|
---|
Category:CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS
MONTHYEARML20137N1591997-03-31031 March 1997 Informs That Licensee Facility Scheduled to Administer NRC GFE on 970409.Sonalsts,Inc Authorized Under Contract to Support NRC Administration of GFE Activities ML20058M0361993-04-12012 April 1993 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents.Forwards Records in App L Which Are Being Withheld Partially for Listed Reasons,(Ref FOIA Exemptions 5) ML20034E2721992-11-23023 November 1992 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re NRC Papers at Hoover Library.Records Subj to Request in App a Are Being Withheld in Part (Ref FOIA Exemption 5) ML20101Q4331991-10-30030 October 1991 Partial Response to FOIA Request Re Investigation of Zack Co Done by Nrc.App E Records Encl & Are Being Made Available in Pdr.App D Records Already Available in Pdr.App F Records Withheld in Entirety (Ref FOIA Exemption 6 & 7) ML20044A9881990-07-11011 July 1990 Responds to Re Util Application to Conduct Onsite Disposal of Dredging Spoils.Concerns of Michigan Eco-Watch Will Receive Appropriate Attention ML20044B0011990-03-29029 March 1990 Expresses Alarm Re Application for Disposal of Dredged Discharge Canal Sediment.Investigation of Activity Level Requested ML20248D6521989-07-20020 July 1989 Forwards Response to Util Re Bills D0184 & D0185 for Plant OL Application Review Costs by Various Program Ofcs Through June 1984 ML20245D9621989-04-28028 April 1989 Forwards Addl Info Re Bunker Ramo Instrumentation Penetration Modules,Per 890131 Request.Util Believes That Modules Environmentally Qualified in Accordance w/10CFR50.49 & NUREG-0588,Category II ML20205C3521988-09-23023 September 1988 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Plant. Forwards App D Documents.App D Documents Also Available in PDR ML20155A7001988-06-0202 June 1988 Informs That Const on Conversion of Plant to gas-fired Facility Began on 880404 ML20155A7401988-05-18018 May 1988 FOIA Request for Documents on 850731 & 870312 Meetings Re Plant.Document Re 840314 Meeting Previously Obtained & Therefore Excluded from Request ML20237B4361987-12-14014 December 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents.App B Document, Board Notification 84-024,encl & Also Available in PDR ML20236X6141987-12-0808 December 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request All Documents.No Addl Records Subj to Request Located ML20236U2571987-11-0505 November 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Ball Type Main Steam Isolation Valves Used at Facilities ML20235B3081987-09-21021 September 1987 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents,Including AEC to ACRS Forwarding Safety Evaluation Re Zimmer.App a Documents Cannot Be Located.App B Documents in Pdr.App C & D Documents Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790) ML20235M4251987-07-13013 July 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Acrs. Forwards Documents for Categories One & Three of FOIA Request.Review of 21 Addl ACRS Documents Continuing ML20235K1731987-07-0909 July 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Info Re Certain Contracts Awarded by NRC for Reporting Svcs.Forwards App a & B Documents.Documents Also Available in PDR ML20234F0911987-06-26026 June 1987 Responds to Appeal Re Denial of FOIA Request for Documents. Forwards Document 5 in App F.Portions of Document 5 Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemptions 6 & 7).Other Requested Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20215K1981987-06-19019 June 1987 Final Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Allegations Concerning Plant.Forwards App G & H Documents.Documents Also Available in Pdr.App H Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20213F9351987-05-0808 May 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request.Forwards App F Document & Weld Allegations.App G Documents Partially Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20206H4951987-04-13013 April 1987 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Bechtel Employment Discrimination.Forwards App E Documents.App D Documents Withheld (Ref FOIA Exemption 6) ML20235G2321987-04-0101 April 1987 FOIA Request for Documents Re Forged NDE Inspectors Certification Supplied by Barclay Intl for Use at Quad Cities Nuclear Station & Stated Investigations at Plants ML20211A9531987-02-13013 February 1987 Advises That Financial Info Submitted for 1987 in Util Satisfies Requirements of 10CFR140.21 That Each Licensee Maintain Guarantee of Payment of Deferred Premiums for Operating Reactors Over 100 Mwe ML20212M7651987-01-16016 January 1987 Informs That Due to Demands on Staff,Nrc Will Respond by 870430 to 850607 Request for Review of Invoices D0184 & D0185 Re OL Application Review Costs Through 840623 ML20207C0151986-12-19019 December 1986 Forwards Notice of Withdrawal of Application for OLs & Termination of Proceeding,Per Util 860711 Request & ASLB 861217 Memorandum & Order Granting Motion ML20207C1191986-12-18018 December 1986 Forwards Order Terminating CPPR-81 & CPPR-82 Based on Fact That Const of Facility Ceased,Units Inoperable & Site Environmentally Stable,Per Util 860701 Request to Withdraw