ML20106G589
| ML20106G589 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Braidwood  |
| Issue date: | 04/30/1996 |
| From: | COMMONWEALTH EDISON CO. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20106G588 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9603140208 | |
| Download: ML20106G589 (369) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:--. . _. .. .. . .
. - . . - . . - . . _ - _ . . = _ .- .- _.
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 9 i i i l
....................................... l
- NOTE
- O
- Approval signatures are on SRB
- Approval Sheet BW-96-02
....e.........e..............e.........
l 1 O 9603140208 960306 PDR ADOCK 05000456 P PDR K: Vim _cenVenifi. doc 1
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR 1 ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 i eg. - d l TABLE OF CONTENTS ! SECTION TITLE PAGE A.1. Siminator Information 4 A.1.1 General 4 A.1.2.1 Control Room Physical Arrangement 5 A.1.2.2 Panels / Equipment 6 A.1.2.3 Systems 11 A.1.2.4 Simulator Control Room Environment 12 A.1.3 InstructorInterface 13 A.1.3.1 Initial Conditions 13 A.1.3.2 Malfunctions 13 A.1.3.3 Controls Provided for Items Outside of Control Room 17 A.1.3.4 Additional SpecialInstructor/ Training Features Available 17 O A.1.4 Operating Procedures for Reference Plant 19
) A.1.5 Changes Since Last Report 20 A.2 Simulator Design Data Base 27 A.3 Simulator Tests 28 A.3.1 Computer Realtime Test 28 A.3.2 Steady State & Normal Operations Tests 28 A.3.3 Transient Tests 30 A.3.4 Malfunction Tests 32 A.4 Simulator Discrepancy Resolution and Upgrading Program 35 APPENDIX 1 List ofInitial Conditions 36 APPEND 1X 2 Remote Function Listing 41 ,
APPENDIX 3 List of Acronyms / Abbreviations 101 APPENDIX 4 Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board Qualifications 105 APPENDIX 5 ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 Certification Report Cross Reference Matrix 107 APPENDIX 6 Simulator Test Procedure and Malfunction Testing Schedule 110 l 1 K:\sim_,certVertifi. doc 2
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ~ ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O : TABLE OF CONTENTS SECTION TITLE PAGE 1 ATTACHMENT 1 Reg. Guide 1.149 Requirements for Dual Plant Simulation Facility 118 i ATTACHMENT 2 Steady State /Nonnal Operations /Real Time / 122 Valve Stroke Time / Transient Test Results , ATTACHMENT 3 Simulator Work Request Procedure 123 ATTACHMENT 4 Simulator Review Board Procedure 124 , ATTACHMENT 5 Simulator and Control Room Layouts 125 ATTACHMENT 6 Malfunction Cause and Effects Book -- O l l 1 i l O K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 3
k BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% l l A.1 Simulator Information A.1.1 General ! 1 This repon is being submitted as the 1995 update to the NRC Certification Report of April, , 1992. The Commonwealth Edison owned Westinghouse PWR 4-loop,3411 MW power plant l l simulator is used for training the Braidwood plant operators. Because of the near exact l l duplication between the two units, it is considered a plant specific simulator for both Braidwood ! units, hereafter referred to as the Braidwood Simulator. However, since only one unit is modeled, Braidwood Unit I shall be considered the reference unit. The shnulator was constructed by Westinghouse in the early 1980's with the first training classes conducted in the fall of 1983. The shnulator software was updated by Simulation, Systems and Services Technologies (S3 Technologies) in the fall of 1991 and declared " ready for training" on January 13,1992. During the Fall of 1994, the interface between the simulation computers and the main control board I/O was replaced which required a complete testing program to be perfonned. The results of this testing are documented in the 1994-95 testing results. Appendix 5 of this report lists a cross reference of sections that satisfy ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 requirements, i This report summarizes the results of simulator testing for the certification years of 1992 - 1996. 1 O O 1 K:Vun_certVenifi. doc 4
. . _ . - . . _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . _ _ ~ . _ . . _ _ _ - _ _ . . - . . . . _ _ . _ _ . _ . , _ . _ . . . . .
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ' APRIL,19% A.I.2.1 Control Room Physical Arrangement The physical arrangement of the shnulator's control room duplicates Braidwood Station with the following exceptions:
- 1. 'Ihe simulator does not have breathing air pack cases.
- 2. The simulator's Switchyard Panel (OPM03J) and General Services Panel (0PM01J) are in-line with IPM0lJ instead of being located approximately three feet inboard.
- 3. Two IBM computers used for log taking and trending plant data.
These exceptions are considered minor and the requirements of ANSI /ANS-3.5 - 1985, Section 3.2.3, Control Room Environment, have been met. i l l l l
)
O K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 5 i
, . - - _ . . _ . . . . _ ~ - -. .- =.-. _-. . - . . . BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.1.2.2 Panels / Equipment The Braidwood Simulator contains sufficient operational panels to provide the controls, , instrumentation, alarms, and other man-machine interfaces to conduct normal plant evolutions of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, section 3.1.1 and respond to the malfunctions of section 3.1.2 for each of the Braidwood Units to the extent identified in the Certification ; i Report. Attaciunent 5 is the control room layouts of Braidwood Units 1/2 and the simulator. The following panels are simulated: i i
- a. . IPM01J h. IPM08J l
- b. IPM02J i. IPM11J l 1
- c. IPM03J j. OPM01J
- d. 1PM04J k. OPM02J (Includes selected U-2 I l
- e. IPM05J components)
- f. IPM06J 1.- OPM03J
- g. 1PM07J m. RM-11/ESD/SER (1PM14J)
- n. Plant Computer (ICX05J)
- The in-plant computer possesses sufficient modeling for the operators to seview the necessary data for the normal, abnormal, and emergency evolutions required by l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. j l
1 O K:\sim_cerNenifi. doc 6
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 A.l.2.2 Panels / Equipment (Cont.) The Braidwood Shnulator does not model the following panels / equi;xnent: ,
- a. OPM05J - center desk area (panially modeled).
- b. IPM10J - radiation monitoring and turbine supervisory panel.
- c. IPM09J - fire protection panel. l
- d. ESD (installed, not modeled on IPM14J).
- c. DC supply to MIDS (installed, not modeled on 1PM08J).
- f. MIDS picoammeter panel (1PM08J).
The Braidwood Simulator is partially modeled for IPM12J. The following components are modeled:
- a. Lift coil disconnect switch box (located at IPM07J).
- b. Containment drain sump flowrate chart recorder.
- c. RIL vs. bank position (8-pen) chart recorder.
1 O K:Mim certVertifi. doc 7
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 A.I.2.2 Panels / Equipment (Cont.) Differences between the Braidwood Simulator and Braidwood Station are: s BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR EXPLANA110N
- 1. Status lights am Some status lights are Does not impact training.
push-to-test. not push-to-test.
- 2. Mechanical step counters. LED step counters. Does not impact training.
LED step counters are used due to high failure rate of mechanical step counters.
- 3. Black meter needles. Orange meter needles. Does not impact training.
l
- 4. OPM02J has a clock. OPM02J does not have a Does not impact training.
clock. l
- 5. Boric acid and Primary Boric acid and Primary Does not impact training.
water totalizers are Water totalizers are . Digital counters am used mechanical counters. digital counters. due to high failure rate of mechanical counters. 1
- 6. Trip and status light Various trip and Does not impact training.
lenses are circular. status lights are square lenses vs. circularlenses. O 1 l l K:\sim._certVertifi. doc 8
i l l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR EXPLANATION
- 7. Sound powered phone jacks Sound powered phone Does not impact training.
are installed on the jacks are not installed. control boards.
- 8. Backplates exist for Backplates do not exist. Does not impact training.
pressurizer safety valve l indication and AF005 valve indication.
- 9. Color banding located Color banding located Does not impact training.
l on meter face. on meter scale.
- 10. Manufacturer's name Manufacturer's name may Does not impact training.
p is on control board be missing on control components. board components.
- 11. Chart recorders have a Chart recorders have Does not impact training.
mixture of magnetic and magnetic closure covers. screw closure covers.
- 12. Screws are used on Screws are not used on Does not impact training.
nametags and mimic. nametags and mimic.
- 13. Switch backplate wording Switch backplate wording Does not impact training, alignment is straight-line. alignment is combination of straight-line and 45' angle.
/m K:\sim_ cent certifi. doc 9
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR EXPLANATION
- 14. Reheater temp. control Reheater temp. control Does not impact training.
panelis positioned panelis positioned
~ 1 inch from guard - 1.5 inches from ;
rail. guard rail.
- 15. Ceiling tile is 3/8 inch thick. Ceiling tile is 1/2 inch thick. Does not impact training.
- 16. FW34 and FW46 valves FW34 and FW 46 use old Does not impact training.
have new style controllers style controllers As the controllers on the simulator wear out, they will be replaced with the new style controllers (SRB # BW- j 96-01). l O l O K:\sim_ certi certifi. doc 10
- = . . . - . - . -- . . . - . . - . . . . - - _ = - - - . . .- - . _ -
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ! - APRIL,19% h l. l A.1.2.3 Systems l l l l l The Braidwood Simulator models most of the plant's control room operated systems. l Systems not modeled by the simulator are: 1 ! l l l a. Turbine-Generator Temperature Monitoring System (TGTMS).
- b. Fire Protection Detection System.
l I
- j. c. Radiation Monitors (RM-23's). l l d. Equipment Status Display (ESD).
l l The systems that are not modeled do not detract from training. The tasks related to these j f systems are handled administratively to ensure procedural compliance is maintained. The Turbine-Generator Temperature Monitoring System, Fire Protection Detection System, and Radiation Monitors (RM-23's) are located outside the nonnal operating area. In addition,- l these non-modeled systems do not impact on the ability to perform the nonnal plant evolutions in ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, Section 3.1.1 or respond to the malfunctions in Section 3.1.2. The Equipment Status Display (ESD) is located inside the normal operating area and is considered visually simulated hardware. t l l f I
- O e
K:Mim certVertifi. doc 11 l 1
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.I.2.4 Simulator Control Room Environment
'Ihe Braidwood Simulator simulates the control room environment to a high degree. The plant's communication systems are present in the simulator. These include the PA system, Motorola radio system and the GSEP phones.
The simulator's lighting was compared to Braidwood Unit 1 in accordance with Work Request B88-115. Minor differences were noted but these differences do not impact training and the requirements of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, section 3.2.3, Contml Room Envirorunent, have been met. The simulator's annunciator tones were tuned to Braidwood Unit 0/1 data in accordance with Work Request U00638 in 1991. The annunciators were tuned as close as possible to match the station's annunciators. i O l l O l l Ki\sim_cerecentifi. doc 12
[ , BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% - A.I.3 InstructorInterface i A.1.3.1 Initial Conditions The Braidwood Simulator has 60 predetermined initial conditions with the capacity for an additional 40 initial conditions to be used by the instructor / software staff when appropriate to store non-protected initial conditions. Additionally, the simulator has 60 backtrack steps to backup the simulator from 1 minute to 60 minutes. The requirements of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, section 3.4.1 have been met. All initial conditions can be found in Appendix 1. A.I.3.2 Malfunctions The current malfunction cause and effects sheets which serve as the malfunction test abstracts can be found in Attachment 6. i The Braidwood Simulator malfunction assessment process utilizes LER's, plant specific operating experiences, NRC bulletins, infonnation notices, and circulars as well as other industry events for detennining additions / deletions to the existing simulator malfunctions, i Each accident analyzed in the Braidwood Updated Final Safety Analysis Report that results in observable indications on Control Room instrumentation is simulated. l l f~h
'V l
K:\sim certNcertifi. doc 13
t BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT , APRIL,1996 j O A.I.3.2 Malfunctions (Cont.) j The applicable Attachment 6 malfunctions are cross-referenced to the ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, Section 3.1.2 required malfunctions as follows: i i Simulator Malfunctions ! ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 corresponding to the ANSI l l Section 3.1.2 requirement , (1) Loss of coolant: (1) (a) Significant PWR S/G tube leaks (a) TH03 (b) CV13, CV22, CV24, (b) Inside/outside primary containment CV25, nil 2, RH11, l i TH01, TH07, (c) Large/small Rx coolant (c) TH04, THOS, TH06, ! breaks (including demonstration TH19 l of saturation condition) l (d) Failure of safety / relief valves (d) TH11, TH12 I 1 (2) Loss ofinstmment air to the extent (2) IA01,IA02,IA03,IA04 l that the whole system or individual IA05,IA%,IA07,IA08 ' l headers can lose pressure and affect the IA09 plant's static or dynamic performance. (3) Loss or degraded electrical power to (3) ED01, ED02, ED03, ED04, the station, including loss of offsite ED05, ED06, ED07, ED08, power, loss of emergency power, loss of ED09, ED10, EDI1, ED12, emergency generators, loss of power to'the ED13, ED14, ED15, ED16, plant's electrical distribution buses and ED17, EG01, EG03, EG04, loss of power to the individual instru- EG06, EG07, EG08, EG09 mentation buses (AC as well as DC) that provide power to control room indication or plant contml functions affecting the plant's response. (4) Loss of forced core coolant flow due to (4) TH16,TH17,TH18 single or multiple pump failure. (5) Loss of condenser vacuum including (5) CWOl, CWO2, FW36,FW37, loss of condenser level control. FW38, FW39, FW40 i K:Vun_cesfcertifi. doc 14 l
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19%
. f3 Simulator Malfunctions ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 corresponding to the ANSI Section 3.1.2 reonirement (6) Loss of service water or cooling to (6) SWO1, SWO2, SWO3, SWO4, individual components SWOS, SWO6 (7) Loss of shutdown cooling (7) RH01,RH02 (8) Loss of component cooling system (8) CC01, CC04, CC05, CC06, or cooling to individual components CC07, CC08, CC09 (9) Loss of normal feedwater or (9) FW01, FWO2, FWO3, FWO4, normal feedwater system failure FWOS, FWO6, FWO7, FWO8, FWO9, FW10, FW11, FW12, FW13, FW14, FW15, FW16, FW17, FW18, FW22, FW23, FW24, FW25, FW26, FW27, FW28, FW29, FW30, FW31, FW32, FW33, FW34, FW35, FW41, FW42, FW47, RP09, RX29, RX30 (10) Loss of all feedwater (normal and (10) FW43, FW44, FW45 emergency)
(11) Loss of protective system channel (11) CH08, RHOS, RP04, RP05, RP07, RP08, RP13, RP14, RP15, RP16, RP17, RP18, RP19, RP20, RP21, RP22, RP23, RX01, RXO6, RX13, RX18, RX21, RX22, RX23, RX24, RX28 (12) Control rod failure including stuck (12) RD02, RD03, RD04, RDOS roda, uncoupled rods, drifting rods, rod drops, and misaligned rods. (13) Inability to drive control rods (13) RD06, RD09, RD10, RD11
- (14) Fuel cladding failure resulting in (14)TH08 l high activity in reactor coolant or off gas
- f. and the associated high rad alanns (15) Turbine trip (15) TCO2, TC15,TC17 K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 15 1
. _ _ ._. . _ _ __ _ .___._ _. _ __ ~ _ _ _ _ _--. _.-. . _ _ .
t i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT Simulator Malfunctions ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 corresponding to the ANSI Section 3.1.2 mouimment (16) Generator trip (16) EG02, EG05 (17) Failure in automatic control system (s) (17) RD07, RD12, RX17 that affect reactivity and core heat removal (18) Failure of reactor coolant pressure (18) CV01, CV04, CV05, CV06, and volume control systems (PWR) CV07, CV10, CVil, CV12, CV14, CV15, CVl9, CV21, CV23, CV26, CV27, CV28, CV29 (19) Reactor trip (19) RD01 (20) Main steamline as well as main feed (20) FW19, FW20, FW21, MS07, line break (both inside and outside MS08, MSO9 containment) U (21) Nuclear instrumentation failure (s) (21) NIO1, N102, NIO3, N104, N105, NIO6, NIO7, N108, NIO9 (22) Process instrumentation, alarms, and (22) AN01, CCO2, CC03, CV08, control system failures CV09, CV16, CV17, CV18, CV20, MSO4, MS06, MS11, RD08, RDl3, RX02, RXO3, RX04, RX05, RXO7, RXO8, RXO9, RX10, RXI1, RX12, RX14, RX15, RX16, RX19, RX20, RX25, RX26, RX27, SIO2, TH10, TH14,TH15 (23) CS02, FW46, RHM, RH07, (23) Passive malfunctions in systems, such as engineered safety features, emergency RH08, RH09, RH10, S103, feedwater systems SIO4, SIOS, SIO6, SIO7, SIO8, S109, SIl0, SIl1 (24) Failure of the automatic reactor trip system (24) RP01, RP02, RP03 (25) Reactor pressure control system failure (25) N/A - BWR only including turbine bypass failure (BWR) K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 16
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% 1 A.I.3.3 Controls Provided For Items Outside Control Room Appendix 2 is a listing of remote functions for the simulator. The appropriate remote functions exist for systems that are operated outside of the Control Room and that are needed to perform normal plant evolutions and/or the malfunctions required by , ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, section 3.1.1/3.1.2. A.1.3.4 Additional Special Instructor / Training Features Available
)
- a. Backtrack As previously mentioned, the Braidwood Simulator has the capability of backtracking. Normally, the students can be backtracked anywhere from 1 to 60 minutes. However, the time frame for tracking the backtrack snapshots is adjustable so that, if the instructor desires, he can offer a backtrack capability of 60 discrete steps with any amount of time between each step
/' ranging from 2 seconds to several hours.
O]
- b. Freezing The Braidwood Simulator has the capability to freeze the dynamic simulation.
- c. Simulator Speed he Braidwood Simulator has the capability to vary the speed of simulation. ne most useful portion of this feature is slowing down the simulation to allow the students and instructor to observe and discuss all parameters. The simulator also has the capability to go into fast time for RCS and pressurizer heatup rate, Xenon, decay heat removal, condenser evacuation, turbine coastdown and turbine metal temperatures.
l l l 'A l V K:Mim certVertifi. doc 17
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT-APRIL,1996 A.I.3.4 Additional SpecialInstmetor/fraining Features Available (Cont.) l d. Override The Braidwood Simulator has the capability of failing any > l control board panel control switch or light either in the on or off ! position. In addition, each control board meter can be l overridden. l
- e. Annunciator The Braidwood Simulator has the capability of failing any point !
( on the sequence of events recorder either on or off causing the I associated annunciator to alann or reset. I l
- f. Auxiliary The Braidwood Simulator has an auxiliary instructor I
Instructor console which can be used when the instructor wishes to Console interact to a large degree with the students. This console is a full scope instructor station identical to the main instructor console. O g. Plant 'Ihe Braidwood Simulator also uses Environmental Plant Parameters Parameters which give the instructor the flexibility to modify parameters which are outside the operating staffs contml. Examples include atmospheric temperature, atmospheric pressure and electrical grid parameters. i l l l t !O l l K:Mim_cerecertifi. doc 18
l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT
- vf) APRIL,1996
! A.1.4 Operating Pro':e< lures for Reference Plant l Le procedures used on the Braidwood Simulator are copies of Braidwood Unit I controlled procedures. When required, (i.e. - changes made to the plant but not yet incorporated into the simulator), temporary procedure changes may be used to acconunodate differences in the simulator and the plant operations. The simulator uses locally generated BOL, MOL and EOL axial flux difference curves since the plant's axial flux difference curves are based on the plant's core age. The locally generated curves are based on Braidwood Station actual performance. In addition, one set of annunciator response procedures (Braidwood Unit 1) are utilized during simulator training. b') V l l l v l K:\sim_ cert \certifi. doc 19
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR , ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A. I .5 Changes Since Last Report System modifications /setpoint changes performed on the simulator for 1992 - 1993:
- a. Modification #20-1-88-032: In-plant Computer post accident monitoring NI points ;
added (U00626)
- b. Modification #20-1-90-014: PS228B/229A failure mode (U01715)
- c. MCR #20-1-91-706: CC9473A/B stroke time change (UO2270)
- d. SSCR #92-002: Pressurizer pressure SI setpoint (U02698)
- e. EC #92-00012: Auxiliary Building pressure alarm time delay (UO2857) l
- f. SSCR #92-003: CST low level alarm setpoint (UO2807)
- g. MCR #20-1-91-708: RY8000's stroke time (U02403)
- h. MCR #20-1-91-671: SI8807's stroke time (UO2691)
- i. SSCR #92-015: Degraded voltage relay setpoint (UO2835)
.g j. SSCR #92-007: Tave deviation alarm serpoint (UO2615)
- k. EC #92-07/08/09: 200 secs, time delay added to trouble alarms (U02842)
- 1. MCR #20-1-91-670: S18804B stroke time (UO2987)
- m. SSCR #92-012: MCR pressure low alarm time delay increased to 50 secs.
(UO3040)
- n. SSCR #92-031: RH suction pressure alarm change (UO3342)
- o. Modification #20-1-91-014: Non-ESF DC breakers replaced with fuses (U02474)
- p. MCR #20-1-89-024: Turbine Supervisory recorders replaced (U01001/2)
- q. MCR #20-1-89-046: IPM01/6J guardrails (U01063)
- r. Modification #20-1-89-069: RH pump bearing temp. IPC points (UO1107)
- s. Control Room Change: Carpet replacement (UO2256)
N' J K:\sim._centcertifi. doc 20
l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS 3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996 l O ! A.1.5 Changes Since Last Report (Cont.) System modifications /setpoint changes performed on the simulator for 1993 - 1994: !' I l
- a. Modification #20-1-89-034: Blowdown computer points added (U02997)
- b. MCR #201-92-667: SI8924 & SI8923A/B stroke times (UO4495) l c. Modification #20-1-93-005: Removal of "EAB Press Low" alarm (UO5072)
- d. SSCR #92-025: Turbine trip setpoints change (UO4350)
- e. Modification #20-1-89-034: S/G upper blowdown computer points added (UO2997)
- f. Modification #20-1-92-004: Remove PZR PORV interposing relays (UO5178)
- g. Modification #20-1-91-013: Main Generator alarm enhancement (UO4747)
- h. MCR #20-1-91-011: CS007's stroke time (UO5198) ;
- i. Modification #20-1-92-005: Change slave relay power for CV8152/8160 (UO51%)
l LO System modifications /setpoint changes performed on the shnulator for 1994 - 1995:
- a. Modification #20-1-92-005: CV8152/8160 Slave Relay (UO5196) l
- b. . SSCR #93-014: S/G NR level setpoints change (U05291) l
- c. SSCR #93-02/021: MS Line/SJAE GS Condenser rad mon. setpoint change l
(UO5110) i d. SSCR #93-005: BA Batch Tank temp high serpoint change (UO5313) l e. MCR #20-1-91-689: New plant radio system (UO2996) l i K:\sim._cerfcertifi. doc 21
-_ __ ._. .__ _ ~ _. _.._ _ . _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . _ _ . _ _ ._
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.I.5 Changes Since Last Report (Cont.) System modifications /setpoint changes performed on the simulator for 1995 - 1996:
- a. SSCR 94-06: PZR PORV setpoints changed (UO5455)
- b. Modification #20-1-94-003: Aux feed suction relay change (UO5606)
- c. SSCR 95-01: Tave change (UO6318)
- d. SSCR 94-19: Aux feed suction setpoints changed (UO6366)
- e. Modification #20-1-94-001: Prevent a VC chiller trip during an SI (UO6409)
- f. SSCR 95-16: FW nozzle high flow setpoint changed (U%520)
- g. P20-1-92-601: Changed power supply of IPA 20JB to ESF power (UO6553)
- h. E20-1-95-209-003: Seperated ESF MCC power for fire concerns (UM611)
- i. SSCR 95-07: Changed RWST 10-2 setpoint (UO6684)
- j. E20-1-95-209-005: Changed power supply of EDG relays (UO6685)
- k. SSCR 95-10: Changed OPDT and OTDT setpoints (UO6718)
- 1. SSCR 95-34 to 39: Changed IA/SA alarm setpoints (UO6942)
- m. E20-1-95-209-010: Changed power supplies for fire barrier concern (UO6939)
- n. Modification #20-1-93-002: RTD bypass elimination (UO6557)
O V K:\sim cerfcentifi. doc 22
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 ry b A.I.5 Changes Since Last Report (Cont.) Significant items added to the simulator and tested satisfactory for 1992-1993 include: ITEM DESCRIPTION /rITLE REASON FOR CHANGE l U00638 Modified annunciator tones. Student Feedback.
~UO2117 Modified delta T channel Student Feedback, failure mode when tripping bistables.
UO2272 Modified main condenser Student Feedback. I hogging pump minimum suction pressure. UO2003 Modified pressure tap Student Feedback. location for 1PI-CC107. 1 0 Q U02567 Modified maximum dilution flow with CV-111 A and Student Feedback. CV-11IB full open. U02804 Revised HD-046 controller Student Feedback. demand at 100% power. UO3092 Modified CV pump bearing NRC Fidelity Feedback, temps. l O - i l 1 K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 23
-r-
i l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l l APRIL,1996 A.1.5 Changes Since Last Report (Cont.) Significant items added to the simulator and tested satisfactory for 1993-1994 include:
)
ITEM DESCRIPTION /ITTLE REASON FOR CHANGE ) l UOI123 Added 3rd Non-accessible Add U-2 components Area Filter Plenum to addressed in U-1 'J OPM02J. Emergency Procedures. l 1 U01758 Deenergized chan recorder Training enhancement. ; drive motor on loss of power, UO3748 Modified Fuel Handling Student Feedback. ! Ch. Booster Fans rad. I monitor interlock power I supply. l UO3789 Modified DC Bus voltage Student Feedback. degradation on aloss ofit's battery charger. j UO3878 Modified limit switches for Student Feedback. ( CV8114/8116. UO3905 Modified rate of VCr pressure Student Feedback. drop during venting operations. UO4555 Modified cire, water blow Station Feedback, down flowrates. UO4554 Modified CW pump Station Feedback, 1 amps. UO2986 Created new malfunction Malfunction Assessment l FW47 "MFP Suction Header Break". 10 w 1 i l K:\sim_ certi certifi. doc 24
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 A.I.5 Changes Since Last Report (Cont.) Signific ant items added to the simulator and tested satisfactory for 1994-1995 include: III M DESCRIPTION /rITLE REASON FOR CHANGE U05197 Modified slave relay K621 Student Feedback. latching. UO5382 Modified RCS loop flow on Station Feedback. a single RCP trip. UO5481 Modified RVLIS response to Student Feedback. i I restoration of power. U05285 Modified iconics response to Student Feedback. l I a Rx trip. U05096 Modified SGTR N-16 Station Feedback. i response, UO6212 Modified floor drain sump Student Feedback. pumps start setpoints. K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 25
h BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.I.5 Changes Since Last Report (Cont.) i Signific ant items added to the simulator and tested satisfactory for 1995-1996 include: IIEM DESCRIITION/flTLE REASON FOR CHANGF 1 UO6312 Modified EH system so Station Feedback. second pump will start j upon turbine trip. j UOM10 Modified the silencing of Student Feedback, back panel alarms.
~UO6610 Raised boron concentration Station Change.
in the RWST and SI Accum. UO6442 Modified CS pump recire Station Data. , flow to match station. UO6456 Created new malfunction Malfunction Assessment. CH09A/B for CNTM H2 monitor line break. UO6506 Modified RCFC check Station Data. dampers close and open - times. UO6598 Added 3 new valves to Station Data. allow isolating of MS drip legs. UO6659 Modified ICC053 to isolate Station Data. on high CC flow. UO6745 Modified EDG cooling Stsion Feedback, such that with a loss at near fullload, the EDG will
, overheat and trip in about
- 20 minutes.
K:\sim_certWrtifi. doc 26
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ' ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.2 Simulator Design Data Base l l The simulator design data base for the Braidwood Simulator is maintained from
]
Braidwood Unit I data. The data base includes the data from which the simulator was designed and built, and on which upgrades and modifications are based. The data base includes design documents, petfonnance data, records, assumptions, simplifications, derivations and other definable data on which the current design of the simulator hardware and software is based. These documents are located in the General Files Simulator (SIM) File. O ! l 1 l i O K:Mim_certVertifi. doc 27
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.3 Simulator Tests i A.3.1 Computer Realtime Test l Real time test (RT-1) was performed per Appendix A of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. The results ! of the test are as follows with the most recent test being located in Attachment 2: *
- a. 1992 - 1993 test acceptable
- b. 1993 - 1994 test acceptable
- c. 1994 - 1995 test acceptable
- d. 1995 - 1996 test acceptable A.3.2 Steady State and Normal Operations Tests i Steady state tests (SS-1) were performed per Appendix B of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. 'Ihe d results of these tests are as follows with the most recent test being located in Attaciunent 2:
- a. 1992 - 1993 test acceptable
- b. 1993 - 1994. test acceptable
- c. 1994 - 1995 test acceptable
- d. 1995 - 1996 test acceptable Normal operations test (NO-1) was performed per Appendix B and section 3.1.1 of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. The results of this test are as follows with the most recent portion of this test being located in Attachment 2:
- a. 1992 - 1993 test acceptable
- b. 1993 - 1994 test acceptable
- c. 1994 - 1995 test acceptable
- d. 1995 - 1996 test acceptable
!O i K:Mim_certWnifi. doc 28
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT i APRIL,19% A.3.2 Steady State and Normal Operations Tests (Cont.) l Surveillance tests (SV-1) are performed once every 4 years per section 3.1.l(9)(10) of - ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. The results of these tests are as folicws with the test procedure being located in Attachment 2:
- a. 1992 - 1993 test acceptable
- b. 1994 - 1995 test acceptable j l
Valve stroke time test (ST-1) was performed in 1992 and 1994. The Simulator Review , Board approved modification of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, Section 4.1 criteria for valve stroke times ofless than twenty seconds. The acceptance criteria (section 4.1) for each valve's ; stroke time is i 10% of the reference plant valve's stroke time. However,i 10% of most l l valve's stroke time ofless than 20 seconds would yield a small tolerance which does not i lend itself to enhanced operator training due to the fact that the operator is not directly affected by a difference in valve stroke time of a few seconds. In response to the potential problem of continually changing most valve's stroke time to i that of Braidwood's, our tolerance was changed to *10% or i2 seconds, whichever is ;
- greater as long as Braidwood acceptance criteria is not violated. A biennial comparison of Braidwood Unit I valve stroke times to the simulator valve stroke times will be performed to ensure that the revised valve stroke time criteria will be maintained. 'Ihis minor change j in the criteria does not detract from operator training. The results of this test are as follows with the test procedure being located in Attachment 2:
l a. 1992 - 1993 test acceptable after completion of WR UO3364.
- b. 1994 - 1995 test acceptable after completion of WR UO6114.
i
- O K
- \sim_certbrtifi. doc 29
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 A.3.3 Transient Tests l Transient tests (TR-1 through 10) were performed per Appendix B of ANSI /ANS-3.5- , 1985. Appendix 4 contains the Transient Test Review Board Members and Qualifications that are used for transient test comparison. The results of these tests are as follows with the j most recent test being located in Attachment 2: I
- a. Manual reactor trip (TR-1) Acceptable (1992-1996)
- b. Simultaneous trip of all Acceptable (1992-1996) feedwater pumps (TR-2)
- c. Simultaneous closure of Acceptable (1992-1996) main steam isolation valves (TR-3)
- d. Simultaneous trip of all Acceptable (1992-1996) reactor coolant pumps (TR-4)
- e. Trip of any single Acceptable (1992-1996) i reactor coolant pump (TR-5)
- f. Main turbine trip Acceptable (1992-1996)
(Maximum powerlevel which does not result in immediate reactor trip)(TR-6) )
- g. Maximum rate power Acceptable (1992-1996) I ramp (100% down to approximately 90% and back up to 100%)(TR-7)
- h. Maximum size reactor Acceptable (1992-1996) coolant system rupture combined with loss of all offsite power (TR-8) j
- O l
l K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 30
- BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19%
A.3 Transient Tests (Cont.) l l
- i. Maximum size unisolable Acceptable (1992-1996) main steam line mpture (TR-9) ;
- j. Slow primary system depressurization Acceptable (1992-1996) ,
l to saturated condition using pressurizer relief or l safety valve stuck open (inhibited I actuation of high head SI)(TR-10) l l l Comparison data for TR ' TR-2, TR-3 and TR-4 was obtained from Braidwood and , Byron Stations Computer System. The data gathering capability is limited to a once per l minute interval. The data for the simulator was gathered on a twice per second interval. I I The difference in scan rates was taken into account during the comparison process. lO l i l ! ) i ) 1 I ! l !( 1 l I i l K:Vun_certkettifi. doc 31
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT i APRIL,19% 1O A.3.4 Malfunction Tests Malfunctions have been tested in accordance with ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. Approximately l 25% of the malfunctions identified in Appendix 6 are tested annually. All malfunctions were tested in 1994-95. The malfunction tests are located in General Files under file SIM-BW-9E1. The malfunction test results were satisfactory with the following exceptions: l l DATE ! BRIEF DESCRIPTION TESTED YEAR MALFUNCTION OF PROBLEM WORK REOUEST SATISFACTORY l 1992- TH19 Rx vessellevel U02818 10-12-93 1993 can't be restored l 1992- ED05 6.9 KV voltmeter UO2532 6-7-92 ! 1993 response is incorrect. l 1993- SIO6 PZR pressure response UO4320 7-14-93 1994 is incorrect. l l 1993- ED08 Diesel FP pump & UO4065 5-10-93 1994 Service Air Compressor UO4066 response is incorrect. UO4067 1993- RH06 CC system rad. response UO4243 6-1-93 1994 is incorrect. 1993- RX06 P-14 annunciator response UO4250 6-1-93 1994 is incorrect. 1994- RX06, RP23 P-14 response for FW sys. UO6111 12-6-94 1995 is incorrect. 1994- CV02 OB PW pump response UO6127 12-6-94 1995 is incorrect. ! l 1994- CC08 Leak isolation response is UO6126 12-14-94 1995 incorrect. 1994- CV13 Cnmt rad. response is UO6128 12-12-94 1995 incorrect. K:Mim_ cert cenifi. doc 32 !
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.3.4 Malfunction Tests (Cont.) 1 l DATE BRIEF DESCRIPTION Thieu YEAR MALFUNCTION OF PROBLEM WORK REOUEST SATISFACTORY l 1994- FW18 17 FW heater emergency U M113 12-8-94 1995 drain response is incorrect. 1994- NI12 MIDS leak detection alann UO6129 12-14-94 1995 tesponse is incorrect. 1994- RM02 Liquid release rad. monitor UO6158 12-12-94 1995 response is incorrect. I 1994- RM05 S/G blowdown rad. monitor U%160 12-12-94 l 1995 response is incorrect. , 1994- RP02 Manual Rx trip switch UO6110 12-15-94 l 1995 response is incorrect. 1994- TC12 HD check valve UO6115 12-12-94 1995 response is incorrect. i 1994- TUO4 Turbine DC emer. oil UO5820 12-21-94 1995 pump response is incorrect. 1995- CV28 1C RCP's seal failure is UO6871 1-10-% 1996 incorrect. 1995- EG07 EDG Gov. response is UO6887 1-10-96 1996 incorrect. i l K:\sim_cerfcertifl. doc 33
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% ! A.3.4 Malfunction Tests (Cont.) I l In the event that a malfunction fails its test, a Work Request is written to correct the problem. In the interim, any malfunctions that are unavailable for training are documented on a "Not Authorized for Use" letter which is kept in the Malfunction Cause & Effects l l Book. This letter informs each instmetor as to which malfunctions are currently unavailable for training. In order to avoid negative training which can result when the simulator progresses beyond design limits, the instructor system computer console displays a message to the instmetor. l This message alens the instructor when selected parameters approach values indicative of j events beyond the implemented model or known plant behavior. The requirements of l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, Section 4.3, Simulator Operating Limits, have been met. i j e A Licensee Event Report (LER) review of all Braidwood events is performed on an annual basis. The LER's will be reviewed as part of the plant malfunction assessment process. A I summary of the Braidwood Unit 1 LER's that were determined to effect simulation follow: LER DESCRIPTION COMMENTS l l 20-1-92-004 Inadvertentjumper placement LER tested satisfactorily. j results in phase A valve closure. i 20-1-94-012 Inadvertant MS isolation at power LER tested satisfactorily, due to equipment failure. l l 20-1-95-004 Reactor trip due to Inst. Bus LER tested satisfactorily. failure. i O I K:\sim_centcertifi. doc 34 l
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ' ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% A.4 Simulator Discrepancy Resolution and Upgrading
- 1. . Identifying, logging, correcting, and testing simulator discrepancies.
TDI 700-02, Simulator Work Request Procedure, describes how an identified , simulator discrepancy is resolved. See Attachment 3 for a copy of TDI 700-02, Simulator Work Request Procedure.
- 2. Tracking of design changes incorporated into the reference plant but not yet [
incorporated into the simulator. The Training Staff receives modifications from Braidwood Station. Modifications are reviewed and if a modification is deemed appropriate to change simulation, a , Work Request is written in accordance with TDI 700-02, Simulator Work Request Procedure. In addition, all modifications that require simulator work are approved and tracked by the Simulator Review Board in accordance with TDI 700-01, Simulator Review Board Procedure. See Attachment 4 for a copy of TDI 700-01, Simulator Review Board Procedure. t I r I l i O l K:\sim_certVettifi. doc 35 I
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPEND 1X 1 LIST OF INITIAL CONDITIONS l l l O
)
l l l 1 1 1 l l l j ! l O K:Vun._cenVenifi. doc 36 l
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 r APPENDIX 1 LIST OF INITIAL CONDITIONS (ICs) IC DESCRIPTION 1 BOL, COLD SHUTDOWN, ALL RODS IN, RCS TEMP 128'F, PZR SOLID, XENON FREE, LOW DECAY HEAT, RH IN S/D L/U, RCPs STOPPED, PZR PORVs IN
" ARM LOW TEMP", SX & CC IN OPERATION, CV OPERATING W/ SEAL INJECTION, ENTER BwGP 100-1 2 BOL, COLD SHUTDOWN, ALL RODS IN, RCS TEMP 170 F, RCS PRESS 340 PSIO, PZR SOLID, BORON 1992 PPM,1D RCP RUNNING, BwGP 100-1 3 BOL, COLD SHUTDOWN, BUBBLE IN PZR, ALL RODS IN, RCS TEMP 156 F, RCS PRESS 375 PSIG, PZR LEVEL 25%, BORON 2003 PPM, ID RCP RUNNING, BwGP 100-1 4 BOL, COLD SHUTDOWN, ALL R.ODS IN, RCS TEMP 193 F, RCS PRESS 349 PSIG, BORON 2000 PPM, IC & ID RCPs RUNNING, CS PUMPS OOS, BwGP 100-1 p) t 5 BOL, HOT SHUTDOWN, PLANT HEATUP, ALL RODS IN, RCS TEMP 341 F, RCS PRESS 340 PSIG, PZR LEVEL 25%, BORON 1491 PPM, RCPs RUNNING, SI PUMPS OOS,1B CV PUMP OOS, PDP OOS, AF013's CLOSED, REMOVING RH, BwGP 100-1 6 MOL, HOT STANDBY, PLANT HEATUP, ALL RODS IN, RCS TEMP 489'F, RCS PRESS 1750 PSIO, PZR LEVEL 25%, BORON 1510 PPM, LOW STEAMLINE PRESS SI BLOCKED, BwGP 100-1 1
7 BOL, HOT STANDBY, PLANT STARTUP, ALL RODS IN, RCS NOT NOP, S/G LVLs @ 66%, STM DUMPS IN " STEAM PRESS MODE", BDPS NOT BLOCKED, i PRIOR TO PULLING S/D BANKS, ENTER BwGP 100-2 8 EOL, HOT STANDBY, PLANT STARTUP, ALL RODS IN, RCS NOT NOP, S/G LVLs @ 66%, STM DUMPS IN " STEAM PRESS MODE", MSIVs CLOSED & l EQUALIZING ON BYPASS, BwGP 100-2 9 BOL, REACTOR STARTUP, S/D BANK RODS WITHDRAWN, RCS NOT NOP, STM DUMPS IN " STEAM PRESS MODE", CRITICAL BORON CONC, HI FLUX AT S/D ALARM NOT BLOCKED, BwGP 100-2 ' 10 MOL, REACTOR STARTUP, S/D BANK RODS WITHDRAWN, RCS NOT NOP, STM DUMPS IN " STEAM PRESS MODE", CRITICAL BORON CONC, HI FLUX AT Os S/D ALARM NOT BLOCKED, BwGP 100-2 K:\sim_cerecenifi. doc 37
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O APPENDIX 1 LIST OF INITIAL CONDITIONS (IC's) IC DESCRIPTION 11 EOL, REACTOR STARTUP, S/D BANK RODS WITHDRAWN, RCS NOT NOP, STM DUMPS IN " STEAM PRESS MODE", CRITICAL BORON CONC, HI FLUX AT S/D ALARM NOT BLOCKED, BwGP 100-2 12 BOL,2% POWER, RCS TEMP 560 F, RCS PRESS 2235 PSIG, STM DUMPS IN
" STEAM PRESS MODE", PRIOR TO TURBINE STARTUP, ENTER BwGP 100-3 )
13 MOL,14% POWER, RCS TEMP 565 F, RCS PRESS 2235 PSIG, STM DUMPS IN
" STEAM PRESS MODE", TURBINE SPEED 1800 RPM, XENON SLOWLY INCREASING, READY FOR MAIN GEN SYNCHRONIZATION, BwGP 100-3 14 EOL,14% POWER, RCS TEMP 558 F, RCS PRESS 2235 PSIG, STM DUMPS IN
" STEAM PRESS MODE", TDFWP OPERATING, XENON SLOWLY INCREASING, BwGP 100-3 Q
(/ 15 BOL,22% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON SLOWLY INCREASING, MAIN GEN AT 220 MW,1 TDFWP IN OPERATION, PLACING ELECTRIC PLANT IN AT POWER LINE-UP, BwGP 100-3 16 MOL,49% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, MAIN GEN AT 550 MW, XENON EQUILIBRIUM, STEADY STATE POWER, BwGP 100-3 17 MOL,49% POWER,12-3-6-3 LOAD FOLLOW FOR 5 HOURS, XENON INCREASING 18 MOL,74% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, STEADY STATE POWER, XENON l EQUILIBRIUM, BwGP 100-3 ! 19 BOL,100% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON INCREASING, JUST COMPLETED POWER RAMP, BwGP 100-3 20 EOL,100% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON EQUILIBRIUM, STEADY STATE ! FULL BASE LOAD, BwGP 100-3 ! 21 BOL,100% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON EQUILIBRIUM, STEADY STATE , FULL B ASE LOAD, BwGP 100-3 MOL,100% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON EQUILIBRIUM, STEADY STATE O 22 FULL B ASE LOAD, BwGP 100-3 K:Mim_cenVertiti. doc 38
i I l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% !O i APPENDIX 1 ! LIST OF INITIAL CONDITIONS (IC's) l IC DESCRIPTION l 23 MOL,30% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON INCREASING,3 CD/CB PUMPS OPERATING, DOWNPOWER FROM 50%, ELECIRIC PLANT IN AT POWER i LINE-UP, BwGP 100-4 l I 24 BOL,13% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON INCREASING, FW CONTROL ON l FRVs, STM DUMPS IN "TAVE MODE",1 TDFWP IN OPERATION, DOWNPOWER FROM 100%, BwGP 100-4 l 25 MOL, REACTOR SHUTDOWN, RCS NOT NOP, ENTER BwGP 100-5 l 26 BOL, COOLDOWN, RCS TEMP 331 F, RCS PRESS 376 PSIG, PZR PORVs IN
" ARM LOW TEMP", PRIOR TO RH LINE-UP, BwGP 100-4 l
27 BOL, COOLDOWN TO COLD SHUTDOWN, RCS TEMP 192 F, RCS PRESS 355 PSIG, IC & ID RCPs RUNNING, TAKING PZR SOLID, BwGP 100-5 28 BOL, TRIP RECOVERY, RCS NOT NOP, XENON INCREASING, S/D BANKS WITHDRAWN, REACTOR STARTUP 7 HOURS AFTER A TRIP, BwGP 100-2 29 RCS LEVEL @ 394.0, MID-LOOP OPS., I A SI PUMP AVAILABLE, CHARGING & i LETDOWN FLOWS EQUAL 30 MOL,49% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON EQUILIBRIUM, STEADY STATE POWER, BwGP 100-3 31 BOL,90% POWER, RCS NOT NOP, XENON EQUILIBRIUM, STEADY STATE POWER, BwGP 100-3 32 SPARE 33 RCS LEVEL @ 398.0, REACTOR CAVITY EMPTY, ALL FUEL ASSEMBLIES IN PLACE, VESSEL HEAD READY TO BE REMOVED 34 REACTOR CAVITY FILLED, READY TO BEGIN REFUELING, ALL FUEL ASSEMBLIES IN PLACE 35-38 SPARE 39 MOL, REACTOR STARTUP IN PROGRESS, INCORRECT ECC, CRITICALITY = BANK C @ 100 STEPS K:\sim_cenkertifi. doc 39 I
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ; ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,19% j APPENDIX 1 LIST OF INITIAL CONDITIONS (IC's) IC DESCRIPTION i l 40 SPARE 41-60 REQUALICs 61-94 INSTRUCTOR ICs 95-100 SOFTWARE ICs l O 1 i l l O i K:\sim_cenVenifi. doc 40
..__._._-..__.__m. _ . _ . . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ . . . . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .
