ML20040D032

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Request for Addl Info Re Equipment Environ Qualification Review of Licensee Resolution of Outstanding Issues from NRC Equipment Environ Qualification Safety Evaluation Repts & TMI Action Plan Installed Equipment.
ML20040D032
Person / Time
Site: North Anna  Dominion icon.png
Issue date: 12/16/1981
From:
FRANKLIN INSTITUTE
To:
NRC
Shared Package
ML20039A822 List:
References
CON-NRC-03-79-118, CON-NRC-3-79-118, RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-737, TASK-***, TASK-TM IEB-79-01B, IEB-79-1B, RFI-C5257-520, NUDOCS 8201290516
Download: ML20040D032 (14)
v • d • e


Text

' '

  • REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION EQUIPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION (EEQ)

REVIEW OF LICENSEES' RESOLUTION OF OUTSTANDING ISSUES -

FROM NRC EQUIPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION SAFETY EVALUATION REPORTS (SER) AND TMI ACTION PLAN INSTALLED EQUIPMENT Virginia Power and Electric Company North Anna Potter Station Unit 2 NRC Docket ho. 50-339 December 16, 1981 NRC TAC No. 42540 Dmpa_ d 8 zot zRos%

. . Franklin Research Center A Division of The Franklin Institute The Benjamn Frank 5n Parkwey, PhiLs, Pa. 19103(215)448 1000

, .y_-, - - -- _ .-, , _m. -,

~*

+ .

RFI-C5257-520 .

BACKGROUND of Philadelphia, Pa. is providing assis-Franklin Research Center (FRC) for the equipment tance to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC)

FRC will environmental qualification (EEQ) review of operating reactors.

per orm an EEQ review of the Licensee's 90-day response to outstanding issues frca the NRC Equipment Environmental Qualification Safety Evaluation Report (SER) and the installed TMI Action Plan equipment. The review will be limited The to safety-related equipment potentially exposed to a harsh environment.

results will be presented in the form of a technical evaluation report for each plant.

This request for additional information (RFI) is the result of an 4, 1981 (1),

evaluation of the information provided by letters dated September May 31, 1981 [2] , and December 1,1980 [3] .* FRC prev'iously requested TMI 31, 1981 [4].

Action Plan information by a telephone memorandum dated August In response, VEPCO transmitted the following information on September 11, 1981 and October 8,1981:

1.- FSAR Sections 6.2.3 and 6.2.1

2. VEPCO response to NUREG-0737, Post TMI requirem'ents dated 31-May-81
3. Qualification Documents:

a.

Babcock & Wilcox transmittal 86-1119091-00, Relief Valve Acoustical Monitoring

b. Isomedix Inc. , Component Testing Division, Environmental Exposure of Liquid Level Sensor dated November 17, IS75, for GEMS level detector, plant ID ILT-DA110A & 'B. ,

c.

Environmental test report summaries of Foxboro products, the Foxboro Company transmitters, plant ID #PT-EM110A & B.

d. Westinghouse Electric Corporation letter NS-SS-79287 da~ted November 28, 1979, subject, Qualification of Electrical Equipr ent for Near Term OL Plants.
  • Numbers in brackets refer to citations.found in the list of references.

4bu FrankHn Research Center A Desman of The Frans6nInsmause

. . .e- . amiummmmamad e w=

._a. w..

,-,,,-y- , , , , - , - - - , , , - - , - , - - - g

RFI-C5257-520

e. Letter from Milton Aron (DeLaval, GEMS Sensor Division) to Arthur Murphy, Stone & Wcebster Engineering Corporation dated 7' May 1974. '

f.

GEMS level transmitter, plant ID #LT-RS-151A & B (test reports) .

A. FRC REVIEW OF THE LICENSEE'S 90-DAY RESPONSE TO THE NRC EEQ SER Date Received by FRC**

Information Requested

1. In reference to the Licensee's 90-day response [1] to the NRC SER [5], a legible single copy of each of the following qualification documents is requested in order that the FRC evaluation may proceed:
a. Trexler, D. L. , General Cable Corporation to Wright, R. D. , Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, Subjects Cable Constructions, December 22, 197*.

b. Chapman, L., Stone, J., Tests of Electrical Cables after Simulated Post Accident Reactor Containment Service, Cerro Wire and Cable Company, a Supplement to Franklin Institute Research Laboratories Final Report

~2 F-C2857, March 1971. .

c. Chapman, L., Stone, J., Tests of Electrical Cables af ter Simulated Post-Accident Reactor Containment Service, Franklin Institute Research Laboratories, Cerro Wire and Cable ~

Company, a Supplement to Franklin Institute Research Laboratories Final Report F-C2750, March 1970. -

d. Learn, J..R., Boston Insulated Wire and Cable Company to Wright, R. D. , Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, 300 V Instrument cables and 600 V Control

  • Cables, January 17, 1972.
    • This column will be completed by FRC as the requested information is received.'

