
, /
]$~ff DUQUESNE PANY REf6. AF' FAIRS MANAGER ren-
' DUQUESNE LIGAT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
l
HUMAN ENG:NEERING DI5ChrANCY (HED) REPORT _
~
a) PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR:
. Fra vher- c) SED NO, A M ) O i3 d) REVIEWED BY: M N. A e) DATE: 3>kh5 d (West 146 house) #
N "Pw g'idgk N (Essex) f) HED TITLE: VMVES n TVs hdif. 8 'i C,
%spw" YG; --
vXt g PDGt Ybr\
- i g) ITEMS INVOLVED: 62 RCS - \-LCN 5 % 53% 535 3 f@V block ulVd5 i m 3,..,,g e.w, w % , mau a sea 4awa %ew6tt 7.q i
=y *c-h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: h ,L{.{ ,{ q. Con roIS dCE Oob ade yAQhe. Endion b&perbud. Twe.2 spnn
-+t> -dese vdves have b be he.le\ epen 4e pedrm he +g rquired. ackicn.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER: l I d Dp C bO Fro m OC.hm (Q4gf) l j) SPECIFIC HlMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PFOBLEM:
Cysws res g e n s e vs . R 6 A \ p a.. 1 1 l
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: h \S ICCOMme_nd ed kk an
& merr-ike ; V
-3 F+ ~ P h.==t'i -
,- D N,, cura tvsnd(/open yAon k 'in s lall< d .
g<c M d.%: ks cha % d4- w p h d a y. g d e m 6 - A - % c k .s w h m %% dbu % sm-suyses%,u %4 qdhsw%' sw M '6+ Achs 14 e'i\\ su pah e-m m-su wi,A A d p W A e m d w2. I k <\p % v h h % es k % d , M % k c,,y shk op.6(4 mw\Q b y%\usm%A\hbog,% %d -Er? ,
'\- M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS V JECT l ANAGER f -
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- b. .
WESTINGH06sE PROGRAM @ DINATOR ,
- 1) REYIEW AND DISPOSITION:
-& & ~Z$
MM-W
~
kn$ 6 l DUQUESNE LIGHT CDNPANY ENGI ING MANAGER 1
- , /_
DUQUESNE Li T COMP M REG (.4FfAIRS MANAGER
/. 8 Ws r> : =>
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
/
25-6-10 t
- 25. Pressurizer relief isolation valve 2RCS*MOV535 will open automatically provided there is no motor thermal overload and either os the following conditions exists
- a. Control switch 2RCS*MOV535 in "AUT0" and selector switch for cold overpressure protection Train B in " ARM"
- b. Control switch 2RCS*MOV535 in " AUTO" and pressurizer pressure in 2/3 loops not low
- 26. Pressurizer relief isolation valve 2RCS*MOV535 willofclose overload and any the provided there is no motor thermal following conditions exists
- a. Control switd. 2RCS*MOV535 in "CLOSE" Control switch 2RCS*MOV535 in "AUT0" and p cu,urizer ,
b. pressure in 2/3 loops low selector switch for cold overpressure protection Train B in " BLOCK"
- 27. Pressurizer relief isolation valve 2RCS*MOV537 will open manually provided all of the following conditions exists
- a. Control switch 2RCS*MOV537 in "0 PEN" .
- b. 2RCS*MOV537 no motor thermal overload
- 28. Pressurizer relief isolation valve 2RCS*MOV537 will open automatically provided there is no motor thermal overload and all of the following conditions exists
- a. Control switch 2RCS*MOV537 in "AUT0"
- b. Pressurizer pressure in 2/3 loops not low
- 29. Pressurizer relief isolation valve 2RCS*MOV537 will close provided there is no motor thermal overload and any of the following conditions exist: ;
(
- a. Control switch 2RCS*MOV537 in "CLOSE" l and pressurizer )
- b. Control switch 2RCS*MOV537 in "AUT0" )
pressure in 2/3 loops low Refer to LSK-25-6K h manual mode of operation is available from the alternate valve. shutdown panel for 2RCS*PCV456 pressurizer power relief A pushbutton on the alternate shutdown panel will transfer room. control to the alternate shutdown panel from the control A manual reset at relay will transfer control from the alternate shutdown panel back to the control room. O V
l 25-6-9 i d provided any of pressuriser heaters group D will be deenerg ze p, the following condtions exist: a. Control switch for group D heaters in "0FF"
" b.
Control switch for group D heaters in "signal AUTO" and and no no pressurizer low pressure deviation p pressurizer high level deviation signal
- c. Pressurizer low level signal
- d. Bus undervoltage
- e. Electrical protection trip
- f. Safety injection signal (train A)
Refer to LSK-25-6G
- 21. Pressurizer heaters group C will be energized provided all of th: following conditions exists
- a. Control switch for group C heaters in "0N"
- b. No bus undervoltage .
M c. No electrical protection trip
- d. No pressurizer low level
- 22. Group C pressurizer heaters are contrclled by proportional control to maintain operating pressure.
- 23. Pressurizer heaters group C will be deenergized provided any of the following conditions exists
- a. Control switch for group C heaters in "0FF"
- b. Pressurizer low level signal
- c. Bus,undervoltage
- d. Electrical protection trip Refer to LSK-25-6J
- 24. Pressurizer relief isolation valve 2RCS*MOV535 will open manually provided all of the following conditions exists
- a. Control switch 2RCS*MOV535 in "0 PEN"
- b. 2RCS*MOV535 no motor thermal overload t . - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ - - _
1 HUMAN ENGINEERING 08SCREPANCV (HED) REPORT a) b ~ PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ H P r a n e_ h e <- c) HED NO.: 4M' 30 I b d) REVIEWED BY: < 4- e) DATE: 3/a5/h5 (Westi,t@ house) T (Essex) d \\ M M" ' f) HED TITLE: Labed dCe \nok egress inkndeck ach on ) l g) ITEMS INVOLVED: "%{ Vakg-Injgd,en (( ((g7 , ! @ C HS Ic v t ero h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: [o,63,2 G. The coords employeck in We_ labe( dqo lr opress exdy wha ason is intend ed.. The labet reacts" Seat L)akr :nred:ce f; \ Wc " when ac.L.aIty ;4 is an " RcP Sea \ (nkc.6n Cl* > GnkJec
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
DI S TEO8 h O - . E COs N j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: htaq dela.y epecah responsG_ cr opera 6c m a.sf ce p n d ; ne_, c e, c L
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS 2 (~hgp d_ kdb(k k Ceg)y ; RT seal \ ci ec.W o n Ci cw Centrci.t e < C4 Comm 83 fGc cR%ve i k N~\ N M ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS PROJECT MANAGER
\
. lU?A24A .
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
- h. Y, ROINATOR WESTIN%USEPROGRAM ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
~
z a7~ - g . v, n...o .
'
- r ;., , r. C, . '. < t A. m;*
- f. 0 9/ = ,*,. $ 1 f. ' . A
~ ,
. + y' g ,,, ,g
'4- #Id OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEiERING MANAGER pa.' 6
[' ' ' OUQUESNE)(IGHTCW.PARYREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER .f ,,.. .I*I. 4'[p> r / Wd H !
' 0UQUESNE LIGkT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
- ^
. t -
- t. ..