i t l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ! l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ! (. APRIL,19% ; i i f t t l APPENDIX 2 1 1 L 1 i t REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING i l l I r 1 l i
, i 1
l l 6 J s i i I K:Mim_cenVertifi. doc 41 1
, . , - - - - - . - _ _ . . - . , - _ _ _ . . . . . - - - - . - -_ - - . . - - . , . . , a
I BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ! ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 l REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING CC01 CC SUCT HDR XTIE ICC9459A (0-100%) i CC02 CC SUCT HDR XTIE 1CC9459B (0-100%) CC03 RCP A UP BRNG CIR ICC9493A (0-100%) l CC04 RCP B UP BRNG CLR 1CC9493B (0-100%) CC05 RCP C UP BRNG CLR ICC9493C (0-100%) CC06 RCP D UP BRNO CLR ICC9493D (0-100%) CC07 CC PP 0 CONNECT BUS 142 (RI/RO) CC08 CC PP 0 DISCH ISOL OCC9465 (0-100%) CC09 CC PP 1 A DISCH ICC9466A (0-100%) CC10 CC PP IB DISCH ICC9466B (0-100%) CC11 CC DISCH HDR XTIE 1CC9458 (0-100%) CC12 CC HX X-TIE ICC9467C (0-100%) ! CCl3 U2 SUP/RTN 2CC9473A/B,59B (0-100%) CCl4 CC HDR MAN XTIE 0CC9509 (0-100%) CC15 CC SURGE TK DRN 1CC2020B (0-100%) l CC16 CC SURGE TK DRN 1CC2020A (0-100%) l CC17 WM M/U AOV IA ICC183 (ON/OFF) CC18 .WM M/U AOV POS 1CC183 (0-100%) CC19 PW M/U AOVIA 1CCI82 (ON/OFF) l CC20 PW M/U AOV POS ICC182 (0-100%) CC21 CC HX 1 INLET ICC9470B (0-100%)
- CC22 CC HX 0 INLET OCC9471B (0-100%)
l CC23 CC HX 1 INLET 1CC9470A (0-100%) CC24 CC HX 0 OUTLET OCC9471 A (0-100%) CC25 TRAIN A CC ISOL 1CC9467A (0-100%)
. CC26 TRAIN B CC ISOL ICC9467B (0-100%)
CC27 RH HX B CC INLET 1CC9504B (0-100%) CC28 RH HX A CC INLET ICC9504A . (0-100%) CC29 RCP A LO BRNG CLR 1CC9494A (0-100%) CC30 RCP B LO BRNG CLR 1CC9494B (0-100%) RCP C LO BRNO CLR ICC9494C (0-100%) ~ O CC31 CC32 RCP D LO BRNO CLR 1CC9494D (0-100%) l 42 ! K:\sim_cenVenifi. doc
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996 (G APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING CC33 RH HX B CC OUTLT ICC9507B (0-100%) CC34 RH HX A CC DISCH ICC9507A (0-100%) CC35 EX LTDN HX B CC OUT 1CC9411B (0-100%) CC36 EX LTDN HX A CC OUT 1CC9411A (0-100%) CC37 LTDN HX A CC INLET ICC9452A (0-100%) l CC38 SL WTR HX CC INLET ICC9449A (0-100%) CC39 LTDN HX B INLET ICC9452C (0-100%) l CC40 LTDN HX A DISCH ICC9452B (0-100%) l CC41 SL WTR HX OUT ICC9449B (0-100%) CC42 CC PP 0 CONNECT- BUS 141 (RI/RO) l CC43 LTDN HX B CC DISCH ICC9452D (0-100%) CC44 RCP A THERM BARR 1CC9496A (0-100%) J CC45 RCP B THERM BARR 1CC9496B (0-100%) CC46 RCP CTHERM BARR 1CC9496C (0-100%) ' CC47 RCP D THERM BARR 1CC9496D (0-100%) , CC48 CC TO SFP HX ICC9503 (0-100%) CC49 1CC685 VALVE MANUAL OPERATION (0-100%) l CC50 CC SRO TK ISOL ICC9462 (0-100%) j CC51 DEMIN WTR TO SRG TK ISOL 1CC185 (0-100%) ! CC52 PRI WTR TO SRG TK ISOL 1CC184 (0-100%) j CC53 CC053 LOCAL RESET . (NORMAL / RESET) I O K:\sim_cerecettifi. doc 43
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT cs APRIL,19 6 O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING CH01 H2 ANALYZER PS-343 STATUS (OFF/ LOW /HIGH) CH02 H2 RECOMBINER CONTROL (OFF/ON) CH03 RX CAVITY DRN V RE9152A & RE152B (CLOSE/OPEN) CH04 EMERG HATCH (CNMT INTEGRITY) (0-100%) CH05 REACTOR HEAD (REINSTALL / REMOVE) CH06 H2 ANALYZER PS-344 STATUS (OFF/ LOW /HIGH) CH07 XFER CANAL GATE VALVE (CLOSE/OPEN) CH08 FUEL BUNDLE IN REFUELING MACHINE (OUT/IN) CH09 CNMT CHIL 1A CONDENSER PS RESET
- (RESET /HI)
CH10 CNMT CHIL 1B CONDENSER PS RESET (RESET /HI) CHil 1A+1C CH WTR INLT CNMTISO IWOOO6A (CLOSE/OPEN) CH12 IB+1D CH WTRINLT CNMTISO IWOOO6B (CLOSE/OPEN) CH13 1 A+1C CH WTR OUTLT CNMT ISO IWOO20A (CLOSE/OPEN) ( CH14 IB+1D CH WTR OLTILT CNMTISO IWOO20B (CLOSE/OPEN) l l O K:\sim_cerNenifi. doc 44
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR j ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,19% l APPENDIX 2 l REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING i 1 I l CR01 QUADRANT 1 REFUELING (NO CHG/DEFUEIJREFUEL) CR02 QUADRANT 2 REFUELING (NO CHG/DEFUEI/ REFUEL) l CR03 QUADRANT 3 REFUELING (NO CHG/DE-FUEL /RFUEL) : CR04 QUADRANT 4 REFUELING (NO CHG/DE-FUEL /RFUEL) CRO5 FUEL ASSEMBLY G-15 REFUELING (OUT/IN) CR06 FUEL ASSEMBLY J-03 REFUELING (OUT/IN) j CR07 FUEL ASSEMBLY H-03 REFUELING (OUT/IN) l CR08 FUEL ASSEMBLY G-03 REFUELING (OUT/IN) CR09 FUEL ASSEMBLY J-02 REFUELING (OUT/IN) l CR10 FUEL ASSEMBLY H-02 REFUELING (OUT/IN) CR11 FUEL ASSEMBLY G-02 REFUELING (OUT/IN) ] l CR12 FUEL ASSEMBLY J-01 REFUELING (OUT/IN) I CR13 FUEL ASSEMBLY H-01 REFUELING (OUT/IN) FUEL ASSEMBLY G-01 REFUELING (OUT/IN) l( O) CR14 i i I l l l l
- O K:Mim_cerecentifi. doc 45 L
,, - -~r -
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5 1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996-O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING
- CS01 1CS022 SPRAY ADD TK DRN (0-100%)
CS02 1CSO40B SATTO EDUCTRN B (0-100%) CS03 1CSO40A SAT TO EDUC TRN A (0-100%) O f l O Q K:\sim_cerecertifi. doc 46 l 1
I l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING CV01 CV8408A PCV-CV131 ISOL (0-100%) l CV02 CV8409 PCV-CV131 BYPASS (0-100%) CV03 CV8421 RC FILTER BYPASS (0-100%) CV04 CV8107A LD RH HX BYPASS ISOL (0-100%) CV05 CV8108 LD RH HX MAN BYPASS (0-100%) CV06 CV8387A 1A CV PP DISCH BYP (0-100%) CV07 CV8387B 1B CV PP DISCH BYP (0-100%) CV08 CV8322A REGEN HX LTDWN (0-100%) CV09 CV8322B REGEN HX LTDWN (0-100%) CV10 CV8402B CV182 MAN ISOL (0-100%) CV11 CV8403 CV182 BYPASS ISOL (0-100%) CV12 CV8439 MAN EMER BOR ISOL (0-100%) CV13 CV8441 PW TO AB FLUSH ISOL (0-100%) q CV14 CV8479A 1 A CV PP RECIRC (0-100%) D CV15 CV8479B 1B CV PP RECIRC (0-100%) CV16 CV8346 LP FILL CV184 ISOL (0-100%) CV17 CV8100 SL RTN ISOL POS (0-100%) CV18 CV8396A SL WTR FILTER ISOL (0-100%) CV19 CV8398A SL HX INLETISOL (0-100%) CV20 CV8398B SL HX OUTLETISOL (0-100%) CV21 CV8399 SL FILTER BYPASS - (0-100%) CV22 CV8400 SL RTN HX BYPASS (0-100%) CV23 CV8376 N2 SUPPLY REGULATOR STIrr (0-50 PSIG) CV24 CV8410 H2 SUPPLY REGULATOR STPT (0-80 PSIG) CV25 CV8419 VCr DRAIN (0-100%) CV26 CV8482 SL RTN-VCT INLET (0-100%) CV27 CV8484 SL RTN-VCT OUTLET (0-100%) CV28 AB8461 BA TANK SUCTISOL (0-100%) CV29 AB8459 BAT PP RECIRC (0-100%) CV30 AB8478 AB RECIRC ORIFI BYP (0-100%) CV31 AB8457 AB RECIRC ORIFIISO (0-100%) k CV32 AB8465 BAT 2 ISOL (0-100%) K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 47 I i
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING CV33 AB8460 BAT PP 1 DISCH (0-100%) CV34 AB8458 AB FILT BYPASS (0-100%) i CV35 AB8469 BAT PP 0 DISCH (0-100%) CV36 AB8468 U2 MINIFLOW ISOL (0-100%) CV37 AB8476 BATCH TK TO PP SUCr (0-100%) l CV38 AB8494 MAKEUP TO BATCH TK (0-100%) l CV39 BAT PUMP 0/1 CONNECTED (PMP1/PMPO) l CV40 CV8104 EMER BOR POS (0-100%) CV41 CV8384A SLINJ FILT A ISOL (0-100%) CV42 CV8384B SLINJ FILT B ISOL (0-100%) CV43 1CV012 SLINJ FILT BYP (0-100%) CV44 CV8369A SLINJISOL 1A (0-100%) CV45 CV8369B SLINJ ISOL IB (0-100%) CV8369C SLINJ ISOL IC (0-100%) O CV46 CV47 CV8369D SLINJ ISOL ID (0-100%) ) CV48 CV8514 CATION BYPASS (0-100%) CV49 CV8516 CATION ISOL (0-100%) l CV50 CV8524A MB DEMIN 1AISOL (0-100%) CV51 CV8524B MB DEMIN IB ISOL (0-100%) CV52 CV8542 BTRS BYPASS IA BLOCKAGE (0-100%) ; CV53 BTRS DEMIN A STATUS (NORM /BOR/UNBOR) l CV54 BTRS DEMIN B STATUS (NORM /BOR/UNBOR) l CV55 . BTRS DEMIN C STATUS (NORM /BOR/UNBOR) CV56 BTRS DEMIN D STATUS (NORM /BOR/UNBOR) CV57 BTRS DEMIN E STATUS (NORM /BOR/UNBOR) CV58 CHILLER PP 0/1 CONNECTED (PUMP 1/ PUMP 0) CV59 AB8465 BAT PP 0 SUCTION (0-100%) CV60 AB8468 BAT PP 0 DISCH (0-100%) CV61 CV8455 PW TO CV M/U (0-100%) , ! CV62 CV8464A PW ORIFI TO CV M/U (0-100%) CV63 CV8467A LTDN HX 1A OUTLET (0-100%)
)
CV64 CV8467B LTDN HX IB OUTLET (0-100%) j K:\sim_ certS certifi. doc 48
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING CV65 CV8432 MAKEUP TO RWST (0-100%) CV66 CV8350 LP DRN HDR TO RCDT (0-100%) CV67 CV8486A SLINJ FILT 1A DRN (0-100%) CV68 CV8486B SL INJ FILT 1B DRN (0-100%) CV69 RAD MONITOR BYPASS 1FI132 (0-100%) CV70 CV112B CV PP VCT SUCT POS (0-100%) CV71 CV112C CV PP VCT SUCT POS (0-100%) CV72 CV112D CV PP RWST SUCT POS (0-100%) CV73 CV112E CV PP RWST SUCT POS (0-100%) CV74 CV8804A CV PP RH SUCT POS (0-100%) CV75 1 A CV PP AUX L.O. PP (OFF/ON) CV76 IB CV PP AUX L.O. PP (OFF/ON) CV77 CV8321 A/8392A REGEN HX CHG (CLOSE/OPEN) CV78 CV8321B/8392B REGEN HX CHG (CLOSE/OPEN) ' CV79 BORON CONC MASTER RESET (0-2100 PPM) CV80 OPWO2PA PUMP CONTACT 3-4 ON MUX 4 LOW VCT LEVEL (NORMAI/OPEN) CV81 1CV8355A/D VALVE MANUAL OPERATION (CONTROLS ALL4 VALVES) (0-100%) CV82 1AB03P PUMP CONTACT 3-4 ON MUX 5 LOW VCTW/RMCS AUTO (NORMAIJOPEN) CV83 CV8105 CHRG TO RCS ISOL VLV (CLOSE/OPEN) CV84 CV8106 CHRG TO RCS ISOL VLV (CLOSE/OPEN) CV85 1CV8483A CV-121 ISOLATION VALVE (0-100%) CV86 CV8428 BA BLENDER TO CHG PUMP ISOL VALVE (0-100%) CV87 CV8553 BA BLENDER TO HUT (0-100%) O K:\sim_ cenVenifi. doc 49
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING l ED001 0104 LINE DISCONNECT (CLOSE/OPEN) ED002 2002 LINE DISCONNECT (CLOSE/OPEN) ED003 U-l MAIN XFMR DISCONNECT (CLOSE/OPEN) j ED004 U-2 MAIN XFMR DISCONNECT (CLOSE/OPEN) ED005 UNIT 1 SAT DISCONNECT (CLOSE/OPEN) ED006 BUS 241 AVAIL TO BUS 141 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED007 BUS 242 AVAIL TO BUS 142 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED008 BUS 133U1 FEED BREAKER (CLOSE/OPEN) ED009 BUS 134U1 FEED BREAKER (CLOSE/OPEN) ED010 U-l FEED TO BUS 033Z1 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED011 U-2 FEED TO BUS 033Z1 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED012 U-2 FEED TO BUS 033W (CLOSE/OPEN) j ED013. U-2 FEED TO BUS 034W (CLOSE/OPEN) O ED014 CHARGER 123 FROM BUS 134Z (CLOSE/OPEN) U ED015 DC BUS 123 FEED BREAKER (CLOSE/OPEN) ED016 IC BUS 111A FEED BREAKER (NORM /OPEN/ RESERVE) ED017 IC BUS 112A FEED BREAKER (NORM /OPEN/ RESERVE) ED018 IC BUS 113A FEED BREAKER (NORM /OPEN/ RESERVE) ! ED019 IC BUS 114A FEED BREAKER (NORM /OPEN/ RESERVE) ED020 CHARGER 111 FEED BREAKER (CLOSE/OPEN) ED021 CHARGER 112 FEED BREAKER (CLOSE/OPEN) ED022 DC BUS 113 SUPPLY FUSE (INSTALLED / REMOVED) ED023 DC BUS 114 SUPPLY FUSE (INSTALLED / REMOVED) ED024 DC BUS 111 TO INV 111 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED025 DC BUS 111 TO INV 113 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED026 DC BUS 112 TO INV 112 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED027 DC BUS 112 TO INV 114 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED028 BUS 156 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) ED029 BUS 157 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) ED030 BUS 158 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) O ED031 BUS 159 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) V ED032 BUS 141 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) K:\sim_cedcertifi. doc 50
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2
)
REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED033 BUS 142 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) ED034 BUS 143 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) ED035 BUS 144 LOCKOUT RELAYS (NORM / RESET) ED036A AC BUS 111A:01:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED036B AC BUS 111A:02:1PA09J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED036C AC BUS 111A:03:lPA01J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED036D AC BUS 111A:05:1PA27J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED036E AC BUS 111A:06:1PA11J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED036F AC BUS 111A:07:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED036G AC BUS 111 A:08:lPA10J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED036H -AC BUS 111A:09:1PA13J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0361 AC BUS 111A:10:1PM06J (CLOSE/OPEN) - ED036J AC BUS 111A:11:1PA45J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED036K AC BUS 111A:12:1PA09J (CLOSE/OPEN) . ED036L AC BUS 111A:16:1PA05J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED036M AC BUS 111A:18:1PM06J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037A AC BUS 112A:01:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037B AC BUS 112A:02:1PA09J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037C AC BUS 112A:03:1PA02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037D AC BUS 112A:06:1PA16J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037E AC BUS 112A:07:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037F AC BUS 112A:08:1PM10J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0370 AC BUS 112A:ll:1PA45J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037H AC BUS 112A:16:1PA%J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED037I AC BUS 112A:18:1PM06J (CLOSE/OPEN) I ED038A AC BUS 113A:01:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED038B AC BUS 113A:02:1PA09J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED038C AC BUS 113A:03:1PA03J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED038D AC BUS 113A:06:1PA15J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED038E AC BUS 113A:07:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) /G ED038F AC BUS 113A:08:1PA10J (CLOSE/OPEN) O ED038G AC BUS 113A:16:1PA07J (CLOSE/OPEN) K:\sim_cettcenifi. doc 51 l
I BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED038H AC BUS 113A:18:1PM05J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039A AC BUS 114A:01:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039B AC BUS 114A:02:1PA09J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039C AC BUS 114A:03:1PA04J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039D AC BUS 114A:05:1PA28J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039E AC BUS 114A:06:1PA12J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039F AC BUS 114A:07:1PM07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039G AC BUS 114A:08:1PA10J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039H AC BUS 114A:09:1PA14J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0391 AC BUS 114A:10:1PM06J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039J AC BUS 114A:11:1PA34J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039K AC BUS 114A:12:1PA10J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039L AC BUS 114A:16:1PA08J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED039M AC BUS 114A:18:1PM05J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED040A DC MCC 123:CGl:1WG046 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED040B DC MCC 123:DG2:1CX08J (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED041A DC BUS 111:BF1-01:1IP05E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041B DC BUS 111:BF1-12:1RD05E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041C DC BFJS 111:BF1-14:1PM11J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041D DC BUS 111:BF1-16:1PLO7J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041E DC BUS 111:BR1-01:1IP07E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041F DC BUS 111:BRI-05:1DC10J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041G DC BUS 111:BR1-11:1PLO7J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041H DC BUS 111:BRI-12:1AF004A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041I DC BUS 111:BR1-13:1PA27J (CLOSE/OPEN)
- ED041J DC BUS 111:BRI-14:1PA13J (CLOSE/OPEN)
ED041K DC BUS 111:BR1-15:1PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041L DC BUS 111:BRI-17:1PLO7J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED041M DC BUS 111:BRI-18:lPA31J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED042A DC BUS 112:BF1-01:11P%E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED042B DC BUS 112:BF1-13:1RD05E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED042C DC BUS 112:BF1-14:1PM11J (CLOSE/OPEN) K:\sim_. certN cenifi. doc 52
l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 lO APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED042D DC BUS 112:BF1-16:1PLO8J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED042E DC BUS 112:BF1-19:1PLO8J (CLOSF/OPEN) ED042F DC BUS 112:BR1-01:11P08E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED042G DC BUS 112:BR1-03:lDC11J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED042H DC BUS 112:BRI-13:1PLO8J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED042I DC BUS 112:BR1-14:1PA14J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED042J DC BUS 112:BRI-15:1PA32J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED042K DC BUS 112:BR1-16:0PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED042L DC BUS 112:BR1-19:1 AF004B (CLOSE/OPEN) i ! ED042M DC BUS 112:BRI-20:1PA28J (CLOSE/OPEN) l l ED043A DC BUS 113:EF1-03:1PA31J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED043B DC BUS 113:EF1-10:1RD03E (CLOSE/OPEN) l l ED043C DC BUS 113:EF1-14:1PA27J (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED043D DC BUS 113:EF1-16:1PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ' ED043E DC BUS 113:EF1-17:1PM04J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED043F DC BUS 113:EF1-18:1PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED043G DC BUS 113:ER1-02:1DC12J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED043H DC BUS 113:ER1-08:1PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) i ED043I DC BUS 113:ER1-09:1PMI1J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED043J DC BUS 113:ER1-13:0PM03J (CLOSE/OPEN) l l ED043K DC BUS 113:ER1-18:0PM02J . (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED043L DC BUS 113:ER1-19:1PA26J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED043M DC BUS 113:ER1-20:0PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED044A DC BUS 114:EF1-05:1PA42J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED044B DC BUS 114:EF1-12:1RD03E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED044C DC BUS 114:EF1-17:1PM04J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED044D DC BUS 114:EF1-18:1PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED044E DC BUS 114:EF1-20:1TG07JB (CLOSE/OPEN) , ED044F DC BUS 114:ER1-07:1DC13J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED044G DC BUS 114:ERl-10:1PM11J (CLOSE/OPEN) O ED044H DC BUS 114:ER1-14:0PM03J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0441 DC BUS Il4:ER1-16:1PA28J (CLOSE/OPEN) l K:\sim_ceitcertifi. doc 53 -
L BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR i ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED044J DC BUS 114:ER1-17:0PA01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ID045A BUS 156:02:1RC01PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) l ED045B BUS 156:03:1HD01PB (NORMILOSF/OPEN) ED045C BUS 156:04:1FWO1PA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED946A BUS 157:01:1RC01PA (NCRM/CLOSE/OPEN) EDO46B BUS 157:03:1HD01PA (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ED0J6C BUS 157:04:RSH (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN l ED0469 BUS 157:05:1HD0lPC (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ED047A BUS 158:01:1CD05PB (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) l ED047B BUS 158:03:1CD05PD (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED047C BUS 158:05:1RC01PC (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ED048A BUS 159:02:1CD05PA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN)
- ED0480 BUS 159
- 03:lCD05PC (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN)
ED040C BUS 159:04:1FWO2P (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED048D BUS 159:05:1RC01PD (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED049A BUS 141:02:1SX01PA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ! EDG49B BUS 141:03:1SI01PA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED049C BUS 141:04:1RH01PA (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ED049D BUS 141:06:DG1A (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED049E BUS 141:08:1 AF0lPA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED049F BUS 141:09:1CS01PA . (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED0490 BUS 141:11:lCV0lPA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED049H BUS 141:12:1CC01PA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ( $ l ED0491 BUS 141:18:0CC01P (NORVdCLOSF/OPEN) ED050A BUS 142:02:ISX01PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN)
. EDb50B BUS 142:03:1SIO1PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN)
ED050C BUS 142:04:1RH01PB (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ED050D BUS 142:06:DG1B (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED050E BUS 142:08:1CS01PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) l ED050F BUS 142:09:1CC01PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED050G BUS 142:10:1CV01PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN)
- ED050H BUS 142:12:0CC01P (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) l l l
K: Vim _cenicertifi. doc - - 54
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT i APRIL,19%
\
APPENDIX 2 , REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED051A BUS 143:03:HTRA&D (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ED051B BUS 143:08:0WS0lPA (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED051C BUS 143:09:1CWOIPA (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ED051D BUS 143:12:1CW01PC (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED051E $ BUS 143:15:0SA01C (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) ED052A BUS 144:03:HTRP,&C (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) l i ED052B BUS 144:04:1SA01C (NORM /CLOSFJOPEN) ! ED052C BUS 144:07:0WS01PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) l ED052D BUS 144:11:1CW01PB (NORM /CLOSE/OPEN) i EDLOA 131XI:B4:1CS001A (CLOSE/OPEN) , ED0538 131X1:C1:1CS009A (CLOSE/OPEN) [ ED053C 131XI:D4:1AF013A (CLOSE/OPEN) i I ED053D 131X1:E1:1AF013B (CLOSE/OPEN) Q ED053E . 131X1:E2:1AF013C (CLOSE/OPEN) U ED053F 131XI:E3:l AF013D (CLOSE/OPEN) . ED053G 131X1:F2:1RH610 (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED053H 131X1:F3:1RH8716A (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED0531 131X1:F4:1SI8801A (CLOSE/OPEN) ! l ED053J 131X1:G4:1SI8807A (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED053K 131X1:H4:ISI8821A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED053L 131XI:Kl:1CV8106 (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED053M 131XI:K2:1CS019A (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED053N 131X1:K3:1CC9412A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0530 131XI:K4:1CV112D (CLOSE/OPEN) ED053P 131XI:M3:1SI8811 A (CLOSE/OPEN) , ED053Q 131X1:Fl:0SX165A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED054A 131X1:L208 (120):0PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) , ED054B 131X1:L216(120):1PA51J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED054C 131X1:L218 (120):0PR3132 (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED054D 131X1:L221 (120):1PA03J (CLOSE/OPEN)
- ED054E 131XI:L224 (120):1PA33J (CLOSE/OPEN)
- ED055A 131X1A
- N1:1SI8920 (CLOSE/OPEN)
K:Nsim_ceifcentifi. doc 55 l . -. .
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED055B 131X1A:N2:1SI8814 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED055C 131X1A:P1:1SI8802A (CLOSE/OPEN) j ED055D 131X1A:P2:1SI8809A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED055E 131X1A:P3:1SI8806 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED055F 131X1A:P4:1SI8835 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED055G 131X1A:Ql:1SI8812A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED055H 131X1A:Q2:1SI8840 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED056A 131X2:B1:1RH8701A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED056B 131X2:B4:1RH8702A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED050C 131X2:C3:1VQ001A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED056D 131X2:C41RC8003D (CLOSE/OPEN) ED056E 131X2:C5:1RC8003A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED056F 131X2:F1:1VQ002A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED056G 131X2:G1:1RC8001A (CLOSE/OPEN) d ED056H 131X2:G2:1RC8001B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0561 131X2:G3:1RC8001C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED056J 131X2:G4:1RC8001D (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED057A 131X2:F220 (120):1PA33J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED057B 131X2:F221 (120):1PA01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED057C 131X2:F212 (120):1PM06J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED057D 131X2:F209 (120):1PA20JB (CLOSE/OPEN) l l ED058A 131X2A:A2:lSI8808D (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED058B 131X2A:A3:1SI8808A (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED058C 131X2B:A5:lRY8000A (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED058D 131X2B:B1A:1MS018A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED058E 131X2B: BIB:1MS018D (CLOSE/OPEN) ED059A 131X3:B4:1AF006A (CLOSE/OPEN) J ED059B 131X3:B5:1AF017A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED05PC 131X3:D5:1CC9473A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED059D 131X3:E4:lSX001A (CLOSE/OPEN)
- / ED060A 131X3
- C205 (120):1PA45J (CLOSE/OPEN) t ED060B 131X3:C210 (120):1PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) i K:\sim_ certN certifi. doc 56
1 i . BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ! l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APPlL,19% APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING , ED060C 131X3:C220 (120):1PA31J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED061 131X4:AS:1CV8100 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED062A 131X5:A4:1CS007A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED062B 131X5:A5:1CV112B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED062C 131X5:C4:1SX016A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED062D 131X5:C5:1SX027A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED063A 132X1:C1:1SX001B (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED063B 132X1:C2:1SI8924 (CLOSE/OPEN) ]' l ED063C 132X1:C4:1RH611 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED063D 132X1:D4:1CC9412B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED063E 132X1:D5:1CC9473B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED063F 132X1:E4B:1MS018B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED063G 132X1:G1:1CS009B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED063H 132X1:02:1CS009B (CLOSE/OPEN) i O' ED063I 132X1:G3:1SI8807B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED063J 132X1:G4:OSX165B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED064A 132X1:J209 (120):1PA32J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED064B 132X1:J211 (120):1AR021 (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED064C 132X1:J219 (120):1PA04J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED064D 132X1:J221 (120):1PA34J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED064E 132X1:J215 (120):1PA52J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED065A 132X2:B1:1RH8702B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED065B 132X2:B3:1RH8701B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED065C 132X2:B4:1CV8112 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED065D 132X2:C4:1RY8000B (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED065E 132X2:D4:1RC8003B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED065F 132X2:D5:1RC8003C (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED065G 132X2:G1:1RC8002A (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED065H 132X2:G2:1RC8002B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED065I 132X2:G3:1RC8002C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED065J 132X2:G4:1RC8002D (CLOSE/OPEN) (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED066A 132X2:F214 (120):1PM09J I . K:\sim_cenScenifi. doc 57
i I BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ! ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996 , O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING l l ED066B 132X2:F216 (120):0/1AR056/12 (CLOSE/OPEN) i ED066C 132X2:F219 (120):1PA02J (CLOSE/OPEN) i
' ED066D I 132X2:F208 (120):1PM06J (CLOSE/OPEN)
ED066E 132X2:F221 (120):1PA20JB (CLOSE/OPEN) - ED067A 132X2A:A2:1SI8808C (CLOSFJOPEN) ! ED067B 132X2A:A3:1SI8808B (CLOSE/OPEN) ! I ED068A 132X3:A4:1AF006B (CLOSE/OPEN) f ED068B 132X3:A5:1AF017B (CLOSE/OPEN) i ED069A 132X3:B207 (120 #1):1PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ; ED069B .132X3:B220 (120 #1):0PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED070A 132X3:F209 (120 #2):0PR033J (CLOSE/OPEN) j ED070B 132X3:F211 (120 #2):0PR34J (CLOSE/OPEN) ) ED071A 132X4:A1:1SX016B (CLOSE/OPEN) i G ED071B 132X4:A2:1SX027B (CLOSE/OPEN) -
- ED071C 132X4:A3:1CS001B (CLOSE/OPEN)
ED071D 132X4:A4:1RH8716B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED071E 132X4:B1:1AF013F (CLOSE/OPEN) ED071F 132X4:B2:1AP013E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED071G 132X4:B3:1CS007B (CLOSE/OPEN)- ED071H 132X4:B4:1AF013H (CLOSE/OPEN)
. ED0711 132X4:C1:1AF013G .
(CLOSE/OPEN) ED071J 132X4:C2:1CV112E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED071K 132X4:C3:1CV8105 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED07iL 132X4:D4:1CC685 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED071M 132X4:F1:1SI8821B (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED071N 132X4:H1:1S18811B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED07iO 132X4:H3:1VQ001B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED071P 132X4:H4:1VQ002B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED072A 132X4A:L2:1SI8802B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED072B 132X4A:L3:1SI8813 (CLOSE/OPEN) : ED072C 132X4A:M1:1S18809B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED072D 132X4A:M2:1SI8812B (CLOSE/OPEN) ; K:\sim_cenVenifi. doc 58
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED073A 132X5:A4:lSI8801B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED073B 132X5:B1:1CV8104 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED073C 132X5:C2B:1MS018C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED073D 132X5:C4:1CV112C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED074 133Y:3C:1RD01E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED075A 133Ul:B1:1CW0lJA (CLOSE/OPEN) ED075B 133U1:C3:1CW001C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED075C 133Ul:C4:lCW001A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED075D 133U1:E3:1CWO1JC (CLOSE/OPEN) ED076 133U1:D203 (120): OFT-CWO40 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077A 133V2:B202 (120):1PA27J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077B .133V2:B204 (120):1PA26J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077C 133V2:B205 (120):1?A22J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077D 133V2:B206 (120):1PA24J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077E 133V2:B208 (120):1PM05J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077F 133V2:B215 (120):1PA31J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077G 133V2:B216 (120):1PA38J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED077H 133V2:B218 (120):1PA19J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0771 133V2:B224 (120):0PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED078A 133V3:C5:1CW018 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED078B 133V3:F2A:0PR05J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED079A 133V4:A1A:1PR09J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED079B 133V4:A2A:0PR09J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED079C 133V4:E2:lFW01PB-A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED079D 133V4:E4:lFWO59 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED080A 133V4:C203 (120):1PA35J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED080B 133V4:C207 (120):1MS01JG (CLOSE/OPEN) ED080C 133V4:C212 (120):1CB039A-M (CLOSE/OPEN) ED081A 133X1A:C204 (120):1TS-CC671 A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED081B 133X1 A:C206 (120):1PR11J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED081C 133X1A:C208 (120):1 TIS-CV129 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED081D 133X1A:C224 (120):1PA05J (CLOSE/OPEN) K:Mim_cenVenifi. doc 59
l l ! BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996
\
APPENDIX 2 i l REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED082A 133X1B:B201 (120):1PA36J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED082B 133X1B:B203 (120):1PA37J (CLOSE/OPEN) ] ED082C 133X1B:B204 (120):1PM12J (CLOSE/OPEN) ) l ED082D 133X1B:B219(120):1PA20JA (CLOSE/OPEN) ED082E 133X1B:B220(120):1PA50J (CLOSE/OPEN) j , ED082G 133X1B:B222(120):1PA07J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED082H 133X1B:B223 (120):1PA20JC (CLOSE/OPEN) ED083 133X1B:C1B:1PIO3EA (CLO3E/OPEN) , ! ED084A 133X3:A1B:1CV06J (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED084B 133X3:E4A:1PR02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED085A 133X3:C202 (120 #1):1CV06J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED085B 133X3:C203 (120 #1):1PM04J (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED085C 133X3:C205 (120 #1):1PM04J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED085D 133X3:C207 (120 #1): LPM 03J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED085E 133X3:C209 (120 #1):1PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED085F 133X3:C211 (120 #1):1PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0850 133X3:C213 (120 #1):0PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED085H 133X3:C215 (120 #1):1PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED086A 133X3:G204 (120 #2):!PA17J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED086B 133X3:G212 (120 #2):1 PR21/28JX1PA 17J (CLOSE/OPEN) ! ED086C 133X3:G224 (120 #2):1PR28J (CLOSE/OPEN)
~ ~
ED087A 133X4:J204 (120):1PA21J ~ '(CLOSE/OPEN) ED087B 133X4:J209 (120):1PM06J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED088A 133Yl:A4:1CB0lPC-A (CLOSE/OPEN) j ED088B 133Yl:A5:1CB0lPA-A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED088C 133Yl:A6:1CD05PA-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED088D 133Yl:B1:1CD05PC-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED088E 133Y1:E4:1CWOO2A (CLOSE/OPEN) , ED088F 133Y1:ES:1CWOO3A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED088G 133Y1:G4:1CWOO2D (CLOSE/OPEN) j ED088H 133Y1:G5:1CWOO3D (CLOSE/OPEN) ED080A 133Y1:D203 (120):1CD05PC-B (CLOSE/OPEN) K:\sim_certVenifi. doc 60
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED089B 133Y1:D205 (120):1CD05PA-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED089C 133Y1:D221 (120):CD210/211 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED090A 133Z2:C202(120):1PM11/12J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED090B 133Z2:C205 (120):1FW01PC-J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED090C 133Z2:C208 (120):MSR VLVS (CLOSE/OPEN) ED091A 133Z2:D3:1FW005 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED091B 133Z2:E4:1FWO4A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED091C 133Z2:G3:lFW002A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED091D 133Z2:04:1FW02P-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED091E 133Z2:H2:1T008PA (CLOSE/OPEN) ED091F 133Z2:H3:111)08PB (CLOSE/OPEN) ED091G 133Z2:H4:111)08PC (CLOSE/OPEN) , ED091H 133Z2:H5:1FW002C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED092 134Y:2A:1RD02E (CLOSE/OPEN) ED093A 134Ul:B3:1CW01JB (CLOSE/OPEN) ED093B 134U1:B4:1CWOOlB (CLOSE/OPEN) ED094 134V1:A1A:1P103EB (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095A 134VI:C202 (120):1CC9415 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095B 134VI:C204 (120):1 TIS-CC672 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095C 134VI:C207 (120):1PM12J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095D 134VI:C208 (120):1PA38J (CLOSE/OPEN) ' ED095E 134VI:C210 (120):1PA43J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095F 134V1:C211 (120):1PA35J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095G 134VI:C212 (120):1PA22J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095H 134VI:C214 (120):1PA36J (CLOSE/OPEN) ) l ED0951 134V1:C216 (120):1PA37J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095J 134VI:C218 (120):1PA50J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095K 134VI:C219 (120):1PA20JA (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095L 134V1:C220 (120):1PM10J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED095N 134VI:C223 (120):1PA20JC (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0%A 134V2:F201 (120):0PA01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ; ED096B 134V2:F217 (120):1PA08J (CLOSE/OPEN) K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 61
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% - O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING ED097 134V3:A1A:1PR03J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED098 134V3:C208 (120): TIS-684/6 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099A 134V4:D202 (120):1PA2h> (CLOSE/OPEN) , ED099B 134V4:D204 (120):1PA25J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099C 134V4:D206 (120):1PM03J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099D 134V4:D207 (120):1PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099E 134V4:D209 (120):1PM04J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099F 134V4:D210 (120):1PM02J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0990 134V4:D211 (120):1PM04J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099H 134V4:D212 (120):0PM01J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED0901 134V4:D218 (120):1PM08J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099J 134V4:D220 (120):1PA30/32J ~ (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099K 134V4:D222 (120):1PA06J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099L 134V4:D223 (120):1PA42J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED099M 134V4:D224 (120):1PM08J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED100A 134V6:C210 (120):1FWO1PB-J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED100B 134V6:F4:1CB003C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED101A 134X5:J202 (120):1PA44J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED101B 134X5:J216 (120):1PA21J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED101C 134X5:J218 (120):1PM09J (CLOSE/OPEN) ED102A 134Y1:A4:1CD0lPD-A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED102B 134Y1:A5:1CD01PB-A (CLOSE/OPEN) ED102C 134Y1:A6:lCD05PB-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED102D 134Y1:B1:lCD05PD-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED103A 134Y2:A4:1CW002B (CLOSE/OPEN)
- ED103B 134Y2:A5:1CW003B (CLOSE/OPEN)
ED103C 134Y2:D4:1CWOO2C (CLOSE/OPEN) ED103D 134Y2:D5:1CWOO3C (CLOSE/OPEN) _ ED104A 134Y2:C203 (120):1CD05PB-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED104B 134Y2:C205 (120):1CD05PD-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED105 134Y3:E1:1FW0lPB-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED106A 134Z2:D3:1TOO7P (CLOSE/OPEN) KAsim_cmfcentifi. doc 62
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING
- ED106B 134Z2
- E3:1FW002B (CLOSE/OPEN)
ED106C 134Z2:Fl:1FWO1PA-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED106D 134Z2:01:1FW0lPC-B (CLOSE/OPEN) ED106E 134Z2:F4:1CB003B (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED107A 134Z4:Cl:1TOO8PD (CLOSE/OPEN) ED107B 134Z4:C2:lTOO8PE (CLOSE/OPEN) ED107C 134Z4:C3:1TOO8PF (CLOSE/OPEN) EDI0li SAT LOCKOUT RESET (NORM / RESET) ! ED110 CROSS-TIE BUSES 35-1/35-2 (CLOSE/OPEN) ED111 CROSS-TIE UNIT 2 BKR 211 (CLOSE/OPEN) , EDI12 CROSS-TIE UNIT 2 BKR 212 (CLOSE/OPEN) l ED113 JUMPER AT CONTACTS 5-6 FOR ACB 1411 (NORMAIJBYPASS) , EDI14 JUMPER AT CONTACTS 5-6 l FOR ACB 1421 (NORMAI/ BYPASS) ED115 2001 LINE DISCONNECT (CLOSE/OPEN) i ED116 OSCORAPH OPER ANNU BKR RESET (NORM / RESET) ED117 133V5:A4:CB003A (CLOSE/OPEN) ! EDilt: 132X3:B220:VQ003 (CLOSF/OPEN) lO l i K:\sim_cerecertifi. doc 63
P BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ; ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT 1 APRIL,19%
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " -
APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING EG01 GEN LOCKOUT RELAY 86GIA (NORM / RESET) EG02 GEN LOCKOUT RELAY 86G1B (NORM / RESET) ! EG03 DGIA CONTROL MODE SELECT (LOCAL / REMOTE /MAINT_O) j EG04 DG1 A UNIT PARALLEL SWITCH (DROOP /ISOCH) EG05 DGIA LOCAL START /STOP (STOP/ NORM / START) EG06 DG1 A LOCAL RESET (NORM / RESET) EG07 DOI A VOLTAGE RAISE / LOWER (LOWER / NORM / RAISE) EG08 DGI A SPEED RAISE / LOWER (LOWER / NORM / RAISE) EG09 DG1B CONTROL MODE SELECT (LOCAL / REMOTE /MAINT_O) EG10 DGlB UNIT PARALLEL SWITCH (DROOP /ISOCH) EG11 DG1B LOCAL START /STOP (STOP/ NORM / START) EG12 DG1B LOCAL RESET (NORM / RESET) EG13 DG1B VOLTAGE RAISE / LOWER (LOWER / NORM / RAISE) EG14 DGlB SPEED RAISE / LOWER (LOWER / NORM / RAISE) EG15 BRKR 41M TRIP (NORM / TRIP) EG16 GEN TRIP TB TEST SW J (CLOSE/OPEN) O K:Mim_cenkenifi. doc 64
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FU'NCTION LISTING EP01 POND WATER LEVEL (584'-599') EP02 POND WATER TEMPERATURE (32-100 F) EP03 ATMOSPHERIC WIND SPEED 34' (0-100 MPH) EPO4 ATMOSPHERIC WIND DIRECTION 34' (0-360 ) EPO5 ATMOSPHERIC WET BULB TEMPERATURE (0-100 F) EP06 ATMOSPHERIC DRY BULB TEMPERATURE (-20-+100 F) EP07 ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE (12-17 PSIA)
.EP08 EXTERNAL GRID FREQUENCY (58-62 Hz)
EP09 EXTERNAL GRID VOLTAGE (300-370 KV) EP10 EXTERNAL GRID EQUIVALENT REACTANCE (0-100%) EPl1 ATMOSPHERIC WIND SPEED 203' (0-100 MPH) EP12 ATMOSPHERIC WIND DIRECTION 203' (0-360 ) EP13 DELTA T ON RECORDER OUR-EM002 (-10 -10 F) O O l K:\sim_ cert \certifi. doc 65
l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING FP01 MPT 1E FP DELUGE RESET- - (NORMAL / RESET) FP02 MPT 1W FP DELUGE RESET (NORMAI/ RESET) FP03 UAT 141-1 FP DELUGE RESET (NORMAL / RESET) FPO4 UAT 141-2 FP DELUGE RESET (NORMAL / RESET) ! FP05 SAT 142-1 FP DELUGE RESET (NORMAL / RESET) l FP06 SAT 142-2 FP DELUGE RESET (NORMAL / RESET) l FP07 FP/WS CROSSTIE FP347 VLV POS (0-100%) l FP08 FP/WS CROSSTIE FP507 VLV POS (0-100%) l FP09 MOTOR DRIVEN FP LOCAL CONTROL (STOP/ AUTO / START) FP10 DIESEL DRIVEN FP LOCAL CONTROL (STOP/ AUTO / START) i l \ i i
- O i
K:Mim_cerfcertifi. doc 66
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR , ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 l i REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING FW001 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO ICB038A (0-100%) FWOO2 STM DUMP SPRAYISO ICB038B (0-100%) FWOO3 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO ICB038C (0-100%) FW004 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO 1CB038D (0-100%) FW005 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO 1CB038E (0-100%) FWOO6 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO 1CB038F (0-100%) l FWOO7 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO ICB038G (0-100%) FWOO8 STM DUMP SPRAYISO ICB038H (0-100%) FWOO9 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO ICB038J (0-100%) FWO10 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO ICB038K (0-100%) l FWO11 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO ICB038L (0-100%) FWO12 STM DUMP SPRAY ISO 1CB038M (0-100%) FW013 CD PP RECIRC BYP ICD 154 (0-100%) FWO14 CD PP 1 A DIS ISO ICD 041A (0-100%)
\ FW015 CD PP IB DIS ISO 1CD041B (0-100%)
l FW016 CD PP IC DIS ISO ICD 041C (0-100%) l fWO17 CD PP 1D DIS ISO ICD 041D (0-100%) FW018 CP DEMIN ISO VLV ICD 189 (0-100%) FW019 CP DEMIN ISO VLV 1CD190 (0-100%) FWO20 CB PP A DIS VLV ICB002A (0-100%) FWO21 CB PP B DIS VLV ICB002B (0-100%) i FWO22 CB PP C DIS VLV ICB002C (0-100%) FWO23 CB PP D DIS VLV ICB002D (0-100%) l FWO24 FW PP A SUCT ISO ICB005A (0-100%) FWO25 FW PP B SUCTISO 1CB005B (0-100%) i FWO26 FW PP C SUCT ISO ICB005C (0-100%) FWO27 FW PP A RCRC ISO 1FWO27A (0-100%) FWO28 FW PP B RCRC ISO 1FWO27B (0-100%) FWO29 FW PP C RCRC ISO 1FWO27C (0-100%) FWO30 S/U FW PUMP RECIRC 1FWO98 (0-100%) TEMPER ISOL VLV 1FWO33A (0-100%) O FWO31 FWO32 TEMPER ISOL VLV IFWO33B (0-100%) K:\sint_cerfcertifi. doc 67 l
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ; APRIL,19% i o APPENDIX 2 l REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING i l FWO33 TEMPER ISOL VLV IFWO33C (0-100%) FWO34 TEMPER ISOL VLV IFWO33D (0-100%) FWO35 FW PREHTR BYP 1FWO41A (0-100%) FWO36 FW PREHTR BYP 1FWO41B (0-100%) FWO37 FW PREHTR BYP IFWO41C (0-100%) FWO38 FW PREHTR BYP 1FWO41D -
- (0-100%)
FWO39 FW ISOL BYP 1FWO44A (0-100%) FWO40 FW ISOL BYP 1FWO44B (0-100%) FWO41 FW ISOL BYP 1FWO44C (0-100%) FWO42 FW ISOL BYP 1FWO44D (0-100%) FWO43 AF PP 1 A SUCTISO 1 AF002A (0-100%) l FWO44 AF PP IB SUCTISO 1AF002B (0-100%) FWO45 AF PP 1A DIS ISOL 1AF004A (AUTO /CLOSE/OPEN) FWO46 AF PP IB DIS ISOL 1AF004B (AUTO /CLOSE/OPEN) O' FWO47 DEMIN M/U TO CST 0WM423A (0-100%) FWO48 CND NORM OVRFLW BYP ICD 146 (0-100%) FWO49 CND EMERG OVRFLW ICD 140 (0-100%) FWO50 CND NORM OVRFLW 1CD143 (0-100%) FWO51 CND NORM M/U BYP ICD 035 (0-100%) FWOS2 CND EMRG M/U ICD 028 (0-100%) FWO53 CND NORM M/U ICD 031 (0-100%) FWO54 SJAE STM ISOL VLV 1MS107A (0-100%) FWO55 SJAE STM ISOL VLV IMS107B (0-100%) FWOS6 SJAE OFF GAS ISOL 10G042A (0-100%) FWO57 SJAE OFF GAS ISOL 10G042B (0-100%) FWO58 17A NORM DRN 1HD008A IA (OUT/IN) FWO59 17A NORM DRN 1HD008A PSN (0-100%) FWO60 17A EMRG DRN 1HD038A IA (OUT/IN) FWO61 17A EMRG DRN 1HD038A PSN (0-100%) FWO62 17B NORM DRN 1HD008B IA (OUT/IN) l FWO63 17B NORM DRN 1HD008B PSN (0-100%) FWO64 17B EMRG DRN 1HD038B IA (OUT/IN) K:\sim_centenifi. doc 68
_ _ . . . _ .- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . - _ . - ..__ _ ~ l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR - ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 , REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING l l FWO65 17B EMRG DRN 1HD038B PSN (0-100%) FWO66 16A NORM DRN 1HD011 A IA (OUT/IN) FWO67 16A NORM DRN 1HD011A PSN (0-100%) FWO68 16A EMRO DRN 1HD041 A IA (OUT/IN) FWO69 16A EMRG DRN 1HD041A PSN (0-100%) l FWO70 16B NORM DRN 1HD011B IA (OUT/IN) , FWO71 16B NORM DRN 1HD011B PSN (0-100%) FWO72 16B EMRG DRN 1HD041B 1A (OUT/IN) , FWO73 16B EMRG DRN 1HD041B PSN (0-100%) FWO74 15A DRN CLR OUTLT 1HD014A (0-100%) { FWO75 15B DRN CLR OUTLT 1HD014B (0-100%) l FWO76 15A EMRG DRN 1HD062A IA (OUT/IN) FWO77 15A EMRG DRN 1HD062A PSN (0-100%) FWO78 ISB EMRG DRN IHD062B IA (OUT/IN)
- FWO79 ISB EMRG DRN 1HD062B PSN (0-100%)
FWO80 14A NORM DRN 1HD020A IA (OUT/IN) FWO81 14A NORM DRN IHD020A PSN (0-100%) FWO82 14A EMRG DRN 1HD048A IA (OUT/IN) FWO83 14A EMRG DRN lHD048A PSN (0-100%) , FWO84 14B NORM DRN 1HD020B IA (OUT/IN) FWO85 14B NORM DRN 1HD020B PSN (0-100%) FWO86 14B EMRG DRN 1HD048B IA (OUT/IN) i FWO87 14B EMRG DRN 1HD048B PSN I (0-100%) FWO88 14C NORM DRN 1HD020C IA (OUT/IN) l FWO89 14C NORM DRN 1HD020C PSN (0-100%) l FWO90 14C EMRG DRN 1HD048C IA (OUT/IN) ! FWO91 14C EMRG DRN IHD048C PSN (0-100%) l FWO92 13A NORM DRN IHD023A IA (OUT/IN) FWO93 13A NORM DRN 1HD023A PSN (0-100%) FWO94 13A EMRG DRN 1HD051 A 1A (OUT/IN) FWO95 13A EMRG DRN 1HD051A PSN (0-100%)
- j. FWO% 13B NORM DRN 1HD023B IA (OUT/IN)
K:\sim_.cenScenifi. doc 69
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING l FWO97 13B NORM DRN IHD023B PSN (0-100%) FWO98 13B EMRG DRN 1HD051B IA (OUT/IN) FWO99 13B EMRG DRN 1HD051B PSN (0-100%) FW100 13C NORM DRN 1HD023C IA (OUT/IN) FW101 13C NORM DRN 1HD023C PSN (0-100%) FW102 13C EMRG DRN lHD051C IA (OUT/IN) l FW10.1 13C EMRG DRN 1HD051C PSN (0-100%) FW104 12A NORM DRN 1HD026A IA (OUT/IN) FW105 12A NORM DRN 1HD026A PSN (0-100%) FW106 12A EMRG DRN 1HD054A IA (OUT/IN) FW107 12A EMRG DRN 1HD054A PSN (0-100%) FW108 12B NORM DRN IHD026B IA (OUT/IN) FW109 12B NORM DRN 1HD026B PSN (0-100%) f 3 FW110 12B EMRG DRN 1HD054B IA (OUT/IN) i V FW111. 12B EMRG DRN 1HD054B PSN (0-100%) FW112 12C NORM DRN IHD026C IA (OUT/IN) FW111 12C NORM DRN 1HD026C PSN (0-100%) FW114 12C EMRG DRN IHD054C IA (OUT/IN) ] FW11'i 12C EMRG DRN IHD054C PSN (0-100%) j FW1li 11A DRN CLR DRN IHD029A IA (OUT/IN) FW117 11A DRN CLR DRN 1HD029A PSN (0-100%) FW118 FLSH TK 1A DRN 1HD094AIA (OUT/IN) FW119 FLSH TK 1 A DRN 1HD094A PSN (0-100%) FW129 11B DRN CLR DRN IHD029B IA (OUT/IN) FW12I 11B DRN CLR DRN 1HD029B PSN (0-100%) FW122 FLSH TK IB DRN 1HD094B IA (OUT/IN) FW123 FLSH TK IB DRN 1HD094B PSN (0-100%) FW124 11C DRN CLR DRN 1HD029C IA (OUT/IN) FW125 11C DRN CLR DRN 1HD029C PSN (0-100%) FW126 FLSH TK IC DRN 1HD094C IA (OUT/IN) FW127 FLSH TK IC DRN 1HD094C PSN (0-100%) O- FW128 HTR 17 BYP ISO IFW005 (0-100%) K:\sim_cerecertifi. doc 70
)
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% lO l APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING FW129 HDT VENTTO 15A ISO 1HD070A (0-100%) FW130 HDT VENTTO 15B ISO 1HD070B (0-100%) FW131 HD PP CONT VLVISO 1HD046A (0-100%) FW132 HD PP CONT VLV ISO 1HD046B (0-100%) l FW133 HD PANEL HI-2 RESET BUTTON (NORM / RESET) FW134 Ul/U2 CST XTIEISO OCD116 (0-100%) FW135 FW HDR CLEAN UP LOOP FWO95 (0-100%) FW136 CP RETURNISO VLV ICD 211 (0-100%) l FW137 CP CONTROLLER ICD 210A/B (0-100%) FW138 S/U FW PP SUCT ISO ICB133 (0-100%) FW139 CD M/U PP 0/1 XTIE OCD113 (0-100%) FW140 CD PP 1 A SUCTISO ICD 037A (0-100%) FW141 CD PP IB SUCTISO ICD 037B (0-100%) FW142 CD PP 1C SUCTISO ICD 037C (0-100%) FW143 CD PP 1D SUCTISO ICD 037D (0-100%) l FW144 FWP B SPEED SETTER MOTOR (0-5800 RPM) l FW145 FWP C SPEED SETTER MOTOR (0-5800 RPM) FW146 AF PP A AUX L.O. PP (STOP/ START) i FW147 AF PP B AUX L.O. PP (STOP/ START) FW148 AF PP B GEAR BOX OIL PP (STOP/ START) FW149 S/U FW PP AUX L.O. PP (STOP/ START) FW150 FW AUX RELAY FUSE TRAIN A (NORMAL / REMOVED) l FW151 FW AUX RELAY FUSE TRAIN B (NORMAL / REMOVED) FW152 FW PP B O/S TRIP TEST (RESET / NORMAL / TRIP) , FW153 FW PP C O/S TRIP TEST (RESET /NORMAI/ TRIP) FW154 1HD046A/B VALVE CONTACT 09-11 ON ILY-HD009A - LOW NPSH (NORMAL /CLOSE) FW155 1CD157A VALVE CONTACT 15-16 ON l PS-CB14X ON LOW NPSH (NORMA 1/OPEN) . FW156 1CD152A VALVE CONTACT 17-18 ON O PS-CB14XON LOW NPSH (NORMAIJOPEN) V , K:\sim_ceikertifi. doc 71
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O APPEND 1X 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING FW157 ICD 05PD VALVE CONTACT 03-04 ON PS-CB14X ON LOW NPSH (NORMAI/OPEN) FW158 IPS-CB014X FOR ALL CONTACTS ON LOW NPSH (NORMAL /OPEN) , FW159 1CD210A/B FOR CONTACTS ON LOW NPSH (NORMAI/OPEN) FW160 1 AF01J LOCAL OPERATION (S5/S4/1HS/ IFW120/S8) (NORM / START /STOP) FW161 AF 1AF005E HANDWHEEL RF (0-100%) FW162 AF 1 AF005F HANDWHEEL RF (0-100%) FW163 AF 1 AF005G HANDWHEEL RF (0-100%) FW164 AF 1 AF005H HANDWHEEL RF (0-100%) FW165 AF 1A SUCT PRESS LO-2 (51) NORM / TRIP (NORMAL / TRIP) O FW166 AF IB SUCT PRESS LO-2 (55) NORM / TRIP (NORMAL / TRIP) FW167 FW PP 1A REC 1RC VLV IFWO12A PP START (NORMAL / BYPASS) FW168 COND HOTWELL CONTROLLING LEVEL CHANNEL (CD042,CD089) FW169 1HD123 HD TANK M/U LINEISO VLV (0-100%) O K:\sim_cen'certifi. doc 72
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ! APRIL,1996 l O_ APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING IA01 SA TO IA ISOL ISA113 (0-100%) ; l IA02 SA TO IA ISOL OSA113 (0-100%) , l IA03 SA TO IA ISOL 2SA113 (0-100%) l IA04 SA TO IA X-TIE (U-0/1) 01A147 (0-100%) ! IA05 SA TO IA X-TIE (U-0/2) 01A148 (0-100%) ! IA06 AIR DRYER 1 ISOL IIA 001 (0-100%) IA07 AIR DRYER 0 ISOL OIA001 (0-100%) IA08 AIR DRYER 2 ISOL 2IA001 (0-100%) l IA09 AIR RCVR INLET X-TIE (U-0/1) OIA053 (0-100%) IA10 AIR RCVR INLET X-TIE (U-0/2) 01A054 (0-100%) , IA11 AIR RCVR OUTLETISOL IIA 013 (0-100%) IA12 AIR RCVR OUTLETISOL OIA013 (0-100%) IA13 AIR RCVR OUTLETISOL 21A013 (0-100%) l /" IA14 TURB BLDG HDR X-TIE (U-0/1) 01A114 (0-100%) IA15 TURB BLDG HDR X-TIE (U-0/2) OIA113 (0-100%) IA16 TURB BLDG HDR X-TIE (U-1/2) 01A055 (0-100%) IA17 UNIT 1 TB TO AB OIA097A (0-100%) l IA18 UNIT 2 TB TO AB OIA097B (0-100%) IA19 AUX BLD HDR X-TIE 01A107 (0-100%) ; l -IA20 AUX BLD HDR X-TIE DIA101 (0-100%) ! IA21 STM DUMP SUPISOL 11A061 (0-100%) IA22 IA TO CB RECIRCS IIA 073 (0-100%) IA23 IA TO HD VALVES IIA 056 (0-100%) IA24 IA TO MSR VALVES IIA 055 (0-100%) IA25 PORTABLE COMPRESSOR (OFF/ON) IA26 11A065 VALVE POSITION (0-100%) IA27 11A066 VALVE POSITION (0-100%) IA28 AF005 VALVES 01A106 (0-100%) ! IA29 EAST MSIV'S (B & C) IIA 127 (0-100%) l IA30 WEST MSIV'S (A & D) IIA 124 (0-100%) j IA31 IA TO SX/CV VALVES OIA100 (0-100%) IA32 IA TO CV VALVES 01A661 (0-100%) l K:\sim_certVenifi. doc 73 l
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% lO APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING IA33 IA TO FW PUMP RECIRCS IIA 1133 (0-100%) , IA34 IA TO FRV'S & BYPASSES IIA 1117 (0-100%) IA35 IA TO BOTH MSIV ROOMS IIA 058 (0-100%) l IA36 AUX BLDG HEADER ISOL OIA480 (0-100%) l IA37 STM DUMPS A-D IIA 274A (0-100%) IA38 STM DUMPS E-H IIA 274B (0-100%) IA39 STM DUMPS J-M IIA 274C (0-100%) IA40 AUX BLDG HEADER ISOL OIA479 (0-100%) IA41 N2 SUPPLY TO ALL SAC'S (OFF/ON) ; IA42 SPARE (0-100%) l IA43 IA ISOL TO IIA 065 (ON/OFF) IA44 IA ISOL TO IIA 066 (ON/OFF) IA45 IPSL-SA004 U-1 COMP AUTO START PREVENT 3TR RELAY (NORMAIJOPEN) O' IA46 U-1 SAC 3CR,4CR, & 8CR LOC RESET (NORM / RESET) IA47 U-0 SAC 3CR,4CR, & 8CR LOC RESET (NORM / RESET) IA48 U-2 SAC 3CR,4CR, & 8CR LOC RESET (NORM / RESET) IA49 SAC 2 UNLOADER VALVE (0-100%) l l iO K:\sim_cerecertifi. doc 74
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 ! REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING MS01 IST MSR A 15A VENT ES100A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS02 IST MSR B 15B VENT ES100B (CLOSE/OPEN) , MS03 IST MSR A 15A VENT ES100C (CLOSE/OPEN) MSO4 IST MSR B 15B VENT ES100D (CLOSE/OPEN) [ MS05 IST MSR A 17A VENT ES101 A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS06 IST MSR B 17B VENT ES101B (CLOSE/OPEN) MS07 IST MSR A 17A VENT ES101C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS08 IST MSR B 17B VENT ES101D (CLOSE/OPEN) MSO9 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003A (0-100%) MS10 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003B (0-100%) , MS11 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003C (0-100%) MS12 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003D (0-100%) MS13 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003E (0-100%) MS14 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003F (0-100%) MS15 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003G (0-100%) l MS16 STM DUMPISO VLV MS003H (0-100%) l MS17 STM DUMPISO VLV MS003J (0-100%) l MSI8 STM DUMP ISO VLV MS003K (0-100%) MS19 STM DUMPISO VLV MS003L (0-100%) MS20 STM DUMPISO VLV MS003M (0-100%) MS21 IST ST MSR A CND VENT ES97A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS22 IST ST MSR B CND VENT ES97B (CLOSE/OPEN) MS23 IST ST MSR A CND VENT ES97C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS24 IST ST MSR B CND VENT ES97D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS25 2ND ST MSR A CND VENT ES99A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS26 2ND ST MSR B CND VENT ES99B (CLOSE/OPEN) MS27 2ND ST MSR A CND VENT ES99C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS28 2ND ST MSR B CND VENT ES99D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS29 i A MSR SHL NORM POS HD099A (0-100%) MS29 t B MSR SHL NORM POS HD099B (0-100%) MS29t ' A MSR SHL NORM POS HD099C (0-100%) O. MS29D B MSR SHL NORM POS HD099D (0-100%) K:\sim_centVertifi. doc 75 ;
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR , ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ; APRIL,19% O ' lU l APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING MS30A A MSR SHL NORM IA HD099A (CLOSE/OPEN) i MS30B B MSR SHL NORM IA HD099B '(CLOSE/OPEN) ' MS30C A MSR SHL NORM IA HD099C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS30D B MSR SHL NORM IA HD099D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS31A A MSR SHL EMER POS HD087A (0-100%) MS31B B MSR SHL EMER POS HD087B (0-100%) MS31C A MSR SHL EMER POS HD087C (0-100%) MS31D B MSR SHL EMER POS HD087D (0-100%) MS32A A MSR SHL EMER IA HD087A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS32B B MSR SHL EMER IA HD087B (CLOSE/OPEN) MS32C A MSR SHL EMER IA HD087C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS32D B MSR SHL EMER IA HD087D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS33A A MSR IST NORM POS HD002A (0-100%) MS33B B MSR IST NORM POS HD002B (0-100%) MS33C A MSR IST NORM POS HD002C (0-100%) MS33D B MSR IST NORM POS HD002D (0-100%) i MS34A A MSR IST NORM IA HD002A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS34B B MSR IST NORM IA HD002B (CLOSE/OPEN) ) MS34C A MSR IST NORM IA HD002C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS34D B MSR ISTNORMIA HD002D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS35A A MSR IST EMER POS HD032A (0-100%) , MS35B B MSR IST EMER POS HD032B (0-100%) MS35C A MSR IST EMER POS HD032C (0-100%) MS35D B MSR IST EMER POS HD032D (0-100%) MS36A A MSR IST EMER IA HD032A (CLOSE/OPEN) I MS36B B MSR IST EMER IA HD032B (CLOSE/OPEN) MS36C A MSR IST EMER IA HD032C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS36D B MSR IST EMER IA HD032D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS37A A MSR 2ND NORM POS HD005A (0-100%)
- MS37B B MSR 2ND NORM POS HD005B (0-100%)
MS37C A MSR 2ND NORM POS HD005C (0-100%) MS37D B MSR 2ND NORM POS HD005D (0-100%) K:\sim_.cenVenifi. doc 76
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR I ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 ; O APPENDIX 2 j I REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING MS38A A MSR 2ND NORMIA HD005A (CLOSE/OPEN) l MS38B B MSR 2ND NORM IA HD005B (CLOSE/OPEN) l l MS38C A MSR 2ND NORM IA HD005C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS38D B MSR 2ND NORM IA HD005D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS39A A MSR 2ND EMER POS HD035A (0-100%) MS39B B MSR 2ND EMER POS HD035B (0-100%) MS39C A MSR 2ND EMER POS HD035C . (0-100%) l MS39D B MSR 2ND EMER POS HD035D (0-100%) MS40A A MSR 2ND EMER IA HD035A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS40B B MSR 2ND EMER IA HD035B (CLOSE/OPEN) MS40C A MSR 2ND EMER IA HD035C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS40D B MSR 2ND EMER IA HD035D (CLOSE/OPEN) MS41 ES TO 17A HTR ES006A (0-100%) MS42 ES TO 17B HTR ES006B (0-100%) MS43 ES TO 16A HTR ES003A (0-100%) MS44 ES TO 16B HTR ES003B (0-100%) MS45 ES TO ISA HTR ES009A (0-100%) MS46 ES TO 15B HTR ES009B (0-100%) MS47 MN STM SUPPLY TO GS MS167 (0-100%) MS48 AUX STM FD TO GS MS163 (0-100%) l MS49 PRESSURE REGULATED LOAD (0-100 PSIG) l MS50 BOILER DISCH VLV AS168 (0-100%) MS51 SG 1 A PORV ISOL VLV MS019A (0-100%) MS52 SG 1B PORY ISOL VLV MS019B (0-100%) MS53 SG IC PORVISOL VLV MS019C (0-100%) MS54 SG ID PORV ISOL VLV MS019D (0-100%) MS55 SG PORV A HAND CONTROL (0-100%) MS56 SG PORV B HAND CONTROL (0-100%) MS57 SG PORV C HAND CONTROL (0-100%) MS58 SG PORV D HAND CONTROL (0-100%) MS59 AUXILIARY BOILER PRESSURE (0-200 PSIG) b MS60 MSIV HYD PP IA ISOL (NORM /ISOL) Ki\sim_cerecenifi. doc 77
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR , ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING MS61 MS FLASH TK DRN MS161 (CLOSE/OPEN) MS62 IMS031 A ISOLATION VLV IMS030A (CLOSE/OPEN) MS63 1MS031CISOLATION VLV 1MS030C (CLOSE/OPEN) MS64 1MS031DISOLATION VLV IMS030D (CLOSE/OPEN). t l l l r lO l 1 l l l !O i K:\sim_cenVenifi. doc 78
, - . . _ ~ . . . - - - - - . _. , _ - . - - - . ~ _ - - . - - .
