ML20128L111
| ML20128L111 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Beaver Valley, Millstone, Calvert Cliffs, Peach Bottom, Salem, Nine Mile Point, Indian Point, Oyster Creek, Pilgrim, Susquehanna, Vermont Yankee, Haddam Neck, Ginna, Yankee Rowe, Maine Yankee, FitzPatrick, 05000000, Crane |
| Issue date: | 07/05/1985 |
| From: | Ronald Bellamy NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I) |
| To: | Muller D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8507110244 | |
| Download: ML20128L111 (5) | |
Text
i r
e JUL 0 5 Bi$
MEMORANDUM FOR:
Daniel R. Muller Assistant Director for Radiation Protection Division of Systems Integration Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM:
Ronald R. Bellamy, Chief Emergency Preparedness and Radiological Protection Branch Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards Region I
SUBJECT:
REGION I EVALUATION OF INDUSTRY SUCCESS IN ACHIEVING ALARA - INTEGRATED RADIATION PROTECTION PROGRAMS AT POWER REACTORS The Region I staff has performed the specific ALARA-related radiation program evaluations that were requested in the memorandum of Hugh Thompson, Director, Division of Licensing to R. W. Starostecki, Director of Reactor Projects, Region I dated May 8,1985.
The results of the evaluations are contained in enclosure I.
For purposes of the evaluations, each facility was matched with the radiation specialist inspector (s) from the BWR or PWR Radiological Protection Section that is (are) most knowledgeable in that facility's radiation protection program. The cognizant inspector (s) then completed
.the appraisal summary sheets for the appropriate facility for. Criterion 6 and Criterion 10 based upon current and past knowledge gained through previously performed inspections. The resident inspectors then reviewed the appraisals. -The resident inspectors generally agreed with the Radiological Protection Sections' appraisals with slightly more favorable assessments in certain instances.
In the event of differing opinions as to the appropriate rating, both are listed.
In the event of a multiple unit site operated by one licensee (e.g.,
Calvert Cliffs I and II) only one evaluation was performed and is deemed applicable to both units.
There were ten facilities (listed in enclosure II) in Region I that were not included in the review process because either they were not operational or operational for a short period of time.
The results indicate that for both categories evaluated, most of the licensees are generally performing satisfactorily.
While several facilities are rated as excellent there are facilities that are in need of improvement in their ALARA programs.
gh P
0FFICIAL RECORD COPY o
'6 2
If you have questions concerning the results, please contact John White (FTS488-1373) or Kevin Holsopple (488-1390) of my staff.
Drl[51 Signed By; Ronald R. Bellamy, Chief Emergency Preparedness and Radiological Protection Branch Division of Radiation Safety and Safeguards, RI
Enclosures:
As stated cc:
J. Taylor B. Murray (RIV)
.D.
Ross C. Eaperiello (RIII)
A. Roecklein R. Hinogue D. Moeller (ACRS)
M. Federline J. Cunningham T. Martin E. Jordan F. Congel R. Cunningham (NMSS)
R. Starostecki
-J.
Roe H. Kister J. Buchanan S. Collins J.-Wigginton E. Wenzinger D.-Collins (RII)
R. Serbu F. Wenslawski (RV) bec:
R. Bellamy J. White M. Shanbaky K. Holsopple W. Pasciak M
RI:DRSS R DR
(:
SS RI:DRSS Beljmiy l
Holsopple Wi 3
ak 7/,5 /85 7
/85 7/
/85 7/ 5 /85 S
KUI i
RI:DRS k DRSS RI) li ns
/(85 Shanba y Ma ti n S.
7/ 3 /85 7/ _
/85 7/
\\
\\
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY n
EtiCLOSURE I
CF.:iEF:A #
10 FACILITY
SUMMARY
RATItiG SHEET REGI0fl I
Ratinas of Individual Evaluators Facility Averace Ratina ll ilitv/ Unit 1
2 31 4
5' 6
7i 9
101 111 12 (0,E.S IM,IU)
~l
[
1 il E
l, 1
- e'vce Valley 1 E
S
.b I
' ' ert C1i.1/2 S
E
?
.3.. ! Ii '.: P at r i c k S
S IM al3fena E
i E
.._5.$HCddam tieck S
S 6
I r.di an Poi nt 2 S
S h
S 7
Ir.di an Poi nt 3 S
S 8
Maine Yankee S
S
? Milistone 1/2 S
S I
'i.e Mile Pt.1 S
3 E
l
- l Oyster Creek E
E IM
'2 Osach Ecttom 2/3 IN IM l
23 3ilgrim IM I
S
'. 4 Salem 1/2 S
E E
'. 5 Susquehanna 1
- S iMI I S
S E
17 7ermont Yankee E
S-S
.'_.3_Yankee Rowe
'9 I
20 4
Sumary Rating for All S
(0=4,E=3,5=2,IM,IU)
Facilities Surnary Rating Perfomed by <Mhme / M y m b'.
Date 4, _2 7as-
........ g,,
-.... -. ?/ -... L,
.. ~...,.
EllCLOSURE I CF.ITEF.:A #
6 FACILITY
SUMMARY
RATItiG SHEET REGION I
Ratinos of Individual Evaluators FacilityAveraSeRating]
j
? cility/ Unit 1
2 3'
41 5
6 7
9 i-101 lle 12 (0,E,S,IM,10) 5 S
_1__:e av e r V al le v I S
2
- 'lvert Cli.1/2 S
E S
.._3_. I ?i.: Patrick S
S
, l,!
a b.i r..3 E
E i
S 5 IHaiin tleck 5
e
- r.fiin Point 2 IM IM h
S t
7
.ndi an Point 3 S
S S
2._.l tai re Yankee S
S
.9 _':illstone 1/2
- ~
S S
- 3
'.i re Nile Pt.1 E
E S
- 1 Cyster Creek 52ch Bottom 2/3 IM IM
.2 b IU 13 2il grim IU
- 4 3alem 1/2 S
S
_ _5 Suscuehanna 1 E
E
- S
?."I I' E
E 1_7_7ermont Yankee S
S
'_. 3 (ar.kee Rowe E-E
'. 9
.:0 Sumary Rating for All S
l (0=4,E=3,5=2,1M,IU)
Facilities Nor%. N4 c ch.
Date 6-2 7-As Sumary Rating Performed by _
. y-Q...;.id..'M~k.
.- M '~'i -.
2:- _-
,e ENCLOSURE II PLANTS EXCLUDED IN ALARA REVIEW Beaver Valley II Hope Creek Limeri ck Millstone III Nine Mile Point II Seabrook I Seabrook II Shoreham Susquehanna II Three Mile Island II 1
0FFICIAL RECORD COPY l
4
-,