ML20085C729
| ML20085C729 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Point Beach  |
| Issue date: | 10/03/1991 |
| From: | Zach J WISCONSIN ELECTRIC POWER CO. |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| CON-NRC-91-114 VPNPD-91-344, NUDOCS 9110110008 | |
| Download: ML20085C729 (42) | |
Text
p v
s r
Wisconsin Electnc POWER COMPANY 231 W Mehest PO Box 7046. Miwoukee3y 53201 (aqa)pn 2345 VPNPC 34 4 i
October 3, 1991
'Documant Control Desk U.
S.
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Mail Station P1-137 Washington, DC 20555 Gentlemen:
4 ROCKETS 50-266 AND 50-10.1 DETAILED CONTROL ROOM DESIGN REVIEW IMPLEMENTATION UPDATE rOTNT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT. UNITS 1 AND 2 Our letter to you dated December 21, 1990 (NRC-90-131) provided a schedule for implementation of the outstanding Detailed Control Room Design Review (DCRDR) upgrades at Point Beach Nuclear Plant.
This letter provides revisions in the implementation plan and schedule for correcting certain Human Engineering Discrepancies (HEDs).
These revisions involve DCRDR upgrades in the areas of power supplies for communications equipment, meter faces for electrical power supply indicators, the Control Roor ventilation contral panel, indicator crystal replacement, meter faces for turbine and rod control, hydrogen concentration indicators, rod control counter reset switches, procedura' changes, meter face range adjustments, Spray Additive Tank iniet flowmeters and meter face pointers.
POWER SUPPLIES FOR COMMUNICATIONF EOUIPMENT:
Human Engineering Discrepancies 152, 343, 344, 579, 598, 606, 781, and 782, all covered under modification request MR-87-216, will not be able to be completed by the scheduled installation date of December 31, 1991.
This modification request called for the installation of an uninterruptible power supply for the Gaitronics and radio equipment from an existing instrument bus.
- However, testing indicated that placing this additional load on an instrument bus could possibly cause voltage spikes.
These voltage spikes could result in spurious turbine runbacks and reactor trips.
In addition, the Gaitronics, the riant's public address system, is not classified as safety-related, and grounds or short circuits in that system could have adverse effects on the reliability of the associated vital instrument bus.
For these reasons, we have decided to power the Gaitronics and radio equipment through a planned non-safety-related station battery.
Q hhhhhj66 I
V U U U c., v POR AwMkm onkunwr&m nqunaw
~____
r Document Control Desk October 3, 1991 Page 2 The installation of this non-safety related battery is covered under modification request MR-90-150.
This installation is scheduled to be completed during the Unit 1 refueling outage in Spring 1993.
Once installed, this modification will allow additional flexibility for future plant modifications and will reduce the loading on the safety-related batteries.
After MR-90-150 is completed, we expect that six months will be required to install modification MR-87-216.
The revised MR-87-216 now calls for the installation of a new inverter and A.C.
distribution panel to power the Gaitronics and radio equipment.
This inverter vill be connected to the new non-safety-related battery.
HED's 152, 343, 344, 579, 598, 606, 781, and 782 are classified safety-significant HED's under the Point Beach Nuclear Plant DCRDR scheme.
We had planned on the resolution of all safety-significant HED's by the end of 1991.
However, these HED's are associated with MR-87-216, and they will not be closed out until this modification is completed.
In the interim, the plant communications systems currently available in the Control Room are sufficier:t for the following reasons:
1.
Gaitronics has an automatic transfer switch which selects power between a normal power source (36E) and an alternate t
power source (34E).
Emergency lighting panels 36E and 34E have the emergency diesel generators G-01 and G-02 as backup power sources, respectively.
2.
The radio repeaters have a manual transfer switch which selects power between two power sources, B33 and B43.
These power sources are backed up by G-01 and G-02, respectively, but are stripped on SI (Safety Injection).
3.
The King Radios are available for use.
These radios are hand-held portables and do not require any AC power source.
Operators normally carry these radios.
4.
Operations can use the sound powered phones which do not require any AC power.
5.
Operations can use the PBX dial telephone system which has its own battery backup.
There are telephonca at various locations in the plant where the operator may have to go, such as the auxiliary feedwater pump room.
f I
=.
s Document Control Desk October-3, 1991 Page 3 METER FACES FOR ELECTRICAL power SUPPLY INDICATORS:
The resolution of HED 10 calls for color banding the meter faces of the Diesel Generator frequency meters on panel CO2.
This color banding would be used to indicate the failed position of these meters at 60.5 Hertz.
It has been determined that this color banding is not necessary_for several reasons.
First, the operators know that the de-energized position for these meters is 60.5 Hertz.
If they were trying to adjust Diesel Generator frequency and the position indicated on the meter did not change, they would suspect possible meter failure.
Second, NUREG-0700 does not require meters in the Control Room to have the de-energized position indicated on the meter face.
For these reasons, no further action will be taken on this HED.
The resolution of HED 32 calls for the modification of various meter faces on Control Room panels IC04, 2C04, 1C20, and 2C20.
The meter faces on 2C20 will be modified in 1992, in conjunction with the Point Beach Nuclear Plant calibration program for Regulatory Guide 1.97 electrical meters.
This program is discussed in a letter dated July 5, 1991 (NRC-91-064).
This calibration program will start during the Unit i refueling outage in 1992.
The reason that these meter faces will be modified in 1992 is that circuit modifications will be performed which will install test switches for these meters.
These test switches will ensure the safety of personnel performing the required meter calibrations.
Addition-ally, the meter faces associated with the Reactor Coolant Pump ammeters will be replaced during the Unit i refueling outage in 1992.
All the remaining meter faces under this HED will be modified by the end of 1991.
The resolution of HED 43 calls for the modification of various meter faces on Control Room panels C01 and CO2.
The meter faces, with the exception of the battery voltmeters and the bus section 4 345KV voltmeter, will not be modified because these meters are not accident-related.
The benefits to be gained by reducing'the number
~
of graduations between numerals on the meter face from 14 to 9 to be consistent with NUREG-0700 guidelines do not warrant the extensive efforts that would be required to implement this modification.
The battery voltmeters on CO2 have been removed from l
CO2, and new battery voltmeters have been installed on panel 2C20.
l The bus section 4 345KV voltmeter will undergo the modification in 1991 to reduce the number of graduations between numerals.
4
---4 e
m
-Document Control Desk October 3, 1991 Page-4 The resolution of HED 189 also requires changing the number of graduations from 14 to 9 on various_ meter faces on Control Room panels C01R, CO2R, 1C04R, and 1C04.
For the same reason discussed in the resolution of HED 43, this modification will not 'ce performed on the incoming, running, and gas turbine generator voltmeters on Control Room pancl CO2R.
Howevor, this modification will be performed on all the remaining meters by the end of 1991 as previously scheduled.
For further information on HED's 10, 32, 43, and 189, the revised Human Engineering Discrepancy records are attached.
CONTROL ROOM VENTILATION CONTROL PANEL:
The resolution of HED 339, covered under MR-88-114, calls for_the design and construction of the Control Room ventilation control panel.
This modification is currently scheduled for completion by December _ _15, 193t.
After completing the design phase, this panel was installed in the Point Beach-Nuclear Plant simulator.
After installation, plant operators recommended several additional improvements, which required a redesign of the panel.
The redesign-of the panel has been completed, but it has slowed fabrication and installation of the panel.
We are still reasonably assured that this modification will be completed on schedule, although future problems could delay its completion until March 1, 1992.
INDICATOR CRYSTAL REPLACEMENT:
- The resolution of HED's 180 and 331 call for the replacement of the meter face-crystals on various Sigma edgewise meters in the Control Room.
These meters are scheduled to have their nonglare crystals replaced'with regular crystals.
Operators feel that the meter faces are.casier to see t'ith the regular crystals.
This crystal replacement was scheduled for completion by December 31, 1991.
Instead, it will~be completed in-1992, in conjunction with the Point Beach Nuclear Plant calibration program for Regulatory Guide 1.97 meters._ This program is discussed in a letter dated July 5, 1991 (NRC-91-064), and is due to begin during the Unit 1 refueling outage in the Spring of 1992.
METER FACES FOR TURBINE AND ROD CONTROL:
The resolution of HED 31 calls for lengthening th, graduation scale markings on meter f aces associated with turbine go /ernor valve position, control rod bank position, and condenser vacuum.
It has been determined that the meters associated with the turbine and control rod bank position are small meters with relatively small i
i
m Document Control-Desk October 3,-1991 Page-5 graduations.
Because of the small size, there is no room on the neter faces to make the required modification.
For this reason, the modification will not be performed on these meters.
Additionally, the condenser vacuum meters require the scale graduations to be lengthened to make them easier to read.-
- However, it has been determined that the graduations are not significantly shorter than the required length and the operators have no problems reading them.
Therefore, no further action will be taken with these meters.
For further information on this HED, the revised record is attached.
HYDROGEN CONCENTRATION I.NDICATORS:
The discrepancy described in HED 770 concerns the fact that only two of the four hydrogen monitors displayed on panel-2C20 are pressure compensated.