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 V APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING N101 SR HI S/D FLUX STPNT N31 (10E0-10E6 CPS) NIO2 SR HI S/D FLUX STPNT N32 (10E0-10E6 CPS) NIO3 INCORE DET A EMERG/STOR BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NIO4 INCORE DET A EMERG/STOR TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NIO5 INCORE DET A CALIBRATE BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NIO6 INCORE DET A CALIBRATE TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NIO7 INCORE DET B EMERG/STOR BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) : NIO8 INCORE DET B EMERG/STOR TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NIO9 INCORE DET B CALIBRATE BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) ! NI10 INCORE DET B CALIBRATE TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NI11 INCORE DET C EMERG/STOR BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) l NI12 INCORE DET C EMERG/STOR TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) l nil 3 INCORE DET C CALIBRATE BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) Q NI14 INCORE DET C CALIBRATE TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) ; NI15 INCORE DET D EMERG/STOR BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NI16 INCORE DET D EMERG/STOR TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) nil 7 INCORE DET D CALIBRATE BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NI18 INCORE DET D CALIBRATE TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) nil 9 INCORE DET E EMERG/STOR BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) N120 INCORE DET E EMERG/STOR TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NI21 INCORE DET E CALIBRATE BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NI22. INCORE DET E CALIBRATE TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NI23 INCORE DET F EMERG/STOR BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) NI24 INCORE DET F EMERG/STOR TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) N125 JNCORE DET F CALIBRATE BOTTOM LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) l N126 INCORE DET F CALIBRATE TOP LIMIT (0-2000 INCH) l NI27 COURSE GAIN ADJ. ON NI POWER RANGE (0-5 VOLTS) I l l 4 0 K:Mim_cerecenifi. doc . 79
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% g APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RD01 DRPI PWR TRANSFER SWITCH (FDi33X1B/ED134V1) RD02 PA CONVERTER CB A (0-235 STEPS) l RD03 PA CONVERTER CB B (0-235 STEPS) RD04 PA CONVERTER CB C (0-235 STEPS) RD05 PA CONVERTER CB D (0-235 STEPS) RD06 MG SET BRK A (NORMAL / TRIP) RD07 MO SET BRK B (NORMAL / TRIP) RD08 RESET STEP COUNTER DURING TRAINER RESET IC & FROZEN (NOT STEP,0, STEP) RD09A BANK OVERLAP SETPOINTS (0-500 STEPS) RD09B BANK OVERLAP SETPOINTS (0-500 STEPS) RD09C BANK OVERLAP SETPOINTS (0-500 STEPS) RD09D BANK OVERLAP SIrrPOINTS (0-500 STEPS) RD0911 BANK OVERLAP SETPOINTS (0-500 STEPS) 0- RD09F BANK OVERLAP SETPOINTS (0-500 STEPS) l
/~T 1
U K:\sim_centcenifi. doc 80
l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996 l O ~ Q APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RH01 RH TO CV LETDOWN RH8734A (0-100%) RH02 RH TO CV LETDOWN RH8734B (0-100%) RH03 RH RECIRC TO RWST RH8735 (0-100%) RH04 TRN A RH/RCS SUCT RH8701 A (0-100%) RIl05 TRN A RH/RCS SUCT RH8701B (0-100%) RH06 TRN B RH/RCS SUCT RH8702A (0-100%) RH07 TRN B RH/RCS SUCT RH8702B (0-100%) l RH08 TRN A RH DISCH XTIE RH8716A (0-100%) RH09 TRN B RH DISCH XTIE RH8716B (0-100%) l RH10 TRN A RH MINIFLOW RH610 (0-100%) l RH11 TRN B RH MINIFLOW RH611 (0-100%) RH12 TRN A RECIRC SUMP SI8811 A (0-100%) RH13 TRN B RECIRC SUMP SI8811B - (0-100%) l RH14 TRN A RWST TO RH S18812A (0-100%)
- J RHIS TRN B RWST TO RH SI8812B (0-100%)
RH16 RH HX A FLOW CONTROL RH606 (0-100%) RH17 RH HX B FLOW CONTROL RH607 (0-100%)
- RH18 RWST LO-2 930C NORM / TRIP (NORMAL /rRIP) l RH19 RWST LO-2 931C NORM /rRIP (NORMAL / TRIP) l RH20 RWST LO-2 932C NORM / TRIP (NORMAL /rRIP)
RH21 RWST LO-2 933C NORM / TRIP (NORMAL / TRIP) l l 1 l l i 4 K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 81
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ; APRIL,19% ' O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RM01 1PRI1J LOC VLV ISOLATION (NORM / RESET) ) O ! a
)
I l l l O K:\sim_certWnifi. doc 82
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ! ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% j O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING j RP01 RX TRIP BRK A (52/RTA) (NORMAI/ TRIP) RP02 RX TRIP BRK B (52/RTB) (NORMAL /IRIP) , RP03 SSPS GEN WARN BOTH TRAIN (NORMAI/ TRIP) RPO4 BYPASS BRK A (52/RTA) (NORMAI/ TRIP) RP05 BYPASS BKR B (52/RTB) (NORMAL / TRIP) , RP06 BYA STATUS-BKR A (NORMAL /RACKIN) l RP07 BYB STATUS-BKR B (NORMAL /RACKIN) - RP08 LIFFED LEADS CLEARS P-4: TRN A (NORMAL / LIFTED) ; RP09 LIFTED LEADS CLEARS P-4: TRN B (NORMAL / LIFTED) i RP10 CNMT PRESSURE HI-3 PB934A (NORMAIJBYPASS) RP11 CNhIT PRESSURE HI-1 PB934B (NORMAL / TRIP) ; RP12 CNhtT PRESSURE HI-2 PB934C (NORMAL / TRIP) . RP13 CNh!T PRESS HI-3 PB935A (NORMAIJBYPASS) l RP14 CNh!T PRESS HI-1 PB935B (NORMAL / TRIP) l (~ RP15 CNh!T PRESS HI-2 PB935C (NORMAL / TRIP) , RP16 CNMT PRESS HI-3 PB936A (NORMAI/ BYPASS) ! RPl7 CNhlT PRESS HI-1 PB936B (NORMAL / TRIP) j RP18 CNhfT PRESS HI-3 PB937A (NORMAI/ BYPASS) ! RP19 CNhtT PRESS HI-2 PB936C (NORMAI/ TRIP) ! RP20 PROTECTION CABINET DOOR #1 (CLOSE/OPEN) { RP21 PROTECTION CABINET DOOR #2 (CLOSE/OPEN) l RP22- PROTECTION CABINET DOOR #3 (CLOSE/OPEN) RP23 ' PROTECTION CABINET DOOR #4 (CLOSE/OPEN) l RP24 BDPS TEST SW RP-31 A (NORM / BYPASS) l RP25 BDPS TEST SW RP-32A (NORM / BYPASS) RP26 SLAVE K606 PHASE A TRN A (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP27 SLAVE K612 PHASE A TRN A (NORMA 1/IN/OUT) i RP28 SLAVE K614 PHASE A TRN A (NORMAL /IN/OUT) l RP29 SLAVE K605 PHASE A TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP30 SLAVE K607 PHASE A TRN A (NORMA 1/IN/OUT) RP31 SLAVE K613 PHASE A TRN A (NORMAIJIN/OUT) RP32 SLAVE K622 CNMT VENT TRN A (NORMAL /IN/OUT) K:\sim_cer6certifi. doc 83
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RP33 SLAVE K615 CNMT VENT TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP34 SLAVE K623 MS ISOL TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) , RP35 SLAVE K616 MS ISOL TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP36 SLAVE K644 CS ACTTRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) - RP37 SLAVE K643 CS ACT TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) ; RP38 I SLAVE K633 AF PUMPS 1/4 S/G LO-2 TRN A' (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP39 SLAVE K647.SITRN A- - (NORMAI/IN/OUT) { RP40 SLAVE K626 PHASE B TRN A (NORMAL /IN/OUT) ) RP41 SLAVE K618 PHASE B TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP42 SLAVE K648 RWST LO-2 TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) ! RP43 SLAVE K621 FW TRIP TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP44 SLAVE K602 SITRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) l RP45 SLAVE K604 SITRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP46 SLAVE K609 SI TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP47 SLAVE K611 SITRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) ) RP48 SLAVE K631 LO LO TAVG TRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP49 SLAVE K603 SITRN A (NORMAI/IN/OUT) j RP50 SLAVE K608 SITRN A (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP51 SLAVE K610 SI TRN A (NORMAIJIN/OUT) RPS2 SLAVE K606 PHASE A TRN B (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP53 SLAVE K612 PHASE A TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP54 SLAVE K614 PHASE A TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP55 SLAVE K605 PHASE A TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP56 SLAVE K607 PHASE A TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP57 SLAVE K613 PHASE A TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP58 SLAVE K622 CNMT VENT TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) ! RP59 SLAVE K615 CNMT VENTTRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) l RP60 SLAVE K623 MS ISOL TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP61 SLAVE K616 MS ISOLTRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP62 SLAVE K644 CS ACT TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) SLAVE K643 CS ACT TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) O RP63 RP64 SLAVE K633 AF PUMPS 1/4 S/G LO-2 TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) l K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 84 l
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 2 l REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RP65 SLAVE K647 SI B TRN B (NORMAL /LN/OUT) RP66 SLAVE K626 PHASE B TRN B (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP67 SLAVE K618 PHASE B TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP68 SLAVE K648 RWST LO-2 TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP69 SLAVE K621 FW TRIP TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) . RP70 SLAVE K602 SITRN B (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP71 SLAVE K604 SITRN B (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP72 SLAVE K609 SI TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP73 SLAVE K611 SITRN B (NORMA 1/IN/OUT) RP74 SLAVE K631 LO LO TAVG TRN B (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP75 SLAVE K603 SITRN B (NORMAL /IN/OUT) RP76 SLAVE K608 SI TRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP77 SLAVE K610 SITRN B (NORMAI/IN/OUT) RP78 FW PP/VLV TRIP FUSES TRN A (NORMA 1/ REMOVED) RP79 FW PP/VLV TRIP FUSES TRN B (NORMA 1/ REMOVED) RP80 MULTIPLEXER TEST SW A,B (NORM /INHA/INIIB/AA_B/BA_B) RP81 INPUT ERROR INHIBIT A,B (NORM /INHIBITA/INHIBITB) RP82 MSTR OUTPUT SELECTOR SW A,B (NORM / TESTA /TESTB) RP83 SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARA 1-2 CONTACFFOR1ACV (NORMAI/OPEN) RP84 SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARB 3-4 CONTACF FOR 1BSI (NORMAIJOPEN) RP85 SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARB 7-8 CONTACFFOR1BRH (NORMAL /OPEN) RP86 SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARA 9-10 CONTACT FOR OA VC CHILLER (NORMAIJOPEN) RP87 SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARB 11-12 CONTACF FOR IBCS (NORMAL /OPEN) RP88 SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARA 13-14 CONTACF FOR 1 A + 0 CC (NORMAL /OPEN) RP89.. SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARB 15-16 CONTACF FOR IBSX (NORMAIJOPEN) K:\sim_ceitcentifi. doc 85
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR- - -- ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTJFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1 + 5 O APPENDIX 2 i i REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RP90 SAFEGUARD ACTUATION SARA 17-18 CONTACT FOR IAAF (NORMAI/OPEN) RP91 TRIP ALL ATWS SG LEVEL B/S AND IMP B/S (TEST / BYPASS) (NORMAI/ TEST) l l O i l I l l I I I
- O .
K:\sim_cenVenifi. doc 86
- l. _ . .. . - . ..- - . . - ...
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 U APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RX001 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 1 FB414A (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX002 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 1 FB415A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX003 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 1 FB416A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX004 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 2 FB424A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX005 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 2 FB425A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX006 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 2 FB426A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX007 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 3 FB434A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX008 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 3 FB435A (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX009 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 3 FB436A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX010 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 4 FB444A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX011 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 4 FB445A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX012 RCS LO FLOW LOOP 4 FB446A (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX013 RCS OT DELTA T TB411C (NORMAL / TRIP) Q RX014 RCS OP DELTA T TB4110 (NORMAL / TRIP) U RX015 LO-LO TAVG TB412D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX016 LOW TAVG TB412G (NORMAL / TRIP) RX017 RCS OT DELTA T TB421C (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX018 RCS OP DELTA TTB421G (NORMAL / TRIP) RX019 LO-LO TAVG TB422D (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX020 LOW TAVG TB422G (NORMAL / TRIP) RX021 RCS OT DELTA T TB431C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX022 RCS OP DELTA T TB431G (NORMAL / TRIP) RX023 LO-LO TAVG TB432D (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX024 LOW TAVG TB432G (NORMAL / TRIP) RX025 RCS OT DELTA T TB441C (NORMAL /FRIP) RX026 RCS OP DELTA T TB441G (NORMAL / TRIP) RX027 LO-LO TAVG TB442D (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX028 LOW TAVG TB442G (NORMAL / TRIP) RX029 PZR HI WATER LEVEL LB459A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX030 PZR HI WATER LEVEL LB460A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX031 PZR HI WATER LEVEL LB461 A (NORMAL / TRIP) l RX032 PZR HI PRESSURE PB455A (NORMAL / TRIP) i l K:\sim cerfcertifi. doc 87 l l l % l
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% ! O APPENDIX 2 i REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING , RX033 PZR ENABLE BLOCK SI PB455B (NORMAI/ TRIP) , RXO34 PZR LOW PRESS TRIP PB455C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX035 PZR LOW PRESS SI PB455D (NORMAL / TRIP) RXO36 PZR HI PRESSURE PB456A (NORMAI/FRIP) RX037 PZR ENABLE BLOCK SI PB456B (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX038 PZR LOW PRESS TRIP PB456C (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX039 PZR LOW PRESS SI PB456D (NORMAL / TRIP) 1 RX040 PZR HI PRESSURE PB457A (NORMAI/ TRIP) ; RX041 PZR ENABLE BLOCK SI PB457B (NORMAI/ TRIP) ) RX042 PZR LOW PRESS TRIP PB457C (NORMAI/ TRIP) i RX043 PZR LOW PRESS SI PB457D (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX044 PZR HI PRESSURE PB458A (NORMAL / TRIP) i RXO45 PZR LOW PRESS TRIP PB458C (NORMAI/ TRIP) PZR LOW PRESS SI PB458D (NORMAL / TRIP) O RX046 RXO47 SGI HI-HI LEVEL LB517A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX048 SGI LO-2 WATER LB517B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX049 SGI HI-HI LEVEL LB518A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX050 SGI LO-2 WATER LVL LB518B (NORMAL /rRIP) RX051 SGI HI-HI LEVEL LB519A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX052 SG1 LO-2 WATER LVL LB519B (NORMAL /rRIP)
- RX053 SG2 HI-HI LEVEL LB527A (NORMAL /rRIP) l RX054 SG2 LO-2 WATER LVL LB527B (NORMAI/ TRIP)
RX055 SG2 HI-HI LEVEL LB528A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX056 SG2 LO-2 WATER LVL LB528B (NORMAL / TRIP) l RX057 - SG2 HI-HI LEVEL LB529A RX058 SG2 LO-2 WATER LVL LB529B (NORMAL / TRIP) ( (NORMAL / TRIP) RX059 SG3 HI-HI LEVEL LB537A (NORMAL / TRIP) ! RX060 SG3 LO-2 WATER LVL LB537B (NORMAL / TRIP) l RX061 SG3 Hi-HI LEVEL LB538A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX062 SG3 LO-2 WATER LVL LB538B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX063 SG3 HI-HI LEVEL LB539A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX064 SO3 LO-2 WATER LVL LB539B (NORMAL / TRIP) K:\sim__cerfcenifi. doc 88
i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR i ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O APPENDIX 2 l REMOTE FUNCITON LISTING RX065 SO4 HI-HI LEVEL LB547A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX066 SG4 LO-2 WATER LVL LB547B (NORMAL / TRIP) RXO67 SO4 HI-HI LEVEL LB548A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX068 SG4 LO-2 WATER LVL LB548B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX069 SG4 HI-HI LEVEL LB549A (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX070 SO4 LO-2 WATER LVL LB549B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX071 SG1 LO-2 WATER LVL LB556C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX072 SG1 LO-2 WATER LVL LB557C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX073 SG1 LO-2 WATER LVL LB558C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX074 SG1 LO-2 WATER LVL LB559C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX075 SGI HI STM RATE PB514A (NORMAL / TRIP) RXO76 SGI LO STM PRESS PB514B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX077 SGI HI STM RATE P PB515A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX078 SG1 LO STM PRESS PB515B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX079 SGI HI STM RATE PB516C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX080 SG1 LO STM PRESS PB516A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX081 SG2 HI STM RATE P PB524A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX082 SG2 LO STM PRESS PB524B (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX083 SG2 HI STM RATE P PB525A (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX084 SG2 LO STM PRESS PB525B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX085 SG2 HI STM RATE P PB526C- (NORMAL / TRIP) RX086 SG2 LO STM PRESS PB526A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX087 SG3 HI STM RATE P PB534A (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX088 SG3 LO STM PRESS PB534B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX089 SG3 HI STM RATE P PB535A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX090 SG3 LO STM PRESS PB535B (NORMAL / TRIP) RXO91 SG3 HI STM RATE P PB536D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX092 SG3 LO STM PRESS PB536A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX093 SG4 HI STM RATE P PB544A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX094 SG4 LO STM PRESS PB544B (NORMAL / TRIP) SO4 III STM RATE P PB545A (NORMAL / TRIP) O RXO95 RXO96 SG4 LO STM PRESS PB545B (NORMAI/ TRIP) K:Nsim cenkenifi. doc 89
i t BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 I REMOTE FUNCTION LI?'11NG RXO97 SG4 HI STM RATE P PB546D (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX098 SG4 LO STM PRESS PB546A (NORMAL / TRIP) { RX100 SG1 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB514C (NORMAL / TRIP)- RX101 SG2 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB524C (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX102 SG3 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB534C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX103 SG4 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB544C (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX104 SG1 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB515C (NORMAL /rRIP) RX105 SG2 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB525C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX106 SG3 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB535C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX107 SG4 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB545C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX108 SGI WTR HAMMER PROT. LB517D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX109 SGI WTR HAMMER PROT. LB519F (NORMAL / TRIP) ; RX110 SGI WTR HAMMER PROT. LB556A (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX111 SG2 W'IR HAMMER PROT. LB528D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX112 SG2 W1R HAMMER PROT. LB529F (NORMAL / TRIP) RX113 SO2 WTR HAMMER PROT. LB557A (NORMAL / TRIP) , RX114 SG3 WTR HAMMER PROT. LB538D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX115 SG3 WTR HAMMER PROT. LB539F (NORMAI/ TRIP) RXI16 SG3 WTR HAMMER PROT. LB558A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX117 SO4 WTR HAMMER PROT. LB547D (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX118 SO4 WTR HAMMER PROT. LB549F (NORMAL / TRIP) RX119 SG4 WTR HAMMER PROT. LB559A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX120 SGI WTR HAMMER PROT. PB516D (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX121 SO2 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB526D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX122 SG3 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB536C (NORMAI/ TRIP) RX123 SG4 WTR HAMMER PROT. PB546C (NORMAL / TRIP) RX124 SG1 HI-HI LEVEL LB556B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX125 SG2 HI-HI LEVEL LB557B (NORMAL / TRIP) L RX126 SO3 HI-HI LEVEL LB558B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX127 SG4 HI-HI LEVEL LB559B (NORMAL / TRIP) RX135 RC LP1 OT DELTA T C3 TB411D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX136 RC LPl OP DELTA T C4 TB41IH (NORMAL / TRIP) K:\sim cenVenifi. doc 90 t
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING RX137 RC LP2 OT DELTA T C3 TB421D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX138 RC LP2 OP DELTA T C4 TB421H (NORMAL /lRIP) RX139 RC LP3 OT DELTA T C3 TB431D (NORMAL / TRIP) RX140 RC LP3 OP DELTA T C4 TB431H (NORMAL / TRIP) RX141 RC LP4 OT DELTA T C3 TB441D (NORMAL / TRIP) l RX142 RC LP4 OP DELTA T C4 TB441H (NORMAL / TRIP) ! RX143 TURBINE POWER P-13 PB505A (NORMAL / TRIP) RX141 TURBINE POWER P-13 PB506A (NORMAL / TRIP) l RX145 SG1 LO-3 LEVEL LIS 431 (NORMAL / TRIP) j RX146 SG2 LO-3 LEVEL LIS 432 (NORMAL / TRIP) l RX147 SG3 LO-3 LEVEL LIS 433 (NORMAL / TRIP) RX148 SG4 LO-3 LEVEL LIS 434 (NORMAL / TRIP) l RX149 1PS-0505 AMS C-20 (NORMAL / TRIP) RX150 1PS-0506 AMS C-20 (NORMAL / TRIP) I i l
- o K
- \sim_cerecertifi. doc 91 l
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% ' O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING SIO1 SI PP 1A DISCH VLV SI8921A (0-100%) SIO2 SI PP IB DISCH VLV S18921B (0-100%) j S103 SiTEST TO RWST VLV SI8963 (CLOSE/OPEN) SIO4 1 A CS RECIRC TO RWST SI001 A (CLOSE/OPEN) SIOS IB CS RECIRC TO RWST S1001B (CLOSE/OPEN) ) S106 SI PP RWST SUCT POS SI8806 (0-100%) SIO7 SITO CL VLV POS SI8835 (0-100%) SIO8 SI TO HL A & D POS SI8802A (0-100%) i SIO9 SI TO HL B & C POS SI8802B (0-100%) l SIl0 PWR FOR SI CL TEST SI8823 (OFF/ON) SIi1 PWR FOR SI HL TEST SI8824 (OFF/ON) SI12 PWR FOR RH HL TEST SI8825 (OFF/ON) SI13 RH DISCH TO CL POS SI8809A (0-100%) RH DISCH TO CL POS SI8809B (0-100%) O Sil4 SII5 RH DISCH TO HL POS SI8840 (0-100%) SIl6 SI SUCT FROM RH POS SI8804B (0-100%) SI17 PWR FOR ACCUM M/U SI8871 (OFF/ON) SI18 CV INJ LINE POS SI8801A (0-100%) SI19 CV INJ LINE POS SI8801B (0-100%) SI20 PWR TO RH HL TEST SI8890A (OFF/ON) S121 PWR TO RH HLTEST SI8890B (OFF/ON) SI22 PWR TO SI HL TEST SI8881 (OFF/ON) SI23 PWR TO CV HL TEST SI8843 (OFF/ON) S124 DRAIN TO HUT (CLOSE/OPEN) 1 O K:%n_cerecertifi. doc 92
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 v APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING SW01 CC HX 0 OUTLET OSX007 (0-100%) SWO2 CC HX 1 OUTI.ET ISX007 (0-100%) l SWO3 SX PP A L.O. PP (OFF/ON) SWO4 SX PP B L.O. PP (OFF/ON) SWO5 SX PP 1A STNR DRN ISX150A (0-100%) SWO6 SX PP IB STNR DRN ISX150B (0-100%) SWO7 U-2 SX SUPPLY 2SX005 (0-100%) SWO8 SX TO FP XTIE OSX174 (0-100%) SW10 CB PP A OIL CLR WS021A (0-100%) SW11 CB PP B OIL CLR WS021B (0-100%) SW12 CB PP C OIL CLR WS021C (0-100%) SW13 CB PP D OIL CLR WS021D (0-100%) SW14 CD PP A OIL CLR WS023A (0-100%) SW15 CD PP B OIL CLR WS023B (0-100%) SW16 CD PP C OIL CLR WS023C (0-100%) ] SW17 CD PP D OIL CLR WS023D (0-100%) SW18 FW PP A OIL CLR WS087 (0-100%) SW19 GEN HYD COOLER WSO44A (0-100%) SW20 GEN HYD COOLER WSO44B (0-100%) SW21 GEN HYD COOLER WSO44C (0-100%) SW22 GEN HYD COOLER WSO44D. (0-100%) SW23 BLOWDOWN CONDENSER WSM9 (0-100%) SW24 WS PP 1 A DISCH VLV OWS002A (0-100%) SW25 WS PP IB DISCH VLV OWS002B (0-100%) SW26 WS PP IC DISCH VLV 0WS002C (0-100%) SW29 FW PP B CLR CNTL SETPT (0-200 F) SW30 FW PP C CLR CNTL SETPT (0-200 F) SW31 EH CLR TEMP CNTL SETPT (0-200 F) I SW32 EXCITER TEMP CNTL SETPT (0-100 C) SW33 GC TEMP CNTL SETPT (0-200 F)
<G SW34 TO CLR TEMP CNTL SETPT (0-200 F)
SW35 ASSO CLR CNTL SETPT (0-200 F) K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 93
i
~
l l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING j SW36 H2SSO CLR CNTL SETPT (0-200 F) l SW37 OSX02PA PUMP CONTACT OLS-SXO96 ON BASIN LVL (NORMAI/OPEN) SW38 OWS01PA PUMP CONTACT 5-7 ON OPLS-WS008A ON LOW NPSH (NORMAI/OPEN) I 1 O : I l 1 i i l l O L) K:Mim_certVertifi. doc 94
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT I APRIL,19% l APPENDIX 2 i REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING TC01 DEH COMPUTER (RUN/ HALT) ) TC02 EGC PERMISSIVE (NORM / INHIBIT) i TCO3 LOCAL MANUALTURBINE TRIP (NORM / TRIP) ! TC04 OPC CYCLING OF IV'S (NORM / INHIBIT) l TC05 EGC RAISE SIGNAL (NORM / RAISE) ) TC06 EGC LOWER SIGNAL (NORM / LOWER) TC07 TURB TRIP BLOCK LEVER (NORM / TEST) TC08 VACUUM TRIP TEST VALVE (0-100%) l TC09 OVERSPEED TRIP TEST VALVE (CLOSE/OPEN) ! TC10 THRUST BEAR TRIP TEST VLV (0-100%) 1 TCl1 BP ARING OIL TRIP TEST VLV (0-100%) l TCl2 FILL EH RSVR VIA HAND PUMP (OFF,0N) l TCl3 EGC MW/ MIN LIMIT THUMBWHEEL (0-50 MW) ( TC14 EGC LO LIMIT THUMBWHEEL (0-2000 MW) l TC15 EGC HI LIMIT THUMBWHEEL (0-2000 MW) TC16 RESERVE EMERGENCY LIGHT (OFF/ON) KAsim_ceitcertifi. doc 95
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 i APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING 1 TH01 RCP A OC TRIP DEFEAT (NORMAL / DEFEAT) TH02 RCP B OC TRIP DEFEAT (NORMAL / DEFEAT) TH03 RCP C OC TRIP DEFEAT (NORMAIJDEFEAT) TH04 RCP D OC TRIP DEFEAT (NORMAL / DEFEAT) TH05 RCP A OVERCURRENT RESET (NORMAL / RESET) TH06 RCP B OVERCURRENT RESET (NORMAL / RESET) TH07 RCP C OVERCURRENT RESET (NORMAL / RESET) TH08 RCP D OVERCURRENT RESET (NORMAL / RESET) TH09 PRESSURIZER SPRAY ISO VLV RYO23 (0-100%) ) TH10 PRESSURIZER SPRAY ISO VLV RYO24 (0-100%) l Till1 PRT VENT TO CNTMT 8043 (0-100%) l TH12 PRT N2 SUPPLY REG STPT (0-50 PSIG) TH13 LOCAL TRIP OF RCP 1A (NORMAL / TRIP) TH14 LOCAL TRIP OF RCP 1B (NORMAL / TRIP) , THIS LOCALTRIP OF RCP 1C (NORMAL / TRIP) TH16 LOCAL TRIP OF RCP ID (NORMAL / TRIP) TH17 REACT. VSL LVL ISOLATION (ISO /OPEN) TH18 LOOSE PARTS MONITORING SYS ALARM RESET (NORMAL / RESET) TH19 STEAM GEN 1 A TUBE PLUGGING (0-100%) . TH2O STEAM GEN IB TUBE PLUGGING (0-100%) TH21 STEAM GEN IC TUBE PLUGGING (0-100%) TH22 STEAM GEN 1D TUBE PLUGGING (0-100%) l l i l l l l O l K:\sim_centcertifi. doc 96 j i
l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 f~h l APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING l TP01 H2 SIDE SOP BYPASS VLV 1TO5242 (0-100%) l TP02 GEN HYD VENT VLV 1HY5024 (0-100%) l TP03. GC FILTINLT GC5403/GC5404 (GC5403/GC5404) l TPO4 GC HX #2 OUTLT GC5405 (0-100%) TP05 GC HX OUTLT GC5406/GC5407 (GC5406/GC5407) TP06 GC HX INLT GC5408/GC5409 (GC5408/GC5409) TP07 GC DEMIN INL GC5420/GC5422 (GC5420/GC5422) TP08 GC DEMIN BYPASS GC5424 (0-100%) TP09 GEN H2 SUPPLY REG 1HY5054 (0-100 PSIG) , TP10 GEN CO2 SUPPLY OC0005 ! ! (0-100 PSIG) TP11 AIR SIDE SO B/U REG ITOS264 (0-50 PSID) TP12 AIR SIDE SO PRESS REG ITO5256 (0-50 PSID) TP13 H2 PRESS REG TO5210/FO5217 (-50-+50 INH 2O) ; t A TPl4 IGC01PA PUMP CONTACT 13B-13C l ON 1PDS-GC023 ON LOW D/P (NORMAI/OPEN) TP15 TP LOCAL ALARM ACKNOWLEDGE (NORMAL /ACK) i O I 0 l K:Mn_cerNettifi. doc 97
l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,19% lO l APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCITON LISTING TUDI TURNING OEAR LOCAL CONTROL SWITCH (AUTO / MANUAL) TUO2 TURNING GEAR LOCAL PUSHBUTTON (NORMAL /STOP/ START) l l TUO3 TURBINE OIL MAKEUP (CLOSE/OPEN) TUO4 TURBINE OIL DRAIN (CLOSE/OPEN) l I l l l l !O l l l l
- O i
K:\sim_cerfcertifi. doc 98 l l
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING WD01 SG A BD FLOW CV SD0054A (0-100%) WD02 SG A BD FLOW CV SD0054B (0-100%) WD03 SG D BD FLOW CV SD0054C (0-100%) WD04 SG D BD FLOW CV SD0054D (0-100%) WD05 SG B BD FLOW CV SD0054E (0-100%) , WD06 SG B BD FLOW CV SD0054F (0-100%) WD07 SG C BD FLOW CV SD0054G (0-100%) WD08 SG C BD FLOW CV SD0054H (0-100%) WD09 CST /COND SEL WX293/WX883A (CST / CONDENSER) j WD10 RCDT DRAIN TO SUMP RE9163 (CLOSE/OPEN) WDil RCDT DISCH RE9171/AB8551 (RWST/ HUT) WD12 RELEASE TK PUMP (OFF/ON) WD13 RELEASE TK DISCH VALVE (CLOSE/OPEN) p WD14 SG BLDN PANEL TROUBLE RESET (RESET / SET) V WD15 BLDN SECONDARY SAMPLE ISOL VLV (AUTO /OPEN) WD16 BA/GW/RE LOCAL PANEL TROUBLE RESET (NORM / RESET) l R \sim_cerfcertifi. doc 99
. ~ _ . _ . _ _ . . _ _ . _ . _ - . . . _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ , , , _ , , _ _ , _ _ , _
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 2 REMOTE FUNCTION LISTING YR01 RM11 POWER SUPPLY SW (NORMAL / BACKUP) YR02 RM23 REMOTE / LOCAL SW (REMOTE / LOCAL) i l 1 l l
\
l i O 1 1 i O K:\sim_cerecenifi. doc 100
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR < ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 l 1 J i l J l APPENDIX 3 l l LIST OF ACRONYMS / ABBREVIATIONS 1' l. i l l' l l l l l l t l l L. l K:Mim_cerfcertifi. doc 101 i t . . . - . .__...._m.- . _ .~ _________!
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 3 LIST OF ACRONYMS / ABBREVIATIONS ACRONYM / ABBREVIATION DESCRIFFION AF Auxiliary Feedwater AN Annunciator BDPS Boron Dilution Prevention System BOL Beginning of Life BwOS Braidwood Operating Surveillance BwVS Braidwood System Engineering Surveillance CB Control Bank CC Component Cooling Water C/D Cooldown CH Containment CS Containment Spray CV Chemical & Volume Control CW Circulating Water O DC D/G Direct Corrent Diesel Generator I l EC Exempt Change ED Electrical Distribution EG Electrical Generator EOL End of Life ESD Equipment Status Display ESF Engineered Safety Features FP Fire Protection FW Feedwater, Heater Drain, Condensate GSEP Generating Station Emergency Plan HD Heater Drains HV Ventilation i HX Heat Exchanger l IA Instrument Air IC Initial Condition I/O Input / output i IPC In-Plant Computer K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 102
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 l APPENDIX 3 LIST OF ACRONYMS / ABBREVIATIONS ACRONYM /ABBREVIAT[QH DESCRIPTION l KV Kilovolt LED Light Emitting Diode LER Licensee Event Report MCR Minor Change Request MIDS Movable Incore Detector System MOL Middle of Life MW Megawatt NI NuclearInstrumentation NR Narrow Range NO Normal Operations PA Public Address PIF Problem Identification Form O PPM PZR Parts per Million Pressurizer PS Primary Sampling PW Primary Water PWR Pressurized Water Reactor RCFC Reactor Containment Fan Cooler RCP Reactor Coolant Pump RCS Reactor Coolant System RD Rod Drive RF Remote Function Ril/RHR Residual Heat Removal RIL Rod Insenion Limit RM Radiation Monitoring RP. Reactor Protection RPM Revolutions per Minute RX Reactor , 1 S/D Shutdown l SER' Sequence of Events Recorder j S/G Steam Generator SI Safety Injection SPDS Safety Parameter Display System SS Steady State K:Mim_cenVertifi. doc 103 j
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 3 LIST OF ACRONYMS / ABBREVIATIONS ACRONYM / ABBREVIATION DESCRIPTION SSCR Setpoint/ Scaling Change Request S/U Stanup SW Service Water SX Essential Service Water l TR Transient Test TC Turbine Control TDI Training Department Instmetion Til Thermohydraulics Model(RETACT) l TP Turbine Plant Auxiliaries TR Transient Test TU Turbine Oil l UF Under Frequency UV Under Voltage VC Control Room Ventilation l WD Waste Disposal WR Wide Range / Work Request XE Xenon YR Radiation Monitor Display l I l l l 'O l K:\sim_cenScenifi. doc 104 l l-L, , , - . -- , -
.~. .__-_.._._._ _ _ ....__.._ .. _._ _ ._ ._ __.____.___.. ._ _ _ _ __. _ ___ _ _ BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% i i APPENDIX 4 : BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW BOARD QUALIFICATIONS I O l O K:\sim_cen ecertifi. doc 105 l
-. . , - .- \
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR
- ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996
^
l APPENDIX 4 BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW BOARD QUALIFICATIONS l MEMBERS OUALIFICATIONS 1 l , l 1. KEN TIEFENTHAL POSITION BRAIDWOOD LICENSED OPERAT('R 1 l , INSTRUCTOR / SIMULATOR FIDEL'TY COORDINATOR. BACKOROUND SRO LICENSE BRAIDWOOD; NAVY EOOW(4 YRS)/EWS (9 YRS)
- 2. DANIEL P. BURTON POSTION BRAIDWOOD LICENSED OPERAT( R INSTRUCTOR /REQUAL LEAD INSTRUCTOR.
BACKGROUND SRO CERTIFICATION - BRAIDWOOD (* SIMULATOR; NAVY EWS (8 YRS)
- 3. PAUL HIPPELY POSTION BRAIDWOOD LICENSED OPERATOR INSTRUCTOR.
BACKOROUND SRO CERTIFICATION- BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR; ; NAVY RO(6 YRS)
- 4. DON LESNICK POSTION BRAIDWOOD LICENSED OPERATOR INSTRUCTOR.
BACKOROUND SRO CERTIFICATION- BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR; BS NUCLEAR I NOINEERINO; BRAIDW' 'OD : RATION SYSTEM j ENGINEERING 5 YRS O K:\sim_certhnifi. doc 106
l- ! BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O : I l l l l l l l APPENDIX 5 l l' l I l ANSI /ANS - 3.5 - 1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l l CROSS REFERENCE MATRIX l-l
- O l
i l l l i
- O !
l l 107 I K:\sim_cenVenifi. doc l i _ _ _ . . _ . - . - . . . _ - _ _ _ _ _ . - _l
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR , ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 5 ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT CROSS REFERENCE MATRIX LOCATION IN CERTIFICATION ! ANSUA NS-3.5-1985 REOUIREMENT REPORT l
)
! SECTQN DESCRIPTION SECTION l 3.1.1 Normal Plant Evolutions A.S.2, Attaclunent 2 3.1.2 Plant Malfunctions A.I.3.2, A.3.4, Attachment 6 3.2.1 Degree of Panel Simulation A.I.2.2, Attachment 5 l 3.2.2 Controls on Panels A.I.2.2 , 3.2.3 Control Room Environment A. I .2.1, A. I .2.4 3.3.1 Control Room Systems A. I.2.3 3.3.2 System Operation Outside Control A.I.3.3, Appendix 2 Room 3.4.1 Initial Conditions A.I.3.1, Appendix 1 3.4.2 Malfunctions A.I.3.2 3.4.3 Other Control Features A.I.3.4 3.4.4 InstructorInterface - A.I.3.3, Appendix 2 4.1 Steady State Operation A.3.2, Attachment 2 4.2 Transient Operation A.I.3.2, A.3.2, A.3.3, Attachment 2 l 4.3 - Simulator Operating Limits A.3.4 4.4 Monitoring Capability Attaciunent 2 i l K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 108
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 APPENDIX 5 ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT CROSS REFERENCE MATRIX ( l LOCATION IN CERTIFICATION ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 REOUIREMENT REPORT l SECTION DESCRIPTION SECTION i l 5.1 Simulator Design Data A.2, Attachment 4 l 5.2 Simulator Update Design Data A.1.5, A.4.2, Attaciunent 4 5.3 Simulator Modifications A.1.5, A.4.2, Attachment 4 5.4.1 Simulator Performance Testing A.2, Attachment 2 l e 5.4.2 Simulator Operability Testing Attachment 2 I
- NOTE l
- APPENDIX A, GUIDE FOR DOCUMENTING SIMULATOR PERFORMANCE, *
- WAS UTILIZED AS THE FORMAT FOR TIIIS REPORT. THEREFORE, *
- APPENDIX A CROSS-REFERENCE MATRIX DATA WILL NOT BE LISTED.
