ML20040E465
| ML20040E465 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Zimmer |
| Issue date: | 03/17/1981 |
| From: | James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | Stello V NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20040E458 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-81-376, FOIA-81-A-15 NUDOCS 8202040370 | |
| Download: ML20040E465 (5) | |
Text
9
~
1 Y.
i
.Ic2 %..zae)
- =
[..
}
//
g*
U.if I ts 511.1 t5
,p 4:,
[.
- t
,.\\,
NUCLEAR REGUI' ATORY COPWl55tofd QC -
' '. d 'P : P i
t.
18 )
RE Glo N lil e
4. a f, i pr.; 9;
- e.
.o
. oQ.A [
tJ s
. 799 smoostvts.T noAn st e, t. ;: :. Q:,..i
. ~.,
s 4
.. c LrN rt,.LvN, sLi.eNoss so 3
... la. T *4 e.
.* ;.t].p i e:
4 U.
t.
f: ;-
i; :i t 4 i
March 17,1981
- i -
- . n r
..".l e W. W.. d 4.,.
. W.
- n;
- V.. *.' *.. - [.
?. d.:.;
. r,, l,
%i c-s% y 3... ~
y.....
..s
.gf.,b. :D '.!
MDDRANDUM. FORr !. Victor Stellogi.Jr'.vDirector,ief fice of Inspedt'idd2itilia +i ts.' 2.i)R it
.4 e.i e i.
and Enforcem.ent. i. ::" 1.~
b.: s 4 M e,ii.i.t vi t. i d. n...'*.
' h. e m.
$1 e
.1. : s is::. ~
L TRbhin H; 5
f N j#. + 2 ';7 ^.7.y fiH.
.j#,.:l i r. James C.~ Keppleril Directore. >KIJt.!'Ed.' /03?ind ! f;}.i 7}1$.N A M*yggs
'(
i.
c,..,,
!it,14 H M t'.T m SUBJECTS!T;'ilN il L:t 11NVESTICAT10N :OFlAPPLEGATE IAI.!EGATIONgiRELATED' TOTI.
,q..
p
--2
.... C :iq?.-
- s.
..a.
N.
.?
p%g gf.,
- I p.i G*.t.,
id..ci,.16:: ilsn,The.. purpose of this.inemorandum:is :to. update ;yob oncthei s'tatus'ef.hthitis HimP.1 in 1
i.a..
.?ct'si!
investigation: and: inform::youlof:.ours futsre : course tof 'setioisir silid:sid-J sWd d b !!d:p
- f. t.9. A:l. We expect: to. complete.Etiext. week.ouriinvestigation of.th'e.*first;19; allegations'.l<i;. 24
- ,i t: Ju n r: i-t i received-:from MrdApplegate.ivia.ihe Governmenti Accour.tabilitiy..Projnct (CAP)';b:bli.4
.i':i :- / g.. :There ha,ve been no significant : findings. co. dates :.:Eitheir.thecallegati6nki.bave fit i:8 c>
-!< a.v
'not ibeen.. substantiated orp for those f. substantiated,:.there is :not'safetyss4mri4Cr.a ':
significance.-
4.LJ. i....t i
i t ' J. i' a.s +. t. m
+ s i.. s a.
aw. - -.
e i. e o...
. As4 a..res' ult :of our finvestigations linto the 419 ialle'gations = theres have".bcen iiLi ml! W5 ics i. 3, O r
.about, twice. that many:additionaltmatteers tuncovered;N Ve eare:now::itirtheisprocess hjlig i s i m.4,i :.Wof:iinvestigatin g'.theseaand i.many !. appear.to be isignificantli siSom'diidfdthinnoEehJri,1) j fb bg W.ivi: ;c... i. significant nones :. involve.badiseldsFonis tructifrale s teel g limpro pe'rly fvdided:iiEi.ieil. hie isir t t: L.: : nenonconformance : reports gralaeki of : traceability.tof atructurali mateiialsi;i:impr6per a 14
' ::e (si.. :.socketi weld.fitupsr. improper veld': inspection. ~criteriac. inadequate radiographs
- Jt) is u: ":
i 4.. on nany.svandor supplied. welds,i'and,.iuadequaterCincinnati : Gas' & Electric!I..sti.::sf E 111 is
. 4. i s Company :(CC&E) quality assurance implementetionei; We anticipatelaboutt twolsi' sis.rW:1is v.i W L.' r. i s.. ::.u nuore weeks.of.on-siteiinvestigationito, complete.our.treview'.of ithese : additional J: ri items..
a l t:. r :. : -. i.: n Of the original ::19 iallegations.our : findings from: interviewing.various people!. r2 ;t differ from:the rfindingsimide:iby GAP.:in their. interviews iof.theIsame. people. ti.14id
- 'm l
> In:this ; regard e we tintend: to rreguestier meeting with the ; CAP attorneyi.r lh c) 1.:': l' ii s her assigned.to this case and:. resolve itheidiscrepanciessa :We ihave: apprised :the::2. ;; nin i:
}.:t * :s. m Department ;of Justice (DOJ)'t(i.'e. g rthe.U.S.. criminal. Division Attorney;ish.:a 1M.::ti b.c.