,s.w t.w;N:.:AING 0;5ar.- A ..! :. . ) h-04;
.) B VP5 - 2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: H . Fnsechee c) wEo NO. asAx-3oi7 d) REVIEWED BY: [. b M, e) DATE: 3/.28 /85 (Westgnghouse) ~ [
T- ~\ \ rM" (Essex) ~]' ' f) HED TITLE: Conboks b b USc kMer v are Oc4 00 4.0 h S. g) ITEMS INVOLVED: charging line isolation valves {2 CMS *MOV289 and 310j h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (:. 6. l . I a. . Th.a. Osted conleols aee 4n be ena n'.p d .l cl in 4-b e s== step . o c.ws*Hovte9 1s M A .n B A 1. and . ace s=Mo nio is a4 EA % Opw=ler movera nl i s not s n.nsi e,d. +o yrnde4toenf oPed, 'an -
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
k IO G C bh \ C-iC)fl$ W40'e) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: M ays en b oper-sh nMmenh oc seacek 6. l
k) REVIED AND RECOWENDATIONS N thqs showkb \%C b o w'\ 54 % ,M k CunktA 4oc % Cih5 4-MOV \M b h hS- \^5d m o d 4 b sE aw w p t p t b b w w a vs p ch A ,' 4 s c gss4 g a v g o j A% c Ads hc -
% ed h% , . .r % g elturd \ecddw w v ws* mon Au ts 9 4 u it, h s'tdsky( Of k!.t,sw Na '. iW e s ~h. ,.
Ii b E bb<- ( h.k 1. \Es h.$$, b ,i M ). h .w i 4 (: T 4~,ad .AT Mss . Aw > 'd '.%
.agi ,M k g c g', ,s j . T,y ,N g s v, s o g_ .-
'- rM ESSEX HLMAN FACTORS PROMCT MANMR l 4
r/mv 1 DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER A /,dx WESTIpSE'N pINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
gpCf $ 3/0 &H'. p/w ." wA & T q ; Mi
~
W9 .J
- - ~ +,
- A s #
A ,u~ h
. g.M N w -
$2 M 3 DUQUESNE LIGHT 1.X)MPANY ENGINEfRING' MANAGER
/ V'/NlT DUQUESNE LIGf COM!ANY WEG. A'FFAIRS 8 NM DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEER 8NG DISCREPANCY (FEO) RE?CRT s) BVPs-2 PLANT / UNIT b) CRIGINATOR, t4. Franh c) se0 No,, geca -30 #9 d) REVIEWED BY: '!/_ e
.) DATE: b/b/h5
..ssfSnoos.)
N a T Ess.x) f) HED TITLE: Thro kle. pesi ion rni ss'i n cz (mm 9 A.t:W. Aw con 6\ vaWes g) ITEMS INVOLVEDs G FW E M &lcv 100 A,B ,C 3D , E , F Ax,F. W. 4w con 6\ yaWes h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION ANO 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G.4 ( .l 0,.
%d ex16 ing confr=1 does nok prov'eche 4 SofC c.ie.n h rar)y 6 con bt. c. . . .,, H y .nhj " op.n " ana"ct
. a c.
8dallad* . There. ' is no 4hr..Q.t. g,(r.n pig,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER:
Ygri( h hton o h Tas k EaK b m Anca b % ib'bd5
~~
. n'.4*kiii% C R405) j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
(urre,n b oprakcC i5 UO6M4 c f rk hii me. b%ie Gchon
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS ~[ Q %.[ E 8 CCGtro kcE.r w g 4. a %ccAM; n capabl k;.
\/ des 4avc alemJy L,een ck g[ f,c+ OT 2 fa b H C A/ 's .
No A c/rw9 e uM 1 ESSEX M FACTORS JECT MANAdER exTe - - DUQUESNS LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
& L 2O3 WEStIpuSE' PROGRAM C09NDINATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER ff~$ 7-/ F H ~ 0000ESNEfGHTC0dANiREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER WSb
'0UQUESNE LIGHT C'OMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.) Sv PS -;;L PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: -
obc' c) HED NO.: k- D 2I d) REVIEWED BY: N I, (Wesd nghouse) / e) DATE: 5/a/6 T -- - h A (Essex)
]
f) HED TITLE: ENeuenc.v ShuMexen Eanel con s are d I . arranged di erech b a.n Mose in 44M M .C. R , G . g) ITEMS INVOLVED: O r%W E. K H cv (oo A , S , c , D , e , ;- h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: b T. O .el b, The.arr is dKua be6en +he ESP and on %. M cs . $=,4 Tn, c,A m a a r., g a b an ceccaLors yd-a6ns.. := Aaylo-t) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION
*~"'
C: R . Sorvas CNC j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: kr\ prs:cc- O r0 h"\e. cTIO h q , rd accanpen4 , may hee. a delapa ceacken oc-may comme an error whe.n b e d ua;+ h A e. d&ced arrangarned on We Emenyxy$hogg,
I k)
\ REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: The ay ry ( e{ Cob { 5 O f\ N' 01 \N \ 6\Qref as RED aMM -la .
'5 5 % *S M E4 me ay of value s on h E idenk d b %e_
30 gosh ar'ran M (baM4) of GEN (-- co), 4 . .h t' (a w s, gk (ov t 4\ 5 ow bN 84 CoMRC .
\s DEC M N w N O k $ ( 6 cc hrohs )
WW'\MI bs ca. u ( f a r b o ma ch k Ek c o *h c o\S . N g/ g'3 V m s-. x ESSEX h FACTORS ECT MMGER [5$ Wh DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANVREVIEW TEAM LEADER
< /
WESTI p SE 7ROGRAM QIORDINATOR ,
- 1) Ifw e6 SITION:
l V(tah WJ6 DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEl! RING MANAGER AA 8~ 0. 7- ATTJ ~ DUQUESN M IGHT M NY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER f DUQU
$ Ww ESNE LIGHT COMPANY OP
HJU.% E%5: NEERING DISCREPANOV (HED) REPORT a) b b 'k PLANT / UNIT t b) ORIGINATOR:.. M Fr-a.n c_h _c- c) NeD NO.: 2 ABXE24 ' d) REVIEWED BY: -
< rl / e) DATE: G/5/65 (Wes dnghouse)
\
(Essex) %" f) RD TITLE: Co n-M6 ano OCy V3$b54 b - Chion-a\ (.qrWM r,ach 4 95Nrankils maa e,r5*puun fd on 'ASW g) ITEMS INVOLVED: see a%e_ heck usk . s h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: ) Some cen W 5 dN M"ihi'M as mh as 33 inches ' back. bm b Md Ed.gt , his exceeds the. se.h loach. lins h of 25 inches and % centrels ace be. yond W e bc.Lional e4ack cf 5%ercenkle Gnale ab.!hs and 9s* percenkle mie.aa,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMEER:
cR. h y R(Iolb TP- . 2. j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: Opc a.bcs am rio - accorn<vtoc a"wd
' and reaching he Conbks c 4 3 re ui g +
AWG '
~
;w. . .
k) rey}EW AND RECOsNENDATIONS: h Frtrn sOcched lisk, dc_derrninc. W id con \rols a%cl opereMoos by shou.td be.1ocabacL oc piank safe % 40 he eded b t cuw_c- m 'he boad. Ensace con 4ro\s are iocah<j no m ce M a.5 inc.hes from Ee. b Qa- c4 4he. console .
