ML20136C914

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Responds to 790417 & 0815 Ltrs.Forwards TMI Lessons Learned Task Force Initial Rept Re short-term Recommendations. Reactor Captain Concept Should Be Included in Task Force Work Scope.W/O Encl
ML20136C914
Person / Time
Site: Three Mile Island Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 09/26/1979
From: Harold Denton
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Pitzer K
CALIFORNIA, UNIV. OF, BERKELEY, CA
Shared Package
ML20136C918 List:
References
NUDOCS 7910170551
Download: ML20136C914 (1)


Text

. - - - -. - _ _ .

l

. u ug ih) k i  !

y y d!p:4 m .m :pr.99w.

74m 1 x+ r kf$Dhffh$h y u .A & c + 1;hh k?hk,khk f, Yhh h,:p:khhh h Y$y p

$%&&$GW6%WW0 l i. .

A.& D ww. &u

&, ,i ,tyrofjCa:rsii.

S 3

fs g % .

, -A x9g m

q" hM"M c

$g. m

% "A

, 3 $ M Didir'rtm'entfoflEh i Mi d ff M -

W75 ($%pc  % p, Wp '

a TM dhhFBisksiefWCalif forntF94720 @ > Miya!O yd b 2

[ O< q.k b /

.n .

e4 4 %  % Ma &, , yyyq.n 9w&gg%m.,,,u.,a$y m w p Q

&m. J g Joug,pua Tetter CliafrmanaHendrie nu bassbeen$ re ,,m erredjtotse m?Eq%@..m,

. .a

  • @M~%@Qn.mp y ;m(y ftihdeFl aRweise.hirfdrig ust35d1979t tof steifoQApri;141.7,Q197,9,2&Yodr$AjM I

1 M arrfvedp atnar$partfcniarl'y(r go e lTJe h@cticj.tiimedf Let;me" assure %you(however$).th - f'[fffN$

c t T'nktf%echinli'zid@hiidimpoptindRofj

',.,[/ WM."rediterfca5taliCTcencep,titEtgi'nated; 9 air $1'ettery'neral'.n'dfdetermipedTthath  % $g  %'

ths Tsciipe ofTeork1by% %%

OYithey Ge

  • NthelTMIa2l.

thenAtomic; Enefgy/

Lessonsp.eardeF.Tisk. Force %hicfbegan woric in' Comissioni should' May 'of? thf's?yeaMI be t'ncladdd 7di M

s

_ Q , ain. .:

3 T 9 ] _ y ' pu./ J., g ,.:

Enclosed is a copy ~ of the initial. report the Task F)orce.!ssued July > Q. v Recomendations...y(NUREG-0578) . '.In .thei sections ofi'M d:1979:. ~ "TNI-2(Lassons, Learned' Taski ForceWSta tust. Report. and, .ShohtoTerm this .Lrepo ni MWWMM gon b.t

e. b;c with Shif t Supervisor.~> Resp.onsibf Tf. ties.Ui.t,d thesS,h,if. t: Technical?Adv,ikb yo,u.wi.ll note

" - a ca D qualie ca fi.tion. .etha syof s , -the?t; the,: .w Ts.skJ,staf%~

operating: orces.emph.a. w efiaa nucleant s.. z,a.dh powerc the.r plantWMNqQyggWco.ma. n..d; ro Several related. aspects of preparedness and qualifications for coping- ), h ' _;

with emergency situations are also addressed in the nsk Force R'eport. /,,E Your coments have been very useful to our work. Should you have further coments, please let me know.

s .

- Sincerely. g .

y ;< V<#

s

.  ; ~ ~ .n ,; r

,- ,, f 31 9 .,

< 0rigNQu@ , ,. .

e,.,. . yc' w. ',

c :r s.,.1_

y y '

, y ;
lL,g~-
z. g. c , ; ,, g L g g .v . ,

y , A.

Jr -~p ; ,.; ya %

n~sp v

L , .

,W' [F h $I.$ & <- p D Q"?

