ML20076M064
| ML20076M064 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Washington Public Power Supply System |
| Issue date: | 07/13/1983 |
| From: | Bell N NORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES (FORMERLY COALITION |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20076M062 | List: |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-CPA, NUDOCS 8307200131 | |
| Download: ML20076M064 (3) | |
Text
_ _ . _ _. ... ..
, __ . - . _ _ _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ . , c -
l -
4 :. % & s % W ;
.* '-'
- In.txtu) Cc:cG_sPONDENO. Ffb.~1dy@yWA a l fCUdMik jy M.
i -
t UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
,a
( r . - Q ,y & 4 p, ,4 %
BEE 9EE_IHE_aIQUI9_E6 EIY_aED_kIGENSIEg_BQ68Q f j i .,k, , g: ,~' c1 In the Matter of ) ' Y 91 u
) &.'Y?4i&w, f$ 2, l WASHINGTON PUBLIC POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM > Docket No. 50- 46QCPALhr.,4~ S.
et. al. ) - d '; .
~ m .
(WP?SS 'Juclear Project No.'l) ) , ' '.M .
G'
- .m . -
\
. - - ( Q, '
l i 99akIIIGE__E98_E6EE_29EEE_59II9E_I9_G95EEb_6Esyggg_Ig_gECONDYQEL a
9E_INIEEE99aI9EIEE_I9_6EEk19aEIt_29b1_13t _1983. ; ,4;g r MD-The Coalition for Safe Power, intervenor in the Eh . ':Mti $
'N above-captioned proceeding served copies of its second setIN ,
.a.'i?.; K. _ ,,
interrogatories on Applicant on June 9, 1983. Applicant reEpodi 9
. ',dn interrogatories 19, 21,'22,d.-25 N :
on June 28, 1983 and objected to ti
.. w ;. V e- ' ..
r m .y ;
27, 28, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 38, 42, 43,"44, 45, and 47. . jyy _ , j
~
j
- ntervenor hereby moves for an Order causing Applicantito... 3
- Q..
respond to interrogatories 25, 27, 28, 31, 32, 35, 38,-and 42(an b
, ,, j -3 '
to respond more fully.to interrogatories 26 and 50forwhicN,%f
'Mi inadequate responses were provided.
[a sg-v.)- M. -
m
- 1. Interrogatories 31, 32, 35, and 38 refer to th[ neb h-idil.- -
Initial Decision (LBP-75-72, 2 NRC 922) upon which the 7
- x. .w ,
. kN. .V; const:: uction permit for the WNP-1 was issued, the role of -;; e BP,A
.;fg_f ,
and how it was established in the ASLB decision. Applicanti.;;.
relies upon the BPA recommendation as the basis for the
~ '??'i&
m WP-W %4.q5- : N" additional extension request at issue in this proceeding. %: . Thei :.. m ~
interrogatories as.they. seek to establish the legal basis
.~4NQ r g,g.
Applicant's reliance on the BPA recommendation concern ' issues y.' .
which are properly discoverable.
4.id@ddh q
.gQ,393
- > ., .c. ;. 4 y
- 2. Interrogatory 25 seeks to discover thediS'ferencebAtw'AenphigA}
- v. m ,a
,v. p,.A three terns which have been used by A'plicant p and the BPAlto'cGU *
"N
,, . :=t .e gin 8307200131 830713 . %%
w Z'Wfk(c' PDR ADOCK 05000460 -
Smi u . .. O . . . . _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _
. _' y
. . - . .-. -. . .. n.. ---- . . - . .
. * .. .q. -W*c3:.
3 , .c c w _ g ~. . yay .
~~- p.Y.
describe the states in which the WNP-1
-mab; and WNP-3 plants_ have,been[.rW ji?:k LE'Y * %'tR=
placed. Intervonor is.not attempting to raise health andfaafety r.i W w T,494 - e
?
issues by this request but only seeking to discover the3 meaning M..ya. g,
. .E , :S~WWf,.iid.
- c:4-+nwe %1k, n
.. .p
- s.
of terms used by'the parties ~ and their agents k in the news ,,<.:- :a nedia: A.,4 *f nd@";y. C5 s . m y ; ., and public documents'.W9. B ...@
-l,k * ,-
..~.
- $ jMM;'k Applicant objects to'. interrogatories 27, 28 an'd42': 3* .,.I!5 ~
M K:,w. W,.4 ', 3. stating that the effect of other of Applicant's projects on thegyg k.'. ~2 W N- -
;l$ & h Qy *'
deferral of WNP-1 15 irrelevant.- The WNP-3 Decision DocumentM M F( M
- .;ft : vng;%d" establishes that thelrestart of construction of WNP-1-iaMf3fMWF! ' 30 C.
