ML20134F644

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Informs That Majority of Commission Agreed W/Proposals in COMNP-83-2 Re QA Initiatives.Staff Requirements Memo Encl for Action.W/O Memo
ML20134F644
Person / Time
Issue date: 03/29/1983
From: Chilk S
NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
To: Palladino
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML20132B439 List:
References
FOIA-84-293 COMNP-83-2, NUDOCS 8508210188
Download: ML20134F644 (1)
v • d • e


Text

.c, ..,

vr.oc.;. ...

' , F '- NUCLEAR REGULATORY COf.'. MISSION

,'yf ,, '#,'.7 i 3 - wAssincton. o.C. 2csss lI Of..f

%.' o . a 'e OFFICE OF THE March 2,9,1983 SECRETARY l

1 I

MEMORANDUM FOR: Chairman Palladino , . 1 FROM: Samuel J. Chilk, Secretary [ f . ,

. .- 9M, ,

SUBJECT:

QUALITY ASSURANCE INITIATf VgS (COMNP-83-2)

A majority of the Commission has agreed with your proposals in COMNP-83-2 and the attached Staff Recuirements memorandum has been forwarded to the staff for action. l e

Attachment:

As stated .

cc: Commissioner Gilinsky

' Commissioner Ahearne Commissioner Roberts Commissioner Asselstine

OIA .

EDO O

4 0

8508210188 PDR 850805 FOIA LEICHTO84-293 PDR

. . 1 I

4 SHAW. PITTMAN. PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE

. .. . v g S- . O F . 0,t&& o..t Co..o..,eo S 1800 w sv nt t 1. m. w  !

f w.sweNGTON.D C 20036 (202) 822100C o g ,9,, ,, , ,,ggg, ,,,,,, ,99,, ,g ,,s.

so== r ~c t s. . c

& -M. o .o** s . c

! ;'o";",',' t.;'.".'te*f . c *! -  !!S;'.',' LO'"t "',itir' ". ". ".'.t,' "

G'l t'cE.:Es,' Vc  !.arria

'.".?r'.t"4:','

  • "t;;'JO te vi t e co. r . n ". 'ta o' . '.M 't?

t,t'?;' :o

' "'c'.'.l

' c C"'c!?."t,"c"'/c c wo2, en oes 6 en "99 ti?,1 J c.O*."4"' "" *  ::" PS'

""Ms.S.*S? *6E" .*c " t? " "?!1?;'?.  ;"c'J't; 3"?.at,'."..

?!Pst' ,",,"?'L*/ "" " c- "8 l"' L L'0.'!.".*! c -

?!r.'r 5,'.'s " ?St.  ! RE".i. "."'s'."c't '

c EMi".3#3,T' .c . . . . . . . .o c

'"??."Etje".i'"/c

,,.*e '::;"?:'?t '" "",2:11"'t;\?.?s*,'! wea .n .on  ?' & L't."h'c ." "' ~ LP3: .'? " ::::b.

L'

'?:2 * ? ',un.'e" t7e':::o's';'::" o 3 l'??'s"? o'Ct'";

2,?? '.a*::*:t

  • c ' ' '

E d.ic.". "l.A, 't.*<c',

,es . Lt.!,'.' c'".'a.'~s-o i '.."".I'#

c-c<... '. . '.?".'

P, .',"o*

o. t",' ". .". P'J. c:X' tc* .o **"S"'*"'**";

. ... ~ oo.

iLWs;'"J' .,e .

ML7:.',*'t t'!c". ! *,. . . c Li't'

  • L'". "..'ltid', '  ;"?"'! t A'r, ht'"' "

7;t?.',t't?tJ's" c. c  ;" ".'J " ."!!:"~'c" c' * ' ' ' " ' * "

  • L.u'.t'ec "!1" . .-. L2 *.'o'."

o f'" -

nt'."c*o'tisa! "... 5 "Pt??;' J"t, s .-

E":!Js:t.'3715.ic ST'N 'o" "! ""'' ll:H::at'##..c-d.';' to" "tO'.". T E c iS~Nf'""#" *'c*"C""'"

'Oc'."J.*c i '.' .'.t

'"ct" 'J.!"RE"' " "" ti'/'o **.!!'""

$ Oktc" "ic"J.'." c. e "?";"'."/.?"Ef? 0,10"?."*!!"L'.

'8'Jo'.??.Wr'?...~

c "' " '

ll1'd". ic'J ""

Mi!.'s i "'c'l'!"

  • c # asov .Osa **g g es. O c
  • ""'"'*"<c'""'""'

April 17, 1984 202-822-1496 Mr. J. M. Felton, Director PREEDOM OF INFORMATK)N Division of Rules and Records CT REQUES office of Administration United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission h fk Washington, D. C. 20555 N h -/ f-Re: Freedom of Information Request

Dear Sir:

Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C.