'W Ll %py6%,

9 -N d.)g.:iq f) < .n , . @M A

&g"Qk(gg&qHaro.1dLDentoriP i RM .q' g Vf$ 'L ;M%

Offices of/NUcBear D,1 rector &y

$yQ 'yf pqQNeyi&Q?Qgg ?{Q%gg; c s,.c Reactor'yQply,y Rhgelati.ont .c(( 6 Ci

v1 uw 2ncros.eennuReeos7sMp$fy;k.Mf?&wpu$&pw NQ&% ekbl ;b%MGQNAf Q . + + h.fy f& .

$h h Midnhf $h8k h h.hh q

aQ*h 8DI:S:TRT  % $f[0NL%

BU.  % %CE '

W y' p N$tMM M '

vb' haw

, ktygg$ %MWye3@hhc&'jDR@seDe@SWwednG@!

4 %gp a ma Sfdit an NI  % gyp ew RhMpy.% Aww gp ,h d

h.$@QDe,rito p M ueDR Q q g :

.Be rgk o,W g Mggpong'.E.D0 ghbgQ;9;pg9 'g M ggt.]u%p  % ,&%

r/ W),g.%

i d ?p y. i D,.da S'SahlOH bwnm.N%~eq g o ,a, . *: See: prev WA f 2; h.;owe w a n.9,9 ..y A.ch ,.w%, P . fm.,Qy.

7

  • - 40uspyeN or'concurr,ence.v -

.x,$ JScnr.:cederedE.DO

- y l SECY (.79.-2428)p N +"f%"

+y rt/;frV.1.

W e %g; cy f.g %

.b e . p\Nk.$g?yj.-

p ly/

rj NNTNMN

$,!O, flE$TF N 5 5$ $ l!LT h N h 5 L@.iF Db. ..SONR'R N N NzNb MU-9 (.'*,'.,1,.., .' L -A 'd A

W i;< % <. '  ?.yN. , ? ...'

f...{ g;' . j .s }; y' t a'W 3, y-- p' 73%

j'l & .,.:,v _i N '_

y er'

  • )..: - j L

~ s .%

g R I,reandol;.w$  ?. .

p(Rfhttsor ' - p"D

.t

-,4 er% gwgg 2

y. my,

.c - **JMicl h'o a ne4f '* R;Tedesco: <

_ECA,eh ,

y ,.g; o~  ; o , &H an_" 2 9gSg . yma pg . .- 3 r .

g ; om t94;M; M9n.d 69f&g73 4 ! JQggE. gggf.7gg,_gfe jgjyy94 (/79W,,.

AQnch@iiWiQciQosof%%$ft.2QL& .;ay 2: .;;.,y. ;,.@g .h{tgfMQ

((f f fff N l$f Yf' 5lfff5N 0fiff

$m$f.w.h s, ;W ks W a WEDf& $h W 4 ? iaW 5 f. .~:;c': w m?  : &b&hyk.A mce;n k .pih y

. m. ., . . c w p-i

,. ,s. .n %w,p.w ..s ,..r . i.wo.:g.:4 4 c;4, c. : 4.p . <a.,,.9mu

~,y *v v m 'y~uy ..s

.A:s a

u .e, m .c g
. , ,. qp $ .

'kh>fbh .h h yppg%,,h, hhhh. A..r.; .hhhh, s %, .. . p hhkhkkh.

g% w;f:m; y h;u+,,n -

p>.4s Sy+Q .44;  : g,g h;f, gnye..

' my 3, yh a M ,u y 3b? e gk:n.

~M, w q&

D yJ.%

Qk Qhp*.q&

n %s m &p kqes? h.ggh. ga. .7 4 4

% % g Q K- Q%m r-D W:' 'i W . a y .saQ  ;,v '

,}W ..

a f,M W p M?#rmu/c.p X,W W, M w hd Mnike m.@a 4 ft: Mpn:g r.oWg n@% A.Q. ;q$q$Q l y;6  : $

NhhM hhhh s mDoca p q p$ bhhh h wqmpgpWpqMapdaw k bhN h M@vX.Un...i,veisi'tVdf'Cil;ffiinfa iMW ,y -

c y 7 d6MWhw M k e b.Jed83 s 4pMW M

h..,e.ADepartment afi,Che mi.-stqryj . %g .