- B.2.1 Steady State Perfonnance A.3.2, Attachment 2 B.2.2 Transient Performance A.3.2, Attaclunent 2 l
l 4
- O K
- Vim _cerfcertifi. doc 109
i l I BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT ! APRIL,19% . l 1 1 ! r 1
- i i
! APPENDIX 6 i
4 SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE I i AND MALFUNCTION TESTING SCHEDULE l i l i
+
( l . O , K:Mim_certVertifi. doc 110
l TDI 700-03 i Revision: 00 l I l lV O l Braidwood Station ! Training Department Instruction i SIMULATOR TESTING PROGRAM A. Purpose l
- 1. The purpose of this guideline is to establish a program to test the simulator in accordance with the requirements of:
- a. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training i
- b. Reg Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in l
Operator License Examinations I
- c. 10 CFR 55.45: Operating Tests
- d. NUREG-1258: Evaluation Procedure for Simulation Facilities Certified Under 10 CFR 55 4
I B. References
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator l l Training
- 2. Reg Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations
- 3. 10 CFR 55.45: Operating Tests
- 4. NUREG-1256: Evaluation Procedure for Simulation Facilities Certified Under 10
(- ( CFR 55 t o- .
TDI 70043 Revision: 00
- 5. Braidwood Simulator Certification Report O C. Instruction
- 1. Testing Administration
- a. Each test will utilize a Test Procedure Cover Sheet, Attachment A. Each cover sheet gives a brief summary of the status of each test. On the cover sheet, the test team will indicate:
- 1) The test number, date perforr9ed and test description.
- 2) For any work request written as a result of performing the test, include on the cover sheet the work request number, brief description and section of test requiring retest (as appropriate). Upon correcting a work request, the initials of the tester and the date will also be entered on the cover sheet.
- 3) Test results:
One or more of the following may be checked: p a) Test completed satisfactorily. The test was performed and Q parameters are within the acceptance criteria. In addition, no work request has been written, or a work request has been written and completed which is relatively minor and does not require a complete retest. In addition, list any Deviation Record numbers (DR #) that are written. Attachment B, Simulator Testing Record, will be used to document any deviations. b) After correction of above discrepancies, test results are satisfactory. The test was performed and most parameters are within the acceptance criteria. However, work request (s) have been written for items which are minor in nature and have no significant effect on the test results. Therefore, a complete retest is not necessary. However, at a minimum the affected portion of the test will be retested. This will include all parameters which were initially outside the acceptance criteria. After correction of the work request, the test can be considered satisfactory and so indicated on the test cover sheet after the affected portion of the test is retested. O 2 A
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 l c) Test results unsatisfactory. Work request (s) were written having a g significant impact on the test results. A complete retest is necessary. This would require the use of an additional cover sheet and copy of the test procedure. DQ NOT DISCARD Ijig FAILED TEST PROCEDURE! File it with the appropriate test j for that year.
- 4) Signature Block: Sign the test as each test is completed. The Simulator Fidelity /Cenification Coordinator (SFCC) must also sign each test.
2: Simulator Testing Program l a. The intent of the simulator testing program is to:
- 1) Verify overall simulator model completeness and integration.
- 2) Verify the current simulator performance against the steady state and transient test criteria of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985.
l l b. The program consists of annual steady state, real time, and transient tests as well as 25% of the malfunction tests, normal operations tests and surveillance tests. Valve stroke time testing will be performed biennially commencing in 1992. For the purposes of this guideline, a year shall begin I on April 13 and end on April 12. The simulator testing program shall r commence April 13,1992 (Date of Simulator Certification Resubmittal). I l
- 1) Steady State Test: Annually, perform the Steady State Operability Test l #SS-1.
l 2) Real Time Test : Annually, perform the Real Time Test #RT-1.
- 3) Transient Tests: Annually, perform the following transient tests:
a) Manual reactor trip #TR-1. b) Simultaneous trip of all feedwater pumps #TR-2. ' L c) Simultaneous closure of all main steam isolation valves #TR-3. d) Simultaneous trip of all reactor coolant pumps #TR-4. l e) Trip of any single reactor coolant pump #TR-5. l f) Main turbine trip (without immediate reactor trip) #TR-6. l g) Maximum rate power ramp #TR-7. t h) Maximum size reactor coolant system mpture combined with loss j of all offsite power #TR-8. i) Maximum size unisolable main steam line rupture #TR-9. , j) Slow primary system depressurization to saturation #TR-10. lO 3 l l
.Q
TDI 7004)3 Revision: 00 g 4) Valve Stroke Time Test: Biennially perform the Valve Stroke Time (g Test #ST-1. ! i
- 5) Normal Operations Test, Surveillance Test, and Malfunction Tests:
Perform ~25% of the testing each year. NOTE
- ANY NEW MALFUNCTION WILL BE TESTED IN THE YEAR IT
- IS TURNED OVER FOR TRAINING AND AT LEAST EVERY
- FOUR YEARS THEREAFTER. THE NEW MALFUNCTION
- SHOULD BE ADDED SUCH THAT AN EVEN MALFUNCTION
- TESTING DISTRIBUTION (~25% PER YEAR) WILL BE MAINTAINED.*
- c. Simulator Malfunction Testing Schedule
- 1) The simulator testing program for these tests is on a four year cycle such that approximately 25% of the tests will be performed each
( year. Attachment 6 of the Simulator Cenification Report identifies the frequency and proposed testing schedule for each simulator cenified malfunction. Attachment C identifies the frequency and proposed testing schedule for each simulator non-cenified malfunction. During the performance of each malfunctio'n test, the test team will update each Malfunction Cause & Effects Sheet. This update will verify that each Malfunction Cause & Effects Sheet is complete.
- d. Simulator vs. Station Hardware Comparison
- 1) A simulator to Braidwood Unit One hardware comparison will be performed within six months after the completion of each Braidwood Unit One refueling outage. Braidwood Unit One photographs or detailed comparison sheets similar to the forms used in NUREG-1258 may be utilized for the comparison. Noted differences between the station and the simulator will be corrected by the Work Request process or the difference will be documented in the Simulator Cenification Repon.
O 4 9
~ ~ . - . . ~ - . - - - . - . , - _ . _ . - _ - - . - . - - - . - . . - . . . - - . - . -
i TDI 700-03 i Revision: 00 i jg
- e. Malfunction Assessment Review Program t
{ lV l
- 1) Braidwood LER's and other industry events will be reviewed annually to assess their potential impact on simulation. This review i
! will determine the LER's and industry events selected for testing. Each ! j of the selected LER's/ industry events will use a Simulator LER Test j E Procedure, Attachment F, to check the simulator response. A Test Procedure Cover Sheet, Attachment A, will be used to document the
- results of each test. The LER's/ industry events, once tested satisfactory, may be referenced and included as an event for the ,
{ applicable malfunction in the Malfunction Cause & Effects Book.
- 3. The SFCC will designate the LER's/ industry events that will be -
} selected for testing. The results of the Malfunction Assessment Review : will be filed in SIM-BW-9F:YR. ! f. Transient Test Review Board ! l
- 1) After completion of the annual transient testing, a Transient Test Review Board will convene to determine if the simulator has the
- capability to reproduce the defined transients.
1 ! 2) The Review Board will consist of 3-5 members with each member jc holding an SRO license or SRO certification. The Review Board will !
- j. compare the simulator transient test results with its baseline data and .
~
determine if the simulator has the capability to reproduce the defined j transients. The transient test comparison will be documented on l Attachment D, Simulator Transient Test Review. The makeup and . 2 qualifications of the Review Board and any differing professional i, opinions will also be documented. 4 g. Simulator Testing Results
- 1) The results of simulator testing will be documented in each year's
- Simulator Certification Report. Deficiencies will be handled by two i methods. The first method is to write a Work Request for those items j which require simulator software or hardware work. The second i
- method is to document the deficiency on the Simulator Testing Record, '
Attachment B. The Deviation Record (DR) is for those items that are j outside of the acceptance criteria yet do not require correction. For j example, the Steady State Test compares Braidwood plant data to the j simulator. If an initial simulator parameter did not fall within i 2% of the same Braidwood parameter, then the acceptance criteria would not j . be met. However, the simulator parameter may be at a nominal value while the Braidwood parameter fell within its expected range during data collection. Each deviation will be approved by the SFCC. The 5 { ! a
~
I -
1 TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 1 f results of the malfunction tests will also be documented in each year's l l Simulator Certification Repon. If a malfunction fails, a Work Request I will be written to correct the failure. In addition, a record of all "NOT AUTHORIZED FOR USE" malfunctions will be kept current and placed in the Simulator Malfunction Cause & Effects Book. This "NOT AUTHORIZED FOR USE" letter will designate the malfunctions currently unavailable for training. A copy of the "NOT AUTHORIZED FOR USE" letter will be filed in SIM-BW-lC3-YR.
- 3. Simulator Modification Program
- a. Incorporating design data into the simulator design data control is required to provide a means for on-going verification of simulator performance. This verification will be accomplished by:
- 1) Reviewing Braidwood Unit One modifications at least once per year i and revising the simulator based on engineering and training value assessment. The simulator will be revised, as appropriate, within 12 j months of installation of the modification at Braidwood Unit One, i Simulator modifications may precede Braidwood Unit One i modifications based on training value.
- 2) Evaluating student feedback and updating the simulator design database,
'O as appropriate.
- 4. Simulator Certification Reponing
- a. An annual update to the simulator certification repon is required to be submitted to the Simulator Review Board by the anniversary date of the current simulator certification. The annual update to the simulator cenification report is submitted and approved by the Simulator Review Board and maintained on file. It is not submitted to the NRC.
- b. The renewal simulator certification report is required to be approved and submitted to the NRC on or before (usually one month in advance of) every 4th anniversary of the cu: rent cenification,
- c. The simulator certification date is the signature date on the current NRC Form 474 on file with the NRC.
- d. The simulator cenification report will be written in the fonnat specified in i Attachment A of ANSI /ANS - 3.5 - 1985.
l l I I O 6 n
)
i TDI 700-03 Revision: 00
- 5. New Training Load O a. Attachment E addresses the minimum testing program that is required to be l
completed prior to accepting a new load for training. The testing program { will include testing all work requests that were completed on the new I training load, testing various malfunctions and remote functions on different IC's, testing selected malfunctions, remote functions and models as determined by the SFCC and verifying that all IC's are written to incorporate the latest hardware and software changes as well as any procedure changes since the IC's were last written,
- b. Any variations from this checklist must be approved by the SFCC.
- c. Upon completion of Attachment E the SFCC will accept the new load for training. Attachment E will be filed in Sim-BW-6C-YR. In addition, the lead ;
software engineer will be informed that the new load has been accepted for l training. I i l l A V l Approved By b4 Date:h4 /993 Training Supenbr , i 1 f O final 7 l 1 i n
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 l l ATTACHMENT A i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: Date Performed Test
Description:
l l l l l Discrepancies Corrected (initials) Step # Conunents Step # for retest WR# and Date l l i
~%
(O l Test Results
- 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
l Retest Complete Date Test Complete Date SFCC Acceptance Date fina! I c
_ . . . . . - - - - . - - - . - - . _ = - - - . . . . - - . . - - - . - . . . - . . . . . . . . . TDI 700-03 I Revision: 00 1 i i ATTACHMENT B 1 SIMULATOR TESTING RECORD l i DR#- TEST # COMMENTS l l l l l l' i i i t [ 1 1 I i i DR(s) accepted l SFCC l l iO i fmal l 1 i . t
. _ --.9..
TDI 70043 , Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT C NON-CERTIFIED MALFUNCTIONS TESTING SCHEDULE ! i NOTE
- l Although Attachment C Malfunctions are Non-Certified Malfunctions,
- these malfunctions shall be tested every 4 years per ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 .
and Reg. Guide 1.149 guidance. These malfunctions may be used to
- enhance simulator training. -
- MALFUNCTION TEST CYCLE ;
NUMBER TITLE (OUARTER - YEAR) AN02 Loss of Fuse to the AN Cabinet Rack 2nd - 1993 O CH05 Rod Stuck During Head Removal 3rd - 1993 1 CH07 Dropped Fuel Bundle During Refueling 2nd - 1994 FP01 Manual Fire Suppression Water System Activation 3rd - 1994 FP02 Auto Fire Suppression Water System Activation 2nd - 1995 l YR01 Loss of RM-11 Communication Loop 3rd - 1995 l l O V nnal 1 __ _ _. _ _ v
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: DATE:
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices)
- a. Actual plant transient data EVENT:
- b. Analytical or design data DATA:
- c. Transient data from similar plant PLANT:
- d. Panel of experts (best estimate)
COMMENTS: l \ \O
- 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION c
l I l l 1 l !.O ! l
- i J
-o_
l TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 t i ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR. TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW VARIABLE COMMENTS I RESOLUTION i l 1 b
- 3. Comparison Results Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one)
- a. ACCEPTABLE
- b. UNACCEPTABLE i 1
4.' Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented) i COMMENTS: O nnal 2 O
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 l ATTACHMENT E TRAINING LOAD ACCEPTANCE PROCEDURE l l TESTED INITIALS / SATISFACTORY DATE
- 1. Test the work requests that still require testing on the new load (some work requests may have been -
previously tested). YES/NO
- 2. RESET to the following IC's and at a minimum, perform the associated evolution (s).
- a. IC-21: Ramp power to 50% at 20 MW/ min. YES/NO
- b. IC-16: Ramp power to 75% at 10 MW/ min. YES/NO
- c. IC-13: Synchronize the main generator to grid and raise power to 20%. YES/NO
- d. IC-15: Perform a FW transfer and establish an AT POWER electrical lineup . YES/NO
- e. IC-26: Place the plant on RH (both trains). YES/NO O f.
g. IC-9: IC-2: Perform a Rx startup to the POAH. Draw a pressurizer bubble. YES/NO YES/NO
- 3. RESET to the following IC's and at a minimum, verify that the listed malfunctions operate correctly per their associated Malfunction Cause and Effects Sheet. For each '
evolution, use the appropriate procedures to stabilize the plant. l
- a. IC-22: TH06 (DBA LOCA). YES/NO l b IC-12: CV23A (Ietdown HX Tube leak). YES/NO
- c. IC-17: RD02 (Dropped Rod). YES/NO d IC-14: CV25 (Charging Line leak Inside Cnmt). YES/NO ;
e IC-20: ED12A (IAss of DC Bus 111). YES/NO
- f. IC-18: FW20 (Feed Break Outside Cnmt). YES/NO
- g. IC-19: NIO9 (PR Failure). YES/NO
- h. IC-23: RX21A (Pressurizer Pressure Channel 455 Failure). YES/NO
- i. IC-24: RX18 (NR RTD Failure). YES/NO
- j. IC-31: TH03 (SGTR). YES/NO f 4. RESET to each of the remaining IC's not used in steps l
2 and 3. Verify that each IC is stable (if applicable) and that the expected plant conditions exist. YES/NO I m
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT E O TRAINING LOAD ACCEPTANCE PROCEDURE TESTED INITIALS / SATISFACTORY DATE :
- 5. At the discretion of the SFCC, verify that the following function properly (List may include systems / components /models recently worked on and/or ANSI-3.5 testing).
\
- a. YES/NO
- b. YES/NO
- c. YES/NO
- d. YES/NO
- e. YES/NO
- f. YES/NO l g. YF.S/NO
- h. YES/NO
- i. YES/NO
- j. YES/NO LO l 6. Write IC's (as needed) to include any procedure changes, hardware changes or software changes. As a guide, use the attached 1
) comments noted from testing the load and comments accumulated in the SNAP Problem Book. YES/NO
- 7. Verify that the Malfunction Cause and Effects Sheets, "NOT AUTHORIZED FOR USE" letter and " Simulator Differences" are updated. YES/NO l 8. A summary of major work performed on the simulator has been routed to the simulator instructors for review. YES/NO New load is accepted for training.
l SFCC LO t final 9-
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ,4 ATTACHMENT F SIMULATOR LER TEST PROCEDURE l LER # Title-l Written By: Date: l The following test procedure will determine if the simulator is capable of reproducing the LER. (Complete as necessary) Attach a Test Procedure Cover Sheet (Attachment A) to document the results of this test. , Instructor Action / : Expected Indication / Results Panel Comnonent Ooerator Action Anree (Y/N) initials i l l i i
,r
. k/ I final 1 l 1 i .
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% O l APPENDIX 6 SIMULATOR MALFUNCTION TESTING SCHEDULE NUMBER TITLE TEST CYCLE (OUARTER-YEAR) AN01 LOSS OF ANNUNCIATOR HORN 2nd-19% CC01 CCW PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1996 CCO2 CCW PUMP DISCH PRESS S%TTCH FAILURE 2nd-1996 CC03 CCW SURGE TANK LEVEL TRANSMITTER FAILURE 2nd-1997 CC04 CCW FROM RHR HX LEAK 2nd-1996 CC05 CCW TO CC HX PIPING BREAK 2nd-1997 CC06 NON-ESSENTIAL CCW SYSTEM LEAK 2nd-1998 CC07 RCP THERMAL BARRIER LEAK 2nd-1999 CC08 CCW HX TUBE LEAK 2nd-1999 CC09 THERMAL BARRIER CCW FLOW X-MTITER FAILURE 2nd-1998 CH01 RCFC FAN FAILS TO START / TRIP, LOW SPEED 2nd-1997 CH02 RCFC FAN FAILS TO START / TRIP, HIGH SPEED 2nd-1998 CH03 CRDM FAN FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1999 CH04 REACTOR CAVITY BOOT FAILURE 2nd-1998 CHM BREAK IN CNTM INTEORITY 2nd-1998 CH08 CNTM PRESS TRANSMITTER FAILURE 2nd-1998 CS01 CNTM SPRAY PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1999 CS02 CNTM SPRAY PUMP SUCTION LINE BREAK 2nd-1998 I CV01 CHARGING PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1997 CV02 PRI WATER MAKE-UP PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-19% CV03 BORIC ACID XPER PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1999 CV04 VCT DIVERT VALVE FAILURE (122A) 2nd-19% CV05 PCV-131 AUTO CONTROLLER FAILURE 2nd-1997 CV06 CLOOGED RCS FILTER (lCV3CF) 2nd-1996 CV07 CLOGGED SEALINJECTION FILTER 2nd-1997 CV08 FAILURE OF FT-131 (L7DN PRESS) 2nd-1996 CV09 FAILURE OF TE-130 (LTDN HX TEMP) 2nd-1997 CV10 PLOW CONTROL VALVE CV121 FAILURE 2nd-1998 CVII CVCS UNBORATED MIXED BED DEMINERALIZER 2nd-1996 CV12 LTDN RFI JEF VALVE FAILS OPEN 2nd-19% l CV13 CHARGING LINE LEAK OUTSIDE CNTM 2nd-1997 CV14 REGENERATIVE HX TUBE LEAK 2nd-19% CV15 SEAL WATER HX TUBE LEAK 2nd-1997 CV16 VCT LEVEL MALFUNCTION (LT-il2) 2nd-1998 CVl7 VCT LEVEL MALFUNCTION (LT-185) 2nd-1999 CVl8 VCT PRESS MALFUNCTION (PT-115) 2nd-1999 j CVl9 MAKE-UP CONTROL FAILURE 2nd-1997 l CV20 BORIC ACID FLOW TRANSMITTER FAILURE (FT-110) 2nd-1998 CV21 CHARGING HEADER CONTROL FAILURE (HCV-182) 2rxl-1999 , CV22 LTDN LINE LEAK INSIDE CNTM 2rxi-1998 l CV23 LTDN HX TUBE LEAK 2nd-1998 CV24 LTDN LINE LEAK OUTSIDE CNTM 2nd-1999 { ' i CV25 CHARGING LINE LEAK INSIDE CNTM 2nd-1999 CV26 SEAL INJECTION LINE LEAK 2nd-19% K:\sim_ cert certifi. doc 111
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 6 SIMULATOR MALFUNCTION TESTING SCHEDULE NUMBER TITLE TEST CYCLE (OUARTER-YEAR) CV27 RCP SEAL #1 FAILURE 2nd 1998 CV28 RCP SEAL #2 FAILURE 2nd-1999 CV29 CHARGING PUMP DEGRADEDIMPELLER 2nd 1999 CWO! CIRC WATER PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1997 CWO2 CIRC WATER PUMP DISCHAROB VALVE FAILURE 2nd-1998 ED01 345 KV SWITCHYARD BREAKER FAILS TO TRIP 2nd-19% ED02 345 KV SWITCHYARD BREAKER TRIPS 2nd 1997 ED03 FAILURE OF UNTI' AUX TRANSFORMER (UAT) 2nd-1998 ED04 FAILURE OF SYSTEM AUX TRANSFORMER (SAT) 2 xi-1999 ED05 LOSS OF 6.9 KV BUS 2nd-19% ED06 FAILURE OF 6.9 KV ABT 2nd-1997 ED07 LOSS OF4160V BUS 2nd-1996 ED08 LOSS OF FEED TO 480V NON ESF BUS OR MCC 2rxl-1997 ED09 LOSS OF FEEDTO 480V ESF BUS OR MCC 2nd-1998 ; ED10 LOSS OF 120 VAC ESF CONSTANT VOLTAGE XFMR 2nd-19% i ED11 120 VAC INSTRUMENT BUS INVERTER FAILURE 2nd-1997 l ED12 LOSS OF DC DISTRIBUTION BUS 2nd-1999 ; ED13 DC CONTROL POWER FAILURE (4160V) 2nd-1998 i O D ED14 EDl5 DC CONTROL POWER FAILURE (480V) 345 KV BUS FAULT 2nd-19% 2nd-1999 ED16 LOSS OF FEED TO 120V NON-ESF PANEL 2nd-1998 ED17 LOSS OF FEED TO 120V ESF PANEL 2nd-1999 EG01 MAIN GENERATOR AUTO VOLTAGE REO FAILURE 2nd-1997 E002 MAIN OENERATOR EXCITER FAILURE 2n&l998 E003 MAIN GENERATOR FIELD PORCINO (VOLT REO) 2nd-1999 E004 BASE FOLLOWER UNIT FAILS TO TRACK 2nd-1996 EG05 MAIN POWER TRANSFORMER TRIP 2nd-1997 E006 D/O FAILURE TO FLASH FIELD 2nd-1998 E007 D/O ELECTRIC SPEED CONTROL FAILURE 2nd-1999 E008 D/O SEIZURE 2nd-1996 l E009 D/O DIFFERENTIAL OVERCURRENT TRIP 2nd-1997 FWOI M AIN FW PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP (MOTOR) 2 xi.I996 FWO2 MAIN FW PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP (TURBINE) 2nd-1997 FWO3 START UP FEED PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1998 FWO4 MAIN FW OIL PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1999 FWO5 TURBINE DRIVEN MFP CONTROL VALVE FAILURE 2nd-1996 I FWO6 TURBINE DRIVEN FW PUMP SPEED CONTROL FAILURE 2nd-1997 FWO7 FW PUMP SPEED CONTROL OSCILLATES 2nd-1998 FWO8 LOSS OF FW PUMP SPEED CONTROL 2rxi-1999 FWO9 S/O FW CONTROL VALVE FAILURE 2nd-I996 FW10 FW REGULATION BYPASS VALVE FAILURE 2nd-1997 FWII FW TEMPERING LINE ISOLATION VALVE FAILURE 2nd-1998 ' O FW12 FW PREHEATER BYPASS VALVE FAILURE 2nd-1999 l (-) FWl3 FW ISOLATION VALVE FAILURE 2nd-19% K:\sim_cerecertifi. doc 112
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% , ; ( APPENDIX 6 SIMULATOR MALFUNCr10N TESTING SCHEDULE N3hiBfa TITLE TEST CYCLE (OUARTER-YEAR) FW14 FEED LINE BREAK BETWEEN FWOO9 & CNTM 2nd-1997 FW15 MAIN FW PUMP SHAFT BREAK 2nd-1998 i FWl6 FW HEADER PRESS FAILURE 2nd-1999 l FW17 HEATER DRAIN TANK LEVEL CONTROLLER FAILURE 2nd-19% FWl8 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (17) 2nd-1997 FW19 FW LINE BREAK INSIDE CNTM 2nd-1998 FW20 FW LINE BREAK OUTSIDE CNTM 2nd-1999 FW21 S/G TEMPERING LINE RUFTURE 2nd-1996 FW22 CONDENSATE PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1997 FW23 FW HEATER BYPASS VALVE FAILURE (CB025) 2nd-1998 ; FW24 FAILURE OF AF SUCTION PRESS TRANSMIITER 2nd-1999 i FW25 GLAND STEAM CONDENSER MALFUNCTION 2nd-1996 l FW26 MAIN FEED REGULATING VALVE SEAT LEAKAGE 2nd-1997 FW27 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (11 DC) 2nd-1996 FW28 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (11) 2nd-1997 FW29 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (12) 2nd-1998 FW30 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (13) 2nd-1999 FW31 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (14) 2nd-1996
- _ h FW32 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (15 DC) 2nd-1997 i l V FW33 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (15) 2nd-1998 l FW34 FW HEATER TUBE LEAK (16) 2nd-1999 I FW35 HEATER DRAIN PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1998 FW36 LOSS OF CONDENSER VACUUM 2nd-1999 FW37 HOTWELL LEVEL CONTROLER FAILURE (CD037) 2nd-1996 I FW38 HOTWELL LEVEL CONTROLLER FAILURE (CD038) 2nd-1997 FW39 HOTWELL LEVEL CONTROLLER FAILURE (CD039) 2nd-1998 l FW40 HOTWELL LEVEL CONTROLLER FAILURE (CD040) 2nd-1999
- FW41 FWISOLATION AUX RELAY FAILURE (TRAIN A) 2nd-19%
FW42 FW ISOLATION AUX RELAY FAILURE (TRAIN B) 2nd-1997 FW43 AUX FW PUMP FAILS TO START /'IRIP (MOTOR) 2nd-1998 FW44 AUX FW PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP (DIESEL) 2nd-1999 l FW45 AUX FW VALVE FAILURE 2nd-19% l FW46 AUX FW LINE RUPTURE 2nd-1997 ! FW47 MFP SUCTION HEADER BREAK 4th-1997 HVOI CONTROL ROOM MAKE-UP FAN FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1998 HV02 AUX BLDG CHRCL BSTR FAN FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1999 IA01 LOSS OFINSTRUMENT AIR 2nd-19% IA02 LOSS OF SERVICE AIR 2nd-1997 l l IA03 IA LEAK INSIDE CNTM 2nd-1998 IA04 1A LEAK ON TURBINE BLDG HEADER 2nd-1999 IA05 SERVICE AIR COMPRESSOR FAILS TO START / TRIP 2nd-1996 1A06 MSIV ROOM HEADER LEAK 2nd-19"7 IA07 STEAM DUMP HEADER LEAK 2nd-1998
! - IA08 AUX FEED VALVES HEADER LEAK 2nd-1999 I
K:\sim_ceifcertifi. doc 113
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 6 - -
- - SIMULATOR MALFUNCTION TESTING SCHEDULE __-__-.--_.!
NUMBER TITLE TEST CYCLE (OUARTER-YEAR) i IA09 PENETRATION AREA HEADER LEAK 2nd-1996 MS01 FAILURE OF MAIN STEAM ISOLATION VALVE (S) 2nd-1997 MS02 MSIV BYPASS VALVE FAILURE 2rxi-1998 MS03 S/O SAFETY VALVE FAILURE 2nd-1999 ; MSO4 S/G PORV CONTROLLER FAILURE 2nd-1996 , MS05 STUCK STEAM DUMP 2nd-1997 MSM MSR FAILS TO ISOLATE 2nd-1998 MS07 STEAM LINE BREAK INSIDE CNTM 2nd-1999 MS08 STEAM LINE BREAK OUTSIDE CNTM 2nd-1996 MSO9 MAIN STEAM HEADER CROSS-TIE RUPTURE 2nd-1997 MS10 HEATER 13 EXTRACTION STEAM LINE BREAK 2nd-1998 MSII LOW PRESS TURBINE INLET PRESS SWITCH 2nd-1996 N101 SR CHANNEL FAILURE 2nd-1999 j N102 NOISY SR CHANNEL 2nd-1996 1 N103 SR CHANNEL HIGH VOLTAGE FAILURE 2rxi-1997 N104 FAILURE OF SR HIGH VOLTAGE TO DISCONNECT 2nd-1998 NIO5 SR DISCRIMINATION FAILURE 2nd-1999 NIM IR CHANNEL FAILURE 2nd-1996 O N107 NIO8 NIO9 IR CHANNEL GAMMA COMPENSATION FAILURE PR DETECTOR FAILURE PR CHANNEL FAILURE 2nd-1997 3rd-1998 2nd-1999 l NI10 INCORE MONTTORING SYSTEM FAILURE 3rd-1996 NIIi STUCK INCORE DEIECTOR 3rd-1997 NI12 LEAK INTO OUIDE TUBE FOR INCORE DETECTOR 3rd-1998 RDOI ROD DRIVE MO SET TRIP 3rd-1999 RD02 DROPPED ROD 3rd-1996 RD03 DROPPING ROD 3rd 1997 RD04 ROD EJECTION 3rd-1998 RDOS STUCK ROD 3rd-1999 RD06 RODS FAIL TO MOVE 3rd-1996 l RD07 UNCONTROLLED ROD MOVEMENT 3rd-1997 ] RD08 DRPI- DATA CABINET FAILURE 3rd-1998 j RD09 AUTO ROD SPEED CONTROLLER FAILURE 3rd-1999 i RD10 FAILURE ON LOGIC CABINET 3rd-1996 I RDI1 POWER CABINET FAILURE 3rd-1997 RD12 ROD STOPS FAIL - 3rd-1998 RDI3 DRPI- OPEN OR SHORTED COIL 3rd-1999 RH01 RHR PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 3rd-1996 ; R1102 RHR HX FLOW CONTROL VALVE FAILURE 3rd-19" 7 i R1103 RRR HX BYPASSVALVE CONTROL FAILURE 3rd-1998 RI104 RHR AUTO SWITCH-OVER MALFUNCTION 3rd-1999 RHO 5 RWST LEVEL TRASMITTER MALFUNCTION 3rd-1996 RH06 RHR HX TUBE LEAK 3rd-1997 i O' RH07 RHR HX BYPASS LINE LEAK 3rd-1998 , 1 1 K:\sim__certcenifi. doc 114
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ! ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPOR" APRIL,19% D APPENDIX 6 i SIMULATOR MALFUNCTION TESTING SCHEDULE ! NUMBER TITLE TEST CYCLE (OUARTER-YEAR) RH08 RWST LEAK 3rd-1999 RH09 RHR PUMP SUCTION HEADER BREAK 3rd-1996 RH10 RHR PUMP DISCHARGE HEADER BREAK 3rd-1997 i RHI1 SUCTION RELIEF VALVE FAILURE 3rd-1998 ) RM01 AREA RADIATION MONITOR ACTUATION 3rd-1999 ! RM02 INOPERABLE RADIATION MONITOR 3rd-1996 ) I RM03 INADVERTAffT AUTO RAD MONITOR ACTUATION 3rd-1997 RM04 PROCESS RADIATION MONITOR ACTUATION 3rd-1998 RM05 RAD MONTTOR INTERLOCK ACTUATION FAILURE 3rd-1999 RM06 OASEOUS AIR MONITOR FAILURE 3rd-1996 ] RP01 AUTOMATIC REACTOR TRIP FAILURE 3rd 1997 RP02 REACTOR TRIP BREAKER FAILS TO OPEN 3rd-1998 RP03 REACTOR TRIP BYPASS BREAKER FAILS TO OPEN 3rd-1999 I RPO4 FAILURE OF PHASE A CffrM ISOLATION TO ACTUATE 3rd-1996 J RP05 FAILURE OF PHASE B CNTM ISOLATION TO ACTUATE 3rd-1997 l RP06 TURBINE TRIP INTERLOCK C-8 FAILS 3rd-1998 ) RP07 UNDER-FREOUENCY ON RCP BUS 3rd-1999 ! RP08 UNDER-VOLTAGE ON RCP BUS 3rd-1996 RP09 INADVERTANT FW ISOLATION 3rd-1997 i \ RPIO INADVERTANT PHASE A CNTM ISOLATION 3rd-1998 RPII INADVERTANT PHASE B CNTM ISOLATION 3rd-1999 ; RP12 INADVERTANT CONTROL ROOM VEffT ISOLATION 3rd-1996 i RPl3 REACTOR TRIP PERMISSIVE P-4 FAILS TO ACTUATE 3rd-1997 l RPl4 FAILURE OF SAFETY INJECTION TO ACTUATE 3rd-1998 ; RPl5 SAFEOUARDS SEQUENCING FAILURE 3rd-1999 RPl6 PERMISSIVE P-6 FAILS TO ACTUATE 3rd-1996 RPl7 PERMISSIVE P-7 FAILS TO ACTUATE 3rd-1997 l RPIB PERMISSIVE P-8 FAILS TO ACTUATE - 3rd-1998 - RPl9 PERMISSIVE P-10 FAILS TO ACTUATE 3rd-1999 l RP20 PERMISSIVE P-11 FAILS TO ACTUATE 3rd-1996 ; 3rd-1997 ! RP21 LO-LO TAVE PERMISSIVE P-12 FAILS TO ACTUATE RP22 PERMISSIVE P-13 FAILS TO ACTUATE 3rd-1998 RP23 PERMISSIVE P-14 FAILS TO ACTUATE 3rd-1999 RP24 INADVERTANT SAFETY INJECTION 3rd-1996 i RP25 SSPS BLOWN OROUND RETURN FUSE 3rd-1999 RX01 STEAM PRESSURE DETECTOR FAILURE 3rd-1996 RX02 UNSTABLE S/G LEVEL COffTROLLER 3rd-1997 RX03 STEAM FLOW DETECTOR FAILURE 3rd-1998 3rd-1999 i RXO4 FW FLOW TRANSMITTER FAILURE RX05 STEAM LINE PRESS DETECTOR FAILURE (PT-507) 3rd-199f RXO6 NARROW RANGE S/O LEVEL FAILURE 3rd-1997 l RX07 WIDE RANGE S/O LEVEL FAILURE 3rd-1998 l b RXO8 STEAM DUMP COOLDOWN VLVS CONTROL FAILURE 3rd-1999 RXO9 STEAM FLOW DETECTOR OSCILLATION - TIME 3rd-1996 K:\sim_cenVenifi. doc 115
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 6
' SIMULATOR MALFUNCTION TESTING SCHEDULE NUMBER TITLE TEST CYCLE (OUARTER-YEAR)
RX10 FIR:iT STAGE PRESS TRANSMITTER FAILURE 3rd-1997 RXli STE AM PLOW DETECTOR OSCILLATION - MAGNITUDE 3rd-1998 RX12 TRI F FAILURE 3rd-1999 RXX 3 PZF MVEL CHANNEL FAILURE 3rd-1996 RX14 FW PUMP MASTER SPEED CONTROLLER FAILURE 3rd-1997 RX15 PZF PRESS MASTER CONTROLLER FAILURE 3rd-1998 RX16 PZF MVEL MASTER CONTROLLER FAILURE 3rd-1999 RX17 ROIi CONTROL SYSTEM FAILURE 3 d-1996 RX18 FAULTY PRIMARY RTD (NARROW RANGE Tc & Th) 4th-1997 RX19 LO! S OF LOAD INTERLOCK C-7 FAILS 4th-1998 RX20 COIIDENSER AVAILABLE INTERLOCK C-9 FAILS 3 d-1999 RX21 FZF PRESS CHANNEL FAILURE (455 & 456) 4th-1996 RX22 PZF PRESS CHANNEL FAILURE (457 & 458) 4th-1997 RX23 OVIIRPOWER DELTA T SETPOINT FAILURE 4th-1998 RX24 OVI!RTEMPERATURE DELTA T SETPOINT FAILURE 4th-1999 RX25 RC' PRESS TRANSMITTER FAILURE (403 & 405) 4th-1996 RX26 RCf. PRESS TRANSMITTER FAILURE (406 & 407) 4th-1997 RX27 RCD PRESS TRANSMITTER FAILURE (408 & 409) 4th-1998 RX28 RCD LOOP FLOW TRANSMITTER FAILURE dnd-1995 RX29 FW REG VALVE CONTROLLER FAILURE 4th-1996 RX30 FW BYPASS VALVE CONTROLER FAILURE 4th-1999 S101 SAI ETY INJllCTION PUMP falls TO START / TRIP 4th-1996 S10 2 SI A CCUMULATOR LEVEL XMITTER FAILURE 4th-1997 S10 3 COI.D 20 IJUECTION CHECK VLV LEAKAGE (SI8818) 4th-1998 S104 Col.D 20 INJECTION CHECK VLV LEAKAGE (S18819) 4th-1999 SIO5 COI.D 20 INJECTION CHECK VLV LEAKAGE (SI8948) 4th-1996 SIO6 COI .D BG BUECTION CHECK VLV LEAKAGE (S18956) 4th-1997 S107 HOT LEO INJECTION CHECK VALVE LEAKAGE (S18905) 4th-1998 S10 8 HOT MG INJECTION CHECK VALVE LEAKAGE (S18841) 4th-1999 SIO9 HOT LEO INJECTION CHECK VALVE LEAKAGE (S18949) 4th-1996 S11 0 HIGH HEAD SI LEAK INSIDE CNTM 4th-1997 SIIi SI ACCUMULATOR TANK RUFTURE 4th-1998 SWOI SX PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1999 SWO2 SX BREAK INSIDE CNTM 4th-1996 SWO3 LOSS OF SX COOLING TO D/G 4th-1997 SWO4 SX DISCHAFGE HEADER BREAK 4th-1998 SWO5 WS HEADER BREAK 4th-1999 SWO6 WS PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1996 TCOI INADVERTANTTURBINE RUNBACK 4th-1996 TCO2 TURBINE TFIP ON LOW LOAD (PDS-TOO71) 4th-1997 TCO3 TURBINE AUTO 1 RIP FAILURE 4th-1998 TC04 TURBINE AUTO RUNBACK FAILURE 4th-1999 TC05 OPC-LP TURB INLET PRESS SENSOR FAILURE 4th-1996 TC06 DEHC- IMP I'RESS XMITTER FAILURE (PT-MS002) 4th-1997 K:\sim._cerecentifi. doc 116
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% APPENDIX 6 SIMULATOR MALFUNCTION TESTING SCHEDULE NUMBER IHLE TEST CYCLE (OUARTER-YEAR) TC07 DEHC - MW TRANSDUCER FAILURE 4th-1998 ' TC08 DEHC - OV/TV OSCILLATIONS - TIME 4th-1999 TC09 DEHC - OV/TV OSCILLATIONS - MAGNITUDE 4th-1996 TC10 LOSS OF DEHC SPEED CONTROL CHANNEL (S) 4th-1997 _ TCli LOSS OF DEHC SUPERVISORY SPEED CHANNEL 4th-1998 l TCl2 EHC PILOT OPERATED IA VALVE FAILS (1EH5042) 4th-1999 _TCl3 TV SERVO FAILURE - VALVE FAILS 4th-1996 TC14 OV SERVO FAILURE - VALVE FAILS 4th-1997 TC15 EH SYSTEM LEAK 4th-1998 TCl6 OOVERNOR VALVES NOTTRACKING AUTO 4th-1999 I TC17 EH PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1996 i TC18 INADVERTANT OTITTTURBINE RUNBACK 4th-1999 ! TH01 PZR STEAM SPACE LEAK 4th-1997 TH02 PZR RELIEFTANK LEAK 4th-1998 TH03 S/O TUBE LEAK 4th-1999
]
TH04 RCS LEAK, HOT LEO (HIGH) 4th-1996 TH0S RCS LEAK, HOT LEO (MEDIUM) 4th-1997 I TH06 RCS LEAK, COLD LEO 4th-1998 ! 1N07 REACTOR VESSEL FLANGE LEAK 4th-1999 ) O. TH08 RCS FUEL ELEMENT FAILURE 4th-1996 TH10 PZR SPRAY VALVE FAILURE 4th-1998 THII PZR POWER OPERATED RELIEF VALVE FAILURE 4th-1999 TH12 PZR SAFETY VALVE FAILURE 4th-1996 TH13 PZR LEVEL DETECTOR REF LEO LEAK 4th-1997 I TH14 PZR RELIEF LINE RTD FAILURE 4th-1998 THI5 RCS WIDE RANGE RTD FAILURE 4th-1999 TH16 RCP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th 1996 TH17 RCP DEGRADED PERPORMANCE/ LOCKED ROTOR 4th-1997 TN18 RCPSHAFTBREAK 4th-1998 TH19 REACTOR VESSEL BOITOM CRACK 4th-1999 TP0I STATOR COOLING PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1999 TP02 STATOR COOLING WATER HIGH CONDUCTIVITY 4th-1996 TP03 SEAL OIL SYSTEM PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1997 I TUO! TURBINE VIBRATION 4th-1998 TUO2 TURBINE BEARING OIL PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1999 TUO3 TRBN HP SEAL OIL B/U PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1996 TUO4 TURBINE DC EMER OIL PUMP FAILS TO START / TRIP 4th-1998 TUO5 TURBINE OIL SYSTEM LEAK ; 'h-1997 Tl106 BEARING LIFT PUMP SUCrlON STRAINER CLOOS 4th-1995 WD01 OAS DECAY TANK RUFTURE 4th-1997 ' i 1 1 ; K:\sim_certVertifi. doc 117 i ; i
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% l l l A'ITACHMENT 1 l REO. GUIDE 1.149 REQUIREMENTS FOR l DUAL PLANT SIMULATION FACILITY Comparison of Braidwood Simulator to Braidwood Unit 2. l l O l 1 1 l l l O K:\sim_centertifi. doc 118 { . - - - . _ , . -
r-l' . BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR
- ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 O
t Q ,) Attaclunent 1 shall demonstrate that the Braidwood Simulator meets the requirements and guidance of ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 for Braidwood Unit 2. l l The simulator design data base is maintained from Braidwood Unit I data. No data base is maintained for Braidwood Unit 2, however, LER's and modifications are reviewed by the Braidwood Training Staff. A summary of the Braidwood Unit 2 LER's that were ! detennined to effect simulation follow: LER DESCRIPTION COMMFl4TS 20 2-92-002 Rx trip due to water hammer LER tested satisfactorily. prevention actuation. 20-2-92-004 Rx trip due to loss of both LER tested satisfactorily. motor-generator sets. O ! 20-2-92-006 Rx trip due to MFP trip on low LER tested satisfactorily. vacuum. 20-2-93-002 Deenergizing K628 fills pressurizer. LER tested satisfactorily. 20-2-93-007 Rx trip due to Feed Reg. Valve LER tested satisfactorily, failing closed. 20-2-94-003 Rx trip due to Main Power LER tested satisfactorily. Transformer failure. 20-2-94-005 Rx trip due to Feed Reg. Valve LER tested satisfactorily. failing closed. l lv i K:Mim_cerfcertifi. doc 119
. _ ~ . . - - - . - . . . . . . - . . . . . . - . - . . _ . -
4 BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 ,
. ) +
An analysis and summary of the differences between each plant and the Braidwood Simulator including facility design and systems relevant to control room personnel as well as control room design and instrument /controllocation are presented in sections A.I.2.2,3
& 4 of this report.
Major system differences between the simulator and Braidwood Unit 2 that affect simulator training are: 4 Braidwood Simulator Braidwood Unit 2
- 1) Electrical distribution system 1) Electrical distribution system and and unit components are labeled unit components are labeled Unit 2.
Unit 1.
- 2) The simulator has annunciators 2) Unit 2 has no armunciators associated with loss of power to associated with these common Radwaste and Turbine Building - systems.
electricalloads, River Screen House power supply problems and Spent Fuel Pit Level and Temperature. 1
- 3) S/G's are a D-4 S/G model. 3) S/G's are a D-5 S/G model.
a) Rx trip / Auxiliary Feedwater Pump a) Rx trip / Auxiliary Feedwater Pump auto-start setpoint is 33%. auto-start setpoint is 36.3%. I b) P-14 setpoint is 81.4%. b) P-14 setpoint is 80.8%. c) Slightly smaller shrink / swell c) Slightly larger shrink / swell ) characteristics than the characteristics than the D-4 l D-5 S/G model. S/G model. _ d) Normal operating level, high/ low d) Normal operating level, high/ low ) alarm setpoints are 66%,92.4% alarm setpoints are 63.7%,92.4%, I and 38%. and 41.3%. l e) ATWS Mitigation System actuation e) ATWS Mitigation System actuation setpoint is 30%. setpoint is 33.3%. K:Mim_certVertifi. doc 120
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT l APRIL,1996
- O We airrently train the operators on Unit I and 2 differences in a classroom setting. This training incorporates the Unit 2 D-5 S/G alarm setpoints, ESF actuation setpoints and normal operating S/G level.
Since Unit 1 and Unit 2 are almost identical, except for the steam generator differences,
' adequate Unit 2 training is conducted by comparing Unit i vs. Unit 2 S/G response.
Since Unit I and Unit 2 operate in a similar manner, only Unit 1 procedures are maintainei 1 and used for simulator training. The Unit 2 abnonnal and emergency procedures are developed from Unit I abnormal and emergency procedures and are almost identical. In J addition, Braidwood Units 1 and 2 emergency procedures are validated on the simulator. i O 1 l K:\sim_ceitcertifi. doc 121
BRAIDWOOD SI'MULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,1996 ATTACHMENT 2 STEADY STATE / NORMAL OPERATIONS / REAL TIME / VALVE STROKE TIME / TRANSIENT TEST RESULTS O K:\sim_centcertifi. doc 122 ,
I [ i l l Test Number: SI-1 ; O Revision #/Date: 4.11/1284 Prequency: Bienmal l BRAIDWOOD SIMUIATOR VALVE STROKE TIME TEST i A. PURPOSE l l The purpose of this procedure is to verify that the simulator's safety-related valves l stmke within an acceptable time period as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. B. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training
- 2. Inservice Testing Program: Valve Surveillance Cmss-reference l 3. Braidwood Simulator Cenification Report l 4. TDI700-03:SimulatorTestingProgram l
C. INITIAL CONDITIONS f 1. Use the cold shutdown initial condition. D. DATA COLLECTION (. 1. Attachment A, Valve Stroke Time Comparison Sheet, shall be used to document ! Braidwood Unit One and simulator valve stroke times. E. TESTINSTRUCTIONS ! 1. Obtain the latest set of Braidwood Unit One average valve stroke times from Reference 2 and record the stroke times in Attachment A, Valve Stroke Time Comparison Sheet.
- 2. Stroke each simulator valve listed in Attachment A and record the stroke time to the nearest tenth of a second.
F. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
- 1. The simulator's valve stroke time shall be +/- 10% or +/- 2 seconds of the
- Braidwood Unit One stroke time, whichever is greater.
G. DOCUMENTATION j
- 1. Retain Attachment A which will be used to document simulator compliance.
, 4 1 l l
Y d Test Number: SV-1 Revision Number /Date: 04. IIA)8/94 O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR SURVEILLANCE TESTING A. PURPOSE The purpose of this procedure is to:
- 1. Verify that ohrator conducted surveillance testing on safety-related equipment or systems can be conducted as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985.
- 2. Verify that the simulator's computed values of selected surveillance parameters shall agree within 10% (12 secs. for D/G starting time) of the Braidwood plant's surveillance parameters.
B. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training
- 2. Braidwood Unit One Surveillance Procedures
- 3. TDI 700-03: Sirnulator Testing Program
- 4. Simulator Test NO-1: Normal Operations Testing C. SURVEILLANCE SELECTION CRITERIA
- 1. The selection criteria used to meet ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, section 3.1.l(10) requirements (simulator surveillance testing) are:
- a. Surveillance is safety-related.
- b. Surveillance frequency is monthly or h as.
- c. Surveillance contains control room indications or requires control board manipulations.
- 2. The surveillances selected for testing have been approved by the Braidwood Simulator Review Board (SRB # BW-89-04).
D. INITIAL CONDITIONS
- 1. Use the BOL,100% power, equilibrium xenon initial condition (IC) unless lower power level is noted in the surveillance procedure.
O 1
y <* Test Number: SV-1 Revision Number /Date: 04. I1 A)8/94 On v BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR I i SURVEILLANCE TESTING i E. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. The Control Room data required by each Surveillance procedure shall be collected. !
\
- 2. Data that is obtained from outside the Control Room shall be obtained, if available, from l the simulator data pool variables. If the data is not available, mark that step N/A. i F. TEST INSTRUCI' IONS
- 1. Ensure that the simulator meets the initial condition as specified in Section D.
esseesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee++eesseessesseeesseessessess NOTE The simulator has the capability to conduct the shifty / daily *
- surveillances, various channel check surveillances and the *
- system lineup surveillances. These surveillances will not *
- be performed.
- ee++e+++e++++see+++seeeeeeee++++++++eseeesseesseeee+++.
**essessesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeese NOTE Plant surveillances requiring data comparison to the
- simulator are identified by an asterisk next to the
- surveillance number. Obtain a copy of the applicable plant *
- surveillance data for comparison to the simulator data.
- seeseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeessees l
l
- 2. Using the latest revision of the Braidwood Unit One Surveillances (BwOS's), perform the l following procedures: (conduct 1992-93 and every 4 years thereafter)
- a. IBwOS 1.1.1.1.e-1: Shutdown Margin Surveillance !
- b. 1BwOS 1.1.4.a-1:
RCS Minimum Temperature for Criticality Surveillance
- c. 1BwOS 1.3.1.2-1: Movable Control Assemblies Monthly Surveillance
- d. 1BwOS 1.3.5-1: Shutdown Rod Insertion Limit During Approach to Criticality !