- 2) F5 = & a 249 shool a nd 4. hand c44 s h k au y ea4ers s t) be. aQ4 to reach contrats 6 gat,%w ~ o u.d- 69t2 WE B 4 A 6M '+ -)4 o b ceu a g
< sc.sga4 o ci yo o c\s ca-oicss4 % % m (th h 6 y I.,, ,
hvw\9 o a dw 5 m @ ra a A d\ ' . O c 'n e e "* f.'c E. p su - Ya \%% nacph as D (A +$ . ESSEX HUMAN FAC W
' PROJECT MANAGER w Ac;n09
/
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER b- . WESTIN SE PROGRAM Cp0RDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
( l l E $v,(rr DUQU$SNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEEkING MANAGER .l A / DUQUESNjEIGHT M ANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER [@M DUQUESNE L7. hit COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l l
a ,.
'Y NOC ?,.Y 1, /f N. _
-- == _. .._--.n.
=4 l
- . ... ::a.
v.
.!Si:iiiii
. :+ :+F' .
g
. . y: . . . . -..
,..... - .
- 0y
- VER
..C A L.
- - @ $. b h
-. .v. N.. . : ,
l ,
.'.,, .,a
- *,.-l 8
. . . - v...<
e .
. - , , g':.i. g. . . . - .
O ' !! h
% . .: . . . . J.-8: . .:"{ii!$ :
TRAAMffam l Th. M G 8. -- - - . - e 4, t
".* ". .:.: y.:.:.:.$. $(..
n e
."..=... . . '. .-
so.
- i: ... 4'thaE N c W :2;. :.. . . . : : ". .
s
- . .:.:.:. .. ss::
. . f.' ':* :
g v.v. R.,-
. ' . @LA-veJ.y..
-. v. .. -
e l
, . -. . . ,. . . - . ::g::$ . . . . . . .
. w v. .. .. ... . . . . -
v
. .'. '.. .. .; .i.'ii$ij:
.: .. "... "."Q.!e.E
.: g.. .L..a. seASE s. $. ::zil:
d 1
. .- . , . -v , ' . v. .. * . ..... . .:3 - -
w ON
- W 1
RFE. Ree<w FIGURE 8 of hb - ASP CONSOLE DIMENSIONS
b A-S4 - 3c 2 4 frowcrico AL. RCCL 97 % */cs- TILE- M A L E-i l
\ .
\ '
~~.,___
h - 9 49,4#. gyg t-4 t. i Ca HT t 's ,. 96 % %- TIT
.A,, M ALE
/ SS' O' 43.g". =s H o u L D C R. HT.
9 =51h % - ri'E
's-gg
, MAus ZS*
-% ss.s"- eve H T-i.
s +h % - ri Le FE F4 A L.C l I zcr ,m.4-v,e,succa -. l I s th %- reLE FL M ALE
/
N.'
- 9 s
FuNc riouAt_ RE At 44 "5 tb %- re tt Fr_M Atr. o RFE kvI*W FIGURE 9 i O{ FUNCTIONAL REACH AND VIEWING ANGLE DIAGRAM
-. . .s. . x f. , % ; a . . z . , .,. ,_... g , _ m.. . , , . . . .,...g . . . ,,.
N -
'P ..
2 G + - l o 19 l l l 1jl[i[ hlb'# ' /a ' ' ' /t ' a IOC80-RE-25G A . . . . . . -
. . . . i , . . .
- ,,,,n... .
.. .. .E3f% 7 .mema
.. c ~ i~. ., . , ..
w fld1 +
,m
.. II r 6 . .... . --
.. . = ..: c-
. :., 1 .,. .sd.g .
~
m .x
....}_..... _.. \.. . . . . . . . . . _ . . . . _ . . ., ...
... .t
. a -
- . . e
- : * * "- * ' * - ~
- Id t
- c. .......
EE YjT << . 7
=
,: ,.;, 3 E .:::, - -
.:r. A: . c m a. A- .
g
= B I r mIm w -,
i 3 #-4-H
=
mm m m .. m ,,,, 4
-r --4 s4--* - + -sM. ,..
" e. '*
, r , , , s _ s s., , . . . , 6.
.s:: - s i s s . . .r . <.e_srs--- ..; , .
- 451 : : n m 3 I, . . . -
@ =a 2
- S - --
- . E, u.a n .
=
. .: a .u. m .. .. ,e >
.i la
. : e p ,, e
.H,
., :: n
.. ., L 8. .
l et i a e . _re. _e e. e t.U.t.si_a a.e t.t t_t.t _tf g ,, - aj - 3
'[ *
- .f . . t. t_r t. t t t. r e r t .r.* t t t. _t t ..._t t. t t .t _e m..a 9 . 9 i g9 . ..
rn . m_ i :: gn. - : : :, i.n- :: - , 4FFEGED ,t - - .. i,_ . .. ~ , P 2.i.Q[ l ! . .3
.. y l l
j ~ L..J L n it '.: C
" 9 :: L.J
? - r(. ? ! n -5 *
-n. xs. j,
_.ut 1 4
,,y,, - - !' :_* "*n ut 1 -h----1 -*~*-----t-'- -- - **t .,; . ,
l I 3 E9 N H fEi!IlH 5 E f,ma.$_.._ : ,ini, :: g igi.g- 4.. ._-9 I4
.1 - . - .. , u..a
,f .-t-- !T =
-f - s ti t._
#j Jt .J_ia -
-b t.%
e"u
.~
i v..-= :t
.:1 ..
1
- t..;
/ n~% .gew:
.m:
.t o ..,
,ei
= .. ..,
t:. e m ..: m 8 :: i 9-
,--i_g;; e." :::1 w., -- A g h :!!
A- ,101,
- jg!'F
.- i -5 .r
.=
.m :: 1 a_:
, , =. m. . -
. . I. . . . . m. -+ ~
g 6..J IJ; . 6.. [ 6..a .. a., L ., y. e r
- ) 41 s1 - 4 4- + -+ i-+-- * -t--ol-la-al , sj . si- 4*-*) -
".1 .
m . ic - 84 .=, . sg -
.: a, ,m
=vverts cm.tocam e . ion :a & ~ -== nee, egvces esus irun cmvaas e svo. ca.: o.o e 3.,
3 a e ng .e Juch ace.F3H3ee
=
2Je '. "w J 4 -t -erJ tecart.s.h. L t .o tn.s ACE sta {EVCgg smaates CF f4ss.1h'tonamWL C asest , unaps Daehasst gumadE-MAa
- mae
.ma na3 * * * * * ! acta'sa stw*t. ass sem O. was y sese *,gEA,C g e .a6s t.ecar.mes'tmasts n c can, i. c .ass.,w.gsta es . m.an som agac cucurs a cn.6stf e . Cap .e. .
- 80. One e.rt Cr44afen 43 33 & esa as as senas.rt .
Omf E4 L141 579t4 se weep et3 gge g e.gge Mas.
