ML20009B717
| ML20009B717 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 07/13/1981 |
| From: | Reveley W LONG ISLAND LIGHTING CO. |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20009B708 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8107170084 | |
| Download: ML20009B717 (23) | |
Text
,, __
9 w b~
,./ ~, g k- q.f$( Y
- r
<gt,f'e'O n %, g , - 11 4,; f ?h,, 4
, N %D%
July 13, 1981 4 /
~
~
7/
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of )
)
LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322
)
(Shoreham Nuclear Power Stat. ion, )
Unit 1) )
LILCO MOTION FOR
SUMMARY
DISPOSITION OF SOC CONTENTION 3 The Contention By Board Order of March 5, 1980, SOC Contention 3 was admitted as follows:
The recent revision 2 of Regulatory Guide 1.97, " Instrumentation for Light-Water-Cooled Nuclear Power Plants to Assess Plant and Environs Conditions During and Following an Accident" details the needed devices and qualifications of instruments, many of which are not presently a part of the Shoreham design.
8107170084 810713 PDR ADOCK 05000322 O PDR
l l
S Material Facts as to Which There is No Genuine Issue to Be Heard
- 1. Regulatory Guide 1.97, Revision 2 (Dec. 1980) defines both what must be done and when it must be done, in order to comply with the guide. See id. at 1.97-7 to -15.
- 2. Shoreham will meet the substantive and schedule requirements of this guide, except as noted in Table 1 of the attached McCaffrey Affidavit. As that table indicates:
(a) Requirements 1, 3, 21, 24, 28 and 42 are subject to potential implementation delays, largely because of possible constraints on equipment availability; and (b) Requirements 5 and 18 for certain, and item 11 possibly, are the subject of exemption requests.
- 3. Thermocouples (item 2(b)(5) above) are covered by SOC Contention 8, which alleges in pertinent part: "[T]he Shoreham plant design does not have instrumentation to permit (i measurement of fuel clad temperature in the range experienced at TMI-2 . . . ."
Argument SOC Contention 3 claims that Regulatory Guide 1.97, Revision 2 " details the needed devices and qualifications of instruments, many of which are not presently a part of Shoreham's design." But as indicated in the autached McCaffrey Affidavit, Shoreham is being modified as necessary to meet the guide, with a few exceptions. Some of the necessary steps have
. i already been taken, some others will be completed by fuel load, l and the rest by June 1983.
As to the exceptions, first, LILCO does not believe that thermocouples are necessary to satisfy the guide. It seems that SOC disagrees. SOC Contention 8, however, deals squarely and at length with the issue. Accordingly, to avoid redundancy and confusion, the question of thermocouples should be litigated once and for all in the context of Contention 8.
Second, it is not clear whether SOC is concerned 1 bout the other exceptions noted above. If it is, then further evidence may be needed as to one or more of them. Presumably, SOC's reply to this motion will indicate precisely its position on these exceptions.
For the reasons stated, LILCO requests that SOC Contention 3 be dismissed under S 2.749 for lack of "a genuine issue to be heard," except as regards (1) thermocouples, which should be removed to SOC Contention 8, and (2) other issue (s) regarding the exceptions described above if SOC raises a genuine issue about one or more of them in its reply to this motion.
Respectfully submitted LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY
/
W. T'ay r Reveley, III
/
Antho F. Earley, Jr.
Hunton & Williams P. O. Box 1535 707 East Main Street Richmond, Virginia 23212 DATED: July 13, 1981 l
l l
l l
l l
l
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of )
)
LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322
)
(Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, )
Unit 1) )
AFFIDAVIT OF BRIAN R. McCAFFREY REGARDING REGULATORY GUIDE 1.97, REVISION 2 Brian R. McCaffrey, being duly sworn, states as follows:
- 1. I am Manager of Project Engineering, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Long Island Lighting Company. A statement of my professional qualifications is attached to this affidavit.
- 2. Table 1 below summarizes what must be done at Shoreham 4
to satisfy Regulatory Guide 1.97, Revision 2, and sets out the facts of Shoreham's compliance.