  1. .g N  % m 9y$y, W,0h . m .Npswa pcpp,g%c6b m

%g#2

.:. 44. m %w

p Begk'el@ey,icil

. g .amqc w g;p.y 1.forniW g Mg n4 M.pM s g@n.Q.%:yy,g.t.;y gND.W.stMlY 94720R up" DVM,% b:v:x ' h WMON

" by y y.m p g p 4:pg g.

m, p d.u.

,W,

Dear \Drdttzery.q,

Q &gQ :w:qwgy.gp pp w$$s$O:gy,

.Q M.9qq 4gWhggW

@W / .:Your?Jetterro M?,W@f* August (15%1979! to1 JfendrieChairman:jMmssqdt@Md$gM;.gp has-!been

-'qJNU C'3

.for 'rkp.1yyisijas';yodr-drisinalhle~ttsCo'f? April 17A1979i'

./[Wriped:.atfa i particulaPTi hectic' tfineJ h6Wevertthat itet y g me'[

M) A N,Wstaf.f 'r. ecognized.sthe2.1mbo. U

'" reac,' tor'. captain"Tconcept,r.tanceiof

. - . m yd. ur--.lette6., and sC'ommittee mw rpu deterbfneditib.itdtheMM '

origina~ted;b'yLthe1

, General, tAdv.1:sory? toa.d n, the Atomi' c  ! Ener5f, Comi ssi'on ,/ shodl di be 'i ncTudsd: i n fthe; sco'peJ :N of ' w

'thej TMI'-2jlessonsAearned'.TaskiFoFceNhiWbeganf work;ini May#

<; ;., A,m . . .;w .;. : 3,.ar  %. b M:

> ~ . m .. . u . , , m . j._; .c .+ . a. . . ..

' Enclosed is a copy (of' the 'initialaeport' by the Task ForcegissuedLin July:v,.$ 4

,, 1979: ~ '"TMT-2 Lessons.Teariie.d TaskiF' o rce nStitus, Report"and'.Short-Tem /FMC q ^

f with Shif t(SVpervisoFResisnii6flftiekan^d' ttief.ShiftJechnici.11 Advinr 4/i

,s

.JyouWil,Lnote/thdt

,Recomendations",,m cal qualfficati6ns^ythelTasliWoFciemp'taff 'ofl ? nuclear (WREGiO578),.?In@the, se of'thd ope' rating's " :E %e i

a Several related aspects"of preparedness ~and qualifications for coping '

with emergency situations are alsoaaddressed in the Task Force Report ~.- ,

l

\

Your coments have been very useful .to our work. Should you have further coments, please let me know. ,

(

4,.

X ~ .

a

=..4,..,

' Sincerely, v * .' -

p 3

u -

h x,p: "

, j' ; " ,

., ~

e

, , , ' d , G[if . ",'.p,

~ >' i

^,. .; ,.,, a ~

9' .r

.yy

't e r.,f . .; ( ; p ,

5'

  • (.~

4_

a.

=7 he f-g g

'%, ~

r e y'f * . f j-  % h.\. ',. f ..0, * }f ' x 0,% Q

~(f c- Q'g.& h' T

  • P%M.M N, A ,,'W((W; jb'?NUREG^-057BW.MM%AMiCb.2*d@ddlPHaro g W @h M M P f F , M AM0ffice664 Nuclear Reacto6 Rig di Denton,[D3rMt
        %j.         A Wv 4/MOMYM
    <Q:                     tEnc.)M uite M @h y W j,0;Iy RIBUTdO p b t4DocketMi Wsg(g50t320 h R W efa W .Q     i
                                                                                                                                                                           %dMD       Q M ,NR                $ d dW% hM                   .