-as't AE l 4 0003 MA4 sI)e
.>te.t 34 98
* % sta's akt ta.38..a'E th4.8 i.e* t re,fgan em gestL M CED E.m.6 verts.ab sEtu.h CTES CF CELD et1LES Sfra
% , g,g,.g ,,
C 4 ** 't Gat O.a.som te.ft963 race cr 1.it .es 3833 W Sf9LE s.3 k[/[/ / !/M
*E 3 W 4
, 1 c L.e.d *."..*. ,o,- inn ,S.T.W4 . 6.c A,W5,5,too.m a, Wsms ma -
G I't.e 30P otM S Ch8*IE OJ.TO svg aus,.at.t.T.ts. tortTTTM.E 0 E M 84hd. Cne. 88E. W SFTLA G .o.EN f*.lf LOCE LR'le 8491K9.tp w c ?= 6
- e en a.e o't to.CC>te4 M W. &#Fe*T* tg aft g.f.D. .G 9eagg agAe , . , , ,
? $a6 wtp s et h 'O F:d8GFEP" 9. E30#C6 SLML ggg G
[ as at,t n .acan Fury.T .m mw: n 'e.o 'o *='ans 5
.i l..
~
0 E __ [__ ww[
z ABv.-3cq f l
-} , , . g . a . y s . g a y s . ), . n . ), l L
, . i
..ws a
** ce .
o.~,. . m> e,
- g. . ., , ,
ur s
... , , a% i, c-ro ., __--
.. . .cnia. . ,, . ... - - .. ., ,.,o__
.l E9,wya4 py g _ ___ ,, gg vg g g g v g_ g . - ,_ - y.
,,4
-,, . 4 m -,= -... ~ . ,
l n .
,.s
<w...
c,-.6
.< m, o.,i -.+ . - . .
I , t C yt cry r . Cd.4 F A. .ru u 4 w fu.P6 L,- e g p 1 m--.
, ,ri,
- o. us..r,,
. w E E .f .c _ _ . , .
t__ c -- m i.
. - - - - - o. _
g 1 at - r ,g i .w= .,
, + ,
. . u.c e . .. . .-r 1 + ,4 -- -c -. m, m.w 4.c.e.<,s =
4i . im . . , , - , . 1, or, v3 .. .c
; .r . .
- w; = .
ec.,.
,r .
,. . L .
-a n.m a - as in c. an, e>
- n. a.i.
. m i__
3 $ aEvaa== se.nnJits a a. .c a p ,De I- m. aux _ . , , , , , , d map.EP% i 1
- g e. . .. . e ac inm g m, Aft. i
- .. .,. .a g3 _ ' .w.
..e e r, i,-i,,ic .c. _
, ~ . s. .. ,m.c -
--- i . . . - .
,. ,i , ac
-.l. N -1,w-
. .X
.. sa ,
ept9 ,, m
.,.,,..,,,,.i, gg . , . ,. ,g .g 1, gi,, gg p y ys ,,, g,,,,,,
.o ii,=
4,
- - , , . ..m __1 m,
.o. , , . . -- .. . .. ,,.- ..
.. t, m
, 0, .
4 . g. u.. s, r-r. si
= 6s,n.
cn een _ ._n ii.s pri.
=
'.=,= . .
==' m =a .
6 __
, . .s
=
1,, & J
,T ,
d.=.=
-- m e .,, c ,6= ..
t ;
=,
., .- la . . .
,+ ,, - - - " " '_
1 t- 3 . i a . .B- -Cs C.. EM. . ,..
.,, ufa ,
F _= - _ _ ,== I MI.T,. 7,.EDevaLL.,4.s f.e,0s ir >-. - __ _ _
.m. a e"W*ac CD., t.gu3.e vis = - _ __ vi . ,
& .ma.ept.,.5 ccTAn.-a.
e,
.m .
i 4 38 i
..a - a.
m,. ii
.. . -. . - ,.c, wi c _
~~
u . ,. . -
- s. , - -
$1 7 Pl . CE y it A ne 7 a . ."cens --
m ,. 38
. .e't,, - - i =, 6 - -
. =i - .vo.i ,_
.4 , , _
.a o c - - . ,
..,, - a i
.>. . .c..no . .
-a.c,
. e
. C W .fEISJ _ _ _ _
, .gr . . 3
. .ec
.c
. .us a no
,w CE.EsW ., . ,
6 mc, - . . e, , .b<t . I
..u
.3, , bis 6 6 m r-- _. , ,= o m_-__., . -. , , . .
JT. r _ - .- cr. - - .
. , # n .n..
mn ., p u
-_- n. -
i s,- ., 1 ..
. . .c.,., . ,,.m .
lo
.m.,, ., -- i s.
e- .
.w e,..-,.. .---i = - -
- t.a c., . . - . - .
g . o , m..,,.
. i. .
y761 I,
. . . W. CT6 8 p4 e .
e
-psi 4.,F . .-- , .. .. -
. --1 -
. == .s m -
can.c , . .> .c p -c. o, r.,
, . c== .
A=i t 1 .
. c. .uc "E mJ E
...n,.
.C
. g.
G O.ff - ei
..,i..
.c . .
at . ac
- =_
.D,- . . ,
7,
.c. <K18. E & - CH3f ac, n . C *'2
" 'O r- - . = s, i . . m- a . ,
# M & ag 7 nk I bb h * . & C d'f.n.E*1 i
= waPM .r e m - 4l.a a
.,'.>.,FJ.'
.J ,? ,r rar 4
^- -- '
~ __- . r_m.m .ma . __
a r1 %. pP .?W 6 DM p.w J SP fjg 2J. . g ER 1M.F ,I. 1**".# .O ' C JEL" * . r.M w. a a er p.. o
=
e
. m, w ,. .
-,e-9 s,
MUCLEAR SAFETY REL.ATED
= .. .-- .-
===.W==.-.a u
Ia _ air ei <.4 n.c.n ew.o,0.
< = ,
=_= -=*^=-t
.o as r cs. n, sua ae m anae .===.... ..- ~
- 9. t o-a s
' I DUQUESNE UGHT"-COMPANY 4T V'E.W b I
* -- - m Al.TN 4 PN' . TCT f & 2 3I f ,is eEAWR VAL LEY POWER 5'AT10PeLNT PC21*
it = = e j _ _--T-_ g, f
====. :.---
.n i
', AA No.1MC-2SGA f, s, . ,.e ec ___ i .- ...
ai
I c-HUMAN ENG8HEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT J a) B V PS/2 l PLANT / UNIT l b) ORIGINATOR: D. J. VoC HINSK Y c) HED NO.: 2#**-3161 l d) REVIEWED BY: . I, e) DATE: 2. // /F5~ (Westingh'ouse) f I i
, A\w (EsseA) N I DEN TIFICA TIoM 0F CeN7 ROLLER DEM A4'O f) HED TITLE:
OR A C TUA L STATUS g) ITEMS INVOLVED: CON Trol S 7A 7 ton S (SEE ATTACHED LIS T) _ h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: con TRoi S 7A TIoM INDIC ATo R S ARE NOT I DENT /f tE D AS WHETHER THEY REFLEc r DEMAND on AcTust S TA 70s. G. 5. I, I e (0 i) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE L GHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION Nt.MBER: , VERIFICA 71oM of AVAILABILIT Y, Rio 5, PARA. C.2. 3 l 7 P- 9, 2 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: OPERATOR CeN Fli s ton EYl S T S BECAOSE C oN Trol S TA 7/* N 14'DICh 70 R S ARE A's T IDENTIFIED As To WHETHE R TIFE Y REFL EC T DEAtAND on actual S~7A TO S
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: ADD DEMAND oR A CTUA L s 7A 70 S ID EN TIFlcA rts A' To ALL CoNTRs LL ER INDIC A 7aM S ON THE A1kl4 Cs# Tfo L Beh S O. ~
~_t. d u 8 x 1. b\of.a. kv% shhd kw wcN- k g ,e acn ss A w A . m A ~M h % b y g ,,g usu- ca_kis a <b A.
fN ESSEX HUMAN' FACTORS PRO T MANAGER
$$b DUQUESNE LIGHT CCDPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER D.l<Mik/s .
WESTIpuSRPROGRAMQEORDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
& M g/
rA ~ g 76 dh
/
/
,,4 .-
C ,D t 3 %ks ?.%? A .
- 6 /? e s [
4e .ke b'h ) e3 clewsrsd
- e. - .a ,ht, 5.6$_S , 4 a W +r o
v "' W a, -! , c.,t ' ~~~ -h
, , ,~ ,.,1s a, ch~l ww lc ~ f - fs-DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER
. . i, s '< '
^ ,.a N'
DUQlfESNE T COMPA Y MEG. AFFAIRS MANAGER fe8rr~ DUQUESNE LIGHf COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
2 i $ 4- 3Iol _. A17ACJfAt EM_T To_. .H E D__ F0 BM _ _I DENTIFICA T/0N 0 F_-. CON _TA0 LLEB DEAF AN O. 0B_ A C TuAL- .STATUSm I TE AA ___AA A R K N 0, . . _ _ _ _ _ _
... PRESS UMIEER_SfRAY__ VALVES _ 1Acs_- ecl+1_TA,_S -_
AM S_ SRIEst OPERA 7 ten Flow [ 2_ABSMC VGoSTA,.B C*NIAo L._ _ VAL VE5 ! 2A}[$ % Nc_V_1516) _ CMARGryc. LING FL*W CsNT9aL VALVC 2 CHS- FC Lil u_ .__ RcP S EAL IkJECTlsM SoHLY VALVG hcl! IVC __ _ A Est DUAL HEAT RELEAs c UALUG 1 s VS k McVie # PRESSU Al PER PRE 3scRE conTgol 2 ACS-PM444A EXCESS L ET DowN FLod CoNTool VALVG Jcys & McV111 CoubebSER S TEAAC DVA f C4NTR 9LLER lits.5-fM94 f - AO11LiAAY FEE 0ivATER Flo w cox7AoL [2 Fief & 4 McitIco_A,B,__ _ VALVES c , D, 6, C _ _ _ w asp-3_-me mm om em m-mew
.,e--e
,emwi.6- _+-e.-+ -u. = m g e.agummen.e awymw--m.
. _,, o.-_ m
-- ._ wgn .e e e-emewa m -so.e
_m-a---mum + -
.- - enem-mem v -e_g,. a ,, . _w aw---+
,m , ,- ,, .w, me m w w -w-a+e+--+-em
,imer..,_ y
--*N- e~ *
- cap. .-e, % e , w .eaem-w . +---m-e um 6 m+ee*=weem-e **
-gap --e- --m-e - - - - - . m
. = -
ATTACW MEN 7 l l C L anific Aries OF HED No. E WW W - 3101 i AT Paeseur T H E nt L A s L F_ w n _. CowT noi. SrArious. oN JMu Mam_ceernoi. BoaRo
...WMicH _INDic Art. . _ _ ACT UA VAkvE. PoblTM. .Rarwan J_una ParawE vawE_PessrsoN
__INESE _ ARE . ..R8Cb1H1C E50_AlfL13 tact 9M_HE AP_ YENT_ELow...C#BTR* L h- AND- _. -- __P S1.S.(HIC _%68 AiS___(_SI_TagoTTugs) . - _ _ _ _ . ___ ._ __. _.. _ ._.. Tat FoVR CONTR0ALERS LETED ABovs Ane Mangro " ourevy Fasocace " cN Tea cournoussa, IwoicatoRS. Tat Exisriwo Lasecug, os Tge C.wra.cteg Snovuo se__Suppusseur. Asene ao Aerw Reatunno.
- h. duco 9-16-85
.v _
-N em e-
_ e-e-e -
-ww--e
.m-a-ammeee.
---=*e.
mww.,-.m.mae
* * * * **
- N* d' N
e _ m+we h amm - e we,g
-=aus --e w--ee---ee-.am---w -=.+.e s **
a>.m- .mu e + gew- ,.,au--ma ,- ---mem-mmmen-w og wame - , ..-w.-...,we .-m -~ wu ,-- --ees. ea e e-,. e e
HUMAN ENG8HEER!NG DZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) E\l ~PA " d PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: d OL3 M m
.)
c) HED NO.: 3 R AW - 32 OI d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7 / 31 / 7 Ll (dstfnghouse)/ M (Essel) ] f) HED TITLE: OXt nopA Onwd m9 & *A D 1 Ssus'aoeL ii g g) ITEMS' INVOLVED: lisc.keAc' Mg, C. I A OctdN ~ [. 7%) 3 M Eb\
%sc.veAc_. 'kbc h G\cA , 6r 6% -(S$ ,%\ B4 3
~
15%be IC bbq h tidp .1-bAsBd [Gqg} ,},\ Bqg h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: k%Q k hko& > MuQ\ 3 0V O ' 6.4.I.Ie..
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLD4BER:
W % \b D tu k u e. D' C Z/]
.R!-{C.?
i Ps, t ras.c j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: l
%b em% t Meeg Aamig .
b) REVIEd AND RECOMMENDATZONS: dJ. , 1 I hw C~. g65 fC A 6 u h>OCCL OA C3 NhD c .21.a1: 6u a w do p otto _A pia
, gy pr rkr R ovei Me~0tGb SwM&^3
~
- g. perwt, ci< H - coMw& M** W" #
, g,, ,,p owfWb.
