ML20127G480

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Palo Verde Units 1,2 & 3.Forwards Documents Listed in App a & B. Documents Also Available in Pdr.App C Documents Completely Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 5)
ML20127G480
Person / Time
Site: Palo Verde  Arizona Public Service icon.png
Issue date: 08/28/1992
From: Grimsley D
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To: Bradley Jones
AKIN, GUMP, STRAUSS, HAUER & FELD (FORMERLY AKIN
Shared Package
ML20127G485 List:
References
FOIA-92-87 NUDOCS 9301210274
Download: ML20127G480 (9)
v • d • e


Text

'

. . w. .+~i c

.. .. .. . . , y

.s FOIA - f.R - F7

,e. .m ,,,,

RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF O{...../

5, +M/ Mf )be INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST F^i 'F '* ~ll !'* '-~

AUG 2 81992 DiK R (l 4 LtVh t h(Si fif pl't 4 d!ae i Hi Out hit H rh. [stnL / T'

. _ , . _ _ _ _ - - . . _ _ . _ . t i 1. - A G t LY AlCORDS Hi- Li ASE D OR NOT t OC A1i D (5ce d+rW ton /

Nu Hent's retuds subpst to the revist t a,e taen wied Nu eht one' ne .c y rex ords sutyett to the rea.4est bare bet n kx aW Requested retoeds s'e awabie thro.wh annther putdic d'stobution peoyam Lee Commenu secUo6 k Arn(y retords sutyect to the rewest that sie kientihed in Appervia W NHC Pubbe Duc ument Room. 2170 L St:r+t, N W., Washm;; ton DC..

M are abe ad v a,34h!e for pubhc inspet tion and copying at the Arnc y records sutet to the re: Nest that are Hentified in Append ufesi___._ are being made a,ehtde for pubhc inspect'on and copying

[ ot t he N AC Pubhc Doc ument Room. ?!?O L Street. N W.. Wamington. DC. m a fob!ct under tho F OI A numt er.

The nonproonotary ve,pon of the propowl's) that you syn d to er tept m a te4 phone (omersation w th a member of my staf f is now being made ave 11able for pubbt wpatDon and (opy.ng at the NRC Pubhc Dm ument noom. 21?O L Speet. N W., Wushmgton, DC. in a folder under tha F OI A number.

Arocy re'.ords submt to the request that are identif ed in Appe rda(es)____ m y bru inspa ted and (opel at the NHC Local Pubhc Document i

Room idenOf>ed m the Comments atticn.

I nr bsed is mformation on how yna vna y obtam a'ms to and the t hats for coNog retords located et the NHC Pubuc Document Hoom. 2120 L Street, N W Washgtan DC A rnt y ret ordi subjec t to the reoun t d'e enclusmi Het o+th sd a t to the req .est bon tmen rt ferred to another f +11e rW atrnt yhes) for r ev en and d: ret t rnporae to you r eci You wiu t e ided by the N HC f or fees totahng $ ________.

't us a >h a n e've a re f und f rom th+ N h C m the c.eunt of $ ___

in v's a of N PC $ response to th s 'e pest, no f urther action es t.< % t A 4 1 on app @ h-u n dat ed _ _, ,No PART 11. A-INIORMATlON WiiHHI LD F HOM PUBLIC DISCLOSURL Certain inbrmativn in the reunted ucords is tiring withheid f rom putA disciosee pu suant r to the eumptions descrited in and for the reasons stated in Part H,11. C. and D. Any et !rned portW of the docuenents fc r w hich only part of the record is t ce g withheld are t eing made available for putTlic

, rip ction and wov ma in it e tv HC PubLc Dowmcr t Room,21:?O L Street. N W . WaAnton, DC in a bi ter order this F OI A nu mbe r .

COYME N TS i

l l

D~ t a u+t uoH. olv < as or ia t 60V Of M UHYAiQN AND PubUC AllONS St HVICL5

. _ Atyt b (.11hf[L f

(

9301210274 920020 PDR FOIA JONES 92-07 PDR -

NnC f ORM 464 (Part O 41-911 m

_ _ . . . . . _ . _ _ _ . . - _._ _ =

t u,. we . %, w. '

C

  • RESPONSE TO TREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (folA) REQUEST FOIA - "

t (CON 14NUAllON) $UO 2 01932 1 6 * ..

