ML20132D630

Informs That Multiple Allegation 84-A-0100 Reviewed During 840807 Allegation Panel Meeting.Ebneter Will Direct Technical Investigation Beginning 840813 at Site.Record of 840715 Telcon & Related Info Encl

ML20132D630
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	08/20/1984
From:	Murley T NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To:	Christopher R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
Shared Package
ML20132D624	List: ML20132D621 ML20132D630 ML20132D641 ML20132D646 ML20132D667 ML20132D676 ML20132D688
References
FOIA-85-560 NUDOCS 8509300239
Download: ML20132D630 (13)

Text

UNITED STATES N

[,8 ,.  %'g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMI REGION 1 I

• • g L j

• & 431 PARK AVENUE

1. 's, ,8 KING OF PRUSSIA, PENNSYLVANI M g g 7: SE Cf E fh,fg p, g MEMORANDUM FOR: R. Keith Christopher, Director, Office of Investigations Field Office, Region I FROM: Thomas E. Murley, Regional Administrator

SUBJECT:

MULTIPLE ALLEGATION 84-A-0100 The subject multiple allegation was reviewed and discussed during a routine allegation panel meeting on August 7, 1984. It was determined that Mr. Ebneter, DETP, will be directing the technical investigation beginning on August 13, 1984 at the Seabrook site. This inspection by DETP will not include interviews with QA/QC personnel regarding possible intimidation. However, I am requesting that you conduct an interview with the alleger to first determine if further investigation into intimidation of QA/QC personnel is warranted. If you have any questions concerning this request, please contact me.

Thomas E. Murle Regional Administra or I q

CC:

Allegation File RI-84-A-0100 I R. Gallo S. Ebneter T. Martin i

8509300239 850916 PDR FOIA GROSSBE85-560 PDR 1I

. ~

/

7 /jf g ,

CONVERSATION RECORD ""h.g f

O VISIT O CONFERENCE g TELEPHONE - -

@ INCOMING Nautisvu g INT Locat.on of % sit / Conference: O OUTGOING

"~ -

NAME OF PERSON (Si CONTACTED OR IN CONTACT ORGANIZATION (Omce, dept.. bureau. T[LEPHONE NO.

wiTH YOU etc )

Mh D h 'u A n ii< '

SUBJECT

,b f & .LU$sA/LEH3

~

(/nm 4A--

LLL.C_.__ ,/AA ,AZ&uh mL A A+ rn w v A-> vl /2& bM x,JL 2 W As J u//Ar~1m /

r / Aw .x 1* W Jjn J f /,

f/$ / . 41 .Mh fL 4W,_L/ // i1 A L-~wL &A2L,'

iJLu'1 1sMLL Aw h.

ACTION REQUIRED f

NAME OF PERSON DOCUMENTING CONVERSATION SIGNAT F DATE

$ U Ao C YO AFAIS pp ACTION TAKEN

~

/

lf 1

sicNATURE TITLE DATE

"##8-888

• ec : sus o - ms.sn mm CONVERSATION RECORD g4Ljow 2fyg,7,5) l . . . . . . . . . .

IseC POmas M '

tlA eIUCLEA3 C 00VLA704Y Commmesacus sNVESDGADON STATUS RECORD vcTeous % i- . m. % , w e, ame . . w ,, m m, n w me um e.

se e., wm n.s. ww w cm e. ==e. n==, v. ,,w e, e. m. nw -w , w ti s ,=,,

, o % .e w c .r.

CAS: .U. dst- CA,800.y o8 7 eC4 o . ,,ue,,,c. .cron . . mo.viova 6 ce=us Q-1-84-020 T c g m ya . ] . ...,... 01:RI

, . .. oo,, . . ,,...

am cato to su u ct bEASR00K NLJCL EAR GENERATING STATION / IMPROPRIETIES IN THE PULLMAN HIGGINS QUALITY ASSURANCE PROGRAM ST ATUS ($p.c4 abre, eW ars rua, e 6eW m.res, raw 9 August 10, 1984: An inquiry has been initiated at the request of the Regional Administrator to detennine if there is a basis for an investigation into allegations that Pullman Higgins Quality Assurance Inspectors were being ordered not to perfonn inspections of unacceptable welding. Estimated completion date of preliminary Inquiry is September 1, 1984. $ g August 31, 1984: Alleger interviewdd, field work pending.

