Testimony of Kp Twine Re Contention 17/26 (1)(b) on Radiological Emergency Response Plan.Evacuation Time Estimate Study Realistically Shows Evacuation of Plume Emergency Planning Zone Possible.W/Prof QualificationsML20054D925 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
Waterford |
---|
Issue date: |
04/20/1982 |
---|
From: |
Twine K EBASCO SERVICES, INC., LOUISIANA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
---|
To: |
|
---|
Shared Package |
---|
ML20054D911 |
List: |
---|
References |
---|
NUDOCS 8204230510 |
Download: ML20054D925 (9) |
|
|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20116G9431996-08-0707 August 1996 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re, Mods to Fitness-For-Duty Program Requirements TXX-9522, Comment Opposing Proposed GL on Testing of safety-related Logic Circuits.Believes That Complete Technical Review of All Surveillance Procedures Would Be Expensive & Unnecessary Expenditure of Licensee Resources1995-08-26026 August 1995 Comment Opposing Proposed GL on Testing of safety-related Logic Circuits.Believes That Complete Technical Review of All Surveillance Procedures Would Be Expensive & Unnecessary Expenditure of Licensee Resources ML20086D8841995-06-29029 June 1995 Comments on Proposed Rule Re, Review of NRC Insp Rept Content,Format & Style ML20085E5891995-06-0909 June 1995 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR73 Re Changes to NPP Security Requirements Associated W/Containment Access Control ML20080A1331994-10-21021 October 1994 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR2 Re Reexamination of NRC Enforcement Policy.Advises That Util of Belief That NRC Focus on Safety Significance in Insps & Enforcement Policy Can Be Achieved by Utilization of Risk Based Techniques ML20073M3261994-10-0303 October 1994 Comment on Pilot Program for NRC Recognition of Good Performance by Nuclear Power Plants ML20072B8521994-08-0505 August 1994 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR26 Re Consideration of Changes to FFD Requirements.Licensee Believes Reduction in Amount of FFD Testing Warranted & Can Best Be Achieved in Manner Already Adopted by Commission ML20065P4121994-04-25025 April 1994 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Rule Re Code & Stds Re Subsections IWE & Iwl.Expresses Deep Concern About Ramifications of Implementing Proposed Rule ML20058G6211993-12-0606 December 1993 Comment on Draft NUREG/BR-0058, Regulatory Analysis Guidelines,Rev 2. Concurs W/Numarc & Nubarg Comments ML20056F3481993-08-23023 August 1993 Comment Opposing NRC Draft GL 89-10,suppl 6 ML20058B6891993-05-0707 May 1993 Affidavit of RP Barkhurst to File W/Nrc Encl TS Change Request NPF-38-135 ML20058E0251990-10-12012 October 1990 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR51 Re Renewal of Nuclear Plant OLs & NRC Intent to Prepare Generic EIS ML20055E9871990-06-29029 June 1990 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR55 Re Mod for fitness-for-duty Programs & Licensed Operators.Util Believes That High Stds of Conduct Will Continue to Be Best Achieved & Maintained by Program That Addresses Integrity ML19353B2241989-12-0101 December 1989 Comments on Draft Reg Guide,Task DG-1001, Maint Programs for Nuclear Power Plants. Util Endorses NUMARC Comments W3P89-0196, Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Maint Programs at Nuclear Plants.Proposed Rule Would Require Establishment of Maint Programs Based on Reg Guides That Have Not Been Developed,Proposed or Approved1989-02-28028 February 1989 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Maint Programs at Nuclear Plants.Proposed Rule Would Require Establishment of Maint Programs Based on Reg Guides That Have Not Been Developed,Proposed or Approved ML20235V4571989-02-27027 February 1989 Comment Supporting Proposed Chapter 1 Re Policy Statement on Exemption from Regulatory Control.Agrees W/Recommendations & Limits Proposed by Health Physics Society in L Taylor Ltr to Commission ML20205P9691988-10-26026 October 1988 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re NUREG-1317, Regulatory Options for Nuclear License Renewal. Supports Contents of NUREG-1317 & Endorses NUMARC Comments on Rulemaking & Position Paper by NUMARC Nuplex Working Group W3P88-1366, Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Conserning Policy Statement Re Cooperation W/States at Commercial Nuclear Power Plants or Utilization Facilities1988-07-13013 July 1988 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Conserning Policy Statement Re Cooperation W/States at Commercial Nuclear Power Plants or Utilization Facilities ML20135F0931987-04-0909 April 1987 Testimony of Bb Hayes Before Senate Government Governmental Affairs Committee on 870326 Re Discovery of Sensitive NRC Document in Files of Senior Official of Louisiana Power & Light Co ML20212N5781986-08-27027 August 1986 Order Imposing Civil Monetary Penalty in Amount of $50,000 Based on Violations Noted in Insp Conducted on 860101-31. Violation Noted:Plant Entered Mode 3 While Relying on Action Requirements of Tech Spec 3.6.2.1 ML20202G3811986-04-10010 April 1986 Order Imposing Civil Penalties in Amount of $130,000,based on Safety Insps of Licensee Activities Under CPPR-103 Conducted from June 1983 - Sept 1985.