ML20023C109
| ML20023C109 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Limerick  |
| Issue date: | 05/05/1983 |
| From: | Martin R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8305110079 | |
| Download: ML20023C109 (16) | |
Text
--.
l e.(
/ ~
/
DISTRIBUTION:
.C See next page AP 1983 hlAY 0 5 1983 f
p arEpc+;
e w x..
fisette.Ho.:i S0-352/353 jn..
9 3
APPLICANT: Philadel>hia Electric Company FACILITY:
Limerick Generating Station
SUBJECT:
SUMARY OF MEETING HELD ON MARCH 22 - 24,1983 ON MECHANICAL ENINGEERING REVIEW On March 22 - 24, 1983, members of the Mechanical Engineering Branch-(HEB) met with representatives from Philadelphia Electric Company (the applicant),
Bechtel (the architect - engineer), and General Electric (the NSSS vendor) at the General Electric Offices in San Jose, California to dTSis the applicant's response to the staff's requests for additional information (RAI). 89 of the requests for additional information discussed were attached to a letter transmitted to the applicant February 7,1983. Two additional requests for information were discussed during the meeting and are included in Attachment 3 as questions 90 and 91..provides a list of. participants at the meeting. Attachment 2 provides a status of the RAI discussed at the meeting and the proposed action.
5 Of the 91 RAI, three remain open and seven* are confirmatory. Of the three open items, two involve analysis not yet performed by the applicant and therefore could remain open items when MEB issues its SER. These items are the Feedwater Check Valve nalysis and upports designed to ANSI B31.1 Instead of ASME NF. Of the seven confirmatory items, at least four are expected to remain confirmatory when MEB issues its SER.
- The staff is continuing the review of the FSAR and the responses to the RAI.
Originni signed by:
R. E. Martin, Project Manager i
Licensing Branch No. 2, DL l
Attachments:
As stated 5
i 8305 M { 0 000 52 cc: See next page P
PDR 3
't
- Item 56 requires a confirmatory revie.t by NRC.
- SEEATTACHEDPAGEFORPREVIOUSCONCURREN3S s
- DL:LB#2/PM
. p2............
LB# PM
- DE:MEB Q
/BC y.
..........y..........-
omc.,
MHaughey:pt rt
...iii I................
neer n
3
- suaw4Me,
, DATE ) 4 /.1.1../. 8. 3............
. 4/.11/.83.......... 4/.18/.83 4
83 i
NRC FOF.M 318 (10-80) NRCM 0240 0FFiClAL R'ECORD COPY
- : usam mu ns-m
<e.
a,.,
u n
x DISTRIBUTION:
i Docket File NRC PDR Local PDR
'N NSIC PRC Docket No.: 50-3'52/353 N
LB#2 File ACRS (16)
N RHartin APPLICANT: Philadelphia EYectric Comapny EHylton Region I FACILITY:
Limerick Generating Station (e'r
- fE n,
SUBJEC T:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING HELD ON' MARCH 22 - 24, 1983 ON MECHANICAL ENGINEERING REVIEW
'N\\ x On March 22 - 24, 1983, members of the Mechanical Engineerin Branch (MEB) met with representatives from Philadelphia Electric Company the applicant),
Bechtel (t e architect - engineer), and General Electric (the NSSS vendor) h at the General Electric Offices in San Jose, Californja to discuss the f
applicant's response to the staff's requests fbr additional information (RAI). 89 of the requests for additional information discussed were attached to a letter transmitted to the applicant Februahy 7,1983. Two additional requests for information were discussed during 'the meeting and are included in Attachment 3 as questions 90 and 91.
\\ provides a list of participants at the meeting. \\ Attachment 2 provides a status of the RAI discussed at the meeting and the proposed action.
Of the 91 RAI, three remain open and five are confirmatory. Of the three open items, two involve analysis not yet performed by the applicant, and therefore could remain open items when MEB issues its SER. These items are the Feedwater Check Valve analysis and Supports designed to ANSI B31\\l-instead of ASME NF. Of the five confirmatory items, at least four ah expected to remain confirmatory when MEB issues its SER.
