ML20039A821

Equipment Environ Qualification Review of Licensees Resolution of Outstanding Issues from NRC Equipment Environ Qualification Safety Evaluation Repts & TMI Action Plan Installed Equipment

ML20039A821
Person / Time
Site:	North Anna
Issue date:	12/16/1981
From:	FRANKLIN INSTITUTE
To:	NRC
Shared Package
ML20039A822	List: ML20039A821 ML20040D032
References
CON-NRC-03-79-118, CON-NRC-3-79-118, RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-737, TASK-***, TASK-TM IEB-79-01B, IEB-79-1B, RFI-C5257-484, NUDOCS 8112210334
Download: ML20039A821 (12)

Text

'

- s e

REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORFATION EQUIPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION (E'EQ)

REVIEW OF LICENSEES' RESOLUTION OF OUTSTANDING ISSUES

~

FROM NRC EQUIPMENT ENVIRotD4 ENTAL QUALIFICATION SAFETY EVALUATION REPORTS (SER) AND TMI ACTION PLAN INSTALLED EQUIPMENT Virginia Power and Electric Company Nocth Anna Power Station 1 NRC Docket No. 50-338 December 16, 1981 NRC TAC No. 42497

()

J YllMIO33h J) 9 e o r

ah

.0. Franklin Research Center l

A Division of The Franklin Institute The Bengan Franklin Perhey. PNia Pa. 19103 (215) M81000 l

~

RFI-C5257-484 BACKGROUND

~

~

Franklin Research Center (FRC) of Philadelphia, Pa. is providin~g assis-tance to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) for the equipment environmental qualification (EEQ) review of operating reactors. FRC will perform an EEQ review of the Licensee's 90-dar response to outstanding issues from the NRC Equipment Environmental Qualifica: ion Safety Evaluation Report (SER) and the installed TMI Action Plan equipment. The review will be limited to safety-related equipment potentially exposed to a harsh environment. The results will be presented in the form of a technical evaluation report for each plant.

This request for additional information (RFI) is the result of ait evaluation of the information provided by letters dated August 24, 1981 (1) and January 30, 1981 (2].*

FRC previously requested TMI Action Plan

- information by a telephone memorandum dated August 31, 1981 (31 In response, VEPCO transmitted the following information on September 11, 1981 and october 8,1981:

1. FSAR Sections 6.2.3 and 6.2.1

2. VEPCO response to NUREG-0737, Post TMI requirements dated 31-May-81 (4]

3. Qualification Documents:

a.

Babcock & Wilcox transmittal 86-1119091-00, Relief Valve Acoustical Monitoring b.

Isomedix Inc., Component Testing Division, Environmental Exposure of Liqu.id Level Sensor dated November 17, 1975, for GEMS level detector, plant.ID ILT-DA110A & B.

c.

Environmental test report summaries of Foxboro products, the Foxboro Company transmitters, plant ID iPT-LM110A & B.

d.

Westinghouse Electric Corporation letter NS-SS-79287 dated.

. Novediber 28, 1979, subject, Qualifiction of Electrical Equipment for Hear Term OL Plants.

• Numbers in brackets refer to citations found in the list of references.

-1_

nklin Research Center A cn==a. Thereemen m I

i I

RFI-C5257-484 e.

Letter from Milton Aron (DeLaval, GEMS Sensor Division) to Arthur Murphy, Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation dated 7 May 1974.

f.

GEMS level transmitter, plant ID $LT-RS-151A & B (test reports).

A.

FRC REVIEW OF THE LICENSEE'S 90-DAY RESPONSE TO THE NRC EEQ SER Information Requested Date Received by PRC**

1.

In reference to the Licensee's 90-day response [1] to the NRC SER (5), a legible single copy of each of the following qualification documents is requested in order that the FRC evaluation may proceed:

a. Trexler, D.

L., General Cable Corporation to Wright, R. D., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Your Inquiry...

Cable Constructions, December 22, 1971.

b. Chapman, L.,

Stone, J., Tests of Electrical Cables after Simulated Post Accident Reactor Containment Service, Cerro Wire and Cable Company, a Supplement to Franklin Institute Research Laboratories, Final Report F-C2857, March I

1971.

c. Stone, J., Chapman, L., Tests of Electrical Cables after Simulated Post Accident Reactor Containment Service, Franklin Institute Research Laboratories, Cerro Wire and Cable Company, a Supplement to Franklin Institute Research Laboratories Final Report F-C2750, March 1970.

d. Learn, J. R., Boston Insulated Wire and Cable Company to Wright, R. D., Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, 300 V Instrument cables and 600 V Control Cables, January 17, 1972.

e Marth, J. R., Qualification of Firewall III Class IE Electric Cables, Rockbestos Company, Rockbestos Report 13-10407-E058-13-2, June 22, 1978.