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20210B9141986-02-0505 February 1986 Notice of Publication of Encl 841219 Order.Served on 860206 ML20198H4461986-01-30030 January 1986 Memorandum & Order CLI-86-01 Denying Remaining Portion of Joint Intervenors 841108 Fifth & Final Motion to Reopen Record Re Character & Competence of Util Per 850711 Decision ALAB-812.Dissenting View of Palladino Encl.Served on 860130 ML20137J3531986-01-17017 January 1986 Order Extending Time Until 860214 for Commission to Act to Review ALAB-812.Served on 860117 ML20138P5301985-12-20020 December 1985 Order Extending Time Until 860117 for Commission to Review ALAB-812.Served on 851220 ML20137U4821985-12-0505 December 1985 Order Extending Time Until 851220 for Commission to Act to Review ALAB-812.Served on 851205 ML20138S0051985-11-15015 November 1985 Order Extending Time Until 851206 for Commission to Review ALAB-812.Served on 851115 ML20138H2451985-10-24024 October 1985 Order Extending Time Until 851115 for Commission to Act to Review ALAB-812.Served on 851024 ML20133F2711985-10-0404 October 1985 Order Extending Time Until 851025 for Commission to Act to Review ALAB-812 .Served on 851007 ML20134L5981985-08-28028 August 1985 Notice of Appearance of R Guild & Withdrawal of Appearance by L Bernabei & G Shohet for Joint Intervenors.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20137J2801985-08-26026 August 1985 Answer in Opposition to Joint Intervenors 850809 Petition for Commission Review of Aslab 850711 Decision ALAB-812, Which Denied Joint Intervenors 841108 Motion to Reopen Record.Kw Cook 850821 Affidavit Encl ML20137J2941985-08-21021 August 1985 Affidavit of Kw Cook Re Recent Equipment Failures Discussed in Joint Intervenors 850809 Petition for Review.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20136J1961985-08-19019 August 1985 Answer Requesting That Commission Deny Joint Intervenors 850809 Petition for Review of ALAB-812 Denying Motion to Reopen QA & Character Competence Issues.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20133L8901985-08-0909 August 1985 Petition for Review of ALAB-812,denying Joint Intervenor Motion to Reopen Record of OL Hearing to Litigate Util Lack of Character & Inability to Assure Safe Operation in Light of Const QA Breakdown.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20133L0421985-08-0808 August 1985 Order Extending Time Until 850920 for Commission to Act to Review ALAB-812.Served on 850808 ML20128Q1861985-07-23023 July 1985 Request for Extension of Time Until 850809 to File Appeal to 850711 ALAB-812 Denying Joint Intervenors Motion to Reopen Record.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20209F1921985-07-11011 July 1985 Decision ALAB-812 Denying Joint Intervenors 841108 Motion to Reopen Record on Const QA & Mgt Character & Competence, Except Insofar as Issues Re Matters Under Investigation by Ofc of Investigation Are Raised.Served on 850711 ML20116P1931985-05-0606 May 1985 Response to NRC & Util Responses to Aslab 850322 Memorandum & Order ALAB-801.Motion to Reopen Record of Licensing Proceedings for Litigation of Util Competence Should Be Granted.Supporting Documentation & Svc List Encl ML20116H3341985-04-30030 April 1985 Notice of Appearance in Proceeding.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20100K3221985-04-10010 April 1985 Supplementary Comments Attesting to Validity of Statements of Fact in Sser 9 & Clarifying & Explaining Current Position on Resolution of Allegation A-48.Util Can Safely Operate & Manage Facility.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20111C7021985-03-14014 March 1985 Affidavit of RP Barkhurst Re Power Ascension Testing Program to Be Performed at Levels Above 5% of Rated Power.Facility & Operating Staff in Excellent State of Readiness to Proceed W/Power Ascension ML20112A9381985-03-14014 March 1985 Affidavit of RP Barkhurst Re Power Ascension Testing Program Performed at Levels Above 5% Rated Power & Delay in Issuance of Full Power Operating Authority.Related Correspondence ML20111B6541985-03-12012 March 1985 Motion for Leave to File Reply to Applicant Answer to Joint Intervenors Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Memorandum & Applicant Response to Supplemental Memorandum.Svc List Encl ML20102C1351985-02-28028 February 1985 Response Opposing Joint Intervenors 850225 Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Memorandum & Response to Suppl.Suppl Untimely Filed.Allegations Unsupported.