Further investigation has revealed that all four of the monitors are pressure compensated.
Because the description of the discrepancy was in error, no further action will be taken-on this HED.
For further information on this HED, the revised record is attached.
ROD CONTROL COUNTER RESET SWITCHES:
I HED 72 incorrectly states that it is possible for the operators to remove the key from the associated rod control counter reset switch when the key is not in a safe _ position.
These switches are used to rezero the equipment associated with the control rod bank position counters.
A check of the bank position counters associated with Unit 1 was performed during the recent refueling outage, and it was y
determined that.this key could not be removed when the switch was in the " reset" position.
These switches are spring _ return to center switches, and the key can only be inserted and removed from the center position on these switches.
Therefore, there is no reason to replace these switches For further information on this HED, the revised record is attached.
PROCEDURAL CHANGES:
1 1The discrepancy descrihed in HED 457 concerns step Sa of Emergency Contingency-Actions 0.0,
" Loss of all AO Power."
This HED calls for a Caution statement to be added because the cross-tie the operators proposed to use to energize the safeguards bus has a
[
limited amperage rating.
The original resolution called for a I
leading study to be performed to determine the conditions when this i
proposed cross-tie could be used.
After further review of this l
HED, it has been determined that it is not the intent of this procedural step to have the operators use the cross-tie referred to l
l
~ -
~
=
Document Control Desk October 3, 1991 Page 6 in the discrepancy statement.
To prevent any misinterpretation of this step, the procedure will be revised and training will be conducted.
This procedural change will be completed before the end of this year.
For further information, a copy of the revised HED is attached.
METER FACE RANGE ADJUSTMENTS:
The resolution of HEDs 347 and 438 call for the modification of the meter ranges on the meters associated with Containment Spray flowrate and Residual Heat Removal System flowrate.
These HEDs are covered under modification request MR-88-018*D which was scheduled for completion by December 15, 1991.
In order to complete this modification, several of the affected meters require the installation of new sensor capsules.
These capsules have just been received from the supplier.
Once these sensor capsules are installed, the meters will have to be calibrated.
We are still reasonably assured that these modifications can be completed on schedule, however problems with sensor installation and calibration could delay their completion until April 1,
1992.
HEDs 347 and 438 are both classified safety-significant under the Point Beach Nuclear Plant DCRDR scheme.
We had planned on closing out all safety-significant HEDs by the end of 1991, but there is a s
possibility that these two HEDs may not be completed by this time.
The resolution of HEDs 405 and 530 call for the modification of the meter ranges on the meters associated with Pressurizer vapor temperature and Containment Spray flowrate.
These two HEDs are also covered under modification request MR-88-018*D.
We are still reasonably assured that those modifications will be completed on schedule, but for the same reason discussed for HEDs 347 and 438, their completion could be delayed until April 1,
1992.
SPRAY ADDITIVE TANK INLET FLOWMETEBji:
The resolution of HEDs 49, 532, and 611 originally called for the removal of an unidentified scale from all the Spray Additive Tank inlet flowmeters.
These meters each have two scales, one in black with units of gallons per minute, and the other in red without any units.
Further review has determined that the black scale on the meters refers to water flow in gallons per minute and the red scale refers to Sodium Hydroxide flow in gallons per minute.
Because of this, the resolution of these HEDs have been changed to properly identify both scales on these meters.
These meter face modifica-tions will still be completed on schedule.
For further information on these HEDs, the revised records are attached.
.~
=
= -
. Document Control ~ Desk October 3, 1991 Page 7 METER FACE POINTERS:
The resolution of HED 34 calls for the modification of various meter face pointer tips on numerous Control Room panels to ensure that these tips are within 1/16 inch of the scale graduations in order to meet NUREG 0700 guidelines.
'"a possible solutions would be to lengthen the pointer arms of the a"'ected meters or replace all the maters.
It has been decided that lengthening the pointer arms could have an adverse effect on meter reliability, and that replacing the meters is not a cost effective solution.
Since these meters are not-safety significant, it has been decided that no changes will be made because the meter face pointer arms are close enough to.the scale graduations to allow the operator to take readings within the required accuracy requirement $o The resolution of HED 35 requires mod.ifications to be made on all 66 Rod Position Indicator (KPI) pointer arms te prevent them from overlapping the sca2e graduations on the meters, It has been decided not to change the pointer arms because the operators feel that this overlap is necessary to aid in the proper alignment of the control rods.
The resolution of HED 36 calls for changing the meter face pointer arms of several meters located on panels 1C03, 2CO3, 2C04, Col, and CO2.
Currently, these pointor arms are black in color which is in violation of the Control Room color scheme.
Painting these pointer arms red, as required, could have an adverse effect on meter reliability, so it has been decided to make no changes to the meters.
Leaving the pointer arms black still provides sufficient contrast against the white meter face background and still permits rapid operator recognition of pointer position as recommended by NUREG 0700 Section 6.5.2.2C.
The reso1.ution of HED 51 calls for modification of meter face pointer arms to prevent scale numeral concealment on all 66-analog Rod Position Indicators and Sigma 1251 dual scale edgewise meters located on panels C01, 1CO3, 2CO3, 1C04, and 2C04.
To prevent the possibility of affecting meter reliability, the pointer arms will not be modified on any of these meters.
Instead, the dual scale edgewise meters will have the numerals on the side of the meter faces enlarged.
This modification will be completed by the end of 199.. as_previously scheduled.
This change is proposed because this 1
HED is not safety-significant, and the operator will be able to read the larger numerals by slightly repositioning his sight if they are concealed-by the pointer.
This will be possible because the pointer arm is thin in comparison to the larger numerals.
Also, major scale graduations and numerals that are in view can be
Document Control Desk October 3, 1991 Page 8 referenced to verify the concealed numeral.
The required modification will not be performed on the 66 analog Rod Position Indicators due to the small size of the meters.
Their small size will not permit enlarging the numerals any further.
For further information on HED's 34, 35, 36, and 51, the revised Human Engineering Discrepancy records are attached.
Please contact us if there are any questions.
Very truly yours, e
O'(p 0('
^
<' c.
%__ g i
Jame4 J. Zach Vice President Nuclear Power Attachments Copy to:
NRC Resident Inspector NRC Regional Administrator
+
- IlUM AN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD POINT BEACil NUCLEAR PLANT r
IIED NO.: 10
......................u.................................................
1 IEEhTIFICATION Date of Pnniout: 09/0E91 ORIGIN: CONTROL ROOM SURVEY - NUREG 0700 GUIDELINE / CHECKLIST NO.: 611,11 GUIDELINE AREA: VISU AL DISP! AYS I'ROBLl'M CATLOORY: PRINCIPLES OF D15 PLAY i
PROBLEM $UB CATEGORY; INFORM ATION TO 11E DISPLAYED LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM j
PANEL:CO2 l
SYSTEM; ELECTRICAL DIST EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO G02 COMP DESC: DIESEL GENERATOR FREQUENCY COMP NO- 001 COMP DESC: DIESEL OENERATOR IVLQUENCY i
DESCRIPTION OF DISCREPANCY:
l NO INDICATION ON METER F ACE TilAT THE l' AIL Pos! TION 15 60.5. ON ONE OF THE5E METERL, A H AND WRTITEN MAkK INDICATES FAIL POSTTION.
i PRET ARED BY: TOBE)
D ATE: 0$/17/85
(.
PROPOSED RESOLITTION:
- THE ilANDWRTITEN MARK ON THE METER H AS BEEN REMOVED. OPERATORS KNOW TH AT THE j
DE-ENERGlZED POSITION OF THE METER 15 00.5. OPERATOR $ WOULD SUSPECT PO531BLE METER FAILURE WHEN THE DIESEL GOVERNOR WAS BEING ADJU';TED TO 60 0 HZ BUT THE
., (SEE NOTES)
RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM U. EVALUATION HED EXPERIENCED BEFORE?
NO ACCIDENT RELATED?
NO TECHNICAL $PECIFICAT]ON5?
NO ERROR RESGNTTION / RECOVERY EXPECTED' NO SUBJEcl1VE PRIORITY RATING: 6.3 j
HED PRIORfrY; 7 l
HED CATEGORY: ENH ANCEMENT l
REVIEWED AND APPROVED - CRDR TEADA06gbl&pkd 19 $- A. Schelbn NOTES:
. FREQUENCY INDICATED ON THE METER DID NOT CH ANGE THEREFORE, TH E I
-. ~.