- 3. Table 2 below provides engineering detail elaborating j upon Table l's conclusions.
\ .
, Brian R. McCaffey Manager of Project Engineering,
. Shoreham Nuclear Power Station -
l LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY July 13, 1981 4
q ~~ . - - - - , . , -
- - , - - , ,v-- ,- - , , , - - - - - - , - . - - - - - - - , - - , - - , , - - - - . -
'. TABLE 1 SNPS CONFORMANCE TO REGULATORY GUIDE 1.97, REVISION 2 Rsg. Guide 1.97, Required Rtv. 2 Requirement Implementation (Maasured Variable)17 Date2/ Status of Compliance
- 1. Neutron Flux 6/83 Required instrumentation already included in design. Additional upgrading of qualifications, power supplies and equipment required, scheduled for completion by 6/83, assuming the timely availability of necessary equipment and qualifications.
- 2. Control Rod Position 6/83 Complete.
- 3. Reactor Coolant 6/83 Additional instrumentation re-System (RCS) Soluble quired, scheduled for completion Boron Concentration by 6/83, assuming the timely (Sample) availability of necessary equipment.
- 4. Coolant Level in Reactor 9/82 Required instrumentation already included in design. Additional qualification required for certain instrumentation. Also, certain power supplies require upgrading.
Above are scheduled for completion by 9/82.
t
- 5. BWR Core Thermocouples 6/83 Exemption requested.
- 6. RCS Pressure 6/83 Required instrumentation already included in design. Qualification of certain transmitters and re-l corders required, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 7. Primary Containment 9/82 Required instrumentation already Pressure (Drywell) included in design. Qualification and expe'ded range required for certain recorders, scheduled for completion by 9/82.
l
-1/
Some requirements appear more than once in the guide. They are listed below only once, however, in the order that they first appear in Table 1 of the guide.
-2/
Assuming that Shoreham loads fuel by September 1982.
Reg. Guide 1.97, Required R:v. 2 Requirement Implementation (Maasured Variable)l/ Data 2/ Status of Compliance
- 8. Drywell Sump Level 9/82 Complete. Existing instrumentation adequate since the sumps are in secondary containment and are isolated on an accident signal.
- 9. Primary Containment 9/82 Required instrumentation already Pressure (Suppression included in design. Qualification Chumber) and expanded range required for recorders, scheduled for completion by 9/82.
- 10. Primary Containment 6/83 Required switches and lights Isolation Valve already included in design.
Position Qualification of limit switches and lights required, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 11. Radioactivity Concen- 6/83 Feasibility of compliance being tration or Radiation studied. Not clear whether an Level in Circulating exemption will be requested.
Primary Coolant
-12. Analysis of Primary 9/82 Additional instrumentation re-Coolant (Gamma quired in sampling system, 4
Spectrum) scheduled for completion by 9/82.
- 13. Primary Containment 9/82 Required instrumentation already Area Radiation included in design. Qualification and expanded range required for certain equipment, scheduled for completion by 9/82.
[14. Suppression Pool 9/82 Required instrumentation already l
Water Level included in design. Additional qualification required for certain transmitters and recorders. Also, relocation of taps required.
Completion scheduled by 9/82.
- 15. Containment and 9/82 Required instrumentation already Drywell Hydrogen (expanded range) included in design. Additional Concentra~ tion required by qualification and expanded range 6/83) required for recorder. Completion scheduled by 9/82 for qualification and 6/83 for expansion of range.
- - - - w r--< ..-- e v- --rm-- - - ~ , - g- - . -, , , - , - ~,y, -,--w-- ---n .-, ,, ,,
~Rtg. Guide 1.97, Required
-Rtv. 2 Requirement Implemqntation (Measured Variable)l/ Date El Status of Compliance
- 16. Containment and -9/82 Required instrumentation already Drywell Oxygen included in design. Additional Concentration qualification required for re-corder, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 17. Containment 9/82 Required instrumentation already Effluent Radio- included in design. Additional activity - Noble upgrading of qualifications and Gases expanded range required, scheduled for completion by 9/82.