M .A L Franklin Research Center A Ommen of The Fremen ensames i

. i 4*

- * - m .e # e um e

~ w.

m 4

RFI-C5257-520 .

Date Received by FRC_**

Marth, J. R. , Rockbestos Company, to

. e. Stone & Webster Heneberry, E.,

Engineering Corporation, Qualification of Cable for Operation During Main Steam Line Break, April 25, 1977.

Lasky, J. S., The Okonite Company, to f.

Barnhart, J. H. , Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Cable,

  • December 22, 1980.

Cookinham, J. B., Westinghouse Corp.,,

g. Jr., VEPCO, NUREG-0588 to Brown, S. C.,

Equipment Qualifics. tion, NAW-361, dated October 30, 1980.

h. Electric Power Research Institute, Evaluation and Test of Improved Fire-Resistant Fluid Lubricants for Water Reactor Ccolant Pump Motors, Volume 1: Fluid Evaluation, Bearing Model Tests, Motor Tests, and-Fire

, Tests, NP-1447, Volume 1, Research Project 893-1, Interim Report, dated July 1980. .

Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering 1.

Corporation, to Lenahan, B. , Okonite l Cable Corporation, Cable, August 12, 1980. .

\

j. Broadway, N. J., Palinchak, S., Effects of Nuclear Radiation on Elastomeric and Plastic Components and Materials, Radiation Effect Information Center,  ;

Report No. 21, Columbus, Ohio. . J

- i

'k . Sheets, M. W. , Tcpical Report on '

General Electric Vertical Induction  !

Motors, Inside.. Containment l Recirculation Spray Pumps - Surry and 1 North Anna Stations - Third Addition to (

Cover Rebuilding Motors Using New l Bearings, Docket Numbers 50-280 and j 50-281, July 23, 1979. l nklin Research Center A Omason of The Frerwen m

RFI-CS257-520 Date Received by FRC**

1. Bell, C. E. , General Electric Corporation, to Bonner, J. , Stone ti Webster Engineering Corporation, pH for Recirculation Spray Pumps, October 28, 1980.
m. Gould-Brown Boveri, Radiation Qualification Report, S.O., No.

33-54685-RR, North Anna Power Station Unit 2, Indoor Secondary Unit .

Substations, December 1980.

n. Anderson, T. M. , Westinghouse Electric Corporation, to Stolz, J. F., Nuclear Regulatory Commission, NS-TMA-1950, September 29, 1978. Attachments include: Westinghouse Electric Corporation,. Sensor Qualification Program IEEE 323, 1971, Demonstrating Program, Final Test Report for the Barton/ITT Modified Pressure Transmitter (Proprietary).
o. Anderson, T. M. , Westinghouse Electric .

Corporation, to Stolz', J. F., Nuclear ,

Regulatory Commission, NS-TMA-2120, September 14, 1979. Attachmerts ~

include: Westinghouse Electric Corporation, Supplemental Qualification Testing of Barton Lot 1 Pressure and Differential Pressure Transmitters

! (Proprietary).

p. Stolz, J. F., Nuclear Regulatory i

Commission, to Anderson, T. M.,

Westinghouse Electric Corporation,

Subject:

Class lE Electrical and Control Equipment, January 15, 1979.

q. Conax Corporation, Design Qualification .

i Test Report for a Conax. Low Voltage

  • Control Service Classification Conductor Feedthrough Assembly, P/N '

7641-21001, Test Report No. IPS-353.2, June 18, 1979.~

s A Dhamen of The Fremen ansensee -

5 RFI-CS257-520 Date Received by FRC**

r. Federic"k, W. C., Conax Corporation, to Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation,

Subject:

Environmental

- Qualification Electrical Penetrations, North Anna Units 1 and 2, January 8, 1981.

s. Sheets, M. W., Topical Report on General Electric Vertical Indaction Motors, Inside Containment Recirculation Spray Pump Motors - Surry Power Station - Second Addendum to Cover Heat Aging, Radiation Exposure, .

