ML20090F726

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Submits Info on Possible Generic Safety Implications Re Difficulty of B&W Plants in Maintaining Pressurizer Level Indications During Transients
ML20090F726
Person / Time
Site: Davis Besse, Oconee, Midland, Crane  Duke Energy icon.png
Issue date: 01/08/1979
From: Creswell J
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
To: Streeter J
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
Shared Package
ML20077K886 List:
References
TASK-*, TASK-03, TASK-3, TASK-GB B&W-0247, B&W-247, NUDOCS 8307060491
Download: ML20090F726 (3)


Text

i -

g 9..

t sim.,...,. e.........e.

~

  • a:cs:.. m l

i

.e.

y *.

e.

i ;e ::--l,4[;g m soo:c,c.

a u m si.c= :.u-=. is re.oi5 mn

..a u-.,.1

.a...a

.. c, D::zs... c. au-:s,ot 2*.,.o.

. 4.r s.
,..,

i I

g i

1:0:0?J.:Gi 70?.:

J. 7..Scrae:ar, Chia', : u:Ic:: E.:pper-54 :1:n 1 I

.v l

77.C?. : '

j J. S. Cresuell, Reac:c:

- nspac:::

S.........

C'.'..*=4.."...

K"r. ' O - G u.....:..

.a.

8

-:. # a..., a-me

.m..*L..3 JS e

e

..u. /. e @ 2 a..,

r.s~).

W.

...s...

J.

e 4 u

t.

s

.L

  • a,.-'.~.~

..'.e Cot.. se..'

~~y '...- 4.. #. c s a

h. v '. '. t' f a a,

=..- ~..~.'.~.,1 a..=.;,

3 t

y a

..1.~..~.-..s.

to.

4.

43 4,.

..s.. *eCn,* 1 3,..,4,. 4,-....e w.. c.s.r s. a.1.

p

...... c s,..., s.e.r..

j 3z

. e no.

a.

. a, g.a. <. a n, a.3 6 3

s.

    • s.:

.<-s..

s...

,a. 3 C.. ; a 3

C..a a.. -..,

t a

s.' - a.....*

e d

."a c #.1."..' a.s.

~. a is su'.- ~.'... _~.' '~. a.'.s

...-.1--

.o a' c 3.' o....

4.

~.5

. i.-..

.i

...- a d..- a.

1.530A

..c~. enb e. 16.

18.'.e-), s.e,..a a...d

.d...'.-

~.#..-.. u :. '.' = > - -

c i

1 pt: s:ep 1.

7:e issues 'or ;censi' ara:isn ara:

r i,

e., -.,., c g. 4.3.,... 4, 4

.r

.3

...a

,.4.a.. sa.sa._.,

1., r._a.<

s..a..

}

r..

. e.

a.. <..,.., c.

4 2,

1. c a..

. s. 1

....,n

..s..,.,...

4

., :s...

c,.s,.

ya., es.o,

(a, a

.a...a.i....... c.a u..

... e,. s.

,. s e e *.*...'^.. c'..'.'... '. a. a. s... c ). c o,, a.u., a.

i o:har IO*; fac'.1':ias.

~.. ~. ~ ~ ~ ~.. '.. -. ~.... '. - '. e.:

~

4 T..e Davis-3 esse 73; sci es in Sce:1:n t. 4.2.7:

1

(

Tne hydraulic for.ca on the feal a samily receiv'ng cha :ss:

.' '. e v i s s '..~...... s a.'.. -. '..

c.' s : s. =_."..-. '.. 7.'.. *. '. c.

4 Addi:ional f==:as.ac:in; on :ha f ea*. essa:b *.y c e :he. asserl:.* y vei;h: and a held down spring for:1, uhich rasul:si in a ca:

d......a.a..s.... a. aAt, <

u. s

.2. t.. <..

3 w...

n w.... -.. - s.. 4......... c :...

4.

l Taa licensee s:::as tha: : hare is a 303'? in:4:1= k fer tha s:2. :ing

(

4 ce ci,.sc ~..-.b..

o coola.

~r.~ r.

2...'v a v =... n e h.. a. '.. *

' S p a...'.' ' -

ca t'en requ':es that the punp be scn :ed at c: ab:ve t

....,.,..g.<

, e s.a.,. "c u.' ' *o a '..* a s.this :a p e :n-3

.. a.