Application to Amend CPs ML20215B9641986-12-0505 December 1986 Notifies Util of 870204-05 Early Emergency Responders Workshop in Chicago,Il to Discuss Lessons Learned & Current Problems in Coordination & Integration of Emergency Response Efforts.Meeting Agenda & Preregistration Form Encl ML20214Q0911986-11-24024 November 1986 Partial Response to FOIA Request for Documents Re Ofc of Inspector & Auditor Investigations.Forwards App B Documents. Documents Also Available in PDR ML20214A0761986-11-14014 November 1986 Forwards Insp & Evaluation of Plant for Adequacy of Stabilization Plan,Documenting 861015-16 Site Insp & Review & Insp of Site Stabilization Rept.Environ Stabilization Satisfactory ML20215M8851986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Insp Repts 50-329/86-01 & 50-330/86-01 on 861015-16.No Violations Identified ML20215N0241986-10-28028 October 1986 Forwards Order from DOE Economic Regulatory Admininstration Granting Exemption from Prohibitions of Power Plant & Industrial Fuel Act of 1978 & Puc of Mi Opinion & Order Granting Relief from Commission 850329 Rate Order ML20211B5401986-10-0909 October 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for Eight Categories of Documents Re Ee Kent Allegations Concerning Facilities. Forwards Documents Listed in App K ML20210S9971986-10-0202 October 1986 Requests Change in Facility Svc List Address to Ref Address. Related Correspondence ML20210S4131986-09-26026 September 1986 Further Response to FOIA Request for 16 Categories of Records Re Facilities.Forwards App D & E Documents.Documents Also Available in PDR ML20214T7431986-09-24024 September 1986 Forwards Form 8-K Filed W/Securities & Exchange Commission. Util Believes Info Presented Bears No Issues Currently Before Aslb.Related Correspondence ML20214N4541986-09-0808 September 1986 Provides List of Activities Re Remedial Soils Work Being Modified Pending Final Disposition of Issues Described in Util 860701 & Counsel s Withdrawing Request for CP Extension.W/Svc List.Related Correspondence IA-86-235, Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR1986-09-0505 September 1986 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR ML20209E6621986-09-0505 September 1986 Responds to FOIA Request for Documents Re Util Response to NRC 840112 Confirmatory Order.Documents Listed on App Available in PDR ML20212K9061986-08-21021 August 1986 Forwards Request for Addl Info Re Environ Review of Util 860711 Request to Withdraw Applications for OL by 860828 ML20206M8311986-08-15015 August 1986 Forwards Util Response to ASLB 860716 Order.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20212J1391986-07-25025 July 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for June 1986.Listed Nonconformance Repts & Addl Documents Closed During June Encl ML20202F9581986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Util Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Appeal Board Jurisdiction,For Filing.W/O Encl ML20207D7261986-07-11011 July 1986 Forwards Motion for Authorization to Withdraw OL Application & for Dismissal of OL & Order of Mod Proceedings & Motion for Termination of Aslab Jurisdiction.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML20203B2351986-07-10010 July 1986 Informs That Review of 820622 Application to Receive Unirradiated Nuclear Fuel Assemblies Terminated,Per .Fission Chambers Should Be Disposed of & Licenses SNM-1904 & SNM-1905 Terminated,Per 10CFR70.38(b) ML20202B1091986-07-0101 July 1986 Forwards Evaluation of 13 Specific Recommendations Contained in BNL Rept of Review of Surveillance & Maint Program,In Response to CE Norelius 860506 Request ML20206T4321986-07-0101 July 1986 Withdraws Application for Ols.Facility Will Be Converted to combined-cycle gas-fired Plant.Abandonment Actions & Equipment Sales Will Provide Assurance That Plant Cannot Be Used as Nuclear Facility ML20206T2401986-07-0101 July 1986 Advises That Since Facility Formally Abandoned as Nuclear Facility,Util Will Not Reply to Generic Ltr 86-05 Re TMI Action Item II.K.3.5 ML20199J9181986-06-30030 June 1986 Submits ALAB-106 Quarterly Rept 51.No New Individuals Assigned quality-related Duties.Const Shut Down Since 840716 & No Const Activities Projected for Jul-Sept 1986 ML20211L0361986-06-25025 June 1986 Forwards Bechtel & B&W Nonconformance Repts for May 1986,per Memorandum & Order ALAB-106 ML20198E9051986-05-25025 May 1986 Forwards ALAB-106 Monthly Rept for Apr 1986,including Nonconformance Repts,Quality Action Requests,Equality Audit Finding,B&W Repts of Nonconformance & Audit Finding Repts. Only Nonconformance Repts Encl 1997-03-31
[Table view] Category:INTERNAL OR EXTERNAL MEMORANDUM