Surveillance
- e. 1BwOS 2.4.1.a-1: Quadrant Power Tilt Ratio Surveillance
- f. 1BwOS 3.1.1-2: Calorimetric Calculation Daily Surveillance
- g. 1BwOS 3.4.2.a-1: Turbine Overspeed Protection Systems Monthly Surveillance
,
- h. 1BwOS 4.6.2.1.c-1: RCS Controlled leakage Monthly Surveillance 2
4* Test Number: SV-1 RevisionNumber/Date: 04.11A)8/94 BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR SURVEILLANCE TESTING ;
- i. IBwOS 4.6.2.1.d-1: RCS WaterInventory Balance 72 Hour Surveillance 1
- j. IBwOS 6.2.3.a-1: Reactor Contairunent Fan Cooler Monthly Surveillance
- k. IBwOS 7.3.1-1: CC System Valve Lineup to Safety Related Equipment Monthly Surveillance j
- 1. IBwOS 7.3.2.a-1: CC Pump Operability Monthly Surveillance ,
- m.1BwOS 8.1.1.2.a-1: 1 A D/G Operability Monthly Surveillance
- n. 1BwOS 8.1.1.2 a-2: IB D/G Operability Monthly Surveillance
- o. 1BwOS 8.2.1.1-1: DC Bus Train Operability Weekly Surveillance i G. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA )
i
- 1. Each surveillance can be perfonned satisfactorily using installed control board mstrumentation or variables available from the simulator data pool and meets the acceptance l criteria given in the surveillance.
- 2. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a l best estimate for each surveillance test and do not violate the physical laws of nature. !
b
'd 3. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not caur.e an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cau*e an alann or automatic action.
- 4. The simulator's surveillance data shall not deviate from the Braidwood plant's surveillance data by more than i10% for the following data:
- a. 1BwOS 4.6.2.1.c-1: RCP sealinjection flows.
- b. IBwOS 6.2.3.a-1: RCFC SX flows.
- c. 1BwOS 7.3.1-1: CC to RH HX flows.
- d. 1BwOS 7.3.2.a-1: CC pump current and discharge pressure.
- e. 1BwOS 8.1.1.2.a-1: 1A D/G voltage, and frequency.
- f. 1BwOS 8.1.1.2.a-2: IB D/G voltage, and frequency.
- g. IBwOS 8.2.1.1-1: DC bus 111 and 112 voltage.
- 5. The simulator's D/G's staning time shall not deviate from the Braidwood plant's surveillance data by more than i2 seconds.
H. DOCUMENTATION
- 1. Retain the surveillance procedures along with the copies of the selected plant suncillance data used for comparison.
3
3 TDI 700-03 R: vision: 00 4 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: A }O- I Date Performed /BIfff V Test
Description:
Nwal 00vuficos 15/43 l 4 4 Discrepancies Step # Corrected (initials)
- Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date i I i
!O ^ i i i [ 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
', 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required. 1 Retest Complete Date Test Complete kZ < Date /4/2r/5r Q G SFCC Acceptance l$pWY Date /2hrkr
'f ' '
final 1
Test Number: NO 1 l Revision Number /Date: 02.11M)9/93 BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR NORMAL OPERATIONS TESTING A. PURPOSE
- "Ihe purpose of this procedure is to verify that nonnal plant evolutions can be conducted on the
! simulator as requir~ed by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. l B. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training
- 2. BwGP 100 5: Braidwood General Procedures
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program C. INITIAL CONDITIONS
- 1. The Initial Conditions (IC's) will be specified under Section E, Test Instructions. l D. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. BwGP Flowchans shall be used to verify and document simulator compliance with the nonnal operations testing. l l
l E. TEST INSTRUCTIONS l
- 1. Using the latest revision of the Braidwood Unit One General Procedures (BwGP's), perform the i following evolutions: I 1
- c. Plant startup from cold shutdown to hot standby and a reactor stanup to 100% power. Use the l cold S/D IC which enters BwGP 100-1 at Step 1. (conduct 1994-95 and every 4 years thereafter) l i i I
- 1) This evolution includes turbine stanup, generator synchronization and load changes.
- b. Reactor trip from full power followed by recovery to full power. Use the BOL,100% power, 1 l equilibrium xenon IC to stan the evolution. (conduct 1993-94 and every 4 years thereafter) 1)'Ihis evolution includes operations at hot standby, turbine startup, generator synchronization, and load changes.
!O I l
e i Test Number: NO- 1 RevisionNumber/Date: 02.11A)9/93 BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR NORMAL OPERATIONS TESTING
- c. Plant shutdown from full power to hot standby and cooldown to cold shutdown. Use the BOL, 100% power, equilibrium xenon IC and enter BwGP 100-4 at Step 1. (conduct 1995-% and every 4 years thereafter) 1)'Ihis evolution includes operations at hot standby, load changes, and shutdown operations with less than full reactor coolant flow.
seeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees NOTES .
- 1. Startup and power operations with less than full reactor l coolant flow are not perfonned since only full reactor flow critical operation is allowed at Braidwood Station. l
- 2. Operator conducted surveillance testing on safety related j equipment or systems, plant heat balance and shutdown margin determination is addressed in the Simulator Surveillance Testmg Procedure (SV-1).
O
- Measurements of reactivity coefficients and control rod 3.
worth will not be performed since these tests require the use of a reactivity computer (which is not a permanently installed instrument) and the operator is not involved in the reactivity calculation (System Engineering function). esseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee**** F. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
- 1. Each evolution can be performed satisfactorily using Braidwood Unit One General Procedures.
- 2. The observable change in the parameters conespond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for each evolution and do not violate the physical laws of nature.
- 3. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alann or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic action.
G. DOCUMENTATION
- 1. Retain the BwGP Flowcharts to document simulator compliance.
2
-) .- -
O m../ v . OR INFORMATIC\ 0% _Y = d a;"' Continuous Use ENTER TIME: 0750
'h C
xr-eREREcuiSTiES our w"br SE= ur-1BwGP 100-4 FLOWCHART kr EXCEPTIONS: h PRECAUTIONS wr E LIMITATIONS AND ACTIONS J . INITIAL EACH RO O SRO O DEC DEC DEC TO < 80% MFP TO AUDiD TO RRD 50% POVER S/Dg 20% CD/CB 15% g 1 v@ v h v h v h v h v hh v FLOVCHART HPD DRAIN v S Kf v v 30% < 25 CLOSE POWER POVER F V009's
~
APPROVED AUG15 W AS S$dfSp
....soo.
. ...m -v--
7 @ v S/D ELEC STEAM DUMPS LINEUP"
Q o Le o
~0R INFORMATI0N 0N Y _
>w --m Revision 5 Continuous Use n
IBwGP 100-4 FLOWCHART EXCEPTIONS: INITIAL EACH RO O SRO O Roos Msn e4 noot MV T RE P-7p f HDP LEVEL b g it 33j E*">
<5*
I I j l l rI bogf cs r ilHE 07f[ DATE IL[Ehf APPROVED AUG151995
,ng,no,,c, en AIDS 4000
o o o "; 18wGP 100-5T1 Revision 7
,, continuous Use ENTER ilHE: O *l oo h
C eREREouiSTiES oa't= 'rk'Ar sE. y <- 1BwGP 100-5 FLOWCHART Fr EXCEPTIONS: O PRECAUTIONS 5fq gy n g cjeu, c , g y,,a, g ,, , ,, gg , g , ,p ,, itT TURB S/D Ster Si nof Sh*Ni$ d*Ja N 'Mb
- E tiHITariONS ano ACriONS 4
FVP N ' INITIAL EACH RO O SRO O l FLOVCHART { l 5 LOV TEMP G S. CI DVERPRESS SURV C6 S/D CD/CB 3 > I I Ov CV v g L.U. 2 RRD r ----> l BwGP 100-2 l l HDDE ALIGN RX CHAT 4GE S/D TEMP TAvE S/D 2 TO 3 FLOV SDM gc 557' bat 1KS f Q( DEGAS Y v Q v QY v v Q( v @HSB( 6 l i 1 Od ei I I I r--- , i ,g ,,,g i L_______J ANMMD _._ ! ._QF__!. _ ._. - - - - - FER 17 B94
.?l"^li':l",":,
( I / .:'. / *s 4 I i
0 0 0 . 1BwGP 100-5T1 Revision 7
,. Continuous Use PORV aan LOV TEMP .
1BwGP 100-5 FLOVCHART
> EXCEPTIONS:
S/G h SeG INITIAL EACH RO O SRO O SAMPLES APPROVED FEB 171994 o $RL .a
'YUR yr /"
MODE STEAM PZR RCS P-Il SI CHANGE PZR DUMP LVL PRES 19301: RCP ( ICV 8455" 3 TO 4 g
; @g ~ ,
@g , @*( @ @'
ACCUM'
@ @ 4 I i = 35W 3fg I I POR m__ _m LETDOVN
O O O .. 1BwGP 100-5T1 ; Revision 7 ;
, continuous Use i
1BwGP 100-5 FLOVCHART ! EXCEPTIONS: RH SAMPLEg
- ' A3 s3' Si/Cv DpS INITIAL EACH RO O SRO O DOS MANAGER
@pf Af 4 i C Y W c
- 4 s 3r PORV G BREAK STROKE 212*
VACUUHgi O Ar , S/D F k SURV AWf O[ h S/D 350s CC RH CDPS CV/RH S
<4 8"%r S G.
ETDOVg 33 36 37 3 @^*"! _J ______________________________ 49 , MODE .
'APPROV E0 S/D PORV CHANGE SyfAr D 4 TO 5 LitEUP fvP g STROKE g Ta i 71994
=
Q Q f(
. . .. . c ,
Q > ( l / J *./ 9 4 4 4
. . . ~ .
O O O - f 19wGP 100-5T1 Revision 7
.- Continuous Use l
c 1BwGP 100-5 FLOWCHART EXCEPTIONS: b INITIAL EACH RO O SRO O RP 7 APPROVED FEB 1. 71994 on?s !nz CS REFUEL S/D RCSp)[kCHEM SOLID k H,De r >/p RCS//r S/DYk RCP DEPRES DRAIN S/D
!C DOS Cs RC DEGAS ADD COOLDOVN RCS - RCSY& VP.
(200* F I i i I 57 i s100* F I ihih C180* F l I 61
< 3 4 0* F l
E hLTE l l l l l l l l L____J L____J L____J L____J TIME /300 DATE Id!8I fS SE /d ( F 1 sua l ) I l / 2'./ 9 4 ) _ _ _4 _ ., ._ _ _ . _ _
*r
, TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: U-/ Date Performed ,/fr/56
/
Test
Description:
Qh ch SMe /edi a/ /v/ 7f mdfM
/
l Discrepancies Step # Corrected (initials) Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date
)dow l
. . . _ i Test Results v
f
- 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete 8 Id Date //a6/14 C) SFCC Acceptance IId y Date //26A6 1
*, i Test Number: SS-1 Revision Number /Date: 10.1009/94 ;
Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR STEADY STATE TESTING i I. PURPOSE j The purpose of this procedure is to:
- 1. Verify that the simulator values for 100% are stable and will not vary by more than 2%
of the initial values over a 60 minute period. -l l
- 2. Verify that the simulator values of critical parameters shall agree within i 2% (plus l instnunent accuracy) of Braidwood Unit One critical parameters and shall not detract from ,
l training as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5 - 1985 " Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use m -i Operator Training".
)
- 3. Verify that the simulator values of non-critical parameters shall agree within i 10% (plus instrument accuracy) of Braidwood Unit One non-critical parameters and shall not detract l l from training as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5 - 1985 " Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for i
/
Use in Operator Training". II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5 - 1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training
- 2. Reg Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program
- 4. Braidwood Computer Point Data (12/89) -
l l l c : lO 1 l
Test Number: SS-1 Revision Number /Date: 10.10A)9/94 l Frequency: ANNUAL i i BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ! STEADY STATE TESTING III. INITIAL CONDITIONS l
- 1. The plant is at steady state power, BOL, equilibrium Xenon.
IV. DATA MONITORING l
- 1. '
Monitor the following points by using the POWER program file SST.CRIA: NOTE *- i
]
Letters a-r denote critical parameters, letters s & t denote non-critical parameters. i O a. Neutron Flux / Core Thermal Power (all channels)
- b. Te (all Loops)
- c. Th (all Loops)
' d. Hi Auctioneered Tave
- e. RCS Boron Concentration
- f. PZR Press
- g. PZR Level
- h. PZR Vapor Temp
- i. PZR Liquid Temp
- j. Bank D Control Rod Position
- k. S/G Ievels (allloops)
- 1. S/G Press (allloops)
- m. S/G Steam Temp (allloops)
- n. S/G FW Inlet Header Temp (allloops) .
- o. FW Flow (allloops) ;
- p. S/G Blowdown Flow (allloops) !
- q. S/G Tempering Flow (allloops) '
- r. MW's Generated
- s. RCS Loop Flow (allloops)
- t. IR Channels (both channels)
O I 2
Test Number: SS-1 Revision Number /Date: 10.10/09/94 Frequency: ANNUAL i 3 ! (%) l l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR l STEADY STATE TESTING V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS l 1. Initialize at approximately 100% Steady State (75% Steady State,30% Steady State), BOL, Equilibrium Xenon, all systems in automatic control.
- 2. If necessary, perform a calorimetric and adjust PR gains.
- 3. Ensure stable plant conditions.
- 4. Record Simulator Values on the Data Summary Sheets for comparison to Braidwood Unit One data.
- 5. Run for a minimum of 3600 seconds with no operator action for the 100% test. Run for a minimum of 1800 seconds with no operator action for the 30% and 75% tests.
O 6. Repeat the test for 75% Steady State, and 30% Steady State conditions. V VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
- 1. The simulator computed full power, steady state values shall not change (drift) by more than
+2% over a sixty minute period from the initial value and shall not detract from training.
- 2. The simulator steady state initial values shall not deviate from the Braidwood plant's measured values by more than i 2%* for critical parameters or + 10%* for non-critical parameters and shall not detract from training. i
*AN INSTRUMENT ACCURACY OF 3%, THE TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION CHANNEL CHECK ACCURACY,IS ADDED TO EACH PARAMETER, AS APPROPRIATE, AS INSTRUMENT ERROR.
3
l' l' Test Number: SS-1 Revision Number /Date: 10.10/09/94 Frequency: ANNUAL lO BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR j STEADY STATE TESTING l ^ l .................................................................... NOTE l
- Any deviations from Acceptance Criteria #1 & #2 will be
- j
- documented and assigned a Deviation Record number (DR #).
- l
- The Braidwood Simulator Fidelity and Certification Coordinator *
- shall detennine the disposition of each DR.
- j VII. DOCUMENTATION
\ . Retain the following documentation:
- 1. This procedure.
- 2. All Data Summary Sheets.
l l 3. Test Cover Sheet. 1 VIII. DATA
SUMMARY
SHEETS I l Attach the Steady State Performance Test Data Summary Sheets for the following conditions:
- a. 30%.
l l b. 75%.
- c. 100 %.
1 4 1 l 4 l t
.-. . . . . . _ . . - _ - - . ~ ~ -
~
O O O . Test Numben SS-1 Rev Number /Date: 10. 10/09/94 100% Power Frequerx.y: Annual Steady State Test Parameter Braidwood Simulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest Highest Value Value Value Permissible Permissible Within 5% Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) (TRUF1 FALSE) N0049 100 95 105- 99 TRUE Power Range N0050 100 95 105 99 TRUE , N0051 100 95 105 99 TRUE N0052 100 95 105 99 TRUE T0406 560 532 588 558 TRUE WR Tc T0426 565 536.75 593.25 558 TRUE . T0446 560 532 588 560 TRUE TO479 565 536.75 593.25 560 TRUE T0419 620 589 651 615 TRUE WR Th T0439 620 589 651 615- TRUE , T0459 620 589 651 615 TRUE TO479 620 589 651 615 TRUE Tave Auct. Hi T0499 583 553.85 612.15 584 TRUE RCS Boron CVBILTND 780 741 819 781 TRUE PO480 2235 2123.25 2346.75 2235 TRUE l PZR Press PO481 2230 2118.5 2341.5 2245 TRUE PO482 2235 2123.25 2346.75 2230 TRUE PO483 2235 2123.25 2346.75 2235 TRUE , LO480 61 57.95 64.05 60 TRUE PZR Level LO481 60 57 63 60 TRUE LO482 60 57 63 60 TRUE PZR Temp (Vapor) T0481 650 617.5 682.5 660 TRUE ; (Liquid) T0480 650 617.5 682.5 655 TRUE Band D Rod Position C0058 220 209 231 220 TRUE i.
---,--a--- - - _ _ . _ _ _ -__ _ _ - - - _ _
.-__m_. _ ._.....m - _ _ _ _ _ . . . . - _ _ . . _ _ _ _ . _.._..-._._..._-._.._-._,__.____....__._...m
~
O O O . i Test Number- SS-1 : Rev Number /Date: 10.10/09/94 100% Power i Frequency: Annual Steady State Test l Parameter l Braxfwood Simulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest Highest Value Value Value Permissible Permissible Within 5% ! Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) (TRUF1 FALSE) i i LO400 67 63.65 70.35 65.5 TRUE , S/G Level LO420 66 62.7 69.3 66 TRUE LO443 66 62.7 69.3 67 TRUE LO460 66 62.7 69.3 67 TRUE ; P0400 920 874 966 920 TRUE i S/G Press PO422 925 878.75 971.25 910 TRUE PO442 920 874 966 910 TRUE ! PO460 920 874 966 920 TRUE ; THTSG(1] N/A N/A N/A 536.1 N/A 1 S/G Temp THTSG(2] N/A N/A N/A 536.1 N/A THTSG[3] N/A N/A N/A 536.2 N/A THTSG[4] N/A N/A N/A 536.2 N/A T2381 436 414.2 457.8 437 TRUE FW Temp T2382 436 414.2 457.8 437 TRUE T2383 435 413.25 456.75 437 TRUE T2384 436 414.2 457.8 437 TRUE F0405 3808 3617.6 3998.4 3700 TRUE FW Flow F0424 3850 3657.5 4042.5 3715 TRUE F0445 3698 3513.1 3882.9 3720 TRUE i F0465 3825 3633.75 4016.25 3717 TRUE F0407 27 25.65 28.35 25.9 TRUE Blowdown F0427 29 27.55 30.45 29.7 TRUE , F0447 28 26.6 29.4 27.2 TRUE F0467 28 26.6 29.4 28 TRUE
.O %
d Test Number: SS-1 Rev Number /Date: 10.10/09/94 100% Power Fmquency: Annual Steady State Test Parameter Braxiwood Semulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest Highest Value Value , Value Permissible Penn;ssible Within 5% Value (-5%? Value ( +5%) (TRuFJ FALSE) F2239 96 91.2 100.8 98 TRUE Tempering Flow F2240 i 98 93.1 102.9 96 TRUE F2241 i 96 91.2 100.8 97 TRUE F2242 96 91.2 100.8 98 TRUE F0400 97 92.15 101.85 98 TRUE , , RCS Loop Flow F0420 99 94.05 103.95 98 TRUE F0440 97 92.15 101.85 97.5 TRUE F0460 97 92.15 101.85 98 TRUE -
~
MW O2800 1180 1121 1239 1183 TRUE IR N0035 3.00E-04 3.00E-05 3.00E-03 4.00E-04 TRUE N0036 3.00E-04 3.00E-05 3.00E-03 4.00E-04 TRUE i i I t I i i'
~
O O O .; i Test Number: SS-1 Rev NumberfDate: 10. 10/00/94 75% Power Frequency: Annual Steady State Test : Parameter Bradwood Simulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest I-bghest Value Value Value Permissible Pemussible Within 5% Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) (TRUFJ FALSE) N0049 75.5 71.725 79.275 77 TRUE Power Range N0050 75.2 71.44 78.96 77 TRUE N0051 75.58 71.801 79.359 77 TRUE N0052 75.1 71.345 78.855 77 - TRUE T0406 558 530.1 585.9 555 TRUE WR Tc T0426 552 524.4 579.6 556' TRUE T0446 557 529.15 584.85 558 TRUE T0479 554 526.3 581.7 555 TRUE T0419 598 568.1 627.9 600 TRUE WR Th T0439 598 568.1 627.9 600- TRUE T0459 599 569.05 628.95 600 TRUE T0479 598 568.1 627.9 600 TRUE Tave Auct. Hi T0499 576 547.2 604.8 576 TRUE RCS Boron CVBILTND 868 824.6 911.4 841- TRUE PO480 2238 2126.1 2349.9 2235 TRUE , PZR Press PO481 2234 2122.3 2345.7 2240 TRUE PO402 2238 2126.1 2349.9 2235 TRUE PO483 2234 2122.3 2345.7 2240 TRUE LO480 51 48.45 53.55 50 TRUE PZR Level LO481 50 47.5 52.5 50 TRUE LO482 50 47.5 52.5 50 TRUE PZR Temp (Vapor) T0481 652 619.4 684.6 660' TRUE 650' (Uguid) T0480 648 615.6 680.4 TRUE Band D Rod Position C0058 186 176.7 195.3 186- TRUE I I i I
O O O . Test Numben SS-1 Rev Number /Date: 10.10/09/94 75% Power ' Frequency: Annual Steady State Test ; Parameter Bra & rood Simulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest Highest Value Value Value Permissible Permissible Within 5 % I Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) (TRUE/ FALSE) LO400 66.5 63.175 69.825 66 TRUE ! S/G Level LO420 64.8 61.56 68.04 67 TRUE I LO443 66.1 62.795 69.405 65 TRUE LO460 67.5 64.125 70.875 67 TRUE L PO400 948 900.6 995.4 940 TRUE : S/G Press P0422 947 899.65 994.35 940 TRUE PO442 945 897.75 992.25 930 TRUE PO460 952 904.4 999.6 945 TRUE THTSG[1] N/A N/A N/A 538.6 N/A S/G Temp THTSG(2] N/A N/A N/A 538.6 N/A THTSG(3] N/A N/A N/A 538.6 N/A THTSG(4] N/A N/A N/A 538.6 N/A T2381 411 390.45 431.55 410.2 TRUE I FW Temp T2382 411 390.45 431.55 410.2 TRUE ; t T2383 410 389.5 430.5 410.2 TRUE T2384 411 390.45 431.55 410.2 TRUE , F0405 2720 2584 2856 2800 TRUE FW Row F0424 2847 2704.65 2989.35 2810 TRUE [ F0445 2685 2550.75 2819.25 2809 TRUE , F0465 2749 2611.55 2886.45 2815 TRUE F0407 63 59.85 66.15 63.6 TRUE Blowdown F0427 64 60.8 67.2 64.9 TRUE } F0447 67 63.65 70.35 66.2 TRUE i F0467 61 57.95 64.05 59.6 TRUE i i
O O O .. Test Numben SS-1 Rev Number /Date: 10.10M9/94 75% Power Frequency: Annual Steady State Test . t Parameter l Braxiwood Simulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Desciiption Variable Unit i Lowest Highest Value Value l Value Permissible Permissible Within 5% ; Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) (TRUF1 FALSE) . F2239 97 92.15 101.85 98 TRUE i Tempering Flow F2240 98 93.1 102.9 97 TRUE F2241 97 92.15 101.85 97 TRUE l F2242 98 93.1 102.9 97 TRUE F0400 ' 97 92.15 101.85 98 TRUE RCS Loop Flow F0420 99 94.05 103.95 98 TRUE F0440 96 91.2 100.8 98 TRUE F0460 98 93.1 102.9 98 TRUE MW O2800 897 852.15 941.85 892 TRUE IR N0035 2.10E-04 2.10E-05 2.10E-03 2.80E-04 TRUE I N0036 2.10E-04 2.10E-05 2.10E-03 2.80E-04 TRUE i
O O O .. Test Number: SS-1 Rev Number /Date: 10. 10/09/94 30% Power Frequency: Annual Steady State Test Parameter Bradwood Simulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest Highest Value Value Value Permissible Permissible Within 5% . Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) (TRUF1 FALSE) N0049 28 26.6 29.4 29 TRUE Power Range N0050 28 26.6 29.4 29 TRUE N0051 27 25.65 28.35 28 TRUE , N0052 29 27.55 30.45 29 TRUE T0406 560 532 588 560 TRUE WR Tc T0426 560 532 588 560 TRUE T0446 555 527.25 582.75 560 TRUE I T0479 555 527.25 582.75 555 TRUE T0419 580 551 609 570 TRUE WR Th T0439 575 546.25 603.75 575 TRUE t T0459 575 546.25 603.75 575 TRUE T0479 580 551 609 570 TRUE , Tave Auct. Hi T0499 563 534.85 591.15 563 TRUE i RCS Boron CVBILTND 1090 1035.5 1144.5 1118 TRUE PO480 2235 2123.25 2346.75 2240 TRUE PZR Press PO481 2230 2118.5 2341.5 2245 TRUE PO482 2230 2118.5 2341.5 2240 TRUE PO483 2230 2118.5 2341.5 2245 TRUE LO480 35 33.25 36.75 35 TRUE PZR Level LO481 34 32.3 35.7 35 TRUE LO482 ' 36 34.2 37.8 35 TRUE PZR Temp (Vapor) T0481 650 617.5 682.5 660 TRUE (Liquid) T0480 655 622.25 687.75 650 TRUE Band D Rod Position C0058 160 152 168 160 TRUE
4 O O O . Test Number SS-1 Rev Number /Date: 10. 10/09/94 30% Power Frequency- Annual Steady State Test Parameter Brakiwood Simulatur Simulator Samulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest Highest Value Value Value Permissible Permissd>le Within 5% ' Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) l (TRUEf FALSE) LO400 67 63.65 70.35 66 TRUE S/G Level LO420 66 62.7 69.3 65.5 TRUE LO443 66 62.7 69.3 66 TRUE LO460 67 63.65 70.35 66 TRUE PO400 1030 978.5 1081.5 1030 TRUE S/G Press PO422 1030 978.5 1081.5 1025 TRUE PO442 1025 973.75 1076.25 1020 TRUE PO460 1035 983.25 1086.75 1025 TRUE THTSG[1] N/A N/A N/A 548.9 N/A S/G Temp THTSG[2] N/A N/A N/A 548.9 N/A THTSG[3] N/A N/A N/A 548.9 N/A THTSG[4] N/A N/A N/A 548.9 N/A T2381 326 309.7 342.3 310 TRUE FW Temp T2382 326 309.7 342.3 310 TRUE T2383 325 308.75 341.25 310 TRUE T2384 326 309.7 342.3 310 TRUE F0405 925 878.75 971.25 900 TRUE FW Flow F0424 940 893 987 895 TRUE F0445 930 883.5 976.5 910 TRUE F0465 925 878.75 971.25 890 TRUE F0407 25 23.75 26.25 25.9 TRUE Blowdown F0427 23 21.85 24.15 24.1- TRUE F0447 25 23.75 26.25 25.9 TRUE F0467 23 21.85 24.15 24.1 TRUE
- _ _ . _ _ . _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ - _ . _ _ _ _ = _ - _-_ - _ - _ _m
Test Number- SS-1 Rev Number /Date: 10. 10/09/94 30% Power Frequency- Annual Steady State Test Parameter Braidwood Simulator Simulator Simulator Simulator Comments Description Variable Unit 1 Lowest Highest Value Value Value Pennissable Permissible Within 5% Value (-5%) Value ( +5%) (TRUFJ FALSE) F2239 90 85.5 94.5 90 TRUE Tempering Flow F2240 95 90.25 99.75 94 TRUE F2241 90 85.5 94.5 92 TRUE F2242 85 80.75 89.25 87 TRUE F0400 98 93.1 102.9 98 TRUE RCS Loop Flow F0420 99 94.05 103.95 98 TRUE F0440 96 91.2 100.8 98 TRUE F0460 97 92.15 101.85 98 TRUE MW O2800 280 266 294 269 TRUE IR N0035 7.00E-05 7.00E-06 7.00E-04 9.00E-05 TRUE N0036 7.00E-05 7.00E-06 7.00E-04 9.00E-05 TRUE
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SEIEET Test Number: Ik'l Date Performed I/4f96 Test
Description:
M a n o., / R v 'T~e& fe.sE Discrepancies Corrected (initials) ! Step # Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date l on O l Test Results [ 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary. '
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date l Test Complete /M IIM Date //v/M SFCC Acceptance sk Date 24 # 16 final 1
_ . ~ . . . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . . _ . _ _ _ . _ __ _ _ __ -_. _ _.
~
Test Number: TR-1 Revision Number /Date: 07.11/08/93 i Frequency: ANNUAL O l V l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST ! MANUAL REACTOR TRIP I. OBJECTIVES r The purpose of this procedure is to:
- 1. Test the simulator response to a Manual Reactor Trip as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985.
l
- 2. Verify the ability of the primary and secondary plant and the plant automatic contml systems to i sustain a trip from 100 percent power and to bring the plant to a stable condition following the ;
transient. l II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License i Examinations.
O
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program. I l
- 4. Braidwood Unit 1 LER 90-08: Rx Trip from Full Power.
\
l III. INITIAL CONDITIONS
- 1. The plant is operating at normal steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits.
- 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown valae.
s , l 3. The bomn concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank D at the properposition. i 1 i 1
Test Number: TR-1 Revision Number /Date: 07. I1/08/93 _ Frequency: ANNUAL O V BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MANUAL REACTOR TRIP IV. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables (Tc, Th, S/G pressure and level shall ,
be onloop I):
- a. Neutron flux (Rx power) !
- b. RCS average temperature
- c. Pressurizerpressure
- d. Pressurizerlevel
- e. Pressurizer steam temperature
- f. Steam flow
- g. Feed flow
- h. Hot leg temperature l l
- i. Coldleg temperature I
- j. S/G pressure
- k. S/Glevel V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Initiate a plant trip by manually tripping the Reactor from IPM05J.
- 4. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
4
- 5. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
O . 2
Test Number: 'IR-1 Revision Number /Date: 07. I1/08/93 Frequency: ANNUAL / BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MANUAL REACTOR TRIP VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA , essesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesesesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesses NOTE
- The simulator response will be compared to baseline data *
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- The Review Board will determine if the simulator has the >
capability to adequately reproduce the dermed transient.
- esseeeeeeeeesesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees The following acceptance criteria are to be used to detennine successful test completion: !
l
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift. I
- 2. Steam generator safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 3. Safetyinjection is NOTinitiated.
- 4. All full length rods must release and drop.
- 5. Successful transfer of allloads from the Unit Auxiliary Transformers to the System Auxiliary Transformers. ;
- 5. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature. j
- 7. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic .
ac6on. 3
~
,l Tcst Number: TR-1 Revision Number /Date: 07.11/08/93 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MANUAL REACTOR TRIP VII. LIST OF FIGURES
- 1. Rx Power --
- 2. RCS AverageTemperature
- 3. Pressurizer Pressure
- 4. Pressurizer Level
- 5. Pressurizer Steam Temperature
- 6. Steam Flow -loop 1
- 7. Feed Flow - Loop 1
- 8. Hot Leg Temperature -Imop 1
- 9. Cold Leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 10. S/G Pressure - Loop 1
- 11. S/G 12 vel-Imop 1 esseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeessee NOTE
- Total steam flow and total feed flow were not available from Braidwood Unit One data. Loop 1 steam flow and feed flow *
- were substituted to aid in data comparison.
- eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesessesseeeeeeees ,,,
O 4 1
RX TRIP 01/04/96 14:02:00 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS l' ' l l 1 I I I I I I I I I I I l l D _ O _ 8 __. 6 - g 4 __ 2 __ v_ 1 I I i i l I I I I I I I I g 0 5 10 15 20 TIME D fcN0049 ( .000 , 105. ) 21090 PWR RNG CH 41 (QUAD 4) TOT O RXTAVG ( 500. , 600. ) 01200 LOOP TABLE
,\ (- . .
N.) J N.J RX TRIP 01/04/96 13:52:51 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1C i I i l l I I I I I I I I I I I 8 - 4 O ' (~ _ r o _ G h 4 _
~
~
G . 2 __ g I i i i 1 1 1 1 I I I I I i i 1 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCP0480 ( .200E+04, . 250 E+04) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455 O YCLO480 ( 20.0 , 75.0 ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459 i
, , ' h P
e , s O 0 _ 4 8 0 0 _ _ 2 4 1 I I 6 I T 9 !
/ M 4 I T 0 !
S
/ _
1 I R 0 ! E Z 5 I 1 R U I S I S E R P I I 0 I 5 I 2 . 1 I 9 O I 0 ) 1 I I S - D I 0 N I 0 O 7 C I E I , S I 0 I 0 E . 0 5 M 0 3 I 0 I T 6
=
I ( N I O i I P S I I I l R V T I I D i X _ . 1 R 1 - ._ - _ - _ - _. 8 f - I 0 4 8 6 4 2 0 T C Y O
7 g \ ( ., . ( j i ; , ) . v (__/ \.d RX TRIP 01/04/96 14:14:35 1C 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS l I I I I I I I I I I l- 1 I I I
- 8 8 _
e h 6 __ e Spu 4 __ M h 2 _ c1 0
- %, / -
1 I I ; '
- i i ! ! ! ' ' ' I i 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCF0403 ( .000 O ycF040s
. 400E+0 4) 06040 SG 1 A FW F FT-510
( .000 .
. 40 0E+0 4) 06060 S/G 1A STEAM F FT-512
2_ ._a; A. # '# n, A - 5 0 9 e l t (O V
+
i l i j i DO O s"e '
- g i i i --
N OW_; ! W
<o - J m O N H
+
o - 0)0 IO N ~ o _ h CL Q OO OO l
,_,. .J J CO
_ Z tr
~ M N
~ CD C0
/.~, o to
$ _ oo (v j -
- - O O g ~
Q Z . . i O O O O - ee W o CD I l
. . i o -
o i o m W . . 1 in llE oo
- H N
mm j OO l Z - O H ._ CL CO - H H T H ( x _ Z - I m f l t ! t l me kCO i "O (D + ._ o ++ l oN oo O
% *O>
D0 U 1 \ . l
(~y ., ,- O,/~5 O %!
- RX TRIP 01/04/96 14:29:02 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 _
Q O 6 _ __ O 4 _ 2 _ O i I I i i i i I i i i i I i i I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME G YCP0400 ( 700. . .120 E+04) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 0 YCLO400 ( .000 , 100. ) 06350 S/G 1A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 I t ATTACHMENT D ! SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW l TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: N ~! ! kx i/P .
. DATE: t/4/% . \
i l
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices) h Actual plant transient data
- b. Analytical or design data EVENT: bib) U-l LEA 90-Oor ,
DATA: '
- c. Transient data from similar plant PLANT: i
- d. Panel of experts (best estimate)
COMMENTS: doo
- l. ,
I 1 I O 2. Data Comparison Summary L l i VARIABLE COMMENTS l RESOLUTION I l
- 0. Powu Acn Accephl h I
'l4 level
% Press I P&A Press 95a. lust Tw L.
/ ,{
&& %e ,
V
- O 1
l l
?.
. TDI 700-03
..., Revision: 00 i
ATTACHMENT D ' SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W VARIABLE COMMENTS i RESOLUTION : Veeb Flow h}one- ,4c cepla) Sleu m flow h b a i l
- 3. Comparison Results Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one)
/
- b. UNACCEPTABLE 4
Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be dncumented)
$WY WAn \
l
/ #7M i
COMMENTS: ! i l final 2
(-~ (._) O
**%an w% ,
Point Plot - Droidwood Station. Unit 1 (GN01014 Rev. O.1] Data trom 06:00 to 07:00 on 06/08/90 Time interval : 1 Minute (s)
?.~4 tv tis h t 76 05 06:10 06 15 06-20 06-25 0630 06 35 06-40 06 45 06 SO 06-55 07 00 1 III II'I IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII Iil I IIII IIII IIII IIIl e ,:,:, -- - - . _ . - -- --
aco - 76.64312 _ _ _ _ __ u' E 448 43AV76 37.79XS u.r: n 1.Ls373 ___ l' I ns,2 ._11IIIII1.1 IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII POINT ID DESCRIPTION UNITS SYMBOL 74004e PZM PJG CH 41 (QUAD 4) DET Q PC e
_ 0 _ 0 -
] 7 _
1 0 i _ _ i 0 I
. i v
e i i
.)
R I - ~ _ 4 5 i 5 . (N 1 0 1 6 0 i i 0 i N l G i [ i i 0I i 5 - 6 0 I _ i . l i i i _ 5i I 4 : i 6 _ 0i I
- i -
- I I
I 0I 4 6
- l 0I i I
i I i 5I 5 -
- I 6 -
0I -
- I I
I I I 0I - I u 6 0I I I L _
]. I O _
- B eL I
I M e Y 5 2 - I
, I S 6
0l I i I S _ l TI W _ I N U U L _ 0i l 2 - 6 0I t i l
\ .
i _ i _ i 5I i
)
0 9 1 h 1 _ 1
/ 6 d _
t 8 0I I 0 i i0 U n/6 I I N I IC O _ n,0 (M I I I T o n P _ it o I 0I I R 3 . a 1 C _ A' 0) t - 6 S T _ S 0 (s 0 E . d 7t : e I I D T . o0 5 o u n I ll I woi e G ido0 tM I I I E I 5I . Br I L 6 0 C R 6 _ - 0 la v 0I t l mr o ot e I I 0 1 I T J P rf in N 3 - t I i ; _ n ae
;o a t I
O P T G m 1 _ P D*i
) s o 3 3 0 3 o o 3 m
- 0 0
m a: n 0 n, 6
% 9m_
7 o W 0 0 c 0 G a 4 a t 0 0
~,.
4 nc : a O. a T a c S 6 s m 4 -u
i 0
. 0 :
] 7 1 0 i O i i
I v e t R I s_ l 4 5 I 5 s, % 1 0 6 1 0 l 0 I N 1 G I [ 1 I 01 I 5 - 6 I 01 I 1 . I l I 5l 4 - _ I 6 I 0l % 1 i I I I 0I 4 6 '
- I I
0I I I I 1 I 51 I 3 - 6 01 I l I l I 0l I 3 - 6
)
0l l l
/ , I L
O B
-, % 5 I
I I S M Y 2 6 0I I I I S T o J i s I I N 0l i U p 2 - 6 l 0i 1 t L i l l i 0 5i 1 i 9 1
/ 6 t 8 i
0I n0 I U/6 I I N n 0 I C I I T o n P i t a o 0I 1 I I R P t 0) 6 C 1 S 0 (s 0 S E d 7 : te _ I I D - o0 o u I _ n I w oi h
;d t M I I
_ o01 5I Br :0 - l 0
- 0 ov 6 l 6
0 i W mr I t I lo e D ot I I P rf in ' T 0 t I N 8 4 n a e 0 i O
;o a im t 1 I
P P P DT _ 0 S 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 _0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~, 0 0 M 0 0 L
0 0 0 0 0 0 80, 4 3 0 4 C 3 L C 0 L 0 W o4
$ 2 4
2 3 2 6 2 2 8 1 0 1 4 0 6 8 1 7 o 7 _. 2 2 1 1 1 2
8
- B -
e -
/% %
f 4 e - O _ g - o-D O- -
~
~
~
c- - Y - o O_ _ O~ } Y e C- , c- Ie1 - S I O ,,,,, ll ~
~
t - l - I to O_ l, .J i
%) -
g . o - tn e O_
- to
- b
- Z r) o -
D .4. N e O_ -l -
~
~
~
O # - Oh Y e g e e,* 4D O -
~
'd O N
3@
- Z O
fO - 0O O
~ {
=
5 4 2 On ? - m vss oo8 - 0 - 8*E -
- p}
vw *O-3' - ~
's g -
c - O CD
@. h
~
IO E E Ii $~ - O # - 5 - Z
, i **
C O O f 6 4 6%E
- 0. OP g ~
_f I
- n. Q. .Q C. , n,
. .O . Q c 4
%d . t /J e a e' E a .: 3 a d ;
.a $
e a a a e a 4 4 a.
't.,
.4 o t- s a -
1 S - i b
0 0 -
) 7 -
0 l 1, l _ O l . I v e l I R 1
- 5 V
I _ - 4 5 . - 1 - 0 6 _ 1 0 i 0 ! - N I G i [ I i 0I l 5 - 6 0I i I i l I 5i i 4 - 6 01 i l I i _ I 0I I _ 4 - - 6 - 0I I I I I I 51 5 I -_ 6 01 I _ I _ I _ I _ I - 0I I 3 - ' 6 _ 0I 1 p I I O L B _ V
- 1 a _
I M _ f . 5 i I S . 2 6 0I I I I S I T I E r I N E _ 0I I U C - 2 - 6 . 0I I I
\ I I
I 0 51 1 I 9 1
/ 6 it 8 0I i Un/06 l l N O
n 0 i i I T o n P T it o 0I I R I I1 _ t a 1
- C T S 0 0( )s 6 S S 0I E o7 : e t I D x.
o0 o u n i a w oi I c r id t M I I _ a0 _ 5I Br :0 i M I 0 6 6 e
- 0 la 0 v I t
lo ot me r I I I D I P rf in T 1 _ t I N i 3 4 n a et I O P G io a m I I T _ i PDT _ _ 0 0, w o c 3 o ? o o O ,. _ - m a % n n o z C _ U 1 2 n.
'. a c.
a c u o 4 4 n r P 3 m o o C C. 0 u r J c e a- m 7 ( c 4 i 1 . T7 s e e a 6 e 6 r _
0 -
- 0 -
] 7 .
1 0 I - i O I i v. e I _ i R . O 4 1 0 0 N 1 5 5 6 0 I I I l i G [ l I i . 0I i 5 - _ 6 _ 0 I _ i I I I I _ 5I I 4 : 6 . 0 I _ I _ I 1 I l 0I l 4 - 6 _ 0I i I I I - I 5I 5 I 6 0I I I I I _ I 0I 5 I - 6 0I I I L - O O I I B I M Y 5 I I S 2 - 6 0I I I I S I TI l I N i is U K 01 I 2 - 6 0 1 I i I I i 5I - I 0 1 9 1
/ 6 it 08 0i I n/
U 6 l I N F O 1 n 0 i I T o n I P R t a o lt 0l I I R O 1 C t
- 0) 6 S
I L S 0 (s 0 E T d7 : e t i I D U o0 o u n I - I 1 I woi id tM I I U G a01 5I t Br -0
- I L
0 ! _ 6 6 I i t
- 0 la v 0i o me t r I D
1 ot I T 5 Pl fri n I N 0 I t i 4
;n ae I
O 0 t P o a im 5 _ l - PDT - o O s O _ m r w o 4r 0 0 3 O - C 0 e a 2 0 C, S c. O a. n o. o 0 1 C L 3 0 1 G 1 t s 0 m H *7 : c 5 J *. 1 : t a 6 1 X L L M : 2 2 F 4 4 s 3 2 I t 1 2 4
l l'[! ; h ;;f !+ ff FbIF!i l [j II: ift!l; iI l 3; l' :!! ' _( _ . 0 0 -
] 7 ._
1 0 I I 0' I _ . I v - e I I . R I 5 _0 4 $ I _ 1 0 6 1 0 I _ O' I _ N~ I_ G' I _ [ l . I _ 0I I 5 - 6 0I_ l I I _ 5I l _ 4 - 6 l _ 0 I _ I l _ I l . 0I i 4 - 6 0I i I l I I 5l I _ 3 - 6 0i 1 I _ 0 i _ 3 - 6 0 I l
/
L .o l I O i B I M e Y S i 5 'l 2 - 6 0 l l i I S T _ I NI H _ l D 0l l' U E 2 - 6 - 0i \ - i 1 I
+
l 0 51 l 9 1 _ 1
/ 6 F 8 0 l it Un/6 0 i
V' l l N 1 4 9 O n,0 R i I - _ l T _ T iono 0 I P I W _ t a l R _ t 0) 1
- C D 6 S S 0: (s 0 E E d 7 e D I
l F t o0 o u I 1 w o ;n l I id tM D V I l o0I G _ 5' U Dr :0 - l _ 0 T 6 6 l S
- 0 la 0I v
l t o ot me r l D I P r in 3 l _ T V N 0 . f t I I I 4 _ . n a e
; t O
P D . o a m l l l F PDi ~ o 3 r. Geg G O F v_ o c ^ a "4 , 0 0 0 1 f 5 1 3 0 0 0 0 0 7 2 0 0 n n a v 0 0 0 0 0 8 1 m n n N a n e n c.
0
.
- 0 -
]
7 , 1 0 l 0 l - i
. l v
e l
)s R 4 5 l
i
<m I
1 5 - . 0 6 1 0 I . 0 - i N I [ G . i I I 0I I 5: . 6 01 . I 1
- i i
l 5I - i 4 - 6 0I I I
. l I
i
~
0I I 4 - 6 0I i I I I I 5I I 3 - 6 0! I I
. I I
I 0I 3 I 6 0I I I L I O
- B I
(\% 5I I I S M Y e . 2 - 6 0I
- I I
. I S e I T I
IN 4 i . 0I I U L _ 2 - 6 - 0I I.I I l I I m- . I I 0 5I I _ 1 - _ 9 - _ 1
/ 6 it 8 0I I T n/0 U 6 I I N :
1 _ O . n 0 - I I 1 I T T _ o n 0I P O _ it a o 1
- I I
R I I C t 0) 6 S J - S 0 (s 0 E di d 7 : te o0 o un I I
- I D t 4
I w oi 1 d t M I
- I A' ic01 r 0 5I - I 1
G _ B : 0 - 6 - t 6 i
- 0 lav 0 I lo me t r I D
- I ot I I T 9 P rf in I N 1 t I i 4 n o e O G
;o a im t I I
P T PDT I/ 0 o a 0 o 0 C d c . o c a a o 4
, w 9 0
0 c c 0 0 C w c zo r
. x -
,!, 1 40 a 0 D. u. e.
a c o. c C3 T 6 z c 1 6 3)
"4 c.
- - r,. n. :.
- m n.
k ; 0
] 7 + _
1 0 I _ , i 0 i i v e l i ,x R J 4 5 5 i I
, % 1 - -
0 6 : 1 0 0 i
, i N i
[ G i i _ i 0i I 5 - 6 i 0I l
^
i i l i 5i 4 6
' ^
i 0i I ^ I l 0i l
/ l l
4 - 6 l 0i l i l i 5i i 3 . 6 l 0i I
- I i
i I 0I 3 6
~ I 0l I i L I O s I B
e pku I M f 5i I S 2-6 I 0 t I i I S i T I W C I N E2 U [ 0I I 2 : 6 I 0I I
/
i I I I 0 5l I 1 9 : 1
/ 6 l 0i T t 8 i0 Un/ 6 i
- l i
N G E L O n 0 i i I T D L o n P I O it o a 0i i R C 1 _ C t 0) 6 I S G S 0 (s 0 E ii D d 7: te I h o0 u -- I E o n I _ i woi I id a01 tM I
- I V.
t Br :0 : 6
- 0 to 5I 0-6 v I 8
i c h 0 - v mr I t J D lo ot e I I P rf in I L_ T N 4 0 t i 4 n ae
;t O
P 0 7 I o a PDT im :
< 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ) 0 0 0 0 0 0
,- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 % 0 0 0 0 0 0 : 0 0 0 0 0 4 00 0 0 0 0 n. 0 e 2 8 6 0 C 2 3 6 07 e 6 5 5 0 $ 4 3 3 1 5 s 5 5 ' 3 E 5 5 5 2
j C[ l
- i
- . g 5 T O_ [ _
O _ i ~ r t) -
/
s' % e O s_ - g _ h) O- - l D'"~ ~ \ Y
- i o
O_ - O_ _ g_ - S . . - O_ -- l n_ 9 I _._ - l
~
.J g ,_
g l j 7 w O_ - i - - g i O~ ~ m e i N b_ \ ~ O m $. - I ",- m N $_ i - bo - i ~ h J e eo - 1 E g O O~ ~ S 8..2 y 5O
'O N 0
Q $ e g o ,g - t - j S5 - - b M e8-y n-O ! g I t; o}8_ E
? 1!
a,
~
a it - - o
%0 t) - ~
b-
'd oO,.E I a.
J
/h U as 8 is i is i. i i* i* i e
f ea 4 a 2 l l l
i, .t '; [ r; !! . f, , .; ,:! !!r L '
- ?Il
, , h
~
w m e = e w
. r o
2 7
- n e
]
1 0 I I m _ + 0 I I v w e I I R e O. I 5 I w 4 5 - 1 - 0 6 e _ 1 0 I 1 n _ 0 - N I i n _ G + [ I I _ + 0I I e e 5 n 6 0 I I I I I I e 5I I 4 -
~
6 . 0 _ I _ I - I + I v _ e _ I _ I w 0I I ,- 4: .- 6 0I - I - I - ~ I
.r
~
I o I u 5I I 5 s a _ v _ 6 0 I I m - I I I w I _ I 0 I 3 - _ 6 - 0 I I w _ L e I I O .O B _ e m g I I M e e Y _ 5 I I S w 2 - 6 w 0I I I , I S ~ I T I G e N S I e U P 0I I
~-
2 - 6 0I N I
~
_ I i I
~
o, I I s 0 5I 1 I 1 9 6
/ 0I t 8 I i0 P Un/ 6 I
I N O 1 n 0 I I I T T o n P I U - O a o I it 0 I R _ 1 C S 00) S t - (s 6 E d7t: e 0 I I D M 1 o0 o u I w o: n N I E d t M i I I G o0I 5I Br :0 : _ I 0 M 6 6
- 0 la v 0 mr I
. t I D - l o ot e I I 0 P fr in I T N 0 I i 4 t n oe I O O t P P ioo m I i P DE O 0 0 0( L 4 0 02 71 0 0 O G O L t e i t 0 0 0 0 2 1 1 o o c. o n a t 0 0 0 4 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 n a n n a. n n. n a n n n 0 0 0 0 0 4 8 m rO. m .