P Aft _i.i.l .il_- APP.~i tC Alll t i RI MP.ilON S _ . -_ _ .. . . , . . .-

. -- ~ -

_m._ . - - - _ . . _

HMords sutiest to the tNuest that est dtatutbnf lei the enclose <ej AppendiafesL.._ _are tacing wwthMd in theit entirety or in part under ttw bemptiott No it) and fut the reason (s) given t t% pursuant to 6 U.S C %241 arid 10 CF H 9 I Na) of MC veyutations.

-- , - - - - - -~ - _ ~ . --- - - . -

,..e.~--...--.-.--pert, 1 ; the weodwid mtmmatam t. inst.f.ed is p sw6uent to laewtive Ord*<. (f sempoon 1)

.m ___ ~ . , _ _ _ . _ _ _ . . _ --.-- _ - _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ , . . _ _ _ , _ _

. _ _ . , _ . . . . . ._. _ . _ ~ _ _ _ . . _ . ._

  1. 1he e. 0.hed etwmahon retaies solei, to tu mitenet 6 e**mpel subes amt p<o< ed ees of NC (t ***puo" Fl 3 The cothi+4s mfmm 5mn .s 6m.ibt

~

r a ', esempted feum pot 4 d4 iewe 4. sis'utA W84swd d aemetion 31

- _ . . ~ . - , , . . . . . . _ ~ -

gss . '

fetions t a1146 of the Atorruc f resv Act, wh*h swof +vti the om tomie of flettorm!Ive or I wmetty Menuiued Date 142 U S C. 21612 H.f,L Lectnon 14 7 of the Atomit inegy Act, die prutotmi the rimlotwo of Umlasphed $4 epanos information (47 U.$ C. 2167), 9 a

a+ it, wipJiews msn emn .o a teede seuet m e onin,cet .o oe f.nanoM mfEmenori that in't. ems anhheid tcw ste seestviint se.d4atert it iempt on el e

3

% ti.e osmm.m.a i. u e...ea to be umbd mor bu.mei. ip.op.4 te<o amm.m.n

. . _ _ . _ _ - _ _ ,___m..-. , . _ _ _ . ,

wp, , _ . . _ _ _

_ _ _ . - . _ _ ~ _ -

., /

the entumenon es <nnoucved to be peopneier, ,,dmme.on psis .t to t <> c i et 2 neoida ti

- - . . - - . . _ _ . - _ . - . . . _ . . . _ _ i

. , ,. -m _. c .. . _ e d . ._ e _. . t..u.~ e _ , ,_

a L.C - _ . _ _ . . . _ _ . - . - . _ . . . . _ _ . _ . . - _ _ . _ _ . . _ _ _

V ..~ (f se. iptca la Apputatde Poiaep

~6 the wohbeW .etuemsona <w wts u miervnti m m" sax'.c , m was.o ai re v.ra eam.b n e- @ d-*. % e . n e >$ i.!v. bun.

JA, , . _ . ~ - . , _ . . - . . . - _ . . . ~ . . . . - - . , . - - ~ . . . . - . _ - - - ... . . .. _. . . - . . .

De6 t semove ho< ein Dmivies et citannomnalintwmaiam *wid tend to .<A.u sne open rut sw e es,hanue of *desa euenos to ow ochbe at=, p#m ens 4 'l $/teste set opd6 4.e Weihheld in H@t of$8ely. the f M t$ Ff ** *W #Ng 9.tPf1*med W4b the p*eds Unchel stdpimpf wsn I'4fe alto es, np #estonetHg Srj'eg#ble f attwal t

s no,iu.. b.< ,u.e.n>e o ,e...e. oe the m i.

  • mad. ~e-i .n ,,.a co inu, em u.c i.4a ow.w v.m m e o.e ageon. - c,-.---...~w_.m-,

m

~ .-..

n .

.. Atimec, w.uk pu.9_ i pma....__._.......~.v.._....._ ee .Dmmen supred t . e onwm, - mn mp%--.

  • i.nu _d . 4 + -

.___-om,_,...