MONTHYEARML20245D2661988-04-15015 April 1988 Requests That Project Managers for Listed Plants Notify Respective Utils of Potential for Unqualified Penetrations. Licensee Should Verify Qualification & Rept Results by 880422 ML20235V3031987-07-17017 July 1987 Forwards Summary of OL Review Costs in 6-month Intervals for Period 840624-860621.Costs for Full Costs Records Through ASLB 861217 Dismissal of OL Proceeding for Plants Will Continue to Be Computed ML20101Q7831987-03-10010 March 1987 Forwards Reformatted Memo Requesting OI to Initiate Investigation Into Alleged Employment Discrimination by Zack Co,Per 870218 Request ML20237E7281986-10-0303 October 1986 Forwards Wj Dircks 811119 Testimony Before Subcommittee on Energy & Environ in Washington,Dc Re QA for Nuclear Power Plants Under Const,Per Request ML20209H8181986-09-12012 September 1986 Advises That Time for Commission to Review ALAB-842 Expired. Commission Declined Review.Decision Became Final Agency Action on 860910.Served on 860912 ML20203P1581986-04-24024 April 1986 Forwards CPC Notifying ASLB of Intent to Convert Facility to Combined Cycle gas-fired Plant,In Response to 860414 Memo.Board Notification by Staff Unnecessary ML20155D6591986-04-14014 April 1986 Provides New Info & Relevant Matl to Ol/Om Proceeding Re Util 860407 Notification of Petition to PSC of Mi for Conversion of Nuclear Plants to Natural Gas ML20198A7141985-10-0505 October 1985 Advises That Licensee Does Not Intend to Pursue Issue of Facility Settlement Exceeding freeze-wall Heave Due to Discontinuation of Const.Issue Will Not Be Pursued Until Project Reactivated ML20140G9421985-09-30030 September 1985 Forwards SER Input.Outstanding Issues Listed,Including Flood Protection of Settled Structures & Adequacy of Dewatering Sys.Related Info Encl ML20133G1281985-05-0303 May 1985 Advises of ASLB Support of All Seismic Conclusions Except Definition of Tectonic Province.Board Found Staff Placed Too Much Reliance Upon Seismicity in Definition of Tectonic Province within Which Site Lies ML20132C9551985-04-12012 April 1985 Forwards B Garde Requesting Commissioners to Appoint ASLB Member to Review,Investigate & Issue Findings Re NRC Handling of E Kent Allegations.Info Supplemental to Previous Board Notifications 82-117 & 83-102 ML20138L2321985-04-0404 April 1985 Forwards BNL Insp Rept Re Gap Allegations Concerning Region III Conduct During Plant Insps.Based on Review of BNL Recommendations,Two Allegations of Improper Conduct Valid. Technical Divs Will Reemphasize Insp Policy.W/O Encl ML20127F8811985-03-22022 March 1985 Documents 820317 Telcons W/B Stamaris & Ee Kent Re Allegations of Welding Deficiencies at Plant.Region III Insps Described,Indicating Welds Acceptable.Kent Disagreed. ASME Code Re Socket Weld Engagement Discussed ML20215K7531985-03-14014 March 1985 Submits Evaluation of BNL Rept on Plant Allegations. Allegation Did Not Identify Any Specific Wrongdoing on Part of Any Named NRC Employee.Insp Effort Would Be Encumbered If Entrance Interview Modified ML20127F9701985-02-20020 February 1985 Forwards BNL Insp Rept Re Allegations 19 & 20 of Employment Discrimination by Bechtel at Plant,For Info.Ch Weil 850327 Handwritten Note Included.W/O Rept ML20127F9951985-02-20020 February 1985 Forwards BNL Rept Re Ee Kent Allegations at Midland Plant. Info Re San Onofre Discovered in Course of Review ML20215K4411984-09-28028 September 1984 Advises That Due to Suspension of Const at Facility,Insp Work on Listed Allegations Will Be Deferred Until Project Restarted.Two Allegations Open & Still Being Actively Pursued ML20215L7581984-08-28028 August 1984 Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR IA-85-213, Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR1984-08-28028 August 1984 Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR ML20095A2411984-07-18018 July 1984 Submits Package Received from B Jones from H Singh, Consisting of Questions of Dr Peck by H Singh,J Dunnicliff to Afifi & Summary of J Kane Deposition ML20094M3701984-06-0404 June 1984 Forwards Rev 4 to Region III SALP Schedule. Schedule Changes to Listed Facilities Explained in Remarks Sections of Schedule.Addl Handwritten Notes Also Encl ML20215K3131984-05-18018 May 1984 Forwards Inquiry Rept Q3-83-001 for Review & Necessary Actions.Discriminatory Employment Termination Still Under Investigation by Ofc of Investigations.Insp of Allegers Technical Concerns Contracted to Bnl.W/O Encl ML20091F5231984-05-0707 May 1984 Responds to 830727 Request for Comments Re RB Landsman 830719 Concerns for Diesel Generator Bldg.Listing of Transcript Pages Will Permit Reviewer to Recognize & Evaluate Similarities & Differences ML20091F5291984-05-0707 May 1984 Forwards Initial Response to R Landsman Concerns Re Integrity of Diesel Generator Bldg,Prepared During 830728 Working Meeting ML20094M7961984-04-13013 April 1984 Forwards Advance Copy of Proposed Rev to Manual Chapter 0516,SALP,for Review ML20087N3351984-03-16016 March 1984 Summarizes 840305 Meeting in Glen Ellyn,Il Re Approval of Const Completion Program Phase I Activities to Support Turbine Roll Milestone.Meeting Provided Addl Info to Suppl 840215 Request for Release of Phase I Activities ML20091F2961984-03-14014 March 1984 Requests Documents Subj to Encl FOIA Request 84-158 Re Novak Visits to Site or Region During Sept-Dec 1982.Related Info Encl,Including Tera Corp Agenda for 840313 Meeting Re Idcvp ML20210S4691984-03-13013 March 1984 Advises Not to Do Any Housecleaning of Paperwork Re Zack,Due to Interrogatories & Document Production Pending ML20091G5601984-03-0101 March 1984 Forwards Draft Ack Ltr & Draft Fr Notice Re Lone Tree Council 2.206 Petition on Facilities.Directors Decision DD-83-16 Denied Similar Relief Requests ML20091F2691984-02-28028 February 1984 Requests