ML20058F225
| ML20058F225 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | South Texas  |
| Issue date: | 06/16/1982 |
| From: | Jay Collins NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION IV) |
| To: | Oprea G HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20058F227 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8207300366 | |
| Download: ML20058F225 (6) | |
See also: IR 05000498/1982002
Text
-
-
'
.s
,
June 16, 1982
Dockets: 50-498/82-02
50-499/82-02
Houston Lighting and Power Company
ATTN:
G. W. Oprea, Jr.
Executive Vice President
P. O. Box 1700
Houston, Texas 77001
Gentlemen:
Thank you for your letter of June 9,1982, in response to our letter of
June 3,1982.
~
'
_
We have reviewed the recaimended changes outlined in your letter, and we agree
that several typographical errors were made and should be corrected. Our
position on each of your reconnended changes is documented in Attachement A.
The errors which we believe should be corrected are documented in an errata
sheet, which is enclosed as Attachment B.
This lett'er, with attachments, and your June 9 letter will be placed in the
Public Document Room with the investigation report.
Should you h5v'e any questions regarding this matter, we will be pleased to
discuss them with you.
.
I
Sincerely,
s
"
'
Original sign
by
- -
,
' John T. Collins
-
'
-
. . -
,
John T. Collins-
'
l
,
Regional Administrator
s
1
~
-
+
.-
-
,
^
' *
'
Enclosures:
<
/
1. Attachment D'. Region IV poiittion on recommended changes ~
.
[]f
'to investig tion report 50 4 98/32-02; 50-499/82-02
/
i
l
2. Attachment B . Errata sheets for investigation report
,
3
50-498/82,-02; 50-499/82-02
ygs
i
.
^
_;
_
.
.
-
-
-
m
.a
d'
~
,
-
,
\\.
I
~
"*
l
,
.a
s -
PDR ADOCK 05000498
-
X
8207300366 820616
-,
"
G
.
%PDR
- ;-
~
c
_
_ _
" ' " > .DBRP.y
... ..
. .. DIESlk. ..
.RA R
I-"....."...
--
. - .. ..
-
-~~
---
-
.c -
cau.s m )JEGa4
ardo/sa
EHJohns an s '
11
u
~
~ ~"6/i /5E"j,n
'
6716282'""
'B/16/82" "
"' "
' . ...
. .. . ... . ..
. . .. .. . . .
. . .
..
~
- * " >
%,.ng" . - . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . = . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . - -
~~-
- . - -
-
-
'"-
..... . . .. ...
..... .. ... .
ecrow aisoocJ.wacuouc
.O7FJCIAL RECORD COPYi
.
_ _
1
_
_.
.
..
_
,
._
8
t -
-
.
Houston Lighting and Power
Company
-2-
June 16, 1982
bec to DMB for dist.'-
bec dist. by RIV
NRR/DHFS
Regional Administrator
NRR/0LB
RRI
RAD ASMT BR
Section Chief
ELD
RESEARCH
Enforcement Assistant
IE FILE
LPDR
- MIS Section
IE/RPRIB
TP Branch
NRC POR
- RPB-1
RPB-2 Files
C. E. Wisner
Investigation & Enforcement Staff
Texas Dept. of Health Resources
-
!
U
'
........... ......
... .................
.. ..... . . .
.
..
..
..
. ... .
.
. ........
. . . . . .. ...
euauturp
............ .....
. ...... ... .... .
.... . ... .. . ...
. . . . . .
...
.. .
.. .. . .
.
...
.. ..
.. . .. ..........
DATEk
......... ........
..... ..... .......
............... .....
............ ......
. .. ......... .
....
. . . . . .
.
... . . . . . .
. e.ac roxu sie no..oi unc= ca'
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
l
_
_ _ _
__
1
,_-.
ATTACHMENT A
.
Region IV Position on HL&P Recommended Changes to Investigation Report 50-498/82-02; 50-499/82-02
.
Page No.
Recommended Change
Region IV Position
4
7th line from the bottom, change the
Region IV acknowledges that Mr. Goldberg's signed
word "his" to "HL&P's."
statement uses the words "HL&P specific questions,"
but his questions are included in that category, so
we do not believe the report is inaccurate and do
not plan to change the wording.