HUMAN ENGINEERINO DtSCRLPANCY RLCORD
}OINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLAST HED NO.: 10 CONTINUCD PREVIOUSLY PROPOSED RESOLUTION OF COLOR BANDINO WILL NOT BE USED AND NO l'URTHER ACTION IS NFCESSARY. (PROPOSED RESOLUTION REVISLD 9'9'91) l
e l
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT HED NO.: 31
..............................,.........m..................m I IDE TTIFICATION Date of Ibtout: 09/13/91 ORIGIN: CONTROL ROOM SURVEY - NUREG 0700 GUIDELINF/CIIECKLIST NO.: 6.5.1.5B GUIDELINE AREA: VISUAL DISPLAYS PROBLEM CATEGORY: PRINCIPLES OF DISPLAY PROBLEM SUBCATEGORY:
LDC ATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2003 SYSTEM: TURBINE CONTROL EQU.PMENT: INDIC ATOR COMP NO: GV 1 COMP DE.SC: EH TURB CNTRL GOVERNOR VLV POSTTION GV-1 COMP NO. GV 2 COMP DESC: EH TURB CNTRL GOVERNOR VLV POSITION GV-2 COMP NO. GV-3 COMP DESC: EH TURD CNTRL GOVERNGR VLV POh! TION GV 3 COMP NO: GV-4 COMP DESC: EH TURB CNTRL OOVDtNOR VLV POSTTION GV-4 COMP NO: HED3101 COMP DESC: VALVE POSTTION LIMTT COMP NO. HEDSO2 COMP DESC: GV TRACKING MLTER CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: ICO3 SYSTEM: TURBINE CONTROL EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO: GV-1 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR VALVE POSTTION COMP NO-GV-2 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR VALVE POSTTION COMP NO: GV 3 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR VALVE POSTION COMP NO: GV 4 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR VALVE POSTTION COMP NO HED3103 COMP DESC: VALVE POSTTION LIMTT COMP NO, HED3104 COMP DESC; GV TRACKING MET 13 CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN COhTROL ROOM PANEL: 2C04 SYSTEM: ROD ComOL EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMPNO !*f31-05 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK D COMP NO dED31-06 COMP DESC: CONTROL B ANK C COMP No HED31-07 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK B COMP NO. HEDR08 COMP DESC. CONTROL BANK A COMP NO: HEDJ1-09 COMP DESC: SHUTDOWN E ANK B COMP NO. HEDE10 COMP DESC: SHITTDOWN BANK A CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM
+
PANEL: IC04
$YSTEM: CONDENS ATE EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO: HED31-Il COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK D COMP NO: HEDE12 COMP DESC CONTROL BANK C COMP NO HED31-13 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK B COMP NO: HEDR14 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK A
l e
llUM AN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLAW 11ED NO.: 31 CONTINUED
.....................................................====.=..==..=====.-
COMP NO: IIED31-15 COMP DESC: SHUTDOWN BANK B COMP NO: ItED31 16 COMP DESC: SHUTDOWN B ANK A CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: IC03 SYSTEM: CONDENS ATE EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO: HED31 17 COMP DESC: CONDENSER 1 A VACUUM COMP NO: HED31-15 COMP DESC: CONDENSER 1 B VACUUM CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2004 SYSTEM: CONDENS ATE EQUIPMENT: INDIC ATOR COMP NO: HED31 19 COMP DESC: CONDENSER 2 B VACUUM COMP NO: HEDJ1-20 COMP DFSC: CONDENSER 2 A VACUUM DESCR1FTION OF DISCREPANCY:
GRADUATION llEIGifT OF SCALE MARKINGS SHORTER TilAN REQUIRED PREPAEED BY: TOBEY D ATE: 05 /20/t15 PROPOSED RESOLLTION:
THE TURBINE AND ROD CONTROL METERS LISTED ARE RELATIVELY SM ALL METERS THAT HAVE CORRESTONDINGLY SMALL GRADUATIONS AND DO NOT ll AVE ANY ROOM FOR MODIFICATION. THERE IS NO PROBLEM READING THE CONDENSER METERS, AND THE GRADUATION HEIGHTS ARE.. (FEE NOTES)
RECOMEND ATION LY: CRDR TEAM
....c II. EVALUATION HED EXPERIENCED BEFORE?
NO ACCIDENT RELATED?
NO TECHNICAL SPECIFIC ATIONS?
NO ERROR RECOGNTTION / RECOVERY EXPECTLD?
YES SUPJECTIVE PRIORTTY RATING: 8.3 lied PRIORrrY: 9 HED CATEGORY: METER FACE MODIFICATION REVIEWED AND APPROVED CRDR TEA 11A05gDM&pid by S A. S helhn
............................====.....-==.............................
NOTES:
. NOT SIGNIFICASTLY LESS THAN REQUIRED NO FURTHER ACTION WILL BE T AKEN.
~
IlUM AN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD POthT BEACH NUCllAR PLAhT '
HED No.: 31 CONTINUED (PROPOSED kE&OLUTION REVISED 9/1391) r
( '
e 4
i d
+
t 1
4 I
t e
a w
9:---
T'"'?
HWAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD POLNT BEACH NUCLEAR PLAN
- HED NO.: 32 I IDENTIFICATION Date ofI taut: 09/03 '91 ORIGIN: CONTROL ROOM SURVE Y NUREG 0700 OUIDELINUCHECKLIST NOa 6.5.1.$C GUIDELINE AREA: YbU AL DISPLAYS ISOBLDI CATEGORY: PRINCIPLES OF DISPLAY PROBLD1 SU10C ATEGORY:
LOCATION :
CONTVOL ROOM AREA: M AIN COSTROL ROOM PANEL: 2C20 S) STEM: ELECTRIC AL DIST. COOLANT LQUIPMENT: INDICATORS CohlP NO. D01 COMP DC: BUS D01 VOLTMETER COMP NO: D32 COMP DESC: BUS D02 VOLTMETER COMP NO D03 COMT DUC: BUS D03 VOLTMLTER COMP NO: DN COMP DUC: BUS DN VOLTMLTER COMP NO. 3 Y01 COMP DUC: BUS IYO! VOLTMETER COMP NO. lY101 COMP DESC: EDS 1YOI VOLTMETER COMP NO: 2Y01 COMP DLSC: r'JS 2Y01 VOLTMLTER COMP NO. 2YlDI COMP DESC: BUS 2Y101 VOLTMETER COMP NO: 1YO2 COMP DESC: BUS lYO2 VOLTMETER COMP NO: lY102 COMP DDC: BUS lY102 YO: iMLTER COMP NO: OYO2 COMP DUC: BUS 2Y02 VOLTMETER COMP NO. 2Y100 COMP DESC: BUS 2Y102 VOL.TMETER COMP NO lYO3 COMP DESC: BUS lYO3 VOLTMCTER COMP NO: lYl03 COMP DESC; BUS lY103 VOLTMUTER COMP NO 2Y03 COMP DDC: BUS 2YO3 VOLTMETER COMP NO: 2Y103 COMP DESC. BUS 2Y103 VOLTMITER COMP NO: lYCa COMP DDC: DUS IYM VOLTMETER COMP NO: lY104 COMP DESC; BUS lYl04 VOLTMETER COMP NO: 2YO4 COMP DESC: BUS 2YO4 VOLTMETER COMP NO 2Y104 COMP DESC. BUS 2Y104 VOLTMETER COMP NO: 2LI-49$ COMP DESC: REACTOR VESSEL MIt LEVEL COMP NO. OL1-494 COMP DESC: REACTOR YESSEL WR LEVEL CONTROL ROOM AREN M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: IC20 SYSTDI: RIACTOR COOLANT EQU;PMENT: INDIC ATORS COMP NO-2 LIM 4 COMP DESC: REACTOR VESSEL WR LEVEL COMP NO: 1LI-495 COMP DESC: REACTOR VESSEL VR LEVEL CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: IC04 I
SYSTEM: ROD CONTROL. REACTOR COOLANT;CVC EQUIPMEST: INDICATORS COMP NO: H ED32-01 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK D COMPNO: H ED32-02 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK C I
COMP NO IIED32-03 COMP DESC CONTROL BANK B 1
~
IIUMAN ENGINEFRING DISCREPANCY RECORD
=
Po1NT BEACH NUCL EAR PLAST lied NO.: 32 CONTINUED COMP NO: HED3244 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK A COMP NO: HED3245 COMP DUC. SllUTDOWN BANK B COMP NO: HED3246 COMP DESC: $HUTDOWN BANK A COMP NO: 110D32-07 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK D COMP NO: HED3248 COMP DUC CONTRot. BANK C COMP NO: lied 3249 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK B CGMP NO: HED3210 COMP DESC: CONTtOL BANK A COMP NO: IIED3211 COMP DUC: 511UTDOWN B ANK B COMP NO. IIED3212 COMP DESC: SHUTDOWN BANK A COMP NO. HED3213 COMP DESC: $1TPS' MIN ROD $ PEED COMP No; HED32-14 COMP DESC: RCP NO, IPIB AC AMPS COMP NO: 2F1134 COMP DESC: IETDOWN LINE FLOW COMP NO: 1-F1128 COMP DESC: GPM CHARGING LINE FLOW COMP NO: 1 PI131 COMP DESC: H2O RCP 1 A LABR SEAL DIFF PILU5 COMP NO: 1-PI-124 COMP DESC: H2O RCP 1B LABP. $EAl D1TT PRES $
CohTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROohl PANEL: 2004 SYSTul: ROD CONTROL.REACIOR COOLAhi,CVC EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO 2 SI-401 COMP DESC: STEP $ PER MINUTE ROD SPEED COMP NO: 2-01-134 COMP DESC: GPM LTDN LINE I LOW COMP NO:2 11128 COMP DESC: GPM CHARGING LINE I: LOW COMP NO:IIED3216 COMP DESC: RCP NO 2P1 AC AMPS DESCRIITION OF DISCREPANCY:
VALUE INCREMENTS BETWEEN ORADUATION$ OTHER THAN THOSE DENTED APPROPRIATE.
t
- PREPARED BY; TOBEY DATE: 05/20J35 PROPOSED RESOLUTION:
THESE METER $ WILL BE RESCALED WTTH THE PROPER INCREMENTAL VALVES.
RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM 11 EVALUATION HED EXPLR ENCED B(FOkEt NO ACCIDENT RELATED?
NO TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONh?
NO ERROR RECOGNITION / RECOVERY EXPECTED?
YES SULUECTTVE PRIORTTY RATING 7.3
m m__
s e
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RFrORD POINT BLACH NUCLE AR PLANT HED NO.: 32 COVilNUI D HED PRIORITY: 9 lied CATEGORY: METER F ACE MODITICATION REVIEWED AND APPROVED - CRDR TEAMAREgIhbuS$1eJ by S. A. Schellin NOTES-THE VOLTMLTER FACES ON 2C20 %TLL BE MODIFIED IN 1992 LN CONJUNCTION WITH PDNP's UPCOMING CALIBRATION PROGRAM FOR REO GUIDE 1.97 ELECTRICAL METER $.
THE REST OF THE MI'IT.R FACES WILL RE MODIFIED IN 1991,(8 0 2/91)
... _.... =. ~.
~.
c HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECUP POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT HED NO : 34-
..................w............................................,
L IDENTIFICATION Date of Printout. (M09/91 ORIGIN: CON 11tOL ROOM SURVEY - NUREG 0700 -
OUIDELINUCHECKLIST NO i 6.$42.2B GUIDELINE AREA: VISUAL DISPLAYS PROBLEM CATEGORY: haETERS PROBLEh! SUBCATEGORY: ICINTERS LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN COfGROL ROOM PANEL: 2C20 -
SYSTEM: EPS RCS MfM EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR -
COMP NO: D10% - COMP DESC: BATIT.RY D105 AMMLTER COMP NO: DOS COMP DESC: BAT'IT.RY DOS AMMLTER COMP NO. 2T1-431 A COMP DESC: RCS WIDE RANGE TEMP COMP NO: 2Tl450A COMP DESC: RCS WIDE RANGE TEMP.
COMPNO: 2Ll460B COMP DESC: STM GENERATOR A WR LEVEL COMP NO: 2Ll460A COMP DESC: STM GENE 7.ATOR A WR LEVEL CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2C04 SYSTEM: NIS RCS EQUIPMEPG: INDICATOR COMP NO: N-41 COMP DESC: PERCNT FULL POWER P.R. NO.1 COMP NO: 2 TI423 COMP DESC: DEGREES F PRESSURIZER VAM)R TEMP COMP NO: 2 Tl 442 COMP DESC: PERCNT PRESSURIZER RELIEF TK LVL COMP NO: 2 TI-130 COMP DESC: DEGREES F NON REGEN HX LTDN OUTLET TEMP '
CONTROL ROOM AREAt MAIN COhTROL ROOM PANEL: 2003 SYSTEM: AFW.'.tFW EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO: 2-PI-4044 COMP DESC: AFW PUMP SUCTION PRESS COMP NO: 2 PI 2591 COMP DE5C: HEATER DRAIN TANK PRESSURE CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CorGROL ROOM -
PANEL: C01 SYSTEM: CSS -
EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO; OT36 COMP DESC: CONT SPRAY ADD TANK LEVEL CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: ICO3 SYSTEM: T O EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO: Al 6020 COMP DESC: G AS PURfrY l
l f
i t
i
~
l HUMAN EmotNEERINO DISCREPANCY RECORD POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT.
HED NO.: 34 CONTINUED s
CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: IC04
$YSTEM: RC$
EQUIPMFNT: INDICATOR COMP NO' 1 T1424 COMP DESC: DEGREES F PRES $URIZLR LIQU10 TEMP -
CONTROL ROOM AFIA: MALN COhWOL ROOM PANEL: C01
$YSTEM: RCS j
EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO; L1-3HM COMP DESC: I'ERCENT FUEL OIL STORAGE TK LVL COMP NO: 1 PI-941 COMP DESC: 1-PI-937 ACCUMULATOR B A 2 PRE 55 DESCPJITION OT DISCREPANCY:
ARROW TIPS OF POINTER ARE FURTHER TH AN 1/16' FROM GRADUATION M ARKINGS $CII2E INDICATLD AT LEAST 3/16';.
PREPARED BY: TOBEY DATE: 05/21135 PROPOSED RESOLUTION.
WE PREVIOUSLY STATED THAT THis 15 NtTr CONSIDERED A SERIOUS PROBLEM AND TH AT Tile POINTERS MAY 3E READJUSTED TO BE CLOSER TO THE GRADUATION M ARKINGS IF THE METER FACE li CH ANCED IN REF ERENCE TO OTHER HEDs FURTHrR EV ALU ATION OF (SEE NOTES)
. RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM II. EVALUATION HED EXPERIENCED BEFORE?
No
' ACCIDENT RELATED?
NO TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS?
NO j
ERROR RECOGNrrION / RECOVERY EXPECTED?
YES SUPJECTWE PRIORrrY RATING: 4,5 HED PRIORITY: 9 HED CATEGORY: METER FACE MODIFICATION I
(
REVIEWED AND APPROVED CRDR TEAKIAID6gDES$kJ by 5. A. Schellin NOTES:
1 l
READJUSTING Tile METER NINTFJ'S WAS FOUND TO BE UN ACCEPTABLE SUCli
llUM AN EN0lNLFAING DISCREPANCY RECORD POINT 11EACH NUCLEAR PLAhT HED No.: 34 coNrtNUI.D ATTEMPTED ADIUSTMENTS COULD 300 PARD 17E Tile RELIAttlLITY Of Tile METERS. A5 Tile POINTER AND ATAM l$ INT 1GRAL TO Tile MOVEMENT ASSEM11LY. (PRolV51.D RESOLLTTION kli15ED 94/Yl)
-~~. -. ~. =.-..._--..
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECOkD FOINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT llED NO.i - 35
+
I IDEvilFICATION Date efI%ntout: 09/13'91 ORIGIN: CONTROL ROOM SURVEY. NUREG 0700 GUIDELINE / CHECKLIST NO. 6.5.2.2B OUIDELINE AREA: VISUAL DISPLAYS PROBLEM CATEGORY: METERS PROBLEM SUB-CATEGORY: POINIT.RS LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: IC04 SYSTEM: RRS RPI EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR COMP NO: IIED35 01 COMP DESC: SHUTDOWN BANK A COMP NO: HED354 COMP DESC: SH(rrDOWN BANK B COMP NO. HED35-03 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK A COMP NO: HED35.N. COMP DESC: CONTROL B ANK B COMP NO: IIED35-05 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK C
- COMP NO: ilED35-06 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK D CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANELi 2C04 5YSTEM: RRS RPI, EQUIPMENT: IND.lCATOR COMP NO: RED 35 07 COMP DESC: SHUTDOWN BANK A COMP NO: HED3548 COMP DESC: SHUTDOWN BANK B COMP NO: HED35-09 EOMP DESC: CONTROL BANK A l..
COMP NO: HED3510 COMP DESC: CONTROL DANK B COMP NO: riED35-il COMP DESC! CONTROL BANK C COMP NO: HED3512 COMP DESC: CONTROL BANK D l'
DESCRIPTION OF DISCREPANCY:
POINTER TIP OVERLAPS Ti!E SCALE M ARKING GRADUATION $
=
l.
PREPARED BY; TOBEY D ATE: 05/21/85 l
PROPOSED RESOLtTTION:
THESF POINTER TIPS WILL NOT BE CH ANO D. THE OPERATORS FEEL OVERLAP IS NECESSARY TO AfD IN THE ALIONMENT OF RODS, i
l RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM
...........................~............................................
II. EVALU ATION IIED EXPERIENCED BEFORE?
NO l
l l
r
-c e
-es.
w y
4 A
llVMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD POINT BEAC}l NUCLEAR P1-ANT
- ~
HED Noa 35 CONTINUED
..==....................................................................
ACCIDENT RELATED7 NO TECHNICAE SPECIFICATIONS 7 NO ERROR RECOGNTTION / RECOVERY EXPECTED 7 YES SUIDECTTVE PRIORITY RATING: 8.5 HED PRIOPJrY: 9 IIED CATEGORY: NO ACTION REVIEWED AND APPROVED - CRDR TE AEIANigDMIS$hd by S. A Schellin
. NOTES 1 i
P r--
l' HUMAN ENGINEEP.ING DISCREPANCY RLCORD TOINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT HED ho.: 36 c................................