The staff is continuing the review of the FSAR and the responses to tb RAI.
-l
\\
R. E. Martin, Project Manager
\\.
Licensing Branch No. 2 DL
\\
t i
Attachmond:
As. stated cc: See~next page i
Qw#casha DL:LB#2/PM
'.PM DE:MEB DL:LB#2/BC l.......
OFFICE)
..................-..a
......a.. a a a..aa..
=a.a.a.a.a..a===.
aa.a a.a..*a a****
............C.,.....
.........g h ey : pt Miau RLI.
l
...Schwencer A
soname >
....... ~...... ~
.4ML83..........'.?.l/lL83.........
. 4L&l.83.........4L...L8 3..........
am>
......... ~. -..
.....-......a....a NRC FORM 318 (1040) NRCM 0240 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY usaee:mi-= e
Linerick Mr. Edward G. Bauer, Jr.
Vice President & General Counsel Philadelphia Electric Company 2301 Market Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 cc: Troy E. Conner, Jr., Esquire Mr. Marvin I. Lewis Conner and Wetterhahn 6504 Bradford Terrace 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19149 Washington, D. C. 20006
~
Frank R. Romano, Chairman Mr. Thomas Y. Au Air & Water Pollution Patrol Assistant Counsel 61 Forest Avenue Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, DER Ambler, Pennsylvania 19002 505 Executive House P. O. Box 2357 Charles W. Elliott, Esquire Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Thomas & Hair 123 North Fifth Street Honorable Lawrence Coughlin Allentown, Pennsylvania 18102 House of Representatives Congress of the United States Judith A. Dorsey, Esquire Washington, D. C. 20515 Limerick Ecology Action 1315 Walnut Street, Suite 1632 Roger B. Reynolds, Jr., Esquire Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107 324 Swede Street Morristown, Pennsylvania 19401 Mr. Karl Abraham Public Affairs Officer Frederic M. Wentz
-Region I County Solicitor U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission County of Montgomery 631 Park Avenue Courthouse King of Prussia, PA 19806 Norristown, Pennsylvania 19404 Mr. Suresh,Chaudhary Eugene J. Bradley Resident Inspector Philadelphia Electric Company U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Associate General Counsel P. O. Box 47 2301 Market Street Sanatoga, PA 19464 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 Joseph H. White III Mr. Vincent Boyer 8 North Warner Avenue Senior Vice President Bryn Mawr, PA 19010 Nuclear Operations Philadelphia Electric Company James M. Neill, Esquire 2301 Market Streec Associate Counsel for Del-Aware Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 Box 511 Dublin, PA 18917 I
~
t Thomas Gerusky, Director Sugarman & Denworth Bureau of Radiation Protection Suite 510 Dept. of Environmental Resources North American Building 5th Floor, Fulton Bank Bldg.
121 South Broad Street Third & Locust Streets Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Donald S. Bronstein, Esq.
Director, Pennsylvania Emergency The National Lawyers Guild Management Ageacy Third Floor Basement, Transportation &
1425 Walnut Street
.r Safety Building Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19102 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Lawrence Brenner, Esq.
Robert L. Anthony Administrative Judge Friends of the Earth of the Atomic. Safety & Licensing Board i
Delaware Valley U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 103 Vernon Lane, Box 186 Washington, DC 20555 Moylan, Pennsylvania 19065 Dr. Peter A. Morris W. Wil. son Goode Administrative Judge Managing Director Atomic Safety & Licensing Board s
City of Philadelphia U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107 Washington, DC 20555 l
Walter W. Cohen Dr. Richard F. Cole Consumer Advocate Administrative Judge Office of Attorney General Atomic Safety & Licensing Board i
1425 Strawberry Square U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Washington, D. C.
20555 l'
Steven P. Hershey, Esquire Mr. J. T. Robb, N2-1 Consumers' Education & Protective Philadelphia Electric Company Association -
2301 Market Street Sylvania House Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - 19101 l
~
Juniper & Locust Streets Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107 Alan J. Nogee The Keystone Alliance 3700 Chestnut Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104 I
i e
k w
,n.