- 18. Radiation Exposure Rate 6/83 Exemption requested.
(inside buildings or areas which are in direct contact with primary containment where penetrations ~
and hatches are located)
- 19. Main Feedwater Flow 6/83 Complete.
- 20. Condensate Storage 6/23 Complete.
Tank Level
- 21. Suppression Chamber 6/83 Additional instrumentation Spray Flow required, scheduled for com-pletion by 6/83, assuming the timely availability of necessary equipment.
- 22. Suppression Pool Water 6/83 Required instrumentation already Temperature included in design. Qualification of RTD's required. Existing range is adequate. Scheduled for com-pletion by 6/83.
- 23. Drywell Atmosphere 9/82 Qualified temperature elements Temperature required to supplement existing ones, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 24. Drywell Spray Flow 6/83 Additional instrumentation required, scheduled for completion by 6/83, assuming the timely availability of necessary equipment.
i
Rog. Guide 1.97, Required Rev. 2 Requirement Implgmentation (Maasured Variable)l/ Date_/
Z Status of Compliance
- 25. Main Streamline 6/83 Required instrumentation already Isolation Valves' included in design. Additional Leakage Control upgrade of qualifications re-System Pressure quired, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 26. Primary System 9/82 Required instrumentation already Safety Relief included in design. Qualification Valve Positions of transmitter required, scheduled for completion by 9/82.
- 2. 7 . RCIC Flow 6/83 Required instrumentation already HPCI Flow included in design. Additional Core Spray System Flow qualification of transmitter RHR System Flow and indicator required, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
,28. LPCI System Flow 6/83 Additional instrumentation required, SLCS System Flow scheduled for completion by 6/83, assuming the timely availability of necessary equipment.
- 29. SLCS Storage Tank 6/83 Required instrumentation already Level included in design. Additional upgrade required for qualifications, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 30. RHR Heat Exchanger 6/83 Required instrumentation already Outlet Temperature included in design. Additional qualifications required for thermo-couples and recorder, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 31. Cooling Water Flow 6/83 Required instrumentation already to ESF System Components included in design. Additional qualification required for trans-mitters and indicators, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 32. Cooling Water Temper- 6/83 Required instrumentation already ature to ESF System included in design. Additional Components qualification required for thermo-couples and recorder, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
. l Reg. Guide 1.97, Required Rev. 2 Requirement Implementation (Mnasured Variable)l/ Date2/ Status of Compliance
- 33. High Radioactivity 6/83 Complete.
Liquid Tank Level
- 34. Emergency Ventilation 6/83 Required switches already Damper Position included in design. Additional upgrade of qualifications re-quired, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 35. Status of Standby 6/83 Required indication already in-Power and Other Energy cluded in design. Additional Sources Important to upgrade of qualifications re-Safety quired, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 36. Secondary Containment 6/83 Complete. Access to secondary Area Radiation containment is not required during accident conditions.
- 37. Sump Level in Spaces 6/83 Required instrumentation already of Equipment Required included in design. Additional for Safety upgrade of qualifications required, scheduled for completion by 6/83.
- 38. Effluent Radioactivity - 9/82 Required instrumentation already Noble Gases, Station included in design. Additional Vent upgrade of qualifications and power supply required, scheduled for 9/82.
- 39. Effluent Radioactivity, 9/82 Complete.
Halogens and Particu-lates (portable)
- 40. Plant and Environs 6/83 High range survey equipment to Radiation (portable) be procured, scheduled for com-pletion by 6/83.
- 41. Plant and Environs 6/83 Portable equipment to be procured Radioactivity by 6/83.
Rng. Guide 1.97, Required Rnv. 2 Requirement Impl (Maasured Variable)77 Dateyentation Status of Compliance
- 42. Post Accident 9/82 New post-accident sampling system Sampling (Certain items being implemented on schedule required by assuming the timely availability of 6/83) the necessary equipment.
- 43. Wind Direction 6/83 Complete.
- 44. Wind Speed 6/83 Complete.
- 45. Estimation of 6/83 Complete.
