ML20090M536

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Package Consisting of Util Responses to AEC Questions on Facility High Energy Line Breaks Outside of Containment
ML20090M536
Person / Time
Site: Monticello Xcel Energy icon.png
Issue date: 03/21/1974
From:
NORTHERN STATES POWER CO.
To:
References
NUDOCS 9105060229
Download: ML20090M536 (17)
v • d • e


Text

- .

. AEC DI 'IBUTION FOR PART 50 DOCKET MA7 TAL (TLMPORARY FORM) CONTROL N0t 2135 FILE:Mid C DATE OF DOC DAE REC'D LTR MEMO RPT OTHER FROM:

Northern States Power Co.

Minneapolis, Minnesota 55401 NONE 3-20-74 e A. V. Dienhart SENT AEC PDR X OTHER TO: ~) -

ORIC 0 ORIG CC SENT LOCAL PDR X INPUT NO CYS REC'D DOCKET NO:

CLASS UNCLASS PROP u 7s XXXXx 0 50-263 4

1 ENCLOSURES:

DESCRIPTIC'.. .

Response to AEC Questions on Menticello No Ltr of trans ree'd.......

High Energy Line Breaks Outside of Contain-ACKNOWLEDGED l>0NUf REMOVE PLANT NAME: Monticello

( 40 cys rec'd )

l FOR ACTION /INFORMATION 3-21-74 GC SCHRENCER(L) 44tIDiANN(L) REGAN(E)

BUT12R(L)

W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ 4 Copies W/ Copies CLARK (L) STOLZ(L) DICKER (E)

W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies COLLER(L) VASSALLO(L) KNIGHTON(E)

W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies KNIEL(L) SCHEMEL(L) YOUNGBLOOD(E)

W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies W/ Copies INTERNAL DISTRIBUTION VREG FILE TECH REVIEW DENTON A/T IND l

' LIC ASST BRAIIMAN

/AEC PDR HENDRIE GRIMES CAMMILL utf1GGS (L) SALTZMAN

' OGC, ROCH P-506A SCHROEDER MACCARY KAS7WER GEARIN (L) 3. HURT MUNTZING/ STAFF CASE KNIGHT BALLARD COULBOURNE (L) pupg GIAMBUSSO PAWLICKI SPANGLER LEE (L)

VIOYD SHA0 MAIGRET (L) UBE w/ nput MOORE (L)(BWR) STELLO ENVIRO SERVICE (L)

HOUSTON MULLER SHEPPARD (E) INFO DEYOUNG(L)(PWR)

NOVAK DICKER GMITH (L) C. MILES V$KOVHOLT (L)

ROSS KNIGHTON TEETS (L) B. XING P. COLLINS IPPOLITO YOUNGBLOOD WADE (E) vvARGA DENISE VtEDESCO REGAN WILLIAMS (E) Vli1ECKER REG OPR vt0NG PROJECT LDR WILSON (L) vt:ARTEE FILE & REGION (3)

MORRIS LAINAS S. REED (L)

STEELE BENAROYA HARLESS 9105060229 740321 PDR ADOCK 05000263 VOLIMER EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION P PDR g v1 - LOCAL PDR_ Minneapolis . Minn. _ ']

(1)(2)(10)-NATIONAL LAB'S 1-PDR-SAN /LA/NY f Q DTIE(ABERNATHY) 1-ASLBP(E/W Bldg.Rm 529) 1-GERALD LELLOUCHE V1*- hSIC(BUCHANAN) 1-W. PENNINGTON, Rm E-201 GT BROOKHAVEN NAT. LAB 1 - ASLB(YOP2/SAYRE/

WOODARD/"H" ST. 1-CONSULTANT'S 1-AGMED(Ruth Gusscan V16 - CYS ACRS X10DJUNtX SENT TO LIC. ASST. NEWMARK/BLUME/AGBABIAN RM- B-127. GT.