1 TDI 70043 Rtvision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: N - 2. Date Performed //f 9 (, Test
Description:
51m aI k covS Sr!P of < // A1FP h s / 1 Discrepancies Step # Corrected (initials) Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date klno _ l 1 Test Results
/
/ 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete #[ I/d Date 1/r/% SFCC Acceptance hyI. e
< Date 1 i
4t/#/% g -- - gi i na 1
. Test Number: TR-2 Revision Number /Date: 08. I1A)8/93 ;
Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL MAIN FEEDWATER PUMPS I. OBJECTIVES The purpose of this~ procedure is to:
- 1. Test the simulator response to a Simultaneous Trip of All Main Feedwater Pumps as required l by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. j l
- 2. Ensure that the simulator's Auxiliary Feedwater System functions properly to restore steam !
generator level after a reactor trip. ee.......e.....e....e.e............ee.e...e..e.e....ee.e.......ee... l N_QIE l
- ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, Section 5.4.2, Simulator Operability *
- Testing, (footnote 3) recommends substitution of Appendix B *
/G
- transient tests if these tests provide a more representative
- d
- comparison to actual or predicted reference plant perfonnance.
In accordance with this recommendation, Byron Unit 2 LER 90-01 was substituted for the Appendix B, Section B.2.2(2),
- Simultaneous Trip of All Feedwater Pumps test. *
.ee.eee.e...e...eee.ee..e..eeeeee.e.....e.....eeee.e..e.e.......e.ee II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training. ;
)
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program.
- 4. Byron Unit 2 LER 90-01: Rx Trip /SI on Low Steamline Pressure / Simultaneous Trip of All Main Feedwater Pumps.
O ; I
i i l*. Test Number: TR-2 l RevisionNumber/Date: 08.11M8S3 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL MAIN FEEDWATER PUMPS l 1 III. INITIAL CONDITIONS l l
- 1. The plant is operating at normal steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D j positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits. !
! I l 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron j j concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value. 1
- 3. The boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank
)
D at the proper position.
~
l !
- 4. The Auxiliary Feedwater flow control valve (AF005A-H) potentiometers are set at 6.5. l
- 5. Steam pressure transmitter, PT-526, bistables are tripped per BwOA INST-2.
IV. DATA COLLECTION l O V 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables (Tc, Th, S/G pressure and level shall I l be onloop 1):
- a. Neutron flux (Rx power)
- b. RCS average temperature I
- c. Pressurizer pressure
- d. Pressurizerlevel l
- e. Pressurizer steam temperature 1
- f. Steam flow l
- g. Feed flow l
- h. Hot leg temperature I l
- i. Coldleg temperature j j. S/G pressure
- k. S/G level 2
i
s -. Test Number: TR-2 Revision Number /Date: 08. I1M)8S3 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT. TEST SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL MAIN FEEDWATER PUMPS V. TEST INSTRUCITONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Spike steam pressure transmitter, FT-525, low momentarily and then restore PT-525 to normal.
- a. At 300 seconds into the transient, restore instrument air to the containment.
- 4. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
- 5. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA sesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesses NOTE
- The simulator response will be compared to baseline data
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- The Review Board will determine if the simulator has the capability to adequately reproduce the defmed transient.
esseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesee The following acceptance criteria are to be used to determine successful test completion:
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. Safety injection is initiated.
- 3. Auxiliary feedwater flow initiates and restores S/G level.
- 4. Both running feedwater pumps trip on the SI actuation.
- 5. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature.
- 6. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic action.
O 3
t j , Test Number: TR-2 ! R visionNumber/Date: 08. I1/08S3 Frequency: ANNUAL BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL MAIN FEEDWATER PUMPS l l VII. LIST OF FIGURES
- 1. Rx Power l 2. RCS Average Temperature
- 3. Pressurizer Pressure
- 4. Pressur zer Level
- 5. Pressurizer Steam Temperature l
- 6. Steam Flow - Loop 1
- 7. Feed Flow - Loop 1 rO V 8. Hot Leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 9. Cold Leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 10. S/G Pressure - Loop 1 l 11. S/G Level- Loop 1
- NOTE
- Total steam flow and total feed flow were not available from
- Byron Unit Two data. Loop 1 steam flow and feed flow were substituted to aid in data comparison.
A
- V 4
'w
~ _ f - 7 2 T O 8 3 O g0 T _ 2 _ _ - ) _ 9 _ 4 0 I e I D 6 A 9 I U
/
l O ( 5 I 0 l 1
/ 4 1
I 0 l HE C L 5 B 1 G A NT I R l P R O I WO I PL I 0 0 l 9 0 0 2 1 1 _ I 2 0
/
I 0 ) )
% 1 I
l S . D I 5 0 N l 0 3 _ O 1 6 C I E I , . S I 0 l 0 E 0 5 M 0 0 4 5 I 0 3 I T . 5 -
= I
( ( N I O I P I I S I R I l T V I I P D C F 1i 9 M 1 f
~ _. ' _. -- _. - _. ~
0 4 G 0 V I 3 8 6 4 2 0 A T O NT CX Y R CO /.
MFP TRIP 01/05/96 09:31:33 1 DIVISION == 45.00 SECONDS lf g g } } l l 1 I I I I
. ~O 8 -
W eunuquums g J-us-4 _ e 2 - _ b m 0 5 10 15 20 TIME
}]YCPO480 ( .210E+04, . 2 40E+04) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455 g (CLO480 ( .000 , 100. ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459 '
O ~~h V(~~% b (J
\
MFP TRIP 01/05/96 09:44:08 1 DIVISION =- 45.00 SECONDS 1C I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~
a 8 ___ m 6 h 4 _ e h 2 _ m I I I I 1 I I i l I I I i l i i O 5 10 15 20 TIME YCT0481 ( 620. , 670. ) 91250 PRESSURIZER STM T -'
, .-~
7.--- b C/ U MFP TRIP 01/05/96 09:48:40 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS 1C I I I I ! I I I I I I I I I I I m 4 8 _ . 6 h 6 _ mute m 4 _ a main h 2 _ 0~! ,0 - 1 I I I I I ! I I I I I I I i 1 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCF0403 ( ,000 ,
. 400E+04) 06040 SG 1 A FW F FT-510 OYCF0405 ( .000 ,
. 400E+0 4) 06060 S/G 1A STEAM F FT-512
O 1 3 0 T 3 O T 5 _ - 2 G GE 9 EL 0 I i L D T L 6 I i OO 9 HC
/
5 I i RR 0 h W
/
1 0 I i AA 1 1 . 5 - 1 P P - OO OO I l L L C C I i R R 0 5 l 3 2 I 8 8 6 6 _ 0 0 O I . i 0 ) ) _ 1 - I i S 0 0 - D I I 3 3 - N 6 6 O C I i E S I i 0 0 E . 5 5 M 0 0 I 3 3 4 T 5 5 I I ( (
=
N I i O - P I I S I I R I _ T V _ I I i _ P D ' 9 6 _ F _ _ _ 1 0 _ M 1 _ = _ _ _ .
. _ O 4 4 C
0 0 1 D8 6 4 2 T T C C Y Y _ CO O
O O O .. MFP TRIP 01/05/96 09:58:05 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS 1r i I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 1 a D J O m 6 _. enum 4 - 0
~
2 ___ 1 I I I i 1 1 1 I I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCPO400 ( .000 , 120E+04) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 Q YCLO400 ( .000 , 100. ) 06350 S/G 1A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51 ,
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 O ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: 7 8-2-/ M A#'# h/r> DATE: Ih/'96
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices)
- a. Actual plant transient data EVENT: g-4 LEX 94 - oo/
- b. Analytical or design data DATA:
- c. Transient data from similar plant Panel of experts (best estimate)
PLANT: 6,v ran COMMENTS: Pu ed of 1.5p<. tis Er S/6 le ve}, I
~Th e % vlalo, d/dA -l% kale J r o < 4 fv o N /e AF Cloni v>his loJ k > a m i.v c. ./4 w., 4L _ w s43,u O 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION
& foutr hlcw Acuok ) j
% I I G A Te s '
f a k ss / Pa le a i l b STh f/ts 5 / 5/G lui l lO I
. . - _ . . .. - . - - - . . - - . . . . ~ .-. - ___ ... . .- -
e.-
. TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 i i
s ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION ; Feb Flow Uen '
&ccul< d s&c m Flos b [ [
. j
- 3. Comparison Results I
Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transier_t: (circle one)
- a. y FDTAnt,h
- b. UNACCEPTABLE 4.
Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented)
/
Kfld v - sDJ .
,- ^^2K1 -
COMMENTS:
. i 2
,m . - - -,-,.y.,-. m a -
TDI 70043 '. Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE CDVER SHEET Test Number: N3 Date Performed \ 5% Test
Description:
$ N ul b <ous c los orc of o // ms w'#
l Discrepancies Corrected (initials) Step # Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date KlorG 1 I l O l l l Test Results v [ 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete KW8 Date iIrk e, O' SFCC Acceptance /2[ 1 a Date Af .f% ( n. 1 j
** 1.0400
$00.0 M "
~N0049 '
0.00 5,00 10.00 100.0 100.0 c$5<
- g. _. . - .. _ _ . _ . . . _ - . . . ..
- t t
( 90.00 90.00 -90.00 L . ._ . . .. . .. j . ___ . _. - 2 ( . l 1 l I ' i 80.00 80.00 . 80.00 ! k 1 l __ . . . . _l . . !.. . ._.__ ; t > . t I l
. i f :
8
- i 1 70.00 70.00 70.00 L. . . l . _. .
. .l . . . . . ..I.
i : I e
.i I 1 8 i
, , I i.
60.00 60.00 60.00 _' __L _ _ . _ . . ..
.m'. . , . y- .._. . . ,,' .l1 i
l
' i i
50.00 50.00 50.00 ,_ y~_ .
- ~ . . . - - - - _ . .
i , 1 i
. - 1 I
i 40.00 40.00 40.00 . c . ( I (_.. : 30.00 ..: 30.00 30.00 ... . ij s. i I 20.00 20.00 20.00 a. . t. . 2 i
..)
. : i 10.00 10.00 10.00
' ' j
, i ! ,
I I i . i ! . 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 c I
..._[
I i
-_....._..I.. .... .. -. 32=d i
iP01.':T 10 . . _ . _ - DESCRJP12!
'N0049 PWR ANG CH di (QUA K 480]ErrM RESjlli,@.I.IRlW V5 @
{0400 S/G 2A NAR ANG LE'., i iu S D___ ..R.T ..THE
.__...__. -- .. _1__8 d A.. N. 9_0 .
%em W I j
w,- -
- i. ,;. 'N.,,,
.o
- f,' $~
+,1. ..
4 00 20.00 RELATIVE 75.00 TIME .30.00 35.0 l(MINS)0 40.0D 50.00 55.00 _ _ _ . . . . . ..._.___.'_ .._4...._E_R 43.00 60.00
;, 2 _ . .. . . j _~__-__q
.i . i
) I l .. ..
~k i l'
!' i 1 .
I f .
- - . . . . . . _ . .. .-.a ._...:.-..._......_z.. .
.~......z.......- .. -- -_. . .. .~
i i !, ! l i i l, t t i I i t :
. i
. . .I
_ . .. . .___ . ; . . . . . . . . _ . f b_.. . . ~. y . . _ _ . . . . . . . . . _ . . . . . - . . . . . . . . .
! / ! : ? 1 4 i I l '/ i
; l: .
i ! i N , i.
....j_. .
- . ._ . . . .. a..
N
._.....i....._.... ...a . . . .!-
j i i i l i .
' .I i I
' l
- /, / l 2 J
./ ..
. g. . .; . . _ . . . . ., . . . . _ . . 5. .- -.
q
/, .
/ .
,e '
e
,, . m IL ' ~., L'J.4 j
.ig t nny
, , . q
. n Q, , . L .:. - ., ,
r
'go t.pifgh on gir.Iftute QMd ..
/
s
,,./- ,
,f' I
,/
.. s / .
t x . ., _. / ; . '
.. _ .. , s. ,
t
.' , s
. 7 , ! .
i e !
- - , - _ _ _ /./ -
; i t
I l i T. 3.]
. .. s
?f4 Ut SYMSOL , ,! BYROM UNIT 2 ~ . . . - . . . . . . . . . . __.._' I T_ S _ . . . . . . _ _ . . . . .._ .. _ . . . . _ . _ . _ _ _ . . . _ . . . ) 4) TOTAL 0 PC O N$4h[}$MMf$$$lS$I@@Y@ (L L T - 5 0 -' PC ~+-
- 0. 0 : 3 0 : 0._0. . - - . .
b
Ah
~
ff5Gifp" ^' 36 .R ~.f t%lgt }w}Q g^
---.2geyp;#
es& g t ,.g.W\'?'
.gp , . . ..
.t
$g d
s isi ? $ $ p u , fit
. %; M, < .i.cAg . ' k.
,. L
7, : .."'.cNe . 3,. ~
M. p .k T 0 4. .0..,~-,
. Q* W}d 1.%g.*m Y
y 1, . .1 0
. .~ .. q < D:3 0
. n .e
/ " "'ge-%;M 4-0 001 k.3 Y. rW m+
!w,770 0. 0 . /.) , .1700.0 y-b10. 0'i)
-iw'/:y- ,. ' 5.00 :7 y Q.Nqircq.? E'~f700.0f;t.y: W.', . '.M 700.0Wpgn h,..h;
- g' *6g y.y,*- R4,}.%gg.fif?'Q{F54!m
,..n.4:..
~
4';ff 'l-{qq.cky>, : ;pj%fg z..n::m.r. q.,'. g.g{g g ,y, , j gg pr. j- ! g
.Qif. fL'f . Q % .'.j y yy.i g g f y[ j t .. .
.. . m. .A .w y -: ~;r r .y,,;.(y 3.y mc p,w;x- a xv s;yq.tr. . . a;.,...
. .w]4. ; . , w .s .m
. e..n
.q, p~.3
;;, . p .
.$ r ts,. .. A
.;g;
'"tu i600.0 d 680.0. , '680.0 680.0 Om l_#'p,5 '
. m,j 3 ,-
r3 t . . . .: . ,,
,?
- . ,g. 3. j
- h. -t ;.
.f,)
t ,.4 650.0 660.0 660.0 660.0 _ -
.n... .. -- --
yw- --1 .._, .m,a-..-a.- - - . " = 640.0 640.0 640.0 6 40 .0 _ . - . .- - . <-..c i 1 620.0 620.0 620.0 620.0 . . q;. . . q H.... f {
. ; .. - .- J su . - - - - .
t 600.2 600.0 600.0 600.0 p....;.~...........) l i j
- {
3 . .' 580.0 580.0 580.0 l 3 t 56;. 560.0 560.0 560.0
.-. . 4 . - ... ,
I r, . I I i 1 540.0 540.0 540.0 540.0 L' _ . ... i *
; I i
!. l !
i t f e 520.0 520.0 520.0 520.0
... . . . - . . ( -a.- . ---
500.0 500.0 500.0 50 0 .0 u.-....~.-i_ - - -
!POItJT 10 DES i
170499 ..a AUCTIONEEREC
- T0481gEPfEJSUR}2E(
WOMWEhLQ9M9,l iTO406 BC LOOP 2A~L 4 ST A..R. T.. . T.I..M. E.-. .
..... d Bi 4'58r88
~
g, ,, -
- E a, a, ?
#E RE IVE iTIME IMINS)%N '
r:. 15.00 .n20100Ayf425.00 y ,yt30.00.y 35.0029o .-a 00 5.00;._,,0.00,i 55.00 + ~60.00, . a;
~; ..
. .. ,p 4 . *
'/'
W
- g W-;-Tf6 5thW,.h h ~ n:;;
%y.7 wg .b.n W y' ". * %e.& .*2 .a5% 2 "2 2l:.yhKW .
.%n:? RWiW RM* &.&._&.,_,_ M&v n.,,&. ::; ;_y -~ J J %,,.f
'. "a .,2 x%
- w. .m u%c
% ,, .:::4.svu.m .
- m : .: 7.m~;v. - ni mx 3.
*ja:^p
.p q&y
}Q, s ;,
.c
, yl.
.i Om -
'i' ' '
-?yy. ;';y}f:g'.cy p'.9
& y, 'f
- TQ:%
;u ~
7 _; .u QP. .j' : 'pg := 9 *
'< -f i gyf : p.. ,; 3.%._i . .Q ..Q,. E
-u., J I, l L
. -e.g-
.._- _ . - - __.., u.a .
4: .s
' h *[,; *. *
.' j g_ E- --- ._.w._ my; N = -- ' A .-
.I t I
..1...-_- _
- . . . . . i. ... -
1 - t I ' t , l ! l
- . i i # i t
! i l l- 8 i
l i l* ! i ._ - . _ _ . _ . . .._...j.._..._...;.__.
......._.....__...___...,..7......,.y
,- j .., v j .
i i 1
' 4 i
4
/
Q I . : as I Apcs tura cc.rd
. ; i i.
3 i 4
.. s ._'. .
i 11 l' i . 3 i
'f8 "- * + + ' ^ ^ M F4GElmq$sagte.wr Westeahan.* w V 2'.4*CS4'Sj'M_ -4"'.*.>*4 -
. ;.y ~ n. ,, .. . . ,f . ...
r -
.. .6&.....,.....-. ... .. ..
Q J ,- i
~, _ .p , ; , ,
' i l l I '
i i
, .4.... ...! . . ... . .. ._t ._...p.__-.... ._
. . . . . _ - . . ..y I
j . ! .
..__._...~.}.. ................:........_......
I
....._...j...._....4...._...q*
i - l
)r
- j
- l l i :
; i l t
1 l.
- - . . _. r ::J > .m ..b.'::- ...-:-: . : -- .- : :- w::. : - f k .-- . .- ..i. . .. .:: -e=- c- ----- " - - . . -
kk.IPTI. 3.trON : _ :.- - .:.:- UNI 1S SYMBO'.
- lSiRON UNIT 2 j ilIGHTAVE,_. DEGF O ', .' '
,HJ@@M~ DEGF ! .
10Tf.LEGjTNTI DEGF - ], , ( COLD LEG T DEGF X t l. M. 9.0 . 00:30:00 i
%o3Wob .j
g
, ., .c . .. ,. - --
* '# i- i
.- N ys , , , g 4[,- t, p,'
p' , fj , -} l ~_. ( hof'*O 'i ? *'A* y F0 405 ' '
- j'.bsT04'8$ ,
E! '.' ~ 61'c UMW SN f, 3 j i - ?i+ 45007O a-Y [k500.~ N $$YO'0'd
. ; .~
*.J $ 0**.,jf0.00 m' 2.5.00 d g;,10.00; - - -
,,.g..,.,
, , ,e * . w.r , - #J
~t- ,
, 4050, 4050. .690.0 '
2350. . - , _; .. . . _ _ . _ . . . _ .. . . . s
-l vn- - %
3600, 3600. W -
+ 0 1
6 .0 2300. L - - .__ - . _. -
...m I
- l. !
i I 6 3150. 3150. 670.0 2250. p..___....-...-..
, .4 o,r - - . . _
l l
.t 2700. 2700. 660.0 2200. .. . .. . .; . . . .. . . .
l
! .I p_. .---
m 2200. 2250. 650.0 2150. _ .. 3 i
- N .' . 1800. 640.0 2100. .. .i i i~
I q
'7R. 13c0. 630.0 2050. ,
t 300.0 900.0 620.0 2000. 7_.. . . . I I e i 450.0 450.0 6:0.0 1950. L. i l a f o i e i 1 0.0000 0.0000 600.0 1900. L _. _ . _ L._ , .- l POINT JD
- u.=.rw a =-.= w . m V048n0J9: LP.RES.SU,RIZ.,E.R s .~ .a y;. a 4i PRESSURIZER
;F0405 S/G 2A STEAM IF0403 S/G 2A FW F i
i . [..S. T A. R T. .T.I M__E . 18, ( . . .
a i
- . :h1vwFMcpM OW .-@: mum y.m s~
%m .-.a.6Rh%B1E%Vr':1.3.'U m W= q$Fhf UK g4 0.y,Af9ttil W). 6, k y v:w & qc:: v# m .; G.:.%:
~
M ?MIREL-ATIVE' TIME V a O1 ~ .nWCW4i96.b :W.:y.Lc: w ' t.25.00
, -- ~ w J.gp20,00gtf425.00,sj30.00 w(HINS) 4
~ -
- ,00jgp. 45.00; a 50.00,Tg.g55.004WW 7 g.A60.dD 4. l.b
=_ -
'OW4 M.,35.00 f a.f+%ogs, TJifd. M, . IN',s M j s. f .m. $fidKM
% :i kc,. . N.: ,u W. J R '.
- i. ,"n'. t .
v .: .pgj+,g
. ,. @,.. a#SJ$. -
,3 y , . ,
m v. .. Q]Tk- * ., !! ,
. M f & n~J.
7
. . #, m$ , ,
y$.
- -+.u nynw- .m'
. - % [ . @. : '.,.
. , -s.'
. bn: .n. u,. , - - ,,
- g. : + u : .~. -
_%:1gf?p
- s. .
p' ,.. __
.:. ..u w.w y.: ' . -
L-- _ . , fx +
.-.. ~ - - - - - - - ~ ~ ~ ~ - +
.':. . . .V"; c' ty .j.) ~- .
s a .: . r s a .= n
.c. l l' e
1.-
,.i j _. _ .) ... .__. c p .__ . ..
.. __.. . . ._. h -
= _ [ ... .___ _ ;_ .p -
, i, . ; i ; ;
i I t
!. l t i -
i t l I. . b ,i
... i. 1
.\
e t
.,....-...._...p..._........ . . _ . . .
._..9.____.......... __.._._;...._.. .,
i i j -
. l l , . .i.
" t 3 l l l . ; ~- J w. -
~~" ~
> ~
4 s, , 4., - , l -
, . . l . :
,t ,
. i . n
, t
,j . s I
.\ ,
--a ,
; ,.y .
k' 4 p n . ;. .717,3C _5.*II O.s P~j f7 - (' ' 5 .0.]t %. , L . s g- , s ;.- , O 1 .d I t Also AvaMNO on j . Apeduce C .rd 1 i . .
- t. ! .
i - l t 1 . 4
- l
.s y -- -
a- .
-- / . . .
_=.N/ V. .l':i. . i SW30' '
.I.
i i i i_ -- +
- 31PM ON O!UTS '
GW. UN!T 2
- a. .
wmow - x yE.S_%,em;..m
-- S4i. PT ;455?M . , _I., ,M PSIG. m.w ,.raa; -- s"m p.%.M...O. .
iTM T DEGF 6 F FT-Si2 K3d + X '
~
FT-500 KSH - A.N 9.0 .. _ . 0 0. :_.3 0. .:_0.0. __ __.. .. . .. _ _. . . _ . _ . . . . Oh h M
%o3+ 0
7 10499 'IP51'00) LO400
' L0404 630.0 1200. 80.00 0.00 0.00 80.00 ;..... ..-d,...._10.00 4 . . . .
5 >
~
l I l _. I' ( '620.0' 2150. 70.00 ,. .... -_l
.70.00 h
.. . a. . ._ .
1 I , 610.0 1200. l f 60.00 60.00 b - -- UM t I ! ! -600.0 1050. 50.00 50.00
...__ .i . . .
n ._ m .-- .~ i i . 530.0 1000. 40.00 '. 40.00 h. . i h;.0 950.0 30.00 30.00 .. l I
- J~..- 900.0 20.00 20.00 l y_ _-
.4 ;
J i
.' B50.0 10.00 10.00 ..
i . 25;.; 800.0 -0.3815E-05 -0.3815E-05 .. 3 :0. 2 750.0 -10.00 -10.00 . A 9 ( 530.0 i 700.0 -20.00 -20.00 8 L...... . ..i -. ._.. l. .. . _ point JD DE.S6
,LO404 S/G 2A WIDE @
LO400 S/G 2A NAR RM I
'PO400 S/G 2A SiyLIR
.T04G9 AUCTIOl;EEAED f9 . F4 7' *O' 4 ' '
- e b 4
%. 'O. '
he . s. LN N i l l
.w
L F ' 25.00 po,,, EE .,E 1 TIME (g7g3,)
- s ... .._... ~ .._ _ . .. _ 3 . o - . .;
- 33. , ,,,,, , , , , ,
2,. o o . 33.co .,,,,,. ;
. -- . y. .. . % ..
;. -tI - . .-w l .
!, t, !
f
. ~
l l 8 j
?
; ! l j w .., J ,- -
' ~^ - --- - .~
,,. , . y
~
I I
,~~"-*"7--. . . . .
j j . **-~-*~~~~...Q
,1 - : t ?
, - .~
i < I. e I __
- i
~L..?---..^-~.......
-" -- + . . . . , ,
i* , , , , , , j fJ~~'
' ' ~ ~ ~ * - - . T , ' - - - = .- . . . .. ! ...;f I ,
N;. ; , I
. R\ l , '
* ?
~, ; !
f f
, I '
' t
' . 'r ' , i t / ; / .'
- l ; g
./ *" . . .
,;.. . ,- 1, -.-. . *
'.x. -
' /
j sla
#./,, ,/er 7
/
/.l .
7, >
,. .. / - ~ ,.... . . .
% ~ '/' . ~-
,.' '~._.*'
.f
~ ~ '
' ANSTEC
.- ~ '
/ APERTURE b*raiofi m q -
Also Apmarc Ava:C.n'.r.im , i j .
-.....1.......~~g~
I i I '
" ~ ~ ~ ~ -)-
s ', P 3 0' ' ~ h) --
~ ~ ' ' - - - ' " "
P'i ~ 0"" . . . . . .
- U.N1TS 2
~ - --- - -
LEVEL LT-501 PC LEVEL LT-Sf7 PC "RESS PT-52.: PS.7- v . ', n .r^^** . . ,. CEGF ,s [@ . 00:30:00.. . . - . . . ._ . _. _
', TDI 70043 Revision: 00 (O
%) -
ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE CDVER SHEET Test Number: N3 Date Performed
\' Sf Test
Description:
$ b l b eous closoec of a // ms WJ l l
Discrepancies Corrected (initia!s) Step # Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date ' hlorL O i Test Results'
- 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete 8b Date f /fd 4 m SFCC Acceptance O[ 7a Afif% v i, , (- - nu Date
, Test Number: TR-3 Revision Number /Date: 08. 9A)8/94 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SIMULTANEOUS CLOSURE OF ALL MAIN STEAM ISOLATION VALVES I. OBJECTIVES
~
The purpose of this procedure is to test the simulator response to a Simultaneous Closure of All Main Steam Isolation Valves as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program.
- 4. Braidwood Unit 1 LER 94-012: Simultaneous Closure of All Main Steam Isolation Valves.
III. INITIAL CONDITIONS
- 1. The plant is operating at nonnal steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits.
- 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value.
- 3. The boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank D at the proper position.
- 4. 'Ihe Main Steam Isolation Valves are open. .
i V 1
_ _ . . _ _ _ . . . _ _ _ . . . . . . _ . . _ . ~ - _ . . _ . _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ . .. _ __ __ .. Test Number: TR-3 RevisionNumber/Date: 08.9A)8M Frequency: ANNUAL , O : BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST ) SIMULTANEOUS CLOSURE OF ALL MAIN STEAM ISOLATION VALVES I IV. DATA COLLECITON I. Setup the ZEiA Plotter to graph the following variables (Te,h T , S/G pressure and leveuhall be onloop 1): l
- a. Neutron flux (Rx power) ,
- b. RCS average temperature
- c. Pressurizer pressure
- d. Pressurizerlevel
- e. Pressurizer steam temperature
- f. Steam flow
- g. Feed flow
- h. Hot leg temperature l
- i. Coldleg temperature
- j. S/G pressure
- k. S/Glevel V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS i l
I. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specifiedin~Section III.
^
j
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Simultaneously close all MSIV's.
- 4. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
- 5. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
i O 2
', Test Number:_ TR-3 RevisionNumber/Date: 08.9A)8/94 l Frequency: ANNUAL l l ,
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST l l l SIMULTANEOUS CLOSURE OF ALL MAIN STEAM ISOLATION VALVES l l l VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA see sseesseeses.....e**** eeeeeeeese e eeeeeeeeeeeeee++es...ee. eee NOTE
- The simulator response will be compared to baseline data *
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- The Review Board will determine if the simulator has the
- capability to adequately reproduce the defined transient.
esse ++eesseesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees The following acceptance criteria are to be used to determine successful test completion: j
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. All Main Steam Isolation Valves close.
- 3. The observable change in the parameters correspond in duection to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature. l
- 4. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an a! arm or automatic action.
l l l O 3
, Tcst Number: TR-3 RevisionNumber/Date: 08.9A)8/94 Frequency: ANNUAL BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST I SIMULTANEOUS CLOSURE OF ALL MAIN STEAM ISOLATION VALVES l 1
l VII. LIST OF FIGURES
- 1. Rx Power
- 2. RCS Average Temperature
- 3. Pressurizer Pressure
- 4. Pressurizer Level I
- 5. Pressurizer Steam Temperature
- 6. Steam Flow - Loop 1
- 7. Feed Flow - Loop 1
- 8. Hot leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 9. Cold Leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 10. S/G Pressure - Loop 1
- 11. S/G 1.evel- Loop 1 NOTE 1 Total steam flow and total feed flow were not available from
- Braidwood Unit One data. Loop 1 steam flow and feed flow
- were substituted to aid in data comparison.
l j l 4 i
A (' "N i (_) (d i ! MSIV'S CLOSED 01/05/96 10:32:55 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I D _ 8 _ 6 _._ 4 _ 2 _ k I I I I I I I I I I I I I i 0 5 10 15 20 TIME YCN0049 ( .000 , 105. ) 21090 PWR RNG CH 41 (QUAD 4) TOT
g- ,
,q f~~'S
(,/ V, U . MSIV'S CLOSED 01/05/96 10:29:16 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __. _ 6 _._ O - 4 _ O K a I l I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME C RXTAVG ( 550. , 620. ) 01200 LOOP TABLE o fCT0481 ( 600. , 700 ) 91250 PRESSURIZER STM T
~
_ 3 5 0 6 Q g 0 2 5 9 45 3 - 4
~
_ T - 0 PT 1 I s L J__II SL 6 I I SE 9 EV
/ RE 5 I P L 0 RR
/ EE 1 I 0
I ZZ 5 I I 1 RR UU S S S S I I EE RR I P P I 0 0 2 5 I I 7 5 6 6 0 0 I I 0 ) ) 1 4 0
+
I I E 0 S 5 0 D I I 2 0 1 N O C I I 4, E 0 S + 0 I I E 0 E 0 0 5 M 7 . 0 I 1 0 3 T 2 I ( ( D I E = S O N I l L O C I S I I S I V V' I I i 0 0 I D f 8 8 S M 1 _ _ d _ ~ _ . _ - 0 4 4 0 O 4 2 8 D 6 D PL CC YY C0
ym rx p ~ % \ %. / 01/05/96 10:39:45 MSIV'S CLOSED 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I l I I I I I I I i l I I 8 _
~
6 _
~
f 4 _ g p _ _ n 2 _ g- -7 - I I I i 1 1 I I
,1 1 I I I I I 5 10 15 20 O
TIME ( .000 . 400E+0 4) 06040 SG 1 A FW F FT-510 C YCF0403 . ( .000 . 400 E+0 4) 06060 S/G 1 A STE AM F FT-512 0 YCF0405 .
~
O O O : MSIV'S CLOSED 01/05/96 10:43:12 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 10 1 I I I i i I I I I I I I I I I h e m 6 __ t 4 __ o & O 2.__ 0 h i I I I I I I I I I i l l I I I o 5 10 15 20 TIME O YCT0419 ( 530. . 630. ) O YCT0406 ( 530. 630. 06830 RC LOOP 1A WR HOT LEG T
)
06825 RC LOOP 1A WR COLD LEG T
_,r - , - , , - - - - - - - MSIV'S CL OSED 01/05/96 10:46:48 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS IC 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __ ' O - 4 _. 2 _ O l ! I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME O YCPO400 ( 350. . .125E+0 4) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 0 YCLO400 ( .000 , 100. 06350 S/G 1A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51
... 1
)
TDI 70043 : Revision: 00 t I O !' l ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: TR-3 / M Jl v'S Closed DATE: / /r/9(,, i l' 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choiciI
@ Actual plant transient data EVENT: U-/ 4E4 Sy - o /z. '
- b. Analytical or design data - DATA:
- c. Transient data fron: similar plant ,
' PLANT: h// weed '
- d. Panel of expens (best estimate)
COMMENTS: AloC 5 i i C 2. Data Comparison Summary 3 ! 1 VARIABLE COMMENTS kESOLUTION h ?* **" Now Accrohtfe i i 1 496
.f f fB Lo I W Pass \
kK lad 71 c - sc A*% /tb$
)
% level Y #
l t !O I l l - - - , ,_ -_- . .. .
. TDI 7004)3 I Revisi:n: 00 i i ( ATTACHMENT D l { SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W i VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION j Fead Flow YDo Aeo nk tie Ste m plow b i l i {
- 3. Comparison Results Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one) a.
- b. UNACCEPTABLE 1
4. Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented) lE Y 02 % 4@8L/ COMMENTS: final 2
I Pla'nta BRAIDWOOD 1 Mode = REAL l Int rval= 1 MINUTE l Points 1-7 ef 11 l cbx 4 ALL M S'E V J
, M Thursday August 11,1994 01:43:00 PM l Type = ANALOG NQ049JP_WRENG_CIL4UGUAD_4LDET 01 i 120- 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 i
08/11/94
*et = N.A.
W i !ig!'ji Vi U 1 {! 1 1 Q Jts = PC g ]# 0 h a 1 2 3 b# Valid = 736 M th = GOOD 4{ h,[ hdl!m kh .;0:a J!if 0 0 0 0 0 0 OhlPh O!$ $ megwrmp: vim' , wpm w m m m mawn> w w wwaym a nnm: man l Value = 0.029996, Status = GOOD l Type = ANALOG 2400,- PO480JPEESSURIZER1El i 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 i
- t = N.A.
)' 4 el 0h 2100bO!N Nbh!b i '
l I 'b Units = PSIG M l i m ;0D l i i
'j i ! i i i 2 2 e3m OI[E p
h Valid = 73B 180 ! ! k ...
/ ,,0 ;
i ' l 0 ' gg ;qMhy;[ b M:th= Ox0003 O.!HiD ;0W ggos n i , i o ' I O
'l i
!N ,
1500ki !NN R!N ' i l'o i l' li 'Ir [ !O m ih! I :
!!U il f0 {
Value = 2239.6, Status = GOOD l l Lo480JERESSufu7FR 1 L1 i Type- ANALOG 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 90[ 08/11/94 ) S:t = N.A. I 1 1 1 1 6 Units = PC dP "n 0 s 1 ll ! ' 1 2 3 , m Vclid= 736 h! O h' i 0 l' ] j,l O (, lll! pgll: lll$h i Mith= 0x000c 3 {p{ g8 i 0 l 1l0 P ' 0 iy0j!{jjj
;0 @
y l i b,
'q i!l 4
4,I 1 d hll ll , h '4 i n ! !!(!LE h! l !! j @!cl![ Value = 51.45, Status = GOOD l TD481JPRESSURIZEFLSIM Tl i Type = ANALOG 660L 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 9:t = N.A. p 55]1j!j! p ? ph j j h j j ' 1' 1j ll,f 64 . -
' } l ,
]Z q lts= DEGF ,9; q 2 '
2 I 3l 5 h '
!l t
)
k;0; Q1alid= 736 M:th= GOOD 62 b jh "h h p d
- t. { j Oj ,
a
'l 0 '
i 1 0l , 1, j ! i!! lik. Ul O l0! i O ' O I' o ! ik i i 60 h!h Nh 0 kll i Il !b !i l iI ' i l i J l l' ' ' l Value = 652.44, Status = GOOD l TD406dRCLLWIDERNG_ COLD _LEGli i Type = ANALOG 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 S:t = N.A. 580l-..m .m m g lU! f,p!!! j- L, 1 540 , i Units = DEGF jB [m n ; l l, i 2, i' '
3"l "/
j'l l ; I Valid = 736 500k! l.1 !! !
!!d 8b b. y '
O ) l 5 0 l 1 q;, 46 ! i I' , Value = 538.25, Status = GOOD l TD419JBC11W1DERNG110T LEG Tl i Type = ANALOG 70 - 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 S:t = N.A. 1 1 1 1 Unita= DEGF 60 P ' j@u ll J. 2 3 Valid = 736 - y 0 !l IOl, I
- h. ( l {j 500$jg[h 0' ji I,'!
M th= GOOD jj-i 0 l
, l ]Ol Q l ,
l; 9 [jh"j;g l l , l q 400% g!y. .h h W M E M i i h l l I ' i i Oill Ii I'I Value = 538.21, Status = GOOD l 104991RCL.HIGHESI_.TAVGJAUCIlONEERin i Type = ANALOG 600- 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 S:t = N.A. I m i , 1 i 1 1 570 ' jj ;, 1
'ts = DEGF d o >0!' l 2 3 y alid = 613 540 h 0l !
; p[,,,,1 l
I
;; c ol,,t, 0
,,l 0I' ll,';i!,lijl,,
Ith = GOOD l' ,
; O1 i
;,r l
[j 0l0ll] l ';
- l: ,0,!L:
l l!i li! l' i 510* I '
'Y ' ' ' ' ' '
j Valee = 537.67, Status = GOOD l
PI'nt = BRAIDWOOD 1 I C,[o $ u r<- , Mode = REAL ! Int *rval= 1 MINUTE l Points 8-11 ef 11 l AM 53V j Thursday August 11,1994 01:43:00 PM l Type = ANALOG PO40QJSINLGEfLLSTM DUT 1 P1 i 1300- 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 St = N.A. 08/11/94 100l 1 qu 1 1 1 ilts = PSIG 0 Valid = 736 g g 0 4 [j pp gj[ l@g[gpg p s!q((jpW2fl] 'li !g ,i 3, , M:th = 0x0003 7o94 ci .M h 3p K @ }! 0{ ,l l ff o!{b;0Nhb O' 9'M N Q! :0!. i
!l 0, '
400 h I 'ib*l Ib$$d!N! i , lI I I I I I' i l l!l Value= 908.91, Status = GOOD l Type = ANALOG LO400JSTMEEN_1_NARRNG 1 Li i 80 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 U ts = PC 60 f0 1
. j: @n y fh V: lid- 736 M:th= 0x0003 4g lll q 0 pi , 0 0
g hp I; hk [ p p
; O g Value = 69.722, Status = GOOD l Type = ANALOG F0403JSIMEEN1EEED_WIRJN 1 F1 i 5000- 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 t= N.A.
Units = KBH 300 $U 30 NE Ii q Og 3g g 1 2 3 V: lid = 736 1000+hg 0: % O O
)) O M::th= GOOD l}iiig .
{7
..p 0: g 0 Value = 0, Status = GOOD l F0405JSIM_ GEN 1STM OUT 1 Fl i Type = ANALOG 5000H 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 08/11/94 Nt = N.A.
3000k mlggg13 p"1 1 1 1 m sits = KBH y 0 gj 1 2 3
,W ild = 736 goog g]p qlg 0 0 0 1000 M !
h Value = 0, Status = GOOD l \ V
,. TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A
. BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET l Test Number: TX-'/ Date Performed I/f/16 Test
Description:
S/m u Ib eavs te &> of a // AC /' '# ferf ,
)
1 1 Discrepancies 1 Step # Corrected (initials) Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date Ynet - O Test Results
- 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete - N <yI/ ; Date / /5'd6, O. SFCC Acceptance O( tg bd Date 2i 9,/'10 final 1
, Tcst Number: TR-4 Revision Number /Date: 06. I1 A)8/93 Frequency: ANNUAL BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL REACTOR COOLANT PUMPS I. OBJECTIVES The purpose of this. procedure is to test the simulator response to a Simultaneous Trip of All Reactor Coolant Pumps as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985.
II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License !
Examinations. l l
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program.
l
- 4. Braidwood Unit 1 LER 93-01: Simultaneous Trip of All RCP's Due to Inadvenent RCP UF Trip, s
III. INITIAL CONDITIONS
- 1. The plant is operating at normal steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits.
- 2. Boric acid of the pmper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron ,
concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value. ! l
- 3. 'Ihe bomn concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank !
D at the proper position. 4 ' C) 1
.. Test Number: TR-4 , Revision Number /Date: 06. I1 A)8/93 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST l 1 SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL REACTOR COOLANT PUMPS l i IV. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables (Tc, T h, S/O pressure and level shall l be onloop 1): '
- a. Neutron flux (Rx power)
- b. RCS average temperature
- c. Pressurizer pressure
- d. Pressurizerlevel
- e. Pressurizer steam temperature
- f. Steam flow
- g. Feed flow
- h. Hot leg temperature
- i. Coldleg tempuature
- j. S/O pressure
- k. S/Olevel i
O 2
t Tcst Number: TR-4 Revision Number /Date: 06. I1A)8/93 Frequency: ANNUAL BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL REACTOR COOLANT PUMPS V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Trip the UF relays via malfunctions RP07C & D.
- 4. At 1950 psig, place the Steam Dumps to the STEAM PRESSURE mode.
- 5. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
- 6. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA eseesseeesseeessessesseseesseeeeeeeeeeeesseeeeeeeeessesseesseeeeeees NOTE
- The simulator response will be compared to baseline data
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board. *
- l The Review Board will detennine if the simulator has the
- 1 capability to adequately reproduce the defined transient.
- eseeeeesseessessesese**esseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeessesseessee
'Ihe following acceptance criteria are to be used to determine successful test completion:
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. All RCP's trip. .
- 3. RCS loop flow decreases to natural circulation values.
- 4. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature.
- 5. 'Ihe simulator shall not fail to cause an alann or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic action.
3
Test Number: TR-4 Revision Number /Date: 06. I1108B3 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SIMULTANEOUS TRIP OF ALL REACTOR COOLANT PUMPS l l l l VII. LIST OF FIGURES l ! 1. Rx Power -
- 2. RCS AverageTemperature
- 3. Pressurizer Pressure j
- 4. Pressurizer ! . vel
! 5. Pressurizer Steam Temperature l ! 6. Steam Flow -Ieop 1 l 7. Feed Flow - Loop 1
- 8. Hot Leg Temperature - Loop 1 l 9. Cold leg Temperatme -Ieop 1 1
- 10. S/G Pressure - Loop 1
- 11. S/G I2 vel- Loop 1 l
i eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees
- NOTE
- Total steam flow and total feed flow were not available from Braidwood Unit One data. Loop 1 steam flow and feed flow
- were substituted to aid in data comparison.
- esseesessessesseeeeeeeeeeeeeesesesseseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee++se I
L l 2 iO l l 4
)J r,L - 8 2 0 T O 2 2 _4 _ O D 0 2 T 1 I
- )
4 l 6 I D 9 A
/ U 5 I I
O 0 (
/ l 1 1 0
I 4 I HE C L 5 B 1 G A I NT R I P I R O WO I P L I 0 0 )J I 9 0 0 2 rL I I 1 1 2 0 0 ) ) 1 I S I D I N . . O 5 0 _ C I 0 0 _ E I 1 6 _ S l , , _ I _ 0 _ 0 l 0 3 E 0 . P 5 M 0 0 _ I I I 0 0 _ R = T . 5 _ T l N I ( ( s O I I P S I C I R V I I L D L A 1 C 1 G 08 6 4 D 2 0 9 4 G 0 V 2 0 A NT C X Y R \ J. OQ rN
O O O . ALL RCP'S TRIP 01/05/96 12:27: 13 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1C l l l l l 1 I I I I I I I I I 1 8 _ 0
] _
6 D 4 2 _ . O C 1 I I I I I I I I l- 1 I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCP0480 ( .190E+04, . 250E+04) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455 O YCLO480 ( .000 , 80.0 ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459
x eU 5 5 3 0 2 _ _ ; 2 4 _ _ _ _ 2 1 I I 6 I T I 9
/ M 5 I T
0 i S
/
1 R 0 I l E Z 5 I 1 R U S I i S E R I I P 0 I I 5 2 1 O I I 0 1
)
9 I i S D I 0 N i 7 O 6 C I E i S I 0 i 0 E . 0 5 M 0 3 I 0 P T 6 I I i ( R = T N I i S O
' I P S I C
I I R V I I L D l 1 L _. A 1 r _ - _ - 0 8 4 1 8 6 4 2 0 T C Y ~O
(~N . (] (./ N/ ALL RCP'S TRIP 01705/96 12:30:50 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I t 8 __ 6 _ m 4 _ 2 __ _ D- ? _
/
l l l l l 1 I I I I l l I I I O O 5 O 10 15 20 TIME D YCF0403 ( .000 ,
. 40 0E+0 4) 06040 SG 1 A FW F FT-510 O YCF0405 ( .000 ,
. 400E+0 4) 06060 S/G 1A STEAM F FT-512
(] 1 4 4 C D 0 T T 3 _ 2 G 2
. _ _ GE 1 I E L I
L D 6 T L 9 I I OO
/ H C 5 I I R R 0
/ WW 1
0 I I AA 1 1 5 1 P P OO OO I I L L C C I I R R 0 5 I 3 2 I 8 8
' 6 6 0 0
,~ ,
% I I
0 ) ) 1 I I S 0 0 D I 2 2 N I 6 6 O C I , , E I S I 0 I 0 E . M 0 0 0 5 I 0 0 3 T 5 5 P I I I ( ( R = T N I I s O
' I _
P S I I C I _ R V ._ I I I L D 9 6 L _ 1 0 A 1 C _ _ _ _ _ _ 0 4 4 _ 0 0 1 D 8 6 D4 2 T T C C Y V CO - ,. J ( .
I ,, x p. .
!g) (-
ALL RCP'S TRIP 01/05/96 12:38:17 1C 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS I I I I I I I I I i i l I I I I w 8 0 - g J-
=
4 _ Q . O 2 _ M I i i I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME h YCP0400 ( 550. . 115E+04) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 O YCLO400 ( .000 , 100. ) 06350 S/G 1A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51
TDI 70043 Revision: 00 O ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW
. TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE:TR-V T//# of AB N / DATE: ////96
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices)
' h Actual plant transient data EVENT: u-l LER 93-o/
- b. !
Analytical or design data DATA:
- c. Transient data from similar plant PLANT: b/d m)
- d. Panel of experts (best estimate) t COMMENTS ut ollGoeses clue L n/acen,<.d of ATb
I k L loop (m e d " mn o - I oez. ) fs i V '
- 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS - RESOLUTION b ' Powu Yon Ace gd4/e
% ce e en + D o.teve. I PER. Tep p h]0e f6A Press Pee Iua Tk T.c /
5+e- P<,s s kQ /6ve) 1
~
., TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 O ATTACHMENT D V SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION f u l VIoes h)on Acupk M Skm flow b b l l I l 3 Comparison Results Simulator ca ability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one) ( A a. ACCEPTABLE
- b. UNACCEPTABLE l
- 4. l Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be docum nted) fWY Qi09 2 &
XM4CLa COMMENTS: final 2
u@-oat 4 5 0 4
....- e- , - ,- -., , . . . .,.y.. .9.... .. . . . . . , ,_
5;' *6
- l
- 6 e b e . .g a .
n __ e e v.
.y +
d 4 e d
*e e
. g 4
dt* e
- e. .
m
- o.
- e
- g. ..d
.. -4 4
..4 M* '.
e d s 4 e e e
'W .
e y
- t g-4 ,
, 'e
- 4 l : :; 2 4'. O p 4
- e-4 I
O , 6 f'~ b p,
, g.. > , .. a
- e. _) n
{. tp *
,3 e-
. c. -
g
*O a s 4 r I
.v sa y99 g r
- -- . ,i . .
- r R
w
\ .M e . 1;T N6 er6 fa
.ay==..
- f W .
** . 4 J4 ..
- - - 4
. - .p .
O
- a
- i. t - .
n
. ;j y qf pg i .!.
k ,i . ,,, e5 D m 9 8 $ k- S s O E 6 O g-
.a r. E a 8 q a - - n
} 4] 9 9 9 9 " # 9 S
- D g -
b
~
dg) 4 N ,* 4
~
O . pew. '"o" - T o'dvoed Stet'ca. 'sa 'i * [F'o*o' t %r. 0.4] Dete w 13:00 to i f:oo em of 'o.es rosa,
% 'atev' : * ?w.e(s) 104ei ess.14ti est.ame0 , , . . ,31 0 9 . . !Y9 . 74'4 , . .*M*4 . . .*W'a . . l439 . . lh34 . 14'4 . . Jh*4 . . J3;sq , lqst , ;fpo
. , . t
. . . . . i - 4 6 . t
- . . . i . s . I
^
579.9259 M 8.7538 -,
\l i t t
i.67.4357 052.8086 -' 1 #
. I '61.2605 840.5375 . . .
i
\
ts5.Ce54 ses.4853 . o48.8503 643.3332 '
.y ,s
/
/
\ /
- .42.e 3dI 840.3210 '
y
) - - .
/
\
7"
\ ,
b3 4200 637.2400 / .. s e.___-
\.
1 .DO.1G 634.1798 . 4 g se>J <
. . . . .. f** l. , . . . . . .
1 85JJ 831.1047 ..s . . . .6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . .a *.a . ............a .... ...ia . ....... . M* * '3 *)! SC&O*: *'*5 w 3'".'90' 70481 PRE 3SURIZER STM T DEGF *
- 1,:.3 h. . t ;. t . i- ,y 5 .au; eor e
.___m m m__.._m_. m .m_. . _ .
e 4 s......, U .
.s g
O w
- O n..
o . f . . I, i e a9s s t l
. l . ;
- I .
sg / g . . .. d , *. / , . i . } .
. /
a. d a \ *
'g . . t
.. r .
. \
s, .
. s, . . .
- e. %_ ..
j . N .
. s .
j j j *. .-
+.
j . gry 'N
- y..
f .. s s 7.. O g,,
~
4 \ h k -d
. b. .*
*. N _, .
s .
- ,, . ~
. ** .,r ; -.
s* y . , .
^ " " ~
~
3 l *O . a h
- F .31 N i mo. 9. 'g' W s
b. 4 -
'U 4
a g ,: h. t
- 2
.( h I ~
3 i
.. I -
dg i
.. l
- A
*p
, 6
.. t *. 4 e e .
O ,. g.V + 6
- t, <f
{ ,- . s p G
- D -
. am 4 .
4 4 . I I c. I b
- 7. I I W
2 I EI 4 a K i E E 4 i E i a D i e % N - e F h 4 J
- ( gd a
3s 9 0 e n b a 9 c s i a 4 d q 9 4 1 m o a ?