Atmospheric Stability
- 46. Environs Radioactivity- 6/83 Equipment being provided, scheduled Exposure Rate (contin- for completion by 6/83.
2ous indication at fixed locations)
- 47. Environs Radioactivity 6/83 Equipment being provided, scheduled
- Radiohalogens and for completion by 6/83.
Particulates (portable)
TABLE 2 -
SHOREHAM ASSESSMENT TO REGULATORY GUIDE 1,97 REV . 2
, Present Compliance to
- Reg 1.97, Rev 2, Reo 1.97. Rev 2 SNPS-1 Design Criteria
- Shoreham Impact i
Changes Measured . Mark Required to
, Itesa variable Type Oual Range Nos. Ra.nge 1A 18 2 3 4A #B SA drs to 7 8 Cunply Fully Regnarks 1 Control B 3 Full in or NA Full in- NA NA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y MA Hone rod not full out position Full in
, 2 Neutrw. B,A 1 10 to 1001 1C51*XR802 10-a-10-* N N N N N N N N Y Y N Upgrade quali- G8 generic flux full power (C51-R602) C/S f1 cations, solution required power supplies (SRM,APRM) C51-R600A- 10-8-10-6 N N N N N N N N Y N h and equipment D
, A 1 Power 1C51*XR803 0-401, range A-D 0-1251 (C51-R603 A-D) 3 Coolant B,A 1 Bottom of 1821-LP007 -150/0/+50 1 N Y 2 Y Y Y N Y Y N Qualified NUREG-0737, level in core (203" to transmitters, Item II.F.2 the support 403") recorders, and reactor plate to 1B21-LIO07 -150/0/+50 1 N Y 2 Y N Y N Y N N upgrade power 3
centerline (203" to supply ior of main 403") upper range steam line 1821-XR004 -150/0/+b0 1 N Y 2 Y Y Y N Y Y N A,B (367" to 577")
1821-LI004 -150/0/+60 1 N N 2 N N Y N Y N N D (367" to 577")
1C.12-XR006 0-+60" to 1 N N 2 N N Y N Y N N 0-180*to (517" to 577")
(517" to IE.GEND NOTAYION NIYHIN TABLE:
e Coltaan Designations Y-Yes
, 14 Seismic qualification per keg Guide 1.100 for instrtsnent loop N-No 1B Seasmic qualification per Reg Guide 1.100 for display instrurnent NA - Not applicable for this type of parameter
)
2 Single tallure criteria- 1-Vualit1*d to IEEE-344,1971 3 Environmental qualitication per Guide 1.89 (NUREG 0588) 2-vualified to IEEE-323, 1971 4A Power source for instrument loop
)
Eb Power source for display instrument 5A Quality assurance level for instrument loop 5h Quality assurance level for display instrument 6 Display type 2
8 Unique identification 1 of 10
TABIJ, II .F.3-1 (CONT'D)
Present Compliance to a Reg 1.97, Rev 2, Reo 1.97. Rev 2 SNPS-1 Design Criteria
- Shoreham T - ct e
697")
1C32-LI008 0-*60" to 1 N N 2 N N Y N Y N N -
A,B,C (517" to
$77")
1821-LI005 0-400* 1 N N 2 N N Y N Y N N -
(517" to 577")
1821*LI004 -150 to
+60 (367" to 577")
4 RCS B 3 0 to Not available New instrumen-soluble on Shoreham tation as part boron of post acci-conc dent sample (saveple) s3 stem 5 RCS B 1 15 psia to 1821-XR004 0-1,500 1 N Y 2 Y Y Y N Y Y N Qualified pressure 1,500 psig A,B psig transmitters and recorder A 1B21*PIOO4 1 N N 2 Y Y Y N Y N N IC32-P1003 0-1,200 1 N N 2 F N Y N Y N N Psig C 1 15 psia to IC32-XR004 850-1,050 1 N N 2 N N Y N Y Y N 1,500 psig psig 6 Nain D 2 0-15" H,0 IE32-PIO31 30" Hg Vac-steam 0-5 psid A-D 10 psig Upgrade line IE32-PIO32 0-100 psig qualifications isolation A-D valves IE32-PIO33 0-100 psig leakage IE32-P1034 30" Hg-10 psig control IE32-PDIO35 0-100" H,0 system IE32-PDIO3B 0-100" H,0 pressure