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20107M7321985-02-25025 February 1985 Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Motions to Reopen.Request Based on Recent Public Repts Re Instability & Lack of Independence of Mgt of Applicant & Lack of Respect for NRC ML20195F5871985-02-25025 February 1985 Affidavit of Rk Kerr Re 841120 Meeting W/Cain,Dd Driskill, R Barkhurst,Admiral Williams & Rs Leddick to Discuss Licensee 1983 Drug Investigation 05-001-83(966) & 841206 Meeting Between Licensee & NRC in Arlington,Tx ML20107M7461985-02-25025 February 1985 Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Joint Intervenors Motion to Reopen.Determination by Aslab That Joint Intervenors Met Burden to Reopen Record for Litigation of Contention That Util Mgt Lacks Competence Requested ML20101T3701985-02-0101 February 1985 Answer Opposing Joint Intervenors 850125 Motion for Leave to File Reply to Applicant 841130 & Staff 841221 Answers.Motion Should Be Denied & Reply Brief Rejected.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20101U3411985-01-25025 January 1985 Joint Intervenors Motion for Leave to File Reply to Applicant & NRC 841221 Responses to Joint Intervenors 841108 Motion to Reopen Three QA & Mgt Integrity Contentions for Litigation ML20101U3511985-01-25025 January 1985 Joint Intervenors Reply to Applicant & NRC 841221 Responses to Joint Intervenors 841108 Motion to Reopen Three QA & Mgt Integrity Contentions for Litigation.Certificate of Svc Encl 1996-08-07
[Table view] Category:TRANSCRIPTS
MONTHYEARML20135F0931987-04-0909 April 1987 Testimony of Bb Hayes Before Senate Government Governmental Affairs Committee on 870326 Re Discovery of Sensitive NRC Document in Files of Senior Official of Louisiana Power & Light Co ML20195F6161984-12-0404 December 1984 Transcript of 841204 Investigative Interview of RP Barkhurst by D Driskill.Pp 1-61 IA-85-123, Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-441984-07-13013 July 1984 Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-44 ML20137A4561984-07-13013 July 1984 Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-44 ML20245K8971984-04-11011 April 1984 Statement of Bp Garde on Waterford III Nuclear Power Plant on 840411 in New Orleans,La ML20069F0581983-03-18018 March 1983 Proposed Corrections to 830208-11 Evidentiary Hearing Transcript.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028F1741983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of SM Hunter on Brochure, Plans to Help You During Emergencies. Fear Situation Should Be Placed First in Brochure.Separate Brochures Needed Based on Distance from Plant.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E9551983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of Gr Klare on Emergency Public Info Brochure. Brochure Clearly Presents Info in Manner to Be Readily Understood by Public at Large.Readability Level ALARA W/O Compromising or Confusing Message.W/Prof Qualifications ML20028E9431983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of Rj Perry on Emergency Public Info Brochure. Brochure Satisfies NRC Requirements & Meets Joint Nrc/Fema Criteria of NUREG-0654.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054J3481982-06-23023 June 1982 Proposed Corrections to Evidentiary Hearing Transcripts. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054D9011982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of JW Benton & AL Lookabaugh Re Emergency Planning,Contention 17/26.Discusses Provisions for Notifying Residents of Evacuation,Roads to Be Used & Evacuation Warning Sys.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054D9181982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Rg Azzarello,A Tsagggaris & Rj Perry on Radiological Emergency Response Plans,Contentions 17/26(1) (a) & (C - F).Discusses Provisions for Notifying Residents of Evacuation Procedures.W/Prof Qualifications ML20054D9251982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Kp Twine Re Contention 17/26 (1)(b) on Radiological Emergency Response Plan.Evacuation Time Estimate Study Realistically Shows Evacuation of Plume Emergency Planning Zone Possible.W/Prof Qualifications ML20054D9281982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Jm Lucas on Radiological Emergency Response Plan.Areas of Parish within Emergency Planning Zone Can Be Evacuated in Event of Serious Radiological Accident ML20054D9311982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Bp Madere Re Radiological Emergency Response Plans.Describes Preparation & Provisions of St John the Baptist Parish Emergency Plan ML20054D9341982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of RW Myers on Radiological Emergency Response Plans.Emergency Plan Meets Evaluation Criteria Re Evacuation of General Public for 10-mile Plume Exposure Pathway Emergency Panning Zone ML20054D9371982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Jj Mauro Re Use of Potassium Iodide as Thyroid Blocking Agent,Contention 17/26(2).No Current Accepted Public Health Practice Exists Which Provides for Potassium Iodide Use by General Public.