• • This column will be completed by FRC as the requested information is received.

nklin Research Center A Omensen af The Fransen enamese

e RFI-CS257-484 Date Received by FRC**

f. Learn, J.

R., Boston Insulated Wire and Cable Company to Wright, R. D., Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, 300 V Instrument cables, October 12, 1976.

g. Marth, J. R., Rockbestos Company, to Heneberry, E., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Qualification of Cable for operation Daring Main Steam Li w Break, April 25, 1977.

h. Federick, W. C., Conax Corporation, to Bonner, J., ' Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, January 5, 1980.

Att'achments include: Conax Corporation, Design Qualification Report for Electric Penetration Assemblies for Marble Hill, IPS-369, June 15, 1979, Revised through November 7,1979,

i. Broadway, N. J., Palinchak, S., Effects of Nuclear Radiation on Elastomeric and Plastic Components and Materials.

Radiation Effect Information Center Report No. 21, Columbus, Ohio.

j. Anderson, T. M., Westinghouse Electric Corporation, to Stolz, J.

F., Nuclear-Regulatory Commission, NS-Tm-1950.

Attachments include Westinghouse Sensor Qualification Program, IEEE 323-1971 Demonstration Program, Final Test Report for The Barton/ITT Modified Pressure Transmitter (Proprietary Class 2).

k. Anderson, T. M., Westinghouse Electric Corporation, to Stolz, J.

F., Nuclear Reg'ilatory Commission, NS-Tm-2120, September 14,1979.. Attachments include: Westinghouse Supplemental '

Qualification Testing of Barton Lot 1 Pressure and Differential Pressure.

Transmitters (Proprietary Class 2).

~

000 Franklin Research Center Am.ouve m

. ps

o RFI-C5257-484 Date Received by FRC**

1. Stolz, J.

F., Nuclear Regulatory Commission, to Anderson, T.M.,

Westinghouse Electric Corporation, January 15, 1979.

m. Sheets, M. W., Topical Report on General Electric vertical Induction Motors, Inside Containment Recirculation Spray Pump Motors - Surry Power Station -

Second Addendum to Cover Heat Aging, Radiation Exposure, Vibration, and Steam / Chemical Spray Exposure Qualification Test, NRC Docket Nos.

50-280, and 50-281, June 12, 1973.

n. Sheets, M. W., Topical Report on General Electric Vertical Induction Motors, Inside Containment Recirculation Spray Pump Motors - Third Addition. Docket Nos. 50-280, and 50-281, July 23,'1979.

o. Union Carbide, Belgium, New Jersey, two letters, subject: Polysulfone Radiation Resistance, December 19, 1967, and January 22, 1968.

p. McCarthy, P. T., Klockner-Moeller Corporation to Brunner, R., Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, Abnormal Environment Qualification Test Report, January 13, 1981.

q. Raychem Corporation, excerpt from Raychem Report RT 1508/1, October 12, 1978.

r. Wheeler, L. W., Rockwell International, to Bechet, C. T.,' Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, reply to 81 ESG-3176, May 19,1981,

s. Bell, C., General Electric, vendor's letter to walker, F.

P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Outside Recirculation Spray Motors, April 10, I

1979.

i 1

-4 M Franklin Research Center A Ohemen of Tte Fransen insanne y

r

RFI-C5257-484 Date Received by'FRC**

ot. Limitorque Corporation, Nuclear Qualification Data for Safety Related Services, NQDS, November 1, 1979.

u. Jor' dan, W.. G., to Maire, D., Westinghouse Electric Corporation, NS-SS77060, April 5, 1977.

v. Devin, P. E., Raychem Corporation, to Bonner, J., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, April 24, 1979.

w. American Environments Company, Abnormal Environment Qualification Test Reports on Series 170 Motor Control Center for Klockner-Moeller, Limited, Reporc No.

STR-13 2778-1,- February 5, 1979.

x. Lasky, J.