I r

[ }

v' September 28, 1984: No Change. -

November 2, 1984: Review of allegers technical concerns satisfactorily completed and documented. One additional 01 interview required prior to closure of investiga-tion.

November 20, 1984: CLOSED Y

l

• 4 3

CHRON0 LOG 3 CAL RICORD OT INQU3RY OR 2NVESTICAT3DN L

• CLOSED:

., OPENED:AUG. 10, 1984

'%NTROL NO: Q-1-84-020

SUBJECT:

SEABROOK TIME ACTIVITY DATE D n,,>,v.ogu a 4 %>AtJ N y~ y (gg t z&-

7 lpo*0.febdf f fe

$ 9 Py c<t.46 f/ 5l< kva2 07 8 % 6 O V ' ' *1 aatd,4ek ar&.A Cdda A w<DgYAvl 4 av .sa Arb/

gfjo<a s .2)itNAb'% 6u&-<ct wezz 9&Cac>,w A A s W), JnWI*

& })-fn g ) // (pg./l

,T h N Y k YdWg (ptDE o2 Ad. 7 2 +

• /'t D

.s<ecaz .

h %.

ad-s g f-~>v n wp+A7n U l'O 4 // '$.h' g//e/f (j l lj & ' b e Z ) -,. )

&W$*2d'

.,. O a6ar&#.-$ p & PJ m pay 1/-fs MQ O 9 0 W ^5

. be . M J 9 J'-/

D0 NOT DISCLOSE [k/WM#D [. M D z / b

((

• This document may contain information exempt from public disclosure.

h5 Y

CHRON0 LOG 3 CAL RICORD OT INQU2RY OR 2NVIST3CA720N l

, P GE 2 '

e

' M ROL No:

0-1-84-020 OPEND: Aug. 10, 1984 CMSG:)[,Jo,y

SUBJECT:

-SEABROCK/ IMPROPRIETIES IN THE PULLMAN HIGGINS QUALITY ASSURANCE PROGRAM DATE TIME ACTIVITY

1. W* SGA~k V &gy 0 9 JO f)/AM ~/

}ptJ/

L*y-1 '> },J &"

7

^9- ~

ll') b ' 8Q a

i i

P T

i l DO NOT DISCLOSE ,

l' This document may contain infomation exempt from public disclosure.

i 1

1

• 9

= ,

j,l. h'<Q j J&tw *

[l's hc" u+x - s ~ 9 nus

/92 0 m.

m /W3oo f4f'&cl ~pn@)<</67 eE

.pyqqad i JJ^p a ;ya - f ~ ~ a 9 m tre~

nas~

u,JnAsm JyyA q%e nup wnm ~4, pas,

/.,~ b~~

.<~i~,a p ,aJ jnd m:Md, Au H ~y, s-c~a 4 Ar.!? ~ /d y& w }& 62rjanQ  ?

L4s n 1.&A G ,Jdd a & J cs A n s N'

&we -

P W' oM& , &~ m s ~

"y JM syn , ,

'f./2<$34dBam

& % A~ .w 99+.

p c- ka +3 d6&& xf kw'

?

unr k %M K u& A

'$ A

.r.4- 4 v'A C-A- + A6 ~

o I f

1/98)'/

k,/wjeJvs a/ A % w um w-ydA

. Esq wsAn wMA

-mJx inac . -J &~ q C /3 5 - G M /4' j s 9;ax JMAnhula}s'AJs

$0 6

& n d Y OG %qxs,wm k p Lu vsv A on p&ayto-f

' J%m JJ)/, J L.m segjafAym&~Y sw~ sp g b w M A+ d d e k j.sv -

ixnDar.dm 9& A A2JMf e~J A or n ,e dAAd~e /scs wA4

& m].A%s& T2, &t#~~)-Vw a77-s mm Lazum=/Amd ., q w . 1 / ~ A 4 p h

and Awep w&sA

&~kb p Mud- m.