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054D9431982-04-20020 April 1982 Rebuttal Testimony of Gb Hutchinson on Contention 8/9. Comments on Idj Bross Paper Presented at Symposium on Effects of Humans of Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054D9471982-04-20020 April 1982 Rebuttal Testimony of Ji Fabrikant on Contention 8/9.Refutes Idj Bross Assessment of Validity of Biostatistical Techniques & Elimination of Risk in Beir III Rept.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049J2461982-03-27027 March 1982 Testimony of SS Epstein Re Adverse Health Effects Linked W/Carcinogens in Environ.Affidavit,Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20041E4231982-03-0909 March 1982 Testimony of Ld Hamilton,Jj Maura & R Kenning Re Contention 8/9.Effects of Low Level Releases from Operation Assessed & Evaluation of Cumulative Impact Due to Plant Operation Conducted.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049J2151982-03-0808 March 1982 Testimony of Vl Campbell Re Cumulative Effects of Toxic Environ Chemicals & Radiation on Health of Population. Affidavit & Supporting Journal Articles Encl.Related Correspondence ML20049J2191982-03-0505 March 1982 Testimony of H Pandit Re Health Risks from Low Level Radiation Emissions.Affidavit,Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20049J2201982-03-0303 March 1982 Testimony of C Johnson Re Cancer &/Or Human Exposure to Radiation.Medical Journal Articles Encl ML20049J2441982-02-24024 February 1982 Testimony of Id Bross Re Health Risks to Southern La Populations from Addl Radiation in 1-rod Range.Affidavit, Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML19341C4951980-05-26026 May 1980 Direct Testimony & Exhibits of Jh Erwin ML19341C5011979-10-31031 October 1979 Testimony & Exhibits of Rj Lurito Re Fair Rate of Return Before Public Svc Commission of State of La ML19341C4991979-10-31031 October 1979 Testimony & Exhibits of Bm Louiselle Re Fair Rate of Return Before Public Svc Commission of State of La 1987-04-09
[Table view] Category:DEPOSITIONS
MONTHYEARML20135F0931987-04-0909 April 1987 Testimony of Bb Hayes Before Senate Government Governmental Affairs Committee on 870326 Re Discovery of Sensitive NRC Document in Files of Senior Official of Louisiana Power & Light Co ML20195F6161984-12-0404 December 1984 Transcript of 841204 Investigative Interview of RP Barkhurst by D Driskill.Pp 1-61 IA-85-123, Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-441984-07-13013 July 1984 Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-44 ML20137A4561984-07-13013 July 1984 Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-44 ML20245K8971984-04-11011 April 1984 Statement of Bp Garde on Waterford III Nuclear Power Plant on 840411 in New Orleans,La ML20069F0581983-03-18018 March 1983 Proposed Corrections to 830208-11 Evidentiary Hearing Transcript.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028F1741983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of SM Hunter on Brochure, Plans to Help You During Emergencies. Fear Situation Should Be Placed First in Brochure.Separate Brochures Needed Based on Distance from Plant.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E9551983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of Gr Klare on Emergency Public Info Brochure. Brochure Clearly Presents Info in Manner to Be Readily Understood by Public at Large.Readability Level ALARA W/O Compromising or Confusing Message.W/Prof Qualifications ML20028E9431983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of Rj Perry on Emergency Public Info Brochure. Brochure Satisfies NRC Requirements & Meets Joint Nrc/Fema Criteria of NUREG-0654.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054J3481982-06-23023 June 1982 Proposed Corrections to Evidentiary Hearing Transcripts. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054D9011982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of JW Benton & AL Lookabaugh Re Emergency Planning,Contention 17/26.Discusses Provisions for Notifying Residents of Evacuation,Roads to Be Used & Evacuation Warning Sys.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054D9181982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Rg Azzarello,A Tsagggaris & Rj Perry on Radiological Emergency Response Plans,Contentions 17/26(1) (a) & (C - F).Discusses Provisions for Notifying Residents of Evacuation Procedures.W/Prof Qualifications ML20054D9251982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Kp Twine Re Contention 17/26 (1)(b) on Radiological Emergency Response Plan.Evacuation Time Estimate Study Realistically Shows Evacuation of Plume Emergency Planning Zone Possible.W/Prof Qualifications ML20054D9281982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Jm Lucas on Radiological Emergency Response Plan.Areas of Parish within Emergency Planning Zone Can Be Evacuated in Event of Serious Radiological Accident ML20054D9311982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Bp Madere Re Radiological Emergency Response Plans.Describes Preparation & Provisions of St John the Baptist Parish Emergency Plan ML20054D9341982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of RW Myers on Radiological Emergency Response Plans.Emergency Plan Meets Evaluation Criteria Re Evacuation of General Public for 10-mile Plume Exposure Pathway Emergency Panning Zone ML20054D9371982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Jj Mauro Re Use of Potassium Iodide as Thyroid Blocking Agent,Contention 17/26(2).No Current Accepted Public Health Practice Exists Which Provides for Potassium Iodide Use by General Public.