3-21-74 DIGGS 1-GERALD ULRIKSON...ORNL 1-RD. . MULLER. .F- 309 <

.s'

\

50 i

. ~60 REGULATORY DOCKED ,g ,

, l Rici%o'

relative to the ten minute assumption is determined from the rate of flooding in the HPCI compartment. The time required for the level to reach a critical HPCI component and possibly I disable the HPCI has been shown to be in excess of ten minutes. Therefore, the maximum time available for safety / relief valve initiation is some time greater than ten minutes. The actual point has not been specifically determined since if the HPCI i operated for ten minutes, the reactor should already be de-pressurized. Following depressurization of the reactor to 150 psig, the LPCI system will automatically operate to com-plete the plant shutdown. I ---e- -- j i '4 i i l l i

l. UlJ1:STION: Solstoit details ed t ho' .uld i t ion.i l p r otec t ion mentioned in paragraph 6. 2. J(1).

I I ANSWER: The additional protection envisioned at the time l j of the report was a plate protecting the turbine building mezzanine floor (elevation 931'0") from a jet of water im-pinging on the floor. This would also have provided pipe j whip protection. Further analysis of the break and break j ' locations resulted in the f ollowing: i

a. Jet Impingement i

1 The original calculations assumed that th,e maximum

operating pre r.sure of the pump . continued for a long period of time. This was a conservative approach that l did not take into account the effects of pump discharge ,

] head versus the flow characteristics (system resistance). l If we ta ke into account these effects (pump run-out), the , j forces due to jet impingement will be reduced by approx-imately one order of magnitude. .Using these new forces l and the same method of calculation described in paragraph 5.1 of the report, the mezzanine floor will withstand the jet impingement, the reby supporting the redundant safe- ! guard MCC without adding any steel plate,

b. Pipe Whip In order to provide protection to the mezzanine floor l

' against pipe whip, four restraints will be added. De tail ' drawings of the pipe restraints are attached. The design load for the pipe restraint was 161 kips. t W ith the addition ol' the tour pipe restraints, the mezza-nine floor wil, be protected; thereby insuring safe shutdown of the plant following a feedwater line break. s 4 i i I l i i . - . - - , - .- -, . ,-.. .. . , . -. -. . . ~ , t 'wg Wi& x % ( NEW) 1 , l , y if.,p 00 j M i d 1 . ,__J L _,  ;(Al" iu cold PCGiTiou i ~ N . \ s \ i l / '- 3 VL " - ~ SECT ~~B-B . ISSUED FOR COA /STRUCT/ON 'M );Y fa\f%) _ av fhxg ECP & _(f0g4 gifi'vy eson ma nev.jomj nevisious J 1.iUNTICELLO NUCLEAlt /,50, S B ,5E E E - C GENEllATING l'LANT -- UNIT 1  : 8# REF. owos. PtPEb/hI *S M $ MONTICELLO. Nin N'ESOTA my _. STE El-JOB NO. DRAWING NO. R ^ ~"l^ - t EVd. PIPE SUPPORT-TURBINE BLDG. - REACTOR FEED WATER PUMPPIPING l00AD ,__tlk 6040 6 3/9 i

rf g eg' sm mcwrios  ;