4
16th and 18th lines from the bottom,
Region IV used the word " timely" to paraphase the
change the word " timely" to " quick."
statement of Mr. Goldberg. We do not believe that
this word substitution effects the accuracy of the
report, and we do not plan to change the wording as
recommended.
5
17th line from the bottom, the word
We do not believe that the requested change is
"no" should be "N0" and in quotation
necessary to clarify the report.
marks.
5
20th line from the bottom, change the
We acknowledge that Mr. Goldberg's signed statement-
word " view" to " review."
used the word " review" vice " view," but we do not
believe the recommended change is necessary to
clarify the report.
8
5th line from the bottom of Mr. Frazar's
Region IV does not concur with the recommended change.
interview, change the word "present" to
Mr. Frazar did not indicate where Mr. Goldberg was at
"available."
the time, only that he was not present. The wording
will not be changed because the accuracy of the report
is not effected.
8
2nd line from top of Mr. Sumpter's
We do not plan to change this wording because the
interview, the word "about" should be
witness was unsure of the date of Mr. Goldberg's
deleted.
request.
8
2nd line from the bottom in Mr. Sumpter's
Although the change is only marginally significant,
interview, the word " discuss" should be
Region IV will change the report (see errata sheet)
changed to " review."
as recommended.
Page 2
.
ATTACHMENT A
.
Region IV Position
Page No.
Recommended Change
-
9
1st line in the top of the page, the
Region IV agrees and will make the recommended change
word "nonengineering" should be changed
(see errata sheet).
to "known engineering."
9
8th line from the top of the page, the
Although this change has only marginal significance,
word " description" should be changed to
Region IV will make the recommended change.
" descriptions."
9
20th line from the top, the word
Region IV does not concur with the recommended change.
" discussed" should be deleted.
The potential problem areas were discussed.
9
30th line from the top, insert the word
We believe that the recomnended change will not
" lead" between "HL&P" and " engineers."
significantly change the meaning of the report.
The signed statement did refer to " lead engineers,"
however, and Region IV will make the recommended
change (see errata sheet).
9
35th line from the top, change the words
Region IV agrees that Mr. Sumpter made reference to
"other representatives" to the name of
only one Quadrex representative other than Mr. Stanley
" Larry Wray."
and will change the wording accordingly (see errata
sheet).
10
Line 28, insert word "not" between "was"
Region IV agrees and will make the recommended change
and " maintained."
(see errata sheet).
11
7th line from the bottom, the word
Region IV agrees and will make the recommended change
" interest" should read " interests,"
(see errata sheet).
insert the word "not" between "would"
and "be," and delete "best."
This
series of words will now read " interests
would not be served."
- . . . - . . . - -
-
- - . ..
--
. ..__.--.-_
-.-
.~ . .- .-
...
-.
-
.
-.
.-
-
!
'
!
Page 3
'
.
.
!
ATTACHMENT A
.
.
i
.
Page No.
Recommended Change
Region IV Position
!
.
Region IV agrees and will make the recommended change
i
13
2nd line from top, Dr. Key has not
.
not.been identified as being a
(see errata sheet).
l
participant in the Quadrex Report,
i
but we feel the words "Dr. Key"
j
should be replaced with the word "he."
!
- ,
"
i
"
t
,
.
t
!
'
4
4
.
4
i
I
J
l
!
'
!
i
r
.
I
s
4
[
i
,
i
i
-
.
,
. _ . .
. . , _ - ..
-
. - . .
.-
c_ _
-
.
ATTACHMENT B
Errata Sheet for Investigation Report 50-498/82-02; 50-499/82-02
The following editorial corrections should be made in NRC Investigation Report
50-498/82-02; 50-499/82-02:
Page No.
Correction
8
In the second line from the bottom, change the word " discuss" to
" review."
9
In the first line, change the word "nonengineering" to "known
engineering. "
9
In the eigth line, change the word " description" to " descriptions."
9
In the 14th line from the bottom of the page, insert the word
" lead" between "HL&P" and " engineers."
9
In the ninth line from the bottom of the page, change the phrase
"other representatives" to "another representative."
10
In the 28th line, insert the word "not" between "was" and " maintained."
10
In the 34th line, change the word "as" to "because."
11
In the seventh line from the bottom of the page, change the phrase
"our interest would be best served" to "our interest would not be
served."
13
In the second line, change "Dr. Key" to "he."
.
_
-
.
-.
.
,.
__