5552 and 10 C.F.R. Part 9, I hereby request copies of all records relating to the Ford Amendment Study performed by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC") and by others at the behest of the NRC pursuant to The NRC Authorization Act for fiscal years 1982-83 (Public Law 97-415), Section 13 (the " Ford Amendment").

This request encompasses, but is not limited to (1) all records of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews relating in any way to authorization, investigation, data compilation, preparation, organization and presentation of the Ford Amendment Study Report; (2) all records of meetings, corres-pondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews relating in any way to " case studies" of commercial nuclear power plant projects performed in pre-paration of the Ford Amendment Study Report; (3) all records e of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of the NRC " pilot program" performed pursuant to Section 13(c) of the Ford Dvpt O Ll .,nmn ~

~ O 8 ,

G/ l F CA 1 ) ~

f

.' (

SHAw, PITTMAN, POTTs & TROWBAIDGE a ., : -.. o, oe s . .. co..o..,.o..

Mr. J. M. Felton, Director April 17, 1984 Page Two Amendment; (4) all records of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of the NRC analysis of audits of nuclear power plant con-struction performed pursuant to Section 13(b) of the Ford Amendment; (5) all records of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of the NRC analysis of the feasibility and benefits of a more prescriptive approach for defining principal architectural and engineering criteria performed pursuant to Section 13 (b) (1) of the Ford Amendment; (6) all records of meetings, correspon-dence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of the review and analysis of the NRC's organization, methods, and programs for quality assurance performed pursuant to Section 13(b) of the Ford Amendment; (7) all records of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of the analysis of project, organizational and institutional issues associated with quality in nuclear power plant design and construction performed by Battelle Memorial Institute's Human Affairs Research Center; (8) all records of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of a review of other selected programs for the assurance of quality performed using Pacific Northwest Laboratory as lead contractor; (9) all records of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of consultations and interaction with the public, licensees, the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards, associations of professionals and any others performed in preparation of the Ford Amendment Study Report; and (10) all records of meetings, correspondence, notes, memoranda, investigations, observations and interviews arising out of the establishment

, of a group of outside senior and expert consultants to l provide individual comments on Ford Amendment Study activi-ties and findings.

To assist in your search, I am enclosing a copy of the Ford Amendment Study Report.

I hereby agree to pay the prescribed fees for locating and copying the records sought by this request.

f CHAW. PITTMAN, PoTTs & TROWBRIDGE

. ,. ... . . 6co ......

Mr. J. M. Felton, Director April 17, 1984 Page Three Do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions or Comments.

Very truly yours, G.Mj' zzr A. Patrick Lei . ton III APL/mlw Enclosure I

L

  • ~

m E- W C M E W W C E C E E = C C aC b- m W = W C m W >= A. >= to E U M E =

C D E M W W g E W m -WW D >= W W w m>

M M C W CO U * .

. M E c 3 A. Ch C *

  • aut C o m' > ZEE U U U C E D D ac, '

W aC C

  • C CcE Z C W C 6 v C >= >- M P .

WE

>- E J >- >- aC eC U M J J C C aC k- W - D E E E a e a C W

< e

- J o

C-J m.

et K u r- c

> M C W m . . .

>= W >= E E E C 2ll i

= C U C C g E W g

aC 6 U E A w

- E h E U U E = C m

E k..

s 4

i e

t B .e l

. l M

1
l

. I 5

I M >

< J J C E

W 4 E

A W U

E E C -C W E J D U M m E C C H & W E .. E M E W L C E W W E C *- W Z E C W I C C E M W g

  • E E W

W C

E E

= = E 8

as: M &

C U E W C g C M g M C > U Q C

  • W 8

E C

E A

=

E

= < LL C

  • M i

& C D s E E C C t 6 . aC c 3 W .E ,

C - C M - i M M - C i M & W H A

= C C v C E v r W c: <

C U E E A 6 as: m g M 6 C M =

> M U W G CC  ! E > E C C W C - E E M J E >

- D c C au: O Cg as: C E F A U M E E A C W M e - >= >

C C & J E E W W C W

- H W E

> *EC W U W J J W ~ >

Eg W C 6 C W E - E C e > W L E >- .J W E D > W L -

  • E M E

k $

E W

- W E 5 m e C

W

& U W > W C e e W E e 9 e

\

~

e 41ml .e 8

6 9

W W E O C W U 9 m l C J l E A A &

1 < <

$ M W e . W C 6 >

C &

~

O &

C -

E

& *EC E E C as U U W W W C 4 < W b>

W _a C W alC &

C W DE CC C"C D W-W M C&

C E as; y E W D

- EE r C V O WW t E E W WM y

= W EE W J > uC c 2 mv -

> C W C CE E CC <

= c. W WE '.'