.a

.~.~=s

.~~.=.^

j upuc d in:o a posi:ica such tha cen:::1 :cd nevr.nen: v=uld be

.hindated.

.!tj 2.

nsp,.:c:icn 3cyc:- 50-315/73~C5, paras::;h 4, evp,.::ed :cac:<vt:7 -

p=ver estillstions in ths Davis-Easse c es.

Tacsc escilla:icns l..

have aisc cc:urre! at Ocecce and.a

=t a:: ibu:ad :: s: 2:a genars:c:

lavel cacilis* ions.

3&*i repor: 3A*.l-100'7 s ta:es in A?.* :

8 O.

t e

O e

8307060491 79093o PDR ADOCK 05o00289 e

s s

k l'2 m

._.._,..._,,,s......__.~.

g s,

d v.-.

~..

~

.. -~

... b:. t f.

. s.; *,

The O.*,.1.-be.s.o..

2 C-?

.. -.. s ~... a-43.e. <.

t./

.k. J - 3 4. <.. J..

CscillE:icn3 in 3:2:= p; css;;;. s en r

  • g,.,

..d

..2,.

g., g g m

1,~

.: c. u.1.. g.

.Q pt.5:

.,.a.

C C..

.s

.....n2,.

r.

6.

... a.3 C,e.s.

D.

6.

.a.

?..., e. a.hCb,.g a

.s.

0 S 4 s.i '.u.<..,.t.2..s

.. 4 A'. c.

C<..,. m..t

-4 g.d. '.

4 **.=. 4.. L.. s....... t,s o.. s.., %

.#..a.J....,,. %.C g..

s.k..'.

3 3..

.h su.4 s* Oy* e d

  • .*..b. t.. 43
  • p.- ^. s p*...*.. ?,

'.'.b..'..-k.

s. *- 4.i.'.". #.-..*. *. C.d c.'

....3

4ductd 30 J 1V 4.1s C. nc CCDseq"Cnct

'"0 2 P. * : 4 ".X 03 it.C!*-

a

. _s'fs 3'"0 D.3djust:tn: Of ths :O' 4 CCS: in ' 1t: 7tSis:SnCO.

A3 3

  • 4 :450. : C
.g.3 ttS s, 4:*. Ac.i" scag.a C

,.:**2 t.4 G gJeta ias 02.1.2.

4

. k.

  1. g. n..C.4.

$4.*.#.3.

3. '. '..

a".".

w..

-g *... *..* *..*. s. 3

,3..*V. fi S.

s d

  • ,.s.. 4;.j~t...an.

C.2. %.2 tu%.4

.45-21,

.w.

. s e.s.2. C., 2.,n

..a2,

  • .*s3 d

41 h.O.

4.1 4.

4.. 4 n

= 3 3 4..t.9.

4.

<e A. t.. S s. C. 9 4 4... t y...

u 4.. c,.

4...

.s.

C.y t... < g

.t.a.. t. 4..,

s.:

A...,.

.k4....

- -, <.,s..<.*

s s.

s.v.

$,.,aggg a 2 *...i..1," #.s C'*.Cs t. C *...." *. *..* E.'.v 8. 1.*.* 1 *. * #..#. *. *. s.%.

.. *. r.#.

..a..

s.

s g.s.. g. ga.t a..J. 4. gU a s......

. O s.... 3

.3 "n a 4. 3 e

. n = s.. A.. 6. e t.e. t,..

i

... re.

. A...g 4,....

.J.%,.....

5.,s.,.

4.,

.J..

3. A p a,. C. S s

.J... <..- A. r %. 4.1's.

4..,

A s.... 4. s... t...

... 3 1,.

%s.. 4,..s e.

4... 12

.=.,.e 4..

e..-

.t e 3.* :./. o

.~..C..2., e....,.. a

.....w..,

.,...<.1.

.av~.1

...s

%..a g 6 * **e oE.e. c s*~ e *c-.

n.

.e-

.*.........A.,/

.z u.'n.<

.,a w.

(e. %.. Kgy g.b. g..! C, 107/

.1 3a. g.8 C. #..* #..* d * *'. 4 - & V '.' * *..

%...+..-*.

8..* b*

. 44

.s. s. C.,.. < =. s. n*.,.. C. 4. C sc t

  • t a.t p ?.1...... s 1. 4 3.

%.e.

p. C.,

  • r.

.e...s..<..

g.

.. t =. S....r.

4

1.,.. 4.*
s. ss... 4......C

......6 y.