- 1. IDENilFICATION Date of Pnnumt: 09'09/91 ORIGLN: CONTTIOL ROOM $URVEY - NUREG 0700 GUIDEIDE/CHFCKLIST NO.: 6,$.2.2C OULDELINE AREA: VLSUAL DLSPLAY$
PROBLEM CATEGORY: METERS PROBLEM $UB-CATEGORY: IothTER$
LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN COTUROL ROOM PANEL: 2C04 SYSTEM: RCS EQUIPMENT INDICATORS COMP NO: 2-TI-405 B COMP DESC: DEGREES F DELTA T LOOP 2A-1 COMP NO: H".D36-01 COMP DISC: PCP NO. 2 PIA AC AMPS CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2003 SYSTEM: TURB OAS EQUllMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO: 2-PI 602i A COMP DESC: PS10 H2 PRES $URE COSTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: CO2 SYSTEM: ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO: IIED36-02 COMP DESC: BU$ 3ECTION 4,345 VOLTAGE COMP NO: HED3643 COMP DESC: PLANT DIESEL GENERATION COMP NO hED36414 COMP DESC: DII2EJ GENERATOR N 002 VARMITER COMP NO:llEDM 05 COMP DESC: BATTERY NO. 2 VARMETER COMP NO: HED3646 COMP DESC: BATTERY NO. 2 AMMETER COMP NO. HED36-07 COMP DESC: 345KV LINE 1!! AMMETER COMP NO: HED36 as COMP DESC: DIESEL GENERATO" NO. G01 V ARMITE'R COMP NO: HED36-39 COMP DESC: BATTERY NO. I VOLTMETER COMP NO, HED3610 COMP DESC; BATTERY NO.1 AMMETER CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL R(X)M PANEL: C01
$YSTEM CVC ELECHICAL EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO.1-LI 106 COMP DESC. PERCENT BORIC ActD TANK LEVEL A 1 COMP NO: HED36-ll COMP DESC: 1105 SECTION 2,345 VOLTAGE CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 1C03 5YSTEM: T URBtGEN, EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO: HED36-12 COMP DESC. GENERATOR ELLCTPJCAL LOAD COMP NO: HED36-13 COMP DESC: TURBINE $HAF SPEED COMP NO P12707 COMP DESC. P51G GLAND STEAM PRESSURE
A i-HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD PolhT BEACl! NUCLEAR PLANT HED NOc. 36 CONTINUED DESCRIITION OF DISCREPANCY; VIOLATING Tile STANDARD PLANT CONVENTION (AND CONVEYINO NO $PECI AL DE31GN ATIOh, TilESE POINTEES AD E COLORED BLACK. WillLE THE PRLDOMINANT COLOR 15 RED.
f PREPARED BY; TOBEY DATE: 0$/22/H litol'OSED RESOLUTION:
111E PREVIOU$ PROPOSED RE50LVT10N CALLED FOR RErl.ACINO OR REPAlhTIN0111ESE l_
POINTLR5 WIT 11 ONES WHICH ARE RED, l'URTHER EVALUATION FOUND THAT PAthTING WAS i
UN ACCEPTABLE, SINCE Tile VTJGHT OF TiiE PAINT ON Tile PotNTER COULD ADVER$ELY AITECT. ($EE NOTES) 1 I
RECONIENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM l
- IL EVALUATION llED EXPERIENCED BEFORE7 NO ACCIDENT RELATED7 NO TECilNICAL $PECIFICATION37 NO ERROR RECOGNITION I RECOVERY EXPECTED?
YES SUBJECTIVE PRIORITY RATING: M,0 HED PRIORITY: 9-IIED CATEGORY: METER FACE MODIFICATION REVIEWED AND APPROVED - CRDR TEAMAOligIhh05e)kd by S. A. $shelhn
....=c.......................................................
NOTES;
. METER MOVEMENT, THE ENTIRE METE 2 WOULD H AVE TO BE REPLACED TO CH ANGE POINTER COLOR.: THIS IS NOT CONSIDERED A VIABLE OPTION (PROPOSED RESOLUTION REVISED 9/6N1) i
=
s l
HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD IVINT EEACH NUCLEAR PLANT HED NO.: 43
...........w..........................
I IDENTiflCATION Date of Prmt.mt. Ca'22N1 ORIGIN: CONT 1tOL ROOM SURVEY - NUREO OKO GUIDELINE /CilECKLIST NO.: 6.5.1.5 A GUIDELINE ARIA: V150AL DISPLAYS PROBLTM C ATEDOWY: PRINCIPLD OF DISPLAY MtOBLEM SU4 CATEGORY:
LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL CO2 SYSTEM: ELECTRIC AL DIST EQU1PMENT: INDICATOR 5 COMP NO,146 COMP DESC BUS SECTION 4 345 VOLTAGE COMP NO-108 COMP DESC: INCOMING VOLTMETTR COMP No,110 COMP DE3C: RUNNINO VOLTME1T,R COMP NO. 200 COMP DESC: BATTERY NO 2 VOLTMETER COMP NO,127 COMP DESC: INCOMING VOLTMCTER COMP NO; 129 COMP DESC: RUNNING VOLTMETER COMP NO: 130 COMP DESC: 345 KV LINE Ill AMMETER COMP NO: 133 COMP DESC: G AS TURBINE GENER ATOR B4 AMMETLR COMP NO: 134 COMP DUC: G AS TURBINE GENER ATOR VOLTMETER COMP NO: 199 COMP DESC: BAlTERY No i VOLTMETER CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN COYTROL ROOM PANEL: C01 SYSTEM: ELECTRICAL DIST EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO: 1.
COMP DMC: INCOMING VOLTMErfR COMP NO; 3.
COMP DESC: RUNNING VOLTMETER DESCRIITION OF DISCREPANCY:
GREATER TilAN NINE GRADU ATIONS BETWEEN NUMERALS.
O PREPARED BY: SCHMIDT DATE: 05/2045 PROPOSED RDOLL* TION:
A THE BATTERY VOLTMETER 5 H AVE BEEN REPLACED BY METERS ON PANEL 2C20. THE BUS SECTION 4 345 VOLTMETER FACE WILL BE MODIFIFD. ALL OTHER METER 5 WILL STAY A5 13 BECALSE OF THE RATHER EYTENSIVE EFFORTS REQUlkED TO OBTAIN THE M ARGINAL BENEFTTS. (SEE NOTES)
RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM
............................................u............
1
s 4
s HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD POINT BEACH NUCLEAR PLANT HED NO,: 43 CONTINUED
==....................
II, EVALU ATION HED EXPERJENCED BEFORE?
NO ACCIDFNT RELATED? ~
NO TECHNICAL $PECU1 CATIONS?
NO ERROR RECOGNTTION / RECOVERY EXPECTED?
YT3
$UBJECTIVE PRIORtrY RATINO: 7.7 HED PRIORITY: 9 HED CATEGORY: METER FACE MOD!rlCATION REVIEWED AND APPROVED-CRDR TEADAUGginMIS$hd by S. A. Schelha
.v.........
..........e................................................
NOTES:
. OF CH ANOING THE NUMBER OF ORADU ATIONS BETWEEN NUMERAL 5 TROM 14 TO 9. IN ADDTTION THE INCOMING AND RUNNING VOLTMETER $ ARE USED ONLY WHEN $YNCRONizlNG THE GENERATOR TO THE ORID, AND NONE OF THLSE METERS ARE ACCIDENT.RELATED, Lk
l{Uhl AN ENGINEERING DISCREF ANCY RICOkD FOINT BEACH NUCLE AR PLAhi HED NO.: 4) 1 IDES TIFIC ATION Date of Pnotout:(N!!9N1 OkiCIN: CONTROL ROOh! SI'RVEY - NURI:G 0700 GUIDELINE / CHECKLIST NO.: 6.5.I 4 A GUIDELLNE AREA: VISUAL DISPLAYS PROBLEM CATEGORY: PRINCIPLfJi OF DISPLAY PROBLEM SUB-CATEGORY: PRINTING ON THE DISPLAY F ACI.
LOCATION :
CO?frROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: C01 SYSTEM: CONT AlNMENT SPRAY EQUIPMEST: INDIC ATOR5 COMP NO, 1 11 930 COMP DESC. Gl%1 SPRAY ADDiriVE TK INLIT FLOW COMP NO: 2-F1-930 COMP DESC: GPM SPRAY ADDff!VE TK INLET I LOW DESCRIPTION OF DISCRIPANCY:
RED SCALE UNITS AND PAR AMEl ER ARE NOT IDENTIFIED.
FREPARED BY: SCHMIDT D All' 0021 '85 PROPOSED RESOLUTION:
SEE HED ell.
RECOMEND ATION BY. CRDR TEAM
==...........................e........................
- 11. EVALUATION llED EXPERIENCED BEFORE?
NO ACCIDENT REL ATED?
NO TECHNICAL SPECIFIC ATidNS?
NO ERROR RECOGNTTION / RECOVERY EXPECTED' NO SUBJECTIVE PRIORITY R ATING: 65 llED PRIORITY: 7 HED CATEGORY: METER F ACE MODIFIC ATION R EVIEV ED AND APPkOVED - CRDR TEAUATEyWtirAkJ by S. A Sehelhn
...........,....no
..u...