Attorne, thent pov. ley (Contdant al tom' nun-capum betaeen an etwney amt havbv tiient ) _ -. __ _ _ __ _._ . . _

f, the named mtemenon a e.emrted hem 1-M4 d s**we inte .a a u e aet 'ema e e M raevied evaw M seth t%et, d aempoon 61

-_ -- - . _ . , . , ~ , . . - . . v.-

-. - - . ~ . - - - - - . - .., -

7 the mtht.eki m ammenon t one.sts of sen.mo c etaed W iew erh erwta pune+es and es i mo 94+4# M p.e seatnew eu sied K ienyison 1)

.q_thdosee could seemWy be espeded to nuotste with en enbicent em ett.no 4+ swie d tooid sever tu ume, d retimn ed imt et

' enbecement etta te. mt o.v cud p....ts, s u u# cop.voti io inte ertmn to i .eus b potent.ot *omwimng ne a ,wenon of Nnc vegniernents feum annu a.we it eampoon 7 MH_ _ . _ _

Om k,*we wouw c mSt.t.,ie en un*enanteo invewm M pc s#v panacy M semenon 7ICH T he mimmanon omuu M twm et . <1 ~1 ami r[- [W w owe u o e ' [o a tm i n e.: te o s o re-a s .w i e s of omintenow un, sus it sempi.on 7 (Du

_ - - _ .-- - ~ - ~ - - . - - - - - - . . , - . - ~ + -

, oint H. . - - . _ - _ - - -

l~

~ _ . --.

PART H C - Of NYING Of fICIALS etbeen to m[i on nahnew .t esempg finm pio Pweiuent to 10 08 H 9 Mtd s@n, 9 7%l of om U $ Neve- Rep'awy C maten fepatent te m 1 tt M hun be dm knwe. end pias di p+1on on m <Iwout 4 cont c e to the put hc w tr+st The twns <espons tde fm the denist a e enme rdhc s's enent.f el behe* se cenymg utfoats ard th6 D ekam. D+a.on et I #tedom M loMmet p end Pubbt at ont 1.vu+$ 018.ie M Adenwetmn. fm any denWs that mey te apts a eu to the I est ube Daertor tot Otwest.o 4 (f DOI . - - - . , - - - --

OlNilNG OfitCI AL } ..lif ti 0674 t-. 141 C 084DL D( N4 D Arf't tt AT(' Of f 4CIAL f!O MC.N TAny 10 b fnkt(M. ' . - - .

.. &.f l. - $ --_ -- -- - l-._ ~Y-. -- - . . h _m , .. ,. .- - _ . .

.V_ _U" k .-___ /& .. .

e ..- Wm . m..d,_ _-C $ _-_ .._ _.~b, m 4

_ - . _ - . . . - - , , - ,:.-._.-_.-- - - , - . . - - - - .--A_ ,. . -

1 l

1

- - - ~ ~ _ _ . _ - . - _ _ . - _ _ _ . . _ - - _ . _ . _ _ _ , _ , . . , _ _ - ~ , - +_

_ _ . _ _ . . m.___.~, . - - - . - . . ._._

. ,- _. -____.____ ___._-_ ___' _P A_R T H D - A PP[ AL _RIGH_f $ _ . -. - - -- m._,_-___.--

The detual by tech d86Ving Olfool ede**f.ed in Part H C wy be opp

  • Cat so the Appenete Otht@ idemifwt there_ Any such appeal must be matte m animg a tt$n '60 days t'seceipt Of t his fotp0f St. App #$16 fYIull be 5ddrensed, at oppf 0pflate, to the i becutive D fertne fut Ope +st uni,in the Sneetery at the comm is,on, or to the inyector Gener n, U S. Nscitar -

Regulatory Commnuon. Wnhmgton,00 20$t4, and shoukt clearly stre or' the enutope and in the lettre that 11 is en "Appest f#0m en Nt.af F0f A Decinen." l NRC FORM 464 (Pett N O 9d U.S. NUCLt All EGULATOftY COMMi$$ TON i

~.. _ , a

~,

.g .

f01A-9?-087 APPLNDlX A (PDRAvailable)

Date To from Sub.ie:t i Pages

1. 05/10/S$ 0. McKnfghton E. Br atit (PVNGS)LicenseCondition2.C.18(b) 3 WGR ANPP Accession #850130329
2. 05/22/85 G. Mcrn19bt el. C. Bruht (PVNGS)LicenseCondition2.C.18(b) 1 NRR A*0? Accession #8505300034
3. 03/27/87 NRC Doc. J. Haynes (PVNGS) Additional 1:.formationon 7 Control ANPP [mergency Operating Procedures (DCS) 8704030051 01/25/89 -- --

Palo Verde [$fAC Train B Subgroup 14 (Test relay monthly functional test Cornpletich) 4 02/20/89 DCS D. Karner (PVNGS) GL 88-14 7 ANPP Acc. #8903020424