Vibration, and Steam / Chemical Spray

  • Exposure Qualification Test, NRC Docket Nos. 50-280 and 50-281, June 12, 1973.
t. Drab, J. B., Limitorque Corporation, to Reilly, P. , Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Motor Operated valves,

. September 19, 1980. Possible attachments include: Reilly, P., Stone

& Webster Engineering Corporation, to Drab, J. Limitorque Corporation, two letters, October 10, 1980 and August 29, 1980.

u. Drab, J. B. , Limitorque Corporation, to Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Motor Operated Valves, ,

October 21, 1980.

v. Excerpt from Raychem Report RT 1508/1, October 12, 1978,
w. Maire, 'D. G. , Westinghouse. Electric .

Corporation, to Brown, S. C., Virginia ,

Electric and Power Company, CH/SI Pump Motors, S.O.,.VRA/VGB-460, August 19, 1980. -

x... Bell, C. , General Electric, telecom to Walker, F. P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Outside Recirculation Spray Motors, April 10, 1979.

, b Franklin Research Center A om.on w The newn w

---__=J-________________________

s. .. .

RFI-C5257-520

~

Date Received by TRC**

y. Devin, P. E. , Raychem Corporation, to Bonner, J., Stone & Webster Engineering ,

Corporation, April 24, 1979.

z. Al-75-2 Rev. 3 (P) - Thermal Hydrogen Recombiner System for Water-Cooled Reactors aa. Al-72 Thermal Recombiner Demonstration Test bb. Al-73 Hydrogen Recombiner for PWR Post-LOCA Applica' tion cc. 'Newcomb, R., Virginia Electric and Power Company, to' MacFarlane, I. , Stone

& Webster Engineering Corporation, Memo concerning oil in CH/SI Pumps, dated December 31, 1980, dd. Lasky, J. S., The Okonite Company, to Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corpcration, August 21, 1980, ee. Drab, J. B., Limitorque Corporation, to Bonner, J. , Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Telecom concerning Motor '

Operated Valves, October 16, 1980.

ff. Rockwell International Report AI-ESGN139TIl20010 - Operational Experience of Thermal Hydrogen Recombiner Systems and Components for .

PWR and BWR Mark III Reactor Systems.

gg. Rockwell' International Report AI-ESGN139TI120002 - PWR Hydrogen Recombiner Radiation Resistance.

hh. Rockwell' International Report AI-ESGN019PP120007 - Environmental .

Qualification Plan for Hydrogen Recombiner Motor / Blower Assembly.

ii. Rockwell International Report AI-ESGN019PP120009 - Environmental Qualification Plan for Hydrogen Recombiners, PWR.

- i 400hu klinFranResearch Center

% a m roi.an m .

j

% , e- -

. }

s

. RFI-CS257-520 Date Received by'FRC**

jj. Rockwell International Report AI-ESGN00lTP0000ll - Functional Checkout for Class lE Motor / Blower Assemoly.,

kk. Rockwell International Report AI-ESGN00lTP000013 - Functional Checkout for Class lE Components Undergoing IEEE 323-1974 Qualification Testing.

11. Brindley, J. H., Rockwell International, to Reilly, P., Stone &

Webster Engineering Corp. , Hydrogen Recombiner, July 17, 1980.

mm. Wheeler, L. W., Rockwell International, to Bechet, C. T., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, reply to 81 ESG-3176, May 19, 1981.

nn. Wyle Laboratories, Final Qualification Plan for Motor / Blower Assemblies for Rockwell International, Energy Systems Group for use in Nuclear Power Station, Qualification Plan NES-57553, Rev. C, July 27,1979.

oo. American Environmental Company, Abnormal Environment Qualification Test

  • Report on Series 170 Motor Control Centre for Klockner-Moeller Limited,.

Natick, Mass., Report STR-132778-1, Februsty 5,1979.

pp. Stone, L. R. , Rockwell International, *

-to Stoll, S. , Stone & Webster -

Engineering Corporation, Hydrogen Recombiner, May 20, 1980.

qq. Blackwood, J. A. , Foxboro Company, to

  • Barachewicz, J., Stone & Webst'er.