ATTACHMENT 1 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS NRC GE R. Bosnak P. Yin H. L. Brammer R. Bloomstrand Y. C. Li R. Patel G. E. Moore (23 & 24 only)
R. Mason f
J. A.lzheiman (PNL' consultant)
R. Pence (24 only)
G. Marr (PNL consultant)
G. Beeman (PNL consultant)
E. C. Rodabaugh (ECR Associates, Inc. consultant)
(23 & 24 only) l BECHTEL PECO i
R. Sampson (22 & 23 only)
J. Phillabaum T. Huston (22 only)
J. O'Rourke J. Berry (22 only)
T. Shannon (22 & 23 only)
G. Berge (22 only)
H. Vollmer T. Emera P. Tutton (24 only)
R. Schlueter (22 & 23 only)
L. Santos V. Aggarwal (23 only)
C. K. Chern (23 only)
H. Khlarallah (23 & 24 only)
O. Nossardi (24 only)
F. Martin (24 only)
M. Schletz (24 only) k
G J
-)
LIMERICK MEB-SER MEETING
SUMMARY
MARCll 22-24, 1983 3.2 CLASSIFICATION FSAR RESP.
Q. # SECTION SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION 1
3.2.1 R.G. 1.29 B
Open NRC to discuss with Kirkwood.
l 2
3.2.1 RPV Int.
GE Closed None.
Revision completed.
(~
3 3.2.1 Turb. Bypass B
Closed None 4
3.2.1 React. Control Sys. GE Closed None 5
3.2.2 CS Structures GE Closed None.
Revision completed.
6 3.2.2 Pipe Supports B
Closed None.
Revision completed.
7 T3.2-1 RPV Support Skirt GE Closed None.
Revision completed.
8 T3.2-1:'
CRD Hsg. Support GE Closed None.
Revision completed.
h T3.2-l RPV Int.
'GE Closed None.
Revision completed.,
10 T3.2-1 Class 3 Piping B
C1'osed None.
Revision completed.
PCY: cal:hmm/X02096* I 3/24/83 9
p.
O O-3.2 CLASSIFICATION (Continued)
FSAR RESP.
Q. # SECTION SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION
,11 '
T3.2-1
- Emerg. CWS B
Closed.
None 12 T3.2-1~
R.G. 1.26 B
Conf.
PECO to provide additional diesel info. by 4/83.
NRC to confirm with Kirkwood.
13 T3.2-1 QA Certif.
8 Closed None.
Revision completed.
14 T3.2-1 QG for C&I GE/B Closed None 4
i I
t PCY: cal: hmm/K02096*-2 3/24/83
p p
LIMERICK MEB-SER MEETING
SUMMARY
MARCH 22-24, 1983 3.6 PIPINGANALYSIS FSAR.
RESP.
Q. # SECTION
, SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION i
15
- 3. <6.1.1 Pipe Diam.
B/GE Closed None.
Revision completed.
16 3.6.2 Terminal Ends B
Closed None 17 3.6.2.1.1.1 Break Crit.
GE/B Closed None.
Revision completed.
18 3.6.2.1.1.1' Pipe Welds B
Closed None 19 3.6.2.1.1.1 Welded Attachment B
Closed None 20 3.6.2.1.1.1 Volumetric Exam B
Closed None.
Revision completed.
21 3.6.2.1.1 Break Crit.
GE/B Closed None.
Revision completed.
i 22 3.6.2.1.1.4 Interm Break B
Closed None 231 3.6.2.1.1.S SC II Break B
Closed None 24 3.6.2.1.3 Pipe, Whip B
Closed None Revision completed.