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054D9431982-04-20020 April 1982 Rebuttal Testimony of Gb Hutchinson on Contention 8/9. Comments on Idj Bross Paper Presented at Symposium on Effects of Humans of Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054D9471982-04-20020 April 1982 Rebuttal Testimony of Ji Fabrikant on Contention 8/9.Refutes Idj Bross Assessment of Validity of Biostatistical Techniques & Elimination of Risk in Beir III Rept.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049J2461982-03-27027 March 1982 Testimony of SS Epstein Re Adverse Health Effects Linked W/Carcinogens in Environ.Affidavit,Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20041E4231982-03-0909 March 1982 Testimony of Ld Hamilton,Jj Maura & R Kenning Re Contention 8/9.Effects of Low Level Releases from Operation Assessed & Evaluation of Cumulative Impact Due to Plant Operation Conducted.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049J2151982-03-0808 March 1982 Testimony of Vl Campbell Re Cumulative Effects of Toxic Environ Chemicals & Radiation on Health of Population. Affidavit & Supporting Journal Articles Encl.Related Correspondence ML20049J2191982-03-0505 March 1982 Testimony of H Pandit Re Health Risks from Low Level Radiation Emissions.Affidavit,Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20049J2201982-03-0303 March 1982 Testimony of C Johnson Re Cancer &/Or Human Exposure to Radiation.Medical Journal Articles Encl ML20049J2441982-02-24024 February 1982 Testimony of Id Bross Re Health Risks to Southern La Populations from Addl Radiation in 1-rod Range.Affidavit, Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML19341C4951980-05-26026 May 1980 Direct Testimony & Exhibits of Jh Erwin ML19341C5011979-10-31031 October 1979 Testimony & Exhibits of Rj Lurito Re Fair Rate of Return Before Public Svc Commission of State of La ML19341C4991979-10-31031 October 1979 Testimony & Exhibits of Bm Louiselle Re Fair Rate of Return Before Public Svc Commission of State of La 1987-04-09
[Table view] Category:NARRATIVE TESTIMONY
MONTHYEARML20135F0931987-04-0909 April 1987 Testimony of Bb Hayes Before Senate Government Governmental Affairs Committee on 870326 Re Discovery of Sensitive NRC Document in Files of Senior Official of Louisiana Power & Light Co ML20195F6161984-12-0404 December 1984 Transcript of 841204 Investigative Interview of RP Barkhurst by D Driskill.Pp 1-61 IA-85-123, Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-441984-07-13013 July 1984 Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-44 ML20137A4561984-07-13013 July 1984 Transcript of 840713 Meeting W/Util in Bethesda,Md Re Util 840628 Response to Ofc of Investigations Investigation. Pp 1-44 ML20245K8971984-04-11011 April 1984 Statement of Bp Garde on Waterford III Nuclear Power Plant on 840411 in New Orleans,La ML20069F0581983-03-18018 March 1983 Proposed Corrections to 830208-11 Evidentiary Hearing Transcript.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028F1741983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of SM Hunter on Brochure, Plans to Help You During Emergencies. Fear Situation Should Be Placed First in Brochure.Separate Brochures Needed Based on Distance from Plant.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20028E9551983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of Gr Klare on Emergency Public Info Brochure. Brochure Clearly Presents Info in Manner to Be Readily Understood by Public at Large.Readability Level ALARA W/O Compromising or Confusing Message.W/Prof Qualifications ML20028E9431983-01-26026 January 1983 Testimony of Rj Perry on Emergency Public Info Brochure. Brochure Satisfies NRC Requirements & Meets Joint Nrc/Fema Criteria of NUREG-0654.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054J3481982-06-23023 June 1982 Proposed Corrections to Evidentiary Hearing Transcripts. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054D9011982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of JW Benton & AL Lookabaugh Re Emergency Planning,Contention 17/26.Discusses Provisions for Notifying Residents of Evacuation,Roads to Be Used & Evacuation Warning Sys.