ML20059G895
| ML20059G895 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | North Anna |
| Issue date: | 10/31/1993 |
| From: | VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20059G842 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9311090173 | |
| Download: ML20059G895 (16) | |
Text
._.
i I
ATTACHMENT 1 CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT NORTH ANNA 2 CYCLE 10 PATTERN RE 1
REVISION 1 OCTOBER 1993 i
t l
l l
i 1
I N2C10/RE Core Opertaing Limits Report, Rev.1 (Oct. 93)
Page 1 of 16 1
9311090173 931102
- ?
PDR ADDCK 05000339 x
P PDR
CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT N2C10 Pattern RE 1.O INTRODUCTION 1
5 The Core Operating Limits Report (COLR) for North Anna Unit 2 Cycle 10 has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of Technical Specification 6.9.1.7.
The Technical Specifications
~
affected by this report are listed below:
3/4.1 1.4 Moderator Temperature Coefficient l
3/4.1.3.5 Shutdown Bank Insertion Limit l
3/4.1.3.6 Control Bank Insertion. Limits 3/4.2.1 Axial Flux Difference l
3/4.2.2 Heat Flux Hot Channel Factor 1
3/4.2.3 Nuclear Enthalpy Rise Hot Channel Factor s
and Power Factor Multiplier l
The cycle-specific parameter limits for North Anna 2 Cycle 10 for the specifications listed above are provided on the following pages, and were developed - using the - NRC-approved methodologies specified in Technical Specification 6.9.1.7.
j i
l 1
I
)
i I
t N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Repon, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 2 of 16
+
I
..,,.,-,._-,,,c,-..,,-,-..,-n,.,-,,,,--,
j 2.O OPERATING LIMITS 2.1 Moderator Temperature Coefficient (Specification 3/4.1.1.4) 2.1.1 The moderator temperature coefficient (MTC) limits are:
I The BOC/ARO-MTC shall be less positive than or equal to
+0.6E-4 Ak/k/ F below 70 ' percent of RATED THERMAL POWER.
The BOC/ARO-MTC shall be less positive than or equal to 0.0 Ak/k/"F at or above 70 percent of RATED' THERMAL l
POWER.
The EOC/ARO/RTP-MTC shall be less negative than
-5. 0E-4 Ak/k/'F.
I 2.1.2 The MTC Surveillance limits are:
The 300 ppm /ARO/RTP-MTC should be less negative than or equal to -4. 0E-4 Ak/k/'F.
The 60 ppm /ARO/RTP-MTC should be less negative than or equal to -4.7E-04 Ak/k/'F.
l where:
BOC - Beginning of Cycle ARO - All Rods Out EOC - End of Cycle i
RTP - RATED THERMAL POWER i
2.2 Shutdown Bank Insertion Limit (Specification 3/4.1.3.5) i 2.2.1 The shutdown rods shall be withdrawn to at least 225 steps.
i 1
2.3 Control Bank Insertion Limits (Specification 3/4.1.3.6) 2.3.1 The control rod banks shall be limited in physical insertion as shown in Figure 1.
4 i
1 I
J N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Repon, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 3 of 16
l t
t 2.4 Axial Flux Difference (Specification 3/4.2.1)-
2.4.1 The AXIAL FLUX DIFFERENCE Limits are provided in Figures 2 and 3.
l I
2.5 Heat Flux Hot Channel Factor-F (Z) (Specification 3/4.2.2) o 2.5.1 The F (Z) limits are:
o 2.19 I
- K(Z) for P > 0.5 F (Z) s o
P s
F (Z) s 4.38
- K(Z) for P s 0.5 o
l THERMAL POWER I
where:
P = -------------------
and RATED THERMAL POWER K(Z) is provided in Figure 4.
t 2.5.2 The F (Z) Surveillance limits are:
[
o 2.19 K(Z)
F (Z)" s ----
for P > 0.5 o
P N(Z)
K(Z) 1 F (Z)" s 4.38
- ----- for P s 0.5 o
N(Z)
THERMAL POWER where:
P = -------------------
and i
RATED THERMAL POWER N(z) values are provided in Figures 5 through 11.
Top and bottom 15% of the core is excluded as per Technical Specification 4.2.2.2.G.
N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rcv 1 (Oct 93)
Page 4 of 16
~
2.,6 Nuclear Enthalpy Rise Hot Channel Factor'- F,"'
and Power Factor Multiplier (Specification 3/4.2.3) i Fan" s 1.49 * [1 + 0.3 * (1 - P)]
l 1
THERMAL POWER
{
where:
P'=
i RATED THERMAL POWER
)
I; l
t N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 5 of 16 t
)
FIGURE 1 l
NORTH ANNA UNIT 2 CYCLE 10 CONTROL ROD BANK INSERTION LIMITS VS. PERCENT RATED THERMAL POWER t
4 2
FULLY WITHDRAWN = 225
- 230, i
i i
fi i
i i
i i
g, l f, f,
i 20 if 4
4 fi M,
,f i
i i
-(14159 )
/i i
i 180
,f i e i,
f
/!