- 7 SRV D 2 Closed not 1B21*PMU 0-100 1 1 N 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y N Qualified NUREG-0737, position closed or 501 psig transmitter Item II.D.3 0 to 50 psig 8 Primary B 1 10 psia to 1Z93*PR 0-60 psig 1 1 Y 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y N Qualified NUREG-0737, contain- C 3 times 501A,B recorder, Item II.F.1 ment A design 1Z93-PI140 12-17 psia 1 N N 2 N N N N Y N N expand range pressure pressure -
2 of 10 '
=
a TABLE II.F.3-1 (CONT'D) e Present Compliance to Reg 1.97, Rev 2, Reo 1.97. Rev 2 SNPS-1 Design Criteria
- Shoreham Impact a
(drywell) O to design a
BA Primary A 1 10 psia to 1293*PR 0-60 psig 1 1 Y 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y N Qualified NUREG-0737, Cont B 3 times 501A, B recorder Item II.F.1 a Press C design pres-(suppr sure;10 psia chamber) to design e
9 Drywell C 1 0-301 1T48*B,R 0-101/ Y 1 Y 2
- Y Y Y Y Y N Qualified NUREG-0737, and wet- A 114A,B 0 '01 recorder, item II.F.1.
, well expanded range Espanded range of hydrogen 0-30s is an concen- additional g tration requirement not specitied in NUREG-0737.
O 10 Drywell C 1 C-105 1T48*0,R 0-105/ Y 1 Y 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y N Qualified and wet- 25A,B 0-25s recorder O well oxygen g concen-tration
, 11 Primary B 1 Closed- Various Closed- 1 1 N 2 Y Y Y Y Y N N Qualified contain- not closed not closed limit switches ment and lights
, isolation valve
- position 12 Drywell D 2 40*F to 1T4 7-%S 50*P to N N N N N N N N Y Y N Addition of New qualitied atmos- 440*F 030 250*F qualified tmperature elemerius phere temperature are being installed tenper- elements to comply with tech ature spec requirments 1T47-TRS 50*F to N N N N N N N N Y Y N 020 250*F 1T47-TRS 50*F to N N N N N N N N Y Y N 010 250*F 1Z93-T1137 50*P to 150*F e
3 of 10
9 .
TABLE II.F-3-1 (Coffr'D) g Present compliance to Reg 1.97, Rev 2, Reo 1.97, Rev 2 SNPS-1 Design Criteria
- Shoreham Impact 4
13 BwR core C.B 1 200*F to Not pro- Approximately GE generic e thermo- 2,300*F vided on 16 new thermo- solution required couples Shoreham couple loops a 14 Radio- C 1 1/2 tech Not pro- Addition of Implementation of activity spec limit vided on gross activity this parameter concen- to 100 Shoreham monitor or a is on " Hold."
g tration times tech heavily or radi- spec limit shielded ation le- R/hr ionization chamber g vel in on the recirc line circula-ting prima-g ry coolant 15 Analysis C 3 104 ci/gm Not pro- Instrumentation g of prl- to vided on in sampling mary 10 ci/gm Shoreham system coolant or TID-g (gamma 14844 spectrum) source term in coolant g volume
% Primary E 1 1 to 10
- 1D21*RE085 10 to 10 8 N Y Y N Y Y Y Y Y Y N Qualitication NUREG-0737,
, contain- C 3 R/hr A,B R/hr of equipment. Item II.F.1 ment high 1 to 10s Expand range range R/hr
, area radiation
, 17 Second- E 2 10-1 to Not pro- New monitor Not provided ary con- 10* R/hr vided on since access to tainment Shoreham secondary con-
, area tainment not radiation required v
l l
iw 4
~9 4 of 10
J TABLE II-F-3-1 (CONT *D)
Present Compliance to gr Reg 1.97, Rev 2, Reo 1.97. Rev 2 _
6NPS-1 Desian Criteria
- Shoreham Impact f
18 Drywell C 1 Bottom to 1G11-LT209 0-48" 1 N N N N N N N N N N New qualified Existing instru-drain B top instrumentation mentation is r numps 1G11-LT210 adeqiiate since level the sumps are in (identified 1G11-LR505 the secondary a and X containment and unidentified isolated on an leakage) accident. The a system has been designed in accordance with A Regulatory Guide 1.45.
