ML20038A410

Partially Deleted Commission Paper Re Ucs Motion for Reconsideration of Hydrogen Control Order

ML20038A410
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	08/21/1980
From:	Bickwit L NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC)
To:
Shared Package
ML20038A409	List: ML20038A408 ML20038A410 ML20038A411 ML20038A412 ML20038A414 ML20038A415 ML20038A416 ML20038A417 ML20038A418 ML20038A419 ML20038A420 ML20038A421 ML20038A422 ML20038A423 ML20038A424 ML20038A426 ML20038A432 ML20038A434 ML20038A435 ML20038A436 ML20038A438 ML20038A439 ML20045E144 ML20045E180 ML20045E183 ML20045E186 ML20045E197 ML20045E207 ML20045E218 ML20045E226 ML20045E237 ML20045E245 ML20045E252 ML20045E789 ML20045E791 ML20045E794 ML20045E800 ML20045E805 ML20045E812 ML20045E817 ML20045E820 ML20045E822 ML20045E828 ML20045E831 ML20045E833 ML20045E835 ML20045E842 ML20045E846 ML20045E848 ML20045E850 ... further results
References
FOIA-92-436, TASK-CC, TASK-SE SECY-A-80-121, NUDOCS 8110290318
Download: ML20038A410 (16)

Text

-

- UNITED STATES 4

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION S

Y-A-20-121 ec Aucust 41 19EO W ASHIN GT ON,0. C. 20555 CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM ADJUDICATORY For:

The Commissioners From:

Leonard Bickwit, Jr., General Counsel

Subject:

UCS Motion for Reconsideration of Hydrogen Control Order (TMI Restart); Further Options for Dealing with Hydrogen Control Discussior.:

I.

UCS Motion A.

Summary On June 4, 1930, the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) filed a moticn requesting the Commission to reconsider its order of May 16 (CLI-30-16) relat-ing to how post accident hydrogen control issues could be litigated in the TMI Unit I restart proceeding.

In its order the Commission denied a request to waive 10 CFR 50.44 and stated that hydrogen control issues could be litigated under - ~~

-UCS believes Ehe' Commission T

10 CFR Part 100.

should have' waived 50.44.

Met Ed agrees with the UCS, but for different reasons.

The NRC staff in

ts respcase to the UCS motion suppcrtef the Ccmmission's order and advocated denial of the petitica for reconsideratic..

GGC belietes t.

f M2.::: r E : n,. -:.. g.g l

7-D ^ ::i.: :;c:i ::

y.m#_'

" ~ ' " "

/, !. c r.

O.....-.

5_.

n.h j?.2 - 9'] g

~

~~

l 1

g 3Ecy EE:

r.is ca er :s :cer.- a:

-1. n :E

. :.. wp..-s i,_,.,.. $,. 4. u...,..

i is.

,,,...z-cc. -,ission c,u..

,..- a.. s s...

. u,.

z a.

a.o...,

.. - 2......a.

.,2,

.a.,

)',

f 8/f0 b'fo1/2 T

4 i'

rit i

t t

i I

i L

t t

i

-i t

Finally, we do not find

___m-i 5

4 i

I.

l

. e

' l I.

k

-_ will be discusse:i further in Part II of this paper.

{

k t

We believe that t

{,

r L

t r

r

,w.-

-l 11 i

,e a

i i

c i

.l 1

i P

t b

,]

?

r Leonard Bickwit, Jr.

i General Counsel 1

1 i

I a

N Y

)

o i

I U

1 Comissioners' coments or consent should be provided directly to the Office of the Secretary by c.o.b. Friday, Septer.ber 5,1980.

i Comission Staff Office coments, if any, should be subnitted to the Comissioners If tilt August 29, 1980, with an information copy to the Office of the Secretary.

the paper is of such a nature that it requires additional time for analytical review and coment, the Comissioners and the Secretariat should be apprised of when coments may be expected.

DISTRIBUTION Comissioners Comission Staff Offices Secretariat o

--,