.I ...j. . - i.N/8x96 ? A"XA"KW(dWGlEX BAMXS +7 C 0,z'L G. a A ._1. . . . . . - Db.~kG - l . _3. LL_. : ..l.t 4"X.4'X'/89NCLE X JI3 /6 . . - . - - . - -- - - 1 A, A _ . . - I h ./ 3"x 8"LG, c. 5. Pf(2< ATE ~L G. Ei W$13/. BEAM X 3 '- 8 -. i - - _6 3_./ 1- l. :.~.~- - 'Jt4."# 9 ':X 9" C,5. 2?A TE . - . . . . , -.. j } ._ . - . _.a . - . -. . .- . - j .-- . - - - - . . . -w -- - - . _ - - ..- - - . ~ . -- - - ---.--- - _ _ . _._L._--.--- - . . - . - . . - -- - - -- - - - --- -- - l ~ 8 '- 6 = , h H b 17 ~ ""#5 , [/ =~7 i Mi , ( ) _ _ ( y s) = = M ~ (TVR)) y 4 r q _ y g ) ((TYr:) Q ~g g 4 , al -f EL. 92 4 ' IU8 . --- i /h LOCATION PLAN d l AREA 2 _ _ -;-- 1 E L ' M4 '~ # t/[tNcoLD I4 ~~ NSA PosmoA lB+ ELEVATION A.A LOAD MARK NO.[M ".M/A . N eN /S1 HEP FOR CCA/SMLIC_Z@N aevisio~s l$ W av l cn 15C h, ni smffW l0gA ma nev]o4re MONTICELLO NUCLEAR . iso SK-5848 2_d_(- C, GENERATING PLANT - UNIT 1 ." REF-DWGS. PIPE MME" $MS."M MONTICELLO, MlitNESOTA , JOB NO. DRAWING NO. REV. ! PIPE SUPPORT -TURBINE BLDG. F W 2 A - H I A t/i O WACTOR FEED WATER PUMPP/P/NG. /0040 N L (,,(*) 4 () 6 Q& - y g , , * ,',[T siz t ot scnierios 1 i V l l'l X h4 F6 E A t/\ > 15 '- 2. '/2." L6 - tn".L.6- .A, ' i W 6 % E ES,t.v,f, T R. L., .Ni t % F C'- 9" ' C C s . 9 L M G . _. . .. ._ 4 ,_ 4 .  ! Y'i> Y % O'-b LG C .5 PL WT F, . . _S._ . ?- , _ . . . 4" X 3" x Mi A N6L E. K / '-/Q" t_C, _6. 2 7. , _ _ _ _4" K T M7 /i4" A Ng LE y l'n4 t 6_ .-.--.{-  ! .q.. . _ . i . 1 l , 1 J Oc0 Til g ,_ 4 .. gw - - - .A _ yeme) prosEt.9M,M W3(.r .x f 50 ~ 'I' h jN ' typ 1 J' f'~ (capeT) __y. . . __ _. 7 "g l , __f 2 g., t , W_2.t x.62. r- @,.g - i / t"' "~

3. g

[3l4i s c j s 2 '/ / , u ?g rf P ' LOCATION PLAN p Y'- AREA I .N 6) 6 l N l u 33.g 14" P l PE i HANGER CR'TICAl. N 8 5-- \ S'.y I a --- ~ q e ELEVATION A A MARK NO..F W RA-ll?.A /S, ;'*77 l 650GD FOR CON GTR UCTn O N m M Ecp $(![# l n e v i s i o e, s av ew n y eno%gg aren nevjo4Tel i MONTICELLO NUCLEAR iso S K -5 &lo - L_90E=-C GENERATING PLANT - UNI'" 1 REF. P PE M (B - G owGs' MONTICF.LI O. MINNESUTA seu ena~ctsoo STEEL $ ~ 1 M - k PEPE SUPPORT-TURBINE BLDG, JOB NO. DR AWING NO. REV. REACTOR FesoWArsa Puw Pigme 10040 m 2A- H2A 6. td L60 4&4 _ 4/91! g 1 'O u $L f~ I ..7 g _- .a ._._L t t i 7 g @c . ._ t_ t vi E L. 9 2 4'. N ~ _ ._(4 ~ .' / l# PIPE H/sNGER CRITICAL I G E cT i O N - B E A #'Ys __\ 55 U E D F O R C O N S'T R U C in o N _, _ _ _ _____ _ tg. y'6Cf , FO nev.joarcl mavi:io~ ev [wd e 15 3 nwn (U4 wa MONTICELI.O NUCLEAR .- iso _SK -5B'LB - L- 106- C GENERATING PLANT - UNIT 1 , REF. pipe M - 7 t o- l'2. MONTICEI,LO. MINNESOTA m rum STEEL O " 145

  • 4 PlPE SUPPORT-TURBINE BLDG. JOB NO. DRAWING NO. REV.