. .. :iS". ::.7. s Mf) a .
g -.. inevitably and incontrovertably tied to the restart ofa.?4 M
@~DMi '.kk 6t b l construction of WNP-3 G.See e.g. pages 40, 75, 23. The WNP-3 . -g?.M. Mr . w ,.J '
+W Uw
. .pn e - - W:
..:= 2-w,.-w Decision Document,also;. i establishes that the on ;
_m potential ' default' .m:wpw, .q ,
. n e. . ., gf3 WNP-4/5 and other events surrounding these terminated unitalTeig .
y
~
R%%:%- ., . 4 contractors claims on'4 and 5I will affect the continued bd e N
~
r',~.'. .i ' w- n FJf
;Qy$
construction of UNP-3 and WNP-l. See eg. pages 2, 3, 21. --1Th airp;4 h.w. f naterial is properly discoverable as the basis for.a showing c g .k N(.]&f-4
' Q.hgri a
" encompass [ing3'a'i'F.H 8.yM N
- G
" good cause" which ALAB-722 defines as
<JrCL,- w. y. %y . w ki M44g st h.o Judgement about why the plant should be complete and is N.D t.N;w v&WM.-~s -
yu . M M.in.p,t a-y, ..W,%.y g rest soley upon a Judgement as to the applicants f ault fori..}.q.J; dg-gm;/,c, ;
+;& . T-@Jw c.
delay." A:A3 722 goes on to say " A Judgement must still be'ny:gt madeM q'J%,'. , 4 vMMM
< . -M.'.@2MS-as to whether continued construction should nonetheless.be-. ,
7 s -.m cn.. : 4.L
; -O M%.s m n6Z. "-
allowed." i D '$fkp
- 6. :F'
. . p :- .
be ordered.to 5 g.sr*A-
- 4. Intervenor further moves that the Applicant t.,.
y respond fully to interrogatories 26 and 50 because the provided ' h.: N._# J ;ft.y.
%~ f c ..
- i. . .y r e s p o r.ses were inadequate and lacking in substance entirely. : gf. .g
, p q'I n.;
f;.c ., Regard.ng interrogatory 26, Applicant should " explain fully the .= v.-5f A i . . >.p.1-QF : answer", showing how each factor identified affects the reatcrt: M,-M.I.! :..,:
.w- x. a .
of constr"uction of WNP-1 and how the decision will made for each ,.,Z. ~p 9.-
. ' '$ e
, l W.. ~( . ,l < ..
- _ - - _ _ _ _ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ - . _ _ _ _ kh
s - . - . w __ - ~ . - . - ___ _ _ _ _ _
. t. .
g.g,.
. .. ~ :
. . , , 2,.:;;.py@n;
<N-. 'M,. ,
~
3 ,.fi,y.-
~
+
x Y. ' ~
..* . sty lq , .
"?.*'=0 g .Q
- nterrogatory SC addresses the ongoing question of the 'f.S ;'9 .i.>:)P!
. r .: * .uy .h ;-:y st w; h. '?
constitutionality of Washin~gton State Intiative 394 which' hasp ~% .l..
- t $ g. .i. g).'43 serious implications according to the WNP-3 Decision Docunent'. , R - W . '* -~ 3jdN )
i
* <^ h~x.pMf.62 Applicant fails entirely to provide a basis for its res ndhfa+m.,. e .. .,.. ,
%A requested in the face of the interrogatory. . , j ' D .h'i S.4.CE9'! "'t '. . .4 -
.. Eh.; . hh'hj x x 2
~
Respectfully submitted, +1 ~ : '.'N
.g
*%d. W @f3 M
) '" [* i :- ' . . . _ _ _ M ____ __ _._,, !$g Dated this day, the 13t ina Bell . _ .,-;;y , , of July, 1983. *' Coalition for Safe Power]?$R*2 l'.'5 M;;k -
. :+8j@ ,
'M(5$d Os' m,.
wyY 4.gw-J4J.M,
-:.. .w.4h 'm TjEN;'Y. - 1
. . ,, -)st
. , "9
.#. .w == 44g. ~
*8
. m %c.
.s ~54
.....?.)Mt?u
.o.
.ggg ^f.22 dd
,%'r +*
o x e , 4 MN . 'M ... E
, .+,?'p.'f.k I '. . w N
- " Jigfy.
4
.'3 w
;;;; %. $ j]f,4 % '
... s .c.o I
*1". V. r.u. sM to .
. Y$ . .
' mm
*t,,
W-A,E% r.4.- . i
. i + , j,p.r . - - , .. 'Tr
.v';%.4.d$%ig
' N$, s'$.: h'enf*
-- es if ','@4als
~d:", C
-Af2*kYp h ht M a.wga.s
" 4 4'.s.. 4h.. ~t n- " " O..
?,C.
% :n *- k
.0 I-
.w.v.cunes
, 0 Sih
.w.am,. $[fhD$ f
. y- 3.Ng- a. ? 3.-v44 6a.wns;
.. 1 -
,-cn'.
- m. Sh
*s e - f.b , r;. k3 .- -Cf w
d' k . !h Y kh l
- MM $b38dM
-}}