S., Okonite Company, to Reilly, P.,

Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, subject: NUREG-0584, Environmental Qualification of Okonite Cable, North Anna Power Station Units 1 and 2, August 21, '.980.

y. Drab, J. B., Limitorque Corporation, to

Reilly, P.,

Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, subject: Qualification Information, North Anna Power Plant Unit 2, VEPCO P.O. 43469-Limitorque O/N 3F1046, September 19, 1980.

2. Drab, J. B., Limitorque Corporation, to

Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, subject: Qualification Information, North Anna Power Station Unit 2, VEPCO P.O. 43469-Limitorque O/N 3F1046, October 21, 1980.

(

aa. Drab, J. B., Limitorque Corporation, to l

Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering l

Corporation, subject: Qualification l

Information, North Anna Power Station l

Unit 1, VEPCO P.O. 43469-Limitorque O/N 3F2144, October 22, 1980.

h UNJ ranklin Research Center f

A 0aa==a of The Fr==*'i >=amae I

(

-c,-

RFI-C5257-484 Date Received by FRC**

a bb.

Foxboro Company Environmental Test Report Summaries of Foxboro Products, T3-1007 series, Radiation.

cc.

Blackwood, J. A., Foxboro to Barachewicz, J.,

Stone & tiebster, October 27, 1980.

dd.

Lasky, J. S., Okonite Company,. tc MacFarlane, I.

S., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, October 10, 1980.

ee.

Marth, J.

R., Cerro Wire and Cable Company to Heneberry, E.,

Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, July 10, 1972.

ff.

Maire, D. G., Westinghouse Electric Corporation, to Brown, S.

C., Virginia Electric and Power Company, August 19, 1990.

gg.

Lasky, J. S., Okonite Company, to

~

Barnhart, J.

H., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, December 22, 1980.

hh.

Cookinham, J. B., Westinghouse Electric Corporation, to Brown, S. C., Equipment

• Qualification, October 30, 1980.

ii. Lewicki, R. G., Reliance Electric Company, to Barnhart, J. H., Stone &

Webster Engineering Corporation, Motor Bearing Lubricant, November 14, 1980.

l l

t

' 00IU l ranMki Rewardi Center 4 w w n. r ma m 1

g

--.~

RFI-C5257-4 84 Date Received by'FRC**

jj. Newcomb, R., VEPCO, to MacFarlane, I.,

Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Qualification Documentation for Lubricants, December 31, 1980.

kk.

Bell, C.

E., General Electric, to I

Bonner, J., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation, Model SK6319XJ1B, October 28, 1980.

j 11.

Conax Corporation, Design Qualification Test, Rsport for a Conax Low Voltage Control Service classification Conductor Feedthrough Assembly P/N 7641-21001, Test Report No. IPS-353.2, June 18, 1979.

mm.

Federick, W. C., Conax Corporation, to

Reilly, P., Stone & Webster Engineering Corporporation, Environmental Qualification of Electrical Penetrations, January 8,1981.

nn.

Federick, W.

C., Conax Corporation, to Bradley, C.,

Stone & Webster ?ngineering Corporation, April 7, 1981.

oo.

Bartolucci, E. J., Okonite Company, LOCA Qualification Report for Okoguard Insulated Cables and T-95 and No. 35 -

Splicing Tapes, Okonite Report No.

NQRN 3, June 1980.

pp.

Conax Corporation, Design Qualification Report for A 42 Conductor #18 AWG, Conax Low voltage Service classification Conductor Feedthrough Assembly Consistent with the Requirements of IEEE Standard 317-1976 (NRC Regulatory Guide 1.63, July 1978). SIPS 353.10.

November 17, 1980.

Genera $ElectricCorporation, Radiation qq.

Resistance of the Class IE Motors,Section III.

i l

- I UdJ Fmnkun Remarch Cer?At A om-a w rw r==m w.m.

\\

~

p

~

RFI-CS257-484 Date Received by FRC**

rr.

Buckley, R.,

Radiation Technology, Inc.

to McIntire, D., Gilbert Associates, Inc., Letter Dated June 8, 1981.

as.

Devin, P.

E., Raychem Corp. to D.

McIntire, Gilbert Associates Inc., Dated May 7, 1981.

tt.

Okonite Company, Qualification of Okonite Ethylene - Propylene Rubber Insulation for Nuclear Plant Service, July 3, 1978.

uu.

Bell, C. E., General Electric, to J.

H.

Barnhart, Stone & Webster Engineering Corporation March 12, 1981, with Attachment - Qualification Report of General Electric Vertical Induction Motors for Class lE Recirculation Spray Pumps for the North Anna Power Station, by M. W.