/>fMa -

OmJA xcAM y ,. A 2 :~ h G *mb, sZpaah)

/2 w . 2 - p u f p w .ef s -

-erpaa~4 m

/ K/*e 3~#" d@

YA 3 - L;/d uJ dg Am a j

~.p d aAM. xA

/mJda w A-J w .uCv.p . s+a n An

D 4

[

um. -)Adon A rumsq~nt J<y d&

D w o cls41. gct c9. -~tL m.aA,a 4Arnsu zf A + J=c Y

% kW k /d 'W~N MA u~s.2nAA .h uupa

.<~q' etic 7 V ~ Ac/m.- & -sc. m N r p a w ;i a n .

w

,q w A J b ce 24 d d A,/; u/ w-,

p- (ncuGJm Ju?

J in A p 4-w AA & A' q J 8 4

-[Av sj Af .A /'!cr.4 m av m JdA A wa/w

.LYA &p

-J-L w

P & ,.-< m m .Am,osmw b-. f} j ) J W .A~/ M' ' w'I'

1. a swA s pe,-cM J (A s w+-2-eJ4 sosn t) /wcAJ

m n .m '

6d Ux4' C fm

&/ d?

as n,

K+A.Am

. 9s Ap tysv -ra J w w Ad Ar " 7 h~ rd&&x.

sos w .i9&/;7r y /M7 .fA u n'

/dc [ A }.A n sf/W

.swJm o~gv~ 67; e add A)0u~cAn'

/

/sa a p aA K , A~.J~f % ia>

wa <a-/tes ch. y)(c~ O w -cA<A

/ Y YNfdd fib $

b) pdJ A f ~w/ foJ~b,%

/ p^ n 1% A n h agA u ~Jafp A v &pi<k y fyw,

+/awg'

/ t<~ & s -9 /n <pJm#4m

,~ A

/hib~G So-a - HH<~ + %

Jesu ~6 f& &, t 9) .5 x 7%Aa: : . 4 e a .;::- U Sm ja am~s;1)t4~am-A w da J b

m'

-ws~s /

>JJa n a n he/ ./J .

Ma b~ trad/Adj h) A ff-

/ 3 pg ~

gagn

/ w n_

&A-bdm sm p+ ,A -

&j, y, ayc wp/ ~

KJ w a.- Mi L >&y'. f . <.

0@ n. / k+A , 6< !& = ; 4 9f.).sjJ' d

.24 d p <v ro./sMw A } k J m dma ArP .49 w Alw" d b f-e 4 - <&~ W nQ$19a ~~f##A m st/b

>m-fdA-u-&-

W '7 ag

/' 4  !

g j'. 3 ) 'I'fca+ - g 4 h h J,J Jw-a s sH '%.ef-L6 $ mb gn #A g> p - f JJB .-, 4 fx CA22 l g n 1,4 /

g . p ~il &c

< spy A f+ 4~& 1 P. 5 / k N ' u ,r d l' ff s~s -

naa-vam s~ z 1L bw&W.

/Ea- J mke D9 eyoc2AW' Juqa Am n c.Joka#,

.24 n mm 24 - Kbsp' J A M s~7/2-< M a;/soir emx

) stu n T ef , den je 1-cA M e A tm.M' su--s2 ; pen m JA>'

& .2 T .6 w o!o dl l

_ /n <w A np&

t a

im un~~h~sw amv ad spes w & s<ay.