Attendance at 840313 Public Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Idcvp ML20091F2731984-02-23023 February 1984 Requests Info Re Plans for Addl Inspectors at Site in Order to Reply to Lr Romo (Lone Tree Council) .Draft Reply Encl ML20091F2891984-02-21021 February 1984 Summarizes 840112 Meeting Re Responsibility for Idcvp. Agreements Listed,Including Technical Support from NRR & Region III in Reviewing Design ML20086Q1061984-02-15015 February 1984 Forwards New Index for Const Implementation Overview Procedures & Instructions & Rev 3 to Third-Party Cost Implementation Overview ML20090H5971984-02-13013 February 1984 Discusses 840124 Memo Re Task Interface Agreement 83-78 Re Region III Request for Design Adequacy of HVAC Sys Hardness Tested Bolts.Highest Hardness Found in Sample Bolts Was Rockwell C 29.Testing Unnecessary ML20091G5911984-02-10010 February 1984 Forwards Oeld Analysis in Response to SECY-84-42 Re Directors Denial of 2.206 Relief (DD-83-16 & DD-84-2). Directors Decision Legally Sufficient Under Applicable Stds of Judicial Review ML20088A0511984-01-30030 January 1984 Responds to 840119 Telcon Re Status of Affidavit Received from Bp Garde,Govt Accountability Project.No Evidence of Misconduct Found.Subj Matter Closed by 830419 Memo to File. Info Deleted ML20091N3381984-01-25025 January 1984 Advises That Recent S&W Hiring of Field Ofc Clerk Whose Spouse Is Employed by Util Does Not Constitute Violation of Independence Criteria.Position Is Local Hire & Nontechnical. Related Info Encl ML20090H5341984-01-24024 January 1984 Forwards Safety Analysis Input Re Structural Design Adequacy of HVAC Sys,Per Task Interface Agreement 83-78. Investigation Did Not Disclose Discrepancies Expected to Cause Operating Problems ML20094K1401984-01-23023 January 1984 Documents Contacts by Kirkland & Ellis Attys Representing Dow Chemical in Suit Against Cpc.Summary of Meeting by Geotechnical Engineering,Inc Encl ML20094M3521983-12-29029 December 1983 Forwards HR Denton Distinguishing Between Terms Important to Safety & safety-related. Related Info Encl ML20125B5191983-12-0707 December 1983 Expresses Appreciation for Technical Assistance Offered by L Abramsom & D Lurie Re Containment Protective Coating Deficiency ML20080T4951983-11-25025 November 1983 Advises That Vollmer Recommended Reopening Midland Hearing on Diesel Generator Bldg Structural Adequacy Issue,Based on Task Group Rept.Vollmer Memo Encl.W/O Encl ML20080T4821983-11-25025 November 1983 Forwards Guidance for Use in Deciding Whether to Recommend That Hearing Be Reopened.Hearing Should Be Reopened Based on Listed Reasons ML20082N6711983-11-22022 November 1983 Discusses Recommendation for Suppl to Board Notifications 83-165 & 83-153 Re Diesel Generator Bldg.Comments & Recommendations of J Kane & F Rinaldi on Task Group Rept & Reopening of Hearing Provided ML20091P0871983-11-18018 November 1983 Forwards Comments on 831021 Rept by Independent Task Group Review of Diesel Generator Bldg.Rept Evaluates Concerns Expressed by RB Landsman of Region III ML20080T4681983-11-16016 November 1983 Advises That Supplemental Info Provided in PT Kuo 831114 Memo to Jp Knight Will Be Transmitted to Midland Board as Suppl to Board Notification 83-165.Issue Will Be Incorporated as Board Notification 83-165A.W/o Encl ML20091P0811983-11-16016 November 1983 Forwards Army Corps of Engineers Re Structural Adequacy of Diesel Generator Bldg ML20090H5011983-11-11011 November 1983 Discusses Contract W/Franklin Research Ctr to Provide Technical Assistance for Underpinning & Remedial Soils Work Review & Plan for Communications Among Parties Involved IR 05000329/19830081983-11-0808 November 1983 Forwards Draft IE Insp Repts 50-329/83-08 & 50-330/83-08 & Notice of Violation Re Allegations Concerning Deficiencies in Design & Const of HVAC Sys.Related Info Encl,Including Zack Co Documentation ML20091F1351983-11-0707 November 1983 Lists Potential Generic Weaknesses Stemming from Insps of Zack Co.Prompt Insp Requested 1988-04-15
[Table view] Category:MEMORANDUMS-CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20245D2661988-04-15015 April 1988 Requests That Project Managers for Listed Plants Notify Respective Utils of Potential for Unqualified Penetrations. Licensee Should Verify Qualification & Rept Results by 880422 ML20235V3031987-07-17017 July 1987 Forwards Summary of OL Review Costs in 6-month Intervals for Period 840624-860621.Costs for Full Costs Records Through ASLB 861217 Dismissal of OL Proceeding for Plants Will Continue to Be Computed ML20101Q7831987-03-10010 March 1987 Forwards Reformatted Memo Requesting OI to Initiate Investigation Into Alleged Employment Discrimination by Zack Co,Per 870218 Request ML20237E7281986-10-0303 October 1986 Forwards Wj Dircks 811119 Testimony Before Subcommittee on Energy & Environ in Washington,Dc Re QA for Nuclear Power Plants Under Const,Per Request ML20209H8181986-09-12012 September 1986 Advises That Time for Commission to Review ALAB-842 Expired. Commission Declined Review.Decision Became Final Agency Action on 860910.Served on 860912 ML20203P1581986-04-24024 April 1986 Forwards CPC Notifying ASLB of Intent to Convert Facility to Combined Cycle gas-fired Plant,In Response to 860414 