NOTES:
tPROPOSED RESOL'JTION REVISED 'H18/91)
4 l
llUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RECORD l
IOLNT BEACH NUCLEAR FLANT MLD NO.: 51
...........................................=............===......======
L IDENT1FICATION Date of ivintout: 04/09 91 ORIGIN: CONTROL ROOM SURVEY NUREG OM GUIDELLNE/ CHECKLIST NO.: 6,5.2.2 A GUIDELINE AREA: VISUAL DISPLAYS PROBLEM CATEGORY: METERS PROBLEM SUB-CATEGORY: PO WTERS LOC ATION :
COh"IltOL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2C04 SYSTEM: ROD COSTROL EQUIPMENT: INDIC ATORS COMP NO: HED51-01 COMP DESC. ALL AN ALIX) ROD POSTTION INDICATORS COMP NO: HED5102 COMP DESC: TAVE-TREF DEVIATION METER CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 1CG4 SYSTEM: ROD CONTROL EQUIPMENT INDICATORS COMP NO. HED514)3 COMP DESC. All AN ALOG ROD POSTTION INDICATORS COMP NO: HED51-04 COMP DESC: TAVE-TREF DEVIATION METER CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM e
PANEL: C01 SYSTEM: ROD CONTROL EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO: P13001 COMP DESC' COMPONENT DESCRI? TION NOT FOUND CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2CO3 SYSTEM: TURBINE SYSTEM EQUIPhtFffT: INDICATORS COMP NO. CV-1 COMP DESC: EH TURB CNTRL GOVERNOR VI.V POSTTION GV-1 COMP NO: GV 2 COMP DESC: EH TURB CNTRL GOVERNOR VLV POSTT17N GV-2 COMP NO: GV 3 COMP DESC: EH TURB CNTRL GOVERNOR VLV POSTIls 6N GV 3 COMP NO: HED5105 COMP DESC: VALVE POSTTION LIMTT COMP NO: HED51-06 COMP DESC: GV TRACKLNG METER COMP NO: HED51-07 COMP DESC: GENERATOR ELECTRICAL LOAD COMP NO: HED51-08 COMP DESC: TURBINE Sil AIT SPEED CONTROL ROOM AREA: MAIN CON TROL ROOM PANEL: ICO3 SYSTEM: TURBINE SYSTEM EQUIPMEST: INDICATORS COMP NO: GV 1 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR VALVE IOSTTION COMP NO: GV 2 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR V ALVE POSTTION COMP NO: GV-3 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR VALVE POSTION COMP NO: GV-4 COMP DESC: GOVERNOR VALVT POSTTION COMP NO: HED5109 COMP DESC: VALVr POSTTION LIMTT
\\
Y l
IIUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RFCORD PolhT DEACil NUCLEAR PLANT.
IIED NOa 51 CONTINUED COMP NO: I!ED51 10 COMP DESC: OV TRACKING MITER COMP NO: 11ED31 12 COMP DESC: TURBINE SilAIT SPEED COMP NO IILD5113 COMP DESC: GENERATOR ELEETRICAL LOAD CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN COKrROL ROOM PANEL: Col SYSTEM:
EQUIPMENT: INDICATORS COMP NO: Ll4038'4M0 COMP DESC: TANK A COND STORAGE TANK LEVEL FT COMP NO: Ll4039/4041 COMP DESC: TANK B COND STORAGE TANK LEVil lT COMP NO. IP1940 COMP DESC: COMPONENT DESCRImON NOT FOUFD COMP NO: IP1941 A COMP DESC: COMPONENT DESCR11 TION NOT FOUN, COMP NO: IPI936 COMP DESC: COMPONENT DESCR!! TION NOT FOUND COMP NO: 1P1937A COMP DESC:LOMPONENT DI.SCRIITION NOT FOUND COMP NO: 972'973 COMP DESC: 1-T13RWST LEVEL PERCENT COMPNO. 934'945 A COMP DESC: COMTONENT DESCRITTION NOT FOUND COMP NO 938S39A COMP DFSC: 1 T)4 A SI ACCUM LEVEL PERCENT COMP NO: 2PI940 COMP DESC: COMPONENT DESCRIITION NOT 120UND COMP NO: 2P1941 A COMP DESC: COMIONEhT DESCR! MON NOT FOUND CCMP NO: 2P1936 COMP DESC: COMIONENT DESCRImON NOT FOUND COMP NO: 2P1937 A COMP DESC: COMPONENT DESCRIPTION NOT FOUND COMP NO: 2L1938'939 ACOMP DESC: 2-T34 A St ACCUM LEVEL PERCENT COMP NO: 934'935 A COMP DESC: 1 T34D SI ACCUM LEVEL PERCENT COMP NO: 572/973 COMP DESC: 1-T13RWST LEVEL PERCENT DESCRimON OF DISCREPANCY:
POINTER OBSCURES NUMBERS ON SCALE.
PREPARED BY: ScilMIDT DATE: 05/2 U PROPOSED RESOLITflON:
Tile PREVIOUS PROPOSED RESOLUTION CALLED FOR READJUSTING POINTERS 1F IOSSIBLE, AND EVALUATING DISPLAYS TO DETERMINE IF PRECISE INFORMATION IS NEEDED IN ANY EOP. DUAL METERS WOULD BE EVALUATED FOR PLACINO NUMBERS DOWN CENTER EVALUATION.. (SEE NOTES)
RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM IL EVALUATION llED EXPERIENCED BEFORE?
NO ACCIDENT RELATED?
NO TECl{NICAL SPECIFICATIONS?
NO ERROR RECOGNITION / RECOVERY EXPECTED?
YES
4 llUM AN LNGINIT.RIN9 DibCRl PANCY klCokD IUltfT BLACil NVCLdAR PLAN 1 l
Ill_O NO.: 4i OWitNUl1*
.................a.
.............................~............o.........
$UtJtCIVE litlORrrY R ATlNo; 7.7 115 D l'RitMt!TY: 9 itLD CATLOORY: MITIA I ACF MOD!lICATioN ki: VIEW 1.D AND APISOVLD CkDR TI'ALIAttgthMt5rpk4 t9 8. A. t helhn
..seu........
.......w......................n.........................
NO7Il
. Or MOVING DU AL MPflR NUMBl~RS 10 CIN11R RINUIRIA $M A! L hUMbl.kl'lli AT WOULD Dr.CKLA$E READiBILTTY. IN$1 TAD, NUMBLR5 WILL 110 M ADl; LAR0!*. M'Til AT LIAS Wil' -sE CtWI.RLD BY POINILR OIT.R ATORA WANT OVI2 LAP ON RPI'$ TO AlD IN ROD AllGNMLNT. (9/6f91) i P
d l
- -.-~
s 4
llUMAN l'.NGINI.I.klNO DLiCREl%MCY Rit'Ok!)
POINT BLACH NUCLEAR PLANT itED NO, 72
.............n..........................................
- 3. IDENTil'lCATION Date of Pnewt; 09/1311 ORIOLN: COf(IROL kOOM SURV!'Y NL' REG OKO OUtOILINIVCHr.CKLIST NO,:15 4 4.3C OUIDELINE AREA: CONTROLA l'ROBLial CATIOORY: ROTAkY CUNTROL $PIClilCATIONS PROT 1LEM SUBC ATl40kY: Kl:Y.OPTAATLD CONTROLS LOCAllONt COf(FROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2004 1YSTIAlt ROD CONT *0L CQUh41ENT: CONTROL COMP NO IILD72411 COMP DDC: ROD CONTROL COUt(l'I R RLil*r CONTROL ROOM AkEA: M AIN CONTROI ROOM PANT.L: IC04
$YSTEA1 ROD CONTROL I,QUl"M LNT; CONTROL COMP NO. IIED?2 02 COMP DIAC: ROD COffi7.0L COUN11.R 1031*I DESCRIPTION Or D15CRLPANCY:
Of LRATOR8 ARE ABLE TO RulOVETilE KEY f ROM THE LOCK Will N Tile $ witch la IN IUllTIONS OTHOR THi.N 'Orr* OR '&AlI' PRLPARED BY; H ARLEY D ATL: C' FM PROPOSED RD01 UTION,
THl: KEY 15 klalO' 10 i ROM WH AT 15 CON!,IDEkl.D A "3 Af t? lusillaN Al ILA litt EOD CONTROL COUffTif s ll AVE lil.EN Rtal:T. THUE $W17t '1101 ARE NOT UhED DURING NORM AL OPIRATION, A CHECK OF UNIT l 5HOWED TilAT Tit ( KEY CANNOT ist RIAlOVED WHILL IN Tile. GEL NOTES)
RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TI.AM t
II. EVALUATION Hi D (Wl'ERIENCLD BILIORi?
hO ACCIDENT RE LATED?
rio TICitNICAL $PECillCATION57 NO 11ROR RI COGNITION / kECOVERY IXPrerEDT YD SUlulCTIVE PRIORITY RATING 5.2
-... _ - ~ _. - -
6 llUMAN EN0lNf131NO DISCREPANCY RLCORI' lolNT !!LAcil NUCLLAR PLANT 110D NO : 72 CORTINt'1 D HI D PRIORTTY: 9 Hl.D CA1 LOORY; CONTROL MODif ICATION 7
REVIEWLD AND AI'I'ROVID CRDR TLAMAthykh31$kJ 9 5. A. $th:thu 6..........................................