..l' aissigned toiOhio :andethe Chief, Special: Processing UnitiiSouthern!Ohin; District).;:p l (.. i is c : :. : oft our ainveistigation efforta:and.have : confirmed.that DOJihasiall.information3Mui-g U
. i s i at provided:to.ius by CAP;- DO.istihformed tss': that, they..have.:found ? the"information!! Edit.p-(.is.:.:..
toibs.without merit.:sfrom.siiDOJ. criminal 1 investigation : standpoint. awe !will-keep id.c
- i... :t
..u.c h.D0Jiinformed ofloiar tinvestilgation'. prog;ress gitesp-clallynindareas.ewhere ave ibelieNieMr
.u criminal. findings may. develop.
i w ;.
r l. ;'...
- 't J:ssi:l'.:2 e
t'
's mil rO y e 4
.n s ',*'. i.....
i
- k l e 4-s. ;
hfe t.s-Q s.t.4 & ll; b 9.. ;
.Kaf g
,y,{$ w M.. Mr. @ If LOWENS81-A-15 PDR M i $ 1(d. 'D s y.sF A/C h4 */.,
.:e"*
.J li :1,,,,eg), R,Ill -
R1 summ'P. Davis /jr I i Xc l er '.
Sf7refeT" IV U CII"3 I /I
- *) 8-ge,y.{ m.
,g p'
... ~. ~
.,A_2//_2 / 81 3/O'}/81 2/87/9R
/[')
t
t t
r
(-
\\
(.
' Victor St ello, Jr..
2:
e ;!...
.:.1 4 3/17/81 1 2 2
.e
- i. 'there is mosE e'videncai of alcoholt and: drug uma nei the Zina r cita in that j..u 14 I :
1 tji l s..
11.
Il p;ij
..eepty. beer containersiand marijuanticigcrctte.buttaiihebu 'bezu fchdtDir l:
.m. llid,li'
.i i g io. i t.: 1kuever. no osa bas s atatedetbat-the'uss vaa ri.rtcinciva at that' much use Jit d t.f
- F.r 4 Y tr 4,5 p i,, affactad construct, ton qualityd WeStre istte=pting' to. identify wort. Valehtvi 4 !t t ila J 681
.Il Ji: si:a 1.. nny.hevs beed performed :by petcons ':uader the:' influence of drugs or alebbol'..;t t Q 14,,3 eb. p g ;.. f..lf.* iara, stiy],.:considering'.,the :bastt way. to address. this" allegation.'lich#
"t p d
4 ': t ;
- . r.. 3
,y
.i a.t.... (lasi;W: "i;@p, N.[ilIIF.$...fi/.:.% plan ito'addtl.with dGLEt withiC tha'next' two 'w'aetAit'cirdia]dUsV our :ffndthgs Qisimi: dr iss ofi that.' tima'.andi:obtainitheir: resolutioni'of thsmNt81t' tha'ti'tima vsf 0111t' L l I'Mldirn f
.%)!', i 1:5 11.- decide.whether any atop work 'o'rder should be'issum'dt'l F.th'a.t4b W nJjlhit:ld_. #M acl"ar.-l
,. s :l: 4.. l.y' l. a.If 7ou hava.any quastions.or' advice iragarding the inforn.ation' prezantad'aboveis kil'dif we would appreciate hearing from you. sg - ta a :4.i:
m ' in rY.12' '.1,.: h r #til
' +i h'i l il l
James C. Kappler '-
F i
r 3
Director 1.
ces R. C. DeYoung. IE I:
9.
J. H. Sniezek., -IE i
D. Tho ::pson, IE. '.
i,,
t, M. +.
' ' J. J. Cu::unin gs, OI A 7.
a -
.: r i ;;,.. :: 6
- i w.
At' bcct:
R. E. JHeishman ::. ?..
v.
t..
... d /.'
- ! i:.
- w. 1.
'i C. E. Norclius :
i ic J. - F. Streeter s
R. F. Warnick P. A. Barrett J. B. ?!cCarten I
l 11 1
1 orncekl 1
l.
I 8*
8-l I
w - c h.____________*____.__'_______l_______
. __e l
o d m
--,___ _ 1
= _ - -
m
e-e 2
OO g
,o 9/2 /
.!'12 5!
0/A flb RA
?b d.fy.
_f e /r,y,
.).
y J,M
" ?&L n.
- m - RAAnaeA
<~
makau4 & ".#54 n.e 4,.a 7t & Ass 4 -
xM~&M4 2C
-M an.
KAD -
2 st e 2P~nc b adf
- h &,.,F W %AW e/
-p A/A C Acd,
'/
/
M x
a
' - RAdd x
M, wA s / 6 7. 2 L a ;.,
e 97a; y.x 7M &
IAAtx b
ng 07s-ery y
' aJ9
4 Aw Rad 2J
\\
e A
'-Xna Ax 7M L C
-J J.A
/
J
-n
'- O r Q
<a) n, A
.FAC.&,
- dAAM761777 rU M
4b ~&
ou A4 A
/
h s_<, 7 S
Od M Anv_h Eg-s=w.a AA A
1&,
a n
%~
48 sa.
.a.
7 A;CJ
& D A <; b +
f(
l'
~
d
m.-
e e
e 9
2 c6+e.
P
'Jy-
.4.s; A n '. ' J / k
,a A" au
-L t*
kniC<~ ~A
.zt 2
.J?d m b 4 2 h a--
w x-2A x
4 6
l l
l