Memo.Board Notification by Staff Unnecessary ML20155D6591986-04-14014 April 1986 Provides New Info & Relevant Matl to Ol/Om Proceeding Re Util 860407 Notification of Petition to PSC of Mi for Conversion of Nuclear Plants to Natural Gas ML20199F5231986-04-0202 April 1986 Board Notification 86-012:forwards Interim Rept of Investigation Conducted by Ofc of Investigations at Plant in Midland,Mi for in Camera Consideration.W/O Rept ML20151L2411985-10-22022 October 1985 Board Notification 85-088:forwards CE Norelius 851005 Memo Advising That Licensee Does Not Intend to Pursue Issue of Exceeded freeze-wall Heave Due to Discontinuation of Const at Facility.No Further Reporting on Issue Planned ML20133F3951985-10-0707 October 1985 Board Notification 85-086:suppls Board Notifications 82-117, 83-102 & 85-045 Re welding-related Allegations at Midland 1 & 2.H Wahl (Bechtel) 850916 Summary of Developments in Suit Filed Re E Kent Allegations & Encl ML20198A7141985-10-0505 October 1985 Advises That Licensee Does Not Intend to Pursue Issue of Facility Settlement Exceeding freeze-wall Heave Due to Discontinuation of Const.Issue Will Not Be Pursued Until Project Reactivated ML20140G9421985-09-30030 September 1985 Forwards SER Input.Outstanding Issues Listed,Including Flood Protection of Settled Structures & Adequacy of Dewatering Sys.Related Info Encl ML20128G7621985-06-28028 June 1985 Staff Requirements Memo Re 850620 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote in Washington,Dc.Edo & RES Should Forward Fr Notice Re Approved Final Rule on Pressurized Thermal Shock for Signature & Publication ML20133G1281985-05-0303 May 1985 Advises of ASLB Support of All Seismic Conclusions Except Definition of Tectonic Province.Board Found Staff Placed Too Much Reliance Upon Seismicity in Definition of Tectonic Province within Which Site Lies ML20132C9551985-04-12012 April 1985 Forwards B Garde Requesting Commissioners to Appoint ASLB Member to Review,Investigate & Issue Findings Re NRC Handling of E Kent Allegations.Info Supplemental to Previous Board Notifications 82-117 & 83-102 ML20138L2321985-04-0404 April 1985 Forwards BNL Insp Rept Re Gap Allegations Concerning Region III Conduct During Plant Insps.Based on Review of BNL Recommendations,Two Allegations of Improper Conduct Valid. Technical Divs Will Reemphasize Insp Policy.W/O Encl ML20127F8811985-03-22022 March 1985 Documents 820317 Telcons W/B Stamaris & Ee Kent Re Allegations of Welding Deficiencies at Plant.Region III Insps Described,Indicating Welds Acceptable.Kent Disagreed. ASME Code Re Socket Weld Engagement Discussed ML20215K7531985-03-14014 March 1985 Submits Evaluation of BNL Rept on Plant Allegations. Allegation Did Not Identify Any Specific Wrongdoing on Part of Any Named NRC Employee.Insp Effort Would Be Encumbered If Entrance Interview Modified ML20127F9701985-02-20020 February 1985 Forwards BNL Insp Rept Re Allegations 19 & 20 of Employment Discrimination by Bechtel at Plant,For Info.Ch Weil 850327 Handwritten Note Included.W/O Rept ML20127F9951985-02-20020 February 1985 Forwards BNL Rept Re Ee Kent Allegations at Midland Plant. Info Re San Onofre Discovered in Course of Review ML20215K4411984-09-28028 September 1984 Advises That Due to Suspension of Const at Facility,Insp Work on Listed Allegations Will Be Deferred Until Project Restarted.Two Allegations Open & Still Being Actively Pursued ML20215L7581984-08-28028 August 1984 Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR IA-85-213, Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR1984-08-28028 August 1984 Comments on BNL Re Proposed Review of Concerns Expressed by Ee Kent.Nrc May Expand on Insp Previously Performed at Plant But Should Not Duplicate Work Already Performed by Region V & NRR ML20095A2411984-07-18018 July 1984 Submits Package Received from B Jones from H Singh, Consisting of Questions of Dr Peck by H Singh,J Dunnicliff to Afifi & Summary of J Kane Deposition ML20094M3701984-06-0404 June 1984 Forwards Rev 4 to Region III SALP Schedule. Schedule Changes to Listed Facilities Explained in Remarks Sections of Schedule.Addl Handwritten Notes Also Encl ML20215K3131984-05-18018 May 1984 Forwards Inquiry Rept Q3-83-001 for Review & Necessary Actions.Discriminatory Employment Termination Still Under Investigation by Ofc of Investigations.Insp of Allegers Technical Concerns Contracted to Bnl.W/O Encl ML20091F5231984-05-0707 May 1984 Responds to 830727 Request for Comments Re RB Landsman 830719 Concerns for Diesel Generator Bldg.Listing of Transcript Pages Will Permit Reviewer to Recognize & Evaluate Similarities & Differences ML20091F5291984-05-0707 May 1984 Forwards Initial Response to R Landsman Concerns Re Integrity of Diesel Generator Bldg,Prepared During 830728 Working Meeting ML20094M7961984-04-13013 April 1984 Forwards Advance Copy of Proposed Rev to Manual Chapter 0516,SALP,for Review ML20087N3351984-03-16016 March 1984 Summarizes 840305 Meeting in Glen Ellyn,Il Re Approval of Const Completion Program Phase I Activities to Support Turbine Roll Milestone.Meeting Provided Addl Info to Suppl 840215 Request for Release of Phase I Activities ML20091F2961984-03-14014 March 1984 Requests Documents Subj to Encl FOIA Request 84-158 