NOTL5:
- Rt.5ET* lo$rriON THL50 KEYLOCK1 DO NOT N11D 10 ILE RI PLACID.
t F
l 4
2
---c-
.,c-m...
.-m4--...-r-
.#--r,-
v
,,w.-w,,
r HUM AN ENGINLLRING Dl%Ckt.PANCY RLCORD POINT Ill ACH NUCLLAk Pi ANT HiD NO : 152
..............................................s............
- 1. IDIN11FICATION Date of Pi niet, WO3'91 CRIGIN. CONTROL kOOM $URVI:Y NURLO 07W OULDI LINL' CHECKLIST NO.: 6 31.2B GUIDLLINE ARLA. YliU AL DISPLAY $
PROBLEM CATEGORY: PRINCIPLt.145 D15 PLAY PROBLLM $UBCATIOORY USABILITt OF D15PLAYLD V ALUE LOC ATION :
CONTROLkooh8.JLA; M AIN CONTVOL ROOM I'AN LL: ICD 4 YSTI.M; AOD CONTROL
'QUIPMENT: INDIC ATOR$
~ (P NO HEDil241 COMP DI.5C: CON!*0L It ANK$ A.B.C.D N.4P 30: HED182 02 COMP DLSC: CONTROL B ANK STI:P COUN11.R5 CONTROL ROOM ARLA M AIN COVrROL ROOM PAN Li. 0004 SYSTLM ROD CONTROL LQUlFMLNT; INDIC ATORS COMP NO. HLDlI2-03 COMP DLSC CONTROL BANKS A.B.C.D COMP NO lif D182-04 COMP DESC: CORIROL BANK $11 P COUNTERS DL5CRIPTION Of DISCRLPANCY:
ROD I%ITION INDICATOR $ READ IN INCHt3 $1LP COUNTT15 RLAD IN 511 PS. WITil E ACH STi> LQU ALING. 8 INCil 0
PREPARE D BY. Tolt! Y DATL OU3n 85 PkolosrD kl3OLUTION:
$1 L HED 348.
kECOMLNDATION fiY: CRDR TEAM
- 11. LVALUATION HLD LNPERlLNCED Bt lOkt ?
NO ACCIDENT kLt.ATLD?
NO TT.CHNICAL $Pl.Cl)ICATION51 NO ERFOR RECOGNITION / RI.COVLRY IMPLCILD?
NO
$UPJECTIVE PRIORITY R ATING. t 8 HED PklORrrY-7
.m-u s
s s
3 lil'M AN I NO1NI1 RING DISCRif ANCY klTOllD lillN^f' Bl Acil NLICLI.AR l't. ANT j
IILD NO ; 182 CONTINUt D
.................................................................,..m.
lLLD CA1LOORY: MiILR I ACE MOD!llCAlloN REVirw1D AND Al'i'ROVI D CRDR TL ALIAUhythbitt@Ad l') $ A $6bellm NOTl_S:
_._m-
- 9 :
-' a
[.~
lg _ t H!fM AN ENGINEFAING D15CkiPANCY RICORD lolNT BLACH NUCLI AR l'LANT IIED NOa 189
.......................................................................u
- 1. LCIRTirbCATION Dew of Iwntout: 08'21!91 l
ORIGIN. COK110L ROOM $URVEY + NUR10 OKO Gl'lDELINI? CHECKLIST NO : 6.51.5 Al GUIDEllNE AREA: V15UAL D15 PLAYS ISOBLD4 CATEGORY: ItlNCIPLIJ OF D11 PLAY ftOBLui $UB C ATI.OORY2 LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: CO2R
$YST Dt: Tt'R E'O EN EQUIPMINT: INDIC ATOR$
COMP NO: 108 COMP DOC; (NCOMING VOLTMETER COMP NO.110 COMP Df3C. RUNNING VOL1 METER COMP NO: HED32 22 COMP DDC: O A$ Tl'tBINE 00ht1ATOR VOLTMETIA
)
COMP NO. N A COMP DDC: 1 A$T 57 ART OOVfRNOR RDL7 CONTROL ROOM AREA M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: C0lR RY$ TEM FIRE IROTECT EQUIPhGNT: INDICAToks COMP NO: P13708 COMP DDC: ilRE % ATER HEADIA itt.$$URE CONTkol ROOM AREA: M AIN CON 110L ROOM PANEL: IC04R
$YSTEM: RCS EQUaPMENT: INDICA 10R$
COMP NO: 1 Tl 418 COMP DDC. kEAC10R FLANGE LEAK OIT llatP CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2CN SYSTDt. RC$
EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR $
COMP NO: 2 Tl 418 COMP DDC: REACTOR T LANGE LEAK OFT TDiP DESCRIPTION Of Di$CREPANCO THE MLTFR F ACE SCA1 E H A$ GREATER TH A N NINE GRADU ATION$ BETMTEN NUMFJ ALS PREPARED BY: TObEY D ATE: 0N01/85 PROPOSED RDOLUTION:
' FAST START OOVERNOR RutT 11 NOT A METTA. TOR THE INCOMING, RUNNING, AND O AS TURDINE OLNERATOR VOLTMLTER$. $LE HED 43. THL REST OF THE MLTIAS WILL
^
Hs VE THEIR METLR FACE $ REPLACED
]
e s
HUM AN LNOINE1. RING Di&CRIPANCY klCORD IUlvr BLACH NUCLT>.R I't. ANT lit.D NO : IW CONilNt!ED RICOMt.ND ATION ELY: CRDR TE AM
........u...............................................................
Il (*V ALU ATION HED l'XPERIENCED BEFORE?
NO ACCIDLNT RELATED?
NO TLCHNICA1. $PIr1TICATioNst No ERROR RICOGNTT10N / RfCOYFJtY E.YPl. CIT.D?
Y13
$UIL'LCTIVE PklORrrY LATINO: 7.7 IIED PRIORITY: 9 llED CATf OORY: MLTER I ACE MODil'ICATION REVIEWI D AND APPROVID. CRDR 1LALIAMythMtir)k d t=y & A. &$helim NOTf3:
PROPO$LD Rr3OLtTTION REV15LD L'22/91.
?
r 1
,s e
llOM AN ENGINFI.RINO DISCRLPANCY kl. CORD IU1N"I llLAcil NUCLI.AR PLANT
^
- lit.D NO : 345
- 1. IDENTilICATION Date of thtst WO.U91 ORIGA OITR ATOR QUISTIONNAIRL3 AND INT 13tVil:W$
GUIDLLIMI.'CitLCKLtsT NO.; 6.5 OUIDillNE ARLA: VISU AL D15f' LAY $
PkollLEM L ATI.OORY: N/A l'Rolit.LM SUB CATLOORY: N'A LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM ARE A: M AlN COf(TROL ROOM PAN! L: 2001
$Y511 M-CONTROL I.QUIPMENT. INDIC A10RS.Rl'1 INDICA 10ki D13CRll' TION Or DISCRI PANCY; ROD IU$ttlON INDICAllVN kl AD$ IN INCill3. WillL1 $TLP ( ).JNTER 15 !N STI P5. ONI.
$TrP f(eU ALS $'8 INCilla A1301HL RP15 ARL SM ALL AND IN DIYl$10NS Of 3 WTill HLAVY LINIA IOR IVE RY 12 INCHI3 AND NUMillR$ 1:VI.RY 24 INCill3 eri RA1DR MUST COUNT TO DLTLRMINI ROD WTTilDR A% Al. DisT ANCL PRETAR LD itY: il ANNU.14N D ATI. Il!!5'It3 PROlVSED RL50LtrilON:
METI:R l' Act Cll ANOI $ % ILL 110 M ADL TO l.l.lMIN ATI'.THE STI P5 V$. INClli.$ AND klaDAllLITY DMCRilANCILS.
RECOMINDAlloN llY. CRDR TL AM
...ou.
Il I V ALU AllON lirD [2iT.RIENCED Bl 1 URI:?
Yl3 ACCIDINT RELATIF No TECilNICAL 5PLCl) Ic ATION5?
YIS LkROR RECOGNITION / RLCOVERY EXilfilD?
NO CUluirTIVE I'RIORTTY R ATING: 5.7 it
. It! D PRIORTIY. 5 1100 CATLGORY: Mn LR I ACE MODlilCATION RE\\114 LD AND AI'I'kOVLD CRDR TL AMA0 fig (%OSrpid l>> $ A. Sehelhn
..a..........
.......u.......a......s.......
.u.......
...u..ue..
..s..
NO TL5:
/
a S
HUMAN ENGINil11NO D150REl%NCY RICORD IVINT BEACll NUCLEAR PLANT i
e fitD NO. 457
....................................n....,...........
i
- 1. IDENTillCATION Dele oll% nim: Odll&!91 ORIGIN: VI AllICATION OUID111NE/CilECKLIST NO.: 0 0 OUIDELINE AREA: GUIDELINE AREA NOTIOUND PRoltLIM C ATEGOkY: N/A PROBLEM SUB-CATEGORY: N/A LOCATION !
CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANELt CO2
$YSTial: EPS EQUIPMENT: PROCEDURE DESCRII410N Of DISCREPANCY:
(CCA 0.0 S A) CAUTION $110ULD BE ADDED WilEN PROCEDURE $ AYS TO M ANUAL LY LNERGlZE
$Al1%UARD5 BUS $1NCE THE $AlEOUMDS AND NON $Al EOUARDS BU5 TIE II A$ LIMTTED -
AMPER AGE RATING PREPARED BY 1001Y DATE: 12/10:13 PROIU51 D R E50LUTION:
IT 15 NOT Tilf INTENT OF Tile STEP IN QUESTION To ll AVE Tilf OPERATOR $ U50 Tile BUS TIE REFERRED TO IN Tile DISCREPANCY, TO PREVDTT Tllis MlilNTIRPH ETATION EROM OCCURING, Tilt PROCEDURE WILL BE REV15ED AND TR AINING WILL BE CONDUCTI D.
-t RECOMENDATION BY: CRDR TEAM II. EVALUATION llED LXPE8(!f NCED bel ORD NO
- ACCIDENT RELATED?
YI3 TECilNICAL SPECIFIC ATION5?
No ERROR RI~ COGNITION / RECOVI RY EXPECTI D?
YES
$UldE4TIVE PRIORITY RATINO: 7.2 If ED PRIORITY: 3 IIED CATEGOR Y: PROCEDUR AE Cil ANGE REVIEWED AND AftROVED CRDF TEAM.
DATE: /r NOTI.5 (R EVISED 11/19 87, PRolaOSED RESOLUTION REVISED 9/llWI)
/
_. ~..
_....-.~-.....-.. _.-.. -
-t t
j e
t
!!UMAN ENGINI.! RING D15CRI'PANCY RICORD l
h)lNT DEACil NUCLEAR Pl. ANT llLD NOa $32
- 1. IDENTil1 CATION Dm of f thema: 09/19S1 ORT.!N: VI~AITICATION OUlDELINI/CifECKLIST NO.:0 t
'UIDELINE AREA:1.AILELJ AND LOCATION AID $
OBlut CATI'OORY: N!A (ROBlut $UBCATEGORY: N/A LOCATION :
CONTitOL kOOM AREA: M AIN CO!(TROL ROOM.
PANELtCOI
$YSTEM: $15,C53 1:QUIPMENT: LAllELS COMP NO 2TI 930 COMP Dl5C: OPM $Pk AY ADDITIVE TK IN!.LT l LOW DFSCRilTION OF DISCREPANCY:
(EOP 01.4(4)J NO INDIC ATION Til AT Tl8E kl D NUMitLP.ED $CA1 E !$ N AOli OR Wil AT Tile INCRDtENTS AkE.
PR EPARED BY: TOlliY DATE 12/lDiB4 I ROM)s[D ktSOLUTION:
SEE llED fill.
kECOMENDATION 11Y: CRDR T1.AM -
.............n....................
4
......c.....................
II. EVALUATION ll[D EXPERIENCED 11Li'ORL?
YE$
ACCIDENT RELATED?
NO TECHNICAL $PECIFICATION11 NO EP,ROR RECOGNITION / RECOVI.RY lWITCIED?
YE3 i
I,UDJECTIVE PRIORITY R ATINO: 6.2 111.D PRIORITY: 8 ilED CATEGORY: METER l' ACE MODIFICATION RLVIEWED AND APPROVED. CRDR 'IE ALIAMgthMurpid by $, A, $rh4lhn
.........m..................................e...........:......
Nt(TIS:
(PROPOSED RESOL UllON REV151D 9/18'91) a-e w r r v w.-
ww--,
=--e,
=,,- e-
-v w --
.wec- -
~e-ew,wv,.e-s-.%-n-1=,e-we - y,w,+
=v + +,+ r-
=v.-
e-- + e erew e--w r ww
g gg -
s I!UM AN ENGIN11 RING DISCREPANCY RI CORD MilNT BEACll NUCLEAR PLART llED NOa 611
- 1. IDLNTillCATION Date of 1%nkmt:Wl9'91 ORIGIN: VLRITICATION GUIDI.LINr/CitiCKLIST No : 6.$
GUIDELINE ARLA: VISUAL DISPLAYS PROBLlat C ATE 00R Y: N/A PROBLEM SUltCA11 GORY: N'A LOCATION 2 CONT 1tOL ROOnt AkF A; M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: Col SYSTEM: C55 LQUIPMENT: INDICATOk5,2 l'1930 DISCRIPTION OF DISCREPANCY:
(EOP415)THis METER H A5 Two stPARATE SCALES ON IT lit t HED NO $32)
PREPARI:D BY: TOBEY D ATE: 12/15'!3 PROPO5ED RISOLtfTION; Tile BLACK SCAll' 15 TOR WATI k I LOW AND Tile RED NUMBElts Aki' I OR N Anti ll.OW. Till WATLR FLOW $CALE 15 NOT NLEDI D IN lilE CONITOL RO(Al,50 IT WILL BE kEMOVLD AND THE SCALE CORkE5lONDING 10 Tile RED NUMht R5 WILL BL Till ONLY SCAll. ON 1 HE MITER (500 NOTIS)
.1 RECOMENDAllON BY: CkDR TEAM 18 EV A1.UATION llED EAPl'RILNCLD BIl-ORF?
NO ACCIDENT RELATI D?
YE5 TI CilNIC AL 5PI CITICATION5?
Yl?,
EkkOR RfCOGNTTION / PECOVERY LXPECTED?
YI.5
$UIUECTIVE PklORrrY RATING; 5,5 HI D PRIORrrY; 3 HLD CATEGORY: M17i R I ACE MODiIICATION R EVIE%TD AND API kOVID, CRDR TLAMAtD6ginMu$bt by 5 A. $<helhn NOTES:
THE UNITS AND PARAMETIR Of THE FED SCAL E WILL BE IDLNTillt.D tl Rol'Osl D I
_______-_]
s g.
4 HUMAN ENGIN00RIMG DISCREl%NCY RECORD s
lotNT BIACil NUCLEAR PLANT lit D NO.: 6 tl CONTINULD RE301.lfl10N REYiSED 9/15NI) 1
t t
6 HUMAN ENGINEERING DISCREPANCY RLCORD 10lRT BEACH NUCLEAR PLART HED No.: 770
- 1. IDENT!fl0ATION Date of IYuuout: 09/13'91 ORIGIN: VERIFICATION OU1DELINE/CiltrKLIST NO.: 6.5 GUIDELINE AREA: VISUAL DISPLAYS PROBLEM CATEGORY: N/A 19.OBLEM SUBCATEGORY: NIA LOCATION :
CONTROL ROOM AREA: M AIN CONTROL ROOM PANEL: 2C20 SYSTEM: COMPRMSED AIR & GAS EQUIPMENT: INDICATOR 5 COMP NO: 2HI 964 COMP DESC: CONT HYDROGEN CONC COMP NO: 2HI-966 COMP DESC: CONT HYDROGEN CONT COMP NO. 2HI-965 COMP DDC: CONT HYDROCEN CONC COMP NO:2H1467 COMP DESC: CONT HYDROGEN CONC DESCRIITION OF DISCREPANCY FOUR llYDROGEN AN ALYZERS FROM CONTAINMENT ARE DISPLAYED ON ASIP BtTT ONLY TWO ARE PPIS $URE COMPENS ATED (H A 964, 963). THE OTHfJt TWO ARE i-OR READING LOCAL HYDROGEN LEVELS (EG. PRES $URI RELIEF T ANK $EAL TABLE)
PREPARED BY: TOBEY DATE: 01/2016 PROPOSED RDOLUTION:
ALL FOUR HYDROGEN ANALYZERS ARE PRES $URE COMPEN5 ATED,50 Tile DiSCREP ANCY STATEMENT 15 LNCORRECT. NO ACTION NEED$ TO BE TAIEN, n
RECOMEND ATION BY: CRDR TEAM
- 11. EVALUATION HED EXPERIENCED BEFORE?
NO ACCIDENT RELATED?
YES TECHNICAL $PECIFICATIONS?
NO ERROR RECOGNITION / RECOVERY EXPECTED?
YL5
$UBJECTIVE PRIORITY RATING-7.3 HED PRIORrrY: 3 HED CATEGORY: LABELING
4 e
4 0
3 HUM AN l'N0lN1l'.klNO DISCRI PANCY klO*U 8%)lNT lil~.Aril NUct 1 AR l'lANT s t til.D No 770 CON 11NUI,D
.....................====****"**************************'**' '
FI Vil%l.D AND AltkuY!D. CRDR TI.ALIAt%glWIS$kJ t; 5 A khelhn
..u................
NOT.5-(PROlt:51 D kl3OLtTIION klTl51,D 8?l)*l) r 8*e e