A 19 Contain- C 3 10-6 to 1D11*RE 10-6 to Upgrade quali- NUREG-0737, ment E 2 10-a 41/cc 021A,B 10* 41/cc tications Item II.F.1 i ettluent C 2 10-6 to 1D11*RE expand range y radio- 10S 41/cc 022A,B j activity 10-* to l noble 1084Ci/cc y gases (incl
- RBSVS) p 19A RBSVS E 2 0-1101 1T46*FR Upgrade flow flow 004A,B qualifications r 20 Environs E Per NUREG-0654 Not pro- Provide new Not being pro-radio- Section II.H.58 vided on monitoring vided as systein a_
activity and 6B Shoreham stations is currently i exposure under review I rate .
l (continuous indications at fixed ,
locations) .
21 Main D 3 0 to 1105 1C32-FR020 0-12x106 NA NA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y NA None ,
teed- design Ib/hr water tiow 1C32-FI 0-bx 106 NA NA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y NA flow 001A,B lb/hr ,
t 22 Conden- D 3 Bottom Input to O to 50' NA NA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y N NA None sate to top plant ,
storage computer tank level 5 of 10
.) .
) .
TABLE II-F-3-1 (CONTfD) j Present Compliance to
- Reg 1.97, Rev 2, geo 1.97. Rev 2 SNPS-1 Design Criteria
- Shorehase Impact i
23 Drywell D 2 0 to 1101 Not pro- New qualified GE generic spray design vided on fIow 1 low instrumentation solution required Shoreham
. 23A Suppr 2 0 to 110% Nat pro- New qualified GE generic chamber design vided on spray 110w instrumentation solution required Shoreham flow 24 Drywell D 2 12 psia to 1Z93-P1140 12-17 psia NA NA NA 2 Y Y N N Y Y N Upgrade pressure 3 psig qualifications 0 to 1105 design pressure 25 Suppres- D 2 30*F to 1Z93*TRS 50*F to NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y sion Y NA Qualified R198 s t Existing range 230*F 500A,b 250*F and recorder. adequately pool (1 1t Expand range.
water monitors this below NWL) parameter temp A 1 1193*TRS 50*F to 503A,B 250*F NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y NA Qualified R1D*s (2 ft and recorder.
below NWL) Expand range 1E41-TI152 50*F to NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y N Y NA 250*F 26 Suppres- C 1 Bottom of 1Z93*LR001 38 below NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Qualified NUREG-0737, alon A ECC6 A,B NWL to 5* transmitters, Item 71.F.1 pool suction above NWL recorders and water line to 5* relocation of above NWL taps D 2 Top or 1E41-LIO13 1* below 1 N N 2 N N Y N Y N N vent to NWL to 2*
top of above NWL weir well (258-6" to 288-69 27 HPCI D 2 0 to 1105 1E41-FIOO3 0-5,000 NA NA NA 2 1 Y Y N Y Y NA Qualified flow design qpa transmitter flow and indicator 28 RCIC D 2 0 to 110% 1E51-FIOO3 0-500 gpm NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y N Y Y MA Qualified '
flow transmitter and indicator 6 of 10 L_ __
b .