E rAk ESSEX' HUMAN PRDJE W MANAGER h DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER d' t
~
WESTING $E PRO 1 RAM COORD)f4ATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
f )s k *
.A a -
24aAp "A n tb h. a & JA 4 nD DUQUESf4$ LIGHT' COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER [ . DUQUESNE p T CO @ NY R G. AFFAIRS MANAGER 0 W&
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HLMAN ENGINEERZNG D8SCREPANCY (ED) REPORT a) ~B\/76 !I h T-2 PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: b- Ad bt e LNo c) HED NO.: A f3C 2- 3262. d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7/3//E'L/ (W(stinghouse) # W. (Essex) tM f) HED TITLE: 1/p r , A A la+ l.Et k kthob kn o d ioPYk fy,1 #G adpidupA MOok Dd M ed g) ITEMS INVOLVED: , b (Q.t.g 6t$L S 3 O f\ EHO_ h rie(-(194\3 9NL h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: Tsto1 I N g 1Abt b O LILk $b %C. Notoe, o tee. pm% 9 av be.shse.eteA 't.+ \ock.s ti baw.xbA. e a . 4.9.4. n . one. weg s& w ap. p s % k dcend (AKde +.An- h is osednol Pa;d .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION
- T~~ P 4 .I I6 3 .4L 2, O.otNT6.ok $ 6WAue_y DGGIN R 40 3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
h&k OCC V\ d b.XdiOt\ d k QaHL. a s u opA o-%w p t %ss-J
h) REVIED AND RECOMMENDAT3ONS: , A\\ O g %5L M 6 b M be, d ' d k u ,ecad. onehh ik_n_. %ed q') tLa_,
%-
- NtrSr-try s'es i7 n +'r.5 Ate po?' CAmcdi 7" SWe7Y no smmer c~~sa w r- ar nu. web ro wtrer j rw by,
' V Acrisy
/o $ fro m oto
~
ESSEX HUMAN FACT JECT MRitAGER WN& DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER i : WESTINGpSE Pf MRAM NATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
Wc h~ rj DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER Y . $-D/~W DUQUESNEfGHTCO@AN'YREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER 8NC DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER m
HtNAN ENG8NEERlNG DlSCREPANCY (ED) REPORT
.> svPs/h a a PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: k Nt 3rkino c) HED NO.: 3 E C 2 - 3203
/ \
e) DATE: 7 / 3/ /Oy d) REVIEWED BY: (We(ting' house) [' rW (Essex) \ f) HED TITLE: Kaig-AybM*A h M M obd d d M E Mkck 'in ob[ ct- '$1 [ LMon hou \$ \]#_.bko
\
JJ
~
g, E.S3 o t4 ENO bdPO h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NLMBER: ( e_ q . o p e s-a M. Ms skuld k 4Lhid so hk kk 366e_k is "oW s'W" e% h 4 a 1.n -th. N(G bEO_d K"Idic4% - 6,44,q, M
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
Ofdbc5,6u.doeg .MLCIN R403
-rP4. t E s . .ts j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
k 6 f tM M Mk 'L.6 G.OII.0Gd.(cc\ d r- h icccmeA corhA woM .
b) REV1ED AND RECOMMENDATIONS: W % OkekY Y 6DL $ & \ONC
- a. och 0 7 5 % g d o v F o r- 6 Arc exh.
,",pp i s ro wrwr~ nxicH is cos m w r- pare A n r--
CoMW'" . &RW /C /fso+gg g , hgygigeoo op w tr wy tow.
- /% &n- x ecam- e- nen, m
ESSEX HUMAN FACTO
\- E'CT MANAGER 4M M DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER i / b :
WESTINsH0 p PROGRAM DOORDIKATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
fede
~
DU(ilESNE L'IGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER k DUQUES IGHT C(3dPANYdits.' AFFAIRS MANAGER [8@
'DUQUESNE LIGHT d)lFANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERENG 08SCREPANCY (E D) REPORT a) hVPS/A PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: _ 'b. b o c h s o n c) HED NO.: 'Ab4h'3 M d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: ./o//6/9 4 (We(tinghouse) /
~ tTYh (Essex)
]
f) HED TITLE: Lo \'o\ 9od *<o- i^ ~ o b- ^" v'O h ** ' e ?. w wr Lu s ' , o s m n . c o b' o m a s g) ITEMS INVOLVED: Au giocg .g- <,La g 4,6 ko4
- s \ oa h a boot h-h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: G . G. %.9, c ,
copou y. . > r a n ' bo t no.\ co n :s o % s e + < u b y
- W " \"
voeu% L g o p **\id" ON 'o M '<'\*.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER:
Co Wo\ too m 4 4 v e. Lakes owh loc a s coc o hs T9 G,( A-9 7)L (_ W %'40 $ j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: Ogo-No c e4cor3 co s h ce+ . % ,as p c u\\$ sboshE d m .g <. ws .
k) REV!ED AND RECOMMENDATIONS: bgh egg - S ba q'h kc at4 w% 7. g , L'r>- >- 11 -^' a,. . t N. P'p -
-( -
y.-3x. ., (
\.. (i(e:i%cm;.,o!
N ; (g .c.
- c. 3 3<. <
% ~._'N '
M MANAGER ESSEX HLMAN FACTORS
}'
E T~'E L /M )s DUQUESNE LIGHT Cor ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
& LllR ?
WESTIfuSEPROGRAM4f00RDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
i G 5 DUOL%SNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER ff 4 - 2) ~ PS
~
DUQUE.SNE LIJIIT CCDPAP6 REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER _ fSW& DUQUESNE LIGAT COWANY OPERATIONS MANAGER -
HtMAN ENG8NEERfNG D8SCREPANCY (ED) REPORT a) IM/PS -M PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: I kACNt vd.no c) HED NO.: A B C. A- Nd/ J s d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7!3/ !P Y (dstinghouse) / W (Essex) X tO ' f) HED TITLE: Mbe tk^w hus \IM6 O \ehe.EnD o peon - en \onacA bu& h s g) ITEMS INVOLVED: gd bwh on hkhbr\e. EM Cor\%\ pcLw_.\ ( HH ) (Buttorm bm bd_ ul h "vahe b+ hW M " ed.ve b2st @4 " m h tubire ento-R M.) h\ \ s c. .2. . h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: MM N86%E4 M k }lAAhh b 5 h u ee_ mes cR \ettewing. 6.4 5.% M
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: ,
6 D OC Lt - W M.\ t3 ,3. M 3LC I// R203 j) SPECIFIC HLMAN ERRORS (s) OR EGJIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
\r\ 00. EO M M b e_ d.k tr\ CL de de. comh4
b) REVIED AND RECOMMENDAT!ONS: Qqg h dr-- C LG6.6 OO 6
*
- e--
wue % e i- 9 a b b e o " d
- gm6E L~ s _- =~ m
- h %y -
i~ -s , _ ,_ _ _, e nm-es v an w, osc mn ur nr & nmc.
- MtM%ES EF Wy D gab ,
- No M 77 w AW&~NC$.
ESSEX H M N FACTOR MANAMR DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER h* f
~
i Ye WESTIN @ SE PROGRAM COSRDINATOR
~
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
Ic e+ DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER Y - bY" $ DUQUESNEjeIGsT <rdMP(M REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER f6P97 d ' DUQUESNE LIGHT Cor ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENG8MEER8NG DISCREPANCY (ED) REPORT a) YE 2 PLANT / UNIT t- ti w c) ED NO.: 2 8 C MN b) ORIGINATOR: _
]
d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 7!3/!E4 (Weitinghouse) /
\_ M (Ess'ex) f) HED TITLE: Onnhama % A 6M_m ia a T e O N\G t-6 .
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: ht gw g ( M O _t. , on e Mc. Pa.neA - (,it4) - M EC 2-h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: not M chan. \e9 sol _ pu.>A.buitens Ea.Me_% a .e- e o.&e. 0 *Tg M - /o H.3.3 cl (t) .
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
bAlboks 6LLt-Veq TP%\ %S \S DL.CZN l%t+ o 3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: M be.tM f\ CkOO A
%K m pbhh . -
g ' '
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
~7 ,,._ r ',... F o ,T 7_Oi11 6Oc ha f 'k JD
(.,.
, -); w n e.t s CE%.K.tw D 1IG i AQ J ?" C ' 3 - - - ?
r_ ? ' C y ". L'. .),. 2 I M '- O y& D- qt L~. . y e x . . x...: . . .i cesde^d " ** " ~
, gps see sepins/e d $y V32 &* an I"'F-- MyI
.ne,.da.,tJ aeAw& i.s wy "He/r.
f4 AfM Ac~ ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS hkM ' CT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER WESTI @ SE PROGRAM C0096INATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
.N Ocb'"
DUQ'UESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER f . 4-2/~$ V DUQUESN GHT CG@ AIY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
' DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER ON
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT
.) PN P5 - 2.