1m f4 f
f n-w i f i 170 fi z
4 f o too
,/'
l l
l f
E,is0
.,f i
i i
o, 140 f
f; f,
f
- n. 13o i f i
,f, un IN 'f.
i i
i i i f
i i i
'fI fa.tLiam !
i i
t no f_...'.
g f----
3,,,
f, o
m 90 i
o, f;
i
,f
+
cf, g
i o 70 l
=
,f ao i
f i 50
.f, i
i i f i i f, i
i i i i
i f '
j y
i i
(
i
_ f,
_ f 3 i
i 1
y
, f, I
f i i i i
i 10 i
f.
i,
0 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 OA 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 FRACTION OF RATED THERMAL POWER N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 6 of 16 l
l i
1 l
FIGURE 2 N2C10 AXIAL FLUX DIFFERENCE LIMITS AS A FUNCTION OF RATED THERMAL POWER (BOC to 5000 MWD /MTU) i i
1.20f02 1.00402
(+6,100) 1
(-11,100) /
\\
Unacceptable g
/
I Operation o
" 8.00401
/
\\
i
/
\\
g g
Acceptable g
~
6.00401
/
Operation j
_O 5
(-24,50)
(+20,50)
I w
4.00401 E
U m'
2.00401 0.00f00
-5.00401
-3.00401
-1.00+01 1.00401 3.00401 5.00401 PERCENTFLUXDiffERENCE(DELIA-l)
N2C10/RE AfD LlW115 - BOC 10 5000 HD/WTU N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 7 of 16 Ju
i l
1 FIGURE 3 I
N2C10 AXIAL FLUX DIFFERENCE LIMITS AS A FUNCTION OF RATED THERMAL POWER (5000 MWD /MTU to EOC) ~
a j
6 1.20402 1
1.00+02
(-11,100)
(+6,100)
\\
Unacceptable 5g
/
)
Operation
" 8.00401
/
\\
I
[ Acceptable k j
\\
5
/
Operation
\\
7
, 6.00401
/
\\
E
/
\\
-- (-27,50)
(+20,50) m 4.00f01 E
El 2.00+01 i
l 0.00f00 4
-5.00+01
-3.00+01
-1.00+01 1.00401 3.00401 5.00+01 PERCENTFLUXDiffERENCE(DELTA-1)
)
N2C10/RE AfD LIMlIS - 5000 WWD/WTU 10 EOC N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 8 of 16 -
1-
-.m get--
-.-m--
s-p.-.
---ty g--
g--m-p
l FIGURE 4 i
K(Z) - NORMALIZED Fe AS A FUNCTION OF CORE HEIGHT 4
1 1.2 i
l i'
l l
i l
1.0 i
2 i
M,1.80 l i
R (32, o.sas)
~ 0.8 O
u.
i i
i j
j O
i i
W l
i N
I i
-O I
4 0.6 !
=
E i
g I
i i
l O
2 i
I G
.4.
i 0
g i
i i
i I
i l
i 1
I 0.2 l
l f
2 i
i i
i 0.0 '
O 1
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
10 11 12 CORE HEIGHT IN FT N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Repon, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 9 of 16 4
I FIGURE 5 N(Z)FUNCTIbNFORN2C10 l
0 - 1000 MWD /MTU BURNUP HEIGHT N(Z) i (ft)
[
t 10.20 1.165 10.00 1.165
{
9.80 1.171 l
9.60 1.175 9.40 1.177 9.20 1.178 9.00 1.177 1.18+0D
\\
[
8.80 1.177 l
\\-
8.60 1~.181 l
8.40 1.185 j
8.20' 1.187 t
$m 8.00 1.186 E[
7.80 1.185 7.60 1.181 es 1.14+00 7.40 1.175 7.20 1.169 E!
7.00 1.160 6.80 1.151 S?
6.60 1.140-
- I
\\s 6.40 1.128 5$
(
6.20 1.114
'f 1,10400
\\
6.00 1.098 E5 5.80-1.085 i
5.60 1.078 5.40 1.074 5.20 1.072 j
5.00 1.077 4.80 1.084 l
1.0E+00 4.60 1.093_
l 4.40 1.100 O.00+00 2.00+00 4.00f00 6.00f00 8.00+0D 1.00101 4.20 1-106 i
4.00 1.112 COREHEIGHT(fi) 3.80 1.117 3.60 1.121 3.40 1.125 3 20
. 32 N2C10/REN(Z)FUNCTIONAI0-1000 MWD /WTUBURNUP 9
2.80 1.149 2.60 1.157 2.40 1.164 2.20 1.171 2.00 1.178 1.80 1.184 N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits ' Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 10 of 16
~..