Re Novak Visits to Site or Region During Sept-Dec 1982.Related Info Encl,Including Tera Corp Agenda for 840313 Meeting Re Idcvp ML20210S4691984-03-13013 March 1984 Advises Not to Do Any Housecleaning of Paperwork Re Zack,Due to Interrogatories & Document Production Pending ML20091G5601984-03-0101 March 1984 Forwards Draft Ack Ltr & Draft Fr Notice Re Lone Tree Council 2.206 Petition on Facilities.Directors Decision DD-83-16 Denied Similar Relief Requests ML20091F2691984-02-28028 February 1984 Requests Attendance at 840313 Public Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Idcvp ML20091F2731984-02-23023 February 1984 Requests Info Re Plans for Addl Inspectors at Site in Order to Reply to Lr Romo (Lone Tree Council) .Draft Reply Encl ML20091F2891984-02-21021 February 1984 Summarizes 840112 Meeting Re Responsibility for Idcvp. Agreements Listed,Including Technical Support from NRR & Region III in Reviewing Design ML20086Q1061984-02-15015 February 1984 Forwards New Index for Const Implementation Overview Procedures & Instructions & Rev 3 to Third-Party Cost Implementation Overview ML20244C8141984-02-15015 February 1984 Board Notification 84-024:forwards SECY-84-34 Re Emergency Diesel Generators Mfg by Transamerica Delaval,Inc.Staff Continuing Overall Assessment of Reliability of Diesel Engines IA-87-778, Board Notification 84-024:forwards SECY-84-34 Re Emergency Diesel Generators Mfg by Transamerica Delaval,Inc.Staff Continuing Overall Assessment of Reliability of Diesel Engines1984-02-15015 February 1984 Board Notification 84-024:forwards SECY-84-34 Re Emergency Diesel Generators Mfg by Transamerica Delaval,Inc.Staff Continuing Overall Assessment of Reliability of Diesel Engines ML20090H5971984-02-13013 February 1984 Discusses 840124 Memo Re Task Interface Agreement 83-78 Re Region III Request for Design Adequacy of HVAC Sys Hardness Tested Bolts.Highest Hardness Found in Sample Bolts Was Rockwell C 29.Testing Unnecessary ML20091G5911984-02-10010 February 1984 Forwards Oeld Analysis in Response to SECY-84-42 Re Directors Denial of 2.206 Relief (DD-83-16 & DD-84-2). Directors Decision Legally Sufficient Under Applicable Stds of Judicial Review ML20088A0511984-01-30030 January 1984 Responds to 840119 Telcon Re Status of Affidavit Received from Bp Garde,Govt Accountability Project.No Evidence of Misconduct Found.Subj Matter Closed by 830419 Memo to File. Info Deleted ML20091N3381984-01-25025 January 1984 Advises That Recent S&W Hiring of Field Ofc Clerk Whose Spouse Is Employed by Util Does Not Constitute Violation of Independence Criteria.Position Is Local Hire & Nontechnical. Related Info Encl ML20090H5341984-01-24024 January 1984 Forwards Safety Analysis Input Re Structural Design Adequacy of HVAC Sys,Per Task Interface Agreement 83-78. Investigation Did Not Disclose Discrepancies Expected to Cause Operating Problems ML20094K1401984-01-23023 January 1984 Documents Contacts by Kirkland & Ellis Attys Representing Dow Chemical in Suit Against Cpc.Summary of Meeting by Geotechnical Engineering,Inc Encl ML20094M3521983-12-29029 December 1983 Forwards HR Denton Distinguishing Between Terms Important to Safety & safety-related. Related Info Encl ML20125B5191983-12-0707 December 1983 Expresses Appreciation for Technical Assistance Offered by L Abramsom & D Lurie Re Containment Protective Coating Deficiency ML20080T4951983-11-25025 November 1983 Advises That Vollmer Recommended Reopening Midland Hearing on Diesel Generator Bldg Structural Adequacy Issue,Based on Task Group Rept.Vollmer Memo Encl.W/O Encl ML20080T4821983-11-25025 November 1983 Forwards Guidance for Use in Deciding Whether to Recommend That Hearing Be Reopened.Hearing Should Be Reopened Based on Listed Reasons ML20082N6711983-11-22022 November 1983 Discusses Recommendation for Suppl to Board Notifications 83-165 & 83-153 Re Diesel Generator Bldg.Comments & Recommendations of J Kane & F Rinaldi on Task Group Rept & Reopening of Hearing Provided 1988-04-15
[Table view] |
Text
_____.
UNITED STATES d8' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
{,,
,E ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS W ASHINGT ON, D. C. 20555 f
O,
- p June 8, 1982 Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino Chai rman U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555
Dear Dr. Palladino:
SUBJECT:
ACRS INTERIM REPORT ON MIDLAND PLANT, UNITS 1 AND 2 During its 266th meeting, June 3-5, 1982, the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards reviewed the application of Consumers Power Company for a li-cense to operate the Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2.
This coplication was also considered at Subcommittee meetings held on April 29, 1982 in Washing-ton, D. C.,
on May 20-21,1982 in Midland, Michigan and on June 2,1982 in Washington, D. C.
On May 20,1982 members of the Subcommittee toured the plant.
In the course of these meetings the Committee had the benefit of discussions with representatives anr consultants of Consumers Power Company, Babcock and Wilcox Company, Bechb i Corporation, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission Staff, and members of the public.
The Committee also had the benefit of the documents listed below.