PLANT / UNIT 7 c) HED NO.: YC - O b) ORIGINATOR: ._ M h DE l.1 N G. MART d) REVIEWED BY: e) 'DATE: (We,sfing' house)~ / N (Essex) , f) HED TITLE: I
~
< U of b 1 bS.
g) ITEMS INVOLVED: BMRtERS 6td 0.omi6DOUS LEbeJD QOSB60TTDJ5 ou Pwa.5 : NCk) - h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: BARR1ER WtDTB MEA 50ttEME4JT5 FALL BElovJ MINtMUM AccePTAbtE GTAtJbAR06 0F 0, os". (o . 4 .3. S c. (i) ,
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtMBER:
ComW sagges TP 4,t E t\ C7 blC\N Rh43
. )-
j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORSKs) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: 8ARPJG2 w\0T44 NOT WCE eme To PftoVtbE OLN1005 EGFNM100 BE%)ts) AMN.EksT POSBBUTT04S. MM Ac7 NATL 6td ot" com160005 Flesult th) A(ctDeJTAL Fust@bTTON S,
k) REVIEW AND RECOMENDA110NS: El1DTH OF BARRIERS MT\085hi PUSBBOT'TDMS S600u) BE tu(ReMG % MEE'T b'100 STA9DAEDS
. Mca is incumr, e m ex s [ r/p ~) g , ,puee y wxw yM~ A E_eux e2
. yo Knw '
e ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS ECT MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
' /
WESTI SE PROGRAM NATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: -
f &c k.n O e h e
~
l DUQUESNE LIGHT Cor ANY ENGINEERING MANAGER DUQUESNE L REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER C6) - DUQUESNE LI COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) bbM PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: - N t @ e.') c) HED NO.: 2BC2--340f d) REVIEWED BY: a) DATE: 7 3/ bh (Wesfringh'ouse) / (Essex)
'\
f) HED TITLE: M W M N I o A 6 ; A /M ' O & W ' " ' d "h * ' g) ITEMS INVOLVED: RF. BI AAE. ( W h 5% TEM (' L WO ) Pui 8 C 2 Cll7J h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: CotORS I4s ONSISTEsOT b) WMv4 E.YSTE/M j ' OW 6M' MB f ED te ON b\P FEggs WWSvtTo45 WWtaJ is E sy3rge ,
. 6VERMc MiTio41 a S s.u <a s.
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER.*
C otVVENTiote s 3 vavaY TPt.1er,9 o uc.in g sc3 j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERR 0f Ns) OR EQUIPENT DESIGN PROBLEM: y,cna e xn /m m a e 4 au -a. w -
k) REVIED AND RECOMMENDATIONS: g m m ary .: t- :4 % M40 Av. >u:, s.iv y su cus Lok Mer. k f r5 /eV h Ac f a &
^# ~
/
.g -
$l V e_
f 0 T i b 'o n fuskI See D1 b p .A-C " # r eM ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS MANAGIER f^Z~GA _' A s2 DUQUESNE LIGHT COWANYAIEVIEW TEAM LEADER
- /
WESTI SEPROGRAMCopMDINATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION: ,
/
1's on) ,
. 'n r
) /l 1lg l{-th0 DU@ESNE LIGHT COWANY ENGIEERING MANAGER b $,h .
//"/GEV DUQUESNELfGHTCol#ANFREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER fd Ww DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
//-6-p'
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) PN PS - 2. PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: % h b E U N E. R M M c) HED NO.: AbC A-WI d) REVIEWED BY: # [- e) DATE: 'OLT. fl.192,4 (Wgsliinghouse) /~ 1~'YA ~ (Essex) f) HED TITLE: EN OPA2 Air:n (on r(Lti dis PL ME- MBJT l e35 TN At.I 90 LAl tJ)t40 M ST AM O A t2 0. A g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
\CEM OPGWATW SWiTUi 04 GT- Pcwd. , PN L EC2.
h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: Kg OPGMT@ SLA)VTCH DISPLALGMENT iS USS 'T14AM MlulMUM BO' ST ArabNC D. D)SPt.Af.ELAliEWT MEAtVE ED A~T 0' O ' . (p. 4 4 . 3. (j ( b
- 1) DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT CO'MPANY INSTRUCTION NLMBER:
(ontvois Suweg. TP 4.I El.) \.3 btCd MG j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: FNL.oce Tb (7.exc60tze Switch POS\TIOM.
k) REVXEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: 9}p j ,g,ja; [g3 e lncLtaSC, dispIGCEyuGvd b O1Oo yAsMw,mggg
, g a r.a mm.-s a e- c e c+et.y waen .:no wsemi~acr.
gu, pt c ig,,- 'a rpppyppy Stu 17C//
, g(Gffl~ ep- $ 0hWlo~ ((Q ') 15 pS/7/W ~ AN o M vff n l~
. ,4/o i4 c 77w 4 FComMse64 ESSEX HUMAN FACf0R CT MA GER d
DUQUESNE LIGHT CODFANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER s: 4
/
WESTI SE RAM INATOR
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
4W S DUQUESNE LIGH COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER e . _____ DUQUESNE COMP RE . AFFAIRS MANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT ANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
b,
'~
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT y , a) $Uf5 *2 ._ PLANT / UNIT '
-s
)
b) 3. ORIGINATOR: A>.kh0W c) HED NO.: D O#~YOUl
~
l
; \ d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: "/7/3' Y
[u ( Vstinghousef /
~
M
~ '
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: NirRD&cs) Ge6e S'emuat) g) ITEMS INVOLVED: j_ y . 3 Alfaceao fan-e rb c STverycoug:EATUR s . L h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: Aiw feui; R C srEm m was Awak~0, Rerver,a, in oxisc u ro pAm 72 00moc ArmWKRG. t = - ,
- 1) , DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: g gg g4 g4 gy gHog6 ,
Ei j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EOUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: 0Pcx4M uns ns4 wnc sp RAur anorruM A!na t1*Jo* NA
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: p,ppy feacrain h cms.ee- circrn e xwnut .r nw ca-:xms.S g'g fi;g r M a a h er Pc4L .