.-e6- geh%

M a ac? Q w P& > % &cc w & - , iv < cA/a4 a

hfsvb= 2 75 ,. <

&~6-sxw'J w n$r-M/~-(.Vs Acm

& . M/qaw'saJeua udgAdaup i AcA tTd/ AA<.tn M y A m s~~rJ- q/~A ngb y.ske

.usmas .e._

,+ a .dd d + 1 %?

l &<df.v &f&& 8J A.yf>r b-

e ,

h

)% f

^% 14 }.9 fs4 f4%

f ~

m '- m d/ J a & m u, /4 AW

"/]x A lL n uit2/jw Ja<JAtuwlc ' v Aixm ..

Wd^\ Ykb d ._ d &

• W dadp MJz} Aene.d MA jfW $

f J a a ac ~ 4 4 o diaJyjaA p z w .

IJs-k c A dw?

[ /O '3o AM i

1 1

1 I

f

T I

' ~

9,.m

/) d (/6 G.5 8) n Ils'*i, f-h

//f/Y/

9<.s-</."& E p 3yv -

. >ve vd .-6y .l'n. !/b a a p / li p / fGo,- /x< A, %.a

, 4-r~ . J ,/ ; ;,ijch ..,6s/ A c ' $ /

/ba v eave- ./<-c 4 L; n. n /.? u. . .W/lw U c~, n u-n. 6 /bnw -

/ -d.

t is <: J -fu J .~ ~ ! _,d'/v &< ,g c. . . -t x , .s%d /~ l- Y /.1.,./

1 JJh~

em s,ws4!,xAv;/.., c] s'-j./ s~

wwj% A& any. svAg y wyn . ~ A6 un<% ,. b f ,

w:44 ./u;hvfsw.1 /v/ ug  :

f3'-t/'/#4 A> eni/. I' /< O J';  !

'Lc'$4-4:h ' l'hyf .-, >4% lnf ,/ 9.

tu /;w A'm 4 sup ,

m/ / Asy%6= 4?d 4msv A~-6 ~ MW th uw~ fJw.p/m j f &.- + - g w ' W 4. l ' . A u g , -/.2

- . l,Va;.I/ W 8 W & W Y u, QM W maff /M

/b d As-SvAr/ / & -64 .n n ,f 'a< A z) -

/-/'s ~ Mad ./<br4d2k

/ r % M m + .- ~ k / 4 & ,'

')

~

f) s,l ,

y. ~ .h A gj' =

J~xl:s/C. '

,ej +l,,..,.. + .

Ap.. . , .

w!<;

, - b , e - J h o s J W ~, d 1b 1L

/ .

~

NY X m m /4 J 7f papn J pa & n_w+va.1 da p gl9 J>p f 3-O -40 Uw gm

-> rs v. / .~. -

A44)M^ o.u~ A yp $p +;J . >

./J AA gen 46,4) M 4 f.ys,

~4s . sm .

/~n W W , / M k A J P m W ,2c.-l;/'eb _

w e

// sw"J p-&e -

a&w wdx//&M h w apem =+ $ ..a --,,pp , g.

- un OEb OxR mra ndscr+

jLcok m _

m. - .

INW-e er-mee. a esa v- e e a-mm--.. w-m,e - y ammowh- ._,-w-m.#.m .. , -, ,is4 gm,.. , . e -e ,..

mhm a eh 2 e ,s e m-.

• %.- .-. , ee-p-,. - e_ , em M g . > - _ , ,,g-a _4 m *- -e-wwa + ~ 4 -- e- u- emme., . ,, w >

$ 4 4g , .--we-ea p 5 m - e,.g esu 4- e 4.-.~e-e am e am mW_e e 4 s -w- e ee weg eas- e me go., ,..ww -me -n aggm. men w q.una==4- INN

• weadem- .mww-@e= .ee-+= g Meem $ hem unes***6m 646deh6 @*eh eef g6 =44'h m- -e. -sind-ee h h += eg e m + egg mee p-=.g,w ,

OA*i==.hW wimb =@

• r==w=