H c as:

M C C m W E EE

& 4 GC 4 E E-J Cm W > CW E & EC

& m &

> J W W > UE

- W E&

J D E aC J D k LC Cr C C CC LL. > >E C & WC

- -U V J J W - -C M C2 CE llD < att aC ac 2 E U m -W N NC H W W aC C E EE C D D at E J JC

> as: 4C E W W >-

at:

E E

A e o 49

W

, I Z

C l M C W Z C aC W W H Z M W W EE W E <W C. W CC W ,

E W

E Z

8' Cc H et AZ W E. W C DE C H ZW E Z eC C W at CE E HZ C W Z e:

W W WE C. *E W E ^WL llll> > CL. C C M - UC Z ClC C ZC C H H CC et CC

- m W E 4:

M > H C D C L M CC J Z H.

a- *C -

  • U e:C y H>M Z ** = toZEZ C H m C d e; C C U Z W eC 4: UM-W C.3 Ww-H

> E Z M > J > ec  ?

C C C et - C. C U i-D Z Z = H N C. eg m H L.J W Z I eC E M E 8 eC M J>

et Z U w w eC J eC C = C - eC C ~ - 4 2 UD CE CE to C. C3WC C W W C. - W C.

W H C eG H w in H

- eC D Z k CC k L C: W = eC ,

C U C C H CC M U 4M (M ww M W CC ZW Z C. J J W N W C> C U CD C.

> EC CD - E I eC C.

> E H I La.J W H eC H W D eC C CC 4.8 et > Z C: M - C. W Z Z = HE E C 2 H W EA C UU W L U Z C: I CE *O H m D CC W Z M Cf j'

J CE C EC M WZ et U W W= CZ~ '

4A M CA C.WHW U W =wm

- C: C W> WHJ=

L C. H CC H CC C ~ >

- - Z cc c U W C DJ C W *C et W C W C aC C C: C C. Q W WD W H EC C M E Z CE C7 EMUH W

e . .

b M b 4

i-f.

1 e t W

e M MEC ECW e W WEE C Z MQU A H JOZZ e Z AK-CW

~ LL ~J e = HC M C M> e<~

< W HMHM H C~CMM

= Z W

ZJc C A

U C-C D E HU .

M W MDWMM J w uc<

< E CZC->

W e - ECZCJ cm M W <ZE CH W C >W ~C

- > Z mMAW  !

MC - WCm

-D e W C3 CUM M e Z< m C3EC Z e H M CzuZ C H H E W Z<W M

- Z ZZ < E <=&WW M C ~W C < MHH

= U C C < LAC- 3 J w MZ O C WC EM 4 W C WW c Z E ZC Z se Z >L L < <3CWZ C H mW W HC U Z t HC C C Z-MZ-W CZ Z W C>--H o

> E M -- C - mWM U C C Z H W Mc<ED D Z C -2 *

  • W =WC H W ~ EC M H COLHH M E H - C Z HEHM C < Z C W Z WWZ N >C = C MM CC C - c= H - ee -m v c Z HH W Z EMMC C < M< E EW CCWHH 6 C DC W> ==J <

g CZ

  • wm Ha M L C ZW Z CC UE=ZM C wZ C WWHCK J E - WW A w-C M < HC H >M MZ3HH W C cu < << ZC UU

> C CW N = m-ZWW m > Ac - M HCAA H M L Z MW UUmMM

< M Cc < HJ EWHZZ Z W MC C ZL ZAC==

c W 6 E WE MH W C C C EC WZZZW H c Em WX M-WCZ J L < U >W < EWW

< C & C WWWHC

> WW Z EC E1W =

U C cc AZ U-AUM

- <E W E- Z=ECW L M cD > - 3' mMmZE .

- H DE C C l V - O E >J W C uu a EJ L D ZW E <C M < WM - E6 W

m o e b M T

\

Og

_ m

~ ~

Vi t

WM MWE Ccw A=>

8 DC CCU EW "CC Z &

  • C W^W CMM C<

WCW WWz w>U 4 Z WCm 23

^ WWW M + C E E H >

C Z Cc4

- C WWW M U >>m

= w CW3 a cv j U W M >

Z ** MNZ C s Eso {

u Z M Ca-W W ECW .

> E > WUU *.

l C C C=W

  • C Z 8 CA H W CCM M E M ZmE

< H

<Ew W

C C CLW E C Z <

l -

C <

W

^

5" WCu WE

  • 6 > *E C >

E E" CE D" l M < mWW W 4 ccW '

> 0 C Z

- C EW-W E AC l C

  • Z Z -

HCm l E W

w CJ JO H -C *

< Z MEW W C ~Z U C Z MC i

- Z < *< J k W MIA

> 4 >H S U W C=WW .