Engineering Corporation, October 27, 1980.

-7

, 000 Franklin Research Center 4 % wn.rr.nma =

%= ,

RFI-C5257-520 Date Received by FRC**

tr. Conax Corporation, Qualification Report for Electric Penetration Assemblies for North Anna Power Station - Units 1 & 2, Virginia Electric and Power Company, Conax W/O 7-02100, IPS-601, October 1980. -

ss. Drab, J. B., Limitorque Corporation, to Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, October 22, 1980.

tt. Bartolucci, E. J., LOCA Qualification Report for Okoguard Insulated Cables and T-95 and No. 35 Splicing Tapes, Okonite Company, June 23, 1980.

uu. Federick, W. C., Conax Corporation, to Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, November 19, 1980.

vv. Lasky, J. S., The Okanite Company, to MacFarlen, I., Sc.ne & Webster Engineering Corporation, Cable, October 10, 1980. ,

ww. Grisdale, R. T., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation to Whom It May .

Concern, December 18, 1980.

xx. GE Radiation Resistance,Section III.

yy. Sears, J. A. and Ramsell, Radiation Test of E10 Series Amplifiers, Standard -

and Radiation Resistant Types, Foxboro Company, Test Report No. T3-1097, November 1973.

z. Conax Corporation, Desight Qualification

. Report for A 42 Conductor No. 18 AWG, Conax Low Voltage Service

  • l Classification Conductor Feedthrough . ,

Assembly Consistent with the l

! Requirements of IEEE Standard 317-1976 (NRC Regulatory Guide 1.63, July 1978). IPS 353.10, November 17, 1980 (Proprietary).

l l

l nk!!n Research Center A Ohnmen af The Fruruen kuumme

_____._._ ___--__.__._-__a__-- . _ _ _._a__ _ __--__._ -_ _

RFI-C5257-520 Date Received by FRC**

ama. Limitorciue Corporation, Nuclear i Qualification Data Sheet, November 1, 1979.

bbb. Federick,LW. C., Conax Corporation, to .

Bonner, J., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, January 5, 1980, ccc. McCarthy, P. T., Klockner-Moeller.

Corporation to ,Bradley, C., Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, April 3, 1981.

ddd. McCarthy, P. T., Klockner-Moeller Corporation to Bonner, J., Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, January 13, 1981.

eee. Lewicki, Reginald, Reliance Electric Company, to Barnhart, J. H. , Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, November 14, 1980.

fff. Buckley, R. , Radiation Technology, Inc., to McIntire, D., Gilbert Associates, Inc. , Letter dated June 8',

1981.

ggg. Devin, P.E. , Raychem Corp to D.

McIntire, Gilbert Associates Inc., May -

7, 1981.

, hhh. Okonite Company, Qualification of Okonite Ethylene - Propylene Rubber Insulation for Nuclear Plant Seitvice, July 3,1978. .

+

iii. Bell, C. E. , General Electric, to J. H.

Barnhart, Stone & Webster Engr. Corp.

March 12, 1981, with Attachment -

Qualification Report of General Electric Vertical Induction Motors for Class lE Recirculation Spray Pumps for the North Anna Power Station, by M. W.

Sheets, January 28,1981, 492HA289.

-9_

0I Franklin Resear ch Center 4 %.#Th.Fr . in

s .

e  ; e ,

RFI-C5257-520 Date Received by FRC**

jjj. Raychem Corp. , A Life Assessment of Raychem Heat Shrinkable High Voltage Terminators, Report No. EDR5018, March 28, 1980..

kkk. J. B. Drab, Limitorque Corp. ,. to R. R. -

Champagne, VEPCO, June 15, 1981.

111. Rahman, R. , Raychem Corp. , to D.

McIntire, Gilbert Assoc. Inc., June 25, 1981.

mmm. General Cable Corp., General Cable Corporation Report on Radiation

  • Resistance of Material Used in Nuclear Power and Control Cable, M. A. Durakis, May 24, 1972.

nnn. VEPCO, Letter and Attachments,.

Environmental Qualification of Class lE Equipment, North Anna Power Station, Containment Electrical Penetrations, Conax Field Splices (Includes Termination Procedure) A. L. Parrish, .

III, July 6, 1981.