RencToa Feeo Wen Pump PipiNe "W 2 A- H 2 A 2./2 10040 s/+_ 'O ) 'i l G O A 0 4- 6 cign al p sin otsen.er,oe ' , ) E J:i"y u"x-~Ti"C3~~PL6.TE T5EE DET D 1 . ._ _2 12. . SI2 JA. FYi4.11% % NAP-CEF CONC.FASTt._. t _. . _ . . _ 3 _. .Jv X 2 F4?. . TAP-B OLT 4__.12_..  ? . .. BEAM 5!.-21 5-3 I , 4W]8 '< 4p 2.V 5 _ BEAM L6.a.%4'-S'_d. . _ 6 _.m.__. .. G X -S ". . C. 6. ELA . . _ . . __ . "L 7 . . ._ l . _ i X_5 '.-- 1%5 7 BE6y)6, PL ( ..E OFT; & 8 I .. T' \. " 'O . -O" C. .9. 2 .5_!1. _.. _ M.lPS _sW E tPi6STt_ _. . _ . _. ..___._ lo 2 _._ t

5. 72 " . . _TA ___RL -

ll . El I'. 0115g3 .,BE6M"K C.S. 4PLN 'I.A. M__TE I -(:o._. -- l2. ! /  ! ~1' h x 0 ~1 V 2. ' z ' o* _L t e* _[ L ,  ;- - 'l 8 0.C. i 3 f(,._9)oh.df-c~'V v __ l 'S5 ' 9SO'- irF A LL u  %, wtg x z7

  • U (atxt$r) e~

A ^T dl A9 b ML V  % p \ .4 .._ . .g_ , \ _.h C ' uJ y L, -.'g' 3-E4 W8X40 m Y_ = - . p LOCATION PLAN

  1. ~  ;

j AREA & 'O I _ _ , }f _ l*Y et. 922' ci '$N '/1 % ) I HANGER _ CRITICAL L 2 L // " i si C- > -*- uvemH,eAe { &s 'O"- ~~- - i ELEVATION A A - , MARK O. /,P 5 I _ 1/_.. K.E_t.Q c M E D QES 6__ MMM S MI at v.,oe e; aevisious av "cus  ?$$ rTurn (OgA ma MONTICi{LLO NUCLEAR iso S K - 5828- L - ZM -6 GENE \TNG PLANT - UNIT 1  : REF. pip, tvi-.g /A- /f / $ffM M O.' :'. i CT. . .! .O 'JINNESOTA OwGs. STEE, , g ,g SAN F RANCtSCO M N O. DRAWING NO. MEV. PIPE SUPPORT -TURBINE BLDG. REACTCR BEED WrthR FW E B - H 11 A I/2. d., ' dom P pi pw r, im/n s o e na n4. .w 1 43 qy i .:.: crwnos f.s cyc '/19 4'M;iTijh" 5.4 GTIFF PL6TE__ j -~ _ _. " ~l[~ ~ M. _1 't/,g' x 4" C . S_. PL A1 E (LEE D ET Jy_ _. _ .. 'kr _k g hoi -@ dy. co)'i$ acta 5 2' 4", % a '- 4 " - < r-q _ 44' . ii l NN ) ,N- o o__d ,T o 'd i we,4o < ," e_, < -z 1 2 . cm . .w DETAIL l 1, + 3..- I ._ EECTIO N-.BF8