W C CCJM '

A Z >DDC M - MCEC W I b @

I

p 1

l b to O E J C 4A CL

  • >E to JW E sEC W Z a

> eC >

C H C3 -

W H ZJ C - U W-

> D Z H aC O as: CL CC C E eC

  • CL > W CU H C .

C C:f J W ! to Z aC W CC st: W eC C to W M t.D I Z A-2' LAJ C D eEC et c C: C CC 2 aC - U H CL y Z = CL to est H W > es >

Z E C H CE C > - -HC H

O CC > JZH H i C - W *C et C Cc Ec E :

O >- 6.J C. eC W D Z J- - C t.D W = 4 C C et W !p E  ! - M ZZC 't E - CC et aC C C3 W to CL E U j l

v aC > Cr x Ce W C W WUZ  ;

CC M W

  • W CE 6 = a Z > C *ZW

> > to W H W N O ZM = - H IW=

C aC W H J Z CL to E P- UV C - W E aC -

th aC Z C E aEC W Z JC W es: W X CC *-= '

O. CL C C W t.J E CL M A att Z et 2 m C E CC - C C et C Z La. - M Z E W a at CH E C LA v aC - W - =

C.D C C H C e m to Z C: C *C to > Z m >= C C J ZJC 2M C >- W act at

  • WZ CL W Z CC Z >-

WC Z eC C *EC U EU CL C CL C W U U E CC W CL MC I L.J > CL M to Z W Q Cf CZ U act C: C y eC -

E CL > M C: U ZZ J - Z I E

  • C U CE > H e; W- C: et: C WCW

>M Z W ec > C p-CW C CE CC C CC W C. CL C C:

EA EEC

-C o o o - et E

  • N

I o ll

[

2

[

t N

>=

J aut B

C C

W C

m W {

Z > .

as .c I CC CC C A C E C: -

1 LLJ C En m Z m 8C C W J Z

  • C LaJ m C >

U -

8

= E U

>- et W W Cc w E C W C W m

  • Eg W 2" Z A aC" D CC C' m

-- U m

>= > CC C e. e

-

Z W

Zm U eC Z ~ m Z E C- "

Z W W i C=

CC 5 C E

W m e

et i

E Z >- C E E m eC - aut < aC < E

- W W Z c Z Z aC; Z3 m E - et C C Ce CW aIC W W E C C - C

  • - W E - C:: W W C' C m> Cc W J W CL. as J Cc mW <. O est C Z N C

=

L

- CE < C et C -

m W Z C" C C" ~ >- m CC

  • C et Z >- - W C >=

h- E W = La. Z CC Cf W m - >

UZ CC C CC C W C = U Z C W W W C C >- - m >= W C C C WE C: W 3 >- m W Cc - m - at:

= CL E > W - m et CL e C m W L

^ P- C :D C - Z W > W Z U >

ac" i E C > C Z Z Z J CC - W >- C w 1 L.J C. W E W C C et W L CE C: C

.C C> eC E CE > - - Z 3 W m < ~ C W ~ L - W >- 40 C Z Z A = Z LaJ >- O C N CL U W U U J W - M-

> Z Z Z U t U W W C N C C N W

- WW O C I >- W CL CL Z Z - E C: W L C

>- EW C - W m W m m W C m eC W - - W >

<. WZ W 6- C: C W Z Z C - W W at: C = Z C et Z > aCll Z CL CL W - - W W CC >= U - W at: - C CE C CE > W W CC W C: D C llst W D W E m 3 L.J >- m J Em > c: W m 8C - et M c., o' o e o e o C e o o e o asC e o n

S 4 g.

s- w. . . .. * .

t f

i i

En W

U GC W

E W

C E 3 - ol p

I M U '

E D W C. *

=  %

>- La E &

D E 5 W W W

  • C E C 2- W X eC C

- m lll: E

  • C E E W .

- e: E D c Lt E C t., C et W C E E H H I C. E E m W W eC m et E E W W C W W E E W C C C C W C C C to M C C E E W

  • C H est eC lll>

W m m E E -

E m N

> en W C. J C eC C.

et E U C E W W Cr W E C WC E

> > > Z W LL.

W w aC E @ w C. V O C H C 3 Clc

  • W U E W W W Z E E E W C = W M C. W eC L
  • E => Z E W C C C.=

m La. to C W = W E E

> W W ~ E C D M eC C H E C E E N C EC @ W W C - E W c @ H C w > e- H D W > > eC E ,

H === K W E H U E - i eC E D J C=

m w e-= W C H E C m C. W C J  % ~ ~

W > a E E elC et C M E '

C. cc W C C W D E W - '

C C. E W U CC CT C. C -J g' . . . o \

e N m W 60 g m m M l

l we 4 . . . . .. . ,,

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20134F644&oldid=2874538"