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20054D9181982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Rg Azzarello,A Tsagggaris & Rj Perry on Radiological Emergency Response Plans,Contentions 17/26(1) (a) & (C - F).Discusses Provisions for Notifying Residents of Evacuation Procedures.W/Prof Qualifications ML20054D9251982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Kp Twine Re Contention 17/26 (1)(b) on Radiological Emergency Response Plan.Evacuation Time Estimate Study Realistically Shows Evacuation of Plume Emergency Planning Zone Possible.W/Prof Qualifications ML20054D9281982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Jm Lucas on Radiological Emergency Response Plan.Areas of Parish within Emergency Planning Zone Can Be Evacuated in Event of Serious Radiological Accident ML20054D9311982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Bp Madere Re Radiological Emergency Response Plans.Describes Preparation & Provisions of St John the Baptist Parish Emergency Plan ML20054D9341982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of RW Myers on Radiological Emergency Response Plans.Emergency Plan Meets Evaluation Criteria Re Evacuation of General Public for 10-mile Plume Exposure Pathway Emergency Panning Zone ML20054D9371982-04-20020 April 1982 Testimony of Jj Mauro Re Use of Potassium Iodide as Thyroid Blocking Agent,Contention 17/26(2).No Current Accepted Public Health Practice Exists Which Provides for Potassium Iodide Use by General Public.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054D9431982-04-20020 April 1982 Rebuttal Testimony of Gb Hutchinson on Contention 8/9. Comments on Idj Bross Paper Presented at Symposium on Effects of Humans of Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation.Prof Qualifications Encl ML20054D9471982-04-20020 April 1982 Rebuttal Testimony of Ji Fabrikant on Contention 8/9.Refutes Idj Bross Assessment of Validity of Biostatistical Techniques & Elimination of Risk in Beir III Rept.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049J2461982-03-27027 March 1982 Testimony of SS Epstein Re Adverse Health Effects Linked W/Carcinogens in Environ.Affidavit,Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20041E4231982-03-0909 March 1982 Testimony of Ld Hamilton,Jj Maura & R Kenning Re Contention 8/9.Effects of Low Level Releases from Operation Assessed & Evaluation of Cumulative Impact Due to Plant Operation Conducted.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20049J2151982-03-0808 March 1982 Testimony of Vl Campbell Re Cumulative Effects of Toxic Environ Chemicals & Radiation on Health of Population. Affidavit & Supporting Journal Articles Encl.Related Correspondence ML20049J2191982-03-0505 March 1982 Testimony of H Pandit Re Health Risks from Low Level Radiation Emissions.Affidavit,Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML20049J2201982-03-0303 March 1982 Testimony of C Johnson Re Cancer &/Or Human Exposure to Radiation.Medical Journal Articles Encl ML20049J2441982-02-24024 February 1982 Testimony of Id Bross Re Health Risks to Southern La Populations from Addl Radiation in 1-rod Range.Affidavit, Prof Qualifications & Supporting Documentation Encl ML19341C4951980-05-26026 May 1980 Direct Testimony & Exhibits of Jh Erwin ML19341C5011979-10-31031 October 1979 Testimony & Exhibits of Rj Lurito Re Fair Rate of Return Before Public Svc Commission of State of La ML19341C4991979-10-31031 October 1979 Testimony & Exhibits of Bm Louiselle Re Fair Rate of Return Before Public Svc Commission of State of La 1987-04-09
[Table view] |
Text
!
-...r-
.g7 [ 7 21 IU 20 April 20, 1982 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of )
)
LOUISIANA POWER & LIGHT )
COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-382
)
(Waterford Steam Electric )
Station, Unit 3) )
APPLICANTS'S TESTIMONY OF KEVIN P. TWINE ON RADIOLOGICAL EMERGENCY RESPONSE PLANS, CONTENTION 17/26(1)(b)
My name is Kevin P. Twine. I am Supervising Resources Planner at Ebasco Services, Inc., in charge of special projects involving land use, demographics, and socioeconomics. I hold a Master of Regional Planning degree from the University of North Carolina. My project-related experience with nuclear facil-ities includes work on environmental reports and safety analyses for four nuclear power plants, one national labora-tory, one fusion test reactor, and one decontamination project.
This work has involved detailed demographic work, detailed land l use studies, studies of agricultural parametrics, and work l
l relating to socioeconomics, aesthetics, and cultural resources, in accordance with the staldards of NRC Regulatory Guides 4.2 l
l 8204250 6'O
~
I
cnd 1.70. In cddition to Waterford 3, the nuclear power plant projects on which I have worked are located in Flordia, Greece, and the Phillippines. For the Florida project, my work on population served as input to the evacuation time estimate which was undertaken there. My involvement with nuclear projects has also included the land use studies for the Oak Ridge National Laboratory Environmental Report, and the demographics and land use work for the Tokamak Fusion Test Reactor in Princeton, New Jersey. I also managed an envi-ronmental report and engineering plan for decontamination of a uranium processing facility in New Jersey.