$y ho celn ,a//opsbis n qwd 4 /og et S ,
d,, L / f n d % ,o g /ia .t= ~ 4,
.- n n-e M "
ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS 2CT 'MANAt>ER EwLAx DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REiIEW TEAM LEADER
- < -/
WESTINGgUSEPROGRAMCOORDI%R ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
e l DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER f5b . //*lvV- 6 DUQUESNEJJGHT COWANfREG. AFFAIRS MANAGER fSWw //- /r - f f DUQUESNE LIGAT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER i
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) bVf5 - 2. PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: /J. ksoJtV c c) HED NO.: A 'A F - 40 0 2 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: ///s /N (%stinghousg
- \
, -- \ m \M
~
(Essek) f) HED TITLE: daarAiw*tur not u . cX M C M M
- M
- N or wi7Hiid G L/M rs g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
CHiu.Ev *-'*13e cau1En caso.'ucx
-7, m ,yg a u m p cw axis ~<A h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
u,., p op 10 g *t:
*Th( (x M,menor Gy ,4ym- Tawinua: g>ce g ng me ;S ra 4 oo m iu ey a;; uwo s~ p
%c s+awseerersy 2 C Hedes . fanscauerwert.-sh- 4"owo o w.-
(notuDo wpre. Sisruh 90 eevtot coeusue wm est incciv.%A,*rwcosume CHtm u% citiu.;Q G/473;ti . It'u recuttw vnwg Lsa1. u' op /N .o" 0 2. capwrx cas.see rye cwoe>vun ra rua.>o car-
- 1) ; DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION s
Nt.NBER
/E4 D8- 7FO S/ gy R Qe.vm,J ht C.\ N R%Mk l ,1 ) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
0&me Czee kwave no /a ca e.ee_c.;- m a u n e a t~-
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: AGce nund /kio ate" raz Aw J unia e en un.; p2 (u, ar a c t. u, c ,e sn a,a og mp, ,, ,.aq., _ , __ _ (spouws.y FA sewaouwe
#14Ar futr PfoCfDuM /T ct FAC,
/
%O ESSEX HUMAN FACTORS T MANAGTR doe--o DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER AL 4L1 WESTINdpEPRDGRAMCOOR6INATOR ,
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
-AA & i A2c/ a e 5~ y l
l a1
~
DUCIJESNE LIGAT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER Sf N l DUQUESNpIGHT40MPA'YREG.AFFAIRSMANAGER ! [8 WW
'DUQUESNE LIGHT t0MPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER l
t
HUMAN ENGlNEERING DZSCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) b ~ PLANT / UNIT b) ORIGINATOR: A> ic G a t y c) HED NO.: Md YOO3 d) REVIEWED BY: e) DATE: 'ils / f'/ (fesiinghousef Y L W\ (Essex) xN M ' f) HED TITLE: Rsr AnD envr r10N i~D t!Ne- tooeoned AWAU26'C caw eG n g) ITEMS INVOLVED: 84M Hyoese v4 NM-y'e'F'- h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: (A M }/yotoc-OU ANALTSept. For sco cvC vb Los) 4CUc1 $N ' f M d'* IM CArsfLC LINe3.
- 1) ; DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NtNBER:
y 33 --rogg { (gg gyd g(cgy ggg j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: (kaooueG W
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: QEud?w CBucED./G frFP5 73 Derzr n ti # inik.~2 M '*.: <- aD 6t?+KV O' h \N ESSEX HUMAN. FACTORS MANAGL9t 9A;/a DUQUESNE LIGHT COW ANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
~
e= WESTINGHO%E PRdGRAM COORMNATOR
~
, 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
~
W ff*C O .
. A DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l
f[Yo DUQUESN p IGHT @ AN TI%EG. AFFAIRS MANAGER 8 kW [DUQUESNELIGHTCOMPANYOP l l
HUMAN ENGINEERING OISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT PLANT / UNIT
- - =74 d k0vCv c) HED NO.:
b) ORIGINATOR: _ d) REVIEWED BY: [ . e) DATE: " bb4 (W[stinghouse V 7 - x o-A . (Essex) ] f) HED TITLE: nesarc r- + a.ur seca,au sesver,a ,a rasovo,rr e acte e r euc u euao u nr.z res: a x . g) ITEMS INVOLVED: l,rukneuc MM G)* uouso " AsZ~ TM 4-h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER: usoio ansr; m< we rivnonerwara naemco a sw or ac.~u meo efrorvie opewen me wa0w oower-p.~ o ac;e,i:,ec 2 isc nnnu sJ t.i~ ors. aswc uoms Acm.d % nae;ec suo-,ce uu o ~A>rt rn~ r s,en mw aag
.sewezo .
- 1) ; DATA COLLECTICN DESCRIPTION AND DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: LG M RE.V \EW
- .14 Mo 8Dotto b L C 1 M R it Q h J) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM:
cyse,a:aa n exa.vo rmr~ e0Au por (acoa or om.ss .a,.1
- - - - - - - v --
k) REVIEff AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
~._u~ s : s a. - l a~~c.
, . . . . ~ . , ..
N.n.xra x.k.nc a : . .. > .s .:. . 7 :.a .- r + ~... .= :<. .. . . .
'5
- 5 : Wercr on. cf-r r a,;-
- 4 s=, reame ese op c Ner+ -as, e i.s-r nic e paz ,. n s+voeo 7priu ng,, .
ESSEX HUMAN FACTOR JECT WANAGER DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER i < < WESTINGHQt.GE u PROGRAM COOKDINATOR .
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
^ "' - -
k4 f [fdd S O 2 OUQ'UESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER lf
, oUouyzegp0MP,YRee. Area 1RSMANAeER g# W-DUQUESNE LIGNT COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
HUMAN ENGINEERimu OISCREPANCY (HED) REPORT a) $$~S PLANT / UNIT l l b) ORIGINATOR: Al R/t:04F c) HED NO.: MN-ME d) REVIEWED BY: Y e) DATE: // b /%t/ Vestinghouse V T eM
~
~
(Essex) f) HED TITLE: neewous e"4-=~55sae zan toe 2. meur,7n7e ue/e g) ITEMS INVOLVED:
}ke.yaorg Lcsc2. Yth w wrrrail tr-twol h) PROBLEM DESCRIPTION AND 0700 PARAGRAPH NUMBER:
/W3 sura Le2/a2- T%merenyx U-i>461 uM &&mbc00 @ de~ **W"-
!4 " rM K +o }&.c me h<ms rceosu Se s e raAivo~ Exis rev ro a-
/4 *J'S t H ser uns oncown nerate cm exub- Thcm eso xg ,
'IM* [ /k i 35J A o2 3 L 9/e1 7R.novsttsrT2r*R. l:rtiu!"O $ to d Os D A M*"CY '"
me,w umam.n ,me. au rs cit =t:aesw.% fiussac &"*r-
- 1) ; DATA COLLECTION DESCRIPTION AND OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY INSTRUCTION NUMBER: -
l eR 339 - foo#3 . LER QAvg DLC W R%\h j) SPECIFIC HUMAN ERRORS (s) OR EQUIPMENT DESIGN PROBLEM: LOG- daos ocr- c/teresc uncawy [G;eoe oc enstitw] CAMP faiwu ao we at >-rnnnec cwswsara,e. on w ca;=ccx curett. ff**56*/M uni f. CObrPPgn,,7 lkEstx) QQ .
k) REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: RGmsrx acr ONx+w n Aneoce' firc t.oe- Gou ~ nsKC c m .r m-y. b s" < %1, &w nocornunv w ta NA nee o. As & Arsuar-05- 77//J f g,
, ffy'- 2 iy[S d917/MST/%Y7VE~ LV)~Me? 5 7b d'P3'W M dockr #7 7drey op GPffhMS EK%^'r 406
.C#/97~ .
yd AC-TfGN e M ESSEX HUAAN-FACTORS E!Bf MANMER
%U- >
DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY REVIEW TEAM LEADER
' i r WESTING @ SE PROGRAM C00RQNIATOR .
- 1) REVIEW AND DISPOSITION:
if $c 9 e e S g OUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY ENGINEERING MANAGER l DUQUESNE d' U- V T CO@ANY REG. AFFAIRS MANAGER
\
8 NM
'0000ESNE LIGN COMPANY OPERATIONS MANAGER
-. -- .. -}}