7. o. s. _sL. SM'- 4 Y[

y b~ ~ f - __ - ,-_ ._h k ()- f.j z. 4 $ .__S t

  • * "3 a)Bi$

} j M HOLE $ f ~~ '-< DETAlL a b 4' o 6' a v4> - y gr \__ T g &ECTTON~~ Q -CU + ' } DETNL 3 w . .. . [Ll'!.h_fM nevqoard; LOCA1T.0 .\ T5M eevisio~s 6 _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ TM'?;MM av gwx p c Tuo n fagA aren MONTICELLO NUCLEAR  % GENERATII,'G PLANT - UNIT 1 MONTICEI,LO, MINNESOTA f REF. DwGS. pip [ N h M , M D 3 _j4 STE Et:- - '~ _. MBNO. DRAWING NO. REV. PIP'E SUPPORT-TURBINE BLDG. RFACTOR PEEDWATER EW 2 B- H I1 A 2/2. mour7 RIPINC, ICO4D ~  ! M L 60 %t - ? /9 i 8g y j;g *:jT si n otscwTios l ._ l . . I W i s X ~/ B B E A tA /[l l ' Y/8 L6. _. I ... 7. _!_ . l . . . ..l. t YI n67r5 A..?-l*Y .'.C' .Lb.?.LAll . C g,N3_., y A,p]. , ,a ,, _ i __3 J_(v., M_1 .i.7/6 M.,P_H3%IP6 9.N M- 0 9 F .. _. 4_I 4 I r AP BOLT _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __ _ _ . _ _ _ ._5 [_._2 . .I L" /8 .y K... l 7 ?2/g  % x *' t'- 4 4/ C . 6 . P.L. A?T. E._ . . _. . __ _ _ _ 1 __6._j.__2.. . ._. _LC RJ Q".X1'-5".._ L 5 P L A J E - . . . _ . ... l .. . . - . _. . .. -_ } . _ i I .y 7

p. . . _-

kb E L . 9 3)'-o" . T.O.S .EL. 930'- 4%. _ 'f 'vJib x 7 8 A "l (E.%\sT) *g g, i = = - .=:-=-== N e M" < _ ,1 .-m - m ,.e -N . ,.fs . u.t i 1'/t - 7 b6 , , g , M ' b 10 , i I _ d i o _ f . Ii. . E L . 9 f 9 '- 7" Je

.s  %

~ Q~ '

l 4? Ps ?1

'O i_.'[g i LOCATION PLAN .. y l , AREA 2 [C . i;l E-} i 'll l i:1 ' EXIST N/4X/// 'b s ,i fll 8 I U g i . C5 o7 p_ .1 tl , , , /I i IV F L'.E L . 9 H'- O" d h^ ELkVATION A.A 8 MARK NO.E,Y/1B H HB__ _2 ~A" l P ' __ .n. [g{p%) 155 uho i:or<. co4 s~rraucTION' f3 m v ;0ATEj R EVISI ON S t,p)p)@.4 BY l CH'K [ ENtifM NM g _ AP ' iso _S E-5.B? R t. - 10 6 - C MONT CELLO NtK'! CAR GI',NF.R ATI NG Pl . $.?.T -- UNIT 1 R E F. PIPE M.tn B - 12 DWGS. STEEL C"'E.4. 1~ 4 MO?A'iCEl.LO. IGN: :. JTA SAN MM<rico __ PIPE SUPPORT-TURBINE BLDG. JOB NO. DRAWING NO. REV F3EACTOR F^titiOWATER l Pu M r# PIPING 4 - ... . . _ , .. .

004O FQB.-%[,y5
b. .p C

1,f v) t r y lit (.67tsi) _._d s /~ v I Wpaah.. _. upashua 1 l ,t'-6k i h i & \ < in" l y 'y -N 1 1 P 6EC7iOtk.,C.C 2'- o" q to" no" -g y ygp. I, .i-I i ,l @ O O o -t )J j 9 -1 $ dq. ny - - - 0