25 3.6.2.1.3 Circumf.' Break GE/B Closed None PCY: cal:hmm/K02096*-3 3/24/83 s<..-~v
. = ~e.e,-.
.,+.
vn.-
-n.
p n
G.
3.6 PIPING ANALYSIS (Continued)
FSAR RESP.
Q. # SECTION SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION 26' 3.6.2.1.3
, Circumf. Break B
Closed None 27 3.6.2.1.3 Break Area GE/B Closed None.
Revision completed.
28 3.6.2.1.3' Longit. Break B
Closed None 29 3.6.2.1.3 Break Geometry GE/B Closed None 30 3.6.2.1.3 Longit. Break GE/B Closed None 31 3.6.2.2.2 Recirc. Stiffness GE' Closed None 32 3.6.2.2.2f Recirc. Operability GE Closed None 33 3.6.2.2.2 FW Check Valve B
Open Response revised.
PECO to followup.
34 3.6.2.3 Power. Level Assump. B Closed None 3 51 3.6.2.4' PDA Whip &
GE Closed None Restraint 36 3.6.2.5.2 Restraint B/PECO Closed None.
Revision Completed.
PCY: cal:hmm/K02096*-4 3/24/83 t
p A
O 3.6 PIPING ANALYSIS (Continued)
FSAR RESP.
Q. # SECTION SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION 3I 3.6.2.5.2
' Operability B
Closed None Restraint 38 3.6 T&F Break Calculation B/GE Closed None.
Revision Completed.
Schedule Commitment.
9 I
I PCY: cal: hmm/K02096*-5 3/24/83
p A
G.
LIMERICK MEB-SER MEETING SUMARY MARCH 22-24, 1983 3.7 SEISMIC ANALYSIS FSAR RESP.
Q. # SECTION SUBJECT
- ORG, STATUS ACTION
' 39, 3.7.3.2.1 OBE Cycles GE Closed None Revision completed.
40 3.7.3.2.2 Fatigue Cycles B
Closed None Revision completed.
41 3.7.3.6 3 Seis Components GE Closed None Revision completed.
42 3.7.3.7.1 Closely Spaced GE Closed None Modes 43 3.7.3.12 Bur.ied Piping B
Closed None 44 3.7.3.13 Boundary Anchor B
Closed None 1
I i
PCY: cal: hmm/K02096*"6 3/24/83
.es
_-~e-
. p A
O i
LIMERICK MEB-SER MEETING
SUMMARY
i e
MARCH 22-24, 1983 i
2 3.9 MECHANICAL DESIGN FSAR RESP.
4 Q. # SECTION SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION 45.
3.9.1.1.1 CR0 Trans.
GE Closed None 46 3.9.1.1.2 CRD Hsg. Trans.
GE Closed None 47 3.9.1.1.3 OBE Cycles for HCU GE Closed None 48 3.9.1.1.5 Startup/ Shutdown GE Closed None Cycles 49 3.9.1.1.2 Normal / Upset Trans. GE Closed None Revision completed.
50 3.9.1.1.9 Pool Cycles GE/B Closed None Revision completed.
t 51 3.9.1.1.9 Scram Cycles GE Closed None 52 3.9.1.2 Computer Programs GE/B Closed None Revision completed.
I 53 3.9.1.3 Exp. Stress Anal.
GE Closed None 54 3.9.1.4 Elast.-Plastic GE/B Closed None Anal.
55 3.9.1.4.1 CR0 Tests.
GE Closed None PCY: cal:Imm/K02096*-7 3,/24/83
~
p O
O.
3.9 NECHANICAL DESIGN (Continued)
- FSAR, RESP.
~
Q. # SECTION-SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS
' ACTION 56 3.9.2 e Pre-op Vib./
GE/B/PECO Closed None Revision completed.
NRC to confirm.
NUREG-0619 57 3.9.2.1 Level 1 & 2 GE/B Closed None Revision completed.
Criteria 58 3.9.2.1 Startup Piping B
Conf.
Pending NRC's review of test spec.