The ACRS reported on June 18, 1970 regarding the construction permit ap-plication for the Midland Plant; on September 23, 1970 regarding several arnendments to the application; and on November 18, 1976 regarding applica-ble generic matters.
The Midland Plant site is located on the south bank of the Tittabawassee River adjacent to the southern city limits of Midland.
The main industrial complex of the Dow Chemical Company lies within the city limits directly across the river from the site.
There are about 2000 industrial workers within one mile of the site, and the estimated 1980 population was about 51,400 residents within five miles of the site.
This makes the Midland site one of the more densely populated sites at distances close to the Plant.
Each of the two Midland units employs a Babcock and Wilcox designed nuclear steam supply system rated at 2468 MWt with a stretch porer rating of 2552 MWt.
The Midland Plant is unique in that the heat generated will be used not only to produce electricity but also to produce process steam for the Dow Chemical Company plant via a tertiary system.
The Midland Plant has been the subject of several major problems related to quality assurance during plant construction.
One of these problems relates to the soil fill under several safety-related structures.
The k
i I'206140166 820608 PDR ACRS R-0979 PDR
3 1
Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino June 8,1982 deficiencies relhting to soil fill have led to excessive settleri.ent and some cracking of these structures, and have also introduced questions concerning the adequacy of protection against liquefaction of the granular portions of the fill in the event of strong vibratory motion accompanying an earthquake.
The Applicant has proposed and is implementing, under close surveillance by the NRC Staff, remedial measures with regard to the foundation deficiencies.
We are generally satisfied with the approach being taken, subject to confir-mation of the overall quality assurance program and the seismic design basis.
Both of these items are discussed below.
With regard to quality control of design and construction, the report of the NRC Staff's Systematic Assessment of Licensee Performance (SALP) review for the period July 1,1980 to June 30, 1981 revealed deficiencies in the instal-lation of piping and piping suspension systems, in the pulling of electrical cables, and in the handling of problems relating to soils and foundation.
Deficiencies by the Applicant in the handling of soils-related matcers have continued to occur, subsequent to issuance of the SALP report.
We believe that the NRC Staff is handling the corrective actions for specifically identified quality assurance deficiencies in an appropriate manner.
In view of the overall concern about Midland quality assurance the NRC should arrange for a broader assessment of Midland's design adequacy and construction quality with emphasis on installed electrical, control, and mechanical equipment as well as piping and foundations.
We wish to receive a report which discusses design and construction problems, their disposi-tion, and the overall effectiveness of the effort to assure appropriate quality.
Our reservation concerning seismic design relates to the lack of adequate assurance that the Midland Plant will be capable of accomplishing shutdown I
heat removal for low probability earthquakes more severe than the safe l
shutdown earthqueke (SSE).
The Midland seismic design basis at the con-l struction permit stage corresponded to a MMI VI, peak ground acceleration of 0.12g, employing a modified Housner spectrum.
For the operating license review, the NRC Staff has reevaluated the original seismic design basis and l
the Applicant and the NRC Staff have agreed on the use of site-specific analyses which have led to increases in the design response spectra for frequencies above about 2 cycles /sec.
Historically, no earthquakes stronger than the newly proposed SSE have occurred within 200 miles of the Plant.
However, expert opinion differs widely on the exceedance frequency of the proposed SSE and on the severity 4
at the site of earthquakes whose likelihood is less than 1 in 10 or 1 in 5
10 per year.
5 Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino June 8, 1982 The Applicant is currently 'eevaluating by selective audit the seismic capability of the plant, as originally designed, to withstand the revised SSE.
Measures taken to assure safe shutdown in the event of an earthquake include the use of dewatering to reduce the potential for soil liquefaction.
We recommend that all systems and components important to decay heat removal be carefully evaluated for their ability to accomplish necessary functions in the unlikely event of lower-probability, more severe earthquakes in order to provide the necessary degree of assurance.
This matter should be re-solved in a manner satisfactory to the NRC Staff.
We wish to be kept informed about the resolution of this matter.
We believe that any recom-mendations for changes in the plant resulting from this evaluation should be implemented by the end of the second refueling outage.
The Applicant has agreed to provide core exit thermocouples, a hot-leg-le.el measurement system, and subcooled margin monitors as instrumentation to detect inadequate core cooling.
Consumers Power Company also plans to include a remotely operable vent on top of both inlet loops to the steam generators; however, Consumers has not committed to supply a high point vent on the reactor vessel head.
This matter should be resolved in a manner satisfactory to the NRC Staff.
The ACRS recommends that the Applicant review further the potential for providing indications of water content or level within the reactor vessel.
The staff of the Applicant includes many personnel who have had nuclear power plant experience.
However, operating experience with this B&W type power reactor is limited, and the NRC Staff is requiring that at least one person having experience on a large commercial PWR be included on each shift for one year. We support the NRC Staff position.
The Applicant's experience with the operation of nuclear power plants should, in principle, place Consumers in a favorable position to provide l
continuing, careful oversight of the operations at the Midland Plant.
In view of some prior adverse operating experience at the Palisades Plant however, we recommend that the NRC Staff institute an augmented audit of operations at Midland, at least during the early years of operation at power.
We have reviewed the evaluation made of the tertiary process steam system for use by Dow Chemical Company.
This system appears not to impose any unacceptable impacts either on the safe operation of the Midland Plant or on the people working 'at the Dow Chemical Company.
The Applicant has undertaken an effort to have a probabilistic risk assess-ment (PRA) performed for the Midland Plant and stated that the results will be available in the fall of 1982.