5. 03/07/69 0. Karner J. Martin Confirmatory Action Letter 2 ANPP R-IV Acc. #8903150026
6. 03/08/89 DCS J. Haynes (PVNGS) Special Report 3 SR-89-002 3 ANPP t.cc. #8903210135
7. 03/17/89 W. Ianning C. Stereed Locations Where Valves Are installed 1 NRR CCI Acc. #8904030125
8. 03/28/89 D. Karner J. Martin Confirmatory Action Letter 2 ANPP NRC Acc. #8904060128
9. 04/03/89 DCS J. Haynes (PVNGS)LER 89-001-00 13 ANPP Acc. 48904130147 o
10. 04/21/89 Control R. Lobel Summary of Heeting Held 4/13/89 20 Components, NRR to Discuss Operation of Atmospheric Inc. Dump Valves Acc. #8904280283
11. 05/25/89 J. Hartin D. Conway Technical Reports file: 89-147-419 132-NRR APSC Acc. #8906050213
12. 05/29/89 J. Hartin F. Conway (PVNGS) Response-to the Augmented 66 R-ly- HRC Inspection Team Report dtd 5/18/89 Acc. $8906120169

6 e Appendix A (Corit.) F01A-92-087 (PDR Available)

Date To from Subject i Pages

13. 06/23/89 J. Martin D. Conway (PVNGS)Restartfile: 89-056-026 4 R-!Y APSC Acc. #8907070126
14. 06/28/89 J. Martin W. Conway (PVNGS) Restart file 056-026 5 R-IV APSC Acc. i8907130287
15. 06/28/89 W. Conway -- Confirmatory Action Letter 2

'NPP Acc. #8907070219

16. 01/28/90 DCS J. Levine (PVNGS)LER 89-001 03 18 APSC Acc. 19002120163 17 06/24/90 J. Itartin W. Conway (PVNGS)Restartfile: 90-056-026 3 R-IV APSC Acc i9007120079

- . . , . , . . , , .-. ,, -. - - w ,,we, e-.--.. --.--,-v.-...- -

m

9 3 f0!A 92-087 APPENDIX B (ReleasetothePOR) 1

{

Date To from Subject l_Pages

1. 08/12/85 W. Bingham C. ferguson Re: Responsibility for long-term 4 Bechtel CE solutions to the physical and o)erational problems found with tie steam bypass valves
2. 01/04/89 B. Mendoza C. Hart Re: Proposal f80760-2 6 Ariz.Nucicar Control Power Projects Components, Inc.
3. 03/03/89 Briefing Sides Re: PV3 3/3/89 3 Loss of Power Event
4. 03/03/89 D. Karner J. Martin Confirmatory Action Letter 2 ANPP R-IV
5. 03/03/89 -- -- Arizona Nuclear Power Project - 14 Action Plan for Unit 3 Reactor Trip Event
6. 03/04/89 -- -- Entrance Meeting - Augusted Inspection 1 Team Annex - EOF Conference Room E 03/04/89
7. 03/06/89 -- -- Miscellaneous handwritten notes 4 Re: PV 3/3/89 event, " Containment Isolation Valve Problems
8. 03/06/89 -- -- Annotated Electrical fault Events 2 with causal factors chart dated 03/06/89 Re: PV3 3/3/89 event
9. 03/06/89 -- -- ASME Section XI History file, 9' Unit 3, computer listing of valves
10. 03/06/89 -- -- Handwritten notes re: 3/3/89 event 1 (loss of power) at Palo Verde 3
11. 03/07/89 B. Coffin Graphics Re: ESFAS Train B Subgroup Relay 4 Ariz.Nuc. Dept. 62 Day Cold Shutdown functional Power Project Test

Appendix 8 (Cont.) F0!A-92-087 (Release to the PDR Date h from Subject i Pages

12. 03/08/89 -- -- Computer record Work Order-333960 2 Re: ESFAS subgroup relay testing
13. 01/25/89 Ptlo Verde ESFAC Train B Subgroup 14 (Test relay monthly functional test Completion) 14 03/15/89 -- H. Davis Daily Highlight Re: Atmospheric 1 NRC Dump Valve failures at Palo Verde
15. 03/15/89 -- -- Detailed Descripiton of Control 9' (FaxDate) Components,Inc.,Yalve(atmospheric- .

dumpvalvesatPaloVerde)