Test 59 3.9.2.4 Prototype Reactor GE Closed None 60 3.9.2.5 LOCA + SSE GE Closed None 61 3.9.2.la.3 Snubbers-Vib.
GE/B Closed None Control 62 3.9.2.1 Pre-op Vib. Crit.
B/GE Closed None Revision completed.
63 3.9.3 AP NUREG-0609 GE/B Conf.
None Pending NRC's New Loads review.
64 3.9.3.1 Piping Func. Capab. GE/B/PECO Closed None Revision completed.
1 65 3.9.3.1.'6 Recirc. Pump GE Closed None Revision completed.
Design' 66 3.9.3.1 NUREG-0800 Req't GE/B Closed (B) None Revision completed.
Conf.(GE) Pending NRC's review of NSSS NL update.
=.
PCY: cal:hmm/K02096*-8 3/24/83
-"~
.u
f.
O O
3.9 MECHANICAL DESIGN (Continued)
FSAR i
. RESP.
Q. # SECTION SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION 67 3.9.3.1 e SRV Piping Fatigue B Closed None Revision completed 68 T3.9-6 Load Combination GE Closed None Revision completed.
69 3.9.3.1 NL Reconciliation GE/B Conf.
None Pending NRC's New Loads review.
70 3.9.3.3.2 Open Discharge Sys. B Closed None 71 3.9.3.4.1 Hi. Cyc. Fatigue
. B/GE Closed None for Supports 72 3.9.3.4.1 Bolts Stress GE/B Closed None Revision completed.
73 3.9.3.4 Prim.& Sec. Stress GE/B Closed None 74 3.9.3.3 Pres. Relief B/GE Closed None Revision completed.
Devices I
75 3.9.3.4
'NF Boundaries B/GE Closed None 76I 3.9.3.4' Support Buckling GE'/B Closed None Revision completed.
77 3.9.3.4.1 Snubber Design B/GE Closed None Revision completed.
PCY: cal:hmm/K02096*-9 3/24/83
l
(-
o O.
3.9 MECHANICAL DESIGN (Continued)
FSAR RESP.
r l
Q. # SECTION SUBJECT ORG.
STATUS ACTION 78 3.9.3.4.1 Snubber Design B
Closed None 79 3.9.3.4.1 Snubber Design B
Closed None 80
- 3.9.3.4.1.
Snubber Test B
Closed None Revision completed.
81 3.9.3.4.1 Snubber Design B
Closed None Revision completed.
82 3.9.3.4.6 Support Design B
Open (1) Class 1 full penetration welding on comp. support.
(2) ISI of AISC items and Class 1 comp. supports.
83 3.9.3.1 Load Combination GE/B Closed Revision completed.
B to follow up commitment.
Ta.ble 84 3.9.4.2 CRD Comp. Design GE Closed None Revision completed.
85 3.9.5 Jet Pump Beam GE/PECO Closed None (IEB80-07)
I 86
871 3.9.6.1 '
Inservice Testing B/PECO Closed None Revision completed.
88 3.9.6.1 Inservice Testing. B/PECO Closed None Revision completed.
i 89 3.9.6.1 ISI Program B/PECO Conf.
PECO and NRC to meet to discuss IST.
90 PCY: cal:hmm/K02096*-10 1
3/24/83
.l
ATTACHMENT 3 QUESTION NO. 90 Show how the Miter in the Non-Straight Main Steam Line has been included in the piping analysis.
QUESTION NO. 91 As a result of the Independent Design Verification Program for Susquehanna, a question was raised concerning the implementation of NB-3113. How is NB-3113 implemented for the Limerick Project?
)
t d
4 I
05 M MEM0 DATED:
MEETING
SUMMARY
DISTRIBUTION:
Doiiument dontrol (50-352/353j NRC PDR Local POR NSIC i
PRC LB#2 File l
RMartin l
EHylton i
RBosnak H. L. Bramer i
Y. C. Li G. E. Moore A