TABLE II-F.3-1 (CONTfD1
, Present Compliance to
- keg 1.97, key 2 Rea 1.97. Rev 2 SNPS-1 Deslan Criteria
- Stercham Ymet 29 Core D 2 0 to 1101 1E21-FI002 0-5,MO NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Qualified spray design A,B gpm transmitters ,:
tiow flow and indicators 30 RHR D 2 0 to 1101 1E11* FR001 0-20,000 system design gpu NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Qualified .
transmitter flow 1 low asad indicator 1811*FI001 0-20,000 NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Qualaried design A,B gpm transmitter flow ahd indicater 31 LPCI D 2 0 to 110% Not provided on Shoreham New system GE generic design flow tlow instrumentation solution required 32 RHR heat D 2 32*F to 1E41-TR100 0-600*F ex- 350*F NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y N Y Y MA Qualified (1E11*TE thermocouples, changer 012A,B) recorder outlet temp 33 Cooling D 2 32*F to 1E41-TR100 0-600*F NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y N Y Y MA Qualified water 200*F ( 1E 11*TE thermocouples, temp to 013 A,B) recorder ESF system cunponents.
34 Cooling D 2 0*F to 1E11*FI100 0-12,000 water
- 10*F NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Qualified j tA,B gpm transmitters flow to design (RHR HX) and indicators ESF tiow
, systun 1P41*FI149 0-12,000 NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA components A,B gpm (RHR HX) 35 SLCS D 2 Bottom to 1C41-LI001 0-5,000 NA NA NA NA *4 Y N N Y Y NA Upgrade storage top A gal qualifications j tank 36 Sep A 1 1G11*LIS 0-24* 1 1 Y 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Upgrade l level in 645A,b qualifications j spaces j ot equip-ment required -
for safety 7 of 10
6 .
TABLE, II-F-3-1 (CONT'D)
) Present Compliance to
- Rt<J 1.97, Rev 2, Reo 1.97, Rev 2 SNPS-1 Design Criteria
- Shoreham Ispect 3
37 SIES D 2 0 to 110% Not pro- New GE generic
) flow design vided on instrumentation solution required flow Shoreham 38 High D 3 Top to 1G11-LIO2t. O te, NA KA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y NA None Indicators are
)
radio- bottom A,8 30,000 gal located in activity 1G11-LI005 radwaste
) liquid A,a control room
- tank 1G11-LIO27 level A,B
) 1G11-LI169 A,B
- 1G11-LI175 A,B
)
39 Emer- S 2 Open- Various Open- NA NA NA 2 - Y Y Y Y Y NA Upg: ve Only reactor
) gency closed closed qual .e : tions building dampers ventila- status and valves are thn included as titis 3 damper appears to be TM1 p osition concern, i.e.,
release oi radio-g active material I from the plant 40 Status D 2 Vritages Emer buses Voltages MA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Upgrade Voltage and cur-of currents and qualifications rent Indication standby pressures currents is provided in power the control room
) and other 1P50-PI116 0-150 psig NA NA NA 2 Y Y Y Y Y Y NA Upgrade f or 4,1tiO v and energy A,B qualifications 480 v buses. bat-g sources tery voltages important are indicated in to safety the control room p and battery anps are indicated at the DC switch-p gear.
, (hydraulic, l pneumatic) 41 Radia- E 2 10-1 R/hr 1D21-RE001 10-n to NA NA NA N N N N N Y Y NA Repurchase and N provided tion to 10* R/ to 030 10* mr/hr quality sance access to exposure hr 1D21-RE032 ntznerous arms secondary con-g with a 1,000 tainment not rates to 041 times normal required O
O 8 of 10
^
m TABLE II.P.3-1 (CONTop) ,
Present Compliance to a Reg 1.97, Rev 2, Reo 1.97. Rev 2 SNPS-1 Design Crateria* Shoreham Impact
=
C2 Etfluent'E 2 10-6 to 1D11-RE042 10-* to NA NA NA N N N Y Y Y Y NA Upgrade quali- NUREG-0737 ,
radio- 10-a gifce 1oa Ci/cc fications and 3 tem 11.F.1
- t cctivity 1D11*RE069 10-8 to NA NA NA N Y Y Y Y Y Y NA upgrade power notte 103 C1/cc supply to ups gases for ID11PNL-041 -
l sta vent
! C2A Sta vent E 2 0 to 1105 1D41-Pr085 -
Upgrade -
flow design 1D11*PT069 qual 111 cations rate flow s
, C3 cifluent E 3 10-3 to 1D11-PNL As deter- NA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y Y NA None NUREG-0737, radio- 10a $1/cc 041,055, mined by item 11.P.1 cctivity 057 LILCO -
helogens 1D11*PNL laboratory and 021,022 equipnent partic- .