C... e..,

../.. s 4..a..'.

I 4C.4i.3...

.r.s.

..4.

. z.., e.... J..e. e..

s... -..n.3 i

.OSs C.=.r.,,,.2..a..:.

.C.3... 4

...s..

o.s.. t 1... t e3,.... e.. i g... ;.. s. *.....#.. -. '..s.. a. u.d.-=..

.tv,

. c L ' C -'. p.* *. *. *. '..

.a 5 4Ca2.; A.2.t ;. 3 < 5 3.'. a.

v4..

.Q r.. 3 4.4 o.

s 3

.J.

.....<3 w a.a....,V...

4 2*

4 4

3 C..., A.4

. n c 7 sb.,. 1.

34....s h C p. s...e...

... L*.

/

ya.

a

.a.3

.e..... m Chl&Os

  • .*4 s #.z # ".3 c.#

'h a p. *.." ". ". #.. e..".,.

  • q" #.. *.

3

.s....u.a

.,v.

l Also no:ed du i:: the Svan: uns che fzC: the: TC=ld ven: of' scale

(..a.s

.s.a.,., w.w.).

. a d.'.*.-

  • C... i- ".as~..~..*d*..-..'..*..*.,..o..

4.

..a.,ya...

s.

- -.. a.. o.' s s s...

1.*

  • 3,..... '.'

.%.a~<.*~.=.~..'..-

w

..,3.,.

s..

3. g.

< a..3.. 3.,..,. e g

.s.

3

s..

9 a....

-4 s..

o..

shCu'.i *oe 4:c:':ad in lioh: o' the reCui:ssen:s of CZ 13.

.1.

,,e

. s

.W. r e s 1. #. '.. - C e *... C.1 r..3 d. '....v. -

2_-

s. d p *.-. = _= ',. a -

esin:c:.an:e is a:: ached as Inclosu:a 2.

T..'s 24=o should "Le avs ha ed

<...... a.a.,uJ~

,n.., e

,. o,....,,.,. z

.v.

..a C...a..n.a.o

<.. u..,,

a..

,<.. e.s p s :...<..,.. c...... C C,.s.t a.,. <.,.. s a..,.. -

.u.....

3 a...u.14

..i...3

,e...c.i., <, <. a....cs.

e e

O e

4

.u.

e

,-,m.,-

.,_,.,,,--,-,--r-,

---yy

-,,y y,

I',

s

.t i

1 l

.: s.c J_.....

.....f 5.

...s p e c.... a... =3.'c.. c _ e.. *. C,..-..

..'e...'~....

- - - * -. <. r 'a.e..s.* a..

rw...

4..

,..<i s,.,14.. s

....,:,_.....,._.s.,.4.,... a..,, e

.4. c. e s

- --. c 3-..3

or sys:e: :o de:erri.e vers: case ther=al ::ndi:10:s.

The reac:'::

ga.. y, e.g.n.e_ pe nu 5.c p. ass.,.<. e

..s

...a

. a

.... c-. s.-...-. au. og s e :v < e. s.

r.s

.....,.........,.t.

,.. i.

he em:::a c* the core (:his has ice: -he c:ss s: h ris,3 esse).

fac: ors are..c: applied ce cer.re:vs.:ively : ni::: values such as

.q anc : cea a n.

. i:lesure 3 descri.mes a= even: t.aa: cc::: ed a:

g 6.

a :....:s ci_. i:y v. ica.

_n

[

resul:ed in a severe :her=al ::..:sien: and e:c ress dif ficui:7 in' ces::olli:.; :he pl: :.

Tae aforece::10.ed f..:ilities shculd he s

.n:;e.s..ag <- so3y. as

, u. e.. s....so --.. < c.. eo. pu~ s<_ :. s s,..,

..r..

2 e,

..,,.s.

i l

1 f) s,..

/.-

r t

O

\\

2. 5. C:ssuai t.

=. e a....

r_ _ s p e c....

l, I::1cse:e:: As s:a:sd c: v/c en.ciesures:

G.=..*.-=.'.'.<

e

.%.. p

..... m.

.<a.

5 6

8 8

I g

e e.

e I

.i.

9 h

i

.1 i:

i 3

8 $

e 43 II f

t. 8 e

1*

9 I

9 l'.

t.

I

.i.

4 l

I m

4 l

e y,

r

-m.-.--

~. m

.,c-

-u