D kf k . kk 17 9 d% WMeWagy v s.p!&WM8Ta Nh entong g tW %g ppRH6ttsonaQSEGy4(ew egygg.y $ dkWW w W;

. %pWBs                  %p ssam           m a %se Sre                                         e                g           g          g$         $          g$e                    &    M           @                      p                gy
   . s;y@Werg#@me%nauemagun$h]W S AD
                                     $ishy pstapED02R98;)Mhav Dy                 .p p                                               g                         % .f 4i            Mg GE 4%gugg                                                                    3mymmWmg                       ggg                                           aggl
             , sug
        . - ,.m .e p'.y g"
                                       .RLre andh.,.                    & Jd yj?D an
. 3-. g.g.g .
                                                                                                                                                                                        !> r    6m y#                  !a; t t n. ,n' l ' o W w.Jg. i.g -, a "M P ?.tv                                                                       .@MJ        u,Aa. %^N               ~'

htte scrt 5 c , rA > ,Nr.4 C;r. 67 - g. q. ..; \) w- ymp - r .. .yt 1

    ;. Mth.OM-Q$.NONbM9.IIES2 b$:.9h k'j' h9.1 *.$g/hy._ g M d 9 d h" h ! J I h [ [ di h h k.t eo                                                                                                                                              k
        .m m m - = = mm m .m w m m ac

n,--. -- . , , , , . . . . - . . . - - , . . , . . . .. - . ._, ,- . . - - , . . . . - -

             ~

f, A' h, a.. - . . . n .s , . Q e3y 3 thy:*s ' m_ n . . A . _ _ - . ~ _ _ - 'J. A ev

  • e i FROM: ACTION CONTROL D AT ES CONTROL NO M sgtli S. Pitzar* COMPL DEAOLiNE 9/lJ/7'i 07198 Profc5JCP Of ChenjStP/ ACKNOWLE DG M ENT DATE OF DOCUMENT U;i{ ygM j tf Qf C&]ifGP!))3, hfTt;E)&7 INTERIM REPLY 4/15 # 9 -

TO: PREPARE FOH SIGNATURE (DdlNi dEndrit FINAL REPLY ,/ CHAIRMAN FILE LOCATION

                                                                                                                         ,/    /              O EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OTHER: W .D A l                                                                                                                               /

DESCRIPTION O LETTER OMEMO O REPORT C OTHER SPECI AL INSTRUCTIONS OR REMARKS Com.:laisit that his letter of 4/17/79 relatim; t.3 t!.e Tal accissat was rasWuced i.a caly iry au raideted fora letter of

  ,            a d.: w l a c ?; m t I

CLASSIFIEO DAT A OOCUMENT, COPY NO. C LASSIF IC A TION l l NUMBER OF PAGE5 CATEGORY f POST AL H EGISTR Y NO. C N$l C RO C FRO bbb [)"dddb l ASSIGNED TO- CATE INFORM ATION ROUTING LEGAL REVIEW G FIN A L U COPY

 !               . .t > c-A                 ;f11/fg                                                   AS$1GNED TO:          DATE             NO LEG AL OBJECTIONS
                                               ~
 \                                                                                                                                           NOTIF Y:

8 C ECO ADMIN & COR RES BP EXT. COMMENTS, NOTIFY: _ g/ ; ; EXT, I JCAE NOTIFICATION RECOMMENDED- C YES C NO I NRC FORM 232 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FCR OPERATIONS

                  " "'                                                                                                                      DO NOT REMOVE TH/S COPY .-

PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL l l l

l

                                                                                                                                                                                                            *%TtyM
                                                                                                                                    * - - . . 7a                                                                                 t.

ys :w 'w*; , '. .

                                                                                                                                               . Q Me 1. T .Wr-*N3i:r                 Nt
                                                                                                                                                                        %u ;:2 4M9%9&                  lt p*ep;f Q                             d M                                       *..   *          ~+
                    ,,w7??.T%
                           ,? v n.qjRc;yl w& !.y ~n'cr m&G&,v'as. , . !,.CWe                                                            %'           JR 499                                                                                                                                                                                           ((y[V
k. g%.gy79 -24287" *Mm? ,o .1.e-ep.,.s. w'n- rv mt,J1,.v g g TQyjggitg4tifsho')7 a . M~ M. ~p,o y 4.paq y q.