In addition, I have been responsible for the supervision of traffic impact studies for one coal-fire generating station in upstate New York, and two large synthetic fuels plants in the northeast, for which I oversaw the work of traffic engi-neering subcontractors in the performance of these studies.
Prior to joining Ebasco, I was responsible for coordinating traffic plans for a new town in Florida, and was in charge of the traffic planning efforts of the Portland, Maine Planning Department.
While at Ebasco, I have also had substantial experience in j dealing with the environmental impacts of major industrial l
l projects other than nuclear facilities. I was responsible for preparing the land use and socieconomic elements of the 1
environmental report for a 600 MW plant on the Ohio River, and was also responsible for directing a comprehensive study of
socioeconomic and land use impacts of the Lake Erie Generating
- Station in upstate New York. My experience also includes several siting studies for coal-fixed power plants, including a 1600 MW plant in Louisiana, a 1500 MW plant in Washington (
i State, and a 2000 MW complex in British Columbia. A summary of l my educational and professional experience and qualifications !
- is attached.
My testimony will address Joint Intervenors' Contention 17/26(1)(b) which reads as follows: >
The roads and highways necessary for (evacuation f of individuals located within the 10-mile plume !
exposure pathway emergency planning zone] are !
inadequate.
l I should note at the outset that neither Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) nor NRC regulations and criteria for emergency preparedness plans require the addition or upgrading '
- t
! of roads and highways for evacuation. Nor do FEMA and NRC have !
l requirements for maximum acceptable evacuation times. However, l t
] Evaluation Criterion J.8 of NUREG-06541/ specifies that the I applicant must provide an evacuation time estimate study for l
, the ten-mile plume exposure pathway Emergency Planning Zone 4 r
("EPZ") surrounding the site, which includes estimates of l evacuation times under various conditions. This study is to be [
in accordance with Appendix 4 of NUREG-0654.
I o t 1/ " Criteria for Preparation and Evaluation of Radiological '
Emergency Response Plans and Preparedness in Support of Nuclear i Power Plants," U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and Federal '
Emergency Management Agency, NUREG-0654/ FEMA-REP-1, Rev. 1, ;
November 1980. ,
i l
l
?
., .- ,, . . . , . - - - . . , - , == , - -.----r , - - , - , - - - - , . - . - , -e .-- ~- -
The primary benefit of the evacuation time estimate study is to provide the officials responsible for making protective action decisions in the event of a radiological emergency with a means to help determine whether, and the extent to which, evacuation is an appropriate protective action response in the specific circumstances surrounding a particular accident. The Waterford 3 study is based on an in-depth analysis of specific and detailed plans for evacuation unique to the Waterford 3 plant and its environs. Moreover, the computer model used for the study can be updated from time to time as appropriate to reflect physical and demographic changes which may occur in the area. The availability of the evacuation time estimate study, in conjunction with the onsite and offsite radiological emergency response plans, provides assurance that adequate protective measures can and will be taken in the event of a radiological emergency.
Louisiana Power & Light, through contract with Ebasco Services, Inc., submitted an evacuation time estimate study to the NRC on June 25, 1980, in response to a request dated December 26, 1979, from Brian K. Grimes, Director of NRC's Emergency Preparedness Task Group, to applicants for construc-tion permits and operating licenses. A revised report was submitted February 26, 1982.2/ While the basic methodology for predicting evacuation response times remained essentially 2/ " Evacuation Time Estimate," Waterford Steam Electric Station, Unit No. 3, Rev . 1, February 1982.
_4_
unchanged, the revised report reflects the plans and assumptions in the current offsite emergency response plans for Waterford 3. It also contains some additional information to conform to the guidance in Appendix 4 to NUREG-0654, which was issued subsequent to the original study.
My role in the conduct of the evacuation time study, as an employee of Ebasco Services, Inc. was to supervise the collec-tion of data on population, industries, and institutional facilities in the area, and to oversee the conduct of traffic planning studies and the implementation of the evacuation model. I have been closely involved with the Waterford 3 project since 1976, and have visited the site area numerous times. I have dealt with many local and state officials, as have other members of the evacuation time estimate study team.
We had therefore built up a substantial data base, and were thoroughly familiar with the Waterford 3 environs by the time we were called upon to do the evacuation time estimate. During the course of that study, I personally visited the site area and traveled throughout the EPZ several times. The project team (including myself) met with Parish civil defense officials and other responsible persons. The evacuation time estimate has therefore been prepared vith a thorough appreciation of local conditions.