~

ooo. Maximum Emergency Environment Test "

Report, Conax IPS-73.4 Rev. A, 5/13/75:

SCEW 24A ppp. Conax Test Procedure IPS-72, Rev. A, 9/24/73 SCEW 24A qqq. Okonite Report NQRN-3, 5-11-81 .

rrr, Geruld-Boveri Letters 4-29-79 and 6-11-81 ,

sss. Limitorque/GAI Letter 3-3-81 ttt. Stone and Webster Calculation ES/180; .

SCEW 33a l uuu. Stone and Webster Letter 8-29-80; ,

SCEW W-5 vvv. Stone and Webster Calculation 12050-RP-122-03 SCEW W-42 l nklin Research Center i

A Denman of Die Frenten wisunne f

n - - y... , , . - ,_.L.---..- --,--,-.--,.,e

. . Uo '

a e i . g.

EFI-CS257-520 www. Raychem Letter 4-21-81 with attached' ENQC-126; 10/78

2. Many SCEWs pertaining to Limitorque motor- '

operated valves were missing information necessary for the FRC review to proceed (model no. motor make, model, and current -

c typer insulation typer brake model and manufacturer). FRC requests this information.

B. FRC REVIEW OF INSTALLED TMI ' ACTION PLAN ITEMS Information Requested Date Received by FRC**

1. Reference 7 does not provide adequate detail with respect to identification of TMI Action

~

Plan equipment installed after 1/1/81.

a. Identification of TMI Action Plan equipment installed with implementation dates after 1/1/81 is requested,
b. The correlation of these equipment items with the specific sections of NUREG-0737

[7] is requested.

(The correlation is needed to ensure that all items are included in the review, e.g., if a transmitter is identified as a TMI Action Plan item, are the cable and terminal blocks associated with the device also identified?]

c. For all installed TMI Acticn Plan

' equipment . identified and not submitted in

  • Reference 3, a System Component j

Evaluation Worksheet (SCEW) (in -

accordance with 79-OlB format) is requested. ,

d. . The approicimate installation date for the TMI Action Plan equipment items is requested so that the appropriate l

qualification criteria (NUREG-0588 or. DOR Guidelines) can be used in the ED2

. evaluation.

6 e nk!!n Research Center A Ohnmen af The Frusen basame

" ~

i <

RFI-CS257-520

2. The qualification documents, e.g., the actual e G1 -

test reports and associated corresponde. ace

  • cited as evidence of qualification listed on ,

the SCEW sheets, for all identified TMI -

Action Plan equipment are requested. (The identification of these reports considered.to

. be proprietary is requerted so that proper control of documents can be maintained.]

3. Where the Licensee has a standard Owners' Group position with respect to a NUREG-0737 technical area or has requested extensions of ,

implementation dates, this information is requested in order to it. corporate it into the review. -

oo G

e e

G W

O e

8 11-4

-vm - - . . %

w

s **

)' C . ,

RFI-C5257-520 .

REFERENCES

, l~. R. H. Leasburg Letter to H. R. Denton and R. A. Clark, NRC.

Subject:

Response to Safety Evaluation Report /NUREG-0588, 90-Day Review for North Anna Power Station Unit 2 Virginia Electric & Power Co., 04-Sep-81 Serial No. 355 Virginia Electric and Power Company 2.

Response to NUREG-0737 Post 'IMI-Requirements Rev. 1, 31-May-81

3. B. R. Sylvia Letter to H. R. Denton, NRC.

Subject:

North Anna Power Station Unit No. 2, Response to NUREG-0588, December 1980 Revision Virginia Electric & Power. Co. , 01-Dec-80 Serial No. 958

4. Telephone Memorandum C. J. Crane, J. Murphy, K. Iepson, B. Krapf (FRC) Conversation with

- L. Engle (NRC-PM) , D. Smith, D. Wood (VEPCO)

Subject:

Request for Information, North Anna 1 31-Aug-81

5. Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Safety Evaluation Report for North Anna Unit 2 Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment NRC, 3-June-1981
6. Virginia Electric and Power Company ,

Response to NUREG-0737 Post TMI-Requirements, Rev. 1 31-May-81

7. NUREG-0737, " Clarification of TMI Action Plan. Requirements" NRC, November 1980
  • nk!!n Research Center A Dunson af The Fransen buense

~ ~ ' O g , . . . . ~ - -- -, - _ _ __ __----3---

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20040D032&oldid=2584548"