- 1'
4 i
l 4
FIGURE 6
~
1.
N(Z) FUNCTION FOR N2C10 f
1 1000 - 3000 MWD /MTU BURNUP i
HEIGHT N(Z)
}
(ft) i
)
10.20 1.165 l
10.00 1.165 1
9.80 1.171 I
9.60 1.175 l
1 a
9.40~
-1.177 i
9.20 1.178 1
9.00 1.177 l
1.15+00
\\
[
I
~
8.80 1.177-8.60 1.181 I
8.40 1.185-I 8.20 1.187 ce 8.00 1.186
~
c 7.80
'1.185 7.60
- 1.181 l
5; 1.1400 7.40 1.175
)
7.20_
1.169 l
E5 7.00 1.160 EE 6.80 1.151.
55 6.60 1.140
((
\\
6.40
-1.128-
-j
(
-6.20 1.114 j
cr 9" 1.1D+0D
\\
6.00 1.098 EE 5.80 1.085 5.60 1.078 I
5.40 1.074 V-5.20 1.072 l
5.00 1.077 4.80 1.084 1.05+0D 4.60 1.093 4.40 1.100 0.00400 2.00+00 4.00f00 6.00+0D B.00f00 1.00f01 4.20 1.106 COREHElGHT(fi) 4.00 1.112 3
3.80 1.117 3.60 1.121 J
3.40 1.125 j
N2010/RE N(Z) FUNCil0N AT 1000-3000 MWD /NTUBURNUP 3.20.
1.132 3.00 1.141 2.80 1.149-2.60 1.157 2.40 1.164 2.20 1.171 2.00 1.178 I
1.80 1.184 i
N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 11 of 16 w-
~
+
--4 e-g e-
+-rv-
"d vi--
l FIGURE 7 1
N(Z) FUNCTION FOR N2C10 3000 - 5000 MWD /MTU BURNUP HEIGHT N(Z)
(ft) 10.20 1.193 10.00 1.183 9.80 1.177 9.60 1.176 9.40 1.179 9.20 1.188 9.00 1.197
/ \\.
8.80 1.205 1 21+;0 8.60 1.212
/,
\\.
8.40 1.216 8.20 1.220 5
/
8.00 1.220 Z 1.19 CD
/
\\
f 7.80 1.220
[-
/
\\
/
7.60 1.217
\\
/
\\
s 7.40 1.213
-s 5
/
\\/
7.20 1.207
\\
/
7.00 1.200
- s 1.174:0 Il 6.80 1.193 y
6.60 1.189 g
j 6.40 1.184 h 1.15+;D
\\
[
6.20 1.176 6.00 1.169 w
z 5.80 1.158 E
5.60 1.146 f
5.40 1.133 5.20 1.121
-f 5.00 1.115 4.80 1.116 khl 4.60 1.119
_ 'u
' II,,
4.40 1.118
- .00+0D 2.00+0D 4.00+00 6.00f00 8.00f00 1.00401 4 00 113 COREHEIGHT(fi) 3.80 1.115 3.60 1.121
)
3.40 1.125 3.20 1.132 N2C10/REN(Z)fUNCTIONAT 3000-5000 VWD/WTUBURNUP3.00 1.141 2.80 1.149 2.60 1.157 2.40 1.164 2.20 1.171 2.00 1.178 1.80 1.184 N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 12 of 16
i FIGURE 8 N(Z) FUNCTION FOR N2C10 5000 - 7000 MWD /MTU BURNUP HEIGHT N(Z)
(ft) 10.20 1.193 10.00 1.183 9.80 1.177 9.60 1.176 9.40 1.179 9.20 1.188 9.00 1.197 1.22+00 8.80 1.205 8.60 1.212 8.40 1.216 8.20 1.220
}
8.00 1.220
_s 7.80 1.220
[
7.60 1.217 h 1.18+00 7.40 1.213
- e j
v 7.20 1.207
/
7.00 1.200 m
m E
6.80 1.193 f
SE 6.60 1.189 6.40 1.184 5
b 6.20 1.176 T 1.14+00
\\
5.80 1.158 6.00 1.169 5
5.60 1.146 5.40 1.133 5.20 1.121 g
/
5.00 1.115 4.80 1.116 4.60 1.119 1.10+00 4.40 1.118 f"
0.00+00 2.00+00 4.00+00 6.00+00 8.00+00 1.00101 COREHEICHT(FT) 3.80 1.107 3.60 1.103 3.40 1.103 3.20 1.109 N2C10/REN(Z)FUNCil0NAT5000-7000 HD/WIUBURNUP 3.00 1.115 2.80 1.122 2.60 1.126 2.40 1.133 2.20 1.140 2.00 1.146 1.80 1.152 l
l l
N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 13 of 16
.~
t t
e t
FIGURE 9 N(Z) FUNCTION FOR N2C10 7000 - 9000 MWD /MTU BURNUP HEIGHT N(Z)
(ft) i 10.20 1.193 10.00-1.183 i
9.80 1.177 9.60 1.176
}
9.40 1.179
.9.20 1.188
[
1.22+00 9.00.