We believe it desirable to have plant-specific PRAs performed for each commercial nuclear power plant and that
Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino June 8,1982 it is particularly appropriate for the Midland Plant because of its rela-tively high, close-in population density. We wish to have the opportunity to review the Midland PRA with assistance from the NRC Staff, and to offer comments or recommendations as appropriate.
We do not believe that this review need delay licensing of the Midland Plant for operation.
Recently, questions have come to light in connection with B&W plants con-cerning the availability of natural circulation in the presence of an interrupted or continuing small break loss-of-coolant accident.
We wish to see a proposed NRC Staff resolution of this issue.
1 The Applicant described an extensive systems interactions study being undertaken for the Midland Plant.
We wish to be informed of the results of I
this study.
We believe that, in view of the population density near this plant, addi-tional prudence is appropriate for the Midland Plant in the resolution of the ATWS issue and other Unresolved Safety Issues.
We endorse the participation of Dow Chemical Company plant personnel in emergency procedures developed on the basis of an assumed failure at the Midland Plant.
Similarly, there should be active participation by Midland Plant personnel in emergency procedures developed on the basis of an assumed failure at the Dow Chemical plant. The Applicant and the NRC Staff should promote continued coordination of these types of relationships, as well as those involving appropriate state and local groups to assure that I
the capability for an effective emergency response is developed and main-tained.
With regard to the eleven items identified in the ACRS Supplemental Report on Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 dated November 18, 1976, we have the follow-ing comments.
The issues related to vibration and loose-parts monitoring, potential for axial xenon oscillations, behavior of core-barrel check valves during normal operation, fuel handling accidents, effects of blowdown forces on core internals, LOCA-related fuel rod failures, and improved quality assurance and in-service inspection for the primary system have all been resolved or are in a confirmatory stage of being resolved. Separation of protection and control equipment has been accomplished in an appropriate manner; however, the safety implications of control systems remains an Unresolved Safety Issue directly applicable to Midland.
Resolution awaits completion of the NRC Staff Task Action Plan A-47.
The effect of ECCS induced thermal shock on pressure vessel integrity has been resolved in part; however, the Unresolved Safety Issue on pressurized thermal shock will apply.
Environmental qualification of equipment remains a generic
Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino June 8, 1982 issue which is under review by the NRC Staff and whose resolution will apply to the Midland Plant.
Instrumentation to follow the course of an accident has been resolved in part by the development of revised Regulatory Guide 1.97.
We do not believe that licensing of the Midland Plant for operation need await further resolution of ar.y of the eleven issues dis-cussed above.
The various other matters identified by the NRC Staff as open or confirma-tory in the Safety Evaluation Report should be resolved in a manner satis-factory to the NRC Staff.
We wish to be kept advised concerning resolution of the turbine missile issue.
The ACRS believes that, subject to satisfactory completion of construction and staffing and if due regard is given to the comments above, the Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 can be operated at power levels up to 5 percent of full power with reasonable assurance that there is no undue risk to the health and safety of the public.
We defer our recommendation regarding operation at full power until we have had the opportunity to review the plan for an audit of plant quality and the proposed resolution of the question regarding natural circulation in the presence of a small break LOCA.
Dr. Kerr did not participate in the Committee's review of this matter.
Sincerely,
k.
P. Shemnon Chai rman
References:
1.
Consumers Power Company, " Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 - Final Safety Analysis Report" including Amendments 1-43 2.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission, " Safety Evaluation Report Related to the Operation of Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2," NUREG-0793, dated Pby 1982 3.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Connission, "NRC Licensee Assessments,"
NUREG-0834, dated August 1981 4.
Letter from J. Cook, Consumers Power Company, to J. Keppler, NRC,
Subject:
Midland Project Response to Draft SALP Report, dated May 17,1982 5.
Letter from J. Cook, Consumers Power Company, to J. Keppler, NRC,
Subject:
Midland Project Quality Assurance Program Update, dated April 30,1981
Honorable Nunzio J. Palladino ~
June 8, 1982 6.
Letter from J. Hind, NRC, to J. Cook, Consumers Power Company, Subject :
Systematic Assessment of Licensee Performance (SALP),
dated April 20, 1982 7.
Letter from J. Cook, Consumers Power Company, to H. Denton, NRC,
Subject:
Summary of Soils-Related Issues at the Midland Nuclear Plant, dated April 19, 1982 8.
Letter from K. Drehobl, Consumers Power Company, to D. Fischer, ACRS, Subject : Midland Project Soils Information, dated April 12, 1982 9.
Statement of Ms. M. Sinclair to ACRS, dated June 4,1982 10.
Letter from B. Stamiris to Dr. D. Okrent and ACRS Members,
Subject:
Midland OL Review, dated May 29, 1982 11.
Letter from M. Sinclair to Dr. P. Shewmon, ACRS,
Subject:
Midland OL Review, dated May 28, 1982
- 12. Statement by Dr. C. Anderson to ACRS Midland Plant Subcommittee dated May 20-21, 1982 13.
Statement by Ms. M. Sinclair to ACRS Midland Plant Subcommittee dated May 20-21, 1982 14.
Letter from B. Stamiris to D. Fischer and ACRS Mambers,
Subject:
Soil Settlement and QA Issues, dated May 20, 1982 15.
Letter from M. Sinclair to Dr. C. Siess, ACRS,
Subject:
Midland Soil Settlement, dated April 26, 1982 M
l l
i l
. -