16. 03/16/89 -- --

Agenda for Electrical Meeting 20 3/16/89 - Slides

17. 03/23/89 -- -- Sequence of Events for the 19 (Presented) PV3 3/3/89 loss of power
18. 06/24/90 W. Conway J. Martin Re: restart action items and 1 APSCo. R-IV closing Confirmation Action Letter dated 12/24/89
19. Undated -- -- Annotated 1.isting of Team Hembers 1 for the Augmented inspection Team Plan PV Unit 3 .'ormed for PV3 following 3/3/89 event
20. Undated -- -- Pages 5-13, 5-14, 10-4 from PV 3 SER Re: Atmospheric Dump Valves
21. Undated -- -- Daily Highlight and Draft Information- 4 Notice Re: Atmospheric Dump Valve failures
22. Undoted -- -- Miscellaneous handwritten note and 3 PV1 diagram, Re: Event of 3/3/89.at Palo Verde 3
23. Undated -- -- Systems Description for Atmospheric- 6 Dump Valve Controls, hain Steam __ .

Isolation Yalves. Pages PGS-1A-21 through PGS-1A-26

, 24. Undated -- -- Handwritten classroom training 8 l

notes: Re: Steam bypass-control

- system, reactor power cutback system-I

~

AppendixB(Cont.) f0!A-92 087

-(Release to the PDR Date To from Subject i Pages

25. Undated -- -- Steam Bypass Control System - Events 9 w/ Causal factors Chart and Valve position traces PV3 event of 03/03/89
26. Undated -- -- Handwritten notes Re: APS letter of 1 3/27/89 on emergency operating procedures
27. Undated -- -- Briefing slide on CCI Valves dated 3 04/10/89
28. Undated -- -- PV Tests Results Report 92CH-36S9 38 Re: testing the Safety Equipment Station System
29. Undated -- -- Recorder per traces for pressurizer 2 pressure, cold leg temperature SBCS valve position, for steam generator pressure
30. Undated -- -- Safety injection Tank drawing 2 schematic
31. Undated -- -- Control Room Discrepancy Records 17-beginning 2/27/89 and ending 3/5/89
32. Undated -- -- Telephone notes of event of 2 3/3/89 at Palo Verde 3 (lossofpower)
33. Undated -- -- Typical-single line drawing 1-Palo Verde Electrical distri-bution Urdatei -- Work Order 332774 to perform 4, 34 --

surveillance test 73ST-32Z10 ASitE Section XI Valve Test

35. Undated -- -- Handwritten notes Re: sequence 4 of events for 3/3/89 at Palo Verde 3 (lossofpower)
36. Undated -- -- Re: MSIV bypass valve operation 1

Aspendix B (Cont.) f01A-92-087 (Release to the PDR Date To from Subject i Pages

37. Undated -- --

litscellaneous notes Re: 3/3/89 1 event (lossofpower)at Palo Verde 3

38. Undated -- -- 89 Palo Verde Unit 3, Plants 1 with CCI ADVs similar to Palo Verde's
39. 4/6/90 File D.Trimble Commissioner Curtiss' Visit to 5 Palo Verde 40 5/19/89 5. McNamee J. Lieberman Response to 4/25/89 letter 2 concerning press reports i

_ __ . _ . _ . _ _ _ - . _ _ . _ . . . _ . _ _ . ~ . _ . . . _ . _ _ _ . . _ . . _ - _ . . _ . . _ _ . _ . _ . - . _ . . _ . _ _ . . .

Hot FOIA-92-87 .I 1

APPENDIX C EliQQR12S TOTAILY WITilliliLQ JH!!iDEB DATE D11QHIPT.10N & EXEliEU,QH ,

l

1. Undated Draft Team Inspection by M. Davis (7 pages) EX. 5 .
2. Undated Draft Augmented Inspection Team Plan (4 ,

pages) EX. 5

3. Undated Draft Proliminary Notification (5 pagos)  ;

LX. 5

4. 4/6/89 Memo to T. Murley, et al., from M. Davis ro: Potential Part 21 Report on Atmospheric Dump Valvos (1 page) EX. 5
5. 3/15/91 SECY-91-72, Proposed Enforcement Actions Against Arizona Public Service Company (EA 91-25)- (11 pages)_ EX. 5

! (

f / AKIN. GUMP. H AUCR & Fct.o. L.L.P.

oMYS M W PiOO fp* Nut N etata 4 00 ,isent citv ct Nt t a A ag e Sitato puitt b bapott pantNt#5M