.e ~ w s .-. -.
~ a a 2
E 1
. ~
,=
W . *et- W ood Ste N .* #.* [G"010 M % .CA] Date % 13c00 to i!:00 em 0? *093 h e ':?'. % (s) ro4o3 po4a5 4209.347 4312.783 . , , , .TM . , 237% . . [Y4 , . [M. . , IM . , IM . , [M . , 7%'% o , lM , , 7% . , l% , , t . . -
+ , . . ; , , .
3746.697 3835.795 7 -- 3284.048 3384.748 _ 8 2821.399 2000.730 . 2358.750 2418.712 _ 1896.102 1942.905 . . . 1433.453 14e8,877 _ 970.8041 te(e508 .. 503.1552 S20.0422 .. 45.50435 4& S2463 -s,
. . . e . , . . . , , 6 i
-417.1425 -427.3e29 ... ......... ... .... ......s ... ..a . . . . . . . . . . . .............i.4 Mr*" O 'JEM' LW S**W F0405 STM GEN 1 STM OUT 1 F MBH + 70403 SILf GLfl 1 f tid WiR !!! 1 F Abli e
f+~-. s
\
o .
*e, *' -
\ ..
O *. e \ , P
- s
\ .
b se ( .
\ e
=--- \ . .
\ .
r g .
- g. , . .
\ .
+
g .
\ .
W l
- pp . 6 ..
** 4 .
s ..
\ s w i .
h = -- a ,. g , l
.. ~
). -
N
. I w I .
* * ^ '
l
- ~
i e
- * * % e .
C, g . 6
+'
p W s . , >=
~
b ee*** o . r- l
. g _
g -
.1 g* t - - W 2
] .ef$ cr 1.1 *-
i w* . . a j l .
) **
j ' y ~ C l k_
- t 3 l yy *
+
j pp. - h l
.r 1
s 5 g g g e s
- 3
- e h R 4 3 s a 5 a a 4
cm N eO em ; 0 $
. =* 4 3 8 3 r, 1 i E C i3 d
3 d,
,1 d a a 1 1 2
r1 3
, i.
I t I i
. e...- .g e -. .
g ..g .. . * . . . ..w- .-e-y- ea6 y l v d
. . . . . ! = *= . g ,-- ,
a I O 5-- I O **
- h, . ..
g, . . g _. ps .: .. W g -. g. ..
.. . g ..
\ ..
x . . )
, x .
'g . Kg ..
O e- e [...
.1:
, F 9 *
. +-4
- 5. - -
2: W .. E g._ : O Ea p -._. .. : y .
,,.* g s'
$,* ,'o k.- *'* ' _-
,, .J Q.
- = - .
! e . 4 g,g o " EH 8 m$?.g .
. 35
, ; -. i s.
g,. 9,8 2 K,.u _y .-. . l Di l
.g.. p ;
I ., A. F - . . k k$
& 4 .
. a. .
.d . .
6 o e . n - c a - g g 1 lQa I$ s s n v ln a e n i ie O @ U n y 3 R E G R R
^
re i 9 = a ! I a B. $ R
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: 'TR- f Date Performed I,/5Y9 f, Test
Description:
Ic/g of Sln;/c SC/ Osf i l Discrepancies Corrected (initials) j Step # Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date ' O n e., l l l
\
Test Results [ _ L ., 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a panial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete [ MN' Date f /5'/96 SFCC Acceptance Date b/% final I
I Tcst Number: TR-5 ' Revision Number /Date: 06.11M)8/93 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST TRIP OF ANY SINGLE REACTOR COOLANT PUMP I. OBJECTIVES 1he purpose of this procedure is to test the simulator response to a Trip of any Single Reactor Coolant Pump as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Fr.cilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program .
III. INITIAL CONDITIONS
- 1. The plant is operating at nonnat steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits.
- 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value.
- 3. 'Ihe boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank D at the proper position.
O 1 l J
l Test Number: TR-5 Revision Number /Date: 06. I1/08/93 { Frequency: ANNUAL O
' b
, BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST ; TRIP OF ANY SINGLE REACTOR COOLANT PUMP l IV. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables (the loop / S/G variables shall be on loops 1-4):
- a. Neutron flux (Rx power)
- b. Hot leg temperature i
- c. Coldleg temperature
- d. S/Gpressure 1
- e. S/G level
- f. Steam flow
- g. Feed flow V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program. I
- 3. Trip 1A Reactor Coolant Pump.
- 4. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
- 5. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
2
. l
[- Test Number: TR-5 Revision Number /Date: 06.11/08M3 Frequency: ANNUAL , BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST ! TRIP OF ANY SINGLE REACTOR COOLANT PUMP VI. ACCEITANCE CRITERIA i l i i eseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeessesseeeeeesese l NOTE ! The simulator response will be compared to baseline data *
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- The Review Board will detennine if the simulator has the capability to adequately reproduce the defined transient.
- seesse++seeeee+++eseeeeeeeeeeeees,seeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee++++e The following acceptance criteria are to be used to detennine successful test completion:
l
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. Steam generator safety valves shall NOT lift.
lO t l 3. Safety injection is NOTinitiated. i l 4. Only 1A RCP trips.
- 5. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature. ;
- 6. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alann or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alann or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic l action.
!O 3
.. Test Number: TR-5 RevisionNumber/Date: 06.11M883 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST TRIP OF ANY SINGLE REACTOR COOLANT PUMP VII. LIST OF FIGURES
- 1. Rx Power -
- 2. Hot Leg Temperature - Loops 1-4
- 3. Cold 12g Temperature - Loops 1-4
- 4. S/G Pressure - Loops 1-4
- 5. S/G Level - Loops 1-4
- 6. Steam Flow - Loops 1-4
- 7. Feed Flow - Loops 1-4 O
i 1 I O 4
{ )'I!l l ' ll xjl ek _ 0 3 T 3 O T 5 0
. - ~ 2 )
2 _ - - ~ 4 1 I I D 6 A 9 I U
/
I Q ( 5 I 0 I 1
/ 4 1
I 0 I H C 5 1 G N I R I R I W I P I 0 I 9
) 0 1
I 2 ( w I 0 ) 1 I I S . D I 5 N i 0 O 1 C I E , S l I 0 i 0 0 E 0 3 5 M 0 I 0 I T .
= i
( P - I N I
- R O i T I .
S I P I C V R I M I D . A 9 1 1 - _ - _. _ 4 f 1 0 0 8 6 4 0 2 N C
'Y
~ /)Q ll
- m ,- ..
~) % s' v' .
1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:23:09 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~
8 _. Q D " _ O 6 _._ 4 __ O 2 __
~
i i i I I I i l i I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME _C YCPO420 ( 100. , 115E+04) 06620 S/G 18 STMLINE PRESS PT-5 0 YCLO420 ( .000 , 100. ) 06400 S/G 1B NAR RNG LEVEL LT-52 3
^'
(J3,
'- F)
' (' ) .
1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 12:58139 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I D e _ 8 __. _ 6 ._ _ 4 _ _ O o 2 _ _ O l i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME O (CT0419 ( 520. 620. ) 06830 RC LOOP 1 A WR HOT LEG T O YCT0406 (,520. , 620. ) 06825 RC LOOP 1A WR COLD LEG T
(, (, <- . I N, ) 1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:07:58 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1C 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O _m - 8 __. 6 ___ -
- a O
2 _ - 1 i i I i i i I i i l I I i i 1 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCT0459 ( 520. 620. ) 06990 RC LOOP 1C WR HOT LEG T C YCT044C ( 520. , 620. ) 06950 RC LOOP 1C WR COLD LEG T
+
~\
\- U 1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:04:27 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I D r 8 _
6 __.
% o O !
2 _ I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I 5 10 15 20 0 TIME ( 520. , 620. ) 06910 RC LOOP 1B WR HOT LEG T
.h YCT0439
( 520. 620. ) 06870 RC LOOP 1B WR COLD LEG T g YCT0426 ,
_ 7 3 5 3
- 5 6
O 0 T - 2 2 P T
- _ _ L 3
1 l S L i S E E V 6 l i R E 9 I P L
/ E G 5 I 0 I N N
/ I R L
~
1 0 I I MR T A 5 S N 1 C C 1 1 I GG I
/ /
I I S S 0 0 I 5 5 I 6 4 6 6 I 0 0 _ I 0 ) ) 1 4 0
+
E I I S 5 . D I 1 0 N I 1 0 1 O C I E I S I 0 I 0
. E . 0 0 5 M 0 0 3 I 0 0 T 1 .
I I ( (
=
P I N I I R O T I S I P i I 4. C V R I I D l A 0 0 _ _ 4 4 1 1 C
- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 0 4 4 0 O eD O6 1
4 2 P L C c Y y CO
~3 g~s .
N] %J _ 1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:30:19 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
- b -
, 8 _
7 a D " W O 6 _ Sum 4 _. O 2_ 1 { l i I I i 1 1 1 1 I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME O YCP0460 ( 100. .115E+0 4) 06680 S/G 1D STMLINE PRESS PT-5 O YCLO460 ( .000 , 100. ) 06500 S/G 1D NAR RNG LEVEL LT-54 e
1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:33:57
! 1 DIVISION'= 30.00 SECONDS Ic I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 _
6 __ 1 4 _ l. 2 __ , I fG _ I I I I I I I I {- 1 I I I I I I 5 10 15 20 0 - TIME b YCF0405 ( .000 , .400E+f4) 06060 S/G 1A STEAM F FT-512 06040 SG 1 A FW F FT-510 9 YCF0403 ( .000 , .400E+04) 4 i
7- .. I
,-.3 7s
\v) (s_/ r t
's /
s 1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:37:30 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 10 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I h 6 __ 4 _ 2 _ 0
- _
O ? / . i i i i i i i , , , i i i i 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCF0423 ( .000 .
. 400E+0 4) 06120 SG 18 FW F FT-520 Q YCF0425 ( .000 , . 40 0E+0 4) 06140 S/G 18 STEAM F FT-522 4
(~) (._ (..) 01/05/96
- x. )
13:41:04 ,- 1A RCP TRIP 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 _ 6 __. 4 _ l _ 2 _ WY - O--7 i i i i i i i i i i i i i 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCF0445 ( .000 ,
. 400 E+0 4) 06220 S/G 1C STEAM F FT-532 YCF0443 ( ,000 400 E+04) 06200 S/G 1C FW F FT-530 O ,
O
---x ,~s .
7-~~3 Q.) NI 'w..] 1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:46:11 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 8 _ e 6 __ 1 4 _ 2 _ -
- W -
wr i i i w i i ! ! ! ! i ! I i i 1 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCF0465 ( .000 ,
. 400E+0 4) 06290 S/G 1D STEAM F FT-542 O YCF0463 ( .000 ,
. 400E+0 4) 06280 SG 1D FW F FT-540
f~ gs -~ . \v E Y 'u ] 1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:19:28 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1f I I I I I I I I l l l l l l l l 8 a __ 0 O n 6 __ 4 _ O i 2 _ l I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C #P0400 ( 100. .115E+0 4) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 O YLLO400 * ( .000 , 100. ) 06350 S/G 1 A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51
\_/ \, / v 1A RCP TRIP 01/05/96 13:11:57 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I >
D e _ 8 _ _ 6 _ ._ a 0 2 _ __ l i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I o 5 10 15 20 TIME
.O YCT0479 ( 520. 620. ) 07080 RC LOOP 1D WR HOT LEG T O YCT0466 ( 520. , 620. ) 07040 RC LOOP 1D WR COLD LEG T
4 - i , TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 i 1-ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW i TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: IR-6' /Tr4 o f /A AGF DATE: //r/M
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices)
F
- a. Actual plant transient data EVENT:
- b. Analytical or design data DATA:
- c. Transient data from similar plant i PLANT: :
g Panel of experts (best estimate) J l COMMENTS: Alo% i O 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE . . COMMENTS RESOLUTION : [ik 90wa Nen e. kok,4 r loot i Tu \ loop I Te \ I low z 4 Tu \ lov 2-V Te. ' loop i ede fue , loop I % level lDef Z-Y M ht5 r
/ I loco 2-V 'h leal l O I 1
l
.. TDI 70043 Revision: 00 O ATTACHMENT D b
SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W
. VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION Icef I Gd Phw YoM-Acculatfr loos I Menm FhJ hoo24 m)Phw
, I Im z4 Sw., Floa) \/
f/
- 3. Comparison Results Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one) a.
- b. UNACCEPTABLE 4.
Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented) N YAY COM ZAC z COMMENTS: O - 2
l
' TDI 700-03 R: vision: 00
)
ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: TR- la Date Performed iI ii ! 9L J , l Test
Description:
Tovhto,_ +f f o , c e-<s 4se l l Discrepancies Step # Corrected (initials) Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date ' h/so 'O Test Results j 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
i
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete d [l Date I!#/96 SFCC Acceptance a Date 4/% 1
1 s
- 6. Test Number: TR-6 RevisionNumber/Date: 06.11M883 Frequency: ANNUAL O) l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST l TURBINE TRIP (MAXIMUM POWER LEVEL l WHICH DOES NOT RESULT IN IMMEDIATE REACI'OR TRIP. <P-8) 1 l I. OBJECTIVES I
l l The purpose of this procedure is to test the simulator response to a Main Turbine Trip'(maximum l-power level which does not result in immediate reactor trip: < P-8) as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. l II. REFERENCES i
- l. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program.
l . U O III. INITIAL CONDITIONS l
- 1. He turbine is synchronized to the grid with Reactor Power = 28% with control rod bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits.
l 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value.
- 3. He boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank D at the proper position.
- 4. P-8 bypass permissive light is lit.
l
- 5. Steam dumps are in the Tay, mode and are available. '
i Lo I l l i
I I
. Test Number: TR-6 Revision Number /Date: 06.I1/08/93 Frequency: ANNUAL (O
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST TURBINE TRIP (MAXIMUM POWER LEVEL WHICH DOES NOT RESULT IN IMMEDIATE REACTOR TRIP: <P-8) IV. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables (Tc, Th, S/G pressure and level shall be on loop 1):
- a. Neutron flux (Rx power)
- b. RCS average temperature
- c. Pressurizerpressure
- d. Pressurizerlevel
- e. Pressurizer steam temperature
- f. Steam flow
- g. Feed flow
- h. Hot leg temperature
- i. Coldleg temperature
. j. S/G pressure
- k. S/Glevel V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Trip the main turbine.
- 4. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
- 5. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
O V 2
!' Tcst Number: TR-6 l . Revision Number /Date: 06. I128B3 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST TURBINE TRIP (MAXIMUM POWER LEVEL WHICH DOES NOT RESULT IN IMMEDIATE REACTOR TRIP: <P-8) VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee++eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee++eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee NOTE
- l Be simulator response will be compared to baseline data
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- l he Review Board will determine if the simulator has the capability to adequately reproduce the defined transient.
i eeeeeeeee+++++++eseeeeeeeeee**** ***ee++.es**********eeeee+******** l The following acceptance criteria are to be used to detennine successful test completion: ,
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. Steam generator safety valves shall NOT lift.
i 3. Safetyinjection is NOTinitiated. -
- 4. The reactor does NOT trip.
- 5. All turbine throttle and governor valves close and remain closed.
i 6. He observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those erpected from a best l estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature. i
- 7. He simulator shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alann or automatic acdon. ..
l 2 f 3 L I t
-= -
7 Test Number: TR-6 Revision Number /Date: 06.11A)8B3 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST TURBINE TRIP (MAXIMUM POWER LEVEL WHICH DOES NOT RESULT IN IMMEDIATE REACTOR TRIP: <P-8) VII. LIST OF FIGURES
~
- 1. Rx Power 2.' RCS Average Temperature
- 3. Pressurizer Pressure
- 4. Pressurizer Level
- 5. Pressurizer Steam Temperature
- 6. Steam Flow -Imop 1
- 7. Feed Flow - Loop 1
- 8. Hot leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 9. Cold Leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 10. S/O Pressure - Loop 1
- 11. S/G Ievel-Imop i eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeese
- NOTE *
- Total steam flow and total feed flow were not available from *
- Braidwood Unit One data. loop 1 steam flow and feed flow
- were substituted to aid in data comparison.
e...e.eeeeeees eeeeeeee. eeeeeee++esee++eeeeeees eeeeee.....e...e e - I o l 4
'~ -
(~ (- U (-)
\_ (s ,
TURBINE TRIP 01/11/96 08.01: 19 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l 8 _ ._ N h 4 _ _ g O 0 - - 2 _ _ I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME N YCT0419 ( 540. , 590. ) 06830 RC LOOP 1A WR HOT LEG T O YCT0406 ( 540. , 590. ) 06825 RC LOOP 1A WR COLD LEG T
O O O . TURBINE TRIP 01/11/96 08.08.15 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 _. 6 _ D O o 4 __ h l i I I I I I I I i i i i l l I O 5 10 15 20 TIME D fCP0400 ( 800. , 120E+04) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 O YCLO400 ( 40.0 , 100. ) 06350 S/G 1A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51
O; (m (J1
% v U ,
TUR8INE TRIP 01/11/96 07:50:43 10 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1 I i 1 I I I I I I I l I I I i l 8 __ DJ 6 __
-a 4 __
D 2 _ o i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME
] YCP0480 ( .210E+04, , 23 0E+04)
YCLO480 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455 ( 20.0 , 80.0 ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459
- . _ _ _ - - . . - , . - . . _~._.__ -._-_ ___ - ______ - - _--_ - __________ _ ______ __-________ - _ _________ ______
t
"% TURBINE TRIP y
01/11/96 07:56:03 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS i 1r 1 1 I I I I i 1 I I I l -- 1 I I I i a 1 8 _._ s . O D _ 6
- f 1
i r - t l , SN; f -- I i f
\ \ -
1lI
\
2 __ ; I O d , I l l Md-Ez 7 l 0 l ! Q 5 10. 15
~
20 TIME b YCF0405 ( .000 .200E+04) 06060 S/G 1A. STEAM F FT-512 _ g YCF0403 (-300. , 120E+04) 06040 SG 1 A FW F- FT-510 i i i
(ss
') () ')
v v . 01/11/96 07:45;33 TURBINE TRIP 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __ o O 9 6 _ 4 _ Q 2 __ S 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME b RXTAVG ( 550. 570. ) 01200 LOOP TABLE ( 600. 670. ) 91250 PRESSURIZER STM T O VCT0481 . P _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ m.____- _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ --_.___-_.___._______.____.--_m _ _ _
%) N./ %J .
TURBINE TRIP 01/11/96 07:41:31 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1C I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __ 6 _._ 4 __ 2 ___ l i I I I I I I N' I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME YCN0049 ( .000 105.
)
21090 PWR RNG CH 41 (QUAD 4) TOT O
-- ._ - _ . - _ - - - - _ _ _ - _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - - - _ _ _ - _ - - - - - - _ - - _ _ - - - - - _ _ ~ _ _ _ . - - _ - _ _ . ---_ m
1 TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 O kJ , ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: TE.-G Tvrioin<_ tvie wf & h@ DATE:
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices
- a. Actual plant transient data EVENT:
- b. Analytical or design data DATA:
- c. Transient data from similar plant i PLANT:
@ Panel of experts (best estimate)
COMMENTS: Nsds ca .YI a deJJe < //,/ /nso) oc] C/,dbw, f '
& /eac/att O 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS i RESOLUTION !
Re Powa / don Acop4/4 G < l'st s o l \ 921. \ tat FeA FleeJ l s w n.~ I Ik / f Y W la O 1
_. ._._.____m_.m__ _ _...___ _ _ . . _ _ . _ . . _ _ . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . . o , \ TDI 700-03 gs Revision: 00 lp ATTACHMENT D !v SIMU' ATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W t . VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION Slew % sS hIoM.
'icuoled/e 1-
% leve I L b
l l l l L
- 3. Comparison Results Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one) l a. ACCEPTAB
- b. UNACCEPTABLE i
4. l . Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented) f Y!4L V
. w COMMENTS:
l 4 final
- 2 L
.[' TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: "TP-7 Date Performed I .bl/ife Test
Description:
(VIow (odt- 06oJo %o tesf I ' Discrepancies Step # Corrected (initials) Comments Step # for rr, test WR# and Date h]enL-l
~
l l l Test Results
- 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily 1
1
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Cooplete RETEST after I correction of above discrepancies m required.
l l Retest Complete Date Test Complete d II Date / /#1/9 A, O SFCC Acceptance -
.g u
- Date 8 7/%
final 1 l l
4
.. Test Number: TR-7 Revision Number /Date: 07. I1/08/93 j Frequency: ANNUAL O
l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXIMUM RATE POWER RAMP 1 i I I. OBJECTIVES i The purpose of this~ procedure is to: l 1. Test the simulator response to a Maximum Rate Power Ramp as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-l 1985. i
- 2. Verify proper nuclear plant transient response, including automatic control system performance,
)
when 10% step load changes are introduced at the turbine generator. ' eees eeesesseeeee++seseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesseeeeee. e. eeesseeeeeeeese NOTE
- ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985, Section 5.4.2, Simulator Operability l Testing,(footnote 3) recommends substitution of Appendix B transient tests if these tests provide a more representative
%/
- comparison to actual or predicted reference plant performance.
- In accordance with this recommendation, Braidwood Startup Test (BWSU NR-36), was substituted for the Appendix B, Section B.2.2(7), maximum rate power ramp test.
e eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee++eseeeeeeeeeeses. II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program.
- 4. Braidwood Startup Test (BWSU NR-36): 10% Turbine Load Change.
l lO 1 i l I t ,
4 Tcst Number: TR-7 Revision Number /Date: 07. I1A)8/93 Frequency: ANNUAL ( BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXIMUM RATE POWER RAMP i s l III. INITIAL CONDITIONS l
- 1. The plant is o~perating at normal steady state conditions at approximatly 98% with control rod
- bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits. !
l l 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron l concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value. ! 3. The boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank D at the proper position.
- 4. The following contml systems are in automatic:
- a. Rod Control.
l
- b. Steam Generator Level.
- c. Pressurizer Pressure.
- d. PressurizerI.evel,
- e. Steam Dump Control (Tave Mode).
- f. Feedwater Pump Speed.
- g. DEHC.
I 1 1 0 2
i
.. Test Number: TR-7 Revision Number /Date: 07.11/08/93 Frequency: ANNUAL l O
U BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST
]
MAXIMUM RATE POWER RAMP , IV. DATA COLLECTION i
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables (Te, Th, S/G pressure and level shall ,
! be onloop 1): l a. Neutron flux (Rx power) : L l b. RCS average temperature l 1
- c. Pressurizerpressure l
- d. Pressurizerlevel
, e. Pressurizer steam temperature . l l f. Steam flow <
- g. Feed flow l
- h. Hot leg temperature
- i. Coldleg temperature
- j. S/G pressure
- k. S/Glevel l V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant me' - the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
l l
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Initiate a 10% load swing from 98% to = 88%.
, a. Reduce turbine load by 118 MW at 2350 MW/ Min. l l
- b. Allow plant conditions to stabilize.
i 1 O '"""'"""""'"""'""" i l 3 l l l
-' Test Number: TR-7 Revision Number /Date: 07.I1/08/93 Frequency: ANNUAL O
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXIMUM RATE POWER RAMP V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS (Cont.)
- 5. Initiate a 10Wload swing from 88% to = 98%.
- a. Increase turbine load by 118 MW at 2350 MW/ Min.
- b. Allow plant conditions to stabilize.
- 6. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA 1 NOTE
- The simulator response will be compared to baseline data
- C
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board. *
- The Review Board will determine if the simulator has the
- capability to adequately reproduce the defined transient.
The following acceptance criteria are to be used to determine successful test completion:
- 1. Pressurizer relief or safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. Steam generator relief or safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 3. Safety injection is NOT initiated, l
- 4. The reactor and turbine shall NOT trip. "-
l S. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected fmm a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature.
- 6. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic action.
O 7. Manual intervention will not be required to bring plant conditions to steady state. O 4
,J Test Number: TR-7 Revision Number /Date: 07.11M8/93 Frequency: ANNUAL i O
V BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXIMUM RATE POWER RAMP VI. ACCENANCE CRITERIA (Cont.)
- 8. Plant variabl6s (Tave, Pzr Pressure, Feed Flow, Steam Flow, Steam Generator Level, Pzr level) will not incur sustained or diverging oscillations.
- 9. Nuclear power overshoot (undershoot) will be less than 3% for turbine load increases '
(decreases). VII. LIST OF FIGURES (downpower and uppower transient) l
- 1. Rx Power
- 2. ' RCS Average Temperature
- 3. Pressurizer Pressure I 4. Pressurizerlevel-l
- 5. Pressurizer Steam Temperature
- 6. Steam Flow - Loop 1
! 7. Feed Flow - Loop 1
- 8. Hot leg Temperature - Loop 1
- 9. Cold leg Temperature - Loop 1 l
- 10. S/G Pressure - Loop 1
- 11. S/G Level- Loop 1 i ...........**.......................................................
- NOTE *
, Total steam flow and total feed flow were not available from l . Braidwood Unit One data. Loop 1 steam flow and feed flow
- were substituted to aid in data comparison.
lO 5 i
q n r~s .
.-.NI U '
01/11/96 10;16:21 DOWNPOWER 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS
" I I I I
~
l l 1 1 I I I I I I I I 8 _ 6 _ 4 _ 2 _ I I I I I I I I I I I I I l l l 0 5 10 15 20 TIME YCN0049 ( 75.0 , 125. ) 21090 PWR RNG CH 41 (QUAD 4) TOT
I * \ l l # !/ \ t \v> l i O tn O
~ ,
i O Q O
~
O i ;, ,
- _ I e
m c) f-N - I N ---. t--
- Co C
WW J N tt) CD H
- < CE
- HD Co
~~~ CL to OW O Ct OO
- OO -
N N w - -
~ Q O O O v -
gn _ Q - . . g OO O - ON O O@ y - Co - - . O - C - o W + + m tr) Z OO 2 M H N g H O@ vv Z - Cr O w H ! 3 Co - O M CL > - - 5 O a- - c - m t l t l " . i l ' l 0@ i CO h@ + o >+ g <O H f~= XO CC % Go n) t
DOWNPOM:R 01/11/96 10;27:59 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1C 1 l I I I l i I I I I I l l I l b 3 _ 4 6 _
~
g O 4 _ q _ 2 _ _ I I l' I I I l- 1 I I I I l' I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME h YCF0405 ( .200E+04 . 400E+04) 06060 S/G.IA STEAM F FT-512 O YCF0403 ( .200E+04 . 400E+04) . 06040 SG 1 A FW F FT-510
DOWNPOWER 01/11/96 10.35.03 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS if I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 6 6 _ N m O N ~ O 2 _ _ i I I I I I ! I I I I I I I I i 0 5 10 15 20 T1NE b YCP0400 ( 600. , 100E+04) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 0 ycLO400 ( 55.0 . 85.0 ) 06350 S/G 1A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51
O O - O - DOWNPOWER 01/11/96 10.31.31 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r l l l 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I h _x -
~
D
~
~
4 _
~
O F 2 ___ 0
. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME b YCT0419 ( 530. . 630. ) 06830 RC LOOP 1A WR HOT LEG T O YCT0406 ( 530. 630. ) 06825 RC LOOP 1A WR COLD LEG T
DOWNPOWER 01/11/96 10.24;18 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I q W o --
~
o 6 _ -
~ ~
V - C 2 _ _ 1 I I I I I I I ! l I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCP0480 ( .210E+04, .240E+04) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455 YCLO480 ( 20.0 , 70.0 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459 0 )
' TDI 70043
\. - Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW' TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: T2-7 hom oo w4/ DATE: 1,l(1/% ,
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices)
- a. Actual plant transient data EVENT: 8w CU NR.36
- b. Analytical or design data DATA:
( c. . Transient data from similar plant PLANT: b4 / vo# f. Panel of experts (best estimate) COMMENTS: ()N/,%3 Oh d4 as sim ,'/a
,o/m f oall
, 3 A ee.
Euso id&%G fodates Cycle l
%e, Q R,. /%C /tul, 4 // rn .
t lO l 2. Data Comparison Sununary VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION O I
$W kYM fu- (ks f P8L Luc 1 l'
54em nJ Fee) now Tw v l G V " I iO 1 l
, TDI 70043 i Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W '
VARIABLE COMMENTS t RESOLUTION
%n Qtess Yed Acuo Lil< ,
S /01 Leved N/ k ' i f l
- 3. Comparison Results Simulator ca abili to reproduce the defined transient: (ciale one)
O a. ACCEPTABLE i I
- b. UNACCEPTABLE
- 4. i Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented) lN WY S$NN JXL1 A i i
COMMENTS: final 2 l 1
BwSU NR-36
""i ' i" AUTHORIZED FOR TESTING 1,0 DATA SHEETS TO BE USED WITH THE APPROPRIATE SECUFNCE DOCUMENT h11.1 10% I4AD DECREASE FROM SPECIFIED POWER (TABLE 1)
(Expected values are indicated in 13.0, Appendix C) a6 d*"
-Hh-i- -Hb4- - W 4- -W 4-INITIAL DURING TRANSIENT FINAL PLANT PARAMETER EPN CONDITION MINIMUM MAXIMUM' CCNDITION Rant Operating Level (MWe-Gross)
~
IJR-MP003 //fo XXX XXX /000 power - Nuclear (%) INR-45 98 r%% 6f 87 87 Hvo (Auctioneered High) (*F) 1TR-412 564 39C 3 E'/ 79/ fave - IAop A (*F) Recorder 2 Pen 1 IF3.2 .Kro. l Arv.I 00.8 4' fare - Loop B ('F) Recorder 2 Pen 2 51n. L S30,7 s ty3 590.1 fave - LooD C (*F) Recorder 2 Pen 3 Cao 370.1 sr4.3 sFo.t fave - Loop D ('F) Recorder 2 Pen 4 572.7 571.7 534 5 71.7 , fref ('F) 1TR-412 T4 'i XXX XXX r9/ l 5 ELTA T - Loop A (%) 1TR-411 9 F3 M W he6 a8 l 6 PAT Satpoint - Loop A (%) 1TR-411 /67 XXX 'N /0 / I drat Setpoint - Loop A (%) 1TR-411 JV XXX XXX /2i pressurizer Pressure (psic) IPR-455 E(3f ZZo f 2Mr 2t3r g pressurizer Level (%) 1LR-459 & '/ Y CI .ST ( I vl Steam Header Pressure (psic) Recorder 4 Pen 2 156 170 /OtG 970 l
/ Steam Flow - Loop A (106 LB/HR) 1FR-510 if XXX XXX 3.E (106 LB/HR) 1FR-520 3. (, XXX XXX .N%4 3 L 34am Flow - Loop C 4 ".Wem Flow - Loop B Steam Flow - Loop D (106 LB/HR)
(106 LB/HR) 1FR-530 1FR-540
'3.6 3.5 Y XXX XXX XXX XXX 3.L
- 3. t._
I 5 team Generator Level-Loop A (%) 1FR-510 &D6 H AO 4 (, 6'/ Steam Generator Level-toop B (%) 1FR-520 GT 6Z 67 6 Steam Generator Level-Loop C (%) 1FR-530 Kr 40 66 6 5-~' Steam Generator Level-toop D (%) 1FR-540 45' 41 ,11.9 7 67 C 5' Feedwater Temperature-Loop A (*F) TO418K ftA e 3* 4/?M /, XXX XXX 404.O Feedwater Temperature-Loop B ('F) TO434W f*L 4/R 9 XXX XXX 4/ 2f' 3 Feedwater Temperature-Loop C ('F) TO454# n/svirl 6/3 V. 3 XXX XXX 4/2 r f Feedwater Temperature-Loop D (*F) TO474r 4/J'/.2 XXX XXX 4/2 r 5-Feedwater Flow - Loop A (106 LB/HR) 1FR-510 3,6 XXX XXX 3. Z C' Feedwater Flow - Loop B (106 LB/HR) 1FR-520 3.6 XXX XXX w aM 3 t Feedwater Flow - Looo C (106 LB/}Ut) 1FR-530 L7 XXX XXX 3. T l Feedwater Flow - Loop D (106 LB/HR) 1FR-540 3./T' XXX XXX 7. 2 Feed Pump Disch. Hdr. Pres. (psic) Recorder 5 Pen 6 s ea s- < /.ro e a o r- u ct Feed Pump B Speed (RPM) Recorder 5 Pen 5 s250 d(9 70 5370 4470 Control Rod Pos. - Bank C (Steps) UOO51 2.2P XXX XXX 2.2.F Control Rod Pos. - Bank D (Steps) U0052 2o3 XXX XXX / 70 g Boron Concentration (PPM) Log Book (, SD XXX XXX (To 4 MCT, Hi Ax /%4A (%) pat.anaan i PSN 4 9 f 5" TMr f:f. 0 ,P-T.O b . i .1, . i -- --- ,------ I s.ve - I22;S C E2 ' I;Td; 22 2;I;b I;U;i-i 1;;I Cib
~
6 a_ h Ta 5 m ie, ,. c-
/
^i f V 44 0055M(081286)/0591A _
~ )/ "(_
T 1 O 4 T 0 6 2 ) 2 > _ __~ 4 _ _ ~ _ 3 I D 1 I A U I Q 6 I ( 9
/ I 1
0 I 4 1
/ H C
I 1 I 0 5 _ 1 G N R . I R I W P I . I _ 0 I s I 9 0 1
\ 2
_ I
~V
( I 0 1
)
~ .
I _ I . 5 _ S 2 _ D I I 1 N . 7 O , C I I E __ S I I 0 E 0 _ 0 M .
. 5 5
_ I 0 T 7 3 I ( I - = _ N I O , _ _ I I R S I _ E I W V l O I I 9 P D 4 P U 1 r _ _ _ _ _ __ O 0 0 1 8 6 4 2 N C
'1 f'b
a - 4 8 1 4 l r i '
-g I L
l 1 i V N o a I l i l
, ~
===
c) H-g - i o - 2 l
~ H
) ,
N - M !
~
~
{' o g _ ww
.J N Lf) CD H e < %
& D C/)
_ CL U) O w O% i
- J Q- l oo o to f ~
N N t n n ( _ o 0) O O O ~ i z oo O _ oN O ~ CD to W g _ - -
~
o o _ 1
. l i
o W -
- I e to I oo ;
H N N !
- H to W ll -
l vv z - i O - H i
% M -
l W g - - t O H _ t CL Q o - l t' o - i l ' l
- i I , l ' Om e
e Om o > +
- g a < a
- r j
X O
% b n []O V
l l 1 l
.' I 4 UPP0hER 01/10/96 13:33;10 - 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I i 1 8 _ _._ U U _ 6 _ 4 _ 2 _ _ 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME C YCLO480 ( 20.0 , 70.0 ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459 C) YCP0480 ( .215E+04, . 2 40 E+0 4) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455 9
U
-) V
~~s (U-)
UPPOhER 01/10/96 13.36:43 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I i l l I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __ y _ m R 6 _._ O _ 4 __ 2 __ I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME H YCF0405 ( .200E+04, . 400E+04) 06060 S/G 1A STEAM F FT-512 O YCF0403 ( .200E+04, . 400 E+04) 06040 SG 1 A FW F FT-510
. . _ _ - - _ - - . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ . _ . _ - _ _ . _ _ - _ . _ . - _ . _ _ - _ - - _ - _ _ . - _ _ _ _ _ _ . - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ - - - - . _ _ _ -_ s
(. .. ,~ ,. , O N.) N/] UPPOWER 01/10/96 13.40:20 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __ _
] _
6 __ _ 4 ___ _ 2 __ l I i I i l i i i i I i i i i I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME D YCT0419 ( 530. , 630. ) 06830 RC LOOP 1A WR HOT LEG T Q YCT0406 ( 530. , 630. ) 06825 RC LOOP 1A WR COLD LEG T
( ,r % r .
%J '\J 5,,/ _
UPPohER 01/10/96 13.45:51 1( 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS l i I I I I I I I I I I I I I i D8 _
- {
h 6 _ w 4 O~ -
- O 2__.
1 I I I I I I I I I i ! I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME YCP0400 ( 600. . 100E+04) 06590 S/G 1A STMLINE PRESS PT-5 0 YCLO400 ( 55.0 , 85.0 ) 06350 S/G 1A NAR RNG LEVEL LT-51
. . - _ ._=.. - . -. - ...-= - .-. .. _ ~. - .-.- . -. - ... . - - . - ~ _-
. TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 l.
ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW-TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: IE-7 t/f0du/<./ DATE: .[/to/5
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices)
- a. Actual plant transient data i b.
EVENT: 5caso Net T 6 Analytical or design data DATA:
@ Transient data from similar plant PLANT: En//mu) vo/A /
1
- d. Panel of experts (best estimate)
COMMENTS: U Y ll& eb % h klc. M Slm //w ,s/w/ /4 shee. Euso FJK-76 con Lu h s C,vele_ 1 '72rve;'TT,,h , kK /wef O $& Arcs.
- O
- 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS
- RESOLUTION 9e PewJ hlen Areak. A
%e. \ r
\ PEL %a l PEA leusl fu. Pau s4,_ cz, w fee) R.w Te- 1 N l 71 Y !O I
(.- i TDI 700-03
. Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION 5% Piess No* ,4-cegsk We
% L eved b b l
l l I I 3 Comparison Results l Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (cin:le one)
- a. CEPTAB
- b. UNACCEPTABLE I 4. Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented) 209 A'RL2' .
- ) COMMENTS: l l l 1 O <1 2 y
AUTHORIZED FOR TESTING 7-2 -7 ,',"8 ?f; it.0 DATA 5HEET5 TO BE USED WITH THE ~ APPROPRIATE SEQUNCE DOCUMBT j . 11.1 10% LOAD INCREASE FROM SPECIFIED POWER (TABLE 2) y _ (Espected values are indicated in 13.0, Appendiz C) u.1 -- - -d.-,- INITIAL DURING TRANSIENT FINAL y PLANT PARAMETER EPN CCMDITION MINI)RRE MAXI)RJM CCNDITION
' { ant Operating I.evel (198e-Gross) 1JR-MP003 /aen XXX XXX / / 527 gr - Nuclear (%) 1NR-45 T7 87 YFS~ 9E 2_
gy (Auctioneered Mich) (*F) 1TR-412 SPD S'7P TP3 .5-P3 ffave taco A * (*F) Recorder 2 Pen 1570.0 .67FA C F2.7 522M gTve - Looo 3 (*F) . Recorder 2 Pen 2 stao C77. F S F2. i mn {sve - Loon C ('F) Recorder 2 Pen 3 EM7 57f.f 532.7 f f2.7 gT,e - teos D (*F) Recorder 2 Pen 4 s n.& 5 7F.5 m .s st2.s s'7ef ('F) 1TR-412 #T/ XXX XXX CJ%/ gg.TA T - Loo. A (%> 1TR-411 yo yo /co 17 FAT Setpoint - Loop A (%) 1TR-411 /66 XXX XXX /d g 2 jfAT Setpoint - Imop A (%) 1TR-411 /-Zf XXX XXX . /2 f Fressuriser Pressure (osie) 1PR-455 22So 2.L"30 22VD 22.16 fressuriser Level (%) ILR-459 S"2. d/ 9 $"7 M
' heas Header Pressure (osis) Recorder 4 Pen 2 %3' 981. 956 156 Reas Flow - Imoo A (10# L8/10t) 1FR-510 9. 2. XXX XXX 3. 6 haas Flow - Loco B (100 L8/HR) 1FR-520 .G.A__ XXX XXX 3.4, AsasFlow-LoooC (106 LS/HR) 1FR-530 .P. 2E XXX XXX 3.6.F Mtaas Flow - Looo D (104 LB/HR) 1FR-540 3.1r XXX XXX 3. d r
, JAs Generator Level-Looo A (%) 1FR-510 W d"7 67 c 4/ { .iids Generator Level-Loos B (%) 1FR-520 4F L/ 4P & f~ steam Generator Level-Looo C (%) 1FR-530 6f /. 2-- C. f Gr Steas Generator Level-Loop D (%) 1FR-540 6MF 6 2. f. 7 6 4/. T'- Feedwater Temperaturo-Loco A (*F) T0418K T'CA # 5*4/11 0 XXX XXX 4/34. / Feeduster Tenoerature-Loco B (*F) T0438r t hA , ,4/J C 3 XXX XXX </33.V Feedwater Temperature-Loco C (*F) T0458A is/e9/8'l 44ff XXX XXX </7V o Feedwater Temperature-Looo D (*F) T04782 V2 f.C XXX XXX 4/'iP3. ro feeduster Flow - toon A (10# LS/HR) 1FR-510 3. 3 XXX XXX J. f= .F Feeduster Flow - Looo 3 (100 LS/HR) 1FR-520 .7. "2,. XXX XXX 3_ (e
- Feedwater Flow - I4oo C (100 LB/HR) IFR-530 ' iip 2 XXX XXX 3.7 Feeduster Flow - Loco D (100 L3/HR) 1FR-540 J.a2 XXX XXX 3. <%
Feed Puno Disch. Hdr. Pres. (osia) Recorder 5 Pen 6 " ro mo "#>- as-A Feed Puno S Speed (RPN) Recorder 5 Pen 5 Fra %e ran (No control Rod Pos. - Bank C (Stoos) U0051 22P XXX XXX 22P Control Rod Pos. - Bank D (Stoos) U0052 /7C XXX XXX 133 Boron Concentration (PPM) Emo Book (e J Z) XXX XXX /,3- O [out. Si As M N 88 d8en s esW 4 P.r. e Pd". 0 920 9 f. 5- l a IId':'9. 'fd 4 w D i; .:1? M1I'-iC"m,'l d 0;I'_ 1 1...'; .____l.0, .'011 i. , 1- $ N
";_. _ . . . . e .
'O#
D F //,g.8 7 _ M ' n /7A /td g 4.
%5N(081286)/0591A i
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE C VER SHEET Test Number: Tk'Y Date Performed Ifl0/96 Test
Description:
MWX $l7c. b OCo4 ro/E [oSJ o[ OMf Yc OowAl test. Discrepancies Corrected (initials) Step # Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date 08k O i l Test Results f'
/ 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily '
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete 8 [ I /~ C Date I //o/96 o SFCC Acceptance
,lIN final Date .,#
1
Test Number: TR-8 Revision Number /Date: 06.1IM883 Frequency: ANNUAL l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXMIUM SIZE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM RUPTURE COMBINED WITH A LOSS OF ALL OFFSITE POWER I. OBJECTIVES
'Ibe purpose of this~ procedure is to:
- 1. Test the simulator response to a Maxmium Size Reactor Coolant System Rupture Combined I with a Loss of All Offsite Power as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985.
I
- 2. Ensure that the simulator's Diesel Generators function properly to power the ESF loads on a SI I concurrent with a loss of offsite power.
{ i II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program.
III. INITIAL CONDITIONS
- 1. The plant is operating at normal steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits. l
- 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value.
- 3. The boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank '
D at the proper position. m 1
- Test Number
- 'IR-8 RevisionNumber/Date: 06.11M8B3 Frequency: ANNUAL O
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXMIUM SIZE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM RUPTURE COMBINED WITH A LOSS OF ALL OFFSITE POWER IV. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables :
- a. Pmssurizer pressure
- b. NR Pressurizer pressure l
- c. Pressurizerlevel I
- d. Containment pressum
- e. Containment temperature V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
l
- 3. Simultaneously run a DBA LOCA concurrent with a loss of offsite power.
- 4. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
- 5. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
9 4 O 2
~ ' Test Number: TR-8 Revision Number /Date: 06. I1A)8193 Frequency: ANNUAL O
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXMIUM SIZE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM RUPTURE COMBINED WITH A LOSS OF ALL OFFSITE POWER VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA i
- NOTE
- ne simulator response will be compared to baseline datn *
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- ne Review Board will determine if the simulator has the capability to adequately reproduce the defined transient.
De following acceptance criteria are to be used to detennine successful test completion:
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. Steam generator safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 3. Safety injection is initiated.
- 4. Both diesel generators start and load their respective ESF bus.
- 5. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature.
- 6. The simulator shall not fail to cause an alann or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic action.
s , O 3
Test Number: 1R-8 Revision Number /Date: 06.11/08/93 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST t MAXMIUM SIZE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM RUPTURE COMBINED WITH A LOSS OF ALL OFFSITE POWER VII. LIST OF FIGURES
- 1. Pressurizerpressure
- 2. NR Pressurizer pressure
- 3. Pressurizerlevel ,
l
- 4. Containment pressure l I
! 5. Containment temperature i lO l i i r i i 5 iO ( 4 l l
(m, () w.) {'g DBA LOCA W/ LOSS OF OFFSITE POWER 01/10/96 14:16:54 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I i I I I I i l I I I I I 8 __ 6 __ 4 2 _. , l i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME YCLO480 ( .000 , 100. ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459
m f^s !
\ .- '
DBA LOCA W/ LOSS OF OFFSITE POhER 01/10/96 14:13:21 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS If D - 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __ 6 b - 1 4 __ m 2 __ t f f -- f f f f ! ! ! ! ! l l l l 0 0 5 10 15 20 TIME D YCP0491 ( .000 ,
. 230E+04) 06760 RCS WIDE RNG CH IV LP 1 P Q YCP0480 ( .170E+04, . 250E+0 4) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455 9
-- z _ . . . - - - - . - - . _ _ _ - . - - _ - . _ - _ _ _ _ . _ _ - - _ - _ _ . - _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ . _ - - . - - - - . - _ _ - . - - - _ _ . _ . . _ _ _ _ . . _ . _ - - - - _ - - - - - - . _ . _ _ _ _ . - - - - . - - _ _ _ _ - -
rm f~. ,a O () : OBA LOCA W/ LOSS OF OFFSITE P0hER 01/10/96 14:20:27 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS 1f I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 _ ' 6 O 4 _. Q] - 2 _ M g_l l I I I I I I I I I I I I I i 0 5 10 15 20 TIME T 3 YCP1000 ( .000 50.0 ) 09080 CONTAINMENT PRESS PT-936 9 CHTAVGCM ( .000 , 300. ) 06180 AVE CNMT TEMPERATURE
. _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ . _ _ . . _ _ . . _ ~ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - ~' TDI 70043 Revision: 00 l
i I5 ATTACHMENT D t SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW ' TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: 'TM-lf lock w/ Loor +rst DATE: @
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choice'
- a. Actual plant transient data 1 EVENT
- b. Analytical or design data DATA:
- c. Transient data from similar plant PLANT: '
i g Panel of experts (best estimate) COMMENTS: Noo i
- O '
L
- 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION
& L Press Afe,tt.
funkgfo DJ fL f/s5t < P2K lootA' , ch Puss CtJ1m %P k LV 4 l l l LO 1
i __ , . TDI 70043 Revision: 00 i !( t - ATTACHMENT D ! 4 4 SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W . 1
- l VARIABLE COMMENTS
- RESOLUTION a
- lt 3
A l 1 A 3 Comparison Results 4 4 Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one) a. 4 !. b. UNACCEPTABLE 5
- 4. Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be docume ted tx 2tu l Oa5lBa XV4,?!L
\
v - COMMENTS: i I F !O - 2
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: TE-(o Date Performed /////96 Test
Description:
[64 f0 A tl S4uek no& w!/4 ouf Ct/ nv-pS I I o tesf Discrepancies Step # Corrected (initials) Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date on I l Test Results
- 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date Test Complete [IM Date / ////96
- C) SFCC Acceptance b Date , if 16
' 1- ra 1 i
Test Number: TR-10 RevisionNumber/Date: 07.11M)8S3 Frequency: ANNUAL >
\'
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST SLOW PRIMARY SYSTEM DEPRESSURIZATION TO SATURATED CONDITION USING PRESSURIZER RELIEF STUCK OPEN. (INHIBITED ACTUATION OF CENTRIFUGAL CHARGING PUMPS) I. OBJECTIVES The purpose of this procedure is to test the simulator response to a Slow Primary Plant Depressurization to Saturated Condition as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985. II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Prognun.
III. INITIAL CONDITIONS l
- 1. The plant is operating at normal steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits.
- - 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value.
- 3. The boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank D at the properposition.
L i 10 1
l
, Test Number: TR-10 Revision Number /Date: 07. I1A)8/93 Fmquency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST 1
SLOW PRIMARY SYSTEM DEPRESSURIZATION TO SATURATED CONDITION USING l PRESSURIZER RELIEF STUCK OPEN. (INHIBITED ACTUATION OF CENTRIFUGAL CHARGING PUMPS) IV. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables :
- a. Relief valve flow
! b. Pressurizer pressure
- c. Pressurizer steam temperature
! d. Pressurizerlevel l
- e. RCS loop flow rate (loops 1-4)
{
- f. Surgeline temperature
- g. Loop 4 hotleg temperature !
- h. Source range l 1. Rx vessellevel
- j. Core exit temperature (for subcooling determination)
- k. WR RCS pressure (for subcooling detennination)
V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Place both CV pumps in PTL.
- 4. Fail open pressurizer relief valve 455A.
I 5. Continue until stable plant conditions are established.
- 6. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
iO I 2
TR-10
" Test Number:
Revision Number /Date: 07.I1/08/93 Frequency: ANNUAL l BRAIDV/OOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST l SLOW PRIMARY SYSTEM DEPRESSURIZATION TO SATURATED CONDITION USING ' PRESSURIZER RELIEF STUCK OPEN. (INHIBITED ACI'UATION OF CENTRIFUGAL t CHARGING PUMPS) l VI. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA - l l seeeeeesseeeeesesseeeeeeeeeeesseeeeeeeee**esesses**essesseeeees**ese i , NOTE
- l ne simulator response will be compared to baseline data
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- The Review Board will determine if the simulator has the ,
capability to adequately reproduce the defined transient. I eseesessesessesseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee**es** l l The following acceptance criteria are to be used to determine successful test completion: l l
- 1. Steam generator safety valves shall NOT lift.
Safetyinjectionisinitiated. 2.
- 3. The observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature.
- 4. He simulator shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic action.
