ML20100H198

Motion to Strike Portions of Applicant & Staff Testimony Re Issue 16 Concerning Tdi Diesel Generator Reliability,Per 10CFR2.743(c).Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20100H198
Person / Time
Site:	Perry
Issue date:	04/01/1985
From:	Hiatt S OHIO CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE ENERGY
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML20100H195	List: ML20100H192 ML20100H198
References
OL, NUDOCS 8504090055
Download: ML20100H198 (5)

Text

- ..

Aprzl 1, 1985

\

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

~Before the otomie sof e't y and Licensing Board

,.In the Hotte.r.of ,,

). , , , ,

. )

THE-CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ) Docket Nos. 50-440 OL ILLUMINATING CO. ET AL. ) 50-441 OL

)

(Perry Nuclear Power Plant, )

Units 1 o'nd 2) )

MOTION TO STRIKE PORTIONS OF APPLICANT AND STAFF TESTIMONY }

Intervenor Ohio Citizens for Responsible Energy ('OCRE*)

hereby moves to strike portions of Applicant and Stoff prefiled direct testimony on Issue #16, on Transomerico Delaval diesel .;

generator reliability.

I. Applicants' Testimony OCRE moves to strike ' Applicants' Direct Testimony or John C. Kommeyer on Issue No. 16' in its entirety, " Applicants' Direct Testimony of Charles D. Wood III on Issue.No. 16' in its entirety, and " Applicants' Direct Testimony of Edward C.

Christionsen on Issue No. 16', with the exception of porographs 39 (with footnote 3), 41,-and 42.

10 CFR 2.743(c) states that only relevant, materiol, 'a n d reliable evidence which is not unduly repetitious Will be admitted. Applicants' testimony (with the exception of the three paragraphs in the Christionsen t e s t i m o n'y , Which contain new information) cleorly foiltto meet the lotter requirement.

i The Kommeyer testimony is virtually identical to the January i 8504090055 850401 PDR ADOCK 05000440 9 PDR

• \

1

(-t 28, 1985 Arfidovie or John C. Kommeyer, filed in support of

.Appliconts*-Motion for Sumory Disposition of I s s u e !!!1 6 . The Wood testimony is-virtually identical to the January 31, 1985-Affidavit-of Charles 0. Wood III, oiso filed in support of- ,

Appliconks' summary disposition motion. The Christiansen testimony is o combination of the Affidavit of Edward C.-

~Christionsen and the Affido'vit or Gary R. Leidich, both doted February 1,'1985 and riled in support or Applicants' summary 4

disposition motion.

(Specifico11y, parogrophs 1 through 27 of the Christiansen testimony are virtually identical to paragraphs 1 through 26 of ,

the Christionsen offidavits poro9Pophs 28 through 38 ore virtually identical to porographs 7 through 17 of the Leidich ofridovits porographs 40, 43, and 46 of the Christiansen testimony are equqvolent to porographs 19, 21, and 22, respectively, of the Leidich ofridovits and porographs 44 and 45

' of the testimony are equivalent to porographs 27 and 28 of the i

Christiansen offidovit.)

i A clearer example of undulh repetitious material-could not be'found. Furthermore, the testimony is of queseionable value, os -it foiled to occomplish its. objective-of demonstrating the obsence of a. genuine issue of material fact'ot the summary disposition stage., -Unlike the Storre s testimony, it hos not addressed thecmatters raised in OCRE's response to the summary disposition motion. Thus', there is little purpose t o tu! served s-v --

, . ~ , _ _-- , ,

. - - _3 j

i 1

4 by'odmitting this. testimony, ,

III. -Starr's Testimony "0CRE moves to strike, portions or the ' Joint Testimony or-Cori H. Berlinger, Drew Persinko,-Spencer H. Bush, David A.. .l

, Dingee, Howard H. Hordy, Adam-J. Henriksen, ond B. J. Kirkwood- <

(: .

.on Issue 16 concerning-TDI-Energency Diesel. Generators at the Perry Nuclear Power Plant', specifically: ,

,the phrase: numbered 4), ' previous Storr conclusions on similar 1- . .

engines-ot Comanche Peck, Grand Guir, and cotowbo', in the lost

}

~

Porogropn on page 12 and the lost sentence in the t'irdh porograph from the bottom of page 21, 'These some guidelines 4

have been applied in recommending licensing detions for other TDI-05RV-16-4 engines at Grand Guir, Cotowbo, and Comanche Peak,4 ,

These statements are objectionable because they are not ,

relevant. Th'e starr's licensing actions at Grand Guir, on 2

Uncontested cose, Comanche Peak, in which the issue of TDI DG i

reliability is not' contested, or cotowbo, where the issue Was raised but no Licensing Board decision ever reached its merits.

. ore simply not applicable at Perry, where the issue is at  ;

hearing, ,

If th'eLStofr's'rindings had been arrirmed by o Licensing Board in the-cited cases, and if the parties in'those r

proceedings had been orrorded on opportunity to challenge or rebut the Starr's position, . and if it could be proven that the other engines were identical to those'ot Perry in terms or i

e 8

.__i.____.__.___2__.___._________._____J

l 4 '

i design,. fabrication, installation, and usage, then the Stoff's Conclusions at the other sites Would be relevant. But such'is not the-cose.

- III. Conclusion ~

Since the portions of the testimony challenged above rail to meet the. Commission's standards for admissibility, OCRE's motion must be granted.- OCRE prays the Board is so moved.

Respectfully submitted, J

Susan L. Hiott +

OCRE Representative j 8275 Hunson Rd.

Mentor, OH 44060 (216) 255-3158 1

cf f

I 4

t i

b J

1 e

41 + e p - , ~ 4 +

l

, .?" .

J  :  :

J

. ;J ll 00ME7,EE ,

• i CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ,

This is to certi'fy that copies of the foregoing were S v g 4 g @

deposit in the U.S. Mail, first class, posta'ge prepaid, this * <

^/sy day of M tL ,

service list'below. 1986tothoseon%,tgegg{3EVINf

i. .

R BRANCH- '

s. . . .i, , s

< f ,

Susan L.,H,ia,tt -

.e

. . d

- SERVICE LIST ,

^

~~

, ~

I CHAIRMAN Terry Lod.ge, Esq.

JAMES P. GLEASON, LICENSING BOARD ,

618 N.'Mich.tgan St.

RToMIC SAFETY & j ,

513 GILHOURE DR. '

Suite 105 SILUER SPRING, MD 20901  ;.

43624 i j, Toledo, OH Dr. Jerry [R. Kline Atomic Safety.&.Licen. sing Board. g U.S. Nuclehr Regulatory Commission i , v} .i ~

-[ .

WasEington(D.C. 20555 - ,

Mr..GlenkO.,hright  ;.

Atomic Safety &. Licensing Board '

U.S. Nuclear Regul'atory Commission, Washington, D.C. 20555 .

• -~ , ,,

e, Colleen P. Woodhead, Esq. ,

Office of the' Executive Legal Director

• U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ,

)

' Washington,.D.C. 20555 Jay.Silberg, Esq. [

. Shaw, Pittmani Potts, & Trowbridge  ?

1800 M Streetg NW h

. Washington, D.C. 20036 y u

Docketing'& Service Branch

.0ffi'ce of'the Secretary , '

U.S.. Nuclear Regulatory. Commission .

• Washington, D.C. 20555 ' ' .

'* Atomic'S'afety.&, Licensing. Appeal.Bo'ard' Panel '-

U.S. Nuclear. Regulatory Commission ..i1

'. Washington,-*D.C. 20555 l

),

• .