The evacuation time estimate study will assist Parish officials in arriving at their protective action decisions.
The evacuation time estimate examines two general scenarios, l
-s-l l
l
clear and adverse weather, and displays the results in a form which is conducive to quickly identifying the estimated times for evacuation of portions or all of the plume EPZ. The time estimate is therefore a tool for local officials to use in implementing their protective actions, for it is an estimate I
against which they can judge the advisability of evacuation under actual conditions.
A computer simulation model was utilized in the evacuation time estimate study. The model is a dynamic, time' dependent model which can account for the movement and delay of vehicles on a minute-by-minute basis. The use of a computer simulation model offers two main advantages. First, it approximates, as realistically as possible, actual vehicle movement, allowing for the identification of roadways and intersections where traffic control may be needed or where routing could be modified to maintain vehicle movement. Secondly, a computer simulation model is relatively easy to update and revise to reflect new information, such as changes in population levels and changes to the highway network.
The methodology used relies on actual demographic and transportation information. The study utilized 1982 population projections derived from the 1980 census for the area, and field studies on special facilities and the roadway network conducted in February, 1980 and January, 1982. The roadway network data consisted of determining the major routes which could be utilized for evacuation, as well as the size of these l
l l
l
routes (i.e., number of lanes), the capacity of the roadways (number of vehicles / hour), the type of roadway (two lane rural, multi-lane, etc.) and the average design speed for each route.
In addition, information was also collected on the intersec-tions along each route, the traffic controls at each intersec-tion, and identification of any other features which could potentially cause traffic delays or congestion. The informa-tion and assumptions used are provided in the evacuation time estimate report.
The demographic and roadway network information bases were combined and placed into the computer model, along with certain assumed conditions, to develop the evacuation time estimates for twelve specified sectors within the plume EPZ. The transient, resident and institutional population was assigned to various evacuation routes, and times were calculated for their evacuation from each area under both clear and adverse weather conditions. The results of the initial study were submitted to the NRC for review and were available to Louisiana Power & Light and Parish officials as an assistance to the development of the emergency plans for St. Charles Parish and St. John the Baptist Parish.
In the period between completion of the initial time estimate study and the current revision, the NRC issued NUREG-0654 containing its final guidance on the format require-ments for evacuation time estimates, and the Parishes' detailed plans for evacuation were completed. These included the use of 1
an outdoor siren warning system which was not assumed in the original study. The recently completed revised time estimate study incorporates the changes needed to reflect these developments, and is responsive to the advice of NRC's evac-uation time study consultant concerning the evacuation model.
Further, the most recent estimate was developed in consultation with Parish officials in order to more closely reflect the methods and policies which might actually be utilized in the event of an evacuation.
The evacuation time estimate study realistically demon-strates that, given tha present roadway network, evacuation of all or a portion of ths plume EPZ is an implementable protec-tive response available for consideration by Parish officials should a radiological emergency occur at Waterford 3. The decision to undertake evacuation, either as the only protective response or in combination with other protective responses, is one which must be made in light of conditions as they are -
occurring at the time of the need to take action. An updated evacuation time estimate will be a valuable tool to assist Parish officials in making that decision.
l I
KEVIN P. TWINE Supervising Resources Planner Ebasco Services, Inc.
Education: B.A., History, Wesleyan University, 1965.
M.R.P., Regional Planning, University of North Carolina, 1967.
Experience: 1979 to Present and 1974 to 1978: Supervising Resources Planner, Ebasco Services, Inc. Responsible for the supervision and preparation of land use, demographic and socioecomic impact studies of major industrial facilities, including four nuclear power plants, one national laboratory, one fusion test reactor and one decontamination project. With respect to these nuclear projects, responsibilities have included the preparation of environmental reports and safety analyses dealing with land use studies, studies of agricultural parameters, aesthetics and cultural resources, in accord with NRC Regulatory Guide *t 1.70 and 4.2. This position has also included responsibility for the supervision of traffic impact studies for several major industrial facilities.
1978 to 1979: Consultant, Fantus Company. Involved in the performance of siting studies for the corporate headquarters of five Fortune 500 companies.
1972 to 1974: Land Planner, Florida Gas Company.
Responsible for land and traffic planning for the Orangewood New Town and other planned residential communities.
1969 to 1972: Community Development Coordinator, City of Portland, Maine Planning Department. Responsible for the development of a downtown urban renewal plan and in charge of traffic planning efforts.
1968 to 1969: Consultant, Gassner, Nathan, Browne.
Performed population-economic base studies for three cities.
1967 to 1968: Memphis and Shelby County, Tennessee Planning Commission. Involved in the development of city parks and recreational plans.
Professional Affiliations: American Society of Photogrammetry.