Sheets, January 28, 1981, 492HA239.

vv.

Raychem Corp., A Life Assessment of Raychem Heat Shrinkable High Voltage Terminators, Report No. EDR5018, March 28, 1980.

ww.

J.

B.

Drab, Limitorque Corp., to R.

R.

Champagne, VEPCO, June 15, 1981.

xx.

Rahman, R., Raychem Corp., to D.

McIntire, Gilbert Assoc. Inc., June 25, 1981.

yy.

General Cable Corp., General Cable r

Corporation Report on Radiation Resistance of Materials Used in Nuclear Power and Contirol Cable, M.

A.

Durakis, May 24,-1972.

zz.

Letter from Ioannidi, J.,

GAI, Inc., for A. L. Parrish, III, VEPCO, July 20, 1981, 5 KV General Cable.

k A Dmenen af The Fransen haumme q.

g

s

~

RFI-C5257-484 Date Received by FRC**

4 aan. Westingho'use Proprietary Report,

" Supplemental Qualification Testing of Barton Lot, Pressure and Differential Pressure Transmitters."

4 2.

Many SCENs pertaining to Limitorque motor-cperated valves were missing information necessary for the FRC review to proceed (model no. ; motor make, model, and current type; insulation typer brake mo' del and manufacturer).

FRC requests this information.

B.

FRC REVIEN OF INSTALLED m I ACTION PLAN ITEMS Information Requested Date Received by FRC**

l.

Reference 4 does not provide adequate detail with respect to identification of M I Action Plan equipment installed after 1/1/81.

a.

Identification of MI Action Plan i

equipment installed with implementation dates after 1/1/81 is requested.

)

b.

The correlation of these equipment items with the specific applicable sections of NUREG-0737 (6] is requested.

[The correlation is needed to ensure i

that all items are included in the

review, e.g.,

if a transmitter is identified as a MI Action Plan item, are the cable and terminal blocks associated with the device also identified 7]

c.

For all installed mI Action Plan equipment identified, a System Component Evaluation Worksheet~ (SCEW) (in accordance. with 79-OlB format) is requested.

d.

The approximate installation date for the mI Action Plan equipment items is requested so that the appropriate nklin Research Center A 3massen of T>s Fransen bumee

-?L-- -.!

w o

. N..

-.l

.0 $. ;

.. J L.--.

'3

v j

I RFI-CS257-484 b) qualification criteria (HUREG-0588 or DOR cuidelines) can be used in the EEQ evaluation.

2.

The qualification documents, e.g., the actual test reports and associated correspondence ci,ted as evidence of qualif. cation listed on the SCIW sheets, for all identified TMI Action Plan equipment are requested.

(The identification of those reports considered to be proprietary is requested so that proper control of documents can be maintained.]

3.

Where the Licensee has a standard owners' Group position with respect to a NURIC-0737 technical area or has requested extensions of 9

implementation dates, this.inforr.ation is requested in ceder to incorporate it into the review.

m S

4 W

e 4

m e

e 4

e g

e m

RFI-C3257-484 REFERENCES

'I '.

R. H. Leasburg Letter to H. R.

Denton and R. A. Clark, NRC.

Subject:

Response to Safety Evaluation Report for Environmental Qualification... IE Bulletin 79-01B 90-Day Review, North Anna Uni.t i Virgi'nia Electric & Power Co., 24-Aug-81 Serial No. 330 2.

B.

R. Sylvia Letter to J. P. O'Reilly, NRC.

Subject:

Response to IE Bulletin 79-OlB, Supplement 3, and Revision 3 to the Ninety-Day Review Report.

Virginia Electric & Power Co., 30-Jan-81 Serial No. 061 3.

Telephone Memorandum C. J. Crane, J. Murphy, K.

Iepson, B. Krapf (FRC) Conversation with L. Engle (NRC-PM), D. Smith, D. Wood (VEPCO)

Subject:

Request for Information, North Anna 1.

31-Aug-81 4.

Virginia Electric and Power Company Response to NUREG-0737 Post 'IMI-Requirements, Rev 1 31-May-81 5.

Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Safety Evaluation Report for North Anna 1 Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment NRC, 20-Oct-81 6.

NUREG-0737, " Clarification of 'LMI Action Plan Requirements" NRC, November 1980

=

L O

A.

000hranklin Research Center

~

Ao a#mr w

.