  • hacoNGattsAstNut

.#700 Pacer *C avt Nut

  • CWD'NG P"C* E45'044. cossposatio%4 av6 ten ttr.an 78?Of 45 @ 499 6200 CALLat St a A6 7520F4616 4333 NEW H AMPSHIRC AVINUE NW

$41969 too $Ulf C doo 8500 NatioNSD ann PL AZ A 65 AvtNut Lov>St PD No 7 300 CON"N' SE' WASHINGTON D C Roo36 SAN ^N'ON'o it AAt 4205 1050 enusSELS tit LGivM 45W 270-0800 IOtH. 37-7 535 29 to F An 17021807 4PBS ,

fil Louisiana stat ti '

neit s e a gnet t e e,ag m set e ,so,. eso Houston ttx.As 77002 t70! 220 $800 February 21, 1992

[RHDOM Of !NFORMATION BY llAND DELIVERY

' ACT REQUE*T Donnie H. Grimsley. Director - g y .cg _g '

Division of Freedom of Information &

Publications Service Gy s gf .,g gj,9 7' U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

Dear Mr. Grimsley:

This is a request pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C. 552, and 10 CFR Part 9 for documents relating -to Palo Verde Units 1, 2 & 3, and more particularly described below.

For the purpose of this request, the term " document" means all memoranda, letters, filings, testimony, exhibits, contracts, transcripts, minutes, notes, drafts, studies, analyses, reports, maps, diagrams, charts, books, articles, pictures, printouts, tapes, or other written, graphic, or computerized information in any f orm which constitutes agency records under the Freedom of Information Act.

The documents we are requesting. can more particularly be described as:

1. All documents,.other than the NRC Augmented Inspection Team report forwarded to Arizona Public Service (APS) on: April 19, 1989; the Diagnostic Evaluation Team Report forwarded to APS on March 16, 1990, and the documents -provided previously -by NRC in response to FOIA request number 90-570, which relate in any way to the Notice of Violation and-Proposed Imposition of Civil Penalty issued to APS on September-

.1 , 1989.

Pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 5552(a)(6), a response--to this. request is required-in ten' days. .We are willing to pay.all necessary:

scarch and copy fees associated with this request. Please: notify-4'h$

i

, ,A IN, but P. HAUCR & FELo, L.L P l Donnie H. Grimsley February 21, 1992 Page 2 the undersigned at (202' 887-4558 if these fees are expected to exceed $400.00. if any. portion of this request is denied, please provide a detailed explanation of the reasons for the denial, as required by 5 L'.S.C. 9 552(a)(6).

Sincere >,

4 M Bradley 3 ies

$ SO'd ~b101 p

f-E

  1. f' o g

a UNITto STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION I

i *, 3f RLutoN V g6 1450 MAktA LANE,SulTE 210

'g * *V

'* [d

, WALNUT CPEt K. CALIFORNIA 94t@$

RM i 1;:.1 Docket Nos. 50-528, 50-529, and 5'; %r License Non. hPF-41, NPF-51, anu UF h ,

Arizona Public Service Company P. O. Box 52034 ..

Phoenix, Arizona 85072-2034 Attention: Mr. W. F. Conway Executive Vice President Centlemon:

The Confirmatory Action Letter of Cecember 24, 1989, described our understanding of the actions you intended to take prior to the restart of Palo Verde Unit 1. In your letter dated June 24, 1990, you certified that you had completed all restart action iteras applicable to Unit 1. Based on that certificatiori, the briefing yod provided to the NRC staff on April 10, 1990, the subsequent discussions held between our staffs, and our review of your completed work actions, we concur that restart of Unit 1 may proceed.

Post-restart actions were identified in your letter dated June 8, 1989, and updated in letters dated November 6,1989, December 9,1989. April 12,1990, and s'une 15, 1990. We have periodically reviewed the status of these actions ard conclude that your actions thus for are acceptable. We will continue to monitor your progress towards the full resolution of these issues.

Based on the above, we are closing the December 24, 1989 Confirmatory Action Letter.

S incere'ly",

1 1) C _

Regional Adminis cc: J. Taylor, E00 T. Murley, NRR '

E. Jordan, AE00 J. Partlow, NRR G. Holahan, NRR J. Larkins, NRR i

J. Lieberman, OE I Q 'h QS ,

1, i so a sser ces sie ss road 2 A13 *3 8010038 to:6e essi/sv90 (i .-

j j

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20127G480&oldid=3466570"