I l lO 3
. Test Number: TR-10 Revision Number /Date: 07.11/08B3 :
Frequency: ANNUAL BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST l l SLOW PRIMARY SYSTEM DEPRESSURIZATION TO SATURATED CONDITION USING l PRESSURIZER RELIEF STUCK OPEN. (INHIBITED ACTUATION OF CENTRIFUGAL CHARGING PUMPS) l l VII. LIST OF FIGURES
- 1. Relief valve flow
- 2. Pressurizer pressure
- 3. Pressurizer steam temperature
- 4. Pressurizerlevel
- 5. RCS loop flow rate (loops 1-4)
- 6. Surgeline temperature I 1
- 7. Loop 4 hotleg temperature
- 8. Source range
]
- 9. Rx vessellevel
- 10. Core exit temperature
- 11. WR RCS pressure l
D G 1 4
, I RCS DEPRESS 01/11/96 08;32:43 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 8 __ o l 6 _. 4 _. 2 _. g g i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I i g 0 5 10 15 20 TIME N THFPRZRPRT ( .000 , 75.0 ) 60100 PRZR TO PRT MIXTURE FLOW O VCPO480 ( .170E+04, . 2 50E+0 4) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455
p (V)
~'
./'s V
V RCS DEPRESS 01/11/96 09.22:10 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS 1C I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O __ _ l ' 8 _ _ 6 _ _ 4 _ __ d 2 _ _ E l l I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME b YCT0482 ( 500. , 670. ) 91255 PRESSURIZER SURGE LINE T g YCT0479 ( 500. 625. ) 07080 RC LOOP 1D WR HOT LEG T
.____._._.______.___.____.____._.____.__.__________________________________.__________________._______.____._______________J
<- (y (- ,
s) b] E)\ RCS DEPRESS 01/11/96 08.44:56 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I O I 8 - g
~~
S 4 __ W 2 _* _ 0 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l i 0 5 10 15 20 TIME D YCT0481 ( 500. , 720. ) 91250 PRESSURIZER STM T Y ( .000 100. ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459 O CLO480 ,
I ^o 0 5 8 5 0o 0 2 _ _ _ e _ - 8 0 I I 4 4 1 2 44 6_ I I - - . 9 TT
/ FF 1 I I 1 FF
/
1 I I AB 1 1 0 5 - 1 PP OO OO I I L L - CC RR I I 0 0_ . 1 9 I I 0 0 _ 6 6 - 0 0 I l 0 ) ) - 1 O S I l 05 D I i 1 0 - 1 1 N O ', C I i E - S . I l 0 0 E 0 0 5 M 0 0 5 I 0 . 4 T 5 I i ( (
=
S S N I i E O R I P S I
, < i E I D V
- I 1 I S D 0 0 C _ - _ 0 2 R 1 ^ _ _ _ _ -
=
_ $ 0 44 - f 0 0 8 6 4 2 QO I FF CC YY Oo O
m O O U RCS DEPRESS 01/11/96 09:10:33 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I l I l I I I I l l l D ~
~
O < ~ 8 _._
=
6 __ 4 _ 2 _ U I I I I I I I I I D I I I I I I I 0 5 10 15 20 TIME b YCF0440 ( .000 , 110. ) 06170 RC LOOP 1C F FT-434 g YCF0460 (-5. 00 . 105. ) 06250 RC LOOP 1D F FT-444
~n s , ~- ,-
(0 NJ 01/11/96 09.36.21 RCS DEPRESS 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS 1r I I I I I l I I I I I I I I I I 8 __. 6 _._ m 4 _ 2 __ I I I I I i I I I I i I I I I l 15 20 5 10 0 TIME
. 200 E +0 5) 01040 SR DETECTOR OUTPUT NILDTOU(1) ( .000 ,
i )/ ( 8 0 0 0 5 . 2
~ .
N h M 9 0 I 6 I 9 L
/ E _
1 I L V _ 1 EE
, / VL _
1 E 0 I L M 5 U _ 1 DN _ AE - E L I HP XX I RR _ 0 0 _ 3 4 . I 00 _ 88 _ 8 8 . ) I hv 0 1
) )
I S 0 5 1 0 D I 1 1 N O , , C I - E S I 0 0 0 0 E M 0 0
. 5 I 0 .
5 T 5 4 - I ( (
=
S S N I E O R I M # P S I U E I DN - D V AE . I I EL S D HP C _ 6 _ M ._ W 0 VV R 1 f _ _ 6 6 RR I 8 4 2 L L OG HH T T NO
~
,n ,
("S .. (J)
~ k) ^ \.J RCS DEPRESS 01/11/96 10:11:08 1 DIVISION = 45.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I U D -
O 8 __ 6 _ 4 _ 2 o l l l l l l 1 1 I I I I I I I I O 5 10 15 20 TIME bCRTTCEXIT(14) ( 500. , 630. ) 06030 INCORE TC READING ( 500. . 2 50E+0 4) 06760 RCS WIDE RNG CH IV LP 1 P Q YCP0491 .
1 TDI 7004)3
.. Revision: 00 i
ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW l I TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: TIR-lo PdA foM OA W4 Cv795DATE: Iffi[%
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choices
- a. Actual plant transient data EVENT: l h Analytical or design data DATA: Wc A P "1 (, o I
- c. Transient data from similar plant PLANT:
@ Panel of experts (best estimate)
COMMENTS: (Ac A f - 9 (, o t was use J -fo r f64 Press, ALS fress.wb l64 Twp anlv. O 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION ReUd Elve F/aW AjoAL Ace ep4//e fett bss s f'aA 14o el I f6b tem 9 k5 loo 0 Elows I-V f pea su e lwh V ' l Ti 5R leal - . -
% b levtl O 1
1 TDI 700-03 ! q . Revision: 00 ; I l ATTACHMENT D SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W i VARIABLE COMMENTS RESOLUTION flem um lud 190& Ace egh,f/e L CEtc Ted / t>> lL 9tnS ^U h \ l l \ d I 3 Comparison Results ' i Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one)
- a. ACCEPTABLE
- b. UNACCEPTABLE 4.
Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documented) I
$YN &
wa
.A-,, AJkoJ ]
COMMENTS: l0 - 2
TDI 700-03 Revision: 00 u *, l ATTACHMENT A BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TEST PROCEDURE COVER SHEET Test Number: TE- 9 Date Performed i ./ lo/96 Test
Description:
W)ew she M c flu. un u% Io l & raf fwo +esf l Discrepancies Step # Corrected (initials) Comments Step # for retest WR# and Date Non l l 0 Test Results
- 1. Test Completed Satisfactorily
- 2. After correction of the above discrepancies test results are satisfactory. Only a partial RETEST is necessary.
- 3. Test results UNSATISFACTORY. Complete RETEST after correction of above discrepancies is required.
Retest Complete Date i Test Complete d Date /[o/G6 O s " c ^"'"'*"'" $ M* "' d" 1
t [ Test Number: TR-9 i,,,' RevisionNumber/Date: 06. I1A)8/93 j Frequency: ANNUAL l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXMIUM SIZE UNISOLABLE MAIN STEAM LINE RUPTURE l I. OBJECTIVES '
'Ihe purpose of thisprocedure is to test the simulator response to a Maxmium Size Unisolable Main
- Line Rupture as required by ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985.
i . II. REFERENCES
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for 'Use in Operator Training.
- 2. Reg. Guide 1.149: Nuclear Power Plant Simulation Facilities for Use in Operator License Examinations.
- 3. TDI 700-03: Simulator Testing Program.
III. INITIAL CONDITIONS O 1. The plant is operating at nonnal steady state, full power conditions with control rod bank D j positioned to maintain the Indicated Axial Flux Difference within limits.
- 2. Boric acid of the proper concentration is available in sufficient quantity to bring the boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System to the hot shutdown value.
- 3. The boron concentration of the Reactor Coolant System is adjusted to maintain control rod bank D at the proper position.
IV. DATA COLLECTION
- 1. Setup the ZETA Plotter to graph the following variables : .
- a. Pressurizer pressure
- b. NR Pressurizer pressure
- c. Pressurizerlevel
- d. Containment pressure
- e. Containment temperature 1
.- _. . .- .._~ - . - _ _ . . . _ . . . - . _ - . - - - - - .- . .
l L i Test Number: TR-9 3 ', ' Revision Number /Date: 06.11/08B3 Frequency: ANNUAL !O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXMIUM SIZE UNISOLABLE MAIN STEAM LINE RUPTURE \ . l- V. TEST INSTRUCTIONS
- 1. Ensure the plant meets the initial conditions as specified in Section III.
- 2. Enter the data collection points from Section IV into the ZETA Plotter program.
- 3. Initiate a maxmium size unisolable steam line break inside containment.
l I i
- 4. Continue until stable plant conditions are established. '
- 5. Graph the variables listed under Section IV.
VI. ACCElrrANCE CRITERIA I
++eeeeeeeeeeeeee++esseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees t NOTE *
! The simulator response will be compared to baseline data
- by the Braidwood Simulator Transient Test Review Board.
- L Re Review Board will determine if the simulator has the '
capability to ad~==*aly reproduce the defm' ed transient. esseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee***eeeseee ne following acceptance criteria are to be used to detennine successful test completion: 1
- 1. Pressurizer safety valves shall NOT lift.
- 2. Steam generator safety valves shall NOT lift.
l 3. Safety injectionis initiated.
- 4. He observable change in the parameters correspond in direction to those expected from a best estimate for the simulated transient and do not violate the physical laws of nature.
I
- 5. The simulater shall not fail to cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would have caused an alarm or automatic action, and conversely, the simulator shall not cause an alarm or automatic action if Braidwood Unit One would not cause an alarm or automatic action.
- O 2
\
! Test Number: 1R-9 Revision Number /Date: 06.11A)8B3 Frequency: ANNUAL O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST MAXMIUM SIZE UNISOLABLE MAIN STEAM LINE RUPTURE VII. LIST OF FIGURES
- 1. Pressurizerpressure
- 2. NR Pressurizer pressure
- 3. Pressurizerlevel
- 4. Containment pressure i
- 5. Containment temperature O
I i sg-O 3
W J 8 0 6 O 1 4 O 0 2 3 9 4 _ _ _ _. T _ 1 I PE I R _ U S T _ 6 I 6 I S A 9 E R _
/ R E 0 _
1 I I P P _ M
/ T E _
1 0 I I NT E _ 5 MT _ 1 N M I N AC I I T _ NE _ OV _ I I C A _ 0 . I 8 8 I 0 1 _ 9 6 0 _ I I _ 0 ) ) 1
. ) . I I
- 0 .
S . D I I 0 _ N 5 _ O _ C I I E S I 0 I 0 E 0 0 5 M 0 I 0 E 3 T . R U I I ( ( T = P U N I I R O I E S I I N I I V L I I
' i M D 0 C S .
0 M 1 . ._ _ _ _ .. .
._ O 0 V r 1 A .
1 8 6 4 2 PT CH n '1 C hO
)
, L
~ <m *-
Nb %b x 01/10/96 14:44:06 MS LINE RUPTURE 1 DIVISION = 30.00 SECONDS If I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~
8 __
] -
6 __ 4 - 2 _ 9 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 5 10 15 20 O TIME YCLO480 ( .000 , 80.0 ) 06550 PRESSURIZER LEVEL LT-459
.o O. .
O~ .__ MS LINE. RUPTURE 01/10/96 14:32:57-l 1 DIVISION =. 30.00 SECONDS If I 1. I l- 1 I l I I I I -l i I I I D e J _ i t _C O 4 _._ _ 1 2 __ , _ l I I I I I I l' I I I i i l l I O 5 10 15 20 TIME-C YCPO491 ( .150E+04, . 240E+04) 06760 RCS WIDE RNG CH IV LP 1 P O.YCP0480 ( .170E+04, .250E+04) 06720 PRESSURIZER PRESS PT-455
TDI 70043 Revision: 00 i !' ATTACHMENT D l l SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIEW TRANSIENT TEST #/ TITLE: TR-9 ex</n ms ivf <ue- / DATE: /Io/M
- 1. Baseline data utilized for test comparison in order of preference (circle appropriate choice
- a. Actual plant transient data EVENT:
- b. Analytical or design data DATA
- c. Transient data from similar plant PLANT:
$ Jr il of experts (best estimate) l COMMENTS: doru l
l '
=
l
- 2. Data Comparison Summary VARIABLE COMMENTS
! RESOLIJfION w k 9tt s5 N6nL- Acce,,c.dk NfL Press ' I fEL Irvel C#M Pus 5 N22 Wf d Y
^
4 i 4 1
I TDI 700-03 ! Revision: 00 )
~.- >
i ATTACHMENT D
\
SIMULATOR TRANSIENT TEST REVIE'W
)
VARIABLE COMMENTS 1 RESOLUTION i i l 1
- 3. Comparison Results Simulator capability to reproduce the defined transient: (circle one)
O a. g esTA o
- b. UNACCEPTABLE i
4. Review Board Signatures (differing opinions must be documenteg) K 7/d
' O.1[hY W
#Ai" V
{ COMMENTS: i k' A i i-final 2 2 i i J _ - . . _ . , . - . _ _ , _ . _ _ _ _ . . . _ - . _
[ l PRISSUR!l!W 11 M P I E B E $ $ 9 o o o o o o
- *' g b b b b P Q O O O 48 s u l
e i I O.0 l f s l 1 i d i d
. I i !
! I i , l i c t
! i i
! I
!. l
' F000.0 I i t E::
- - pv-
, -s a l s-1 l
. m2.
.>O
-A D r.
s5 O& c-* i l w* m 4000.0 -c N x i i Ef a T 3C o
- o a n e, <
=>
{
< m '
K
; ~Js
(/) g a e i H p# c w o Ch
=
oa~ X -
.e 6
o.
- es 5 O ** O T E000.0 ip '*
m Z :e C l
- P l
- I f .
] 8000.0 h_ '
- i : i l j l l
l * ' ik i i i i I l ! i
'l ::..:. -
1 I i. 8
. ., -_..- -. . , , . . _ = . ,. _ _ , , .
- c-
,.y v
.l
. Pattle magggggg ,;p' I c=
~, ,,
l i e I, l 0.0
-- ~
i e i , 2900.0 [ E*' e.. l :.. i - OmC C gg 2' ,, i e3
! s-i p*
! 4000.0 -8 o i 1 N '
e' x < l o at %. o o 1 3: M > 2 1
- 'ee
< o 8 m l e
M i E
-a , S, I
C% M l O! O Ch C l l X C ' p-a > *c O o f 0515.0 I
- U a TT1 1 ;;*
Z f a i
- j e
. ; e 9
4 0000.0 #~ t I 1.00(+0* - s#
i-J l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR 1 ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT 1 4 APRIL,1996 LO i i
- ATTACHMENT 3 i
SIMULATOR WORK I REQUEST PROCEDURE s t i 1 i d i d 1-4 io l l i 1
-i i
l O ' 123 KMm_cerfcenifi. doc
I TDI 70042 Revision: 00 O Braidwood Station l Training Department Instruction l l SIMULATOR WORK REQUEST PROCEDURE A. Purpose l
- 1. The purpose of this procedure is to delineate the method used to track, review,
, approve, implement, and test hardware and software work on the Braidwood l Simulator. t - B. References I l i 1. INPO TQ-504: Simulator Configuration Management - Good Practices
- 2. TDI 700-01: Simulator Review Board Procedure ;
C. Instruction . .
- 1. Definitions:
- a. Comouter based tracking system - A CECO computer system used for controlling and tracking simulator maintenance.
l b. Minor Hardware Maintenance - items associated only with hardware aspects
- of the simulator. Maintenance items that do NOT require parts to be
' withdrawn from the storeroom except as outlined below. Examples of minor maintenance:
- 1) Recorders a) Repair / replacement of broken strings.
I m
TDI 700-02 Revision: 00 b) Correction of inking problems. c) Repair / replacement of broken spring clips.
- 2) Lights a) Replacement of broken light bulbs in sockets, b) Removal of stuck light bulbs from sockets.
- 3) Miscellaneous a) Cleaning of printers.
b) Cleaning of spilled ink on main control panels, etc. c) Rehanging of existing labels and name tags that have become loose or fallen off. d) Cleaning sticky and diny switches. e) Calibrating meters O 2. Procedure
- a. Work Request Initiation
- 1) A work request may be initiated by any staff member discovering a need for change or repair to simulator equipment or software.
Trainees should be encouraged to bring potential simulator problems to the attention of their instructor through the use of verbal and written feedback. I
- 2) The originator shall write the following information on the Simulator Work Request (Attachment A):
a) Equipment Name. b) EID (Equipment Identification) Number. This number can be obtained from the EID printout located at the instructor station. c) Location. The location can also be obtained from the EID printout. It is normally the panel on which the device in question G is located. 2 O
TDI 700-02 Revision: 00 6 i d) Work Requested / Problem. Provide a full description of the requested work or problem encountered. Be as specific as { possible. Include LOAD #, IC #, and % PWR in the spaces I provided. Sign and date in the space provided, i e) Route the work request to the Simulator Fidelity / Certification Coordinator (SFCC).
- 3) The SFCC shall perfonn the following on both the WR and in the t computer based tracking system: I a) Review the work request for applicability, clarity, accuracy, and ;
legibility. If the work request is cancelled, mark it as such and return it to the originator along with the reason for its ' cancellation. Since no work request number has been assigned, the work request may be disposed of. b) Enter the work request into the tracking system and obtain the assigned work request number and write the assigned number in the space provided. c) Enter the work request description. ' O d) Enter the appropriate lead work group in the Dept. block. If more than one work group is needed then an additional work group may be designated in the SUPP DEPT block. t L e) Assign a SME (Subject Matter Expert) by entering his/her initials ! in the SME block. SME review may not be required for every work request. If the SME review is not required, mark the SME Approved /Date block N/A and continue with this procedure at section C.2.b.2). f) Complete the Test Required block by .:ircling Y or N to indicate whether testing will be required upon completion of the maintenance. i l g) If testing is required complete the Testing By block by circling the appropriate department to conduct the testing. h) Route the work request to the assigned SME. O 3 m
TDI 70042 Revision: 00 i
- b. Work Request Approval
- 1) The SME shall perform the following:
a) Review the work request. b) Provide additional information to the description of the problem. Attach Simulator Work Request - Sheet 2 (Attachment B) as necessary, c) Attach a hard copy of drawings and data required to support the - work requested. < d) If so indicated, write a test procedure using Attachment C that will determine if the maintenance has been successfully completed. e) Sign and date the work request in the SME Approved /Date block. f) Route the work request to the SFCC.
- 2) The SFCC shall perform the following:
O a) Assign a Priority to the work request using Attachment E as a I guide. 1)) Assignment of a priority above B22 requires the notification ; of the appropriate simulator maintenance group. This l notification is required so that, if necessary, additional { resources can be assigned to accomplish high priority items ' in a timely manner. Notification can be made via telephone. 2)) IAwer priority items (below B23) may have their priority raised based on the length of time since the work request was initiated. The priority of an item may be increased in single st:p increments for every 30 days a work request remains open. 3)) In no case will a priority of a work request be elevated past B23 solely based on the length of time a work request has remained open. O a 4
~
. _ ~ . . . . _ _ - - _ _ - . . . - - . - . - -- - _ - -
- TDI 700-02 Revision: 00 4
$f 4)) Priority increases sliould be made as a joint decision by the i SFCC and appropriate personnel from the Simulator Support 4 Group. The option to raise the priority of a work request ] should be used pmdently. b b) Assign an Availability to the work request. [ c) Complete the ANSI Certification block by circling Y or N to { indicate if the work request is a simulator certification item. This l field is intended to be used to identify those items directly related s to the simulator certification report, yearly update to the . ; j_ certification report and certification testing. d) Complete the Modification block by circling Y or N to indicate if the work request is associated with a modification at Braidwood Station. If the work request is associated with a modification, ; enter the modification number in the MOD # block, and enter the l Mod Implementation Date in the space provided. The modification implementation date is the date Braidwood Station declared the modification operational. If the work request is not I associated with a modification, enter N/A in the MOD # block and Mod. Implementation Date field. O e) Review the work request to determine if it will require /cause the l simulator design database to change. Indicate if the design database will be affected by circling Y or N in the Database I Change block. f) If the simulator design database is affected, assign an SRB # per Simulator Review Board Procedure (TDI 70041) and enter that number in the SRB # block. - I g) If the simulator design database is not affected enter N/A in the SRB Approved /Date block. h) There may be times when the training staff identifies a simulator function (such as a malfunction or an initial condition) which no longer appears to be responding properly. At this tinw, in addition to the issuing of a work request to repair the problem, the SFCC , shall add the simulator functica in question to the Simulator l NOT AUTHORIZED FOR USE letter. When the simulator function has been repaired, tested and determined to be valid , again, the SFCC shall clear the itera from the letter. O 9 5
. - . . _ yr . . _ . - . . - ... . _ . - . _ _ _ . . .
TDI 700-02 Revision: 00 i l 4 i) Review the work request, sign and date the SFCC Approved /Date l block. ' j) If the work request involves a design database change, submit it , to the SRB (Simulator Review Board) for approval per Simulator Review Board Procedure (TDI 700-01), k) If the work request does not involve a design database change, route the work request to the section clerk.
- 1) The section clerk shall copy the work request and route the copies as follows:
1)) Original copy of the work request - filed in the work request master file / work request log. - 2)) One copy of the work request - routed to the appropriate , work group leader along with supporting documentation. ; i 3)) One copy of the work request - route to the SFCC. i 4)) One copy of the work request - route to the Training Supervisor.
- c. Conduct of Simulator Maintenance
- 1) The actual performance of simulator mair' we shall be controlled and performed in accordance with Conduu of Maintenance (SIMULATOR SUPPORT GUIDELINE - 1).
- d. Work Request Testing - The SFCC shall perform the following:
9
- 1) If testing is not required, verify that the required work has been l completed and continue with this procedure at section C.2.e.
- 2) Ensure that the necessary testing is performed to verify that the simulator maintenance has been completed satisfactory.
- 3) Indicate the results of the testing by checking the appropriate block in the Pass / Fail block.
4
- 4) Write in any pertinent co.nments in the Remarks block and sign and date the Remarks block in the space provided.
O . 6 i
-_. .. _ . . O. .
TDI 700M Revision: 00
- 5) If the testing passed then proceed as follows:
a) If the work request has Y circled in the Database Change block verify that the design database has been updated by reviewing the Simulator Database Update Checklist (CONDUCT OF MAINTENANCE SIMULATOR SUPPORT GUIDELINE - 1). Indicate the status of the database change by circling Y or N in the Conf. Database Updated block and complete the VERIFIED BY: SFCC Init & Date block, b) If the work request has N circled in the Database Change block write N/A in the VERIFIED BY: SFCC Init & Date block.
- 6) If the testing fails then proceed as follows: 4 l
a) Document the problems /discrepanciw found in the Remarks block. l l I b) Report the work request as having failed testing. c) Route the work request package to the appropriate work group for rework / discrepancy correction. O e. Work Request Completion !
- 1) The SFCC shall perform the following:
a) Verify that the work request is completed. b) Obtain the original copy of the work request, sign and date the SFCC ACCEPTANCE /DATE block. c) Route the completed work request package to the Data Processing clerk.
- 2) The Data Processing clerk shall complete the WR closcout.
l 3) The Data Processing clerk shall route the work request package to the
- section clerk.
l; 4) The section clerk shall file the completed work request package in General File #SIM-BW-6.
- f. Work Request Cancellation (Design database related work requests) i i
7
- ~
m
J~ l i TDI 700-02 i Revision: 00
. \
- 1) Design database related work requests can only be cancelled by the i Simulator Review Board in accordance with the Simulator Review l Board Procedure (TDI 700-01). 1
- 2) The Simulator Review Board Chairman shall perform the following:
a) Mark the work request cancelled in the Work Performed block { along with the reason for cancellation. b) Circle CANCELLED in the SRB APPROVED / CANCELLED block. c) Sign and date the SRB Approved /Date block. d) Route the work request to the SFCC for cancellation.
- 3) The SFCC shall perform the following:
a) Report the work request as cancelled using the computer based l system.
,- b) Forward one copy of the cancelled work request to the originator. I c) Route the work request to the section clerk for filing in General
)
File # SIM-BW-6. :
- g. Maintenance That Must be Performed Immediately - Outside of Normal Working Hours
- 1) This method of routing work requests is for special cases and should only be used in situations where a simulator failure (usually hardware orientated) inhibits the effective use of the simulator. Work requests requiring Simulator Review Board approval shall not be accomplished until SRB approval has been granted.
- 2) The work request routing and data entry will follow the normal procedute except that the SFCC approval along with computer data entry shall take place during the next regular work day.
- 3) If the work request has been completed prior to the final approval, the work request should be annotated to show that the work has been accomplished, and that the work request is in routing for approval and 4
data entry only. O . v l N 4 s , - ..
l TDI 700-02 l Revision: 00
- h. Change in Scope - during the performance of maintenance or testing j situations will arise where the scope of the requested work may change or '
expand beyond the area originally requested and approved. Should a situation arise where there is a change in scope, a new work request should be l initiated in accordance with section C.2.a. of this procedure to cover the .
' increased / changed scope. I
- i. Minor Hardware Maintenance l
- 1) Upon identification of a minor hardware problem the originator shall .
l fill out the following sections of the Minor Hardware Maintenance Log 1 l' (Attachment D) - Originator's Section: l l a) Originator's Name 1 b) Date c) EID # of item needing maintenance. This number can be obtained t from the EID printout located at the instructor station. If the EPN l # is available on the equipment name tag it may be used in place of the EID #. d) Panel #. j e) Problem - provide a description of the problem in sufficient detail ! for the HW Technician to correct the problem. '
- 2) The SFCC shall perform the following:
a) Review the Minor Hardware Maintenance Iag (Attachment D) periodically to ensure needed maintenance is being accomplished. b) Make arrangements to have a HW Technician complete needed ! maintenance. , c) If a Minor Hardware Maintenance IAg (Attaciunent D) item requires work not considered routine or minor, place an X over [ the Problem block and write the Simulator Work Request number assigned to the problem in the Work Performed block. O 9 w
TDI 700-02 i Revision: 00 i 1
- 3) Hardware Technician i
a) Upon receiving a work assignment from the Minor Hardware I Maintenance Log (Attachment D), the HW Technician shall: 1)) Review the problem description and location. 2)) Obtain authorization to correct the problem. 1 3)) Perform the appropriate repairs / maintenance requested. l J
= i 4)) Complete the following sections of the Minor Hardware i Maintenance log.(Attachment D) - HW Technician Section:
)
- HW Technician's Name
- Work Performed - provides a brief description of the work performed.
l b) The HW Technician should request, when necessary, that the repaired item be functionally tested. ; c) If the HW Technician determines that the maintenance required is k beyond the scope allowed by the section, he/she shall notify the SFCC to determine of a Simulator Work Request should be written. Approved By 2- -
> Date: 4 '993 Training SupervSor !
O (mal 10 i 9.
1 TDI 700-02 Revision: 00 I i i \ ATTACHMENT A No. l UI l l l l l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR WORK REQUEST Ecuinment Name EID
'l I IIIIIIIl l l l l l l l l Location l WORK REQUESTED / PROBLEM LOAD # lIC# l%PWR l Requested By/Date l JQ SME Anoroved/Date TEST REQ BY PR ORIT" AVAIL l -l l l Y N C'PS HW SW l l l l l l ANSI CERT MOD MOD # MOD IMPL Date FUPP DEPT DATABASE SRB #
Y. N Y Nl ll l l l CHANGE l l YN SRB Approved /Date SRB SFCC Approved /Date Assigned To Group / Area l- APPROVED / l CANCELLED l l l l l l l l l l WORK PERFORMED Work Como Date Parts / Tools Est Mrs Act Mrs Maint Code Maint Cause PM CM Conf Database Updated Y N I l jl ll l l l l l l l Y N Y N VERIFIED BY:l l SFCC Init & Date i TEST #1 REMARKS PASS FAIL S gnature/Date l TEST #2 I REMARKS PASS FAIL Signature /Date l SFCC ACCEPTANCE /DATE l l final 1 c...
TDI 700-02 Revision: 00 l' ATTACHMENT B l BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR WORK REQUEST SHEET 2
. Page _ of -
No.l Ul l l l l l WORK REQUESTED / PROBLEM (CONT) l l [ . WORK PERFORMED (CONT) Pans / Tools (CONT) I TEST # REMARKS PASS] FAIL Signature /Date l TEST # REMARKS PASS ! FAIL Signature /Date l O
~
l M
A_4hM.J JA4_,.Wm.Eif W~*aa :E4.4WM-+-n mNmm.isMV..mnm emmai- -. - - - - aw__ TDI 700-02 Revision: 00 ATTACHMENT C WORK REQUEST TEST PROCEDURE WR No. U
$3fiE Bi1L!LIS
~1.
SAT /UNSAT l 2. SAT /UNSAT
- ' 3. SAT /UNSAT l-l
- 4. SAT /UNSAT References i-
- i. ;
i = !O l l 3
, final I
i 2 j.__.... ., ->
l l l TDI 700-02 l Revision: 00 l ? . ^
\
l ATTACHMENT D ' MINOR HARDWARE MAINTENANCE LOG ORIGINATOR HW TECHNICIAN NAME: DATE: NAME: EID#: PANEL: WORK PERFORMED: PROBLEM: ORIGINATOR HW TECHNICIAN NAME: DATE: NAME: EID#: PANEL: WORK PERFORMED: PROBLEM: 1 O ORIGINATOR HW TECHNICIAN NAME: DATE: NAME: EID#: PANEL: WORK PERFORMED: PROBLEM: ORIGINATOR HW TECHNICIAN NAME: DATE: NAME: EID#: PANEL: WORK PERFORMED: PROBLEM: l-f 'O final I
I i; TDI 700-02 I Revision: 00 f ATTACHMENT E , SIMULATOR WORK REQUEST PRIORITY CODES 3 A00 - SIMULATOR IS SHUTDOWN AND PROHIBITS TRAINING IN PROGRESS.
- TRAINING CANNOT CONTINUE AND SIMULATOR MUST BE MADE AVAILABLE FOR MAINTENANCE.
" 1
- SAFETY HAZARD.
- B10 -
SIMULATOR OR EQUIPMENT PROBLEM PROHIBITS MEETING j TRAINING OBJECTIVES SCHEDULED IN THE NEXT 8 HOURS. ; ! B20 - SIMULATOR OR- EQUIPMENT PROBLEM PROHIBITS MEETING J , TRAINING OBJECTIVES SCHEDULED IN THE NEXT 24 HOURS. 4 B21
- SIMULATOR OR EQUIPMENT PROBLEM PROHIBITS MEETING TRAINING OBJECTIVES SCHEDULED IN THE NEXT 7 DAYS. '
B22 - SIMULATOR OR EQUIPMENT PROBLEM IDENTIFIED AS A RESULT OF A l REGULATORY AUDIT (I.E.: NRC, INPO, ETC.). B23 - SIMULATOR OR EQUIPMENT PROBLEM PROHIBITS MEETING l TRAINING OBJECTIVES SCHEDULED IN THE NEXT 30 DAYS. B30
- SIMULATOR OR EQUIPMENT PROBLEM IDENTIFIED AS A RESULT OF A OR RELATED TO AN ANS 3.5 PERFORMANCE TEST ITEM, SIMULATOR FIDELITY, OR SIMULATOR CERTIFICATION.
B31 SIMULATOR OR EQUIPMENT PROBLEM RESULTS IN SOME DEGRADATION OF TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS. THE PROBLEM DOES NOT, HOWEVER, RENDER THE TRAINING FEATURE UNUSABLE. B32 - SIMULATOR OR EQUIPMENT PROBLEM CAUSES NO SPECIFIC DEGRADATION IN TRAINING EFFECTIVENESS. THE PROBLEM MAY BE AN IRRITATION TO TRAINEES OR INSTRUCTORS IN THE CONDUCT 01-SIMULATOR EXERCISES.THIS ITEM SHOULD BE RESOLVED TO ENSURE TECHNICAL ACCURACY. B33 - ROUTINE AND COSMETIC SIMULATOR ITEMS THAT HAVE NO IMPACT ON TRAINING. C00 - ROUTINE ITEMS NOT RELATED SPECIFICALLY TO THE SIMULATOR. Cmal I _n
, . . . . _ . . _ . . _ _ _ . . . _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ - - - ._ ~ _ _ . . . _ _ . . . _ . . . _ _ _ . . _
BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICATION REPORT APRIL,19% ATTACHMENT 4 SIMULATOR REVIEW BOARD PROCEDURE i l O c t 1 i a O K:Mim_cenVenifi. doc 124 t., ._. -- .,a.- . _ . . . _ . . _ _ . _ _ , _ . _ . . . . _ _ _ . . _ . . . . _ _ _ . . _ . . . _ . . . . , . . . _ . . _ _ . . _ . _ . . . _ _ _ . _ _ ,
I TDI 700-01 , Revision: 00 ) 1 O Braidwood Station i Training Department Instruction l SIMULATOR REVIEW BOARD A. Purpose
- 1. The pumose of this procedure is to establish a consistent process for r. viewing changes to the simulator design database and reviewing other items concerning simulator certification.
O a B. References
- 1. ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985: Nuclear Power Plant Simulators for Use in Operator Training 1
- 2. INPO TQ-504: Simulator Configuration Management System-Good Practices l l
' 3. TDI 700-02: Simulator Work Request Procedure C. Instruction
- 1. Definitions
- a. Design Database - A collection of material which documents the current performance and appearance status of the simulator hardware and software.
It is further defined as the contents of the General Files Pattern Simulator (SIM) file. Any document that is N_QI in the General Files Pattern Simulator (SIM) file is N_QI considered part of the Simulator Design Database. O I - n
TDI 700-01 Revision: 00
- 2. Procedure
( a. Scope
- 1) The Simulator Review Board functions as a management team to:
a) approve changes to the simulator design database. b) authorize and document deviations between the simulator and reference plant. c) approve Simulator Cenification Repons. -
- b. Simulator Review Board Composition
- 1) The Simulator Review Board will consist of the following members:
a) Senior operating representative (Operating Engineer or above). b) Training Supervisor, c) Licensed or cenified SRO (Training). d) Licensed SRO (Operating). d) Simulator Fidelity and Cenification Coordinator (SFCC). 1
- 2) A minimum of three members must be present to conduct a Simulator Review Board Meeting. Every effon should be made to include a senior operating representative.
- 3) Other personnel may be invited to the Simulator Review Board M'eeting to observe or serve as subject matter experts.
- c. Determination of Simulator Review Board Discussion Items
- 1) The SFCC determines which items require review by the Simulator Review Board. Required revicw items are:
a) Modifications which affect the simulator design database.
, b) Other changes which affect the simulator design database.
i i c) Simulator Cenification Report (prior to submittal to the NRC and annual updates). 2
. _ - _ 9 ..
TDI 700-01 Revision: 00 )
,c d) Other items designated by the SFCC.
1
- 2) When it has been determined that an item requires a review, the SFCC assigns a Simulator Review Board number (SRB #) on the Simulator I Review Board Approval Sheet.(Attachment A) {
i a) The SRB # will be logged as BW-YY-ZZ where: YY ' = year ; ZZ = sequential SRB # for that year I b) In addition, the following information will also be recorded on Attachment A: I 1)) Work Request number (WR #), if applicable. ! l 2)) Modification number (MOD #), if applicable. 3)) Brief description of the discussion item. ! 4)) Assign the file pattern number with the appropriate year (YR) for FILE: SIM-BW-5-YR. )
- 3) The Simulato,. Review Board Log Sheet (Attachment B) is used for -
assigning SRB numbers and tracking the status of each SRB discussion item.
- 4) The SFCC maintains the Simulator Review Board Log Book.
- d. Simulator Review Boad Meeting Preparation
- 1) The SFCC submits the package of Simulator Review Board Approval Sheets (Attachment A's) to the Simulator Review Board Members when a Simiator Review Board Meeting is warranted.
a) Tne Simulator Review Board should meet at a minimum of at least once every three months and each meeting should have no more than two hours of discussion items scheduled. b) The SFCC gathers the necessary data to discuss each item. This data should be recorded on the Simulator Review Board Approval Sheet (Attachment A). This data may include: cost, manpower (hardware and/or software), lead time for obtaining parts, simulator availability, and regulatory commitments. 3
TDI 700-01 Revision: 00 p e. Review Process l V
- 1) The Training Supervisor normally serves as the Simulator Review Board Chairman.
2) The Simulator Review Board Chairman addresses each discussion item (new business) and leads a discussion concerning each item.
- 3) The SFCC addresses all open discussion iteris (old business).
- 4) The Simulator Review Board members should consider the following prior to voting on each item:
a) training value/ impact.
, b) resource requirements.
d c) priority relative to other changes,
' d) cost / benefit.
e) regulatory commitments.
- 5) A majority of the members present must agree on the disposition of each 3RB discussion item. The appropriate members will sign Attachment A signifying agreement with the disposition. In addition, any dissenting members will sign Attachment A signifying disagreement with the disposition.
- 6) Discussion items requiring further clarification (items that were not APPROVED or DISAPPROVED) are placed on HOLD until the next Simulator Review Board Meeting.
- 7) The Simulator Review Board Chairman may use the comments section of Attachment A to document q,uestions or comments concerning the discussion item.
- 8) Each discussion item is addressed to determine if a Simulator vs.
Station Difference exists based on the disposition. The results of this determination are documented in the comments section of Attachment A. 1 3
' (LJ 4
m I
TDI 70041 Revision: 00 l l
- 9) Discussion items involving work requests:
a) If APPROVED, circle APPROVED on the SRB i APPROVED / CANCELLED block of the work request. In addition, the work request is signed by the Simulator Review Board Chairman in the SRB Approved /Date block. i b) If DISAPPROVED, circle CANCELLED on the SRB ; APPROVED / CANCELLED block of the work request. In I addition, the work request is cancelled by the Simulator Review Board Chairman and the reason for the cancellation is documented on the work request and Attachment A.
- 10) The SFCC updates the Simulator Review Board Log Sheet (Attachment B) after each Simulator Review Board Meeting.
l I l w O l l l l l Approved By: ' l ate- f 1993 . Training Supervid ! l O Unal 5
.g -
l i TDI 700-01 Revision: 00 l ATTACHMENT A O BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR REVIEW BOARD APPROVAL SHEET SRB # BW- MOD # WR# 1 DISCUSSION ITEM , 1 l COST COMMENTS ! l MANPOWER HW-l SW-l LEAD TIME (PARTS) SIMULATOR AVAILABILITY l REGULATORY COMMITMENTS WILL BE DOCUMENTED AS A i SIM VS. STATION DIFFERENCE IN CERTIFICATION REPORT YES NO l, DISPO51 TION CONSEN IING SIGNATURE 5 Approved Disapproved Unairman/vate Hold Date FILE: SIM - BW DISSENTING SIGNATURES O final 1
- TDI 70041 Revision
- 00 I
/*
ATTACHMENTB BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR REVIEW BOARD LOGSHEET i l ITEM DESCRIPTION OF DISPOSITION SRB # CLOSED SRB ITEM WR# (DATE) APPROVED DISAPPROVED HOLD . 1 l i o l l l l V final 1
i I BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR ANSI /ANS-3.5-1985 CERTIFICAT'.ON REPORT APRIL,1996 ATTACHMENT 5 SIMULATOR AND CONTROL ROOM LAYOUTS O O K:\sim_cenVertifi. doc 125
*i w -w - m -
?m----
i i 1PM11J t 1PM12J OPMR2J 1PMORJ 1PMOTJ 1PMOEJ 1PMOEI I t A1 A2 ', j
' *,1PMO5J !
B1 ', g 4 's f UfET ; SUPV DESK t t !
/o it '
ED I 1 - NE - P C UD t g 1PMOEI t TS - M _ X A NE , { EK CABINET 1 0 V I5 t i R 4 5 TK t _ a a _ t j
- t F t t
t t t 3
, ' 1PRW4J OPM01J OPMO3J ,'
1PRN1J 1PMG2J 1PM03J LNT1 PAPELS LNT1 PNELS LNT1 PAMES CORA00NPNELS ANTS 1 &21 1CNDEI-OPERA 1DRCONBOLE 1PMBEl-IEACIOR& QEM.WOL CONT. 1PM11J-CONTA5SENTIBOLATION SPMD1J-GEM 5tALSSMCES 1 PRS 1J-GEM 5tATOR&AUXLIARYPOMiR 1PMBEl-EMLSAFETYFEATLNES 1PRet2J-RISC.NrTRtmENTATION SPMB2J-HVAC 1PM02J-TUfWDE 1PMBTJ-pA3CLEARWSTRtmENTATION 1PM141 ALARMPIWfTERCONBOLE IRIBil-SMTCHYARD 1 Pts 1J.COPEENSATE 1PMOEl-pf00REWSTRSENTATION
- 1PM04J-FEEDWATER ATTACHMENT 5 : BRAIDWOOD SIMULATOR CONTROL ROOM LAYOUT i
. . - - - .-~ -. --- . . . _ . . - . _ -.
I i j oe ee i l p- --.- -
= a m. , m . . , , , ,
_ _ . _ _ . j e,, t i
~~
f
.-_.s -
-"-,.~~ e
.m.* T * -- 68 ? t ;
g' Am.,- -w:
; 2 _
i M ,-f l r i
~ q q Q., 4, Y2 , 31 W g(.. ;x a 4
- ars a ' to I
[ #
***8*' ..sg I W1
, ?g1 h. ?.
y.(4, . . .
' ~ "
s o ,* !
; # J. W7: 9,: N :1: E 1 E h;s-a 3g'- ~ -- 7 h
g --S aq_* ._wg_F^:a _ ftG . ----a m1a V
,+/ e if E i # ,r/> f) i a w u
'eg er v
,/ ;
h '=aN R' - N
reYws 'M8*
- k M-d3
<h,
=w y,.. d i
. - - . - - ~
l
.g-aR j
.+
i lg E *c. - "< . . - y. ..-'* -- T -1 m .l ?q@ ,
, a._
g g' 7a L . .-- .= e., - f o p I
-s h{ 'e
[14' ) t
~
gj l .x - a g Ua .r g Iv 8 wa -., s m_.,surt russe (-A i.u t - :e\b i s >4-
-o* yss f ~I t.W ,
u 1 G ga s < 1*:,,,,
, i.' ,
4 ),<- ,,p , y
**= l '#..C*". .,?,, ( - ! .,[w M . a .- ,i
\
\ J +* - .av stab' 6-an h
, py,,ogrftne 3
=
na.h* l(i-*z. -a orm.asJ-e . i e h' p @y\*' ( *M' i_ h* 7 t
, c l . . "'- f '. . .y W-**4#a
! A,c, I as 8 '- #*Y M ah' is'-a*
%' I
'f> I - ' ;* '
_ __ M.'~a* . _ _"8*
,g i i , i i 3 y g g +. .".9 'W.q(g_. i _ e La.=a m.1 a := ~m A x"1m m e.etag wum,
- N' x= , m qf-
, - i, 4- w _.
$.,' ' 6_.eV_
sy .* *
- .., g- ;*=== ' w '
Y my,3 joisesl ,1 {$ !
].._J ris
, . ,, . , , ____'s== _ _ _ . _ . -
p
\ , va. ! .au at u'
)' _ et.,ar i ,g., .
e' W s m er (t ,,,, ,
~
-- 1 ,
'I~h i
,, ) __
...V,,'*'.* O, ,4.
- h
.e fH p. - ,_
.--. .g, <, 4 j
'- N ~
h " ~.( s a id
,=,6 4 p.at SNO. ceuTWc4T.ow concautoemtwu-sumsomrean men Mvd
- u. _ _o ess amm s-set
. ant i e .e=<**
'***'" viv s.e .,te .c q NOTES I s
-^w REFERENCF, DRAWINGS l I
- seofa tus ,s e proa N'.*
.,.-o.u ~ .a.n.ne.N m ..,r.,w$. w a Nutammaak.wvus aus owmansa sus pne smoo m
=.ca.m-, .= =w o- e.
,,, = .aL etas meses r6asa Pues et. ase<cresunn a or*** m oser n e A es.7 .k
. .u n ..v
*T^t 'o** i.o sei a Laisa e we m.s am onwmmo as enions. e-n.ae aim eum ae.Psmen pusean .oA# ems
- a. . 3 gia.. sic .ame c n;nO5J 3CuoRJ A Grthsfam4 6 pm :.,a L21ns pasenpg
, . ,,,,,, ...., ,,,%,,,.,.,,~,,,....g,,,,,,,,qas
- .........m,
*MCalJ tennotJ anase CanaPu't.vgidL cas seuest ga gi,ggg.agig sse pwee.est ad es a peevan **"'"I***'*#'T'****4D*'"**
was.courraut esime summ.v vera, 6 311s 'Juss,v.t.s.e
.,auces wo :* ==.m
*=oss,
=comens6 ea c we s 6 -s la ,
sa,se.rm 24..ma., ritau esp . o.rv.is.m. ests).uJ SP 3 . *33 e.e3.sr. . .4 as r, tcow.a m.aa WH
., o.J eru.eeJ
. J teas.pe .co-cas,t.m.ag . .n.a.s.eyg e c, e '. a py.2W a.derst,.esa Ew Sc6 EEe'.h8'
. .88,"#.*.88 8'.4 88.fc8'"#.863 c8446 idBl. *ge,vstd4 =c.m wik . o . as. ima
,W 21'teOhJ teases cepe'EWh hcAW l'het bA ,
s 4 A>L SEP'it Damadapte SWR Pa.Eli.& d' (dpfW40q, LEIOJMBIelutof76 $$4R95 80c6 @Ck38tt. [ ,a~ muo.va, N*, , ., ,6 k2/ * * * * ~ r.=.=o$J
.. .n.co s,sne.c.t m
cs.,r*'a'a*i,', n'a',',". ". [o,m 1"d' 'm" '"d ** '
. .e # J
,%es 2P54 MJ a r.mos 4 M*+ *aes .
ervne mo g s mou
. *-essis o.r.ia.*.*
.s. e Dom CAS6E 8ese bagt'R.ff deowt coorfmem Aosts ett -
pii ia SphesiJ am.nAseensme, ca suses.6essi,, m , .assi
.SeLAr a + 3tes.Jo'2ys3 #'"" = fld0h8 SEE '50dE o*40nat8tah o ecr s 8088 r**e 6A,iove aussen comaritow '
s'te4J 3PhtE3J ts46 esgtsth4Ntatta.s pued6 a.nek ==.".
.. f1EDiaDT9'D tas 1 C# a*O EI 'N II',E#M"b If 8 N' Nkk tf agy p ,.gyo,fp
.s
.N6J JPt*54J ALAfthe 88mtygg4 Comedt.5 g (Ast Pc'tr EA( 4 ed" oeJ as smefj e 2F%*S13 i
) .*'+ .**% e !** AC'en (n6. ch.p. s vereysg ac3i O ,
u% : ,g ,.,,..... C ASc5 GuALL SecucN m A ce4:.%h.sta *aw.4D.s,ua s. c er,, g t
; s.+ewvacuo c sta . me ,
, $r'uraceas soo=i oipecta mea u, ec,n,wna,L 4, .,
i 4 apw,J d _. - _ _ _ _ _ . _ N ^=e --.--_--- l 4
~* ,
>R 1
./ -
,, . ; O3 -
.s . h .... (2.9
,. ; b- , .. , & -
F E
.g l i
. . . f 4i
-t-5 ;'-ct y-4l g _. ~g T T y Q.. g' F
.;. t , .g _
y %._$
..M,s
; ,_~
.u -- ,.s-z i - _
'd f
_ _ _, _ _)ma Ows EM W3y0QQ /\ e y 5 ese e
- ; ,,~, - y -.gh.w 9-up,v /
,, [ 3 61V . . .1 *L* F ,3 v\*
w,-x a y: ~ , p - EK1EW y E ) san E:5& y%.. 1 L,W' 9
.A.y N
.i .~l u -
--j s v .u
-A v .. ' t. i e,t._a a i ymc ~ t.~ s 4}.- . 6 -
.. m. G s r- m0c. f~ , y
. e .
,i q ;
[ i k ). :x g , 3 j W d@ ANSTEC - a %.. .. ,1 l HM a lE
- 8 g[n% ;
APERTURE L. _ ' E183, Sib i e CARD g.g .q w i v.- y ,,. i v l T,l ,,, l L f* [td !,* -N'\ %""'t i 10u Abo Avci!cNo on~ v -
'O.FJ".rne nu a r,
., e .. . ,,,,, pa r) y r. i + Aperture Card ~
,* .,gT~ h -
-- - b yi.- c% -
.W v
g ! - - ~ m, (F.B see em m . . mioes - _ _ _ .1 an.a tsa /e4,- . *
=
_,ar.; gT '
.T s.. 7s _ _a_a_ _s a s__ _x_ _ a __ cy_,
i i* s' J-N s'=c) , g l 2 i
," a
- v. i t.' ,*. A I fg..g ga g. ,.
~~~~'* -4,4 1
% a A V_ V a 5'*v=M . uj 3 /3 w.
.3 ..
1 - - . - -..a ,s. : t,p m .v i m _ WgZgefhe l
~
NUCLEAR SAFETY ret ATED ~ __ touweuwtis SHowN oN THrs onAwiNc. 1 T ' I?sas - E"'E 0 00
~ _ -. .
. - - , . _. s me ,
*<4 me o> i d ,,,- - m: aguasa at- '
,,g e ,
p ,,,u,, w,, g ,y,,,,w , f , ,, ,, q,_ __ m wra ooc rm., - i m.,.,,_ w g , a
- .+ -nww p .o m , ;
w e. c s roa -i.v . 4 a
~
oy T ,t . hh x3-C-' - BRAIDdOOD E IA TION 6 61 T ' & 2 _,ggI;- .___n__,
~
r ma.cwo. - m aiuno son en. t {s-=*a'. T *_'M 4 y 4 -
,,,,,. I "
m e y
.y,'N- r =- -c=
~ ass /* yamsim.,j G!t L u e4 aMy
- l If1,M.,
m bnm s m- .-~~*=m.s*'u."- 2
~~"***
i-
~
sW'm _ </ d* *****~* 1 F # M .., u.,d %.,,n; - g, e
- V}}