r y.ey qg ( j n tQ h= ?y 4 hms ,:w% :w %; m.W ~tc v-

                      "opp                                                                                                                                                                                         ih.. ,%t
                                                                                %..d%,%q#             NRC SE"CRETARI AT4

_ u r/;;; W.J -

                                                                                          /}m
                                                                                                                        +            ,,
                                                                                                                                                      ",r b3g% ~.-Q)!Q. s                                 y nfr            wpg&
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ' ., g.g.

l.r ? - .G -l.%&n L M J'(~f:. ,, m,7' i

                       %[i/;

7,

                                                                                                        ..            9                               --

4o.<e.c #c v.a

                        . 9/7 7.lTOsaO..comm ssioner                                                                                           '.          Gen. Counsel 5.4:1M fd;G b    X@E        xec.       Dir./Oper.
                         "Ni d'b                           1 O. soiicitor' ^' ' Mf' k.: $1--

S ,4 ' O cong. U.. son

                                                                                                                                                  . O secretary                                . l !S                  ##h         .
                                                                                                                                                                               , > s ,7;. h- g,.
                                              'P'                   ,      L C Public A. ff airs                                     .t.~-                                                                                 . ,% ,;)

w ~-

                                              .y s ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ..,m3,
                        ,, e.
                                                                           ,n,                                                                                                            ,                        m.         aJ,
                                                ,, ;n. . ,     ?, ; f t,         p.                                                                          ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              , ,Sf.'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 92/

s

                              ,.                                                                                                                                                                    5 t n ', 9-                                                                                                                         '

f' _ encom,ng: 'Kanneth Pitrer- < 4 ! c .c - l : From: Ilni v . nt- Ca.. Rorkelev ,( sra 9 e.. , s .

                                                                                            ' chairman War ririo                                 ' o,te AfM/70                                                                       ,
                                                                            ' To:                                                                                                                                    %

ComD1aint re: manner in which his Subiect. lat+ b w'as handled. Ltr. concerned AEC/GAC p ra v i e"'eroenmmendation relevant to TMI accident

                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ? '
                                                         . Prepare reply for signature of.                                                                                                                          ..,i f                                                                                                                                                                  '     's        Odd
                                                                                                                                                                                                           ..<v ; v. ,
                                                      /                 ' Chairman                                                                                                                                   3
                                                                                                                                                                                        '                   "~t'4, w.
                                                          . O commiss.oner                                                                                                                               O .:. O;)             .

M EDOm GC, CL, SOL, PA, SECY O sign.ture biock om:eteo Return original of incoming with response O'roro,rectrepiv- > 0 ror .ppropri te action Suspense

  • August 30 f O - For inform.iion ,

I R Ls i -v K ,.,. . 1.,. w~A> q..< O ror recommeno. tion uts........s 1L. e e

               *                                , Remark s: -
                                                                                                                                           . .. .. . %..w ,/ f      m.'_','_. 8
                                                                                                                                                                          .W                      -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .c y my , :m                       %

f4  %, c

                                                                                                                                                   .                    4 , ,                                               -

u: e* ' p ;.4

                                     .:    M.,
                                                                                                                              ' Combs
                                                                                                                                                                ^                  +
                                                                                                                                                                                        ' MMAM)f            v.: ". y .=

[?k $ FoItbaCbmmissio'n; , l

                                                                                                                                                                                            .W                       ,^T'                  '

a [;j + . , -f q"'

                                                                                    ,"        ,,..c                                                                                                                                      -
                                                    .                      .'         .* Send three (3) copies of reply to Secy Mad Facility                                                   s;         ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   <P.Qs
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       +.z e
                                                             ,t e, s ,                   e            e
                                                                                                                                                                                 ,       i CTfD                    SP!'
  • 5nces:

un

                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ,.6
                                         +

i[ a 'VT' - a: i  ;././ b,.s.' j"l j

                                                  ,. Jh                          4      -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         .i
                                                      ,3'             .
                                                                                                                                                                                               ; -                 m, w - ,
                                                                                                                                                ~

l 4}}