ulates (sampling)
C4 Environs & 3 10-* to Not pro- Provide radio- 10-a fi/cc vided on 3 portable activity St.orehem equipment rtdio-hnlogens End 3
particu-lates (portable) ,
t5 Plant E 3 10-8 to Not pro- Purchase high ,
and 10* R/hr, vided on range survey environs photons, Shoreham equipment rtdia- 16-8 to
, tion 10* R/hr i (portable) Detas and low energy photons C6 Plant E 3 Multi- None End channel environs gamma-ray radio- spectro-Ectivity meter (portable) 9 of 10
5_____________-
D
- YABIJ. II.F.3-1 (COWP'D) 3 Present Cosspliance to
- Reg 1.97, Rev 2, Ree 1.97. Rev 2 SNPS-1 Desian Criteria
- h Shoreham T m et C7 Post E 3 As req'd Not 3 accident provided New post acci- NUREG-0737, sampling dent, sample Item II.B.3.
on system capability Shoreham Boron, chloride 3 and dissolved oxygen are additional 3 requirements not specified in NUkEG-0737.
) 48 Wind direc-E 3 0-360* 0-540* NA NA: NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y NA None tion G9 Wind E 3 0-30 mes 0-100 mph NA NA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y NA None speed
) 50 Latima- E 3 -9* to tion of 1B*F
-10* to
+20*F NA NA NA NA Y Y Y Y Y Y NA None
) atmo- 164 ft for 117' spheric intervals interval stability
)
)
?
?
)
)
)
10 ot 10
s BRIAN R. McCAFFREY Manager, Project Engineering for Shoreham Nuclear Power Station Long Island Lighting Company My name is Brian R. McCaffrey. My business address is Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, P. O. Box 618, Wading River, New York. I am Manager, Project Engineering for the Shoreham Nuclear Power Station. As such I am responsible for the overall engineering and licensing of the Shoreham Station. In this capacity, my organization directs and approves the engineering efforts of the Architect Engineer and Nuclear Steam Supplier. This organization is also responsi-ble for directing the activities leading to an Operating License from the NRC.
I graduated from the University of Notre Dame in 1967 with a Bachelor of Science Degree in Aerospace Engineering, and received a Master of Science Degree in Aerospace Engineering in 1972 from the Pennsylvania State University and a Master of Science Degree in Nuclear Engineering in 1978 from the Polytechnical Institute of New York. I have also completed a General Electric BWR Design Orientation Course in 1978.
My professional experience follows:
Since 1973, employed by Long Island Lighting Company. From January 1979 to April 1980 held the position of Project Engineer for the Shoreham Nuclear Project, and from April 1980 to June 1981 was Assistant Project Manager -- Engineering and Licensing. Responsibilities basically as set '
out above.
I From October 1977 to December 1978 held the l position of Senior Licensing Engineer for the i
Shoreham Nuclear Project. Responsible for the licensing activities leading to an Operating License.
From June 1975 to September 1977 held the position of Senior Engineer in the Power Engineering Depart-ment with responsibilities as Project Coordinator for gas turbine installations and Lead Mechanical Engineer for nuclear projects.
l l
n
-2_
From January 1973 to May 1975 held the positions of Associate Engineer and Engineer in the Power Engineering Department involved with balance of plant engineering on both fossil and nuclear power stations.
From 1968-1972, employed by Grumman Aerospace
, Corporation. Primary responsibilities were in the areas of aircraft aerodynamics and flight test stability and control.
I am a member of the Amer.ican Society of Mechnical Engineers and the Long Island Section of the American Nuclear Society, and I am a Registered Professional Engineer in the State of New York.
l I
, .. -. - - . , - . . - - - - - - - - . - - , - , - _ . - - , , . - . . .- - . - - .-- ,-