0) \."# f N HOLES) \ N s E tm o N - o o_

/hhaj \%0E0 FOR con ST Ru CTION lgg l 186l [-- n e v. oare; ncvisioNs < bik oat te Jg4 mq MONTICELLO NUCLEAR i MO - K ' S 67.h k._2% - C C; - ' R/,TINC .sT': . ext 7 3 REF. PIPE M *2.lB t? 'E ,. lCEL1,0, .\;; ; ,' . : 0TA SAN FRANesco S* EEL _C. *2 4.L _A __ Pipt $1]ppORT-TURBIN6 BLOG. M NO. DRAWING NO. REW REACTOR FEEDWA TER g.0 40 -f=W2 8 tH its 2h O PUMP PIPIN6 ye<,o404 __-_- - gig? s i b . I 4. _ QUESTION: Since the torus is not strictly a pipe, the j statement that the torus will not be damaged because the torus wall thicknes s is greater than that of the HPCI steam i li ne , may not be accurate. Similar circumstances on other i BWR torus plants necessitated the installation of impact j plate s or restraints to prevent the HPCI and RWCU lines ' from impacting the torus. An analysis must be performed

l to show the impact energy the HPCI line will have on the torus. Please submit such an analysis for all high energy i lines which could impact the torus (page 23).

The only high energy line that may impact the i ANSWER: ' torus is the HPCI primary steam line. The statement con-tained in the report was based on the meeting held in Bethesda, Maryland on February 5,1973 where the same j point was discus sed. In performing additional analysis the suppression chamber 1 integrity will be maintained but some permanent deformation of the shell may occur due to pipe whip from postulated break points (see criteria in Appendix A of the report). This shell deformation would not impair the ability of plant personnel to safely shutdown the plant. We are continuing our analysis and design in order to protect i the suppression chamberand present any shell deformation. i Any restraints required will be installed when the analysis and design are completed. i 1 e 1 l i s o a i I i i l i l 1 ! 5. QUESTION: What are the environmental consequences of a primary steam sample line break on any safety related l equipment and cabling? (page 30) ANSWER: The primary steam sample line is located on the l west side of the turbine building. The line goes from the main steam line (PS I- 18-ED) to the sample rack located at j clevation 937'of the west side of the turbine building. The west side of the turbine building does not contain any safety related equipment or cabling that would be affected by this break. Our analysis indicated that a break in this !" steam sample line would not interfere in the safe shutdown of the plant. i a 1 e i i 1 l l l l e - , - . . , , .~, , - - . - - . - . - . - . -- , - , . . e e 1 } 6. QUCSh0N: What are the environmental consequences of a j main stean. or feedwate r sensing line break on safety related i equipment or cabling? (page 32) 1 )' ANSWER: The main steam instrument sensing lines are routed from the primary steam lines to panel C210 located l at elevation 951' of the east end of the turbine building, j Until the lines penetrate the turbine operating deck, they are

within the condeser compartment. There is no safety related i equipment (except one of two emergency service water lines) i or cabling located within the condenser compartment. The emergency service water line is a 3" schedule 160 pipe which will not be damaged by the instrument sensing line (l") break per the criteria contained in Appendix A of the re por t. An instrument sensing line break above the turbine ope rating deck at the rack itself will have negligible environmental consequences. The safeguard MCC's are located at elevation

, 91l' and 931' of the east end of the turbine building. Reactor protection system instrumentation (Turbino/Generatur Load Rejection instruments) located in the general area will not be affected since the cables from these instruments are within conduits and the cabling rated at 90 C. This rise in air temperature and humidity within the large volume (above the turbine operating deck) due to a a,ensing line break will be ! minimal. The break will be detected by an area radiation I monitor which is located about ten feet from the instrument rack. l The feedwater instrument sensing lines are located on the east side of the turbine building at ele vation 911'-0". A ,_ break in the feedwater instrument sensing line may possibly

affect one of two safeguard MCC's (located at ele vation 911').

This will not interfere with the safe shutdown of the plant following the logic described in the section on feedwater line breaks. i ( I v . _ . . .-. - - - _ . - - -

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20090M536&oldid=2795318"