1.197 8.80 1.205 i
8.60 1.212 8.40 1.216 i
ec II 8.20 1.220 l'
cd 8.00 1.220 i
7.80 1.220 C
f 2; 1.18+00 7.60 1.217 7.40 1.213
\\/
55 7.20 1.207 EE 7.00 1.200
{}
/
6.80 1.193
[
6.60 1.189 l
6.40 1.184 1
5$
\\
6.20 1.176 l
9f 1.14+00
\\
E5 6.00 1.169 l
5.80 1.158 i
5.60 1.146 l
5.40 1.133 l
/' '#
5.20 1.121 5.00 1.115
\\/
4.80 1.116 1.10+00 v
4.60 1.119 4.40
'1.118 0.00+00 2.00+00 4.00+00 6.00+00 8.00+00 1.00+01 4.20 1.117 COREHEIGHT(FT)
.' 00 1 113 3.80 1.107 3.60 1.103 3.40 1.103 N2C10/REN(Z)TUNCIl0NAT7000-9000 WWD/NTUBURNUP 3.20 1.109.
l 3.00 1.115 2.80 1.122 2.60 1.126 2.40 1.133-2.20
-1.140 2.00 1.146 1.80 1.152 N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 14 of 16
\\1
i l
i r
FIGURE 10 N(Z) FUNCTION FOR N2C10 9000 - 17100 MWD /MTU BURNUP HEIGHT N(Z)
(ft) 10.20 1.193 10.00 1.183 9.80 1.177 9.60 1.176 i
9.40 1.179 9.20 1.188 1.24+00
/
\\
9.00 1.196 8.80 1.205 8.60 1.211 8.40 1.216 85
\\
8.20 1.222 I
8.00 1.227 S:
7.80 1.230 i
. 0+00 7.60 1.231 5l 7.40 1.239 ms 7.20 1.245 EE
[
7.00 1.248 l5 6.80 1.249 i
s,/
6.60 1.245 l
\\
6.40 1.241 53 6.20 1.231 de 1.16400
\\
6.00 1.222 El 5.80 1.206 5.60 1.190 l
l 5.40 1.169 5.20 1.145 y
5.00 1.131 4.80 1.128 1.12400 4.60 1.129 i
4.40 1.132 l
0.00400 2.00400 4.00f00 6.0D400 8.00100 1.00401 4.20 1.134 l
COREHEIGHT(FI) 4.00 1.134 3.80 1.133 3.60 1.131 3.40 1.129 N2C10/REN(Z)FUNCil0NAT9000-17100 WWD/WIUBURNUP 3.20 1.131 3.00 1.130 2.80 1.132 2.60 1.139 2.40 1.14'9 2.20 1.158 2.00 1.166 1.80 1.174 l
N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 15 of 16
' ~
i l
FIGURE II N(Z) FUNCTION FOR N2C10 17100 MWD /MTU AND BEYOND HEIGHT N(Z)
(ft) l 10.20 1.169 10.00 1.166 9.80 1.159 9.60 1.157 9.40 1.160 9.20 1.171
/
9.00 1.183 1.24+0D
\\
8.80 1.196 8.60 1.207 8.40 1.215 o$
\\
8.20 1.223 8.00 1.227 g[
7.80 1.230 7.60 1.231 E; 1.20+0D 7.40 1.239 7.20 1.245 E5 7.00 1.248 6.80 1.249 52 6.60 1.245
- f 6.40 1.241 l}
k f
6.20 1.231 "f 1.15+00
\\
/
6.00 1.222 l5 N'
5.80 1.206
't 5.60 1.190 5.40 1.169 5.20 1.145
/
5.00 1.131 Mk 4.80 1.128 1.12400 t
4.60 1.129 4
4.40 1.132 0.00+0D 2.00+00 4.00+00 6.00+00 5.00+0D 1.00401 4.20 1.134 COREHEIGHT(FI)
' 00 1 13' 3.80 1.133 3.60 1.131 3.40 1.129 N2010/REN(Z)FUNCTIONAT17100WWD/WTUANDBEYOND 3.20 1.131 3.00 1.130 2.80 1.132 2.60 1.139 2.40 1.149 2.20 1.158 2.00 1.166 1.80 1.174 N2C10/RE Core Operating Limits Report, Rev 1 (Oct 93)
Page 16 of 16